Author Archives: SHG

A Victim’s Guide

At Injustice Everywhere, Packratt has crafted something that, to my knowledge, has never before existed:  a guide for victims of police misconduct.  And Packratt should know, having unceremoniously entered the game when he, out of nowhere, found himself thrust into the role of victim. 

That’s usually how it happens, ordinary person in the wrong place at the wrong time, suddenly on the wrong end of a police officer’s baton and attitude.  To the cop, it’s not worth a second thought.  Beat a person and he’s a perp, no matter whether it’s a bad person or a citizen.  It happens that the wrong guy gets whacked, but once the deed is done, there’s no turning back.  As Packratt learned, what happens afterward can be just as difficult to navigate and as bizarrely incomprehensible as the initial act of abuse.

There are 6 steps in the Guide, plus some additional thoughts that reflect sound experience.  As Packratt notes, and I reiterate, the guide will not perfectly cover every scenario, nor every jurisdiction.  No guide can be that comprehensive given the variables.  But it’s an excellent overview and speaks to some overarching truths that a victim needs to know. 

The fly in the ointment, if any, is that most victims of police misconduct won’t be aware of what to do until after they’ve made several mistakes, most notably the shift in attitude of being the outraged citizen screaming at the top of his lungs to the beaten victim,remaining silent.  The problem, of course, is that no one anticipates being a victim, and therefore no reason exists to be aware of the guide beforehand. 

Included in the Guide, as Steps 4, Organize Your Thoughts and Build Your Case, and 5, Find A Lawyer, But It’s Harder Than You Think. is some critical insight that Packratt learned the hard way. 



Why? Again, as a person who has received a lot of letters from police misconduct victims seeking help, 9 out of 10 times they are writing while still in a state of shock and what they write barely makes sense, is missing a lot of necessary information, and is not going to help them find a lawyer who will want to take their case. Usually, it’s all a confusing jumble, but that’s mostly a symptom of the trauma and shock caused by the incident, so it’s understandable, but it can cripple their chances at finding help.
People come to lawyers with a laundry list of perceived wrongs, each of which is the worst thing that’s ever happened to anyone since the beginning of time.  It’s like telling the doctor that your pain is the worst ever.  It informs only that you’re angry, but not whether you have a viable claim.  We need factual information, not feelings.  You’ve only got a certain amount of time to explain what happened, and if you use that time to explain how you feel about what happened, you’ve wasted your time. 

While every single minute detail may be critical in your mind, its unlikely to be significant legally.  I’ve heard a description of the 30 second beating take more than an hour to describe.  You aren’t going to get an hour to describe it.  It’s not because no one cares, but because you’re one of many who want to use up the same hour, and we only get to spend it once. By organizing your thought around the salient facts, you make good use of your time.  By oozing every iota of angst, you tell the lawyer that what you really need is a therapist, and provide no useful information from a legal perspective.




Sure, you were probably told that the ACLU takes any case they hear about or that lawyers would be crawling out of the woodwork to take your case… Well, you were misled. The ACLU only takes a fraction of cases, usually based on whether the case will make precedent or make a lot of headlines, they are very selective about what they take and not helpful otherwise.


Lawyers don’t like to take on police misconduct cases either. They are difficult to win and take a lot of time to build… and most police misconduct victims don’t have the money to pay them up front. So, when lawyers aren’t being paid upfront lawyers have to gauge the risks involved in taking your case against how likely it is they would win and if what they would stand to win would pay for all that time and expense they’d spend on your case. Don’t feel bad if they turn you down, it’s all business since they have to make a living too.
Common wisdom, defined as ideas that get you into worse trouble than you started with, is that anybody can find a lawyer willing to take their case just for the asking.  After all, we constantly hear about frivolous lawsuits, and certainly yours is absolutely valid and filled to the brim with merit.  Lawyers should be begging to take your case.  As Packratt learned the hard way, it’s just not true.

Contrary to the expectations of many, not every harm caused by police will give rise to a cause of action.  Cops are given more latitude in their conduct than anyone else on the street, and what normal people would perceive as an egregious act of violence becomes a mere mistaken when committed by a police officer.  If you don’t like it, remember when next you vote for some law and order candidate.  Even if your circumstances give rise to a cause of action, lawyers need evidence.  Your swearing that you would never lie isn’t the same as medical reports and photographs.  Without evidence, the best case goes south.

And then there’s the nasty issue of “damages”.  Damages means compensable injuries or harm.  Even if the rest of the stars align, this aspect tends to be the crushing blow for most victims.  Worse still, it’s delivered not by the cop, but by the lawyer.  Most of the time, the victims of police misconduct suffer little compensable harm.  A day in jail, some bruises and humiliation, a dubious criminal charge (with an equally dubious disposition), and there will be no pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. 

When delivering this news, the victim invariably looks at the lawyer in shock, proclaiming that her injuries are enormously significant to her.  No matter how empathetically the bad news is framed, I’ve never seen a victim not blame the messenger.  It can be heartbreaking, but as Packratt correctly notes, it’s a business decision.  Lawyers can’t run a practice by bringing lawsuits in cases without adequate damages.  And, given that few victims can pay the freight for the suit, and seek a lawyer who will take a contingency fee (a percentage of the recovery), the recovery has to be sufficient to make the suit financially worthwhile.  It’s not a matter of greed, but survival.  Lawyers’ children need to eat just like yours.

While Packratt advises to keep trying and to be patient and professional in your efforts, the sad truth is that many, perhaps most, police misconduct cases will never result in a lawsuit.  The lawyers who do this sort of work are very picky, learning early that taking on the wrong case can destroy a practice.  There are far more wrongs in the world than the law is capable of redressing, a sad but hard truth.  It’s not that we don’t sympathize or agree, but we’re forced by necessity to make hard choices.  We don’t want to add to your pain, but we often do.

This is an excellent piece of work by Packratt, and one that should be read by every victim of police misconduct as soon as possible. If nothing else, his experience, painful though it was, will serve to help others who find themselves in this nightmare.  Again, Packratt has shown his generosity of spirit in using his horrible experience to help others.  He will never receive the appreciation that he deserves for what he’s given others, and my thanks for his efforts pale in comparison to all he’s done.

The Justice Factory

One of the newest and brightest additions to the blawgosphere, Jamison Koehler, at his as yet unnamed blawg,* writes a post about ordinary injustice from his days as a Philadelphia public defender.  The post exists on two levels, the surface being the point he’s trying to make, about a judge who grew annoyed with him for “wasting” her time.


After years of doing this work, I had developed a good system for pulling up the things I needed to know at a single glance at my cheat sheet.  But that was only half of the battle.

The other half was to walk the client through the options and to come to a decision that the client was comfortable with. 

You are doing all of this with other clients knocking on the door because they need to speak with you.  You are doing this with the court crier coming out to tell you the judge is getting impatient and you’d better get your ass back in the courtroom.  And you are doing this with angry and confused clients, many of whom are distrustful of you as a public defender.

On that particular day, Jamison’s daughter sat in the courtroom to watch her father at work.  He tried to make sure the judge knew his daughter was there, so that she might show a bit of kindness in her demeanor and not embarrass a father.  Still, he had a hearing to do at the insistence of his client, which was, in the judge’s eyes, “frivolous”, and clients to speak with, which pulled him away from the well when the judge wanted to dispense “justice” at a more rapid pace than Jamison’s conferring allowed.

Despite his having sent word via the clerk to the judge that his daughter was in the gallery, the judge’s attitude did not improve.



Later, during a break, I asked her what had happened.  “You won’t believe the things they said about you when you were out of the room,” she said.

“Who said things about me?” I asked, expecting that she had heard some grumbling from within the gallery.

“The judge and the court people.”

This was a lesson for his daughter, but not the one he hoped would be learned that day.  Rather than gain respect for the system, or the court, the lesson was that the law is more assembly line than bespoke.  Slow down the factory that cranks out “justice” and you will annoy the foreman.  The foreman doesn’t want to be annoyed.  Ironically, as Jamison writes, the judge (with whom he was otherwise friendly) wanted to know if his daughter planned on becoming a lawyer after her experience in court.  The foreman had no idea that her impatience and disrespect might possibly be a bit off-putting.  To the foreman, the smooth running factory is paramount and, apparently, attractive. 

But there was also a subtext to Jamison’s post that likely wouldn’t occur to anyone who became so inured to working in the justice factory.  While Jamison takes well deserved issue with the judge’s assembly-line approach to her job, and annoyance with him for doing his too well, this part of his description is troubling.



Of the 40 or so clients I had on the list that day, probably 25 or 30 were there for trial.  And for each and every person on that category, I needed to know what the charges were, what prior convictions they had, whether or not a new conviction would violate the terms of probation or parole for one of those convictions, what the prosecution alleged, what my client had said, and whether or not we had any witnesses of our own.  If we did have witnesses, I needed to talk with those witnesses to assess their credibility and to determine if their testimony would help our case.  If the defendant was planning to testify, I needed to make the same determination with respect to credibility and prepare him or her for what was to come.

After years of doing this work, I had developed a good system for pulling up the things I needed to know at a single glance at my cheat sheet. 
This is unimaginable to me.  He’s staring at 25 to 30 trial ready cases, and first needs to speak with witnesses?  He’s got cases ready for trial where a defendant wants to testify but has yet to be prepped?  The reasons for this are obvious; he’s a public defender with a list of defendants to represent.  Every day, there’s a new list.  Every day, there are new people to defend.  The list grows longer, the hours in the day do not.  He’s trying to do everything he can to provide an adequate defense for every human being whose life is in his hands. He’s “developed a good system” to do so.  It’s a good system within a very bad system.

That Jamison would be expected to go to trial without weeks of preparation, inspecting evidence, visiting the crime scene, meeting with potential witnesses, prepping those you intend to call, preparing  in limine motions, memoranda of law, jury instructions, tagging evidence, reviewing documentation at least twice, if not three times, is disturbing.  There is so much to do to properly defend a person.  There is no time to do any of it when you have 25 to 30 cases ready for trial.

Like Jamison, judges sometimes grow impatient with me when I announce that I am not yet ready for trial because I haven’t had an adequate opportunity to review the prosecution’s belated turnover.  I’m often told that, “I’m sure a lawyer of your experience can figure it all out over lunch,” or some similarly half-flattering, half-insulting, dismissive comment intended to keep the assembly line of justice moving forward.  I refuse to bite on such comments, invariably replying that while I appreciate the court’s faith in my abilities, I nonetheless require preparation time lest my inadequacies deny my client his right to an adequate defense.  I do not embarrass easily.

It’s easy for Jamison to overlook the fact that, as a public defender, he had 25 to 30 cases ready for trial for which he was wholly unprepared.  That’s was his ordinary life as a public defender.  Ordinary injustice is what the factory produces, and it cranks out a ton of it every day.

______________________
*  Jamison, attempting to straddle the marketing blawgosphere and the substantive blawgosphere, goes by the name Koehler Law Blawg in the hope that it will draw business to him, while allowing him to write substantive posts and participate in the blawgosphere.  While his posts are interesting, his writing is excellent and he’s got much to offer, my emphasis on the substantive blawgosphere rather than the marketing blawgosphere precludes my linking to his “marketing name.” I hope that asides such as this will push Jamison to forego the marketing angle and give his blawg a real name, so that I can provide more helpful link love in the future.

Educate Me

In my recent post about the kiddie swarm attacking Amy Alkon for not being politically correct, a number of comments were posted by nasty little children that never saw the light of day.  One poster, a newcomer to SJ (as is often the case when I post on a subject of interest to those not normally inclined to concern themselves with issues of criminal law) decided to take me on, and I allowed a series of his posts to show. 

He was clearly some kid who was going to teach me a lesson for trying to challenge the wisdom of the Flies.  For all I know, he may be the Lord of the Flies himself, given that his email name was “worldruler”, which, when I called him out on this detail, he responded that I was a superficial idiot to judge him for this.  Oddly, I understand his point, since every child these days believes that he’s the ruler of the world.  Or should be.

But in his final comment, he caught me by surprise, saying something that revealed far more than he could possibly realize.


It’s sad, really. You’re like Alkon, unable (or perhaps unwilling) to understand the culture of the Internet. So you take offense at our customs and violate our most sacred taboos, and when someone comes to educate you, you blow him off as a “narcissi(s)tic idiot.”
Note that one of his side issues was that I was a “regular idiot” for my failure to use spellcheck when I called him a “narcissitic idiot.”  This was a critical, and inexcusable, flaw to the child.  The old man, proud of the day he bought his first IBM Selectric II, failed to use spellcheck.  There are no typos in a spellcheck world.

For all the lawyers who’ve endured my ridicule of the Slackoisie and their mentality of entitlement and narcissism (spelled correctly without benefit of spellcheck), and who are bombarded with self-proclaimed experts telling them to change the world to make their slacker lives more fun and pleasant, this is what you are up against.  They aren’t satisfied with work/life balance.  They won’t love you because you care deeply about their global values evolution.  You can’t win their hearts by giving every one of them a trophy.

What you don’t realize, and the experts don’t know, is that they believe they already own the world.  They have their own customs.  They have their own sacred taboos.  What they are doing is educating us, the dinosaurs who still stumble around until we finally collapse and die, about how they will change everything once they seize control.  They, we are told, come from the culture of the internet.  We are history.

Some say that this is just typical generational squabbling, as our father said of us and our grandfathers of them.  It means nothing, and the children will mature when the responsibility of carrying on is placed in their hands. They will manage, as did we and our fathers before us.  This is wrong.  The World Ruler is right.  The culture of the internet has changed the game.

There can be no question that the digital world has fundamentally altered the way we exist.  It’s made information remarkably available to anyone for the asking.  It’s changed the nature of human interaction.  These are both good and bad things, but for those who grew up with the internet, it’s simply the way things are.  Much has been lost to the internet, the ability to distinguish between good information and bad, the beauty and depth of true interaction and real thought. 

The digital world has empowered every kid to believe that he’s got nothing to gain from human experience, that he not only knows everything there is to know, but is fully prepared to hold a place at the table with the rest of society from the moment his fingers can dance on a keyboard.

Many of my contemporaries won’t believe me.  Their lives haven’t changed that much.  They haven’t experienced the brilliance or wrath of the Slackoisie.  They exist in a transitory time warp, where the old continue to exist as they always have, using some of the peripheral aspects of the digital world and thinking that makes them hip and savvy.  They have no idea of the culture that has grown up around them, but of which they know little.  They laugh at kids texting, with their cute little shortcuts and emoticons.  Harmless childish stuff.

What they don’t see is the empowerment of the lowest aspects of human nature in children, their disdain for duty, responsibility and honor, quaint phrases for which no shortcuts exist because they are never uttered.  They chalk up the children’s simplistic and self-serving expressions as lack of maturity.  “They’ll grow up when it’s their turn,” they say.   What they don’t recognize is that these are children whose ideas have been reduced to 140 characters, and who will always seek an expedient way to shortcut understanding of more complex problems.  They will not find solutions because their world is built around magic bullet answers.  They are proof that H.L. Mencken was right.  They are Oscar Wilde’s cynics.  They will not learn.  They will just Google the question.

And what makes me know this?  One of the benefits, if one can call it that, of blogging is that I hear from a wide swathe of people with one thing in common.  They spend time on their computer in the digital world.  When old men try to stick their nose into this world, using the mechanisms that worked well in face to face interactions, they often appear foolish and disconnected.  To many of the Slackoisie, that’s how I appear.  I refuse to use words like “tweet”, and have been viciously castigated by children who inform me that I’m so uncool that they can’t bear to read me.  I can live with that. 

Others find that their lack of computer savvy, their reliance on personal credibility in a world where credibility no longer matters as every anonymous day-tripper believes that he’s the center of the digital universe, taints them.  Sometimes, they deserve to be treated like internet pariahs, where the only thing that stopped people from telling them that they were boors and intellectually deficient before was that it was poor form to insult someone to their face.  Now that no one need actually look into another person’s eyes, insults are easy and old fools aren’t immune from the truth any longer.

My child commenter, the World Ruler, is wrong, yet right.  There is a culture of which I am not a part.  While I may know more about it then most people of a certain age, it moves so quickly and morphs in ways I would never anticipate that it’s impossible to stay on top of it while watching from the outside.  And I have no delusion that I’m not on the outside.

By denying this is happening, by denying this is a problem, by believing that support, encouragement and acquiescence is enough to overcome the Slackoisie, we do our children a horrible disservice.  Life is not limited to what happens on a computer screen.  By the time they realize that every problem they face, and they will face as many as we did, does not have a magic bullet solution that can be expressed in 140 characters of less, they will have done themselves grievous harm.  We need to stop encouraging this now.  It’s not just a harmless prank.  If we help to perpetuate this immaturity, they will never grow up and take responsibility.

Client Service, And All That Guff

The email from Stephanie West Allen at Idealawg pondered what exactly was meant by the linked post by self-proclaimed Leadership Expert Andrew Hughes.  I had to first get past the leadership expert part. 






Andrew Christopher Hughes - EzineArticles Expert Author 





Andrew Christopher Hughes

 


Andrew Hughes is a Leadership Expert and Master Coach, helping businesses and individuals develop courageous and authentic leadership patterns that produce superior and permanent results. Andrew is an experienced and successful leader with impressive leadership credentials in the legal industry as part of the senior leadership team of a national law firm. He is now a Director of Dare2XL and is located in Newcastle, Australia.

Where do these people come from?  Who buys into this crap that they are experts in anything?  We are inundated with self-proclaimed experts busily selling their guru-dom to the intellectually challenged.  Are there really enough weak-minded losers to keep an industry of snake oil salesmen afloat?  Apparently so.

The post that Stephanie referred to was another of the Slackoisie, the world is changing so you better change with it, bits of nonsense.  The sort that seeks to justify selfishness and entitlement, the typical Slackoisie traits, as the new rage for lawyers in place of those nasty, old-time characteristics of hard work, responsibility and excellence in representation.  Here’s what our grinning expert had to say:



Values have changed
As illustrated by the ‘problems’ firms are experiencing with X and Y geners, there has been a global values evolution. These generations are less willing to accept the same incursions on their family and social lives in return for rewards in the future. They are also less tolerant of organisations that fail to give them the opportunity to be part of a larger cause, one that exists outside of a profit motive or the meaningless client service guff that is often dished up.

Meaningless client service guff?  I wonder what the clients think about that. I wonder whether the clients agree that they’re paying lawyers so that they can feel good about themselves, have their newly-changed values indulged, on the clients’ dime and at the expense of their representation.  After all, isn’t lawyer happiness the primary concern of clients?

He’s certainly right that firms are experiencing “problems” with generations X and Y.  (No, not you. You’re wonderful, just like mommy said. It’s the other ones I’m talking about.)  That they believe that their professional responsibility is all about what makes them happy, and pays for the Beemer, is bad enough.  We certainly wouldn’t want the young set to do anything that required effort or inconvenience.  That would conflict with their values, and as our leadership expert informs us, we can’t have that.

But that this expert informs us that client service is “meaningless guff” is fundamentally absurd.  The only reason lawyers are given their ticket is to serve clients.  Without clients, we would be sweeping streets, provided anybody would hire us given the lack of sweeping skills.  Clients are why lawyers exist.  And yet our expert has it the other way around, that clients exist to provide a fun and profitable place for lawyers to go during the day so they don’t have to sit on the couch eating Cheetos and watching Oprah.

Given that lawyers are having such difficulty dealing with the Slackoisie, and for the most part cannot comprehend how new lawyers have so fundamentally misconstrued the reason why they are handed a very substantial paycheck every other week, people are searching for ways to make things work.  The young set sees posts like this expert’s and believes that they are right to demand changes that make them happy and fulfilled.  Older lawyers, who are discontent with the law fail to notice the absence of logical nexus between their discontent and the Slackoisie solution (though they will figure it out soon enough when the college tuition bill arrives) see acquiescing to the demands of the Slackoisie as the path of least resistance.  And everyone looking for an excuse to indulge their weaknesses and self-interest at the expense of their clients will embrace this nonsense.

When lawyers forget that its all about clients, then it’s over.  Our purpose is lost, together with all the good perks we get for being lawyers.  Does this mean that leadership isn’t all about work/life balance and new values?  I’m afraid it does.  Sorry.

A Bad Decision Gets Worse

When the Supremes held in Maryland v. Buie that police, arresting a defendant inside a house, had the right to conduct what is euphemistically called a protective sweep, it literally opened the door to enormous 4th Amendment mischief.  In the name of officer safety, police would now “search” a home, the theoretically most protected sphere we have, to make sure there was no one hiding in the closets who might emerge and shoot a cop.

Of course, protective sweeps quickly devolved into checking rooms where contraband was naturally in plain view.  Protective sweeps soon involved opening drawers and cabinets (you never know whether there’s a little person hiding in a drawer, you know). The lines quickly blurred and warrantless searches of homes became commonplace under the rubric of a protective sweep.  But what’s the 4th Amendment when compared to officer safety?  Isn’t officer safety more important than anything else? 

In the spirit of remembering the rubric while forgetting the rationale, Eugene Volokh brings us the 9th Circuit decision in United States v. Lemus, which does the unthinkable. 


In United States v. Lemus, the Ninth Circuit held that such a search of part of the home is constitutional, even without any reasonable suspicion, at least when that part of the home “was a place from which an attack could be immediately launched.” The gun that was found in plain view during the search could thus be used as evidence to convict Lemus of being a felon in possession of a gun. The court noted that the living room door was open, “which created additional hazards for the officers”; but I don’t think that can be seen as a limitation on the holding, since a potential attacker could easily open a closed door as well. And the court even notes that “[a] bullet fired at an arresting officer standing outside a window is as deadly as one that is projected from one room to another,” which suggests that the searched room doesn’t even have to be one that has a door leading out to the place where the arrest happens.

As noted in Judge Kozinki’s dissent, at least in Buie, the police are already “legitimately” within the home.  Here, the majority has completely disconnected the sanctity of the home from the need for police safety.  From there, Judge Kozinski indulges in something few judges ever do.  He openly states the truth, what quietly happens in real life while other judges color it over with platitudes and facile denials.



How has it come to this? There’s a simple answer: Plain view is killing the Fourth Amendment. Because our plain-view case law is so favorable to the police, they have a strong incentive to maneuver into a position where they can find things in plain view, or close enough to lie about it. This is a case in point. While the officers were finishing their room-to-room sweep of Lemus’s apartment, apparently finding no one and nothing suspicious, the detectives entered as well. Yet Buie permits only a sweep for people who might be dangerous. Once the officers found no one in the living room, what authorized entry by the detectives? There was absolutely no reason for the detectives to enter except to try to find contraband in “plain view.” So, the detectives went in and, while there, Diaz thought he saw “something sticking out from the couch” that “looked like the butt of a weapon.” Longoria then lifted the couch cushion “to make sure” and found a gun. Under what theory of “plain view” may police lift cushions off a couch to make sure something is contraband? Why weren’t the officers required to get a warrant — if they could — based on what they saw, before rummaging through the couch?

The Lemus holding doesn’t merely disconnect the Buie rationale from the rubric, but extends it to a degree that is barely appreciable at first glance.


[The panel] allows police to search an arrestee’s home without suspicion, so long as the arrest is within a rifle shot of the home. [Emphasis Added.]
Say that a decent marksman can accurately fire a rifle from a thousand feet away.  That means that any house within a thousand feet of an outdoor arrest would now, under this ruling, but subject to a warrantless, suspicionless search.  It might involve the home of the person arrested.  It might involve the home of some nice family wholly unrelated to the arrestee.  It might involve any home the police are itching to enter.  After all, you never know where a bullet can come from, and isn’t officer safety the most important thing involved?  Bear in mind, the decision requires no belief, nor any basis for a belief, that there is any threat to the officers.  It’s prophylactic, better safe than sorry.

Add to this calculus the fact that police are frequently in the position of picking and choosing when and where to arrest someone.  In instances where they know in advance that they are going to take someone down, they can plan their arrest so that the individual is in his home, near his home, near your home, wherever they know they can find him, at the time of arrest.  It’s not exactly rocket science to do a little advance planning so that they get the opportunity to do a little warrantless search protective sweep in the process.  Two birds, one stone.  Efficiency in government. 

While this was bad enough under Biue, where the police could effectuate an early morning takedown at the home of some suspect, and get a free search of the home in the process, Lemus opens up an entirely new strategy of doing the takedown outside the front door of someone else’s home, for which there is no probable cause whatsoever but in which the police have a really strong interest in searching. 

And don’t expect a knock on the door before the cops burst into the neighbor’s house.  After all, it’s a protective sweep, and even though they may know with absolute certainty that there’s no threat inside, they still have to maintain the appearance of protecting officer safety.  Safe officers don’t knock.  That would just be stupid.



Downfall: The Spoof As Lawyer Advertising

I first became aware of the “Downfall” Meme when Marc Randazza posted about it at the Legal Satyricon.  If you have just emerged from a hole, these are spoofs based on a film called Downfall about Hitler, where people add in their own subtitles to the same 4 minute film snippet.  Youtube has a bunch of them.

My initial reaction to the meme was that it was very wrong to use a Hitler film for such frivolity, but I got over it after watching a few.  It was a spoof at Hitler’s expense, and after letting go of my initial revulsion, I came to find many of them very funny and an excellent way to take what may be the lowest point in human engagement and recreate it in a way that shows its wrongfulness through humor.  Others will no doubt disagree, and I respect that as well, but I’ve come to be something of a fan.

Yet, everything has limits.  And when new Legal Blog Watch author  Eric Lipman, who apparently just emerged from a very deep hole yesterday, posted about a who used the Downfall meme as their firm advertisement, it pushed the limits too far, in a number of different ways. 



Before getting to the video, a blue screen emerges with the lawyers taking credit as director and producer of the video.  What the…?  That was just a plain lie.  This was an actual 2004 foreign film, produced by Constantin Film Produktion GmbH. and nominated or an Oscar for Best Foreign Film.  They added subtitles, as have dozens of other people, none of whom tried to take credit for the production of the video.  Opening with a patent lie is hardly the best idea for lawyers to promote themselves.

As to the spoof aspect of the video, the subtitles added for the meme, it just wasn’t funny.  It might have been.  Many others are.  This one wasn’t.  It was heavy-handed and witless.  Perhaps they weren’t shooting for funny, but then, without the humor component, the use of Downfall to convey their message is no longer salvageable by dint of the meme.  It’s just an offensive use of Hitler for self-promotion. 

What of the inherent comparison between the government here and Hitler?  It’s a comparison I reject entirely and diminishes all associated ideas.  I won’t let people draw the comparison here in comments, and delete any comment that tries to do so.  The use of Hitler in that respect offends me beyond compare, and I find it intolerable.  I realize that others draw the comparison regularly, but there is nothing that this country does, no matter how bad it is, that reaches the depths of the Nazis.  Nothing.

Finally, the question arises whether this is a good idea for lawyer advertising.  I imagine that it will appeal to a select group, whether because they are inclined to enjoy a video portraying Hitler or have such a strong hatred of the government that they will agree with the comparison between the two. 

No one, however, familiar with the Downfall meme will be impressed by this effort.  No one with any wit or sense of humor will find this attractive.  No one who seeks a good lawyer will be swayed by the judgment demonstrated by this take-off, and no one who expects their lawyers to be honest will find this acceptable.

No, this falls below the level of taste and good judgment that I would expect from criminal defense lawyers, even if they limit their practice to DUI.  If you wondered what might be worse than lawyers strutting about in hot pants, now you know.  The race to the bottom is on.

Saving Amy Alkon

I like Amy.  She’s an advice columnist, and she’s got moxie.  Moxie is something I respect.  Whether I agree with her politics is irrelevant.  There are plenty of people I respect and admire, even though we disagree about things.  As it happens, I agree with her quite a bit, but that’s got nothing to do with anything, as far as I’m concerned.

Other people disagree.  By other people, I refer to the Slackoisie who follow Tintin at .  He’s got a hate on Amy Alkon like you wouldn’t believe.  So he’s enlisted the entire third grade to engage in a smear campaign against her.  From Patterico’s Pontifications, they have targeted Amy’s new book, I See Rude People , at Amazon for fake and destructive reviews.



And it’s working.

For example, a Sadly, No commenter boasts of having left this one-star review :



If you want to learn how to be really rude and obnoxious and yet keep some weird semblance of self-esteem with a large dollop of ego on top, this book is for you! Arnold Alkon has many lessons on how to set straight innocent people who might have the misfortune of crossing her path and pissing her off. A must read for anyone who lives in the same town as Mr Alkon!


Sadly, No commenters have gone en masse and voted this review as “helpful.” As of this writing, almost 80 people have voted this review helpful — meaning it is now the first review people see when people look up Amy’s book.

I haven’t read Amy’s new book.  I’m still waiting for her to send me a review copy.  I’m patient.  But this attack by the Lord of the Flies is not merely a disgrace, but an affront to anyone who believes that ideas, people who espouse ideas and people who write them down so that they end up in a book, should be subject to the revenge of the playground when the children don’t like her. 

The Sadly No blog is a monument to immaturity and narcissism.  That’s fine too, as the Slackoisie need somewhere to go during the day since they clearly will never be employable adults.  But to engage in this smear campaign against Amy because they disagree with her views, and to do so in such an overt (and childish) manner for the purpose of harming her financially by faking negative reviews, rather than challenging her ideas, is total garbage.

My guess is that my politics are far closer to those of the kiddies at Sadly No, and yet I am disgusted that these children have no more useful way to spend their time than try to harm someone for disagreeing with them.  To the flies, I say leave Amy Alkon alone.  To the rest of you, support Amy and don’t let the swarm get the better of us.

Maybe Lawyers Should Remain Silent Too

Many a lawyer has found himself in deep trouble after the klieg lights are turned off in a high profile case, realizing that the words emitting from his mouth have just backed a defendant into a corner from which there is no escape.  That’s foolish.  But even the wealthy defendant, say former Brocade CEO Gregory Reyes, who has the wherewithal to hire a PR firm to handle damage control, can find himself just as foolishly cornered.

Via Law.com :


The quotes came from Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom partner Richard Marmaro, who represented Reyes during his first backdating trial. Jury selection in the retrial begins Thursday in San Francisco.

Even though Marmaro is no longer representing Reyes at trial, prosecutors will seek to introduce Marmaro’s press release statements by calling to the stand one of the most well-known — and pugnacious — public relations men in the country: Michael Sitrick. Reyes employed Sitrick before his first trial, and prosecutors have subpoenaed documents from Sitrick’s PR shop, Assistant U.S. Attorney David Anderson said in court Tuesday.

U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer indicated that Marmaro’s quotes may very well come into evidence, though he hasn’t decided yet. Had Reyes made statements to Marmaro with the knowledge his lawyer would broadcast them, attorney-client privilege might be waived.
The problem is that Marmaro’s press release, handled by pugnacious PR guy Sitrick, claimed that Reyes did not backdate options.  It was the old, “I’m innocent; I didn’t do it; It never happened,” defense.  No doubt it seemed like a good idea at the time, to deny everything.  Mind you, it didn’t help, since Reyes was convicted at his first trial, though the conviction was reversed for prosecutorial impropriety in the summation.

Reyes now has a new lawyer and a new trial about to start.  He also has a new defense.  He did it but there was nothing illegal about it.  Everybody knew about it, so there was no intent to defraud.  The only problem, now, is that the two positions are contradictory, and the government is taking the position that the original press release, where Marmaro attributed to Reyes the position that it never happened, constitutes a waiver of privilege.  The judge, while not yet agreeing, isn’t yet disagreeing either.  Oops.

To his credit, Richard Marmaro used a public relations guy to handle the media/crisis management aspect of the case.  Not to his credit, the public relations guy, Michael Sitrick, committed to a defense that now returns to bite Reyes, and his new attorneys, in the butt. 

There seems to be a significant possibility that the outcome of the government’s effort may show that the press release, revealing the defense, came not from the defendant but from the lawyer and/or PR guy, and therefore is a reflection of what they thought would be a really good approach rather than an admission by the defendant himself.  That won’t bode well for Marmaro or Sitrick, though Marmaro will bear the brunt of the problem if it turns out that way.  After all, he has a duty as an officer of the court not to manufacture a false affirmative position that’s attributed to his client and spewed out publicly.  The PR guy has no duty to be honest about anything.

Whether this falls under the outsourcing PR = outsourcing ethics rubric has yet to be seen, but one very simple question arises from the current mess.  Why can’t lawyers learn to just keep their mouths shut when there’s a camera or microphone shoved in their face if they have nothing good to say?

Bernie Kerik Gets His Full Term

I haven’t been much of a fan of former New York City mayoral chauffeur and almost-Homeland Security Czar, Bernard Kerik, who was never reluctant to use any disaster for self-aggrandizement.  But he copped his plea to a deal that gave him a guidelines sentence of 27 to 33 months.  Yesterday, he was sentenced to 4 years.



Under the terms of a plea agreement, the prosecution and the defense recommended that Judge Stephen C. Robinson sentence Mr. Kerik to 27 to 33 months in prison. But the judge departed from the sentencing recommendations, giving Mr. Kerik a longer sentence because he said he had betrayed the public’s trust.

“I think it’s fair to say that with great power comes great responsibility and great consequences,” Judge Robinson said. “I think the damage caused by Mr. Kerik is in some ways immeasurable.”
While I find myself surprised to write this, the additional 15 months above the top of the guidelines makes little sense.  It’s not as if the extra time will have any general deterrent impact on anyone holding, or seeking to hold, high office in law enforcement.  The conviction itself, and resultant ruination of his reputation and future, is as strong a deterrent as anyone in such a position will need to think twice, if they are so inclined.  And if they aren’t so inclined, 15 more months isn’t going to change them.

While the judge’s observation, that Kerik betrayed the public’s trust, is indisputable, that was a given from the plea itself.  This was incorporated in the plea, and had Bernie not been a high-flier in law enforcement, chances are essentially non-existent that he would have found himself in the dock to begin with.  The higher one flies, the farther the fall.  Bernie fell long and hard.

So the question is what about the consequences, the addition of 15 months over the guidelines sentence as spelled out in the plea agreement, served a legitimate sentencing function.  I don’t see anything.  The seems like piling on, and in a rather trivial way at that.  If Judge Robinson wanted to make a big point of it, add another 5 years to the sentence, not 15 months.  Sure, another 5 years would certainly seem to exceed that which was necessary to satisfy the requirements of 18 USC 3553, but then so does 15 months.

Had Bernie Kerik been sentenced to the top of the guidelines, the only commentary would have been to note that no one is entitled to the low end, and Bernie knew what he was facing when he signed off.  But this serves as a reminder when entering into a plea agreement, even one as heavily negotiated as this one must have been, that when it says that it does not bind the judge’s hand at sentence, it means it. 

As for Judge Robinson’s explanation for his upward departure, there’s no platitude that one can disagree with, and yet nothing that wasn’t obviously the case at the time of the plea.  If the court saw the guidelines sentence in the plea agreement as inadequate, that should have been made clear up front rather than leave the defendant open for ambush at sentence.  I understand Judge Robinson’s rationale, but it shouldn’t have come down that way.  Even Bernie Kerik deserves an appropriate sentence, and that sentence should have been no greater than the top of the guidelines.

There’s An App For That

Already, the blawgosphere is atwitter over the class action filed in Robbins v. Lower Merion School District, where an assistant principal at Harriton High School is alleged to have remotely activated the webcam on a student’s laptop and observed what is diplomatically called inappropriate behavior.  Above the Law has it covered from the salacious angle (calling “creeptastic”).  Volokh  Conspiracy takes a quick look at its legality, where Orin Kerr sees it as a clear 4th Amendment violation, though not unlawful under any statute.

Aside from the nasty implications of school administrators peeping into the bedrooms of coeds late at night, it dawned on me that we’ve barely scratched the surface of how computers, whether via webcam as here or other functions like voice recorder, can turn into a two-way mirror into aspects of our lives that were never meant to be seen by others. 

That this case arises in the context of a school administrator smacks of sloppiness. Had the assistant principal used the improperly obtained information with a bit more guile, perhaps the student would never have known where she got it.  The remote activation feature could have provided hours of information and amusement for years to come.

Lacking the depth of understanding of the capabilities of technology of others, I’m left to speculate.  But it seems fairly clear to me that webcams on laptop computers, already a fairly ubiquitous feature, has huge potential for a Brave New World that hasn’t received much thought as yet.  There doesn’t appear to be much question but that the technology exists to activate webcams from far away, and that anyone who has the key to the door will be able to do so.  Might that anybody be law enforcement?  Might that anybody already have the key, and already be watching?

The Lower Merion School District has responded to the allegations of the suit, stating that the remote activation feature is there as a security measure if laptops are stolen.  It would certainly be useful in that regard.  They further state that they won’t activate the feature again without the written permission of students and parents.  No reason to doubt them, now that they’ve had their hand smacked.  But even assuming they are as sincere as can be, and I’ve no reason to believe otherwise, does this mean that others won’t employ the feature to do a little extracurricular studying?

For techno-dinosaurs like me, the capabilities of electronic devices never cease to amaze.  Like everyone else, I enjoy the benefits of the latest, greatest advances, and marvel at the near daily miracles that technology brings into my home.  I do not, however, consider the implications of the untold uses and capabilities of each new device, each new application.  I suspect few others do either, limiting their attention to the shiny purpose of new toys rather than the nefarious uses to which it could be put.

I suspect we are surrounded by devices that can provide the government with an incredible amount of information about us, ranging from our whereabouts to what we wear to sleep at night.  And if we whisper to our spouse in bed with the computer nearby, they may well hear our words as well.  Even if this isn’t true today, how long before it will be true?

As with the Lower Merion School District, reliance on the government, whether local, federal or somewhere in between, to honor our privacy and never, but never, peak into our homes despite having the capability to do so, is not sufficiently heart-warming for my purposes.  Anybody out there trust the government that much?  Anybody out there trust each and every individual law enforcement officer to honor your privacy?  Come on. 

While I’ve advocated for a new approach to 4th Amendment protections, one that will avoid trying to shove new technology (round peg) into old law (square peg), this isn’t a legal problem as much as an unintended consequence of all the great benefits tech brings us.  We love our tech, but it’s an open window on our lives that allows any peeping LEO to look in at will.  Even if they sincerely promise that they would never do such a thing.