Author Archives: SHG

The Dirty Harry Syndrome

Doug Berman reports of a 10th Circuit decision reducing the sentences of $40 million Ponzi-schemers Norman Schmidt and Charles Lewis.


The district court properly calculated Schmidt’s guidelines sentencing range and he has not overcome the presumption of reasonableness of his within-guidelines 330-year sentence (which is reduced to 310 years by our setting aside his convictions on four counts).

What a bunch of softies, cutting sentences willy-nilly and letting these guys fall through the cracks.  Though as Doug notes:


I suspect that Schmidt won’t be too eager to celebrate the fact that his projected release date has now been moved up from the early fall of 2291 to the early fall of 2271. Indeed, because Schmidt is in his mid 70s, I would wager he won’t end up serving even one-tenth of his new sentence. Just leave it to a white-collar scoundrel to find a technicality like life expect any to ensure he never has to serve the bulk of his (apparently reasonable) prison sentence.

The point is that people perceive our system as unduly lenient, pro-defendant, soft on crime.  This despite the fact that sentences of multiple lifetimes are considered reasonable punishment for non-violent crimes.  I keep suggesting to white-collar defendants that they might as well kill a few of the people they don’t like while they’re at it, since it’s not like a few more years on the back end is going to hurt any.

What makes the American public see the system in such a bizarrely false way?  We’ve got more people, per capita and in real numbers, in prison than anywhere else on the planet, and still that’s not enough to sate the lust. 

Jonathon Simon at PrawfsBlawg attributes it to our glorious cinematic heritage.


[M]ost Americans still imagine our courts to be the leaky and lenient institutions they were (unfairly) depicted as being in 1970s backlash movies like Dirty Harry (1971). As our justice system comes instead increasingly to resemble the hardened core of the robotic killing machines in the Terminator series, our ability to set proper limits to our own quest for security is very much in question.

It’s clear from the comments here, mostly from non-lawyers, Texans and personal injury lawyers, that Dirty Harry remains very much in their thoughts.  Anger and revenge, exemplified by the desire to shoot people for walking on their lawn, as well as the desire to shoot people for posting on a blawg suggesting that they should not shoot people for walking on their lawn, prevail.  There’s a lot of anger out there.

It doesn’t appear that we will shake this misperception by logic or reason.  It’s not grounded in logic or reason, and no amount of cases to the contrary appear to change it.  While people may agree that a particular outcome is unjust, they are still stuck on the notion that the system as a whole is notoriously soft on crime.  The fact that our government, regardless of who sits in the big chair, feeds into this national psychosis for its own benefit, the maintenance of power and control through fear, doesn’t help, but it similarly doesn’t force people to stay with the program.  We can stop drinking the Kool-Aid anytime we want.  We just, apparently, don’t want to.

If Simon is right, there is only one thing to do.  Make a movie.  Where are the anti-Utopian movie makes, the Aldous Huxleys and George Orwells of this generation.  Get their agent to call James Cameron’s agent and put a deal together to create the movie that will change it all.  Forget Michael Moore.  We need a big movie, not some Indy puff piece about justice and a fat guy with a microphone.  Special Effects are critical. 

Until then, we can take hope from the 10th Circuit cutting 20 years off the back end of a 330 year sentence.  Break out the bubbly.  Reasonableness has been achieved.  Justice was done. 

The Trio of Doom




The credit goes to Bruce Carton, who read about the idea and liked it.  Since he’s now go the keys to Legal Blog Watch, it seemed like a natural.  The panel that Avvo let slip away would be his for the asking, and so Three Angry Lawyers became a reality.  Sorta.

Brian  Tannebaum, Mark Bennett and this curmudgeon, have each been critical of marketing and social media gurus, though not always in the same way or for the same reasons.  This will likely come as a surprise to some, who might have expected us to be on the same page about all of this.  More interestingly, by using this new-fangled webcast technology, those who have read our thoughts may enjoy putting faces, voices and real-time attitudes, to the words.

Here’s webcast. 





27CDB6E-AE6D-11cf-96B8-444553540000>



Here’s the back story. In preparation, the three of us emailed each other with such deep questions as “are we doing this?” to “does Greenfield even know what a webcam is?” This was truly a “seat of the pants” operation, with no idea where we would be starting or where it would go.

While the webcast shows the three of us, plus our intrepid host, I was unable to see either Bruce or Brian on my screen, and could barely hear them.  Bennett was visible, in a twisted, psychedelic acid-trip sort of way, which was disconcerting to say the least.  As the webcast was about to begin, Bennett figured out how to use the texting feature, and began sending me texts regarding Tannebaum’s physical appearance and attire (or lack thereof).  As I now know from the images, Tannebaum was wearing clothes and you can’t even see his fly, thus precluding any possibility of Bennett knowing whether it was properly closed.

I’m sure that younger lawyers would handled these texts in stride, being far more experienced with them than I am, but I was easily distracted by Bennett’s texts, not to mention his lurid descriptions.  Obviously, Bennett had no problem texting during the course of the webcast, demonstrating his strong multitasking and tech skills. 

Brian, in the meantime, had just finished his double Vente hi-test mocha latte frappucino, and was amped up for the show.  What some of you may not know is that we have a long history of baiting Brian, who has a slight tendency toward the sarcastic.  It’s all in good fun between us, and so no one takes the mocking as real.  In fact, this was about the nicest we’ve ever been toward each other.  It was downright calm compared to our usual exchanges.

Unfortunately, we never really focused on a particular issue and addressed anything with nuance or depth.  It was all very superficial, which I attribute to the awkwardness of the medium and the brevity of the webcast.  Had we chosen a specific subject up front, we might have dealt with it in a more fruitful fashion.  The synergy that might be expected from having the three of us in the same room wasn’t there when we were talking at a picture (or a black square) on our computer screens.  As substance goes, however, this webcast failed to satisfy.

It was fun to play with the guys.  And it would be a lot more fun to do it again, but next time with a better plan and more of an opportunity to have a deeper discussion.  In the meantime, we learned two very important things.  First, that Tannebaum buys shoes off the internet.  Second, that we need to make sure Tannebaum has a beer beforehand rather than spend his morning at Starbucks on his laptop sucking up those mocha frappucino lattes.

One Little Smack

Deborah McGraw, the victim of a petty larceny, expressed the perfectly natural desire to give the alleged perp, Dallas Jarrett, a good smack.  Just one would do, and then they would be square as far as she was concerned.  Kanawha County prosecutor Stewart Altmeyer conveyed the offer, jokingly perhaps, to drop the charges in exchange for a smack.  Jarrett agreed.  Oh boy.

From the Charleston Gazette :

According to [Kanawha County Prosecutor Mark] Plants, Altmeyer jokingly conveyed the victim’s suggestion to Jarrett and his lawyer. Jarrett was represented by assistant public defender Katherine Kessell, according to court records.

Jarrett and his lawyer accepted the offer, Plants said.

“Although the victim was happy with the outcome, this result is just unacceptable,” Plants said. “The Legislature does not allow for physical contact as a form of punishment, and even if it did, a judge would have to make that decision, not a prosecutor.”

Turns out, the joke was on Altmeyer, who has been suspended without pay for one month, and will have this follow him around forever.

While “alternative” sentence options have presented problems before, this one is particularly curious in that the proposition was to dismiss the charges, leaving Jarrett free to go about his life as if nothing happened, in exchange for a smack.  He agreed to it. His lawyer agreed to it.  The victim agreed to it.  No judge involved.  While the situation is not significantly different than that in Bedford County, Pennsylvania, where two women were forced to stand outside the courthouse with signs saying that they stole money from a 9 year old on her birthday, in order to get the prosecutor to recommend probation, it somehow has a different feel to it.

Clearly, a good smack by the victim isn’t one of the potential sentences available for the offense.  While a victim may ask for it, Altmeyer had no authority to offer it in exchange for dismissing the charge.  Legally, it was very wrong.

But something strikes me as imperfect about the analogy.  That corporal punishment isn’t part of the sentencing structure seems disingenuous.  If a person is put to death for a crime, how bad can a smack be?  It may not be painless, but it’s quick and then it’s over.  Everyone goes home reasonably happy.  There’s no sense about this case that the prosecutor applied undue pressure to coerce the defendant into agreeing to the smack.  This wasn’t rammed down his throat.  Everyone was amendable to the resolution.

In trying to find a conceptual ledge to hang on to, to differentiate the wrong of a non-permitted punishment from the right, the best I can come up with is that the Bedford case appeared to be highly coercive while this case seems to have left everybody satisfied.  But that hardly seems to be a sufficient rational basis to justify why one seems so wrong while the other, not so much.

And yet, this smack doesn’t strike me as such a bad way to resolve the case.

“A Broad Range of Experience”

That’s how Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer describes the background of the man he proposes be appointed to the Second Circuit seat formerly held by Sonia Sotomayor.  Raymond Lohiar is currently the Chief of the Securities and Commodities Fraud Task Force in the Southern District of New York, a position he’s held for less than a year, having risen through the ranks.

From the WSJ Law Blog :

Out of law school, Lohier (Harvard, NYU Law) clerked for U.S. District Judge Robert Patterson, then spent a few years at Cleary Gottlieb before joining the U.S. attorney’s office in 2000. In his time there, Lohier also served as deputy chief and chief of the Narcotics Unit.

With this resume, Schumer offers very high praise:


“Mr. Lohier is not only a highly qualified candidate for the Second Circuit and a lawyer whose views have been tempered by a broad range of experiences, but, as a proud Haitian American, he is a candidate who would enhance the diversity of the federal bench.”
I don’t know Raymond Lohiar personally.  I’ve never had a case with him and, frankly, can’t recall any discussion of him by anyone who has.  I’m not inclined to question whether he’s a brilliant lawyer, nor am I particularly disturbed that he’s being offered for an appeals court, rather than start at the bottom (so to speak). 

But the obvious implication of Senator Schumer’s statement is that the Lohiar comes to the nomination with one asset that distinguishes him, his Haitian ancestry.  For obvious reasons, Haiti is in vogue these days.  That Schumer felt compelled to mention this is almost insulting to Lohiar, who I would suspect thinks the appointment would be wonderful, but would hope to have some greater attributes than his heritage to commend him.  This is so quintessential Schumer, and unfortunately, Democrat.

The rest of the story, I am sorry to say, is similarly stereotypical.  Raymond Lohiar’s “broad range of experience” is a few years as a Biglaw associate and the rest as a prosecutor.  He’s never held the hand of a client as the client makes the most difficult decision of his life.  He’s never seen the destruction the law can wreak on a family.  He’s never gotten to really know good people who make bad mistakes.  These are the things that temper a judge’s view.

Will any politician look beyond the safety and impressiveness of governmental titles when selecting someone who will sit on the bench for the next 40-50 years?  But this isn’t just an “any politician” situation; This is a Democratic President with a Democratic almost-super majority in the Senate.  And they are building a judiciary that would make any Republican administration proud.

The politics are easy to understand.  A smooth ride through the Senate and another hole filled.  Diversity trumps philosophy and real breadth of experience.  But if the Obama administration can’t find a qualified person whose career includes the recognition that the law can be the problem, the police aren’t always our saviors, that order and safety come at the expense of freedom, who will?

I’m sure that Raymond Lohiar will make a fine judge.  Whether he will be the fine judge that we hoped would come from a Democratic administration, with the sensibilities that come from a range of experience that might include some hard time in the trenches as, oh, a criminal defense lawyer, is another thing.  It appears that no one, Democrat or Republican, is particularly interested in having those sensibilities reflected in their diverse judiciary. 

No, the “hopey, changey thing” isn’t working for me yet either. 

Words of Consent

Over at Volokh Conspiracy, Orin Kerr posts about a decision, State v. Meekins, 2009 WL 4876866 (Tex.App.-Amarillo 2009). where the validity of a consent search is ultimately determined based on the nuance of language.


A police officer stops a driver named Williams for a traffic violation. After checking out his driver’s license, the officer asks the driver for consent to search the car:

That solicitation continued over a period of about a minute and included approximately six requests. The officer asked that many times because appellant would not commit one way or the other. Indeed, captured on the video of the event was the officer informing appellant that he was being asked a “yes or no” question. Furthermore, the last request propounded to appellant consisted of Williams asking: “Do you mind if I look?” To it, appellant answered “yes,” according to the officer. Upon so replying, appellant was ordered to exit the car.  

Held: The car cannot be searched, as this exchange cannot satisfy the standard of clear and convincing evidence Texas law requires to prove that consent to search was freely and voluntarily given.


The problem, of course, is that the answer “yes” to a “do you mind” question is a negative rather than a positive under the ordinary rules of construction.  Apparently, this rule applies in Texas as well as the United States. 

My impression is that Orin see this decision as a curiosity, a decision of interest.  I see it as a brutal reminder of the failure of testimonial evidence by police officers at suppression hearings.  What distinguished this case was that the officer’s words were captured on video.  Absent video, this is how the testimony on cross-examination would have gone:


Officer:  I asked the defendant for consent to search his car and he gave it to me.

Defense Attorney:  You don’t recall the exact words you used?

Officer: I said, “do you consent to my searching your car,” and he said “yes”.

Defense Attorney:  You didn’t say “do you mind if I look?”

Prosecutor:  Objection, asked and answered.

Judge: Overruled. Answer the question.

Officer: I said “do you consent” and he said “yes”. just like I already told you.

Defense Attorney: Nothing further.
How do I know what the testimony would be?  Because I’ve heard it too many times.  And there’s not a thing that can be done about.  Without any means of proving the words, the exchange, the scene, we are left to the police officer’s description of what transpired between him and the defendant.  And you can bet that it’s going to be presented as a fait accompli.  Aside from the rarest of instances, where an officer takes the stand and testifies to an exchange that actually involves the potential for a real exchange, there is no question that can be asked that will elicit anything other than the officer’s conclusory testimony.

The only way to challenge this testimony is to put the defendant on the stand for a swearing contest.  The hope, if you can call it that, is that a judge might be inclined to believe that defense counsel wouldn’t be so foolish as to expose his client to cross-examination unless it was worth it, that the testimony is true.  While this can happen, it’s still a long shot.  A very long shot.  Few judges will take the chance of siding against the cops.  They almost always go with the odds.

These hearings often do grave harm to a lawyer’s forearm.  That’s because the defendants, hearing the officer’s testimony, grab hold and squeeze.  They squeeze tightly.  The blood stops circulating.  Tingling begins, and then fades as the hand becomes lifeless.  It’s amazing how strong the grasp of a person who forced to sit silently as a cop lie on the stand can be. 

One might suppose that the colorless, flavorless, unnatural exchange offered by the officer’s testimony might cause a judge of reasonable intelligence and experience to question whether the testimony is factual or conclusory.  No cop has ever asked “do you consent?”  It’s invariably a game, where the players use such ploys as “you must be hiding something” and “I’ll be happy to get a warrant.”  And yet, the testimony comes out the same at the suppression hearing no matter how many times its presented as a conclusion.

So where do we learn that real life doesn’t mirror the police officer’s testimony?  From the rare video, for one.  From witnesses, especially neutral witnesses when the officer mistakenly allowed people to be close enough to hear his words, for another.  Unfortunately, neither of these scenarios happens frequently enough to alter the regular testimony or make the judge wonder whether he’s backing the wrong horse.  Most of the time, it’s just the cop and the defendant.  Who you going to believe?

It’s heartening to read about the decision, where the court parsed the language to recognize that the vagaries of a question fail to satisfy the requirement of demonstrating free and voluntary consent.  It might have been more heartening had the court never reached the 6th attempt by the officer to obtain consent, the 5 prior failures to give it being more than sufficient to demonstrate that the defendant did not wish to consent, and that the continued pressure by the cop to get him to submit to the shield vitiated any possibility of free and voluntary consent.  But I will take a good decision as it comes, even if it could have been better.

It’s disheartening, however, to think of the vast majority of suppression decisions where there was no video recording of the words spoken, and where suppression is denied based on the conclusory testimony of the officer.  This one win only highlights the thousands of losses where there’s no video, and courts happily defer to the facile testimony of the officer when denying that any constitutional violation occurred.

Popularity and the Price of Teacups (Update)

This has nothing to do with real popularity, but with the pseudo-popularity that comes with the attendant “benefits” of things happening with a blawg, or a blawger, that aren’t anticipated.  Whether it’s being sued by a dog-shooter because you’re viewed as the easiest mark around, or praised at the Association of Professional Responsibility Lawyers Conference for highlighting impropriety, you never know what the day will bring.

I received two surprises yesterday.  The first one, via Mark Bennett, was that there was a new scraper in town.  This one called himself , with the URL of expert-legal-advice dot com.  No name is mentioned at the website, but the Whois reports that its run by Phillip Vadala out of Sydney, Australia. 

The site offers blurbs from a mere seven legal blogs, Above the Law, How Appealing, Life at the Bar, SCOTUSBlog, Volokh Conspiracy, WSJ Law Blog and Simple Justice.  Click through to read the full story, and you’ll find the complete image of the blawg, from title bar to side bar, post included.  Except it’s not the blawg.  It’s copied onto an expert-legal-advice URL.  Yet another entrepreneur who is of the view that the content created by others is a great thing to sell, much like the USLaw dot com scam before it.  Only this time, there’s a mere seven blawgs being scraped. 

Despite my having sent a very nice email over to explain that a business model based upon stealing content from others isn’t really a good thing, it’s still there.  Maybe the Wall Street Journal will do some heavy lifting this time around. [Update: I’ve heard from Phillip, who was unaware that scraping was wrong, and, in a very cooperative fashion, agreed to remove the full posts from his website and link back to the original posts instead.]

Then I learned from a commenter that there’s a forum called JD Underground, which apparently is a website for young lawyers to complain to each other about the misery of their lives and the law.  For anyone who still doubts the existence of the Slackoisie, this is living proof.  It’s Slackoisie Central.

The commenter asked whether I was aware of a discussion about me over there.  About me?  Why the heck would these kids want to talk about me?  Well, for whatever reason, they did, and there was a thread at the forum called Is scott greenfield a JDU poster?

While I’m honored, in a peculiar way, that these young lawyers care enough about what an old lawyer has to say to even ask the question, but I’m afraid that the answer is no.  The thread itself is disheartening.  So many fragile little teacups with so little understanding.  As another commenter here asked, was I upset that they were calling me “mean” rather than curmudgeon?  Well, it wasn’t my first choice, but if that’s the way my views are perceived, there isn’t much I can (or care to) do about it.

I understand only too well that young lawyers are characterized by narcissism and entitlement, that they grew up in a world without criticism and therefore see anything critical as mean and bitter.  It’s sad that they can’t connect the dots, that the misery they complain of may have a little something to do with their facile external excuses for all the failure and disappointment of their brief lives.  But they can call me any names they like.  Maybe the discussion, superficial and immature though it may be, will eventually have an impact on one of them and they’ll stop whining and starting doing something to improve their lot.  It’s a stretch, but it could happen.

The point of all this is to contrast the experience of a somewhat more experienced blawger with the new ones who, like my fragile teacups at JD Underground, cry, lash out or run walk away when they aren’t met with appreciation and warmth.  It’s not just you.  You aren’t special, singled out because you are new to the blawgosphere and beaten to a pulp by the old guys.  It’s all of us.  Me and you.  We are all subject to the scrutiny, whether we’ve been here for years or minutes.  And those who can’t take it won’t make it.

Over at WindyPundit, Mark wrote a tongue-in-cheek post the other day following my effort to explain to new blawgers that their marketing patrons were less than forthright when they induced them to start a blawg and rake in the bucks.  The title of his post is Surviving Scott Greenfield, an homage of sorts.  If I was inclined to be concerned about maintaining a carefully crafted internet persona, I might be troubled by being named the poster boy for maligning new bloggers.  But I’m not.  Windy offered 8 pieces of advice, and it well serves new blawgers to read them.  That I was used as the vehicle to make a larger point is how the deal works.  I write stuff and it provides the fodder for others. 

No one in the blawgosphere is immune or above either criticism, disagreement or commentary.  We are all the fodder for each other’s posts because ideas feed on themselves. That’s how it should be.  I am quite content suffering the slings and arrows, as well as shooting off a few of my own when it seems appropriate.  I don’t cry about it.  I don’t whine about it.  And, frankly, it’s far better that some Slackoisie think of me as a grumpy old meanie than not think at all.

For crying out loud, you little teacups, suck it up, write what you think and buck up for the storm that may blow your way.  It’s either that or run away.  Knowing that the storm can strike at any moment will push you to think a little harder, write a little better and contribute something a lot more worthwhile than the crap that masqueraded as ideas up to now when you chatted amongst your Slackoisie pals and thought you were solving the problems of the world by blaming everyone out there but yourselves.  Take a stand and then prepare for the worst.  Stop being a teacup.

Suing The Blogger, Low Hanging Fruit

It was covered all over the mainstream media.  The video was on Youtube.  A petition circulated across the internet calling for the shooter to be prosecuted, with more than 5400 people signing on.  This all happened because Christopher Comins tried to kill two dogs by shooting them at point blank range.  Fortunately, Comins has lousy aim and dogs lived.

So what does a shooter do when he’s caught on video and properly castigated everywhere?  He sues a blogger.

Matthew Frederick VanVoorhis has a blog called Public Intellectual, where he posted about Comins’ dog-shooting.  The title is Christopher Comins: Barbarian Hillbilly Dog-Assassin (w/Friends in High places). My guess is that Comins objected to being called a Hillbilly.  I bet Hillbillies objected to being associated with Comins.

The post is harsh.  Then again, trying to murder dogs, especially when the owner is screaming to stop and you’re close enough to see the collar around their necks, deserves some harsh words.  But Comins is a businessman.  He’s got both the wherewithal and motivation to make somebody pay for his getting caught.


Christopher Comins owns CustomFab, which builds special steel-pipe products for Walt Disney World and NASA. Moreover, Comins and Carter attend prayer groups with Orange County Mayor Rich Crotty (in fact, Carter and Mayor Crotty have made the news before for shady land deals). Crotty was appointed Mayor by Jeb Bush in 2001. Additionally, Comins has generously funded the Bush administration. In short, Comins is in bed with a group of folks who know how to get away with stuff. And it shows.
That somebody is VanVoorhis.  Given the scope and breadth of the attacks on Comins for his dog-shooting, only one rational explanation surfaces to explain why he picked VanVoorhis to sue for defamation.  He’s the easiest target.

Like most bloggers (as opposed to blawgers, for whom this doesn’t necessarily apply), writing is a not-for-profit venture.  We’re not talking 501(c)(3), but that there’s no money in it and VanVoorhis blogs because he chooses this medium to express himself.  It’s pure blogging, with no ulterior purpose beyond speaking one’s mind.  That makes VanVoorhis an easy target.

Now that Comins has picked him to sue, the burden falls on the bloggers shoulders to defend himself, to pay the freight to exercising free speech.  It’s the American way. Any dog-shooter with cash can sue any poor schnook who wrote about him that he wants.  After all, how many bloggers want to dump a pile of money, assuming they have pile to spare, into a defense against some crazed, but better funded, hillbilly NASA contractor.

But the news isn’t all bad for VanVoorhis.  He’s defended by one of the most vigorous and brilliant free speech on the internet lawyers around, Marc Randazza.  And Randazza isn’t satisfied to just defend a blogger’s right to free speech and fair use.  He’s going after the dog-shooter as well. 

Maybe the poor blogger isn’t quite the low hanging fruit that the dog-shooter thought he was?  Maybe, as long as there are lawyers like Randazza around.  Maybe, to the extent that anyone around the broader blogosphere isn’t aware that Christopher Comins is a dog-shooter, they will be soon because he’s decided to attack a blogger for going after him for being a dog-shooter.  Wouldn’t that be a shame?

Refer Or Recommend: The Total Attorneys Loophole

Almost immediately after  the decision issued granting dismissal of disciplinary charges against the Connecticut 5, Total Attorneys issued a press release proclaiming that the Connecticut Statewide Grievance Committee “validated” its internet advertising model.

Total Attorneys President Kevin Chern says that Connecticut has truly vindicated the company’s Internet advertising model.  “The Committee heard evidence from the state’s Chief Disciplinary Counsel and examined our business model,” he said.  “After carefully considering how consumers reach our sites, what information is collected, how territories are divided and the disclaimers provided for consumers, the Committee determined that we are not recommending attorneys but simply providing advertising.”

While I’m happy for the five lawyers who stood as scapegoats for Total Attorneys, Chern’s proclamation of validation is not merely premature but disingenuous.  So what is it that they did?

Total Attorneys is one of the magic bullet websites that allows lawyers in specific niches to “purchase” territory.  TA works Google to gain prominent page rank so that potential clients go to its websites when they are searching for a lawyer.  The clients put in their zip code and are sent to the lawyer who owns that turf.  In TA lingo, these clients are called “leads”, and the lawyer pays TA $65 for every lead who contacts them, whether they are retained or not.

The decision was based on the distinction between a referral and a recommendation.  The grievance committee found that clients were referred, but not recommended, and hence there was no violation of their disciplinary rules because the rules are limited to recommendations rather than referrals.  That’s one thin reed.

To reach this conclusion, the committee relied largely upon a disclaimer on Total Attorneys’ website claiming that this was not a recommendation.  Disciplinary counsel argued that when one, and only one, lawyer’s name comes up to an inquiring consumer, that’s tantamount to a recommendation.  The committee said no.

The decision states that “territorial exclusivity of the arrangement was not an implied endorsement and that the fees charged . . . were the appropriate costs of advertising on the website.”  The former position is dubious at best.  The latter is facially wrong.

When a potential client asks for the names of lawyers who serve a particular niche, and in return receives one, and only one, name, there can be no clearer message.  This is the lawyer to use.  This one lawyer, because they’ve only been given one lawyer.  No one tells the client that the reason is that the lawyer bought his territory.  There’s no mention of that nasty little detail.  If there was, I suspect clients would run the other way as fast as they could, recognizing how deceptive and manipulative this recommendation referral was.

But to equate paying $65 per lead to the sharing of advertising costs is absurd.  Costs are fixed.  Leads are variable.  To argue otherwise is nonsense.  To believe otherwise is just plain wrong.  The business model of Total Attorneys is to sell “leads,” those nice people who lawyers are supposed to think of as their respected clients.

While Kevin Chern’s claim of “validation” may be seriously overwrought, it’s true that the Total Attorneys advertising model wasn’t condemned.  That being so, buying up some turf from TA (and getting a free pass to the Get A Life Conference) may not result in having your ticket yanked.  But that doesn’t mean that any lawyer with a semblance of integrity or honor can now hook up with TA with a clear conscience.

There are a wealth of opportunities on the internet to engage in conduct that has the potential to bring in a few bucks, at the cost of your integrity.  Some think that words like integrity, not to mention honor, professionalism and excellence, are only used by us dinosaurs.  Bottom feeders are always looking for the get rich quick scheme.  The Slackoisie believe that the practice of law is all about what’s in it for them.  It’s up to each of us to decide what type of lawyer we want to be.  Not just our particular niche of the law, but whether we will do anything for a buck, no matter how slimy or disreputable. 

Just because the Connecticut grievance committee didn’t rule against the five doesn’t mean that we need to race to the bottom.  It’s up to each of us to select our path, high or low.

H/T Kevin O’Keefe

David DeCosta, Unsmeared

When news of his arrest hit the papers, it was a different time.  It was only about three months ago, but a lot has happened during those three months.  And Phoenix criminal defense lawyer David DeCosta, those were probably the longest three of his life.

Matt Brown was the first to post about DeCosta’s arrest for bringing drugs into the prison, allegedly to give them to his “Mexican Mafia” client.  As we now know, they like using descriptions like “Mexican Mafia” around Maricopa County.  It makes them sound particularly evil and menacing. And foreign.  The Mexican part is more damning than the Mafia part.

Matt, a young but tough criminal defense lawyer, got ripped by fellow criminal defense lawyers for posting about DeCosta’s arrest.  He was slammed hard for not writing about how DeCosta was innocent, how the allegations were lies, how he relied on a report from the Arizona Republic rather than investigate all the facts on his own.  Mind you, none of his detractors provided comments showing the merit of their claims.  Their only purpose was to go after Matt for commenting on a story in the paper, one that was quite similar to another criminal defense lawyer, Jason Keller, who had pleaded guilty to the crime.

But the poor showing by the locals in their attacks on Matt opened another door, one that spread nearly viral across the internet, about how the rest of us didn’t grasp just how bad Sheriff Joe Arpaio was.  While we knew about Crazy Joe, they were right.  We didn’t grasp the depth of the problem.  On the other hand, they didn’t grasp the depth of their misdirected anger.  Without this level of anger, however, there’s a good chance that the situation in Maricopa County would not have had the staying power to grab and hold the attention of so many blawgers and others across the country. Silver lining to the cloud.

After that, there’s been the Adam Stoddard debacle. The Judge Donahoe indictment.  The lawyer rally and the federal grand jury investigation of Crazy Joe and more.  It’s been a very busy few months in Maricopa County.

And now the Arizona Republic reports that charges against Phoenix criminal defense lawyer, David DeCosta, have been dismissed.



Charges were dropped Monday against a defense attorney accused of trying to smuggle drugs to a jail inmate believed to be affiliated with the Mexican Mafia prison gang.

David DeCosta, 43, was charged with promoting prison contraband, conspiracy to promote prison contraband, two drug counts and assisting a criminal street gang after a Maricopa County Sheriff’s deputy claimed he caught him trying to pass drugs stapled inside a legal pad to a client he was representing in a court hearing.

To avoid the appearance of conflict of interest, the case was prosecuted by the Pinal County Attorney’s Office before Navajo County Superior Court Judge Thomas Wing.

According to a spokesman for the Pinal County Attorney’s Office, the charges were dropped without prejudice for lack of evidence, which means they can be filed again if further evidence emerges.
Ignore the end of the last sentence, reflecting mere poor reporting and a dumb as dirt reporter who doesn’t understand that cases dismissed before jeopardy attaches are inherently “without prejudice,” not because there’s any expectation that new evidence might emerge.  It was a gratuitous, and dopey, inclusion that marred an otherwise triumphant report. 

Lack of evidence means that they can’t even manufacture a case against DeCosta.  No doubt Maricopa County Attorney Andy Thomas would have done everything in his power to make sure that the charges stuck.  It may have helped that the case was prosecuted by the Pinal County prosecutor, as the surrounding counties appear to have had enough of the Maricopa craziness.  They aren’t inclined to be party to Crazy Joe and his pet Andy’s rampant impropriety these days.

The nightmare is over for David DeCosta.  But dismissal isn’t enough.  The charges smeared him, and it was wrong that his name should ever be associated with the crime for which he was accused.  He committed no crime.  He did nothing wrong, except maybe his job too well.  In Maricopa County, defending those accused of crimes is an offense against Arpaio.  Of these, DeCosta is guilty.

It would be foolish to suggest that things have righted themselves in Maricopa County.  There’s still an enormous amount to do before anything close to that can be said.  But one thing is now righted, and that’s the vindication of David DeCosta.  While it’s small comfort to DeCosta, his arrest started a ball rolling that may lead to the end of Crazy Joe’s reign of terror on Maricopa County.

To the extent that the blawgosphere spread word of the false charges against DeCosta and contributed to the pain he endured, the very least I can do is spread the word of his innocence as clearly and loudly.  Criminal defense lawyer David DeCosta is innocent of all charges and was wrongly accused.  If this overstates the significance of dismissal, that’s fine with me.  It’s far easier to allege a crime and wrongly smear someone than unsmear the innocent.