Author Archives: SHG

The No-Fly List, A Brief History

Given the attention paid these days to the “no-fly” list, it seemed worthwhile to note Jeffrey Kahn’s Very Brief History over at Co-Op.


On September 10, 2001, this incipient no-fly list had about 20 names on it.  By comparison, the State Department’s TIPOFF watchlist (created in 1987 to track known or suspected terrorists of all stripes, colors, and modi operandi), had about 61,000 names on it.  This discrepancy positively outraged several members of the 9/11 Commission.  In a rather harsh cross-examination in early 2004, several commissioners jumped on this numerical disparity between tens of thousands of people that the State Department suspected to be bad enough to deny a visa, and the dozen or so that the FAA suspected were about to try to blow up an airplane.

And so, things changed:

By that time, however, the list had expanded rapidly.  And with this numerical expansion, the list’s intended purpose broadened as well.  The No-Fly List — an actual list now known by that name had been created to replace the piecemeal system of FAA Security Directives as new agencies like the TSA were formed — was no longer to be a protection only against concrete threats to particular planes or routes (although this obviously remained a core purpose).  The list was now conceived to serve other purposes, too. 

Bet you didn’t see that coming. 


[A]ccording to recent congressional testimony, the No-Fly List includes only about 170 U.S. persons out of a total of approximately 3,400 individuals), the actual constitutional protection for that abstract concept is rather narrow and not particularly modern in its origins.  It is black-letter law, and has been for some time, that although the right to travel is generally protected in our society, there is no right to travel by any particular mode of transportation.
For all those curious about how we slide down the slippery slope, read Jeffrey’s post and his follow ups. 

The Nuts and Bolts, Awake On Trial

Norm Pattis writes about the little details that play a significant role in a defendant’s life on trial, such as getting the defendant to court and back in reasonable condition to assist in his own defense. 


My client is housed in a correctional institution about a ninety minute drive from the courthouse. Trial begins each day at 10:00 a.m. So to arrive at the courthouse in time, the man is awoken at 3 a.m., transported from one location to another in the state’s penal system, and then deposited, exhausted, at the courthouse around 9:30 or so. He is exhausted because the ride back from court each night is just as circuitous as the ride to court. He routinely arrives back at his institution each night at 11 p.m. or so. The other day, he did not get back until 1:00 a.m.
Impossible for any human being to focus, help, just stay awake, under these conditions.  Obviously, the trial is important to the defendant, maybe one of the most important things in his life, and the logistics make it essentially impossible for him to be sufficiently alert to know what’s happening, no less assist.

And the judge won’t do anything about it.  Not for lack of sympathy about the situation, nor for agreement that its wrong, but because of the unwritten rule that judges don’t tell corrections what to do. No matter what.

Norm doesn’t understand why.  I don’t understand why. I never have.  But it’s always been this way.  Norm attributes it to a failure of the separation of powers.  From a technical sense, he’s obviously correct, but it fails to explain what happens in a judge’s head when he’s charged with safeguarding a defendant’s rights, agrees that he has the right to be awake during his trial, yet refuses to take action to make that happen.  There’s a tension underlying the nuts and bolts operation that has never been adequately explained.  Naturally, the defendant is the one who suffers for it.  Both Norm and the judge get as good a night’s sleep as their personal constitution’s allow.

And if you think that others might agree about how essentially unfair and wrong it is to deny a defendant, for the brief period of time that he’s on trial, the ability to be present, to be awake, to be able to assist, Norm follows up with the public comments to a story about his client.

Forget about people caring that a defendant on trial be allowed to get some sleep.  He’s lucky they don’t just lynch him.

David Lat: The Cheap Chocoholic (Update)

From Randy Cohen’s Ethicist column in tomorrow’s New York Times Magazine:


When I checked into a hotel in California, I was starving, so I ate the $6 box of Oreos from the minibar.  Later that day, I walked down the street to a convenience store, bought an identical box for $2.50 and replenished the minibar before the hotel had a chance to restock it.  Was this proper?  My view is “no harm, no foul.”  In fact, my box was fresher; the Oreos I ate were going to expire three months before the box I replaced them with.

-DAVID LAT, NEW YORK

Hmmm.  David Lat.  David Lat.  Where have I seen that name before.

Cohen’s view, of course, is that this conduct is reprehensibly wrong.



The hotel is providing not just a product but also a service — the convenience of having Oreos available in your room, 24/7. To create this utopia of constant confectionery access, the hotel had to pay someone to travel the world and select the finest vintage cookies, order the Oreos and stock the minibar. You enjoyed that service; you must pay the (ridiculously high) price.
Of course, Cohen neglects to take into account the value of Lat’s service of going to the store to replenish the almost-stale Oreos.  Or maybe not.

David Lat.  That name sounds so familiar.

Update:  Lat confesses.




Maricopa’s Andrew Thomas; Still Crazy After All These Years

We’ve become painfully aware of Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s butt boil, prosecutor Andrew Thomas, rounding up the judges and local officials as part of their quest to wipe out the conspiracy of evil bent on criticizing Crazy Joe.  One might surmise that Thomas, being a wily scoundrel, is a late-comer to the cause, hitching his wagon to Crazy Joe and enjoying the ride.

Not so.  In fact, Andrew Thomas comes by his position honestly, as we learn from this Walter Olson (now of Overlawyered fame) article in Reason from the last century (July, 1997 issue):


Brace yourself: The root cause of everything from street muggings and gang delinquency to rudeness at traffic lights to excessive lawsuit filing has finally been found, and it’s…libertarianism. At least that’s the view of Andrew Peyton Thomas, an attorney with the state of Arizona and a frequent contributor to conservative magazines.

He blames crime, rudeness, and litigiousness on the “live-and-let-live urban lifestyle” as spawned by “the moral laissez-faire disorder of libertarianism.”

Mr. Thomas, author of Crime and the Roots of Order, has made a momentous discovery: “The root of our crime problem,” as he informed Standard readers on March 17 of this year, “is a rights-happy radical individualism.”
And you thought Libertarians were only responsible for questionable fashion choices at political rallies and interesting blog posts.

There’s not much more to say about this, except that Walter called out Thomas more than a decade ago, and the people of Maricopa County are still bearing the brunt of this arch-enemy of “rights-happy radical individualism.”  I thought you ought to know.

Let Me Call You Sweetheart

The Second Circuit finally found a condition of supervised release it didn’t like in United States v. Reeves.  Via Eugene Volokh,


This appeal requires us to consider the validity of a condition of supervised release [following a prison term for possessing child pornography] that obligated Reeves, upon entry into a “significant romantic relationship,” to notify the United States Probation Department and to inform the other party to the relationship of his conviction. We conclude that the condition is unduly vague and not “reasonably necessary” to achieve the objectives of 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a)(2)….
The court easily disposed of the fact that no person of reasonable intelligence has a clue what “significant romantic relationship” means, and the technical aspects of its inclusion in the formal judgment but never having been raised during the sentence.  Similarly, given the facts of the case, where the defendant was initially investigated for the theft of social security funds, which resulted in finding a cache of child pornography (bet you didn’t know that theft of social security funds is a gateway crime for kiddie porn), that the condition failed to bear even an arguable relationship to any legitimate sentencing objective.  Eugene discusses these issues fully, and no need to revisit them here.

But this decision does open the door to consideration of the conditions of supervised release that both extend into the ordinary affairs of people, as well as give unfettered discretion to probation officers to make demands on their charges upon pain of violation.  For the judge imposing the condition, it may be a significant and deliberately imposed restriction, included with the best of intentions.  But who decides?

Consider, for example, a rather typical condition of supervised release (or probation), that the defendant receive therapy if the probation officer believes it appropriate.  Are probation officers competent to diagnose defendants?  Yet they are placed in a position to command that a defendant receive psychiatric treatment, including revealing his inner thoughts or being medicated.  If the defendant fails to do so, whether because he lacks the financial ability to comply or disagrees with the need, he risks being violated for the mere disobedience to the command and further incarceration.

Given the current obsession with sex offenders, and particularly the public’s disdain for any rights (including associational) they may have, the inclusion of a condition (such as the one by EDNY Judge Nicholas Garaufis in Reeves) doesn’t seem terribly surprising.  Granted it was done in a particularly flippant manner, in that it was neither requested by the government nor subject to due process at the sentence, but even if it had been raised during sentence and the defense was given the opportunity to challenge it, it might well have been imposed nonetheless. 

The language of the condition suggests that Judge Garaufis sought to limit the bleeding somewhat.  It only applied to significant romantic relationships.  By making it conditional, the court made it unconstitutionally vague.  So would it have been acceptable if the condition included all romantic relationships?  Still too vague.  What about any relationship involving any sexual contact whatsoever?  Aside from President Clinton, this doesn’t seem too vague for a person of reasonable intelligence to comprehend.  Even a probation officer should be able to determine compliance (assuming he’s got some way to figure out who the defendant is courting).

If the kiddie porn collector, even one who had otherwise never laid hands on a child or had any cognizable psychological impulse to do so, became involved with my daughter, you can bet that I would want to know.  And you can similarly bet that I would, supervised release condition or not.  It’s just how I roll.

If the logic holds true, that anyone who has a conviction that might raise a concern for someone with whom they subsequently start a romantic relationship, then shouldn’t notification become a standard condition of release?  But if that so, then we are branding them with the scarlet letter, and we are effectively precluding them from establishing relationships following a conviction by forcing them to “disclose” their wrong-doing at a time when its abundantly likely to be premature, to kill the opportunity to establish the type of trust and feeling that might cause a person to trust another despite having been convicted of a crime.

If a person on supervised release harms someone, and particularly if the person is convicted of a crime relating to sex and children, and the harm is to a child, I would anticipate the townspeople storming the courthouse, pitchforks and torches in hand.  Should there be a condition of disclosure?  And if so, should it be left to probation officers to decide if, when, how?  It’s a disastrous recipe, but it’s not entirely crazy either.

Criticism, A “Far Left Conspiracy”

John Dozier is a very accomplished lawyer.   He tell us so right in .


John W. Dozier, Jr., Esq., Internet Lawyer, President of Dozier Internet Law PC (PEER ratings: “AV” by Martindale Hubbell (Internet Lawyer), “Legal Elite in Intellectual Property” by Virginia Business Magazine and Virginia Bar Association, “SuperLawyer” by Superlawyer Magazine, and member of the Bar Register of Preeminent Attorneys in the law of the Internet)

Dozier is also the “internet” lawyer who is known for sending out copyrighted nastygrams, claiming that the recipients can’t post his correspondence online because they are his.  For that, he’s suffered rather widespread, make that universal, criticism.  It seems that no one respected his authoritah.  It’s hard to be a very accomplished lawyer these days.

But Dozier wasn’t put off by having blawg after blawg call him a flaming idiot.  He knew what it was really all about, and though he would have to stand alone against the rest of the world, he was prepared to do so.


We’ve been quite vocal at Dozier Internet Law about the nasty habit of the far left leaning and liberal blogosphere attacking through words (and otherwise) individuals who dare disagree with their “information yearns to be free” and “hands off the web” mantra. These interests claim that our free speech guaranteed by the First Amendment protects the right to attack with impunity anyone with whom they disagree. 

I have often said that the left wingers are all for the right to free speech, until they don’t agree with it. Time and again you’ll see discussions and postings about using the Streisand Effect to retaliate against someone for offering an opposing voice. It is a policy aimed at destroying dissension, particularly in Internet legal and policy areas. “First things we do, let’s kill all the lawyers.” Consider the context of the statement if you don’t already know and it quickly becomes apparent that this effort to bully, undermine, attack and destroy lawyers is the rallying cry for the police state…a world in which dissidents are held out to public scorn and ridicule by a vicious mob (Streisand Effect) or relentlessly attacked by masked intruders (anonymous speakers). 

Though he may stand alone, he is the victim of the far left who attack him, hold him out to public scorn and ridicule,  It’s not easy being John Dozier, the lone honest voice on the internet in a sea of far left, cool-aid drinking liberals.


This is the world in which we live today. Honest, honorable, intelligent, well mannered, battle worn veterans of the world rarely participate in online dialogue because of the attacks their participation invites. And so you get a very one sided, jaded, biased perspective on Internet law and policy issues. The far left liberals not only control the message, but police the web for anyone not drinking their kool-aid.  
One almost feels badly for Dozier.  No doubt he believes that he stands for truth, justice and the American way.  No doubt he sees that mass of lawyers, ridiculing him for his bizarre ideas, as a vicious mob.  When one wraps themselves in a firmly held, yet singular view, it easily seems like the world’s against him.  And indeed, when it comes to John Dozier, it is. 

Of course, it has nothing to do with the far left, or liberals, or any political persuasion.  It has to do with the fact that Dozier’s ideas are absurd.  It has to do with Dozier’s copyrighted cease and desist letters, which took an otherwise inconsequential lawyer and made him the butt of a thousand jokes.  Sorry, John, but an AV rating and being a Superlawyer with Cheese doesn’t really make you special.

More to the point is Dozier’s monumentally poor grasp of the First Amendment.  Dozier can assert any bit of nonsense he chooses.  He’s got a blog and he knows how to use it.  No government has demanded that he shut his digital door, or else.  But the First Amendment bears no connection to anyone else taking you seriously, or more to the point, ridiculing you for your bizarre assertions.  Write something stupid and people will call you stupid.  But you absolutely have the right to be stupid all you want, just not without getting called on it.  Because your vicious mob of detractors has the right to speak as well.  Typical of the self-proclaimed martyr, Dozier has twisted the right into a one way street.

I would expect that Dozier’s obviously flawed understanding of the First Amendment would find no support from the lawprof community.  Yet it bears remarkable similarity to the Cyber Civil Rights ideas propounded by Maryland Law School Professor Danielle Citron, to which many lawprofs have rallied in their zeal to show their gender equality bona fides.  One element of this fight against the vicious mob is that attacks on ideas by women have created a hostile environment.  Just like Dozier claims that the attacks on his dopey ideas have created a hostile enviroment. 

Nobody likes to have people say mean things about them, but it’s part of the give and take of life.  Say something out loud, and you invite someone to disagree.  If you can’t take the heat, then whisper it only to friends or keep it to yourself.  Or if your detractors are the idiots, then let your supporters speak out against them.  But no one gets to own the right to speak to the exclusion of those who disagree.

There will be a panel discussion today as part of the AALS meeting, directed toward “outrageous gender- or race specific comments” by law students, and the relation to their fitness to practice law.  The gist is that speech that defies their orthodoxy should be banned, and the speakers deemed unfit to be lawyers.  Kinda like a vicious mob of left wingers?  It’s unlikely that John Dozer, Jr., Esq., will find an empty seat on the panel next to Danielle Citron, but he’ll be there in spirit.  The only distinction is whose kool-aid is tastier.

Avvocative: You Get What You Pay For (Update)

When Avvo developed it’s  AvvoAnswers “product” (their word, not mine), it was replete with numerous obvious faults.  One problem they didn’t have was the willingness of lawyers to play the game, or to be more precise, to game the product.  Mark Bennett has kept a close eye on this at his Social Media Tyro Blog, where he coined the term “answhores“.

Not long ago, Avvo decided to let people know how great AvvoAnswers is working out.


The growth has been tremendous and we’re all pretty happy with how well the Answers product has resonated with both lawyers and clients. We’ve talked with lawyers that have been getting business through their answers. They’re very vocal when they get clients.

But, clients can be considered the silent majority. They don’t send out a tweet when they’re dealing with fairly private legal issues.

After providing a chart that bears a striking resemblance to Pacman, with the responses of 327 questioners, and concluding that 83% said they received a helpful answer (no explanation given as to the criteria for what was considered “helpful”), Sachin Bhatia, Product Manager, goes on to note the responses to the following:


Would they consider hiring a lawyer who provided an answer to their question?



  • 21% selected “Yes”
  • 47% selected “Maybe — it’s just one factor in deciding”
  • 15% selected “No — I’m not happy with the answer provided” (note similarity to Pac-Man chart above)
  • 17% selected “No — I don’t need to hire a lawyer”
If anything, this seems to debunk any theories that Avvo Answers is only for people looking for free legal advice. About 1 in 5 don’t need a lawyer, but nearly 7 of 10 might actually hire the lawyer that answered the questions.

Unlike Sachin, I was unconvinced, particularly in light of Bennett’s information.  A significant part of the problem is that “legal consumers,” as Avvo prefers to call its free riders, are the least qualified to determine the accuracy and propriety of answers to their questions.  This ignores, of course, the question of whether simplistic, misleading, ill-stated or loaded questions are susceptible to a competent answer at all. 

Notably, Sachin makes no mention of how much Avvo’s questioners are willing to pay, if they even connect up “hiring” with paying at all, a lawyer.  I can help here, as I’ve gotten a ton of emails and calls, probably about 1000, via Avvo.  I did get one case out of it, so I’m not complaining, but given my vastly broader sample, not to mention my inherent inclination to be helpful, here’s what I’ve found.


Would they consider paying for the lawyer they hire?



  • 47% asked why they should have to pay if they’re innocent
  • 12% asked if they could hire me pro bono
  • 22% asked if I would come to Des Moines to handle their DUI
  • 18% asked if I would accept $13 and a chicken, because that’s all they had
  • 0.9% asked if I would sue the last lawyer they found on Avvo for stealing their money so that they could pay me
  • 0.1% asked when we could get started defending them from the charges


    Given the obvious difference between the results of my highly scientific study and Avvo’s, I naturally turned back to Bennett for some clues as to why such dissonance exists.  Bennett did not disappoint. 

    In yet another blog dedicated to Avvo and its Answhores, named Avvo Pimp, it’s explained :
    [thumbnailCAEK1HSA.jpg]

    Well, one might say that pimping is about style. Others might say it’s all about dat money. And even others may say it’s about respect. Avvo Pimps though, are all about those points. All those answers get’em 15 points.

    Gotta get that street cred.

    But, how do a pimp get street cred? Easy. Just put some whacked out crap on the Avvo site. Don’t matter what you got to say, but say it like Johnny Cochrane would.

    Or, even better, put some junk together that you can cut and paste into your answer like my homeboy Mr. Brinkmeier do. Take a look at this post and then take a look at some of his other shit.

    Homeslice is like Steve Jobs with all dat cut and paste.

    And what duz that get da pimp? Mo points, Mo points.
    Apparently, lawyers who answer questions are given points for doing so, no matter if their answers are correct or wrong, long or short, helpful or not.  These points must do something for them, like get a star next to their name, or maybe earn a new pair of hotpants if enough are accumulated.  I dunno.  But they are desirable to some lawyers.  The Avvo Pimp is about with lawyers who :

  • Posting to states they ain’t licensed in
  • Pasting the same jive ass template answers to every damn thing they can
  • Tellin the peeps – “find a local attorney”.  Duh !!??
  • Piggybacking answers with “I agree with the previous response”.


  • And he’s kind enough to given us a free taste, which exemplifies one of the “Pimpalicious” answers that Avvo’s legal consumers find so wonderfully worthwhile.   The question (which happens to be about New York law) isn’t nearly as important as the answer, though you can read it all if you want.  Ironically, the answer is correct, if a bit terse, but the beauty is in the totality of the AvvoAnswer:


    Lars A. Lundeen  Lars A. Lundeen




    Contributor Level 8   This attorney is licensed in Vermont and 1 other state. 


    No.

    Legal Disclaimer: Mr. Lundeen is licensed to practice law in Florida and Vermont. The response herein is not legal advice and does not create an attorney/client relationship. The response is in the form of legal education and is intended to provide general information about the matter within the question. Oftentimes the question does not include significant and important facts and timelines that, if known, could significantly change the reply and make it unsuitable. Mr. Lundeen strongly advises the questioner to confer with an attorney in your state in order to insure proper advice is received.

    And another satisfied legal consumer.  Not only a great product, but a way for lawyers to do their part to help educate the public on important legal issues. 

    Update:  And if you think AvvoAnswers emits an unplesant odor, consider the stink coming from  LawGuru, where every “answer” starts with the advice that “you need to hire an attorney” and ends with a call to action.  Contact me, me, me…

    H/T Randazza’s Legal Satyricon

    Readers Mailbag, No. 72

    From time to time I respond to emails so that you may enjoy, as I do, the wonderful, often enlightening, occasionally thrilling, usually insulting, things people have to say to me.  Why should I suffer alone?


    Greenfield,

    If Sheriff Joe Arpaio is so evil, so criminal, so horrible as you and the rest of your criminal lawyer cronies say, how come he’s the most popular Sheriff in Arizona and why hasn’t the FBI done anything?  Hah, you’re full of [hot air].

    Since you’ve asked a two-part question, I’ll give you a two-part answer.  The reason he’s so popular is that Crazy Joe appeals to the base prejudice and anger of the masses.  It doesn’t make you a bad person.  Well, yes it does, but it doesn’t make you special.

    As to part two of your question, wrong.  A federal grand jury has been convened to consider “accusations that Arpaio has abused his law enforcement power with criminal investigations of critics and political foes.”  In response, Crazy Joe “denied [that he had] knowledge.”  Finally, a statement we can all agree with.


    Greenfield,

    Why won’t you follow me?  I followed you three times on Twitter and you never followed me back.  I even tweeted to you and retweeted one of your tweets, and still you didn’t follow me back.  You are rude and a pompous ass.

    You’re right, but forgive me for taking your points out of order.  I don’t know who you are. I don’t know what you have to say.  Why in the world would I follow you?  I have no idea why people follow me, except that some of them think there’s an outside chance that I will watch them on their dorm cam or might be suddenly overcome with a need for search engine optimization.  As for the rest of them, I’m befuddled.

    Some people believe that there’s an obligation to follow back anyone who follows you.  I don’t.  In fact, I don’t think there’s any obligation involved in twitter at all.  A lot of really stupid stuff has developed around twitter, ranging form the cutsie language, right tweeples, to the forced friendliness with people you don’t know who write insipid twits.  I’ve been called bad names by people because I prefer the word “twit” to “tweet”.  What brutally empty life do these people lead to find this to be a problem?  Are people who care about how many followers they have any better?

    And you, my erstwhile follower, are hurt that I have not shown you twitter-love (twove?) by following you back.  I have enough on my plate reading the twits of the people I actually know and already follow, and I can’t stand the noise whenever a new twit comes along.  If you’ve got something to twit to me, you’re welcome to send it directly.  But I have no plans on following anyone else unless I absolutely must, no matter how many times you follow/unfollow me.  If it makes you feel any better, I’ve never twitted anything worth reading anyway, so it’s not like you missed anything.


    Greenfield,

    You are friends with that Brian Tannebaum guy, who is always busy going after someone on his blog or on twitter.  What’s his problem?  Why can’t he just be nice to other people and get along, instead of always having something mean and nasty to say? 

    Mean and nasty?  Tannebaum?  Are you sure you’ve got the right guy?  Carolyn Elefant interviewed Brian at length about his efforts to serve his fellow lawyer.  She called him, “even handed, and thoughtful. Even compassionate.”  This makes Tannebaum the criminal defense lawyer equivalent of Mother Teresa (a particularly low threshold with the qualifier).  

    Most lawyers online feel compelled to be nice so that people will like them.  Being “liked” is critically important, according to marketers, if you want to get business, and that’s the purpose of most lawyers online, getting business.  Being nice, however, means that lawyers suspend the normal, critical scrutiny, being far more concerned that others perceive them as good guys than who these purported gurus, the ones who seem to have all the followers, all the answers, all the friends,  

    Brian Tannebaum does what he does for himself and the rest of us.  He looks.  He checks.  And, unfortunately, he finds a pervasive thread through these one-time lawyers cum social media gurus and marketers of far more spin than honesty.  By sacrificing his own “nice guy” persona in favor of a little accuracy and transparency, Tannebaum allows you to go one trying to play friend to everyone, yet still learn who is lying through their teeth. 

    If anything, you owe Tannebaum a huge debt of gratitude for doing the dirty work that you avoid at all costs. You should send him a bottle of wine.  He prefers the type with screw-off tops. And nothing over $10.


    Mr. Greenfield,

    You are cordially invited to attend The Commonwealth Regional Law Conference 2010, which will focus on “21st Century Lawyer: Present Challenges & Future Skill.”  The conference will be held in Abuja, Nigeria.  Would you like us to make reservations for you?
    No.

    Who Owns Cyber-Stalking?

    It’s merely coincidence that recent posts about cyberpaths are followed up by an AALS conference on Cyber-Stalking, to be run by the Section on Women in Legal Education.  The title of the panel discussion will be “The First Amendment Meets Cyber-Stalking Meets Character and Fitness,” and much to my surprise, includes Danielle Citron on the panel.

    For those who don’t recall, Citron, a University of Maryland Law School law professor, is the leading proponent of cyber-stalking being a gender discrimination issue, which she would redefine as Cyber-Civil Rights.  By doing so, the issue changes from one focused on free speech rights to one focused on gender discrimination, the latter specific concern perpetually trumping the former, less specific right, amongst many in the academic community.

    The write-up on the conference spells it out:


    Is there a problem with law students using websites to make outrageous gender– or race-specific comments (often about other students or faculty members)? (See lawvibe.com/the-autoadmit-scandal-xoxoth/ .) Is this conduct beyond question as free speech or does this conduct raise character and fitness issues that law schools must address?
    Over at Volokh Conspiracy, Eugene has been asked to alert readers to this panel.  He’s done so, but to his credit, includes a caveat.


    But I should also express my worries about the proposals that the panel appears to be aimed at contemplating.

    If the panel were just planned to discuss the possibility that schools and state bars consider criminal and constitutionally unprotected conduct by students — such as making threats — that might be one thing. But the reference to “outrageous gender– or race-specific comments” suggests that the proposals would likely go considerably further.

    There are many familiar problems with such general codes — but the “outrageous gender– or race-specific comments” focus suggests that this code is aimed at suppressing offensive viewpoints, and not just uncivil ways of expressing all viewpoints. The rationale for that can’t just be that rude law students make rude lawyers, who might browbeat witnesses, make life hard for litigants, opposing counsel, and judges, and so on. (That rationale would itself be insufficient to justify denying someone a license to practice law based on otherwise constitutionally protected speech, but I set that aside for now.) The rationale must be that people who “outrageous[ly]” express racist or sexist views are unfit to be lawyers, presumably because they’ll act on those views in the future.
    While Eugene’s focus, as is the panel based on the title of the program, appears to be on the imposition of a “political correctness” litmus test on law students, extrapolating from their speech that they would make unfit lawyers,   From my seat, there are additional fears that extend in two opposite directions, both of which are disturbing to free speech rights.

    On the broader side, I believe this panel is part of the broader agenda to turn cyber-stalking into cyber-civil rights, and that the purported question of whether this bears only upon law students and law schools is a subterfuge to bring lawprofs together under the neo-feminist umbrella that would make speech subject to their brand of approval.  While Eugene’s concern is that it be limited to “rude law students,” it seems almost impossible for the same views to be so arbitrarily limited.

    On the narrower side, the idea that the thought police will be ever-vigilant within law schools in order to decide the fitness of any bar applicant’s views is shocking.  Not many lawprofs are bold enough to challenge the cyber-civil rights crowd, and as Citron’s pursues her agenda with those opposing facing the likelihood of being branded a misogynist, she could end of the Czar of gender propriety for the next generation of lawyers.

    No one is denying, or disagrees, that this is a problem or an issue, though the alleged focus on law students seems a bit too facile.  But it’s a problem because cyber-stalking, if not general rudeness (as is the nature of narcissistic and entitled Slackoisie), is inherently an issue that permeates online communities.  It’s not owned by either gender, and it’s not up to Danielle Citron to decide that everyone’s free speech rights must give way to her gender-based myopia.

    Of course, nobody asked me to be on this AALS panel.  Who will present the contrary view?

    The Irresistable Device Meets the Immovable Force

    It’s fair to say that I like cars, as the proud owner of a 1964 Austin Healey 3000, Mark III (Phase 2).  It’s fair to say that I like computer-type stuff, being a blawger and all.  It’s fair to say that the subject of this New York Times article scares the daylights out of me.


    To the dismay of safety advocates already worried about driver distraction, automakers and high-tech companies have found a new place to put sophisticated Internet-connected computers: the front seat.

    Technology giants like Intel and Google are turning their attention from the desktop to the dashboard, hoping to bring the power of the PC to the car. They see vast opportunity for profit in working with automakers to create the next generation of irresistible devices.

    The combination of dashboard and PC is absolutely perfect; so many uses that will ease and facilitate our lives, our businesses, our need to never be so far from a computer screen that we can’t hear the little noise when we get a new twit. 

    There’s no need to explain the myriad of uses for this combo.  Anyone can see how incredibly beneficial it can be, making cars as real an office as any corner of a skyscraper, providing access to critical information exactly when you need it, providing a little something you want to watch rather than exhaust fumes of the car in front of you when stuck in traffic.  No need to justify it further.

    But, even the most zealous advocate has to recognize that it’s not without issues.



    “This is irresponsible at best and pernicious at worst,” Nicholas A. Ashford, a professor of technology and policy at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, said of the new efforts to marry cars and computers. “Unfortunately and sadly, it is a continuation of the pursuit of profit over safety — for both drivers and pedestrians.”
    I’m not much of a fan of cellphones while driving, believing that chatting up some very important person really isn’t worth the life of another person.  Others have informed me that I’m dead wrong, that they need their cellphones while driving and that banning cellphones is just another deprivation of rights and big government intrusion into their lives.  I disagree. 

    There is no “right” to drive badly and put other people at risk of death.  The studies have clearly shown that driving while talking on a cellphone is more dangerous than driving drunk.  If it was simply a matter of people deciding to risk their own lives, I might be less inclined to resist the natural temptation to  acquiesce to this, but they put my life, my kids’ lives, at risk.  Their desire to talk on the phone isn’t worth my life.

    If cellphones were bad, this is just mind-bogglingly worse.  But wait, you say.  Certainly no automaker/computer giant would do something that would put us at risk simply to make more money.

    The technology and car companies say that safety remains a priority. They note that they are building in or working on technology like voice commands and screens that can simultaneously show a map to the driver and a movie to a front-seat passenger, as in the new Jaguar XJ.

    “We are trying to make that driving experience one that is very engaging,” said Jim Buczkowski, the director of global electrical and electronics systems engineering at Ford. “We also want to make sure it is safer and safer. It is part of what our DNA will be going forward.”

    Well, that sounds encouraging.  And what are they planning to do, since safety remains “a” priority?


    A notice that pops up when the Audi system is turned on reads: “Please only use the online services when traffic conditions allow you to do so safely.”
    Well, that will stop the idiot dead in his tracks, right?

    I trust that many readers will be responsible about their driving, even if access to the internet, and maybe a few Youtube music videos, is just inches away.  They will recognize their responsibility to others on the road, and won’t do something as incredibly stupid as watch the movie intended only for the front seat passenger.  But you bet your bottom dollar that someone (you know, the fellow with the backward baseball cap in the other car) will not be as responsible as you.  He will not heed the on-screen warning.  He will succumb to the allure of the flashing lights on his dashboard.  And he will kill someone.

    To argue this point online is nearly crazy; so many are technophiles and embrace every shiny new toy with a love that was once reserved for a sweetheart.  At a time when good people, smart people, find it nearly impossible to pull themselves away from a computer screen lest a twit arrive that demands their immediate response, the idea of having access to your digital lifeline in front of you and ignoring it seems absurd.  It will be used.  It will be loved.  And it will result in harm to someone, whether that be you, your loved one or someone you’ve never met.

    Where does the madness end?  We have the technology to make this happen, but do we have the sound judgment to say, “enough”?

    A car is about two thousand pounds of hurtling death.  About 50,000 people a year die so that we can enjoy its mobility. The risk of harm by terrorism is a joke compared to the risk of driving down the road.  Yet we happily relinquish our rights to be safe from the threat of underpants bombs and turn a blind eye to the rocket coming toward us with its driver absorbed in the latest meme. 

    No matter how much better this combination of technology and mobility will make our lives, we can’t ignore that we must first remain alive.  You can always check twitter when you reach your destination.  Trust me, nothing important will happen without you.