Author Archives: SHG

Form A Single Line And Tell Us Your Income

Eugene Volokh thought the title to this post at Skating on Stilts was funny enough to warrant a post about the title alone:



“Actually, a Chip That Big Will Have to Come Off Your Shoulder and Go Through the X-Ray.”

OK, I’m not sure I’m entirely persuaded by Stewart Baker’s post — it’s not clear, for instance, why handcuffing was proper under the circumstances — but the title is very funny.


But “not entirely persuaded” falls short of not at all persuaded, funny title or not.  The post referred to is about more than handcuffs:



A well-known war blogger, Michael Yon, is complaining that he was detained and handcuffed when he refused to answer TSA’s questions. Yon took the position that he could decide what questions it was proper for TSA to ask, and if he didn’t think the questions were proper, he refused to answer.  Said Yon, “If I am the guy on that passport and I don’t have any contraband in my luggage, it is a matter for the FBI, not the TSA.”

Stewart Baker has a definitive view of Michael Yon’s shoulder chip:


This is precisely the kind of attitude that will have to change if we’re ever going to have real air security.  If we want TSA to look for terrorists, not just weapons, and after Christmas, it’s obvious that we do, then we’ll have to expect TSA to ask questions, including questions whose relevance isn’t immediately obvious to the traveler. 

The media, following heightened security following the underpants bomber, has made a point of noting that passengers have been almost universally compliant with the new security measures.  The reports are meant to suggest that we’re all on board with them, we understand that the TSA is just protecting us and we’re happy to comply. 

That’s not necessarily the message at all.  Rather, the message I take is that resistance is futile and will only lead to longer delays, more heated tempers and maybe even an introduction to handcuffs.  Things are bad enough, and on line in an airport isn’t the time to make them worse.

Except that shoulder-chip carrier Yon, according to Baker, wants to undermine our entire security apparatus based upon his personal, subjective view of what the TSA should be allowed to ask.  So we should all get blown out of the sky because Michael Yon says so?

Notably omitted from both Baker’s “silence of the lambs”post and Eugene’s “it would be funnier without handcuffs” post is a bit of information on what was asked of Michael Yon to put that big ol’ chip on his shoulder.



At this point the TSA officials escorted Yon to a designated screening area where they examined the contents of his bag.  “Then they asked me how much money I make,” Yon said.  Yon suggested to the TSA officials that the question was inappropriate and unrelated to transportation security.  The award-winning blogger noted another TSA officer approached Yon: “he asked who do I work for.”  ”I did not answer the question which clearly was upsetting to the TSA officers.”

Yon was escorted to a room elsewhere in the airport where he said he remained silent during much of the questioning.   According to Yon, “they handcuffed me for failing to cooperate.  They said I was impeding their ability to do their job.”
Like Baker, I agree that we mere mortals may not know the rationale for our TSA protectors asking for certain information.  It may be that travelers with lower income are more likely to blow up airplanes.  Or maybe those with higher incomes are more likely.  The TSA has not made me privy to their secrets.  But regardless, to demand that person boarding an airplane disclose his income seems off-the-wall nuts and unacceptably intrusive. 

One has to assume that Baker knew what the question asked of Yon was before coming up with his very funny headline about Yon’s chip on his shoulder.  One therefore has to assume that Baker has no problem with the question.  Given it’s intrusiveness, one has to assume that there is no question that Baker would find beyond the pale.

[Insert really offensive, really intrusive, question about strange sexual proclivities.]

Why not?  Where is the rule book about how far the TSA can go?  What questions are off-limits?  At what point are we allowed to have a chip on our shoulder, just because some guy in a funky  uniform who was a server at Dairy Queen the month before asks you an inappropriately personal question?  While we might not like the rigors of the current security regime, most people have gone along with it just to get on the plane and go.  Does this mean that the TSA got the message that it can do anything, anything at all, and we’ll just happily comply?  Maybe so.

But what makes no sense to me is that the only problem Eugene had with this funny-titled post is the handcuffs?  I can’t see Eugene answering the question.  I can’t see me answering the question either. 

Children v. Unions

The New York Times editorial contrasts the clash of two sacred cows, children and unions.  As hard as it may be to imagine, the most significant force against the reform of failed criminal justice programs have been the unions, and the politicians who depend on them for financing, representing prison guards. 

It was a brilliant idea to build prisons in depressed upstate locations, where there was land aplenty and rampant unemployment.  It took the bad guys away from the masses, and made for a pretty good local economy when people needed it.  But along the way, people forget that it wasn’t about their having jobs, but about the people they were holding.  These people included children.



A report by a task force appointed by Gov. David Paterson describes a failing system that damages young people, fails to curb recidivism and eats up millions of tax dollars. Children should be confined only when they present a clear threat to public safety. But the most recent statistics show that 53 percent of the youths admitted to New York’s institutional facilities were placed there for minor nonviolent infractions.

Not surprisingly, these institutions do a terrible job of rehabilitation. According to a study of children released from custody between 1991 and 1995, 89 percent of the boys and 81 percent of the girls were eventually rearrested. New York’s facilities are so disastrous and inhumane that state officials recently asked the courts to refrain from sending children to them, except in cases in which they presented a clear danger to the public.
The reports showed that these children were in need of mental health services and education, but they were unable to get the help they needed within their communities because all the cash flowed upstate to prisons.  If you’ve got prisons, you need to fill them up or all that money is wasted.  No one likes to see money wasted.

In the face of these reports, the unions are up in arms.  The upstate politicians are up in arms too, as they don’t want to lose their financing or invoke the wrath of their constituents who will lose their jobs.  Frankly, it’s understandable.  It’s just not acceptable. 

At the extreme end, we have the two Pennsylvania judges, Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. and Michael T. Conahan, who were placing kids in confinement for a kickback.  Trading off the lives of children for upstate jobs isn’t entirely different, except that the cash flow is spread out a little broader and it’s done in the name of government.

There are some who have given up hope on children, who buy into the child-predator myth and believe that kids are beyond redemption.  If so, then prison is the way to go, keep those nasty children away from good, law-abiding folk.  But this clearly doesn’t apply to a child who presents no threat of harm to anyone.  And even the ones who do are still children.  Children, for crying out loud.  No one is arguing that they don’t do harm and aren’t in need of incarceration at times, but that they are not unsalvageable and beyond help.

While there may be argument about what to do with the most violent, the most dangerous, there should be no argument that the vast majority of children who find themselves in some form of juvenile justice scrutiny have the capacity to be helped and to go on to lead happy, productive lives.  Unless we warehouse them in upstate prisons, where all hope is lost and no help is found, so that union members can continue to have gainful employment.

It’s not that I don’t appreciate that prison guards have families and children of their own to support.  It’s not that I take lightly the loss of jobs in otherwise depressed counties.  It’s not that these people don’t have legitimate needs of their own.  But when the choice is between children and unions, the children must win out.  Children cannot be traded for jobs.  Sorry, unions.  Sorry, prison guards.

Cameras Redux: Judge Kozinski Says Times Have Changed

“I think there’s something sick about making entertainment out of other people’s legal problems,”


  -Associate Justice Antonin Scalia, 2005.

With the sort of regularity that would make a geriatric blush, the question of cameras in the courtroom returned when 9th Circuit Chief Judge Alex Kozinski announced that it was time to give it a try.  Any suspicion that Judge Kozinski has learned a lesson from ill-advised images is over.  The game is on.

Norm Pattis at his aptly-named blog rips the suggestion.

Alex Kozinski, the chief judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, has announced that his circuit will “experiment” with cameras in Court. He wants “to help us find the right balance between the public’s right to access to the courts and the parties’ right to a fair and dignified proceeding.”

The public’s right to access,in one permutation or another, forms the basis for the argument that legal proceedings should be subject to cameras.  It’s a vague concept, but one that sounds pretty good and certainly comports with populist sensibilities.  We would hate to have secret court proceedings, where the peering eyes of the public are forbidden and decisions are made behind closed doors.  But that’s the far end of the spectrum from television cameras in the courtroom. 


Court TV was supposed to edify us all about what went on in the courts. What we ended up with was ’round-the-clock shlock. Producers looked around for trials with sex appeal. Cameras were placed in these courtrooms, and then editors clipped the “sexier” moments for broadcast. To add color, lawyers were recruited as talking heads to “interpret” the significance of what was shown on the screen. The result was hardly edification; indeed, all we succeeded in doing was creating a few new talking heads, who copped just the right attitude on screen: Nancy Grace gracelessly rages about crime; Catherine Crier decries the role of lawyers. And the public, that vast entity of folks with some inchoate right to know, knows about as much as it knew before the klieg light’s flashed — zip.\

Seeing isn’t understanding.  The folks with the cameras aren’t interested in illuminating the fascinating area of law.  They sell commercial time for a profit.  That’s fine, as it’s the nature of their business, but we can’t forget this when they wrap themselves up in arguments that they want cameras in the courtroom for the good of mankind. 

On the other hand, there are a number of very hard, very real reasons to not permit the legal proceedings to be made into television fodder.  I’ve spelled them out before.  Yet Judge Kozinski says times have changed.



But as Judge Kozinski said in an interview, “a lot has happened since then.” He cited advances in technology, the rise of Internet video transmission and greater experience of successful use of video in state courts and at the federal appeals level. “We thought it was time to take another look,” he said.

Judge Kozinski emphasized that the new initiative was still an experiment, and that it would be dropped “if it in any way impairs the fair administration of justice.” But he also noted that he did not expect to see problems.

“It’s a little bit of an uphill battle” to get courts to adopt technology, he said, adding: “We all have to be much more tech savvy than we really ever were, or particularly wanted to be. It’s just the nature of life in the 21st century.”
The only change noted is advancement in technology, that old dog again.  While that would alter the obtrusiveness of the physical cameras, that was the least of the problems.  This was never a technology issue, but a human one.  And it is disconcerting for the Chief Judge of the 9th Circuit to say that they will drop the experiment if it impairs justice.  It’s quite difficult to assess the impairment of justice, or the degree of impairment, and what does he plan to do for the litigants whose justice was impaired?

There are no new arguments in favor of cameras in the courtroom.  Judge Kozinski offers nothing in support of his “times have changed” position.  Maybe it’s just a love of new technology that leads him down this road, the sense that it’s inevitable and might as well start with him.  Judicial entropy.

There will be no illumination for the public.  There can’t be, when they are only shown snippets of trials, the dramatic or salacious, and left to some glib talking heads to “explain” it.  The truth is that trials are largely a bore, tedious to watch and often senseless until the end.  Court TV found this out when it folded it’s tent and became Tru TV.

Norm agrees with Justice Scalia.  So do I.  But then, we’re just criminal defense lawyers.  Why would we care about fair trials?

The 4th Amendment, On Sale At Amazon

Over at Volokh Conspiracy, Orin Kerr questions the vitality of Kyllo v. United States, the decision holding that the use of infrared thermal imaging devices to detect a marijuana grow house constitutes a search and thus requires a warrant.


This post asks whether that result is still good law. I realize that probably sounds a bit nutty at first, as Kyllo is only a few years old. But Kyllo deliberately adopted a test designed to let the result change with social practice . This post asks whether changing social practices already allow the police to use thermal imaging devices without a warrant.

The Supreme Court announced the following rule: “when . . . the Government uses a device that is not in general public use, to explore details of the home that would previously have been unknowable without physical intrusion, the surveillance is a “search” and is presumptively unreasonable without a warrant.” Because infrared temperature sensing was not in “general public use,” the thermal imaging was a “search” that required a warrant. 
As Orin notes, variations on these “high-tech” devices are now readily available at Amazon for under $100.  Under the announced rule, contingent on a device “not in general public use,” it would seem that the holding in Kyllo is passé.  While Orin doesn’t say so, I suspect that this is meant to show why his “technology neutral” approach to the 4th Amendment makes sense, as otherwise rules would change, or become outdated, based on extraneous acceptability of technology by the public.

An initial, and somewhat obvious, problem with the Kyllo decision, that feeds into Orin’s question, is the way the rule was framed.  By making the test “general public use,” the court built in obsolescence.  Any device, the proper use of which is dependent on the public’s use, knowledge, acceptance, is subject to change over time.  The test was not grounded in reasonable expectation of privacy per Katz, which (as Orin notes) Justice Scalia ridiculed, but rather the prevalence of ordinary folks walking around with infrared thermometers, whether used to check out the neighbors or just the chicken in the oven.

I can’t disagree with Orin that the test hasn’t aged well, and isn’t likely do any better if we just let it mature some more.  Today’s scientific oddity can easily be tomorrow’s child’s toy, the way things are heading with technology.  Worse still, the Supremes are (forgive me) kinda old, and may not be on the cutting edge of technological use in certain demographic brackets.  And their clerks aren’t the coolest kids around, and may not share their peers’ zeal for the latest, shiniest toys.

But that doesn’t suggest an indictment of the Kyllo outcome, or my grudging agreement with Orin’s “technology neutral” approach.  It’s just one poorly framed test.  It’s not the first, and it certainly won’t be the last.  Even as I tap out these words, I can hear Orin saying, “Oh yeah, wise guy? So what test would you suggest?”  I’m glad you asked.

The use of any device, whether mechanical, electrical or electronic, to obtain information that could not be obtained without it is a search. A search requires a warrant.  Absent plain view, the question should not be how to pigeonhole new technologies into the plethora of exceptions developed over the past century, whether tethered to its originating rationale or just a short slide down the slippery slope, but why we’ve stood idly by while the  exceptions have swallowed the rule.

That the device may be in common use, or readily available to the shopping public on Amazon, should bear no relevance to the definition of a search.  How long will it be before they are selling the mental equivalent of the old “x-ray specs” that graced the back page of comic books when I was a kid? 

The law will never keep pace with developing technologies, nor should it have to.  We’ve always had the right rule at hand, but haven’t paid enough attention to it in our zeal to find ways around it.  Technology has given us a second chance to take back the 4th Amendment, to return to a time when we honored the principles rather than strained to find ways to avoid them.  Let’s not blow it this time.

Keeping The Cash Cow Happy

It’s as if the world inside the Academy was untouched by human hands.  At least the hands of a lawyer.  While practitioners complain that students emerge from law school unprepared to face the world as lawyers, and students complain that the fine time they have inside the Ivory Tower serves only to make the slap in the face as they step through the door into the real world more painful, law professors are busily trying to figure out ways to make the experience different.  Better. Fun.

Over at PrawfsBlawg, Howard Wasserman floated an idea about how to up the fun quotient on exams:



For no particular reason, I started thinking today about doing a question in which students would get a one-frame cartoon (The New Yorker would be the obvious source, but we could find them from other sources) and have the student relate that cartoon to the material in the course. My wife had an exam that did this in a sociology course and it sounds like a fun idea (although she said it was the hardest exam she had in college).


Could this work? And does anyone have ideas on cartoon(s) to use?

This could, of course, be great experience if a client arrives at your office, one-frame cartoon in hand, and asks your advice.  A commenter suggested that his effort would come to naught.


I realize I am a stick in the mud, but as a 3L, I would ask you not to attempt to be fun or cute with your exams. No one likes taking or grading exams, but they are usually worse when a professor attempts to break out of the mold with something playful. Such exams often suggest that the professor does not take the process seriously, and that the grades themselves are arbitrary.

To be crass, think of an exam like a colonoscopy: it’s not a fun procedure whatever you do, and the doc’s only going to make it worse by performing it in a clown suit. Exams and grades have a major impact on your students’ futures, and they will appreciate you more if you treat the process with the seriousness it deserves.

Out of the mouths of babes.  But Wasserman was not so easily deterred.  While he might have overstepped on the clown suit idea, he still questioned, in a subsequent post, whether there was a better way to make law school exams more “fun”:


The idea is to try to break the tension of the exam a bit. As a student, I found it helpful if there was something unique or fun about the exam, even if only as a momentary distraction. There is a balance to be struck, of course. We as prawfs can try too hard. And there always is a risk that only a few students will “get” the humor or culture references–and perhaps that “getting it” will provide an unfair advantage on the exam itself. Several people raised this issue as to my cartoon idea and maybe it falls on the wrong side of the line.

But the broader question stands: Can students enjoy exams just a little bit and is there anything we can do to help? Or is an exam always an uncomfortable medical procedure and any effort to make it otherwise merely detracts from the seriousness of the exam itself?

One of the perpetual problems with intramural discussions amongst scholars is that they try to arrive at idea about how best to train lawyers without involving lawyers in their discussions.  Since so few real lawyers bother to read the lawprof blawgs, the lawprofs are left to their own devices.  Having stumbled upon Wasserman’s post, I decided to butt in and provide an outside perspective:


I hope I don’t ruin the fun by injecting the practitioner’s perspective, but one of the missing ingredients we see in the blossoming law student is tolerance for the reality that life as a lawyer is frequently not “fun”.

Judges can be decidedly unfun. Clients too. Perhaps the effort to make exams more fun is counterproductive at a time when practitioners complain that law students emerge from school largely unprepared to meet their professional responsibilities?

My comment was roundly ignored, which made me feel right at home.  Not their home, but mine, where I am roundly ignored by those who care most for me.  While this was occurring over at PrawfBlawg, the New York Times Room for Debate discussed a similar question, whether graduate students are “students” or “consumers”. 

There is a fundamental rift in how law schools perceive law students.  While one might suppose that they are all busy kissing up to their cash chow, that’s not quite the case.  Consider Richard Vedder, director of the Center of College Affordability and Productivity and teaches economics at Ohio University:


The “student as customer” philosophy has created an underworked and overindulged group of future national leaders, something that likely will prove costly in the long run.
But as others in the Debate Room argue, they can’t do the things that professors like to do without cash-paying students to fund them. 

The one thing that Wasserman’s question ignores is the efficacy of making law school more fun.  His concern with amusing his students, and himself, and making the law school “experience” more enjoyable, is fundamentally misfocused.  It not only perpetuates the fraud of trying to convince law students that law is fun, that they are entitled to fun, that they will have fun when they leave the ivy-covered buildings and take their folding chair in the boiler room, or if they are very lucky, the library. 

Law isn’t fun.  If you want fun, find something else to do.  And if you need fun to help get you through the rigors of law school, then get out now and save your pennies.  You’re headed for a miserable life.

I can understand why Howard Wasserman is trying to make the children in his charge enjoy their experience more.  He’s concerned for them, likes them and wants them to feel better about law school.  It’s a kind thing to do, from his point of view.  But these same students will not find such kindness or thoughtfulness when they strike out on their own.  They will find decidedly unkind judges.  They will find particularly unkind bosses.  They will find clients for whom kindness to them is like the plague.

Law schools are particularly against the idea of becoming trade schools, and I do not agree that theory and understanding of the law has no place in law school, though I do believe that students need to learn the mechanics of their chosen field as well as concepts.  But neither requires that they be coddled.  Indeed, teaching law students to overcome adversity is critical to their survival as lawyers. 

Rather than make law school a more pleasant, a “funner”, place, it should be as difficult and, even, miserable as the practice of law.  If they can’t hack it, then maybe they will be taught the most important lesson they can get from law school: They shouldn’t be lawyers.

They’re Not All Venal. But…

Andrew Sullivan at the Daily Dish offers his “Email of the Year,” a missive from an unnamed Department of Justice attorney about Fouad al-Rabiah, one of those purported terrorists rounded up after 9/11.  The problem is that the DOJ knew al-Rabiah to be innocent of any wrong, yet tortured him anyway.  You know, you can never be too sure.

The email stated:


The conclusion drawn by each of my colleagues – some of whom are liberal Democrats, some of whom are conservative, law-and-order Republicans – is, to a person, that the detention and interrogation programs the United States implemented in the months and years following 9/11 is not only a complete abrogation and violation of international law and, in many cases, federal law – it is also fundamentally immoral.  We also agree that the al-Rabiah case is by far the most egregious yet to come to light. 
The email goes on:


That said, I am surprised you did not highlight what me and my colleagues agreed was the single most horrifying passage from the Court’s decision.  It was the Court’s quotation of something an interrogator said to al-Rabiah during his interrogation.  The interrogator told al-Rabiah:

 


“There is nothing against you. But there is no innocent person here. So, you should confess to something so you can be charged and sentenced and serve your sentence and then go back to your family and country, because you will not leave this place innocent.”


Court Memorandum and Order, p. 41 (emphasis mine). 


The immediate reaction to this expose is that there are good, true, honest people in the Department of Justice, who believe in the Constitution and the precepts that make America great.  The feeling didn’t last very long.

Of course, it’s better to know that there are men and women of every political stripe within our government who know the difference between right and wrong.  But knowing the difference isn’t enough.  It’s a start, a necessary precursor, but not enough.  It takes another step, acting upon the difference, that matters.  Where are these good DOJ lawyers when it comes time to tell their superior, a judge, a congressional committee, the American public, that something very wrong is happening? 

In a strange way, it would almost seem better if the DOJ lawyers failed to be capable of distinguishing right from wrong.  Then, we could chalk their actions up to ignorance.  But knowing that they were well aware of what was happening to an innocent man, we are left with only cowardice.  Of the two states, cowardice is far worse.  Any DOJ lawyer who knows of the government torturing, prosecuting, an innocent man and does nothing is a coward.

I’ve had the honor of knowing a government attorney who was brave.  I’ve known an AUSA who refused to prosecute defendants who were innocent, or the victims of government impropriety.  This was a lawyer who told me, and the court, the truth, and then walked out of the courtroom, refusing to do the government’s dirty work.  I stood in awe of this lawyer, for I knew the risk she took.

I also knew the AUSA who jumped into the void, took up the cause even after the truth came out, to please her masters and gain a reward by being such good little servant to the government.  There was a first class seat awaiting her on the next plane to Washington, where she would get a plum job with a big title.  The government appreciates loyalty.

Sullivan may be quite impressed with the email he received.  I’m less impressed.  The author knew better and did nothing about it.  I wish I knew what became of the brave AUSA who knew the truth and acted on it. 

Happy New Year, Maricopa

While most of us are tipping glasses of champagne and watching as the ball drops, Lydia Guzman had her eye on her cellphone, waiting for the next message that Sheriff Joe Arpaio, with his deputies and his volunteer posse, are sweeping up people with dark skin and black hair to get a taste of his special brew. 

Guzman, the director of the non-profit immigrant advocacy group Respect/Respeto, and sends out a text message alert to let people know when Crazy Joe is at it again.  Arpaio says he doesn’t mind, “it isn’t interfering with our operations because every time we do it, we still arrest a good number of people, including illegal aliens.” But he does think that she may be committing a crime rather than exercising free speech.

Mark Bennett received an email that explains things in much greater detail than does Arpaio to the Arizona Republic newspaper.

Dear Atty. Bennett: I live in Arizona. Why don’t we do something about Sheriff Joe? We do – we have re-elected him 5 times and every time he runs we RE-ELECT HIM AND WILL KEEP RE-ELECTING HIM AND IF HE WANTS TO BE PRESIDENT OF THE U.S., WE WILL ELECT HIM FOR THAT, TOO!!! HE IS ONE OF THE FEW PEOPLE WHO IS OBEYING OUR LAWS, WHO IS PROTECTING THE PEOPLE OF THIS STATE AND COUNTRY. What are you – a globalist or just  what Lenin called liberals “useful idiots”? Our state is now the murder capitol of the nation, the kidnapping capitol of the nation, the car theft capitol of the nation!  If an American goes to a meeting and objects everything being given to Mexico or Mexican illegals, he or she gets arrested. But MECHISTAS can come and yell, “Death to the U.S.A.”, “We will push the U.S. into the sea!”, “Kill the gringos”, and lots more terrorist chants and the police are not allowed to tell them anything or even so much as ask their name (despite the fact the Patriot Act is in force!).

His emailer calls herself a “Patriot”, and no doubt she is.  In her own mind.  She goes on to list heinous crimes committed by these marauding illegals, the standard murder, rape and pillage stuff, that would make one furious with anger and fear.  She talks about how she knows all these things to be true.


I have two girlfriends whose children have all been murdered by illegals. I have spoken to a 15 y.o. who was shot at by Mexicans in his school because they tore down the U.S. flag and put up the Mexican flag and he said he was going home to get his flag. I spoke to the mother of a little 11 y.o. who was almost beaten blind by Mexicans. And many others and in all cases the schools refused to do anything. We h ave been infiltrated by Mexico in this state. They are teaching “hate” and “revolution” in our schools and when someone takes the proof down to the capitol, every time – it gets stolen (excuse me “it disappears”). 
Of course, if you try to find any evidence of these terrible crimes, you won’t.  I didn’t, and I tried.  It’s impossible to argue with a person who claims to have spoken with the victims, but there isn’t a new story anywhere to be found.  Amongst the conspiracy community, this can be explained by the liberal media concealing these horrible crimes.  Amongst real people, Bennett’s “Patriot” is another frightened person who has been sucked in by fear-mongerers who fabricate tales of terrible crimes that exist only in their minds, but serve well to keep those who are inclined to fear in line.

There is no doubt that some of the people in Maricopa County of Mexican heritage are not here lawfully.  There is no doubt that some commit crimes.  So too do nice white boys.  And black boys.  And brown boys.  But there is no grand conspiracy.  Oddly, if Crazy Joe was so effective, and if this conspiracy existed, they would leave Maricopa County for greener pastures like Texas, where there was no Crazy Joe and the vast conspiracy of illegals could run rampant.  Yet there’s no cry for Crazy Joe to move to Houston and take up arms there. 

But people like Bennett’s “Patriot” don’t question the reports that spread fear and hatred.  That would be unpatriotic.

Bennett distinguished his “Patriot” from a real one, the type that honors our laws and our people, from the Constitution on down.  This fear of illegals fuels a state of war in Maricopa.  Fear of terrorists fuels a state of war elsewhere. Fear makes people see and hear and believe the darnedest things, and believe them with all their heart.  Fear is primitive.  Fear is fundamental to our nature, our need to protect ourselves so we survive.  Fear always trumps reason.  Survive first and think later.

It doesn’t take a brilliant demagogue to use fear to manipulate people. It only takes a few scared people, unwilling to stop and think before allowing fear to take over.   Once you’ve got them afraid, they will do pretty much anything to protect themselves.  It doesn’t matter that their fear exists mainly in their own, aluminum-foil covered heads.

If anybody has a reason to be afraid in Maricopa County, it’s Lydia Guzman.  Yet she continues to keep her eye on her cellphone, ready to send out a text message warning others of Crazy Joe’s next sweep.

Taking Legislators Prisoner

Norm Pattis has never been one for the small idea.  It’s go big or go home.  I have argued that prosecutors should spend a few days in prison before being allowed to ask a judge to incarcerate a fellow human being.  You know, just to have some clue what they were doing.  But compared to Norm, I’m a piker.  Norm’s proposal makes mine look like kid stuff.


I have a proposal designed to improve the criminal justice system. No lawmaker should be able to seek re-election to a third term unless he or she agrees to serve six months in prison.

The benefits of such a system should be obvious to everyone.

He had me by the second sentence, but Norm gratuitously explains:


Lawmakers churn out additions to the penal code annually. When they are not adding new offenses, they are extending the length of sentences for offenses already defined. A congressman or a state legislator has great power to set the terms and conditions under which increasing numbers of Americans live. Indeed, the penal code is now so vast and complex that we are almost all criminals at least part of the time. When everyone breaks the law, the rule of law breaks down as prosecutors acquire the discretion to pick and choose whom to punish.

Lawmakers tinker with the penal code without much comprehension of the real cost of what they are doing. Let’s spread the pain a little, I say. Let’s make sure the good men and women so quick to throw the book at folks taste a little of their own medicine.

Now it’s not entirely clear why Norm would wait until third-term re-election for lawmakers to come to grips with what they do.  They get to vote from day 1, so why not start them out right rather than endure two terms of cluelessness before they learn what imprisonment means?  But Norm has thought this through fairly well.  Let them enjoy the perks of power for a while, so they come to feel all strong and important, comfortable in their job, powerful in their position, before pulling the rug out from under them.


So I say require lawmakers to live in the holes into which they consign so many Americans. It’s not such an onerous suggestion, really. No one is forcing a lawmaker to pack his bags for a stay in the Hotel Despair. A lawmaker can walk away from power and its perquisites after a few terms. But if the hunger for power remains, then let power face the stark reality of what it can do to a man or woman: put the lawmaker away and deprive him of the liberty to hug his wife, kiss his child or dream the modest dreams that console his constituents.
As much as they can do plenty of harm in their first two terms, their power increases dramatically the longer they stay in office, and that’s when they get to do the gravest damage to others.  And it would be so much more effective, pulling them away from the comfort of their homes, the love of their families, the adoration of their constituents, the perks of office, and let them live in the same hole to which they so happily send others.  Maybe then, as Norm notes, they will come to understand what ten years in prison means, and why their insane sentences, 30, 40, 50, are astronomically absurd.

Of course, the idea is absolutely crazy.  Nuts.  No one would ever go for it.  And if this was the requirement for a third term of office, no one but a person truly dedicated to public service, to serving others, would even consider suffering six months in prison.  And we certainly wouldn’t want that to happen.

A Loser’s Manifesto

It took me a long time to read the post at Big Debt, Small Law.  Not just because it’s a very long post, but because white text on a black background, a favorite combination of the Slackoisie, is hard on the eyes.  The post is a biting commentary on the misery of a Biglaw wannabe, who was happy to offer his mean-spirited thoughts without demonstrating the integrity of putting his name to them.  Calling himself Law is 4 Losers, he has well-developed metacognitive skills.  He is, indeed, a loser.

It’s not that his laundry list of criticisms of solo practice is wrong.  As Carolyn Elefant says (using some rather surprising language, I might add), they are largely correct:  “Solo practice is shitlaw.”  Or more accurately, it can be.

It’s long been my position that solo practice is hardly the panacea that some would paint it.  It’s fraught with difficulties, problems, annoyances, that one would never experience in a big firm.  The skillset needed for success is quite different, and broader, than is required to be a cog in a wheel.  And not every lawyer is cut out for it.  Indeed, I would argue that most aren’t.

And that’s the point that L4L doesn’t grasp in writing his Loser’s Manifesto. 

It would appear that L4L is a disenfranchised Biglaw wannabe who blew his wad on law school and now, after the fact, has come to the realization that he’s not getting the BMW.  He doesn’t fit into the pigeonhole of Biglaw library chair-warmers, can’t stomach the boiler room where contract attorneys toil and doesn’t have the chops to be a successful solo.

As much as every kid who thinks he wants to be a lawyer should read Norm Pattis’ post. Another Year in the Trenches, they should also read L4L’s New Single-Hangers Get Hung Out To Dry.  The Slackoisie need to know that this isn’t all sunshine, lollipops and rainbows.  They need to realize what it means to be saddled with a mountain of debt and no BMW in sight.  They need to know that the law-as-a-business is a lousy, difficult, often unfulfilling one.

But for those who reject the law-as-a-business philosophy, who know what they are getting into and still, despite everything bad that can be said about it, choose to risk it all and join a profession, there is a potential for a purposeful life that L4L will never know.

I envision L4L to be surrounded by a legion of young, unemployed and unemployable lawyers, angry and miserable about how law school and life has cheated them.  And they have been cheated.  They were sold a bill of good about a future that doesn’t exist.  They happily took on the debt, and suffered the indignities of torts and contracts, believing that their happiness, wealth, fame, power, would be waiting for them as they walked out of the bar exam.  They were lied to.  There’s nothing outside the door but hard work.

Let every inchoate lawyer read about the misery of L4L’s life.  This could be their life as well, and it will hopefully scare away the vast majority of children whose mommies and daddies told them to become a lawyer and live the good life. 

It won’t scare away the few who belong in the profession.  It won’t alter those who want to dedicate their careers to providing excellence to their clients, to face incredible odds and power, and stare it down. 

Very few really belong in solo practice.  Far more are qualified to fetch coffee for partners or read page after page in a boiler room.  It’s quite difficult to hone one’s skills to the point that one lawyer can take on a government and prevail, but the best can and do.  Far better than any wheel-cog could ever imagine.

Let the losers flee.  Flee, losers, flee.  Those who remain are the lawyers.

Best Criminal Law Blawg Post of 2009: And The Winner Is…

The nominations for the Best Criminal Law Blawg Post of 2009 demonstrate one thing beyond any doubt, that the criminal law blawgosphere is not merely alive and well, but thriving.  While other neighborhoods in the blawgosphere may feel tired or stagnant, struggling to remember why they write or finding a subject worth the time and effort, the criminal law blawgosphere has produced a huge number of truly exceptional posts, ranging from the humorous, to the practical, to the critical, to the theoretical, to the personal.

Reading the nominated posts, I cannot express the pride I feel to be a part of this community.  The breadth and depth of these posts, and the myriad terrific posts that didn’t make the list, written by many different blawgers from many different perspective, tells me that we are first hitting our stride.  And there is no indication that the criminal law blawgosphere won’t continue to produce excellent content for the foreseeable future. 

My effort to determine the single best post for 2009 was no small feat.  The choices were all terrific, save one that was offered in jest, The nominated posts should serve as a map for anyone interested in learning and appreciating what the criminal law blawgosphere has to offer.  It’s like a “Who’s Who” of criminal law blawgers, and every blawger deserves our attention and appreciation.

After thoroughly vetting the nominations, I arrived at the top five posts of 2009.  In chronological order of publication, they are: 


If you notice that Jeff Gamso from the never-ending source of so many criminal law blawg posts, Ohio, is disproportionately represented, that’s because Jeff’s blawg, Gamso-For The Defense, is, without a doubt and as already noted by Mark Bennett, the best new criminal law blawg of the year.  Jeff arrived quietly and let his writing speak for him, and it has spoken loud and clear. 

For anyone who thinks that there’s no room left in the criminal law blawgosphere, that it’s already filled to capacity with the likes of big names like Bennett, Cernovich, Gideon, Tannebaum and Pattis, let Jeff Gamso be your inspiration for jumping in, offering some brilliant writing and making yourself a valued member of the community.  There is always room for another great criminal law blawg.

And now, for the main event.  In the enormously difficult effort to find one post that distinguished itself from the many great offerings of the criminal law blawgosphere, I focused on one that combined the best attributes, depth of thought, literacy, interest, over-arching issues of deep concern to criminal lawyers, longevity and passion.  The task was nearly impossible, but one post emerged as the clear winner.

The winner of the Best Criminal Law Blawg Post of 2009 is


Gamso – For the Defense: Do They Really Believe This Stuff?


Thank you, Jeff, for your great work and contributions to the criminal law blawgosphere. 

Now get off my lawn.