Author Archives: SHG

Cuffs Are Out For 2010

I am informed that a number of things I do are no longer considered fashionable.  I still use the same AOL email address I began using in the late 80s. I am barren of tattoos and piercings.  My briefcase is beginning to show its age.  Even my favorite pen is broken.

When I found a hole worn through the left front pocket of my gray trousers, I admitted to myself that it was time to get a new pair.  They had served me honorably for more than a decade, but the trail of loose change left behind as I walked purposefully down Lafayette Street forced my hand.

After inspecting the various shades of gray, and three season weights, that the trouser store offered, I selected a pair that was identical to my last one.  As the fitter knelt to measure the length, I casually said that I would like cuffs.  He looked at me sadly, realizing that he was kneeling before someone who had clearly lost touch with reality.  His eyes told me that I was pathetically out of touch.

With a thick accent, I was told in no uncertain terms that cuffs were no longer in style.

Most of my choices to stay with the familiar, the comfortable, the things that have served me well over the years, have a basis in reason.  Sure, they reflect my personal sensibilities as well, but at least I can offer an explanation for why I refuse to change.  Cuffs present a problem.

There really isn’t a good reason for a gentleman to have cuffs on his trousers.  While they do catch the occasional small item inadvertently dropped, that isn’t their purpose.  They originally came about as a way to add weight to the pants leg, to help maintain the appropriate drape.  This has never presented a problem for me, my drape being quite adequate regardless of weight.  I tend to prefer the feel of heavier material, which naturally maintains its proper drape.  The cuffs were superfluous, from a functional perspective.

The fitter conceded that he would be happy to cuff the hem of my trouser if I insisted.  I realized that he was merely trying to please me, despite my refusal to be fashion forward and heed his advice.  I thanked him, and told him that I was prepared to be stared at in the mall, jeered at when I attended a Rave, ignored as I stood at the velvet rope and helped across the street by a cub scout seeking a badge.  I like cuffs.  There is no good reason for it, and it may be nothing more than vanity, but I like cuffs.

If you happen to see a fellow wearing trousers with cuffs in the courthouse hallway, that would be me.  Please feel free to say hello.  But don’t stare.  I already know that I’m a “fashion” disaster, but I’m good with it.

ABA Blawg 100: Death of the Beauty Pageant

As most of you know, the ABA Journal is running its third annual Blawg 100 beauty pageant.  It started a while back, but today is the last day.  Up to now, I’ve refused to mention it here, but I do so today because it reflects what’s become of the blawgosphere, a metaphor for our consideration.

The first year of the Beauty Pageant, it was more of a fun game, not to be taken too seriously as no one had much of a clue what it meant.  It seemed nice to be recognized as having done sufficiently good work to get onto the ABA Journal’s radar.  Everyone like’s a little appreciation and validation of their efforts.  The competition was deeply flawed, but it was a work in progress.

Second year was somewhat troubling. Good blawgs were ignored.  Non-blawgs were included.  It had the stink of arbitrariness and pointlessness.  We learned that the blawgs, although some weren’t even blogs, named to the 100 were those that someone on the ABA Journal staff decided, for no apparent reason, struck their fancy.  Feelings were hurt by those who didn’t make the cut.

On the other hand, some blawgs began to take the competition much too seriously, as if winning made them real or significant where they were inconsequential otherwise.  A competitive atmosphere arose, which ultimately resulted in the cogs of the ABA Journal altering the votes as improperly cast in a back room somewhere, and naming winners.  The victory rung hollow for some because of this.  For others, they took their victory where they found it, and touted their mastery of the blawgosphere.

This year, the Blawg 100 bears all the arbitrariness of its predecessors, with some worthless, even dead, blogs making the cut and some wonderful blawgs ignored.  Those with inadequate self-esteem pumped and stumped for their great victories, which would entitled them to put a badge on their blawg to promote the ABA Journal.  How glorious a victory would be.

The ABA Journal changed the process this year, requiring erstwhile voters to register with them in order to vote.  Why would anyone register with the ABA Journal?  I didn’t register.  I didn’t vote.  Sure, it would prevent “voter fraud,” as if this vote matters, and it just happens to have the collateral benefit of hyping the ABA Journal and obtaining a great deal of information from those for whom voting was so important that they would actually register to do it.

The competition this year was almost as silly as last.  Simple Justice, with a write-up I found wrong and offensive, was, ironically, in the justice category, along side Mark Bennett’s Defending People and Doug Berman’s Sentencing Law & Policy.  Also included was Crime & Consequences, the mouthpiece of the right wing Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, and Jeralyn Merritt’s Talkleft, focused on the liberal political perspective.  It’s an incongruent mash-up of politics, styles and approaches.  I can’t choose amongst them, as they all are important parts of my blawgosphere. There is no basis for comparison between any of them.  Each is a valued part of a whole.

My choice not to participate in the Beauty Pageant this year, not even to mention its existence on Simple Justice, was in part to maintain my intellectual honesty, given that I’ve been a frequent and harsh critic of the ABA Journal.  Between its absurd Legal Rebel series, promoting the worst of what’s become of lawyers in a farcical promotion of marketing, mediocrity and manipulation, to its deafening silence on monumental issues like the indictment of judges in Maricopa County for refusing to buckle to threats of force, the ABA Journal has demonstrated its irrelevance to the legal profession.  I cannot, in good conscience, enjoy the games it offers while criticizing its failures, and so I refused to do so.

To the extent that putting the ABA Blawg 100 badge on my sidebar will serve to fool the unwary and ignorant into thinking that what happens at Simple Justice matters, I will use it.  Not because it’s true, but because anything the helps to further my message serves my purpose.  I have no qualms about taking advantage of silly things to further a broader agenda.

But one thing happened that compels me to even mention this ridiculous Beauty Pageant.  This:

Votefortechnolawyer

Neil Squillante at Technolawyer wants to win his category so badly that he has started a sweepstakes with cash prizes, substantial cash prizes, for those who vote for Technolawyer.  Nothing that I’ve experienced as a part of the blawgosphere, as a blawg in the ABA Journal Blawg 100, has made me more ashamed than this.

This is what has become of the blawgosphere. The marketers, hypsters, snake oil salesmen have fought hard to change this from a community of thought and expression to a crass commercial opportunity.  Nothing could be more crass than this.  Obviously, Squillante thinks he can eke some monetary benefit from winning, enough so that it’s worth putting up a substantial amount of money to buy votes.  There’s no rule against it, though the ABA Journal seems to make up rules for its Beauty Pageant as it goes along.

I urge everyone reading this post to now register and vote for Technolawyer in the hope of winning the $500 top prize.  You would be foolish to pass up this opportunity to get some cash in your pocket for doing nothing of consequence.

It’s unlikely that the ABA Journal, should it run this Beauty Pageant again next year despite the wholesale lack of interest as shown by the few votes cast, will include a “world weary” ranter like me again.  I never seem to have anything nice to write about it anymore, and if I don’t appreciate their promoting Simple Justice, why waste the space when it could be better used to promote a blawg that will appreciate the ABA Journal more than I do.  But if the staff at the ABA Journal decides to hold this Beauty Pageant again next year, and inexplicably decides to include Simple Justice despite its obvious disdain for my critical “rants”, I won’t put up a dime for your vote. 

If you want to make some money off this Beauty Pageant, vote for Technolawyer now.  It would be shame if nothing beneficial happened for you while the blawgosphere went down the tubes.

An Old Lawyer’s Message

Rarely does a blawg post resonate with the force that Norm Pattis’ did a mere two days ago.  When he wrote Another Year in the Trenches, he sought a catharsis, a way to purge himself of his demons.  His post struck me.

Curiously, it struck many others as well.  I don’t mean that it’s curious that a moving, extremely well-written post would have an affect on others, but that so many of those who were moved by Norm’s post were young, some not even lawyers yet.  It was a glimpse into their future, but not something they could possibly feel as yet.  And this was clear by their efforts at offering “uplifting” comments, as if they could encourage Norm to get past his “funk” by reminding him of the good he’s done, of the lives he’s saved, of the benefit he’s provided in his years of criminal defense.

Norm knows that.  I know that too.  We’ve both offered many a word of encouragement to the discouraged young lawyer faced with his first jury verdict when he was absolutely sure he would win.  We’ve comforted the lawyer for the innocent, whose life will be spent in prison, whose family will be husbandless and fatherless, because some cop fudged the facts or some judge took the path of least resistance.  We’ve been there, with kind words and comforting thoughts.

But we know a truth that no young lawyer, and certainly no law student, can possibly know.  We are engaged in a process that begs us to push back a tidal wave of misery.  And another tidal wave after that.  And another.  It never stops.  They come rolling in, one after another.  After a while, we get tired of trying to stop the tidal wave, knowing how many more are behind it. 

There is no need to remind us that we save lives, one at a time.  We know.  And sometimes we do save a life.  More often, we try our best and fall short.  We tell ourselves that we’ve achieved a small victory for a defendant, when we know that the best we’ve managed to eke out is saving his children from the larger failure of never seeing their father walk free in their lifetime.  What must a ten year sentence look like to a young child?  How many young children must grow up without a parent, while we convince ourselves that we’ve helped?

The young lawyer bolsters himself against this feeling of futility by believing in platitudes, in the myths we construct around our efforts to keep us going in the face of futility.  They are not yet jaded and tired.  They believe that they make a difference.  They believe that the next judge will listen, that the next cop will tell the truth.  They believe that justice can be achieved.  They believe that they know what justice is.

There are only so many times an old lawyer can bang his head against a wall without it hurting more than he can stand.

Norm has fought these battles for a very long time.  He’s tried many cases, and listened to many defendants speak about their lives.  He knows what becomes of their lives.  He knows too well.  He’s had great victories.  He’s had crashing defeats.  And still the tidal waves keep coming. 

The message I take from Norm’s post, and one I share with Norm, isn’t intended for the young lawyers or lawyers to be.  We need you, your youth, your zeal, your belief, your resolve, to take up the fight.  Underneath the cynical shell, we remain idealists who believe that a system can be fashioned that won’t destroy lives, if only we can keep fighting the tidal waves.  But old lawyers get tired.  Young lawyers, especially those in their prime, where their skills have developed to the point where they can mount the good fight yet not suffer the cynicism of one loss too many, need to push back against the tidal wave.

Norm is just in a funk.  He will be revitalized on his own, when the next person walks in his office with a life in need of saving.  Norm will shore himself up, put on the armor and feel that surge of energy that flows through your body as you walk into the courtroom ready to do battle.  He doesn’t need his hand held, or to be told what a wonderful job he’s done.  He knows.

As the next tidal wave approaches, you will see Norm right up front, ready to push with all his might.  It’s just what he does.  Norm just needed to let out the frustration, the feeling of exhaustion from having to push again.  But he’ll do it, because that’s what he does.  That’s what old lawyers do, even though they’re tired of pushing. 

Young lawyers, and lawyers to be, understand that Norm hasn’t given up hope.  He’s just tired.  But he’ll get over it.  If you take anything from Norm’s post, step up to the fight while Norm rests and aspire to work as hard for as long as Norm to make things better.  They day will come when you young lawyers will have to fight the tidal waves without the old lawyers, and the best homage you could offer Norm is to start now.





Ending Taser Terror

In a decision that, from start to finish, reflects the most thoughtful and incisive review of the impropriety of police use of Tasers whenever it’s convenient, the 9th Circuit in Bryan v. McPherson held that the propriety of police use of a Taser is judged by 4th Amendment standards for seizure, and that it constitutes an intermediate level use of force that can only be justified by an immediate threat and the absence of less invasive alternatives.

This is a huge decision.  No longer, at least in the 9th Circuit, can a police officer tase a person at will. 

The facts of the case are truly atrocious.  From the Sacramento Bee :


In the summer of 2005, Carl Bryan, 21, was pulled over for a seat-belt violation and did not follow an officer’s order to stay in the car.

Earlier, he had received a speeding ticket and had taken off his T-shirt to wipe away tears. He was wearing only the underwear he’d slept in because a woman had taken his keys, the court said without further explanation.


During his second traffic stop in Coronado, he got out of the car. He was “agitated … yelling gibberish and hitting his thighs, clad only in his boxer shorts and tennis shoes” but did not threaten the officer verbally or physically, the judges wrote.


That’s when Coronado Police Officer Brian McPherson, who was standing about 20 feet away watching Bryan’s “bizarre tantrum,” fired his Taser, the court said.


Without a word of warning, he hit Bryan in the arm with two metal darts, delivering a 1,200-volt jolt.


Temporarily paralyzed and in intense pain, Bryan fell face-first on the pavement. The fall shattered four of his front teeth and left him with facial abrasions and swelling. Later, a doctor had to use a scalpel to remove one of the darts.


McPherson made all the standard sounds to justify his use of force, how he felt “threatened” by this “:aggressive” “non-compliant” seat-belt non-wearer who failed to obey his command and resisted his lawful order.  The court called McPherson’s bluff, and shot down his excuses. 

McPherson then went into Bryan’s “gibberish”, alleging that he might have been mentally ill, for which he was excoriated by the court for suggesting that mental illness was the perfect justification for using force.  I would anticipate police officers nationwide to exclaim how the 9th Circuit doesn’t “get it,” that mentally ill people pose a threat to their safety (since one never knows what a mentally ill person will do), thus justifying a quick tasing to make sure that the officer makes it back in time for the donut run home safely.  But the court understood:


“Officer McPherson’s desire to quickly and decisively end an unusual and tense situation is understandable,” Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw wrote for the court. “His chosen method for doing so violated Bryan’s constitutional right to be free from excessive force.”
Finally, we have a clear and decisive ruling that knee-jerk resort to the Taser, the lazy-man’s method of ending non-threatening citizen encounters just shy of a bullet between the eyes, is an unconstitutional use of excessive force in effecting a seizure under the 4th Amendment. Amen.

H/T Dr. Sunwolf

Judge Larry Himelein Gets Slapped

While it’s usually David Lat’s domain to look under the robes (yuck), the decision of the Commission on Judicial Conduct in the case of Cattaraugus County Judge Larry M. Himelein is just too chock full of really great insider stuff to ignore. 

Judge Himelein, who clearly has strong feelings on the subject of the Legislature’s refusal to grant a pay raise to judges any time in this or last millennium, decided that he wasn’t going to take it anymore.  He recused himself from cases involving law firms that had a legislator on board, and made it clear that this wasn’t because he couldn’t be impartial, but because it was the only effective “weapon in [judges’] arsenal” to force movement.

This flew in the face of some advisory judicial ethics decisions that concludes that judges need not recuse themselves based upon the various lawsuits to force the legislature to address judicial pay, though the decisions concluded that it wasn’t mandatory, not that it was inherently unethical.

But Larry Himelein had perhaps an excess of moxie, and a hair-trigger finger on the “reply all” button on his email.  And he wasn’t afraid to use them.  From the WSJ Law Blog :


Yesterday’s filing also said Himelein (Ithaca College ‘71, Suffolk Law ‘75) participated in: “[c]hiding, browbeating and insulting judges who did not recuse (calling them ‘wusses,’ ‘non-self-respecting,’ ‘gutless,’ and ‘wimp[s]‘), denigrating downstate judges in particular (’lackies’ and ‘toadies for the politicians’) and telling them to ‘grow some stones,’ respondent repeatedly urged his judicial colleagues to recuse en masse (’How about everyone recuses by 5:00 today???’).”
That’s right, he really called his fellow judges all those things.  And they were particularly directed at New York City judges. I bet they weren’t pleased with some upstate hick judge from Cattaraugus County (who even knew New York had a Cattaraugus County?) calling them names. And a county court judge, not even a Supreme!

While I have long advocated for judges to take charge of their own fate in the pay dispute, and stop relying on the kindness of legislators or hiding behind the platitudes of judicial propriety while complaining bitterly at how their frozen pay won’t support their children’s education.  The Legislature’s gamesmanship on the issue of judicial pay defies the usual standards of judicial propriety, and there is no dignity in poverty.  It may not be a crime to go for a decade without a raise, but it is an affront to separation of powers and a facial assault in the independence of the judiciary.  While the advisory opinions are long on judicial propriety, they fail to resolve the judicial independence problem.  Leaving the judiciary begging at the Legislature’s door is, in my opinion, a far worse fate than showing that there’s a person beneath the robe.

That said, Himelein went whole hog, taking no prisoners in his assault on New York City.  That was doomed to come back to haunt him.  As much as I admire his “stones”, and agree with his view that the judiciary will relegate itself to the back of the bus if it doesn’t learn to stand up for itself, this was not likely the way to make friends and influence people. 

The good news, of course, is that the Commission on Judicial Conduct, after cataloging Judge Himelein’s many transgressions in his blast emails and recusals, agreed to a censure as punishment.  For those unfamiliar with this disposition, it’s the public statement that “you were a very bad boy judge and never do that again.”  It’s not like they docked his pay or anything, the bunch of gutless wusses.

Calling The Pot Black

I’ve been taken to task, and rightfully so, by Gideon at A Public Defender for posting about New York City’s negligible murder rate while the rate by which blacks are arrested for smoking pot has skyrocketed.  In my defense, I can’t write about everything, and it’s not like I didn’t call this problem long ago.

The problem now, as discussed by Gid and Jim Dwyer at the New York Times is not only that cops, without serious crime to occupy their time, keep busy by busting kids for smoking dope.  But not just any kids.  Black kids. Latino kids. Worse still, when a white kid gets popped for smoking a joint, chances are very good that he will get a Desk Appearance Ticket, a notice to appear in court at a later date.  The black and Latino kid, on the other hand, will be arrested, spend the night at Central Booking and be arraigned about 24 hours later, at which point he will be offered an infraction with a few days community service and a fine.

That the traffic flow for whites and blacks/Latinos is so different is explained in Dwyer’s column as a by-product of long-standing police practice, that there are more cops on the street in black and Latino neighborhoods than downtown, and they therefore nab more kids uptown. 


“Marijuana arrests — which rarely lead to jail — are concentrated in neighborhoods with the highest concentrations of violent crime because that’s where the police focus their attention in order to reduce victimization,” [Mayor Bloomberg’s chief criminal justice aide, John]  Feinblatt said. “This continued focus on low-level offending has been part of the city’s effective crime-reduction strategy, which has resulted in a 35 percent decrease in crime since 2001.”

This ignores its inherent prejudice.  This “highest concentrations of violent crime” argument has been used for decades, while crime has dropped but the police presence has continued unabated, now spending their time frisking and nabbing pot smokers.

What’s wholly unappreciated is the magnitude and impact of this approach.  The chart below from Queens College Professor Harry G. Levine via  Change.com shows it far more clearly than words can express.


While thoughtful commentators question the value of the continued war on drugs, New York City pot arrests have increased exponentially.  The human and financial costs of this nuclear explosion in pot arrests is huge, but few realize how massive the numbers have grown. 

The most telling distinction, however, isn’t the growth in marijuana (or marihuana, as New York State law inexplicably calls it), but that white kids get DATs and blacks and Latinos get arrested.  Nothing makes the point more clearly, because the decision of whether to hold a defendant or issue a DAT is a purely discretionary act on the part of the cops. 

White pot smokers, to the extent they are even arrested, are both sufficiently sympathetic and sufficiently trust by the police to return to court on the appointed day, while black and Latino kids receive neither sympathy nor trust and are held in custody for arraignment.  There is no information on the disposition of these cases, but I wouldn’t be surprised to find that the latter receive higher fines, more community service, and this comes on top of spending a night in jail.

As Dwyer notes, marijuana was ‘decriminalized” in a fit of sanity back in the 70s.


The possession of less than an ounce of marijuana was decriminalized by the State Legislature in 1977, reduced to a violation, the equivalent of a traffic ticket. “Burning” it or having it “open to public view” is a misdemeanor.

Of course, almost every arrest is for the misdemeanor, since the cops nab the pot-perp for smoking on the street or claim that they had it in public view when they write up the charges, even if the bust was inside someone’s home.  Happens all the time.  This is rarely subject to any scrutiny, since the cases are invariably “pled down” to the infraction and everybody goes home.  These aren’t the types of cases where people are willing to fight to the death, or pay the freight for a fight. 

These are assembly-line cases, like prostitution and numbers were (and may still be, for all I know) when I was a young lawyer doing arraignments.  In and out, and the defendants are more than happy to take a non-criminal disposition and get out of the courtroom as quickly as possible. 

I don’t suggest that the solution to this overall problem, or its overtly prejudiced handling, is that we need more serious crime to keep cops occupied.  It would be nice if the police, on their own, recognized that they treat blacks and Latinos poorly, and chose to end their biased handling of people of color.  But I wouldn’t count on that either.

Perhaps one answer is that arraigning judges take notice of the sea of dark skin before them, and ask themselves why only blacks and Latinos seem to show up in the AR parts.  Once they have their judicial epiphany, perhaps they could address this disparity by altering their sentencing policies to reflect the fact that these defendants have already spent a night in jail for the heinous crime of smoking a joint, something the DAT kids managed to avoid. 

Two little words, “time served,” might be a way to level the playing field.  And even the cops, who don’t believe that the sentence is sufficient, might start issuing DATs to blacks and Latinos, just to hope that they fail to appear and then have warrants to justify their subsequent stop and frisk.  At that point, it’s up to the recipients of the DATs to prove the cops wrong.

A second, and more effective, approach might be to grant Clayton motions to any defendant without a prior who was held on a pot charge.  The defendant won’t get his night in jail back, but it’s a way to smack the cops’ hand for the disparate treatment of blacks and Latinos.  Of course, that would be a bold move by judges, requiring a firm belief that it’s wrong to treat black and Latino kids differently than white kids.  Could that really happen?

Not For Publication

Lawyers are a hoot.  We write stuff in letters that makes us sound like we’ve got army behind us if the recipient doesn’t buckle.  Heck, in Maricopa, judges can’t enforce their own decisions, and yet some guys in blue pinstripes (not the Yankees) strut about like they own the place.

Walter Olson at Overlawyered posts about a letter from Los Angeles attorney Martin Singer to photographer Anthony Citrano over the monumental issue of whether Demi Moore’s hips were retouched in a cover photo for some magazine.  Who cares, right?  Well, apparently, Demi cares, and therefore Singer cares. 

Brooklyn native Singer, who stands 6 foot 10 inches and 270 pounds in writing, begins his lawyer letter ominously:


Confidential Legal Notice
Publication or Dissemination is Prohibited

So serious.  So strong. So…so…lawyerly.  The rest of the letter is just as funny, especially the last paragraph, which not only reiterates Singer’s confidentiality demand but incorporates a bunch of other typical lawyerisms that state the obvious as if it mattered.

On one level, you would think that an LA lawyer would have a clue that this letter, which has cousins sent to Boing Boing and Jezebel, was not only going to go public, but that it would serve as a vehicle to make Singer a laughingstock and embarrass lawyers everywhere.  Isn’t Streisand from LA, Marty?

It’s not like Singer is unaware of what can happen when you send out letters with incredibly stupid, pompous, overbearing demands like this.  Singer did the same thing last summer, and got his butt handed to him for being such a jerk.  Back then, he claimed his demand letters were copyrighted, which naturally gave rise to ridicule for making such an absurd claim.  Singer, a self-described “pit bull,” was revealed as a “chihuahua.”  But the little dogs aren’t this stupid. They learn after getting a smack on the behind. It looks like Singer doesn’t learn.  Or maybe the smack wasn’t hard enough to make him realize what an idiot he looks like.

For those non-lawyers who might read this, be aware that the reason this is so goofy is that a lawyer letter can’t tell you that it’s confidential.  It’s just a bluff, a gambit by the lawyer to find out how stupid and easily scared the other guy is.  Tell your mother, your friends, or put it online.  It’s yours to do with as you please.

But what about Marty Singer?  Is he ever going to figure out that his launching these facacta missiles keeps coming around to hit him in pinstriped-clad touchy?  Must he continue to make lawyers look like foolish oafs.  Will he ever figure out that the Streisand Effect applies to him (not to mention his celebrity clients) like anybody else?

And who cares if Demi Moore’s hips were retouched anyway?

Fuggedaboutit.

Dying To Be In New York

The New York Times reports that New York City has logged 461 murders to date this year, potentially making 2009 the lowest number since record keeping began.  Included in that number are some old cases, including a shooting that occurred in 1960 where the fellow died of infection in 2009.  Another from a 1965 assault.

The lowest year, at least until the end of the week was 2007 with 496.  Chances of racking up another 35 murders by Saturday don’t look good.  The stats are interesting:


Most of this year’s victims — 283 of them — were killed with a gun fired by someone they knew. Others were stabbed (90 cases), hit with a blunt instrument (28) or asphyxiated (16). One victim was murdered with a car.

Only 34 percent of the victims, no matter how they died, were killed by strangers.

That last statistic, that 66% of victims were killed by someone they knew, is critical.  While people continue to blindly accept the myth that we live in City plagued by violent, anonymous crime, it’s simply untrue.  Watching “Like It Is” with Gil Noble a couple of Sunday’s ago, an activist argued for a community based program to stop the murders that plagued his neighborhood.  There was a grand total of one this year.

The police, naturally, argue that this amazingly low rate reflects their great work.  Maybe.  Certainly, it doesn’t reflect that they haven’t done their job well, so there’s credit for the cops any way you look at it.  And if 66% of all murders are committed by people who know their victim, there’s little the police could do to stop it in any event.

Doug Berman sees a similar lesson in these numbers for sentencing reform:


First, New York state in recent years has been reducing its overall prison population and its incarceration rate.  Second, the two federal districts that impose among the greatest number of below-guideline sentences are based on Manhattan and Brooklyn.  Of course, based on these data, I would not make a bold claim that there is a direct causal link between more lenient sentencing outcomes and reduced crime.  But I do think these NYC realities help refute the notion that crime reductions can only be achieved by more severe sentencing outcomes.

While reforms or reduced sentences may not be the cause of this atmosphere of reduced murder, they haven’t caused the sky to fall, as so many cry will happen every time someone suggests that the answer to every criminal problem isn’t more and lengthier incarceration. 

The vast majority of murders, 283, were caused by gunshot.  The police attribute the reduced rate to New York’s efforts to get guns off the street:



Curbing gun use is linked to lowering the homicide rate, officials said, and Mr. Kelly lauded the mayor’s effort to stop illegal guns from flowing into New York, saying 90 percent of the guns that are confiscated after they are used in crimes come from out of state. He also cited the department’s program of questioning and frisking some people on the streets as a “lifesaving” strategy that had led to the seizure of 7,000 weapons this year, including 800 guns.
It’s unfortunate that the Times neglected to flesh this claim out a little more, give that this “lifesaving” strategy involved 496,000 stops, of which more than 90% were black or Latino, and led to seizures of about 800 guns.  Bear in mind that we’re still only talking about that 34% of murders between strangers here.  That’s 620 unconstitutional stops for every gun taken off the street. Not an impressive result.

Still, the point that guns are effective weapons, turning an angry moment into a death, can’t be ignored. 

For all the bravado expressed by men (it’s almost always men, and usually from Texas) about how they want to have their gun close at hand so that they can kill anyone who steps on their lawn uninvited, neither your machismo nor your death penalty nor your stand-your-ground-castle-doctrine exists in New York.  Yet you maintain blind faith in the benefits of killing others, and think New York City is a sewer of violence.

Maybe this is just one New Yorker’s view of the world, but we seem to be doing pretty well here without ever-harsher laws, the death penalty and he-men shooting stupid kids.

Some criminal defense lawyers will complain that these low crime rates are bad for business.  Certainly it leaves lawyers with more free time on their hands, time that used to be spent defending accused murderers.  Sanity tells us that we’re just going to have to live with that.

But this should put to rest any argument that the absence of “tough on crime,” increased criminalization and harsher penalties will lead to a plague of violence.  It’s just another Menckian solution that appeals to the cowboys and simpletons.

Maybe next year, we could consider whether giving individuals accused of crimes their full panoply of constitutional rights would impact the murder rate?  Maybe we will learn that judges can honor the Constitution without risking the downfall of society to a plague of violence.  It seems that plagues aren’t what they used to be.

Nominations Open for Best Criminal Law Blawg Post of 2009 (Update)

Since everybody seems to enjoy a contest, it seems like a good idea to try one that shoots for something more substantive than who’s blawg has the prettiest graphics.  And so, I announce the Best Criminal Law Blawg Post of 2009 contest. 

Here’s the deal.  Anybody can “nominate” a post for the honor, including their own.  SJ posts are off limits.  You can nominate them anonymously, with great fanfare, just by name or with a detailed explanation of why you think a post is the best.  It can be a post from a criminal defense lawyer, a prosecutor or a non-lawyer, provided it’s subject is criminal law.  It can even be a post by a lawprof. You can nominate as many posts as you like.

For this contest, and for this contest only, I will allow links to be included in comments to the posts (not just the blawgs, but the actual posts) nominated.  Spam links will be deleted.

This is a chance to think back over the year and give everyone some great posts to read, to ponder, to discuss and maybe even change some minds.

My plan is to announce the winner on New Year’s Day.  This plan, of course, is contingent on readers doing their part and nominating some great stuff.  If we don’t get enough nominations, or the quality of what is nominated sucks, then the contest will be a bust and will reflect poorly on what we do.

Judge will be entirely on my shoulders, and I will be as arbitrary and capricious as I please.  That said, I will do my best to select the blawg post that best reflects our finest work, our highest tradition, our deepest thoughts and our best purpose in putting words on a computer screen.

I hope that everyone will contribute, and that we can demonstrate the vitality of the criminal law blawgosphere.  Now nominate.

Update:  Nominations will close as of 5:00 p.m. EDT today, December 31st. 

Update 2: Nominations are now closed.

Feige’s Fiction and Bronx Reality

Before David Feige became famous, with his book “Indefensible” and his television series, Raising the Bar, he was a real lawyer working for the Bronx Defenders.  And that means he represented real defendants.  And that means things didn’t always go swell, because that’s how it works when you represent real defendants.

In a decision issued December 18th, one of David’s clients sought to vacate his conviction in a 440.10 motion for ineffective assistance of counsel.  The motion, People v. Radcliffe, went before Bronx Justice Richard Lee Price, whose decision is one of the most remarkable I’ve ever seen.  Not merely because it involves a lawyer turned celebrity who is accused of ineffective assistance, but because David, who supported his former client’s motion in the finest tradition of the criminal defense lawyer, put into writing one of the deep, dark secrets of the courtroom that is never to be revealed.

A little background is necessary to appreciate the situation.  After a hard-fought suppression hearing, with misidentification being fairly clearly raised as the defense to the charge of possession of a weapon and assault, both in the second degree, suppression was denied, but the testimony was clear.  According to David Feige, the trial judge, Dominic Massaro, gave him a “slight nod of the head” and said he was “intimately familiar with the vagaries of eyewitness identifications.”  David decided to waive a jury and proceed on the hearing record plus some stipulations.  The defendant was acquitted of the top count but convicted of the lessers, and sentenced to 15 years.

In the motion to vacate the conviction, the defendant raises the plethora of typical allegations, which are disposed of quickly by Justice Price.  He then gets to David’s mea culpa, which he notes have kept him

awake at night wrought with guilt for having made “the most stunning and appalling decision” of his career.

It’s one thing to lose.  It’s another to have given away another human being’s life.

Historically, there are only two reasons why a criminal defense lawyer waives a jury.  The first is that his client, or the case, is just so ugly that they fear no jury will be able to overcome their prejudice to render a fair verdict.  In that case, a judge, assuming one disinclined to hang the defendant first and try him later, will be more capable of a decision unfettered by bias.

The other alternative is the nod and wink, the old-time contract where the judge would let a lawyer know, subtly, to go non-jury.  The deal was that when a judge suggested that a lawyer go non-jury, the judge would acquit.  This isn’t corrupt in the sense of a judge being bought, but rather that a judge believed the defendant to deserve an acquittal and wanted to save everyone the time, effort and problem of a crazy jury verdict. 

A nod and wink, and an acquittal it would be.  This was the deal.  It’s not like this was written down anywhere, but it was the unspoken code of the courthouse.  Except that David Feige spoke of it, and Justice Price was “shocked”.


This court finds it acutely disturbing that after spewing his mea culpas, Mr. Feige implicitly abdicates responsibility to Justice Massaro for the verdict not being what he anticipated. “Had Justice Massaro not done what he did, I would had [sic] proceeded with a trial, as I had throughout my career and as I always intended to do.” Unfortunately, for both Mr. Feige and the defendant, nothing in the record before this court remotely suggests that Justice Massaro assured, promised or guaranteed that he would acquit the defendant. Even Mr. Feige’s characterization that Justice Massaro gave him the “wink” is devoid of any factual support. In fact, as noted above, Mr. Feige based his strategic decision on a dubious head-nod and “unmistakable” look, which does not remotely qualify as a promise or guarantee. To infer that Justice Massaro somehow made false or misleading representations is intellectually dishonest.

David’s allegations are many things, but intellectually dishonest is not one of them.  If anything, he’s broken the code of silence about contracts.  What’s the point of a nod and wink if everybody knows what they mean?  Part of the same deal between judge and defense lawyer is that they not walk down the hallways crowing about how the judge was about to give the defendant a walk.  And here was David Feige, putting it in writing in an affirmation, made under penalty of perjury, spelling out the deal for all to see.  Could Justice Price allow this to happen without a darn good spanking?

Maybe David misread the signs.  Maybe Justice Massaro never meant to suggest that he go non-jury, or on a stipulated record.  Maybe the days of the contract are dead, and even old-time judges like Massaro feel no compulsion to honor it.  I can’t begin to know where things went so very wrong here.  But clearly they did.  David’s owning up to this fiasco, falling on the sword, is what one would expect of an honorable criminal defense lawyer.  Most, unfortunately, would let their former client fry before admitting mistake.


Perhaps Mr. Feige does indeed seek redemption for his perceived malpractice or perhaps there are other motivational forces in operation. Neither is of any moment. If, however, Mr. Feige is indeed guilty of the ills he claims to be, then in light of the accomplished author and producer he has become, disbarment, which he curiously appears too eager to accept, seems far from adequate. If, on the other hand, Mr. Feige is simply remorseful for misreading Justice Massaro, such remorse hardly qualifies as error, much less ineffective assistance of counsel; it is merely an unsuccessful defense strategy.
It’s hard to understand how the mistaken reading of the nod and wink can be characterized as “merely an unsuccessful defense strategy.”  It’s not a strategy, but a contract, and if there was no contract ab initio, then the deal busts all around.  Certainly the defendant shouldn’t be the one to pay the price if David misread the nod and wink, having been denied the ability to test his guilt because his lawyer misinterpreted a furtive glance.

But Justice Price has issued a decision designed to make one thing abundantly clear.  This never happens.  This is a fiction, an urban myth.  No judge would ever give a criminal defense lawyer a nod and wink.  Never.  Right.

H/T Andrew Lavoott Bluestone