Author Archives: SHG

The Difference Between 7 and 5

In a very moving post questioning the cost of, and funding for, the criminal justice system in general, and public defenders in particular, Gideon at A Public Defender poses a challenge to those who try to tweak around the edges in an effort to improve matters:


But it’s all a futile exercise. It’s never going to happen unless there’s a fundamental shift in the thinking. That shift may well be driven by the financial engine. So how about taking a different tact. How about we keep detailed statistics: how many people end up going to jail for a violation of probation for drug problems instead of to a treatment facility? Let’s keep a record of that for 3 years and calculate the cost of sending that person to jail. How about defendants sentenced to 7 years in jail where 5 years would have been just as good. Keep a track of the costs there. How many inmates were denied entry into programs for lack of beds and so instead were forced to take a prison sentence? Let’s keep track of that.
Buried in this paragraph is one sentence that has long been particularly disturbing: How about defendants sentenced to 7 years in jail where 5 years would have been just as good. Sentences, the end result of a plea or verdict, have a magical quality in the public’s mind.  It’s as if they are meted out according to some secret magic formula, determined with some measure of exactitude to serve the various purposes that people think sentences should serve. 

People believe that the sentences judges impose are based upon some hard, real evidence, no proof, of what length of time is needed to accomplish their purpose.  For most people, incidentally, that purpose is retribution only, the sole factor that ever seems to be important to anyone. 

Like the value of a lost leg in a personal injury case, the proper length of a sentence is hardly clear.  In many instances, we can anticipate a sentence based upon generalized experience for similarly situated defendants.  Often, this is due to the options available from the Legislature, which become broader or more limited as different theories prevail.  But assuming a relatively broad sentencing range, it’s left to a judge to fix a point within that range.

How does a judge decide that a sentence of 17 years is proper?  Why not round it off at 15?  What not 17 years, 3 months?  What’s special about 17?  And yet, some defendants are sentenced to 17 years. 

As Gideon notes, every day in prison has a cost, both to the defendant, his family, and for those of you who couldn’t care less about the defendant and his family, to the public.  We pay, and pay big, to keep defendant’s locked away.  It’s a cost that many believes makes sense, at least in most instances, but only a fool is happy to overpay.  If we can accomplish all the retribution that makes us feel better about ourselves in 5 years, why sentence him to 7?

The truth is that judges have no magic powers at all when it comes to sentencing.  Most realize it, but also realize that sentencing is part of their job and they try to do their best.  Some try to justify it empirically, as the federal sentencing guidelines pretend to do, but the best they accomplish is consistency.  This removes one aspect of arbitrariness from sentencing, but doesn’t begin to touch the caprice of contending that 7 years is better than 5 years.  Or 9 years, if you want to push on the other end.

There are some sentencing lines that make sense.  We may feel that a particular crime mandates that an individual spend the rest of his life in prison.  Life sentences are pretty clear.  The next dividing line is 25 years, an enormous length of time that is more than sufficient for any crime that doesn’t mandate a life sentence.  After that comes 10 years, an eternity to almost anyone.  This number is often the dividing line between a plea and trial for serious crimes; Defendants simply refuse to take a sentence of more than 10 years and are prepared to roll the dice before going in quietly.  On the lower end of the spectrum, the dividing lines are 5 years, 3 years and 1 year, reflecting the intervals for crimes of varying severity.

The question is how a judge arrives at the conclusion that ten years is too low but 12 years is just right.  The only time this makes sense is when there are co-defendants, whose conduct is distinguishable such that one should serve a longer sentence than another.  If the defendant whose conduct was bad, but not as bad as his co-defendant, gets 10, then it makes some sense that the co-defendant be sentenced to 12 to reflect his more egregious wrong.  But while this may explain intervals between sentenced imposed on co-defendants, it doesn’t explain the basis for the specific sentence imposed.

As Gideon contends, the years have brought us ever-increasing sentences, with ever-increasing costs.  This followed the “tough-on-crime” trend that was borne of a sense of public frustration largely fed by politicians and media who were busily sensationalizing crime and manipulating the public fear to their own advantage.  Sentence inflation, at best, is palliative, making us feel better without actually improving our safety or the system, and without anyone giving thought to the costs incurred.  This doesn’t touch, by the way, the collateral issue of defendant’s leaving prison drug free and capable of gainful employment, another sore spot.

Gideon is right.  It’s time to scrutinize the bizarre and inexplicable sentences imposed, to terms of 17 years or 23 years or 8 years, and ask what conceivable basis could there be that would compel a judge to sentence a defendant to such an odd length of time.  Every year beyond that which is necessary is a cost society, nor a defendant and his family, should not be forced to bear.  We all suffer from these absurd sentences, and their whimsical imposition must be brought under control. 

Where To Keep The Prisoners

A commenter here who goes by the handle “Dissent” has a blog called Pogo Was Right, referring to a simple cartoon that says more than all the posts I will ever be able to write, and a sister blog called Chronicles of Dissent.  In referring to a post of mine, Dissent called my writing style “take no prisoners.”  This gave me pause.

An entire army of blogolators exists to tell others how to blog.  How to blog to get business.  How to blog to get famous. How to blog to get rich.  How to make your blog last forever.  Of course, blogs are still at the youth stage, unclear what they will be when they grow up.  It’s an age of uncertainty, self-doubt, searching for answers.  Blogolators are people who have personally achieved nothing, and so teach others how to be successful, having figured out that the only purpose to blogging is to create an industry where people believe they need someone of dubious merit to teach them how to accomplish something that can only grow organically.

It had never occurred to me before that I had a style. I sit down and write, and from where I sit, each post looks different.  Some are more humorous than others.  Some are relatively thoughtful for a trench lawyer.  Some are sentimental.  Some are just plain goofy.  They are whatever flows from the ol’ digits at any given moment.  As Shakespeare wrote, I don’t know what I think until I see what I write.  I’m often as surprised to see what my post says as you.

There are, however, some basic premises to my writing.  If I have a point, I try to make it.  If it’s unclear, and sometimes it’s very unclear judging from the comments, then I have failed.  I sometimes try to convince myself that I made my point too subtle, rather than I just blew it.  It makes me feel better to pretend that I’ve been subtle rather than sucky.  Sucky makes me feel bad.

There are times, however, when I just go for the jugular.  It’s the killer instinct in me, primal and vicious.  I’m not necessarily proud of it, but it’s who I am.  People have accused me of being sensationalistic, writing unduly provocative posts to attract readers.  I never write to attract readers, and no post has ever been unduly provocative as far as I’m concerned.  At most, they are just the right amount of provocative.  And if they are provocative, it’s because that’s how I feel.  There is no ulterior purpose here.  None.

But do I “take no prisoners?”  I suppose I don’t.  It’s not that I have anything against prisoners, per se, but I wouldn’t know where to put them and, frankly, have no desire to take care of them.  I don’t even like pets.  True, I have a cat that we keep outdoors as a mouser.  I call it “cat”. But I don’t feed it, and still it stays here. 

Is there a purpose to taking prisoners?  If a subject is of sufficient interest to me to write about it, then why would I be concerned about how others will react?  Anyone who writes about things that matter to them, with the concern for how others will react, will end up satisfying no one and nothing.  Their point will be watered down, lest it offend the prisoners, if one can find a point in it at all.  It no longer reflects the writer’s position or view, but rather the need to appease others by writing nothing that a reader might find troubling.  Milquetoast writing.  Milquetoast thinking. The first rule becomes offend no one.  The result is say nothing.

Why bother to write if you’re afraid of what you have to say?  You won’t feel any satisfaction, and no one will care to read it.  No one has ever complimented a beige wall.  Whether you’re thoughts bring in the cheers of those who agree with you or the jeers of those who think you are the most demented idiot on earth, at least you have thoughts.  Cogito, ergo sum. 

I recently had an email exchange with a lawprof who felt deeply hurt by things that were written about his ideas.  He informed me that they were too harsh, too rough, too disrespectful.  Ironically, he wasn’t referring to things I had written.  He was on the verge of giving up blawging, finding it too vulgar for his sensibilities.  Of course, if he wants vulgar, he should cruise some non-lawyer blogs, where the language and ideas are so crass that they make me cringe.  I don’t cringe easily.

My response was to stop being a baby and fight back.  Just because some of us take no prisoners doesn’t mean you can’t win the battle, or even the war.  I draw from the same arsenal of words available to everyone else (except for the few that I make up, but then there’s nothing stopping you from making up a few of your own).  The only consideration is to make sure that you get your point across.  If that means taking no prisoners, so be it.  If no one gets your point, you have only yourself to blame.


Safety First: Fly Naked (Update)

Some of us have been critical in the past of the Transportation Safety Administrations reactive measures to assure that airline passengers arrive safely at their destination.  It was as if 9/11 would never happen again, failing first to appreciate the imaginative Richard Reid and his shoe bomb, and now, Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, with high explosive sewn into his clothing.

But there was no hand-wringing or recriminations at the TSA this time. They moved forward decisively with immediate remedies to close the gaping loopholes that are always made painfully obvious after the fact.  Within a mere 24 hours of the near-tragedy, the New York Times disclosed some of the changes:


The government was vague about the steps it was taking, saying that it wanted the security experience to be “unpredictable” and that passengers would not find the same measures at every airport — a prospect that may upset airlines and travelers alike.

Upset the foolish or not, this is a critical aspect of passenger safety, tricking would-be terrorists by having no safety measures in effect at certain airports to befuddle the overly prepared.

But several airlines released detailed information about the restrictions, saying that passengers on international flights coming to the United States will apparently have to remain in their seats for the last hour of a flight without any personal items on their laps. It was not clear how often the rule would affect domestic flights.

Overseas passengers will be restricted to only one carry-on item, and domestic passengers will probably face longer security lines. That was already the case in some airports Saturday, in the United States and overseas.


Some have questioned this “knee-jerk” response by the TSA, reflecting their own lack of understanding of how real safety works and how the too-real threat to our national security must be stopped, merely because these restrictions bear no cognizable relationship to Abdulmutallab conduct.  These critics, of course, lack inside knowledge both of the ways terrorists operate and how these restrictions fit with the TSA plans for the future.

Initially, it is well known that acts of terrorism will only occur after the individual terrorist has purged his bowels.  If not, then there could be massive humiliation, both to the cause and the terrorist’s mourning family, if the subsequent description says that he messed himself.  By not allowing a potential terrorist to go to the lavatory, a fundamental necessity in all terrorist plans will be eliminated, thus making it impossible for the seated terrorists, such as Abdulmutallab, to proceed with their plan. Bet you didn’t think of that, Mr. Critical, did you?

Another fact, well-known to security insiders, is that terrorists are fashion plates, and will not go anywhere without at least two carry-ons to assure that they are properly attired when meeting virgins.  One never knows exactly how one should dress in advance of the moment, particularly when it comes to weather conditions aboard the plane.  By limiting hand baggage to only one, the TSA seeks to create fashion paralysis, a major stumbling block to any would-be terrorist’s moment of truth.

But these are just the immediate rule changes, designed to prepare us for the major ones to be imposed.  In the future, passengers will be required to fly naked.  As they ramp up the advertising campaign, No Shoes, No Clothes, No Problems, they have come upon a solution that will put an end to the fear of airline attacks.

To the untrained eye, one might suspect that the purpose behind this rule is to eliminate any place to secrete an explosive device.  To those of us more attuned to the harsh realities of terror, we know this to be false.  The true purpose behind this change is to create an atmosphere of such utter, nauseating disgust that it will be impossible for anyone to function.

Think about the people you see on airplanes.  Then imagine what they would look like naked.  Eeeew. That’s right, fat, old, wrinkled, smelly bodies surrounding you.  Not a muscle would flex on board, fearing that they might touch someone’s sagging fleshiness.  Every muscle would go limp.  Minds would shut down.  Aside from the occasional retching, there would be utter silence as people froze in place to avoid any possibility of human contact.  You can’t bring down an airplane with your eyes tightly shut.

Some might argue that this is too cruel to contemplate, and indeed, it is extreme.  But when it comes to the safety of Americans, there is no restriction that goes too far.  We must be able to travel safely, without fear of harm.  When it comes to protecting Americans, what better weapon do we have in the War on Terrorism than ourselves?

Update:  Randy Barnett at VC has posted the new “temporary” TSA Rules, applicable until December 30th.  Most notably amongst them is airlines are required to have their gate agents:


Perform thorough pat-down of all passengers at boarding gate prior to boarding, concentrating on upper legs and torso.
As if these harried, sometimes a little nutsy, gate agents don’t have enough on their hands, they must now frisk every passenger before boarding.  They aren’t trained to do so.  They have no security available if they find something.  There will be men frisking the upper thighs of women, and vice versa.  There will be no screening available for further investigation.  And let’s hope nobody has a catheter.

The good news is that they won’t be required to do this if the passenger happens to be a Monarch or Head of State.  It’s not like the TSA is unreasonable about it.

Nancy Grace: When Twinkies Clash

To call Nancy Grace’s grasp of criminal law shallow is to insult puddles. The woman whose television persona is built on the concept that there’s no need for evidence when a heavily hair-sprayed delusion will fill the void has given new meaning to the words, “where there’s smoke, there’s fire.”  Put a match near her head and test her approach.

One ramification of the CNN Hostess Twinkie is that real lawyers won’t appear on her show.  The corollary is that the only people who will grace her set are those whose desire to have their lovely face on the screen exceeds any interest in dignity or integrity.  Clearly, nothing lawyerly will ever come of it, but it does allow the lawyer to impress their potential client base with the great importance of having television pundit credentials, especially for those to whom Nancy Grace represents the epitome of deep thinking. 

I, of course, mean no slight to CNN for giving this popular television lawyer a pulpit to spew.  It’s all about selling commercials, and I, as a capitalist, fully appreciate that the need to attract as broad an audience as possible, to sell consumer products and services.  And if Nancy Grace is what the people want, so be it.

I believe that this adequately expresses my thoughts on Nancy Grace’s merit as a legal analyst and commentator and the information value of her television show in aiding the public’s understanding of the law.

In the absence of real lawyers to fill the empty air time between Grace’s delusions and commercials, the show has been largely relegated to the handful of lawyers who want so desperately to be on television that they are prepared to join in the inanity of the shameless.  Like Grace, they too have earned the description of Twinkie.

But even twinkies have limits, we learn from this post by Alexis Neely, who proclaims that she will never again appear on Nancy Grace’s television show.

A couple years ago, I got caught up in this idea of fame and for a little while, it sort of took over my life.  I told myself it was about making a difference and having an impact in the world, but then I read this article that says fame is really about the need to fit in and belong and I could clearly see my real motivation.

In one of her never-ending metacognitive moments, Alexis realized yet again that her self-serving rationalizations were nonsense, and that the tripe she purported to teach others was, at its core, a reflection of her own need for acceptance and validation.  So her twits to her fans that she would be appearing on Nancy Grace (“look at me, aren’t I special”), all to the greater glory and financial value of her legal consulting business, were revealed as a reflection of her sense of personal unworthiness.  Not exactly a selling point for the perky gal who gave herself the title, “America’s Favorite Lawyer.”


It started to become clear when I did all of the Michael Jackson coverage.  I began to see I wasn’t really making a difference in the world and helping people with the media I was doing.  I was spreading rumors and gossip.  Sure, it was public and not behind anyone’s back, but was it really any less insidious?

I put it out of my mind because I liked getting all dressed up and putting on makeup and getting picked up by a car service and feeling special.  So I kept doing it.

Even during this moment of self-revelation, Alexis couldn’t help but let us know about how she did “all the Michael Jackson coverage.”  Old habits die hard, especially when they make you swell with self-importance.

I took 2.5 hours out of my day to get my hair done, get driven down to CNN on Sunset and get my makeup done and then sit in a chair for an hour watching Nancy run the same clip of one of Tiger’s girlfriends saying she was sorry if she hurt anyone over and over and over again at each break.   I was on for less than 2 minutes with half of that time Nancy asking me inane questions I  like “When did he [Tiger Woods] have time to be with all those women with two children?”

And therein lies the crucial question for which a highly trained, thoughtful, incisive legal mind is required on the Nancy Grace show.  The puddle cringed.  This was more than even a twinkie could take.  Unfortunately, it was only half a lesson learned.



So I’m taking a stand.  For now on, I will not do any television unless I’m totally clear that I’m doing it because it will help to lift viewers to a new level of awareness.  I will not contribute to the inane dialogue, gossip and drama that is being perpetuated with most of today’s television programming.

The solution isn’t to eschew the need for validation by pretending to play a lawyer on TV, but rather that the Nancy Grace show is beneath the dignity of even a twinkie.  Fame, apparently, is still a primary driving force, even if not sufficient to overcome the absolute worst that faux-legal punditry has to offer. 


I do believe I’ve been given a gift of looking great on camera, being able to convey a message quickly, and think on my feet.  And I do not want to waste or deny that gift.  But, it will need to be utilized in some way that does not make me feel dirty afterward and that is driven by my highest level desires to make a real difference in the world and raise people to a new level of awareness.
It may not be much, but it’s better than nothing.  Once there are no lawyers left in America willing to demean themselves by appearing on Nancy Grace’s show, perhaps CNN will get the message and cancel it, replacing it with cartoons so as not to lose the audience.  After that’s accomplished, we can work on the self-esteem issues of those too twinkified to realize that there is no validation to be found as a lawyer by playing one on TV.

Or maybe this gift can be used for some greater purpose.  Home shopping, perhaps?

The Second Circuit’s Holiday Message To Lynne Stewart

When the 2d Circuit remanded Lynne Stewart’s sentence to SDNY Judge Koeltl, with directions that he decide whether she committed perjury, and then take that into account in his sentence, there apparently was a nagging sense that the decision’s 191 pages failed to adequately express their desire.  So, according to this New York Law Journal story on December 24th, the decision was amended.


A majority told Judge Koeltl to make a finding on whether Stewart committed perjury at trial and examine in greater detail her abuse of her position as a lawyer — two factors that would both increase the sentence and help the circuit evaluate whether it was reasonable. But new language was added Wednesday at the end of the amended opinion requiring Koeltl to revisit the terrorism enhancement in the federal sentencing guidelines “and take that enhancement into account” — which could add years to Stewart’s sentence.

As was already brutally clear, dissenting Judge John Walker was not happy about the 28 month sentence.



The decision not to impose the enhancement had angered Judge John M. Walker Jr., who said in dissent in November that he was “at a loss” for “any rationale that could reasonably justify” a sentence he called “breathtakingly low.”

Not that Judge Walker was trying to micromanage Judge Koeltl’s sentence, even when he feels compelled to express his displeasure with the substantive decision as to what the appropriate sentence would be.
 
It was already obvious from the original decision that the Circuit was telling Judge Koeltl that it found his failure to decide the question of whether Lynne committed perjury in testifying in her own defense error, the implication being that she lost at trial, the jury rejected her testimony as credible, and she should therefore be given a higher sentence to accommodate this. 

While it’s hardly necessary that the sentencing court, even given the conviction, reach the conclusion that Lynne’s testimony was perjurious, rather than a view of her conduct based upon her understanding rather than the government’s, and it is similarly not inherently accurate to conclude that the jury’s conviction necessarily meant that they found her testimony to be false, there can be little doubt that Judge Koeltl got the Circuit’s message.  Whether he will cow to the Circuit is another matter, and whether Judge Walker’s “breathtakingly low” comment should influence the sentence, is another matter.

Fortunately, the amended decision does not include the language, “and we wouldn’t be too upset if the resentence included life plus cancer.”  One would think that the Circuit, in its original 191 pages, could have made its position sufficiently plain that it wouldn’t require an amendment, lest the judge believe that he’s got any choice in how harsh to be.  More importantly, one would think that the Circuit wouldn’t feel so desperately compelled to stick its nose into Judge Koeltl’s sentencing decision.  If it wanted a particular sentence imposed on Lynne, why not just say so rather than play these games.

Cell Phones Aren’t Closed Containers

A New York Times editorial applauds the Ohio Supreme Court’s 5-4 4-3 decision in Ohio v. Antwaun Smith, holding that police officer cannot search a cell phone without a warrant.

The Ohio Supreme Court has struck an important blow for privacy rights, ruling that the police need a warrant to search a cellphone. The court rightly recognized that cellphones today are a lot more than just telephones, that they hold a wealth of personal information and that the privacy interest in them is considerable. This was the first such ruling from a state supreme court. It is a model for other courts to follow.

The court was asked to apply analogize a cell phone to a closed container, such as a cigarette pack which might contain drugs, which would be searchable as an exception to the Warrant Clause based upon reasoning that began with caselaw developed to stop the plague of bootlegging back in 1925. 

This is the conflict between the “technology neutral” approach espoused by Orin Kerr, which would apply existing 4th Amendment law (and naturally the exceptions to the law) rather than develop a new jurisprudence that accommodates the distinctions between current and developing technology, the digitized information that can be found on any new device commonly used, from cell phones to PDAs to computers, and the physical world.

The Ohio Supreme Court rejected the attempt to pigeonhole cell phones as “closed containers,” and would enable police to search them without a warrant.



We acknowledge that some federal courts have likened electronic devices to closed containers. E.g. United States v. Chan (N.D.Cal.1993), 830 F.Supp. 531, 534 (finding that a pager is analogous to a closed container), United States v. Ortiz (C.A.7, 1996), 84 F.3d 977, 984 (following Chan in holding that a pager is a closed container), United States v. David (D.Nev.1991), 756 F.Supp. 1385, 1390 (finding a computer memo book “indistinguishable from any other closed container”). Each of these cases, however, fails to consider the Supreme Court’s definition of “container” in Belton, which implies that the container must actually have a physical object within it. Additionally, the pagers and computer memo books of the early and mid 1990s bear little resemblance to the cell phones of today. Even the more basic models of modern cell phones are capable of storing a wealth of digitized information wholly unlike any physical object found within a closed container. We thus hold that a cell phone is not a closed container for purposes of a Fourth Amendment analysis.

Not only does this decision reflect a meaningful understanding that devices, replete with digitized information so vastly beyond the mundane physical evidence for which the exceptions were developed, bear no comparison with the antiquated closed container analogy, but the court returned to the basic rule, that warrantless searches are presumed unconstitutional rather than start from the premise that there must be an exception for everything.  It’s a return of vitality to the 4th Amendment.

The court also refused to distinguish cell phones based on the specific attributes of each particular device, concluding that they all contained a “wealth of digitized information wholly unlike any physical object.”  As obvious as this statement may be, it’s a huge departure from the pigeonhole approach that would extend the old exceptions from the physical to digital world.

Given how ubiquitous the use of technology has become, with almost everyone carrying around a large part of their life story in a tiny piece of electronics, this decision is very significant.  The view that the law can accommodate every new technological development by some facile analogy to search exceptions for physical evidence left us in a position where our privacy was at the mercy of the latest bit of technology, where every new toy that happened to be on or near someone’s person at the time of arrest would give the government access to almost any aspect of their lives given the vast quantity of personal information stores in computer chips. 

By rejecting the pigeonholing of new technology into antiquated and inapplicable legal concepts, the extension of past exceptions into future technological developments, the Ohio Supreme Court has given us a chance that our future is not undermined by a century of bad caselaw, every-increasing exceptions to the constitutional prohibition on warrantless searches.  The question now is whether other states will adopt this view as well, and whether the Supreme Court will recognize that the exceptions developed to make sure that the 4th Amendment never stops a cop from searching when the mood strikes shouldn’t be carried over to developing technology.

It’s too soon to say whether there is still life in the 4th Amendment, but at least this decision by the Ohio Supreme Court suggests that the Warrant Clause isn’t dead yet.

A Christmas Carol for Criminal Defense Lawyers

If there is a Christmas Carol for us, this would be my choice.


While others will no doubt have choices of their own, the words of Little Drummer Boy reflect the spirit of what criminal defense lawyers offer.  I hope you enjoy it too.

Merry Christmas to all.  And Happy Anniversary to my parents, married 60 years ago today.  Aunt Gert was wrong.

Come Rest Ye Merry Blawgers

There are some wonderful people who have given gifts to innumerable others this year, without asking anything in return.  Indeed, they are often challenged, criticized and attacked for having done so.  They are the blawgers, lawyers (and some non-lawyers who missed their calling) who write.  There’s no fame or wealth for their efforts.  There’s no cost to any reader for enjoying, or hating, what they have to say.  They write it. Others read it. It’s as pure a gift as there can be.

Last year, I offered my appreciation to the Wise Men (and women) of the Blawgosphere. Some are gone and new ones have joined.  All have become a part of a grassroots offering of thoughts, news, and sometimes even wisdom. To them, I am no more than a reader like any other. 

While we all appreciate our readers, that anyone would use their precious time to read what we scribble, I suspect that readers don’t always have much of an appreciation for what blawgers do.  Many think there are financial gains to be had from blawging.  I assure you, there are none. 

Blawgers give of their time, their thoughts, their talents to write.  In return, they are told how ignorant and stupid they are by people they don’t know.  They are stalked and threatened with physical harm by actual psychotics with keyboards.  Why would anyone put up with such abuse?  Yet they do, and continue to write. 

I appreciate my fellow blawgers.  Very much.  And I would like to take this opportunity to thank them for the gifts they give me all year long.

Mark Bennett, Dan Hull,  Gideon. Jeff Gamso, Marc John Randazza, Mark Draughn, Joel Rosenberg, Brian Tannebaum,  Carolyn Elefant, Eric Turkewitz, Norm Pattis,  Eugene Volokh, Orin Kerr,  Ken and Patrick, Mike Cernovich, Ken Lammers,  Matt Brown,  Scott Henson, Walter Olson, Charon, Radley Balko, Geeklawyer, Jamie Spencer,  Jon Katz, Jonathon “I Don’t Need No Stinkin’ Links” Turley, Tom Goldstrin and Lyle Denniston, Dan Harris, Ron Coleman, Colin Samuels, Douglas Berman, Dave Hoffman, Frank Pasquale, Dan Markel, Dan Solove,  David Lat, Kevin O’Keefe, and the Queen of the New York Blawgosphere, Niki Black.  I’m sure I’ve left other people off this list, and I sincerely apologize for the limits of this old man’s mind.

Thank you.  Each and every one.

A Merry Maricopa Christmas

No matter who or where you are, you can’t help but be filled with the special spirit of the holiday season, peace on earth and goodwill toward man.  Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas has one extra special gift on his list: a criminal investigation of any your fellow county attorneys who criticize you.  With love, Andy.

From Nick Martin’s incomparable Heat City, Thomas’ Christmas Eve missive to former State Supreme Court Chief Justice Ruth McGregor, who has been charged with overseeing Thomas’ and Arpaio’s December to Remember accusations against those who criticize him, particularly Yavapai County Attorney Sheila Polk and Pinal County Attorney James Walsh, both of whom sent letters to the Arizona Republic criticizing Arpaio’s abuse of power.  Polk called it “totalitarianism”.

Move by the ghost of Christmas future and a deathly fear of coal in his stocking, Thomas felt compelled to smack these traitors to the cause:


Now, Thomas wants a former state Supreme Court justice to investigate his neighboring prosecutors as part of what he calls “an orchestrated campaign to pressure law enforcement in Maricopa County to drop charges against influential criminal defendants and suspects.”

Thomas accused the other prosecutors of essentially breaking the law by criticizing him and the sheriff. He said the pair violated rules for attorneys in Arizona, as well as tainted the pool of possible jurors in the ongoing cases.
Obviously, when there are critics to be silenced, it can’t wait for New Years.  No holiday good cheer will stand in the way of Arpaio and Thomas protecting the citizens of Maricopa County from the shrill words of these conspirators who seek to take advantage of their eggnog-addled minds.  If they can only convince their sycophants that this is a massive conspiracy of politicians, judges, prosecutors and lawyers, then maybe all is not lost.  After all, why believe all these people that Arpaio and Thomas are insane when you can believe in a vast conspiracy against them?

As the many supporters of Crazy Joe Arpaio, even those who are not quite 55, have some time to ponder between today and New Years Eve, perhaps they should consider whether those wild anarchists, Polk and Walsh, are really part of a vast conspiracy determined to undermine the pink fabric of Maricopa County, or whether Crazy Joe and his butt boil Thomas are engaged in a bizarre and outrageous abuse of their authority, the Constitution, and bent on seizing total control by accusing anyone who challenges their conduct as criminals. 

But don’t feel badly for Crazy Joe and Andy Thomas this Christmas morning, as they huddle near the fire and conspire about who to indict next.  At least they will always have each other, even as those who remained silent too long out of fear of what these lunatics might do have finally shown the courage to speak out against their abuses. 

Merry Christmas, Maricopa.

Relics of the Lawyer’s Life

As we close out another decade, it’s always fun to look back on the things that were once cool, once absolutely necessary, to the existence of a lawyer that are now relegated to the junk heap.  Bruce Carton, who has taken over Legal Blog Watch from Carolyn Elefant and uses his wonderful sense of humor to offset the very serious Bob Ambrogi, runs through a list from New York Magazine.


   1. Answering machines (haven’t seen one in 5 years)
   2. Lickable stamps (haven’t licked one in 5 years)
   3. Foldable road maps (still have a couple, sorry)
   4. Cathode ray tube TVs (have several littering my home)
   5. Incandescent light bulbs (huh? I have many of these in my home)
   6. Paying for pornography (ummmm …)
   7. Smoking in bars and restaurants (good riddance)
   8. Fax machines (these relics have not gone away in the legal world, hopefully they are on their last leg)
   9. Hydrox cookies (Oreos rule)
  10. Cassette tapes (Ha. Those barely made it into the 90s, let alone the 00s)
  11. The French franc, and every other former currency in the Euro zone (It’s all about the Euros, baby)
  12. Floppy disks (now used only for drink coasters and in bad movies)
  13. Phone books (one just arrived in my mailbox, so too early to declare these dead)
  14. Polaroid photos (way dead)
  15. Bank deposit slips (still alive in my bank)
  16. Subway tokens (way dead)
  17. The Rolodex (I haven’t had one in 5+ years but still on the desk of many 50-something lawyers, no doubt)
How do you deposit a check without a deposit slip?  Obviously, I missed something.  But then, I have no plans to get a flat screen TV until my Sony Trinitron dies, so what do I know?

Bruce then cuts to a “more focused” list for lawyers:

1. Checks: Many people under the age of 30 have never written a check in their lives, and probably never will.
2. Courier services: At some point, lawyers will stop paying people to drive pieces of paper around in cars or on bikes.
3. Desktop computers: Just a matter of time on these. I predict the legal field will be desktop-free at some point in the not-too-distant future.
4. Paper time sheets

I won’t bother with paper time sheets, since I’ve never used one in my life.  But the others?  Am I that out of touch?

Checks:  I do not like electronic transfers.  I want something in my hand that shows that I’ve paid for something and that the other side received it.  What’s making me nuts these days is that my bank no longer returns all my original checks, despite my instructions not to pay anyone who doesn’t tender a physical check. They laugh at me.  Check 21, they say.  Bite me, I respond, and they laugh some more.  It’s legal proof of payment, I’m told, and I don’t doubt that it is, but they are my checks and I want them back.  The most annoying part of the process is that the copies they return in lieu of the real checks are on a different size paper, so that I can’t make nice piles of old checks as I’ve done for the past 25 years. I hate that.

Courier Services:  I suspect that courier services will go away as a simple matter of economics. There just won’t be enough people using them to justify their continued existence, since we can now send packages overnight anywhere in the world.  But if you need to get someone’s signature on a piece of paper today, you’re going to miss having them around.  And for those who think signatures are old school, and that facsimile signatures are just as good, wait until someone disputes that they signed something.  Then you will miss couriers.

Desktop Computers:  Like most people nowadays, I use multiple computers.  I have three laptops and one desktop. No matter how you spin it, the desktop is more powerful.  And when it starts to drag, throw in a few more Gigs of RAM and it works like a dream again.  Laptops are convenient, but there’s no substitute for a desktop computer when you feel the need for speed.

I’m not a total curmudgeon.  I happily gave up my wet paper copier back in the ’80s, and reluctantly let go of my IBM Selectric III, though I regretted it when I had forms to fill in.  But I’ve still got my land lines, and refuse to believe that cellphones will have the sound quality and reliability necessary to replace them. 

And I happen to prefer Hydrox to Oreos.  I just do.  So sue me.

When I was a kid, everything that said “space age” on it was cool.  It was faster and more convenient.  Saving time was everything, provided you didn’t mind that these “new and improved” beauties had no flavor, no substance, no soul.  Today, we pray to the tech god, happily tossing old ways to the winds in favor of the newest, coolest, shiniest toys.  We’ll see whether our choices are good or bad.  Time will tell.