Brian Tannebaum rides herd over the
twittersphere, trying to make sure that lawyers huffing and puffing themselves to others stay honest. By that, he has tried to make sure that lawyers who
overstate their
qualifications, including their continued right to call themselves lawyers, This arises primarily when they use the title “lawyer” to promote themselves as social media guru, a meaningless phrase that’s been sorely abused.
He recently picked up on a lawyer from my neck of the woods,
Kathleen Scanlon, who was caught up in a fairly large
real estate fraud case. She pleaded guilty and is awaiting sentence.
What drew Tannebaum’s attention to her wasn’t that she was indicted or pleaded guilty, but that she continued to aggressively pursue business on twitter under the guise of being a real estate lawyer and “social media rockstar,” even after the guilty plea. It was the brazenness of it that caught Tannebaum’s attention, and so he outed her.
This led to a post by Mark Bennett at his
Social Media Tyro blog, using the Tannebaum/Scanlon exchange on twitter, where Scanlon deleted her twits and altered her profile to cover her tracks, then denied that she did any such thing, to discuss how
purported “social media expertise” has become the refuge for disgraced lawyers.
Scanlon didn’t take kindly to being the poster girl, and went on a tear in
the comments to Bennett’s post. Her words run the full gamut, from ignorant to disingenuous to deceitful. The best choice would have been to remain silent, but that apparently wasn’t in the cards. Instead, she argues and argues, writing some things that should never emerge from the fingers of a person awaiting sentence.
Should her words come to the attention of the court or prosecution, there may well be good reason for her plea deal to explode in her face. Not only is there no remorse whatsoever, but there’s outright denial of any wrongdoing and an extremely aggressive claim of undeserved victimhood. Scanlon makes no bones about her right to do whatever she has to do to continue to make money in real estate, shifting focus ever so slightly so that her “hiatus” (her word) from the law won’t interfere with her ability to make money.
This is not the lesson one would expect a guilty defendant to learn. It’s certainly not what a guilty defendant should express publicly.
While there is much of concern in Scanlon’s comments, this seems to me to be the most troubling:
With respect to the criminal case, I pled to Scheme to Defraud because I was advised to do so in light of the non-incarceration promise, the seriousness of the charges & possible penalties, the incredibly prohibitive cost of going to trial (which is what I wanted to do at the risk of blowing my children’s college education fund) and probably the most important – that I am the mother of two elementary school age boys. Perhaps you might want to peruse the indictment for a better background on this case: http://manhattanda.org/whatsnew/press/2009-07-8.pdf . Use your super criminal lawyer skills and search my name in there. My lawyer’s first reaction was “what did you do? where is the crime?”. I put my family first, ahead of the law license because I have my priorities straight.
What she did was pretty clear: She represented straw buyers in real estate closings, which served to steal mortgage money. She didn’t kill anyone, but it’s still a crime. And claiming that you didn’t know they were straw buyers is silly.
But you can’t have it both ways. There are pleas of convenience, even though they aren’t supposed to happen, where a person makes a business judgment that it’s smarter to plead guilty than fight. But to claim poverty as the reason for the plea stinks. To lay it on your children’s future is malarkey. Pleas of convenience come from the fact that they’ve got you nailed to the wall, not because you’re innocent and they can’t prove otherwise.
The problem isn’t that Kathleen Scanlon (or Scanlondesio as she’s called in
Webcrims) is such a horrible person. It appears that she did wrong, that she was swept up in the furor of cheap mortgage money and scam real estate closings. From what I understand to be the case, this was pervasive amongst real estate lawyers before the crash, and since somebody had to close these strawman deals, it might as well have been Scanlon to collect the fee. I do not suggest that this is an acceptable excuse at all, but proportionality is always an important consideration.
That said, Scanlon has made her bed by continuing to hold herself out as a lawyer and claiming “rockstar” status while awaiting sentence, then fighting about it when called out. Contrary to the conspiracy theorists, there’s no “nod and wink” amongst the bar to conceal wrongdoing by other lawyers. Had Scanlon not pushed the envelope, and pushed it hard, she would have never made it onto anyone’s radar. Had she not decided to fight rather than be conciliatory, she might have enjoyed a much more understanding reception. But at each turn, Scanlon chose the route destined to exacerbate her problems.
There are three points to be learned from this mess. First, it’s wise to lay low while awaiting sentence. Second, when you promote yourself as a “social media rockstar,” don’t be shocked and angry when people notice. Third, there is no situation that can’t be made worse with a little effort and poor judgment.
I bet that Scanlon can put her knowledge of real estate to good use in the future, support her kids and find great success. She certainly doesn’t seem the type to be kept down for long. And I hope that she’s learned from this mess in the meantime.
Update: In a timely twist, another self-styled social media type (she denies having ever called herself a guru),
Sheryl Sisk Schelin who blogs as The Inspired Solo turns out to be a suspended lawyer. When confronted by the Brians (Tannebaum and Cuban), she responded by playing prune-faced school marm to their internet sheriff. Her post, Life’s Too Short to Listen to Bullies: How to Respond to @sses on Twitter, is fascinating for its bluff and swagger, that those who “challenged” her are babies and bullies because they didn’t behave the way she wanted them to.
On the other hand, nowhere in her post does she mention anything about her suspension from the practice of law.
The question of when or how a disbarred, disgraced, suspended attorney should acknowledge their problems is an interesting one. But one this is clear: If they can’t practice law, they should not hold themselves out as a lawyer, whether directly or by implication. That’s where all the arguments all fall down.