Author Archives: SHG

Things To Do In The Snow (Update)

1. Throw snowballs.
2. Pull out your handgun.
3. Call for backup.

From Radley Balko, it looks like Reason TV was in the right place at the right time.



While Radley correctly notes that the uniforms shows better sense (not to mention restraint) than the Hummer driving detective Baylor, it’s not like they whispered in the detective’s ear, “uh, don’t you think you might want to put the gun away and, like, uh, leave before the video goes viral?”

And as for those in the crowd screaming old 1960’s nastiness to the cops, come up with something new, please.  That’s just so dated.

Update: And after a thorough investigation,


Assistant Chief Peter Newsham tells LL: “There was no police pulling guns on snowball people.”

That clears that up. 

Live Scientific Testimony Redux

Adam Liptak has an article in the New York Times on the January 11th oral argument scheduled in Briscoe v. Virginia, revisiting the Supreme Court’s decision last term in Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts.  You will recall that the court held that the practice of submitting laboratory reports into evidence without a live witness was held to deny the defendant’s confrontation rights.

In light of the problems found with police labs by the National Academy of Science, not to mention the New York State Inspector General, and the speed with which the Supremes have taken on a new case to revisit a decision that’s less than a year old, Briscoe presents a problem.

There are two changes between last June and now.  The first change is the replacement of Justice Souter with Sonia Sotomayor.


The 5-to-4 vote in the original case also raises issues about the vulnerability of the decision because there were unusual coalitions on both sides, with Justice David H. Souter, now departed from the court, in the majority. His replacement, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, is a former prosecutor, and her views on the issue are unknown.

This points to one of the institutional failings of the Supreme Court, that a one-person change in personnel might be sufficient to change the interpretation of what constitutes fundamental rights.  After all, how fundamental can a right be if it changes from term to term or person to person.  It reduces the value of a Supreme Court decision to a transitory whim, and suggests that nothing about the law is truly fundamental.

The other change is experience, as states have operated under the Melendez-Diaz rule since last June and are now positioned to offer hard experience where before they had only speculation.



“Already data and anecdotal evidence are demonstrating an overwhelming negative impact,” a friend of the court brief submitted by 26 attorneys general last month said. The decision, they said, “is already proving unworkable.”


Daniel F. Conley, the district attorney for Suffolk County, which includes Boston, said most criminal defense lawyers there were insisting that analysts testify, “posing a very serious administrative problem for us in drug cases.”

There are 35 chemists in the state’s drug laboratories, according to the state’s brief, and there were more than 20,000 drug prosecutions in Massachusetts in the last fiscal year.

Sounds daunting indeed, Provided you don’t think too hard about the numbers.  There may well be more than 20,000 drug prosecutions a year, but there aren’t 20,000 trials.  If those 35 chemists had to testify 20,000 times, the issue would then be whether the constitutional right to confront witnesses was of sufficient importance to outweight the financial burden on the state to hire more chemists.  While I would still argue that to be the case, the right of confrontation not being contingent on the allocation of resources from the public fisc, we need not go that far.  It’s a red herring.

Experience from Washington and Ohio, which has gone to the system required by Melendez-Diaz, offers a more accurate view:



After the change to the stricter system, demands for court appearances from forensic chemists in Washington spiked to more than 50 a month from around 10, the brief said, before settling around 24.

But it is not clear that the additional work was especially onerous. By the defendant’s calculations, the additional appearances amounted to “a little more than 1,000 additional hours per year — or about one-half a person-year.” The Drug Enforcement Administration, in a letter to a Justice Department lawyer last month, acknowledged that the number of chemists involved in drug cases has dropped to 18 from 23 since 2006.

Ohio, too, has long had a system that complies with a strict interpretation of the Supreme Court’s ruling in Melendez-Diaz. Its 14 forensic scientists made 123 appearances in drug cases in 2008, or fewer than one a month each, according to the state’s solicitor general. They were away from the lab an average of five hours each time.
But Briscoe doesn’t seek a complete return to the pre-Melendez-Diaz days, but rather a hybrid system where the prosecution can introduce a lab report without a live body, and the burden shifts to the defense to request that the chemist be produced for cross-examination during the defense’s case.  Virginia argues that this is a more “efficient” use of resources.

While it may be more efficient, though that’s a point that I would be disinclined to accept at face value, it fails to pass constitutional muster.  The lab report still comes into evidence, its results being published to the jury, without any ability to challenge.  The old adage that “the bell rung cannot be unrung” comes to mind.  The jury still has the “scientific” proof, with the defense left incapable of preventing its admission even if it’s a wholesale fabrication by an incompetent or deceitful lab technician. 

If that’s not reason enough (and it is), the Virginia system compels the defense to put on a case, thus dictating that the defense either waive any challenge to the lab report or accept a strategy that is forced upon it by law.  Further, if the defense has no other witnesses, calling a chemist as the defense’s sole witness in its case in chief serves to highlight the evidence by going through it a second time, and may well leave the defense in the untenable position of seeking to challenge a witness about whom the defense knows little or nothing, and who may or may not offer any meaningful basis to question the analysis.

When one crosses the chemist during the ordinary course of the introduction of the lab report, often by voir dire at the time the prosecution moves to admit the evidence, the testimony is given no greater weight than it would otherwise have, and the defendant’s case in chief isn’t dictated by a rule of “efficiency”. 

Evidence should not be admitted first, and challenged later.  Either it is admissible in the first place or it isn’t admissible at all.  The Virginia procedure turns the sequence on its head, and adds a variety of problematic tactical decisions that invariably inure to the defendant’s detriment.  The Confrontation Clause was meant as a test of the efficacy of evidence, not a threat to the defendant for risking a challenge.

That the Supreme Court has chosen to hear Briscoe, after having eked out a clear decision in Melendez-Diaz, doesn’t bode well for the vitality of the Confrontation Clause.  There doesn’t seem to be much point in taking the time to restate what was stated less than a year ago.  But the worst part of this potential undermining of the right to confront a witness against the defendant is that the trade-off is cash and carry.  That the state prefers not to hire enough chemists to testify is a sufficient reason to deny defendants the right to confront the witness directly.  What if they decide not to hire enough judges to sign warrants? 

But then, the introduction of laboratory analyses is entirely different, since they’re “scientific” and we can certainly trust crime labs to produce fully accurate and honest results, right?

The Pointy Head In The Trench Rule

Following my post about the significance of future lawprofs being PhDs, moving those who teach law school ever farther away from those who practice law, I received an email from a very well regarded lawprof who, as it happens, does some serious representation as well.  The email asked:


Is there some threshold of previous or recent practice experience that a law professor can satisfy to *not* be considered a pointy-headed academic? 

The lawprof who asked, and who shall remain nameless unless he chooses to make his identity known, told me that despite the fact that he’s very much a full-time lawprof, and a very active author and theoretician, when he’s in court “kicking ass,” he feels like a lawyer.  And from what I’ve seen of his work, he is indeed very much a lawyer. 

So while the question seemed easy to answer in his case, that whatever the threshold might be, I regarded him as much a lawyer as lawprof, I have no answer that would provide a bright line test. 

There are really two questions involved.  First, how much “real world” experience should a person have as a lawyer before entering the Academy as a full-time lawprof to have a legitimate claim to being experienced as a lawyer.  This first question breaks down into two parts, that being the length of the experience and the nature of the experience.

The second question is whether full-time lawprofs need to keep themselves in the game during their tenure in the Academy to maintain the status of having experience. If so, how much time, or what quality of practice, in the trenches is necessary?

Since being asked, I’ve given some thought to the question.  My gut is that the first question is easier to answer, with a minimum period of practice of at least three years to gain what might be deemed basic experience.  I have no empirical basis for this length of time, however, and it’s likely influenced by the fact that prosecutors, at least around here, make a three year commitment to the office.  My experience with them is that this is enough time for them to come to grips with the basic realities of practice.

Of course, my three year stint assumes that they are actually practicing law, rather than sitting in the library of some Biglaw firm cite checking, with the occasional coffee run for a partner being the only time they break out.

I find the second question harder to answer, and one that is less a matter of hours or cases than a matter of the nature of the representation.  I responded with this:


Maybe even more importantly is keeping the feeling of what it’s like to win, and especially to lose, so that it’s not an abstraction.
In retrospect, I should have written what it’s like to lose when your client is innocent.  There’s no understanding of what we do without knowing the feeling of being responsible when an innocent person is convicted.  There’s no understanding of what the law is supposed to do, of what distinguishes platitudes from basic rights, without this sense of personal responsibility toward your clients.

The problem with my answer is that it offers only a vague sense of what I think matters rather than a rule by which others can guide themselves.  Is there a well-founded rule?  Is there a consensus at least? I dunno, but I would be interested in hearing what others think.

Trench lawyers can be pretty brutal in criticizing lawprofs and the Academy for being disconnected from the practice of law and, frankly, lacking the requisite qualifications to teach students how to become lawyers.  Rather than just smack them for their lack of experience, perhaps we can do something more useful this time.  As Judy Tenuta used to say, it could happen.

Sympathy For The Devil, Maricopa Cut

Let’s face it, we’ve been pretty rough on Sheriff Joe Arpaio lately.  I call him Crazy Joe, but he’s not crazy at all.  Nobody wields the power he does without being awfully smart.  The trite expression is crazy like a fox, and indeed he is.  Fox-like, I mean. 

That some think the criticism of the sheriff is undeserved is shown by the Heritage Foundation’s Hans A. von Spakovsky, who has posted at the National Review Online’s “The Corner” about The Persecution.


The Washington Times has a good editorial today about the “ideological vendetta” being waged by the Holder Justice Department against Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, Arizona. The vendetta was prompted by Arpaio’s participation in the 287(g) program, which allows local police to help enforce our immigration laws by detaining illegal aliens. This is a program the Left wants ended, and since they have not been able to persuade Congress to get rid of the authorizing legislation, they are prodding the Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security to do it for them.

This is a real sign of the desperation by the Civil Rights Division. They have been harassing Arpaio for the past year and even generated a DHS audit of him (despite having had no complaints that he was not complying with the rules of the 287(g) program), trying to scrape up enough evidence to justify a civil-rights lawsuit against him.

Most of us were unaware that this was a political vendetta by “the left” against the sheriff because he’s been too effective in stopping illegal immigrants.  It wasn’t about putting prisoners in pink underwear, in tends, in the desert, eating subsistence gruel.  It’s about the lefties sacred cow of giving welfare to illegals.

Andrew Sullivan at The Atlantic explains further by providing letters from his readers.


Bottom line – Arpaio is perhaps the best representative of the true base of the GOP in this state.  The more people attack him, the higher his ratings go up.  Most establishment Democrats in Arizona believe that, especially considering what’s happened in previous years.  One person I’ve worked with closely in the past worked at the highest levels in the Napalitano administration for most of her time in as Governor.  This person explained to me that Janet got heat from the left over most of her tenure for not being tougher with Joe and holding him accountable.  But her people knew that Janet walked a tight rope – she won by less than a point in 2002 – and was really the only thing keeping the right-dominated legislature from passing whatever they wanted.  So she erred on the side of a general hands-off approach, and won Joe’s silence for the most part.  His aggression was not something they wanted to have to deal with, particularly because of how intrusive and invasive Arpaio’s methods are.

And then there’s the appeal to the adult community-types:


Sheriff Joe’s whole shtick is about how tough he is on crime.  And my parents don’t really care about the particulars of how that happens.  To them, stories of immigrants skirting the law or committing crimes are tragedies that must be stopped. 

It seems that Sheriff Joe Arpaio feels the fear and anger of the common man.  He understands what they want and need, and he’s not afraid to give it to them.  Sheriff Joe Arpaio is a man of the people, a populist.

One of the more common themes in the comments here is that the pervasive injustice in the functioning of the American legal system will bring about an uprising, a popular insurrection, when the common man has had enough of government abuse.  It’s possible that those who feel this way, who believe that this is the future, are right.  The only problem is that the uprising is more likely to be led by Sheriff Joe Arpaio than Thomas Jefferson.

There are a great many people dissatisfied with the United States government’s handling of things.  But you may be even less happy with the alternative.  Sheriff Joe Arpaio is a very popular fellow.

Cormac Carney: Judicial All-American

There are a few aspects of sports that carry lessons that lawyers should know.  That the rules of the game matter.  That the team comes before the individual.  That fear of failure is surest way to lose.  You stare down pain, adversity and fear, and just do what you have to do.

These must have been the lessons learned by Cormac J. Carney, who was appointed by President George W. Bush to the United States District Court for the Central District of California.  He is the only federal judge who played in the old United States Football League.


At UCLA, he was an All-American wide receiver. He was an Academic All-American in 1981 and 1982, the first Bruin football player to win the honor twice, and was named one of the NCAA’s top eight student athletes for 1982-83.

He played one season with the Memphis Showboats of the United States Football League, then went to Harvard Law School on an NCAA Post-Graduate Scholarship.

On December 15th, Judge Carney caught the Hail Mary.  Not only did he throw out the indictment against Broadcom’s Chief Financial Officer William Ruehle, co-founder Henry Nicholas, General Counsel David Dull, but he vacated the plea by co-founder Henry Samueli and dismissed his indictment as well.  It was a watershed decision.


BASED ON THE COMPLETE RECORD NOW BEFORE ME, I FIND THAT THE GOVERNMENT HAS INTIMIDATED AND IMPROPERLY INFLUENCED THE THREE WITNESSES CRITICAL TO MR. RUEHLE’S DEFENSE. THE CUMULATIVE EFFECT OF THAT MISCONDUCT HAS DISTORTED THE TRUTH-FINDING PROCESS AND COMPROMISED THE INTEGRITY OF THE TRIAL.

TO SUBMIT THIS CASE TO THE JURY WOULD MAKE A MOCKERY OF MR. RUEHLE’S CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO COMPULSORY PROCESS AND A FAIR TRIAL. THE SIXTH AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION GUARANTEES THE ACCUSED THE RIGHT TO COMPULSORY PROCESS FOR WITNESSES IN ITS DEFENSE. FOR THIS CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO HAVE TRUE MEANING, THE GOVERNMENT MUST NOT DO ANYTHING TO INTIMIDATE OR IMPROPERLY INFLUENCE WITNESSES. SADLY, GOVERNMENT DID SO IN THIS CASE.

The original transcript was produced in all capital letters, so I’ve stayed true to its form.  It’s one of the few decisions worth being published in all caps,  These words need to be shouted into every courtroom, at every judge, at every prosecutor, across the nation.

It’s difficult for non-lawyers, even lawyers who don’t practice in federal court, to appreciate how straight-forward, how bold, how clear this decision is.  More importantly, the underlying problem, the intimidation of witnesses and abuse of criminal sanction against individuals and their families, is a pervasive weapon used by the government against mounting a defense.  The government does everything in its power to make certain that they aren’t playing on a level field.  A football player understand this and knows how wrong it is.

The list of actions taken to coerce exculpatory witnesses not to testify for the defense is long, going as low as to threaten to force Dr. Nicholas’ 13 year old son to testify against him.  Even that was not enough, with the government trying to suborn perjury by having witnesses change their testimony to inculpate Ruehle.  For any defense lawyer who tries to get witnesses together to testify on behalf of a defendant, the story is painfully old news.  The government has gotten to witness after witness, long before the defense has a chance, and has either scared them so that they won’t speak with, no less testify for, the defense or flipped them through threats of prosecution. 

The government must not do anything to intimidate or improperly influence witnesses?  It does so all the time.  All the time.  It’s one of the government’s most fundamental tactics, to strip the defense of necessary testimony.  It’s always a shock to defendants that people they know so well, worked with, trusted, have turned their backs on them because they fear the government.  The intimidation is overwhelming.  The pressure unbearable.

It’s extremely rare for a person to show the fortitude to stand up to the government and say, “do whatever you want, I’m going to tell the truth.”  And as rare as it is in general, it’s even more rare in white collar criminal prosecutions.  Masters of the Universe are the first to cave in when their self-interest is threatened.  Forget loyalty or honesty.  They will do anything to save their tail.

But United States District Judge Cormac Carney, who knows that a wide out is allowed the opportunity to catch the long ball without being pushed by the end or having the safety’s arms holding his down, wasn’t afraid to throw the flag. 

At the end of his decision, Judge Carney recalled a passage from Berger v. U.S.:


“THE UNITED STATES ATTORNEY IS THE REPRESENTATIVE, NOT OF AN ORDINARY PARTY TO A CONTROVERSY, BUT OF A SOVEREIGNTY WHOSE  OBLIGATION TO GOVERN IMPARTIALLY IS AS COMPELLING AS ITS OBLIGATION TO GOVERN AT ALL, AND WHOSE INTEREST, THEREFORE, IN A CRIMINAL PROSECUTION IS NOT THAT IT SHALL WIN A CASE, BUT THAT JUSTICE SHALL BE DONE. AS SUCH, HE IS IN A PECULIAR AND A VERY DEFINITE SENSE THE SERVANT OF THE LAW, THE TWOFOLD AIM OF WHICH IS THAT GUILT SHALL NOT ESCAPE OR INNOCENT SUFFER.

HE MAY PROSECUTE WITH EARNESTNESS AND VIGOR. INDEED, HE SHOULD DO SO. BUT WHILE HE MAY STRIKE HARD BLOWS, HE IS NOT AT LIBERTY TO STRIKE FOUL ONES. IT IS MUCH HIS DUTY TO REFRAIN FROM IMPROPER METHODS CALCULATED TO PRODUCE A WRONGFUL CONVICTION AS IT IS TO USE EVERY LEGITIMATE MEANS TO BRING ABOUT A JUST ONE.”

These words have been repeated many times in a courtroom, but rarely give any more than lip service.  Rarely are they followed up by a remedy that demonstrates any comprehension that the Constitution isn’t a roadblock to circumvent.  Rarely does a judge speak these words to show that the government has struck foul blows rather than hard ones.

This is a decision that every lawyer and judge must read.  And when next you try to speak with a witness who should be helpful to the defense, only to learn that the FBI reached them first and intimidated them into refusing to cooperate, bring this decision with you to court and ask the judge whether he ever played football.

Marketing the Wrong Message

A fellow criminal defense lawyer emailed me the other day.  He decided to check out New York criminal defense lawyers on Avvo, and was surprised by an advertisement that popped up on the search page.  Maybe surprised isn’t exactly the word.  Maybe angry.

So he sent me a link and asked me what I thought of the ad. I was immediately repulsed by the face that appeared on my screen.  “No, you idiot,” he responded.  Not that.  The advertisement on the other side of the page.  This one…



That’s ugly, but likely effective.  Put aside the question of whether a law firm really wants the sort of “clients” that Avvo has to offer, consisting primarily of those seeking free answers to inane questions.  Obviously, they do or they wouldn’t advertise.  After all, who doesn’t seek defendants whose opening salvo is, “why should I have to pay a lawyer if I’m innocent?”

But are they the “Top Client Rated Criminal Defense Attorney in New York?”  Probably, according to how one defines that.  If it’s defined as the lawyer who has asked more misdemeanor defendants to go to Avvo and write something nice about him, then I suspect that Jeremy Saland (Avvo Rating 8.1) is the lawyer with more client ratings than anybody else in town, with 16 client ratings to his name. 

Does that mean anything?  Well, it beats the hell out of 16 clients complaining about you, that’s for sure.  On the other hand, most lawyers don’t seek client ratings as part of their marketing campaign.  Some, myself included, tell our happy clients not to do so, though I would expect that those lawyers with a volume practice would have an advantage regardless. 

Does this mean there should be a rush for other lawyers with high volume practices to get their clients to write nice things about them?  Maybe, if this is how they want to promote themselves. 

But the balance of the advertisement is more unsavory.  Top Criminal Defense Firm?  Not even the qualification.”One of the…?”  Puffery, for sure, but too much so?  After all, this is an advertisement, and the purpose of an Advertisement is to sell, right?  If you can’t throw some hyperbole into an ad, where you can you throw it?  And it could be worse.  At least it didn’t say “and all the other lawyers suck.”  The day will come when someone puts that in an advertisement, when there’s nowhere left to go.

The part that disturbs me the most is the next line of the ad, the one that reads “Former Manhattan Prosecutors Fighting for Your Rights, Liberty and Integrity.”  No, not the inexplicable use of integrity in the sentence, which troubles me only from the standpoint that it makes no sense.  Most readers won’t even notice, and just like to see words strung together than comport with their vague image of what they are looking for in a criminal defense lawyer, despite the fact that the sentence makes no sense.

No, the part that disturbs me is the former prosecutors part.  As I’ve explained before, I consider this type of advertising unethical.  The reason is simple: It plays upon the misconceptions of the public and is intended to mislead.  There are two components to this:


The pitch is intended to capitalize on a basic misperception by the public, that the skills one develops as a prosecutor, characterized as “experience in criminal law,” translate into the skills one requires as a criminal defense lawyer.  As has been discussed ad naseum, there is no intrinsic connection between the two.  Indeed, the transition from the dark side to the light is often painful for former prosecutors, who mistook the love they received from the court as personal rather than institutional.  Suddenly, all those things that made their efforts successful as a prosecutor were gone, and they found the defense side to be painfully difficult.  While some former prosecutors make spectacular criminal defense lawyers, some are miserable failures.

As honest former prosecutors acknowledge, their stint in the district attorneys office provided little of value in gaining the skills needed to do criminal defense.   But that’s not the worst of it.


A secondary implication, which is often suggested, and sometimes overtly claimed, is that by being a former prosecutor, a criminal defense lawyer has some inside track to getting his old buddies to let him have special sweetheart deals, or that he’s got some special friendships with the judges before whom he appeared day after day after day, who will do him (and therefore you, dear client) special favors that would not come your way but for his inside connections.
That former prosecutors try to perpetuate the myth that they have insider connections that will inure to the benefit of clients is deeply troubling.  Potential clients eat this stuff up.  They want to believe that this is all some game, and they can win by buying themselves the “right” lawyer who can whisper something into the right ear and get them a quick and easy walk.  So what if it’s a lie?  It brings in clients.  Sure, it undermines what little integrity the system has, playing on the worst beliefs of dishonesty and gamesmanship, but it brings in clients.  And isn’t that what advertising is supposed to do?

I wonder whether Avvo vets advertisements for their content.  I would imagine not, being far more concerned that the check, rather than the advertisement, is good.  But if I’m wrong about this, no doubt General Counsel Josh King will correct me, and note that I’m just being an abrasive ass about it. It could happen.  So the advertisement is right there on the page when one looks for New York Criminal Defense Lawyers, a consumer service brought to you by the good folks at Avvo.

So I told my buddy that while I didn’t think much of the advertisement, he shouldn’t fret about it.  After all, it’s on Avvo.  Somebody has to field all the calls and emails looking for pro bono representation.  Better these guys than us.

Slackoisie Need Not Apply

From an advertisement for an associate position on Craig’s List :


I will not tolerate:

* Dishonesty. I will not stand for a hint of it.
* Out of control ego. You have no reason for it.
* Emotional instability. Wrong line of work for you.
* Lazy people looking for to make their life easy. I work hard, and you will, too.
* Spoiled children of privilege – you may be the apple of your parent’s eye, but here, it is about production.
* Drama. It affects your ability to earn money.
* People who cannot follow instructions. I only like to repeat myself during closing argument.
* People who cannot manage their time. Do I have to explain why?
* Anyone who ever is smart or mean with a client. They are our present and future.
* Disloyal or passive-aggressive personality types. I am direct. You should be, too.
* Anyone prone to forgetting who the boss is. My way or highway.
* People who stew over not being paid “what they are worth.” You are worth what you can find a job to pay you.
* People who only ever see problems, not solutions. This business is about solving problems. I will show you how.
* Sissies. You are going to be in front of scowling Judges, mean Defense attorneys, weeping clients. I will be nice to you, but that’s about it.

Many will read this and react, I would never work for this jerk.  No sweat.  This jerk would never hire you.  But whoever would work for him, whoever he would hire, will not only get a job, but this:


You will learn how to do everything I ask you to do directly from me. I will make you a great, skilled attorney.

You see, right now you aren’t a “great, skilled attorney.”  I know, you think you are.  You “feel” like a great, skilled attorney. Your mommy says you are.  But you’re not.  You may have a license, but you’re not really an attorney at all.  You can’t do the things attorneys are expected to do. You don’t know how.

Don’t feel bad about it.  Nobody leaves law school capable of practicing law, and those who profess that any yutz straight out of law school can be a successful solo are blowing smoke.  Even the ones who do it may come to realize that, after a few years, they stunk in the beginning.  Of course, they don’t realize until after they stop stinking up the courtroom, if they ever realize it at all.

But for so many of the Slackoisie, they will never make the grade because they can’t get through the list without crying.  No one can teach you to be un-stupid. 


The individuals whom I’ve met or heard about over the last couple of years that have formed the basis of this opinion are smart people, and in some cases, exceptionally smart people. At least, that’s what I can tell from the importance of their jobs or the successes recounted on their resumes. These were people vetted through multiple interviews, and determined to be well-suited to their legal jobs. In short, they weren’t just the “man off the street.” And yet, their attitude suggested they were stupid. This is something I clearly cannot teach you how not to be. No lawyer can. To be un-stupid you have to feel embarrassment, or fear, like the fear of losing, the fear of making a mistake, or the fear of looking like a complete ass.
To those who believe that they are absolutely entitled to be any darn way they want to be, that the legal profession should remold itself around them, accommodate them, change for them, this is heresy.  To those who teach them, hold conferences for them, consult with them about how to make millions while working only three hours a week, this is a lie.  To those who blame see the problems, but dismiss them because they aren’t their fault and instead blame their parents, their employer, the political party with which they disagree, this is offensive.  But all your arguments won’t help you.  They won’t make you un-stupid.

You can run away from these harsh assessments into the loving, caring, comforting arms of the cadre of consultants who will take your meager funds to tell you what you want to hear.  But that won’t make you un-stupid.  You can tell me that some day, you will rule the world and then it will be wonderful, where you can get your BMW without ever having to take off your bathrobe and jammies.

Or you can be un-stupid.  Your choice.

When Science Isn’t

In a perverse way, criminal defense lawyers, like everyone else, want to believe that the police crime labs are competent.  It’s not that we don’t want to be capable of disputing their findings, but that we realize that lab results are almost invariably persuasive to judges and jurors.  That means that their scientific results put people away.  At the very least, let’s hope that they are correct about it.

Science, unfortunately, has prove to be one of the most difficult disciplines to meld into law from nearly every perspective.  It’s a killer because it’s so difficult to challenge, but it’s been corrupted at every turn in the courtroom.  Judges rely upon it because they are clueless when it comes to science.  There are no science courses in law school, and at best they pretend to know the words uttered by witnesses without having the slightest idea of what underpins their testimony or expertise.  Forget Daubert. Forget Frye. It’s all gibberish to us.

So when we learn that the New York State Police Laboratory was staffed by incompetents and managed by liars and deceivers, none of whom care a whit about the fact that their “scientific” results are a fraud and scam designed for the sole purpose of achieving the outcome of conviction, it’s a killer.  From the New York Times :



The New York State Police’s supervision of a major crime laboratory was so poor that it overlooked evidence of pervasively shoddy forensics work, allowing an analyst to go undetected for 15 years as he falsified test results and compromised nearly one-third of his cases, an investigation by the state’s inspector general has found.

And when the State Police became aware of the analyst’s misconduct, an internal review by superiors in the Albany lab deliberately omitted information implicating other analysts and suggesting systemic problems with the way evidence was handled, the report said.

The report named a number of lab supervisors at the time — including the director, Gerald Zeosky, and assistant director Richard Nuzzo — and describes them as unfazed by the inquiry and dismissive of Mr. Veeder’s broader claims. Mr. Zeosky remains in charge of the lab. Mr. Nuzzo was promoted and given a new job in the internal affairs division, but police officials said he would have had no involvement in the investigation of the lab.
Even under the best of circumstances, we’ve come to learn that police crime labs have forsaken scientific inquiry in favor of reaching the desired conclusions needed to convict the people the police wanted to convict.  The National Academy of Science has already determined that the goal of crimes labs isn’t to perform good science, but to nail the bad guy. 

But as shown by the New York State Inspector General’s report, it’s not just that they don’t care about incompetence.  They’re fine with it.  Maybe even proud of it. 

Here’s the rub.  As any lawyer who is fortunate enough to have the wherewithal to conduct independent testing of substances or evidence knows, they will be met with sheer and utter disdain by the judge.  The prosecutor will ignore requests, or stonewall them, or create roadblocks based on chain of custody or adulteration claims, so that we are ultimately constrained to go back to the court for an order to allow an independent scientific evaluation.  And the judge will pooh-pooh it away.  If we can even get the judge to consider the motion. 

Once the prosecution gets its results from the crime lab, everything after that is all a big joke.  The defense testing is viewed as a desperate grasping at straws, making life difficult for the cops and prosecution, and just another waste of time for the court.  Sure, judges will acknowledge that state crime labs have their issues, but the “real” problem is always in some other case, before some other judge.  Every judge believes that the lab results before him or her are routine.  There’s no problem here, counselor. Move along.

What makes scientific results different, however, is their conclusive affect on a judge and jury.  If the lab report says so, then so it is.  As much as judges and lawyers aren’t scientists, neither are most jurors.  We all bow to the god of science, even when we know that it’s not omnipotent. 

So the state, at least the Inspector General, acknowledges that the State Police Lab, sucks.  Do you think there will be a single judge across the State of New York who refuses to admit a lab report into evidence as a result?  I don’t.  Not one.  Even if it was written in crayon.  I would love to be dead wrong about this, but I don’t think I will be.

There’s No Hiatus From Saying The Wrong Things (Update)

Brian Tannebaum rides herd over the twittersphere, trying to make sure that lawyers huffing and puffing themselves to others stay honest.  By that, he has tried to make sure that lawyers who overstate their qualifications, including their continued right to call themselves lawyers, This arises primarily when they use the title “lawyer” to promote themselves as social media guru, a meaningless phrase that’s been sorely abused.

He recently picked up on a lawyer from my neck of the woods, Kathleen Scanlon, who was caught up in a fairly large real estate fraud case.  She pleaded guilty and is awaiting sentence.

What drew Tannebaum’s attention to her wasn’t that she was indicted or pleaded guilty, but that she continued to aggressively pursue business on twitter under the guise of being a real estate lawyer and “social media rockstar,” even after the guilty plea.  It was the brazenness of it that caught Tannebaum’s attention, and so he outed her.

This led to a post by Mark Bennett at his Social Media Tyro blog, using the Tannebaum/Scanlon exchange on twitter, where Scanlon deleted her twits and altered her profile to cover her tracks, then denied that she did any such thing, to discuss how purported “social media expertise” has become the refuge for disgraced lawyers.

Scanlon didn’t take kindly to being the poster girl, and went on a tear in the comments to Bennett’s post.  Her words run the full gamut, from ignorant to disingenuous to deceitful.  The best choice would have been to remain silent, but that apparently wasn’t in the cards.  Instead, she argues and argues, writing some things that should never emerge from the fingers of a person awaiting sentence. 

Should her words come to the attention of the court or prosecution, there may well be good reason for her plea deal to explode in her face.  Not only is there no remorse whatsoever, but there’s outright denial of any wrongdoing and an extremely aggressive claim of undeserved victimhood.  Scanlon makes no bones about her right to do whatever she has to do to continue to make money in real estate, shifting focus ever so slightly so that her “hiatus” (her word) from the law won’t interfere with her ability to make money.

This is not the lesson one would expect a guilty defendant to learn.  It’s certainly not what a guilty defendant should express publicly.

While there is much of concern in Scanlon’s comments, this seems to me to be the most troubling:


With respect to the criminal case, I pled to Scheme to Defraud because I was advised to do so in light of the non-incarceration promise, the seriousness of the charges & possible penalties, the incredibly prohibitive cost of going to trial (which is what I wanted to do at the risk of blowing my children’s college education fund) and probably the most important – that I am the mother of two elementary school age boys. Perhaps you might want to peruse the indictment for a better background on this case: http://manhattanda.org/whatsnew/press/2009-07-8.pdf . Use your super criminal lawyer skills and search my name in there. My lawyer’s first reaction was “what did you do? where is the crime?”. I put my family first, ahead of the law license because I have my priorities straight.
What she did was pretty clear: She represented straw buyers in real estate closings, which served to steal mortgage money.  She didn’t kill anyone, but it’s still a crime.  And claiming that you didn’t know they were straw buyers is silly.

But you can’t have it both ways.  There are pleas of convenience, even though they aren’t supposed to happen, where a person makes a business judgment that it’s smarter to plead guilty than fight.  But to claim poverty as the reason for the plea stinks.  To lay it on your children’s future is malarkey.  Pleas of convenience come from the fact that they’ve got you nailed to the wall, not because you’re innocent and they can’t prove otherwise. 

The problem isn’t that Kathleen Scanlon (or Scanlondesio as she’s called in Webcrims) is such a horrible person.  It appears that she did wrong, that she was swept up in the  furor of cheap mortgage money and scam real estate closings.  From what I understand to be the case, this was pervasive amongst real estate lawyers before the crash, and since somebody had to close these strawman deals, it might as well have been Scanlon to collect the fee.  I do not suggest that this is an acceptable excuse at all, but proportionality is always an important consideration.

That said, Scanlon has made her bed by continuing to hold herself out as a lawyer and claiming “rockstar” status while awaiting sentence, then fighting about it when called out.  Contrary to the conspiracy theorists, there’s no “nod and wink” amongst the bar to conceal wrongdoing by other lawyers.  Had Scanlon not pushed the envelope, and pushed it hard, she would have never made it onto anyone’s radar.  Had she not decided to fight rather than be conciliatory, she might have enjoyed a much more understanding reception.  But at each turn, Scanlon chose the route destined to exacerbate her problems.

There are three points to be learned from this mess.  First, it’s wise to lay low while awaiting sentence.  Second, when you promote yourself as a “social media rockstar,” don’t be shocked and angry when people notice.  Third, there is no situation that can’t be made worse with a little effort and poor judgment. 

I bet that Scanlon can put her knowledge of real estate to good use in the future, support her kids and find great success.  She certainly doesn’t seem the type to be kept down for long.  And I hope that she’s learned from this mess in the meantime.

Update:  In a timely twist, another self-styled social media type (she denies having ever called herself a guru), Sheryl Sisk Schelin who blogs as The Inspired Solo turns out to be a suspended lawyer.  When confronted by the Brians (Tannebaum and Cuban), she responded by playing prune-faced school marm to their internet sheriff.  Her post, Life’s Too Short to Listen to Bullies: How to Respond to @sses on Twitter, is fascinating for its bluff and swagger, that those who “challenged” her are babies and bullies because they didn’t behave the way she wanted them to.

On the other hand, nowhere in her post does she mention anything about her suspension from the practice of law. 

The question of when or how a disbarred, disgraced, suspended attorney should acknowledge their problems is an interesting one.  But one this is clear: If they can’t practice law, they should not hold themselves out as a lawyer, whether directly or by implication.  That’s where all the arguments all fall down.



Money Makes The World Go ‘Round

My good buddy Gideon, Connecticut public defender extraordinaire, had a comment over at A Public Defender that rocked his world.  Private criminal defense lawyers and public defenders have one thing that differentiates their concerns: Money.



I always thought we were brothers (and sisters). You, the criminal defense lawyer in private practice, and I, the public defender. Cousins of a sort. We had one common objective: acquittals defending the Constitutional rights of those unlucky enough to be sucked into the vortex that is the criminal justice system.

 But now it seems that there’s this schism between us. This divide that I’d never noticed.

Commenter Bill Thompson explains :



Your observations are but the tip of the iceberg relating to the inherent conflicts between the private bar and public defenders. The “money” factor is the absolute wedge dividing otherwise natural allies.


Thompson’s comment doesn’t just address the “wedge” that comes from private lawyers smearing PDs in order to scare them into hiring retain counsel, the most obvious example of the money issue.  Thompson goes right to the heart of what we do.


PD’s here complain about the phenomenon of over-indictment, while private practitioners celebrate it as “the difference between driving a Chevy and a Cadillac”. PD’s speak of decriminalizing drug offenses while profit-minded attorneys rue the day. It’s these differences which typically land a lawyer interested in criminal defense in one camp versus the other.
While heavy on cynicism, Thompson’s point has certain merit.  Private criminal defense lawyers feed their families because people get arrested.  Legalize drugs, for example, and a huge source of revenue disappears.  Drug cases are good business, whether we want to publicly admit that or not.  The clients tend to be easy to work with and prepared to pay the fee as a cost of doing business.  Murder cases are more of a problem, since there’s no money in murder and many accused murderers can’t afford a lawyer.  That’s bad for business.

But do we still care about good laws, fair laws, due process and our client’s welfare?  I suspect the “wedge” is overstated for most private criminal defense lawyers.  I would use myself as an example, but no one elected me the representative of the private criminal defense bar.  The best I can do, then, is offer my observations of my brothers (and sisters) in the trenches.

While I’ve known many lawyers who are as mercenary as Thompson suggests, that isn’t the “wedge” that divides most private lawyers from public defenders.  The thing that disturbs private lawyers most, at least in New York City, is that defendants who can afford counsel are nonetheless given a free lawyer for the asking.  There is no meaningful vetting process, and every defendant is handed a PD or 18b lawyer at arraignment by default.

Why buy the cow if you can get the milk for free? 

Public defenders aren’t concerned about defendants who can afford a lawyer but elect to stick with the PD.  I suspect they are flattered, though they should be angered.  These defendants suck up their time, time which should rightfully belong to defendants for whom Gideon (the decision, not the blawger) was intended.  They complain about being oppressively overworked, yet don’t turn anyone away, even if they drive up in a shiny Mercedes wearing 20 pounds of gold and diamonds around their neck.

To the private criminal defense lawyer, the defendant who can afford a lawyer is their domain.  The PDs are taking away their next meal.  Where’s the mutual love?  Defend the poor and downtrodden all day long, but let the private lawyers make a living too.  While PDs see themselves as just helping those in need, private lawyers see them as poaching on their turf. 

This raises the question of how one distinguishes a defendant who can pay from one who cannot afford an attorney.  Here too there’s a schism.  For most PDs, and some private lawyers, a defendant who can afford counsel is one with cash in the bank (or the suitcase, as the case may be).  Most private criminal defense lawyers, however, would contend that defendant’s possessed of assets, house, car, jewels, are clearly capable of paying. 

The difference here is the question of whether a person accused of a crime is required to render himself destitute in order to mount a defense, selling off all his assets to pay for a lawyer.  The PD thinks not.  The private lawyer thinks that there is no difference between cash in the bank and cash in the Mercedes to justify his getting a free ride.  Regardless of how a defendant chooses to keep his assets, if he’s got them he should use them.  Obviously, this is because the private criminal defense lawyer wants to earn a fee.  In fairness, someone has to pay the cost of defense, and if not the defendant, then the burden falls on everyone else.

While Gideon feigns ignorance of this “wedge” between the brothers and sisters of the criminal defense bar, I’ve no doubt that he fully understands the various concerns and divisions.  I similarly believe that he knows that there is far more in common than not, and that most private criminal defense lawyers are not nearly as mercenary or cynical as Thompson’s comment might make them appear.  Not that there aren’t greedy, lying, scummy criminal defense lawyers.  There are, and we can often tell who they are by their efforts to scare or scam potential clients into purchasing their crappy services.

Call me Pollyanna, but I believe that the really greedy lawyers are a distinct minority, and most private criminal defense lawyers put the interests of defendants well ahead of grubbing money.  But they still need to feed their families, and that means they need to represent paying clients.