A while back, Carolyn Elefant at Legal Blog Watch raised the question of whether it’s appropriate to give Continuing Legal Education credit to lawyers for programs on legal marketing. While Carolyn isn’t a fan of compelled CLE in the first place, the issue of teaching lawyers to market isn’t as intrinsically troubling:
The Wisconsin Law Journal piece quotes Law Marketing Blog author Larry Bodine, who criticized the omission of marketing courses from CLE as “a major shortcoming.” Likewise, many solo and small firm lawyers believe that incorporating marketing and practice management courses into CLE programs can help these lawyers succeed, says Christopher L. Strohbehn, a member of the CLE committee. Stohbehn also points out that Internet marketing and social media are fast replacing Yellow Pages advertising and lawyers need to understand their ethical obligations when using 21st century technologies to market their practices.
* * *
So if CLE is going to be mandatory anyway, bars should allow lawyers to take courses on practice management and marketing to enable lawyers to run ethical, profitable practices. Moreover, in the long run, courses that help lawyers do well financially prevent the kind of desperation that may lead them to “borrow” money from client trust accounts, or do far worse.
Putting aside, for the moment, my concern that this is a total load of nonsense, that lawyers should spend their time packaging and selling themselves like the latest designer fashion, an email received the other day clarified how naive this belief that lawyer marketing is appropriately included in CLE.
The email came from Public Relations and Media Group, touting their “upcoming event.”
CLE Lecture – PR and Marketing for LawyersThere’s no mention of who will be the instructor, and clearly this isn’t a law firm, bar association or law school, but an entity whose purpose is to selling marketing. How the heck did this group obtain authorization to provide continuing legal education? Who in their right mind would give an PR firm the power to confer CLE credits for teaching ethics to lawyers? Apparently, the State of New York did so.
Extended Lunch & Learn
One CLE Credit Hour — Ethics & Professionalism
(Three hour program. The course is appropriate for both newly admitted and experienced attorneys)
This program will help ensure that the strategies for growing or maintaining your practice conform with ethical requirements. You will gain practical tips for choosing marketing methods that are suited to your practice, personality, and your means.
To the extent that mandatory CLE makes any sense at all, it’s to keep lawyers abreast of the law and their professional responsibilities. It is not, despite Larry Bodine’s self-interested perspective, to teach lawyers how to cash in. CLE was never intended to help lawyers achieve “financial success,” except in the extended sense of improving their competency so that potential clients will desire their services because they are better lawyers for it. Obviously, that purpose has been lost.
I realize that it’s much easier to put up a glossy website telling potential clients what a great, experienced, aggressive, passionate lawyer you are than to actually be one. The latter takes time and effort. The former can be done in minutes. I also realize that for every lawyer who puffs his abilities and worthiness, a client is deceived. While this can certainly help the new solo to get business that he would otherwise not get, it comes at the expense of ethics and integrity, not in conformity with it.
Ultimately, marketing puts lawyers who actually have experience, competency and ethics at a clear disadvantage to those who are happy to be unscrupulous to make a quick buck. The competent lawyer can’t distinguish himself online because the incompetent need only use the same words to tout himself to the unknowing legal consumer. How would the consumer know the difference?
The ethical lawyer would never puff his qualifications or deceive people to score a case. The ethically challenged lawyer has no qualms about doing this at all. And contrary to those who argue that marketing is pro-consumer by providing information they would otherwise be denied, marketing isn’t informative. It’s deception and manipulation. And ethics are not facilitation, but a restraint on deception and manipulation.
That said, how in the world can ethics be trusted to be taught to lawyers for CLE credit by the people whose business it is to sell marketing to lawyers? It’s insane.

