Author Archives: SHG

If Ethics Are Taught By Marketers

A while back, Carolyn Elefant at Legal Blog Watch raised the question of whether it’s appropriate to give Continuing Legal Education credit to lawyers for programs on legal marketing.  While Carolyn isn’t a fan of compelled CLE in the first place, the issue of teaching lawyers to market isn’t as intrinsically troubling:


The Wisconsin Law Journal piece quotes Law Marketing Blog author Larry Bodine, who criticized the omission of marketing courses from CLE as “a major shortcoming.” Likewise, many solo and small firm lawyers believe that incorporating marketing and practice management courses into CLE programs can help these lawyers succeed, says Christopher L. Strohbehn, a member of the CLE committee. Stohbehn also points out that Internet marketing and social media are fast replacing Yellow Pages advertising and lawyers need to understand their ethical obligations when using 21st century technologies to market their practices.

*  *  *

So if CLE is going to be mandatory anyway, bars should allow lawyers to take courses on practice management and marketing to enable lawyers to run ethical, profitable practices. Moreover, in the long run, courses that help lawyers do well financially prevent the kind of desperation that may lead them to “borrow” money from client trust accounts, or do far worse.

This assumes, obviously, that marketing is an acceptable and necessary component of practicing law, and that it will be done in conformity with our ethical considerations. 

Putting aside, for the moment, my concern that this is a total load of nonsense, that lawyers should spend their time packaging and selling themselves like the latest designer fashion, an email received the other day clarified how naive this belief that lawyer marketing is appropriately included in CLE.

The email came from Public Relations and Media Group, touting their “upcoming event.”



CLE Lecture – PR and Marketing for Lawyers
Extended Lunch & Learn
One CLE Credit Hour — Ethics & Professionalism
(Three hour program. The course is appropriate for both newly admitted and experienced attorneys)

This program will help ensure that the strategies for growing or maintaining your practice conform with ethical requirements. You will gain practical tips for choosing marketing methods that are suited to your practice, personality, and your means.
There’s no mention of who will be the instructor, and clearly this isn’t a law firm, bar association or law school, but an entity whose purpose is to selling marketing.  How the heck did this group obtain authorization to provide continuing legal education?  Who in their right mind would give an PR firm the power to confer CLE credits for teaching ethics to lawyers?  Apparently, the State of New York did so.

To the extent that mandatory CLE makes any sense at all, it’s to keep lawyers abreast of the law and their professional responsibilities.  It is not, despite Larry Bodine’s self-interested perspective, to teach lawyers how to cash in.  CLE was never intended to help lawyers achieve “financial success,” except in the extended sense of improving their competency so that potential clients will desire their services because they are better lawyers for it.  Obviously, that purpose has been lost.

I realize that it’s much easier to put up a glossy website telling potential clients what a great, experienced, aggressive, passionate lawyer you are than to actually be one.  The latter takes time and effort.  The former can be done in minutes.  I also realize that for every lawyer who puffs his abilities and worthiness, a client is deceived.  While this can certainly help the new solo to get business that he would otherwise not get, it comes at the expense of ethics and integrity, not in conformity with it.

Ultimately, marketing puts lawyers who actually have experience, competency and ethics at a clear disadvantage to those who are happy to be unscrupulous to make a quick buck.  The competent lawyer can’t distinguish himself online because the incompetent need only use the same words to tout himself to the unknowing legal consumer.  How would the consumer know the difference? 

The ethical lawyer would never puff his qualifications or deceive people to score a case.  The ethically challenged lawyer has no qualms about doing this at all.  And contrary to those who argue that marketing is pro-consumer by providing information they would otherwise be denied, marketing isn’t informative.  It’s deception and manipulation.  And ethics are not facilitation, but a restraint on deception and manipulation.

That said, how in the world can ethics be trusted to be taught to lawyers for CLE credit by the people whose business it is to sell marketing to lawyers?  It’s insane.

Findlaw Plays Dirty

Ask anybody in the blawgosphere about the  New York Personal Injury Law Blog and they will immediately tell you what a great job Eric Turkewitz does with his blog.  It’s one of the best known, best respected PI blawgs around.  Everyone knows that.  Everyone, apparently, except Findlaw.

As Turk found out to his amazement (though not amusement), Findlaw like the name so much that it created its own New .  It’s shabby and worthless, but that’s not surprising given that it’s not written by a lawyer, offers no insight and is merely intended as a conduit to push personal injury cases through to lawyers who pay for the privilege. 


And, surprise, surprise, when you read the “articles” that are written they have a link at the bottom with the “call to action” to contact one of the lawyers that pay FindLaw to promote and advertise for them. As it happens, I know many of those on that list, and some are friends of mine. And you can bet your last dollar that I will let them know what FindLaw is up to, and they can decide for themselves if this is the type of conduct that they approve of.

And in case you think this is of no concern to you, this isn’t the only niche specific blog that Findlaw has decided to throw against the wall.  Others include , “written” by the same non-attorney author as the other and with the same link at the bottom in the “call to action.”  Today, it’s New York. If it works, you can bet that Findlaw will put up a scam blog in your neighborhood.

These aren’t blogs, of course, in the sense that we understand them.  There are mere names designed to trade in on search engine keywords, and capitalize on Findlaw’s SEO ability to get their scam blogs higher than yours on the search engine’s first page.  Does this surprise you?  Did you think that only individual lawyers and firms could come up with the idea that if they post a blog, clients will come running and they will get fantastically rich?  Didn’t you expect to be trumped in your marketing efforts by someone bigger and badder?

But this particular effort comes with two distinct issues, both disgraceful.  First, you don’t steal someone else’s name, even if it is a really good name that you want for yourself for marketing purposes.  The Turk is a known quantity in the blawgosphere, and New York Personal Injury Law Blog is his.  That Findlaw, which has resorted to scum marketing across the board in its efforts to monetize itself, would steal Turk’s name is outrageous. 

Second, for all of you who see marketing as the only value in blawging, who buy into the total nonsense that blawg are all about bringing in clients, you’re being outflanked.  As argued numerous times, no matter how low you’re prepared to go to try to score some business, there will be someone out there who will happily sink lower.  At the moment, Findlaw is about as low as it gets.  But don’t be surprised when it goes even lower.  The race to the bottom is far from over.

Turk will no doubt demand that Findlaw change the name of its latest marketing ploy, and the blawgosphere will join together to shame Findlaw for this crap.  We’ve been under assault for a long time with lawyer marketing efforts, whether in spam comments, lying websites, or worthless marketing blogs, often scraping content from real blogs to make them appear legitimate.  You’ve got no idea the amount of work done by the backroom staff to try to stave off this marketing onslaught.  At the same time, we suffer the snake oil salesmen telling newbie lawyers that social media is the path to riches and success, assuring that the battles fought today will be repeated tomorrow when the next wave of self-promoting lawyers hits the internet.

For those of you who have placed their reputation in Findlaw’s hands, be prepared to be tainted by the company you keep.  For those of you who think that the blawgosphere is the easy road to success, you’re being played for a fool.  And for anyone who still thinks Findlaw is a fine, upstanding, legitimate entity with which to do business, meet Eric Turkewitz, the latest lawyer to get slimed by Findlaw’s scummy ways.

Breaking Links

There have recently been a number of comments that included links to various other places, ranging from news stories to books to blog posts, and which I have gone in and deleted.  The commenters reactions have ranged from apologies to anger.  Since I would prefer not having to edit comments, and not having to deal with angry comments, it seemed like a good time to write about links in comments.

As a general rule, don’t do it.

Does that cover it?  What, you want to know why?  Do I really have to explain myself?  Fine, my house, my rules. Not good enough? Sheesh. 

So here’s the reason.  I reserve the right to decide who and what gets link love from Simple Justice.  There are people and places and blogs that I prefer not to include as a link here.  I give plenty of link love on my own to those of my choosing.  It’s not like I’m Jonathan Turley or anything, never giving so much as a hat tip to the source of my posts.  I do plenty.

But I similarly maintain the prerogative to decide that others, not of my choosing, don’t get a link here through the back door.  Dear readers, you are welcome to comment, but not to throw in a link to whoever you think is brilliant, wonderful, worthy, important.  That’s my choice, and mine alone.  I pay the bills here, so I get to decide.

A bit arbitrary and capricious, you say?  Yeah, so?  I would go so far as saying whimsical, if that will quiet y’all down.  But the point remains that it’s my choice, not yours.  I will often allow or include a link to other blawgers I like and appreciate, while denying it to those I don’t.  Just my choice in how I use my blawg.  Do I use this power haphazardly?  Sure. I have the keys and have no qualms about using them in any way I see fit.  If the mood strikes me to include something, I do.  If not, I don’t. It can be that simple, and that arbitrary. I admit it.

I will never allow someone who is not on my blog roll to include a link in a comment to his or her own blog.  That’s just offensive, no matter who you are or how good your blog might be.  It’s tacky and self-aggrandizing.  If anybody’s going to be self-aggrandizing around here, it’s me.  And then I’ve Bennett to remind me when I am.

A secondary reason for my no-link position is the comment equivalent of the broken windows theory.  Linking encourages more linking, which not only overburdens me in editing, changing, deleting the links, but encourages all manner of spammers trying to sneak a link into a comment.  I hate that, and won’t countenance it.  And if your link has to die to keep spammers away, so be it.

To bottom line it, I’m not trying to be pointlessly heavy handed about deleting links, nor to make a commenter look foolish or wrong.  Comments are not appropriate places to include links in posts.  On occasion, someone will ask me and I will give them the go-ahead to link away.  I’m not a total jerk about it.  But show me the courtesy of not inserting links into comments and I won’t be put in the position of deleting them.

And contrary to popular opinion, I don’t delete links because they involve a post that is critical of what I’ve written.  Just find a way to ridicule me without using links.  You can do it, as have thousands before you

I hope this clears everything up.

Changes? What Changes?

As we come to the end of another year, and another decade, there are naturally the slew of recapitulations floating about.  Most take the form of “top 10” lists of no lasting consequence, but others are a retrospective on more substantive matters.  The former are, also naturally, more popular as they take far less effort to absorb.

At Law 21, Jordon Furlong writes of the changes of the closing decade:


What’s left to say about the 2000s? What the legal profession (and the marketplace in which it operates) have just gone through was, as Brad Hildebrandt points out, unprecedented in almost every way. I won’t recap the changes — as Law21’s second full year draws to a close, you can read about them in many of the 274 previous posts here. But at a glance, we’ve seen astounding technological advances (primarily online) that change how legal services are accomplished and delivered, the rapid development of service providers outside the confines of national borders and the legal profession, and two recessions, the latter serious enough to trigger a long-overdue shift in the balance of power between lawyers and their clients. By the decade’s end, we saw the first signs that fundamental change in the marketplace, talked about for so long, was finally, really happening.

How did I miss it?  As far as I can tell, there are a bunch of new gadgets to buy, and ways to waste time that never before existed, but clients still call on the phone and then come in for a meeting.  I go to court and wait until my case is called.  A year or two later, the case gets tried before a bunch of people who reach a verdict. 

True, in federal court I must file papers electronically, using a system that was difficult and unwieldy on the day it was introduced and remains unchanged since.  State court papers will move by hand or snail mail though.  Somehow, I don’t think this is what Jordon is talking about.

I’m not arguing about whether Jordon is right in claiming that we’ve seen “astounding technological advances” in the law over the past decade.  I’m wondering why, if this has happened in other practice areas, why criminal law has been left out?

I read all of Jordon’s posts to keep abreast of developments in legal technology.  If I didn’t read Jordon’s posts, I wouldn’t know about many of these developments, as they rarely make their way into the world of the criminal defense lawyer.  While others have “virtual offices” and “cloud computing” and outsourcing to places where they pay pennies on the dollar for legal services, we still do things pretty much the same way as we did since the day I got my ticket, except that cool lawyers now use computers instead of IBM Selectrics.  That was a huge advance, I admit.

Why have we been left out of this technological revolution?  Why do we not have virtual meetings with clients, and virtual court appearances?  Why do state courts not have electronic filing, and why is ECF still almost impossible to navigate?  Why do prosecutors not send papers and discovery in pdf files via email, instead using email to make sure we received them a week later than the judge (assuming that it’s not an intentional ex parte communication)? 

But Jordon’s real joy is raised by what technology has done for our clients.


Clients (both consumer and corporate) possess more knowledge of and more influence over legal services delivery than they’ve ever had, and both will grow. In sheer numbers, more people figure to have real access to justice in the 2010s than at any time in history.

Where are these clients and why are mine not enjoying this benefit?  Mine are no more knowledgeable than they’ve ever been.  At least based upon the number and nature of questions asked, they surely don’t seem to have any greater depth of understanding than before.  As for influence of legal services delivery, they hated paying for a criminal defense 25 years ago and still do today.  I’m not at all clear what this means, but I don’t believe that it’s making clients any happier.


Lawyers who are really devoted to service, to stewardship, and to the best interests of others will welcome the coming explosion in access to justice, whether it benefits us financially or not. If the resources are emerging outside our walls to provide people with better legal services at a lower price, then the real professionals in our midst will make those resources available to clients and make whatever adjustments are necessary to their own business models to ensure their continued viability. 
Now I’m devoted to client service, and welcome the “explosion in access to justice.”  Of course, my justice may not be your justice, but let’s not get bogged down in semantics.  But there is remarkably little in what technology offers that reduces the cost for criminal defendants.  This may have to do with the fact that there has been little change in our practice, or that we’ve been left out of this exploding access to justice.  Either way, every cost associated with the practice of law seems to go up every year, leaving me to wonder why lawyers in other practice areas are able to serve their clients at a lower price while criminal defense lawyer costs only move higher.

I certainly don’t doubt that Jordon’s observations, about this tech revolution in the law, is happening.  I’m just not seeing any of it.  About the only difference I’ve seen are the emails from people seeking free advice and representation.  Is that it?  Have criminal defense lawyers been left out of the technology revolution, or is it just me?  Or is it not quite as revolutionary as it sounds?

Joining The Maricopa Choir (Godin Update)

Changes are happening in Arizona, though cause and effect remains somewhat unclear.  Not that it really matters, as movements take on a life of their own.  Along with the extremely successful lawyer rally came Yavapai County Attorney Sheila Polk’s op-ed in the Arizona Republic.  The latter was unanticipated, but a hugely significant addition to the cause at a propitious moment.

As Jeff Gamso notes,


These folks are in the same business. They’re members of the same political party. They’re natural allies. Prosecutors simply don’t engage in this sort of attack on other prosecutors without cause. Or without thinking about the consequences.

With nearly perfect pitch, Arpaio’s spokesman did exactly what one would pray he would do:


Arpaio’s chief deputy, David Hendershott, told reporters Monday that once he learned of Polk’s column over the weekend, he notified the FBI that they should investigate Polk for hindering the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office’s corruption investigations.

Hendershott’s response was exactly the note one would expect from Arpaio.  Naturally, he maligns Polk as having tried to “tank the case” she was working on because she’s part of the conspiracy against Arpaio.  And so, Yavapai County Attorney Polk joins the Maricopa Supervisors and judges as part of the vast conspiracy against Crazy Joe Arpaio and his butt-boil, Thomas.

It’s far easier to dismiss a bunch of lawyers rallying against Arpaio than it is the neighboring county’s prosecutor.  And even the immigrant fearing, faux-crime fearing, myopic 55+ crowd, can smell paranoia, even if they can’t spell it.

What we have witnessed over the past month are acts of increasing boldness and bravery.  True, it was long past due for these acts, but they come in their own time.  I’m sure when Jim Belanger called for a rally he had no idea that Sheila Polk would speak out in support of his purposes.  Polk saw the opportunity and seized it, placing herself squarely on Crazy Joe’s enemies list.  She joined the tenor of Maricopa lawyers, bringing a beautiful soprano to the harmony.

Up to now, there are two common threads the bind those who have spoken out.  A respect for law and the Constitution, and a willingness to accept the risk of Crazy Joe’s ire.  The latter is not inconsequential, given the fact that Arpaio is in command of an armed force and has shown no reluctance to abuse his authority to silence his enemies.

That the Arizona Attorneys for Criminal Justice and NACDL have been silent is a disgrace.  Are they waiting for someone to throw an awards dinner before they lift their voices?

On the other hand, the story of the lawyer’s rally appears in the ABA Journal.  It was as routine a post as they could offer, sandwiched between Mich. AG Likens Carp to ‘Nuclear Bombs,’ Asks High Court to Stop Lake Entry and Ex-Pro Bono Chief for Kaye Scholer Suspended for Failing to Pay Taxes.  The ABA’s motto is Defending Liberty, Pursuing Justice.

Having taken the initiative to write about what is happening in Maricopa County, the absence of any recognition, of any position, of any concern, for the fact that this is a watershed event in the war against the Rule of Law being played out in the courthouse square, is the final note.  In the choir of voices singing about the constitutional crisis playing out in Maricopa County, we now have our castrato.

This was the time for the ABA Journal to show a fraction of the gumption shown by the Maricopa lawyers, by Sheila Polk.  This was the moment when a platitude was given meaning or proven empty. 

The ABA Journal has been busy running beauty pageants designed to get lawyers to register with its website, and pretending that marketers and social media gurus are Legal Rebels.  This would be embarrassing enough on its own, palpable demonstrations of how vapid and superficial the ABA has become.  They are selling a Legal Rebel skateboard, for crying out loud.

We could happily overlook its efforts to achieve pseudo-coolness if only the ABA Journal had seized this opportunity to actually serve a purpose, to take a stand, a firm, clear and forceful stand, at this point in time when it meant something.  Not tomorrow or next week, after the brain trust figures out that their failure to stand up has made the ABA the embarrassment of the legal world. 

By the mere act of having written about this event, while failing to either recognize its importance or take a stand, the ABA Journal, and thus the ABA itself, has shown itself to be irrelevant.  Go run another beauty pageant or skateboard sale. That’s all you’re good for.  The time to act has come and gone. It failed.

Back in Maricopa, the voices are building toward a crescendo.  It’s unclear how long the song will last, or how its final verse will play out.  There are voices, such as the Governor’s and the United States Attorney’s, who have yet to be heard.  There is the threat by Crazy Joe’s spokesman that “[t]hinges are going to get a lot uglier before they get better.” 

While the problems of Maricopa play out in smaller ways across the country, nowhere else has it reached critical mass.  It took someone as crazy, arrogant and overt as Joe Arpaio to bring the fight between law and order out in the open.  Now that sides have been chosen, the battle engaged, lives and reputations hanging by a thread, there can be no easy way to stop the choir from singing. 

Just how ugly has yet to be seen.  But for those in the choir right now, the harmony sounds wonderful, if still lacking the voices of those too afraid or irrelevant to join in.

Update:  As if by kismet, marketing philosopher Seth Godin today offers a post First, organize 1,000.



I think the ability to find and organize 1,000 people is a breakthrough opportunity. One thousand people coordinating their actions is enough to change your world (and make a living.)


1,000 people each spending $1,000 on a special interest cruise equals a million dollars.


1,000 people willing to spend $250 to attend a day-long seminar gives you the leverage to invite just about anyone you can imagine to fly in and speak.


1,000 people voting as a bloc can change local politics forever.


1,000 people willing to try a new restaurant you find for them gives you the ability to make an entrepreneur successful and change the landscape of your town.

The lessons of marketing can be put to use for the good of mankind as well.  Is that 1000 number an absolute, or is there some wiggle room?

Play That Funky Music, White Boy

In the comments to my post on Cormac Carney’s remarkable decision in the Ruehle/Broadcom trial, Chuck questioned whether I went over the top in my applause of the decision.


But I’d wait to canonize the judge until he gets around to applying the same principles in a case without corporate white-collar defendants.
There’s a sense amongst criminal defense lawyers that the only defendants whose rights are shown respect are of the white collar variety.  This perception has some awfully good basis in reality, as we are all made painfully aware on a regular basis of how judges blow off significant issues, ranging from actual innocence to constitutional violations, without breaking a sweat.  How many judges lose sleep wondering if their efforts that day put an innocent in prison, enabled the government to run roughshod over the Constitution or empowered a cop to lie his way to a conviction.

Some of the judges I know realize that these things happen, but insulate themselves from the actual effect of their decisions by taking comfort in the odds.  Odds are that the defendant is guilty, that the cop, though perhaps a liar, is more truthful than deceitful.  They don’t think of their decisions as reflecting a lack of respect for the Constitution, but rather a pragmatic approach.  After all, just because the cops can’t do anything right isn’t a good reason to let criminals run rampant.

But to say that things like the Carney decision never happen outside of white collar cases is wrong.  As I read Carney’s decision, I immediately thought of a drug case I did many years ago, where SDNY Judge Ken Conboy, who has since left the bench to make his fortune at Latham, ripped the lungs out of the government and the DEA for rampant dishonesty in their handling of a drug case.  I also recalled a white collar case in the SDNY where the judge couldn’t have cared less about obviously lying federal agents, where his reaction was “so what?”

My initial reaction to Chuck was to not look a gift horse in the mouth.  It was a great decision.  That it didn’t involve Clarence Earl Gideon was hardly a reason to be critical.  They can’t all involve Clarence Earl Gideon.  But the real issue wasn’t that this decision, concededly great as far as it went, didn’t inure to the benefit of the common defendant, but that only the rich, the powerful, the clean, have a shot at a great decision that preserves and elevates constitutional rights over ease of conviction. 

It does seem that way, sometimes.

There are some factors that need to be considered before one tarnishes Judge Carney’s opinion.  Initially, there is no question but that white collar defendants are inherently more sympathetic to federal judges.  Had they not been indicted, they might have met at a cocktail party, or perhaps dined together.  The pain of damage to their family life is easier to feel when your children share the same school and play on the same lacrosse team or crew together.

This isn’t likely to change anytime soon, given the nature of how federal judges are selected.  There aren’t many senators who hang in the ‘hood, inclined to urge the President to appoint one of their homies.  And when a regular guy finds himself on a federal bench, there’s an inclination to be more like the other judges than make waves.  That said, there are some exceptions, as there always have been.  And they render opinions, and grant suppression, and trial orders of dismissal, that favor normal defendants.

The problem is that these rulings don’t make the papers.  Broadcom is a big, high profile, white collar case.  When you get a decision in a case like this, it’s going to make a splash.  It’s going to hit everybody’s radar and be the subject of a hundred newspaper stories and a thousand blawg posts.  It’s big news.

When there’s a good decision in a case involving some murderer or drug dealer, nobody knows.  It doesn’t make the front page, and even if it becomes the subject of a blawg post, it seems to be forgotten relatively quickly, largely because it’s viewed as the anomaly.  Then, when a decision like Judge Carney’s comes along, the cries go out about how it’s only the white collar defendants who get a break.  It’s just not necessarily the case.  Good decisions, whether for white collar defendants or not, are rare.  Strong statements of fealty to the Constitution are rare.  Brave decisions that cut against the popular devotion to order are rare.

Rather than complain about the unfairness of it all, it’s better to raise awareness of those good decisions, without reservation.  By doing so, we empower judges to take their positions more seriously, to take the violations of the Constitution perpetrated against our clients more seriously, and to join with those brave judges who have done so and received appreciation rather than approbation for it. 

To the extent that our voices matter, let them be heard to encourage the best that our judiciary has to offer.  No, it isn’t likely to start a tsunami of judicial interest in safeguarding the constitutional rights of all defendants, and no, it isn’t likely to change the predominant belief that their best path is to go with the odds, and no, it won’t encourage presidents who campaign on a promise of change to appoint judges who might conceivably bring about change.  But it’s got a greater chance of encouraging those judges who are on the cusp to do the right thing.

Judge Carney did the right thing, in a decision that will, and should, be played as loudly as possible.  Why do anything to muffle the sound?  Just play the music and show appreciation where it’s due. 

Maricopa Lives (Update)

The lawyer rally could have been the moment of Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s greatest triumph, demonstrable proof that there was no one in Maricopa County with the guts to stand up to him.  Instead, it was a shining moment of dignity and honor, where about 300 lawyers put their personal safety aside and their reputations on the line.

From the Phoenix New Times :


An estimated 300 people turned out to protest the reign of Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas in front of the county courthouse today — at least two-thirds of them local attorneys.

The noon rally was a surprising show of strength from a profession that generally prefers filing motions to openly agitating — and indeed, the few scattered immigration activists in the crowd definitely stuck out from the majority of protesters, who were older, whiter, and almost entirely clad in suits.

The rally, begun with an email sent by Phoenix criminal defense lawyer Jim Belanger, reflected the seriousness of purpose and breadth of support within the local legal community against Arpaio and his henchman, Thomas.

Attorney Tom Ryan kicked things off by explaining that he was neither a criminal defense lawyer, a Democrat, nor a liberal. “I’m a native of Chandler, Arizona, a Republican, and a lifelong East Valley conservative,” he said, setting things straight right out of the chute. 

But, Ryan said, it was time for “all concerned men and women of the Bar to come together.”

“Andrew Thomas is a bully and a coward,” Ryan said, to cheers from the phalanx of lawyers, “who, when he does not get his way, abuses the awesome power of the county attorney in a misguided and unethical attempt to get his own way.”


The battle has now been joined.  For the many supporters of Crazy Joe, who saw him as a populist saving them from the hordes of marauding illegals, while failing to comprehend why their savior can’t just do any darn thing he pleased (as long as it was somebody else, be it Mexican, politician or judge), the vision of white men in suits who charge by the hour using their own time, their own voices, to sing “America the Beautiful” may make some wonder whether they might be wrong about Arpaio.

But it’s just the first battle in a war that won’t be easily won. 


Several Superior Court judges hovered on the periphery, listening in to the goings-on. One of them told us how frustrating it was for judges not to be able stand tall and tell the community at large what is going on these days downtown.

The judge said he had no feeling one way or the other at the moment for how all this is going to turn out. But, he added, that he is not so hopeful.

One rally is a start.  A good start, but still just a start.  No doubt that the judge appreciates the depth of the problems faced in Maricopa County far better than we do, as well as the fight they will face from Arpaio before any change is accomplished.  Bear in mind, the lawyers and judges are constrained by the rules for which they are fighting.  Arpaio has no constraints.  He can fight as dirty as he wants, since no rules bind him.

At the Arizona Republic, there is an op-ed by Sheila Polk, who worked as a lawyer for the Sheriff the neighboring Yavapai County Attorney, who worked on Arpaio/Thomas cases  for six months due to conflicsts of interest, until she couldn’t take it any longer.  She turned back the files and took a shower.  Now, she tells about it.


My discomfort grew daily and my role in restraining potential abuses of power increasingly more difficult. It was a relief to package up the files and return them to Maricopa County.

Maricopa County is not my jurisdiction, but I can no longer sit by quietly and watch from a distance the abuses of power by Sheriff Arpaio and County Attorney Andrew Thomas.

I am conservative and passionately believe in limited government, not the totalitarianism that is spreading before my eyes.

The actions of Arpaio and Thomas are a disservice to the hundreds of dedicated men and women who work in their offices, and a threat to the entire criminal-justice system.

This is an act of bravery, as no one wants to come out as a traitor to a popular and powerful man with the anticipation of being smeared and crushed like a bug.  Sheila Polk did it anyway.  She took a huge personal risk. 

I challenged the locals of Maricopa County to stand up for themselves if they wanted the continued support and interest of the rest of us.  They have risen to the challenge.  There is little we can accomplish from the outside without the willingness to stand up for what’s right by those on the inside.  And now that they have come out and taken the risk of Arpaio’s wrath, the duty swings back to the rest of us to do what we can to support their effort, to back them up, to keep the battle moving forward.

Where is the Arizona Attorneys for Criminal Justice?  Where is every bar association in Arizona?  Does the Constitution, the abuse of law, mean nothing to them?

Where is the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers?  Where are all the subsidiary state associations, even the ones who give awards to prosecutors?

Where are the national media outlets, the newspapers, the television news magazines? 

Which side are you on, boys, which side are you on?

Addendum:  It’s too early in the day for an update, but this must be added to the post.  The ABA Journal posted a story about the rally as part of its “daily news.”  No outcry.  No opinion.  Just another lawyer/cat in a tree story, to be overshadowed by the truly important things the ABA Journal does, like run contests for those with low self-esteem.

If the ABA Journal wants to take note of what’s happening in Maricopa County, then how about it have something meaningful to say about it.  Cowards?  Aloof?  Irrelevant?  If there was any question about the value of the ABA in the lives of lawyers, this should put it to rest.  If the ABA Journal has nothing substantive to say while the lawyers of Maricopa County put their butts on the line, then the ABA has no reason to exist.

That’s right.  Why don’t you throw another beauty pageant.

Update: Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett interviews Jim Belanger, the Phoenix lawyer who started today’s rally.

All Eyes On Maricopa County (Rally Update)

Today is the big day, when the lawyers of Maricopa County will gather in the square aside the County Courthouse, arm in arm, to stand up to the reign of Sheriff Joe Arpaio and his boil, County Attorney Andrew Thomas.  This is big.  Huge.  I know this because Bennett and Gamso told me so, that blawgers must “shine the light.”  Gamso even has an advance image of today’s rally.

But Brian Tannebaum, who first brought out the news of today’s rally at the Maricopa Courthouse, is  less sanguine.

Certain events cause a groundswell, or as we call them in internet language “go viral.”

That lawyers in Maricopa County, Arizona, have had enough and will meet at the courthouse today to show their solidarity, is unfortunately not one of those events.

It seems that the Arizona Attorneys for Criminal Justice hasn’t bothered to include it on its list of fun activities for the holiday season.  The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers has yet to show any interest.  Whether the lawyers of Maricopa County care enough to show remains to be seen.


This is a bad time to expect a big crowd at any event, other than a holiday party or deep discount flat screen TV sale, but I do hope that the lawyers of Maricopa County, civil, and criminal, take their lunch hour and drop by the rally.

Having a large number of lawyers attend this event will make a big statement.

Having a small number of lawyers attend makes a bigger statement.
Public statements are funny things. They cut both ways.  I wonder if anybody thought about that in this ambitious plan? 

I watched Good Morning America today, just to see if they made mention of the rally.  They had some great tips on how to save on last minute gifts for friends and family.  None of it involved Arizona.  No analogy to Tienemen Square.  No blue pin-striped officer of a criminal bar association speaking out for the Constitution and Sheriff Joe’s abrogation thereof.  Nada.

It’s important that the lawyers of Maricopa County turn out in force today.  If they don’t, it’s over.  And it would have been different if the organized criminal defense bar associations took up the cause.  Even a little bit. Maybe they’ve been too busy getting those holiday bargains.  After all, when you’ve worked so very hard to earn a very important position as an executive officer in something as big as the NACDL, it’s hard to find the time to concern oneself with the small stuff like Joe Arpaio and Maricopa County. 

At least us blawgers keep shining the light on Maricopa County.  It would, of course, be more useful if someone was looking.  Hopefully, at least the locals care enough to eat their lunch in the courthouse square today.

Update:  As of approximately 12:50 p.m. Arizona time, there are about 300 to 400 people at the lawyer’s rally, per Nick Martin.  That is a huge crowd, and, as Tannebaum noted, “makes a big statement.”

A Felony and An iPod

I feared it would come to this, but I would have never expected it to come from a Scottish lawyer.  At Inkster Solicitors, Brian Inkster has taken the long-feared plunge that could spell the end of law as we know it, though might well be good for the economy.  He’s giving away a free iPod for registering with his new website.


You could even win an Apple iPod nano by registering on the websites for updates.

It’s not like you have to hire him to get the Ipod.  Just register for updates. Talk about easy.  Since I don’t have an Ipod, and I have nothing against freebies, I considered it, but realized that the chances of my needing a Scottish Solicitor were really slim, and it would be wrong to take his Ipod without much of a chance of giving him business in return.

It appears that “social media” has done well for Inksters, producing 22% of its new clients.  You can’t argue with success, and you can’t blame Brian for being a huge fan of social media as a means of marketing his firm.  He puts the “solicit” in Solicitors. 

So I wondered, how would that work for criminal defense lawyers.  Would a free iPod be enough of a draw?  Commit a crime and get a Nano?  Maybe with a docking station? That might be good enough for an infraction, maybe even a low-rent misdemeanor, but hardly much of a draw for any serious crime.  Maybe a Kindle?  Nah. Not that many potential clients are big readers.  They would just fence it.

What about something really big, really shiny?  Get a free Laptop (choice of colors) with every Class “B” felony or higher?  Maybe, except for kiddie porn defendants, for whom this could present a real problem.  And almost everyone already has a computer, so it might not do the trick for getting a defendant motivated to fight those decades in prison.  Plus, it could serve to keep decent criminals at home, playing computer games, rather than push him onto the street to wreak much havoc.  That wouldn’t help much.

No, if we’re going down the premium road, it would have to be something that would provide just the right incentive to not only bring the client in the door, but keep him coming.  After all, repeat business is the foundation of legal success.

That’s when it hit me.  For every 10 felony defenses, get one free!  I could make up little cards, and each time a client returned for yet another criminal defense, I could punch a little hole around the edge, obliterating a gun or maybe a baggie of heroin, to signify how close he was to his free defense!  We could have a different card for white collar criminals.  Maybe platinum colored with little checkbooks or backdated stock options.  With proper branding, it could create quite the cache next to his AmEx card in his wallet.

Now that we’ve broken through the wall of hardcore marketing, what with half-price sales, BOGO free and iPod giveaways, the possibilities are endless.  I can’t wait to hear from you. Operators are standing by.

LawProf Althouse: Shoot The Vicious Snowball Predators

While the video taken by Reason TV’s Dan Hayes was sure to evoke some controversy about Washington, D.C. Det. [FNU] Baylor, it struck me as fairly certain that it would be the detective, not the snowball fighters, who would bear the brunt of scrutiny.  Not so, according to lawprof Ann Althouse.


There is a difference between a snowball fight and throwing snowballs at moving vehicles. In a snowball fight — like this cool one in Madison a couple weeks ago — you have voluntary participants playing at fighting with each other. Throwing snowballs at cars, on the other had, is surprising people who happen upon the scene and it’s distracting them — and doing so at a time when it is particularly difficult to drive. Drivers do not know the extent of the interference when it begins, and they can be frightened or easily stimulated into braking or accelerating — when there is snow and ice and when pedestrians are nearby. Whether the vehicles are Hummers or not makes no difference.

Apparently, there are strict rules by which snowball fights are to be run.  How strict?  Violate those rules and it’s a capital offense. Worst still, Althouse takes issue with the Hayes’ description of Baylor’s weapons management.  Hayes uses the word “brandish”, which Althouse deems an overly active verb:


“Brandished” is a heavy word and “brandished… at” connotes that he pointed the gun at people, which he did not.

I take issue with the word “connotes”,   “Pointed” means pointed. “Brandish” means to “shake or wave wildly” or “to exhibit in an ostentatious or aggressive manner.”  And “prune-faced school marm” means someone who finds the possibility that unruly, rule-breaking, vicious snow-ball-at-Hummer-throwing people will go unpunished unacceptable.  If only Althouse was there with a yardstick to put a stop to this in the first place.

But it isn’t merely the vicious throwing of snowballs that disturbs her. 


Why couldn’t people have spoken with him in a civil way and conveyed the assurance that there was no problem requiring police attention? Did they consider that there might be people elsewhere in the city, during the snow emergency, who actually would have benefited from help from a police officer who got delayed by unruly adults who thought snow suspended the rules and made it okay to throw objects at moving cars?

New rule: When confronted with angry cop waiving (but not brandishing) gun, talk nicely.  After all, they were “unruly”, and you can’t have that.

What’s curious about Althouse’s screed is that it never appears to dawn on her that there is but one reason to unholster a weapon, and that is to use it.  Would she have manufactured excuses for Det. Baylor’s actions had he pulled out his gun and started shooting?  Would one dead “unruly” adult have been fine with her?  What about a dozen?  Is she an advocate of the death penalty for unruliness?  For snowball throwing?  Where is the line where Ann Althouse would have these vicious snowball predators put to death?

Althouse found some of the words chanted by the crowd distasteful.  I did too.  But I wouldn’t advocate for, or excuse, their being shot for having chanted unpleasant words.  Sticks and stones, Ann.  Not even snowballs.  And let’s not forget that had Det. Baylor not stopped his Hummer, whether to break up unruly street thugs or because he was pissed off at someone hitting his shiny car with a snowball, and pulled out his gun, there would have been no chanting.  Independent intervening event, lawprof?

Finally, Althouse, explaining more rules about which many may be unaware, approvingly describes this near-riot as a “guerrilla snow ball fight” because it happened in the snowbound streets of D.C.


A fun snowball fight would be sited in a park of some kind, not in the middle of the street.
This sounds like the modern version of Marie Antoinette’s “let them eat cake,” with almost an audible sniffle as explains the difference between vicious snowball street predators and fun-loving bucolic park snowball fighters.  If only the organizers of this vicious snowball fight had chosen a more appropriate site, Althouse would have endorsed it as good, clean fun.  After all, no such thing as a fun snowball fight might happen spontaneously, as in wherever the people were at the moment it began. Only evil snowball predators bent on law-breaking destruction would engage in such vicious frivolity.

There’s nothing wrong with Ann Althouse deciding that had she been walking the streets of D.C. and came upon this snowball fight, she would have just kept walking.  It doesn’t have to meet with everyone’s idea of a good time, or a good choice.  But to suggest that a police detective pulling out a gun, with the obvious potential that it would discharge a projectile and strike someone, is beyond the pale.  We don’t execute people for engaging in snowball fights.  Even snowball fights that break Ann Althouse’s rules.

H/T Gary Carson at American Traditions.