As Christmas nears, wreaths of fragrant evergreens appear on doors, buildings, the grills of pick-up trucks. And for those whose lives were lost in the service of their country, wreaths are placed on their graves across the nation on December 12th in a program called Wreaths Across America. It’s a fitting honor to those who have given their lives for us, and a comfort to their families to know that they are not forgotten.
To the parents who grew old without a child, to the children who grew up without a parent, to everyone who lost a loved one or friend, the thoughts of their loss wasn’t limited to one day a year. In a season of joy, it’s only fitting that we remember as well. By placing a wreath on the graves of our war dead, we show that we honor their sacrifice.
However, there remained a glaring gap. Many of our war dead were lost to the sea, and there are no graves upon which to place wreaths.
A Coast Guard Auxiliarist and World War II veteran recognized this gap, and has begun a program to remember those men and women lost to the sea. The program, called Wreaths Over The Water, was begun at the Lake Worth Inlet Coast Guard Station in Florida. On December 12th, a ceremony was held to honor those without graves. A wreath was placed on the tide for each service, Army, Navy, Marines, Air Force, Civil Air Patrol, Coast Guard and Merchant Marine, each saluted as the wreath floated out to sea. Then one more wreath was laid upon the tide for those Missing in Action and Prisoners of War.
The politics of war bears no connection to the sacrifice of these men and women, or the loss of their families and friends. Having given their lives, the least we can do is remember them, offer comfort to their families and honor their sacrifice.
The hope is that this is the birth of a tradition that will find its way into the hearts and minds of Americans across the nation. This December 12th, there was but one ceremony held in Florida. Next year, let this ceremony be repeated across the nation. Those whose bodies were lost to the water are no less deserving of our thoughts.
Author Archives: SHG
The Sound of Magic
The case was remanded, however, because the radar evidence, from a Genesis gun that only provides a valid reading when stationary, was only one basis for the ticket. The officer, Ken Roth, had another.
“As it approached,” [Roth] testified, “I could hear the vehicle on the roadway, which based on my training and experience it is [sic] consistent with a vehicle that was in excess of the posted speed limit.” Roth said he had learned to “audibly determine if a vehicle was speeding” as part of his field training several years before, although he did not identify the sensei who taught him this skill or how, exactly, he was trained to do it.
On his second appeal, Freitag prevailed.
The weight of the evidence does not support the conclusion that Freitag was exceeding the posted speed limit, specifically because Patrolman Roth’s testimony that he audibly and visibly determined that Freitag was speeding is not credible. . . . It is simply incredible, in the absence of reliable scientific, technical, or other specialized information, to believe that one could hear an unidentified vehicle ‘speeding’ . . . . In addition, although he admitted that there was another vehicle on the roadway and traveling the same direction as Freitag’s at the time, the officer did not explain why he could hear and distinguish Freitag’s vehicle, while he could not even hear the other traffic. . . . A thorough review of the record compels this Court to conclude that the trier of fact lost its way and committed a manifest miscarriage of justice in convicting Freitag of speeding.So justice was done, and we all get to go home happy, right? Another ridiculous decision, eventually righted on appeal. Mind you, the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Judicial Circuit took ten pages to reverse, with one judge dissenting. The court remanded the case. The court did not hold that the officer’s testimony that he could discern that a car was speeding based upon sound is ridiculous, absurd or outrageous, but that the prosecution failed to provide adequate evidence of the officer’s training to qualify him as an expert in the sound of speeding.
The initial appeal, like the second, resulted in remand, despite the fact that the case was tried and the evidence was on the table. Roth had two claims in addition to the failed radar: That he could visibly tell the car was speeding by watching it in his rear view mirror as he was driving, without observing the vehicle in relation to a stationary object. A great deal is known about visual observation of a speeding vehicle. It can be done with training and practice, but for it to be accepted as evidence, it requires that the speed of a vehicle be measured against a stationary object. Otherwise, it’s invalid.
Roth’s second claim was the ability to hear that the car was speeding. There was another car on the road as well, but he claimed that he couldn’t hear that car. In addition, the car was behind him, traveling in the same direction.
So the radar evidence was out, the visual evidence didn’t have a chance, and the prosecution was left with the audibility claim. And on the first appeal, with all of this known, the case was remanded. At the second trial, the judge found the officer credible as to his ability to determine speed by sound and convicted. The appeals court again reversed, but again remanded to give the prosecution the opportunity to prove his expertise. This isn’t funny at all.
Implicit throughout this misbegotten case is the belief that police possess some sort of magic that the rest of the world lacks. Had Patrolman Roth given the name of his instructor and some details of his training in audible speed detection, there would be a very good chance that the conviction would have been upheld. There may still be such a chance on the next appeal.
There is no magic. Police officers do not possess magical powers that allow them to defy the rules of nature or physics. No one can tell the speed of a car by sound. No one. This doesn’t change because they did their police training at Hogwarts. This doesn’t change because an officer testifies that he had an instructor teach him magic, with dates and details sufficient to give his testimony the imprimatur of reliability.
The decision of the Court of Appeals should have been one sentence: Conviction reversed as unfounded and charge dismissed. Every claim is not entitled to be proven, and given a second or third chance to be proven. When the claim is facially impossible, that’s enough.
Jeff Gamso, being an Ohio appeal’s maven, notes that part of the problem with this case is that the defendant and his wife proffered hyperbolic testimony in his defense. They testified that guilt was impossible since Daniel Freitag never speeded. Such testimony doesn’t sit well with judges. Accordingly, Freitag seized defeat from the jaws of victory with his incredible testimony. But as Jeff points out, the burden is on the prosecution to prove guilt, not the defendant to prove innocence. While this concept eludes many, it shouldn’t present that much of an issue for a judge.
What distinguishes this case from those that are merely hysterically funny and ridiculous is that the police officers ability to do the impossible was taken seriously, not once but twice. Do the Ohio courts really believe in magic? How many other judges will blindly believe that police officers are capable of magic as well?
The Obligatory Caveat
Over at Reason, Radley Balko posts about the fight over Chicago’s “thick blue wall,” and how cops strive to achieve less accountability for their conduct. It’s an interesting post, well worth the read.
But in his final paragraph, Radley does what so many others do. What I sometimes do. What it seems like everybody does.
I’m sure the bulk of the officers in the Chicago Police Department are professional, courteous public servants. But that doesn’t let the department or the city off in its failure to discipline those who aren’t.
Is he “sure”? Does he believe it at all? Or is this the hat tip to the widespread myth that every instance of police misconduct is an isolated incident (aka One Bad Apple)? I mean, seriously, this is Radley Balko, David to the police industry’s Goliath. Dog blogger. Fearless libertarian. Chronicler of police abuse and misconduct. And he begins his concluding paragraph with the obligatory exculpatory caveat that “the bulk” of cops are “professional, courteous public servants?” Why? Why, Radley, oh why?
The answer, at least from where I sit, is that there is a fear that we are fostering fear and hate-mongering. To vilify all cops based upon a specific incidents seems wrong and overwrought. It’s not the purpose of exposing any particular situation of abuse or misconduct, and it may well be extremely unfair to others when we know that there are people who will both read about abuse and extrapolate that into an all or nothing proposition. Black and white is how most people see the world. Cops are good or bad, rather than people.
So the obligatory caveat is inserted into a post, the purpose of which is to slam the crap out of Chicago’s pervasive problems with abuse and misconduct by police. Of course, if the caveat is true, then there’s little point to the post, the impropriety being the isolated incident and the bulk being a good bunch of fellas, professional and courteous and all.
Still, it’s a problem in that trying to avoid one misimpression leads to another. The obligatory caveat suggests that there are two groups of cops, a large “good cop” one and a small “bad cop” one. This further leads to the mistaken belief that if we could just get rid of the small “bad cop” group, everything would be hunky dory. Not so.
There aren’t two discrete groups. There are cops and cop culture. The same police officer who will risk his life one day to save that of another, and the next day beat a black man for disrespecting him. So is he a hero or a villain? It’s all according to which day the video camera is on him. It’s all according to whether you are the person saved or the person beaten.
The problem is vertical rather than horizontal. Police officers are human beings, fraught with the same issues that confront everyone else. Overlaid is their cultural expectations, that people must respect their authority, that people must obey their commands, that no one understands a cop except a cop.
Sure, there are some bad apples, people who seek out the job to compensate for their low self-esteem and diminished manhood. These are, without a doubt, the most dangerous people to have a sidearm, as they are looking for ways to assert their power and will abuse it at any opportunity. If the obligatory caveat is about most cops not being “bad apples,” then I agree.
But even the good apples do bad things, whether it’s concealing the wrongdoing of their brethren, aiding a cop who’s abusing someone, and remaining silent when they know that others are committing crimes while hiding behind their shields. The potential for impropriety in policing is enormous, and I would doubt that any police officer, anyone, retires without having done wrong. They were just fortunate enough to have survived the job without being under the spotlight.
We need the police. There are real criminals out there who will do real harm to real people, and the police, for better or worse, are our protectors. They may fail at times, but they also succeed. We cannot paint them all as evil or bad or abusive, and pigeonhole them as the scourge of society. That would be unfair and, frankly, totally unhelpful. However, that doesn’t lead us to the conclusion that the bulk are cartoon character good guys. We need to smarten up and get beyond the obligatory caveat. But we aren’t there yet.
A Blogger Outs Himself; He’s a She
Call me old fashioned, but I believe that my word is my bond, something that you can trust.
While some may accept her gender-bias rationale and forgive James (whose real name remains a mystery), her trespasses, the point is the ease with which someone can become something they’re not on the internet, and the willingness of others, many others, to blindly accept it.As Chartrand explains over at Copyblogger, she created a male persona because as a woman, she faced so much gender bias that she couldn’t earn enough to support her family. But as a male, Chartrand found the financial success that eluded her as a female.
I’ve had many an argument here and elsewhere in the digital world about whether they know the people with whom they are interacting online. People tell me, absolutely insist to me, that they do know who they are talking to. A whole industry has grown to promote the use of the internet to “network” and create “trusted relationships” with others. They teach us to market to potential clients and other lawyers by creating trust. Trust is the predominant, and most abused, word in online marketing.
It’s hogwash. Utter, sheer,unadulterated hogwash.
Anyone can become anything they want to be online, whether in the blogosphere, on twitter, anywhere you go. A faked picture, some sweet sounding words, and a great humanitarian is born. You love him (or maybe it’s a her). You want to be his friend. You trust him. You haven’t got the slightest clue who you’re dealing with.
Ironically, the ones doing all the preaching about trust, the marketers, are the most notorious for faking their identities. One kid who lost his first job, a job that last a mere 8 months, touts himself as a highly experience corporate lawyer who wants to be paid to teach others how to be rainmaker. Teach? Make your own rain first. Another lectures lawyers about the power of twitter when he’s yet to put in his first day’s work as a lawyer.
Does that do it for you? Well, how about another who has a business teaching lawyers to blog for profit, but neglected to mention that he started the business after he was disbarred for sticking his fingers into a trust fund for minors. Or there’s the gal who is drumming up business on twitter for as long as she can between her plea and sentence for real estate fraud. Or another gal who claims to have given up her million dollar law practice, where she only had to work a few days a week, to become a 24/7 marketing guru at ridiculously high prices because she had a calling from God. You can’t make this stuff up, except online.
The reason these people come to the internet, the blawgosphere, twitter, is that they know that there are millions of people here who will trust them blindly. They can puff themselves, lie about themselves, create personas they would never get away with in real life. And lawyers, supposedly those who are knowledgeable and sufficiently cynical, eat this stuff up. They believe. They will argue that their belief is absolutely justified. They adore these charlatans. They attend their lectures and conferences. They pay these charlatans.
As an aside, I’ve been occasionally accused by some dopes of covertly blawging to promote myself, despite my anti-promotional public stance, because of the link on my sidebar to my website. On my website is my complete resume, with dates and details about who I am and what I’ve done. Every inch of it is completely verifiable. It’s not there for promotional purposes, but transparency. Anyone and everyone who is interested can learn anything they want to know about me. I am what I am, no better or worse.
Some of the loudest, most prominent people addressing the blawgosphere aren’t who they say they are. Not even close. James Chartrand is a woman. It doesn’t matter if you can understand why she chose to change her gender, the point being that she could, she did, and she became something she isn’t. Whether you want to see it as a white lie, it’s still a lie.
Is there somebody who wants to be your guru? Got a product or service to sell? Says they can teach you how to get rich and famous like them? Have tens of thousand of sycophants, all believing they hold the magic secret to success? Do they emphasize how it’s all about trust? Check under the hood. Look very closely. You may not like what you see.
Three Felonies A Day, The Blawg
Harvey Silverglate is a Boston criminal and civil rights lawyer of great renown, Not necessarily a household name, as with the show ponies who run when a TV station calls to pontificate for 30 seconds on cases they know nothing about, but the type of lawyer whose fame was amongst lawyers and earned in the courtroom. And he’s now joined the Volokh Conspiracy as a guest blogger.
Harvey wrote a book entitled Three Felonies a Day, How the Feds Target the Innocent. While I love the title and concept, I wasn’t as thrilled about the book itself. From what I can see of Harvey’s first post, however, his plan is to address the underlying concept of the book that was somehow lost in the war stories of peculiar instances of overcriminalization and prosecution. In other words, he’s now going to do what I wished he had done in his book.
The point is that ordinary people doing the ordinary things that ordinary people do will, based upon a structure of vague and shockingly comprehensive federal criminal laws, commit federal felonies on such a regular basis that we are all criminals, and that we are sitting ducks should the feds choose to come after us. It’s not that we’re evil, or the conduct we commit is deemed reprehensible by society and worthy of punishment. It’s that there are so many laws, and that the laws are so vague, that with minimal effort, the feds can indict and prosecute pretty much anyone they want.
I look forward to Harvey’s blawging about the idea. This is a subject that should both shock and appall every right-thinking person, coming on a generation of get-tough and get-tougher on crime politics that compelled legislators to quickly and roughly craft laws that will cover every situation that might conceivably arise. In the process, they’ve criminalize mere normal living. Yet most people haven’t got the slightest clue that it’s happened, or how pervasive the problem is. Indeed, few are concerned until it’s their turn in the dock, when it suddenly appears as if the whole world’s gone nuts.
Welcome to the blawgosphere, Harvey.
Hip Hop Interview
A call came in the other day from a New York hip hop radio station asking whether I would be interested in doing an interview plus a call in segment about criminal law. The caller explained to me that they were long on street cred and that their listeners, of which he told me there were many, were very interested in learning what to do when stopped by the cops.
Having done call in radio in the past, I wasn’t thrilled at the prospect. For many of the same reasons that Avvo Answers sucks, responses to caller’s questions tend to be at best worthless and at worst dangerous. I told the fellow that I’m not inclined to provide glib responses to half-baked questions that someone may rely upon one day to his detriment. What I said was, I don’t want any kid getting shot by a cop on the street because he listened to something I said and didn’t understand that the time to forcefully assert his rights wasn’t when he was staring down the barrel of a gun.
This was when the caller started getting excited, telling me what a great thing that would be to tell the audience. Maybe they could just do an interview without the call-in part.
Then the caller started explaining to me how their listeners had a tendency to be in need of a criminal defense lawyer. I was shocked to learn that his inner city demographic of young, hippy hoppers of color might occasionally need a criminal defense. His enticement, I explained, was of little interest to me. My days of representing kids for marijuana busts were long past. His listeners didn’t fit my client demographic, so there was little benefit to me in doing his interview.
However, the opportunity to provide some basic legal advice, such as exercising the right to remain silent and refusing to submit to the shield despite the trickery used to obtain consent for a search, interested me. I could offer these kids some critical advice about their rights, stuff that would actually be understandable in advance and perhaps save a few from making a huge mistake. This was something I would be happy to give if we could work out the details.
The caller was elated, and told me he would send me an email. It came within minutes of my hanging up, with an attachment. The email itself said nothing of consequence, so I opened the attachment. It was a price sheet.
I was stunned. At first, I thought he must have made a mistake, sent me the wrong attachment. But as I looked at the price sheet, I realized that it was no mistake. This radio station, broadcasting to young people on the streets of New York with very large speakers in the car, radio cranked up to bone crushing volume, expected me to pay them for the privilege of being interviewed. Not only would I provide content for their show, but they would get some cash in exchange for “advertising” my services.
I’ve done a lot of interviews in pretty much all media. Some paid me for the service. Some gave me a meal and sent a car to drive me around. Some gave me nothing. Some followed me through hallways, streets and elevators. But no one had ever asked me to pay before.
It really makes perfect sense. For those lawyers willing to buy adwords like marijuana or pot or the like, this was a perfect opportunity to buy their way onto the radio to reach the crowd they seek. In fact, it’s quite brilliant, and I’ve no doubt that many criminal defense lawyers would jump at the chance of buying some air time for themselves. The price, actually, was quite reasonable, if you’ve interested in paying for it.
But this most definitely wasn’t for me.
Historically, the media loves lawyers. They can always get one to show up and talk at the drop of a hat. Lawyers love to get their faces on the screen, their voices on the dial, their names in the paper. As if this makes them famous. It doesn’t, but they don’t care. They will drop everything to run in front of a camera. Lawyers are such media sluts, even when they know nothing about a case or are asked to speak to a subject about which they are wholly ignorant. Media sluts don’t are about such things as ignorance. It’s all about becoming famous.
Finally, a radio station has figured out a way to make a buck off it.
Sum It Up
Yesterday, the prosecutor in my case gave a textbook example of hide-the-ball opening argument. The first three minutes of his “argument” was merely a repetition of the complaining witnesses testimony with simple declarative sentences about what other witnesses said: a sort of TV Guide version of the trial condensed into uncritical and bland prose that were not intended to persuade. He spent the balance of his time merely reciting the law the judge was about to read. He ended with a simple request for a guilty verdict. The state failed in its opening to address any of the weaknesses in its case. It was not really argument at all.Before moving forward, bear in mind that in different jurisdictions, the sequence differs. Sometimes the prosecution goes first. Sometimes the defense. Sometimes the prosecution gets a second shot after the defense goes. The defense never gets a second shot.
My client and I were stunned. All the drama and stress of trial for this? My client and his witnesses and had just testified. There was no need to remind the jury of what they had just said. And the themes we hoped to argue were already set in the cross examination of the state’s witnesses and by our witnesses. If by arguing we really were going to do nothing more than give the state a final shot at what we had already laid before the jury, what, frankly, was the point? We picked a smart and self-confidence jury. We trust that group.
So we waived closing argument.
Trying a case requires a huge amount of hubris by definition. To stand in the well and address the jury takes both confidence and belief, in yourself and your case. For the brief period of time that we’re on trial, we believe completely in our cause. There will be plenty of time for critical self-analysis later. There’s no room for doubt in the well. But when Norm says that he liked his jury, “[w]e trust that group,” it’s hubris run amok.
Juries are not to be trusted. It’s not that the jurors aren’t trustworthy. It’s not that they are stupid or foolish or evil or hostile. It’s that we never (emphasis on never) know what’s really going on in their heads. We want to believe that we’ve picked a “smart and self-confident” jury, but we can’t tell. And if they’re self-confident, and it’s not clear what that means with regard to a jury, how do we know if those satisfied smiles mean they are for us or against us. Both smiles look the same.
Norm’s conceptual point is well-taken. If the last piece of good, strong, hard evidence did everything you want it to do, and the prosecutor’s summation didn’t lay a glove on it, then why go muck it up? More importantly, why give the prosecution another shot? He could always do better, even great, the next time. A basic rule of trying cases is stop when you’re ahead. Sure, you could always be more ahead if you make one more point or ask one more question, but that could just as easily be the one that blows the case wide open; your next step could be on a landmine.
At the same time, we can never assume that the jury got it. When we cross examine a witness, we pick them apart if we can. We do it fact by fact, point by point. We know what we’re trying to accomplish, but the jury doesn’t. They lack the overview and often can’t discern the significance of any particular answer until afterward. The problem is that our hard won point may mean absolutely nothing to the jury at the time, and it doesn’t register. We think we’ve scored. They don’t think about it at all.
Closing argument is when we put it all together. We add up all the points scored throughout the trial and, mustering every ounce of our persuasiveness, make it as clear as possible. If we’re lucky, they were listening and heard us win our points. When we raise it in argument, something clicks in their heads and they say to themselves, “oh yeah, I remember that.” Now it has meaning. Until summation, it was one of a great many loose sounds that floated through the courtroom, disconnected from the many others.
More often than not, the testimony that we rely upon consists of small pieces, sometimes merely inflection or a single word, that we hope will change the meaning of something critically important. When the word was spoken, what was the juror doing? Yawning (it happens a lot)? Wondering whether they fed the cat? Eying the hottie in seat 4? We don’t know. Our focus was on scoring the point. And even if we had an eye on the jury box, the indicia of recognition may just as well have reflected a satisfying decision about what to eat for lunch. We just don’t know.
Norm hasn’t gotten a verdict yet in his case, so the propriety of his decision to waive closing argument remains a mystery. He won’t read this post before his verdict comes in; he’s got more important things to do. But he may learn whether he made the right choice before Miller Time rolls around. I certainly hope he has no regrets. Every case is different and, maybe, the one he’s trying will be the one where no summation is the right call.
As for me, I’ve never waived closing argument and can’t imagine ever doing so. Let the prosecutor have two shots arguing against me. I only need one. But I would never give up that one shot to explain to the jury what they’ve just experienced.
Book Review: The Complete Idiot’s Guide to the Criminal Justice System by Robin Sax
Never has a book been more aptly titled than The Complete Idiot’s Guide to the Criminal Justice System. The problem is that you can’t tell from the title whether the complete idiot is meant to refer to the reader or the author. The book was written by Robin Sax:
[A]n Assistant District Attorney in Los Angeles County where she specializes in sex crimes against children. When she is not in court, she is on television as a legal analyst and commentator covering criminal cases and trials. Robin is also a lecturer at UCLA’s Paralegal Program, and an adjunct professor at Cal State.
California criminal defense lawyers may wish to make note of this bio when considering hiring any paralegals out of UCLA. There may be some re-training to do. This is the same Robin Sax who wrote Predators and Child Molesters: What Every Parent Needs to Know to Keep Kids Safe, which received a rave review from Nancy Grace.

When I received my (FCC take note) free review copy, I approached it with extreme curiosity. While there’s no doubt that the public could use an “idiot’s guide” to the criminal justice system, there was an obvious concern about one written by a prosecutor. Would it be a bit one-sided?
As it turns out, yes, yes it was. More than a bit. Note this perspective set forth in the introduction:
We’ll look over the shoulder of the police as they investigate a crime, find out why and when they get search and arrest warrants, and find out why they always give those Miranda warnings to a suspect…
After the defendant is charged, the trial begins. We’ll cover the actual trial process, from bail to jail.
Notice anything peculiar in how Sax sees the process? In most books, even those I don’t care for, I almost invariably find aspects worthy of some praise, at least for the thought provoked. This is possibly the first book I have ever read that, almost line by line, was wrong. But it is available on Kindle, if that makes a difference.
My approach to this book was to consider how one might explain a complex, often contradictory system, to people who want to, but don’t, really understand its mechanics. I tried not to read this book as a lawyer, but as a person who knew nothing of the system but wanted to learn. The problem is that anyone who reads this book will come away with no more knowledge about the system than when they started, but will in fact believe they know something when they have been grossly misled. Any layman reading this book will end up worse off than when they began. It’s that bad.
I could dedicate a great deal of time to explaining, almost line by line, chapter and verse, what’s wrong with this book. It’s just not worth that much of my time. As I am politically against burning books, I won’t suggest it. Bury it. Bury it deep. Oh what the heck, if ever a book needed burning, this is it.
Signs of Life in Maricopa
From Brian Tannebaum, there is an email circulating around the county:
On Monday, December 21, 2009, at 12:15 p.m., I would like to rally as many people as we can to the patio in front of the Central Court Building to protest the illegitimate, despicable, and cowardly actions of Andy Thomas and to demand that he be suspended from the State Bar of Arizona. Please circulate this email to as many people as you see fit.
At the same time, Chandler, Arizona, criminal defense lawyer Matt Brown has begun to see the light as well.
I doubt that anyone outside of Maricopa County has the power to make a difference. The feds have more firepower than Sheriff Joe, but what makes people think the DOJ is willing to do anything meaningful about it? I’d love to see a national opinion poll on what Sheriff Joe is doing. The DOJ can start as many hotlines as it wants, but it’ll just incite people to write things like this and this. It’ll rally the troops behind Sheriff Joe.
Matt wrote that I’ve started losing interest in Maricopa County. That’s not quite the case. Talk is cheap, and all the grandiose talk about light shining and injustice and Kafkaesque-ity either serves a purpose or is the murder of words to no end. What I’ve lost interest in doing is keeping up the good fight when none of the Maricopa players was willing to do anything to help themselves.
But as Windypundit notes,
The good news is that Joe Arpaio will probably not be Sheriff of Maricopa County for much longer. The bad news is that’s because he’s currently leading the polls for the Arizona Governor’s race.If Crazy Joe was to run for governor of Arizona, polls show that he would beat the likely Democratic candidate by 12%, a huge mandate. My fellow blawgers may be full of their self-importance about shining lights and all, and how their inspirational words must continue to sing throughout the land, but I’m a bit more practical.
The good people of Arizona love Crazy Joe and his usurpation of basic rights and law; they think he’s the only who’s got it right. They think the rest of us are nuts, and the noise we’re making is foolish. If this isn’t met with a substantive response, rather than another dozen blawg posts from lawyers in the comfort of far off places watching Maricopa County through a telescope, then the voters are right. We are nuts.
My attempt to recognize, and explain, the limitations of what we in the blawgosphere are doing fell on deaf ears. Not a single comment reflects an understanding of the point, some nipping at tangents about newspapers writing about Crazy Joe and others inflexibly insisting that we, blawgers, must continue because that’s all there is. Here’s the deal. Writing about Maricopa County isn’t a way to keep blood circulating through blawgs, or gain readers, or generate cross-links and comments. It’s about Maricopa County. There’s real bad stuff happening down there. If you saw a child attacked, would you jump in to stop it or write about it? The former accomplished something. The latter, not so much.
Up to now, there’s a been great deal written about Crazy Joe and Maricopa. But there has been no massive outcry across the nation for the federal government to step in and restore the rule of law, the honor of the Constitution, the assault on the judiciary and the end of Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s reign of terror. The feds haven’t taken up arms. The newspapers aren’t interested (and please don’t comment about a meaningless “balanced” article; it changes absolutely nothing) in calling for change. The government officials charged with keeping “warlords” like Crazy Joe in check have remained under their desks, hiding from him.
It’s only been a bunch of blawgers patting each other on the back for being he-men calling out Crazy Joe from a safe distance. I’m as inclined to wraps myself in the mantle of righteousness for my efforts as the rest of the blawgers, but I also try to remember that real people have live with what is happening on the street. Our words may bring some comfort, but they need more.
Having digressed, I return to the point of this post. The lawyers of Maricopa County have chosen to take a huge risk by calling for a rally against Crazy Joe’s henchman, Andy Thomas. It may not seem like a huge risk to those unaware of Arpaio’s inclination to do his enemies harm, coupled with his near absolute power to achieve whatever he wants, but the lawyers in Maricopa are surely aware of what it means to confront Joe (even if via Thomas) directly. They have finally decided that they’ve had enough of his subversion of law and are prepared to do something to take charge of their lives and their court system.
To the extent that the support of the blawgosphere has helped to empower the local lawyers, wonderful. But what they are starting is real, not mere words. They are putting their butts on the line, and that’s something worthy of real support. Whether it’s going to work, or the best tactic, isn’t necessarily important at the moment. It would seem that far more will be needed, but it has to start with something. And that something must be real, and this rally is real.
It’s unlikely that the voters of Maricopa County, or the entire state, will have a sudden epiphany and realize that Crazy Joe isn’t just a folk hero. But the judges, the other elected officials, the Feds know better. They know very well that Crazy Joe has become a law unto himself, and they know exactly why this can’t be permitted to happen, even if the voters love his shenanigans. They all learned the phrase “tyranny of the majority” in school, and if they had the guts, they would join the rally with the lawyers of Maricopa County.
I won’t physically be in the plaza in front of the County Courthouse of Maricopa County on December 21, but I will be there in spirit. I applaud the lawyers who show, willing to take the chance to regain control of their world. A small step, perhaps, but real.
Tiger’s Break
“I am deeply aware of the disappointment and hurt that my infidelity has caused to so many people, most of all my wife and children. I want to say again to everyone that I am profoundly sorry and that I ask forgiveness. It may not be possible to repair the damage I’ve done, but I want to do my best to try.Tiger is one heck of a golfer. How he is as a husband isn’t any of my business. Forget the “brand”. Play golf.
I would like to ask everyone, including my fans, the good people at my foundation, business partners, the PGA Tour, and my fellow competitors, for their understanding. What’s most important now is that my family has the time, privacy, and safe haven we will need for personal healing.
After much soul searching, I have decided to take an indefinite break from professional golf. I need to focus my attention on being a better husband, father, and person.
Again, I ask for privacy for my family and I am especially grateful for all those who have offered compassion and concern during this difficult period.”
