Author Archives: SHG

In Judgment of a 12 Year Old

Twelve years of age is about the time when parents believe a child is old enough to care for another child.  That’s when they feel sufficiently comfortable going out in the evenings, with the 12 year old in charge.  That’s when the telephone calls come, asking if the 12 year old can babysit.  The window of opportunity is small, as the social life of a teenager soon leaves them unavailable, and leaves parents forced to parent on their own.

But the convenience of having a little man or woman available to care for a younger child is not without its limitations, and those limitations can be significant.  When Brittiany Young left her 5 week old daughter, Millan, with her 12 year old cousin in a car while she went into Target to shop, the results were devastating.

On July 4, the boy was left alone in the car with the baby while her mother, Brittiany Young of Kennesaw, shopped in a Target store. The mother returned to the car 18 minutes later to find her baby limp and unresponsive.  The baby died a day later of blunt force trauma, according to an autopsy.

Prosecutors said the boy shook the infant and slammed her head against a hard surface.

It appears that Millan started crying after his mother left, and the 12 year old, who was unnamed, didn’t know what to do about it.


“He was scared and didn’t know what to do so he tried everything he could to get the baby to stop crying. He didn’t know what to do and I don’t expect him to know what to do,” the judge said. “In order to get the baby to get quiet, he committed batteries against this baby.”

So the boy was tried for the murder of his 5 week old cousin.  To the extent one can find anything that can be called “fortunate” about this case, it was tried before a judge who demonstrated enormous understanding.


“What I found is that you did some things wrong,”Cobb County Juvenile Court Judge Gregory Poole explained to the boy Friday. “I haven’t found you did something as bad as they say you did.”

The boy was acquitted of the murder, but convicted of two counts of misdemeanor battery.


The judge said his ruling became clear when he saw the tiny pink onesie the baby was wearing when she was injured. That’s when he realized just how delicate and small the baby was. An active child like the boy could have easily harmed the baby just by not being careful, he said.
It’s one thing to have a 12 year old babysit a 5 year old.  But a 5 week old infant?  Parents have no clue what to do with an infant when they cry.  How in the world would a 12 year old?  Indeed, that the scenario existed for this tragedy to happen demonstrates that poor judgment of the baby’s mother, perhaps even bordering on criminal though it’s difficult to be to harsh on a mother whose 5 week old was lost.  Bad judgment happens, both to mothers and 12 year olds.  I can’t even bring myself to make a joke about whether Target was having a sale.

Why it was necessary to put a 12 year old on trial for what clearly was not a criminal homicide, especially in a state known for its affinity for treating children like unrepentant monsters, merely adds to the demonstration of bad judgment on the part of adults.  Thankfully, there was one person, Judge Gregory Poole, who showed the maturity of judgment, the depth of understanding, to avoid turning one tragedy into two. 

Are We Mere Blawgers?

I wrote that it was getting tedious posting about the daily travails of Maricopa County when there was nothing, from where I sit, coming of it from the locals.  Mark Bennett took me to task,


The mainstream media are paying no attention, and everybody from the voters to the judges in Maricopa County seems to be either effete or complicit. Why should guys like Scott spend any more time or bandwidth on Maricopa County? Because tyranny must be stopped somewhere, and it thrives in darkness.
Those are strong words.  Inspiring words.  But are they inspiring only to us blawgers?  What about the Phoenicians (as Jeff Gamso calls them).  Had anybody in Maricopa County been sufficiently inspired yet?  I know they’ve been outraged, but enough to put themselves at risk and do something about it?

Here’s my problem.  Certainly the antics of Sheriff Joe Arpaio needed a darn good airing, and I’ve tried to be helpful in that respect.  I think I have.  But there will come a time when the entire blawgosphere will be unable to shine that light on every nook and cranny of Maricopa County, and Crazy Joe’s antics reflect nothing if not a vigorous strategy to win at all costs.  He can keep a swarm of blawgers busy for hours on end, every day.  He knows we’ll eventually tire, or find a shinier object in the blawgosphere to watch.  He can wait.  You don’t keep power like this for a generation without patience and tenacity.

What then?  Life in Maricopa County goes on as it always has, with Crazy Joe in charge and everyone else hiding under their desks or engrafting themselves to his backside to bask in the shadow of power.  Nothing has been accomplished. Nobody saved.  Aren’t we special? 

The problem, as I see it, is that the blawgosphere has a certain amount of power to focus our bright light on impropriety, but it is hardly omnipotent.  We can help, but only so far.  Ultimately, it’s the people on the ground who have to take over the fight. both because they are the only ones positioned for the real battles that must be won, and because this is their world.  If they lack sufficient interest, or sufficient guts, to fight their own battles, our little ray of sunshine isn’t going to accomplish much.

Contrary to Bennett’s assumption, I had no intention of leaving Maricopa completed behind.  This was not a choice between enable or abandon.  It was, however, a decision to stop doing the blow by blow, the color commentary, on every daily twitch out of Crazy Joe.   Maricopa County will not be my full time beat, both because there are other things in the world that interest me and that it’s time for the locals to pick up the slack.  Of course I would still post about the craziness from time to time, and if there was an incident like Stoddard going way over the top, I would likely be inclined to go way over the top on my end as well.

But the strong, inspiring words by my good buddy Bennett made me think of something else as well.  Blawgers are far more insular than many readers realize.  We get to know each other, we communicate amongst ourselves, we come to take the things that happen here as pretty real.  Maybe too real.  Maybe when we talk to each other, we lose perspective about the weight we carry, the importance of what we do in the blawgosphere.  Maybe Sheriff Joe Arpaio couldn’t care less what we blawgers have to say about him.  Maybe nobody in Maricopa County cares.  We may be shining a light, but is anybody really looking?

For all the efforts of the blawgosphere, and Bennett has provided a good list of posts about Sheriff Joe and Maricopa, and certainly Nick Martin at Heat City has done more than his share to keep everyone informed, we have failed to make the mainstream media take real notice.  Did you read the editorial in the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal about Maricopa County?  Neither did I.

Perhaps we give ourselves more credit than we deserve.  I want to believe that the thought the comes from the blawgosphere has sufficient merit to persuade real people to do real things, but maybe it does nothing more than offer a cathartic outlet for the very small percentage of humanity that bothers to read it and actually cares.  I don’t think Crazy Joe loses sleep at night worrying about what some blawger is going to write about him.  We might be a thorn in his side, but not a knife in his heart.

I think the best we can hope for is that some of Arpaio’s adversaries know there are people behind them across the nation, and hopefully that will give them the strength and support they need to fight back.  If we can do that much, then the blawgosphere has a good reason to exist.  That’s a lot to accomplish by a bunch of distant lawyers tapping at keyboards.

Are we mere blawgers?  Yes.  We are mere blawgers.  Let’s not forget that, both for its strengths as well as its limitations.

Who Hates Social Media Snake Oil Salesmen?

When Justinian Lane wrote his screed against the omnipresent lawyers who, facing hunger and eviction, recreated themselves as social media experts, the newest, coolest phrase in the online lexicon became “social media snake oil salesmen.” 


Tonight, I reached my level of tolerance for snake oil salesmen who bill themselves as social media experts for lawyers. 

If a guy with a J.D. is trying to make his or her money from teaching other lawyers about social media, you can be sure that he or she is a failure as a lawyer.  Lawyers who are good at rainmaking have one thing in common, no matter whether they do their rain dance for plaintiff or defense firms: They’re rich.  They don’t try and teach others how to be rainmakers because (a) they don’t want the competition, and (b) they don’t need the money.

In the past couple of days, it’s been a meme running through the bowels of the blog and twittersphere.  Just yesterday, a post emerged at , a blog that has never promoted an idea that couldn’t be better captured on twitter with characters to spare, that spread like wildfire, entitled One Size Fits All Snake Oil Targets Lawyers.


2010 Prediction: Droves of people are going to try to sell legal professionals their product, gimmick, “next best thing”, social media strategy, eBook, webinar, and who knows what. Anything for a quick buck.

Those of us who have been online for awhile, and you know who you are, have the responsibility to protect other legal professionals from these people.
This defender of the vulnerable lawyer is Rex Gradeless, an unemployed 2009 law school grad who, as described by Avvo, is recognized due to “the Paris Hilton effect: he’s famous for being famous.”  His sole achievement is amassing more followers on twitter than any other lawyer (or lawyer to be, as the case may be).  Despite the fact that it hasn’t paid off for him, he nonetheless gives lectures to lawyers about the wonders of social media and how to be as famous as him. 

I am in complete agreement with Rex.  Those of us who are aware of the shenanigans being played on the unsuspecting have a duty to protect others from “these people.”  But there’s a problem.  When we do, we get our butts handed to us for beating up on them.  Our critics come from two primary sources, the brotherhood of snake oil salesmen, the mutual protection society that covers up each other’s lies, scams and overt silliness in the flowery yet meaningless language of the trade, and those who pay (or at least pay heed) for these snake oil salesmen and need to prove that they aren’t the dumbest people on the internets.

You can’t have it both ways.  Either those of us who, like Rex, have been online for awhile have a responsibility to call out the charlatans or not.  You want to know who’s blowing smoke?  We know.  We know who’s puffing their credentials, who’s outright lying, whose stories are suspect and whose are total nonsense.  But to tell you, we’ve got to hurt some feelings.  There’s just no nice way to call a liar a liar.

My tenure online has brought me plenty of criticism because of my refusal to mince words.  I call them as I see them, and I call them in language that (I believe) leaves little doubt as to what my point is.  This gives rise to a wealth of criticism about my being too harsh on others.  The braintrust at the ABA calls my posts “rants”, while their counterparts at Avvo thinks I’m an “abrasive ass.”  I find the latter offensive, only because I don’t use that kind of language in my posts, and I’m quite disappointed that Josh King, Avvo’s GC, was incapable of coming up with a way to make his point without using an epithet.  But their point is quite true, compared with the many tepid, unclear, wussy posts that permeate the blawgosphere, mine tend to be more forceful.  I’ll take the heat for it and have no plans on watering down what I write.

So Justinian Lane and Rex Gradeless are right.  So is Brian Tannebaum, described by Avvo as “unattractive yet insipid.”  But if anybody really wants to know the truth about your good buddies who are out there offering to teach you how to make millions from blogging and twitting, then be prepared for things to get ugly.  There’s just no other way to learn the truth other than to learn the truth.

And I’ll start right here.  Hey Rex.  Look in the mirror, kid.  The line for beating me up starts on the right.

Do Drug Dealers Have The Right To Defend Themselves?

From Eugene Volokh, a difficult question arises of whether a drug dealer, during a deal gone wrong, has the right to defend himself by killing the other party to the criminal transaction.  The story comes from the Baton Rouge Advocate :



Anthony Manzella … and Andrew Robertson … were on one side of an alleged drug deal … and … Johnny Barnes … was on the other side.

 

Barnes’ companion, Jeral Wayne Matthews Jr. … allegedly struck Manzella[] in the head with a rifle butt before the deal was finished, and Manzella shot and killed Matthews with a .40-caliber handgun, Clinton police said in July….


Twentieth Judicial District Attorney Sam D’Aquilla said he interprets a section of the law dealing with justifiable homicide to preclude self-defense in drug deals that result in a homicide.
Eugene deals with the case from a statutory perspective, addressing his disagreement with the prosecution’s position that the statute precludes a drug dealer from invoking justifiable homicide, and offers an excellent argument that the statutory limitation doesn’t apply in the way that the prosecution contends.

But for those of us in common law jurisdictions, the question remains as to how this should play out.  The argument that the right to keep and bear arms is based upon a natural right to defend oneself against others.  Does this change if the defense happens in the course of a drug deal or other criminal transaction?

One easy answer is that it’s better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6.  This, of course, answers nothing, since the question assumes that the person defended himself, the other person died, and the issue is whether this is a murder or justifiable homicide.

On the one hand, when a person engages in criminal conduct, the foreseeability of violence occurring is a problem.  It’s hardly the same as an ordinary bloke walking down the street, attacked by a mugger and pulling out his Glock and blowing the mugger’s head off.  This person is on the front page the next day as a hero. 

But the drug dealer killing the drug buyer is both unlikely to win any awards and may have a very difficult time claiming that he was an innocent bystander to violence.  It’s arguably the nature of the beast, at least at higher level drug deals.  Indeed, many arguments have been made against a defendant charged with possession of a weapon with intent to use it that the weapon was there solely for defensive reasons, and that its possessor had no intention to use it affirmatively against anyone.  In other words, drug deals are dangerous business, and a person needs to protect himself.

On the other hand, when one party to a drug deal threatens deadly force against another, does that person lose his natural, and constitutional, right to live?  Would the law have him suffer a bullet to the head rather than defend himself?  No matter how evil a criminal the person may be, does he not maintain his human right to defend himself from death at all times?

It seems to me that the law must distinguish between the underlying crime and the homicide, separating the rights and wrong of the two rather than bunching them together to determine whether defense is justifiable.  Obviously, no one is going to let themselves be killed regardless of what the law says about it, taking comfort in the fact that they didn’t commit a second crime, even if they had to die to prove it. 

While the drug dealer remains criminally liable for the drug deal, he would be entitled under the law to defend himself from an aggressor despite the fact that the killing occurred during the course of a crime, bearing in mind that this is expressly for a killing in self-defense, as opposed to a felony-murder.  If the law was to do otherwise, it would essentially mandate that a person be required to allow himself to be murdered or be liable for murder.  That’s an absurd choice.

While few people will be particularly sympathetic to the drug dealer who kills in self-defense, the difference between someone dealing drugs and committing murder remains huge, in concept if not always in sentence.  No matter what one thinks of drug dealers, however, the law should never be construed to require someone to die to avoid criminal liability.  The right to defend oneself is perhaps the most fundamental right we possess.  No law should take it away.



Do They Know They’re Being Used?

A few days ago, a solicitation from Findlaw (“a division of West”) came across the old email with a sufficiently interesting subject line to make me look before deletion.  “NYC #1 for marijuana arrests at 39,700 last year alone,” it said.  Maybe it was a study of over-reaching criminalization? It couldn’t hurt to look.

Boy, was I wrong. 



I am a local marketing consultant here in Midtown and I work locally with other criminal defense lawyers like you to find new clients and qualified cases. I have reviewed your website and I wanted to point out a couple of important facts since 65% of people now start their search for a NYC lawyer online (NYSBA Journal ’09):


–          New York City is the #1 city for marijuana arrests at 39,700 last year alone (Source: http://legalseo.blogspot.com/)


–          New York is a top five city for searches online for criminal lawyers, DWI, and Police Brutality (Source: Google Trends)


I help criminal defense attorneys like you who have websites to improve your visibility online to help capture these searches and new cases as well as support your referral clients.


Imagine, a ton of nickel and dime arrests, all there for the picking, if only I would “improve my visibility” by capturing searches.  Nothing special.  I get a dozen of these solicitations a day, like pretty much everybody else in the business.  But the next line changed everything.


We have successfully done this for other attorneys in NYC including: Gearld [sic] Lefcourt, John Marks, Jay Goldberg, Ryan Blanch, Gerald Allen, and many others and I would like to help you to.

Lefcourt, Marks, Goldberg? These are names of some real lawyers, enough so to offset a joke like Ryan Blanch.  So these guys are now SEO spamming Google to get their hands on the marijuana market?  Well, that’s got to be pretty embarrassing.

From what I can see, these guys went to Findlaw to do their websites for them.  Do they know that this Findlaw marketing rep is using their names to solicit business?  Do they know that they are being held out as keyword spammers?  Do they know that they are being used as the poster boys for the massive marijuana trade in New York City?

I tend to think that neither Lefcourt, Marks nor Goldberg thought that they were going to become marketing fodder for Findlaw (“a division of West”) when they signed up for websites.  I doubt that they know that some marketer was going to use them as examples of “success stories” in the wide world of marijuana defense lawyer searching to try to get others, like me, to sign up too.  I think they should know what Findlaw (“a division of West”) is doing with their names and reputations.

Guys, if you are that hungry for business, I would have been happy to send some marijuana cases your way.  Next time, just give me a call.  Don’t make me have to find out about your unfortunate situation from some marketer.

No One Gets A 35 Year Do-Over

A press release was issued yesterday announcing that Innocence Project of Florida will stand at the North Door of the Polk County, Florida, courthouse to release news that DNA test results in the case of Jimmy Bain proves his innocence.  Great news?  Well, sure, it’s always great to correct a wrongful conviction.

But Jimmy Bain has already spent 35 years in prison,  convicted of a crime that occurred in 1974, when he was only 18 years old.


On March 4, 1974, the boy was sleeping in a queen-sized bed between his sisters, 10 and 11, when a man crawled through an open window and quietly lifted him out of bed.

The boy didn’t wake up when the man carried him out the door and through an orange grove to a baseball diamond in an open field. He didn’t wake up till the man laid him in the dust and yelled at him to pull down his pants.

Later, the boy told police the man said he thought he was a girl, because his hair was pin-curled with bobby pins.

“He made me turn over,” the boy said.

The 9 year old boy described the man as having “bushy sideburns” and that he said his name was Jim.  The boy’s father was the assistant principal, and knew Jimmy Bain, who had bushy sideburns and rode around on a motorcycle.  Back then, everybody had bushy sideburns, just as kids today have that dumb-looking cowlick in the front of their hair.  It was the style.  Just as the style for the establishment was to assume that kids who rode motorcycles were criminals.

There was semen found in the boy’s underpants that came from someone with blood type B.  Jimmy Bain had blood type AB.  No matter.



At trial, an FBI analyst testified that the semen on the underpants came from a person with blood group B. Bain’s blood group is AB, but the analyst said Bain could not be ruled out as the person who deposited the semen. A defense expert testified that because Bain’s blood group was AB with a strong A factor it ruled him out as a suspect.

Bain, who had no previous criminal record, provided an alibi. He and his sister told police they were at home watching TV together at the time the boy disappeared. The jury convicted him anyway.
Kids who rode motorcycles weren’t to be trusted. They were bad seeds.  They got what they deserved.  That was how people thought back then.  As those of us who rode the occasional motorcycle in 1974 know, we went on to shave off our bushy sideburns and become lawyers, doctors and even assistant principals.  But not Jimmy Bain.  He’s been in prison all that time.

And the person who raped a 9 year old boy?  Who knows.

There will be the usual dance steps following today’s announcement, with the state retesting, verifying, then deciding whether to spend the next year or two fighting the merit of DNA testing, all before Jimmy Bain takes a breath of free air.  If and when Jimmy Bain is released, he will spend a few years trying to get some compensation from the state for his 35+ years in prison.  It will almost be the same as having those 35 years of his life back.

And the victim, the boy who is now 45 years old, who fell apart after his time in the Marines, ended up in the same prison as Jimmy Bain in 2006.  He never got over the rape.  And now he learns that nothing is certain.  He’ll never get those years back either.

As Maricopa Turns: The Insurrection

Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas didn’t start out as an appendage firmly attached to Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s butt.  As a little boy, he dreamed of being a fireman, or maybe a plumber (for the White House perhaps?).  But like any lawyer with aspirations of power and influence, he understood the need to figure out who was the toughest hombre and, barnacle-like, clamp on.  That hombre Was Sheriff Joe Arpaio, the man who can be crazy as he wannabe.

After Sheriff Joe’s son by adoption, Adam Stoddard, sacrificed himself for the good of the office, some naive folks thought the battle was over.  It wasn’t, of course.  It was just beginning, as the Sheriff was about to start his turn.  Like the old joke about which body part is in charge, Arpaio was determined to be the sphincter.  And so his plan unfolded.

First there was the sick-out. Then the vigils. The press releases, the ransom demand (complete with hostages) and the refusal to assign officers to Lisa Flores’ courtroom followed.  (Too many links here and elsewhere to cover.) It all worked as expected, clogging up the system and showing them all who owns the system.  As one would expect, they all took it, doing nothing to further antagonize the Big Guy lest he get even meaner.  Joe Arpaio stared at them, and they averted their eyes.  Cowards come in all manner of dress, whether public official business suits or black robes.

The latest, though, is more brazen than before, as it challenges not only the foes of Crazy Joe but every citizen of Maricopa, and even those who want to pretend that they hold the power of the federal government in their sweaty clenched fist, to reveal themselves as sheer, utter, powerless pretenders.  The sheer audacity of Arpaio’s absurdity makes this latest ploy a “put up or shut up” moment.  If he gets away with this one, he can get away with anything.

Sheriff Joe Arpaio, with the aid and comfort of his butt-boil, Andrew Thomas, has charged his latest nemesis, Judge Gary “Mr. Contempt” Donahoe, in a criminal indictment with three felony counts of bribery, obstruction of justice and hindering prosecution.  Matt Brown at Chandler Criminal Defense has uploaded the paperwork.  And then Sheriff Joe called a press conference, to make sure that all the people hiding under their desks in the hope that Arpaio doesn’t notice them will be aware of his mighty power.

But maybe, just maybe, Judge Donahoe was a bad boy, and it’s merely coincidental that his indictment comes immediately on the heels of his issuing a decision against young Stoddard that angered his surrogate daddy, Sheriff Joe?  From the Phoenix New Times :

Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas this afternoon struggled to explain his decision to charge the county’s presiding criminal court judge, Gary Donahoe, with three felony counts — including bribery, obstructing a criminal investigation, and hindering prosecution.

But Thomas couldn’t offer any evidence to the assembled media scrum that Donahoe actually had accepted a bribe of any sort. Instead, he and Sheriff Joe Arpaio (who stood next to Thomas at the lectern) offered the same vague allegations they have made for nearly a year regarding the county’s planned court tower, currently under construction.

In fact, the county attorney said no evidence exists that the veteran judge personally has received anything in the way of a personal financial benefit during the flap over the $347 million construction project

Arizona has a “very broad” definition of bribery, Thomas said in response to requests for specificity.


Not exactly crackerjack summation material, but then Thomas had to do the best he could when he was shooting blanks.  He expected, apparently, the compliant and fearful Maricopa press corp to pick up the slack.

He later told the gaggle, “If I’m not explaining this well, I hope you’ll help me.”

Say what?

“In fairness,” Thomas said, after enduring increasingly pointed questions, “I admit this is a hard thing to believe.”

Are you persuaded yet?  Neither was Arpaio, apparently, who added his own deep thoughts.


Here’s how a somber Arpaio explained his side of things: “Sometimes, you have to do what you have to do.”
And that, for better or worse, sums up life in Maricopa County.  Right, Boss?

Since Matt Brown wrote about the arrest of criminal defense lawyer Dave DeCosta, invoking the misguided wrath of the locals, two things have become painfully clear to those of us whose eyes aren’t constantly focused on Maricopa County, Arizona.  The first is that Sheriff Joe Arpaio is, without a doubt, completely and utterly out of control, perhaps one of the most dangerous threats to law, order and sanity, in the nation.  He’s not just out of control, but he’s out of control with an army behind him. 

The second thing is that there is the apparatus of government, the one that we’re supposed to honor and obey, that has proven itself both incapable of mustering the strength, the bravery, to confront this lunatic and shut him down.  And by apparatus, I mean the entirety, from the populace that elects people to the people elected, whether robed or suited, to the “officers of the court” who feed off the system.  But I don’t stop there.  There are state officials, federal officials, all of whom play a role in putting down insurrection in their midst.  And make no mistake about it, when a county sheriff seizes control, it is an insurrection.

Arpaio has crowned himself King, with Thomas as his jester.  There is only one way to rid oneself of the King.  The rest of the government, and the people for whom it exists, have shown that they lack the fortitude to do, as Sheriff Joe said, what they have to do.  There’s only one set of balls in Maricopa County, and Joe Arpaio owns them.

It’s grown tedious hearing about, and writing about, the doings of Crazy Joe in Maricopa.  No doubt he has a few more bullets in his gun that will soon whistle through the air.  If there’s no one, from the Governor to the United States Attorney to the indicted Chairman of the Board of Supervisors to the judges to the lawyers to the citizens, with the guts to take him on, then why waste more time or bandwidth on Joe Arpaio? 

We can either officially declare Sheriff Joe Arpaio the King of Maricopa, or his subjects can rise up against him, take a chance, maybe even take a bullet, and put an end to his reign.  If the locals are unwilling to stand up, to take a risk (as if it was a risk, since they are getting hammered anyway), and do something for themselves, then injustice, corruption and impropriety in Maricopa will be just too banal for further discussion. 

There are plenty of people in Arizona with the power and authority to take on Sheriff Joe Arpaio.  The absurd Gary Donahoe indictment, if nothing before it, is a clarion call.  Either do something to protect your own house from insurrection, or accept the fact that you are a subject of the King.  Maybe, like Andrew Thomas, you can offer an oath of fealty and serve in his court.

Is Twitter Really A Conversation?

Whenever a new technology gets some traction, its advocates attribute all manner of benefits.  Twitter, we’re told, can find clients for your dying law practice.  Twitter can make you trustworthy.  Twitter can cure cancer.  So I’m anticipating a bit, So what? You think it can’t happen?

After I twitted yesterday that lawyers ought to use their real names on twitter rather than marketing names, or as Mike called it, “branding”, I received a number of replies from other twitterers disagreeing.  Naturally, they were people who didn’t twit under the real names.  One point made was that when someone else owns your name (i.e., @JohnSmith), what are you supposed to do?  The answer seemed obvious enough, to come up with some variation that provides at least a clue, rather than adopt the twitter name @HungryDesperatePersonalInjuryLawyer.

But one response was particularly interesting, “It’s abt the convo, so follow the tweets.”  Ignore the abbreviations, necessitated by twitter’s 140 character limitations.  Is twitter a conversation?

Twitter lovers will insist it is.  I think it can be, but mostly isn’t.  If one twits with people you know, then it might fall within the parameters of a conversation, defining conversation that a substantive communication between two or more people.  Little of what’s twitted is substantive.  But more importantly, who knows who you are twitting with? 

The person who raised the conversation point would appear to be a lawyer, but is she?  Is she even a she?  If she is a lawyer (and a she), is she an old lawyer like me, or a kid lawyer.  How do I make a point with her without knowing her frame of reference? 

Most of communication comes from non-verbal cues.  We can see who we talk to, what they look like, how they react to our statements.  A joke is recognized as a joke by tone of voice.  The meaning of statements change based on emphasis.  None of this happens on twitter.  It can be quite sterile, and often leads to people misinterpreting the meaning of twits. 

Even between people who know each other fairly well from other venues, twitter misunderstandings occur.  When the twits are between people who have no clue who the other is, it’s almost inevitable.  When one of the ersatz twitterers is a total fraud, and there are many (and I mean many) people who pretend to be something they’re not (whether lawyer, social media expert or human being) on twitter, what then?

It seems that conversations can happen on twitter like anywhere else, but only if the parties to the conversation have some working advance knowledge of who they are twitting to and, more than likely, some established relationship.  Sure, you can have some fun quips with someone who twits with you out of the blue, but that’s no conversation.  For those who promote the use of twitter to “establish trust,” they’re just kidding themselves.  How in the world can you come to trust someone about whom you know nothing more than you like his twits?  If that’s your idea of trust, then you need to beat the agoraphobia. 

I’ve come to enjoy twitter, though it hasn’t quite replaced all human contact.  But for those who believe that this is “real”, and that they are “engaging” with people they don’t know, “building relationships” by blindly following others and “connecting” with people who twit under newly created brand names, you really need to get out more.  These aren’t “conversations”, but a pale substitute for a real life.

As for who you are on twitter, that’s entirely up to you.  But if you want any chance of having a “relationship” with me, use your real name.  At least then there’s a chance that you will treated like a real person.

Honest Services Somersaults

While the image of Justice Antonin Scalia “turning somersaults” is intriguing, it certainly seems that the Supremes are united in their view that “honest services fraud” is an incurably vague catch-all, after yesterday’s oral argument in Black v. U.S.  and Weyhrauch v. US.  Bummer. 

SCOTUSBlog provides an excellent discussion of the arguments made, and the judge’s reactions and questions, so there’s no need to repeat them here.  But the point is well made:



The arguments in Black and Weyhrauch moved back and forth over what specific “honest services” are demanded by the mail fraud amendment adopted by Congress 21 years ago.  Is the law violated if a worker reads the racing form after misleading the boss into thinking he was actually working? What about playing hookey to go to a ball game? Or telling the boss you liked his hat when you really didn’t?  More broadly, might the law be so vague that 100 million workers might be violating it without knowing it?

So, the Justices wondered, if “the average citizen” cannot know what the law outlaws, can the law be constitutional?
This formulation presents an interesting problem.  Honest services fraud, on its face, would cover swiping a pen from your employer just as well as some petty politician accepting a bribe, and any number of theoretical schemes in between, Worse still, it leaves the definition of what constitutes “honest services,” or how a business person or government official should make decisions in the ordinary course of performing their function, subject to the armchair quarterbacking of federal agents and prosecutors.  Can you imagine some 28 year old AUSA telling the purchasing officer of some multinational that he committed a federal offense by buying from his pal, who happens to represent a company that he knows and trusts, rather than the lowest bidder with no track record and inadequately financed?  It could happen.

The fact that prosecutors love this crime so much is usually a sign that it’s a very bad law.  And when Justice Scalia thinks so, it must be.

But what of the “average citizen” angle?  Certainly no average joe can figure out what honest services fraud means, but if that’s going to be a read standard, the truth is that people haven’t got a clue what conduct violates most federal offenses.  And many state offenses as well.  I supposed this “average citizen” is the guy standing next to the “reasonable person,” another beloved fiction in the law.  Yet no one knows who either of these fellas are.  We’ve never met them.

Most of the criminal law, and particularly federal crimes, fall outside the comprehension and experience of normal people.  They don’t grasp the details, the elements, the aggravating and mitigating factors.  They may have a general idea of right and wrong, but the specifics elude them.  And of course, it’s not like they check out the statutes before deciding to commit a crime, just to be sure. 

There have long been cries that all laws should be comprehensible by anyone with a high school education, but that’s be shown ad naseum to be a pipe dream.  So if laws routinely, and necessarily, are beyond the ken of the average citizen, what are the limitations?  How specific must a law be to pass constitutional muster?

It appears that the Supremes are poised (at least after the Skilling case is argued) to hold that honest services fraud is unconstitutional, and good riddance.  As we watch prosecutors employ their “imagination” to find ways to criminalize whatever they want to prosecute, the question presented is where to draw the line.  While rejecting honest services fraud is a good start, there remains about 4000 federal regulatory/criminal offenses left that are subject to abuse and misuse because of imaginative applications and vague language. 

Where does it stop?  It would be great if the Supreme Court would let us know.  And if it stops with the “average citizen,” then there are a whole lot of laws that need tossing.

Future Lawprofs: Moving Further Away From Lawyers?

While calls, or better yet make that screams, from the profession to make law school more relevant to the actual practice of law were recently heard across the blawgosphere, it appears that the latest trend in lawprof hiring may be one that dooms any possibility of bridging the gap.  Paul Lippe is not going to be happy about this.

Over at CoOp, Dave Hoffman (no relation to Marc Randazza, and any similarities in appearance are purely coincidental) asks whether PhD’s are going to become the norm for those seeking entry level positions in the legal academy.

The last few comments on this Prawfs thread raise an inquiry as old as the legal blogosphere: does it maximize to get a PhD on top of a JD if you want to get a job in the legal academy, or can you achieve the same ends with a fellowship, or by publication alone?

In my view, it’s an easy choice (with a few qualifications): go PhD or go home.

While some might see this as just the latest flavor in academic  hiring, soon to be replaced by applicants who wear turtlenecks or some other equally relevant criterion, Dave offers a reason for fear:

There are more PhDs in the legal academy every year.  They’ve all of the motivation in the world to demand the training as a credential for entry level hires, and as they age in their schools they will begin to flex their muscles.  Looking ahead to 2015, I’d say that the current cutoff of schools that softly demand a PhD for entry level hires (i.e., 1-10 or thereabouts) will trend toward all of the top tier.  It’s those mid-level schools which are going to be increasingly tied into central universities as budgets crunch, with resulting Provostian pressures.

In other words, when little PhDs grow up, they will want new lawprofs to have little PhDs just like them.  It’s only human nature to want to replicate oneself, with the added benefit of justifying why you wasted all that time getting the degree rather than using a law school education to, oh, practice law.

The implications are serious for lawyers, as the nice folks who are supposed to be teaching youngsters to be lawyers have made the personal choice to put as much distance as possible between themselves and the nastiness of legal profession.  In the past, one might at least anticipate the most lawprofs spent a couple of years in the library of a large law firm or prosecutors office where they believed that they now knew everything there was to know about being a lawyer.  

If Dave Hoffman is right, the closest they will ever come to a courtroom is one that has the word “Moot” in its name.  Instead of gaining the benefit of learning about life in the trenches, their world view will be formed while running from one campus building to another, never realizing that there is a whole world outside the university to which they’ve never been exposed.  And these will be the men and women who train future lawyers.

Orin Kerr thinks that Hoffman’s valuation of a PhD may be overstated.


I’m not so sure. Such things are hard to measure, but my sense is that Ph.D.s are often overvalued in entry-level hiring right now. Hiring committees change every year, but some committees see them as a very big deal. Time will tell whether that perception is accurate. Right now that perception is based on a prediction about the kind of scholarship those with Ph.D. credentials are likely to produce — more serious and more important than those with just a J.D. But we don’t know if that prediction will pan out. Maybe it will. But maybe it won’t. And if it doesn’t, the preference for Ph.D.s. at some schools likely will soften.
But even Orin recognizes that the potential (likelihood?) that PhDs will prove to be less valuable in legal scholarship is subject to Dave’s replication theory.

For practicing lawyers who think that lawyers fresh out of school lack the skills needed to practice law now, the future may be far more dim.  A lawprof with a PhD is likely to be far more entrenched in the theoretical than the practical, and far more likely to have had no experience in the actual practice of lawyering.  If you think lawprofs today fall short of the qualifications to teach students to be lawyers, imagine what a future of teachers without any practical experience at all will mean.  Oh, the weather outside is frightful.

One shining hope seems like a possibility however.  As law schools continue to compete for students, perhaps this will present an opening for those schools that aren’t likely to be the top draw for the brainiest PhDs to counterprogram themselves as the practical law schools, “the law school where you actually learn how to be a lawyer.”  We can dream, can’t we?