Author Archives: SHG

Maricopa Help Wanted: Flak With Brain (Update)

As predicted (as if it was hard to guess), Sheriff Joe Arpaio has geared up his PR machine to go after Judge Gary Donahoe for taking Adam Stoddard “political prisoner.”   Crazy Joe put out a press release dedicated to proving that Donahoe is a criminal’s best friend.


An examination of Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Gary Donahoe’s record over the past 18 months shows that defendants who have committed crimes such as child abuse, drug, and aggravated assault, often walk away without serving any jail time.  Yet, this week when a young Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office detention officer who acted in good faith attempting to maintain the safety and security of courtroom staff and the public, was ordered to serve jail time by Judge Donahoe as a way to fire a political shot and to send a message to the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office.

Oh my.  Evil judge.  Except Crazy Joe’s attempt to stack the deck against Donahoe with example after example of heinous criminal freed by this pinko liberal criminal lover didn’t pan out quite as well as he hoped.  From the Phoenix New Times :


“Judge’s Record Shows Bias…” reads the headline of the news release. It goes on to state that criminals who commit the crimes of “child abuse, drug possession, and aggravated assault often walk away without serving any jail time” when sentenced by Donahoe.

The Sheriff’s Office wants to rescue its employee from the hoosegow and come off looking like a martyr. But it really hosed this one.

A bit of extra research (with the help of Superior Court staff) shows that, in five of the six examples, Donahoe either included prison time in his sentencing or was following the recommendations of the County Attorney’s Office.

Well, this is certainly a bit embarrassing.  It turns out Arpaio’s flak must have rushed the research, and now makes the Sheriff look like a blithering idiot and a liar. Hardly what one would expect from such a crackerjack investigator as Sheriff Joe, especially coming after his last brushup with the media when they finally figured out he was making up the law in his press interviews.

A screw-up like this could blow the whole Get Donahoe Campaign, and then he would just be left with Stoddard stealing from a defense lawyer’s file.  That could look bad.  Attempts to reach the author of Sheriff Joe’s attack ad were rebuffed, when it was learned that the old flak was now living in a tent in the Arizona desert and digging holes by day.

But as a top notch scheme, Sheriff Arpaio has prepared for all eventualities.  The Sheriff has asked the Maricopa Board of Supervisors for an additional $7 million to cover anticipated legal fees not otherwise included in his $271 Million budget.  When going to battle, you can never have a big enough war chest.

Whether the Board of Supervisors will accede to Sheriff Joe’s request, or give him more money than he’s asking for, remains unknown.  They are all hiding under their desks to avoid getting splattered with the blood from Judge Donahoe’s expected decapitation. 

Update: And just to make sure that nobody on the Board of Supervisors might, oh, vote against Crazy Joe’s request, or do something really mean like cut his budget to zero or make him sleep in a tent in the desert, N.html”>he’s going after two board members :



Maricopa County Supervisors Don Stapley and Mary Rose Wilcox were indicted on multiple counts related to their work with the county, according to records County Attorney Andrew Thomas released Tuesday.

Stapley was indicted in November 2008 on 118 counts alleging omissions and misstatements on his financial-disclosure forms during a 14-year period. But retired Judge Kenneth Fields dismissed the misdemeanor counts against Stapley in August, and prosecutors decided to drop the remaining charges in September. Days later, the Sheriff’s Office revealed a new probe into Stapley’s suspected misuse of campaign funds.

The indictments from a Maricopa County grand jury are the latest allegations Thomas and Sheriff Joe Arpaio have leveled against county elected officials and administrators.
Concidentally, Stapley just become chairman of the Board of Supervisors, but Arpaio would certainly not go after him to persuade the others that disagreement might have dire consequences.  On the other hand, maybe the message is that if they don’t get some balls and put an end to the tyranny, they will always be hiding under a desk praying that Crazy Joe doesn’t indict them for fun.

H/T Jameson Johnson



A Brand New Weapon For The Cops’ Arsenal

Over at Turley’s place, where he took some time off from pumping for the vote for the ABA’s cutest lawprof blawger, there was yet another story of a child tased.


Now, police in Pueblo, Colorado have tasered a 10-year-old boy who threw a stick at an officer and was holding a pipe. Captain Jeff Teschner defended his deputies by saying that the use of pepper spray would have put the officers in danger with an unruly ten-year-old boy.

Teschner insisted that “They couldn’t get close enough to deploy pepper spray without putting themselves in danger.”
Thinking about the risk inherent in police subduing these vicious, violent stick-wielding children, where their pepper spray could cause them to suffer the horrible fate of teary eyes and momentary blindness, I strained to come up with something new, novel and safe for our protectors from the young.  After all, what could be more important when confronting a child-predator than making sure our boys in blue made it home safely for dinner?

I thought and thought.  It’s not easy, you know, to come up with something truly effective to protect those who protect us.  And don’t they deserve that extra effort?

And then it dawned on me.  Crazy at first, but the more I thought about it, the more effective yet safe it seemed.  I know, your first thought is how will they ever manage to fit a new weapon on their Sam Brown belt, all the room being taken up by the Glock, the Taser, the pepper spray, the mace, the two extra quick-draw magazines and the Dunkin’ Donuts buy 10 get 1 free card (needed in case they come across some kid who doesn’t respect their authoritah).  That’s the beauty of my new weapon.  It won’t take up any room at all.

So you ready?  Here it is.  Patience.

Just wait a few minutes.  Heck, maybe even a half hour.  But eventually the kid will get tired or bored and want to get back to the TV to watch the new Spongebob Squarepants, and put down the stick.  And I guarantee that the cops will be safe, as there is no threat at all that the children will use this weapon against them.  Everyone knows that kids have no patience.

The only risk to the police is suffering the burden of overtime.  After all, if they can’t end the stand-off immediately, there’s a good chance that they will have to remain on the job for an extended period of time.  In a worst-case scenario, it could be an hour.  But don’t fear.  They will make fresh donuts again for you.  After all, you’ll be a hero.  And a child won’t be harmed.

A Neighborhood Holiday Stroll

In many communities, it’s traditional to take a walk around the neighborhood as the Christmas season approaches to see what’s up with the neighbors.  While it’s a little harder to see the twinkling lights through the haze of the blawgosphere, today seemed like a good day for a stroll.

There’s much ado at the Legal Satyricon, where Marco Randazza, after his hiatus to re-establish himself on the left coats after being ordered to leave Florida post-haste, has resurfaced with a vengeance.  From his forthright interview with the omni-hysterical Bitter Lawyer comes gems like:


So why didn’t you go to work for a bigger firm known for doing First Amendment stuff?

This was all back in 2000, one of the best job markets law had ever seen.  But when I got my masters in 2002, things weren’t as good.  The job market was just mediocre by comparison, and I didn’t like those Big Firms.  I don’t fit in at Big Firms.  I’d rather drive a stake through my balls than work in BigLaw, where it’s all about being a billing machine and ethics aren’t important.
"Brother from another mother" This is why Randazza gets a Christmas card from Biglaw every year.  The feeling, apparently, fell short of unilateral, and now everyone sleeps better for it.

It’s a little known fact that Ron Coleman of Likelihood of Confusion, was once Randazza’s conjoined twin.  To the right is the last photograph of taken before the risky surgery.  While the operation was a rousing success, and Coleman has never again been invited to the Pornography Awards, the surgeons had to chose which of the pair would get the shared brain.  Trying to even things up, of course, the surgeons gave the shared genitalia to the other.  If only he knew what to do with it.

Down the road apiece was Jamie Spencer’s place, where he too was the focus of some external scrutiny.  While commenting on a new local prosecutor blawg, D.A. Confidential, Jamie’s innocent question invoked the wrath of another commenter, calling himself Acerbic, who obviously ended up on the short end of the brains/genitalia continuum.

Dissatisfied with proving himself in the comments, Acerbic found it vitally necessary to immediately dedicated to Jamie.  Naturally, Spencer responded with equal alacrity by capitalizing on his newfound title, The Unethical Attention-Whoring Crappy Douchebag Lawyer.  For those of us who were hoping to garner the title for ourselves, too late.  That lucky dog.

A few steps down was Amy Derby’s place, which was surrounded by her adoring fans following non-publication of her international best-selling book, Chronic Bullshit Syndrome.   

Chronic Bullshit Syndrome


Wouldn’t it be nice to read a book that isn’t a how-to for manipulating your online “friends” into joining your circlejerk for a profit? I thought so too. Hence, the birth of my latest work:

Case studies show that Chronic Bullshit Syndrome affects 4.7 out of 5 internet users* today, causing thousands of social networkers to walk around with their heads so far up their asses that they ultimately experience tragic health problems as a result.


The marketplace, and your asshole, has had enough. For only $7, you can buy your copy of Chronic Bullshit Syndrome today. It’ll clear that shit right up.


I hoped to get Amy to sign a copy of my book with something inspiring, but she had already left to go on her national bogus book tour, where she hopes to try out every Chinese restaurant in the nation.

And finally, I arrived at the offices of Hull McGuire (formerly Julie McGuire and Whatshisname).  It was late, but I could still see the candle burning inside where Dan Hull, surrounded by sleeping associates, was preparing a motion by writing in coal on the broad end of a shovel, his favorite legal delivery mechanism.  I was deeply touched by his dedication, and feel compelled to share with you Dan’s extraordinarily touching, deeply sentimental, Christmas message:



It brings tears to my eyes every time. 


Simels Gets 14 Years For Tough Talk

The indictment was a shock.  The conviction was a surprise.  The sentence, well, was within the realm of the expected.  Bob Simels, who once flew pretty high in the criminal defense bar, was sentenced to the custody of the United States Bureau of Prisons for 14 years by Judge John Gleeson.

There was significant dispute whether the tough talk on the phone with a government informant, about “eliminating” or “neutralizing” witnesses meant what the government contended, bribing or murdering witnesses against his alleged drug kingpin client, Shaheed (Roger) Khan.  While the language made most of us cringe, there was substantial doubt within the ranks of criminal defense lawyers that Simels meant it that way. 

Apparently, that doubt hasn’t changed since the conviction, and Judge Gleeson was less than impressed.



The judge was clearly annoyed by arguments raised in letters submitted by Simels’ fellow lawyers suggesting he had been prosecuted because of his aggressive style, or that his tough talk about “eliminating” or “neutralizing” witnesses was taken out of context.

“You still haven’t held yourself accountable for your criminal acts. But you’re not required – I will,” Gleeson said. “These are such egregious crimes and you need to be punished for them.”
It would appear that whatever doubts remain amongst the criminal defense bar never entered into Judge Gleeson’s thoughts.  This may be because Judge Gleeson went from the United States Attorneys office straight to the bench, or because, having sat through the testimony, he’s firmly convinced that Simels meant it exactly as the government said.

If Bob Simels indeed planned to engage in bribery, or be complicit in the murder of witnesses against his client, then the sentence is not merely well-deserved, but perhaps even a bit soft for such a crime.  Criminal defense lawyers don’t do this, not for the best paying drug kingpin or for anybody else.  We defend.  We don’t murder.  We are criminal defense lawyers, not criminals.

But there is a bright spot to the hearing before Judge Gleeson.  At the time of conviction, there was very deep concern about Simels’ associate, Arienne Irving, who appeared to be merely swept along with the tide against Simels, and could not conceivably have had any say in what Simels was doing.  More evidence of the collateral damage that comes to lesser defendants who are tainted by the evidence against the primary defendant, where the jury is unable or unwilling to differentiate between the conduct of the defendants.

The good news is that Judge Gleeson recognized this and tossed Irving’s conviction for insufficient evidence.  It won’t give her back the year lost to this case, or the ruination of her legal career, but it beats spending 14 years in prison for working for someone who committed a crime. 

Where Ethics Go To Die

The tale of Judges-for-sale, Michael T. Conahan and Mark A. Ciavarella Jr., who threw away 6500 children for money, is certainly the sort of thing that would overshadow ordinary, run-of-the-mill impropriety.  It’s a blot on Luzerne County, Pennsylvania and a lesson for the rest of us about quietly tolerating judicial crime for fear of upsetting the powerful.  If this was all that had happened there, it would have been more than enough.

But it isn’t all that was happening in Luzerne County, as unbelievable as that may seem.  This place is a judicial cesspool, and the only reason there hasn’t been an overwhelming outcry is that Ciavarella and Conahan were such outrageous criminals that they dwarf pretty much any other impropriety one can think of.  That doesn’t make Judge Michael T. Toole look any better, however, and it would be wrong to ignore his misconduct just because it didn’t rise to the level of his fellow judges.

From the Legal Intelligencer :


Federal authorities have charged Luzerne County Judge Michael T. Toole with honest services fraud and with filing a false tax return.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Pennsylvania announced the charges and an accompanying plea agreement Wednesday afternoon. Toole faces a maximum of 23 years in prison and a fine of $350,000.

Under his plea deal, Toole has agreed to cooperate with federal authorities and provide information “concerning the unlawful activity of others.” He will also resign from the bench as part of his plea agreement.

Do they not pay judges enough in Luzerne County that they all need a side job?  As Toole is going to cooperate, how many more judges, and no doubt lawyers, will be swept into a web of corruption?  Where does it end?

And if this plain vanilla corruption isn’t enough to make you angry, consider this:  Toole entered into his plea agreement on September 25, yet continued to sit on the bench as a judge.  Let that one sink in.  The judge signed a plea agreement and continued as a judge for months.



One knowledgeable source told The Legal Intelligencer there was frustration on the part of some investigative agencies that Toole was allowed to stay on the bench after he had signed his plea agreement.

When asked about the delay, Heidi Havens, a spokeswoman for the U.S. Attorney’s Office, directed a reporter to a sentence in the office’s release announcing the agreement, which read:

“Because the Information contains a charge relating to a tax matter, the Office of the United States Attorney for the Middle District of Pennsylvania was required to obtain separate approvals for the charge from Department of Treasury and Department of Justice officials in Washington.”

The United States Attorneys office was complicit in this subversion of the judiciary by concealing the fact that Toole had signed the plea agreement because it still required administrative approvals.  This has got to be the most ridiculous excuse ever.  No one from the United States Attorneys office thought it wise to inform the Luzerne County administrative judge that there was an executed plea agreement, but that they were awaiting sign-offs?  Wasn’t the admission by Toole to the commission of a crime enough to warrant telling someone?



Luzerne County Common Pleas Court President Judge Chester B. Muroski said Toole, who abruptly notified the court last month that he was taking vacation, never notified him of pending charges or a plea agreement.

Had he known about Toole’s plea agreement, Muroski said, he would have refrained from giving Toole “any judicial assignments” and would have reported Toole to the Judicial Conduct Board and the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts.

“I don’t know how anyone can function as a judge once they enter into a plea agreement with the government,” Muroski said.
That Toole was less than forthright about his charges or plea comes as no surprise.  The guy is corrupt, and we don’t rely on corrupt public officials to spread the word of their corruption.  But there is no excuse whatsoever for the feds to have clammed up, to have shown the disdain for the people of Luzerne County that comes with allowing Toole to remain on the bench without saying a word. 

As for the administrative judge, Muroski, his point about Toole is well-taken, but I hate to point out the obvious.  Some administrative judge you are, given that you have two judges selling children into prison and another judge selling decisions on the open market, all under your nose and you know nothing about nothing.

Just because Toole isn’t nearly as corrupt at Ciavarella and Conahan doesn’t make him a piker.  And just because the plea wasn’t signed off doesn’t mean its admissions never happened. And just because nobody told the admin judge doesn’t mean that pervasive corruption isn’t happening.  Luzerne County is an ethical cesspool, and there doesn’t appear to be anyone there who isn’t somehow smeared by this mess.

Blawgospheric Darwinism (Update)

Miffed at Mark Hermann’s post about why Biglaw blogs are boring, Kevin O’Keefe, CEO of Lexblog and head cheerleader of the blawgosphere, tried to rip Mark a new one in his post at Real Lawyers Have Blogs.  After noting that both he and his family are drug users (not that kind), Kevin points out that it doesn’t qualify him to blog about drugs. If he did, people would wonder what kind of drug user he was (now, that kind).


They’d be probably be right. I couldn’t expect folks to view me as a much of an authority on the subject.

But it’s never stopped Mark Hermann, a leading defense lawyer at Jones Day, with a particular expertise in pharmaceutical claims, from offering commentary on the effectiveness of law blogs on his Drug and Device Law Blog (excellent blog on that subject).

Sure, it’s a disingenuous argument, since Kevin’s in business to sell blogs to lawyers.  At it happens, Kevin is extraordinarily knowledgeable about blogging and other webby-type stuff.  But knowledge alone doesn’t make someone an honest broker.  I also happen to know that Kevin is a huge advocate of substantive blogging rather than being a flagrant shill for business, both because it doesn’t work and because it’s a blight on the blawgosphere.  It’s not like he’s going to refuse business because some law firm wants to blog badly, but Kevin has long advocated for good blogging as a way to keep his peeps happy and his business thriving.

In the comments to Kevin’s rant, I raised an issue that raised Kevin’s hackles, Blawgospheric Darwinism.  After reiterating Hermann’s point that most blawgs are boring, I wrote:


And if they weren’t, there would be far too many blogs to read, and they would fail for lack of readers in any event. The reality is that no one reads 500 blogs a day and no one ever will, so they will focus on the handful of blogs that are informative and interesting and the rest will fall by the wayside. It blogospheric Darwinism, and there’s no argument you can make that will change this certainty.


Too much of anything is, well, too much.  That covers the blawgosphere as well.  Only the fittest will survive, not because the others are awful necessarily, but because we would be deluged with far more than we could absorb if every blawg that came down the pike was a winner.  There would still be a natural vetting process, and people would still read only the few that capture their interest best. 

Kevin, as expected, disagrees.


The chance we’ll see only a handful of law blogs because of what you describe as ‘blogospheric Darwinism’ makes as much sense as saying we’ll see the end of lawyers networking and building relationships with their target audience for client development. Lawyers, and more of them, are going use client development tools that work, blogs being one of them.
I wasn’t sure how best to describe this response.  A non-sequitur?  A failed analogy?  I settled on goofy, mostly because I like the word.  Words I don’t like as much are “networking”, “building relationships” and “client development.”  Those are marketing words, sufficiently familiar yet too vague to nail down.  While a successful blawg, according to how one defines success, can serve some sort of “client development” type purpose, it’s hardly the equivalent of chatting up potential clients.  But more to the point, the unsuccessful blog, defined (for the moment) as one that nobody reads because it’s boring, is like chatting up an empty room.  You can call it networking, but it’s not going to bring anybody in the door.

The laws of nature apply to the blawgosphere, whether that’s good for Kevin’s business or not.  I can appreciate that he wants to sell every lawyer out there a turnkey blog.  I’m a capitalist too.  But the notion that every blog can find an audience is sheer nonsense.  Anybody can blog. Everybody can’t.  There are going to be successes and failures in blawging as in every other endeavor, even if every potential blawger puts in the effort to create good content and makes the blawg interesting.  There is a saturation point.  There are diminishing returns.  There is survival of the fittest.

Unless a time comes when the real world has so little to do that people can spend every waking minute reading blawg after blawg after blawg (and then some), there will be natural selection.  The blawgs that people find most interesting, whether because of humor, thought-provocation or breathtaking brilliance, will have readers.  The blawgs that are lacking in content, or just plain boring, will be digital ghost towns. 

This isn’t an argument, Kevin.  This is reality.  And it doesn’t take a maven like you to figure out that this is how the blawgosphere works.  Mark Hermann knows it.  I know it.  And you know it too, even though it doesn’t comport with the Lexblog line. 

Update:  The forces agin’ us have sought to recast the existence of good blawgs v. bad blawgs into a war between blogs whose primary purpose is to capture readers by being funny v. serious blogs.  This rationalization is utterly nonsensical, and merits address since those who are now starting out in the blawgosphere shouldn’t be misled by this strawman argument. 

I can’t think of a popular blawg whose purpose was to become popular, except maybe Above the Law, and whose goal was to use whatever means it could to attract readers.  Rather, popularity was a by-product of the effort, passion, and, on occasion, humor.  But some of the most popular and well-read blawgs around aren’t funny at all.  Is SCOTUS Blog a laugh riot?  Does My Shingle play to the crowds?  Is Randazza geared to the mass market?  Of course not. 

What we see instead is the spin of bloggers who want to present a brave front despite the fact that they write, as do the rest of us, yet fail to engage an audience, so they claim that they are thrilled with the intimate success of their blog.  If they are, that’s great. But as Mark Bennett points out in his Social Media Tyro Blog, there is one continuing theme that permeates blogs that fail to capture a readership as a by-product of its content:  The purpose of blog is to market.

Those dissatisfied with their lack of readers try to attribute nefarious intent to those who, for whatever reason, have had some degree of success blawging, while simultaneously claiming that they’ve accomplished some dignified victory in their small but select readership.  If you write something that people want to read, then you can’t stop them from reading.  That people aren’t reading what you write doesn’t prove virtue. 

If you want to write, then write.  If people want to read what you write, they will.  Cut the crap.  Cut the spin.  If no one is reading your blawg, the problem isn’t that others are trying to be “funny”. The problem is that people don’t find your blawg sufficiently interesting to spend time there.  That’s Blawgospheric Darwinism, and no amount of spin is going to change it.

Maricopa Sunday: Liddy and Donahoe Do The Jig

While Maricopa County court detention officer Adam Stoddard awaits breakfast in bed at the Mesa Hilton, where he remains imprisoned awaiting the daily massage and poolside cocktail, Nick Martin at Heat City has posted the latest effort by G. Gordon Liddy’s pride and joy at finding a backdoor to the impending shootout on the streets of Phoenix.

Stoddard’s attorney filed a motion to unseal the letter that formed the basis of Stoddard’s “concern” and was seized from defense lawyer Joanne Cuccia’s file behind her back.


Stoddard’s counsel needs access to the letter at issue to present a proper defense.  Fairness requires that Stoddard have access to all material that may be necessary to a proper defense of the action in order to avoid a deprivation of his rights or property without due process of law.

On it’s face, the argument is nonsense.  Stoddard had every opportunity to explain what caused him to rifle through the file and seize the letter, and unsealing it adds nothing whatsoever to the mix.  Judge Donahoe examined the full letter and concluded that there was nothing, save the four words claimed by Stoddard, that gave rise to any arguable basis for his conduct.  And, it goes without saying, that this motion comes a wee bit too late in the proceedings to make a difference. 


In a response filed Thursday, public defense attorney Maria Schaffer pointed out that Donahoe reviewed the entire letter and said the four words were the only things necessary for Stoddard “to completely defend himself against this allegation of improper conduct.”

“It is noteworthy,” Schaffer wrote, “that at no point…during the remainder of the hearings did Mr. Liddy ask that the letters be unsealed in their entirety.”

Of course, waiver of a criminal defendant’s privilege isn’t dictated by the seizure of his confidential communication by a court deputy.  Such a backward notion would undermine the privilege at will, since any deputy could seize anything he wanted in clear violation of the defendant’s rights, then force the defendant to chose between the vindication of his rights or the waiver of privilege.  It’s would be a catch-22, if it was necessary.  Fortunately, it isn’t, since the motivation for the seizure comes from the mouth of the officer, not the content of the letter.

So is Liddy throwing a Hail Mary?  Not so fast.  Included in Stoddard’s papers is the transcript of the October 30th hearing before Judge Gary Donahoe, which suggests that judges, like defendants, ought to be given Miranda warning before sounds emit from their mouths.


So I’m still not sure I’m even going to entertain a contempt finding at this time, so I’m letting this play out to see what evidence I get. But right now, unless they’re entitled to fully defend against this contempt allegation, I’m not going to hold them in contempt.
Suddenly, things appear a bit different based upon Judge Donahoe’s explicit statement that he would not hold Stoddard (them?) in contempt in the absence of a full waiver of privilege.  The problem isn’t that Donahoe was right to say this (he wasn’t) or whether a waiver is truly necessary to provide due process to the defense (it isn’t).  The problem is detrimental reliance.

Right or wrong, once Judge Gary Donahoe announced to the defense that he would not hold Adam Stoddard in contempt in the absence of a waiver of privilege, they are entitled to rely upon his statement.  It was one boneheaded thing to say, but he said it and even Adam Stoddard gets to rely on the judge’s pronouncement.

While it’s doubtful that a motion to unseal, after the fact, is the proper mechanism to raise this point, as opposed to a motion for reargument based upon the court’s misapprehension of the law, it happens to be a very good point.  And it’s a very good point that exists only because Donahoe spoke these ill-conceived words.  It will certainly be a valid argument to be raised on appeal.

And poor Adam Stoddard languishes in the Mesa Hilton while his brethren hold candlelight vigils in his honor.  No wonder Crazy Joe Arpaio has managed to out-maneuver every attack on his hegemony over Maricopa County up to now.  It’s got to be the water.

The Public Defender Made Me Do It

From Pogo Was Right, the CBS outlet in Sacramento covers what has reached near urban legend status, the accidental downloading of kiddie porn resulting in a young man going to prison for years.


Matthew White, 22, said he was surfing for pornography two years ago on Limewire — a fire sharing application that allows users to trade music, movies, games and pictures — when he discovered that some of the files he had downloaded were images of children.

Matt claims he quickly erased the files.

“It didn’t appeal to me,” he said. “I was looking for women my age, so I just wanted to download ‘College Girls Gone Wild’ and accidentally downloaded underage pornography.”

It’s certainly not an outlandish story, and apparently supported by the allegation that when the police came to search his computer, they were unable to find any evidence of the child porn until they accessed long-deleted files.


About a year later, FBI agents showed up at his family’s home. The family agreed to let agents examine the computer, and at first, they couldn’t find anything.

Investigators later were able to recover the deleted images from deep within the hard drive.

“I asked them, ‘Where did you get that? I don’t remember that.’ I asked them, ‘Could I access that if I wanted to?'” Matt said. “They said no.”

A pretty good argument that this was, at worst, an accidental download, right?  But where it goes from here has me stymied.


Facing 20 years in prison for possessing child pornography, Matt is pleading guilty on the advice of his public defender in hopes of getting a three and a half year sentence. He will also serve 10 years probation and have to register as a sex offender for the rest of his life.

Matt’s father says other parents need to be warned about the consequences of stumbling across illicit material.

“One day, you’re going to get a knock on the door and have your child taken away for many years,” he said.

So why cop a plea to such an awful deal?  Why cop a plea at all?  Is this an example of a public defender pushing a client to plead out rather than fighting the accusation?  And given the appearance of his parent’s house in the news video, which appears to be a very nice middle class home, why is he represented by a public defender at all?

Maximum possible sentences are often used to coerce a plea, but it’s absurd to suggest that a 22 year old with no prior record, a plausible defense and only deleted images would get prison time.  The clear impression given by this news story is that he’s innocent but has no choice in the matter. 

The sub rosa suggestion of the story is that this kid is going to prison because he’s represented by a public defender, implicitly some crappy freebie lawyer. [Addendum: Note comment below.]  Indeed, the question posed at Pogo was:


Why is he pleading guilty and can’t some good lawyer volunteer to represent him pro bono?”
The answer to the first question is something of a mystery, and the best guess is either that the evidence is different than he describes it or that he’s following his lawyer’s advice.  But the second question misses the mark.  While 22 year old White may not have the funds for a lawyer, it clearly appears that his parents could provide him with whatever he needs.  At least there is no suggestion to the contrary.  That they have chosen not to do so is suggests that he’s either not so innocent or they don’t like their son very much.

It doesn’t fall to a good lawyer to defend White pro bono.  It’s not the lawyer’s job to pick up the slack when a parent doesn’t think his son is worth the effort, the risk, the burden of retaining the best possible counsel.  If a young man’s parents don’t believe that his freedom is worth their savings, or even a second mortgage on the home, why would the burden shift to a lawyer to defend him for free?  Lawyers aren’t the mommies and daddies of every accused, putting themselves on the line when the defendant’s parents are unwilling to extend themselves.

Whether Matthew White should spend a day in prison or not is a matter that can’t be discerned from this one-sided presentation, which certainly suggests that a three and a half year prison sentence is grossly excessive.  But if that’s so, and if he and his parents believe that he’s being coerced into a plea by a public defender, then they need only dust off their wallets and retain a lawyer in whom they repose greater trust. 

But to complain about the unfairness of it all, while doing nothing to change it, is disingenuous.  They have a choice, and they have only themselves to blame for not exercising it.  Don’t blame the public defender. Do something about it.

A Trial Without Evidence

The verdict is in. Amanda Knox is guilty, sentenced to 26 years in the brutal murder of her roommate.  The only thing missing is proof.

For aficionados of the Nancy Grace school of law, this is what they would have happen in every trial.


To many Americans, this trial is an outrage. “It’s probably the most egregious international railroading of two innocent young people I’ve ever seen,” said John Q. Kelly, a former prosecutor known for getting a civil verdict against O.J. Simpson for the murder of his ex-wife. Speaking on CNN last month, he called it “a public lynching based on rank speculation.”

But that’s how this trial looks through the eyes of an American lawyer, whose world hasn’t collapsed into Nancy Grace-like platitudes and assumptions.  In Italy and the United Kingdom, Amanda Knox was excoriated for her “inappropriate” post-murder behavior, and that’s enough to justify her conviction.  Indeed, it’s enough to demand her conviction.  She must be guilty, proof be damned.



The Italian legal system is wholly foreign to me, though I do know that many of the protections that characterize our system, real juries, vetted for bias, and proof beyond a reasonable doubt, are not a part of it.  I know it takes a very long time for a trial, as this one lasted almost a full year, leaving Knox in custody for almost two years prior to her conviction.  The head judge at her trial is required to provide an explanation for the verdict within 90 days of its rendering.  I wonder if it will say more than “we believe she did it.”

There is no making sense of this from our frame of reference.  It doesn’t begin to comport with anything remotely familiar to what we consider a fair trial, a system of justice.  Obviously, the Italians see things differently, and aren’t particularly concerned that this translate easily into English. 

During the summation, the prosecutor told the jury about the things Amanda Knox might have said to Meredith Kercher before the alleged drug-induced orgy that ended with her throat being slashed.



“You are always behaving like a little saint. Now we will show you. Now we will make you have sex.”

This would be a horrible thing to say, except that it never happened.  No one says that such a statement was ever made.  But summations in Perugia aren’t limited to evidence, as they are here.  Rather, this is a permissible indulgence into  fantasy, a made up dramatization of what the prosecutors contend might have happened.  It’s used to inflame the jury.  It’s what prosecutors try to do everywhere, except that there are no restrictions on such fabrications in Italy.  Still, arousing passion gets a far better visceral response that appealing to reason.  Reason requires evidence.

For those who seem to be in a perpetual rush to do away with all those “technicalities” that get in the way of sentencing defendants who are deemed guilty from the moment the police announce whodunnit, is this really the sort of trial that meets with your satisfaction?  You applaud our system in its failures, arguing that we give criminals too many rights.  Well, Amanda Knox has enjoyed the alternative.  Are you happy now?  Is this really what you prefer?

The Fascinating Life of a Blawger

While every blawger I know is, of course, incredibly interesting, it appears that there is none as fascinating as Tom Goldstein, honcho at SCOTUSBlog.  He’s so fascinating that the one-time shoeless SCOTUS chaser, now fully dressed Akin Gump partner, has sold his life rights to NBC in anticipation of a television show about his life.


For those who haven’t heard of Goldstein, his story goes like this: He was a fourth-year lawyer at Boies, Schiller when he decided he wanted to pursue a Supreme Court practice. He quit the law firm and worked at home as he looked for cases likely to make it to the high court, volunteering to represent litigants for free. He made it work. Now Goldstein is an appellate litigator with Akin Gump who has argued 21 Supreme Court cases.

While it’s not entirely clear how one distinguishes solicitation when it applies to Supreme Court cases as opposed to, oh, chasing ambulances for a decent PI case, you can’t fault Goldstein for taking a chance and making good on it.



Variety has reported that NBC is developing a show based on Goldstein’s early career, when he sat shoeless in his house pounding away on the Web, pitching his wares to parties involved in potential Supreme Court cases, and making a name for himself.

According to the article, the show’s working title is “Tommy Supreme.” Supposedly the show will be an “inverse House,” depicting a likable guy in an unlikable profession.
Of course, Dr. House is also brilliant, but I don’t think they mean that Goldstein is an idiot.  In fact, he’s done quite an extraordinary job, both with this blog and his career.  Plus, he’s a very funny guy, despite his having settled in with a firm like Akin Gump.




So what does Tommy Supreme think about his sudden climb to fame?


“It’s really weird,” Goldstein told us Friday afternoon. “But it is what it is. They’ve put an awfully lot of thought into this.” Goldstein says that in order to get the show off the ground, he had to sell his “life rights” to Sony Pictures Television. “I can’t go out and sell ‘Tom Goldstein’ action figures now,” he jokes.
Joke though it may be, it’s an important lesson for the rest of us in the blawgosphere.  Make your deal for action figures now, before Sony buys your life rights.  Don’t let what happened to Tom Goldstein happen to you.

I think it’s terrific that television has taken an interest in Goldstein and I hope that this show makes it on air.  His story really is quite fascinating, and he’s done a terrific job at SCOTUSBlog.  And when Tom Goldstein action figures make it the shelves of my local Lawyer-R-Us, I plan to buy them in every color suit available.  Congratulations, Tom.