Author Archives: SHG

Run It Up The Flagpole and See Who Salutes

You can’t help but like retired Col. Van T. Barfoot.  The 90 year old served with distinction in World War II, Korea and Vietnam.  He won some medals, including a Purple Heart.  And the Medal of Honor for staring down three Nazi tanks with a bazooka.  He’s a patriot, and he comes by it honestly.  He’s put his life on the line, and certainly needs no apologies to put up a 21 foot flagpole to fly the flag for which he was prepared to give his life.

This is why the decision by the Sussex (Virginia) Homeowners Association, via Turley, to deny Barfoot’s pole seems so wrong.  From the ABC News :



The Sussex Square homeowners’ association says the flagpole violates the neighborhood’s aesthetic guidelines. It originally ordered him to remove it by 5 p.m. Friday or face a lawsuit, but on Thursday it pushed back the deadline until Dec. 11.

The group has said Barfoot can display the flag, as long as it’s in a way that conforms with association rules, such as from a pole mounted on the front of the house.

“This is not about the American flag. This is about a flagpole,” the association said in a statement.
Housing developments that are run by homeowner’s associations aren’t everyone’s cup of tea, and definitely not mine.  When the decision is made to purchase a home within such a development and subject to the association’s often overbearing rules, they do so for a reason.  They seek the sort of aesthetic consistency that some people relish; the ability to make sure that the guy next door doesn’t do something that will offend your sensibilities.

The problem here is that the “guy next door” in this case is Barfoot.  The rules of the association are part and parcel of what you buy when you make the decision to give up your freedom so that the other fellow will give up his.  As silly as aesthetic choices may seem to some, they are very much a part of the quality of life that some people desire, and after the deal is cut, the agreement to forego the bundle of freedoms that we might otherwise possess, to enjoy that additional freedom of living without some crazy guy next door painting his house purple and keeping junk cars in the driveway, we live with it.

It’s not as if they came up with the rule just to hassle poor Barfoot.  The rule were there before he put up his flagpole.  It was one of the rules that he agreed to abide when he decided to live within the rules of the homeowners association.  It wasn’t a personal attack or affront.  It’s just a rule, like the ones that requires people to mow their lawn or paint their home in a pre-selected color.  That’s what makes these communities desirable for people who have had enough of other people’s individual choices and prefer to live in a neighborhood whose appearance will meet their approval for as long as they live there.  If that’s what they like, what’s wrong with that?

It’s not that I don’t feel badly for Barfoot.  The man has every sympathy-evoking factor on the planet.  Who can say “no” to a 90 year old vet who was willing to give his life for others?  But then, the rules don’t prohibit him from receiving medical care, or even flying the flag itself.  It’s just about tall flagpoles.  While the absence of a flag won’t kill him (and hasn’t up to now), there is no rule that prevents him from hanging a flag from a pole mounted on his house. 

The comments at Turley’s blog struck me as very telling, and gave rise to my posting about this.  Many commenters took the position that Barfoot had earned the right to do as he pleased, or that it was his property and no one could tell him what to do.  To the extent that one can discern an opinion from Turley’s post itself, this appears to reflect his thinking as well.  While it’s understandable that Turley and his readers strongly believe in individual rights, and similarly see the homeowner association’s rules as ridiculous, they completely miss the point.

Col. Barfoot made the decision to purchase a home within, and subject to the rules of, the Sussex Homeowners Association.  He knew that he would be subject to the aesthetic limitations of the rules, and he know that his neighbors would be as well.  He decided to purchase his home anyway.  He enjoys the benefit of his neighbors maintaining the consistency of appearance of the neighborhood that characterizes these associations.  It enhances the quality of his life by providing him with a neighborhood atmosphere that meets his expectations. 

It’s a compact between neighbors for their mutual benefit.  That it’s not how you would like to live is irrelevant.  No one will force you to move into the neighborhood.  You do so by choice.  You do so knowingly.  The people who purchase homes subject to these rules desire these rules and desire the homogeneous appearance that characterize these neighborhood.  The entire concept falls apart the minute one homeowner asserts his individual right to do something that violates the rules.  He ruins it for everyone.

That said, it would appear that the homeowners association is trying to do the right thing by seeking to mediate the dispute.  Perhaps the entire neighborhood will agree to let Barfoot have his flagpole, the rules notwithstanding.  Perhaps a smaller flagpole will be acceptable.  They don’t appear to be in “zero tolerance” mode, but rather trying to find some middle ground.  This is about as reasonable as it gets.

The message isn’t that individual rights are dead, but that we are constrained by our own voluntary choices.  When a group of people choose to relinquish certain rights for the benefit of all, it’s unfair to expect that it applies to everyone but you.  I salute Col. Van T. Barfoot for his contributions to our nation, and I hope that they are able to work something out that everyone can live with, but he has no right to ignore the rules that he enjoys when applied to his neighbors.

Flip Side of the Spam Scam

Scammer/Spammers are nothing if not agile.  And so, while Eric the Turk at New York Personal Injury Blog pursues the scandalous Martindale-Hubbell Spammer-Palooza, fellow New York blawger Andrew Bluestone at New York Attorney Malpractice Blog has found what it feels like to be on the other side of the scam.  See what happens when you establish too much credibility?

Apparently, some miscreant has stolen Bluestone’s law firm identity and  This entry was posted in Uncategorized on by .

The Poster Boy For Intellectual Embarrassment

Jones Day partner and fellow curmudgeon Mark Hermann wrote a post at Drug & Device Law about why Biglaw blogs are a bore.  And he would know.

But no such post would have teeth in the absence of a foil, someone against whom he could juxtapose the attributes of Biglaw to show how and why they succumb to their risk averse, voice averse, interest averse prose.  And Hermann, my good buddy, chose me.  Such an honor.

So what does Hermann think?


Be funny! Be provocative! Do something that will draw readers in.

That’s the key for many successful blogs, such as Simple Justice. It’s not a first source of news. It’s not breathtakingly intelligent (although it’s not bad on that score — don’t take offense, Scott). But it has a voice. It’s funny, and it can be thought-provoking.

No offense taken, Mark.  After all, I’m just lucky I can spell offense, no less take it.  I once had a really good thought, but then I saw something shiny and couldn’t remember what it was.  Oh well.

But that’s not all Hermann’s got to say in using me as his poster boy.  It’s enormously gratifying to know that I serve a greater purpose to the breathtakingly intelligent Biglaw online community.  Though they may be far too serious and thoughtful (ya know, the way lawyers are supposed to be) draw in readers, at least there are schlubs like me to use as the alternative.

You see, Biglaw has an image of gravitas to maintain, and attempts to be humorous or provocative could place them in jeopardy in the eyes of their very important clients.  A solo, on the other hand, can be as big a horse’s ass as he wants, since he’s got nothing to lose.


On the other hand, if you read our attempted humor and are offended, you might not be so constrained. You might write directly to us (and some of you have) or you might write to others in our firm to complain about us (and some of you have done that, too).

Solo practitioners don’t have to worry about that risk: If Scott Greenfield embarrasses himself at Simple Justice, no one can complain to his colleagues. Not so for those of us in the AmLaw 200.

Heck, I must embarrass myself at least three times a day, and that doesn’t even include the dribble glass that Mark isn’t aware of yet.  Apparently, it’s my willingness to embarrass myself that makes readers come to Simple Justice.  They just can’t get enough of my spilling my vapid thoughts all over my nice white shirt and tie.  I bet they just laugh and laugh, thinking to their Biglaw selves, I might be boring but at least I’m not him.  After all, why would any solo practitioner care if he’s the buffoon of the blawgosphere?  It’s not like he’s got partners who won’t let him eat lunch with them.

Carolyn Elefant wondered whether I was offended by Hermann’s post.  I’m not.  It’s a culture thing, where Biglaw is scared to death of anyone figuring out that they might spill something on their white shirt and tie.  While Hermann sees it as breathtakingly intelligent lawyers protecting themselves from being revealed as insipid cogs, I see it as the fearlessness of speaking one’s mind (even if that mind falls short of brilliance on many an occasion). 

There’s nothing that makes me feel prouder than knowing that I am here to amuse the good men and women of Biglaw.  Even if only by dribbling on myself.  I’m here for you, Mark.

Volokh Teaches Tranparency

There is no question that Eugene Volokh is a brilliant law professor, and, I might add, a good guy.  Having put together one of the most fascinating groups to ever call themselves conspirators, he’s added immeasurably to the vitality of the blawgosphere. It would have been more than enough had he rested on his laurels, and no one would have thought any less of him if that’s where it stopped.

But it didn’t stop there.  Instead, Eugene took an enormous risk by posting a link to his oral argument (he started @39 minutes in) before the Nebraska Supreme Court, where he represented the defendant, pro bono, in a criminal/First Amendment case, State v, Drahota.  Why was this a risk, rather than some lawprof showing off his pedantic genius?  For all that Eugene has written on First Amendment issues as well as others, this was only his second oral argument. 

Eugene readily admits that he was nervous.



I was a bit nervous during my oral argument, perhaps because it was just the second argument I’ve ever done, and perhaps because it was just because having to argue a real case in front of real judges is pretty daunting.

Fortunately, I remembered that a judge once told me it’s good to be a bit nervous at oral argument, or at least better than to come across as glib and a know-it-all. Maybe some might disagree on this — but at least it kept me from being nervous about being nervous, in addition to just being nervous.

Eugene didn’t have to do any of this.  He could just as easily have noted the case, the issues, and, when the decision issues, his win (or why the court was wrong).  No one would have asked why he didn’t link to a video of his argument.  No one would have asked whether he afraid as he stepped to the podium.  No one would have questioned whether Eugene Volokh, scholar, was up to the task.

For those who, like Eugene, feel the butterflies as you approach, it’s got to make you feel better to know that someone as accomplished as Eugene in the law feels the same way.  Granted, the choices aren’t limited to nervous or a glib know-it-all, but everyone has to work their way up to calm, professional and knowledgeable in their presentation.  We all start somewhere.

I decline to comment on Eugene’s presentation, except to say that it appears to be very effective with the court.  At the end of the day, substance always trumps form when it comes to an effective presentation.  That said, I am incredibly impressed with Eugene’s bravery and humility in being so transparent with his own work.  There was no need to put his professional reputation at risk, yet he did. 

The Streets of Maricopa

When the day came for Adam Stoddard to put up or shut up, he appeared to surrender.  But the question that day, whether Sheriff Joe Arpaio blinked, could not be answered by watching the trees and ignoring the forest.  It seemed obvious that the problems afflicting Maricopa County wouldn’t be solved in a day, and that Crazy Joe wasn’t going quietly into the night.

Daylight brought some greater clarity to Arpaio’s tactics. 



Some 20 minutes before a group of union members planned to rally in the shadow of Maricopa County’s main courthouse on Wednesday, their colleagues in the sheriff’s office gave the green light to reopen the facility after it had been evacuated for a morning bomb threat.

The result was that the law-enforcement unions got an audience in the hundreds as crowds streamed back into the courthouse for afternoon proceedings. But more importantly, they go a much-larger platform to call on the Superior Court to release an officer jailed for defying a judge’s order.

“We demand that detention officer (Adam) Stoddard be freed and his record cleared,” shouted John Solano, the president of the Maricopa County Association of Detention Officers, as the crowd stared and listened.
When the deputies called in sick that morning, followed by a bomb threat that empties the courthouse, some questioned whether this was some union ploy.  That question’s been answered.  But the strategy remained unclear until Tom Liddy, putatively the deputy county attorney, took the stage and proved that the apple hasn’t rolled far from the tree.  Acting as if he’s the personal mouthpiece for Crazy Joe, he rallied the troops of deputies gathered in the courthouse plaza:



The attorney railed against what he called the “political war” that has been going on for the past year among Maricopa County’s elected leaders, judges and most-powerful appointed officials. But his comments focused mostly on the judiciary.

He echoed the sentiments of Stoddard’s colleagues who said the detention officer was “a victim” of the infighting.

“If you want to have your war on your own time, do it,” said Liddy, who used to have his own radio talk show and ran unsuccessfully for office before becoming a county lawyer. “But leave the people in uniform alone.”
No longer is this about Stoddard’s rifling through Joanne Cuccia’s file.  No longer is this about Crazy Joe’s people ignoring the law and doing as they please.  Arpaio has pulled one of the most successful pages from his playbook, and seeks to turn this into some political vendetta against him.  Arpaio’s the victim.  He’s just a good man fighting for the little people against the evil cabal of judges and elected officials who want to turn Maricopa County into a suburb of Tijuana, force the geriatrics to eat tacos and wear sombreros and make welfare the cash crop.

Don’t laugh.  It’s worked for Arpaio before.  Whether it’s recognized as absurd spin by his constituents may not be the point, as they may well care a lot more about keeping the Mexicans down than any vague notion of justice.  Remember, the threat that touches you personally is far more real than the one that only applies to the other guy.

And while this plays out, Adam Stoddard is holed up in the Mesa Hilton.  By now, he’s got to be on overtime.  Not a bad gig.

Lesson For Today: Terrorist Math

Though there has not been a single instance in the United States of a package left in a public place exploding and wreaking death and destruction following 9/11, our government has been fostering fear of the legendary “suspicious package” long enough for it to have found its way into the criminal law.  It’s a mainstay of posters on the New York City subway system, and has made its way to the halls of Purdue.

Via Radley Balko at Reason,


Last month, Purdue University student Roy Sun was arrested and charged with “terroristic mischief.” He could face up to eight years in prison. His crime? He got a little too pissed off about a parking ticket.

Sun got the ticket and had a boot put on his car after local parking officials discovered he was using a permit that didn’t belong to him. So Sun removed the boot, put it in a box with $20 (the amount of the fine) and the ticket, and put the box in the school’s Visitor’s Center, which also happens to be where students go to pay parking fines.

Mind you, Sun could have taken it all to the clerk who accepted fine payments, and who happened to be working when all this occurred, but chose instead to leave it in a wrapped box, tempting fate.  And fate bit him in the butt.  Sun’s stunt bought him a charge of terroristic mischief.


Police said terroristic mischief is when a person knowingly or intentionally places a device with the intent to cause a reasonable person to believe that it is a weapon of mass destruction.
Imagine, a college student who’s pissed off about a boot being placed on his car pulled a prank.  Of course, 9/11 changed everything, unless one considers a boot to fail the “device . . . [that] a reasonable person [would] believe is a weapon of mass destruction.” 

It’s not that Sun’s move was a smart one.  It wasn’t, under the circumstances.  But since when are college student pranks limited by being smart moves?  They weren’t when I was in college, but it got us a chewing out by the Dean of Student Misbehavior, not a criminal charge.  The worst that would happen is that we would be put on double secret probation.

It takes little effort to stick the word “terrorism” in front of any other word in the language of crime, but that doesn’t make it real.  Nor does the fact that some unduly sensitive receiver of congressional terrorism funding finally finds a use for its anti-terrorism weaponry give rise to an offense that somehow makes it an actual threat.  The problem is mathematical, with two competing equations:

Box + Unknown Contents = Bomb
Terrorist Funding + No Real Threat = Creating Threat Where None Exists

There was no threat here.  Whether there was even a purpose close to suggesting a threat is unclear, since Sun could just as well have decided that leaving his package in the hallway to be found by the clerk, rather than confronting the clerk, was the better choice.

But using fear of terrorism as the wedge to take any claimed offense and turn it into a potential terrorist threat is almost as goofy as making a billion people remove their shoes in airports because one nutjob tried (and failed) to put an explosive in his heel.  Not everything that potentially scares someone turns an act of mischief (at most) into an act of terrorism.  Let’s save the accusations for something real, and let’s remember that college kids do dumb stuff because they’re, well, college kids.


A Scholar Blogs: The Wrong Question

Over at Volokh Conspiracy, Orin Kerr admits that he’s evolved. 



Back in 2005 and 2006, a lot of law-professor bloggers wondered whether blog posts could and would serve as ways to advance scholarly ideas about law. At the time,  I was very skeptical :

Can blogs help advance legal scholarship? I think the answer is that they can, but that the format isn’t well-suited for the job…

Fast forward to the present, and I now think my old self was wrong. Or at least a bit off. I now think blogging actually does provide an effective way to present new scholarly ideas in many cases.


What Orin neglects to mention is that he, and Eugene and others at VC, are largely responsible for the seriousness with which the ideas offered in blogs are taken.  Other lawprof blogs have followed suit.  And, some might argue, have offered an idea or two themselves from time to time. 

But Orin’s measure of scholarship is the old standard, law review articles. 


The main reason my view has changed is that I think the legal academic culture has changed. In the past five years, legal blogs have become an acknowledged and accepted part of the world of legal scholarship. Exactly why is open to debate. It might be because more law professors are blogging. It might be because our experience has been that what profs say on their blogs is usually the same as what they say in their articles. Perhaps the new online journal supplements have blurred the traditional paper-vs-on-line distinction. Whatever the reason, there seems to be more of a convergence between scholarly blogging and “traditional” law review articles today than existed 4 or 5 years ago. That convergence encourages more scholarly blogging and recognizes its value.

The implicit, or maybe not so implicit, message is that scholarship is what’s written by lawprofs in law review articles, those tedious, footnote laden dinosaurs read by some student editors and maybe one or two other lawprofs, diehards in a niche looking for inspiration to write their own law review article perhaps?

As my buddy CharonQC would say, bollocks.  Scholarship isn’t what shows up in some moribund law review, but creative ideas subject to peer review.  That law journals were once the only game in town for the aspiring scholar to strut his stuff means nothing in a world where ideas can be floated before a jury of one’s peers without ever killing a tree.  Break free from the chains, brother.  And remember, it’s not like  real people read law review articles, not that lawprofs care.

The point is that it’s about the ideas, not the format.  A good idea in two paragraphs beats a good idea in two thousand any day.  And it’s a lot harder to do.  As my good buddy, Dan Hull, reminds:




I have made this letter longer–because I have not had the time to make it shorter.

—Blaise Pascal (1623-1662), mathematician, physicist, philosopher, in “Lettres Provinciales“, No. 16, 1657

Which leads inexorably to the next issue, already anticipated by Orin : the adoration of “complex and sophisticated words [to] create the impression of complex and sophisticated arguments.”  The point is to create the appearance of brilliant scholarship when the substance is lacking.  Ann Althouse calls it the “obfuscation” of ideas that could be presented “crisply and simply,” and takes up too much time to interpret.  Big words do not scholarship make.  It’s the ideas, and ideas are no more constrained by $10 words than by law reviews.

But that doesn’t mean that every blog by a lawprof qualifies as scholarship.  Not because it can’t, but because it doesn’t.  Some provide remarkably little in the “idea” category, more like squibs about cute or funny news without any commentary, deep or not,   Others provide a stream of news within a very narrow niche, along the lines of “isn’t this interesting.”  Informative, but not scholarship. 

At the same time, one can even find scholarship in trench lawyer blogs, like this post by Mark Bennett.  Is it heresy to suggest that lawyers have ideas worthy of note?  I think not.

Blogs are merely a delivery mechanism.  That they are too brief, and usually too clearly written, to meet the approval of students who determine what writings end up in the next volume of a law review is only meaningful if one concludes that the medium is more important than the message.

There is, however, one huge distinguishing factor differentiating blogs from law reviews.  People read blogs. 

Mistrial Number 4 For John Gotti

People often ask, just how many times can a person be tried in federal court if the jury is unable to reach a verdict?  The United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York is pondering that same question today, after the jury in John Gotti, Jr.’s fourth trial deadlocked and Judge Kevin Castel declared a mistrial.


The government, meanwhile, which had charged Mr. Gotti with racketeering and murder conspiracy, released a statement saying that it had not yet decided whether to pursue a fifth trial. Elie Honig, the lead prosecutor in the case, took the gentlemanly step of wishing Mr. Gotti well on his future and warmly shaking his hand.

That’s very nice of Honig.  It should always be so gentlemanly when you get to mistrial number four.  But it’s time to put this to rest.  Four tries is more than enough.  They should have stopped after two.  The Southern District has not only embarrassed itself by its persistence, but would be unable to obtain a credible verdict in any event.  Try someone enough times and the law of averages suggests that eventually you will get a conviction.  But that won’t convince the rest of us.


“The evidence was just not there to prosecute the guy,” said one of the jurors, all of whom remained anonymous. Others said they did not believe the government’s chief witness, John Alite, a confessed hit man and a former member of Mr. Gotti’s crew.

I could have told the government that.  In fact, I did.


The jurors’ sharpest words came when they were asked if the government should retry Mr. Gotti. No, they said resoundingly— the only unanimous verdict they had reached.

“They should stop this now — it’s ridiculous,” said one of the jurors, a middle-aged man. Another juror, a woman, said of the prosecution: “It’s abusive. It’s almost become a mockery.”


The juror is almost right.  It’s already a mockery. 

The Worst Kept Secret: Cops Lie

It will come as a shock to no one to learn that cops lie sometimes.  It’s the sort of thing that everyone seems to know, from the New York Times when it published its “testilying” series back in 1994 to anyone who’s seen the Patrick Pogan video of cyclist Christian Long getting knocked off his bike onto his critical mass.

Everyone, it seems, except judges.  Whether to maintain their pristine impartiality, or to make their job easier by going with the odds, judges have managed to ignore what’s long been obvious to everyone else, within and without the system.  Cops lies.  Not all the time, but a lot.  Not about everything, but about enough.

Detectives Henry Tavarez and Stephen Anderson lied when they claimed that Maximo and Joe Colon sold them cocaine at Club Delicias de Mi Terra.  There was a video camera that told the truth.  How did we ever survive without video?  You see, cops never lied before there was video.  We know because there was no evidence to prove that every word out of police officer’s mouth wasn’t true.  Hence, they never lied.  Now they do.

The Colon brothers sued the New York City, and the City moved to dismiss.  Unfortunately for the City, the case went to Judge Jack Weinstein, who’s been on the bench forever and knows that he’s never going to be appointed to the Supreme Court.  That leaves him free to make rulings that younger judges might not want to make.  He’s the Bobby McGhee of the Eastern District. 

Judge Weinstein denied the motion, but took it a step further.  From the New York Daily News :


Informal inquiry by [myself] and among the judges of this court, as well as knowledge of cases in other federal and state courts … has revealed anecdotal evidence of repeated, widespread falsification by arresting officers of the New York City Police Department,

It’s as if the judges were all whispering to each other in the judges’ lounge about it.  But Judge Weinstein let the cat out of the bag.


The judge said that despite better training for recruits and tough disciplinary action for bad cops, “there is some evidence of an attitude among officers that is sufficiently widespread to constitute a custom or policy by the city approving illegal conduct.”
For those of us working in the trenches, or chronicling the cases of false testimony, this makes it sound almost trivial.  But the fact that Judge Weinstein wrote the words “widespread falsification” in his four page decision is huge.  It’s not the first time a judge has found that a cop lied, and it’s unlikely to cause a seismic shift in judges rejecting the testimony of police officers wholesale.  The odds still favor the cops, and judges know it.  But still, he went beyond the “isolated incident” language that has long marked the judiciary’s adventures in fantasy.

It’s unlikely that we will ever have a judge opine that there has never been a single trial where a law enforcement officer didn’t give false testimony, to some greater or lesser extent.  Whether to fill in the gaps, exaggerate a detail or present an accusation made of whole cloth, testimony that is 100% truthful and accurate is the zebra in the courtroom.  I’m sure it happens, but very, very rarely.  That doesn’t mean the defendant didn’t do it, but as Murray Kempton liked to say, “there they go again, framing the guilty.”

This decision is the product of the confluence of two things, the existence of a videotape proving that the detectives were lying and a judge who is old and bold enough to not care whether anybody likes his decisions or not.  There are bold young judges too, but a ruling like this is a career killer.  Most young judges aspire to higher position, and don’t love our defendants as much as they love their families and themselves. 

Had there been no video conclusively proving the lie, a conclusion like this would be taken as proof that Judge Weinstein is just utterly biased against cops.  Without video, there can be no lie.  Just like without DNA, there can be no innocence.  The cops need only have their testimony; we need hard proof.  A credibility tie always goes to the cops.  Actually, any testimonial pissing match always goes to the cops. Unless there is video.  At least that’s how the odds have always played out in court up to now.

This is a step forward in the battle against testilying, though not one that will inure to any particular defendant’s benefit.  It will cause a few right-minded judges to come to grips in their own minds with the fact that it’s now out in the open that cops lie.  Other judges won’t care at all.  But every journey begins with a single step, and Judge Weinstein has taken that step here.

H/T Packratt at Injustice Everywhere

No One Left To Honor (Update)

It’s been years since anyone at the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers gave any thought to why the association was formed, why it exists, what purpose it serves.  It’s slogged along, from scandal to pointlessness, collecting its rather steep dues from lawyers who have some vague sense that they ought to belong, because of the name if nothing else.

If other criminal defense lawyers want to piss their money away on the NACDL, on wedding dresses and match.com for the former executive director, on a listserv where answers require the purchase of Gary Muldoon’s commission-paid book, on a paid lobbyist who duplicates the efforts of other organizations yet has accomplished nothing, so be it.  It’s no skin off my nose.

The one redeeming feature of the NYSACDL was the Annual Dinner, a chance to see old friends, talk shop and enjoy the camaraderie of trench lawyers.  Historically, the association gave out awards at the dinner to either the biggest names it could get it’s hands on as a draw, or to those who would bring in a couple of tables of paying guests.  Either way, it was all about money, but at least the choices gave a hat tip to the association’s putative purpose by honoring criminal defense lawyers and judges.

No more.  Proudly displayed on the front page of the NYSACDL website is the anouncement for this year’s main honoree.
 

NYSACDL ANNUAL DINNER 

JANUARY 28, 2010

MARRIOTT FINANCIAL CENTER HOTEL

NEW YORK, NEW YORK. 

Honoring

ROBERT M. MORGENTHAU

Life Time Achievement Award


For anyone unaware, Bob Morgenthau is the legendary District Attorney of New York County.  Morgy is retiring, and his job is going to former prosecutor turned criminal defense lawyer turned prosecutor, Cy Vance.   It’s not that Morgy wasn’t a great District Attorney.  If there was a DA Hall of Fame, no doubt he would be in it.  But this is the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and they are honoring the fellow whose life time achievement is prosecuting people.

Are there no criminal defense lawyers worthy of being the primary honoree?  No judges who’ve done anything worth noting?  Or has the incoming president lost all sight of why this association exists, preferring instead to bask in the glow of greatness, even if it’s the warmth of the prosecutor?

Will the tables around the banquet room be filled with prosecutors, there to honor their mentor?  The NYSACDL had but one hard and fast rule, no prosecutors allowed.  Apparently, that’s fallen by the wayside.  Perhaps they want to hobnob with the assistants in the hope of getting a better deal on some quickie plea?  Maybe they believe that prosecutors are more important than criminal defense lawyers, and want to enhance the dinner with their official presence?  Maybe George Goltzer wants to get his picture taken with Morgenthau so he can put it on his wall and impress people?

There is much to commend Robert Morgenthau, who served with honor and distinction.  But he has no place being honored by the NYSACDL.  Believe me, the District Attorneys Association isn’t going to honor a defense lawyer.

To call this a slap in the face to criminal defense lawyers is to trivialize the significance of this choice.  While criminal defense lawyers across the nation stand up for what’s right at grave personal risk, the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers has chosen instead to bend over and kiss prosecutorial butt.  This is a disgrace and an insult to every criminal defense lawyer in New York and elsewhere. 

Update:  Having heard from numerous folks on the subject, it appears that war has broken out within the association between those who are utterly dismayed by the unilateral decision to ignore, yet again, the exceptional work done by criminal defense lawyers in New York in favor of honoring Morgey, not to mention the absence of a Brennan Award winner (given to a judge) this year and Marshall Award winner, which was initially to be given to a very worthy member of the association but (although the name has now been deleted from the award recipients) will now go to a Biglaw firm for its pro bono work.

It’s not that the Biglaw firm is unworthy of recognition.  It is indeed very worthy.  But is there not a single criminal defense lawyer in the State of New York who is a member of the association worthy of its recognition?  Of course there is. But worthy or not, the NYSACDL won’t give it to you.  You may be worthy, but you’re not important enough to make the cut.

More interesting are the reactions.  Some are shocked by this mess.  Others are appalled by those who are shocked, breaking the tradition of sweeping all nastiness under the rug so members don’t see how the sausage is made and the association can perpetuate its carefully crafted appearance of righteousness.  The adage, sunlight is the best disinfectant, comes to mind, but cockroaches just scatter when the light shines on them, and come back out as soon as the light goes away.  If the members can’t be bothered to figure out why those who send out their dues bills show them no respect, then they get the association they deserve.