Judge Gary Donahoe took a wild chance when he ruled in the case of Adam Stoddard, court detention officer in Maricopa County who was caught rifling through defense lawyer Joanne Cuccia’s file on video that Stoddard, who works under Sheriff Joe Arpaio. Donahoe held Stoddard in contempt and ordered him to make a “sincere apology” or go to jail.
Initially, Donahoe shifted the burden of making the call on the apology to Cuccia, but he quickly realized the error of his ways and amended his decision, shifting the burden back onto his own shoulders. With the November 30 deadline looming, Deputy County Attorney Tom Liddy sought to delay the inevitable, but Donahoe refused his request.
At about 8:30 p.m. local time, Adam Stoddard took to the courthouse plaza for a press conference. He issued this statement:
Was there any doubt that it would come to this?I am Maricopa County Detention Officer Adam Stoddard. I work in the Court Security Division of the Sheriff’s Office and have been with the Sheriff’s Office for five years.
Recently, Superior Court Judge Gary Donahoe ordered me to hold a press conference to publicly apologize for doing the job I have been trained to do.
Part of my job in providing security to the court is to inspect documents brought into the courtroom. On October 19th, I saw a document that I had not yet screened, and that raised security concerns. I retrieved that document in plain sight and had court personnel copy it to preserve it as evidence in case it was a security breach.
It was a split second decision and I do not regret my actions.
Judge Donahoe has ordered me to feel something I do not and say something I cannot. I cannot apologize for putting court safety first.
This is a constitutional crisis, and one long past due. It’s unlikely that Judge Gary Donahoe decided that this case, this decision, this moment in time was when he would pit the integrity of the judicial branch of government against the firepower of Sheriff Joe Arpaio, but that’s exactly what he’s done. It’s might versus right.
Sheriff Joe has run Maricopa County as a fiefdom. It’s no secret, and he’s not without the support of the serfs for his bizarre personal view of what the guys with guns should do. Arpaio is the Lord of the Flies. It’s not that he hasn’t had his run-ins with the courts before, but the results have always been to buy his way out of trouble on the taxpayers’ dime. And enough of the taxpayers have been willing to pay for Arpaio’s trespasses to keep him in business.
He can’t buy his way out of this one. There’s no cash alternative.
Stoddard’s carefully crafted statement, while brazen, is not entirely wrong. If he doesn’t regret his conduct, then he would be incapable of a sincere apology. The notion of ordering someone to be sincere is itself dubious, given that people will believe whatever they believe. They can’t be ordered to believe otherwise.
But that shouldn’t give rise to a misunderstanding of Donahoe’s order. He didn’t order Stoddard to be sincere. He offered Stoddard an opportunity to purge himself of the contempt. The punishment is jail, and the apology was the key to the cell door. It was entirely Stoddard’s choice, or Arpaio’s according to how you prefer to look at it, whether he sought to avail himself of the opportunity. The choice has been made.
On the other hand, it’s not up to Stoddard whether his conduct was proper. It’s not up to Arpaio either, assuming one accepts the premise that there is a higher authority in Maricopa County than Sheriff Joe. Judge Gary Donahoe has drawn a line, not in sand but concrete. It’s been crossed. Now what?
It’s time to execute judgment. Who will take Adam Stoddard into custody? Judge Donahoe has no army, no gang of men with guns to do his bidding. He commands only words, and relies on the force brought to bear by Sheriff Joe to give meaning to his words. While the sheriff might be happy to comply when he agrees with the court, he’s not the sort of guy who is inclined to take directions with which he disagrees. If he doesn’t do his job at the command of the judge, and no reasonable person suspects he will, then who will seize Adam Stoddard and take him into custody?
If no one, then the system is revealed to be at the mercy of the Lord of the Flies. Is there a judicial branch of government in Maricopa County, or does Sheriff Joe own the place? Today should tell.
Maricopa County Superior Court spokeswoman Karen Arra said Adam Stoddard must report to the 4th Avenue Jail in downtown Phoenix or face arrest after he was ordered to apologize to a Phoenix attorney Monday night.
Update 2: According to the Phoenix New Times, Sheriff Joe Arpaio announced that Adam Stoddard will surrender to jail today.
“My officer will surrender,” Arpaio said during a news conference, adding that he wouldn’t say exactly where officer Adam Stoddard will be, because of security concerns.
Arpaio claims Donahoe has a “vendetta” against him and will soon release information about the judge that proves it. “For political reasons, [Stoddard’s] been thrown to the wolves,” Arpaio said.
Update 3: This just in from Nick Martin, Adam Stoddard reported to jail, but the Sheriffs Deputies refused to book him, claiming a clerical error. Word is that he will try again tomorrow. Maybe.
Update 4: Again, per Nick Martin, despite being told to go home, Stoddard chose to spend the night at the jail anyway, even though he’s not booked in as a prisoner. No word on whether he got the presidential suite.
