Author Archives: SHG

Showdown in Maricopa (Update x 4; Stoddard Spends Night in Jail Voluntarily)

The executive branch of government controls law enforcement.  The legislative branch funds law enforcement.  The judicial branch depends upon the kindness of strangers, and it doesn’t get any stranger than this. 

Judge Gary Donahoe took a wild chance when he ruled in the case of Adam Stoddard, court detention officer in Maricopa County who was caught rifling through defense lawyer Joanne Cuccia’s file on video that Stoddard, who works under Sheriff Joe Arpaio.  Donahoe held Stoddard in contempt and ordered him to make a “sincere apology” or go to jail. 

Initially, Donahoe shifted the burden of making the call on the apology to Cuccia, but he quickly realized the error of his ways and amended his decision, shifting the burden back onto his own shoulders.  With the November 30 deadline looming, Deputy County Attorney Tom Liddy sought to delay the inevitable, but Donahoe refused his request.

At about 8:30 p.m. local time, Adam Stoddard took to the courthouse plaza for a press conference. He issued this statement:



I am Maricopa County Detention Officer Adam Stoddard. I work in the Court Security Division of the Sheriff’s Office and have been with the Sheriff’s Office for five years.


Recently, Superior Court Judge Gary Donahoe ordered me to hold a press conference to publicly apologize for doing the job I have been trained to do.


Part of my job in providing security to the court is to inspect documents brought into the courtroom. On October 19th, I saw a document that I had not yet screened, and that raised security concerns. I retrieved that document in plain sight and had court personnel copy it to preserve it as evidence in case it was a security breach.


It was a split second decision and I do not regret my actions.


Judge Donahoe has ordered me to feel something I do not and say something I cannot. I cannot apologize for putting court safety first.
Was there any doubt that it would come to this? 

This is a constitutional crisis, and one long past due.  It’s unlikely that Judge Gary Donahoe decided that this case, this decision, this moment in time was when he would pit the integrity of the judicial branch of government against the firepower of Sheriff Joe Arpaio, but that’s exactly what he’s done.  It’s might versus right.

Sheriff Joe has run Maricopa County as a fiefdom.  It’s no secret, and he’s not without the support of the serfs for his bizarre personal view of what the guys with guns should do.  Arpaio is the Lord of the Flies.  It’s not that he hasn’t had his run-ins with the courts before, but the results have always been to buy his way out of trouble on the taxpayers’ dime.  And enough of the taxpayers have been willing to pay for Arpaio’s trespasses to keep him in business.

He can’t buy his way out of this one.  There’s no cash alternative. 

Stoddard’s carefully crafted statement, while brazen, is not entirely wrong.  If he doesn’t regret his conduct, then he would be incapable of a sincere apology.  The notion of ordering someone to be sincere is itself dubious, given that people will believe whatever they believe.  They can’t be ordered to believe otherwise. 

But that shouldn’t give rise to a misunderstanding of Donahoe’s order.  He didn’t order Stoddard to be sincere.  He offered Stoddard an opportunity to purge himself of the contempt.  The punishment is jail, and the apology was the key to the cell door.  It was entirely Stoddard’s choice, or Arpaio’s according to how you prefer to look at it, whether he sought to avail himself of the opportunity.  The choice has been made.

On the other hand, it’s not up to Stoddard whether his conduct was proper.  It’s not up to Arpaio either, assuming one accepts the premise that there is a higher authority in Maricopa County than Sheriff Joe.  Judge Gary Donahoe has drawn a line, not in sand but concrete.  It’s been crossed.  Now what?

It’s time to execute judgment.  Who will take Adam Stoddard into custody?  Judge Donahoe has no army, no gang of men with guns to do his bidding.  He commands only words, and relies on the force brought to bear by Sheriff Joe to give meaning to his words.  While the sheriff might be happy to comply when he agrees with the court, he’s not the sort of guy who is inclined to take directions with which he disagrees.  If he doesn’t do his job at the command of the judge, and no reasonable person suspects he will, then who will seize Adam Stoddard and take him into custody?

If no one, then the system is revealed to be at the mercy of the Lord of the Flies.  Is there a judicial branch of government in Maricopa County, or does Sheriff Joe own the place?  Today should tell.


H/T Nick Martin at Heat City and Jeff Gamso.

Update:  The first shot has been fired:


Maricopa County Superior Court spokeswoman Karen Arra said Adam Stoddard must report to the 4th Avenue Jail in downtown Phoenix or face arrest after he was ordered to apologize to a Phoenix attorney Monday night.

It whizzed across the bow.  Upon information and belief, Stoddard was eating a warm, nutricious breakfast of Cap’n Crunch and grits and watching Sponge Bob Square Pants, so he missed the morning news. Stay tuned.

Update 2:  According to the Phoenix New Times, Sheriff Joe Arpaio announced that Adam Stoddard will surrender to jail today.


“My officer will surrender,” Arpaio said during a news conference, adding that he wouldn’t say exactly where officer Adam Stoddard will be, because of security concerns. 

However, Arpaio also contends that this situation arose because of Judge Donahoe’s feelings toward him:



Arpaio claims Donahoe has a “vendetta” against him and will soon release information about the judge that proves it. “For political reasons, [Stoddard’s] been thrown to the wolves,” Arpaio said.

Arpaio has a long history of blaming problems caused by his over-reaching on political enemies, and usually follows up by alleging criminal conduct on his enemies part.  Apparently, even Sheriff Joe wasn’t prepared to test his power head to head with the court system, preferring instead to use more time-tested methods.

Update 3:  This just in from Nick Martin, Adam Stoddard reported to jail, but the Sheriffs Deputies refused to book him, claiming a clerical error.  Word is that he will try again tomorrow.  Maybe.

Update 4:  Again, per Nick Martin, despite being told to go home, Stoddard chose to spend the night at the jail anyway, even though he’s not booked in as a prisoner.  No word on whether he got the presidential suite.

Tainting Tiger (Update)

The initial reaction to the Tiger crash was a great joke :  So what club did she use?  Yeah, I laughed at that one too.

But a couple of days later, a few missed meetings with the cops, and suddenly it’s not so funny.  Why?  Because Tiger has  a criminal defense lawyer, Mark Nejame.  This makes him a bad Tiger?

As Miami criminal defense lawyer Brian Tannebaum speculated, it was likely that Tiger was being advised by his regular lawyers, not to mention his flack, his housekeeper and an assortment of golf pros, about what to do with the cop before it dawned on one or more of these learned folks that they didn’t have a clue what they were talking about.  Not that this stops a lawyer from giving advice, but the best minds in a room of clueless people is hardly a substitute for one knowledgeable person.

Since this was all about how to deal with the police, it was only natural that the right type of lawyer for such advice would be a criminal defense lawyer.  And it only took a few days for his regular guys to come up with the idea.  And so Tiger’s now been informed that he’s under no duty to speak to police.  As in, when they ask you to come in, have your lawyer say, “thank you, but no.”  That’s all the advice he needs, for now at least.

But why is it that by dint of going to a lawyer whose practice is in a niche that renders him competent to give advice on the subject of how best to address the police, Tiger has become tainted? 

It’s much like going to a psychiatrist, even though people want to pretend that it’s not.  The mere fact that you need the help of a mental health professional carried a stigma; you were nuts.  It’s politically incorrect to still think this, though most people still do.  To avoid this stigma, nutty people refuse to go see a shrink, as if everyone around them hasn’t already noticed that they’re nuts.

Being represented by a criminal defense lawyer carries a similar stigma.  If you didn’t do something wrong, why would you need a criminal defense lawyer?  Of course, if you have nothing to hide, why won’t you let cops search your car?  It’s a great game to play, but also one with both an obvious answer and a dangerous downside.  You consult with a criminal defense lawyer because your civil lawyer doesn’t have a clue what to do, is inclined to do the worst possible thing because of the combination of fear and ignorance, and doesn’t want to lose the opportunity to get his name in the paper and another decent fee.

Criminal defense lawyers deal with police.  We know what people are obliged to do as well as what they need not do.  The police, who want nothing more than to question anybody that interests them, are not a fine source of advice, any more than the civil lawyers.  I can’t remember how many times defendants told me that they asked the cops during the interrogation whether they should have a lawyer present. Somehow, the cops never think it’s necessary.

Even worse than the civil lawyer is the flack, whose only concern is how things will play out in the media.  “But it won’t look good for you if you don’t meet with the police, Tig.”  And it won’t look good if he’s arrested based on his statements to the police either, but the latter will go on much longer than the former.  Flacks tend to be more concerned with appearance than reality. 

Tiger Woods makes a darn good living, and can afford to get some decent legal advice.  Whether he’s chosen his advisers wisely is beyond me, as I’ve known some very wealthy people who listen to some very bad advice.  But that aside, turning to a criminal defense lawyer for advice on how to deal with questioning by police is not only a good decision, but the only one that would potentially provide him with the information necessary to make a reasoned decision.  If he had asked me, I would have told him that there was absolutely nothing to be gained by speaking to the police.  Don’t do it.

For those who believe that having a criminal defense lawyer somehow makes Tiger look “guilty” of something, remember that his choices were limited to a bunch of legal advisers who lacked the competency to help or a criminal defense lawyer, the only practice area that could provide him with sound, competent legal advice.  It doesn’t mean his “guilty” of anything except good judgment.

Update:  By way of contrast, White House party crashers Michaele and Tareq Salahi have retained counsel too.  Their choice, however, isn’t a criminal defense lawyers, but an entertainment lawyer, Paul Gardner.  Who made the better choice?  Time will tell.

Four Cops Dead (Update x 2)

When the news broke, it was just a horrible, terrible story about four police officers, sitting in a coffee shop preparing for their daily patrol.  Slaughtered.  Moments ago in this still-breaking story, reports that the “person of interest” in the murders, Maurice Clemmons, is either cornered or dead.*

Much will be made in the near future, assuming that Clemmons is the shooter, about how Mike Huckabee cut him a break, and how that break ended with four dead cops.  This “Willie Horton” redux will be the fodder of political pundits, and won’t be discussed here.  It will likely be the basis for a new round of fear-induced sanctions designed to keep people locked up forever and ever, ignoring that this is huge news because of its oddity rather than normalcy. 

But it’s always the one-off situations that get American’s twisted, the message never being clear to a fearful and angry public.  Perhaps there will be someone commenting here on this aspect, using a mix of words in all caps to prove how emphatic they are.  Nutjobs always like to put important words in all caps to make their point.  They think it makes them more convincing.

But while most of the media and blawgosphere will deal with these aspects of this horrible situation, I’m going to be more than a bit opportunistic and use this to pursue a collateral point, one that I’ve been harping on lately.  Assuming that Clemmons survives to be prosecuted for these murders, he will be represented a lawyer. 

There is little known at this moment that militates in the shooter’s favor.  There is little that can explain away the murder of these four police officers.  Some will be inclined to speculate about what drove Clemmons to fire, but such speculation is a fool’s game.  No matter how miserable his upbringing, no matter how hard the trauma to his head, there is no justice to be found in Clemmons’ deed.  And yet he will be represented by a lawyer.

Chances are pretty good that the lawyer who finds him or herself defending Clemmons will be reviled, just as Clemmons will be reviled.  If the lawyer is smart, he or she will keep his mouth shut and his head low.  Nobody wants to hear platitudes uttered over the coffins of the dead cops.  Don’t tell me, “but they’re true, they’re true.”  That’s the sort of myopia that brings hatred and ridicule down upon us.  If criminal defense lawyers can’t grasp their function, how can we expect others to do so? 

The time will come for the lawyer to do his job.  What the strategy will be, what tactics will work, has yet to be seen.  But the criminal defense lawyer will be charged with making the tough decisions and carrying them out.  And if there’s a way, a gap, a mistake, a hole, that will enable that lawyer to walk the man who murdered four police officers out of the courtroom, then that’s what he or she must do.

If Clemmons is guilty as sin, if Clemmons’ commission of the crime can be proven, there will be no abstract justice to be found here.  Those who need to wrap themselves up in platitudes so that they won’t feel dirty and disgusting will be left to shiver.  But a criminal defense lawyer, a real one, will walk into that courtroom, stand beside the man who murdered four cops, and defend him.

In an interesting juxtaposition, Ron Coleman posted about the ugly advertisement by Texas lawyers Lindeman, Alvarado & Frye,  Ron wrote:


But the choices made in these ads completely undermines that bona fide prospective, mainly because in the graphic, hyper-realistic and borderline pornographic pictures, the crimes being referred to are really happening.

Guess what, law firm?  People who have been wrongfully accused of these acts, or who desperately want the world (including the justice system) to believe the accusation is wrong, want to be represented by the lawyers who only have innocent clients.

While Ron disclaims the imprecision of his statement (though it’s unclear to me what he means even by that), the gist of this post demonstrates how little lawyers outside our niche, even great lawyers like Ron (an IP lawyer, by the way), understand what we do.  Any firm who promoted itself as defending only the innocent would be either out of business or a laughingstock.  This is a fantasy promoted by people who can’t begin to imagine representing those people.  Of course, they have their own flavor of “those people,” but take for granted that it’s different for them because, well, that’s what they do. 

Prosecutor and former defense lawyer Ken Lammers says we are noble and do serve justice.


Defense attorneys seek justice. It’s not the straight forward justice that prosecutors enjoy. It’s a more esoteric form. Defense attorneys advocate for short term injustice and in the process they assure societal justice in the longer term. That’s either seeking justice or having it occur as an unintended, collateral consequence.
Ignore him.  He’s a prosecutor just blowing smoke to make us feel better about ourselves.  We’re part of a system of justice, and so what we do is serve justice (in some esoteric way).  Obviously, or they wouldn’t let criminal defense lawyers into the courthouse to annoy the government.  But if you need to go beyond the generic raison d’être, you’re screwed.  Especially if you need to believe that our system produces justice.  It’s just a name we call it, because system of incarceration sounds so cynical. 

If you feel compelled to ask yourself “why?” do it just once before you decide to take your first criminal case and never ask it again.  Almost everyone  in the United States of America will agree that Maurice Clemmons is evil and must be punished.  At least one person will stand beside him and defend him.  That person will be a criminal defense lawyer, because that’s what we do.

*Update:  Latest word is that after a 12 hour stand-off, Clemmons was not to be found.

Update 2:  Maurice Clemmons has been shot dead.  No criminal defense lawyer will stand beside him.  The police are certain that he was the shooter.  I have no reason to think otherwise.  Let’s hope they’re right.

How Not To Have An Impact On The Jury

Via Dan Hull at What About Clients?, a rather bizarre little story about Kansas lawyer Sam Kepfield’s attempt to make a point.


Lawyer Sam Kepfield pulled the dud grenade out to make a point in a forgery and theft case against a Hutchinson, Kan., woman.


The Hutchinson News reports that Kepfield set the grenade on a ledge in front of jurors, then moved it to the prosecutor’s table. He reportedly pulled the pin from the grenade and asked jurors, “Are you afraid now?”


“I was trying to demonstrate what’s called an imminent threat,” Kepfield told the paper.

There was no objection and the presiding judge simply asked that Kepfield remove the grenade from the table. Kepfield’s client was convicted following 15 minutes of jury deliberations, according to the Hutchinson News.


The use of demonstrative evidence is often promoted as a wonderful way to make a concrete point when conceptual arguments fly over the heads of the jurors.  It’s not without limits, however.

We’re often caught between a rock and a hard place in trying to come up with ways to make clear to jurors, who may or may not be capable of understanding arguments,   We fear that we won’t be understood, so try to come up with a way to make our argument absolutely clear.  So clear that no one could possibly miss it.

For reasons unknown, Sam Kepfield thought the grenade analogy would do the trick.  And it may well have been the perfect way to show what is meant by “imminent threat.”  But it ‘s impossible to ignore two things:  First, the jury returned a guilty verdict in 15 minutes, and second, Kepfield got himself in a heap of trouble for his efforts.



District Attorney Keith Schroeder intends to also alert the Kansas attorney general’s office.

“Clearly, I’m concerned about the situation and the safety of my employees, and I’m concerned about the way the jury’s treated,” Schroeder said.
One might wonder why, given that the grenade was a dud, the district attorney can still raise a legitimate issue of safety.  The answer is that Kepfield might have believed the grenade to be a dud, and it turned out that his belief was correct.  But then again, he couldn’t be sure that the grenade wasn’t live, even if just a little bit, until he pulled the pin.  Anybody crazy enough to use a grenade to make his point might not be sufficiently trustworthy to be certain that it wouldn’t explode.

This isn’t a condemnation of demonstrative evidence, or even a suggestion that the use of props to help the conceptually-challenged to understand a point isn’t something worth considering.  Just don’t scare the crap out of the jury, judge and prosecutor in the process.  Think long and hard before you place something on the rail that will strike fear in the hearts of the men and women who will be deciding your client’s fate.  While they may take jury duty seriously, they are unlikely to be prepared to die for it.

Comments, Plan B

People approach blawg comments very differently.  Some write them out, edit them, review them, send them around for approval from their friends, and then cut and paste them into the comment section.  They probably spend more time than I do writing.  Others write the first thing that pops into their head, no thought, preparation or revision.  Either way, they show up, and the author lives with the consequences.

It’s my guess that a number of people who posted comments in the past week would, in retrospect, have preferred that they hadn’t.  Whether because they were posted in the heat of passion, or just seemed like a good idea at the time, they weren’t received as well as the authors thought they would be.  The typical reaction, when things don’t go as planned, is to persist in pushing the argument, more often than not resulting in the situation getting worse and, all too often, embarrassing.  The old adage, when you’re in a hole, stop digging, comes to mind.  This is a tough lesson.

I occasionally look at a comment I’ve written and find, after reflection, that it’s unclear, not what I meant to say or just wrong and/or stupid.  But I have an advantage that others here don’t.  I have the keys to the blawg, and can revise my comments at will.  It’s unfair to everyone else, of course, but that’s the blawger’s prerogative, and I have no plans on giving it up. 

That said, I receive the occasional email from someone who has posted a comment which the author later decides is something they wish they hadn’t.  I completely understand.  Provided that the comment hasn’t generated replies, I will usually accommodate a request to remove or amend someone’s comment.  The comments aren’t intended to be a game of gotcha, and revising one’s thoughts is a normal and natural occurrence. 

I’m not talking here about a typo or improper tense.  Anyone who makes a big deal of trivial errors like that in a comment is a jerk.  Everybody gets a free pass on such mistakes in the comments, so don’t even bother asking me to correct them.  This is a blawg, not an appellate brief. And I have no plans on being your personal secretary or spellchecker.  Heck, I won’t even do that for myself.

But when you do what I do, post a comment that in retrospect does not reflect what you believe or mean, I want to offer you the opportunity to take it back.  Of course, I can’t do this once the conversation following a comment has grown around it.  That would be unfair to those who’ve relied on the comment and moved forward.  Once people reply, the best you can do is explain yourself.  And if you wrote in haste and realize that your comment is wrong, it wouldn’t hurt to say so.  Most people respect someone who admits a mistake rather than just keeps digging.

This isn’t to say that I plan to give everyone a mulligan.  If you’ve put a controversial point out there which reflects your position, but are later embarrassed by the fact that reveals that you suffer from some serious personality defect, don’t expect me to sanitize it.  But I will try to be a little more user friendly when appropriate.  Too many comments lately will come back to haunt their authors in ways they may not really deserve.  I’m just trying to help.

Sorry, No Justice Today

The very first post at Simple Justice, dated February 13, 2008, was about “justice”.  And still it’s a subject of discussion.  It’s one of the primary concerns of the young lawyer, not because they are stupid or malevolent (or brilliant and well-intended, as the case may be), but because they have a need to believe that they are serving a higher purpose. 

It’s understandable that lawyers want to believe that there’s a higher purpose to what they do.  Who doesn’t?  And it’s certainly understandable that non-lawyers want to think of our work as falling on the side of justice, as it’s particularly hard to justify what we do if it serves an unjust purpose.  Of course, detractors of criminal defense lawyers see it exactly that way, unjustifiable.

Jeff Gamso, who has worked this side of the road for a while, posted about this following mine, and then posted a follow-up, which addresses two questions, whether there is or should be crimes that are so repugnant to a criminal defense lawyer that he wouldn’t touch them, and what constitutes that higher purpose that inexperienced lawyers need to justify themselves.


I don’t doubt for a moment that the role (and maybe it’s that I don’t view it as a “job” but as a calling) serves a higher good than just the client’s interest. I think there’s nothing nobler in the law, and little nobler outside it, than to advocate for and serve the criminally accused and the criminally convicted. Unlike Scott, I have yet to find the category of person I won’t willingly represent (the Bernie Madoff’s of the world might be it, but they’ve never come knocking). When I say that I represent _______, I’m proud to be able to say it. And to mean it.

That IS the higher purpose. To stand beside the reviled. To say here I am. You only get to him through me. I am the bulwark against the system and against the power of the government. If there’s justice at the end, it’s incidental, and I’m not working for it. (And, by the way, opposing injustice – whatever that might be – isn’t the same as pursuing justice – whatever that might be.)

Jeff is correct on both issues.  My decision not to represent people who sexually abuse children isn’t a point of pride on my part, but a failing.  I am so repulsed that I do not believe I can fulfil my duty, and I believe that fulfulling me duty is paramount.  In other words, my refusal to represent is a fault on my part.  That I refuse is the best I can do to avoid taking a case and then failing to fulfill my duty. 

What disturbs me still is that the message isn’t getting across, and instead is twisted, then twisted again, by the stubborn and entitled justice-needy lawyer. Jeff has been clear as a bell. So have I.  So have many other experienced lawyers. This has proven of no consequence to the justice-needy lawyer, who, despite his dearth of experience, insists that this is consistent with his personal vision of morality and justice, which means that it really is about justice all along.

In a comment to Jeff’s post, John Kindley, a very bright young lawyer despite his rather extreme political views, murders a whole bunch of words in the effort to show that he’s not a bad fit as a criminal defense lawyer.  Kindley has become something of a poster boy for the Slackoisie, though not because he’s afraid of hard work.  It’s about his narcissism, as demonstrated by the fact that five out of 6 paragraphs begin with the word “I”, and the sixth prefaces “I’m” with “In short,” a phrase that has no place in his writing.  It’s about his entitlement, as shown by his noting that he’s the least experienced lawyer in the discussion, yet insists that his opinion is entitled to predominance.  But as a poster boy, Kindley reflects the future of criminal defense, and thus is best not ignored as mere foolish ramblings.


In short, I’m very cognizant of the injustice perpetrated at every turn by the State against defendants. Therefore, while part of the intent of the “formula” is to remind prosecutors that they should be seeking justice and not simply as many convictions and the harshest punishments they can get, in my experience they only occasionally really do. In the cases that have meant the most to me, I have felt myself squarely on the side of justice and the State squarely on the side of injustice. I don’t want to implicitly give the State credit for “seeking justice” it doesn’t deserve.
While non-lawyers can have a grand time playing the game of pigeonholing criminal cases as good and evil, that’s because they are just kibitzing.  Their “opinions” are of no consequence, as they are neither advocate nor judge.  But when a lawyer charged with a representing an individual accused of a crime plays this game, it’s dangerous.  The need to find some way to rationalize his representation in terms of his personal vision of justice puts his client at risk.  We don’t have the right to risk our clients on the altar of our personal beliefs.

On the one hand, it may be an overt realization that a particular client is unworthy of his particular brand of justice.  On the other hand, it may be that the rationalization covertly causes the lawyer to envision a strategy that comports with his personal brand of justice rather than the client’s best interests.  Even these words, “client’s best interests,” become too fuzzy, as he may well rationalize that whatever he, in his judgmental heart, believes to be ‘right” can be mentally manipulated to mean “client’s best interests” if he’s not too rigorous in his thinking. 

And that’s the heart of the problem.  The mind is a fascinating organ, allowing us to play all sorts of nasty, ugly games with ourselves to permit us to believe what we want to believe, that we are serving some higher calling while still doing our job.  Criminal defense lawyers hold all sorts of political and philosophical views, spanning the same spectrum as anyone else.  But when we enter the well, we’re just criminal defense lawyers.  We leave our personal world outside the courtroom, and inside we defend our clients, whether saint or sinner.  

Of course we understand that we, are part of an overarching system, have a justification for our existence.  We keep the government honest as best we can.  But we defend some brutal, evil people, whose constitutional rights were honored, who were treated properly by police, who were given every benefit of the doubt, who well deserve punishment, and we get them off if we can.  Without blinking or a second thought. 

My bet is that Kindley will murder another thousand words to explain why this is still “congenial [his word] to [his] broader outlook on life.” It’s still all about him.  It was my initial hope that his self-absorption could be broken, that he would come to realize that criminal defense was not dependent on John Kinsley’s “outlook on life.”  Despite my efforts, I’ve been unsuccessful, and I fear that he is simply the rather long-winded voice of a generation that believes that duty is conditioned on their personal approval of what they do.  

This is not really about Kindley, in other words, but about criminal defense lawyers who undertake the representation of human beings with the self-delusion that it’s conditional: All is well as long as they can rationalize why they are serving “justice”. 

My response to Kindley was “We defend. Get it or get out.”  And I mean it.  Any lawyer who needs to stroke his conscience, to twist his representation of a defendant to meet some personal sense of justice, to come to terms with his personal moral dilemma, should find another practice area, if not another profession altogether.  You are not cut out to be a criminal defense lawyer.

Amongst real criminal defense lawyers, this is never really a subject of discussion.  Anyone who feels the need to argue the point further reveals him or herself as being unfit to handle the responsibility of defending a human being charged with a crime.  There is no room for rationalizations of justice in the well.  We defend.  Get it or get out.

Mortgage Blowback

Suffolk County Supreme Court Justice Jeffrey A. Spinner clearly has empathy.  Unfortunately, it’s the sort of empathy that may well wreak havoc when one considers that unintended, but obvious, consequences of his decision.  As reported in Newsday (with apologies to anyone who can’t access the link since Newsday isn’t really a newspaper anymore):


Last Thanksgiving, Greg Horoski and his wife faced foreclosure. Thursday, they celebrate the holiday in the East Patchogue home they now own outright, thanks to a State Supreme Court justice’s ruling to cancel their mortgage because of a bank’s failure to act in good faith in working out a foreclosure alternative.

Justice Jeffrey A. Spinner in Riverhead ordered the $292,500 mortgage “canceled, voided, avoided, nullified, set aside” and blasted the actions of IndyMac Mortgage Services, a division of OneWest Bank F.S.B., and its representatives, as “harsh, repugnant, shocking and repulsive,” according to his Nov. 19 decision.

What did the bank do that was so “harsh, repugnant, shocking and repulsive?”  They expected to get paid.  Even the “homeowner”, Greg Horoski was amazed at this result.


“We never asked for this,” Greg Horoski, 56, said Wednesday from the modest single-story home on Oakland Street. “I was shocked, honestly.

“It’s not like we said, ‘Judge, please throw the loan away.’ We just wanted them [the bank] to be reasonable.”

While those who are blinded with rage at their circumstances might cheer the decision to stick it to the bank, will they be as cavalier when they or their children can’t find a bank willing to do business with them for fear that some cowboy judge will void their mortgage? 

The Horoski saga is remarkably ordinary.  The refinanced and pulled a little over $100,000 out of their home when the market was good.  They fell behind after some normal medical issues arose.  They tried to get the bank to work things out with them, but the bank behaved like a bank.  It appears that what really annoyed the judge was the bank’s attitude during the action:


Spinner’s decision notes that the couple appeared at every court conference despite their health problems. Conferences were rescheduled five times because of the bank’s failure to cooperate, the decision says.
The judge’s annoyance is well-warranted, and appreciated by every lawyer who would never show such disrespect to a court.  But this sort of conduct warrants sanctions, not voiding the mortgage.  The former is a terrific way to penalize a party or its lawyers who have made the other side suffer for its failure to appear or comply with the court’s directions.  The latter is a way to make banks rescind mortgage offers, or move to Alabama.

As maddening as the impersonal and patently unhelpful attitude of mortgage lenders may be, there are two overarching concerns.  First, without them, there will be no mortgages and people can’t purchase homes.  Second, they put out the money and they are entitled to get it back, with interest.   This was no scam loan or contract of adhesion.  It was just your basic mortgage.  Sometimes, people who get loans also get sick, or get laid off, or just have problems repaying.  That’s the nature of loans.  They knew when they took the mortgage that they would have to repay, and as Greg Horoski’s post decision statement shows, he’s almost embarrassed at the monumental gift he’s been given for no good reason.  He knows this decision is over the top.

We would all love to have a human being on the other end of the phone, someone who might actually think when we call with problems, and then help to resolve them.  Banks suck.  They aren’t human. They have no heart.  But they do have money, and we need that money.  This isn’t the way to make banks into nicer people.  This is the way to make banks run away.

Reach Out And Put The Touch On Someone

The New York State Department of Corrections had a long running scam, known only to incarcerated prisoners, their families and those of us who had the misfortune of getting a collect call from them.  There’s nothing like seeing a $25 collect call on your phone bill when a client calls to say “hi”.  The New York Times describes it thus:


New York, like many states, used the phones in its prisons as a profit center. MCI, which provided the phone service, agreed to pay the prison system 57.5 percent of the fees it charged for prisoners’ collect calls. The state then allowed MCI to charge outrageously high rates: 16 cents or more a minute plus a $3 surcharge for every call. Families paid as much as $300 to $400 a month, according to one advocacy group.

The state did away with the practice in 2007, but the suit already filed proceeded, seeking a refund for those who paid.  The Court of Appeals’ 5-1 decision in Walton v. NYS DOCS put it to an end, affirming dismissal and concluding that no constitutional rights were violated.  The Times editorial offers this as a message to others:


What was left for the New York State Court of Appeals to decide was whether family members were due refunds. They contended that the excessive fees were an illegal tax that violated inmates’ equal protection rights. This week, the court, by a 5-to-1 vote, rejected the suit.

The decision is regrettable. But even the majority noted that the plaintiffs had strong arguments that the high rates were bad policy because they made it difficult for inmates to maintain family and community ties, and that released prisoners who lack these ties are more likely to return to a life of crime.

That is a message other states should heed. Prison systems may not have to subsidize these calls, but they should not be using them to balance their budgets. When prisoners cannot afford to keep in touch with their wives, husbands, parents and children, everyone pays.
Unfortunately, this isn’t the message sent by the Court of Appeals.  The message was that it hated the policy, but there was nothing unlawful about it.  For the state less concerned about New York sensibilities, or prisoners, the message is that this is a great way to collect revenue off the backs of inmates, who now have no cause to complain, so long as it doesn’t disturb the taxpayers too much.

While some people might find this policy reprehensible, many simply won’t care.  If it doesn’t affect them, or they don’t carry the heavy burden of social conscience, then why not raise revenue on the backs of criminals.  After all, they’re criminals.  Who better?

While I can’t fault the majority decision in this case for its technical rationale, Judge Robert Smith’s dissent offers a clear vision of where the technical law fails to recognize harder realities.


The majority holds that DOCS was engaging in market transactions, drawing an analogy to a per-call commission that might be charged by an owner of real property for use of a pay telephone “in a public airport or a private shopping mall” (majority op at 12). The majority overlooks an obvious distinction: the people who use the phones at airports and shopping malls are not prevented from leaving the premises by armed guards. . . It is not exploiting, to quote Judge Posner once more, “the monopoly of force that is the definition of government” (Arsberry, 244 F3d at 566).

Here, the State has used its imprisonment of inmates as a source of economic leverage. I cannot accept this as legitimate market activity. If the State can do this, why could it not charge for in-person visits to prison inmates — at a rate 50 times the cost of making such visits possible? Why could it not charge commissions — limited not by the State’s costs, but only by what the traffic would bear — on sums earned by inmates in work release programs? Why could it not charge prisoners who seek furloughs an amount limited only by the prisoners’ willingness to pay? I cannot believe that the majority would characterize any of these transactions as normal attempts by a government agency to turn a profit in a marketplace, but the majority offers no adequate explanation of why the transactions in this case are different.

It’s absurd to suggest, as the majority does, that there is no difference between prisoners and any other telephone users. There are no market transactions in prison.  At least not with the state.  While it’s true that telephone providers gouge wherever they can, a practice that everyone but major shareholders finds reprehensible, prisoners are different. They have no option.  It’s pay or be isolated.  Worse still, it isn’t even the prisoner who pays, but the wife or mother at home.  She did nothing to deserve this.

Of course, since the practice has been stopped here, and the Legislature has forbidden it for the future, the pressure was off the court to remedy an ongoing situation.  Now, it was just about the refund.  But as Judge Smith points out, there remains a laundry list of new ways the state could grab some loose change from prisoners, and who’s to say that a new governor with a budget deficit won’t see this as a viable revenue stream for as long as he can get away with it?

It’s legitimate to sentence prisoners and restrain their freedom.  It’s hardly legitimate to take an insular group with absolutely no bargaining power and suck money from them and the few who care about them.  The great power of the state to impose whatever burden it pleases on a group that is held at gunpoint is not an acceptable way to fund the DOCS coffers.  And if the Court of Appeals of the State of New York has rejected the arguments that this tyranny of the minority is unconstitutional, it’s unlikely that many other states will be shaking in their boots at the thought of doing so.

Some lesson.

What’s A Parent To Do?

So your kid is having a bad day.


The finding of neglect in this case is based on a single physical confrontation between the mother and her adolescent son, Corey Mc. (hereinafter the son), who at that time was 15 years old and 5 feet 10 inches tall. The evidence in the record established that the mother and the son had a troubled relationship. In this particular incident, the mother confronted the son over what she believed to be a specific instance of inconsiderate behavior, after which she left his room and closed the door. The son came out of his room and directed a stream of profanity-laced invective at the mother, who attempted several times to withdraw from the confrontation. When the son continued his verbal abuse, the mother either punched or slapped him in the face. The incident escalated further, and the son knocked his mother down and continued to curse at her; she got up and hit him on the face with the heel of her shoe, bloodying his nose. The mother then immediately called the police to seek medical attention for the son.
Judge Edwina Richardson-Mendelson at Queens County Family Court found that the mother neglected her child.  The Appellate Division, Second Department, reversed Matter of Corey Mc. v. Tanya Mc. Many will fault the mother for having struck her son in the face with the heel of her shoe.  It probably wasn’t the best decision, but then it wasn’t made under the best of circumstances.

That the neglect ruling came as a result of a single instance of violence, in light of the situation, is certainly troubling.  But it raises some broader questions about what parents are supposed to do when a child is out of control.  Nothing in the decision suggests that the child was otherwise bad or uncontrollable, no claims of a string of arrests or other violence by the boy, nor any claim of a string of gratuitously violent or harmful acts by the mother.

The failure of a parent to discipline a child is almost invariably deemed blameworthy, and people are hardly reluctant to ask why a bad kid’s parent didn’t fulfill her responsibilities in raising the child properly.  It’s unlikely that anyone thinks that the shoe to the nose was an appropriate method of dealing with the situation, but given the circumstances, particularly that the mother tried to withdraw from the confrontation but the son wouldn’t allow it, what response would have been better?

The rules were once fairly clear.  Spare the rod and spoil the child.  The risks today are impossible to calculate.  Corporal punishment is largely off-limits, if not the quickest way to the local hoosegow.  Granted, earlier generations were never denied a swift and certain spanking when they defied their parents, but then real abuse, ranging from broken bones to cigarette burns, exists.  The battle lines are far too fuzzy to see during those calm, deliberative periods when parents ponder how best to discipline children.  They are non-existent when the fur is flying, the situation heated and tempers flaring.

Visions of parental propriety appear to be largely drive by dogmatic positions: No parent should ever physically discipline a child.  No child should ever be allowed to get away with showing such disrespect to a parent.  These irreconcilable positions leave parents at best confused and at worst liable for criminal charges and perhaps loosing their children. 

For those who believe that they are entitled to dictate how a parent raises their child, I wonder whether they will similar take charge when the child gets out of control and Super Nanny isn’t in town.  There may be a fine line between stern parental discipline and actual abuse, but this does little to help a parent come to grips with how to deal with a child out of control.  Nor is the hope of reversal by an appellate court a really good child-rearing method. 

Clear lines are needed before the fight happens, and at present there are none to be found.

H/T Eugene Volokh

As Long As You Can’t Add

Via Turley.



The question is not how many Fox viewers will figure out that the pie chart comes out to 193%, but how many will argue that this somehow makes perfect sense.  Thus far, the best explanation is that math is another Obama socialist conspiracy.  This explanation, of course, is obviously false given the Obama administration’s explanation that Health Care Reform is cost neutral. Politics defies the constraints of arithmatic.

And if you believe in inertia, consider Lou Dobbs.

Next week:  Can politics defy the rules of gravity?