Author Archives: SHG

Remy Meets His Fate

For those of you who don’t know, Ramiro Orozco is a former public defender, now private criminal defense lawyer down Mississippi way.  He’s a tough guy, and a staunch defender.  Remy, as he’s called, is no pushover and has never, to my knowledge, shied away from a fight.

That’s why Remy’s experience means so much.  You see, Remy got pulled over by a cop and, despite everything he is and everything he knows, his reaction is quite telling.


Last night on my way home from the gym I was pulled over by local law enforcement’s finest. It was around 8:00 pm and I was sweaty and tired when I saw the blue lights in my rear view mirror. As I puled over, I began to feel my pulse rise and my hands get nervous. I thought to myself, “Why am I nervous and afraid? I haven’t done anything wrong!?

Anyone, lawyer or layman, who isn’t nervous and afraid likely is brain dead.  You are about to enter a world where one side has all the power and the other none.  One side has a weapon and the society’s seal of approval to use it.  The other, at best, has platitudes that are only meaningful if there’s someone around who cares.

Remy’s stop turned south quickly, with the officer wasting little time playing the game.


He asked me for my license and registration and I nervously asked if I could get it out of my bag in the back seat. He replied, “Sir if you like I can get it for you.” (Here was his first attempt to search my car) I said no it was ok and that I would get it. That is when his tone changed and he replied, “Is there something you are trying to hide?”

Once the officer has gone down that path, the die is cast.


I told him that I had nothing to hide but that I would get my wallet myself. He then ordered that I lower the back window, “for his safety”. When I cracked it open, he barked for me to lower it all the way. As I cracked the back window I watched as he stuck his head in my car looking into the back and at the floor board of the car. I nervously request that he please respect my privacy and keep his head out of my car.

He refused and told me that he had the right to protect himself and make sure that I was not reaching for a gun.

It’s all so tricky and muddled at this point.  Certainly, Remy wouldn’t suggest that he doesn’t have a right to protect himself, even though Remy has given him no reason to fear for his safety.  But then, protesting the officer’s actions is tantamount to inciting him, to challenging the officer, thus creating greater conflict and anxiety.  Bad things come from greater conflict and anxiety.


As I stood there in the cold fighting off the onslaught of questions with confused yes and nos coming out of my mouth, I finally drew the courage to draw the line when he asked me if the tattoos on my arm were gang related? This was the last draw… I stopped took a deep breath and replied, “I am nervous because I am standing on the side of a highway because of a “traffic stop” have never been taken out of my car and interrogated because of it.”

No, this isn’t going to be used as an opportunity to suggest that tattoos are rarely a good idea, though they aren’t.  It is, however, an opportunity to point out that most people could never have mustered the courage that Remy showed by drawing a line and refusing to cross it.  Ordinary people have two reactions, just going with the flow while praying that it stops, or getting too angry to control, and doing something incredibly foolish.  The ability to keep one’s cool while putting on the breaks is rare, even for a criminal defense lawyer whose life is dedicated to dealing with police officers and the law.


This is where I dropped the bomb on him and informed him that I was a attorney and that I was not allowing him to search because it was my Constitutional right and that by taking me out of my car he was in effect detaining me and that such detention was a violation of my Constitutional rights because he had no probable cause…

Dropped the bomb is precisely what happened, and when one drops the bomb, one can never be sure whether the explosion will get the enemy or you.  Remy was pushed too far, however, and took the calculated risk.


I no longer needed a light to see because his face first turned beet red and then pale white. This looming giant with a gun, bright lights and a badge seemed to literally shrink before my eyes. I have never been apologized to so many times in my life. He apologized for almost everything but my being fat!
It worked.  But this is critically important: Just because it worked this time doesn’t mean it will work next time, or for you, or for anyone else.  The other option for the officer was to pull his taser and fire, or perhaps put Remy on the ground for his assaultive conduct, or any number of other aggressive used of force that could have harmed, perhaps permanently, Remy just to teach him a lesson.  After all, there were only two people present to explain what just happened, and Remy was only one of them.

Much of Remy’s experience is unfortunately typical.  The sight of flashing lights behind you is intended to strike fear in the heart of the most law-abiding citizen, as is the uniform, the approach, the demeanor and everything else about a traffic stop.  It’s part of a calculated scheme to make the citizen submissive, which is good for the police officer.  Yes, it’s a safety measure, and one should never forget the First Rule of Policing: Make it home for dinner.

At the same time, nervousness is the normal human reaction to a traffic stop.  I once asked a panel of prospective jurors to raise their hands if they didn’t feel nervous when they saw the lights of a police cruiser in the rearview mirror, striking for cause everyone whose hand wasn’t raised as a liar or incompetent to serve.  Every person of normal or better intelligence is nervous.

This too inures to the officer’s benefit, as a nervous drive is an excuse to do pretty much anything.  That judges buy into this is the inside joke of suppression, as if the person with nothing to hide isn’t nervous.  Everyone is nervous.  Everyone.  Even Remy.  Even me.

There is an inclination on the part of those who “have nothing to hide” to take the path of least resistance and let the officer search.  The whole point of the question, do you have anything to hide, is a psychological button pushed to overcome the citizen’s free choice.  No one, given the belief that he can assert his rights without repercussions, would allow a search.  The point is that the question is designed to make one feel that there will most assuredly be repercussions from the assertion of rights, and they won’t be good.

Why fight if you’ve got nothing to hide?  Aside from the fact that more people have something to hide than they realize, because we are not the captives of law enforcement.  We are endowed with certain inalienable rights, and we either assert them or lose them. Of course, this is easier to write on this blawg than assert on a dark road when it’s only you and the cop present.

Finally, all worked out for Remy, to the point where the officer apologized for his excesses and chose not to beat Remy to  a bloody pulp.  While this is great for Remy, it’s applicability to you is suspect.  You may not be able to honestly say you’re a lawyer.  You may not be able to react with sufficient restraint to avoid infuriating the officer.  You may not get an apology.

Thankfully, Remy survived his experience intact.  The same can’t be said for everyone.  Be careful out there.

H/T Bobby Frederick at the South Caccalacca Criminal Defense Blog.

Mea Culpa in Maricopa (Update)

Judge Gary Donahoe has issued his opinion in the Adam Stoddard contempt hearing.  To everyone’s shock, Judge Donahoe held the court detention officer in contempt.  Heat City sums it up:


But Donahoe rejected that story, saying there’s no way “a reasonable detention officer” would have thought a crime was taking place based on what he saw.

“There was no immediate or future security threat that would have justified a reasonable detention officer in DO Stoddard’s situation removing, seizing and coping a document from a defense attorney’s file,” Donahoe wrote in his ruling, which was made public today. “A reasonable detention officer would have recognized after spending approximately 37 seconds reading the paragraph in question, that the ‘key words’ had nothing to do with an immediate or future security threat to the jail or anyone else.”

Even more curious is the court’s “punishment”, with the judge ordering Stoddard to make a written and oral apology, the latter to be done at a press conference, with defense attorney Joanne Cuccia left to decide if the apology is sufficiently sincere.  If not, Stoddard goes to jail, per the order.

Taking the ruling on contempt first, it’s likely shocking to all involved that Judge Donahoe took what amounts to a huge local political risk by angering the local power.  Of course, it may well be that there was no sweeping this one under the carpet, due to the attention it’s received nationwide, and that contempt was the only available option.  Note to Maricopa defense lawyers: Maybe this isn’t just blathering?

On the other hand, the punishment is somewhat goofy.  Aside from the public shaming aspect, Judge Donahoe’s shifting the burden of determining Stoddard’s sincerity to Cuccia is a trick, pure and simple.  If she was to decide that it was an inadequate or insincere apology, then Donahoe’s in the clear and whatever fallout occurs is Cuccia’s fault.  Cuccia certainly doesn’t want every deputy in the county to hate her, so she isn’t going to paint a target on her forehead.  Everybody down there has to know this.  It was a pretty shifty move on the judge’s part.

So is this half a loaf?  Maybe a little more than half?  I think so, and it’s significant that the attention of others focused on the wild west of Maricopa County might have contributed to Judge Donahoe’s decision making process.  Clearly, given the penalty, however, there’s still a way to go. 

Update:  Via Gameso, the N.html”>Arizona Republic has Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s reaction to Judge Donahoe’s decision:



“My officer was doing his job and I will not stand by and allow him to be thrown to the wolves by the courts because they feel pressure from the media on this situation,” Arpaio said in a press release. He further said, “I decide who holds press conferences and when they are held regarding this Sheriff’s Office.”
I get the sense that Sheriff Joe is not respecting Judge Donahoe’s authority.  I wonder what will happen should Stoddard be forbidden by Sheriff Joe from apologizing. I wonder if they will call each other names.  Or worse.  This could get awfully nasty.

Go Straight To Jail, Do Not Pass Go

The Second Circuit has decided the Lynne Stewart appeal, and at 191 pages,  it’s a doozy.  The majority decision was written by Judge Sack, with Judge Calabresi writing in concurrence and Judge Walker both concurring and dissenting. 

The gist of the majority is that Lynne must surrender to serve her sentence of 28 months forthwith, while the case is remanded for resentence (which strikes me as a bit odd) for Judge Koeltl to decide whether she committed perjury, a determination he did not make at the original sentencing, then consider how that would impact the guidelines and sentence her with that as part of the mix.
Neither Judge Sack nor Calabresi suggested that Judge Koeltl’s sentence was otherwise substantively unreasonable.  Indeed, Judge Calabresi was downright effusive toward Judge Koeltl’s diligence in the handling of this case.

Judge Walker was another story.  He found the sentence imposed unacceptable, much like Andy McCarthy at NRO.


Yes, the sentence — that’s the interesting part. The court has sent Stewart’s case back to the trial judge for reconsideration of her absurdly short 28-month jail term (after the government asked for 30 years). The sentence has divided the appellate panel. All three judges agree that the sentence needs to be reconsidered. But two judges, Sack and Calabresi, seem to be narrowing the complaint down to whether Stewart committed perjury at her trial, which — if she is found by the sentencing judge to have done so — would call for a modest increase. In dissent, Judge Walker’s point is that a 28-month sentence for the terrorism-related offenses Stewart committed is a travesty whether or not she committed perjury.
Fortunately, not everyone who utters the word terrorism necessarily resorts to hysterics or hyperbole.

It’s not surprising that the conviction was affirmed, as the appellate battle was really directed to sentence.  I suspect that Judge Koeltl’s failure to decide the perjury issue was to avoid rubbing salt in the wound, not to mention that directly conflicting testimony doesn’t imbue a judge with the power to figure out who was telling the truth.  It’s one of the most difficult and painful decisions a judge can make, and why make it if it isn’t going to alter the outcome?

Still, the Circuit has ordered him to do so, and he most assuredly will.  Regardless of which way he comes out, little will change.  Lynne will be in a federal prison (it’s unlikely that a convicted “terrorist” will be designated to a camp) and a few more months, should it be imposed, won’t alter anything.  Our nation won’t be any safer from lawyers or terrorists, if you can tell one from the other.

The End of the Duopoly?

In the old days, we had books.  Then along came Westlaw with its CDs. Then Lexis with its online search.  This was revolutionary, but uncomfortable.  First, it meant that we had a room full of very expensive law books that were soon to be worthless.  Second, it meant that we had to trust search via a computer rather than leaf through the piles of books that kept us warm at night.

As everyone knows, Lexis and Westlaw are the way lawyers research today.  A rather expensive way, I might add, and still rather unwieldy in their search mechanics, largely dependent on judges’ use of the language we’re looking for. More imaginative judges make life miserable,as they use odd phrases that are hard to find.  For newer lawyers, the comfort level is much greater than it is for old timers.  For old timers, we’ve never really trusted them, even though we sign the checks every month.

This may change any moment now, as Google Scholar will be posting court decisions.

Starting today, we’re enabling people everywhere to find and read full text legal opinions from U.S. federal and state district, appellate and supreme courts using Google Scholar. You can find these opinions by searching for cases (like Planned Parenthood v. Casey), or by topics (like desegregation) or other queries that you are interested in. For example, go to Google Scholar, click on the “Legal opinions and journals” radio button, and try the query separate but equal. Your search results will include links to cases familiar to many of us in the U.S. such as Plessy v. Ferguson and Brown v. Board of Education, which explore the acceptability of “separate but equal” facilities for citizens at two different points in the history of the U.S. But your results will also include opinions from cases that you might be less familiar with, but which have played an important role.

I don’t know that I will be any more comfortable doing research on Google Scholar than I was on Lexis (I refused to use Westlaw after I was embarrassed to learn that some of their text was inaccurate), but at least it won’t cost me to be uncomfortable.  I similarly won’t know until extensive experience whether it actually works, at least for criminal law, or whether it’s sufficiently comprehensive.  There are a ton of questions about its reliability.  Until lawyers can be assured of its reliability, it cannot be relied upon.  We can’t afford to miss cases.

That’s not to say Google Scholar isn’t trying. It appears that Google will even include it’s kinda/sorta version of Shepard’s.


We think this addition to Google Scholar will empower the average citizen by helping everyone learn more about the laws that govern us all. To understand how an opinion has influenced other decisions, you can explore citing and related cases using the Cited by and Related articles links on search result pages. As you read an opinion, you can follow citations to the opinions to which it refers. You can also see how individual cases have been quoted or discussed in other opinions and in articles from law journals. Browse these by clicking on the “How Cited” link next to the case title.
I doubt that reading caselaw is going to help the average citizen to better understand the law. Many lawyers read the decisions and don’t get it. Same with judges. It’s not just reading the words that provides comprehension.  Most of us have enjoyed clients who do research to “help us out,” and are well aware that time in the law library isn’t a substitute for a deeper understanding of the law and how to craft a viable argument.  Still, no harm in giving everyone a shot at knowing a little law, provided they don’t do anything dangerous with it.

But if it works, it could be huge.  And if it doesn’t work, at least well enough to serve as a viable means of legal research, Google Scholar might be just the one to keep on top of it until it does.  I’ve never really accepted the premise that we have to pay to access decisions issued by our courts, a branch of government.  We pay them to sit and pay them to decide already.  Why must we pay an outside company to read their decisions?  Yes, I realize that someone has to amass them and provide a means of access, but it still grinds my gears that the cost is so ridiculous high. 

I’m rooting for Google Scholar.  I’m rooting for this new development to be great, thorough, reliable and accurate.  If I never had to use Lexis again, or pay for the privilege, I would be good with that.

H/T Radley “Mr. Duopoly” Balko

Scare Tactics

I received an early morning call from a woman who was in tears.  Long story short, she made a mistake at the GAP and didn’t pay for everything that had been placed in her stroller.  After tendering several hundred dollars for clothing, she was pinched on her way out of the store for a forgotten trinket.  Believe her or not, it’s not important.

She was in tears because, not being an experienced criminal, she didn’t know what to do and decided to search the internet for a lawyer to represent her.  Naturally, she called the number listed for the number one choice on Google.  In New York, we all know who that is.  She was informed that this was a very serious offense, for which she could go to jail for a year.  Thus, she should rush down immediately with cash in hand so that her four children wouldn’t be left motherless.

Do you wonder why she was hysterical?

Of course, this is sheer and utter crap.  No first offense petty theft charge, alone, will mean jail time.  It’s remarkably unlikely to be any worse, no matter how badly screwed up by the defense lawyer, than a plea to a violation, a non-criminal offense, and a couple of days community service.  At worst.  Chances are fairly good that a better disposition, including dismissal, can be obtained by a halfway decent lawyer.

I talked with her for a while to calm her down.  I was outraged that some lawyer, or perhaps lawyer’s flunky, chose to cause this woman such horror and pain.  For what? A fee?  They would cause her to fear jail, the loss of her children, to scare her into racing down to the office with cash in hand?  Not even a decent legal fee, though more than enough for the charges involved, yet they would do this to someone.  I am outraged.

I spent about a half hour undoing the damage this heartless miscreant did, assuring this crying woman that she will not be going to jail for a year, not be separated from her four children, not be a statistic.  I referred her case to a young, extremely competent and understanding lawyer, who I have no doubt will take exceptional care of her. 

Still, my blood boils at the tactics used to make a buck at any expense.  This is not how human beings behave toward one another, and this is most assuredly not how criminal defense lawyers behave.  This cannot happen, and it cannot continue.  We do not practice law purely to see how much we scare a fee out of a client, and we do not scare people under any circumstances.  This “money at any cost” mentality that is permeating the bar is going to ruin us; it’s a disgrace.

I’m begging you, please don’t to this.  It doesn’t matter how hungry you are, how desperate you are for a fee, how successful you are at lying, deceiving, scaring and harming potential clients.  This has got to stop.  This cannot be tolerated.

Please stop it.  Please do no more harm.  I’m begging you.

Hope For Federal Court

It’s a tough place, federal court.  How tough?  Check out Bennett’s post about pro se litigants before District of Texas Judge David Hittner.  Ouch.  Nothing warm and fuzzy there.  From the lawyers’ perspective, we understand why judges get surly and annoyed when we waste their time, or try to pull something off on them and get caught.  But it’s painful to hear a federal judge speak to a citizen with such utter disdain.  And it’s painful to hear the same disdain, if not worse, in the citizen’s voice.

While it’s foolhardy for a litigant, particularly a pro se litigant, to deliberately antagonize a judge, it’s worse for a federal judge, a person with life tenure, to demonstrate such a fundamental lack of judicial temperament.  This isn’t how a person should be treated, no matter how annoying or misguided he may be. 

Which brings us to our kinder, gentler judiciary under our new Democratic President, who was to usher in a period of Hope.  The stars were aligned, with a Democratic majority in the Senate, for change, the doctrinaire and dogmatic appointees to the federal bench under our former regime.  President Obama was handed a mandate for change, and what has he done with it?

There is, of course, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the former prosecutor and Circuit Judge whose empathetic approach to the law has yet to be fully appreciated.  Aside from her, the team roster is a bit bare.


President Bush, who was intent on leaving an ideological imprint on the judiciary, made his nominations quickly and pushed hard to have them confirmed. By the end of his first year, according to a report by the liberal group Alliance for Justice, he had nominated 65 federal judges and 28 were confirmed.

By that measure — and those of the Clinton and Reagan years — Mr. Obama has moved slowly. As of Nov. 4, he had nominated just 26 appellate and district court judges, and only four of them had been confirmed.
I realize that President Obama is a very busy fellow, what with a couple of wars and a recession to fix, not to mention the perennial war on health care reform.  But he’s got people.  You don’t really think the president himself goes around to every potential district judge’s house and meets their kids, do you?

But my fear of the squandered opportunity runs somewhat deeper, and this likely has to do with the fact that I stumble into federal courts from time to time.  Would it kill a Democratic President to appoint people to the federal judiciary who shared a healthy respect for humanity, the Constitution, individual freedom and civil rights?  Must the breadth of choices be limited to the archly pro-law enforcement to the largely pro-law-enforcement.  Must the philosophical reach of potential judges range from those who’ve never seen a 4th Amendment exception they didn’t like to those form whom good faith covers all flaws?

Yes, of course I realize that I’m being silly.  The Dems need to show that they aren’t wild-eyed, pointy-headed libs who want to let criminals take over the country, and so out-harsh the Reps with their tough on crime.  Bad to worse is the best we can hope for.  So there’s what Hope means in the federal judiciary.

But at least judges could be polite about it as they deny suppression and lock defendant’s away.  There’s just no reason to be rude.  So get to work, President Obama, and start naming names to recreate the federal judiciary in your image.  Sure, they will rule no differently than the appointees of your predecessor, but at least they will smile as the mete out the sentence.  It’s the best we can hope for.

A Referendum on Blawgs

Every year, a few folks run beauty pageants in the blogosphere.  Some do it to bring attention to themselves, and others do it to bring attention to the blogosphere.  For the new blogger, it’s a validation of their existence and worthiness, a recognition that their efforts aren’t unnoticed.  For the less new blogger, it’s more sport than anything else. 

It brings the winners vast wealth and prestige.  Actually, it brings the winners nothing more than a few new readers for about a week, who will then decide whether to stay or go based on what the blogger has done lately.  There’s no prestige, and certainly no wealth, to be had from winning anything online.  Not even bragging rights.  But it can help to establish the vitality of the blogosphere, and in that way reflect whether the continued existence of blogs is worth the effort.

The 2009 Weblog Awards are now open for nominations.  They have a category for Best Law Blog.  Anyone can nominate any blog, and they have.  It doesn’t mean that every blog nominated will be put to the vote; most of the nominations will fall by the wayside and only about ten will make the cut.  This will include perennial favorites, like The Volokh Conspiracy (winner in 2008) and Above the Law (winner in 2007).

The 2009 Weblog Awards

The question is who else will be included in the Best Law Blog category, and this question could serve as a referendum on where the direction of law blogs is heading.  It’s a question that concerns me greatly, as I’ve watched the growth of blogs by lawyers or law students grow exponentially, but in a disturbing direction.  Rather than write about issues of law, many write about social media and marketing for lawyers, and call their efforts law blogs.  Some have nominated themselves for the Best Law Blawg award.

Already, the blogosphere (and note that I don’t call it the blawgosphere, which in my view relates to law by definition) has shown a marked shift away from substantive law toward lawyer advertising and promotion.  Will these blogs (not blawgs) represent law blogs going forward?  Will lawyers no longer be measured by their substantive posts but by the numbers of twitter followers or their 10 rules for successful blogging?  Will the online space once inhabited by real lawyers be taken over by lawyers pretending to be social media gurus?

As regular readers are painfully aware, I find this trend terribly distasteful, a huge effort by those who have none of the requisite skills, talent or track record of success in the practice of law trying to establish themselves, and make a living, by teaching other lawyers who are even less computer savvy that the future of being a successful lawyer is emulating used car salesmen.  No need to be a good lawyer or demonstrate competence in the representation of clients, since it’s all about one’s use of social media.  If you need to read more, SJ is replete with posts about the evils of lawyer advertising and self-promotion.

The point now is that real lawyers have a choice available to them.  The lawyer social media gurus will be promoting themselves unmercifully to win recognition in the 2009 Weblog Awards, unlike anything I’ve seen in the past.  They want to be validated as the voice of the lawyer, as the way of the future, as the legitimate representation of who and what lawyers will be in the future.  Do real lawyers want blogs about how to twit, or how to blog, or how to capture millions of clients while only working three hours a week, to reflect what lawyers are to the world?  Or would you prefer that lawyers be represented by thoughtful, substantive blawgs that discuss the law.

Stop by the 2009 Weblog Award page for Best Law Blog.  Nominate your favorite blawg.  If it’s already there, second (or third) the nomination.  It’s not terribly important which one it is, as long as it’s a blawg that reflects what you believe to be the essence of what it means to be a lawyer.  But use this opportunity to send a message to the marketers, the social media gurus, that they are not blawgs, they do not reflect the law and they will never represent the essence of lawyers online.  Lawyers are not all about marketing, self-promotion and the quick buck, but about the law.  Wouldn’t it be nice if a little dignity prevailed?

Is It Wrong to Draw Lines?

A reader sent me a link to a story from a blawg called Bad Lawyer, written by an anonymous New Yorker who, it appears, is a criminal defense lawyer of a certain age.  Much like me, save the anonymous part.  It’s a very good blawg, and I appreciate learning of its existence.  Sure, I wish its author would come out, and join the rest of the blawgosphere, but there’s still much to offer there, and I find myself nodding in agreement with the anonymous old coot as I read his stuff.

Ironically, the story that was sent to me is one of the few with which I don’t agree.  It figures, right?  The post, via AZFamily, is about a Phoenix judge who orders a church to stop feeding the poor.  Outrageous, right?  Well, maybe.  Or maybe not.


[A] “Judge” ordered a Phoenix Church to stop feeding the poor and homeless, because, get this, when you feed the poor and homeless, the wrong element come into your neighborhood.

The Judge  a retired former Justice of the Arizona Supreme Court is Robert Corcoran, who is sitting as a City of Phoenix zoning board hearing officer.

As you might have guessed, the issue isn’t about whether churches should feed the poor, but zoning.  Here’s Corcoran’s decision.  Bad lawyer is not merely disappointed by the outcome, but outraged.


Whenever I encounter a story like this–I bear in mind,  the beatitudes, especially: blessed are they who hunger and thirst for righteousness for they shall be satisfied.  This is a Judge who has satisfied us all by betraying official heartlessness and cluelessness;  and may his outrageousness generate an outpouring of care, mercy, and love.
I can appreciate his concerns. I share these concerns.  Caring for those in need is a fundamental obligation of every member of society.  The problem is that I can also appreciate the fact that it can be accomplished without subsuming the lives of every other member of society.  In other words, people are entitled to enjoy their homes, their lives, the fruits of their efforts, even as others are in need of, and deserving of, the help of others.

I don’t fault the church for doing as it did.  It’s mission is to help others, and its efforts to fulfill this mission should be applauded.  At the same time, I cannot fault Corcoran for concluding that the residents had a right as well.  To this end, a critical detail was that the City of Phoenix found an alternate location for the church to fulfill its mission where it would not negatively impact the local residents, but the pastor of the church rejected it, preferring his church’s location to the alternative.

In the absence of an alternative, the more important interest, that of feeding the poor and homeless, would prevail.  Certainly the survival of other human beings trumps the comfort of local residents.  But few decisions require such harsh choices, and this one didn’t.  When an alternative exists, as it almost always does, that will allow for both legitimate interests to be served, then it’s perfectly reasonable to preserve the right of people to enjoy their lives, even if it means that a greater good must suffer some accommodation.

The point is that we are all entitled to enjoy our lives within the lines society draws.  As cold as it may seem, we must not all starve because some do.  Yes, the hungry must be fed, but that doesn’t make those who aren’t hungry wrong or evil.  Our nation was founded upon the principle that the of the pursuit of happiness is one of its basic purposes, and I refuse to accept that it’s wrong for people to do so.

There is a tendency to see the world as black and white, a zero sum game.  This is exacerbated by human suffering, where the stakes are higher and the sides are more tightly aligned.  It’s counterproductive to back everyone into a corner when there are options available that can serve all interests, and it’s wrong to suggest that it is inherently evil for people to want to enjoy the normalcy of their lives simply because not everyone can do the same.  We can accomplish far more by working together to respect all interests at stake rather than pitting people against each other.

It’s not heartless for a family to want to enjoy the security and comfort of their home. And it’s a mitzvah to help those in need. We can accommodate both, and be better off for having done so.

Too High A Price

Many years ago, before I was admitted to practice law, I worked for someone who was, even back then, considered an old time criminal defense lawyer.  He didn’t know much about the law.  He was a “trial man,” a rough and tumble kind of lawyer who was full of bravado and not much else. 

He had a blue collar type of practice, with an emphasis on numbers, small-time drugs and prostitution, the basic vices of uptown Manhattan at the time which provided the primary source of his income.

Every once in a while, a female client would walk into his office, the door would close, and he would emerge a short time later all sweaty and disheveled.  Even now, the image is revolting.

At Bennett’s Defending People and Lat’s Above the Law, the question was posed whether lawyers should be permitted to have sex with their clients.  It arises because of a proposed new rule in Texas prohibiting such conduct, with California close behind.  On the one hand, there is the problem of freedom of association, a lawyer being as entitled to exercise constitutional rights as real people.  On the other, it’s an opportunity for a person in a position of trust to take advantage of vulnerable people, to abuse that trust.

Over the past 25 years, I’ve had the occasional offer of sex in lieu of payment.  I’ve declined.  I use it as a teaching moment for clients about the duty of a lawyer toward their clients.  Some appreciate the lesson.  Others would prefer to save the money.  Neither has persuaded me to change my view.

Like Bennett, I’m not in favor of a regulation governing even minute aspect of the lawyer/client relationship.  But then, I naively hope that lawyers would behave professionally and honor the trust given them by clients just because it’s the right thing to do.  Perhaps there is an epidemic of lawyers having sex with clients which compels changes to clarify the lawyer’s duty.  If so, I’m not aware of it, but then there are many things that happen out there that don’t touch my practice.  There’s no regulation that says lawyers shouldn’t give clients a wet willy, but I want to believe that such a regulation isn’t needed. 

When my former boss closed his office door, it was wrong.  He took advantage of people who needed him, relied on him, for his own gratification.  This had nothing to do with his right of association or privacy, and had everything to do with violating trust.  It’s true that some of the women who were behind that closed door took no issue with what happened there, but that’s because abuse of trust, abuse of their bodies, was common to their lives. 

I have no doubt that others closed their eyes and thought of anything other than being with that old, disgusting man.  But they lacked the money to pay, and did what they had to do.  Sometimes, these women were the spouses or girlfriends of clients, rather than the client themselves.  This took it to an even lower depth of abuse, but didn’t seem to alter my former boss’ willingness to take advantage of the situation.  He rationalized his conduct as doing them a favor.  It’s amazing how people can lie to themselves to justify doing wrong.

There is no circumstance, no situation, in which a lawyer should engage in sexual conduct with a client, or on behalf of a client.  If there’s true love behind the impulse, then wait until after the case is over.  This doesn’t threaten any right of the lawyer, and there is no legitimate argument against precluding lawyers from trading sex for a fee, or using their position of trust to persuade someone to engage in sex with them.  The rule should be clear and absolute.

That we need to have a rule, or have a discussion about having a rule, is a sorry reflection on lawyers and humanity.  But lawyers are people, and often people who take a very flexible view of their duty to allow them to do whatever they please no matter how obviously wrong it is.  And so a need arises for rules to prohibit lawyers from doing things they know they shouldn’t do.  So be it.

There are plenty of people out there in the world to love and lust.  Keep your hands off your clients. Keep your hands off your clients’ wives, girlfriends, mothers, sisters and friends.  That’s the price of holding a position of trust, and if it’s too high for you, then you shouldn’t be a lawyer.

Who Stole Kevin O’Keefe’s Brain?

I realize that there are many in the blawgosphere who think Kevin O’Keefe, Lexblog honcho and the Head Cheerleader of Blogging, bears much responsibility for all the really bad blogging that has gummed up the works, cluttered up the blawgosphere and enabled unworthy and incapable lawyers to use the blawgosphere for crass commercialism.  I disagree.

While Kevin provides the tools, he also has been a strong advocate for using the tools properly.  Granted, he may encourage lawyers to blog for the wrong reason (in my opinion), and perhaps his methodology is a bit over the top (using blog names that tend to grossly exaggerate his customers’ relative merit), but he’s got a business to run.  At least he emphasizes that a blog without substance is a failed blog, one that will never bring in business and never receive recognition.  I’ve always respected Kevin for this.

But now he’s gone off the reservation, and this isn’t the Kevin O’Keefe I know and love like.


This week the State of Connecticut began hearings on whether five attorneys violated state ethics rules by participating in an Internet advertising program run by Total Attorneys.

Cast in the light of protecting consumers, Connecticut’s action is another step backward for consumers and the lawyers who serve consumers by providing legal services at reasonable prices.

Unlike Carolyn Elefant, whose concern was for the five solo practitioners who have been targeted as the scapegoats for Total Attorneys’ total impropriety, Kevin hops on the marketer bandwagon to back up the business interests whose existence depends on desperate lawyers willing to wear short shorts and walk the streets. 

The arguments in favor of Total Attorneys are fairly straightforward.  First, the complainant, Zenas Zelotes, is a lawyer, not a consumer, meaning that he’s a bad man for complaining.  Second, the fee-splitting arrangement offered by Total Attorneys to any lawyer desperate enough to pay for their services, is just a hop, skip and jump down the road to perdition from Goggle Adwords, as if Google Adwords is the paradigm of legal ethics.  And third, all the other really cool marketers are already on the bandwagon.


Several well-respected, web-savvy legal professionals have chimed in to defend Total Attorneys and the five Connecticut lawyers who stand to face disciplinary action, including Larry Bodine, Carolyn Elefant, and Avvo’s Josh King. Bob Ambrogi has been following this story as well, pointing out that “these complaints point to the lack of clarity and consistency in the rules of conduct governing lawyers.”

Just to avoid the fuzziness of this paragraph, Carolyn Elefant has defended the five scapegoated solos, not Total Attorneys, and Bob Ambrogi has written about it in his capacity as chronicler at Legal Blog watch, not as partisan, and has not taken Total Attorneys side.  Kevin does find comfort in the views of Larry Bodine and Josh King, who calls limitations on lawyers walking the streets:


The vestigial remains of the courtly days before lawyer advertising, these rules are typically a mix of picayune detail and over-expansive reach, an attempt at lawyer exceptionalism in our 21st century media landscape.

Bodine just calls the whole thing “zany“, employing the slippery slope argument to suggest that as long as lawyers are already whoring around, why not just let flash a little thigh so that marketers can make a living too.

There isn’t a single argument proffered that holds up to scrutiny.  What difference does it make who brought the complaint or how long the complaint is (since everyone mentions that it’s 303 pages long)?  Why should the fact that lawyers have stepped onto the slippery slope compel them to slide down to the bottom?  But most importantly, the argument that there is no harm to consumers is wrong.  Whenever there is a lack of honesty about how and why a consumer is directed from a search to a lawyer, forgetting for the moment that the website gets paid for the referral, there is harm.  Dishonest by lawyers is inherently harmful to everyone involved. 

Who amongst the marketers is willing to step forward and champion the notion that lying lawyers is fine with them?  I know you believe it, but not one of you has the guts to come out in the open and admit it.  It wouldn’t blend well with your carefully crafted online warm and fuzzy personas, now would it?

And if that’s not a good enough reason, how about this.  Consumers are mislead by websites that use their wham, bam, spam and search engine optimization to steer clients away from competent, reasonably priced, honest lawyers and into the hands of lawyers who are happy to fee-split for the privilege.

Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett spelled out the issue as clearly as can be:



Am I engaged in “an attempt at lawyer exceptionalism”? Absolutely. 21st Century media landscape or no, lawyers are, and should be, exceptional. We have been given gifts—above-average intelligence, the opportunity to receive an advanced education—that the vast majority of people could never hope to receive. Further, society has given us a protected franchise: if an ordinary person tries to practice our art, he can go to prison. People entrust us daily with their lives, their fortunes, and their freedom.

Surely, in light of the exceptional advantages and responsibilities we’ve been given, it’s appropriate that higher rules be applied to lawyers than to those hawking Ginsu knives?

No. The marketers think that the same rules should apply to advertising lawyers as to used-car salesman. Law, to them, is a business governed by the rules of business, rather than a profession governed by its own higher rules. In the minds of the marketers that’s just peachy, since law-as-profession is just another way of saying “lawyer exceptionalism.”
I see that Kevin neglected to make note of Bennett’s post before jumping on the marketer bandwagon.  Maybe Kevin missed it.  Did you miss Bennett’s post, Kevin?  Is that where you went wrong?  Maybe you should forget about adding the twinkie contingent to your blogroll and spend more time listening to real lawyers?  Exceptional lawyers. 

Of course, it’s true that the elimination of ethical proscriptions on all the things that make it harder for the least competent, least ethical, least worthy lawyer to get clients would benefit the lowest echelon of the legal business.  And why not, marketers implore, since the competent, ethical and worthy don’t need their services, instead having clients seek out their services because of their reputation for excellence.

Kevin used to tell lawyers who used Lexblog to be excellent.  He used to tell them that the way to success was to demonstrate the finest qualities that a lawyer could possess on their blogs.  That was the sort of advice, if not command, that flowed from the brain of the Kevin O’Keefe I knew.

Who stole Kevin’s brain?  Please give it back.  Immediately.  He needs it.  And so do the rest of us.