That’s why Remy’s experience means so much. You see, Remy got pulled over by a cop and, despite everything he is and everything he knows, his reaction is quite telling.
Last night on my way home from the gym I was pulled over by local law enforcement’s finest. It was around 8:00 pm and I was sweaty and tired when I saw the blue lights in my rear view mirror. As I puled over, I began to feel my pulse rise and my hands get nervous. I thought to myself, “Why am I nervous and afraid? I haven’t done anything wrong!?
Remy’s stop turned south quickly, with the officer wasting little time playing the game.
He asked me for my license and registration and I nervously asked if I could get it out of my bag in the back seat. He replied, “Sir if you like I can get it for you.” (Here was his first attempt to search my car) I said no it was ok and that I would get it. That is when his tone changed and he replied, “Is there something you are trying to hide?”
I told him that I had nothing to hide but that I would get my wallet myself. He then ordered that I lower the back window, “for his safety”. When I cracked it open, he barked for me to lower it all the way. As I cracked the back window I watched as he stuck his head in my car looking into the back and at the floor board of the car. I nervously request that he please respect my privacy and keep his head out of my car.
He refused and told me that he had the right to protect himself and make sure that I was not reaching for a gun.
As I stood there in the cold fighting off the onslaught of questions with confused yes and nos coming out of my mouth, I finally drew the courage to draw the line when he asked me if the tattoos on my arm were gang related? This was the last draw… I stopped took a deep breath and replied, “I am nervous because I am standing on the side of a highway because of a “traffic stop” have never been taken out of my car and interrogated because of it.”
This is where I dropped the bomb on him and informed him that I was a attorney and that I was not allowing him to search because it was my Constitutional right and that by taking me out of my car he was in effect detaining me and that such detention was a violation of my Constitutional rights because he had no probable cause…
I no longer needed a light to see because his face first turned beet red and then pale white. This looming giant with a gun, bright lights and a badge seemed to literally shrink before my eyes. I have never been apologized to so many times in my life. He apologized for almost everything but my being fat!It worked. But this is critically important: Just because it worked this time doesn’t mean it will work next time, or for you, or for anyone else. The other option for the officer was to pull his taser and fire, or perhaps put Remy on the ground for his assaultive conduct, or any number of other aggressive used of force that could have harmed, perhaps permanently, Remy just to teach him a lesson. After all, there were only two people present to explain what just happened, and Remy was only one of them.
Much of Remy’s experience is unfortunately typical. The sight of flashing lights behind you is intended to strike fear in the heart of the most law-abiding citizen, as is the uniform, the approach, the demeanor and everything else about a traffic stop. It’s part of a calculated scheme to make the citizen submissive, which is good for the police officer. Yes, it’s a safety measure, and one should never forget the First Rule of Policing: Make it home for dinner.
At the same time, nervousness is the normal human reaction to a traffic stop. I once asked a panel of prospective jurors to raise their hands if they didn’t feel nervous when they saw the lights of a police cruiser in the rearview mirror, striking for cause everyone whose hand wasn’t raised as a liar or incompetent to serve. Every person of normal or better intelligence is nervous.
This too inures to the officer’s benefit, as a nervous drive is an excuse to do pretty much anything. That judges buy into this is the inside joke of suppression, as if the person with nothing to hide isn’t nervous. Everyone is nervous. Everyone. Even Remy. Even me.
There is an inclination on the part of those who “have nothing to hide” to take the path of least resistance and let the officer search. The whole point of the question, do you have anything to hide, is a psychological button pushed to overcome the citizen’s free choice. No one, given the belief that he can assert his rights without repercussions, would allow a search. The point is that the question is designed to make one feel that there will most assuredly be repercussions from the assertion of rights, and they won’t be good.
Why fight if you’ve got nothing to hide? Aside from the fact that more people have something to hide than they realize, because we are not the captives of law enforcement. We are endowed with certain inalienable rights, and we either assert them or lose them. Of course, this is easier to write on this blawg than assert on a dark road when it’s only you and the cop present.
Finally, all worked out for Remy, to the point where the officer apologized for his excesses and chose not to beat Remy to a bloody pulp. While this is great for Remy, it’s applicability to you is suspect. You may not be able to honestly say you’re a lawyer. You may not be able to react with sufficient restraint to avoid infuriating the officer. You may not get an apology.
Thankfully, Remy survived his experience intact. The same can’t be said for everyone. Be careful out there.
H/T Bobby Frederick at the South Caccalacca Criminal Defense Blog.

