Author Archives: SHG

But For Video: Misplaced Anger Edition

Every once in a while, a mistake occurs and a defendant is released who shouldn’t be.  When this happens, the evil defendant may make a run for it, hoping that his good fortune will allow him to continue to pillage.  The unaware defendant, however, may chose a different path, like the one that leads straight back to the jail to collect his belongings. 

One might suspect that the defendant who returns to the jail, quietly, politely, without the slightest degree of hostility, might be treated with some kindness, having merely done the normal thing, the right thing.  Nope.  Not when it’s the Kings County, Washington, jail.  From the Seattle Times :



[45 year old Daniel Macio] Saunders was mistakenly released from jail June 10 when prosecutors failed to alert the jail that charges had been filed. The prosecutor’s office blamed the mistake on a paperwork error.

Saunders went to the evidence unit June 11 to retrieve personal property that had been taken when he was booked into jail.
So what do you do when the guy you mistakenly released walked happily back into the jail?

Clearly, Saunders did nothing wrong, either in his being released or in his return to collect his things.  He was as compliant as could be, even holding the door open for the officer to enter.  Whatever happened to a simple “thank you?” Yet that didn’t prevent him from getting a darn good tuning up at the hands of Seattle’s finest.  Not just the typical, unwarranted use of force, but a severe beating, and then a tasing for good measure, rinse and repeat another four times.

But there’s the video, you say?  At least that will do the trick.  Well, not quite.


Prosecutors say the tape, “while not pretty,” exonerates the officers, who said in statements and sworn court documents that Saunders resisted arrest and “armed himself with a screwdriver and tried to injure the officers with the weapon.”

The Seattle Police Officers’ Guild said Saunders resisted and disobeyed the officers.

“They did everything right,” said Guild President Sgt. Rich O’Neill.
At least we can agree that the tape isn’t pretty.  From the prosecutor’s perspective, the video clearly shows how Saunders “actively resisted” the officers.  Of course, from the prosecutor’s perspective, the only appropriate reaction was for Saunders, essentially jumped without explanation, being unaware of the mistake leading to his release, to lie there and allow three cops to beat the living daylights out of him for no apparent reason.  How dare Saunders try not to let them beat him.

There’s little doubt that the violent police conduct was a product of externalizing their anger over the mistaken release, an embarrassing affair at best.  The cops screwed up, so the defendant requires a good beating.  Certainly anyone can appreciate that, right?

The only remaining problem is how a prosecutor could possibly view this video and reach the conclusion that this “exonerates the officers?”  I guess these old eyes of mine just aren’t working as well as the prosecutor’s.

H/T Injustice Everywhere

Caution: Simple Justice May Be Bad For Your Emotional Well Being

Every once in a while, I stray from legal topics into subject that bring in readers unfamiliar with Simple Justice.  Inexplicably, these readers, usually non-lawyers, feel compelled to explain to me at great length their thoughts and feelings on what appears here.  One such reader, Andrew, who is in the business of selling test preparation,  left a comment which included the following:


Lastly, swearing and berating those who care enough to spend their invaluable time starting a conversation with you is a great way to publicly demonstrate to others that you have no regard for the emotional well-being of others. If you would exhibit this attitude on Twitter and Facebook, then I definitely recommend you NOT use these social mediums EVER.
My first inclination was to politely explain to the commenter that he was a moron.  My second inclination was not to be so polite.  But in an effort to assist Andrew’s emotional well-being, I’ve decided to try to clarify matters in a calm, comforting manner.

My existence isn’t predicated on enhancing your emotional well-being.  I couldn’t care less.  That’s not why I’m here, this blog is here, anything I write is here.  Your emotional well-being is your problem, not mine.  And if you don’t like it, get lost.

You see, Andrew, the flaw in your understanding is that not everyone employs social media to sell something.  I know, I know, it’s beyond your wildest imagination.  After all, you’re busy trying to sell parents on buying whatever it is your selling so that little Johnny can get into college despite his straight “C” average, and that requires you to stroke them and make them like you, as if you truly care about Johnny’s, and Mommy’s, well-being.  You carefully craft a social media persona, create the appearance of deep empathy for the travails of others, knowing that if people like you, they will be more inclined to write you a check.  I understand.

The problem, Andrew, is that your understanding of the use of social media is myopic and dense. You are the very person against whom I rail, because you are what reduced every advancement in technology to its most base component, crass commercialism.  Because this is your purpose, you project it onto everyone else.  Whether that’s a sign of ignorance or psychosis is a matter for highly trained professionals, but the point is that your purpose is not universal.  Some people express opinions for purpose other than to get into Mommy’s pockets. 

You’re confused now, I realize.  Why?  Why would anyone do anything if not to make a buck?  It must be terribly hard for you to understand that there is a world out there consisting of people whose purpose differs from yours.  After all, if you are the center of the universe, what could possibly justify the existence of these outliers who don’t share your motivations?

The answer is really quite simple.  There is a marketplace of ideas that must, by definition, be disconnected from the marketplace of goods and services where you dwell.  Once ideas become subsumed in one’s marketing efforts, they are reduced to nonsense.  If one expresses a thought that is unpopular, that might turn a potential customer off, and then the carefully crafted persona of empathy crashes and burns.  A shill can’t allow that to happen, and so ideas must be suppressed in the name of business.

Simple Justice is deliberately impolite.  Discussions of ideas can offend people.  Discussions of ideas can turn off potential customers and clients.  I take that risk willingly, because without it there can be no worthwhile discussion of ideas. There are plenty of places on the internet where no one is offended, no customer is turned off.  This isn’t one of them.

To tell you the truth, you aren’t exactly the sort of person who should be reading Simple Justice.  Nor is that marketer, Doug Greathouse, who made the incredibly foolish mistake of thinking he could puff his marketing business in the comments here with impunity.  He offers nothing to the conversation. You offer nothing to the conversation.  You don’t belong at a blog the isn’t dedicated to respecting your desire to market.  And at Simple Justice, the desire to market is not respected.  If anything, it is ridiculed.

I urge you, and anyone who thinks like you, to go elsewhere to find a warm and fuzzy place where others appreciate your goal of trying to sell whatever it is you sell to mommies.  There is no room for someone like you on a blog that cares nothing for your emotional well-being.  And in case I wasn’t clear, I care nothing for your emotional well-being.  And I surely didn’t ask for your thoughts on any subject.

And I apologize for writing a post that you felt compelled to read.  I apologize for my post being twitted, such that you saw it and stopped by.  I apologize for writing something that made you feel the need to comment.  I apologize if I’ve offended you. But please don’t follow me on twitter.  Please don’t read anything here at Simple Justice.  No one here is going to buy anything from you, so there’s no purpose in your ever returning.  Besides, coming here can be harmful to your emotional well-being, and I certainly don’t want to be responsible for that.

And that goes for anyone else who feels that I have callously harmed their emotional well being.

Do It For The Children: “Meep!” Edition

It’s about time.  25 students at the Calumet middle school in Chicago were arrested for a food fight.  “You can take someone’s eye out with pudding, you know,” I muttered to no one in particular. 

“My children have to appear in court,” Erica Russell, the mother of two eighth-grade girls who spent eight hours in jail, said Tuesday. “They were handcuffed, slammed in a wagon, had their mug shots taken and treated like real criminals.”

Some mother you turned out to be, Erica.  No remorse at all for the clothing that will need to be washed, the floors the will need to be scrubbed.  Is this the lesson you’ve taught your delinquent girls, to wield slices of white bread like ninja stars?  Maybe their stint in a holding cell will be just the ticket to teach them who’s in charge, and prevent a future of shooting heroin and wearing fishnet stockings.  It starts with a food fight, but ends up with bank robberies.  Are you raising bank robbers, Erica?

But the compelling need to squash violence in the cafeteria is one thing.  Silencing a conspiracy of students is another.  Via Turley,


[Principal Thomas] Murray stumbled on a conspiracy on Facebook where he learned that kids in the Danvers High School in Massachusetts intended to say “Meep!” in school — mimicking the lab assistant to Dr. Bunsen Honeydew, Beaker, of “The Muppet Show.”

As if Murray was going to stand by and allow the students to take over and “meep” in his school!  Not during his watch they won’t.  No way, baby.


Murray, however, did not want it in his school and banned it — sending an automated call to parents warning that any student using “Meep!” could be suspended. His minions had uncovered a plot for students to do a “mass meep” in one part of the school.
The disruption that a “mass meep” would cause to the educational process is more than any professional educator could stand.  This must be stopped. This must be silenced.  This cannot be allowed to happen or the next thing you know, there will be a food fight.

So naturally, some do-gooder anti-establishment Bill Kunstler wannabe lawyer, Theodora Michaels, decided to undermine the authority of Principal Murray with a snarky internet letter.



An open letter to Principal Murray of Danvers High School (MA):


Meep.


Sincerely,
Theodora Michaels


Very nice.  It’s not hard enough to teach children to behave with respect and submission to authority, so we need some wise-guy entertainment lawyer to lob grenades into the delicate balance of respecting authority and being obsequious. 

Fortunately, Principal Murray demonstrated no fear in confronting Michaels’ outrageous affront to education.


She says that the response was fast and furious: “Yesterday I received a reply email from Assistant Principal Mark Strout, which said (in full) “Your E-mail has been forwarded to the Danvers Police Department.”
That will teach Theodora a lesson or two.  We can only hope there’s still room in the holding cell after they’ve rounded up all the scoundrel food-fighters.  What do you have to say now, Michaels?

Meep?

Putting “Political Ideology Ahead of Safety”

Senator John Cornyn of the Great Republic of Texas knows when a man needs killin’.  And accused mastermind of the 9/11 attack on the World Trade Center, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, is just such a man in Cornyn’s eyes.  Forget all the talk about how safety is jeopardized by putting him on trial in a “civilian court” like a “common criminal.”  They know better.

The fear is clear.  If KSM is tried in the Southern District of New York, liberal Manhattan jurors won’t vote to execute him. 


But one challenge in seeking the “ultimate justice” is New York’s jury pool, which is generally perceived by prosecutors and defense lawyers to be more liberal than other places.

Indeed, the last executions in federal cases in Manhattan occurred in the 1950s, most notably the case of the Rosenbergs.

While our United States Senators, including the amorphous Joe Lieberman of Connecticut, are busy playing the crowd, they are well aware of silly inflammatory nature of their rhetoric about the inability of our federal courts to deal with this trial. 


Sen. Joe Lieberman, I-Connecticut, agreed with [Texas Rep. Lamar] Smith that suspected terrorists ought to be tried by military commissions.

“It is inconceivable that we would bring these alleged terrorists back to New York for trial, to the scene of the carnage they created eight years ago, and give them a platform to mock the suffering of their victims and the victims’ families, and rally their followers to continue waging jihad against America,” he said in a statement.

Since when is a trial a “platform to mock the suffering” of anyone?  It makes it sound as if KSM gets to control the proceedings, as if the federal judge who conducts this trial will be a willing accomplice in stage show designed to encourage jihad.  Please. There is nothing KSM can do that will make him appear appealing to America or most the world.  As for those who agree with him, he will be the martyr no matter where the trial occurs. 

What is most troubling about these politicians is their efforts to deliberately convey to the public the belief that the legal system, the Constitution, only applies when it suits them.  The fact that there is a dispute over the propriety of trying KSM in New York demonstrates that they’ve been very effective in crafting a belief that anyone labeled a “terrorist” falls outside the realm of the criminal justice system.


Republican lawmakers and the self-promoting independent senator from Connecticut, Joseph Lieberman, pounced on the chance to appear on television. Despite all evidence to the contrary, they said military tribunals are a more secure and appropriate venue for trying terrorism suspects. Senator John Cornyn of Texas, a former judge who should have more regard for the law, offered the absurd claim that Mr. Obama was treating the 9/11 conspirators as “common criminals.”

Don’t blame Cornyn and Lieberman for seizing the opportunity, but question why anyone would take them seriously.  For better of worse, the United States has developed a methodology for determining whether anyone who has committed an offense against our nation.  Theoretically, this methodology comports with the demands of the Constitution, the fundamental framework for the operation of our government and its assertion of authority over others.  These Senators took an oath to uphold this Constitution.

Yet they jump through hoops, blurt out inflammatory claims as if our system only applies to “common criminals,” and seek to delude the public with false claims that the system upon which American justice is grounded is suddenly incapable of dealing with an incoming flight from Gitmo?  They suggest that there must be another secret America, where trials are conducted in secret to protect our ears from the evils of torture and our people from the threat of still more jihadist bombers?

Here’s a newsflash.  We already know about the waterboarding.  It’s been in all the papers.  We know that KSM was subject to waterboarding 183 times.  That’s old news, and the disclosure at trial isn’t going to surprise anyone.

Here’s another newsflash.  If the jihadists want to blow up a building to show us what they think of our system, our “freedoms”, there are plenty around.  We’ve got a country filled with big building built from Indiana limestone, and even if KSM is tried in a newly built courtroom on the Island of Cuba, they can still blow one up in Nebraska and capture our attention.

We have one thing to offer in support of our position that America represents freedom, democracy and the rule of law, even in the face of difficult and troubled times.  Our adherence to our own principles.  I know, this seems wrong to those who never really like the idea of giving a terrorist a better shot than he gave us, but that’s what distinguishes us from them.

And our Senators know all this, so I’m hardly telling them anything new.  This is just the surrounding fluff to make palatable their real reason for their vigorous opposition to trying KSM in Manhattan.  They just don’t trust New Yorkers to put him to death.  It’s that simple.  And the funny thing is, they’re probably right.

The question isn’t whether we’re capable of trying Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, but whether America could stand letting Khalid Sheikh Mohammed live after the trial. 

But before we leave the “political ideology” front, Jonathon Turley asks a very good question.



The decision to send some detainees to military tribunals, however, is a baffling contradiction. Holder has denied the Administration the high ground in the debate by trying to appease both sides and deny due process to some of these accused individuals. It is a case of snatching hypocrisy out of the jaws of principle.
Just as Cornyn and Lieberman can’t have two Americas, neither can Holder.

Big Numbers and No Influence

Like it or not, a very large part of Mark Britton’s role as CEO of Avvo is to market.  It’s a social media business, and social media businesses don’t survive without finding someone willing to pay them money.  So when Mark takes a position contrary to the every-growing population of social media experts, it means something.  And, as Mark puts it, he’s letting the “cat out of the bag.”


…the number of one’s Twitter followers has nothing to do with his or her influence. In other words, 9.9 times out of ten, the heavily Twitter-followed have as much influence as this guy. You don’t know him, do you? And, that’s the point. This guy could go on Twitter tomorrow and start following 100,000 people. Within a couple of months, he would have tens of thousands of followers, simply because the people he originally followed are flattered to be followed and follow him back.

So here is the true Twitter litmus test on the influence front: Look at the ratio of the number of people someone is “following” vs. their “followers” (i.e., divide their “following” number by their “follower” number). The closer that ratio is to 0 (e.g., 125 “following” divided by 40,000 “followers”), the more influential that person is. And, conversely, the closer that ratio is to 1 (e.g., 34,956 “following” divided by 40,000 “followers”), and especially if it exceeds 1 (e.g., 42,566 “following” divided by 40,000 “followers”), the *less* influential that person probably is. Rather than being a thought leader, maven or ninja, they are regular people just like you and me — they just work harder at spamming Twitter for followers than you or me.
While I hate to quibble, it’s not quite true that they are just “regular people,” unless your idea of regular people are those whose goal in using twitter, perhaps the internet as a whole, is to promote the living crap out of themselves and their businesses.  While I hesitate to use a percentage, my experience is that the vast majority of people twitting do so exclusively as a delivery mechanism for marketing.  That means that marketers are marketing to marketers who are marketing to other marketers.  And then, there are a few people who just happen to be on twitter for fun and, occasionally, to hang out and communicate with their friends.

Recently, my young friend Adrian Dayton, who has done a bang up job of establishing himself as a twitter expert despite the lack of clarity as to what qualifies him to teach anything to lawyers, has been giving seminars to those lawyers too dumb to twit on their own.  In the process, he twits to his 38,000 almost 39,000 followers to retweet his twit.  The purpose is to show the “power” of the retweet and the influence he wields by virtue of his many followers. 

It’s a fascinating exercise, both because it’s likely to be quite persuasive to Adrian’s audience, and it’s a total load of crap.  Of course, the audience is unlikely to realize that latter, lacking a clear understanding that followers on twitter are too often named “Britney” or themselves only interested in gathering as many followers as possible in their simplistic quest at marketing hegemony.  It’s a meaningless bit of theater, except for the fact that its goal is to get people to pay to learn the magic secret of great twitter influence.

Mark makes the point with a Charles Schulz impression.


To put this into [comic] relief, let me offer an offline, hypothetical conversation between, let’s say, Lucy and Charlie Brown.

Lucy: I went to a party last night with 65,000 people … I’m sooooo influential.

Charlie Brown: Really, who did you talk to?

Lucy: I don’t know, I just talked and talked.

Charlie Brown: Was anyone listening?

Lucy: Of course they were! Didn’t I just tell you there were 65,000 people!


As for me, I’m just going to keep pulling the football back every time some social media guru tries to kick it through the uprights.  I realize that technology is full of strange and mysterious ways, and that the chorus of people telling you that you absolutely, positively must utilize every new shiny thing or your practice will die and your life will be over.  Somebody has to remind you that there is no magic bullet that will change the fundamental requirements of a successful law practice: hard work, competence, integrity and client service. 

And somebody has to tell you that there’s no shortcut, like amassing a bunch of worthless followers on twitter.  My thanks to Mark Britton for letting that cat of the bag.

Lessig Blew It

When Harvard Lawprof Lawrence Lessig decided to invite Eliot Spitzer to speak at the Edmond J. Safra Foundation Center for Ethics, it could have gone either way.  Sure, Spitzer’s one-time babe, Kristin Davis, took issue with the fact that she bore the consequences of his lack of zipper control, while he got to lecture at Harvard.  She asked some very good questions of Prof. Lessig, but as far as I can tell, Lessig never answered.

This could have been a winner.  After all, who better to discuss ethics than one who has sinned?

Alas, that wasn’t Lessig’s approach.



Professor Lessig said that until resigning in March 2008, Mr. Spitzer “inspired the very best in our profession” and is “the most important living prosecutor on a wide range of corruption.”
There is possibly nothing Lessig could have said that would have highlighted the blatant hypocrisy more. 

It’s certainly a professor’s job to teach a lesson to his students.  The lesson Larry Lessig taught was that cynics are right, that there is no reason why a person like Eliot Spitzer, who wielded his office like the sword of the avenging angel, shouldn’t be forgiven his own trespasses when he was incapable of showing the slightest empathy toward anyone else. 

Eliot Spitzer is an important prosecutor.  Not because he was so good at it, or that his investigation and prosecution of corporate corruption did much to help society.  He was important because he was the personal embodiment of the hypocrisy of the legal system.  How dare he go after others while engaging in criminal conduct himself?  How dare he be as harsh, as vicious, as unforgiving, while he was every bit as engaged in wrongdoing as those he targeted.

There was a wonderful lesson to be taught by Larry Lessig at Harvard.  And Lessig totally blew it.  Instead, the message was clear.  Neither honor nor integrity matter.  Just squint a bit and turn your head a little to the left, and all the deceit and hypocrisy magically disappears.  Then we can pretend whatever we want, as if reality is no constraint to the lesson plan.

That this lesson was taught by the director of the Edmond J. Safra Foundation Center for Ethics at Harvard Law School leaves me to wonder: Is there anyone left who cares, who comprehends, what it means to possess ethics?  Clearly, Lessig hasn’t a clue.

Chicago Puts The Brakes On Lidar

There are four ways to tell if a driver is speeding.  Two old school, observation and following, and two new, radar and laser, and even radar is considered pretty old school these days. Laser, also known at Lidar, is the method all the really cool cops use.  Except in Chicago.

Via Kevin Underhill at Lowering the Bar, the Chicago Trib reports that speeding tickets based on Lidar are being tossed:

Within the past year judges in Cook County Traffic Court in Chicago determined that speeds captured by lidar were not admissible because the devices had not been proven scientifically reliable in an Illinois court, said Jennifer Hoyle, spokeswoman for the law department, which prosecutes most speeding tickets in the city.

The judges brushed aside the office’s position that such a legal hearing was unnecessary because lidar devices, which use a light beam instead of radio waves, have been used by police departments across the country with no problems for a long time and because some courts outside Illinois already had found them to be scientifically sound.

This is quite extraordinary, given the inclination of the courts to grab hold of scientific methodology it doesn’t understand and apply it because, well, it exists.  Laser guns have become ubiquitous in law enforcement, the tool of choice for many speeding applications since it purportedly eliminates certain of the faults and maintenance requirements of radar (yes, there are faults, if anyone bothered to read tha manual, and radar, if properly used, requires daily upkeep and constant calibration).  Once scientific thingies like this become “generally accepted,” rightly or wrongly, the idea that a court would reject it until actually proven within a jurisdiction is heresy. 

To their credit, judges in Chicago have refused to accept Lidar evidence in the absence of proof by Frye hearing.


The legal procedure required to prove a technology is scientifically reliable — a Frye hearing, as it is known in Illinois — is laborious and expensive, experts said. The hearing requires witnesses and can stretch for days.

That’s the reason the city law department was reluctant to initiate one against a defendant, Hoyle said.

Since last month the department has begun seeking such a hearing in the small percent of speeding cases in which the defendant has a defense attorney, she said. But each time the defendant has chosen to pay the fine rather than participate.

The department hopes the Cook County state’s attorney’s office will secure a Frye hearing because that office handles the most serious speeding cases in which the defendant has more invested.

And what is the plan should the City fail to prevail at a Frye hearing?


If they fail, Hoyle said, the prosecutors will seek a state law that explicitly recognizes lidar as scientifically reliable.
There’s the rub.  As Kevin points out, this is like the Indiana legislature’s attempt to redefine π, which is certainly a better use of their time than outlawing gravity.

I have no idea whether Lidar is a scientifically valid method of determining the speed of a vehicle, or what flaws, false positives or negatives, limitations or problems are faced by its use.  I do, however, admire the judges in Chicago who refuse to just go with the flow and adopt the use of this technology because everyone else is.  The courts are awash in bad science, most of which serve the government to prove that citizens are breaking the law and many, historically, are proven somewhat less accurate and effective than originally believed.  Not that it helps those individuals convicted based on junk science.

The point isn’t that Lidar is junk science.  The point is that a bunch of judges are doing their jobs as gatekeepers of technology, introduced as conclusive proof of an offense.  If the state wants to get its evidence into court, it has to prove it validity first.  And no, it can’t just pass a law saying a particular piece of technology is admissible into evidence any more than it can pass a law stating that the sun revolves around the earth.  Science either is or is not valid, and lawmakers don’t get to change it.

The View Through The Bars (Update)

Amongst the many emails received daily with news, videos, stories and promotions that are floating around out there (most of which I can’t possibly post about, much to the consternation of readers and publicists), came this installment from the Ann Arbor Chronicle, Washtenaw Jail Diary: Chapter 3.  Largely because the sender made no effort to hype the content, I took a chance and read the article.  It was worth my time, and I hope worth yours.

This articulate and introspective view by an anonymous detainee, that started as twits and developed into a narrative, with the anticipation that it might be published as a book, reflects one person’s understanding of law and life inside.  Some of his ideas will offend lawyers, particularly public defenders who take their responsibility seriously and will bristle at being called “public pretenders.” or snake oil salesmen.  Bear in mind that this isn’t about you, but about the author and his understanding of a very strange and foreign world.

Some excerpts, just to whet your whistle.


I am taken from my block and brought to a room back near the dreaded holding tanks, meeting with the person with whom I am to entrust my life. And here, in front of me, is Clarence fucking Darrow, himself – all bluster and a bit cartoonish, reveling, it seems to me, in being the center of attention. He is surrounded by assistants, interns, law students – almost all of whom, I am strangely curious to discover, are attractive young women.


The Pretender tells me that I am not the usual kind of person he represents, since I am apparently well-spoken and educated. But that does not prevent him from launching into street lingo, some of which I ask him to translate for me. He speaks this way out of habit, I am guessing, to try to win the trust of his usual crop of clients.

I have mixed feelings about my Pretender. Do I want what appears to me to be a snake oil salesman representing my interests in these felony cases? Maybe this is exactly the kind of person I need on my side. The lawyer in my misdemeanor cases seemed much too timid for me – in fact, agreeing with the prosecutor in court.

Moot question. The price is right for the Public Pretender. Free is all I can afford, and I guess you get what you pay for.


It’s really worth reading, both for its inherent interest and value, as well as for a deeper understanding of how we’re perceived by others in our effort to do our job.

And if you enjoy this, you might also want to revisit this story by Jeffrey A. Tucker from the Ludwig von Mises Institute, another really great view from the inside. (Thanks to Kathleen, our hinterlands correspondent for reminding me of the Tucker post.)

Fear of Flying

When Steve Bierfeldt, the Campaign for Liberty Staffer, was stopped and held for carrying $4,700 while going through airport security, the TSA explained that he violated their basic rule : Just do what you’re told.  If people would just cooperate, it would make our government’s job so much easier.

Quietly, the TSA backed off after suit was filed by the ACLU on Bierfeldt’s behalf.  As reported by the Washington Times :


The new rules, issued in September and October, tell officers “screening may not be conducted to detect evidence of crimes unrelated to transportation security” and that large amounts of cash don’t qualify as suspicious for purposes of safety.
Taken at face value, this is huge. 

“We had been hearing of so many reports of TSA screeners engaging in wide-ranging fishing expeditions for illegal activities,” said Ben Wizner, a staff lawyer for the ACLU, pointing to reports of officers scanning pill-bottle labels to see whether the passenger was the person who obtained the prescription as one example.

He said screeners get a narrow exception to the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits unreasonable searches, strictly to keep weapons and explosives off planes, not to help police enforce other laws.

But that, of course, is the ACLU’s version of the new rules.  Does it mean that the government will no longer check laptop computers for pornography?  Does it mean that they will limit their inquiry only to weapons and explosives?  What does the TSA have to say?



TSA spokeswoman Lauren Gaches said the new “internal directives” are meant to ensure their screeners are consistent. She acknowledged the policy on large sums of cash had changed, but wouldn’t provide a copy of either document. She said the directives would not be released unless a Freedom Of Information Act request was submitted by The Washington Times.

“TSA routinely assesses its policies and screening procedures to ensure the highest levels of security nationwide,” she said. “Currency alone is not a threat, and TSA does not restrict the amount of currency a traveler may carry through the checkpoint.”
A few little details appear to distinguish what the TSA has in mind from what the ACLU thinks it got.  While the amount of currency, alone, may no longer suffice to hold a traveler, what about the multitude of other things that might give rise to screeners deciding to play cop?  It’s rather outrageous, and ridiculous, that a government agency has issued directives to its personnel but refuses to release them to the Washington Times without a FOIA request.  Why are they keeping the rules a secret?

Nothing that spokeswoman Gaches said suggests that the TSA is going along with the ACLU’s vision of limiting screening to weapons and explosives.  At best, they are agreeing that cash alone isn’t a sufficient reason to detain and question a traveler.  But what of cash and furtive movements, excessive nervousness, unacceptable responses to commonlaw inquiries? 

And if TSA screeners are supposed to be consistent, what about the sideways glance  and wink at the Customs agent, or the local cop, or anybody else in a uniform with a gun who might be interested in asking a few questions?  They aren’t subject to the TSA’s directives, and there remains no constraint, as the ACLU suggests, on their asking whatever questions, and taking whatever actions, seem like a good idea at the time.

Frankly, one of my biggest fears is that some militant terrorist is going to board a plane with a roll of dollar bills and hurl it with great velocity at the head of one of the flight crew.  Can you imagine the havoc that would wreak?  It’s the Shoe Bomber Affect, one wild-eyed doofus’ misguided attempt to place explosive in his shoe has caused untold millions of people worldwide to walk barefoot through metal detectors.  One man with bad hair did this to hundreds of millions of people.  The possibilities are mind-boggling.

The good news is that this change in policy may well impact the natural inclination for those in uniform to feel entitled to question or challenge any conduct that strikes them as worthy, as we pass through a screening process that presents an extraordinarily intrusive opportunity to inspect us.  But this hardly reaches the panacea of limiting searches at airports to just weapons and explosives, as much as the ACLU would believe the contrary.  A step in the right direction.  A small step.

Threading the Needle in Marikafka County

Jameson Johnson, a Phoenix litigation support guy, tells me that Radley Balko’s name for Maricopa County, Marikafka, has become part of the local lexicon.  The division between the criminal defense side, those who have even the smallest expectation that law will prevail over order, could not be more clear than the image painted of the courtroom in the continued hearing of Adam Stoddard by Nick Martin at Heat City.


Maricopa County Judge Gary Donahoe looked out on a courtroom divided cleanly in half on Tuesday, all the way back through the gallery. On one side was a packed batch of local defense attorneys. On the other, a battery of sheriff’s deputies, each donning a brown uniform and badge.

This image didn’t escape the judge’s attention.


Donahoe scanned the courtroom and shrugged. “There is a line here that I have to balance,” he said. Then he asked the two sides what he should do.

It’s as if the judge feared that the wrong decision, the one that upset the brown badged side, and he wouldn’t make it out of the courtroom.  If not that day, then some day.  Stoddard’s fellow deputies wouldn’t forget that he didn’t back them up, no matter what.  That’s how the deal works when you wear a uniform and carry a gun.  I f you expect them to take a bullet for you, you better be prepared to take one for them. 


The defense attorney, Joanne Cuccia, whose file was rifled by Stoddard behind her back as she argued, took the stand on the final day of the hearing.  Her testimony was curious.


Final testimony wrapped up Tuesday with Cuccia saying she was concerned about her reputation. An attorney for 10 years with a spotless record with the bar, Cuccia said she felt like she was being accused of a crime herself. “I’ve never been accused of wrongdoing before,” she said.

Craig Mehrens, a high-profile Phoenix lawyer who is representing Cuccia in the matter, asked her: “Other than your reputation, what else do you have as a lawyer?”

“Nothing,” she said.

Certainly, Cuccia was hurt at the suggestion that her file harbored evidence of a crime, or that she subverted the local process by failing to adhere to the courthouse protocol.  But rather than express outrage at Stoddard’s conduct, she was defensive, as if “she was being accused of a crime herself.”  She wasn’t, so why succumb to feelings of guilt and regret?  More importantly, where was the outrage at the violation of the sanctity of her file?

The question is now in Judge Gary Donahoe’s hands, but it has become increasingly unclear what the question is.


Donahoe said he did not have the authority to hold Stoddard in “direct criminal contempt” because the offense had not taken place in front of him or even in his courtroom.

If anything, Donahoe said, he could decide to hold the detention officer in “indirect civil contempt,” which carries much less weight. Even then, Stoddard has already given the documents in question back to the defense attorney, so Donahoe said he was unsure what order the contempt citation could carry.

What you are smelling is capitulation.  Donahoe is undercutting the point of the hearing, piece by piece, inch by inch, letting the audience down easy as if his hands were tied.  Poor Judge Donahoe.  Whatever can he do?


“I don’t want to unnecessarily hinder or prevent deputies from carrying out security in the courtroom,” Donahoe said.

But Mehrens argued the judge has a greater duty to protect the attorney-client privilege, a sacred right in the legal world.

“I would argue that’s exactly your job,” Mehrens said.

Any attack on that is harmful to the entire legal system, he said. He asked Donahoe to hold not only Stoddard, but also the entire Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office, in contempt and to fine the people involved personally.

Of course, that’s not going to happen.  Tom Liddy (yes, son of that Liddy), the county attorney who represents the deputies, offers the compromise that will allow Donahoe to pretend to do his job while doing no more than pacify the crowd.


“It is not the position of the sheriff that was the right thing to do,” Liddy told the judge. “It’s the position of the sheriff that he had a good-faith basis to do so.”

Liddy conceded that Stoddard could have handled things better, but that this was merely a poor choice in the good faith performance of his duty.  Having seen words on a paper that raised “red flags,” what choice did Stoddard have but to safeguard the public from this evil Mexican drug gang member, a gang that has been known to “corrupt criminal defense lawyers.”

Mehrens wasn’t buying, and put up a valiant front:



But Mehrens responded by telling the judge that all the talk about the Mexican Mafia and what other attorneys have done in the past is a distraction from the case at hand. No one has suspected Cuccia of being corrupted, and in fact, the document that was taken never revealed a crime had taken place.

“It was not a good faith belief,” Mehrens said. “It is a belief by him and by the people he works for that they can do anything they want and get away with it.”
There is really no legal argument to be made in favor of dumb good faith trumping the attorney/client privilege, but as Donahoe made clear, he isn’t going to let that stand in his way of staying on the good side of the deputies.  His decision will eventually issue, but the writing on the wall is already pretty clear:  Stoddard was wrong, but not malevolent, in his violating Cuccia’s file.  Donahoe will give Stoddard a relatively firm rebuke, but no penalty for his actions, both because Donahoe’s hands are tied and because Stoddard’s only motivation was to perform his duty to protect the court and the public.  Donahoe will admonish the sheriff’s department to train their deputies to be more respectful of the sanctity of the defense file, and to seek court intervention when they believe that the file contains evidence of a wrong.  And everyone will go home happy.

One might think that Judge Donahoe doesn’t have the guts to do his job, to stare down the sea of deputies in his courtroom and let them know which side of the law they work for.  But I doubt he has the slightest interest in doing so, even if he had the balls for it.  His comments seem designed to further his real purpose, to deflect the glare of a watching nation from a video of one of the most outrageous and egregious violations of privilege so that this ugly and tense moment in the Marikafka County courthouse fades quickly from memory. 

I can’t help but wonder, as the edge of this matter grows increasingly dull in the hands of Judge Gary Donahoe, whether any of the locals who felt that it would have been too dangerous and troublesome for Cuccia to make a stand at the time this happened, to have not “calmed down” with her feelings of persecution, to have used that opportunity to strike a blow. 

What do they plan to do after Donahoe decides?  Call it Marikafka County and smirk at their wit?  Big deal.