Author Archives: SHG

Duty To Twit

While the name Justin Bieber draws a total blank around here, apparently he’s got something that makes pre-adolescent juices flow.  Enough so that about 3,000 young women, with their parents since someone had to drive them, came to Roosevelt Field Mall in Nassau Count, New York.  Apparently, the nice people who run the mall, and were aware that 15 year old Mr. Bieber would be making a personal appearance, were caught unprepared for such devotion.

The police, fearful of the unconstrained crowds, decided that things had gotten out of hand and were, appropriately, fearful that bad things were going to happen.  So they turned to James Roppo, 44, an executive with Island Def Jam records, and told him to twit :

Police said that Roppo, senior vice president for sales for Island Def Jam Records, was at the mall Friday and hindered crowd control by not cooperating when police requested that he send a Twitter message asking the crowd to leave.

Diane Peress, Nassau assistant district attorney, said that Roppo created a “very dangerous situation” by failing to help police disperse the fans gathered on a second-floor balcony.

“Young people were being pressed up against the glass,” Peress said. The group pressed against a railing so hard that it was bent, she said.

People could have fallen from the balcony or the rail could have collapsed, Peress said. “It’s a miracle more kids and more people weren’t injured.”

There’s little doubt that this could have turned to tragedy, with potential harm to many young people.  But to blame this “very dangerous situation” on James Roppo is hard to comprehend.  Clearly, he didn’t cause it.  There’s no allegation that he engaged in any affirmative act that either gave rise to a danger or contributed to a danger.  What he did, according to the police side of the story, is fail to twit.  This raises a simple question: Is there a duty to twit?

Roppo was arraigned on a string of charges on Saturday.

ChargeDetail Disposition/Sentence
PL 195.05 00 A Misdemeanor, 1 count, Arrest charge, Arraignment charge

Description Obstrct Gvrnmntl Admn 2nd
PL 260.10 01 A Misdemeanor, 1 count, Arrest charge, Arraignment charge

Description Act Manr Injur Child < 17
PL 120.20 00 A Misdemeanor, 1 count, Arrest charge, Arraignment charge

Description Reckless Endangerment 2nd
PL 240.45 01 B Misdemeanor, 1 count, Arrest charge, Arraignment charge

Description Endangering Health Of Oth
PL 120.05 03
**TOP CHARGE**
D Felony, 1 count, Arrest charge, Arraignment charge

Description Aslt- 2:int Caus Ph Inj To Off

The top count,  assault in the second degree, provides:

3. With intent to prevent a police officer . . . from performing a lawful duty, he causes physical injury to such  police officer.

Nowhere in the reports of the fracas is there any information about Roppo causing physical injury to a police officer.  As to the lesser charges, each involves the commission of an act.  If the police claims are accurate, which Roppo denies, his offense was one of omission, not commission. 

Even with that, it appears that the allegations may be wrong.  As Peter Kafka at Media Memos shows, twits were indeed twitted to tell the young ladies to scram.

Slightly confusing, because Bieber’s Twitter account–presumably the one the cops wanted Roppo to use–does indeed show that he asked his fans to leave at 4:30 pm Eastern :

bieber twitter

But apparently that was too late :

bieber twitter 2

There appears to be absolutely no legal basis whatsoever to support the prosecution of James Roppo, whether one believes the police that he’s a terrible man for failing to do as they told him or not.  There simply isn’t any duty to twit, nor any argument to support the allegation that his failure to do as he was told by police violated a duty imposed on him by law. 

While it may well be the right thing to do to help police to disperse a crowd of unhappy girls, full of whatever flows through their bodies at the thought to Justin Bieber, the failure to do so isn’t a crime.  This didn’t stop First District Judge Anthony Paradiso from imposing $50,000 bail, apparently in order to assure that Roppo didn’t flee to Tasmania to avoid the charges.  Perhaps he feared that Roppo would be a threat to society by not twitting again.  The reasoning is unclear.

It’s hardly clear that a twit by Roppo, or by Justin Bieber as the case may be, would have had any impact on this situation, and there’s little doubt that it had the
potential for danger.  Given the demographics, it’s hard to imagine that most of the young ladies would have been aware of a twit had it been sent.  Of course, perhaps the mothers and fathers present would have gotten it and told their kids that it was time to go home.  If anything, a twit by Justin Bieber would have certainly been more likely to convey the point than one by Roppo.

But regardless of the efficacy of the twit, the police cannot manufacture a duty to act, upon pain of criminal liability, just because they want to. It doesn’t matter whether the twit would have helped or not, whether the situation is dangerous or not. The police sought to impose a duty on Roppo to twit as he was told.  No such duty exists, and criminal liability is imposed for an act, not an omission.  Even in Nassau County, which has long had its share of twits, even before twitter was invented.

H/T Ed. at Blawgreview, who has taken quite a shine to this story.

A Blog That Shouldn’t (Update)

I’m often attributed with the sentiment that “anyone can blawg; everyone can’t.”  I’ve found an exception to my rule.  Amongst the many who seek the attention of more establish blawgers are the newbies, hoping to make it onto our blogroll or, better still, get us to post about their existence.

I received a fairly aggressive request from a woman  named Stef at a blog called Forward Movement, and in a moment of weakness, decided to take a look.  The blog bills itself as a home for wayward youth.

This general interest blawg is a collection of young professionals and their efforts to move their careers forward. Authors may be developing a side interest apart from their practice area, writing to enhance their name recognition, or searching for new employment. All authors are Attorneys or MBAs, and are within several years of having graduated.

I admit to having smirked at the “several years of having graduated” (how many years are there in a “several”), but I have a soft spot for kids and decided to look deeper.  So I took a look at what was posted under “Criminal Law” to see what the kids had on their mind.  I wish I hadn’t.

The latest post was by Keyana, who describes herself as “an aspiring criminal defense attorney” who has “not begun practicing law yet.”  One might suppose that either or both of this factors might influence her to remain silent.  One would be very wrong.  Not only does Keyana feel the need to express her thoughts, but on a subject of some significance.  Her post was entitled, How Attorneys Can Represent Their Guilty As Charged Clients In Good Conscience.

As an aspiring criminal defense attorney, the moral dilemmas that I will inevitably face trouble me. Especially in the arena of litigation, it seems to me all attorneys experience some degree of moral conflict at one point or another regardless of whether the trial involves a criminal or civil matter. And so the ultimate question is how does a criminal defense attorney in good conscience represent the guilty? And by the same token, how does a civil attorney in good conscience represent the wrong?

Like every tough question, there is no bright line answer. However, after given these questions much thought and reading what other people have to say about this issue, I believe litigators can align their professional duties with their moral responsibilities by (1) Seeking justice and (2) Thinking creatively.

Criminal defense lawyers hear the question posed at cocktail parties all the time.  It’s a great way to chat with nice but clueless people who find our work “fascinating”.  What it isn’t is a “tough question.”  Not for a lawyer.  Not for a criminal defense lawyer.

If anything, it’s a Rorschach test.  If you have to ask the question, then you shouldn’t be a criminal defense lawyer.  Probably not a lawyer at all.  And if it troubles you, then perhaps a career in waste management would be best.  And what did her criminal law prof at Pepperdine teach her that she arrived at this understanding?

It’s my belief that you can seek justice and be a zealous advocate simultaneously even when you believe your client is in the wrong because justice is a multifaceted concept. Justice encompasses not only traditional notions of morality and fairness but due process. As far as morality and fairness are concerned, even the guilty is entitled to a fair outcome. It’s the attorney’s duty to present their client’s side of the story to help facilitate a fair outcome. In terms of due process, this entails constitutional protections. And so, if for example a case is won on a constitutional technicality, such as evidence being inadmissible because it is fruit of the poisonous tree, that too is justice. My point is justice is complex and it does not come in one-size-fits-all. And so even if you are certain your client is guilty or was in the wrong, in some aspects of the case justice may be on your client’s side and it’s an attorney’s duty to bring those details to light.

It pains me to read this.  Not just because Keyana, who I’ve no doubt means well, has so little understanding of the role of defense lawyer, but that she felt the need to express her thoughts publicly. Why would you do this?  You’re young. You’re new. You’re barely a lawyer who has never actually done anything yet, and still you expose your thoughts to public scrutiny.  It’s crazy.

In fairness to Keyana, my sense is that she doesn’t mean what she writes.  She simply doesn’t know better, and harbors the childlike comprehension of criminal defense that so many do as they step out of the classroom but before they ever step into the courtroom.  She may well make a wonderful criminal defense lawyer some day, after someone explains to her why her thinking is so far off base.  Some day, she may deeply regret having posted this.  But posted she did, and forever it will remain, like a dark, ugly spot on an otherwise distinguished legal career.

So Stef, the perpetrator of this misbegotten blog, wants me to notice it.  And I did.  And I bet she now wishes that she never sent me an email, because I’m not being nearly as supportive of her efforts as she would hope.  While I credit her for her effort, that counts for far less in the real world than it does in school.

And Keyana, if you feel a moral dilemma at defending the guilty, perhaps you should consider being a prosecutor, for whom “seeking justice” is a more appropriate standard.  Defense lawyers cannot harbor such “troubles.”

I offer this bit of advice to Stef and Keyana, budding lawyers endeavoring to find their place, and a job, in the legal world.  Not every thought that pops into your head is something you want to expose to the world. And when you jump around, waving your arms screaming “look at me, look at me,” don’t be surprised if someone does, and isn’t impressed.  You can’t control what they see, and they may very well see things that you don’t.  I wish the both of you the best of luck in your legal careers.

Update:  It comes as no surprise that this post enraged some of the slackoisie, who have never before felt the sting of criticism.  Upon reflection, I would be remiss in not helping them to understand why this post was written (as they clearly haven’t grasped it on their own) and why their opinion on whether this post is appropriate is of no consequence.  While it’s unlikely that they will agree with me, at least until they are more seasoned, at least this might plant a seed that will ultimately grow into understanding.

The “young professionals” want a forum to promote themselves publicly, and there is certainly no shortage of social media gurus telling them that this is the wave of the future, the way that the un- and under-employed can showcase their talents.  But these same “young professionals” are incautious, opining on subjects they don’t as yet understand.  In the world of the Slackoisie, ignorance presents no problem.  They are entitled to opine, right, wrong or otherwise, and others are obliged to forgive them their ignorance.

We’re not their mommies and daddies.  They are no longer being graded by their lawprofs, where a well-written but wrong answer will net them a passing grade.  By making the decision to post your thoughts publicly, you invite public scrutiny.  Do not expect a pat on the head when your thoughts are wrong.  Do not expect to be forgiven your error because you’re a “baby lawyer.”  You are a lawyer. You are expected to either get it right or demonstrate sufficient restraint not to post.  You do not get a free pass.  Those days are over.

Of course, but for Stef’s provocation, Keyana’s post would never have come across my screen.  This might be best viewed as adding insult to injury, as I didn’t go looking for some “baby lawyer’s” post to pick on, but merely accepted Stef’s invitation.  You can’t have it both ways, screaming “look at me” and then, when I do, expecting me to turn away.

And finally, the gist of this post was to teach a lesson about playing the role of public pundit when one lacks the ability, or authority, to do so.  The lesson wasn’t directed solely at Stef or Keyana, but to any young lawyer inclined to think that they can mess around in the blogosphere without suffering the consequences of their actions.

I’m chastised by a commenter, third year lawyer  Olga Wayne, for writing this post, told that I should be “ashamed” of myself, told that there were a thousand others things I could have done if I didn’t like Keyana’s post.  While true, it’s irrelevant.  This post isn’t about liking what Keyana had to say, but about making a point about public posting by young lawyers.  If they don’t know what they are talking about, they shouldn’t post.

More to the point, Olga, a fairly typical representative of the Slackoisie, argues that my post is inappropriate (and I am a laundry list of bad things, from thin skinned to pathetic) because it fails to meet with her approval.  This is a critical lesson for the Slackoisie, and for Olga in particular, who otherwise grasped nothing from this exercise.  No one, but no one, in the big, real world needs to meet with your approval.  That you would even consider your sensibilities so significant is sheer narcissism, which unfortunately is epidemic amongst the Slackoisie.  The recurrent theme of entitlement amongst children, that their opinions are paramount, is a very dangerous thing.

It’s time that young lawyers, whether 3 minutes or 3 years out of law school, learn about the responsibility that comes with expressing themselves publicly.  Someday, you may well prove yourselves to be brilliant and accomplished lawyers.  Until that day, be cautious about what you post publicly.  If you don’t know what you’re talking about, or you don’t grasp your relative place in the world, control the impulse.  It may result in someone, like me, writing things about you that you would prefer not be written.

When The First 18 Doesn’t Count

Judge John Cataldo did something that never happens.  Almost never.  In the absence of DNA evidence, some sort of hard proof to hang his hat on, Judge Cataldo nonetheless  tossed Fernando Bermudez’s murder conviction after five prosecution witnesses recanted, saying they were coerced and manipulated into fingering Bermudez for the murder of 16 year old Raymond Blount.

Cataldo found that there was no evidence connecting Bermudez with the murder and dismissed the case.  It came on the 11th try, and after Bermudez served 18 years in Sing Sing.  While Mark Dwyer, chief assistant district attorney in Manhattan, says his office is pondering whether to appeal, they won’t.  Eighteen years is enough, and they don’t like being on the losing side twice in the same case, and they really hate being the appellant, where all the presumptions cut against you.

So time to throw a party?  Speeches about the bravery of Judge Cataldo and impropriety of the prosecution?  Not just yet.

Bermudez has some unfinished business to do.  Twenty-seven months of it, to be precise.

While he was a bit preoccupied with the murder case, Bermudez also had a federal drug case. In the relative scheme of things, it wasn’t likely his most pressing concern at the time, and he copped a plea.  This is the way these things typically go.  When there’s a big fight and a small fight, just get the small fight off your plate so that you can concentrate on the big one.  And so he did.

But after serving 18 years on the now-dismissed murder case, he still has an unserved sentence of 27 months.  No, he gets no credit for the time spent in state custody.  Yes, it would make sense in the grander scheme if he did, but he doesn’t.  That’s just the way prison time works.  That’s the nature of dual sovereigns: Each gets his due, for better or worse.

After his release on the murder, White Plains District Judge Kenneth Karas allowed Bermudez to go free on bail until June 30, 2010


to give his lawyers time to  try and convince the federal Bureau of Prisons that Bermudez has long since served the 27 months in prison as part of the 18 years he wrongly served.
There are a host of ways in which Fernando Bermudez’s situation can be righted.  The United States Attorney’s office can acquiesce in a resentence.  The judge can change the sentence, nunc pro tunc.  The Bureau of Prisons can recalculate his sentence with credit for the time in Ossining.  Each of these fixes requires the “kindness” of the government, as Bermudez has no right under the law to demand that his 18 lost years be applied to cover his 27 months still owed.

Of course, no one thinks that it would be right for Bermudez to now be compelled to serve an additional 27 months, after serving 18 years for a murder he didn’t commit.  That Judge Karas released Bermudez clearly shows that he doesn’t think so.  On the other hand, if the newspaper report is correct, Judge Karas wants the defense and the Bureau of Prisons to work it out.  This is another way of saying that he’s not going to take responsibility for fixing the problem.  Notably, there’s no mention of the United States Attorney’s office fixing the problem.  The spotlight is on the defense and BOP to straighten out this mess.

The system is crafted in such a way as to assume that it works, and works properly.  There aren’t many backdoors built into the system to allow for screw-ups and breakdowns, like the guy who spends 18 years in prison for a murder he didn’t commit.  Since that’s not supposed to happen in the first place, there’s no reason why there should be any procedure to compensate for problems that arise out of situations that should never happen.  To have a process to fix such a mess would be acknowledgment of a failed system.  Congress would never admit to owning such a broken system.

The only question remaining, after the New York District Attorney’s time to appeal runs out after 30 days, will be whether any of the players in this saga will take the responsibility of making sure that Bermudez doesn’t go back to prison to serve another 27 months.  The BOP is a monstrous bureaucracy, and monstrous bureaucracies have no heart.  Will someone deep within the bowels of BOP be bold enough to do the right thing?  And if not, what will the judge and United States Attorney do about it?  Without the acquiescence of someone on the government side, the defense can do nothing.

Everyone knows what the right thing to do is.  Who will take the responsibility to do it?

Never Too Early To Prepare To Avoid The Death Penalty

Like most parents, I’ve read books on child rearing in the hope of doing something right.  Yet nowhere did I read the part about making sure your child is given an IQ test, just in case he is convicted of a capital offense some 30, 40 years later.  In Kentucky, this would be a wise thing to do.

Via Turley,

Donald Giles would appear to have the trifecta of mental incompetence arguments against execution. He is a paranoid schizophrenic with an IQ of 61 and a history of suicide attempts and depression. However, Jefferson County Circuit Judge Martin McDonald has ruled that Giles, 41, may be put to death if the jury so rules in his trial for the 2003 murder and robbery of Charles Goodlett.

Some might think that Atkins v. Virginia would preclude such an outcome.  Not according to Judge McDonald.


Kentucky law statutes actually ban the execution of a person with an IQ of 70 or below but McDonald ruled that Giles should have been given an IQ test as a child to claim such an exception.
The law giveth and the law taketh away.  After all, without an IQ test as a child, establishing that Giles fell below the normal range of intelligence, what used to be called mentally retarded before such words were taboo, how can McDonald be assured that this isn’t some cleverly crafted scam to deny him the opportunity to put someone to death?  Recent fabrication is always a problem when there’s a potential execution on the horizon, and to deny the people of Kentucky an execution would be wrong unless the defendant can prove that he’s unworthy of death,  Don’t blame the judge; after all, there was nothing stopping Giles from having an IQ test long before this whole mess happened.

Except maybe the fact that most parents don’t anticipate that their child will eventually face execution but for neuropsychological testing.  Which is why you need to know this.  After all, you certainly wouldn’t want your child to be executed because you didn’t plan ahead.

Judge Martin McDonald, however, is of the opinion that disclosure of this preparation secret is wrong.  From the Louisville Courier-Journal :



Senior Judge Martin McDonald criticized The Courier-Journal on Friday for an article the previous day about Donald Giles, who is legally mentally retarded but facing the possibility of the death penalty along with Robert Holt in the 2003 murder and robbery of Charles Goodlett.


“I don’t like The Courier-Journal blasting something in the media about a case we’re getting ready to start jury selection on,” McDonald said Friday, as the trial was set to begin. “I mean, it’s counterproductive.”


I mean, seriously, if the newspapers go and blast the trick to beating an execution, how do they think they’re ever going to execute any mentally retarded defendants in Kentucky?  Counterproductive indeed.

Avvo’s Big Three? Not Me, Thanks

The other day, an offer came over from Bryan Jones, the advertising sales manager at Avvo.   The subject line of the email was a grabber: Avvo to Feature Only 3 Criminal Defense Lawyers in New York County.  Only three? 


Avvo.com is a resource for two million consumers per month who are seeking legal assistance. In New York County alone we had over 2,100 searches last month from consumers researching Criminal Defense Law. I am contacting every Criminal Defense lawyer in your area today to inform them of an advertising opportunity that would place their picture and contact information at the top of the page for every one of these searches.

Three.  Three lawyers will have the exclusive opportunity to have their picture and info placed on every search page for a criminal defense lawyer.  And if I act quickly enough, since it’s first come, first serve, I could be one of those three.

When Avvo first came on the scene, the fundamental justification for its existence, not to mention access to information about lawyers nationwide, was to aid consumers in finding an attorney and assessing competence by both providing basic information about every lawyer available and rating them on a ten point scale.  It was all about the consumer.  Just helping consumers.  Certainly, helping consumers is good, right?

For lawyers, the draw was a place where a lawyer could provide information about himself and his services that would be seen by many consumers of legal services.  For free.  A consumer would be able to search all lawyers in a given field in a given geographic location and compare them, making an educated decision about who to retain to represent them.  For free.

And now I’m told that my puss, a face made for radio, can grace the page of your Avvo listing.  For a small fee.  If I act quickly, because there will only be three, first come, first served.  It doesn’t matter whether I have good rating or a bad one.  It doesn’t matter if my disciplinary record is good or horrendous.  It only matters if I’m willing to pay the fee to make sure that when a consumer seeks to educate himself about you, he gets to see me. 

What an offer!  Everything Avvo said it stood for, every consumercentric argument, flushed down the toilet.  It’s not about educating consumers, but about promoting the three.  So what if it’s the three worst lawyers in the jurisdiction.  So what if their competence is one step above a rock.  So what if their blue pinstripe suit is covered in sludge from the gutter. They paid the tare and they are the lucky three.

I responded to Bryan.

I would pay you not to include me so the idiots who go to Avvo will stop bothering me with their incessant emails and phone calls for free legal services.

Yes, I did get a client via Avvo. One.  I’ve also gotten about a thousand calls and emails from people who want me to be their free source of legal advice.  Whether about a DUI in Phoenix or a question from a college student writing a paper or the mother who is seeking a pro bono lawyer to defend her child, they go to Avvo, find a lawyer and ask.  No harm in asking, right?  Except every telephone call I take, every email I read, sucks up a piece of time that I can never get back. Since time is a finite resource, it has to come from somewhere, and that somewhere is the time I would otherwise spend on my clients, my family, myself.

I received calls from people actually looking for representation.  Sometimes, they were even from people in New York, given that it wasn’t really viable for me to travel to Seattle to handle their misdemeanor marijuana arrest.  But there was one common theme in the callers: None wanted to pay for a lawyer.  My favorite, oft-repeated statement from Avvo callers, is “why do I have to pay for a lawyer if I’m innocent?”

Avvo, you see, promotes the idea of lawyers providing free advice.  This is one of the ways it draws people to its website, offering people the opportunity to ask questions of “real lawyers” and getting free answers.  It’s even got a name for it, AvvoAnswers, perhaps the most dangerous concept in Avvo’s business plan.

After discussing the telephone call problem with Avvo’s CEO, Mark Britton, I made some tweaks to my Avvo listing to clarify what type of practice I have, the hope being that it would cut down on the number of calls and emails.  It didn’t work. 

Bryan got back to me after my snarky response.


Those are called leads if you do not wish people to call you I would recommend you remove your number from the website

Unwittingly, Bryan summed up the problem quite well.  I don’t want “leads”.  I’m not selling used cars.  I want people in need of my services to be able find me, compare me to other lawyers if they wish, and should they decide that I might be a good choice to represent them, call me for the purpose of retaining me.  I defend people accused of a crime for a fee.  I do not offer free advice, two-fers or loss-leaders.  I do not offer low, low prices.  I do not want “leads”.

As per Bryan, this is not the service that Avvo provides.  Avvo offers “leads”, people who want free legal advice and free representation.  If this is what you’re seeking, then you should take Bryan up on his offer to be one of the fortunate three.  But be quick about it.  First come, first served.

It will be interesting to see who the lucky three turn out to be, now that we know what they are willing to do to get “leads”.

New York’s New DWI Bill: Compounding Stupidity

The vote is in. Hooray!  Save the children.  Get tough, get tougher.  There are no sweeter sounds to the ears of a politician than the applause of their constituents.  And there are few things constituents applaud more than a tough new law to save the lives of children.  Or, at least, seems to do so.

If nothing else, the New York Legislature has shown that it can pass a law as fast as Congress did the USA Patriot Act.


Something crazy happened in Albany this week: The Assembly passed a bill, then the Senate passed their version of the bill, and then Governor David Paterson signed it into law—all in two days! Yesterday New York instituted the nation’s toughest drunk driving law, making it a felony to drive intoxicated with a passenger 15 years old or under. The bill, “Leandra’s Law,” was named for the 11-year-old New York girl killed in a DWI crash on the West Side Highway last month.
One month between dead child and new law?  Two days between introduction and signing? It’s a miracle in a state that can’t pass a timely budget to save its life.  Put aside the rule of thumb, that no law named after a person is a going to be good, and let’s consider its inherent merit.

New York law already provides for felony DWI.  The new law doesn’t increase the penalty, but rather mandates that the charge cannot be reduced below a felony.  Mandatory.  A word that seems to have come under a great deal of scrutiny lately for being, oh, very wrong, with terrible unintended consequences.  Perhaps it takes a while for the news to reach Albany?

And don’t quibble with details, that what happened to Leandra has nothing to do with the content of the law, since Leandra wasn’t riding in a car with a drunk, but was a victim in the car into which the drunk crashed.  That’s already a crime, so they had to come up with something new, even if wholly unrelated, to name a law after her.  And it would be wrong for a child to die without getting a law named after her.

I can both understand and appreciate her father’s angst, and his quest to make sure his daughter didn’t lose her life in vain. I really can.  This just isn’t the answer, no matter how good it may feel at the moment.  Of course, that’s why we have detached legislators to enact laws rather than emotional parents.  A lot of good that does us.

While everybody agrees that drunk driving is a bad thing, and is particularly bad when there are children involved, whose lives should be given greater concern by the driver, sufficient to make the decision not to drive drunk, it’s never quite that easy.  Consider the parents driving home with junior in the back seat, dinner at a friend’s house with a couple glasses of wine.  Lawful?  Maybe.  Criminal?  Maybe.  Obvious to the otherwise law-abiding and particularly good parents of junior?  Unlikely.  Happens all the time?  You bet.

On the way home, parents get stopped.  There are far too many ways and reasons why someone gets stopped, so it really doesn’t matter why, except to say that they neither struck another vehicle nor caused anyone any pain.  But they’re stopped, a P.O. Smith smells a 1982 Château Latour on Dad’s breath.  Out comes a black box that reads BAC .08%.  And there’s junior, happily playing in the back seat to kill the time until he can get home and catch the last half hour of Pokemon.

Dad gets busted.  Felony conviction. Loses his job. Loses his license. Loses his house because he can’t pay the mortgage because he has no job or license. Cable TV shut off so junior can’t watch Pokemon, not to mention have a roof over his head or eat.

Way to go!  Save the children!  Woo hoo!

The problem is that if Dad was a serious drunk driving problem, the law already enabled prosecutors to charge and convict for a felony.  But there was discretion, the ability to address the specifics of the case, the defendant, the situation, so that unintended harm wasn’t the result.  But as we’ve learned from years of failed and misguided mandatory laws, take away discretion to address the particulars and we’re left with absurd application of law and, invariably, unintended disasters.

The problem is that legislators always seem to forget about this when it comes time to vote on the law named after the latest dead child.  They should enjoy the applause today.  Tomorrow, we’ll be back to fixing the mess they’ve gotten themselves into.

Prosecutorial Immunity: Sometimes, A Legal Fiction Is Just A Fiction

It’s often difficult to understand why a prosecutor who has engaged in the affirmative act of concealing exculpatory evidence, or fabricating evidence of guilt, is clothed with immunity.  Mistake or accident is one thing, but why should they be immune from liability for a deliberate act?  The simple, albeit unpalatable, explanation is that the Supreme Court says so.

And so the 2d Circuit in Warney v. Monroe County reversed Judge Latimer in the district court and conferred absolute immunity who withheld the results of a DNA test from a convicted defendant during his habeas proceeding. From Mark Hamblett at the New York Law Journal :


Douglas Warney was wrongfully convicted of the 1996 stabbing murder of William Beason in Rochester, N.Y., and served 10 years in prison. Warney, who has an IQ of 68, was allegedly coerced into giving a typewritten “confession” that contained a number of inconsistencies and included facts of which he could not possibly have known.

While Warney’s federal habeas corpus petition and his appeal from a state court decision denying him access to DNA evidence were pending, Monroe County Second District Attorney Larry Bernstein, without authorization and without telling anyone, had DNA testing performed in February 2005 on seven samples from the crime scene, including blood found on the murder weapon and under the victim’s fingernails.

The testing, revealed in a Feb. 17, 2006 written lab report, showed that all of the blood matched the profile of a man who was neither Beason nor Warney.

For those who love to think of the system as a balancing test, the need to protect the efficacy of prosecutions trumps the need to not convict innocent people.  Better to put the innocent in prison than have prosecutors nervous about being liable for their deliberate acts of concealment.  It’s a value judgment, and the Supremes have clearly expressed where they stand.


Judge Jacobs explained that the U.S. Supreme Court, in Imbler v. Pachtman, 424 U.S. 409 (1976), defined the scope of prosecutorial immunity by reference to the “function” performed, with the shield of immunity covering those acts that are “intimately associated with the judicial phase of the criminal process.”

“For once a conviction becomes final, there is no longer a pending adversarial criminal proceeding; the ‘judicial phase’ is technically finished,” Judge Jacobs said. “Yet, by the nature of their office, prosecutors will necessarily remain involved in criminal cases; opposing civil habeas petitions (or other forms of collateral relief); amending restitution orders; pursuing parole violations; or resolving disputes over a prisoner’s projected release date.”

This is where the decision gets very curious.  If the prosecution phase is over, how does the fact that prosecutors “necessarily remain involved” have to do with the fact that habeas petitioner, like forfeiture proceedings, alter the fact that these proceedings are “civil in nature.”  The reason this matters so much is that the courts, by denominating them civil in nature, a fiction created by simply changing the word “criminal” to “civil”, deprives the defendant of the panoply of rights he would otherwise received, ranging from right to counsel, to burden of proof, to the right to a jury.

So the civil/criminal distinction is real when it inures to the benefit of the prosecution, but becomes mere fiction when it exposes the prosecutor to liability?  Well, yeah.  Exactly. 

In large measure, the need for these legal fictions is a by-product of bad caselaw.  Why, in this instance, is prosecutorial immunity dependent on the stage of proceedings rather than the nature of the misconduct?  It’s based on the historical rationale for protecting the judiciary from suit, twisted just a bit to cover the prosecutor.  In other words, the reason it’s ridiculous is that its genesis was self-serving and intellectually dubious.


“The office of public prosecutor is one which must be administered with courage and independence. Yet how can this be if the prosecutor is made subject to suit by those whom he accuses and fails to convict? To allow this would open the way for unlimited harassment and embarrassment of the most conscientious officials by those who would profit thereby. There would be involved in every case the possible consequences of a failure to obtain a conviction.
While these are very nice words, “courage and independence” have nothing to do with deliberately concealing evidence of innocence.  They could have easily limited the “harassment and embarrassment” by holding that liability was limited to intentional acts.  Problem solved.  But the court chose not to go down that path, and instead carved out an exception for malfeasance in the investigative stage of the proceedings, and since then it’s gone downhill from there.

While the Supreme Court has the Pottawamie case under consideration, this would be an opportune time to reconsider the entire framework of prosecutorial immunity and the distinctions drawn on the “stage of proceedings” paradigm.  But nobody argued that, and the court won’t consider it.  They should.  It would put an end to the absurd problems dealing with prosecutorial immunity, and save the court the embarrassment of having to continue to manipulate reasoning by its occasional reliance on facile legal fictions.

Kurt Greenbaum: Reporter As Rat

There are lines that should never be crossed, and Kurt Greenbaum, journalist and director, apparently by default, of social media for the Saint Louis Post-Dispatch crossed one.


Kurt Greenbaum blogs at STL Social Media Guy, and is the online news director and now director of social media.  On his hard-hitting blog, Greenbaum asked readers: “What’s the craziest thing you’ve ever eaten?”  A not especially clever person wrote, “Pussy.”  Harhar.  A moderator deleted the comment.  Wanting his voice to be heard, the nit-wit posted again, “Pussy.”

Even in St. Louis, this doesn’t pass for wit.  But there are two ever-ready solutions to comments that are deemed inappropriate. Delete them and/or ban the commenter.  It’s both a matter of policy at the STL Social Media Guy blog, and a matter of fundamental etiquette in the blogosphere.  The former is what official people care about.  The latter is what anyone claiming to be a social media guy would recognize as a foundational part of the online code. 

We are not the school marms of the digital world, running back to the bad boy’s mommy (or employer in this case) to tell how nasty he was.  But Kurt wasn’t aware of this, and his inner school marm couldn’t handle either the policy or etiquette.  Not only did he do the unthinkable, but he was proud enough of being a rat that he posted about it.



A few minutes later, the same guy posted the same single-word comment again. I deleted it, but noticed in the WordPress e-mail that his comment had come from an IP address at a local school. So I called the school. They were happy to have me forward the e-mail, though I wasn’t sure what they’d be able to do with the meager information it included.


About six hours later, I heard from the school’s headmaster. The school’s IT director took a shine to the challenge. Long story short: Using the time-frame of the comments, our website location and the IP addresses in the WordPress e-mail, he tracked it back to a specific computer. The headmaster confronted the employee, who resigned on the spot.

For those of you who comment but don’t realize that blogging programs provide those of us with our hands on the wheel a lot more information about who you are and where you’re from, we know stuff.  We just don’t tell.  Even if you are annoying, or worse, we don’t tell. 

I take no issue with Kurt’s decision to delete the comment, if for being a bad joke if nothing else.  As bad words go, “pussy” is hardly the worst around, but I can understand completely that he wanted to keep a newspapers blog clean and wholesome.  There are a lot of truly nasty, angry and vulgar comments made online, and I’m not particularly partial to them either.

But don’t be a rat.  Delete, delete, delete, but don’t rat.  Yes, it can prove to be a lot of work to keep up with the nasty commenters.  If it’s too much for you, then either shut it down or find someone who can handle the burden. But don’t be a rat.

Kurt was apparently shocked to learn that his cleansing of the blogosphere didn’t go over well.  Rather than applause for his “fixing” this miscreants wagon, he was castigated by his readers.  I mean hammered, one after another.  And so, in true school marm form, Kurt tried to rehabilitate himself by rationalization; explaining away his incredibly poor choice.



Did I overreact? Maybe I did. I am constantly frustrated by the difficulty of dealing with this kind of language. And in this case, I was motivated by three things.

First, this came from a school. I didn’t know if it came from an employee, a guest or a student. But I viewed it as a “teachable moment” and a chance, perhaps, to nip something in the bud, to engage the community to help me. I didn’t anticipate that the reader would resign.

Second, the comment was posted, deleted and intentionally posted a second time by the same person. Too much time had elapsed between posts for it to be a mistake or an accident. The reader was determined to post it.

Third, it was easy. As I said, I didn’t have to dig for the school’s information. It was readily available on the e-mail alert. Had it not been there, I may have deleted the comment and moved on.
For a journalist, Kurt woefully fails to connect the dots.  All of this three motivations may be absolutely true, but none either explains or justifies his taking the affirmative step of reaching out to the school to rat out the commenter.  Most disturbing is his third “thing”, that it was “easy”.  “Easy” is not the bar by which we measure right and wrong.  Indeed, it’s a common excuse by those who commit crimes, as if doing wrong because it was “easy” somehow mitigates the offense. 

Many of the Social Media Guy’s readers were subsequently offended by his calling the commenter a “jackass” in a twit, calling it flagrant hypocrisy.  I don’t see it that way, as the twit was a different medium and a personal expression, rather than the language used on the newspaper’s blog.  The rules for commenters differ from those for the blogger, as commenters are guests in the blogger’s home.  But while I wouldn’t attack Kurt’s choice of word, the spirit behind it shows his lack of understanding of the damage he’s done to unfettered speech.  Did you lose your job for calling a reader a jackass, Kurt?  Are epithets fine only when you deem them acceptable?

Kurt Greenbaum has done grievous harm to the blogosphere.  While no one has the right to see their comment up in lights, no one  expects their confidences to be broken by the affirmative act of disclosure.  Kurt’s attempt to excuse his misguided conduct entirely ignores the conceded fact that he reached out to the commenter’s source to rat him out.  He’s a rat.  He obtained confidential information and disclosed it.  It doesn’t matter how hard or easy it was, or how much he was offended by the rather benign word “pussy”.  Kurt Greenbaum is a rat.

Two lessons are taught by this school marm.

1.  No one can trust their confidences to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. 
2.  Kurt Greenbaum has no place in social media.

It appears that he was right about this being a “teachable moment,” though I doubt this was the lesson he was shooting for.  I can only hope that the teacher involved was god-awful, as it would be terrible shame if Kurt’s inexcusable conduct deprived students of a good teacher.  One whose worst fault was a mediocre sense of humor.

The Virtue of Brevity, Or Mommy Said So

While it would be all too easy to discuss the recurrent theme of genetics in the Ozarks, I will force myself to stay away and note just two salient details from this AP story about Officer Dustin Bradshaw’s decision to taser an unruly 10 year old girl.

First, he only did so after her mother, who happens to be the person who called the police for help in dealing with her child’s tantrum, told the officer to taser her.  The good news is that Mom never suggested that the cop plug her between the eyes, despite earlier reports.

Second:


The report said Bradshaw administered a “very, very brief” stun with the Taser, put the girl in handcuffs and carried her to his patrol car. She was taken to the Western Arkansas Youth Shelter in Cecil.
This is critical, because its so much better when delivering a shock of 60,000 volts to limit it to a “very, very brief” period.  Isn’t that right, Old Sparky?

I can’t help but wonder how this advances testing of tasers on the physical and mental development 10 year olds. Perhaps this will open the door to tasers in the classroom if the unruly child has learned her lesson?

H/T Injustice Everywhere (and if you’re not following @InjusticeNews on twitter, then you’re wasting your time reading Simple Justice).

Naming Names

Very few names are so unique that you can’t find a few hundred, maybe even a few thousand, other nice people with the same name.  Sure, your name is special to you, but it’s equally special to everyone else who shares your name.  What it isn’t is a very good way to discern the identity of a criminal. 

That lesson should have been driven home the first time Fredericksburg, Virginia, police officers arrested Rodney Maurice Morton, about 13 years ago.  Or the second time, in December, 2007.  It shouldn’t have happened again the third time in February, 2008.  Crazy story, of course, but Rodney Morton never asked that he share a name with a fellow who happened to engage in a lot of bad stuff.

Rodney Maurice Morton, as opposed to Rodney Lee Morton, wasn’t exactly of a criminal bent.


Rodney Maurice Morton works for a national security agency of the federal government, has a security clearance and no criminal record, court records state.

He does, unfortunately, have numerous arrests, all eventually dismissed.  He’s had to endure his daughter being called by police looking for him to arrest him.  That surely wasn’t pleasant, any more than being taken away in cuffs and locked up, but it was nothing compared with the next exposure to law enforcement.



But on May 1 of last year, King George deputies surrounded Morton’s house and informed him he’d been charged with selling cocaine to an undercover officer in Fredericksburg on March 5.

A city grand jury indicted Rodney Maurice Morton, but a judge dismissed that charge on June 2, 2008, after it was determined that Rodney Lee Morton was again the intended defendant.
In case you didn’t notice, Morton was indicted for the alleged crime of his namesake and it took a month for the system to figure out that it had the wrong Rodney.  Again. 

The experience of being arrested, cuffed, booked, held and arraigned isn’t a pleasant one under the best of circumstances.  It’s absolutely shocking to the system of an innocent person who has been wrongly accused.  Imagine what it must feel like to a person who is not merely innocent, but wrongly identified.  Imagine what it must feel like the second time.  Or third,

Given the advances in technology and communication, it seems almost impossible that police could screw up in ways such as this.  Of course, given the frequency of search warrant executions on the wrong address, merely arresting the wrong person because he has a similar name hardly seems so terrible.  Still, the police would have us believe that they know what they’re doing, that they are capable and competent, the “new professionals” as Justice Scalia calls them.

Basic, low-rent screw ups like this must serve to remind us that the assertions of law enforcement, are not, per se, reliable.  They just aren’t that smart, aren’t that good, aren’t that trustworthy.  They get it wrong all the time.  No, not always, and not in the entirety, but wrong nonetheless.  And screw-ups result in misery for regular people.  Sometimes death.  Sometimes decades in prison for the wrong person.  And the cops (and prosecutors) are invariably certain that they are right, and were right all along, until they are proven wrong.  Even then, they do everything in their power to smear the victim and justify their screw-up.

But they can’t smear Rodney Maurice Morton.  He’s clean as a whistle, security clearance and all.  They can make him miserable, disrupt his life and cost him a bundle to defend himself from their screw-ups.  But they can’t shift the blame on him.

Of course, not all of us work for a national security agency and have security clearance.  Just pray that one of the thousands of people who share your name doesn’t do anything nasty.  It might not be so easy for you to persuade the judge that its some other guy who did the deed. 

H/T Injustice Everywhere