Author Archives: SHG

Zero Tolerance For Three Strikes

The New York Times has once again figured out that zero tolerance policies in schools is disastrously harmful and foolish.  Stop the presses?  Hardly.


Congress took a reasonable step in 1994 when it required states receiving federal education money to expel students who brought guns onto school property, but states and localities overreacted, as they so often do. They enacted “zero tolerance” policies under which children are sometimes arrested for profanity, talking back, shoving matches and other behavior that would once have been resolved with detention or meetings with the students’ parents.

This arrest-first policy has been disastrous for young people, who are significantly more likely to drop out and experience long-term problems once they become entangled in the juvenile justice system. It has led to egregious racial profiling, with black and Hispanic students being shipped off to court at a higher rate than white students. And it has been a waste of time for the police to haul off children to the courts when they should be protecting the public from real criminals.

This is about as obvious as it gets, likely glommed from any one of about 50 prior editorials spanning the past decade and republished on a slow news day.  But to cap off its position, the Times lauds the alternative policy “developed” in Clayton County, Georgia.



School officials who want to back away from the failed zero tolerance policy are looking to a farsighted model developed in Clayton County, Ga., a fast-growing enclave south of Atlanta. Its juvenile courts were nearly overwhelmed by students referred from their schools — mainly for minor offenses like fistfights and disruptive conduct.

Juvenile court officials met with the schools and explained the dangers of criminalizing what are essentially normal childhood behaviors. They also helped to retrain school counselors and cooperated with the schools to create a three-strikes system for dealing with minor offenses.
Oh my God!  A three-strikes system!  Wherever did they come up with such a “farsighted model.”  How innovative.  How brilliant.  How . . . California.  

I really can’t figure out what to make of the New York Times editorial board.  Do they read their own paper?  Are they testing us to see if we do?  Who are the boneheads, us or them?  Of course three strikes is better than zero tolerance, merely because it gives people three tries at zero tolerance before they do something stupid.  But just as was discovered when the three strikes concept was initially developed (and not, by the way, in Clayton County, guys), it gets awfully stupid as well, when the third strike turns out to be some trivial offense, in this case some typically childish behavior that school kids have done forever and was dealt with by ordinary teachers in the normal course of a school day.  Though it takes three tries to get the kid to be prosecuted, and some will invariably never reach the third strike, the concept is as foolish and harmful as zero tolerance, divided by three.

I’ve come to the belief that this has more to do with catchy names than with anyone thinking beyond their hairy knuckles.  Catchy names and easy application.  So easy, even a school principal can apply it.  So easy, no one need fear being criticized for being a blithering idiot for having the cops arrest little Johnny for shooting a spitball.  So easy that officials can always say, don’t blame us for being a bonehead; that’s the policy.

It’s understandable that schools always seek out the easy, CYA method of dealing with students that insulates them from parent and community attack for being harmful to children.  After all, that’s why we pay teachers the big bucks.  But what in the world makes the editorial board of the New York Times engage in such absurdity?

Let’s say that this editorial is found to be pervasively persuasive, and school districts across the country end their zero tolerance policies and institute a three strikes policy.  So the Times will then have a reason to publish a new editorial, attacking three strikes as an over-reaction?  Of course, they won’t do that until someone comes up with some new policy with a cute name and susceptible to knee-jerk application by some school official somewhere.  It would be far too much effort to expect anybody in school to just think.

There’s No Atheists On A Hard Drive

The continuing discussion of how the Fourth Amendment applies to developing technology, raised by Orin Kerr’s “technology neutral” approach, an approach with which I’m somewhat less than thrilled, takes an interesting turn in digital forensic examiner Larry Daniels discusses the applicability of traditional legal concepts.  

Orin takes the position that traditional concepts, developed through the caselaw over generations, should be applied by analogy to new and developing technology.  My view is that we need to come up with new concepts rather than try to fit square pegs into round holes.  At DFI News, Larry explains how, for all the very hard thinking that lawyers put into the subject of whether a search of a hard drive, and all the collateral nasty stuff found, this might technically fit into the plain view doctrine.  His verdict?  Lawyers don’t get it.


Kerr writes about the need to map the physical world to the virtual world of digital storage, because the laws are constructed based upon what happens in the physical world of a law enforcement officer examining a scene.

While this is the correct approach, he falls into the trap of mistaking a forensic examination of a computer hard drive with a search of a computer. This is the fundamental disconnect between understanding how plain view doctrine should be applied in digital evidence cases; what constitutes a search versus what is a forensic examination.

It’s a little unclear to me how Larry says that Orin’s approach is correct, while simultaneously saying that it reflects a “fundamental disconnect” between the physical world legal concept and its digital world application.  I suspect he’s just being deferential.  But Larry goes on to explain himself using the real world analogy of the file cabinet, a long time  favorite of those who try to explain the concept of digital storage.



For example, in the physical world going through files in a filing cabinet would allow an item to come into plain view in the normal process of opening those files. However, if a document in a foreign language was present and the investigator did not read that language, it could not come into plain view since it would not meet the requirement of being immediately recognized by the officer as illegal or contraband material, even though the officer can plainly see the document.

If you imagine that the hard drive is a room and in that room are filing cabinets (partitions i.e. C:, D), and in those filing cabinets are both folders containing files and files themselves, you have a good mapping of the virtual file structure of a hard drive to the physical equivalent of a room containing filing cabinets.

In searching through a physical filing cabinet, no special tools or skills are employed beyond the ability to open and look in folders and to read documents or peruse pictures.

If you equate that to a non-expert computer user sitting at the keyboard opening folders and looking at files while using no special skills or tools, you have basically the same operation. Any file the user can open and view without adding a tool, using special expert knowledge or forensic tools, should be able to regard evidence they see as part of the search as being in plain view. This is the essence of a computer search.
Conversely, Larry argues that anything that cannot simply be opened and recognized as contraband on a computer without use of any special tool or knowledge cannot be considered to be in plain view.  Thus, if any idiot can find it and recognize it to be something bad, then it’s in plain view.  If something more is needed, then it isn’t.

If we assume that Orin’s approach is correct, then Larry’s analysis makes sense.  My problem is that I do not agree with Orin’s approach, in that the concepts that have been developed to address searches in the physical world are intellectually valid and applicable to the digital world.  I am particularly fearful of the use of facile analogy to justify searches, when the rationale behind the concept’s development was never intended, argued, or even considered as applicable to the digital world.

Let’s take the file cabinet approach to the search of a hard drive, or more likely a mirror image of a hard drive, which in itself presents huge obstacles for 4th Amendment application.  While there are some similarities in the operation of a hard drive that lend itself to the analogy to the file cabinet (folders and files), are an individual’s expectations of privacy in the contents of their hard drive similar to that of a file cabinet?  While the analogy has been widely embraced, it’s validity only goes so far.

Computers are not file cabinets.  They aren’t left in a physical location for anyone to open when we leave the room.  We don’t expect anyone to grab our computer, turn it on, roam around the desktop and see what’s going on in there.  We don’t put our personal correspondence into a file cabinet at the office, but we have personal emails saved on our computer.  We don’t leave our diary in a file cabinet, yet we our personal thoughts are digitally held on our computers, often for years after they’ve been written and long after we’ve changed our thoughts.  While the operation of a computer bears similarities, our use of, and expectations in, our computers are vastly different.  Yet the law doesn’t recognize any of this by way of the file cabinet analogy.

Larry’s insight, from the technical side of how one searches a computer hard drive is critical to any legal analysis of the propriety of a search.  Still, the question of whether every digital file that can be opened with a simple double click is in plain view fails to take into account the bottom line concept of whether this violates a reasonable expectation of privacy.  Indeed, when it comes to emails, the current status of the law is that we have no reasonable expectation of privacy given that they are stored on our ISP’s server.  Is everyone who uses technology now charged with the inherent understanding of exactly how all of this works such that any expectation of privacy in our digital world is lost?

This isn’t the way real people use or understand technology, and it shouldn’t be the way the law determines the scope of our rights under the 4th Amendment.  We need a much better way, one that addresses the rights of people to be secure in their papers and effects.  As much as it’s convenient to take old concepts and apply them to the new, albeit wholly unrelated, digital world, it fails to protect us.  We need a new body of law on search and seizure that protects the people, as the 4th Amendment was intended to do.

Not A Good Day In The Neighborhood

It started out with an email from an in-house lawyer at ALM.  She wanted to know what became of my battle with the scummy scraper website, US Law dot com, a commercial enterprise built on the premise that it could take the content from legitimate blawgs, republish them, duplicate their image with their own logo superimposed on the face and sell advertising for their efforts.

ALM, publishers of such titles as American Lawyer, Corporate Counsel, and blogs such as the AmLaw Daily and Law.com, just became aware of USLaw’s scraping their content.  They were not pleased, and have put their legal department to work to deal with the rascal doing them dirty.  As the attorney for ALM told me, she was shocked by 


 “the idiocy of stealing ALM and other legal blogger’s copyrights, because a bunch of legal experts won’t notice or something??”

I’m not sure if she meant that I was a legal expert or she was, but it’s about time that ALM realized this was going on.  It’s only been years.

Later in the day, an email came in from Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Blog.  Not only had his posts been scraped by some garbage website called , but they inserted some curious keywords in his text to boot.


Turkewitz writes which nonetheless Houston rapist invulnerability profession Mark Bennett is “live-twittering” currently (here) whilst his dependent picks a jury, during slightest a single sovereign justice ruled only final week which a sovereign manners demarcate tweets from court.
Houston rapist invulnerability?  It will take one strange search query to come up with that phrase, but it’s unlikely that Turk wants to be known as having written it or that Mark Bennett is thrilled to be called the Houston rapist invulnerability.  This is the sort of website that produces those 100 Best Law Blog lists that people with low self-esteem link to because some unknown person of unknown competence puts their blawg on a list of no merit on a website of no substance.  Everybody loves a list, especially when it makes them feel special.

Within minutes of Turk’s email came another from Brian Tannebaum, who was apoplectic about a blog by someone named Steven G. Ericson called .  It wasn’t enough that Ericson scraped his post, but stole his title bar photo and the comments to his post as well.  Seriously, he scraped the comment string.  This was more than poor Tannebaum could take.

Some of us create.  Some of us steal what others create.  The latter don’t care much about what they take.  Some, like the “idiot” who runs US Law dot com believe that it’s their right to steal.  After all, if it’s available on an RSS feed, it’s theirs for the taking.  But to the outside observer, the googler, the person looking for information on a subject, or just to read something interesting, they wouldn’t know who was who.  And there is no doubt that the those doing the stealing work far harder for the SEO juice that gets their scraped content higher on the search engine rankings than those who actually produce content.  After all, they have more free time on their hands.

There are still many in the blawgosphere who don’t realize what is happening around them, who they are getting in bed with.  I was quite surprised to find that John Wesley Hall’s blawg, Law of Criminal Defense, sports a banner on his sidebar for US Law, as if this somehow benefits him rather than supports a scraper.  And Hall’s a former president of the NACDL and a long time blawger.  You would think he would know better.  Yet there it is, proudly displayed, supporting a website that steals content from blawgers for its own profit.  And he’s not the only one.

Many of those who create are angry about those who steal from them, but they are frustrated by the lack of any reasonable avenue of recourse.  As the blawgosphere and internet continue its expansion, this problem will continue to mushroom.  The scum have no reason to stop, and will continue to shamelessly steal. 

It’s time that an effective means to take down these scrapers, to remove them from the search engines, to have their ISPs and servers disappear them.  The problem is out of control and an effective remedy is needed.  The first step is for all legitimate blawgers to recognize the problem and disengage with these “networks” and blawgs and commercial websites.  Don’t link to them, don’t recognize them, don’t support them by displaying their banners.   Call them out whenever possible as the scrapers and scum they are.  Stop the madness.

‘Cause The Bible Tells Me So

One of the jurors later confirmed that reference to scripture played a part in his deliberation. In his view, “the Bible is the truth from page one to the last page”.


How many peremptories does it take to keep true believers off a death qualified jury in Texas?  Don’t bother answering.  It rhetorical.  But then, how many Bibles must there be in a jury room to aid in the deliberations.  In Khristian Oliver’s case, the number is four.

One of the jurors testified that about 4 Bibles were in the jury room. Key passages were highlighted and handed around among fellow believers. At one point, a juror reportedly read aloud from a copy, including the passage: “And if he smite him with an instrument of iron, so that he die, he is a murderer: the murderer shall surely be put to death.”

That would be Numbers, 35:16. 

The fiction that jurors decide the fate of defendants based upon the law is one that we hold dear, otherwise exposing a fatal flaw in the system.  But we do acknowledge, indeed expect, that they bring into the jury room their experience in life.  This is what the judge tells them to apply in their deliberations, their decision about a fellow human being.  Life experience includes one’s religious belief.  No Mullah could ask more of the most militant terrorist.  But this, naturally, is entirely different, because this is us and it’s a Bible.

The 5th Circuit wasn’t pleased with the way this death sentence was meted out.


In 2008, the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit found that the jurors had “crossed an important line” by consulting specific passages in the Bible that described the very facts at issue in the case. This amounted to an “external influence” on the jury prohibited under the US Constitution.

On the other hand, they weren’t sufficiently displeased to do something about it.


However, it concluded that under the “highly deferential standard” by which federal courts should review state court decisions, Oliver had failed to prove that he had been prejudiced by this unconstitutional juror conduct. In April 2009, the US Supreme Court refused to take the case, despite being urged to take it by nearly 50 former US federal and state prosecutors.
Not prejudiced?  Of course not.  They jury merely applied their own life experiences in reaching the decision to execute Oliver.  The murderer shall surely be put to death.  The Bible says so.  Surely, you wouldn’t argue that jurors who believe that the Bible is the word of God, the Truth, are wrong.  Aren’t they allowed to believe?  Of course they are.  This is America, and Americans are allowed to believe what they want, even that the Bible is the literal Word.  And if the Bible commands the he be put to death, then death is shall be.  That’s all we ask of a jury.

Was it wrong to impose a sentence of death on Khristian Oliver, the irony of his name notwithstanding?  If it’s because the jury was influenced by the sentence that a religion would have them impose rather than consideration of the criteria that the law demanded, then yes.  But was he prejudiced?

It doesn’t matter now.  Khristian Oliver was executed on November 5.

H/T CharonQC

Child Lifers: Get There By Camel

If a camel is a horse designed by committee, the Justices seem to be bent on trying to send kids to prison on a camel of their own design.  From Adam Liptak at the New York Times :


Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr. suggested a compromise approach that did not involve categorical distinctions but would instead require consideration of the offender’s age in deciding whether the sentence was proportional to the crime case by case.

“We know from Roper that death is different, and we know from Roper that juveniles are different,” the chief justice said. “Wouldn’t it make sense to incorporate the consideration of the juvenile status into the proportionality review?”

Probably no one told him that they sentence kids on a case by case basis now.  Then there’s Justice Alito:


Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. seemed to join the chief justice in rejecting what he called a per se approach while remaining open to “proportionality challenges that take into account the particular circumstances of the juvenile in question.”

But Justice Alito added that some juvenile offenders deserve life without parole, describing cases “so horrible that I couldn’t have imagined them if I hadn’t actually seen them” — “raping an 8-year-old girl and burying her alive” and “raping a woman in front of her 12-year-old son and then forcing the son to engage in sexual conduct with the mother.”

Of course, if the cases weren’t nasty, ugly and horrible, they wouldn’t be sentenced to LWOP in the first place.  Justice Breyer saw it as ageism issue:


Justice Stephen G. Breyer said the words of the Eighth Amendment might justify categorical distinctions, at least for the youngest offenders. “It’s pretty unusual to have this,” he said. And, at least for 13-year-olds, he continued, “it is a cruel thing to do to remove from that individual his entire life.”

This may have something to do with the onset of puberty, which is happening at an increasingly early age according to statistics from Victoria’s Secrets.  Justice Ginsburg was unprepared to take the lower road.


Other justices noted that the law routinely makes distinctions based solely on age. “Think of the teenager who can’t drink, can’t drive, can’t marry,” said Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, adding that those legal lines were not drawn case by case. “They say no juvenile can drink — no juvenile.”

Justice Kennedy appears to be the only one who questioned whether there was a rational basis behind LWOP:


Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, the author of the Roper and Kennedy decisions, both by votes of 5 to 4, said his “initial instinct” was that life without parole was no more effective in deterring crime than life with the possibility of parole.

But Justice Antonin Scalia said deterrence was not the only reason for punishment. “One of the purposes is retribution, punishment for just perfectly horrible actions,” he said. “And I don’t know why the value of retribution diminishes to the point of zero when it’s a person who’s, you know, 17 years, 9 months old.”

This, of course, brings us back to the case by case determination.

Jeff Gamso, being an Ohio criminal defense lawyer who has faced defending against the death penalty, points out that a sentence of LWOP is a sentence of death, albeit one that takes longer to carry out.  In contrast, Mike at Crime & Federalism argues



Why do these “children” not deserve life in prison?  Because ten years from now they’ll realize, “It was wrong to rape and torture a woman before requiring her to perform oral sex on her own son”?  Because they just made a mistake, and are deserving of a second chance?  Really…Why should these teenagers be released?


The teenagers in the Dunbar Village Incident are privileged to remain alive.  A just society would have put them down like the savage animals they are.  

Oh, I know, but they are human – as if that is a self-proving argument rather than mere speciesism.  If the Dunbar Village teenagers are human, then either human needs redefined; or humanity needs to be taken out by an asteroid.
Is this mere speciesism?  Is so, that’s fine by me. We are human, and for whatever reason, we get to decide the fate of our own.  That we do so with a greater degree of sensitivity and understanding than is employed with vicious animals is a perk of being at the top of the food chain.  He may be right that we should be less absolute with other species, but the argument doesn’t support the position that we should behave less thoughtfully when dealing with our children. 

As I argued earlier, there is no hard, rational basis to draw a line under the 8th Amendment cruel and unusual punishment clause to hold that a sentence of life without parole for children under the age of 18 is unconstitutional.  And yet it appears that a majority of the court believes that it’s wrong, though the expressed views vary widely on how wrong, what should be done about it and where the line should be drawn. 

Without a bright line, we’re right back where we started.  The age of the defendant versus the “horribleness” of a crime is no less normative a basis for its imposition than we now face,  Both factors are already part of the mix, and yet LWOP is imposed.  And to use Justice Scalia’s argument against him, retribution isn’t the only purpose of sentencing.

The real battle may be over whether the age of 18 or 13, or some number in between, is the proper cut off.  Historically, the age of 18 has divided juvenile from adult, though that line has been fudged when it comes to prosecution, and it’s not entirely clear why 18 was made the cut off age in the first place and whether it remains, given changes in society, the correct age.  On the other hand, no rational parent of a 14 year old will argue that she’s mature enough to do as she pleases, and suffer the consequences.

What’s missing from this discussion, and the argument before the Supreme Court, is an empirical understanding of children, or their development, of the changes they go through and their reasoning and comprehension processes.  Without this, we’re just making this stuff up.  Making stuff up, however, has long been a tradition at the Supreme Court.

The Good Life

As the Supremes prepare to hear oral argument in Graham v. Florida and Sullivan v. Florida today, one has to wonder why.  The underlying issue is whether life without parole is a constitutional sentence to impose on a juvenile for an offense less than homicide.  As Liptak states in the New York Times,

There are just over 100 people in the world serving sentences of life without the possibility of parole for crimes they committed as juveniles in which no one was killed. All are in the United States. And 77 of them are here in Florida.

Florida.  What in the world would make them think that this was the right thing to do?  Because life plus cancer was too harsh?

The state’s attorney general, Bill McCollum, explained the roots of the state’s approach in the first paragraph of his brief in Mr. Graham’s case.“

Bythe 1990s, violent juvenile crime rates had reached unprecedented highlevels throughout the nation,” Mr. McCollum wrote. “Florida’s problemwas particularly dire, compromising the safety of residents, visitorsand international tourists, and threatening the state’s bedrock tourismindustry.” Nine foreign tourists were killed over 11 months in 1992 and1993, one by a 14-year-old.

A terrible problem.  A simple solution. One that, in retrospect, demonstrates how simple solutions can seem so right at the time, but aren’t. 

Shay Bilchik, who served as a state prosecutor in Miami from 1977 to 1993 and is now the director of the Center for Juvenile Justice Reform at Georgetown,said the state took a wrong turn. “We were pretty aggressive in thoseyears in transferring kids into criminal court,” he said.

Hesaid later research convinced him that his office’s approach was muchtoo aggressive and had not served to deter crime. “My biggest regret,”he said, “is that during the time I was in the prosecutor’s office, wewere under the false impression that we were insuring greater publicsafety when we were not.”

But now it’s the law, and Florida hasn’t been reluctant to use it.  So the issue comes before the Supreme Court. 

Is it unconstitutional to impose a sentence of life without parole on a juvenile for a crime short of murder?  How does one tell?  There is no clear test for such a decision.  What makes it so harsh, so wrong, that a couple of Supreme Court justices will know which way to vote?  And ultimately, it comes down to that, a couple of justice.  Maybe just one justice.  Guided by what?

The problem is that our Constitution was never meant to decide such questions.  When we get to the point of sentences short of death, the determination of propriety is purely normative, a personal vision of right and wrong.  There’s no hard rule to guide the Supreme Court.  There’s no test to measure it. 

That any legislature would conclude that ever-increasing harshness is the answer to every criminal problem is crazy, but the founding fathers never counted on Florida.  There was never an expectation that such simple, and such baseless, solutions would be enacted.  There was an expectation that if you put enough good people in a room, sanity and good judgment would prevail.  They would know, for the balance of human experience, that such simple solutions were just plain ridiculous.  No one would ever do something so foolish as resort to the ridiculous.  And yet they have.

I don’t know that it is unconstitutional.  I don’t know that the Constitution micromanages such details in the criminal decisions of a state.  I don’t know how we can tell if it would, what test would be applied to reach such a decision.

But LWOP for kids at all, no less for crimes short of murder, is just nuts.  Absurd overkill is not something that any rational, reasonable legislature should ever enact.  And yet they do, even though there’s no empirical evidence to show that it makes any sense at all. 
The problem is that states that have approved of the sentence of LWOP argue their emotional justification, the super-predator fallacy, the harm to victims, the crime wave, the need to stop these children. 

If LWOP parole is constitutional, what will they do when they figure out that it doesn’t change the way children think and behave?  Can life plus cancer be far behind if this sentence?  Can the Constitution serve as a substitute for sound, rational judgment?  It wasn’t meant to be, but when states can’t manage to control the exercise of mindless fiat, the enactment of simple solutions, there’s no choice.  Somebody has to stop the madness, and the Supreme Court will be the last resort.

The Path of Least Resistance

We all have darn good reasons for what we do.  At least they seem darn good to us.  At least they seem darn good to us at the moment.  It tends to be the path of least resistance, but our minds tell us that it’s the road we should take if we want to fight another day. 

In retrospect, we don’t always make the best choices, if we’re fair about it and reasonably honest to ourselves. Sure, we can rationalize it otherwise, provided we’re alone in a room and nobody else is around who might be a bit more honest than we are to ourselves, but it allows us to feel relatively good about ourselves without that nagging, “wow, did I really screw up that bad” feeling.  We need that to keep going every day.

There’s been a lot of criticism thrown about the place lately.  Not surprisingly, some have taken umbrage to it, and others have challenged it.  Many have found it dogmatic and doctrinaire.  We’re criminal defense lawyers.  We’re tough guys.  We stare down evil and take our chances, and anybody who isn’t ready to go to jail for the cause is a worthless, gutless, wussie.  It’s a bit extreme.  More than a bit.

It’s unpleasant to use a blawg to highlight lawyers facing unusual circumstances and find them wanting.  Especially when, as has been pointed out by some commenters, it’s all too easy to be critical from a distance, when it’s not your butt that’s going to end up on the hard wooden seat of a jailhouse bench.  We all want to do our jobs, do them well, and go home at the end of the day.  We’re lawyers, not sacrificial lambs.

For the record, I’ve faced choices like those I’ve questioned.  We all do from time to time.  Thankfully, it isn’t a daily occurrence that we risk contempt, or worse, to do our jobs. But the nature of our work isn’t like other jobs, even other jobs in the law.  We are a peculiar breed, choosing to stand next to some unsavory characters, some truly hated and despised defendants, and be their voice.  That puts us in the line of fire.  It’s our choice to be there.  No one stopped us from doing real estate closing instead.  We could be lawyers, kinda, and never faced tough choices.  Instead, we’ve chosen to defend the least powerful person in the room, and put ourselves in a position where getting our teeth kicked in, or hands cuffed, is always a possibility.

On the few occasions that someone has informed me that one more push, no matter how slight, would land me in contempt, or under investigation as the case may be, I pushed anyway.  I’ve never been held in contempt.  I’ve never been indicted.  I’ve never been jailed.  But I have been threatened by some nasty judges who meant business.  And still I stood my ground.

I wrote a while back that you either stand for something or you stand for nothing.  I meant it.  I mean it for me, and I mean it for anyone else who does this job.  I want to go home after work like everyone else, but I also want to be able to look at myself in the mirror.  Now that I’ve reached the top of the hill, and find myself slipping down the back side, the worst thing for me would be to believe that I’ve spent all these years in the trenches and done nothing more than make sure I made it home safely.  There has to be more to a life than safety.  There has to be some purpose, or this was all a big waste of time.

No one expects that every criminal defense lawyer is going to grow a set, stand up for the cause and risk their personal safety and freedom.  Frankly, most of us have very low expectations of others.  But low expectations are almost always fulfilled.  My hope is to raise consciousness and expectations.  Maybe one lawyer who might be inclined to shut their mouth rather than speak out loud and clear, and risk the wrath of a judge rather than sacrifice their client, the law, their dignity, will feel empowered to make a different choice. 

It won’t be easy, and it won’t necessarily be fun.  You may win, but you could also lose.  But at least you will have lived.  You can’t fight another day if you’ve never really fought before.  Sorry if this doesn’t make you feel good about yourself.

Just A Diligent Kinda Officer

The continuation of the contempt hearing for Adam Stoddard, Maricopa County’s finest, was held yesterday before Judge Gary Donahoe, although much of it happened without prying eyes after he closed the courtroom at the insistence of Tom Liddy, with the County Attorney’s office.

To my great disappointment, Nick Martin was unable to attend yesterday’s hearing, leaving us with only the Arizona Republic version of events.  Given its anemic coverage of the last hearing date, it’s a rather sorry substitute.



“Going to,” “steal” and “money.”


Those four words, grouped in the same sentence, prompted a Maricopa County sheriff’s detention officer to remove documents from a defense attorney’s file last month, according to court testimony Thursday.


Officer Adam Stoddard testified that a handful of factors contributed to his decision to position himself behind the defendant, Antonio Solis Lozano, during Lozano’s Oct. 19 sentencing hearing. And while Stoddard was there, his eyes “glazed over” a document with the four words that caught his attention.

And why did Stoddard mosey up behind the defense attorney so that he might happen to “glaze over” the open papers on the table?


Stoddard said the fact that Lozano had numerous papers that court security had not searched concerned him. People in the back of the courtroom who were there to see Lozano also made Stoddard suspicious, according to his testimony.

And sun was in his eyes, and there was a hole in his racket.  So aside from the discrepancies between the video and this testimony, not to mention that the file he was “glazing over” was the attorney’s and not the defendants, and the lack of any logical connection between people being in a courtroom, where they are entitled to be unless Donahoe’s on the bench, and papers on table, Stoddard’s doing a bang up job on his second try to come up with an explanation.

The problem posed is that Stoddard, after being widely ridiculed for his ridiculous attempt to justify his wholly improper invasion into the defense lawyer Joanne Cuccia’s file, had a few days with the county lawyers to come up with a better story.  Despite this gift, he still can’t offer any rationale for his conduct. 

It would seem impossible for Judge Gary Donahoe to be unaware of the fact that his decision will be the subject of intense interest and scrutiny across the country.  This is not just a little Maricopa thing.



Stoddard’s decision to remove the documents from the file of Joanne Cuccia, Lozano’s former attorney, led to an outcry from defense attorneys, an avalanche of media attention once video footage of Stoddard’s move was released, and a packed house in Donahoe’s courtroom Thursday.
No matter how tightly the judge seals the courthouse doors, this one won’t be easily swept under the carpet.  But lest you think that this suggests that the people of Phoenix might be inclined to lay siege to the courthouse with torches and pitchforks, take a hard look at the comments to the AR article.  There seems to be no need to connect up the comments to anything remotely resembling fact, or even rational inference.  It would be funny, but for the fact that this appears to the predominant sense of the community. 

Clearer still is the fact that 64% of registered voters in Arizona give Sheriff Joe Arpaio a positive job performance rating.  He may be an outrageous, but he’s theirs and they love him.  That’s because the good people of Arizona hate them criminals and Mexicans, though not necessarily in that order.

I’m telling you, there’s something in the water.

We Almost Made It To 5

As Doug Berman notes, the 5th birthday of the Supreme Court’s Booker decision is approaching. Ah, it seems like only yesterday that the Sentencing Guidelines were mandatory and any defendant who didn’t rat was going down the river forever.  So naturally, the alternative to slavish consistency, reducing judges to 3rd grade mathematicians and grid readers, is back on the table. 

In the Wall Street Journal, Amir Efrati lobs a grenades into the system to mess with our heads. He offers two anecdotes in his law column to suggest that we’re back to playing spin-the-sentencing-wheel:


First, writes Efrati:



Earlier this year, a Florida man who had been running a fraud scheme that cheated investors out of about $15 million decided to come clean.


Michael Riolo, 38 years old, offered information to the government before the case was brought and turned over his computers, records and assets.


Last month, U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra of West Palm Beach, Fla., gave Mr. Riolo 24½ years in prison.


Fifteen million, 24½ years. Contrast this with another little story:



In another case this fall, Michael Regan, a Massachusetts hedge-fund manager, also turned himself in and pleaded guilty to running a similar scheme that defrauded investors out of $9 million. His sentence [issued by U.S. District Judge Carol Amon in Brooklyn]: seven years.


Why the disparity? It’s hard to say.


It’s hard to say, but that doesn’t stop Efrati from trying.


Efrati writes that the disparity owes, at least in part, to landmark Supreme Court cases in 2005 and 2007 that gave federal judges more freedom to depart from sentencing guidelines. The new latitude has caused a problem to creep back into the federal system: Defendants can receive wildly different sentences for similar crimes.
There are few things more useless to rational discussion that basing conclusions on superficial anecdotes, then using the anecdotes to leap to baseless conclusions.  Efrati demonstrates a talent for both.  If the only factor to be considered on sentence is the amount of the alleged loss, then there might arguably be a point to Efrati’s article.  But it’s not, and there’s not.  Instead, it’s misinformation designed to foster the same simplistic approach that gave rise to the Sentencing Guidelines in the first place.

Did either of the defendant’s cooperate?  Was there a 5k1.1 letter involved?  What about the sentencing factors under § 3553(a)?  There are a multitude of individualizes considerations that go into an appropriate sentence, almost all of which are ignored by the Sentencing Guidelines, which elevated consistency over anything else. 

Of course there are disparities in sentencing.  There should be disparities in sentencing, as there disparities in the individuals being sentenced.  Glossing over the details, the very factors upon which individualized sentences are supposed to be based such that we can move beyond one-size-fits-all sentencing that is so attractive to people for whom thinking is a terrible strain, does not contribute to a “debate”; crunching numbers will never serve as a viable argument for how properly to deal with human lives.

Having lived through the Sentencing Guidelines since 1987, and watched as judges were compelled to impose sentences that no one, except the coldest kid prosecutor, thought reasonable, the experiment was tried.  And failed.  That some would rehash the same arguments that gave rise to the Idiots Guide To Sentencing does not mean that the rest of us need to indulge it another time around. 

There is no debate.  Disparities happen.  There is a risk that some defendants will receive sentences more harsh than would be imposed under the guidelines, but foreclosing the opportunity to seek a sentence predicated upon the specific nature of the case and individual defendant’s circumstances is not the answer.  I refuse to get back on this merry-go-round.  Any anybody who thinks Judge Carol Amon is a softy is clueless anyway.