Author Archives: SHG

The Final Final?

Over at PrawfsBlawg, Rick Bales raises an issue that has totally eluded me up to now, but that may serve to recreate law school in the same way that over-assessment has undermined the point of showing up in high school three days a week.  Testing.


An issue that’s hot right now in higher education generally, and becoming hot in legal education, is outcomes assessment.  How do we know that students are learning anything from our courses?  Single, end-of-semester examinations and bar examinations are poor determinants of student learning.  They both are summative rather than formative, meaning that students do not find out until it is too late whether they are learning the material at an adequate level (contrast weekly quizzes – if a student regularly performs poorly on quizzes, the student knows she needs to step up her game).  They both are snapshots: they demonstrate what a student knows at a single point of time rather than what is retained over time.  For both, there is very little correlation between what is tested, how it is tested, and real-life law practice.
Many things are mixed together in this paragraph, and have the potential to fundamentally alter the way law is taught.  Some may think this is good. Others not so much, but it’s a hot topic within the Academy and yet practicing lawyers, the consumers of law school products, know almost nothing about it. 

Paul Lippe recently started a debate over whether law school 4.0 should focus on the theoretical or practical, and it dealt with some critical issues for the future of lawyers.  Academics disagreed.  While that side of the issue remains unresolved, the testing side can sneak up on us and similarly do a whole lot of damage.  It’s hardly a benign problem for the consideration of lawprofs alone; When law school education is assessed on a regular basis rather than just a final exam, the mechanics of how law is taught will change.

My initial thought is that we already have lawprofs in the classroom.  Don’t they know, via Socratic Method, who has a clue and who doesn’t?  But then I remember that Socratic Method is no longer the favored form of pedagogy, and that it’s no longer acceptable for teachers to tell students that they’re wrong.  That would harm their fragile self-esteem, and subject the law schools to angry phone calls from the parents circling above.  Nobody wants to hear from the parents.

The demand for constant assessment, which for some strange reason has become accepted as the routine, may result in teaching to the test, or the death of inspirational lawprofs, or simply taking away the time that was earlier used to teach law.  Maybe this isn’t such a bad idea after all?  But if assessment became the rule, some of the most important things I learned in law school would never have survived.

Then there’s the question raised by Rick about the correlation of testing and the practice of law.  One final exam is, obviously, summative.  But then, so it a jury verdict.  It’s not like you get to go back and redo your cross after the jury foreman says “guilty”. 

But the aspect of this demand for assessment that strikes me as most troubling is the maturing-down of law school.  While perpetual adolescence is a widespread problem for the Slackoisie, and evidenced by the comments at Above The Law, which caters to the younger set, and Sweet Hot Justice, confronting such monumental concerns as associates having acne outbreaks, law students are supposed to be capable of counseling clients shortly after they leave the hallowed halls.  This demands a certain level of judgment and maturity.

If law students can’t be trusted to exercise the level of maturity necessary to assess themselves, their work ethic, their knowledge, their understanding, and need the nanny to test them weekly to make sure they aren’t missing something or falling behind, then will they be capable of demonstrating the level of maturity necessary to fulfill their function as a practicing lawyer?  Bear in mind, not every law student will be warming a chair in the Biglaw library.  Some will actually have to go out and work for a living, and will be expected to be a lawyer from Day 1.

It’s difficult to say whether the calls for continued regular assessment reflect an extant failure of maturity on the part of law students, or whether it will be the cause of prolonged adolescence.  If the former, then it’s too late.  If the latter, then we’re putting another nail in the coffin of the profession.  But either way, it would be wise for the practicing bar to put in its two cents before another seismic shift in how law is taught happens without our knowing.

Sullivan’s Justice; Still Inexplicable

It’s not that Andrew Sullivan smoked some pot, which in itself is no big deal despite the fact that it’s a big enough deal to land most people in the hoosegow, but that no one has yet come up with a rationale that can make any sense of the government’s decision to give this very prominent blogger at The Atlantic, winner of the 2008 Best Blog, a free pass.  But that doesn’t mean no one is trying.

Via Doug Berman comes an academic effort to explain the facial disparity that Magistrate Judge Robert B. Collings found inexcusable and unjustifiable.  The official explanation:


Collings found the request, and the vague explanation, puzzling, given that the U.S. Attorney’s office routinely prosecutes pot cases, even involving small amounts. So he called a hearing, held September 2. There, Sullivan’s lawyer, Robert Delahunt, Jr., explained that the charge could complicate his client’s attempt to become a U.S. citizen. (Sullivan is British by birth. He is also HIV positive, as he has often noted on his blog, and U.S. law continues to discriminate against potential citizens who are HIV-positive, a subject Sullivan has written about often.)

This went over poorly, the arguments being the same garden variety excuses that apply in a wealth of prosecutions that aren’t dismissed.  But then, the defendants aren’t Andrew Sullivan.  So Doug took matters into his own hands.


Because I was not quite sure what to make of the case, I asked former federal prosecutor Anthony Barkow, who is now the Executive Director of the Center on the Administration of Criminal Law at NYU School of Law, if he had some thoughts on the matter.  To may great pleasure, Barkow and one of his NYU students penned a terrific commentary.

I have to assume that Doug’s description of Barkow’s explanation is a matter of professional courtesy, because it is just horrible.  Whether that’s because it’s a string of disconnected platitudes about “Justice” that entirely ignore the only issue raised in this case, disparity of treatment, or reflects wholesale ignorance of the fact that Sullivan’s situation is remarkably ordinary, with defendants charged with minor offenses often having immigration and/or health consequences.  And most of the time, their homeland is far less hospitable than the United Kingdom.

Barkow begins by “explaining” that Mag. Collings ignored a basic concept, the power of the sovereign to exercise discretion:

But in his focus on horizontal equity, the Magistrate himself ignores another “cardinal precept of our legal system”: that the Executive exercise its discretion to insure that its charging decisions accomplish just ends, rather than apply blindly the power of the State to punish whenever it is possible to do so.

He then “explains” that collateral consequences exist for criminal prosecution:


The consequences that attend collaterally to criminal convictions are often significant and debilitating. They include disenfranchisement, deportation, or the loss of the ability to live in public housing or to work in various professions. Indeed, in the case of low-level crimes such as marijuana possession, the seriousness of collateral consequences often exceeds the punishment that derives directly from the commission of the crime.
From whence he concludes:


Thus it was entirely appropriate for the United States Attorney to consider the impact that a prosecution could have had on Sullivan’s pending immigration status, especially given the small quantity of marijuana that Sullivan was accused of possessing and the fact that Massachusetts recently decriminalized the possession of up to an ounce of marijuana.

If this is a “terrific” explanation, we’re in far deeper trouble in academia than I thought.  It’s not that there’s anything to disagree about in Barkow’s commentary, though it reflects the depth of understanding that any criminal defense lawyer who has been in the trenches more than a week would possess, but it wholly misses the issue. 

No one says prosecutors shouldn’t exercise discretion, or have the authority to do so.  No one says that the collateral consequences of conviction aren’t draconian. But what does that have to do with the fact that of the thousands of defendants who receive no such consideration, suffer draconian consequences, only the powerful, like Andrew Sullivan, is deserving of better treatment?  That’s the question. Barkow never goes anywhere near it.  He doesn’t, as far as can be discerned from his commentary, even understand it.

But now that the question is on the table, I’m going to take a stab at providing a hard answer as to why Andrew Sullivan was welcomed into the warm bosom of the legal system when others are not.  Rather than rank favoritism, the heightened status of an Andrew Sullivan gave the prosecution pause to think about the issues, the problems, the consequences of their actions where they were not sufficiently interested to do so in other cases. 

Whether it was Joe Smith or Jose Morales before, neither defendant was a real, living, breathing human being to the men and women who suffered the butt of our criminal justice system.  The prosecution went through the routine motions, sloughed off the harshness of their actions as part of the job, and felt nothing.  They went for a drink after work and slept well that night.  They never gave the impact of prosecution on these defendants a second thought.

But when Andrew Sullivan stood in the dock, it was real.  Here was a person, not merely a defendant.  Here was some trivial offense, one that many (including the brethren in the United States Attorneys office) indulged though they avoided talking about it in the courtroom, that had the potential to wreak havoc on his world.  He was intelligent, respected, erudite.  He was like them.

When it was Andrew Sullivan standing there, the significance of what they were doing took on life.  And they, for once, recognized that it would be crazy to ruin his life over such crap.

I don’t begrudge Andrew Sullivan getting a pass for possessing a little pot.  I begrudge Joe Smith and Jose Morales not getting the same concern and recognition as Andrew Sullivan.  They have lives and families, dreams and aspirations.  They are human beings.  Every reason that applies in favor of giving Andrew Sullivan a pass applies to them as well.

Free Andrew Sullivan!  Just free the rest of them as well.

Newsday: Rice Was Wrong

It’s not easy to find on its second generation website, which lacks the panache of its first attempt but provides greater access to advertisements, but today’s Newsday editorial is quite extraordinary.  Simply put, the editorial states that Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice was wrong, completely wrong, in her failure to charge Damnell Ndonye for her false allegations of gang rape.


Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice will not charge the 18-year-old who lied about being gang raped in a Hofstra University dormitory. That’s a mistake.

Society, however, would have been better served if the district attorney had left her fate to the judicial process.

To appreciate the significance of this position, one needs to have some understanding of local politics.  Nassau County was the most firmly secure bastion of Republican machine politics left in the nation until 2001, when Tom Suozzi was first elected County Executive.  That brought to an end the regime of Joe Mondello, heir to Joe Margiotta, over what the Syracuse University’s Maxwell School of Public Affairs called the “worst run county in the nation.”  

Tom Suozzi rode into office as a reformer, and Kathleen Rice rode his coattails.  Newsday, with the blessing of everybody who wasn’t on the county’s Republican Party payroll, supported the change.  There was no choice, given the disastrously bad shape the county was in, and the absence of any hope of improvement without a change in administration.  Newsday was definitively pro-Democrat.  And nothing has changed to suggest that the Nassau County Republicans would do any better today than before.

Some might say that Newsday would be disinclined to be critical of a county Democrat.  Others might say that the editors would rather stick a needle in their eye than write anything negative about a Democrat.  That’s why this editorial is so significant.

The editorial goes on to explain why Rice is wrong.



Rice argues that her deal is better because it identifies Ndonye, puts her on record admitting to a lie and guarantees that the young woman gets mental health treatment. But that’s not enough to tip the argument in the district attorney’s favor. Ndonye was already identified in media accounts and on Facebook as having lied. What’s most disturbing, however, is that what Rice did implies a lack of trust in the judicial system.

Beyond the details of how law enforcement handled this case, are its implications for the future. Rice justifies her decision not to prosecute because it would have a “chilling effect,” making actual victims fearful to come forward. That concern is misplaced. Historically, police and prosecutors have been hostile to women who made rape charges, but the consensus now in law enforcement is that these cases should be fully and aggressively prosecuted. For legitimate claims to be taken seriously, however, society must also know that phony ones will be punished. That’s what will make the voice of every true victim even stronger.

Instead, Rice’s resolution risks creating the perception that there isn’t much downside to making up a story that could have sent someone to jail for 5 years. Even though the charges were dropped, the men’s names and photographs are forever linked with one of society’s most heinous crimes.
Strong position.  Sound arguments.  Most importantly, independence from the underlying politics that many fear guides Newsday’s coverage.  Even if Newsday has a generalized bias in favor of Suozzi and the Democrats, it’s critical for any credible newspaper to acknowledge that the favored son, or the District Attorney hanging on to his coattails, can be wrong.  And when they are, integrity demands that you call them on it.  Newsday has done just that.

Bravo, Rita and Alleen.

More Than A Mere Pester

The title of my first post on Maryland v. Shatzer, which will be argued before the Supreme Court this coming Monday, pretty much summed it up: Do Constitutional Rights Have an Expiration Date?  But then, that’s just my view, and what else would you expect from a criminal defense lawyer.

Orin Kerr at Volokh Conspiracy thinks the Supremes will take a different view, agreeing with Don Dripps and Yale Kamisar, who lay out their position at CrimProf Blog, where they believe that time, time, time is on the cops’ side.  The post provides a thorough jog through the caselaw from Miranda to Edwards v. Arizona  and Minnick v. Mississippi.

For anyone unfamiliar with the facts, Shatzer was in prison when he was approached by a cop and immediately invoked his right to counsel.  Three years later, with some additional evidence, the case was reopened and Shatzer, still in prison (though a different one) was approached again. This time, after being given warnings, he talked. Oops.

The issue is whether the initial invocation of the right to counsel was still effective 31 months later.  The lawprofs think this would make a great exam question, and ask “Can Edwards’s protection possibly last this long?”  The lower court said no, but the Maryland Court of Appeals reversed.


It was unable to find any case that relied “solely upon the passage of time factor standing alone” (emphasis in the original) to conclude that the Edwards protection had expired.  Nor was the court impressed by the argument that a “break in custody” occurred when Shatzer was released back into the general prison population in between the two meetings with the police.

The lawprofs are unimpressed with this reasoning.


The Maryland Court of Appeals may have gone astray by dwelling too long on the “break in custody” exception.  The Edwards rule was designed to prevent the police from pestering or badgering a suspect who has asserted his right to counsel at his first meeting with the police.  But two interrogations in 31 months can hardly be called “badgering” or “pestering.”  Why not say that when so much time has elapsed between the first and second meetings with the police that no reasonable custodial suspect could possibly believe that he was being badgered by the police or that the police were trying to wear him down, the Edwards protection should expire?  Mr. Shatzer undoubtedly will argue that there is a need for a bright-line rule in this area.  Two and a half years may seem long enough, but what about two and a half weeks or two and a half days?  Absent a break in custody, i.e., a substantial change in circumstances, Shatzer will maintain, the Edwards protection should remain in effect.
They conclude that it is “most unlikely” that a majority of the Court will agree that Edwards protections “never wears out.”  Or, if we eliminate the double negative, the Court will reverse.

Just as Dripps and Kamisar argue that the Maryland Court of Appeals placed undue emphasis on the “break in custody” exception, it strikes me that they have placed undue emphasis on the “pestering” rationale, and thereby missed a crucial, and very real, problem.  The duration of the invocation isn’t merely about stopping police from badgering a suspect who has invoked his right to counsel, but about finding a moment of weakness, of compliance, of submission, and exploiting it to obtain a statement that would otherwise never be given.

Bear in mind, there’s no harm in the police going back to the well to see if they can catch the suspect at a moment of weakness, since the alternative is to be precluded from questioning the witness at all until counsel is provided.  The cops have no need to be bullies in their approach; they just need to get to the suspect at the right moment, when there is a lapse in the sound judgment displayed by his invocation of right to counsel.

Of course, the fact that Dripps and Kamisar’s rationale only gets a C- doesn’t mean that it won’t be adopted by the Supremes.  As they note, there is likely to be a few justices who would prefer to do away with the protections altogether.  Sound reasoning and policy won’t necessarily stand in the way of a decision stripping defendants of their protections.  But if they decision goes against Shatzer, the next question is going to be a doozy.

Even assuming 31 months, more than two and a half years, is “long enough” to dissipate the invocation of counsel, what about two and a half months?  Weeks? Hours?  What possible rational basis can exist for drawing a line where the right runs out?  What a holy mess a reversal in Shatzer will make of things, with judges reaching deep within themselves to decide on an ad hoc basis how long is too long.  Or more likely, can they get away with permitting the cops to try another dip in the well.

Life in the Fast Lane

It’s tough to be a criminal defense lawyer.  It’s a hard practice, banging your head against the wall in courtroom after courtroom, judge after judge.  The clients can be difficult. Judges treat you like you’re the legal equivalent of Pee Wee Herman.  And your former law school classmates think you’ve chosen a life of loud desperation.

But times change, at least as far as the way your former classmates think of your choice.  From Temporary Attorneys, a blog dedicated to the life of the Biglaw second stringers,  These used to be the lawyers from lesser schools, or with the ones who made up the bottom of the class, allowing the winners to make up the top.  Remember, there’s no top third without a bottom and middle.

These days, however, as Biglaw layoffs have devastated the ranks of young lawyers with loan coming due, even former law review editors have more time than PS3 games can fill.   What are their options?


In Chicago, only top tier, top 1/3rd of the class, former biglaw associates with 2+ years of litigation experience need apply (products liability associates preferred!). Unreal. Game over.

“Counsel On Call is currently interviewing attorneys with at least one year of solid electronic document review experience for a contract assignment in downtown Chicago. Must have worked as a litigation associate in a large law firm 2+ years. Experience with products liability litigation strongly preferred. Full time, requires a three month commitment. Top tier school and top 1/3 of class required. Please e-mail resume to [email protected].”

And that’s to get a temporary job doing document review.  For CDLs unfamiliar with that phrase, documents are pieces of paper with writing on them.  You take them and look at them. Sometimes you have them on computers and don’t have to take them in hand. This avoids nasty paper cuts.

Document review is the bottom ladder of the Biglaw rung.  It’s the dregs. It has to be done, but not by anybody who has any dream of a successful career in Biglaw, and certainly no one who ever expects to make partner.  Once you do document review, you can never go back.  It’s like the scarlet letter of Biglaw.

So what’s it like to do document review?  I mean, there’s no shame in doing hard work, and anything worth doing is worth doing right.  Here’s a peek inside the life of the document reviewing attorney at Labaton Sucharow.


Labaton which hired a bunch of attorneys for its Countrywide project some months ago and paid them $32 flat per hour with absolutely no benefits announced that the firm will be closed for Yom Kippur and there will be no pay. How wonderful! I am all for respecting each others’ religion, but I draw the line when it takes money out of my pocket. If you wish to take the day off, enjoy, but why should a company consider it okay to close down on a religious holiday, not a federal one, and screw their Countrywide “employees” out of a day’s pay. Labaton, you suck. You are cheap.

One of the named plaintiffs in Countrywide is the NYS Comptroller, so you Labaton think it is fine to get business from a government entity, operate in New York City and then hire attorneys for a long term project while giving them no benefits whatsoever, and then to boot, impose a religious holiday on them. What the hell is wrong with this country? No wonder that it is so fucked up. It is one thing to get screwed by an agency, but you Labaton made us your employees. You want to pay us the minimum by cutting out the agency’s take, and then you bill the client God knows what for our services, all the while providing no benefits in return. We can’t even get paid overtime because of the bullshit professional exemption in NY. The cleaning people have more benefits and rights than we do.

I get the sense that the writer isn’t happy.  When the lawyer is jealous of the cleaning people, that’s a fair call.  As described, document review is the lawyer equivalent of a sweat shop, where they are treated like, like, contract workers.  They are paid an hourly wage to perform a specific task.  The job comes without benefits, and when they don’t work, they don’t get paid.  And from what I read, $32 an hour isn’t bad, considering that wages go as low a $18 per hour.

Not all the contract attorneys are so unappreciative of their paycheck.  Some are actually thankful to work at all.


Just wanted you to know that I started a large scale project today. It’s the De Novo project in NYC. It’s packed to the gills with over one hundred coders. Everyone seems to be in good spirits and thankful to be back at work. In fact, I think many of us are suffering from post-traumatic stress. Whether it was spending months unemployed wondering how we were going to feed our families, or having the fortitude to put up with the “gansta gang” at Sullivan & Cromwell which was oftentimes the only show in town, we have been through a lot. Let’s hope this recovery is sustainable.”

Kinda restores your faith in lawyers, doesn’t it? Such good will in the face of adversity.

Now aren’t you happy that you decided to dedicate your professional career to defending the oppressed and gave up the glamour of a job at Biglaw?  Maybe the top third wasn’t really as “best and brightest” as they thought they were.  If nothing else, it makes indigent defense rates seem downright attractive.

ABA Journal to Lawyers: We Quit

It was a sad day around the blawgosphere when news broke that the ABA Journal had decided to shut its doors, having been purchased in a last ditch pre-liquidation sale to Mad Magazine.  The organ of the American Bar Association was no more, though it’s name would live on in an Onion-esque fashion. 

Within minutes, the new owners published their first piece, and a doozy it was. Keeping the Legal Rebels theme, since the folks at Mad Mag found themselves unable to do better than the ABA Journal had already done to itself, came




Rex Gradeless has a unique ability to pinpoint useful information for a variety of audiences. That probably explains why the recent St. Louis University School of Law grad has more than 71,000 followers on Twitter, where he’s known as @Rex7.


For Gradeless the question now has become what to do next, and the economy is influencing his decision-making. While he’d like to do civil litigation, the jobs are scarce. In August, shortly after taking the Missouri bar exam, Gradeless had a soft offer with a top-20 law firm he wouldn’t name. The position wouldn’t start until January 2010, Gradeless says, and he’d hopefully be doing legal and Web 2.0 work.


“You have a juggernaut of marketing types in law firms who want to control the message, and it’s hard for them to see it’s not going to be possible forever,” Gradeless says. “Hopefully I can educate them and we can start doing some of this other social-networking-type stuff.”
I swear, I don’t know how these guys come up with this stuff.  What an imagination!  But there was more, an interview with Rex Gradeless, offering his insights on twitter to lawyers across the nation.  According to ABA Journal writer Stephanie Francis Ward, “you were so interesting we went waaaay over 30 minutes.”  It offered gems like this:

@SFW70 : Can you give examples of social media that actually worked to get lawyers new, paying business?
27CDB6E-AE6D-11cf-96B8-444553540000″ id=”PhoneviteVoicePlayer” width=”250″ height=”140″ codebase=”http://fpdownload.macromedia.com/get/flashplayer/current/swflash.cab”>

Okay, so maybe they pushed the envelope a little too far by trying to make us think that the real ABA Journal would seriously use an unemployed law school grad to teach lawyers across America how to get business based on twits.  The best one was when she asked Rex Gradeless his opinion on whether there were malpractice risks associated with social media.  Can you imagine?

Granted, the old ABA Journal, before it became a satire rag, had its moments, like when it put the FBI: Gotcha website in its Blawg 100. They must have been howling in the offices over that one.

I, for one, will miss the old ABA Journal, but the new one is certainly a lot more fun to read.  I can’t wait to see what they will come up with next.

Caveat:  Before anyone gets their panties in a twist, this isn’t a knock of Rex Gradeless, who has done an extraordinary job of creating a public profile for himself based on nothing more than collecting followers.  Rex isn’t to blame for the demise of the ABA Journal, or capitalizing on noxious fumes that overcame the judgment of its editorial staff.

They First Came For Our Shoes

Richard Colvin Reid was not successful in his efforts to light a fuse that, he hoped, would ignite pentaerythritol tetranitrate, a high explosive contained in the lining of his shoe.  But because of him, millions of Americans are required to remove their shoes as they enter the security zone at airports.  Whether bare or stocking-ed, we are constrained to suffer the indignity of going shoeless “for our own protection.”

If this is the measure of safety, we’re in trouble.  From Bruce Schneier (note: the comments to Schneier’s post are a must read):



[L]ast month someone tried to assassinate a Saudi prince by exploding a bomb stuffed in his rectum. He pretended to be a repentant militant, when in fact he was a Trojan horse:


The resulting explosion ripped al-Asiri to shreds but only lightly injured the shocked prince — the target of al-Asiri’s unsuccessful assassination attempt.


While the efficacy of concealing explosives within a body cavity is questionable, the same could be said for a shoe bomb but it didn’t give the TSA much pause.  Safety first. 

As lawyers, we look at the validity of arguments taken to the logical extreme.  This certainly provides an opportunity to do just that, as logic dictates that if we are to be reactive to every potential threat to airline travel, itself a delivery mechanism that has already been used, the next step will be as extreme as it gets. 

Many contend that the system in place in airports is designed primarily to create an atmosphere of safety rather than assure actual safety, given that anyone bent toward terrorism would be inclined to find the next new way to secrete a weapon to defeat the existing security measures.  Others suggest that it’s all designed to keep Americans afraid, and thus retain control over their thinking and facilitate their willingness to allow the government to engage in ever more intrusive means of investigation. 

Either way, it’s the sacrifice of freedom on the alter of security.  As Ben Franklin informs, we then deserve neither.

The illusion was revealed before Congress during a hearing on the USA PATRIOT Act last week, under the questioning of Senator Russ Feingold.


Only three of the 763 “sneak-and-peek” requests in fiscal year 2008 involved terrorism cases, according to a July 2009 report from the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts. Sixty-five percent were drug cases.

Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis.) quizzed Assistant Attorney General David Kris about the discrepancy at a hearing on the PATRIOT Act Wednesday. One might expect Kris to argue that there is a connection between drug trafficking and terrorism or that the administration is otherwise justified to use the authority by virtue of some other connection to terrorism.

He didn’t even try. “This authority here on the sneak-and-peek side, on the criminal side, is not meant for intelligence. It’s for criminal cases. So I guess it’s not surprising to me that it applies in drug cases,” Kris said.
Way back when we were fighting the war against terrorism, and the Department of Justice put together everything on its wishlist for a onetime shot at gaining investigative weapons that had been routinely rejected by Congress as improper, unduly intrusive and flagrantly unconstitutional, the answer to all questions was terrorism.  The mere utterance of the word made representatives, senators and citizens melt.  No one, except the Gentleman from Wisconsin, would be so unAmerican as to deny the need to safeguard the American people from terrorists.

But that was when we were naive.  That was when we retained an expectation of privacy, when we believed that Americans had a right to free movement, when we wore our shoes from the moment we put them on our feet until we were firmly planted in our very narrow airplane seat.  That was when we needed a darn good reason to give away our birthright.

No one argues the point anymore.  No one refuses to show identification in order to use the prepaid ticket to fly from one American city to another, as if we were under no duty to identify ourselves to any government agent having done nothing to justify their demand for such.  No one refuses to remove their shoes.

And the Department of Justice no longer needs to pretend that any of this relates to our safety from terrorists.  Don’t blame the Attorney General or Congress for fooling us or giving away our freedom.  They could never have done so without our willingness to obey.

Now bend over.  You’re holding up the line.

H/T Radley Balko

Up To The Task?

Most criminal defense lawyers labor in obscurity, hoping to one day get that big case that will thrust them into the limelight and turn their small time practice into a household word.  It’s not always that easy, and there’s nothing like a story in the Wall Street Journal ripping the lawyer to shreds to make one wonder why you got out of bed that day.

Before Najibullah Zazi hit the headlines as America’s newest alleged terrorist, he sought out the services of a local lawyer in Denver.  He ended up talking to Art Folsom,   Folsom gave Zazi and told him to give him a call if he needed anything.  Who knew?



It was quite by accident that the biggest terrorism case in recent years landed on the doorstep of small-time defense lawyer Art Folsom, who has made a living on drug-possession and drunk-driving cases, along with the odd divorce.


Mr. Folsom represents Najibullah Zazi, accused by the U.S. government of plotting to build and detonate a lethal explosive as part of an active al Qaeda cell. Mr. Folsom, 37 years old and a graduate of the University of Denver College of Law, is up against scores of FBI agents and federal prosecutors who have worked feverishly for weeks to build the case.

Let’s face facts.  Defending someone accused of terrorism is both extraordinarily unusual within the confines of criminal defense, and difficult under any circumstances.  Aside from a handful of lawyers who have chosen to take up arms in a truly brutal niche, one where the rules are all different and there’s neither money nor glory to smooth over the rough spots or sweeten the pot, even the most experienced federal criminal defense lawyers have little experience with defending terrorists.  My thoughts turn immediately to Josh Dratel, who took over from me as amicus chair at the NYSACDL, who has chosen the path of defending accused terrorists.  It’s a brutal, and unrewarding, road.

But that hasn’t stopped others from talking about Folsom.


Veteran criminal defense attorneys have been unusually blunt in assessing Mr. Folsom’s qualifications. “Mr. Folsom is just in over his head,” said prominent Denver defense lawyer Daniel Recht, citing Mr. Folsom’s performance so far and minimal experience in federal court.

It’s not that Recht is necessarily wrong, as he explained to the Denver Post :


Three experienced criminal defense lawyers on Monday questioned the strategy of the attorney for Najibullah Zazi, saying that allowing a client to talk to the FBI for 28 hours was at best “risky” and at worst would lead to a criminal charge.

“He shouldn’t have done it,” lawyer Daniel Recht said of Zazi’s attorney, Art Folsom. “He literally walked his client into prison. In fact, this fellow would not be in custody now but for the advice of his attorney.”

Recht would have advised Zazi not to talk to the FBI until Recht had a full understanding of what Zazi may have done, what he might be questioned about and what the FBI might have on wiretaps.

Well, yeah.  Attorneys without federal experience often lack the appreciation of what they think of as being “cooperative” and are afraid of telling the FBI to get lost.  The FBI can be quite intimidating, even to lawyers, and you’ve got have a pair to stare them down.   Whether the problem was Folsom’s lack of federal experience, or that he was cowed by the agents, or both, he was certainly over his head and left Zazi dangling in the wind.

Still, Art Folsom isn’t giving up the reins.



With a shrug and a drag on his cigarette, Mr. Folsom begs to differ. “I’ve been practicing criminal defense for 10 years,” he says. “This is an enormous case, but when you get down to the core principles, it’s about criminal defense.”

Folsom has at least brought in J. Michael Dowling, who has “25 years of experience in drug trials and other federal cases,” though notably not handling terrorism cases.  But that doesn’t mean that Folsom is relinquishing his spotlight,


But Mr. Folsom remains lead counsel. TV crews stake out his office, in a building that also houses a massage therapist and a jewelry shop. After hearings, he is the one who faces the cameras.

The lure of the klieg lights is particularly hard to ignore the first time around, but as he will find out very quickly, they are extremely hot.  It’s very easy to get burned.

Then there’s the question of money, since few accused terrorists also happen to possess much by way of personal wealth.



Amid the hubbub, Mr. Folsom has his own legal problems. He was charged this summer with possession of less than an ounce of marijuana, a petty offense that carries a small fine. He says the pot belonged to a friend. A pretrial conference is set for mid-October.

Mr. Folsom expects the Zazi case to take up much of his time, though his client has no money to pay him. That’s a bit tough, he says: “I’d like to be able to keep making my car payments.”
Handling a major media case is all-consuming.  Just fielding the telephone calls is a full-time job.  But when the client is broke, and the car payments keep coming, and the desire to continue, whether altruistic or addiction to the limelight, takes hold, it’s a problem.  In the worst of all possible worlds, Folsom is financially devastated by the case, loses whatever other cases he might have or get for lack of time, and is ultimately excoriated in the media for his inept representation.  Maybe, if he plays his cards really poorly, he becomes the goat for ineffective assistance of counsel and loses his license.

And this has nothing to do with the client, Najibullah Zazi, who will not doubt feel the fullest weight of the government come crashing down upon him in one of the most intense, and difficult, cases a defendant can face.  Terrorism defense really isn’t the province of amateurs.  Even with vast federal experience, the demands of a terrorism defense are different, and experience in this very small niche is incredibly important if you expect to have any chance at success.  It is not, as Folsom says, just a criminal defense at its core. No drug dealer faces the state secrets doctrine.

For all those young and “small time” lawyers hoping to catch the big one, be careful what you wish for. You just might be the next Art Folsom.

Retrial After More Than A Generation (Plus A Sexually Mutilated Corpse)

While an immediate retrial after a hung jury presents some additional hurdles for the defense, the situation is different when 27 years have elapsed since Robie J. Drake was first convicted of the murder of two Tonawanda teens in 1982.  And according to his lawyer, Andrew LoTiempo, he’ll need $500,000 for experts if the prosecution wants to persist.

There was never any question that Drake shot the two teens, who were making out in a 1969 Chevy Nova in the parking lot of an abandoned factory.  Back in 1981, there was nothing terribly unusual about that, although today two teens kissing may sound a bit quaint.  From the Buffalo News :


Drake, who was 17 at the time, has never denied that he shot Smith and Rosenthal as they kissed in a rusty 1969 Chevrolet Nova parked in an abandoned factory’s parking lot off River Road in North Tonawanda.

He told police that he thought the car was empty and was using it for rifle practice. Smith was shot twice and Rosenthal 16 times.

But the prosecution’s case isn’t based on the shooting, but rather than aftermath.



Then-Niagara County District Attorney Peter L. Broderick Sr. presented experts to assert that Drake was driven to kill by a purported psychological syndrome called “picquerism,” in which a person derives sexual satisfaction from a shooting or stabbing.

Drake drove the Nova to a nearby landfill, where two policemen caught him trying to stuff Smith’s nude body into the trunk.

The results of two autopsies turned up evidence of a bite mark on the girl’s chest, which examiners said was inflicted after her death, along with other violations of her corpse.

For obvious reasons, the really good evidence, of sexual mutilation of the girl’s corpse, is what the prosecution sought to use against Drake then, and still wants to use against Drake now.  In the interim, however, it caused the Second circuit to toss the conviction.


But in January, the U. S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York City ordered a new trial on grounds of prosecutorial misconduct.

The federal court found that picquerism is “quackery” and that Broderick’s star witness inflated his resume and committed perjury with Broderick’s knowledge.

While it’s unclear whether the prosecution plans to try its hand a “picquerism” again, it has announced its intention to introduce the sexual mutilation of the corpse.  LoTiempo, in his threat to require a half million for experts on retrial, is trying to put the screws to the prosecution if it seeks to use this sordid post hoc evidence.


“That becomes irrelevant now. He’s not charged with doing anything to those people after they were dead,” LoTiempo argued.

He said the only purpose of the medical evidence was to bolster Broderick’s claim of picquerism. But if the medical evidence comes in, LoTiempo said, he would have to fight it by hiring a proctologist, a pathologist and experts in DNA, bite marks and ballistics.


While no one can deny the “yuck” factor of Drake’s alleged post shooting conduct, if indeed “yuck” even begins to cover it, this really tests the bounds of undue prejudice.  Certainly, the power of this absolutely horrific evidence will be impossible for a jury to ignore, and will assuredly cause a visceral reaction that will prejudice the jury against Drake.  But it is, as LoTiempo notes, wholly irrelevant to the issue of murder.  It’s just so darned sick and juicy.  How can any prosecutor pass up such salacious and disgusting evidence?

But there are other issues raised by this retrial that raise curious issues.


Meanwhile, Brandt and Assistant District Attorney Timothy R. Lundquist are asking to have some testimony from the 1982 trial simply read to the new jury.

Some witnesses have died, including one of the two arresting officers and the doctor who performed the first autopsy. But the prosecutors say others are too old or live too far away to testify again.

That can happen after 27 years.  While there may be no statute of limitations on murder, witnesses often have a finite shelf life.


LoTiempo said he would insist on live testimony whenever possible.
Whenever possible?  Maybe LoTiempo is better at writing zeros on an 18b application than he is at remembering constitutional thingies, like the confrontation clause.  It’s really, really hard to cross-examine a transcript, which is why those robed people in D.C. bothered to decide Crawford v. Washington.  Whatever difficulties are presented by lost witnesses aren’t the defense’s problem, Andy, and you don’t have suffer testimony read from 27 year old transcripts.  Even if that means it’s impossible for the prosecution to make its case.

But all this is happening in beautiful Buffalo, so it’s yet to be seen all of the bill of rights have made their way that far north yet.

H/T Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen.

Nassau DA Rice Feels The Heat

While it’s premature to claim democracy is alive and well in Nassau County, at least it’s not yet moribund.  After Joy Watson, former heard of sex crimes and candidate for District Attorney, finally had an opportunity to state her position on why Rice blew the decision to decline to prosecute Danmell Ndonye, the Hofstra false rape accuser, her opponent, current District Attorney Kathleen Rice was forced to publicly explain.

Of critical significance, the plan to bury the decision and story after the 5:00 o’clock Friday press release was thwarted.  Feeling the pressure of a story still kicking despite her efforts to use the news cycle to her advantage, Rice gave a press conference on Monday to explain herself.  No matter whose position one supports, the story has been resurrected.

Newsday, which apparently has plenty of room for Kathleen Rice even if there’s little space for Watson, reports:



In her first interview explaining the decision, Rice said her goal had been to ensure that the young woman publicly admitted guilt, accepted accountability and responsibility for her crime and repaid the community through service.


Rice, who said she never personally spoke to or saw the young woman, said she was satisfied prosecutors had plentiful evidence of Danmell Ndonye’s lie, which sent four innocent men to jail.

This is a fundamental shift in strategy by Rice, who earlier explained that her reason for declining to prosecute was to avoid discouraging rape victims from coming forward and because Ndyone was “deeply troubled.”  The strategy has now turned to a “tough on crime” rationale, apparently based on a belief that prosecuting would have somehow served to sweep this under the carpet.


“We did not want any loopholes,” Rice said.

Without explaining what “loopholes” she’s talking about, the only ones that come to mind our those nasty constitutional rights and criminal procedures.  Was it fear that the police, or perhaps her office, had violated Ndonye’s rights in the course of its investigation?  Is there a loophole that Rice knew about that remains unknown to the rest of us?  Or is this merely a play on the public to denigrate the Constitution as a bunch of technicalities that let criminals go free?



Rice, who defeated Dillon four years ago, slammed back, saying Watson doesn’t understand how modern prosecution works.


“Had this case gone to court, the record would have been sealed,” Rice said, noting that Ndonye’s age and clean record, combined with a misdemeanor criminal charge likely would have netted her zero jail time.


“There would be no public admission,” Rice said, “no public accountability,” because as a youthful offender the records would have been sealed.

Rice’s flip-flop aside, this is simply wrong.  The prosecution would have been public, as is every criminal prosecution. Ndonye, at 18, could not have been prosecuted as a minor, and most assuredly would not have been.  While it’s possible that she might have been granted “youthful offender treatment” at the time of sentencing, which would have caused her criminal record to be sealed, it happens after the prosecution is completed, not, as Rice appears to suggest, to conceal the prosecution from public view.  It would have had absolutely no impact on a public admission or public accountability, which comes before the YO determination is made.

And as to a prosecution “nett[ing] her zero jail time,” didn’t anybody tell Rice that Ndonye isn’t going to jail under her “deal”?

While it might be worthwhile to parse Rice’s explanation in further detail if it truly bore a connection to her decision to decline to prosecute, there is little to suggest that it’s anything more than an effort, in the face of public outrage, to re-spin the move..


“There is no doubt that this is not a politically popular decision,” said Rice.
Every once in a while, the public will surprise a politician by recognizing their position as fundamentally irrational. It doesn’t happen often.  The problem now is that Rice’s new strategy, that the courts couldn’t be trusted to be as tough on crime as she is, makes no more sense than not prosecuting an admitted false rape accuser because it would dissuade true rape victims from coming forward.