Author Archives: SHG

The Silent Monday

Not to beat a dead horse too hard, but the story of Danmel Ndonye’s false gang rape accusation is nowhere to be found in today’s Newsday.  Before the qualifying “false” was added, it was one of the biggest stories in Nassau County, national in fact.  Now, silence.  The District Attorney’s trick worked well.

Given that there’s but one newspaper that covers Long Island, New York, and that one Newspaper ran a story about what District Attorney Rice’s opponent in the upcoming election that barely mentioned the opponent, and included little more than a snippet of what Joy Watson had to say, it seemed appropriate that someone provide both the forum for her thoughts as well as a reminder that the story may have died, but not the issue.

Joy posted a comment about the case and Kathleen Rice’s decision to let Ndonye have a free ride.  It appears here complete and uncensored through the filter of a reporter’s keyboard. 


I welcome this opportunity to spell out my reasons for outrage over the DA Rice’s failure to prosecute. The false allegation is indeed a crime. Failure to charge sends a message to those who make false allegations – if you lie, and in this case potentially sending young men to prison for 25 years, but are troubled, the DA will give you a pass from the criminal system. Why do we need judges? Why do we need police? Let the DA handle everything. And isn’t it fair to say that anyone who would falsely accuse someone of rape is troubled? Is the DA, by her conduct, suggesting anyone who makes such an allegation gets a pass??

More importantly, Rice’s decision downplays the impact on the lives of these young men and their families. They are the true victims of a false allegation motivated by a young woman unable to explain her whereabouts and condition to her boyfriend. The focus should stay on the criminal conduct, the only criminal conduct in this case, that of the false accuser.

To suggest that charging this woman would deter true victims of rape is illogical and wrong. The prosecution of false accusers will provide greater support to those who are true victims because the public will come to realize that false allegations will not be tolerated.

For Rice’s spokesman to categorize my reaction as “shoot first and ask questions later” is also illogical and ignores my 20 years as a Nassau prosecutor, handling Sex Offenses for over 7 of those years. While false allegations in Nassau might be new to Rice, I have handled such cases, resulting in arrests, exactly as I proposed in the media.

There could be an entire new thread about the expense to the taxpayers of this County caused by this false allegation, but that’s another story. As is Rice’s failure to mention that her office signed off on the charges before they were brought.

Without comment, Rice’s camp attacked my motives as political. I am proud to be a candidate for DA. The mishandling of this case is additional evidence of why I should be elected on November 3rd.
Given the importance of the race for District Attorney, coupled with the importance of the decision to let a person who accused five men of a rape that never happened go unprosecuted, people should know more than what the one organ on Long Island deigns to tell.  It should not quietly fade away over the weekend.

Today is Monday, Yom Kippur.  The Day of Atonement.  It’s a day to remember sins, not forget them.

Issue Joined on a Hofstra Sunday

It’s not that the Hofstra false rape case is the most important ever, but that the 5 o’clock Friday effort to bury the story over the weekend by Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice shouldn’t be allowed to succeed.  Whether you agree with the decision not to prosecute the false rape accuser or not, at least someone should know.

Given that Rice is up for election, which appears to be her primary motivation in the exercise of prosecutorial discretion, it’s only right that her opponent for the job be given her say. 


The candidate, Joy Watson, who headed sex-crime prosecutions under former District Attorney Denis Dillon, said the seriousness of the accusation and the impact on the accused men warranted a criminal prosecution.

“I certainly would have held her to the charge,” Watson said while campaigning in Westbury. “I would have charged her and let the probation department and the court make a determination as to the appropriate sentence.”

“If the system is going to say, ‘You’re troubled, so you’re not going to get charged,’ what kind of reverberations does that send through the entire judicial system?” asked Watson, who is running on the Republican and Conservative lines. Rice is a Democrat.

Well, I’m not quite sure what is meant by “reverberations”, and unfortunately Joy Watson doesn’t tell us.  Considering that she’s running for District Attorney, it would have been a better idea to tell us what she thinks rather than asking an obtuse rhetorical question.  One informs.  The other, well, doesn’t. 

This would have been an enormously significant opportunity for Joy Watson to stake out her position on what she would do as DA, particularly since she was once the bureau chief of sex-crimes in Nassau County.  While the false accusation isn’t a sex crime, the debate surrounding the decision to decline prosecution is all about sex crimes.  Who better to shine some light on the subject?  But she didn’t.

And Rice, not being shy, replies:



Rice spokesman Eric Phillips said the district attorney “got to the truth quickly, got four innocent guys out of jail and held their accuser accountable.” He called Watson “a candidate . . . whose political pandering has given us all an insight into her ‘Shoot first and ask questions later’ philosophy of justice.”
If one squandered opportunity is bad, two is worse.  What the heck is Eric Phillips talking about?  It makes no sense.  First, he ought to know that Rice should never raise the issue of political pandering, her being a carpet bagger brought in by Suozzi from Philadelphia to fill the slot on his ticket that would have otherwise gone to someone he really couldn’t stand.  And second, when it comes to political pandering, nothing can top what Rice has said about drunk driving, pandering in its purist form.

Then comes this “shoot first” quote.  You mean like Rice throwing four innocent men in jail for a rape that never happened?  There’s nothing about what Joy Watson’s said that bears any connection to that characterization.  Maybe he was caught without a decent quote at hand and did the best he could?

For reasons that should be clear to anyone, the elected District Attorney’s decision is one that she will be forced to live with, if anybody remembers it after her deft media handling.  For reasons that should similarly be clear to anyone, Rice’s opponent doesn’t appear to either have any clear vision of how and why discretion should be exercised either, or else her lack of experience in speaking with the media prevented her from making her position clear.

There is one additional possibility, though I hesitate to believe that it could be true.  Perhaps Joy Watson had something meaningful to say about the decision not to charge Danmel Ndonye, but Newsday, whether author or editor, decided to leave that part out of the story.  If so, I invite Joy Watson to let us know.  Of all the various possibilities, that would be the one that is most damaging.

Real Lawyers Eat Weenies

Few in the blawgosphere are willing to post anything that might offend anyone.  God forbid that a potential client or referral source is made to feel badly about himself, resulting in a loss of revenue to the writer.  “Well, he’ll never get a case from me!” 

There’s a name for such people, and Dan Hull at What About Clients? isn’t afraid to say it out loud.  They’re weenies.  They come from Generation Weenie.

What is Generation Weenie?



Being “just a copy” is outlawed. I just left Los Angeles, where it’s tough to offend anyone about anything. Like NYC, LA is not for everyone. No one cares what you think in either city. It’s wonderful. My take: both LA and NYC these days make even Chicago seem like an effeminate Alan Alda-land. PC and unoriginal thought are frowned upon in America’s two most important cities. LA and NYC tend to look down on Weenies. If you live somewhere else, try not to be a Weenie.

Frankly, I’ve been running into a lot of Weenies these days–from cultural liberals who keep surrounding themselves with no one but like-minded people, to religious educated white collars too afraid or too lazy to think anymore on their own, to “professionals” who always reserve the right to do third-rate work. They have this in common: they are highly emotional about keeping to their low aspirations and narrow views of the world.

They’ve stopped growing–and they are very happy with that, thank you very much. These people have children. It’s worrisome.
Yes, this covers a broad swathe of people.  While the Slackoisie, because of its narcissism, will likely think he’s writing about them, he’s not.  Generation Weenie is not about an age group but an attitude group.  Weenies come in all ages.  They even have a website about them, which comes with its own caveat: If it offends you, then you are a member of Generation Weenie.

Some people say that I’m mean.  Mike told me the other day that sometimes I’m a “dick” in some of my responses to comments.  One might suppose that was a weenie thing to say, but Mike’s no weenie.  He was just being accurate, and I took no offense.  The problem is that Generation Weenie is offended by anything that challenges its self-esteem and entitlement to be weenies. 

We even train young lawyers to be weenies.  Rather than toughen them up so they won’t cry in the courtroom the first time a judge doesn’t give them a trophy, they’re taught that totally wrong answers are just differently correct.  Law student weenies have no clue that they are weenies. Tell them that they are weenies and they will tell you that you are mean and bitter.   That way, they won’t have to face up to their weeniness, taking sanctuary within the bosom of their fellow members of Generation Weenie.

Generation Weenie supports its members, one coming to the aid of another to support and enable each to be a weenie.  They use words like “I feel” and “I believe” and “I am confident” as if the world was about their emotions.  When you prick one, they all bleed.  Then they all moan about it, sharing in the pain.

It’s much easier to be a member of Generation Weenie than to be your own person.  I wonder how many of you I’ve offended today?

A Case I’ve Never Tried

Over at Gamso For The Defense, Jeff Gamso tells of his experience representing a defendant in a capital case.  For anyone who doesn’t understand what “capital case” means, it’s the beloved death penalty. Lose big and the defendant is put to death.  If I read Jeff correctly, he didn’t try the case but either did the appeal or post-appellate work.  I’ve done nothing similar.

During the brief period that New York had a theoretical death penalty within the time frame of my practice, I’ve never represented a defendant in a capital case.  Thank God.  I’ve never wanted to.  I don’t want to.  Call me what you will, but I hope to never be in that position.  Never.

Jeff’s recounting of the experience sums it up.



And the family came up to me, not all of them and not together, but one at a time, his mother first. It was like a mantra as one after another said


You did all you could

Meaning it for comfort. Meaning that it was all that could be done. Meaning that some god had chosen and I should know that I’d tried my best and they appreciated that. And I said to each of them, “Thank you.” Because what else can you say. But you know, there’s no comfort in those words.

It’s not that they’re empty. They’re meant sincerely, the motive is pure and the sentiment is all positive. But that’s from the speaker.

At your end, when your client has just been murdered and you’ve been powerless to prevent it, the only answer is that if this is all I could do, then I’m not good enough. And if it wasn’t all I could have done, then I’m neither good enough nor diligent enough.


In my mind, every case I try is a capital case in the sense that I take it with the utmost seriousness.  Some clients think we see cases on a sliding scale of seriousness, with less consequential offenses sloughed off and more serious cases getting all the attention.  That’s not true.  Every case is treated like life or death; every trial is fought to be won.  Anything less is a personal disgrace, a surrender and a waste of time.  If you don’t try a case to win, you have no business trying cases at all.

But others become inured to losing.  The obvious example is the lawyer who sleeps during a capital case. It seems unimaginable.  Real lawyers agonize over trials and especially waiting for the verdict.  Jeff uses his experience to jump over to Norm Pattis’ writing about waiting, day after day, for his jury to return a verdict in a murder case.  Norm talks through the pain of waiting.


For days now, Norm Pattis has been agonizing on his blog ( here and here and here, for example) about the murder case he’s been trying.

As I say, I understand. All of us who’ve been there, understand. The cases are about the clients. But the agony is about us, too. Our adequacy, our skills, our competence.
Norm’s jury came back, guilty on a lesser and hung on the top counts. That means he gets to do it over again.  Jeff posts about the double jeopardy implications of this retrial, and reflects on how precedent justifies the illogic of giving the government multiple tries to convict despite the constitutional admonition that no person shall twice be put in jeopardy.  But that’s the law, and they’re sticking to it.

But what of Norm?  He’s pushing adrenaline through the roof waiting for the jury to utter the right words.  Hung beats guilty any day, but isn’t nearly as sweet as not guilty.  As soon as the words come out of the jury foreman’s mouth, your body deflates.  All the energy drains out of you.  You’re spent. 

The thought of retrial is horrible.  You o come to the first trial with an edge, psyched up to leap into the unknown, with your arsenal of weapons sharpened and a few up your sleeve that the other side knows nothing about.  The ability to shock and awe your adversary and her witnesses is the moment you live for.

Retrial is an entirely different story.  Norm says “there is no reason for the state to expect a better result next time,” but there is.  Next time, they will clean up, smooth out, the gaps and rough edges of their witnesses’ testimony.  There will be no surprises the second time around.  Transcripts of every word spoken will be typed and read, and reread.  The spontaneity of the first trial produces a genuiness of our arguments to the jury.  The second trial comes off as rehearsed, lacking the raw emotion that electrifies the first trial.

All this works to the prosecution’s advantage. The greatest benefit is that they has the witnesses, and the witnesses always testify better on the second try.  They’re still nervous on the stand, giving them the sense of authenticity, but have been well-schooled to avoid the pitfalls of the first trial. 

The defense, on the other hand, has used up all its surprises in the first trial, and has shown his skills to everyone in the courtroom.  Sure, some arguments can be better honed, and there are no surprises from the prosecution’s side either, But skill and surprise is a far more potent weapon for the defense than the prosecution.

My heart goes out to Norm, who has to hunker down and reach critical mass a second time to gear up for retrial.  Thankfully, even if the jury foreman fails to say the word “not” before “guilty”, he won’t have to hear the comforting words of the family of a client who has just been murdered by the state.

The Look From The Rear

It seemed like Anthony Arambula did everything right.  A man breaks into his Maricopa County home and runs into his son’s bedroom. He sends his wife and kids outside, then gets his gun out of the closet and holds the burglar at bay.  He calls 911.  But what happened after that wasn’t quite what he had in mind.

From Courthouse News :


Phoenix Police officers already in the neighborhood heard the crash of the Arambulas’ window. When they approached the house, Lesley says, she told Sgt. Sean Coutts that her husband was inside holding the intruder at gunpoint. Lesley says Coutts failed to pass on that information to the two other officers.
 
Inside the house, the Arambulas say, Officer Brian Lilly shot Anthony six times in the back while he was still on the phone with the 911 operator – twice when he was on the ground. 

The officers ran into the bedroom after Anthony told them, “You just killed … you just killed the homeowner. The bad guy is in there.”

Darn it.  Cops hate when that happens.  No, not because they pumped 6 bullets into the wrong guy, but because they could get in big trouble.  Cops hate getting into big trouble.

Tony Arambula didn’t die, however.  Instead, he sued.  In a rather interesting complaint, more along the lines of melodramatic chatting than legal description, one detail makes the cops’ efforts to cover up their mistake exceedingly difficult.  It seems that the 911 call was still being recorded as Lilly was busy shooting.  And still recording after he stopped and realized his mistake.


According to the complaint, Lilly can be heard on the 911 tape telling Coutts, “We fucked up.” 

Lilly says on the tape that he did not know where Anthony’s gun was when he shot him and that he “opened fire because he heard loud noises and saw someone who looked like he might be the ‘Hispanic’ male they were pursuing” before getting to the Arambulas’ house, according to the complaint.

But we all look like Hispanic males from the rear.

If things were bad after Lilly put six bullets into Tony, they got worse as the cops were left to figure out what to do about it.


Sgt. Coutts was quick to commence the cover-up of their terrible mistake. Sgt. Coutts asked Office Lilly where Tony’s gun was at the time Officer Lilly had opened fire on Tony. Officer Lilly admitted that he did not know where Tony’s gun was: ‘I don’t know. I heard screaming and I fired.'”

Lilly later told a police internal affairs investigator that Anthony had pointed his gun in his direction, “in the ‘ready’ position,” the complaint states. But Anthony Arambula says he was facing away from the officers, who could not have even seen his gun. 

The complaint continues: “Still not knowing that he is being recorded n the 911 tape, Sgt. Coutts interrupted Officer Lilly’s admission and apology with his assurance that the cover-up would commence: ‘That’s all right. Don’t worry about it. I got your back. … We clear?'”
And it goes on and on, with the cops dragging Tony Arambula outside the house by his shot leg onto gravel in the backyard, where he was put on display for his wife and children.  He was placed on the “hot hood” of the squad car and driven down the street writhing in pain. 

Later, they tried to get the gun dealer who sold Tony the weapon to go along with their pretense that the gun may have been illegal, but the dealer refused to play ball.  Then detectives tried to pin drug warrants on Tony from other states that he’s never been to, but the details didn’t match. 

It’s so much easier when you shoot the wrong guy and just put a throw-away in his hand to justify it. It’s harder when you shoot the homeowner.  And it’s really hard when the 911 recording catches it all.  And you thought it was easy to be a cop.

H/T Dissent.

We have met the enemy and he is us.

Read ‘Em And Weep

Over at the Volokh Conspiracy, a battle royale raged over whether legislators should be required to read bills before voting on them.  While no one suggests that legislators shouldn’t read bills, or that they shouldn’t have sufficient time to read bills before voting if they desire to do so, the argument is focused on whether the actual reading of a bill by the actual person voting on the bill should be mandated.

There are numerous posts on the subject already, and well worth the read.  But in response to Jonathon Adler and David Post, Eric Posner has offered a response to the imposition of a bill-reading mandate that incorporates some thoughts that go well beyond the topic at hand.


The argument fits a genre of populist rhetoric that claims that problems of governance can be solved with simple, common-sense rules, denying that political institutions are highly complex organizations that have evolved in response to needs and pressures, and that simple-sounding rules rarely do any good in complex settings.
We are constantly confronted with people who are fed up, and rightfully so, with the complexity of law, and who demand a simple solution to the law.  There’s always a simple solution, and it has such surface appeal that there is always support behind it arguing that we, lawyers, have made a horrific mess of things in our effort to overlawyer every iota of the human experience.  The snappy response is to quote H.L. Mencken, “For every complex problem, there is a solution that is simple, neat, and wrong.”

In the context of bills, there are two problems with the obvious “just read the frigging bill” position.  Much of what’s in a bill is technical stuff that isn’t substantive to the law proposed, and much of what’s in the bill requires a depth of knowledge on the internal subject of the bill that is beyond a legislator’s ken.  In other words, they would learn more about a bill from a trusted expert on the subject who has read the bill than by reading it themselves.  And yet, this still isn’t an excuse for not taking personal responsibility for the critical duty to know what you’re voting on.  After all, if your “trusted expert” is not to be trusted, or not so expert, then the legislator becomes a patsy.  That won’t do.

This problem could be alleviated if laws were written so as to be clear and comprehensible to an ordinary person of reasonable intelligence with a high school education, right?  Then, even a politician could understand them and would have some clue what he was voting on.  This is a core belief of those who contend that the law has become overly and needless prolix.

Orin Kerr, however, takes the wind out of their sails:


Complicated Karen: I’ve been thinking about how much privacy the law should give to private e-mails held by an ISP. A lot of people think e-mail should be protected by a warrant requirement. What do you think?
Clear Chris: I completely agree. I propose a simple rule: E-mail should be protected by a warrant.
Complicated Karen: Great. Now let’s start thinking about some exceptions. Imagine an Internet subscriber wants the ISP to disclose the contents of his e-mail. Maybe he has forgotten the password, or he needs an authenticated version. Should we have an exception for consent?
Clear Chris: Well, yes, of course. If the person really consents, then the government shouldn’t need a warrant. That’s obvious.
Complicated Karen: Great. What kind of standard would you choose for consent? Knowing? Knowing and voluntary? Intelligent? Is it consent in fact? Would you allow implied consent? And what about third party consent? How about business e-mail?
Clear Chris: Woah, that’s a lot of questions! I don’t really know, to be honest. I just want the exception to be clear so people can understand it.
Complicated Karen: Sure, I agree, clear is great. At the same time, we need to think about just what kind of consent you have in mind. Otherwise it will just punt the issue for the courts to make up the law later on. Moving along, what about an exception for emergencies? Should we have an emergency exception? For example what if the police tip off the ISP that the e-mail is being used by a kidnapper, and the government would need several hours or more to get a warrant. Should we allow emergency disclosure if the ISP wants to disclose?
Clear Chris: I don’t know, once we start getting exceptions, it seems like the exceptions are going to swallow the rule. But I’m not a nut; if there’s really a kidnapping, and the ISP is willing to disclose, I think an emergency exception for kidnapping is reasonable. But I want the exception limited to kidnapping.
Complicated Karen: How about terrorists attacks? Serial killers? Maybe we should craft a general exception for severe emergencies?
Clear Chris: I’ll have to think about that one; I’m pretty skeptical, but I’m not sure I would want to totally rule that out. Let’s come back to that one.
Complicated Karen: Sure. What about if the ISP is outside the U.S.? What then?
Clear Chris: Who has an e-mail account outside the U.S.?
Complicated Karen: A lot of people do, actually. Someone in the US might have an account with servers in Canada. And for that matter, someone in Paris might have a Gmail account in the U.S. Do you want to require a warrant for all of these cases?
Clear Chris: I’ve never thought about that one, I have to admit. But well, yeah, sure, let’s have a warrant requirement for those. I want a clear and simple rule, so let’s keep it clear and simple.
Complicated Karen: Sure, that’s fine. But to do that, we’re going to modify some other laws. Under current U.S. law, U.S. officials can’t get a warrant for overseas: warrants are traditionally for U.S. use only. And how do you want to create U.S. jurisdiction over crimes occurring abroad? If a person commits a crime in France, that can’t authorize a U.S. warrant under U.S. law. We either need to negotiate a treaty with the French government to handle that, or else we can say that French crimes committed in France are U.S. crimes, too, allowing warrants to be issued in the U.S.
Clear Chris: Yikes, are you nuts? Suddenly you’re talking about the treaties and French law, and all I wanted to do was have a simple rule! You keep trying to make things complicated. Why not just make it simple?
Complicated Karen: I’m trying to keep it simple, actually. But to make the law what you want it to be, you need to think about these issues: Otherwise you’ll announce a simple rule but it won’t have any legal effect because of other aspects of existing law.
Clear Chris: Lawyers! You guys always like to make things complicated; No wonder you bill by the hour.

As he concludes, it’s not that clear and concise laws aren’t a good thing and a goal, but that there are competing interests between clarity and comprehensiveness that must be satisfied.  This isn’t to say that we don’t have bad, overly prolix, incomprehensible laws, or that every law needs to be as lengthy and painful to read as it is.  No one suggests that Washington is doing a bang up job on drafting legislation.  But that the cure could be worse than the disease.

And, of course, none of this alters one basic principle that shouldn’t get lost in the sauce. No bill should sail through so quickly that any legislator who wants to read, digest, comprehend it is not given the opportunity to do so.  Like, oh, what happened with the USA Patriot Act.

False Advertising: The Norm For The Future?

Amongst the many things that come across my email are “press releases” announcing wondrous things of little consequence.  One such release was about a new website called New York Criminal Defense Lawyer.  It caught my eye.


New York Criminal Defense Lawyer is an industry leader in legal law information for the state of New York and their website expansion marks a recent growth pattern for this popular website.

An industry leader is quite a claim for a website whose existence is maybe 12 minutes old.  But hyperbole is like breathing to flacks, so it’s hard to let silly things like that put you off.  But if this site offers “legal law” information specifically directed toward New York criminal defense, it’s something I ought to know about.  So I checked it out.

Not surprisingly, it was a sham. As it turned out, it was the website for Rachel Kugel, a lawyer whose name I had never before heard.  I should have stopped there, but I didn’t.  I couldn’t help but wonder who she was, given how audacious her website and claims were.  Aside from Alexis Neely, who bills herself as “Americas Favorite Lawyer” despite her positioning as the Mother Teresa of legal marketing, this was as bold, if nonsensical, a marketing effort as I had seen.

Near as I can tell, this former Cardozo Law student was admitted in 2005 in New York and New Jersey, where she does drunk driving cases.  Since then, her claim to fame is appearances on Fox News and Court TV, where a nice looking young woman is always appreciated. 


Rachel took this passion and continued it during law school at Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law in New York City. There she was selected to work on cases at the Innocence Project, devoted to exonerating the wrongly convicted through DNA evidence. She also worked on cases through the Criminal Defense Clinic and garnered an internship with the Legal Aid Society Criminal Defense Division in Manhattan.

Rachel then worked for a well known medical malpractice law firm also in Manhattan. Through her experience with criminal defense work and then her work on cases involving medical and scientific evidence she began to combine her skills and work on criminal matters that involve these issues.

Rachel continues to hone and sharpen her skills attending continuing education classes on DUI defense and medical and scientific issues all over the country. She is also very active in the community fighting for fair treatment of the accused and prisoner’s rights.

Rachel is in private practice in Newark, New Jersey, is admitted to the State Bar of New Jersey and is a member of the American Trial Lawyers Association.


So she had some exposure during law school, and after a stint with a med mal firm, she’s trying to break into criminal defense.  Good for her.  There are some funny aspects to her website, particularly the “fees” page, which says



However, most cases are relatively simple for an experienced defense attorney like myself. I know exactly what to expect in court, and I can quickly size up your case, and quote you a fee during a free phone consultation.

And she takes credit cards, which makes a quickie plea that much faster.

But then came the curious part.  It wasn’t just a matter of enjoying some TV talking and a desire to become a lawyer that drove her to these marketing extremes. it turns out that she is a Marketing Expert!


Hi! It’s Rachel Kugel, Esq., the Million Dollar Practice Designer! I am so glad you found this site. Everything you need to take your law practice to the next level is here. Design the law practice, and life, of your dreams…..read on…..



“REVEALED:  3 SIMPLE STRATEGIES THAT CAN DOUBLE YOUR LAW PRACTICE INCOME! GET MORE PROSPECTS TO RETAIN YOU, EVEN WHILE YOU INCREASE YOUR FEES.”


Now hyperbole is one thing, but “the Million Dollar Practice Designer?”  Come on.  But there was more.



“Give Me 60 Minutes and I will Show you How I Started Closing 90% of Prospects, and Doubling My Fees All Without Going In To The Office”



Dear Friend:



Hi, I’m Rachel Kugel, lawyer and entrepreneur. I am finally ready to reveal the secret of how I went from struggling solo lawyer to the owner of s thriving law practice that makes me all the money I need and then some while still leaving me the time and freedom to actually enjoy my life…..a feat I once thought was impossible in the practice of law.
How does this nice, young lawyer go from budding DUI lawyer to marketing guru.  What is it that drives this shameless pretense?  Obviously money, but is there no end to the absolute garbage that has permeated both the internet and the minds of young lawyers?  For those of you who take umbrage at my castigating the legal marketers, pretending the “everybody does it so I have to do it too,” how does this one square with your self-serving rationalizations?

For all I know, I may have trained this young lady at the Cardozo ITAP program, where I teach trial practice.  For all I know, she may be very nice, very dedicated and very hardworking.  For all I know, her interest in criminal defense may be sincere.  But none of that matters given how she’s sought to promote herself in this disgraceful way.

This seems to be more than just a growing trend amongst young lawyers, but a pervasive belief that they are entitled to craft a false persona, spread it far and wide, for the purpose of self-promotion.  This is the road to success.  This is the future of law as far as they are concerned.  And if it doesn’t stop, lawyers will drown in a pool of putrid deception.

The only message that young lawyers hear is that marketing, marketing, marketing, is what makes a lawyer. What message are you sending?

Correction: I have been informed that I have incorrectly used the phrase “America’s Favorite Lawyer” with regard to Alexis Neely. In fact, it is “America’s Favorite Lawyer™, ” as she has registered the trademark.  My bad.

Not Every Nurse Loves Cops

When the story broke about the forced catheterization of a suspected drunk driver, whose blood and breath just wasn’t cooperating, the question arose as to why healthcare professionals were so compliant with police demands.  We now have an answer, courtesy of Chicago Nurse Lisa Hofstra.


Lisa Hofstra was the nurse in charge of the emergency room at Illinois Masonic about 4 a.m. on Aug. 1 when she said an officer named Rodriguez asked her to take blood samples from a man to determine his blood-alcohol level, according to a lawsuit filed in federal court. Hofstra allegedly told the officer the man had to become a patient first and she wanted to consult with her supervisor.

The officer cuffed her and placed her in the back of a squad car, according to the lawsuit.
The question wasn’t compliance with the officer’s demand, but timing.  He wanted it now. She refused to jump.  What makes this particularly unusual is that cops and emergency room personnel work together regularly, and usually have a strong bond.  But Lisa Hofstra didn’t feel the love as she was held captive by Officer Rodriguez (first name unknown).

 
 The question raised is whether the cop was simply so taken by his omnipotence that Nurse Hofstra’s failure to jump upon demand outraged him to the point of seizure, or whether there was some other factor at work.  Chicago’s own Mark Draughn, the  WindyPundit, isn’t buying that this was merely the refusal to draw blood upon demand, but speculates that Lisa Hofstra did more.


I don’t know any more than this, but clearly something crazy happened here. What kind of nutball cop disrupts the operation of a hospital emergency room by dragging away the triage nurse for no good reason?

There seems to be something missing from this story, however. I doubt that even the craziest nutball cops do things like this (very often) to people who are courteous and polite. My guess is that Nurse Hofstra “mouthed off” or committed some other imagined offense that cops like to interpret as a crime. Triage nurses have to be decisive and firm with demanding people, so perhaps she was a bit brusque in her dealings with officer Rodriguez.
Mark may be right, particularly given his qualified statement that it could be some “imagined offense that cops like to interpret as a crime.”  That’s a hole big enough to drive a Mack truck through.  But I see no reason to speculate.  After all, the cop walked into Nurse Hofstra’s home making demands, not the other way around.  Her demeanor wasn’t in issue as she gets to behave any darn way she wants in her emergency room.

The problem is that the power to seize is unchecked on the street.  Sure, it is subject to review afterward, but there was no one in that ER equipped to put a stop to Officer Rodriguez’s insanity.  What if patients died awaiting care?  No doubt Officer Rodriguez had more important concerns on his mind, like proving the driver he stopped was drunk than to consider the ramifications of his exertion of authoritah.

Given the generally cooperative nature of police and healthcare workers in the ER, it’s likely that Rodriguez’s expectation was that his request, which turned immediately into a command upon Lisa Hofstra’s failure to immediately accede, would be performed then and there.  This points not to the problem of medical priorities, or medical ethics, or even the cooperation between ER personnel and cops, but to the inability to stop a cop from doing whatever he, in his fit of pique, chooses, even if that means he gets to hold a charge nurse hostage until a hospital ER bows to his will.

Of course, it’s just another isolated incident.

H/T Turley

Pottawamie and the Shaking Prosecutor Syndrome

The Supremes will soon hear oral argument in a case that few Americans would believe could arise today, yet reflects the ugliest underbelly of the failure of the criminal justice system, Pottawamie v. McGhee.

The facts are that prosecutors, faced with the notorious shotgun death of a white former police captain, John Schweer, who was working as a security guard in the early morning of July 22, 1977, needed to convicted the “perpetrators” of this heinous crime.  What they did next was unthinkable.  From the District Court opinion:


In essence, each of the asserted claims allege that the prosecutors Hrvol, Richter, and Wilber improperly concealed exculpatory evidence; concealed the alleged coercion of witnesses; participated in court proceedings; coerced witnesses; participated in the Schweer murder investigation; and conspired with the respective police defendants to commit the alleged misdeeds against the Plaintiffs.

The criminal defendants spent the next few decades in prison.  The question now arises from a 1983 action against those who conspired to engage in the big three wrongs that prosecutors can commit: conceal exculpatory evidence, coerce evidence, manufacture inculpatory evidence. Despite doing so, are prosecutors due absolute immunity (like judges and witnesses), qualified immunity (like police), or no immunity at all?

Over at Crime & Federalism, Mike parses the Department of Justice amicus brief, which argues that the “solution” to prosecutorial wrongdoing isn’t liability to those harmed under Section 1983,   Here’s the DOJ solution:


If the allegations here are true, petitioners engaged in prosecutorial misconduct of an execrable sort, involving a complete breach of the public trust. But absolute immunity reflects a policy judgment that such conduct is properly addressed not through civil liability, but through a host of other deterrents and punishments, including judicial oversight of criminal trials, and criminal and professional disciplinary proceedings against prosecutors. 

What is most extraordinary about this argument is that the institutions upon which DOJ would rely are the ones that failed entirely in this case, both to protect beforehand and to redress afterward.  As one might expect from the government, its answer is to trust it to clean up its own mess.  No need for its victims to get their hands dirty. No need for the victims to be compensated for the 25 years lost.

Another brief, however, from a group called Black Cops Against Police Brutality, tells a very different story.  Drug & Device Law, Mark Herrmann, and provides an exceptional overview of the historical failure and perversion of the criminal justice system in the wrongs done blacks.  As Mark ably demonstrates, the problem isn’t merely an historic relic, a trip down memory lane to Scottsboro, but a problem that continues to this day, our facile beliefs to the contrary notwithstanding.



We can imagine few rulings of this Court that would send a more negative message about American criminal justice than to permit white prosecutors to frame African-American suspects for the murder of a white police officer, admit the outrage, and then walk away with impunity, after their victims have wrongfully suffered twenty-five years in prison.

The BCAPB brief argues that prosecutors should be afforded only qualified immunity rather than absolute immunity, eschewing the no immunity position.  It derides the Pottawamie argument that without absolute immunity for prosecutors to engage in flagrantly outrageous wrongs, that prosecutors will be too afraid of liability to perform their jobs.


The Justice Department’s picture of government lawyers quaking in their wingtips lest the pursuit of criminals subject them to amages is demonstrably false.

Mark then runs through the reality of indemnification, an unfortunate fact that shifts the burden of liability for the wrongdoing off the prosecutors and onto the taxpayers.  But the more pointed argument is that police, despite receiving only qualified immunity, somehow manage to do their job, even to the extent of dying in its performance, despite this.  There is no equivalent Shaking Cop Syndrome.

From a policy perspective, offering absolute liability provides no incentive to prosecutors, or the governments for which they work, to avoid deliberate and intentional violations of constitutional rights.  The DOJ claim, that the government can police itself, thank you very much, is laughable.  It just doesn’t happen, and has never happened, even though it might seem in theory like a satisfactory solution to someone who believes in unicorns or the “new professionalism” of police.

Mark goes on to argue that the government’s “fear” of a tidal wave of suits against prosecutors is illusory.



Under Buckley’s functional test, much prosecutorial conduct is still covered by the absolute immunity standard. The volume of cases in which prosecutors play a significant enough role in pretrial investigation to be subject to even frivolous allegations under a qualified immunity standard is much smaller than the number of cases in which the police are vulnerable to suit.
Which raises the bottom line question for BCAPB: Why should prosecutors be held to a lower standard than police?  One might suspect, perhaps even desire, a higher standard of integrity from lawyers who fulfill the governmental function of prosecuting citizens.  Would that be too much to expect?

Kudos to Mark Hermann for an excellent brief, and for being there to fulfill the critical function of representing amicus curiae in this case.  He’s made this fellow curmudgeon proud.

Naked Marketer Mudwrestling: Bodine v. O’Keefe

The issue has been joined.  Larry Bodine raised quite a ruckus when he concluded that twitter was a marketing waste.  He then compounded the challenge when he reiterated his views at Law.Com’s Legal Technology page.  It was more than Kevin O’Keefe could stand, and his head exploded all over the front page of Real Lawyer Have Blogs. 

Bodine’s post is directed at the areas he considers most fruitful for those who prefer to walk the streets in hotpants.



You could hear the collective groan when Twitter made the cover of Time magazine and marketers realized that they had to become familiar with yet another online medium. There’s Facebook, MySpace, Naymz, Spoke, Plaxo, LinkedIn, Martindale Connected, Legal OnRamp, JD Supra and listservs, to name a few online social networks. It seems overwhelming.

The good news is that marketers and lawyers can ignore most of them.
Or lawyers can ignore marketers, but that’s just my two cents.  Larry then launches into his “things to ignore” mode.


• Begin by eliminating the time-wasters — and in my opinion, the primary example is Twitter. Consider this. A new study by Pear Analytics found that: 40 percent of the tweets on Twitter were “total pointless babble.”


• 10 percent of Twitter users account for over 90 percent of tweets, according to Harvard Business School.


• Among people with a Twitter account, 60 percent drop out after one month and never come back, according to Neilsen Wire.


• 55 percent have never posted a tweet, according to HubSpot.com.


This is where things get dicey.  It’s not really about loving or hating twitter, but where to effectively market.  Every 12 seconds, a new site opens that proclaims itself to be the “industry leader,” a curious claim given that the totality of their existence is 12 seconds.  But hey, we’re talking marketing here so there’s no room for truth or accuracy.

Lexblog’s Kevin O’Keefe is an unabashed cheerleader of twitter.  He loves it.  He believes in it. He promotes it with a vigor that most men reserve for marital bliss.  Maybe even more vigor than that.


The first third of the article went way out of its way to belittle the power of Twitter as a relationship building and networking tool. This should comes as no surprise as the author of the article is making a name for himself in bashing twitter.

Based on the results I am hearing lawyers are getting by building relationships through Twitter, and getting clients as a result, I am beginning to think that Twitter offers the highest ROI of any networking/relationship building tool.

I suppose if Legal Technology News were around in the days of Alexander Graham Bell, they’d be siding with the lawyers who thought a lawyer’s use of a phone in rendering legal services was clearly unprofessional and, of course, unethical. A small group of radical lawyers decided to use the phone, probably for perceived mindless babble.

Smack.  The only thing missing from Kevin’s retort is “Bodine, you ignorant slut.”  But what really riled him up isn’t Bodine’s position, but that it appeared on the Legal Technology page of Law.com.


Perhaps I shouldn’t get worked up about misguided advice from someone who I don’t believe understands Twitter, but Legal Technology News decided to the run the story. A story that will passed around by managing partners and chief marketing officers clinging to the past. A story that will needlessly keep the legal profession lagging behind the industries, corporations, and consumers we serve. That’s a disservice to the American lawyer.

A disservice to the American lawyer?  Well, that may be a stretch, considering the entirety of marketing is a disservice to the American lawyer, including turning twitter into part of the vast cesspool of legal marketing.  But again, that’s just my two cents.

Enter Monica Bay at the Common Scold, who also happens to be the editor of Law Technology News for ALM.  Monica jumped into the middle (fully clothed, however), with this:


Oh please.

 1. For starters, get your facts right, Kevin: This article never ran in Law Technology News.  It did, however, run in an ALM newsletter, and was picked up on Law.com’s Legal Technology site. 


2. Larry Bodine (who Kevin declines to ID in his post) is a member of the LTN Editorial Advisory Board, and often writes controversial articles that get everybody talking and thinking. This is a good thing.


3. As for whether LTN — or any other ALM entity — should have run the article: The last time I checked, LTN (and ALM) readers [lawyers, IT professionals, paralegals, GC, vendors, et al] are smart, savvy, and like to debate.


Nothing like patting yourself (and your readers) on the back a bit, there, while just a tad overly defensive.  I sure hope you didn’t hurt anything with that extended reach.


In fact, I WANT all points of view in LTN, because that’s how we best serve the entire spectrum of our wonderful legal community.

That’s why I choose a wide array of articles (and opinions). And why I regularly participate in panels discussing important technology trends and issues. Oh yeah, btw, O’Keefe participated on two recent ALM panels that I moderated, talking about how lawyers can use Twitter (LegalTech NY 09 and LegalTech West Coast 09).
All points of view includes Kevin’s throw down to Larry, who didn’t ask for any help in fighting off the forces of O’Keefe.  Larry’s stance is clearly controversial in the face of the many voices trying to make a buck off lawyers and twitter, or the techno-lawyer-cheerleaders who have enough free time on their hands to travel from conference to conference proclaiming how twitter built them a huge law practice, and how for a very reasonable fee they can do the same for yours.

For observers of this intramural war, this is hugely amusing.  I’ve come to enjoy twitter, which grows on you (fungus analogy intended) provided you don’t get caught up in the whole follower number deal. There is no prize, by the way, for the lawyer with the most followers.Like Kevin, I’ve heard of some lawyers who claim to be making millions off twitter, though their claims seem entirely contingent on a couple of anomalous factors.  The first  is that they are in a very narrow niche practice in a peculiar place, where lawyers around the country need to find someone to meet unusual criteria and aren’t too picky when it comes to the competence of the lawyers to whom they refer cases.  Twitter thus serves as an alternative way of finding the oddballs.

The other factor is that twitter, at 140 characters, prevents lawyers from coming off too stupid.  There’s only so much stupidity one can fit into a twit.  Blog posts, on the other hand, have enormous capacity for proving that a lawyer is an idiot.  Even a half-witted lawyer can feign a modicum of competence by merely retwitting articles within his niche, thus completely concealing any glaring gap by living off the work of others.  These lawyers are the remoras free-riding on the backs of sharks.

But there are more “lawyers” who think their futures are bound in becoming social media experts, and twitter is an opportunity for them to rake in the dough by teaching lawyers who are incapable of figuring out how to market themselves in 140 characters. 

Personally, I hope Larry Bodine wins the day, not because I believe that he’s right (though I do) but for purely selfish reasons.  Wouldn’t it be really nice if there was one online street where you didn’t have to dodge the girls in hotpants asking if you want to go on a date?