Author Archives: SHG

The Hofstra DA Goes To School (Update)

I’ve been reluctant to post about the Hofstra rape case, or rather the Hofstra false rape case, because the scenery has changed with far greater speed than a car passing by on the Long Island Expressway.  It’s swiftly gone from cops announcing their guilty 5, raping a girl in a bathroom lured their by someone taking her cellphone, to one of the evil males taping consensual sex on his cellphone.

The false accuser, confronted with news of the video, spills her lies. and suddenly the world turns 180 degrees. The debate now shifts to whether the accuser should be publicly named and prosecuted.  The dilemma has been well noted by Emily Bazelon, who has since been called out by Glenn Reynolds for her failure to name the perpetrator of the false rape claim, Danmell Ndonye.  And Ann Althouse thinks it’s time for women to grow up and take responsibility for their sexual conduct, Ndonye crying rape to avoid being thought of as a slut.

Big issue punditry aside, there’s an actual decision to be made here, and there’s been no focus on the fact that the local District Attorney, Kathleen Rice, has yet to make that issue.  Granted, she Nifong’ed herself at the start, jumping aboard the guilty bandwagon as quickly as she could, and jumped off even more quickly hoping nobody would notice.  But Rice, who has set up her political fortunes as an avenging DA, has yet to do the one thing that district attorneys are charged to do.  Decide to prosecute.

A  Newsday article by Ann Givens purports to lay out the considerations that Kathleen Rice is weighing in her decision of whether to charge Ndonye.


On the one hand, they will want to discourage people from lying to law enforcement, and show that there will be consequences for doing so, experts said. On the other, they don’t want to discourage legitimate rape victims from coming forward, or discourage people who lied at first from telling the truth later on, experts said.

This explanation is quite amazing for missing the point on both sides of the issue.  The perpetrator did not merely lie to law enforcement.  Martha Stewart lied to law enforcement.  This woman falsely accused 5 men of rape, for which they were arrested, incarcerated and had their names and images spread far and wide as rapists.  She importuned law enforcement, always happy to nail 5 black men for sexual deviance, by alleging what she knew to be heinous conduct, and all to cover up her own conduct, her shame of being thought of as a slut who willingly chose to engage in sex in a bathroom with 5 men.

And the flip side of the thought process is even less valid.  A false rape accuser does nothing to inhibit a true rape victim from coming forward.  There’s nothing similar about the situations,  True victims have no fear of a video revealing them to be a liar.  True victims have no fear of being exposed as a fraud and criminal. 



Lois Schwaeber, director of legal services for the Nassau County Coalition Against Domestic Violence, said cases where people make false reports of rape hurt all legitimate rape victims seeking justice. But she said prosecuting someone who has made a false report will discourage real rape victims from coming forward as well.

“They may feel that if they can’t support the charges they are making with enough proof, they could be charged.”

Perhaps she didn’t notice that part where Ndonye admitted that she fabricated the rape.  What does a false accuser have to do with a real victim?  Or do these lines not exist when it comes to such claims?

Nor does the secondary rationale hold water.  Ndonye didn’t tell the truth because she had a sudden flash of conscience about the crime she committed and the harm she had done.  She cracked because she was confronted with the fact that she was a liar.  You want an incentive to tell the truth?  Videotape your sexual encounters.

Of course, had the sequence of events been slightly different, and it was revealed that one of the five men in the bathroom had taped the encounter before Ndonye lied, the papers would have had a different lede.  Taking photos of bathroom sex is certainly lurid enough to be worth a story.

This all amounts to a flag being run up the pole to see who salutes.  Rice is up for re-election, and opposed by a legitimate and well respected contender for the post, Joy Watson.  She doesn’t know which  direction will get her the most votes, and the least criticism.  There’s a huge risk for Rice in charging Ndonye with a crime, as shown by the way Newsday has framed the considerations.  Rice doesn’t want domestic violence and rape advocates to jump down her throat for discouraging real victims.

But Rice knows that a crime has been committed.  Rice has the evidence to prove her case.

Rape is a heinous crime, and Rice was all too happy to make sure the charges against the “rapists” were broadcast far and wide.  When she ended up on the wrong end of the story, though, she never apologized to the five men who she put in jail because of the false allegations.  And now she tests the waters to keep her political hands clean for her failure to charge the source of these heinous false allegations. 

As interesting as the thoughts of pundits on the subject might be, the real decision sits in Kathleen Rice’s hands.  The decision won’t be made because of right and wrong, crime or no crime, the effect on real rape victims.  The decision will be made on what will make her constituents want to re-elect her and what she can get away with.  If this wasn’t true, the decision would be a no-brainer.

Update:  At 5 pm on a Friday, Nassau DA Kathleen Rice announces that she won’t prosecute Ndonye, the false rape accuer.  That’s how one buries a story so it’s lost over the weekend and never heard from again.  Coincidence?

Tased For Being Disabled While Black

As Jeff Hoard at True/Slant says, “[e]ach time I think there is no way there can be a more outrageous incident,” another comes along to prove him wrong.  Today’s involves Gregory Williams, a double amputee in Merced, California, who was tased twice, apparently for his lack of cooperation in allowing cops to push him out of his wheel chair so that he could crack his head open on the ground. 

And then there was the humiliation :



Even worse for him, Williams says he was publicly humiliated after his pants fell down during the incident. The officers allegedly left him outdoors in broad daylight, handcuffed on the pavement, nude below the waist. Williams said the arrest also left him with an injured shoulder, limiting his mobility in his wheelchair.
And then there was the six days in jail without being charged.  At least prosecutors decided not to be complicit.  But what was the point of pulling his pants down and exposing him publicly?  Were they trying to see whether he was hiding a pair of legs somewhere?


Jeff Hoard is right.  When you think it can’t get any worse, the cops keep proving you wrong.  I wonder what will top this one? I can’t imagine, but that’s just a product of my not having the capacity to see the world through the eyes of a police officer.

The Downside of Client Reviews

It’s unclear why it just came to light, or how it managed to get through the review process, but one lawyer on Avvo received an anonymous review by a purported client, and it wasn’t pretty.  Since it’s likely that the review will be removed soon, after having been up for about a month at this point, here’s what was said:




Good but fishy

Posted by: anonymous, 2009-08-03 about 1 month ago.




  • I do not recommend [attorney].


  • I used [attorney] 1-6 months ago.


  • [Attorney] handled my Insurance matter.


  • I have previously worked with 1-2 lawyers.

Client Review:

She responded to me promptly, but when it came down to getting the case filed in court she was not there for me as initially promised. She lied about the reasoning for not wanting to help me and this made me think twice about her as a lawyer!
There is now a long list of lawyers flagging this comment as wrong, primarily on the basis that the reviewer was anonymous, precluding the lawyer from responding, or even knowing which client was dissatisfied.  Obviously, I’ve eliminated the lawyer’s name from this post since there’s no way to know whether this complaint was legitimate or some variation on the Andy Nolen astroturfing scheme.

The problem posed is what to do about negative reviews.  Clearly, the entire point of reviews is lost if only positive ones can be offered.  So much for the claim of providing useful information for consumers when it’s only one-sided.  But then, it’s hardly a stretch to understand why a dissatisfied client would want to post a negative review anonymously.  Wars have been fought on the internet over anonymous posting and commenting, from the neo-Publius to the no-weenies to the Ned Beatty Rule.  Each position has its merits.

This situation defies solution.  It doesn’t matter what frilly words are used to describe the wonders of client reviews, or the wonderful benefits it offers the consumers of legal services.  It is inherently flawed, and this is why.  If only positive reviews are posted, then it’s not only unhelpful to consumers, but misleading.  But if clients can’t review lawyers anonymously, then it will have a significant chilling effect on negative reviews, and it’s completely understandable why people don’t want to identify themselves when calling out a bad lawyer.

The benefits of the concept is easy to understand.  Law consumers would have a resource to use to determine whether the lawyer behind the smile lives up to his rap.  The detriments are also easy to understand, and aside from the illegitimate complaints and the astroturfing, there remains the fear that clients will review a lawyer poorly because of dissatisfaction with the outcome of a case, refusing to recognize that lawyers aren’t plumbers and can’t guarantee that they’ve fixed the leak.  Let’s face it, clients aren’t concerned with the effort or the process, but the result.  That’s a fact of life for lawyers.

I was asked yesterday if I was for or against anonymous reviews.  Neither is my response.  I don’t think the system can work. The good intentions of Avvo aside, it is an inherently flawed concept that at best misleads and at worst wrongly harms.

Jericho Catches Fire

When last we visited Jericho, Arkansas, a police officer shot the assistant fire chief in the back inside the courtroom.  A story this ridiculous demands an update.  And I’m here to oblige.  But it’s not likely to be what you expect.


Don Payne says he was shot in the back by a Jericho police officer over two weeks ago now. He says he was planning on getting back to work as soon possible, until he received a termination letter from the mayor. “As it comes to my attention of the improper behavior that you displayed as the assistant fire chief of the town of Jericho”: Those are the words of Jericho mayor Helen Adams to Don Payne.

This would be the improper behavior of using his back to stop the travel of a bullet.  A waste of government resources perhaps?  Mayor Helen thereupon relieved Payne of his fire chief duties.  He was fired from his volunteer job because he was shot.

As you will recall, the police chief decided to disband the police force “until things calmed down.”  After all, you wouldn’t want to have a police force in an uncalm town of 174 people.  But even small towns can burn.



All of Jericho’s 18 firefighters have quit in a move to stand by a former assistant fire chief who was shot by an officer at city hall on Aug. 27 and then fired by the mayor last week, according to WREG-TV.

Remarkably, there’s no information about the cop who shot Don Payne in the back in the Jericho town courtroom.  It’s unclear whether the Mayor really loves the cops or really hates the fire department, but for the time being, Jericho’s got neither.




The Loser Is Always Right

As much as I toy with the heartstrings of marketers, there’s one who usually manages to stay one up on me, marketing genius and philosopher, Seth Godin.  If only the people I do business with paid attention to him. If only.


Given the choice between acknowledging that your customer is upset or proving to her that she is wrong, which will you choose?

You can be right or you can have empathy.

You can’t do both.

It’s bad enough that the only voice you can get on the phone when you have a problem is one that speaks broken English in a thick accent.  You know they have a script, and that they can’t do anything that’s not on the script.  You know they are going to mouth the words that they are very sorry for your problem, and then read the portion of the script that explains why it isn’t their fault.  If there is no script for that particular problem, then they are going to say that it’s their policy not to be able to do anything to help.  And they will close by asking if there is anything else they can do for you.  Else?



It’s not the nature of capitalism to need to teach people a lesson, it’s the nature of being a human, we just blame it on capitalism. In fact, smart marketers understand that the word ‘right’ in “The customer is always right” doesn’t mean that they’d win in court or a debate. It means, “If you want the customer to remain a customer, you need to permit him to believe he’s right.”

If someone thinks they’re unhappy, then you know what? They are.
If it was an option, I wouldn’t buy anything from anyone.  I wouldn’t use anyone’s services.  It would save me from dialing the 800 number of death.  But given my limited skillset, I need to buy things.  Despite the wind blowing in my face, I spit when something goes wrong. 

My personal preference is to get an honest response.  I’m a sucker for truth.  When the customer service rep tells me that they get a ton of calls because their product sucks, or it’s their company policy to gouge the customer at every turn, I can appreciate that.  I don’t like it, but at least my question is answered. 

But when I contact a small business, where the actual owner, or maybe the owner’s husband, gets on the phone, there’s no company policy to hide behind.  These are the ones who take problems personally, and are most inclined to argue the point.  As Seth points out, however, it’s really not an argument at all.  They want to prove to me that they didn’t do anything wrong.  I still have a problem. 

Sometimes, the owner will walk me through a process which, by its end, will show me where I went wrong.  This is not done to prove that they’re right and I’m wrong, but to resolve my problem by educating me.  Sometimes I am wrong, and by doing it right the product or service issue can be corrected.  That’s all I want.

But more often, the reaction is defensiveness, telling me that I don’t have a valid issue or that my problem simply can’t be.  There’s nothing more absurd than my sitting by the phone, broken widget in hand, being told that the widget can’t break.  If it’s a one shot purchase and they want to guarantee that I will never do business with them again, this tactic is perfect.  Of course, they also guarantee that I will let anyone I speak with, who might be interested in their widget, not to buy from them.  If it’s valuable enough, I might sue them.  If it’s socially important, I might write about it.  If they piss me off enough, I might do both. 

But I won’t buy from them again.  They’re right and I’m gone. Cause and effect.

After a conversation yesterday with a Cablevision CSR about the charge on my bill for a cable box that I never wanted but that they insisted I take unless I was prepared to forego receiving the channels I was otherwise paying for, I wondered whether the cost of acquisition of a customer was worth the cost of retention.  The price involved was $6.75, not enough to go through hoops but, in conjunction with the other aspects of Cablevision that make the hate personal, enough to make me call Verizon FIOS.  They already drove me to FIOS for my internet connection, and cable TV was their last foothold in my house.

The fellow on the phone told me that no way, no how, was Cablevision going to give me the box for free, or give me all the channels I was paying for without the box.  I asked whether it was worth it to Cablevision to lose me as a customer.  He told me it was. 

In a couple of weeks, I’ll get a call from a salesperson for Cablevision begging me to “come back.”  This will happen too late to matter, since by then I will be happily ensconced in the FIOS family plan.  They should know this, but still they will offer me some deal that will give me far more than I sought during my call yesterday.  I will tell them that it’s a shame they didn’t offer me the deal before I left them.

Why, if you want me to purchase your goods or services, if you advertise, if you run promotions, if you solicit my business, would you want to make me hate you by proving you’re right when I have a problem?  Yet so many do.

15 Minute Lawyer Meets Uncle Fred

The only thing wrong with communism is that human nature got in the way.  It’s not that Marx and Hegel didn’t have a good idea, but that they assumed something about people that was unjustified.  They assumed that people would be kind enough to each other to go with it.  History proved them wrong.

John Kindley, a young lawyer with some very strong libertarian political beliefs, took to the soapbox to challenge my assertion that many of the problems we face in the legal profession are due to a surplus of lawyers.  His solution was to eliminate the barriers to entry.


The solution, contra Greenfield, is not to raise the barriers to entry, but to lower them drastically, by eliminating the artificial costs of becoming a lawyer and the artificial attractiveness and expectations of the legal profession associated with those costs.

Why are so many attracted to the law, leading to our society’s production of so many (some would say too many) lawyers? A major reason is that the lawyer still has a privileged and vaunted status in society, akin to that of doctors, while the 3 year law degree is far more do-able for more people than the education required to become a doctor. What if that vaunted status conferred by merely becoming a lawyer was eliminated by eliminating the current barriers to entry?

I’m also of the mind that law should be the province of the people and not of the profession. It’s a real problem when somebody without a lot of money is, for example, going through a divorce and needs representation. He or she should be able to afford such representation, but in our current system such representation can be almost or actually out of financial reach. That would be less the case if the barriers to the profession were reduced or eliminated.

Though quite bright, brevity is not John’s strength.  His full explanation takes a while to read, and somewhat longer to digest.  But is he on to something?

Amongst the assumptions that John indulges is, as “already established on [Simple Justice] that law school does almost nothing to prepare law students for the actual practice of law anyway.”  This is correct as to the practice of law, but needs to be distinguished from the understanding of law and the ability to think like a lawyer.  While law school fails miserably to teach a person how to practice, it does an adequate job of teaching students about the concepts of law.  It may not be sufficient, but it’s nothing to be sneezed at.

Adding to the mix, Jeff Gamso adds in a comment :



Say you have a legal problem. You want to sue someone or you’ve been sued or you’ve been charged with a crime. You can represent yourself or you can hire a lawyer or maybe get a public defender or court appointed counsel. But what if you’re smart enough to know better than to represent yourself but don’t want to spend (or don’t have) the money to hire a lawyer and (if it’s criminal) don’t like/trust the lawyer provided for you at government expense? You have no alternative. Why should that be?

If you look around and find yourself in that position and find yourself concluding that the smartest guy you know is your Uncle Fred, and if he’s willing, why can’t he represent you? You can represent yourself for godssake. Why can’t you choose a non-lawyer proxy?

Why not Uncle Fred?  The argument to eliminate the barriers to the practice of law thus comes from two separate directions, that it would put an end to the status of lawyers, thus ridding the profession of those who engage solely for the purpose of accumulating wealth and social prominence (as if).  By weeding out those who have no business being lawyers in the first place as well as the costs that drive lawyers to do foolish things, the problems caused by the surplus of lawyers will go away. 

From the other side, we empower people to avoid the high cost of legal services, and put the choice back into their hands by allowing them to be represented by Uncle Fred (or Aunt Matilda for those inclined to see sexism under every rock).  It’s their life, so why not let them make their own choices about who will speak for them? 

Worthy of consideration at this juncture are calls that laws should be comprehensible by regular people, such that neither lawyers, nor a legal education, should be necessary to have a full understanding of what laws mean.  While this point is somewhat different, in that laws are intended to guide and control the conduct of people, and it seems rather pointless to enact laws which fail to serve their purpose directly, the flipside is that too often no writing will be understood the same way by different people, and no writing is so absolutely clear and comprehensive as to cover every situation that people can devise.

Some very interesting ideas for radical change to the legal profession.  Certainly more rebellious than the dream of teaching SEO marketing to lawyers.  And fundamentally flawed.

We are all in agreement about the problems facing the legal profession, running the gamut of greed and deception to incompetence.  This is why we have this conversation.  But one approach seeks to elevate the profession’s quality and integrity, while the other would reduce it to the lowest common denominator.  The result of the latter would be disaster.

Kindley belief is that by removal of barriers to entry, only the best would survive and thrive.  Those who are now entering the law for the wrong reasons, status and money, would either lose their incentive and be relieved of their disincentive to move to another job, since they wouldn’t be burdened with enormous law school debt.  His points are well taken, but don’t prove the libertarian Utopian position that meritocracy would reign supreme. 

We have every bit as much of an opportunity for the best lawyers to be the ones with all the clients, with those lawyers lacking in skills being forced out of the profession for lack of business.  This, of course, isn’t the case because clients don’t select lawyers based on merit.  They are rarely capable of distinguishing the good lawyer from the bad, or even the mediocre, since they can’t ascertain strong skills from weak.  A nice smile, empathetic words and firm handshake can be offered by the worst lawyer as well as the best.

Rather, we see that getting business has less to do with competence than with marketing, availability and price, the very things that detract from the quality and integrity of the profession.  Eliminate the barriers and we will end up being an occupation of glad-handers, long on warm and fuzzy and short on substance.  No one will be the wiser.

From the more practical perspective, imagine trials conducted by Uncle Fred. Now Nephew Billy thinks very highly of Uncle Fred and finds him to be the smartest guy he knows. The significance of this assessment can only be determined based on who Billy knows.  If Billy hangs out with the wrong crowd, then Uncle Fred’s intelligence might be over-rated. 

Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, that Billy is an innocent man arrested for a heinous crime.  Uncle Fred defends.  Fred has no idea about rules, or evidence, or voir dire, or cross-examination.  He does his best, but falls short.  Billy gets convicted and sentenced to death.  Is society okay with putting Billy to death because Uncle Fred wasn’t up to the task?  After all, Billy picked him to be his defender, and we respect Billy’s choice.

In a more mundane example, what about Uncle Fred preparing Billy’s Will.  Uncle Fred’s ability to write with clarity is far better than Billy’s, but not quite up to the level of Legal Rebel, Ken Adams.  Billy dies and no one is quite sure what the heck he wants done with the doublewide.  What then?  Perhaps Uncle Fred decided to make himself the primary beneficiary, not to mention executor, of Billy’s estate to the detriment of his 17 kids.  That’s not good.  Maybe Uncle Fred was never very good with commas, leaving the Will simply indecipherable. Do we rely on Uncle Fred’s post hoc explanation for what Billy intended?  Uncle Fred, by the way, is a heroin addict.

While these examples are somewhat silly, they reflect some of the many problems that dumbing down the law would present.  The problems would be vast, and as we realize that the law, based on its own application of entropy, would invariably become increasingly complex and convoluted, the absence of a group of people who are both educated in the law and qualified to engage in its practice would produce either anarchy or the demand for the recreation of the law as a profession.  We’re back where we started.

The challenge here isn’t to adhere to any dogmatic philosophy.  That John Kindley is a bit dogmatic is ably demonstrated by his aside that he is also in favor of tearing down barriers to entry to the medical profession.  To make my point on why this may not be the best idea, I hereby offer to perform a colonoscopy on John for a very reasonable price.

Rather, the challenge is to reverse our course, off the path of law being more business than profession, and instilling in its practitioners the desire to excel and conduct themselves with the utmost integrity.  To accomplish this, we need to address the surplus of lawyers competing with each other, sliding down the slippery slope of incompetence and disrepute with each new TV commercial, website, SEO marketing campaign and lie to potential clients about what they can guarantee, followed up by a warm smile and firm handshake. 

We are not good enough.  The solution is to be better.  Much better.

A Well-Conceived Scheme

Good scams are just good scams.  Do you think it’s accidental that the Nigerian lottery/inheritance scam has gone on for more than 30 years? I remember getting letters in the mail about it before there were faxes or computers. It sucked people in then. It still does today, even though one would think that everyone knows it’s just a scam.

So too with the elite drug cops in Chicago, where four members have pleaded guilty after cooperating against the brethren.  No, they didn’t cooperate because they suddenly remembered that they were cops, or decent human beings.  They did it to get a six month split sentence plus probation.  It’s all just about getting the best deal for themselves.

But the story that was told at the plea wasn’t a new one.  It was the same thing that happened in New York City’s Dirty 30 scandal in 1994.  And 15 years later, it’s still going strong.  After all, a good scam is a good scam.

The premise is simple: Steal from drug dealers and there’s no one to rat you out.  The victims are dirty, so no one will believe any complaints they might have about the cops taking cash and drugs.  And since they’re dirty, who cares about cops stealing from them.  Think of it as the redistribution of wealth from criminals to police officers, a little payback for their risking their lives every day to protect us and keep us safe.  No harm, no foul.

When the four former police officers admitted their roles in this scheme, a heavy sigh could be heard.



The Chicago police superintendent, Jody P. Weis, said he was pleased with the guilty pleas.

“We look forward to the conclusion of this case,” Mr. Weis said, “so the entire department can move forward from this unfortunate chapter in our history.”
That’s all it is, you see.  An “unfortunate chapter,” and now it’s over.  No need to look, people; just keep on walking.  One (4?, 9?) bad apple.  Isolated incident. Just keep walking.

I’m sure glad that this problem is fixed.  And now I can attend to the estate of my hitherto unknown deceased great uncle in Nigeria.

This (pointing) Is A Book (Update)

Walking around Christiane Amanpour’s apartment on Central Park West the other day, I found myself reading the titles of the books on her shelves.  She had a remarkable collection of books, interspersed with photographs of her and important people, ranging from presidents to the Dalai Lama.

From behind me, a woman muttered, “I wonder what this would look like with Kindle.”

Much can be learned about a person by looking at the books they keep.  There’s only one thing that can be learned about a person if all those books are replaced by Kindle.  They have no soul.

In the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Mary Graber writes about the Slackoisie and books.

My students snicker when I tell them to smell books.

The ones who think I can’t tell that they have been surfing the Web instead of typing notes turn from their screens and look at me as if I had grown a third eye.

“Yes,” I say, “go to the library shelves. Pull out an old book and smell it.”

This is not something they can Google, as they often do when I present information outside of their comfort zones.

It’s not that Graber sees no place for Wikipedia in society, but that they have no respect for those old things called books.  They don’t give them easy answers at the touch of a button, bringing them right to the point without having to waste time wading through all that extraneous stuff like reasoning, explanation, history and understanding.

Today’s students think knowledge comes at the keyboard, from sites such as Wikipedia. I learned at a recent teaching workshop on Millennials that a common complaint seen on evaluations is “the teacher acted like she knew more than the students.”

Imagine that, teachers who think they know stuff that students don’t.  Outrageous!

But this trend parallels the loss of respect for books, which represent the shoulders of giants on whom we stand looking backward at the wisdom that came before us, to paraphrase Edmund Burke. The teacher, who has studied the books — solid and unchanged by random strokes of the keyboard — should offer a repository of wisdom. But current pedagogy encourages teachers to be “facilitators” who stand aside while children learn from peers in groups. Workshops on using digital media, and even cellphones, in the classroom add to the demise of the book — and to the demise of the idea of authority and lasting values.

That the Slackoisie, with their stunted grasp of reasoning and logic, and overextended valuation of their own qualities and competence, are confident that there is no question they will ever need to answer that can’t be found in a few seconds and a few keystrokes.  They are full of their prowess of technology, unaware of their inability to understand it.

Oscar Wilde called a cynic someone who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.  The parallel is alarming.  And no doubt beyond the ken of the Slackoisie to appreciate.  After all, there’s no wikipedia entry for why the Slackoisie don’t get it.

So next time a millennial has a desire to put something up their nose, he should consider going to a library and smelling a book.  It’s one of those old, dusty things on the shelves that contains not only the specific fact you’re looking for but all the understanding it takes to appreciate the significance of the fact.  But do it quickly, as it may not be there for long.

H/T Stephanie at Idealawg

Update:  Greg Lambert fires back: Your books smell like elderberries.  Of course, they are no longer books, but “information resources.”  Greg’s post has a great video of Don Tapscott rationalizing the corruption of the Slackoisie and terrific comments.

The Walmart Lode

When Turley wrote about Walmart being at the core of yet another call to the cops to protect society from parents photographing their children in the bath tub, he noted that Walmart is a never ending source of incredibly stupid acts.



What makes this lawsuit so interesting is the inclusion of Walmart as a party. I am not sure what this blog would do without Walmart. When Walmart is not destroying Civil War historical areas, it is supplying blogs with a steady supply of abusive corporate conduct here and here and here), crimes committed by employees (here and here and here), or crimes by customers (here and here and here and here and here).
It’s one thing that someone at Walmart, renown for its film developing, joined the cadre of those on the lookout for those sex offenders formerly called normal parents (or grandparents), but there’s no apparent end to the wrongs that Walmart is integral in righting.  Why is that?

Some might say that it has much to do with the sensibilities of your typical Walmart employee.  Neither pretentious nor flashy, these are the salt of the earth.  Regular folk with solid American values.  Hard working, moral and filled with common sense. Just like the patrons of Walmart, thrifty and unwilling to throw their hard-earned money away on frivolities.

There are a million voices on the internets and elsewhere lauding these regular folk and their values.  They cry, “what happened to common sense?”  Guess what?  This is common sense. Just not your common sense, but it’s about as common as it gets. 

There’s a pretense we all hold that we are the norm, that whatever thoughts flow through our heads are the ones shared by ordinary, rational people of good will and intention.  We believe in our own thoughts, and we believe that most people, the normal ones, share them.  We are deluding ourselves.

As rational as we wish to believe ourselves to be, the same is true of most everyone else.  Except we all disagree.  Every single one of us.  We may share a few thoughts, overlap from time to time, but we also harbor thoughts that others believe to be absurdly wrong.  Maybe even dangerous.  Except we don’t know it and refuse to acknowledge it.

Walmart is likely an excellent microcosm of America, and that’s why Walmart employees, Walmart management and Walmart shoppers provide this seemingly endless stream of stupid acts.  We are all Walmart greeters, no matter how much we think otherwise. 

Common sense is alive and well. And it’s on sale at Walmart.

Rebel Rebel, Your Face Is A Mess

When the ABA Journal announced it’s Legal Rebels project, snickers could be heard in law offices across the land.  ABA and Rebel were not the sort of words one would expect to find in the same sentence.  But ABA Journal editor Ed Adams twitted, “Get used to it!” Tough words to live up to.

They began with a Legal Rebels Manifesto, which according to its preface. The ABA Journal’s “community of readers edited the document more than 65 times,” making their rebel manifesto subject to popular approval, and produced this:



I am a proud member of America’s essential profession. Without lawyers and the rule of law, a free, fair and open society is not sustainable.

I recognize that the legal profession’s traditions – the world’s most respected legal education system, most successful law firms and fairest court system – were once radical innovations.

In this time of economic crisis, I am committed to improving those institutions and creating innovation in the practice of law. I will question and, when appropriate, change the status quo. And I will use technology to serve my clients and society.

I’ll help remake the profession I hold dear so it can continue to deliver on America’s promise.

I’m an innovator. A maverick. A pathfinder.

I am a Legal Rebel.
Earthshattering, right?  Okay, maybe not, but motivational?  At least if you think that using technology is rebellious in some tacit way.  They apparently removed the part that read, “I will no longer wear wingtip brogues, but will replace them with flip-flops.”  Now that was too rebellious, and there was no sense pissing off the wingtip contingent.

The problem here is that it’s really cool to name people innovator, maverick, pathfinder, Rebel.  Maybe not maverick, or its common permutation, mavericky to describe the sort of stuff mavericks do, but some slick Republicans slipped that one past Ed Adams.  But using words, even cool ones, requires some sort of appreciation of their meaning.  Let’s go with “a person who resists any authority, control, or tradition,” since no one expects Legal Rebels to seek the overthrow of the government.

And so the ABA Journal named its Legal Rebels and offered their profiles.  It then went on an east coast Rebels tour, there apparently being no Rebels worthy of meeting anywhere else.  Unlike most of you, I’ve actually taken the time to look at the ABA Journal’s Legal Rebels.  With a very few exceptions, I’m afraid that the ABA Journal wouldn’t know a Rebel if it bit them in the butt.

The list contains some good lawyers.  It contains some great lawyer, in fact.  But Rebels?  Not so much.  It’s more along the lines of a 50 year olds idea of what constitutes well-dressed people.  Oh my God, she’s wearing white after Labor Day.  What a Rebel!  Some are engaged in relatively commonplace computer use, and others are trying to promote their quasi-law businesses in the age of social media as the next great frontier.  Much of it might have been cutting edge a decade ago, and perhaps the ABA Journal just figured out that wingtips aren’t as fashionable as they once were, but it’s now just monumentally ordinary.

No one can blame the “Rebels” for enjoying the ABA Journal’s free promotional opportunity.  After all, it’s good for their profile and can’t hurt business.  For most of the “Rebels”, it’s all just business, and anything that helps is welcome, no matter how silly the basis for their promotion.

Rather, this Legal Rebel project reflects on the relevancy of the ABA Journal.  It’s unclear whether they even realize what some of their choices are up to, or that they’re busy promoting banal business interests while calling them Rebels.  What is clear is that there are Legal Rebels out there, who are challenging the common wisdom of the legal profession, but their names are nowhere to be found on the list.  That’s because real Rebels are often calling for unpleasant things that shake up and disturb the readership.  The ABA Journal certainly doesn’t want to drive away its readership by calling attention to things that would miff the wingtip crowd. 

And don’t ask me to name the true Legal Rebels.  You already know who they are, and I’m not competing with the ABA Journal for eyeballs.  Besides, real Rebels don’t do it to get their name on a list, unless it’s the Nixon’s enemies list. Few things would be as embarrassing to a real rebel as being called a Legal Rebel by the journal of the most establishment organization in town.

That the Legal Rebels project turned out to be just further evidence of how unrebellious lawyers, and the ABA Journal, truly are comes as no surprise.  You didn’t really think that the ABA Journal was getting behind anything radical, did you?  After all, it’s always possible that wingtips will come back into style.  And when they do, Ed Adams will be right on top of it.