I’ve been reluctant to post about the Hofstra rape case, or rather the Hofstra false rape case, because the scenery has changed with far greater speed than a car passing by on the Long Island Expressway. It’s swiftly gone from cops announcing their guilty 5, raping a girl in a bathroom lured their by someone taking her cellphone, to one of the evil males taping consensual sex on his cellphone.
The false accuser, confronted with news of the video, spills her lies. and suddenly the world turns 180 degrees. The debate now shifts to whether the accuser should be publicly named and prosecuted. The dilemma has been well noted by Emily Bazelon, who has since been called out by Glenn Reynolds for her failure to name the perpetrator of the false rape claim, Danmell Ndonye. And Ann Althouse thinks it’s time for women to grow up and take responsibility for their sexual conduct, Ndonye crying rape to avoid being thought of as a slut.
Big issue punditry aside, there’s an actual decision to be made here, and there’s been no focus on the fact that the local District Attorney, Kathleen Rice, has yet to make that issue. Granted, she Nifong’ed herself at the start, jumping aboard the guilty bandwagon as quickly as she could, and jumped off even more quickly hoping nobody would notice. But Rice, who has set up her political fortunes as an avenging DA, has yet to do the one thing that district attorneys are charged to do. Decide to prosecute.
A Newsday article by Ann Givens purports to lay out the considerations that Kathleen Rice is weighing in her decision of whether to charge Ndonye.
On the one hand, they will want to discourage people from lying to law enforcement, and show that there will be consequences for doing so, experts said. On the other, they don’t want to discourage legitimate rape victims from coming forward, or discourage people who lied at first from telling the truth later on, experts said.
And the flip side of the thought process is even less valid. A false rape accuser does nothing to inhibit a true rape victim from coming forward. There’s nothing similar about the situations, True victims have no fear of a video revealing them to be a liar. True victims have no fear of being exposed as a fraud and criminal.
Lois Schwaeber, director of legal services for the Nassau County Coalition Against Domestic Violence, said cases where people make false reports of rape hurt all legitimate rape victims seeking justice. But she said prosecuting someone who has made a false report will discourage real rape victims from coming forward as well.
“They may feel that if they can’t support the charges they are making with enough proof, they could be charged.”
Nor does the secondary rationale hold water. Ndonye didn’t tell the truth because she had a sudden flash of conscience about the crime she committed and the harm she had done. She cracked because she was confronted with the fact that she was a liar. You want an incentive to tell the truth? Videotape your sexual encounters.
Of course, had the sequence of events been slightly different, and it was revealed that one of the five men in the bathroom had taped the encounter before Ndonye lied, the papers would have had a different lede. Taking photos of bathroom sex is certainly lurid enough to be worth a story.
This all amounts to a flag being run up the pole to see who salutes. Rice is up for re-election, and opposed by a legitimate and well respected contender for the post, Joy Watson. She doesn’t know which direction will get her the most votes, and the least criticism. There’s a huge risk for Rice in charging Ndonye with a crime, as shown by the way Newsday has framed the considerations. Rice doesn’t want domestic violence and rape advocates to jump down her throat for discouraging real victims.
But Rice knows that a crime has been committed. Rice has the evidence to prove her case.
Rape is a heinous crime, and Rice was all too happy to make sure the charges against the “rapists” were broadcast far and wide. When she ended up on the wrong end of the story, though, she never apologized to the five men who she put in jail because of the false allegations. And now she tests the waters to keep her political hands clean for her failure to charge the source of these heinous false allegations.
As interesting as the thoughts of pundits on the subject might be, the real decision sits in Kathleen Rice’s hands. The decision won’t be made because of right and wrong, crime or no crime, the effect on real rape victims. The decision will be made on what will make her constituents want to re-elect her and what she can get away with. If this wasn’t true, the decision would be a no-brainer.
Update: At 5 pm on a Friday, Nassau DA Kathleen Rice announces that she won’t prosecute Ndonye, the false rape accuer. That’s how one buries a story so it’s lost over the weekend and never heard from again. Coincidence?
