Author Archives: SHG

NOW Pressures Judge To Convict, Before Trial

Queens State Senator Hiram Monserrate has only two claims to fame.  First, he was one of the defecting Democrats who was responsible for shutting down the New York State Senate during the month of lunacy.  Second, only a month after the then-City Councilman was elected to the Senate, he slashed his girlfriend’s face.  Need I mention he was a New York City cop for 12 years before deciding to become a public servant?

Having decided that he would do better with Justice William Erlbaum than 12 peers, the latter being unlikely to ignore the videotape of him punching, grabbing and slashing Karla Giraldo to the tune of 20 stitches in his accident defense, Monserrate decided to go non-jury.  He’s represented by my buddy Joe Tacopina, who has had great success defending cops.  Of course, Joe Tac’s best work is before a jury, where his charm and good looks do him no harm.

Inexplicably, this was too much for the National Association of Women to take.  Given Monserrate’s elevated profile from his Albany debacle, combined with his unkind treatment of his girlfriend Karla, whose story of assault later changed to an accident as Monserrate was bringing her a glass of water, he became the latest poster boy for misogynistic politician.  So a plan was hatched.


The National Organization for Women in New York State is calling on the judge trying State Senator Hiram Monserrate on domestic violence charges to give him “the maximum sentence allowable by law.”

There’s only one problem.  Monserrate hasn’t been convicted yet.  Details.  But NOW is nothing if not well organized when it comes to applying pressure.



“Call or write the Honorable William M. Erlbaum,” the women’s organization told supporters in e-mail messages this week. “Send a message that violence against women must be stopped and perpetrators must be brought to justice.”

It included a template for sending a message to Justice Erlbaum that concluded: “I implore you to do the right thing by punishing Senator Monserrate, giving him the maximum sentence allowable by law. By doing so, you will be sending a very important message and that is that violence against women is a serious crime.”

Not surprising, Tac doesn’t think this is a very good plan as he prepared for trial.


“They’re trying to improperly persuade the fact finder,” Mr. Tacopina said in an interview. “It’s akin to writing a letter to a juror.”

Nuh uh, says NOW.



Marcia Pappas, the president of the women’s organization in New York State, acknowledged the campaign to influence Justice Erlbaum, saying in an interview, “We’re imploring him to do the right thing.”

She said the campaign was nothing unusual for what she called “an activist organization” that has often written to family court judges in child custody cases.

“I’m sure the judge knows what he needs to do, so his position is not compromised,” Ms. Pappas said.
Of course, if the judge already knows what to do, then why bother him with letters?  What makes this scenario interesting is that the judge is the factfinder in a non-jury trial, yet fair game to public pressure.  And Pappas’ statement notwithstanding, obviously the purpose of the campaign is to let the judge know that they will hang him out to dry if he makes the wrong call.  At least they will try.

Tacopina is correct in comparing this push to punish to improperly reaching out to a juror in one sense, but a judge isn’t a juror, and there is no law I can think of prohibiting NOW from trying to influence his decision.  On the other hand, Justice Erlbaum isn’t likely to shudder in fear at the thought of a bunch of letters from NOW members demanding the maximum punishment.  It’s likely that he will remember the sequence of events, first guilt and only afterward punishment, in any event.

It would not surprise me if this NOW campaign backfires bigtime.  Curiously, Monserrate has a tough case against him, with videotape of the assault to confront and only his girlfriend’s changed testimony to back up his story.  Given that it’s fairly clear that her story changed to exculpate him, coupled with the tape, getting the judge to bite won’t be easy.

But there’s a tendency to get both annoyed at such overt political efforts to influence the outcome, and to bend the opposite way in order to avoid the impression that such efforts work (and thereby provide an incentive to the next group inclined to exert pressure) that may give Monserrate an edge where before he had none.  While NOW may be impressed with its power and influence, it’s unlikely that Justice Erlbaum will share its self-image.

Ultimately, I suspect that the judge will do the right thing, meaning that he’ll try the case fairly and this background noise will fade away.  But it’s amazing how this misbegotten scheme is the first, and possibly only, thing that has made Monserrate look even a little bit sympathetic.  Before he was a pompous, arrogant State Senator who beat up and slashed his girlfriend.  Now he’s the lone man fighting the hordes of NOW who are trying to improperly influence justice and deny him a fair trial. 

If Monserrate has any gentility in him at all, he’ll send Pappas a thank you note. It would be the right thing to do.

CLE Gone Wrong

To the extent that feral lawyers have any pretense at organization, bar associations are meant to serve that function.  But as this post at Above the Law shows, even the New York State Bar Association listserv has turned into another forum for nastiness and self-loathing in the current economic atmosphere, where a relatively new, still unemployed, Fordham law grad reached out in an effort to find a job.  His attempt was met with ridicule.

This reflects a problem.  Not just a problem with young unemployed lawyers, but with older lawyers who have their own problems with business, enough so that they can’t find the grace to be kind if not helpful.  It bears the stink of desperation that’s spreading through the profession.

Our bar associations and law schools can smell the aroma as well, and are trying to do something about it, or perhaps capitalize on it as the case may be, by running Continuing Legal Educations programs on the critical legal topic of, ta da, social media.  Stop laughing.  I’m serious.

The idea of continuing legal education was born of the notion that too many lawyers would allow their knowledge and skills to languish after passing the bar, leaving them substantively lacking while imbued with the monopolistic right to hold themselves out as qualified to represent others in the law.  CLE was made mandatory, since lawyers couldn’t be trusted to keep abreast of developments in the law on their own.  Schools and associations, not to mention a cottage industry of private fee-based providers, were authorized to provide CLE.  All to make lawyers more competent.  Really?

There has been a rash of CLEs on the topic of blogging and social media.  What the heck does this have to do with better representing clients?  While it’s fine for lawyers, traditionally about 12 steps behind the rest of society in its acceptance and adoption of technology, to want to learn what all the hoopla is about, but in satisfaction of their mandated CLE requirements?  Spare me.  Not only is this a flagrant bastardization of the concept of CLE, but it further promotes the facile belief that law is all about snagging business rather than serving clients. 


“But Greenfield (you moron, optional), without business we starve, and that doesn’t help anyone (especially us).”
Fair enough, but that doesn’t mean that it becomes fair game for continuing legal education.  If you want to attend conferences on how not to starve, as opposed to how to get a life, by all means do so.  But don’t expect CLE credit for it.  These conferences aren’t for the benefit of clients, but for the benefit of lawyers.  No one said you couldn’t take whatever courses you wanted, but that you can’t substitute continuing legal education for continuing marketing education.  No, they are not equivalents.

But the problem gets worse.  A while back, I was astounded by an NYSBA blogging CLE where the speakers never blogged.  It was followed up by another seminar with someone who “blogged”, assuming that one considers blatant self-promotion, as in “if you’re arrested, I will win your case,” blogging.  Mind you, the blogger was quite impressed with himself and his blogging skills.

Since then, the drizzle has become a deluge.  There appears to be no end to the number of programs, and the ready availability of people holding themselves out as experts to speak at these programs.  Just yesterday, a new one appeared in my emailbox, with speakers characterized as “social media practitioner” (huh?) and “twitter expert.”  Where does one take the test to become a twitter expert?

Aside: At a cocktail party yesterday evening, I met a person who is writing novel about twitter. They didn’t grasp the irony at all.

I can’t blame the people who have gotten themselves gigs as speakers at these CLEs.  After all, they get CLE credit for doing it, and are promoting something they are engage in and enjoy.  Some have a great deal of knowledge on the subject, though others don’t appear to have any reason for being on the panel whatsoever.  And some have a big horse in the race, their financial interests being acutely connected to persuading lawyers to hop on board their wagon.  Everyone appears to be a great lover of technology and supporter of social media as the newest, greatest thing ever.  This is a “do it or die” conference, and the fact that a few stand to cash in on the “do it” part doesn’t seem to matter.

One more thing happened yesterday (yes, it was a busy day) that drove the problem home.  I, along with a few other malcontents, was asked to be on a social media panel at a conference on the upper left coast.  They wouldn’t pay for travel.  They wouldn’t pay for room or board.  But I could attend the balance of the conference without paying the fee.  This was sheer madness. It’s one thing to ask me to sacrifice my time, but to expect me to pay for the privilege is insane.  And attending a conference that falls ten steps below sticking a needle in my eye is not much of an incentive.

And then it dawned on me.  The reason the only sounds heard at social media CLEs are the dulcet tones of sycophants is that the others would never pay to play.  There’s nothing in it to justify traveling around as apostles of social media.  Only those who see profit in the activity would be bothered, and willing to suffer the cost.

In the process, bar associations and law schools are putting their imprimatur on lawyer marketing when their CLE mandate is to improve the skills and qualifications of lawyers so that they can better serve their clients.  If the good lawyers on the NYSBA listserv wanted to do the unemployed Fordham law grad a solid, they could saved the snark and just replied with one word.  Plastics.

Putting The Profit Into Crime

For anyone who truly admires outside the box thinking, you’re about to become a big fan of Las Vegas casinos. It’s well known that casinos, unlike other businesses, take crime within their very flashy walls serious, so much so that they maintain quite elaborate security forces and their own private jails, where people can theoretically be held until the gendarmes come to fetch them.

If this seems troubling, it beats the old system, gently referred to as the broken knee approach.  But as anyone who has ever put chip to felt should know, the rule of casinos is that the odds favor the house.  With a captive audience, it would just be wasteful to pass up an opportunity like this.  Enter United States Justice Associates.

From KTNV Contact 13 in Vegas, 



The video begins with ominous music and grainy jail images… inmates in CCDC uniforms and handcuffs shuffling out a courtroom door to return to their cells.

“At the end of this video, you will be required to make a decision that could affect you for the rest of your life,” the male narrator says in a serious tone.

“Hello, I’m speaking to you on behalf of United States Justice Associates. You have been detained by this establishment because of your involvement in a crime,” the narrator says.

The video spells out a program where people detained by casinos can beat the rap merely by signing a confession and paying $500.  No prosecution, no trial, no record.  The $500 fines are split between the casino and USDA, and, according to report, the “reward” to casinos may be as much as $730,000 per year.

The program is the brainchild of Stephen Brox, who, much to his misfortune, didn’t find the same program available to him when he was arrested earlier in the week on sexual assault charges.  The Las Vegas Metro Police are now looking into this program, investigating coerced confessions and extortion.  Oddly, Brox wasn’t talking.  But his attorney was.



“This program was designed, it is my understanding, to avoid arrests, avoid clogging up our already over-clogged justice system and to address relatively minor offenders with appropriate counseling,” [Brox’s attorney, Robert] Draskovich says.


“It appears that a flat fee was chosen, which is not illegal, and it appears the casino did receive a part of the fee. The person deciding to go into the program had the ultimate choice whether he or she wanted to participate in the program,” says Draskovich.


And the video they watch while contemplating that decision in a casino holding cell tells them, “It’s important to make payment arrangements immediately. Otherwise your case and admission of guilt will be forwarded for prosecution, resulting in a conviction and jail time.”

Not only does it provide a new revenue stream for the casinos, but it keeps the court dockets lower. A win-win, if ever there was one.  But some might wonder, given that these are casinos and accordingly subject to some scrutiny because of an alleged unsavory past, what would make them think that this scheme was a great idea.  No problem.



When the program was pitched to a group of casino security chiefs it came with a letter obtained exclusively by Contact 13. It’s signed by then-Chief Justice Court Judge Douglas Smith, who’s writing it on behalf of United States Justice Associates. It carries his personal recommendation of their program, “wholeheartedly, and without reservation.”

Judge Smith has been questioned by police and did not return our calls for comment.

We’ve also learned the program was pitched by Sheriff-turned Station Casinos security boss Bill Young.
Shockingly, Chief Judge Smith received a $500 donation to his election campaign from USJA.  No, it’s not shocking that they made the donation, but that Smith sold out for a mere $500.  He could have done a whole lot better. 

What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas.

H/T Packratt

Poor Allen Stanford

Dick DeGuerin did a lot right when he began his representation of billionaire R. Allen Stanford.  He also did one thing really wrong.  He forgot to get paid.  As nice as it is to be a billionaire, it doesn’t help much when your assets are seized pending forfeiture.  Now Dick DeGuerin has to withdraw from the case, having come to the conclusion that he bears little resemblance to Mother Teresa.


As DeGuerin left the courtroom, he wished his former client good luck.

The relationship between the famed criminal defense lawyer and his client, the former cricket king and high-flying world traveler, included DeGuerin trying to turn Stanford over to authorities before he was charged to show he was not hiding.

It also included a scuffle in DeGuerin’s office with a local civil lawyer who wanted a role in Stanford’s defense.

When the client is a billionaire, everybody wants a piece of the pie.  But nobody knows you when you’re down and out.  In fairness, chances are pretty good that any funds Stanford would have used to pay DeGuerin would have been seized by the government anyway.  That will comes as a surprise to many, that even attorneys fees aren’t safe, but they are as much subject to forfeiture as any other funds.

The problem arises from the confluence of two rules, both lousy.  First is the unconscionably low threshold for forfeiture, mere probable cause.  Any half-baked, concocted story will do, and it’s hardly a stretch to take an indicted defendant and fashion a reason to call his money dirty. 

The second rule is that forfeiture is an “in rem” proceeding, meaning that it operates as a legal fiction, that the “res‘, the ‘thing”, offends the sovereign.  Why does this matter?  Because things don’t have rights.  People have rights.  Things just sit there, naked in their rightlessness. Not only does this disconnect the “res” from the person from whom it was seized, but it eliminates issues surrounding the lawfulness of its seizure. 

There is one additional bit of ugliness that goes along with the legal fiction of an “in rem” proceeding.  Anyone claiming superior title to the thing, like the person from whom it was seized, is placed in the position of claiming it, and thus subjecting himself to all manner of civil disclosure.  If the claimant also happens to be a criminal defendant, which ironically is often the case, it’s like a prosecutorial colonoscopy.  As much as one would prefer to avoid such an intrusion generally, it’s particularly undesirable when you’re under indictment.

The upshot of this process is to turn our modern day trials into a reasonable facsimile of the old witch trials.  You remember them, where proof of guilt was that the witch floated and didn’t drown, such that she deserved to be burned at the stake.  The procedure is to first remove a defendant’s ability to financially mount a defense, based on the presumption that his money is dirty, convict him justifying its initial seizure and then exclaim, “see, I told you he was guilty and that the money was dirty.”

So now the billionaire will be represented by a federal defender.  Not that there’s anything wrong with that.   As Mike explains,


The Federal Defenders are usually very good.  Most public defenders are good lawyers.  They are simply too overworked to do a good job on any given case.  One person said it best: “If I had my choice, I would want to be represented by my public defender’s office.  However, I’d want to be their only client.”  One-hundred open criminal case files would turn any lawyer into mush.
It’s pretty likely that the federal defenders would be just as happy to not have this case to deal with.  It’s just another burden on an already burdened, and underfunded, bunch of lawyers who really didn’t figure that their efforts would be put to defending billionaires.  Billionaires, by the way, can be very demanding.  Federal defenders really aren’t geared up to handle very demanding billionaires, and whatever time is dedicated to the defense of R. Allen Stanford comes at the expense of time that would otherwise be available to the truly indigent, who will become the silent victims of this shift of fortune.

All in all, it’s been a good day for the government.

Quality Matters; It Just May Not Be Enough

Edward Wiest sent me a twit asking, What will @ScottGreenfield think, about this post by Jay Fleischman at Legal Practice Pro, a blog about “marketing, managing and growing a profitable law firm.”  I’m glad Ed did, because the chances of my ever seeing this post otherwise are slim to none.  Maybe even less.

Jay’s post, entitled You’re A Good Lawyer – Big Deal, might at first blush seem the polar opposite of my anti-marketing philosophy, where I harangue the forces of evil who promote lawyers marketing themselves as “experts”, or “aggressive, caring, blue,” or “former prosecutor,” or whatever magic words some marketer urges upon the business-less lawyer seeking enough lucre to buy a loaf of bread on his way home.  I’m constantly harping on competence and quality.  Here’s what Jay has to say about it:


There is nothing more annoying that a lawyer who says, “I don’t understand why I don’t get a lot of business.  I’m a really good lawyer.”

Big deal.  Lawyering ain’t rocket science, and don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.  If they do, move away from them as fast as you can.

And this is coming from a lawyer, someone who’s been plugging away for quite some time at it.

We are technicians, schooled in a profession that is part mechanics, part art.  The old saw is that they call it  the “practice of law” because you never get perfect at it.  True words indeed.

Ask any lawyer who’s been practicing in a particular niche for more than a decade and they’ll confirm (if they’re being honest, that is) that the basics remain the same and all that changes is nuance after awhile.  Sure, laws change and precedent evolves – but the basics stay the same.  Nail those and you’re halfway there.  Probably more.

To be fair, Jay’s a bankruptcy lawyer, and his words about what it takes to be a “good lawyer” strike closer to home in his niche than mine.  Or perhaps we just have different ideas about what it takes to be a good lawyer, though I agree that it isn’t rocket science.  For the purpose of further discussion, let’s assume that Jay’s whining lawyer’s self-assessment, that he is in fact a “good lawyer,” is accurate.  What then?


Here’s the ugly truth – no matter how busy you are, no matter how quiet your phones are, no matter how full or empty your waiting room is … that’s entirely up to you.  Nobody else.  Your hand makes the moves on the chess board that results in someone saying, “Hey, that looks like a good lawyer to hire.”  Your efforts constitute the grease that makes the wheels turn.

He’s right.  It’s not enough to simply be good at what you do.  Sitting alone in your silent office, relishing in your quality, doesn’t make for much of a practice.  If you’re the only person who knows that you’re good, then you’re going to be a very lonely lawyer, and your family will be hungry.

But Jay’s position, at least in this post, begins from the premise that you are, in fact, a good lawyer.  This is a critical distinction between Jay’s follow-up suggestions and those of the other marketers, and the “anyone can go solo no matter how incompetent you are” crowd.  First, be a good lawyer.  There is no legitimate way around this first hurdle.  None.

Jay makes some curious observations about referrals, the primary source of clientèle for good lawyers.



But when it comes down to brass tacks (I have no idea where that saying comes from, but I like it) the reality is that people make a decision based on the way the lawyer markets his or her practice.  Word of mouth, advertising, web searches, bar referral programs … whatever road leads “Joe Legal Problem” to the lawyer is definitely NOT in any way related to that lawyer’s overall qualifications.

The only thing that comes close is word of mouth, but only in the form of a referral from a friend or family member who used the lawyer and got a good result in the past.  But even then, the referring client may have gotten a terrible lawyer and a dead-simple case.  Not to trash talk anyone, but sometimes a case is so easy a college kid could bumble his or her way through it.
While he’s right about bad lawyers obtaining the occasional good result, that’s the tail wagging the dog.  More likely, a good lawyer obtained a good result, or at least the best result possible.  It’s generally a good idea not to let oddities cloud one’s vision, even though they do occur.  On the other hand, a website replete with unwarranted puffery about a lawyer doesn’t seem to have much to commend it over word of mouth referrals based on good results, so is it better to get clients based on some modicum of reality or to pursue riches based on a total sham?  The answer to this question tells a lot about a person.

Jay finishes off his post with 8 suggestions of things to do to bring clients into your very quiet office.  Aside from his second suggestion, which implicates some ethical considerations that would apply to New York lawyers, they are pretty basic and pretty good.  Given my admiration for Seth Godin, and my enjoyment of Harold Robbins, there’s some great reading in there.

Of particular note is letting the clients you do have know that if they are pleased with the representation you’ve provided, you would appreciate their letting others know, since client referrals are the best source of business.  This isn’t easy for many lawyers to do, as it feels somewhat slimy and demeaning.  And if clients are happy with you, won’t they refer people to you anyway?  Maybe, but many don’t want to think much about lawyers when they don’t have to, and often merely pointing out the obvious means the difference between them speaking your name some day in the future and standing mute.

But before I end, let’s return to the initial assumption, that the lawyer complaining about his lack of business was, per his self-assessment, a good lawyer.  Says who?  If your phone isn’t ringing, perhaps no one shares your self-assessment?  If you’ve come to this conclusion in the absence of actually providing any competent representation of clients, consider the possibility that you aren’t yet a good lawyer.  Maybe you will be, eventually, but believing in yourself is not a substitute for competency, no matter what anyone else tries to sell you.

The first step is always competence.  Without it, the best you can hope for is to live a lie.

What I Owe You

Having established Simple Justice some time ago, I regularly receive requests from folks.  All sorts of requests. From the constant link exchange emails, as marketers tell their clients to seek, to guest posts, to advice on all manner of blawging issues.  And then there are the new lawyers seeking to break into practice, or break into criminal defense, or just not break anything. 

From there we have the defendants, who are empowered by the ubiquitous lawyer websites to ask questions of lawyers who do not represent them.  Free questions. Free answers.  The business model of many of our finely conceived lawyer-finder type websites all involve entitling people to expect answers to their questions upon demand. The websites sell advertising off views by people seeking free legal advice.  Lawyers are expected to provide the fodder to draw the eyeballs, while the website makes money off their backs.  And lawyers appear all too happy to be stupid.

I quietly ask myself, from time to time, if I’m the only person who thinks this is lunacy.  When I tell a unknown caller, who merely wants to tell me their story for a half hour or so and obtain some free advice that will change his life, that I cannot do so, I hear him curse me out for being a horrible human being; a greedy lawyer.  Do other people find this acceptable?

No, thank goodness, I am not alone.

From Mike at Crime & Federalism and Walter Olson on twitter, I have found a brother.  Better still, someone as curmudgeonly as me who is willing to spell it out, tell it like it is, take no prisoners.  Meet John Scalzi.  He’s a writer, which means he can do so better than me, but if I was a writer rather than a lawyer, then I would write what he does.

I would love to copy and paste his whole post in here.  True, the application to law isn’t precise, and requires a bit of squinting at times given our different functions, but there isn’t a word in there that isn’t worth reading.  I won’t, however, because they are his words, not mine.  But I will take a bit, fair use and all, to whet your whistle.


The person who determines what a writer should do for others is the writer, not you. Why? Well, quite obviously, because it’s not your life, and you don’t get a say. And if you’re somehow under the impression that well, yeah, actually you do have a say in that writer’s life, take the following quiz:

 


Think of your favorite writer. Now, are you:
1. That writer?
2. That writer’s spouse (or spousal equivalent)?
3. Rather below that, a member of that writer’s immediate family?
4. Rather below that, the writer’s editor or boss?


If the answer is “no” to the above, then guess what? You don’t get a vote. And if you still assume you do, that writer is perfectly justified in being dreadfully rude to you. I certainly would be. I certainly have been, when someone has made such assertions or assumptions. And if necessary, I will be happy to be so again.


It’s as if I’ve found my long lost brother.  When I wrote something similar, the Slackoisie were all over me like flies on feces.  They didn’t get it then, and likely won’t get it now.  They are, you see, entitled.  They are the people Scalzi is writing about, the ones who think they have a right to demand that others perform for their convenience, serve their interests, wait on them.  Like their mommies did.  It’s all about them, and the rest of us exist only to make their lives easier.  Or else we’re mean to them.

I wish to take this opportunity to welcome John Scalzi into the Curmudgeon Club.  If he wants to be president, the job is his.  Now please read the rest of his post, and pretend that it came from me.

The Sound Exercise of Discretion

Too often, we learn of the wrongs, the bad choices by cops and prosecutors that make us wonder where their mothers went wrong.  Lest one get the wrong impression, not every exercise of prosecutorial discretion results in another shocking, mind-bogglingly stupid prosecution.  Sometimes, prosecutors use their authority to make sure the right thing is done, and when that happens, they deserve recognition and appreciation.

From the AP, prosecutors in Ravena, Ohio, joined with the defense in concluding that an autistic 18 year old was not competent to stand trial for the fatal beating of his mother, a professor at Kent State.



Prosecutors and defense attorneys told a judge Friday that an autistic teenager is not competent to stand trial in the fatal beating of his mother, a Kent State University professor.


The attorneys said they accepted a mental health evaluation of Sky Walker, 18, that concluded he is unable to help in his defense.


The prosecution would be satisfied if the judge orders Walker sent to a facility that ensures that “the public is protected from any further acts of violence or aggression,” said Chief Assistant Prosecutor Francis M. Ricciardi.


Less than two weeks after the mental evaluations were completed in March, Walker was moved from jail to a state-run center in Toledo. The center’s nine group homes serve about 160 people, most of whom have severe mental retardation.
How easy would it have been for prosecutors to argue that autism is no excuse for a terrible crime, and pursue this young man with the full weight of its power.  Like shooting fish in a barrel, another successful murder conviction was there for the taking.  And yet, they acted with restraint, with thoughtfulness and with recognition of the limits of culpability inherent in autism. 

The implications of both mental illness, traumatic brain injury and autistic spectrum disorders are vast for the criminal justice system, and largely underappreciated.  The decision by the Revena prosecutors to join with the defense in recognizing the impact of autism on Walker’s mental state demonstrates a remarkable concern for justice and the integrity of the criminal justice system.

Bravo.  Justice was served, and I hope that Sky Walker receives the care that he needs and will help him.

Think You Can Help? Then Let Soros Pay

This is hardly intended to open a discussion about whether you love or hate George Soros, so don’t go there.  Like him or not, he puts his money where his ideals are, and has established the Soros Justice Fellowships.


The Soros Justice Fellowships fund outstanding individuals to implement innovative projects that advance the Open Society Institute’s efforts to reform the U.S. criminal justice system. OSI’s strategy takes aim at two overarching ills: the over-reliance on incarceration and harsh punishment, and the lack of equal justice—especially for people of color and the poor.

The application period for fellowship is open, and will close on October 14th.  They are actively seeking applications, so don’t assume that the deal’s done and all the really important projects have the loot locked up.

As can be seen from the list of last year’s fellowship winners, the breadth of projects funded is quite broad, with some even on the sketchy side (in my opinion).  So many readers have done, are doing, and want to do projects that fall within the parameters of the Fellowships that it would be a terrible waste to ignore this opportunity.  The funding is there, and there’s no reason to believe that your ideas, your projects, aren’t as important and worthy as past fellowship winners.

And just to show how worthwhile these fellowships can be, Amy Bach, author of Ordinary Injustice, was a Soros Fellow in 2003, providing funding to allow her to write the book.  Not too shabby, eh?

Amongst last year’s winners, I noted that there was nothing to suggest recognition of the power of the blawgosphere to move the effort for justice forward, and that this was a major omission on their part.


I queried the good Soros people on the absence of blawgers, and was told that, since their goals include public awareness of criminal justice issues, they would “welcome” applications from blawgers.  “Applications”, I responded?  “Feral blawgers don’t ‘apply’ for things. It’s not in our nature to do anything so ‘official’.”  But that doesn’t prevent the Soros bankers from doing a quick spin around the blawgosphere to see the efforts being made here to enlighten the world as to the frightening reality of our criminal justice system.
As they’ve again asked for applications, rather than taken a test drive through the blawgosphere, I suspect they have yet to adopt my suggestion that blawgers aren’t the sort of folks who apply for things, but just do the very work they seek to further.  In other words, they won’t come looking for you, even though they should.  But that doesn’t mean you don’t deserve the support, or that they aren’t interested in our efforts, which will have (again, in my opinion) much farther reaching impact than many of the projects that they’ve support in the past.  I trust they won’t continue to ignore the most powerful tool out here for the cause of justice. 

So if you’ve got a project, go for it. The worst that can happen is you don’t get it. And I bet there’s a good chance, given some of the great work done by my friends around the blawgosphere (with no outside support whatsoever) that your efforts are worthy of a Soros Fellowship.  Go for it.

The Good Samaritan

In a series of posts over at The Agitator, Radley Balko chronicles the experience of his reader, Josh Wexler, with a New Orleans police officer, William Torres.  Wexler watched from his car as Torres ran a stop sign and then struck a pedestrian.


[Wexler] saw a New Orleans police officer run a stop sign and strike a pedestrian with his car in the French Quarter at 12:45 p.m. Jan. 29.

When the pedestrian raised his hands as if to say, “What are you doing?” the officer rushed out of his vehicle and “angrily” grabbed the startled man, Wexler said.

The officer in question, William Torres, reportedly forced the pedestrian to place his hands on the hood of his squad car and reached for his handcuffs as if to arrest him.

This is the natural sequence of events, ambulance optional.  Josh Wexler, being of the sort who would read Balko, chose not to close his eyes and run away, but rather intervene.


He got out of his vehicle and told the officer he saw him run the stop sign and hit the pedestrian. Wexler told Torres he had no right to arrest the man.

At this point, Torres reportedly allowed the pedestrian to go free, directed his attention to Wexler and asked, “Do you want a ticket?”

“A ticket for what?” Wexler said. “I didn’t do anything.”

“It’s a simple question. Yes or no. Do you want a ticket?” Torres reportedly responded.

This again is the natural sequence of events.  Radley’s readers overwhelming praised Wexler’s testicular fortitude.  I join them, though I wonder whether it would have been more effective to call his local news desk and take some video rather than test the good will of William Torres.  As my But For Video posts have sought to make clear, no cop does wrong if there’s no video.  We have yet to move to the place where the word of a citizen prevails in a pissing match with a cop.

The sequence of events is important, because it appears over and over again.  Challenge a police officer and he arrests you, thereby removing your credibility and reducing your complaint to a challenge of his cause for arrest.  It’s taught in cop school.  It’s so basic that even the dumbest cop around knows how to do it. Plus, it’s fun. At least for them.  As Jeff Gamso notes, did you think the cop was going to admit his fault?

Over at Popehat, Ken was reminded by Wexler’s effort of a news shows effort to find out what would happen if a regular person walked into a police station and asked how to complain about a cop. The dialogue is hysterical in its absurdity.  The reason it’s so funny is that we know that the “citizen” is an undercover news guy and that the encounter is being recorded.  If it was real, it wouldn’t be nearly as funny.

The real life follies between cops and citizens is the worst kept secret around. We all know about it.  We’ve all seen the videos.  And yet, it’s as if no one in a position to do anything about it is aware of it at all.  Ask and you’ll get this blank stare and the distinct impression that they are unfamiliar with the concept.  Ken, former prosecutor that he is, says:


You’re free to assume — as unqualified supporters of cop culture tend to — that these are outliers and extreme cases and incongruities and that in most cases cops are perfectly professional when you try to file a complaint. With that level of credulity, you’ll probably wind up as one of my clients.
Within the onion, however, there is recognition of the truth. as well as the need to deny that this is how things work.  If there was acknowledgment that the police have been playing this scam, institutionally, the belief is that it would undermine public trust and support of the police, which would undermine their ability to perform their function, which would render the nation unsafe.  As cops like to say, if you don’t like them, call a criminal the next time you need help.  Of course, that might in fact be good advice.

The truth isn’t that everyone in power doesn’t know this open secret, but that the rationale is false.  As the dirty little secret becomes increasingly undeniable, and it is by dint of videos, blawgs and the efforts of people like Josh Wexler, trust and confidence in the police is increasingly undermined and the tide will change.  When no one can plausibly deny the problem, there will be a shift that compels any credible person in power to confront it.  We may not be there yet, but it will come if we keep the pressure on.

Josh Wexler is a good Samaritan.  William Torres is a mutt.  Thankfully, the mutt didn’t just beat the good Samaritan to a pulp to shut him down. 

Cy Vance Is New York County’s New District Attorney

Not since 1975 has anyone even considered removing the name on the door.  Robert Morgenthau probably could have stayed in the big office until his last breath.  That’s respect. But having fulfilled his obligation to serve the public, and with Leslie Crocker Snyder nipping at his heels, it was time to pass the baton.  He chose Cy Vance, Jr.  So have the people of Manhattan.

With 44% of the vote, as against 30% for Snyder and 26% for Richard Aborn, Cy won the Democratic primary yesterday.  Since no Republican is running, that’s the ball game.  Cy Vance will be the District Attorney, the first new one that most New Yorkers will know in their lifetime.

Cy brings much to the office.  New ideas.  Respect for the City’s demographic make-up, coupled with a recognition that something is fundamentally wrong when 90% of the people stopped and frisked are black or Latino, particularly when only 10% of those stopped and frisked were subsequently arrested.  This doesn’t reflect a safety concern, unless one considers the safety of blacks and Latinos from the police.

Unlike others, Cy has seen life from both sides.  He was a criminal defense lawyer as well as a prosecutor, a point raised by his opponent, former judge Leslie Crocker Snyder, whose judicial career was marked by her harsh sentences and even harsher rhetoric.  That Leslie sought to smear him for doing his job as a defense lawyer tells much about her.  That Cy understood, appreciated and served his clients as a defense lawyer tells much about him. 

Basic to the mindset of every person who has stood beside an accused is an appreciation of the fact that our Constitution is something observed by the police and the courts primarily in the breach.  We know if to be so, and are ever vigilant to be its last defenders.  This can’t be explained to the line prosecutors, who are still too young and green to believe that the fine men and women of the NYPD aren’t always so fine, or always so honest.  But when the boss suggests that they scrutinize their cases, their witnesses, their claims, for impropriety and unfairness, and that the overwhelming assumption will no longer be that the cops are always right, always truthful, there is hope that integrity will flow from the top down.

What I found most persuasive about Cy’s representation that he remembered the lessons learned in the trenches was his proud announcement of his support from the Innocence Project’s Barry Scheck and Peter Neufeld.  Some DA candidates would conceal the endorsement of such people.  Few would court it, or want it.  No, it’s the PBA endorsement they seek, the backing of the cops, who in turn back those who back them.  Business as usual.

Cy embraced the endorsement of Barry and Peter.  That was the clincher.  Even more surprising, Cy welcomed my endorsement, as if it would make a big difference in the vote.  Given what I do for a living, most DA candidates would flee the praise of a criminal defense lawyer.  Cy didn’t.  When he said he was going to be DA for all the people of New York County, he meant it.  I was honored that he cared.

The margin of victory in a three person race, 14%, is huge.  It reflects the desire of the people of Manhattan to have a District Attorney who can not only be trusted to prosecute, but to know when not to prosecute.  It shows that respect for the Constitution, the rights of defendants and supervision of a huge police department that cannot be trusted to honor the Constitution on its own is alive in Manhattan.  New York County rejected the simplistic tough on crime rhetoric of the Leslie Crocker Snyders for the smart on crime and respect for human beings approach of Cy Vance. 

In her congratulatory twit last night, Dr. Sun Wolf wrote:


@CyVanceforDA Congratulations! Do justice, love mercy, walk quietly with your god.
Amen.  Congratulations, District Attorney Vance.