Author Archives: SHG

But What Do Biglaw Children Think?

At Above the Law, David Lat is trying out a new concept for his dedicated fans, almost all of whom are either students on law review determined to land that Biglaw job of their dreams, or young associates determined to keep that Biglaw job of their dreams.  In a public service of sorts, Lat has started a series on “small law,” meaning the practice areas that the inconsequential people practice, like personal injury, real estate, and, oh, criminal.

Aside from his use of an ambulance in the post, the point of which flies right over my head, here’s Lat’s promotion of Personal Injury Law:


But is personal injury getting a bad rap? If you’re a successful PI lawyer, you can make a fortune — all while standing up for “the little guy,” by vindicating the rights of the injured. See, e.g., John Edwards; Philip Corboy (recently honored by his alma mater, Loyola – Chicago, after making a major gift).

Here’s an open thread on personal injury law. Please share information, in the comments, about PI work — what it entails, your hours, your pay, opportunities for advancement, etc. Thanks.


P.S. One of our favorite fellow legal bloggers is a personal injury lawyer: Eric Turkewitz, of the New York Personal Injury Law Blog.

So in its favor is . . . money?  And Turkewitz, who is indeed a walking advertisement for PI, but then we can’t all be the Turk. 

But Lat’s somewhat lackluster support for PI law is nothing compared with the thoughts of his readers, I use the word “thoughts” in its broadest sense.  My favorite is comment 30 :


I went to a top 10 law school. Why on earth would I want to use my expensive law degree to do something that anyone can do?

But other prefer comment 11 :


Although working in personal injury would allow an aspiring lawyer to accrue mass wealth (unlikely, considering that they are in personal injury as a result of working insufficiently hard earlier in life), it is not worth the metamorphosis into a parasite that would result from said work.

Incidentally, I do covetable legal work at my father’s preeminent peer law firm.
The problem here, by the way, isn’t Lat’s facial snarkiness about the subject of “small law.”  He’s actually trying, within the confines of his audience.  The problem here is the attitude of the audience.  Think about this the next time a wave of Biglaw layoffs roll around and some of their refugees get hungry enough to ask for a job.

And just so we’re clear, I would be curious to know whether anyone who commented on the post at ATL thinks they can try a case, or whether they think they’ll win because they have the biggest mouth when commenting anonymously.

The Sound of Silence

My case was advanced so that we could appear before the court to take a plea.  It was a good plea; my client wanted it and I agreed that it was the right thing to do.  We were there before the courtroom doors opened so that I could sign the case up right away.  In this court part, arriving late meant that you spent the better part of the morning waiting for your case to be called.  The early bird definitely got the worm, and I would be out of there as quickly as possible.

The case was called and the perquisite words were spoken.  There was a disposition. The calendar assistant added the necessary charge to the complaint and spelled out the details.  And the judge then turned to me, as it was my turn to speak the mantra of the plea.

Silence.  I totally blanked.  For the life of me, I couldn’t remember the mantra.  There was a terrible silence.

Then, it came back me, and I mouthed the required words to withdraw the previously entered plea of not guilty and enter a plea of guilty to the new charge.  Everything went along as usual, and the deal was done.

As I left the courthouse, I was appalled that I had forgotten the mantra.  This is the second thing one learns in the trenches, right after the routine not guilty plea at an arraignment.  And then I realized the problem.  I hadn’t done a state court plea in years.  I suddenly felt a swell of pride, that I couldn’t actually remember the last state court plea I had done. 

It’s not that I’m “too good” to plead my clients guilty.  That would be a ridiculously foolish idea.  There are certainly times, and case, where a plea is the appropriate outcome and in the client’s best interest.  It’s just that guilty pleas are a last resort, a worst case scenario, most of the time, and something that I try very hard to avoid. 

To the young buck in the courtroom, I imagine that my silence when the mantra was supposed to come out of my mouth might be taken as a sign that I might not have known what I was doing.  After all, every young buck learns the mantra right away.  I hope that they instead might take my silence as a sign that the guilty plea mantra isn’t what being a criminal defense lawyer is all about.  Maybe they shouldn’t learn the mantra right away.  Maybe it shouldn’t be so ingrained in their heads that they could repeat the mantra in their sleep.

That’s my hope.  But I don’t think that’s what ran through their heads.  After all, it is the mantra.

Rakoff’s Revenge: When It’s Time To Say “No”

The SEC hasn’t been doing too well lately.  After the revelation that it was played for a fool during five separate investigations into Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, it’s now had it’s head ripped off by SDNY Judge Jed Rakoff.  The plea deal cut with Bank of America to dispose of charges that it lied to its shareholders about $5.8 billion in bonuses paid to Merrill Lynch executes required that BOA pay a fine of $33 million.  Of course, that money won’t come from the pockets of the folks who did the lying.

Judge Rakoff, who had to approve the deal, was less than thrilled:


It is not fair, first and foremost, because it does not comport with the most elementary notions of justice and morality, in that it proposes that the shareholders who were the victims of the Bank’s alleged misconduct now pay the penalty for that misconduct. . . . [T]he notion that Bank of America shareholders, having been lied to blatantly in connection with the multi-billion-dollar purchase of a huge, nearly-bankrupt company, need to lose another $33 million of their money in order to “better assess the quality and performance of management” is absurd.

He rejected the deal and set a trial date.  A roar was heard across Foley Square.  Now one might suspect, aside from some BOA executives and some really red-faced SEC lawyers, that everyone with half a brain would be thrilled by Judge Rakoff’s principled rejection of the deal (Mike at C certainly was impressed), both from the perspective of “notions of justice and morality,” seldom considered notions in rubber stamping deals, and that someone finally took corporate executives and their very close friends at the SEC to task a year after the Lehman Brothers collapse.

Well, not everyone.  Over at Conglomerate, David Zaring stands up for the downtrodden, the SEC lawyers,calling Judge Rakoff’s rejection of the deal “posturing”.

The good judge just turned down the plea deal between the SEC and BofA on its communications with shareholders on the Merrill deal.  And he set a trial date.  I of course think highly of Rakoff, and know that judges have to approve consent decrees that involve future judicial oversight (which makes for plenty of approvals, as they almost all do), but I’ve never understood this sort of posturing.  The parties aren’t going to go to trial, and the fact that the SEC would like to come back to court if BofA fails to meet the terms of its deal is hardly a great way in to close judicial supervision of those terms.  After all, what else is the SEC supposed to do, throw up its hands?  What if divorce courts started doing something similar?

Where’s the deference, Zaring demands to know.


When I was a government lawyer and I ran into angry judges for this or that reason, I always wanted a showdown.  “Fine, judge, dismiss the case, because we aren’t trying it,” I dreamed myself saying, or “go ahead, hold the United States in contempt, I dare you, but we’re doing things the way we want to, not they way you want to.”  My superiors always overruled me, thankfully for the rule of law, but really, parsing deals like Rakoff is doing here does no one any good.  Even if he just wants to change the fine and get more disclosures out of it all.  I prefer our litigant-driven system of justice to what they have in, you know, France.
Forget about the whole collusion aspect, the pocket agency, the friendly deal.  Forget that the SEC is a government agency whose existence is to protect the public, and that this deal stinks from the word “go” by making the victims pay the fine for the harm done them.  If the SEC says so, who is Judge Rakoff to say “boo”.  Really, this is the myopic view of the almighty government lawyer, certain that his “litigant-driven” system entitles a lawyer with a government ID to do as he pleases.

But Zaring’s real issue doesn’t appear to be the rejection of the plea deal per se, but that Rakoff set the matter down for trial.  As he says, the SEC isn’t going to trial.  Why?  Because they don’t wanna. That’s why they cut the deal, duh. 

There’s a reason all that money is spent on building courthouses, with their marble hallways and wood-paneled courtrooms.  It’s to try cases.  If BOA executives lied to its shareholders in order to scam their approval of a deal, then this is the place to resolve it if the people who did wrong are to be held accountable.  The fact that the SEC found a quick and dirty way around the problem, that the particular individuals who engaged in the fraud will shift their liability to the shareholder victims is not a reason to avoid a trial.  That the SEC lawyers don’t really want to be put to the test of trial means that we need new SEC lawyers. 

Zaring calls for deference, but there is a threshold of sanity that must be met before one hands over decision-making to some collusive deal that is so fundamentally absurd that it’s laughable.  What if the prosecution and defense cut a plea in a rape case that required the victim of the rape to serve the time?  But the prosecution agreed, so they are due deference, right?

That Judge Rakoff’s eminently sane rejection of this deal comes under attack for its failure to let the SEC have its way reflects a fundamental misapprehension by the SEC of its reason for being.  It exists neither to serve the financial industry, as friend and protector, nor to meet the expectations of lawyers who are, for a brief period in their career, in its employ.  And thankfully, Judge Rakoff said “no”. 

Zaring may be absolutely correct that the SEC lacks the gumption to go to trial, and won’t be forced into the well no matter what Judge Rakoff orders.  But that’s an indictment of the SEC as well as Bank of America.  Maybe we’ll need two trial dates instead of one,

Baby You Can Drive My Car (Update)

A bit of a dispute broke out on twitter when @AlexisNeely, who now bills herself as “America’s favorite lawyer,” twitted, “Anyone know how the mommy bloggers score free cars in exchange for review/blogging?”

Brian Cuban then took her to task for blogger payola, though acknowledging that if she could find anybody “desperate enough” to give her a free car, more power to her.

After watching some interviews with mommy bloggers on GMA, where they explained how baby companies were sending them stuff, expensive stuff like strollers and toys, for them to review and, as expected, to promote, I found the issue of blogger payola quite fascinating.  Do bloggers carry enough clout to be worthy of bribes? 

I review books occasionally, and the books are sent to me for that purpose and without charge.  Amy I guilty of blogger payola?  Perhaps.  Of course, as my reviews show, the fact that I don’t buy the books hasn’t inhibited me from panning them.  But I suppose that I should make clear that I received something for free.

I’m with Alexis on this one, and Brian too.  Send me a free car and I’ll tell you what I think.  I’ll let you know that it was a freebie too, but just send me the car and we’ll work out the details.  As a blawger, I write about a somewhat broad variety of things, and might persuade someone to give a product a chance.  So send me stuff. 

The fact is that blawging doesn’t net the blawger much of anything, aside from a few free books.  That clients don’t flock to blawgers (the claims of marketers notwithstanding) has been discussed to death,  We aren’t invited to A-list parties.  We aren’t even invited to E-list parties.  Sometimes, we’re not even invited to our own family’s parties, but that’s a different issue.

So if manufacturers, retailers, whoever, want to spread the word about their products, why not bloggers?  And if they are looking to sell to the demographic that reads blawgs, as opposed to those who have a keen interest in baby strollers, why not law blogs?  We likely reflect an very desirable demographic, though it will be hard to quantify the numbers per se.  And we use stuff, and there’s no reason why we can’t post a review about the items that readers might be interested in purchasing.

As to disclosure, as well as honesty, I don’t see an issue.  If it’s free, then we should say so.  The credibility of the review is less dependent on the price paid (or not paid) as it is on the credibility of the blawger.  If someone should send me a free, oh, Mercedes Benz SLS Gullwing (hint) and I hate it, you’ll know.  Besides, if I already have the car, it’s not like they can take it back.

Let’s face it, blawging is a relatively thankless thing to do externally.  What would be so terrible about getting a little vig for the effort, provided that we play it straight and maintain transparency?  So if anybody wants to reach my readers, feel free to send me stuff at will.  I don’t promise I’ll like it.  I can’t say that my review will sell a million of ’em.  But it certainly seems worth a try. 

I’ll be waiting at the front door for the car to arrive.  Holding my breath.  Turning blue.  Don’t make me wait too long.

H/T Bennett

Update:  Naturally, the very same day that I write that blawgers don’t get invited to A-list, or even E-list, parties, what do I get but an invite to a party at Christiane Amanpour’s house because of my blawging.  That’s pretty cool.  But I still want the free car.

Two Agents and a Hacker Go to a Bar

If you’ve followed Patrick at Popehat for any length of time, you will know that he’s got a short fuse.  Not a bad fuse, but a short one.  He’s not the sort of guy one would want to piss off.  But some telemarketer who called himself “Brian” did so, and riled Patrick up real good with just two words.  Bad move.

It seems that Brian called Patrick from “card services.”  You know “card services,” this nice folks who call each and every one of us regularly to let us know that they can reduce our credit card interest rates.  These fine and helpful people, along with the nice people who want to extend our auto warranty, have a recorded message requiring us to hit 1 to speak with a representative.  Most of the time, if the wrong word comes out of your mouth first, the next sound you hear is “click”.  I always say the wrong thing when I press 1, because I always hear “click”.  They do not seem to have much respect for the federal “do not call” registry.

Patrick said the wrong thing as well, but he didn’t hear click.  Instead, he heard two words that still resonate in his ears. The sound is not pleasing.

Patrick says he’s determined to find the nice folks at card services and make them unhappy.  He’s got a number on his caller ID, but I suspect he won’t find anyone at the other end of the phone in Omaha.  The word is that these people hang out in the Orlando, Florida area.  Apparently, this is where they train for gainful employment at Disney World.

The question I have is somewhat different than Patrick’s.  I don’t ask where they are so I can fly down to Florida on the next Airbus, rent a wreck to drive to their boiler room and beat the living daylights out of Brian.  Rather, I wonder why, given that these folks seem to call, well, everyone there is on a daily basis, no one from our federal government has seen fit to shut them down. 

Sure, this isn’t a terrible crime in the sense of murder or possession of cartoon pornography, but still it seems to be beyond the ability of the ordinary citizen to fix, and in violation of a few federal laws.  Of course, it can have some very harmful consequences, whether by tying up a phone line when needed in an emergency, or interrupting something critical under the mistaken belief that the call is legitimate.  But it’s the pervasiveness of the problem that seems to demand that it be dealt with.  Few issues affect as many people as this, a credit to autodialing.

My guess is that the government is far too busy doing border searches for terrorists and pornographers to spend its time tracking down telemarketers.  I can well understand, given the danger pornographers present to our homeland security, but doubt that it would really require that much of a dedication of scarce resources that it couldn’t be done.

Here’s my thought.  All that would be needed is two special agents and a geek, preferably a hacker.  The two agents will only be needed for the collar and processing; they don’t bring much else to the table.  The government need only create a contest for geeks to locate the source of these telemarketing calls, sifting through the fake telephone numbers to their home server, and making it blow up.  Then the agents swoop in and cuff the big guys, who are likely an unattractive married couple.  It seems like it’s always an unattractive married couple doing this sort of stuff.

And you really wouldn’t have to offer much of a prize to the geek to who did the dirty work.  A nice badge for the website and bragging rights would likely be all the incentive they need.  Hacking is less a matter of reward than the pride of being able to beat the system.

If this seems too much trouble, how about finding out where the credit card money went from those where are taken in by these telemarketers.  Hard as it is to imagine, somebody has to actually agree to pay these nice folks or they would be forced to go back to their day jobs at Dairy Queen.

It just strikes me that even though these telemarketing calls are more annoyance than anything else, anything that annoys essentially everyone in the country, including Patrick, might be worthy of a little attention.  Come on, government.  You can find a crime for pretty much everyone.  You can fix this.  I know you can.

Cash And Carry Expert (Update)

There once was a time when people chose to be lawyers for a reason.  They wanted to defend criminals, or put them away. They wanted to try cases.  Their mother or father was a lawyer.  The reasons are endless; but the reason wasn’t to make money any way they could. 

Lawyers sometimes ended up in a practice area they didn’t anticipate. Life just worked out that way.  If they found that they enjoyed it and were good at it, great.  If not, they struggled to find their way into a different practice area.  Not everybody is cut out to be a litigator.  Not everybody is cut out to be a transactional lawyer.  Hey, we’re people. We have things we prefer to do, just like everybody else. Nothing wrong with that.

Once we found a niche in law that suited us, we worked at it. We developed the skills necessary to do our job well, to know our business.  After all, what good is a lawyer who lacks the capability of performing within his niche?  Worse still, clients would entrust this niche lawyer with their needs, and if the lawyer couldn’t produce, then he would fail to serve his clients adequately.  This is the antithesis of performing a lawyer’s duty, the taking of a fee from a client without the ability to deliver the quality of services promised.  This is law at its worst.

This is why I found Adrianos Faschetti’s post at Grant Griffith’s ignominiously-named Blog for Profit deeply disturbing.  Adrianos explains the background:


The thought of becoming an “expert” in 6 months may seem impossible to you. But I did it and I’m going to show you how.
But first let me share my story with you a bit because I think it’s instructive.

It all started in March of 2008.

I was struggling to make ends meet as a solo attorney and I was desperately trying to find a way to finally break through and make a better living. I did just about everything you can think of to generate income from typical networking to ‘harassing’ attorneys in the courthouse to rustle up some work.

I was at a really low point in my life. There is nothing like knowing that you have a lot to offer others and at the same time consistently finding it difficult to pay the bills.

I am certainly sympathetic, having long been critical of those who lie to struggling lawyers that solo practice is a panacea, pushing them away from unpleasant, albeit paying, work at firms and businesses and into solo practice with false promises of success and work/life balance.  Hungry lawyers become desperate lawyers, and desperate lawyers do foolish things.

Adrianos’ solution was to reinvent himself into an “expert”.  In his case, it was “internet defamation law,” the product of having been retained to handle an internet defamation case. 


I got hired to handle an Internet Defamation case.

That happened less than 2 years ago and now people call me from all over the United States seeking my advice on Internet Defamation. I don’t say this to brag. I say this to motivate you to find your own wonderful obsession and to share it with others.

Now I know some of you might be thinking, “I thought you would show us how to become an expert in 6 months. You’ve been doing this for 2 years!”

Let me be clear. I believe I became an “expert” on the subject in less than 6 months because I studied it like crazy and few people knew anything about it. However, I certainly became an expert within 6 months because Google said I was.

And one thing is for sure: You are what Google says you are.


Had Adrianos stopped before the penultimate sentence, I would applaud him.  While I’m not a fan of lawyers taking on causes which they are not already equipped to handle, at least his response was to study “like crazy.”  There are few substantive areas of law that can’t be learned by a reasonably intelligent lawyer sufficiently to provide competent representation. 

But Adrianos didn’t stop there.  His final sentence that blew me away:


And one thing is for sure: You are what Google says you are.


My alternate title for this post was, “I’m not really an expert; I just play one on the internet.”  Therein lies the fault, and a fatal fault it is.  What the balance of Adrianos’ post promotes isn’t the creation of expertise from hard work and study, but the creation of the appearance of expertise through manipulation of information. 

One might think that this is something he might prefer to keep under wraps rather than lay out on writing for the whole world to see, but there’s no reticence here to let everyone know that he’s elevated appearance over reality.  This is the marketer’s perspective.  Truth be damned, it’s all about appearances.

Adrianos gives a list of things he did on his path to becoming an “expert”.  The list isn’t exactly bad, or wrong for that matter, though there are some nits to pick.  For example, his first item is to select the right niche.  Absolutely.  But his right isn’t based upon finding a practice area you care about or are particularly good at.  It’s about finding a niche where you can cash in.


I chose Internet Defamation for a number of reasons:



  • I noticed that almost no one was writing about it. And even the blogs that did discuss Internet Defamation only did so on occasion (it wasn’t the main focus of the blog).
  • Internet Defamation seemed to be a common problem that had potential for growth. I saw that more and more businesses were going online (duh) and that more and more people were venting their frustrations about people/businesses online.
  • I knew I could master the subject in a short period of time because it was new. The internet as we know it is only about 15 or 16 years old. It’s not as if I was aiming to learn everything about securities law or real property law (which has been developed over a much longer period of time). This made it easy for me to become an “expert” in the subject.
  • I liked the subject. You don’t need to like something to master it, but it’s a lot more fun that way.

Notice his fourth reason,where Adrianos goes out of his way to state that you need not “like” your niche.  He had the opportunity to state that it was critical, when choosing your new “expertise”, to pick one that moved you.  After all, you could spend the rest of your working life doing it, and caring about your practice area could spell the difference between a life of professional satisfaction and misery.  The lure of easy expertise was enough to eschew whether one cared. 

His third item was to start a blog, about which he wrote:


This is obvious so I won’t spend a lot of time on it. Starting a blog on California Defamation forced me to learn about the subject. This forced me to become an expert on the subject. You should start a blog too if you haven’t already.

Cart, meet horse.  By definition, creating a blawg in a practice area suggests some degree of knowledge. Maybe even expertise.  What it does not suggest is that you know essentially nothing whatsoever about the practice area and will learn about it as you post.  It presents two analogous flaws.  First, the posts may well be wrong, and the blawger is providing misleading or erroneous information to others.  Second, the posts will serve as announcement to those who have a clue that you are by no means an expert.  It’s one thing to be thought of as an idiot. It’s another to put it in writing and conclusively prove it.

Assuming the purpose of a blog is to market, they are not means to becoming an expert. Blogs are means of using and displaying expertise already acquired.  For those of us legally entitled to use the title “attorney” and suggest to the public some modicum of specialized knowledge, doing so when we know we lack any is not merely ill-advise, but deceptive.  We know that we can pretend to be experts and to offer opinions that others may be inclined to believe, but we do not do so.  It’s wrong.

Adrianos next provides some sound advice on how to ingratiate oneself with others on the internet who can help you.



I suggest sending them a tweet letting them know how much you enjoyed one of their blog posts (only if this is sincere). The question I often ask myself is, “if I had nothing to gain from this, would I still do it?”

Another good idea is to offer to write a guest post. But make sure it is better than what you usually write on your own blog. If the guest post is well-received, you will gain the respect of the blogger.

The great thing about approaching internet relationships this way is that it will draw you to people who are knowledgeable, likable, and interesting. And if the feeling is mutual it will eventually lead to opportunities down the road.

I certainly made the right friends and they have helped me in so many ways. They’ve helped me with technical problems. They’ve helped me stay focused and inspired. They’ve given me marketing advice. They’ve invited me to speak at public events. They’ve given me a kick in the pants when I needed it. They’ve promoted my work. Why did they do all this?

What’s unfortunate about this advice is that it reveals that Adrianos didn’t focus on meeting defamation lawyers, but rather internet gurus and marketers.  This is a function of misdirected focus.  Remember, you are what Google says you are.  This conflation of expertise with the appearance of expertise left Adrianos connecting with those who could facilitate his appearance rather than his being an expert.  Acceptance as an expert by those accomplished in a field of law is more difficult than acceptance by those trying to sell you their services.  The latter can be had easily.  Regardless of whether they befriend you, they are available on a cash and carry basis.

Curiously, it appears that Adrianos did so many of the right things for the wrong reasons.  Hidden within his post are the details that reflect his accomplishments, selecting a niche that he cared about and was interested in, and working hard to learn the substantive aspects of his new-found niche.  While these by no means establish “expertise” in fact, they are certainly on the path.

However, the whole of the post presents a dangerous, and damning, proposition, that one can create the fictional appearance of expertise on the internet in 5 easy steps in 6 months.  The fact is that Adrianos is quite right, the internet is awash in people who have fabricated the appearance of “expertise”, and most people can’t tell the difference between those who possess the expertise they claim and those who are total frauds.  Indeed, many of the most prominent frauds have aggregated their voices to create a hosanna chorus around each other,  carefully protecting each other so that no one will learn of the sham.

And most in the blawgoshere will applaud Adrianos’ post at Grant Griffith’s Blog for Profit, a name the speaks volumes, while hating me for being critical.  They want a quick and dirty road to success.  I only offer hard work.  Boo, Greenfield.

Update:  Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, addresses the other aspect of Adrianos’ post, what it really means to be an “expert”.  Hint: It’s not six months of blogging.

Even Contracts Have Limits

Contrary to popular belief, mother is not always right.  From the Albany Times-Union :



The mother of a 19-year-old man and the mother of a 13-year-old girl thought they would avoid legal problems if they signed an agreement that allowed their children to have a romantic relationship, Schenectady police said.


[Shawn] German of Hulett Street is charged with second-degree rape and a host of other charges for allegedly having the relationship with the girl.
 

His mother, Tracy A. Lisi, 38, and the other woman, whose identity is not being released by police because they said it would identify her daughter, an alleged sex crime victim, were both charged with child endangerment.


Police said the two women knew the age difference between German and the girl could pose legal problems so they created the agreement signing off on the match.
It doesn’t strike me as being necessary to discuss at length why the mothers involved are, oh, sick.  It’s a stretch to suggest that either one should have procreated, but that issue seems to have an inversely proportional relationship with good judgment.

What is fascinating is that these two moms, apparently all on their own, recognized that there might be a little legal issue with the plan, and came up with the notion that they could solve it by contract.  The law fixes everything.  Perhaps they have access to the internet, and sufficient wherewithal to type in basic letters to arrive at what they perceived to be a legal solution to their dilemma, how to authorize a 19 year old boy to have sex with a 13 year old girl.  I wonder what the Google search looked like.  What are the chances they ended up at Popehat, where so many sexual/legal inquiries seem to go.

Maybe they happened upon one of those free lawyer answer websites and learned all about the intersection of contracts and committing crimes?  Maybe they went to Legalzoom and bought a basic do-it-yourself contract for sex with a child.  The article doesn’t say.  A copy of the contract would have been helpful, to see how well drafted it was.  Even if it wasn’t up to Ken Adams’ standards, it might have been a darn good try.

But for all those who think that there’s no particular need to have a clue what you’re doing when it comes to the law, and advocate self-help and one size fits all, let this be a bit of a warning.  There remains a certain element of knowledge and judgment in the practice of law that people inclined to contract away their 13 year old’s sexual favors might lack.  Maybe everybody shouldn’t be their own lawyer.

H/T Poet Emeritus David Giacalone

How To Succeed In Law School. Maybe

Paul Horowitz, with whom I rarely disagree, urges law students to be themselves rather than “package” themselves to appeal to individual professors, in this post at PrawfsBlawg.  In other words, don’t try to game the system.


A little of this advice is useful to some extent: if your professor says, for instance, that she wants you to cover all the issues on an exam rather than delve into a few at great detail, you’d do well to listen.  But students who think this approach is the best or most efficient way to yield good grades are, I think, quite mistaken.  This approach yields few long-term benefits and only uncertain short-term benefits.

These students are not trying to suit the preferences of Professor X or Professor Y; they are simply trying to be good lawyers (or at least good law students).  They develop a skill set that gets them far better results, and with less duplication of effort, than if they had tried to game the system by figuring out each individual professor’s pecadilloes.

While this advice would meet with Pollyanna’s approval, and the suggestion that students would do better to strive to learn how to be a “good lawyer,” it reflects one of the fundamental errors of legal pedagogy as opposed to practical efficacy.  Good lawyers win cases.  Good lawyers figure out what they have to do to win cases.  Good lawyers, amongst other things, learn about their judge, find out what arguments appeal to the specific individual who will be making decisions in their case, and hone their arguments to suit the person in the robe.

The difference in opinion here goes to the difference in function.  A scholar may view the law as he would want it to be, as he will argue it should be. regardless of whether it will produce the desired outcome or not.  It’s a conceptual approach rather than concrete.  Lawyers don’t have this luxury.  No matter how brilliant our analysis and argument, at least in our own minds, the bottom line is that we’ve either prevailed for our client or not.  No defendant goes happily to prison because we’ve taken the high intellectual road.

Gaming the system, while not the way I would explain it, is a skill that practicing lawyers must develop if they hope to serve their clients.  In a comment to Horwitz’s post, Orin Kerr (who, by the way, has added his name to the caboose of the LaFave, Israel, King, and Kerr Criminal Justice hornbook) makes this point:


Telling professors what they want to hear is not only of significant help in getting high grades, it also teaches an essential skill of lawyering: The student who learns how to tailor a message to Professor X to get an A becomes the lawyer who knows how to tailor a legal argument to Judge Y to win summary judgment.

Of course, the trick is actually knowing what the Professor wants to hear: With some professors that means matching their ideology, but with some professors it means something else. Therein lies the difficulty.
It would be wonderful if practicing lawyers could ignore the vicissitudes of judges and focus instead on the loftier purposes of the law, secure in the knowledge that the judge will ignore his perspective and prejudice, recognize a well-conceived and intellectually honest position and rule in its favor.  But for those lawyers who will practice on earth, serving the client in the face of bone-headed judge comes first.  Our job is not to be right, but to win.

What a great way to teach law students this very pragmatic, and very important, lesson.  Don’t pass it up.


Book Preview: Ordinary Injustice

I’ve begun reading Amy Bach’s new book, Ordinary Injustice, How America Holds Court.  She’s had me by the end of the introduction. 

When I’m done, I’ll write a proper review, but I’m just so darned excited about the book that I want to post something immediately.  This is the first book I’ve ever read that is steely clear that the failure of our the criminal justice system isn’t found in the spectacular but the mundane.  It’s our routine, the acceptance of doing things the way they’ve always been done, moving people through the system like cattle and shrugging off the details that distinguish justice from the assembly line.

Amy Bach has a post up at Huff Po which gives a slight, though somewhat misleading, view of what she’s up to.  In this teaser piece, she talks about a few of the higher profile cases reflecting failure of the system.  This really doesn’t reflect what she does in the book, which avoids the low hanging fruit of big time failures for the less gaudy, but infinitely more pervasive, banal failures.

Consider:


Ordinary Injustice results when a community of legal professionals becomes so accustomed to a pattern of lapses that they can no longer see their role in them.  There are times when an alarming miscarriage of justice does come to light, and exposes the complacency within the system, but in such instances the public often blames a single player, be it a judge, a prosecutor, or a defense attorney. 

While it is convenient to isolate misconduct, targeting an individual only obscures what is truly going on from the scrutiny change requires. The system involves too many players to hold only one accountable for the routine injustice happening in courtrooms across America.
Never has it been said so clearly, and so well.  Ordinary Injustice has the potential to be the wake-up call that all of us involved in the criminal justice system need.   Bach leaves no one in the system untouched, as well she shouldn’t. 

While I will withhold judgment until I’ve finished the book, my reading thus far leads me to believe that this book is the real McCoy, and that Amy Bach has nailed it. I had almost given up on book review, having read a number of books which appeared to have great promise, only to be sorely disappointed that the content failed to live up to its promise.  This doesn’t appear to be the case with Ordinary Injustice.  It’s already surpassed my expectations.

This book could be the “must read” we’ve been waiting for.  I just thought you ought to know.