Author Archives: SHG

Too Much Information

While this will come as a shock to some, writing a blawg requires a great deal of restraint.  It’s awfully easy to use it as a mechanism to vent about one’s day to day feelings, whether misery or elation.  Doing so often requires some explanation of the day’s activities, not to mention provides the reader with some clue as to why the writer is feeling that particular way.

While this may be fine for the basement pundit, it’s not acceptable for a lawyer.  We cannot blawg about our cases, our clients.  It’s that darned confidentiality thing, as an Illinois public defender found out the hard way.  From Legal Profession Blog :



Between June 2007, and April 2008, Respondent wrote and published an Internet web log (“blog”) entitled “The Bardd (sic) Before the Bar – Irreverant (sic) Adventures in Life, Law, and Indigent Defense.” Approximately one-third of the blog was devoted to discussing Respondent’s work at the public defender’s office and her clients, and the remaining content of the blog concerned Respondent’s health issues and her photography and bird-watching hobbies. In the work-related blogs, Respondent referred to her clients by either their first name, a derivative of their first name, or by their jail identification number.
The charges go on to note the details, as well as the PDs involvement in not correcting a client’s fraud before the court.  It runs the gamut from stupid to incredibly stupid.  Not having read the blog, I will venture a guess that it included plenty of non-stupid stuff as well, but that doesn’t do much to explain what happened here.

Much of the criticism of the public defender, who is named in the charges but will not be mentioned here, is for her inclusion of the first name of clients or their jail ID.  How foolish could she be to provide such obvious identifying information, critics assert.

Nonsense.  How foolish could she be to post about her clients at all.  Even though names and ID numbers enable even the least connected reader to figure out who she’s talking about, mere descriptions of cases or scenarios would be fully adequate to apprise those who are familiar with her cases, like cops or prosecutors, to identify the people in her posts.  How dare she expose her clients in any way whatsoever.

Confidentiality is not a joke.  Confidentiality belongs to the client, not the lawyer.  It is not up to us to decide whether disclosure matters, or what’s appropriate to disclose and what’s not.  We are entrusted with information about human beings, and public discussion of these human beings carries huge risks of breach.  There is a very clear way to avoid undermining the confidentiality of those who entrust us with their personal and private information: Don’t disclose it.  Not at all. Not even a little bit.

People have occasionally questioned why I never write about my own cases or clients.  This is why. 

It’s not that I don’t have feelings about them, or great examples of points I make via the stories of others.  I’ve got a ton of ’em.  But they aren’t my stories to tell.  No matter how strong the urge to let you know about the case I worked on today, I can’t.  I won’t.  Sure, I could change the names of the “innocent”, or fudge the details sufficiently to conceal the specifics from the unwary, but there is always the chance that my adversary will read the post, put two and two together and end up with 17.  Today’s innocuous comments are tomorrow’s confessions.  While perhaps extreme, why would I even conceivably take a risk with my client to provide a reader with a mildly curious anecdote.  Not that I don’t appreciate my readers, but my duty to my client comes first.  Way first.

That the “respondent” is a public defender may also be seen as an element of the problem here, as if PDs either have a lesser duty of confidentiality toward their clients, or just don’t care as much.  I refuse to accept the latter, and the former is facially wrong.  We are all lawyers and have precisely the same duty toward our clients.  If there is a lack of personal connection based upon volume and limited communication, then there is only one answer.  Get over it.

Blawging is fun.  It can be informative.  It’s a great way to spend a few minutes.  But it is neither a justification for disclosing client confidences, nor a free pass for the ethically challenged.  Don’t post about your clients or your cases.  Even those of you who want to lie to the public to get business, fabricating false stories of great victories in case after case.  It will come back to haunt you.  It should come back to haunt you, and if you do post out of school, I hope it does.

Refuse in Vein; Cops To Draw Blood (Update)

Under the carefully balanced regimen to collect evidence of drunk driving, a police officer can request that a driver submit to a breathalyser test and a driver can refuse.  If the driver refuses, there is a giveback that he will lose his driving privileges for a period of time as well as have his refusal available for use as evidence against him.  For anyone still wondering how the trade-off plays out, no cop stopped for drunk driving has ever agreed to blow unless he was certain he would pass.

Apparently, this regimen isn’t good enough anymore in the war against drunk driving.  From the “>Idaho Press-Tribune, via Packratt at Injustice Everywhere :

Nampa police are being trained so they can take blood draws in the field to determine whether drivers are under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

Sgt. Matthew Pavelek said in a news release Monday the Police Department recently took part in a program that trains officers to be qualified phlebotomists — blood-draw technicians. The training is funded by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and is presented by the College of Western Idaho.

Pavelek said that by having police officers trained to take blood, they are able to conduct blood draws on suspected DUI motorists who do not consent to breath or other chemical testing during impaired-driver related investigations.

The consequence for refusal to blow into the magic black box just became a whole lot more serious.  The point of the program is to reduce the cost of obtaining a blood test by eliminating the middle man, the cost of having the blood test done at a hospital, and allowing the cop on the street to do it himself.

The article makes no mention, but I would assume that a search warrant would still be required before a police officer would be permitted to stick a needle in anyone’s arm.  I’m going to proceed on this assumption because the alternative is unthinkable.  Given that the Washington State Supreme Court has just upheld the use of forced blood testing pursuant to a warrant, it seems to be the trend.  Whether it’s a better trend than forced catheterization is a personal matter.

On one level, this spells the death of refusal.  Whereas our right to say no was once part of a arguably balanced scheme designed to allow the individual some measure of personal freedom, it now succumbs to forced intrusion into our veins at the hands of the police.  While a warrant requirement might remove some taint of police use at will, these warrants will be provided over the phone, ex parte.  You can bet that the call won’t be made to the judge who is inclined to scrutinize such applications, if there is such a judge, and that the carefully scripted mantra to obtain a warrant will be memorized by every officer on the road.  In other words, don’t expect many warrants to be refused.

But consider the image of roadside blood draws on dash cam videos.  Whether it’s mom with three kids in the minivan, or grandma moving too slowly, or a large man unhappy about being stopped, the vision of police officers thrusting a needle into the arm of the suspect is shocking.  It’s hard enough to find a vein and draw blood under normal circumstances.  At least it’s hygienic in a hospital.  Picture it with a struggling suspect on the roadside.

In the quest to eliminate drunk driving, the tools are expanding as the rights are diminishing.  Whether this tool is too reminiscent of Marathon Man, too painful and potentially harmful, has yet to be seen, though its potential for error and abuse is palpable.  And the liability may dwarf even the handiest of law enforcement tools, the taser.

Is there no line beyond which the zeal to nail drunk drivers won’t cross?  While the MADD activists will invoke the image of dead children to justify the forced roadside blood draws, this won’t bring much comfort to the driver forcibly held on the ground while a cop jabs a needle in his arm.

And if this goes too far when it comes to drunk drivers, imagine how it will be for those who pissed off a cop and are “tested” to remind them who’s boss?  This is a very bad idea, and I hope one that finally pushes the envelope too far.

Update:  And the New York Times catches up to this story.  Some additional background, and note the simplistic explanation of Schmerber (per Gamso’s comment).  The Times story also makes clear that this isn’t about the officer taking the suspect to the hospital to draw blood, but doing it on the spot:

I would imagine that a lot of people would be wary of having their blood drawn by an officer on the hood of their police vehicle,” said Steve Oberman, chairman of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers’ committee on driving while intoxicated.

Once they are back on patrol in Nampa, in southwestern Idaho, they will draw blood from any suspected drunken driver who refuses a breath test. They will use force if necessary, including getting help from another officer to pin down a suspect, Ms. Watson said.

There’s a roadside image for you, not to mention an interesting trade-off of law enforcement versus the right not to have the government stick a needle in your arm.

The High Price of Free Speech

By all accounts, oral argument before the Supreme Court in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission did not go well for the proponents of McCain-Feingold and limitations on corporate cash overwhelming the political process.  Even the New York Times has given up the ghost of anticipating a ruling that would prohibit corporate contributions from corrupting politics, begging instead for a decision limited to the rather peculiar facts of the case, that it acceptable for big money to fund Hillary, The Movie, for broadcast on pay per view.

While there is certainly a conceptual ledge to stop the slide down the slippery slope of unfettered free speech when it comes to corporate political funding, there is similarly a purist’s concern that gaming free speech to inhibit its exercise by those who can, and will, corrupt politics hits at the heart of this fundamental right.  On the one hand, multinational corporate cash does not reflect the political speech of people, and may well represent the ideological views of foreigners who own the corporations, and clearly dwarfs, and thus minimizes if not undermines, the ability of individuals to exercise their right to political speech.  All this is certainly true, even though the conservative wing of the court appears to ignore it.

The conservatives also seemed incredulous that vast amounts of corporate money flooding into campaigns could be seen as corrupting the system. We agree with Senator John McCain, who told reporters after the argument that he was troubled by the “extreme naïveté” some of the justices showed about the role of special-interest money in Congressional lawmaking.
And yet, it remains free speech.  Who says rich people can’t exercise their rights because they can do so more effectively than poor people? It may not feel fair, but as the philosopher, Reb Tevya said, it’s no crime to be rich.

Assuming that the Supremes will strike down limitations on corporate spending and, in the name of the First Amendment, open politics in the United States to any and every influence big money can exert, will that trigger the end of democracy as we know it?  Will the influence of individuals, of interest groups long on will and short on cash, be drowned out by well produced movies, television commercials, radio ads, all the media conventions that big money can buy?

That’s up to us.  It’s not like we don’t know that these influences exist and are being used to manipulate public opinion.  Some may reflect legitimate, fact-based opinion.  Others may be flights of fantasy, deliberately deceiving us into hating those they want us to hate.  And bear in mind, it’s not like Michael Moore, whether you love him or hate him, has no agenda. 

While I have some doubts whether our forefathers anticipated the influence of multinationals on the political process when they decided free speech mattered, they certainly expected the wealthy and educated to have the ability carry greater sway over public opinion than the poor and ignorant.  Indeed, democracy is held hostage by the ignorant.  It can be argued that the manipulation of media by wealth will render us all ignorant, feeding us only the crap they want us to swallow.

But this can also be seen as part of the maturation process of American politics. The Fourth Estate, assuming it continues to exist in some form, can still provide us with information about our candidates and issues, meaning that we will still have an opportunity to educate ourselves no matter how glossy and easily digestible the corporate influence might be.  We also know that big money is being used to manipulate our beliefs, and have the ability to guard against it, to recognize it for what it is, to accept or reject it.
 
Of course, the cynical view is that Americans are too stupid and lazy to make the effort to learn.  It’s so much easier to sit back in the la-z-boy, beer in hand, and let the information flow from the tube to the brain, accepting it at face value and believing ourselves fully competent to decide our fate.  Like lambs to the slaughter.

This leaves it up to us.  Democracy takes work.  Nobody promised that it would be easy to maintain a free nation without getting out of the recliner, except for bathroom breaks during commercials.  Perhaps we’ve had it too easy for too long, being spoon fed politics in 90 second intervals.  McCain’s “extreme naïveté” is one that assumes that Americans will never get off the couch and think for themselves.  He may be right, but we do have the power to alter the equation, and we have it on our own, no law needed.

And of course, we always get the government we deserve.  No Supreme Court decision can change this.  It’s entirely up to us.

Cronkite In His Healey: And That’s The Way It Was

Walking past the Austin Healey dealership in New York, Walter Cronkite made an impulse decision to walk inside and buy himself one.  For those of you who wonder why a fellow today would drive a 40+ year old car as fast he can around a tight corner, perhaps this can explain.



If this hasn’t made it clear, then you’re hopeless.

How You Want To Die

Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, the unavailability of Plan A, in your sleep surrounded by your 36 adoring great grandchildren.  Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, that Plan Z, at the wrong end of a needle cocktail, isn’t mandated.  And let’s assume, for the sake of argument, that a choice has to be made.  That’s why we have advance directives, right?

It’s become an article of faith that determination of how we choose to go is best made when we have a clear and viable mind, aren’t under extremis, We all either have one, or are remiss for our failure.  We know better.  Whether it’s a matter of ending our life with dignity, or relieving the burden on our loved ones, everyone knows that Living Will is the way to go, right?

Over at Co-Op, Kathleen Boozang has shaken my confidence with this provocative challenge.


Rebecca Dresser of Washington University in St. Louis employs personal identity theory to oppose exclusive reliance on  advance directives, arguing that the competent, functioning person who decides what health care she should receive, say, fifteen years hence is not the same person to whom these directives will apply.  That is, that the person now in a nursing home with Alzheimer’s Disease  who no longer recognizes his wife or children but seems basically content , is not the same “person” who executed the Advance Directive a decade or two ago with a dread of incompetence.

Speaking to the situation of her student, about to ship off to war, Boozang writes:


I have become disenchanted with power we accord autonomy.  Sometimes other principles should prevail, and sometimes a decision is patently wrong or irrational or transient.  I can’t bring myself to aid an 18 year old who should be on a date at the movies prospectively decide whether he’s willing to live a life without legs, or imagine whether she can tolerate living with the consequences of brain injury.
We assume that we know how we will feel when the time comes to make a decision. For the most part, people use advance directives to avoid heroic life-preserving care, assuming one believes life to refer to the functioning of some bodily organs without others, like the brain.  We sign off on pulling the plug, and we’re confident with our decision.

It’s been such a long time since my Living Will was prepared that I can’t recall precisely what’s in there, though I’m sure that it reflects my more youthful cavalier disregard for life under conditions that were less than optimal.  While not quite ready to pull the plug for losing my Adonis-like physique, an opportunity since squandered, I was clearly of the view that I did not want to live if my brain was significantly compromised.  Is that still my view?  And where, along the spectrum of intellectual deficit, am I ready to give it up? 

While I’m not quite convinced that advance directives aren’t a better alternative than letting some doctor in Florida make my decisions for me, Boozang has given me good reason to rethink my views, and more importantly, to inject some additional concerns and advice to young people who seek a Living Will, whether they are in uniform or post-partum and feeling the need to nest.   Do young people really have an adequate grasp of life, death and disability to make decisions about how much, or little, they are willing to suffer before choosing to die?

Much to think about, and important to think about.  After all, it’s not like you can change your mind after Plan B goes into effect.

Readers Mailbag, Flack Edition

Many strange and interesting offers come across the Simple Justice mail desk.  Some, like the ubiquitous link exchange offers from other websites, are so commonplace as to require no more than a click to forget.  But every once in a while, an offer comes along that is so odd that it captures my attention.  Once such email came yesterday.


John Reed
Media Relations

Stoy Idea Summary: Grace Suarez is a appellate lawyer working from home using her iPhone and a simple database, Bento, from FileMaker to make her busy law practice as paperless as possible.

INTERVIEW; an interview is available with Grace Suarez.

PHOTOS: High-resolution photos of Grace Suarez and her usage of this technology can be emailed to you.

How does your schedule look to talk with Grace about her usage of an iPhone and the Bento database for that phone?

Thank you.
John Reed

I’ve heard stories about how letters were lost behind counters, or through cracks in the wall, and weren’t heard from for decades, maybe even generations.  Could this happen to an email?  Could John Reed have sent this to me a decade (or more) ago, when the paperless office concept was a little closer to a new idea?  With high-resolution photos, no less.

But then, there were no iPhones then. No, this was new.  Some flack actually sent out an email about an idea that had been around, and practiced, for more than a decade, as if it was novel and interesting.  So I let Reed know (because I’m a helpful sort of guy) that he was shooting blanks, to which he responded:


Hmmm, other media love it.

We’ll opt you out
Hmmm indeed.  I wonder if someone is considering a feature length movie?  In black and white.  But still a talkie.  Given the extent of discussion around the blawgosphere lately (like here, here, here, here, here, here, here and of course, here) about the state of marketing for lawyers, though I would guess Reed is really promoting Bento and not Grace Suarez, high-resolution photos and interview opportunities about her usage of an iPhone notwithstanding, this strikes me as yet another critical point to be made.

I bet Grace Suarez is a fine lawyer, who is making a sincere effort to pursue the paperless office, though I recall Andrew Bluestone winning an award from the ABA for doing so about than a decade ago.  But by allowing someone who apparently hasn’t got a clue what he’s talking about to use her in his lame promotion, and offering high-resolution photos and an opportunity to interview about iPhone usage (OMG, does she really have an iPhone! Wowwy-kazowwy!), she’s placed in the middle of some unwanted attention.

If you’re a lawyer, is this really the attention you want?  Don’t be seduced by the lure of high profile, especially when the effort is as pathologically pathetic as Reed’s.  Next week, Grace Suarez will travel to court in a motorized vehicle!  High-resolution photos available.  This is not the way you want your name spread around the digital universe.

Also yesterday, the ABA Journal put out a story entitled How a Solo Gained More than 600 Facebook Fans for His Fledgling Firm.  You can’t make this stuff up.  Not a word about whether he’s gained a single case, no less created a successful, or even sustainable, law practice.  Just that he’s got 600 Facebook fans.  That’s almost as important as @Rex7 having 70,000 twitter followers, but no job.  Perhaps the lawyer involved is a great lawyer, competent and hard working, but this article makes him appear to be a loser whose only claim to fame is the collection of names on Facebook.  Why would he want to promote himself in the ABA Journal as a loser?  Why would the ABA Journal post such a vapid story? 

Promotion is certainly on the mind of many, as it’s being pounded into the heads of lawyers across the spectrum as the fastest, easiest way to get your name out there and become a great success.  But perhaps you ought to consider, in light of what’s happening to lawyers who forget that they’re professionals and instead allow themselves to be sold like laundry detergent by their hired gun experts, to not take John Reed’s call.

And now forsomething completely different.

Yet another brainstorm offering the lure of giving free advice, because the other 50 that do so aren’t sufficient.


Our website, www.Newlawyer.com, is a great resource for the public.  The whole idea behind the website is a professional network of attorneys located across the United States who offer free advice to those seeking it via free consultations.  More times than not, attorneys will charge a client before they speak to them for the first time.  However, in this day and age, many people cannot afford to speak to an attorney even the first time.  Therefore, we offer a great resource in that 90% of our attorneys are available to speak to the client at no cost. 
I’m holding out for a website that will let me try cases for free on the internet.  Wake me up when you’ve go that nailed down.  And it wouldn’t hurt if you could also provide a listing of supermarkets, clothing stores and restaurants that feed and dress lawyers for free.  For those of you who believe that your future is in giving free advice to people on the internet, I have but one question: Do you have an iPhone and some high-resolution photos like Grace Suarez?

The First Day, Again

Today is the first day of school in New York.  Carefully timed to miss the president’s message to students by a whisker, young men and women will march forward, some in anticipation and other with trepidation.  Unlike the father in the television commercial, this is not the most wonderful time of the year for me.

I have only one child left at home, with one having moved on to greener pastures.  When the first one shuffled out of the house, I realized that she went from crawling to texting before my computer booted up.  The alacrity with which a child leaves you is unlike anything else.  So much time, love and effort is dedicated to their welfare, and then they’re gone.

Many of my dear friends send their children off to renown boarding schools for their high school education.  These are feeder schools to the Ivies, where other well-to-do parents send their children to mingle amongst their own, learn how to be both ladies/gentlemen and survivors.  I kept my son home for high school.  I couldn’t bare to lose him a day earlier than necessary.

My daughter went to boarding school for three years, and while I cannot express the depth of my appreciation to her school for the exceptional job they did, I regret every day without her.  There are too few under the best of circumstances, and the loss was brutally difficult.  But it was necessary under the circumstances, and I suffered her absence for her sake.  It was the right choice.

When my friends children come home for the occasional weekend visit, holidays or vacation, they are almost unrecognizable.  They grow taller, more manly or womanly, more . . . gown up.  I wonder to myself how my friends feel about missing each day that their children changed, grew hair above their lip or curves that replaced straight lines.  I never say it aloud, as it’s none of my business, and I certainly don’t want to make the pain any worse. 

It’s comical as parts change, but not quite the whole.  Seeing the near-man mustache deepened with the remnants of chocolate milk, I see the manchild.  Some days, I believe that he’s grown overnight, as he stumbles downstairs growling at me for waking him up, or challenging the adequacy of his tooth-brushing.  But I cherish the change that comes each day, even if it’s hardly as apparent as when they are invisible for months at a time.

There will only be a few more first days of school for me.  Then it’s over.  I will miss them terribly.

Lesson From Touring Brazil

While there was little doubt that Lori Drew’s conduct toward Megan Meiers was wrong, and there ought to be a law, there is no doubt that pedophilia tourism is an outrage far worse.  No responsible human being would argue to the contrary, as there are few more disgusting, disgraceful, inhumane acts than pedophilia.  So what could possibly go wrong with a harsh law prohibiting it?

From the BBC, an unnamed 48 year old Italian tourist, visiting the coastal city of Fortaleza with his wife and daughter, was seen kissing his 8 year old child in public.


Witnesses told police the man allegedly touched the girl in an intimate way.

Under a strict new law partly designed to combat child sex abuse in South America’s largest country, he faces eight to 15 years in jail if convicted.

The unnamed man has been in custody for almost a week. A new attempt to secure his release this weekend failed.

His Brazilian wife says the case is all a misunderstanding, while staff at the resort where the incident took place have been reported as saying they saw nothing unusual.

We want so desperately to put a stop to conduct that harms others, especially children.  But for those who contend that there has to be a way to separate out the crime from the innocent conduct that is somehow mistakenly swept along with it. stories like this serve to remind us of how difficult this task can be. 

While it’s conceivable that this Italian tourist touched his daughter in a way that alarmed witnesses, and even that it was improper and perhaps even criminal, the more likely scenario is that this was a misunderstanding, perhaps culturally driven, or perhaps even grounded in prejudice.



He was reported to the police by a Brazilian couple who claimed he had been touching a young girl inappropriately and had kissed her on the mouth while they were both at a swimming pool close to the beach in full view of other tourists.

It appears the couple who made the allegations did not know that the man was with his daughter.

The north-east of Brazil has for some years had a problem of pedophiles traveling to the area, often from overseas, and strongly-worded warnings about the penalties for exploiting children are posted in most hotels.

However the wife of the arrested tourist says it was all a misunderstanding by witnesses who had misinterpreted seeing a foreign white man with a young darker-skinned girl.

Some people think that a father kissing his 8 year old daughter on the mouth is inappropriate.  Even worse when it’s a white man and a darker-skinned girl.  This had all the makings of a crime. 

Given the limits of the written word, and the often quick and dirty drafting of legislation in reaction to public demand, suffering further from carelessness, compromise and demagoguery, law can become as much of a problem as a solution.  Some would hope that the police or prosecution would serve as a safety valve on the unintended, even absurd, application of law.  Ah, hope.  Haven’t we seen enough videos, read enough stories, to know better?  Consider former prosecutor,now Judge, John Jackson’s debunked rationalization for maintaining his belief that Cameron Todd Willingham deserved to be executed. 

The anticipation, or expectation, that laws will be enacted to save us from every perceived wrong, but will be handled delicately and thoughtfully, is mere wishful thinking.  While many police officers and prosecutors will exercise sound discretion in the performance of their duty, some will not.  Whoever is on the receiving end of the overly zealous enforcer will take no comfort in the latter. 

Whether we see it as overcriminalization, or society run amok in its desire to rid itself of criminal conduct, we ignore it at our peril.  We would all hope to live in a world where no one harmed anyone else, but wishful thinking won’t overcome the collateral damage in our rush to reach legal Utopia.

Law, Meet Malthus

Dan Slater, who had done a killer job at the Wall Street Journal Law Blog after taking over for Peter Latman and before being disappeared, has re-emerged at the New York Times in this scathing blast at the legal profession.  The thrust is clear: We’re churning out way too many lawyers.


As firms begin an industrywide overhaul, which has entailed slashing jobs and reconsidering hidebound inefficiencies like the lockstep salary, students will compete for half as many $160,000-a-year jobs this year as they did last. According to the National Association for Legal Career Professionals, the 2008 recruiting season marked “what is likely to be the beginning of a weaker legal employment market that may last for a number of years.”

Meanwhile, as job opportunities abate, law school matriculation rates rise unchecked. Each year, the number of students who enroll at one of 200 law schools approved by the American Bar Association inches closer to 50,000.

No one, but no one, seem to either care or take responsibility that we are drowning in lawyers.  The law schools won’t voluntarily cut their numbers, particularly since students are profit centers to cover the cost of scholarship, the dirty little secret of the Academy.  Little Johnny’s big tuition bill has nothing to do with the cost, or value, of his legal education, but subsidizing the cost of professors busily writing articles and books to attain tenure or prove they’re the next Cardozo.

The ABA, charged with validating the worthiness of law schools, continues to put its imprimatur on buildings with cancerous libraries without limit.


The American Bar Association, which continues to approve law schools with impunity and with no end in sight, bears complicity in creating this mess. Yet a spokeswoman, citing antitrust concerns, says the A.B.A. takes no position on the optimal number of lawyers or law schools.
So the numbers go up, up, up, with no end in sight.  Schools won’t do it.  The ABA won’t do it.  And who wants to tell Mom that her baby is butt ugly, or that her apple pie tastes just awful.  After all, we’re talking about education, the soul of the American dream.  There is no greater promise promoted than that an education assures us of a bright future, a successful future, a winning future.  Who doesn’t want to be a winner, or for their children to be winners? 

Sadly, it’s a lie.  The promise of hard work and a guaranteed job starting at $160,000 is an anachronism.  Besides, the work is miserable and you won’t have time to wheel around in the Ferrari anyway, since you will be spending every waking hour in the library, or holding some arrogant partner’s briefcase, or fetching a mocha frapucino (Grande, Vente is for losers).

But more importantly, we can’t use you.  Supply and demand is still a viable concept, and we are way oversupplied.  It’s had some nasty effects on both the profession and society, and it’s time to stop making excuses for it and start recognizing it, and the problems it has caused. 

Sure, we’ve produced a generation of Slackoisie carrying a boatload of debt, barely capable of practicing law and complaining bitterly that the profession needs to change its evil ways to make their lives funner. But they had a choice in the matter.  They could have studied math or science, rather than philosophy, political science or dead romance languages, and found themselves a useful career.  That they couldn’t stand the sight of blood isn’t a justification for allowing anybody who breathed admission to law school.

In fairness, I am sympathetic that no one explained to you what the law is, or what lawyers do, before you took the LSATs, giving you the opportunity to run away before making the biggest mistake of your life.  The law is not for sensitive poets, or quick buck artists, or people who want to make happy hour.  Every day.  The law is a profession.  Well. it was once a profession.  

Lawyers carry an enormous responsibility.  We have these thingies called “clients”, who are real people or businesses that expect us to be honorable, fair, reliable.  These real people or businesses rely on lawyers to perform this thingy called work, and to do so on their behalf, expecting us to be diligent and careful, to appreciate that their existence and lives and livelihood depends to some extent on our performing that work thingy they expect of us.  Even when they aren’t sitting in front of us, they expect us to hold their interests dear and to labor on their behalf, with their interests coming before our own.  These are the duties of a professional. 

But when there are either too many lawyers running around, or too many lawyers culled from people poorly suited to handling the responsibility of a lawyer, a mess ensues.  Lawyers start taking on cases that lack merit, in the off chance that they can glom some quick money out of it.  Lawyers start raiding the escrow fund to keep up appearances because the phone hasn’t rung in a while.  Lawyers make promises they can’t keep to separate a client from his money, lest anyone with cash in his pocket walk out the door.

This was once an honorable profession.   There was an appreciation of the trust that people, businesses, society placed in our hands.  We served others because that was our responsibility, our duty.  Sure, there were always some bad apples in the bunch, but the vast majority of lawyers conducted themselves with the utmost integrity because it meant something to be a professional, to be handed the keys to the candy store knowing that we could be trusted not to eat any more than we deserved.  It was a matter of personal honor.

Today, lawyers sneer at honor, as if it’s some relic that only old men still talk about.  The law has changed into a business driven by self-promotion and self-deceit, where we rationalize scamming and spamming as necessary in this dog eat dog environment.  Lawyers have no choice, they say, but to wrestle in the gutter to pay off those student loans, to pay the lease on the BMW, to make feed the kids, to make mommy proud.  No one wants to be the lawyer who starves, and so they do whatever they have to do to survive.

Supply and demand.  Had supply been not been cancerous, demand would be more than adequate to assure that everyone worthy of the title lawyer was well cared for.  There would be no need for a cottage industry of legal marketers, pigs in lipstick urging us to ignore the slimy feelings and get into the selling game, like new, improved laundry detergent.  I’ve been told many times that this is how the game is played today, both by the buyers and sellers of iniquity, assuaging their conscience for disgracing their profession.  Spare me.

Our failure to mind our own profession has raised Malthus from the dead.  There are dead bodies lying outside the offices of Biglaw.  There are lawyers wearing hotpants walking the streets in search of business.  There are miserable clients wondering why their smiling lawyer sold them down the river.  And there are honorable men and women wondering why they are in the company of these others.

It’s not too late to change this.  The first step is close the supply valve to a trickle.  And point sensitive poets elsewhere.

Define Bully

The New York Times offers an editorial supporting Judge George Wu’s tossing of the Lori Drew conviction.  Not exactly a controversial position, at least around here.  But the editorial, like so many written on a holiday weekend in New York City, concludes with an odd paragraph that leaves one to wonder how much grog Punch Sulzberger was drinking.


Lawmakers should enact laws that can withstand challenge to give prosecutors tools to go after bullying of all kinds. What prosecutors cannot do is stretch federal law to label run-of-the-mill Internet activity as criminal.
Of course, there is a liberal tendency to believe that every wrong requires a law to fix it, and wrong is largely defined by its undesirable outcome.  The difference between liberal and conservative approaches is that the latter would require no law, just a darn fine execution to fix the problem, without all those namby-pamby details that muck up the works.

But before lawmakers rush out to pass another criminal law, perhaps someone ought to consider what we’re talking about.  The popular word for describing the problem is “bully”.  The dictionary definition is “one habitually cruel to others who are weaker,” but that’s hardly the definition implied by the Times, or generally used by anti-bullying advocates.  Rather, bullying appears to be the conduct of anyone who says or does anything that makes someone else feel threatened or merely badly.  In other words, you’re a bully if you hurt someone’s feelings.

Do we really want a law to criminalize people who hurt someone else’s feelings?

Certainly, there are many who are of the view that they are entitled to speak their mind without fear of someone else telling them their an idiot.  This permeates the argument of Danielle Citron, who takes it a step further by claiming that it’s women who are most frequently the target of criticism, which therefore converts it from hard feelings to a gender based attack.  The curious reactionary position is that by elevating the free speech right of bullies, we inhibit the free speech right of women, since they are disinclined to speak their mind knowing that someone might disagree with their ideas and tell them that they’re stupid.  This will hurt their feelings, thus making giving rise to the bullying issue.

I’ve been called a bully for criticizing the ideas or conduct of others.  Of course, no one I’ve criticized is weaker than me, and they have every opportunity to defend themselves or criticize me back.  But we’ve reached a point in our common understanding that it’s not the nature of the threat, but the sensitivity of the object of the threat, that defines the wrong.  I’m a bully because I made someone else feel badly about themselves.  Why anyone cares what I say is beyond me, but apparently they do sufficiently to pin the label on me.

Here’s the problem.  People promote a lot of ideas on the internet.  Some are fascinating and well-conceived.  Some are just bone-headed dumb.  Some are downright evil.  But ideas are, in themselves, harmless.  Sure, no one likes it when someone disagrees with them, or even worse, says their ideas are stupid (unless covered up by so many glowing adjectives that one is incapable of understanding what the heck they are saying).  But that’s the nature of presenting ideas.  Not everyone is going to agree with you, and by engaging in the act of publicly opining, one invites scrutiny. 

There’s a huge difference between ideas and engaging in conduct based upon those ideas.  There are laws, plenty of laws, prohibiting conduct.  We can’t physically attack people, whether for financial gain or spurred on by some angry idea floated on the internet.  The act is criminal.  It’s already covered.  To the extent that the harm done carries a varying degree of moral culpability based upon the intention or motivation of the performer, it can be addressed within the scope of sentence.  But the attack itself is already a crime. 

So what this anti-bullying law comes down to is not the conduct to be prohibited, since it’s already prohibited, but the wrong of hurting people’s feelings.  Bear in mind that as awful as the Lori Drew case was, Megan Meiers’ committing suicide is an extreme anomoly, as few people would be pushed to harm themselves as a consequence of hurt feelings.  Laws derived from anomolous situations, particulary when given the name of the victim, are invariably the most dangerous laws enacted. 

The anti-bullying advocates (are there any pro-bullying advocates?) press for a world where people will no longer be permitted to present ideas that offend others, or more accurate challenge ideas that others present in a way that hurts their feelings.  To remove the anti-bullying pejorative language, they want to criminalize criticism.  Citron would do so only for women, apparently because they are too weak to defend themselves from brutish internet men.  I think more highly of women than she does, having had my butt kicked far too often to think of women as the weaker sex.

But the desire for a world where no one’s feelings are ever hurt, upon pain of criminal sanctions, is absurd.  Not only does place the gun in the hands of the most sensitive soul, but it would foreclose debate, discussion, disagreement.  In the name of avoiding hurt feelings, we’ve already created taboos that preclude meaningful discussion of many topics, the most notable being race.  Do we really want the bully police hauling in anyone who challenges beliefs for Hurt Feelings in the Third Degree?

As kids, we were told that the rule of thumb was “sticks and stone may break your bones but words will never hurt you.”  The truth is that words can hurt, but only feelings.  That’s the risk we take when we express ideas, when we interact with others, when we extend ourselves out into the world.  If you don’t want your feelings to be hurt, then hide inside your room.  But if you go outside, exist with others, offer your thoughts, someone may well disagree with you and hurt your feelings.  That’s what it means to live.

Does the New York Times really think we need a law making the expression of disagreement a crime because it will hurt some person’s feeling?  Apparently so, and that’s just fundamentally stupid.  I hope I didn’t hurt your feelings, Punch.