Author Archives: SHG

No Apology Necessary

There’s a dirty little secret about small town, local-yokel police departments.  There’s nobody watching.  In the back of our heads, we all believe that there is someone out there overseeing cops to make sure they aren’t out on their own like Visigoths, raping and pillaging, doing whatever they please, an armed and authorized bunch of banditos.  We believe this because the alternative, that they answer only to Lord of the Flies, is too absurd to believe.

Welcome to Jericho, Arkansas. Population 174.  Seven cops. One fire chief, now hospitalized.


It was just too much, having to return to court twice on the same day to contest yet another traffic ticket, and Fire Chief Don Payne didn’t hesitate to tell the judge what he thought of the police and their speed traps.

The response from cops? They shot him. Right there in court.

And the article, bizarrely enough, speaks only to Payne’s stable condition.  So what did they do about the cop who decided to shoot him, right there in court?  They are investigating, natch.  But the police chief has taken a strong position.


Now the police chief has disbanded his force “until things calm down,” a judge has voided all outstanding police-issued citations and sheriff’s deputies are asking where all the money from the tickets went. With 174 residents, the city can keep seven police officers on its rolls but missed payments on police and fire department vehicles and saw its last business close its doors a few weeks ago.
The mayor couldn’t be reached for comment.  I bet.  Not even an apology to her Fire Chief.
If you think that this is just some backwater phenomenon, you’re kidding yourself.  Who do you think watches the cops in small towns and tiny villages?  Where do the management skills, oversight, integrity, “new professionalism,” come from?  Contrary to popular belief, there is no backroom filled with competent, qualified professionals scrutinizing the operations of every two-bit police force. 

While Jericho, Arkansas, offers an extreme window into utter law enforcement failure, do you really think it’s not happening in a police force near you?  How much do you know about what goes on in the backroom at the police station?

H/T Turley

The First Step Onto A Slippery Slope

While it’s not entirely clear why, CrimLaw’s Ken Lammers posted about the Supreme Court’s 1924 prohibition era decision in Carroll v. U.S., which he calls the Carroll Doctrine.  It’s more familiar to most criminal defense lawyers as the automobile exception, the decision that began the string of cases that exempted the search of vehicles from the strictures of the 4th Amendment.  It’s one of my personal favorites.

The slippery slope is one of the primary logical fallacies, that from one decision, others must inevitably flow.  And indeed, it is rarely inevitable, as there are conceptual ledges where the slide can, and usually should, stop.  But the automobile exception is one of those rules where the slide continued unimpeded, down, down, down.

Ken described the automobile exception:

After a review of a number of statutes, basically doing an original intent analysis, it states that for buildings a warrant may be easily obtained while for vehicles “it is not practicable to secure a warrant, because the vehicle can be quickly moved out of the locality or jurisdiction in which a warrant must be sought.” Going further it explains that an officer can’t just stop any vehicle he wants to.

The measure of legality of such a seizure is, therefore, that the seizing officer shall have reasonable or probable cause for believing that the automobile which he stops has contraband [] therein which is being illegally transported.

To sum it up, Carroll allows LEO’s with probable cause to search an entire vehicle because of the mobility of the vehicle and the difficulty of obtaining a warrant in a timely manner.

As lawyers, we’ve lived with, and confronted, the automobile exception so many times that we rarely give much thought to its history, and how the slide down the slope happened to reach the point where it now stands, that courts view automobile searches as a simple equation:  Car + Probable Cause = Lawful Search.  Indeed, even the probable cause part of the equation is honored more in the breach, so that it works out to be Car + Any half-baked reason to search = Lawful Search.

In his consideration of the exception, Ken recognizes that the rationale belying the exception was far more reasonable in the prohibition era than today, given that we have cellphones and computers, and cops can obtain a warrant within minutes from a neutral magistrate anywhere in the world.  But he has a rejoinder to technology, which I will call the Kentucky Response:

I can already hear the howls of protest. “In the modern world we have radios and cell phones. Carroll is outdated law!” Well, maybe so in your locality, but let’s consider those of us in far Southwest Virginia. My county borders Kentucky. There are mountains everywhere, cell towers are extremely spotty, and there are plenty of places back in the way back, with three or four mountains between the deputy and civilization, where anything short of satellite communication just ain’t going to work.

The Kentucky Response falls into the category of the lowest common denominator, meaning that everyone’s constitutional rights become subject to the neighborhood with lousy cell service.  Of course, the local police could always install proper radio communications to enable them to live like civilized people (Ken’s language, not mine), but the failure to do so entitled them to perpetuate the automobile exception for the rest of us.

Where this explanation gets far more interesting is the reaction by Mark at WindyPundit.  Not being a lawyer, but being an extraordinarily astute observer, Mark offers the babe-in-the-woods reaction to Ken’s explanation.

More to the point, as Ken says later:
In the modern era, the use of Carroll assumes that smugglers are smart enough to try to ply their trade in areas where it will be difficult for LEO’s to easily get search warrants.
I’m deep in my ignorance of the law here, but it seems to me that the exception should only apply when it actually is difficult to get a warrant, not just because it might possibly be difficult in general. It’s possible that what I just said is actually what Ken meant, and I just didn’t get it.
Ken sums up the hypothetical deputy’s choices this way:
If the deputy releases Jones, so he can go get a warrant, Jones will be back across the border in 5 minutes. If the deputy secures Jones in the back of his car while he drives 10 miles down the road where he can get radio contact he has extended a seizure of a person without an arrest. The least constitutionally intrusive practical act is a search of the vehicle on the scene.
This argument has a lot of merit, but let’s be straightforward about one thing: The least constitutionally intrusive act is to let Jones go. Yes, it means the “bad guy” will get away. But if our rights only apply when they don’t interfere with the activities of government agents, they’re not really rights at all.

While a bit fact-bound, Mark’s poking makes an important point.  The exception has long since been disconnected from the rationale, an unfortunately typical outcome as one slides down the slippery slope.  More significantly, Mark nails the critical issue that courts have long since forgotten:  The point of a constitutional right isn’t to figure out ways to circumvent it, but to enforce it.  As he says, “bad guys” will occasionally get away as a result of constitutional rights.  And good guys will be allowed to be secure in their persons and effects.  That’s the trade-off that out forefathers came up with, and it wasn’t meant to be undermined whenever it resulted in an inconvenient situation for the police.

In an addendum, Ken adds this:

the federal supreme court has entirely excised any exigent circumstances requirement so that all an officer needs to do the search is mobility of the car and probable cause that contraband is in it

In other words, Deputy Smith could stop Jones’s SUV right in front of the county courthouse at 3 in the afternoon on a work day, and he could still search it without a warrant because the car is mobile. This sounds like a bad case of remembering the rubric while forgetting the rationale.

It’s good to see Mark borrowing one of my favorite phrases, particularly since it’s a perfect fit.  The automobile exception, as originated in Carroll, is an anachronism in itself, that has grown to be a monster and swallowed the rule.  Police can stop and search a car essentially at will, with the mere incantation of “furtive movements” or “unusual nervousness” justifying a search for weapons, and then extended to all areas of the car, including all sealed containers within it.  They can strip the exterior off a car to search for secret compartments.  All without anyone’s approval or liability for their actions.  And if they have a person they want to stop and search, they need only wait until he leaves his house and drives away to nail him.  All this, even though the justification for Carroll has long since ended.

Some judges are disinclined to ignore the rationale behind the automobile exception, and from time to time they hold that a search of an automobile violates a defendant’s constitutional rights. But most apply the simple equation, and any search of a car, no matter how weak or frivolous the justification, is just fine with them.

And the best reason Ken can come up with the maintain the automobile exception is the Kentucky Response, Remember that if your car is ever stopped and searched.  Even if it’s in front of the courthouse.

The Death of A Preacher

Via Radley Balko, Georgia Preacher Jonathon Ayers is no longer with us.  A mere 29 years old, with a wife 16 weeks pregnant, Ayers did what a preacher is supposed to do, helping sinners.  For that, he was executed by two plain-clothes officers of the Georgia tri-county drug task force.

According to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution,


“I’ve rerun it in my mind,” Carpenter [Ayers’ brother-in-;aw] said. “He had used an ATM inside, got into his car and then a black Escalade pulled up and [they] jumped out … If they ID’d themselves, he couldn’t hear them because his windows were up.”

GBI spokesman John Bankhead said witnesses heard the two men identify themselves as law enforcement officers.

The sheriff also told reporters the agents “yelled, ‘Police. Stop.’ ”

Stephens County Sheriff Randy Shirley said the shooting came after Ayers hit one of the agents with his car as he backed up. The second one shot Ayers because the 29-year-old minister had maneuvered his car toward him in a “threatening manner,” Shirley said.

Ayers wasn’t involved in any drug deal.  Ayers had done nothing wrong to justify the interest of the drug officers.  Ayers is dead.  What Ayers did, as is shown in the videotape of the execution, is go into a convenience store and use the ATM, then go to his car and begin to drive away.  As he did, a black Cadillac Escalade, a vehicle preferred by drug officers because it makes them feel like drug dealers themselves, pulls up and two officers jump out and start shooting, point blank, at Ayers’ car.  And Ayers is now dead.

There is no argument that Ayers had done anything, anything, criminal, precluding the choir from singing that he deserved to die anyway.  He didn’t. 

The police try to shift the blame by insisting that it was Ayers fault that the cops had to execute him.


Police say they saw Jonathan Ayers with the target of a prior drug and prostitution investigation before they approached him. Stephens Co. Sheriff Randy Shirley, said, “The target was seen meeting with the deceased and at one point getting out of the car of the deceased. They went down from a local establishment down to the Shell Station.”

Shirley said that undercover officers then confronted Ayers, after he left the store. “They identified themselves as police and Mr. Ayers backed up into one of the agents, and then pulled his vehicle forward in a fast motion toward the other agent… at which time the agent fired two shots into the automobile,” he said.
The claim is that Ayers drove his car at an officer in a “threatening manner.”  From the video I saw, he drove his car in the same manner everyone else drives their car, but the officer jumped in front of him, as he assumed the shooting position that killed Ayers.  But the police had their excuse at the ready.  They are well-rehearsed in press statements that shift the blame from their officers firing bullets at innocent people to dangerous evil people who just didn’t listen.

But the excuse falls flat in the case of this preacher-man.  He committed no crime.  He had no reason to fear the police, or worse still, to want to do harm to an officer.  His family has tried to understand this as a situation where Ayers didn’t realize they were police, and might have thought they were out to rob someone who had just gone to an ATM.  Why Ayers, the innocent man, needs to explain how he reacted to police who jumped out and started shooting at him is beyond me.  Unlike cops, preachers aren’t trained in the art of responding to people shooting at them. 

There is no explanation, of course, from the Georgia Sheriff as to why his men felt compelled to try to jump Ayers at the gas station, endangering many lives in the process, in the first place.  They jumped to the wrong conclusion in the first place (what a surprise), and then exacerbated the situation by their tactical arrogance of expecting their target to understand that he was to submit to their authority.  There were 100 better ways to handle the situation, all of which would have left Ayers alive and provided the police with the opportunity to find out that their knee-jerk assumptions of criminality were dead wrong.  And they were dead wrong.

Now, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation is going to investigate.  Too bad there wasn’t time taken to investigate before they executed Ayers.  And make no mistake.  Preacher Jonathan Ayers was executed.

Guru Who?

Over the summer, I received two offers to write books.  Yes, I felt very important and worthwhile, having people come to me and ask me to put my words of wisdom on paper for all the world to read.  It was almost a Sally Fields moment.

Alas, I declined.  The offers weren’t quite as financially rewarding as I would hope, to the tune of my essentially subsidizing the publishers for the time I would spend writing.  It’s one thing to write because of restless fingers syndrome, and another to write because someone wants to make money off your efforts.  Not that I have anything against making money.  I am a capitalist through and through.  But if someone is to make money off my efforts, I would prefer it be me. 

But the financial issue wasn’t the primary reason for my turning the very kind offers down.  The most basic reason is that I don’t know that I could have met the expectations of the books.  I don’t doubt for a minute that I could have written enough tripe to satisfy the publishers, their only interest being that my efforts be sufficient to sell sheets of paper with writing on it to unsuspecting lawyers.  It’s my own expectations that wouldn’t be met.  Could I produce a writing that would be truly worthwhile?

One of the publishers sought a book along the lines of how to win criminal cases.  There’s no answer to that question.  The idea was absurd.  How ridiculously arrogant would I be to pretend that I can craft a book telling other lawyers the secret to winning.  The only thing I know is to work hard, and then work hard some more.  What would I write on the next page?

There are so many people out there who want to be a guru, even if it means that they are only one chapter ahead of their disciples in the textbook.  Then there are some really bad books out there, plainly meant to be read by the perpetually ignorant.  The ego boost from having one’s name on a book, and being able to lay claim to being an author, must fill a gap in the lives of many lawyers, enough that they are willing to shove all good sense under the desk and whip out the old Selectric III.  Do they ask themselves, do I really have anything to say that will help others to be better lawyers?  Am I really so wonderful that I can tell other how to do it?

The word guru evokes a negative reaction in some people. It’s seen as a pejorative term, where someone unworthy holds themselves out as having the wherewithal to tell others what to do.  There are a lot of people who do exactly that, but want to avoid the taint of being called guru.  You can’t have it both ways.  If you hold yourself out as having the answers that others need, then you hold yourself out as a guru.  Whether you deserve to be a guru is another matter.  I’m no one’s guru.

I just like to write.  Don’t get me wrong, I would love to write a book.  Poems maybe.  Not Haiku though.  Maybe someone will ask me to write a law book that I will feel comfortable about, competent to do.  Maybe I’ll happen onto an idea that I feel is really worthwhile, where I can help others with some solid and sound advice.  There are a few things that I think I know pretty well, and can offer some serious insight.  I’m not that they are book-worthy, though they could fill a pamphlet without much problem.

I am flattered and appreciative of the offers to write books.  But when and if I do, I also want to be proud of what I’ve done, and feel that I’m worthy of the honor to provide information to others. That time has yet to come.  I’m still learning.

Ugly Decisions of Meaningless Words

The other day, I received an email from a lawprof (yes, some of them do chat with me on occasion) about a decision in which he was involved that resulted in a huge win for the good guys.  While still basking in the glow of the win, he expressed his disappointment in the decision itself, rambling and often incoherent.  The view is often different from the inside.

My response, though he didn’t ask for my thoughts, was that we always dream of a brilliant decision, the kind that is cited forever with approval, but we take a win no matter how ugly.  They just don’t come along with great frequency.  An ugly win is a win nonetheless, and absent knowledge of all the specific facts and circumstances, the real details of the case, the wins don’t look so bad from the outside.  It’s like having a case in the newspaper, where we know that they’ve got the facts all wrong, but if it works to our advantage, we take it anyway.

What’s curious about this is that those of us who read judicial opinions and try to figure out what impact they might have on our work spend such an inordinate amount of time trying to make sense of things that the insiders know makes no sense at all.  This comes from a variation on the presumption of regularity, that judges aren’t all nuts, stupid, deceptive or manipulative.  We presume that the facts recited are accurate, and that there’s a legitimate reason that they’ve reached whatever decision they’ve reached, without being openly cynical about it.

Then comes along an opinion like Judge Stephen Reinhardt’s, concurring in United States v. Hickey , via Mike at C, which blows the lid off of the secret world of make-believe of appellate courts.  They’ve got a decision to make, and they aren’t going to let anything like reality stand in the way.


I do not favor depriving words of all meaning simply in order to reach a desired legal result.  Here, I see no reason, rational or otherwise, to treat the word “superseding” as meaning “not replacing,” as we have done before and as we do again here.  An abundance of judicial creativity has been devoted to tasks like interpreting “another” to mean “the same”[fn2]; “slight” to mean “substantial” [fn3]; and “superseding” to mean “not superseding” [fn4].  I propose redirecting that creativity to better uses, such as finding terms that actually mean what they appear to mean. We could start by using “second indictment” or “first additional indictment” to describe an indictment that follows the original indictment, but does not “supersede” it. Were we to do so, we might earn more public trust and respect than we are accorded now. Any additional amount, no matter how slight, i.e. substantial, would be most welcome.
Mike has all the details of the case, not to mention to footnote citations, in his post.  My concern is more about the game played, the one where we parse appellate decisions for significance in their language and implications for the future.  We can argue this stuff all day, as if they carefully crafted each phrase, each sentence, to convey something of lasting importance to the law. 

Who the heck are we kidding? 

Now I enjoy doing appeals as much as the next guy.  Crafting an argument, well cited with incisive quotations from esteemed judges that clearly present my arguments, fully grounded in firm law, can be very satisfying.  And yet decisions come back that make me wonder if we’re talking about the same case.  The facts of the case seem only vaguely familiar, and sometimes there are new facts according to the decision that can’t be found anywhere in the evidence.  And then there is the black letter law that says “day”, and then the “but” conclusion that says “night”, happening so suddenly that I’ve risked whiplash trying to figure out how the decision got from here to there.

Am I naive when it comes to my own cases?  Hardly.  I’m every bit the skeptic you find here.  But I can be a bit optimistic that this case, this decision, will be the one that reflects an honest and accurate application of law to fact.  By fact, I mean what actually happened in the case, rather than a set of “facts” that exists only in the facile vision of a hell-bent judge.  I feel quite fortunate to have had a fairly good number of sound decisions, both at the trial and appellate levels.  But like all lawyers, I’ve had my share of Alice-in-Wonderland decisions that make my want to scream.

It would be easy to rationalize the bad ones, the incoherent ones, the painfully wrong ones, based on Judge Reinhardt’s brutally honest concurring opinion.  Even paranoids have enemies, right?  But to do so would be to give up all hope, and without hope we would stop striving to achieve the best we can for our clients.  We need to pretend that there’s a chance that our next decision will be a great one, a monumental one, a decision that students of the law will be required to learn.

And yet, if we just get a win in an ugly, incoherent, rambling decisions, we’ll take it.  If they want to use the word “slight” to mean “substantial”, at least let them do so in our favor.  Trust me, it won’t happen often.

Playing Find The Expert

I haven’t always been kind to those who offer 10 rules for success.  Naturally, this hasn’t endeared me to the cadre of folks who profess to tell others how to deal with such novelty items as blogs and twitter, seeing each new medium as either the path to great riches (for them) or the absolutely, positively, definitely future of the law.  Call me a curmudgeon, or prickly for that matter, but everybody bought 8-track tapes and leisure suits once.

It’s gratifying, therefore, to find others joining the chorus of skepticism.  At The Inquisitor, Duncan Riley questions whether a trust crisis is coming to social media experts:


 The label social media expert is being used by all and sundry just because they have used Twitter, or started a blog, or at the extreme, have a Facebook account. It’s not a title I’ve ever applied to myself, although it has been applied to me on occasion. I’m probably qualified to use it given my experience, but I have no particular interest in being a “social media expert.” I’d rather use my skills to build something quantifiable that doesn’t involve me telling others at every opportunity that I have some idea about what I’m doing.

The problem here is that in many cases the implied trust is flawed: the audience expects to hear true experts, but that trust only extends as far as the audience’s knowledge level; once you get more knowledgeable audiences, those not really qualified to talk will be caught out. As a fundamental, that has to undermine trust, and once that stretches out across many, the whole sector suffers a trust crisis that even those qualified may be caught up by.
There’s something deeply troubling about people who have placed the mantle of expert around their own shoulders, and then offer themselves to others (for a fee).  Twitter is lousy with social media experts for lawyers, my primary focus, all available for speaking engagements.  The blawgosphere is replete with blawgers telling others how to successfully blawg.  And yet I’ve never heard of half of them and can’t help but wonder how someone who has yet to achieve success deigns to tell others how to do it. 

But the most disturbing issue of trust is the dirty little secret underlying one’s social media existence.  It’s not necessarily real.  So many have reinvented themselves online, creating their carefully crafted personas, that the lawyer first coming into the blawgosphere wouldn’t have a clue who is worthy of trust and who is an unmitigated liar.  And make no mistake, there are unmitigated liars out there.  It just takes a while to figure out who they are.

Lawyers, like most people who enjoy meals, need to earn a living.  While I’m not exactly convinced that the internet is the future of lawyer marketing, or that it’s really a very good way to find much of anyone whose services one wishes to retain, it’s undeniable that many lawyers have, and many more will, seek to use the internet as a primary means of communicating their existence to the world.  My bet is that the more lawyers tout themselves online, the more likely the media will topple over from the sheer weight of it all.  Every lawyer can’t be the most loving, the most aggressive, the biggest, baddest, smartest, meanest lawyer around.

But in the interim, while the media mature and the laggards in the law feel compelled to catch up to the early adapters, the social media experts will be there to teach them how to ramp up overnight and achieve success beyond their wildest dreams.   Riley’s explanation of why this presents a trust crisis spells it out pretty well.  The joke that every person with a blog or more than 12 twitter followers is a social media expert is no joke at all. 

To the newcomer, they seem to know so much, be so savvy. The newbie, fearful that new technology has passed him by, is desperate to catch up and not be the only kid on the block who doesn’t twit.  They turn to the person with what appears to be the shiniest credentials, never realizing that there’s no one behind the curtain.  As those of us who have observed this happening for a while have come to realize, there are plenty of curtains out there, but not too many folks who have accomplished enough for themselves to have anything to offer anyone else.  But that hasn’t stopped anyone from proclaiming themselves to be a social media expert.  Trust is the first casualty of technology.

I disagree with Riley in only one respect.  The crisis isn’t coming.  It’s here.

ABA to Prosecutors: Stop Being Unethical Scum

While I was AWOL, Scott at Grits for Breakfast picked up on a post by Alexandra Natapoff at Snitching Blog about a new ABA opinion requiring prosecutors “make timely disclosure to the defense of all evidence or information known to the prosecutor that tends to negate the guilt of the accused or mitigates the offense.”
 
Alexandra explains the opinion:


The opinion interprets this ethical mandate very broadly: it is more demanding than constitutional Brady disclosure requirements; it covers all information favorable to the defense, not just evidence; it is up to the defense, not the prosecution, to evaluate the utility of the information; the government must disclose information as soon as is reasonably practical, and the defendant cannot waive these rights or absolve the prosecutor of her disclosure duties.
Anybody got a beef with this?  I didn’t think so.  So why hasn’t this opinion been smeared across every criminal law blog throughout the blawgosphere?  Why have the lawprofs not expounded in pedagogical fashion about the scope and breadth, not to mention ethical implications, of this rule.  Why are we not dancing in the streets?

Let’s begin at the mothership, Brady v. Maryland, the case that likely gave rise to more guffaws within the Supreme Court’s sanctum sanctorum than any other since Plessy v. Ferguson.  Brady is filled with so many sweet words that it could give a criminal defense lawyer cavities, but it’s a right without a remedy.  It leaves the fox in charge of the chicken coop, the prosecutor being the initial arbiter of what must be disclosed and, worse still, when to do so.  After the verdict has proven to be a convenient time for many prosecutors, which likely is decided after the celebratory beer blast following the sound of “guilty”.

As Brady has been one of the most painful jokes the law has to offer, so too is the ABA’s belated chorus of Kumbaya.  Aside from the fact that the ABA’s opinion carries slightly less weight than the hot air of its debates, it’s nothing more than amusing given that the Supremes feel compelled to undermine even the non-practicing theory of Brady by issuing decisions like Van de Kamp v. Goldstein, absolving prosecutors of responsibility even in the oddball circumstance of Brady non-disclosure coming to light.

However, Alexandra’s point that this opinion reflects a growing recognition that this is a very real problem, and has disastrously bad consequences, is well taken.  That the ABA not only recognizes the need for change and sees the extant law as inadequate and going in the wrong direction, perhaps it will eventually have an influence on either courts or legislatures who are considering the issue.  Of course, it’s unclear that legislators are worried about the problem, given how their attention is largely focused on getting re-elected.   Nonetheless, it’s certainly better that the ABA comes out in favor of supporting disclosure of Brady and extending it to the point where it might actually serve its promise.

The relative silence on this opinion isn’t so much a reflection of the lack of interest on the part of criminal defense lawyers, but our not wanting to be the butt of yet another lawyer joke.  This is no laughing matter, and it should be appreciated that the ABA, toothless tiger though it may be, put in the time and effort to take a stand on this critical issue. 

It’s just that we’ve all lived through the promise of Brady, and again with Kyles v. Whitley , only to be reminded case after case that it’s an empty promise.  We don’t want to have our hearts broken again.

Taser’s Response: They’re Just Plane Crashes

In a fascinating and thorough exploration of the Taser phenomenon, via our hinterlands correspondent Kathleen, Scott Thill at Alternet not only runs through the ever-increasing saga of abuse and death at the end of an electrode, but gets an executive, and one of the founders of Taser International, to spill his guts.


“You’re picking plane crashes,” argued Steve Tuttle, vice-president of communications and one of Taser International’s founding members, by phone to AlterNet. “We’re not in the business of armchair quarterbacking, and we don’t write the use-of-force policies. That’s left up to individual agencies and the constitutional guidelines. When we see the controversies, we have to take a look at the totality of the circumstances.”

That Tuttle immediately reacts with the “not my job” defense is hardly surprising.  And indeed, has some merit when viewed in light of the manner in which cops use Tasers in lieu of thinking.  After all, it’s just so much easier to tase someone than talk to them.  But it hardly covers all manner of problems arising from the proliferation of Tasers.


They are indeed plane crashes, full of human and mechanical wreckage that are nearly impossible to turn away from. And with each new astounding report, they’re bringing more heat onto the already embattled company, whose stock has plummeted nearly 80 percent since 2005. In 2008, Taser had to dish out $5 million in punitive damages after a product-liability suit found the company to blame for improperly informing police that repeated shocks could kill suspects such as Robert Heston, who died after police officers in California tasered him multiple times until he stopped moving. In addition, Taser has settled at least ten cases out of court with not distraught suspects but rather police officers, who were injured by tasers during training.

There’s been little written about cops harmed during Taser training, though plenty about how cops shrug it off as if it’s nothing.  It’s not that Tasers don’t will a gap in the resources available to law enforcement; Indeed, it’s a far better tool than putting a bullet between a suspect’s eyes when force is required.


In Taser’s defense, its deployment has displaced other mid-range weaponry like pepper spray and batons — “a caveman’s tool,” asserted Tuttle — and even more old-fashioned, hands-on techniques like punching, kicking and chokeholds. And the use of tasers has decreased danger to both suspects and officers, according to some unlikely sources.
However, the promotion of the Taser from the outset, emphasizing it’s harmlessness, coupled with its use in mass media to suggest that it’s a marvel of modern technology, that has elevated the Taser from a dangerous weapon to cult status.

But it is clear from the increasing penetration of the taser into pop culture that use of the weapon within, and without, legally limited guidelines — the gray area so beloved by lawyers, marketers, and law enforcement — carries some kind of cachet.

“We’ve seen it used spectacularly,” Tuttle explained. “I’ve seen hundreds of cartoons that have it. I saw three shows last night that had it, including a Disney kids’ show and a Cops episode. It’s out there in pop culture. That poor yahoo that said ‘Don’t tase me bro!’ got us tremendous name recognition. We do provide them to prop houses, which give it to movies that use them.

Ask your kids what they think of Tasers, and don’t be surprised if they tell it’s “coo-ooo-oool!”  Seriously, if Batman uses one, it must be cool. 


“There’s a learning curve when departments get tasers,” Tuttle concluded. “Cops aren’t perfect. They’re human, but we expect them to be Robocop.”

A fitting description, given the fantasy of power and technology that tasers and other weaponry imbue their carriers with. Compelled by an increasingly permissive militarism that has gone supernova since 9/11 and armed with state-of-the-art force technology, taser-happy cops are in danger of becoming cyborgs out of step with the humanity they’re in charge of pacifying. Characterized as Heroes or elevated to the status of Robocop, without fully understanding the weapons that can save their lives, and kill those they’re supposed to protect, they’re walking a tightrope between thuggery and enforcement, and losing their balance with every bad episode.
The problem, ultimately, is that the Taser is already ubiquitous (except in Memphis), already a part of our pop culture, and already in the hands of poorly trained police officers and departments lacking appropriate use-of-Taser policies that recognize that these are not harmless devices, particularly when deployed with as little thought and concern as the dumbest or laziest cop on the street might exercise. 

In the old days, the question posed was whether one would give a loaded gun to a child.  The new question is whether one would give a charged Taser to an untrained cop.  The results speak for themselves.  Bad consequences are always just “plane crashes,” unless you happen to be the guy on the plane.

Where Does “Cheap and Simple” Fit In?

There’s almost a visceral reaction to any idea that includes the words “cheap and simple” or “good enough.”  But after reading Carolyn Elefant’s thoughtful explanation of why, when applied to the right areas of law and under the right circumstances, it makes perfect sense, the shaking and sputtering has begun to subside.



More likely, lawyers haven’t been discussing this issue because we’d prefer to avoid acknowledging that sacred legal services can ever be “cheap and simple” because that would lead to competition based on price and a race to the bottom.


Or would it?  Because my take away from the Wired article isn’t that cheap and simple means compromising standards.  Rather, at the core of cheap and simple is to deliver value by providing the key features of a product that matter most to consumers.
Carolyn is referring to Robert Capps’ recent article, The Good Enough Revolution:  When Cheap and Simple Is Just Fine, promoting the unbundling of legal services and volume selling of the some of the less sophisticated and complex legal products, such as simple wills or shareholder agreements.  The point is that not everything we, as lawyers, produce requires the mind of an inchoate supreme court justice. 

Less than perfect, but quick, easy and inexpensive, may well be more fruitful for society than perfect, sophisticated and beyond the reach of those who need it.  It’s the confluence of individualized expertise and reasonable cost.  Given how many legal things are required by ordinary folk to navigate their normal dealings in life, the high cost of monopolistic legal services seems more than a bit unfair.  The trade off of perfection and cost begins to make a lot more sense when we think of it in these terms.

But does this apply to criminal defense as well?  One could well argue that the bulk of criminal defense addresses low rent offenses, ranging from disorderly conduct and public drinking/urination to the wealth of vagrancy related offenses, and are disposed of at arraignment with a quickie plea and a fine or a day or two of community service.  It doesn’t take a brain surgeon to accept the offered plea and speak the magic words of a guilty plea.

This is where I start to shake again, unfortunately.  Not that I’ve done much of this sort of work for the past quarter century, but I can remember the early days when I handled my fair share of low level offenses.  Rather than cop the quick plea and move defendants along an assembly line, I felt compelled to read the complaint for adequacy, talk to my client about the details of the arrest and search, keep abreast of the relevant law and, with some regularity, argue for legal insufficiency or bad search or some other fault in the proceeding.  Even when the plea would result in nothing more than a violation and a $100 fine.  There was this bone in my head that made me feel that it was my duty to be a lawyer rather than a grocery clerk.

Carolyn’s point, that cheap and simple isn’t the same as cheap and cheesy, rings true.  There is much that can be accomplished without a lot of fanfare and at a very reasonable cost by simply losing the bells and whistles and focusing on the client’s very limited, very clear-cut, very basic needs.  Like every lawyer on the face of the earth, I have a simple will in my computer that merely requires a change of names to complete.  Five minutes and the whole thing is done, assuming that it’s just a matter of inserting names where blanks used to be.

In the past, I’ve watched clients agonize over who to make executor or guardian after I’ve explained the consequences of certain choices and the potential problems caused by ill-advised, knee-jerk decisions, and note that by the time a will is needed, they won’t be around to undo the poor choices made today.  But then, does my throwing monkey wrenches into their simple decisions add value to my service or just make a simple task needlessly complicated?  I think it helps, but then that’s because it reflects my view of what lawyers should do.  Of course, it takes that five minute simple will and turns it into 3 meetings and 22 telephone calls, not to mention the formality of execution.

The virtue of unbundling services is clear.  Far too many people simply can’t afford the legal services they need, which means they must either forgo obtaining services, a serious problem given that our society has way too many legalistic requirements to simply eschew compliance, or pay for services beyond their means.  I don’t want any children going hungry because the folks spent the grocery money on my time.

And yet, my experience is that there are few aspects of legal practice that are truly cheap and simple, and wouldn’t do far better with thought, effort and diligence.  Maybe it’s only one in ten that requires greater effort than a quickie form filled out in five minutes, but how do we know that until we’ve talked to clients, understood their needs and made sure that their idea of cheap and simple isn’t our idea of potential legal disaster?  It’s a tough question.