Author Archives: SHG

All Reasoning Is Not Created Equal

In a post about the irrationality of testing methodology, Jeffrey Harrison at MoneyLaw touches on a subject that sticks in the craw of first year law students and those who are deeply concerned with keeping them all warm and fuzzy.  Being that it’s the opening of another round of the game show, “So You Wanna Be A Lawyer,” unemployed edition, this seems a particularly good time to remind law students, and those who deign to teach them, that reasoning matters.


And now back to logic. Remember your high school math classes. Some teachers said to show your work and then gave you credit if you got everything thing right except, say, the final step. Others just machine graded.The problem is this. In most complex math problems there are many ways to get a wrong answer. Some reveal that the test taker did not have a clue. Some reveal that the test taker forgot to carry the one on the last step. The machine grader gives them the same credit although their knowledge and understanding are quite different. The teacher who requires the student to show his or her work makes a distinction because there is a distinction. Of course, the same is true in law where the issues are not simply complex but more nuanced.
Ignore the grading aspect and focus instead on the reasoning aspect.  One of the most disturbing, yet recurring, themes amongst law students who comment around here is their inability to distinguish between emotion and reason, causation and correlation.  Up to now, 1Ls got away with winning arguments any way they could.  It was perfectly sufficient if they achieved their end by screaming louder or withholding sex.  Winning was winning, and the rest was simply finding the mechanism to accomplish the goal.

This doesn’t tend to work nearly as well before judges, and therefore isn’t an acceptable basis for becoming a lawyer.  Despite the touchy-feely approach to legal education, where the self-esteem needs and holistic concerns of personal morality and satisfaction transcend the nasty, ugly, demeaning approach of demanding that students be capable of both assessing a fact pattern for its relevant details and then crafting a rational argument that logically flows from the facts and law to the end to be achieved.

They don’t wanna.  They like their own emotional argument, and if it’s good enough for them, then it should be good enough for the rest of us.  It’s their right!  And what makes reason so much better than whatever it is they believe?

In Jeffrey’s post, he notes that it’s irrational to mark the student who gets the ultimate answer wrong the same whether it’s been well-reasoned, though marred by minor or single error, or wrong because it’s devoid of reason and understanding.  Sure, wrong is wrong ultimately, provided that there is a discrete right and wrong answer.  As lawyers, we come to realize that right answers are only right until some court somewhere decides otherwise, leaving us with quite a few fuzzy lines.  Over enough time, we even find that some black letter law is written in the sand, and is subject to change with the swipe of a hand.

But the ephemeral nature of law tends to get in the way in law school, and is best left for the lessons of misery as one matures in practice.  Law school is for the teaching of foundations upon which nasty experience can build, and foremost of our foundations is to think like a lawyer.  The rest can be learned in a diligent afternoon.

Logic isn’t personal.  It doesn’t care how you “feel” about something.  Your preferences are irrelevant.  And no, you’re not entitled to your own opinion.

This doesn’t mean that you can’t be creative in the crafting of an argument, or the understanding of why a court reached a particular holding.  Indeed, a deeper understanding, informed by experience, may often yield a different rationale for a holding than the one commonly accepted and taught to you.  Provided you understand the accepted rationale, taking the initiative to challenge the rationale by a logical, albeit different, line of reasoning is a higher order skill.  But it must still be based on sound reasoning.  Of course, your professor may not agree with your explanation and burn you for it on tests, but that’s the risk you take.

Jeffrey asks whether logic is still taught in schools.  It is in law school, even if not called logic anymore.  Or at least it should be if law school is to serve any purpose.  The ability to craft and convey a logical rationale for a position is fundamental to the practice of law.  It’s time to put away the child-like arguments that have worked well up to now, and may still work at beer blasts and sock hops.  But they won’t work with other lawyers and judges, none of whom care a whit about how you feel or whether your self-esteem is undermined when you’re told that your argument is rejected with a terse “denied”.

And as lawprofs decide whether the ease with which a scantron satisfies their grading is more important than the ability of a student to present a well-reasoned position, even if it falls short of perfect, consider whether motivating and incentivising your students to leave their childish notions of reason behind and strive to achieve logic is more important than remembering the case name or getting the holding right.  It’s not that holdings don’t matter, but any student who gets a good grade but can’t reason will fail as a lawyer.

From what I’ve seen here, and I’ve seen quite a bit from our law student and young lawyer friends, we have a severe logic gap coming out of law schools.  They can’t think worth a damn.  As the trend toward warm and fuzzy at the expense of sound reason spreads, it’s only going to get worse.  If young lawyers can’t distinguish between sound reasoning and their personal feelings, they will fail as lawyers.  And yes, as Jeffrey suggests, their failure is a reflection of the failure of their legal education to teach them the difference.  

Welcome to law school.  I hope you know what you’ve gotten yourself into.  Now get to work.

Love’s Labour’s Lost

It being Labor Day and all, what better time to express some thoughts about those who exist to serve those who cannot help themselves, the infirm.  Certainly, there’s no fault to be found in those born with challenges that the able-bodied will never know or understand, and they depend on the kindness, the empathy, the labor of a cadre of workers who care for their needs.  Without this labor of love, who would tend to them and give them the care, the kindness, they so dearly deserve?

And then we have those whose toil somehow manages to be all about them.  Their politics. Their self-righteousness.  Their holding people who have been entrusted to their care hostage to their official prerequisites.  Where once laboring the field of healthcare was about serving others, there’s at least one official woman who appears to have no qualms about using her post to punish a patient whose needs don’t match her wants.

Meet Nyle Magi, who suffers from MS and paralysis.  And meet Adrien Vaughen, official woman.



How did we become a place where labor, the people we pay to perform a service and nowadays often referred to as “human capital,” a phrase developed to feign greater admiration for “our greatest resource” while simultaneously diminishing humans by relegating them to another cog in the wheel, believe that they, the ones getting paid to provide a service, are in charge of us, the dopes doing the paying?   If they don’t like the gig, they don’t have to do it.  Slavery was long ago abolished. Nobody puts a gun to their heads to do any particular job.

Yet, the ethic behind labor has evaporated.  I’m not (this time) talking about the work/life balance debacle, but about the regular, everyday sort of labor, where we are thrilled beyond belief when we find someone who happily does what they are paid to do, performing well and without complaint.  It doesn’t happen often.

This is as true of the lawyer as the fellow who digs ditches, though the consequences are obviously very different.  But the notion of hard work, service, responsibility has become foreign to the American dream.  Worse still, that harm befalls those who make the mistake of relying upon others, particularly when they have little choice in the matter, is a travesty.  A lousy paint job is a nuisance.  A man left to wallow in his waste by someone charged with his care is an outrage. 

While Labor Day was meant to be a celebration of the efforts of those whose perform the tasks that keep our nation running, there are too few of us remaining who deserve to be celebrated.  It’s not that the Wobblies were wrong, but that we’ve transcended the separation between labor and capital to the point where labor holds capital hostage rather than the other way around.

For all those who are struggling in this difficult economy, or raise the “Buy American” flag as if the fault belongs to the shoppers rather than the producers of crappy goods at too high a price, take a hard look at whether you earned your paycheck or skated by doing as little, or as poorly, as you could possibly get away with.

But if you, like our official woman, with smile intact as she condemns in the video, have chosen to use your petty authority to do harm, then I have a special Labor day greeting for you.  Suffer as you make others suffer.

This video implicates other issues as well, from medical marijuana to cluelessly hiding behind patient confidentiality to conceal abusive and ignorant harm.  But it’s Labor Day, and so we focus on happy holiday matters.  Happy Labor Day, Adrien Vaughen.  No yucky diapers for you to change.

H/T Balko

But For Video, The Weekly Version

I had a beef with my good buddy Packratt at Injustice Everywhere.  He’s killing me.  And, he’s making me feel bad. I don’t care to feel bad, so naturally I took it out on him rather than admit that it’s entirely my fault. 

The problem was simple: He’s so far ahead of the curve, and produces so much information on police misconduct and abuse, that I can’t keep up with him.  Worse still, when I post about a story, I later learn that he had the story a month earlier than anyone else and I just failed to catch it.  Nobody likes to feel inadequate, and PR keeps making me feel that way.  I hate him for it.

In an act of generosity to his lessers, Packratt sent me a link to his latest post, The Week in Police Misconduct Video.  Now people like me tend to latch on to a particular video, dissect it, deconstruct it, and then do my best to explain how and why this reflects a failing of our society to address the harm we cause ourselves in an effort to highlight our faults and improve our condition. 

Packratt, by his efforts to collect and document the plague happening across our nation, doesn’t have the opportunity to treat each video with such detailed efforts.  There are just too many.  They come too quickly.  They become overwhelming by their sheer mass.  God bless the dash cam, without which we would never have documentary evidence of what really happens on the streets of America, or how unbelievably dumb so many cops are that they would behave the way they do on video.

Having hopefully made a sufficient mea culpa, and given you enough reason to go immediately to Injustice Everywhere and watch each of the five (yes, count ’em, 5) videos that appeared this week alone, let’s cut to my favorite and ask ourselves why.



The trick in this Beaumont, Texas, video isn’t to watch the fellow in the forefront, who one would otherwise assume to be the star, but rather the guy in the background on the right.  He’s standing there, doing as he was apparently told, hands on the roof of the car.  Eventually, he’s taken to the rear of the car and appears to go cooperatively, no issues raised.  So far, no biggie.

Then comes some galoof with a baton.  He’s kinda doofy looking, probably unhappy with his sex life and feeling rather unfulfilled in this arrest as no blood has been spilled.  What’s a cop to do?


In this video, the man in the background on the right is taken around the back of the pulled-over car to be cuffed when another officer pulls his baton, walks towards him, and then unleashes a barrage of 13 baton strikes to the apparently compliant suspect. If that wasn’t enough another officer then tasers him after he’s taken to the ground.
Bet you never saw the Taser coming!  The sheer gratuitousness of the violence, it’s utter pointlessness, is what makes this my fav of the week.  No excuses. No explanations.  The cop just wanted to give somebody a good tune-up, and so he did.
 
Two additional details worth noting.  First, none of the other cops were apparently bothered in the slightest by their compadre’s whupping of this otherwise docile fellow.  Second, even a neaderthal like doofy-cop should have been aware of the fact that he was on candid dash-cam, yet the synaptic connections were obviously not firing, leaving one to wonder just low the intellectual bar is set in Beaumont.  Remember, people’s lives are at stake based on the processing speed of police officers.  If they can’t figure out what to do when it’s in their own self-interest, what are the chances they can figure it out when it’s only about you?

And if there was no video of this utterly pointless, totally senseless, absolutely gratuitous beating, would anyone believe it happened?  I can hear the prosecutor now, “Why would Officer Jones want to beat Derrick Newman?  He’s got nothing against him.”  I’ve heard that argument a thousand times before there was ubiquitous video.  That’s a thousand beating that went unbelieved, right Judge?

So Quantity Doesn’t Trump Quality

While we’ve often come at the intersection of law and technology from different directions, making the potential for a massive crash quite strong, I’ve always had great respect for Kevin O’Keefe, proprietor of Lexblog, Real Lawyers Have Blogs and, of course Lextweet.  While he’s always been a vigorous proponent of technology, he’s never wrapped it up in a bow of baloney, It’s always been the delivery system for meaningful work rather than a magic bullet in lieu of it.  I respect that.

Yet as an early adapter of Twitter, which produced Lextweet, a twitter feed of lawyers and lawyer-type folks apart from the rest of the twitterverse, he put some relatively unattractive photos of people on the right sidebar and called them “Top community members on Twitter.”  That’s where I first learned that Rex7, an unemployed law student, had collected more twitter followers than anyone else (over 71k at the moment).  

In the past, I’ve had some fun challenging the notion that collecting followers on twitter was a meaningful or worthwhile endeavor.  But was I missing something?  Perhaps there’s a prize for having more followers than the next guy, or promoting oneself despite the ready appearance of buffoonery?  After all, if Kevin thought it worthy to put pics and numbers of these twitter superstars on his sidebar, who was I to doubt that this meant something important?

This time, apparently, I got it right and Kevin, after a while, got to the intersection a bit later than me.  Fiery crash avoided.



There’s a growing number of people on Twitter who are seeking large numbers of followers, apparently as a showing of their importance.


Why the chase the for followers?



  • Ego?


  • Insecurity?


  • Need to feel important?


  • Trying to sell services and products by spamming others?


  • Whoring themselves out to other spammers?


  • Trying to increase their measure of influence?

I don’t know. But just because someone has a lot of followers on Twitter does not mean they are offering anything of value on Twitter or that they have any expertise in anything, let alone social media and social networking.

As wonderful, or at least enjoyable, as many find technology, the knee-jerk reaction to new opportunities seems to be to establish oneself as dominant through the most obvious means.  In the case of twitter, it’s number of followers. In a rational sense, this metric would be more of failure than success, since as Kevin notes, the things one does to accumulate followers are rather ugly and counterproductive. 

There’s a tipping point between being followed by people you know, you like, you care about and who care about you, and the scam factor of mere numbers.  It’s got its analogies in every new medium, and can invariably be ascertained by the growth of slimebags selling magic ways to achieve greatness without really trying.

The irony here, of course, is that Kevin, in his early zeal to promote twitter, which he saw as one of the greatest advancements in technology after the blog, was one of the foremost promoters of big numbers by his inclusion of the most-followed twitterers in his sidebar.  It was a mistake in the first place, and he now realizes that it led lawyers down the wrong path.


I’m sorry if LexBlog promoted some of this follower chase by LexTweet displaying legal professionals using Twitter in the order of how many people were following someone. We’re working on ways to change that.

Quantity may have been the quick and easy way to judge in the early days, but it’s false god. 


If you’re looking for followers on Twitter, do it the old fashioned way. Share news and information of value to your target audience. Word gets around and more people will follow you. Follow others you’d like to get to know and learn from. Share things of personal interest outside the law. You’ll find that others with similar interests will begin to follow you.

As with blogging, or pretty much anything else in life worth doing, quality will always bear out in the end.  I was resistant to twitter in the beginning, thinking it another fool’s game for people whose thoughts never exceeded 140 characters.  I was wrong.  I’ve learned that it has its place and, frankly, has become a regular mode of communication for many, including myself. 

But even with my modest 600+ followers, there are a bunch who are totally worthless, following me for the follow back (ain’t happening), to sell me something (ain’t happening), or to entice me to view their dorm cam (really ain’t happening).  I’ve given up trying to delete them as they tend to go away on their own when they find out that they’ve followed someone who is worthless to their purposes.  As I noted a while back,


Give me 10 followers with whom I actually want to interact and I’ll trade you 10,000 spammers. 
It’s important that Kevin has come on board, because he carries far more sway in matters of technology than I ever will.  My concern is that the techno-grab that has been embraced by so many lawyers as the magic bullet to solve their business deficits has done grievous harm by undermined the few vestiges of honor, integrity and client service that remain in a once-vaunted profession.  By taking on those who have spent their time collecting worthless followers, and thereby trying to slay a monster than he was integral in creating in his own self-interest, Kevin has made as strong a statement as he can.  The day of dumb quantity is over. It’s time to grow up.

Quality trumps quantity.  Kevin O’Keefe says so.  Now if he would only remove those pics from his sidebar.

But It Says So In A Journal

This has already made its way around the internet, but just landed on my screen courtesy of Dave Hoffman at Co-Op.  Given how much we lawyers just adore science, and view it with awe and wonderment, relying on it as irrefutable proof of fact and convinced beyond a doubt, reasonable or otherwise, that if it’s in a journal, it must be so, it’s critical that we understand the sausage-making process.

Sit back.  Grab a full bottle of Patron Gold and bowl of guacamole on this Labor Day weekend, and relish in the fact that we, criminal defense lawyers, aren’t the only miserable people in the world who feel as if we’re trying to stop the tide from coming in.  Feel the warm glow, from the Patron if nothing else, envelope you.  And have someone you love notice the wry smile on your face as you reach point 104, which reads in reaction to the demand that length be shortened, “Declare ‘death to all commas’ a worthless piece of unnecessary punctuation if ever there was one.”

Enjoy.

How to Publish a Scientific Comment in 1 2 3 Easy Steps

7 Things At Once

It’s always irritated me when I’m sitting on the phone to have someone come up to me and just start talking, showing me papers, demanding my attention.  I’m already using it.  I apologize to the caller, look the person standing in front of me straight in the eye and say, “do you not see that I’m on the phone?”  That’s when I get the smack, as they reply, “and you can’t chew gum and walk at the same time?”

We’ve become a world that applauds the multi-tasker, the superhuman who can talk on the cellphone, holding a vente mocha frapucino in the same hand as the mascara brush, while maneuvering a 2 ton behemoth through a slalom course surrounded by young children on bicycles with little fringy things emanating from their handlebar grips.  Not only could they do all these tasks at once, but they could do them as well, if not better, than the rest of us. These are our heroes.

According to a study by researchers at Stanford University, whose purpose was to determine what made these heroes so different, so much better, than us mere mortals who were required to focus, one task at a time, it’s all a lie.  From the New York Times :



Last week, researchers at Stanford University published a study showing that the most persistent multitaskers perform badly in a variety of tasks. They don’t focus as well as non-multitaskers. They’re more distractible. They’re weaker at shifting from one task to another and at organizing information. They are, as a matter of fact, worse at multitasking than people who don’t ordinarily multitask.


“Multitaskers were just lousy at everything,” said Clifford I. Nass, a professor of communication at Stanford and one of the study’s investigators. “It was a complete and total shock to me.”

Initially suspecting that multitaskers possessed some rare and enviable qualities that helped them process simultaneous channels of information, Professor Nass had been “in awe of them,” he said, acknowledging that he himself is “dreadful” at multitasking. “I was sure they had some secret ability. But it turns out that high multitaskers are suckers for irrelevancy.”

I’ve always had the ability to switch gears very quickly, moving from case to case, from serious to light-hearted.  But I tend to focus on the task at hand with great intensity.  When I write, I hear nothing.  If I’m interrupted, you can see it in my writing, where there’s an obvious (to me at least) break in the thought process as exposed by the words.  It was a regular source of ridicule around my household, there everyone from the kids to the gardener (usually at the kids’ goading) would make fun of me for being a unitasker. Vindication!


“The core of the problem,” Professor Nass said, is that the multitaskers “think they’re great at what they do; and they’ve convinced everybody else they’re good at it, too.”
It’s not merely that multitaskers appear to be so much more capable to those of us who require focus to perform a task well, but that they appeared to be able to get so many things done while we were busily trying to complete one stinky little task.  They are deluding themselves.  I’ve had too many occasions to challenge the value and quality of work performed by multitaskers, finding it consistently lacking in detail and depth.  I’m told that it may not be perfect (duh) but that’s the giveback for being so productive. 

It’s not productive to do many things poorly.  Good enough isn’t good enough.  No one salutes the latte drinking, cellphone chatting driver who only ran down one kid because he managed to miss five others.

And as for the Slackoisie, who maintain that they can write a brief whilst listening to their Ipod with The Soup blaring on the tube, your work isn’t as brilliant as you think.  If your boss says it is, then perhaps your boss isn’t any better at it than you are.  Your self-assessment that you’re doing just fine, actually quite wonderfully, is a product of the Dunning-Kruger Effect, not strength of intellect. 

One off-shoot of this study is the confirmation that we cannot validly assess our own performance.  The constant bombardment of people claiming how wonderful they are, how great they’re doing, how critics of their ways are just so terribly wrong, because they think they’re doing fine, is full of it.  It’s time to cut the crap that enablers (and promoters) use to surround incompetence with the imbued benefit of wondrous glory.  It’s still incompetence, no matter how many flourishes to make it seem uplifting.

The moral of the story is that while you might be able to do seven things at the same time, you can’t do them well.  Maybe the next time our cutting edge visionaries decide on what color is the new black, or where next years hemlines should be, competence, attention to detail, and focusing on one thing and doing it right will be back in style. 

When The Cop Arrives

The 911 operator tells the distraught caller not to worry, the police are on their way and will be there any moment.  There’s a sigh of relief.  The people we depend on to come in an emergency, to help us, to make things better, are on their way.  Everything will be alright.  That’s what goes through our minds.

Things didn’t quite work that way for Pam Jordon, via Turley, according to the EyewitnessNews12 in Wichita, Kansas.  Her grandson, Isaiah, was found floating in the backyard pool.



Jordan says she scooped the boy up, took him into her kitchen, and the CPR she did on him was working.  Jordan says the boy vomitted (sic), regained a pulse, and color was returning to his blue lips.  She says her grandson still wasn’t breathing, though.

The family says they’re upset because the first officer on the scene told Jordan to back away and didn’t continue CPR.  They say when two other officers arrived minutes later, they immediately grabbed equipment and restarted CPR.

“I trusted him to take over,” says Pam Jordan, a former medical assistant.  “That’s why I specifically asked him, ‘Are you going to take over?’  It’s a life and death situation.”
Anyone reading this would ask the same question, why.  Why would the officer order Jordon to stop administering CPR?  The answer is control.  The first thing a police officer does upon entering a situation is take charge of it in order to assess it and determine what needs to be done.  It makes a strange sort of sense, given the role the officer is taught to play.

The problem is that in emergent situations, where life is at stake based on the need for immediate action, the time taken for an officer to process the scene, ascertain the status and determine what action should be taken, is limited by the officer’s intellectual capacity, mental processing speed, personal skillset.  In other words, if the first cop on the scene is a dunce, or simply slow-witted, the kid dies.

We optimistically, and quite naively, attribute a certain level of intelligence, thoughtfulness and competence to all police officers.  The fact is that while some are extremely bright, and often quite skilled in certain areas, others are just dumb as bricks and generally oafs.  They might be very nice and well-intended, and be exactly the person you want at your side in a firefight, but under no circumstances would you want then to make an important decision, especially one where the life of a child is at stake.  Yet they are every bit as much a cop as the smart ones.  And there’s no capital “D” tattooed to their forehead so you can which is which.

So control of a frenzied situation is seized.  All actions are stopped.  Everyone is supposed to calm down and stay that way.  Step 1 in the process is accomplished.  Rule followed.  Job well done.  Little boy dies. 

We tend, especially at a blawg like this, to distinguish police officers as good or evil. It’s overly simplistic in many instances, but serves to make the point that wearing blue isn’t sufficient to make you one of the good guys.  What we also need to remember is that the men and women who are given shields are not a whole lot different than those walking the streets in sneakers or high heels.  Some are smarter than others.  Some are lazier than others.  Some are up to the job at hand and others just aren’t.  They run the gamut.

Just pray that the first one that shows when it’s your loved one floating in the pool isn’t the brick.  It’s not an easy job, being a cop, and requires quite a bit of intelligence to perform well.  Not all police officers have the right stuff.  Whether Isaiah would have survived had CPR been continued isn’t clear, but it’s clear that he didn’t once the officer took charge.

Confronting The Cult

What hole exists in the psyche that makes some people, some lawyers, feel the need to make someone their leader, and them his follower?  Whatever it is, whether the cool-aid, the fear, the lack of self-esteem, it’s flowing freely at Gerry Spence’s Trial Lawyer College.  And Norm Pattis has become the target of their ire.

Norm, a one-time follower, one-time challenger to the cult, had made peace with Spence.  Why Spence cared whether he had Norm’s love is beyond me, but being a magnetic personality and perhaps the greatest lawyer of our time, Spence apparently had the opposite void of his followers, the need for admiration and validation.  When Norm withheld his love, Spence wanted it back.  The Treaty of Versailles followed.

But when questions arose about financial practices at TLC, called the Ranch by those whose “lives are changed” by a bit of psychodrama and a lot of basking in Spence’s reflection, Norm called them on it.  It’s not clear why Norm broke the truce, or why he wanted to jump into a fray where there were so many happy sycophants to beat him to a pulp.  Norm is either inordinately brave or stupid, and which one is subject to where you stand.

Having never attended the Trial Lawyers College, and therefore not being one of the Tribe (as they call themselves), I have no horse in this race as to whether this is part of a financial scam being run for the benefit of Spence, or whether he’s deserving of whatever scarce resources he can get his hands onto such that any infidelity should be overlooked.  I can squint with the best of ’em, but leave it to others to sift through the numbers and the lease and the 501(c)(3) paperwork.  There are plenty of dirty not-for-profits in my own sphere that Wyoming can deal with its own.

But the attack on Norm from the anonymous Tribespeople presents a different problem.  These are lawyers all, and as such should be able to separate their need for religion from their intellectual ability to recognize legitimately raised issues.  They may well choose to ignore or overlook them, but attack because someone announced that Gerry Spence is marching around the ranch naked?  Scratch that image.  Too late.

In a question posed to Norm in a tone that was so frail as to melt the hardened heart and compel a response, Cheryl Carpenter asked why Norm had abandoned the Tribe, had chosen to attack Gerry.  Why, if nothing else, couldn’t Norm just sit it out and let things go as they would.  Norm explains, to the extent anyone can explain, the path that led him to do the unthinkable: Question the leader of the cult. 

As someone who doesn’t care much for cool-aid, I can clearly sense Norm’s ambivalence toward Gerry Spence.  There is some weird love and admiration there, while simultaneously discomfort with his elevation to lawyer-god status.  Isn’t it enough that Gerry Spence is a great, if not the greatest, lawyer of our time?  Must his Tribe go that next step to make him above reproach?  And does his Tribe, many members of which I know and respect, lose their ability to detach themselves from their spiritual leader and see that he’s just a man?

Not to bring the believers down, but there’s one hard point about which you need to be reminded.  You’ve gone through TLC and have come out the other end. Yet you are not Gerry Spence.  You haven’t achieved lawyer Nirvana.  Your pinball score isn’t any higher than top quality non-tribespeople, and some of you aren’t anywhere near high score.  You may have enjoyed the filling of that spiritual hole left behind by childhood trauma or parental neglect, but it didn’t make you Super Lawyer (with or without cheese).

You can adore Gerry Spence all you want.  Put up that really cool photo of him on your office wall if it makes you feel better.  Hang the sage/dirt amulet on the corner of your law school diploma.  Whatever.  But don’t blame Norm Pattis because the cool-aid doesn’t last forever. 

If Gerry Spence is your cup of tea, enjoy.  But this cultish behavior borders on the sick.  Whatever you do, ignore the call to buy brand new Nike sneakers. 

Places No One Should Ever Go

When the breathalyzer showed that Jamie Lockard, 53, wasn’t above the legal limit, Lawrenceburg, Indiana, Police Officer Brian Miller wasn’t satisfied.  Odd, isn’t it, that the magic black box that conclusively proves guilt wasn’t good enough to prove innocence.  So like any good police officer who is certain that he’s right, evidence notwithstanding, Miller did what he had to do.

Lockard was taken to the hospital, strapped to a gurney, where he was held down as a nurse inserted a catheter into him to extract urine.

Apparently, this was done pursuant to a warrant, raising the curious question of what exactly Miller alleged, and what exactly the judge who signed the warrant was thinking, given the nature of this most intrusive invasion of his body in light of the breathalyzer reading.  Regardless, the end result of the urine test showed that Lockard was still under the legal limit.

Most people are painfully well aware of how successful advocacy groups like Mothers Against Drunk Driving have been in overstating the harm, and vilifying ordinary citizens, in their zeal to stop drunk driving.  But just how far is this going to go?  We’re just a heartbeat away from removing kidneys to prove that a fellow drove drunk, all evidence to the contrary notwithstanding.

As most men can attest, there are few things that one can do to a person that will induce immediate nausea and the fight reflex than insert a catheter against one’s will.  There are places where no one should go, and this is one of them.  Is there anything that Lockard could have done, or Miller could have believed, that would justify an intrusion into a body like this? 

So we’re clear on the evidentiary need, if Miller so firmly believed that his observations proved Lockard drunk, then he’s certainly permitted to offer them as testimonial evidence to make his case.  Drunk driving can be proven through testimony, as it was in the days before we had little black boxes that do mysterious and magical things, or even lengthy catheters.  Sure, it lacks the panache of scientific evidence, which no jury would ever reject since science supplants reason, but it’s perfectly viable evidence.

The catheter invasion, therefore, is merely the cop’s preference to obtain better proof than whatever it is he’s got to offer.  In other words, he wanted the test to gild the lilly, afraid that his own observations wouldn’t cut it.  And if so, the worst that would happen is that Lockard walked. 

Did these thoughts not occur to the judge who signed the warrant authorizing the forcible insertion of a catheter in a man’s penis?  A man, I might add, who the magic black box said was not intoxicated beyond the legal limit.  Do we need to add “insertion of catheter” to “tasing” on the list of things that should be done to prosecutors and judges before they trivialize the consequences of their actions?

As a society, we give an extraordinary amount of authority to a handful of people and expect them to demonstrate an iota of sound judgment before using force against us.  What we cannot allow, after the fact, is to ask over and over, what the hell were they thinking.  Does it really require much thought for this cop, or his enabling judge, to have realize that the forcible insertion of a catheter to obtain better evidence is just plain sick?

And naturally, having failed to obtain the evidence of Lockard’s drunkenness after execution of this disgusting and disgraceful conduct, they were constrained to charge him with obstruction of justice.  Maybe because he didn’t smile as they shoved the catheter into a place where no one should ever go.

H/T Popehat and Turley

Geek Is Not A Foreign Language (Update)

It could easily be seen as a compliment to Defending People blawger, Mark Bennett, that he finds himself in the crosshairs of others who want to be him.  Just recently, he’s had to fend off some local third-stringer named Andy Nolen who got the brainstorm to smear other Houston criminal defense lawyers with fake reviews on yahoo!, while making himself the savior.  After being called out by Mark, a false review was posted to Avvo, which was quickly tossed.

These are the things real lawyers are forced to go through in the digital world.

And then there was Melina Benninghoff, whose blog was a simple scraping of posts stolen from elsewhere, notably Bennett’s.  It doesn’t matter whether Benninghoff did it personally or left it for someone else to do for her, since (as has become Mark’s mantra)when you outsource marketing, you outsource ethics. 

This brings back the fond memories of another scoundrel, U.S Law.com, a low-rent garbage website that tries to eke out a living by stealing content from real blogs and selling advertising. 

When this is done by lawyers, it’s a clear representation of how marketing has corrupted the ethics of desperate lawyers who are incapable of maintaining a practice based on their skills and competence, so that they’ve chosen to scam the public (and other lawyers) to create the impression of competence where none exists.  No, they shouldn’t be lawyers.  No, they shouldn’t be trusted.  No, they shouldn’t be hired.  Not even for a quick mani/pedi.

But the underlying problem isn’t one limited to lawyers. The problem is that some geeks are of the view that there are no rules when it comes to the internet; at least no rules that apply to them. Because it’s so easy, no, simple, to steal content via RSS feeds from anyone, anywhere, they are entitled to do so, no questions asked. 

The thought process goes something like this:  We (meaning those of us who create content) don’t get it.  If our content is put out on an RSS feed, it’s an invitation to the rest of the digital universe to take it, use it, change the name and offer it as their own.  It’s not their fault that they’ve taken us up on our RSS feed invitation. If we put it out there for them to take, then why should we blame them for doing so?

Before explaining why this notion is fundamentally wrong, allow me a moment of reflection.  Bennett learned of Benninghoff’s theft of his content from me, when I notice that a link to me came from Melina Benninghoff’s “blog”.  After seeing the scraping, I sent Bennett an email alerting him to the theft.  I know that Bennett, as a creator of content, isn’t too keen on worthless rats stealing the fruits of his effort.  I knew that he would want to know, and wouldn’t take kindly to it.

A few months earlier, following my excoriation of U.S. Law.com for ripping off blawgs at will, Bennett sent me a book called Digital Barbarism by Mark Helperin, who makes me look like an amateur curmudgeon.  I’ve been reading the book slowly, as Helperin’s words take time to absorb and require absorption to appreciate.  It’s a work of genius.  I might consider reviewing the book, but I’m unworthy.  Mark Helperin is far better a writer, a thinker, than to deserve the praise of a lowly lawyer like me. 

Now back to the geeks.  Stealing doesn’t take brilliance, and barely takes effort.  See the plate glass window at the front of the store?  Throw a rock through it and you can grab anything shiny inside you want.  It’s simple.  Any moron can do it.  You can do it. But it’s illegal, it’s criminal, it’s wrong.  The fact that you can steal easily doesn’t change the nature of stealing.  What synapse isn’t firing that leads you to think otherwise?

Two factors seem to embolden the geek entitlement mentality.  First, they assume no one will know that they’ve stolen content from others.  It’s a big digital universe and it takes an awful lot of vigilance, or some dumb luck, to stumble on a theft.  Second, there isn’t much that can be done about it.  We aren’t likely to go around suing every scumball website like U.S.Law.com that’s existence is premised on theft, lies and idiocy, even if we can figure out who is operating the sleazy sites.  Like the eponymous Chase of U.S.Law.com, likely a twelve year old working out of his mommy’s basement trying to scam up enough money to keep the juice flowing to his playstation 3.

But legitimate blawgers have one weapon available, and it’s a particularly potent weapon when it comes to scum like the Andy Nolens and Melinda Benninghoffs of the world.  We can shame them by making sure that as many people as possible are aware of the fact that they haven chosen to engage in unethical, scummy conduct.  We can undermine their purpose by using our page rank to surpass their page rank, so that when they not only obtain no benefit from their sleazeball tactics, but our perpetually held out to ridicule for what they’ve done.

It’s possible that Melina Benninghoff doesn’t even realize that she’s become the butt of some very harsh criticism.  It’s possible that she allowed some ignoramus to have his way with her lawyer marketing strategy.  But this remains her responsibility; Responsibility is what being a lawyer is all about (and no, it’s not about making lots of money so you can achieve work/life balance).  Whether she actively or passively failed to take responsibility for her online presence, she remains responsible.  That’s one of the burdens that comes along with a law license.  Too hard to do?  Tough.

If Benninghoff is a real lawyer, then she will profusely apologize to Bennett, and everyone else she’s harmed.  She will admit her wrong and acknowledge that she has wallowed in the gutter.  She will learn from this egregious wrong.  She will no doubt be given a stern lecture, but will ultimately be forgiven, for she is but one of a multitude of bone-headed lawyers who have been taken in by the culture of legal marketing and social media that has undermined what little remains of the integrity of the profession.  In other words, she’s neither alone nor special. 

She’s just pathetic, along with so many others who think that lawyers put on dark red lipstick and hotpants to walk the streets in search of clients.

As for Andy Nolen, there’s no excuse and no forgiving.  Like another of his ilk, Ollie the Cabdrivertising lawyer, whose time will be occupied defending the this post from Mark Bennett.  Some quasi-senscient nutjob named Wayne Conley, who is apparently the guru in charge o
f Melina Benninghoff’s internet and twitter marketing effort, has decided to go toe to toe with Bennett.  I imagine the scraper will have to be scraped.  This Wayne Conley is not merely illiterate, ignorant and foolish, but totally out of his league trying to mess with “a loved one” of Bennett’s. 

There’s only one question remaining.  What will Melina Benninghoff have to say about all this?  Stay tuned.