And now back to logic. Remember your high school math classes. Some teachers said to show your work and then gave you credit if you got everything thing right except, say, the final step. Others just machine graded.The problem is this. In most complex math problems there are many ways to get a wrong answer. Some reveal that the test taker did not have a clue. Some reveal that the test taker forgot to carry the one on the last step. The machine grader gives them the same credit although their knowledge and understanding are quite different. The teacher who requires the student to show his or her work makes a distinction because there is a distinction. Of course, the same is true in law where the issues are not simply complex but more nuanced.Ignore the grading aspect and focus instead on the reasoning aspect. One of the most disturbing, yet recurring, themes amongst law students who comment around here is their inability to distinguish between emotion and reason, causation and correlation. Up to now, 1Ls got away with winning arguments any way they could. It was perfectly sufficient if they achieved their end by screaming louder or withholding sex. Winning was winning, and the rest was simply finding the mechanism to accomplish the goal.
This doesn’t tend to work nearly as well before judges, and therefore isn’t an acceptable basis for becoming a lawyer. Despite the touchy-feely approach to legal education, where the self-esteem needs and holistic concerns of personal morality and satisfaction transcend the nasty, ugly, demeaning approach of demanding that students be capable of both assessing a fact pattern for its relevant details and then crafting a rational argument that logically flows from the facts and law to the end to be achieved.
They don’t wanna. They like their own emotional argument, and if it’s good enough for them, then it should be good enough for the rest of us. It’s their right! And what makes reason so much better than whatever it is they believe?
In Jeffrey’s post, he notes that it’s irrational to mark the student who gets the ultimate answer wrong the same whether it’s been well-reasoned, though marred by minor or single error, or wrong because it’s devoid of reason and understanding. Sure, wrong is wrong ultimately, provided that there is a discrete right and wrong answer. As lawyers, we come to realize that right answers are only right until some court somewhere decides otherwise, leaving us with quite a few fuzzy lines. Over enough time, we even find that some black letter law is written in the sand, and is subject to change with the swipe of a hand.
But the ephemeral nature of law tends to get in the way in law school, and is best left for the lessons of misery as one matures in practice. Law school is for the teaching of foundations upon which nasty experience can build, and foremost of our foundations is to think like a lawyer. The rest can be learned in a diligent afternoon.
Logic isn’t personal. It doesn’t care how you “feel” about something. Your preferences are irrelevant. And no, you’re not entitled to your own opinion.
This doesn’t mean that you can’t be creative in the crafting of an argument, or the understanding of why a court reached a particular holding. Indeed, a deeper understanding, informed by experience, may often yield a different rationale for a holding than the one commonly accepted and taught to you. Provided you understand the accepted rationale, taking the initiative to challenge the rationale by a logical, albeit different, line of reasoning is a higher order skill. But it must still be based on sound reasoning. Of course, your professor may not agree with your explanation and burn you for it on tests, but that’s the risk you take.
Jeffrey asks whether logic is still taught in schools. It is in law school, even if not called logic anymore. Or at least it should be if law school is to serve any purpose. The ability to craft and convey a logical rationale for a position is fundamental to the practice of law. It’s time to put away the child-like arguments that have worked well up to now, and may still work at beer blasts and sock hops. But they won’t work with other lawyers and judges, none of whom care a whit about how you feel or whether your self-esteem is undermined when you’re told that your argument is rejected with a terse “denied”.
And as lawprofs decide whether the ease with which a scantron satisfies their grading is more important than the ability of a student to present a well-reasoned position, even if it falls short of perfect, consider whether motivating and incentivising your students to leave their childish notions of reason behind and strive to achieve logic is more important than remembering the case name or getting the holding right. It’s not that holdings don’t matter, but any student who gets a good grade but can’t reason will fail as a lawyer.
From what I’ve seen here, and I’ve seen quite a bit from our law student and young lawyer friends, we have a severe logic gap coming out of law schools. They can’t think worth a damn. As the trend toward warm and fuzzy at the expense of sound reason spreads, it’s only going to get worse. If young lawyers can’t distinguish between sound reasoning and their personal feelings, they will fail as lawyers. And yes, as Jeffrey suggests, their failure is a reflection of the failure of their legal education to teach them the difference.
Welcome to law school. I hope you know what you’ve gotten yourself into. Now get to work.
