Author Archives: SHG

Welcome The Digital Fourth

When the 9th Circuit, courtesy of Judge Alex Kozinski, decided United States v. Comprehensive Drug Testing , they may well have brought the law into the digital age for the first time.  For real.  Orin Kerr at Volokh Conspiracy has done an extraordinary series of posts about the case, its implications, its conflicts, and they are a must read for every criminal defense lawyer.

Being ever helpful, Judge Kozinski has even summarized the new rule:


When the government wishes to obtain a warrant to examine a computer hard drive or electronic storage medium in searching for certain incriminating files, or when a search for evidence could result in the seizure of a computer, see, e.g., United States v. Giberson, 527 F.3d 882 (9th Cir. 2008), magistrate judges must be vigilant in observing the guidance we have set out throughout our opinion, which can be summed up as follows:

1. Magistrates should insist that the government waive reliance upon the plain view doctrine in digital evidence cases. See p. 11876 supra.

2. Segregation and redaction must be either done by specialized personnel or an independent third party. See pp. 11880-81 supra. If the segregation is to be done by government computer personnel, it must agree in the warrant application that the computer personnel will not disclose to the investigators any information other than that which is the target of the warrant.

3. Warrants and subpoenas must disclose the actual risks of destruction of information as well as prior efforts to seize that information in other judicial fora. See pp. 11877-78, 11886-87 supra.

4. The government’s search protocol must be designed to uncover only the information for which it has probable cause, and only that information may be examined by the case agents. See pp. 11878, 11880-81 supra.

5. The government must destroy or, if the recipient may lawfully possess it, return non-responsive data, keeping the issuing magistrate informed about when it has done so and what it has kept. See p. 11881-82 supra.

For anyone in this business, the sweeping breath of this approach is just astounding, which brings me to the only aspect of this decision that Orin has yet to discuss.  A while back, we had a disagreement about whether the 4th Amendment doctrine developed over the past couple of centuries was better applied to  new technology, whether by analogy or directly, or whether the courts needed to develop a new approach to evidence that fell outside the scope of anything the framers, or the courts of the past, had ever imagined would exist.

My argument was that we needed a new approach, largely because the old one is riddled by exceptions that have long ago swallowed the rule, and because the developed law monumentally fails to offer any meaningful protection.  Orin took the approach that we would do better to apply existing doctrine, which he called his “technology neutral approach.”

While I wouldn’t go so far as to say that this decision proves Orin wrong, I would take the position that Judge Kozinski and the en banc 9th has taken my side in the argument, that the old paradigm fails to satisfactorily address protecting the privacy of the individual when we leave the physical aspects of the search in the dust and focus instead on our digitalia, the true content to be protected. 

But before we get too excited by this extraordinary decision, which would likely render every computer search every done unconstitutional, Orin makes a critical point in noting that it may well conflict with new Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 41, which creates a process that conflicts with the Kozinski rules at critical junctures, and that the Comprehensive Drug Testing decision, if rendered pursuant to the Circuit’s supervisory powers authority rather than as a 4th Amendment doctrinal decision, would be trumped by the new rule, effective December 1st.

Still, that the 9th Circuit has now challenged the tail that wags the dog, at minimum there’s a crack in the door of old school search and seizure doctrine, and now a hope that a little sun will shine through that crack.  Given the significance of digital search for the future, let’s hope that this decision at least gives rise to some thought before the federal courts eviscerate all protections under some new “computer exception” rule that exposes our innermost thoughts to the nearest  flatfoot with a flash drive.  It’s the content, not the container.

My Blogolater Can Beat Up Your Blogolater

My fellow curmudgeon, Mark Hermann, has stolen my newest new word, blogolater.   This comes on the heals of my finally receiving due credit for coining the term Slackoisie in the Urban Dictionary.  The only problem, of course, is that I didn’t actually invent either word, the former having come from Hermann himself and the latter from Dan Hull.  But I’ll take as much credit as I can get since my skills in lexicography are somewhat stilted.

But Hermann’s word refers to the cottage industry of blog support, those folks who provide turnkey blogs, or teach you the twelve rules of blogging, or bring you coffee to celebrate your first blog post.  He came up with this word during his unscientific research into the lifespan of a blog.  It’s now officially twelve hours.  There are 17 million blogs, 52% of which are defunct before the pot of coffee is fully brewed.

Since I’ve enjoyed modest success with Simple Justice, assuming one defines success as getting a few people who aren’t related to read my blawg, I could conjure up some rules that would probably help.  I could make a list, and then everybody would read it because people love lists.  They especially love lists if the name of their blawg is one it.  If I had a blog about cheese, and listed the ten best legal blawgs including Above the Law, I bet that Ellie would write a post about it. 

I won’t write a list, however, as I’m not in the business of telling others how to succeed at blawging.  I do this for self-preservation, as I’ve got more blawg-stuff to read than I can handle already, and I surely don’t need more.  I don’t promote seminars about how to be the next blawgospheric hero.  I see blawgers I’ve never heard of pontificating on how to blawg.  It strikes me wrong, but if that’s what they want to do, so be it.

On the other hand, I do have a few things I see from newbie blawgers that turn me off right away.  The first is the newbie self-proclaimed expert.  Jamie Spencer has a list of new kids on the block, one calling itself Ask the Criminal Law Expert.  Maybe he is an expert.  Maybe he’s not. But I hate it already.  Proclaiming yourself an expert is really tacky.

Most new blawgs are self-promotional, and think that they’re going to impress the crap out of would-be clients who stumble upon it in the search for a home for their hard-earned money.  That’s never worked before, and isn’t likely to work with each new blawg that comes along.  There is almost nothing that guarantees failure more than self-promotion.  Yet this happens over and over.

Then there’s the folks who start up blawgs and say nothing.  Great idea.  Lots of people really want to spend their time reading nothing.  It’s fascinating.  It’s interesting. It’s worthless.  I’ve been accused of being unduly bold in my opinions.  This is a curious criticism, since they’re my opinions and if I didn’t think they were correct, why would I bother to put them out in the blawgosphere?  Plenty of people want to tell me what an idiot I am for having them, so I might as well feel strongly about them before bothering to offer my butt to be kicked.

For better or worse, I have thoughts.  I don’t proclaim myself the expert, as though my opinions are, by definition, the only correct ones, and I may well be wrong about things (though I don’t think so, most of the time).  But at least they are thoughts.  Those who publish wishy-washy, pointless, wiggly commentary either lack the conviction of their beliefs, or don’t actually have any beliefs and just post stuff to keep their blawg alive until they learn that they aren’t going to get rich and famous as a blawger.

The blogolaters won’t tell you this stuff.  They will tell you to post regularly and be interesting and you too can establish a viable presence in the blawgosphere.  But if you don’t really want to be here, then why bother?  As Hermann and I have said before, you aren’t going to hit the bigtime because you have a blawg.  If you aren’t writing because there’s some bone in your head that makes you want to write, then you’re wasting your time.  If you expect something in return, then you’re going to be deeply disappointed.

But as long as you give it a try, you will keep the blogolaters happy.  And they will keep telling you that you too can be a blawgospheric hero.  Maybe a few of their progeny will prove to really have something interesting to say and worthy of your precious time to read.  And that’s all one can ask of the blawgosphere.

Second-Guessing Judges

Doug Berman posts about a Heritage Foundation report entitled “Adult Times for Adult Crimes: Life Without Parole for Juvenile Killers and Violent Teens.”  It decries efforts to by “anti-incarceration activists” to undermine life without parole for juvenile offenders,  and “hold these dangerous criminals accountable.”

Replete with the usual hyperbole, drawing from the images of super-predator children of such unredeemable evil that they really ought to be put to death, but can’t because of the misguided Supreme Court decision in Roper v. Simmons, prohibiting capital punishment for children, the report argues that we must maintain this vital tool in the war on crime.

But it’s this line from the executive summary that really caught my attention:


If they succeed, an important tool of criminal punishment will be eliminated, and all criminal sentences could be subjected to second-guessing by judges, just as they are in capital punishment cases today.
Never before have I seen anyone attempt to characterize judicial review as “second-guessing by judges,” as if it’s the next intrinsic evil of the system that will devastate some Stygian sense of retributive justice and leave society at the mercy of these evil child criminals.

All criminal sentences are, and must be, subject to second-guessing by judges.  That’s why we have judges.  That’s why we want judges.  The Spanish Inquisition didn’t do such a great job of things, and we’ve learned a bit from it.  We do not want individual hanging judges, or juries, to impose harsh, dirty justice, disconnected from its legitimate purposes and imposing the visceral reaction of the angry townsfolk. 

Put aside the obvious, that these are children, immature and unprepared to think, act and reason like adults.  Put aside that we cannot continue to throw children away and justify it as saving society, particularly when they aren’t out own children.  But beware this attack on “second-guessing judges.”  This, along with the activist judges rhetoric, is the sort of thing that causes our system to devolve into the abyss of pure, mindless retribution.  It’s easy.  It feels good.  And it’s wrong.

And as long as I’m at it, don’t forget that these are children. 

Long Distance Law

Whenever I go away, whether for vacation, conference, trial or otherwise, I make certain that all my cases are fully covered and that my clients know that I will not be at the other end of the phone whenever they call.  It has to be or I would never be able to get away.

So naturally, with minutes of leaving the country, catastrophe strikes at least half of them, demanding my immediate attention. Not quite real catastrophe, but client catastrophe, meaning that they desperately need to ask me a question which is life or death to them at that moment.  Most of the questions require an answer like, “no, it doesn’t mean anything,” after which they sigh and say “sorry to bother you.”

But it’s not my perception of the question, but theirs, that matters.  If it’s critical to my clients, then it’s critical.  And because I’m out of reach, critical questions necessarily arise.  Managing them is all in the preparation.  The preparation is having other lawyers upon whom you can depend available to help you when catastrophes arise. 

This requires two things: First, having lawyers you trust to handle your client emergencies.  Second, having lawyers you trust willing to help you out.  The first is a matter of honest assessment, finding people in whose care you would entrust the people who have put their trust in you.  The second is a matter of mutual survival and generosity.  I take care of them whenever they need my help, and they are there for me when I need theirs.  We are all better off for our support and cooperation.  And we provide each other with a support system that allows us to do things that solos could never otherwise do. 

My phone has been ringing nonstop since I’ve left the United States.  What a surprise.  Usually, the minute I hop on a plane is when a huge new case comes in.  This has become such a cliché that whenever business gets slow, I immediately leave the country to get something new and great.  It always works.  It has yet to happen this trip, but I still have plenty of time and no doubt it will.  Good things always happen at the worst possible times.

When the call comes in, however, I take comfort in knowing that my friends will help me out, cover me, deal with the emergency and make sure it’s there for me when I return.  It’s good to have friends.  It’s better to have friends you can trust to take care of your practice when you’re away.

Poor Richard

The WSJ Law Blog posts that Judge Richard Sullivan ignored the expectations of both government and defense at the plea of Madoff co-conspirator Frank DiPascali.



Specifically, the 45-year-old Sullivan (William & Mary, Yale Law), who became a judge two years ago after spending more than 10 years as a prosecutor at the U.S. attorney’s office in Manhattan, denied bail to Frank DiPascali, a possible key witness in future Bernard Madoff-related prosecutions. That occurred after DiPascali pleaded guilty to helping carry out Madoff’s fraud scheme, including lying to investors, creating lots of fake documents, and repeatedly lying under oath to SEC investigators. He is facing 125 years in prison.
Let that be a lesson to would-be rats.  It doesn’t always cut the way you think, and sometimes, just sometimes, the judge won’t rubber stamp the deal.  Mike at Crime & Federalism praises Sullivan for his independence, and he’s got a good point.  The job of judge isn’t to play handmaiden to the government, and the judge is supposed to make up his own mind as to what the proper disposition should be.

But this comes at me from a somewhat different direction than Mike.  As one gets older, one sees kids grow up, and some eventually put on robes.  I remember Richard Sullivan as a snot-nosed AUSA, having had a case with him early in his prosecutorial career.  I’ve never been before him since he took the bench, but he was seriously anti-defendant then, and I can’t imagine that power has mellowed him any.  He was the kind of prosecutor who would demand extra time for a defendant because he figured he would commit a crime in the future, and he might as well get him sentence for it ahead of time.  Why get behind the curve?

Not all former prosecutors that I knew before they became judges turned out this way.  John Gleeson didn’t.  Louis Freeh, somewhat.  But Richard Sullivan was too tough as a prosecutor, and obviously hasn’t changed his ways.  I’m all for an independent judiciary, but I’m also for judges who don’t view themselves as avenging angels.  I don’t know that Richard Sullivan can ever be talked off the ledge, and I’m not for judges who think that there’s no such thing as too harsh.

But the good thing about Sullivan, and particularly his decision with regard to putting DiPascali in on the plea when everyone expected him to walk out, is that it shakes up the rules for rats that too many rely upon when talking their way out of culpability at the expense of their brothers. 

A large contingent of the defense bar has come to anticipate that they can skate around their responsibilities as defenders and fulfill their criminal clients’ wildest dreams by becoming adjuncts to the prosecution.  The clients say whatever they have to in order to save their skin; some of it may be true, but it’s often filled with the false details, the negative innuendo , that matches the prosecution’s desires to clean up a dirty case.  Let them have sleepness nights wondering whether they will have to face Judge Sullivan, who couldn’t give a rats ass what they sold to cut their deal.  And let their lawyers look like fools and liars when they slap on the cuffs.  This was never my idea of how to practice law, and I’ve never found a way to rationalize ignoring my duty to my clients to cut the quick and easy deal.

I guess there is a need for judges like Richard Sullivan.  I just hope that I’m never before him.  With my luck, he’ll be the judge in my next case.  And he’ll pay me back for my first one.

It’s 2:00 am; Do You Know Where Your Kids Are?

At least it’s 2 am in New York.  In Almeria, it’s 8 am, which means it’s time for fencers to start the day with a 5 mile run before breakfast.  Also before the temperature reaches 110 degrees in the shade. 

It’s hard to wake up at 1 in the morning, and on the first morning after arrival, your body still feels like it’s in New York, no matter what language the signs say.  But the coaches, none of whom are American by the way, feel that the United States fencers are soft and need some toughening up.  They are employing the modified Ukrainian method.  Modified only in the sense that there are no beatings with fists.  Otherwise, it’s the same.

The fencing venue looks to have been built for an Olympics, huge with tons of marble.  But no working air conditioning.  It gets incredibly hot in there, especially by the third practice of the day in the late afternoon.  The third practice lasts about 3 hours, or until someone passes out from heat exhaustion.  A few of us soft American parents try to remind the coaches that no child should die in this process.  They think we’re all wussies. 

For this week, they are fencing with the Ukrainian national team.  This isn’t the American national team, but just kid fencers who were good enough to get asked to come, so they are a bit outmatched.  Still, they are holding their own against the Ukrainians for the most part.  Mind you, the Ukrainian team is fresh when it starts fencing; the American kids have an hour workout in the heat before they start to bout.  Some of them look like they can’t stand up, they are so exhausted.  Still, they fence their hearts out.

Did I mention the food is awful?  I love Spanish food, but the food in the hotel is just miserable.  So it’s a good thing that the fencers are too tired to eat.  But then when sleep time rolls around, at 10 o’clock Almeria time (or 4 pm New York time), they can’t quite do it.  They toss and turn until about 4 am Almerica time (10 pm New York time), when they pass out.

But they are back up at  2 am New York time to run 5 miles the next morning.  These kids could argue, but they would rather do it, fight through the exhaustion and prove they are as tough as the Ukrainians. 

The real competition begins on Sunday.  We’re here early to get adjusted.  It’s taking quite a bit of adjustment.  If only they had better food. 

Simels Goes Down

Bob Simels was convicted of 12 out of 13 counts.



Robert Simels, a New York criminal defense lawyer, was convicted by a jury of a scheme to “eliminate” and “neutralize” federal witnesses slated to testify against one of his clients.


Simels, a former Special Assistant Attorney General for New York’s Special Prosecutor’s Office who once represented pop artist Peter Max, was convicted of 12 of 13 charges against him, including multiple counts of witness tampering, bribery, and illegal possession of eavesdropping equipment. He was cleared of a sole charge of making false statements to the U.S.
My understanding of the case, relying on some awful tapes made by the rat of Simels giving instruction about “eliminating” and “neutralizing” witnesses, is that the context and detail of the tapes was damning.  As much as he could explain his use of specific words, the surrounding detail was far harder to dismiss, and undermined his argument that this was just his way of using “street” talk to make his point to the rat.

In an earlier New York Law Journal article, a number of practitioners were asked if they would use language like Simels.  They gave carefully guarded answers, conceding that we talk to clients in a different fashion than we would to a judge or jury, using words designed to make our point in a way the listening would best understand.  Of course, no one was asked, or answered, about how much detail would be used in describing how one would eliminate a witness, particularly about harming bystanders in the process.  The lawyers were careful not suggest use of the precise language used by Simels.

This case will likely have a chilling effect on how lawyers speak to clients, their family and “friends” in the future.  It’s good that it does.  The words Bob Simels used weren’t necessary, and perhaps this will remind all of us not to be careless, sloppy or confusing in our choice of language.  Of course, the jury believed that Simels did chose his words carefully, and meant exactly what he said.

This should also remind us that we are lawyers, and our zealous representation must always remain within the bounds of the law. 

What is troubling is that Simels associate, Arienne Irving, who has been largely forgotten in this case although she too faces life in prison, was convicted along with Simels.  It’s my read from the news reports that there was essentially no evidence against her, other than being Simels associate.  While Simels is master of his own fate and made his own choices, I question what role she had in this fiasco, and whether her indictment was a ploy to get her to flip on Simels.  Now she’s convicted, and it’s not clear what she did or how she shared Simels’ intent to justify it. 

While it’s fair to rip Simels to shreds, give some though to Arienne Irving.


H/T Ed at Blawgreview.

Plax Cops to 2

In a shocking move, Plaxico Burress pleaded guilty to a sentence of 2 years imprisonment.  It’s not so much shocking because it ended up this way, but because this offer would have remained on the table until trial, leaving his lawyer, Ben Brafman, with the chance to move, per Heller, to dismiss the indictment, without any risk to the defendant’s circumstances.

Of course, sometimes defendants just want to be done with the case.  The fight drains out of them and the uncertainty becomes more painful than the harsh reality. 

I wonder if that’s happened here. 

The shame is that this was the perfect case for a Heller motion, but it’s not to be. 

Fender Bender. A Really Bad Fender Bender

There are fender benders and there are fender benders. This might be the all time worst.

For the one or two of you who, like me, didn’t make it out to the Monterrey Historic races, consider this one :


Some of us weren’t able to attend the Monterey Historic races over the weekend, but the first thing we heard once the laptop spooled up was that a very expensive Ferrari 250 TR smacked into a bunch of tires at Laguna Seca. This has turned into the crash heard ’round the world for a few simple reasons. Make that thirty four reasons, to be exact. That’s right Ferrari only made 34 250 Testa Rossas from 1956 to 1961. Actually, let’s just make that 21 reasons, as the 250 TR is the preferred version of the car, and only 19 customer cars and 2 racers were built between 1958 and 1959. And while a 1957 250 Testa Rossa just sold this past May for $12,200,000, making it the most expensive car, well, ever — the 1958 TR that cashed this weekend is “only” worth about $8 million.
Some might ask why anyone would drive a car this valuable around a race course.  Because this car must be driven.  There’s just no other answer.  Besides, if you can’t afford the crash, this isn’t the right car for you. 

 

And some details.





1958 Ferrari 250 TR post crash at Laguna Seca – click image above to watch the “video”

Here and There, Aqui y alli (Update)

The expediter expedited.  The impossible happened (and really quickly), and I am now on the Costa del Sol.  After putting the traumatic travel events behind me, I just wanted to let it be known that we are alive and kicking.  Tired, but kicking.  Cafe con leche helps.  Cerveza tambien.  Don’t even ask what it took to get from Malaga airport to the hotel in Almeria.

Only important news is that Supremes have sent Troy Davis back to the District Court for an evidentiary hearing.  He’s not dead yet, and maybe there’s still some life in actual innocence as well. 

I’ve read the comments left in the interim.  Some are great.  Some aren’t.  I leave them to you to figure it out.  For those inclined to be jerks, try your best not to.  Please.

Biggest question:  Why have we heard nothing from Dan Solove?  Maybe some of the other blawgers in the practical blawgosphere might be interested in why the lawprofs aren’t talking to them?

Second biggest question:  How many people at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center will smile at Andy Nolen, the scoundrel, when he walks down the hallway?

Hasta luego.

Update:  Met the former police commissioner of Andalucia, who just happens to be a fencing master training the Spanish national team.  He asked what I did for a living, via translator, and I explained I was a criminal defense lawyer.  He then responded, through the translator, that he knew I was a policeman the moment he saw me, and he’s going to take special care of my son.  Something was lost in translation, but I can live with that.

He asked me where I was from and I said Nueva York.  He said, “Guiliani?” and we both pretended to spit at the same time.  I guess Guiliani doesn’t translate well either.