The plan is that I’m to travel with my son today, to attend an international fencing camp where, ultimately, the Americans will fence the French for world supremacy. My son will be on the American team. The plan is that we’ll remain on the beautiful Costa del Sol for about two weeks, defending America’s honor. And other fun stuff.
If things work out the way they are planned, I should have access to the internet as I do normally. That’s what they told me. You might never know I was typing from a lounge chair on the playa. No, I will not be wearing a speedo. Trust me on this.
But so far, things aren’t working out exactly as planned. When I pulled out my passport this morning, I happened to take a look inside (for no particular reason) and noticed that it expired last April. Expired, as in it’s no good anymore to travel to Spain. I called the State Department, who asked me who died. I said I did. The duty officer was not amused.
So, very early tomorrow morning I will go to an expediter, who will take my expired passport and new application and a not insubstantial sum of money to the Passport officer and try to procure me a new one. I will wait around for him, folding and unfolding my hands. I will hum tunes. I will be patient. I have no choice. I screwed up. Now I must pay the piper. Or the expediter, as the case may be.
So things are in flux at the moment, but the one thing that will not happen is writing posts. When I say I’m going very early, I mean it, and there will be no time for posts. Whether there will be time later, or from Spain, or not from Spain according to how expeditious the expediter can be, has yet to be seen. I have no idea what the day will bring. But I will not disappoint my son, and I will do everything possible to make this trip happen.
At least, that’s the plan.
Author Archives: SHG
Come Out, Come Out, Wherever You Are
I’m rather surprised you continue to read Concurring Opinions given your contempt for academia. If we’re all a bunch of clueless out-of-touch fools with our heads in the clouds, and the true wisdom is held by those who practice law, then why waste your time reading us?
But perhaps that’s what you want to continue doing — make broad generalizations about academics and bash these stereotypes.
I’m not writing to try to convince you otherwise — the tone of your post and others demonstrates that you’re not likely to change your opinion of academics anytime soon. But I must say that I find your post and others about my co-bloggers to be unnecessarily dismissive and nasty.
I’m not writing to stop you. Continue on if you must. Hurl out your insults, hasty assumptions, and anti-academic tirades. It’s a big blogosphere, and everyone’s entitled to his/her opinion. I just couldn’t resist venting my annoyance.
I read Co-Op. I read PrawfsBlawg. I read many of the lawprof blawgs. I read them because many of the posts are fascinating, have new ideas or express worn thoughts in new ways. I read them because I learn from them. Although this might not give rise to a post about how wonderful they are, though it sometimes does, I read every post at Co-Op because it adds to my knowledge. Lawprofs are happy to receive positive reactions. But must they whine when it’s not all hugs and kisses?
And what about you? Do you read practitioner blawgs? Any of them? Aside from the odd post that mentions your name, what practitioner blawgs do you read regularly? When is the last time you, or anyone over at Co-Op, has suggested that a practitioner has anything worthwhile to add? Practitioners have quite a bit to say, and a wealth of insight into how the law actually functions. Yet you wouldn’t know it from Co-Op.
But here’s an idea: attack the arguments he’s actually making. Not “the true wisdom is held by those who practice law”, but some useful wisdom and insight into law is learned by the practice of law, and ought to be incorporated into the study of law — particularly by those who are going to teach others to practice law.My “attacks” on academia, which Dan reads as “vehement contempt,” are invitations to challenge the intersection of theory and practice. While many practitioners have no use for academics, many of whom have little or no real world experience in the law despite the fact that they are charged with raising the next crop of practicing lawyers, I disagree. As I explained in my response to Dan’s comment (which he would have called a tirade had I written it to him, but I won’t because he’ll be offended by my tone), we can do better working together than ignoring each other.
He didn’t say that for the first — or twenty-first time — in his response to you here; it’s a theme he’s been harping on as long as I’ve been a regular reader of SJ.
From this outsider’s POV, it’s a curiosity of legal academia. In medical academia, there’s a whole lot of attention paid to the experience of clinicians — and if you need a few cites, they’re easy to find. In Civil Engineering trade schools, a whole lot of the academics not only have done things like, say, build bridges what haven’t fallen down, but pay a fair amount of attention to them what has built bridges what haven’t fallen down.
John Neff’s reaction to the tête-à-tête was that the practitioners were being “shunned” by the lawprofs. I suspect that Dan doesn’t see it that way. I suspect that Dan sees it the problem as one of our making, that we’re too inclined to attack in offensive tones and course language. We can’t manage to get our point across in a sufficiently nuanced, which some might characterize as effete, manner. Dan is right about this. We are a bit brutish compared to the lawprofs, and they may be rightly offended by our tone.
But is the answer to hide, Dan? You think we don’t like you. We think you don’t like us. Outsiders think this is ridiculous, having the potential for far more useful discussion and avoiding it because of hard feelings.
So I pose a question to all of the academics, the scholars, the lawprofs out there. Not just Dan, who was at least ballsy enough to show up here to vent his feelings, but to all of you who post at blawgs about the law, about subjects that affect real people, about your theories that you want judges to adopt. Why won’t you engage in discussions with practitioners?
In the past, you’ve been forced to endure the allegation that you are engaged in a “circle jerk,” a crude description that, almost to a person, has caused no shortage of anger. But the point of this description is that you only interact amongst your own kind, a closed circle that allows for no outsider dissent or challenge. I officially apologize for my own use of this offensive and juvenile phrase, though not for the concept it embodies. It’s accurate. But it can be changed.
And if you don’t respond, don’t engage, continue to shun practicing lawyers while inviting only members of your own club to react, we are left to conclude that you have no faith in your scholarship, that it can’t withstand scrutiny by practitioners. If so, then what purpose is there to your scholarship? All those smart people holed away in the Ivory Tower, unwilling to have their theories put to the test. Then we are left with no doubt that you write only to amuse yourselves and impress your friends in the Academy.
Is that all there is to legal academia? Maybe I’m way off the mark. Hey, I’m no scholar, just a trench lawyer trying to learn a thing or two from people who have better thoughts than me. If I’m wrong, let me know. Dan, Dave, the other Dan, anyone? Let’s get this out in the open. It’s time for a little sunshine on this divide between the acadmics and the practitioners. Let me have it. Hit me with your best shot. I can take it. Let’s air it out and then put this hostility behind us. We will all be better off this way.
But stop hiding. We know you’re out there.
Health Care Follies
Discussion of health care is all the rage in the media, and like most of you, I watch and read with delight, learning much about my fellow Americans. My self-perception was that I was reasonably well-informed, but I’ve come to learn that my certainty that health care reform was needed, but nagging doubts about whether the proposals on the table were adequate, reflect my ignorance.
The media has been bending over backwards to try to show sentiment from all sides of the debate. It seems that mine isn’t shared by many. Most people are either quite certain that the Democrats’ plans are the spawn of the devil or that they are Utopian dreams. And Sarah Palin insists that we’ll have death panels, no matter what anybody says, so that her quitting government won’t be in vain.
Here are some of the things I learned:
An altacacca informed me that she won’t tolerate government messing with her medicare, and government better keep its mitts out of healthcare.
A men from Georgia, who I believe is a baseball player for the team “John Deere” based upon his cap, though his weight belies his athleticism, informed me that 85% of Americans already have healthcare and are doing just fine, so why screw it all up for the 15% who are too lazy to get a job.
A morbidly obese woman, who seemed very nice and cuddly, informed me that the government is violating her constitutional rights by making her pay for someone else’s healthcare.
A man in Pennsylvania informed me that Arlen Specter is evil and will have to stand before God one day for judgment.
Utah Senator Orrin Hatch informed me that it is wrong to characterize people expressing their concerns by screaming stupid stuff in public at government officials as unAmerican. I bet Henry Gates will be happy to hear this.
I’ve come to realize that anyone who has healthcare coverage that they don’t have to pay for themselves is very happy with the current system, and that as much as they don’t want anyone denied coverage (except people who speak Spanish), they aren’t about to jeopardize their own situation to help them.
I’ve come to realize that there are a lot of people who just hate paying taxes, and anything that holds the potential to raise taxes is evil. This doesn’t apply to bombs and weapons systems, which are needed to protect freedom. Freedom isn’t free.
I’ve come to realize that the Constitution protects Americans, and that each and every American gets to interpret it in whatever way best suits their pocketbook. While I’ve long believed that the Constitution is a flexible document, I never realized it was that flexible.
I’ve come to realize that healthcare is an individual right. Individual in the sense that only that one individual has a right to it, and all the other individuals can go screw themselves.
I’ve come to realize that very few, maybe even no one, shares my concerns over whether a subject as sensitive and critical as healthcare can be entrusted to a new bureaucracy comprised of official women will fulfill the needs of Americans who are currently paying exorbitant premiums or have no access to care aside from emergency rooms today. While carriers and managed care providers have done a less than spectacular job of demonstrating an intelligent approach, I remain concerned that government could be as bad if not worse at it.
I similarly worry that the monies siphoned out of the system in salaries, bonuses and profits of private insurers, drug companies, doctors with their own CAT scans convincing seniors who use their offices as social centers to have every booboo tested, resulting in the exorbitant premiums paid by those of us who don’t have an employer to cover our costs, will be lost to government officials whose assistants, undersecretaries, deputies, assistant deputies and their 75,000 employees in 96 regional centers instead.
I worry that the conference committee will design a camel to race with thoroughbreds, in order to appease every special interest group needed to be on board with reform.
And I worry about the people who live amongst us and don’t have affordable health care. They are perfectly nice people. They have cute kids. They could use access to health care too. I know that it could cost me some more money, though I still can’t figure out where all the money I pay in premiums is going since my family only uses about 1% of what we pay in premiums for our medical needs. But my American can afford to make sure no one lacks medical care. Or starves to death. I’m prepared to give up a few bunker busters to pay for it, and maybe a F-whatever bomber or two.
But then, I don’t know nearly as much about healthcare as others. Or so I’m informed.
Reason #37 To Hire Cops Who Shave
Long Branch, New Jersey, police officers Kristie Buble and Derrick Meyers, both 24, walked up to some old guy, wet from the rain and peering into the window of a vacant house, to investigate. He told them his name, but he had no ID. The accompanied him to his tour buses, where he proved he was Bob Dylan.
Like a rolling stone. It’s hard to be a legend in New Jersey.
Addendum: Dr. SJ informs me that I’m an idiot for making light of this as just another stupid story. “Since when does someone have to produce identification to cops in order to walk around?” She’s right, of course. I find myself relieved whenever a police/citizen interaction doesn’t result in tasing, arrest or death. My expectations are so very low.
Does The Word “Slackoisie” Offend You? Good
Stephanie West-Allen has posted a commentary by Susan Cartier Liebel, shopkeeper at Solo Practice University, that followed yet another self-justifying article by a generational consultant at Forbes, about how Susan doesn’t care for the word “Slackoisie”. The term, “coined by Dan Hull and April Boyer,” and one of my personal favs, offends Susan.
There’s a ridiculous term floating around ‘Slackoisie’ to describe Gen Y. It offended me because it implies wanting something ‘different’ then the same work model meant you were in your parent’s basement, eating potato chips in your pajamas playing on the internet waiting for your million dollar idea without working for it. I’m a tail-end baby boomer and I totally relate to this article. I want to fall down in a stupor when I hear that those who want to change the model are slackers (ergo the term ‘slackoisie’). If someone can build a better mouse trap, bring it on!
What these ‘elders’ are really offended by is something noted in this article, a lack of respect and skepticism for those over 30, that somehow those under 30 know more, are better qualified to do anything and resent those over 30 for the world we live in which isn’t to their current liking. But that’s a very different reason for ‘over 30’s’ disdain of Gen Y. It has nothing to do with their work ethic. It has to do with Gen Y’s lack of ‘respect’ and maybe even gratitude for those who are older.
And maybe this is simply nothing knew…except the terminology.
Let’s take this from the top. The term “Slackoisie” is derogatory. By definition, it’s supposed to offend those it describes, or else it wouldn’t be very derogatory, now would it? Thus, if it offends you, then it’s doing its job. This doesn’t make it ridiculous, but a term that serves its purpose.
That said, it’s not left to those who are offended by a word to decide on its definition. I realize that Susan is playing to an audience that is unfamiliar with logic, or logical fallacies, and wouldn’t be inclined to pick up her enjoyment of the strawman fallacy. That’s the nature of the Slackoisie. The symmetry of using a fallacious argument to rally those who couldn’t comprehend why it’s fallacious is nothing to sneeze at. It’s a great tool, provided that no one points out that you can’t do that. But there was little chance of that happening when it was used to bolster an article that no intelligent person would read.
So why was Susan so offended?
It offended me because it implies wanting something ‘different’ then the same work model meant you were in your parent’s basement, eating potato chips in your pajamas playing on the internet waiting for your million dollar idea without working for it.
Well, it doesn’t “imply” any such thing. That’s very clearly what it refers to, though it’s about Doritos and not potato chips. Please get your snack foods right, Sue. You don’t get to redefine it because you want to be the heroine of the Slackoisie. But what you’re trying to convey, though somewhat obscured by some mixed tenses and dubious word choices, is that you’re offended by its denigration of work/life balance, the touchstone of the Slackoisie.
Guess what? Tough nuggies. Now I realize as much as the next guy that work/life balance is a sacred cow of the Slackoisie, and these are your bread and butter at your version of pay-per-view, Solo Practice University. You have to keep up appearances of agreeing with these kids who are willing to pay to learn the magic bullet of internet marketing so that they don’t have to put in the effort of gaining competence and wasting all that time providing excellent client service. It’s so much easier to just market themselves online to make a quick buck and achieve success as solos. We’ve crossed this bridge many times already.
But don’t blame me for refusing to keep this dirty little secret quiet. My perspective is the practice of law, not the selling of SPU. I hate to remind you of this, Susan, but you made your choice when you decided to put marketing ahead of competence. I don’t blame you, since you can count on the marketers to do everything in their power to help you achieve financial success at SPU, as it also serves their pecuniary interests as well. A guy like me would be terribly disruptive, saying mean things whenever the integrity of the profession was at risk. You can’t have integrity when you’re trying to run a business.
So if you’re of the view that the millennials don’t fit the definition of the Slackoisie, then there’s no reason the word should bother you at all. And yet it does. You say, “if someone can build a better mousetrap, then bring it on.” Better for whom, Susan? That’s Stephanie’s point. It’s all about what’s good for the Slackoisie. There’s no mention of what’s better for the clients.
Until those who want to lead the great unwashed into successful solo practice recognize that this is a profession, the purpose of which is to serve our clientèle, the word Slackoisie will continue to appear. And it will continue to sting and offend. As it should.
Bad Result Breeds Ineffective Assistance
From this New York Law Journal article (which is unfortunately only available to those willing to pay for the privilege), Carrion was convicted in 1991 after a high speed chase and shootout, where he was holding 11 pounds of cocaine. He got the worst of the battle and was left a paraplegic. In 2004, Carrion sought a writ of habeas corpus which, after going up and down, was granted by SDNY Judge Shira Scheindlin, rejecting the magistrate’s recommendation for denial.
“Carrion testified that [Roy] Kulcsar never advised him as to the sentencing ranges for the charges he faced,” Judge Scheindlin wrote in her 51-page opinion. “Although this testimony is self-serving, I find it credible, especially given his demeanor in testifying and Carrion’s other corroborating testimony that he lacked the sophistication to invent.”
On the other hand, she said, Mr. Kulcsar “testified he had no present recollection if he ever discussed with Carrion the mandatory minimum and maximum sentences for every count in the indictment.”
I have long admired Judge Scheindlin’s deep concern for the rights of defendants. She’s a bold judge, and has always demonstrated a heartfelt understanding that real people suffer in the system when things go awry by doing something about it. And clearly, a leap from 10 years to 125 emits a horrible stench. But was this Roy’s fault?
“Given that the drug charge carried a minimum of 15 years-to-life, the People’s plea offer of 10 years-to-life was extremely generous,” she said. “There was no reason why Carrion should not have taken the plea offer and certainly no reason why Carrion should not have been strongly advised of the advantages of doing so.”
Judge Scheindlin found that Mr. Kulcsar’s assistance “fell below an objective standard of reasonableness” because “he failed to advise Carrion of the sentencing exposure he faced if he were convicted at trial” and “he failed to give Carrion advice regarding the advisability of accepting the plea offer that was sufficiently robust under the circumstances.”
Roy’s position is clear:
“I don’t believe a lawyer’s role is to tell a defendant what to do,” Mr. Kulcsar said. “You see applications all the time where a defendant pleads guilty and he says, ‘Well, the lawyer told me to plead guilty.'”It’s all too easy to Monday-morning quarterback the decision to accept or reject a plea offer. Should it be the law that the attorney decide whether the defendant should take the plea, and then manipulate, cajole, force the plea upon the defendant. I think not. In fact, I think that forcing a defendant to cop a plea is one of the most unethical things an attorney can do. Explain it fully, honestly and clearly? Absolutely. Advise the defendant as to the relative risk of a plea versus trial? Absolutely. Ram it down his throat? No. Never. The ultimate choice must always belong to the client, after he has been fully and properly advised.
It strikes me that Judge Scheindlin’s decision was designed to provide Carlos Carrion with relief that he deserved, and that Roy was just the conduit to justify the outcome. My bet is Roy’s shoulders are big enough to carry the weight, and his reputation can well withstand the smack. But it didn’t have to fall on Roy for justice to prevail.
The better alternative would have been to lay blame for the outrageous distinction between the 10 year plea offer and the sentence of 125 years on former Judge Snyder, who exacted a spectacular penalty for Carrion’s having exercised his right to trial. Famous for her excessive sentences and inappropriate vituperative rants, the 125 year sentence provided a far better justification for the grant of habeas relief than Roy’s advice.
But then, it may be more palatable to lay blame on the defense lawyer than a judge. At least Carlos Carrion received relief, and I bet that Roy Kulcsar would rather he be blamed for insufficient advice than see his former client suffer. That’s the kind of lawyer Roy is.
Endorsement: Cy Vance, Jr. for Manhattan District Attorney
Consideration of who should sit in a chair that’s held but one backside for the entirety of my legal career, plus, comes from both the perspective of the citizen as well as criminal defense lawyer. The New York County District Attorney’s office is an impressive animal, both from the excellent quality of its staff as well as its internal integrity. I’ve fought with these guys for over 25 years, and while it hasn’t always been perfect, it’s been by far the best I’ve dealt with.
Filling Robert Morgenthau’s shoes is not going to be easy. He’s been a towering figure, as was his predecessor, Frank Hogan. There are many who wear the “tough on crime” mantle, and would use the office to pander to the fears of New Yorkers, but few who have the fortitude to both do the job demanded of the person who can almost see Wall Street from the very large office, but do it with the level of integrity and self-restraint shown by Morgenthau, as well as improve its fairness based upon what we’ve come to know about a flawed system and the handling of such awesome power.
Cyrus Vance, Jr., is the right person for the job.
All New Yorkers look to the DA to fulfill his duty to protect them from crime. Even criminal defense lawyers seek an effective prosecutor, as much as some might not appreciate that we walk the street too, and have no desire to be anyone’s victim. But everyone wants to be a crime-fighter, so that claim offers little to the mix that we couldn’t find elsewhere.
It’s Cy’s broader vision, his understanding that insensitivity to the cultural differences amongst New Yorkers, blind faith and support for police that leads to abuse, misconduct and deception, that undermines a willing adherence to the law and a city dedicated to fairness for all.
Some years ago, it was the strength and integrity of Robert Morgenthau’s Official Corruption Bureau Chief that led me to bring information about abuse and corruption within the 30th Precinct. Recognizing the depth of the problem, and accepting the premise that only from defendants would he learn what the cops were really doing on the street, this generated the investigation that led to the Dirty 30 scandal. It’s this concern for integrity that can’t be lost in the zeal to be “tough on crime.” Morgenthau had it. Cy Vance has it as well.
What makes me say this? Check out Cy’s position on fair convictions. He’s not merely aware of the wealth of issue surrounding bad IDs, junk science and false confessions, but he’s determined to put an end to the conviction of the innocent, “just because they can.” Cy realizes that wrongful convictions are a societal disaster, and has shown the guts to acknowledge that they happen and that it’s his job to do something about it.
If this wasn’t enough, just yesterday Cy did something that blew my socks off. He publicly announced his endorsement by Barry Scheck and Peter Neufeld of the Innocence Project. My enormous admiration for Barry’s and Peter’s work aside, the fact that Cy is proud of his support beyond the “usual suspects” speaks volumes.
I could offer reasons why I have issues with Cy’s opponents for the office, but there’s no need to go negative about them. My endorsement of Cy Vance isn’t based on his being merely better than other, less worthy candidates. I endorse Cy Vance because he’s the right person for District Attorney, no matter who else is running. Cyrus Vance, Jr. is the right person to fill Robert Morgenthau’s shoes.
But Technology Doesn’t Love You Back
Over at Law21, Jordan Furlong has been the prophet of technological change, dedicated to the proposition that tech changes everything. And indeed, he’s proven himself right, but not in the way he hoped. After noting that he’s been good about saving his posts to Word files, just in case, he explains:
The reason why I take all these steps was amply illustrated yesterday when URL-shortening service Tr.im shut down with no advance warning. All of the stats it was tracking have disappeared, and all the links it created could be gone by Jan. 1, 2010. If you’ve been following me on Twitter, this could be problematic, since I’ve been using tr.im links for a few months now. (I switched from tinyurl.com and eventually from bit.ly simply because tr.im bought me one extra character to play with,vital in Twitter’s 140-character universe.) It’s a bigger problem for me, though, because I’ve been using Twitter as a micro-publishing tool, so I’ll now need to go back, click on all those tr.im links I posted, and resave them using some other method. That’s assuming, of course, Twitter keeps my old posts — Robert Scoble, for one, isn’t sure they even exist anymore.
Jordan’s post is a warning to others. I am amongst those others. We have a vast assortment of tech tools available to us, with a equally vast array of cheerleaders imploring us to move into the 21st Century, hop on the bandwagon, get with it. What few talk about is that some of these tools won’t be around tomorrow. Or the next day.
And as some tech falls by the wayside, so too will the content and connections we thought were safe.
I learned this lesson the hard way when my VoiP provider, Sunrocket, disappeared off the face of the earth one day, holding my telephone number captive. No warning. No notice. Just here today, gone tomorrow. Tough luck, baby.
Chances are pretty good that anyone reading this post has become dependent, to some greater or lessor extent, on the miracle of modern technology. Some love it so very much that they lead cheers, and maybe even pray to it in privacy. But the assumption that because it exists today, it will continue tomorrow, is foolishness.
New technologies come and go. I’ve got my old Iomega zip drive, on which I backed up a ton of data, which won’t work with the USB port on my rather pedestrian computer. If I need to access the data, I’ll need a new zip drive. But then, who needs a zip drive when my flash drive does it all, and better.
Then again, every post on Simple Justice is stored on a server located in the bowels of somebody’s business. I couldn’t tell you where, and it wouldn’t really matter if I could. I depend upon the fact that they will continue to be there, but if they pull the plug tomorrow because cash flow has dried up, everything would be gone. Unlike Jordan, I haven’t saved my posts to Word files. Or any other files. I just write, and let the magic of technology do the rest.
As some of Jordan’s commenters note, I consider it ephemeral, and it’s not like I would recreate it if it disappeared. But then, I would certainly prefer it remain in existence rather than disappear. And if it did disappear tomorrow, I might have a different opinion about its existence, since you don’t know what you’ve got till it’s gone.
To anyone who has been around long enough to remember when vinyl was replaced by 8 tracks, you know better than to trust in the future of technology. Some of it never catches on, and some of it now seems so antiquated as to be laughable. What were we thinking?
Still, this hasn’t stopped today’s techno-savants from believing with all their heart and soul that the latest, greatest miracle of science is the final word. And they are betting their lives on it. Or at least their life’s work.
Having never had the mind for predicting the next great thing in tech, I demur to more savvy individuals. I’ve no doubt that Jordan is absolutely right that technology has, and will continue to, change the way we practice law. You can’t go back to the farm after you’ve used twitter (to micro-blog, I’m told).
But no matter how much you love technology, never forget that it doesn’t love you back. Thanks for the reminder, Jordan.
The Alfalfa Field Doctrine
Daniel Lira, 32, was working inside Wal-Mart’s loading dock area when he got into an argument with co-worker Craig Schmidt, 49. He ended up hitting Schmidt in the face. Schmidt responded by pulling out a .25-caliber semiautomatic Beretta handgun and shooting Lira in the head from as little as 10 feet away. Yellowstone County Attorney Dennis Paxinos, however, released Schmidt in light of Montana’s “castle doctrine law” which allows citizens to use potentially lethal force in self-defense — despite the escalation in the level of force by Schmidt from a fist fight to a shooting.The bullet did not kill Lira but grazed his head.
The means by which self-defense in the homes slips down the slope to shoot anyone who might hurt you in church isn’t all that hard to follow.
As State Representative Krayton Kerns (R-Laurel) explained in one news report, “The ‘castle doctrine’ only applied to an occupied structure, one tiny little place, (but) what if you’re not in an occupied structure? What if you’re out in an alfalfa field? What if you’re walking down the street with your wife, your kids and your dog? It’s too restrictive to have it just be the ‘castle doctrine’. You are the castle. Wherever you go, your right to self defense goes with you.”Makes perfect sense, doesn’t it? After all, if it’s about defending oneself, should it matter where the threat occurs? Are we less interested in self-defense in the alfalfa field than the bedroom? Does the attack hurt any less?
The problem, of course, is twofold. First, who is attacking whom is often a subjective matter, if we assume good faith on the part of the shooter to begin with. Rarely does anyone say, “well, yeah, I attacked him and he defended himself by punching me back, so I pulled out my Beretta and killed him.” On the other hand, someone inclined toward shooting someone who really pisses them off when there’s no one else around could rather easily say that the victim attacked and he merely defended himself. Dishonest, perhaps, but certainly not inconceivable.
I can already hear the choir in the background, in a slow, Texas drawl, chanting, “better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6.” But fellas, you don’t know which end of the Beretta you’re going to end up on. If you’re in your own home, then at least we have a way to measure who gets to shoot whom. We’re all equal in the alfalfa field.
Lawyers test arguments by taking them to their logical extreme and seeing whether the theory underlying them holds up or produces absurd results. Unfortunately, the logical extreme often involves a Wal-Mart, which can’t be good for business.
The controversy over whether killing a person who enters (or comes close to) your home (or an unoccupied neighbors home) has yet to be resolved. The straight-out Castle Doctrine hasn’t proven to be as simple to execute in a rational manner, consistent with the notion that we just don’t kill people for lack of a decent show on TV, as hoped. Nonetheless, the machismo of cheap life and self-righteousness has greased the slope to the point of landing on the loading dock of Wal-Mart.
The really crazy part of this is that there will be many who will argue that this return to the wild west is what America is all about. Of course, that’s as long as the other guy doesn’t draw first.
Another Tragedy Brings Another Law
When Diane Schuler’s car, carrying 5 children, crashed going the wrong way on the Taconic Parkway, it was a tragedy. Four dead in her minivan, and another 3 in Guy Bastardi’s trailblazer. But when it was revealed that she had a blood alcohol level of .19, not to mention pot in her system, it was an opportunity not to be missed.
And like clockwork, the politicians have come up with a new law. First, Republican State Senator Charles Fuschillo. Then Democratic Governor David Paterson. Naturally, Nassau District Attorney Kathleen Rice, the drunk driving avenger who has used murder charges as the hammer to pound her name into the minds of voters, locked arms with the Fuschillo proposal.
The gist of the new proposal is to enhance punishment for those who drive drunk with a child passenger.
Cases of aggravated vehicular homicide or aggravated vehicular assault in which a child passenger is killed or seriously injured would be treated as violent felonies, with penalties ranging from 3½ to 25 years in prison.It’s a well worn equation: Death of a child + drunk driving = new law. It’s always good for a political play, showing how our elected officials are “doing something” about the latest problem on our radar. And, as usual, few consider its illogic, necessity or unintended consequences.
In addition to tightening penalties, the proposed legislation would treat those caught on a first drunken-driving offense with a child passenger as “serious offenders” and require that they be subject to a mandatory interlock provision for one year. The provision requires the installation of a device that makes the car inoperable unless the driver demonstrates, via a breathalyzer test, that he or she is not under the influence of alcohol. Right now, the installation of interlock devices is left to judges’ discretion.
There are sound arguments for using child passengers as an enhancement factor, foremost of which is that the drunk driver knows as he cranks the ignition that he’s got children in the car, whereas having a child in the car to be hit or crossing the road is an unknown variable. To impose an additional duty of care because of this makes sense. Further, children aren’t in a position to take the keys away from a drunk adult, or to call themselves a cab rather than drive away with a drunken adult. And finally, children may not have the capacity to recognize that Mom or Dad or Uncle Joey is smashed, or sufficiently “happy” to make them a danger on the road.
But on the flip side, the death of an innocent victim is still death, tragic and undeserved. The family of Guy Bastardi doesn’t take comfort in the fact that he was an adult when he died. His children don’t feel better about it. Nor does 15 year old Joseph Marino, mowed down on his bicycle yesterday by Caroline Goss, with her 6 year old in the Jeep Cherokee, as he clings to life.
There is a difference between the driver with .08 BAC and .19 BAC. But there is little difference between the driver on the cellphone whose neglect kills someone. There is a difference, of course, for texting while driving, which is far more dangerous than drunk driving. Twenty-three times more dangerous.
The difference here is that the death of a child produces a visceral reaction of horror, which blinds us to reason, and that there are few supporters of drunk drivers, to speak out for a rational approach. On the other hand, conduct perceived as less morally culpable but as or more dangerous, is a much harder target. As the drunk driving laws become increasingly harsh, mandatory and convoluted by new laws crafted in knee-jerk reaction to specific incidents, while the law simultaneously ignores impending tragedy by more socially acceptable weapons, we end up with a satisfying yet irrational state of affairs.
The law already criminalized the endangerment of children, whether by driving drunk or any other way one can imagine. It’s one the books, and been on the books, for a long time. Adding an enhancement from another angle to replicate existing law changes nothing and exposes people to inconsistent, and therefore arbitrary, punishment.
On the other hand, the wrong that drunk driving laws seek to prohibit isn’t altered by the tragic outcome, but the initial turn of the key in the ignition. Whether one makes it home safely or kills a busload of children bears no connection to the causal conduct. Culpability should be driven by mens rea rather than fortuitous outcomes.
Similarly, if the busload of children are killed by the driver texting rather than drunk, are the children less dead? Will their parents be less heartbroken? But texting doesn’t have the moral culpability that we impose on a drunk driver.
And then there is the issue of blood alcohol content as the measure of the crime. Criminal laws are supposed to be crafted in such a way as to give ordinary citizens notice of the prohibited conduct, but no person can determine his BAC, a scientific measure. Rather, it’s a standard designed to facilitate prosecution, providing police and prosecutors with a brightline measure of guilt rather than a citizen of a brightline measure of prohibited conduct.
And as the push to stop drunk driving achieved greater momentum, the BAC limit dropped, now at .08. The number is arbitrary, and fails to take into account a variety of critical factors that distinguish between the drunk driver and someone in full possession of their faculties. Compare the female, 105 lb. occasional drinker at .07 with the male, 237 lb. hard drinker at .10, the former being a danger and the latter being as good as he is when sober.
While we use the word “drunk”, a pejorative term designed to impugn the driver, the law encompasses the absolutely ordinary diner who has enjoyed a bottle of 1961 Château Lafitte Rothschild with dinner as well, and then drives home from a very fine restaurant. The line between the drunk and the fine diner is too unclear to offer guidance between the gourmet wine enthusiast and whiskey swilling animal. We don’t know until we read the headlines the next morning who is who.
I’m neither a fan nor apologist for the drunk driver. I don’t care much for the cellphone talker and really can’t stand the texter. It pains me when a child dies in a tragic accident, and when an adult dies too. Yet I’m a huge fan of rational, comprehensive, well-conceived, properly designed laws that are narrowly tailored to address the conduct at issue and meld appropriately with existing law.
Every time a tragedy strikes these days, the law suffers along with the victims. We’ve got to stop letting the headlines drive legislation rather than reason. It’s not that the problems aren’t real, but that the legal solutions aren’t sound.
