Author Archives: SHG

AALS Creates Permanent Committee on Hemlines

Some years, hemlines go up.  Some years, hemlines go down.  If they didn’t go up some years and down others, there would be no reason for hemlines scholars to exist.  And so it goes for the American Association of Law Schools, which has decided to grant permanent status to a Section for the flavor of the month, balance.


The AALS granted permanent status to its Section on Balance in Legal Education! The Section aims to maximize the health, well-being and career satisfaction of law students and lawyers. I applaud the AALS for recognizing that this area needs attention and creating a permanent Section on Balance.

Balanced law students develop positive habits in law school that carry with them to their law practices. No matter the area of law, having good coping skills for stress, an established personal moral code, and a sense of purpose are essential for not only career satisfaction but embodying the high level of professionalism expected at the bar.
Do unbalanced law students wobble and fall down?

It’s ironic that at a time when practitioners (and law students) argue that law school fails to put our young lawyer capable of performing the duties expected of them, a position that lawprofs contend is wrong and ignorant, since they certainly are far better at self-assessment than are the people hiring and working with their student output, the AALS chooses to focus on balance.

Like so many contentions that are politically popular but nonsensical, the words strung together not only fail to make a cognizable sentence, but appear to be facially contradictory.  How does career satisfaction lead to a high level of professionalism?  I don’t know either.  Both are nice phrases, but there’s no logical nexus between them. 

But the part that really amuses is the part where balance law students will establish a personal moral code.  Would that be the moral code that tells them it’s perfectly fine to wear ripped jeans and flip flops in court?  After all, it’s personal and they’re allowed to decide for themselves what morality should be. That’s balance?

This is another example of using peppy phraseology to conceal a substantive swamp.  Balance means the antithesis of professional responsibility; it’s the right to only have to be professional when it’s convenient, so that one can enjoy whatever life has to offer whenever one wants to, professional responsibility be damned. 

And by the way, it we leave it up to each individual to develop their own personal moral code, remember that there are other Jeffrey Dahmers out there.  Get the point?  This is one incredibly dumb idea.  I only wish it was surprising.

Next year, the AALS will be considering a permanent section on Ice Cream Parties.  It very controversial, with the Anti-Balloon group raising quite a ruckus.

H/T Stephanie West-Allen at Idealawg.

It All Comes Down To The Taser

When Ryan Smith’s tasing into compliance with a court-ordered subpoena for his DNA was approved by Niagara County Judge Sara Sheldon Sperrazza, the blogosphere was shocked.  Mind you, this news was broken here (via our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen Casey, who took the trouble to get her hands on the decision) and then repeated across the blogosphere by worthless miscreants who wrote about it as if they had discovered it all by themselves, without so much as a hat tip.

But unlike those bottom feeders, our hinterlands correspondent remains on top of the Smith case, bringing the next piece of this ugly puzzle from the Smith trial, via the Buffalo News :



But Delorise Garner couldn’t identify any of the attackers, including Ryan S. Smith, 21, who is on trial in the home invasion, a subsequent shooting and a separate gas station robbery.

That failure to identify will be typical of this trial, co-defense counsel David C. Douglas said in his opening statement.

“You won’t hear any human being identify Ryan Smith as a person who was at any of the crime scenes,” Douglas told the jury of eight women and four men.

But DNA will place Smith at the scenes, Assistant District Attorney Susan B. Bjornholm said.
Not that eyewitness identifications have any great credibility, but they certainly serve to convey the victim’s trauma.  On the other hand, DNA is scientific, and everybody knows that if science says so, then it has to be.

The upshot, however, is that the Smith trial without the DNA seized by taser would be . . . over.  Without a means of identifying the perpetrator of a crime, there’s no case.  When the issue arose as to the use of a taser to obtain Smith’s submission to the police, or his willing consent as the police might frame it, there was no indication that the DNA wasn’t just icing on the cake, with the cake being the testimony of eyewitnesses that Ryan Smith was the perp. 

We now know differently.  We now know that without the DNA, which the prosecution had obtained earlier but lost, the case was done.  It’s now the critical link between a potential conviction and a trial order of dismissal.  This obviously ups the stakes for both sides on trial, and for those observing who were appalled at the use of a taser to put a smile on Smith’s face.  Do you feel strong enough about the impropriety of using a taser to obtain compliance with a subpoena to watch Ryan Smith walk?

As is so often the case, law is made like sausage.  Ryan Smith is not a sympathetic fellow.  He’s not a hero.  While I don’t know him, my guess is that he’s not the sort of fellow you want dating your daughter.  But this is where bad decisions happen, when dumb cops, over-zealous prosecutors, outcome-oriented judges, all meet. 

It would have been far easier for Judge Sperrazza if the prosecution had a victim who could ID Smith as the assailant, so that she could suppress the DNA, chastise the cops for being boneheads, and issue a decision that wouldn’t have subjected her to blawgospheric ridicule.  But she’s looking down the throat of a potential walk of the accused if she tosses the DNA, and Judge Sperrazza wasn’t about to take the risk.  The risk of Ryan Smith walking.  The risk of siding with the defense.  If she’s going to get beaten up, better that it be for backing the good guys of law and order than the vicious, nasty Ryan Smith.

While the trial isn’t over yet, and the defense will challenge the DNA as flawed, experience teaches that overcoming scientific evidence like this is extremely difficult.  Jurors don’t understand it and accept it at face value.  Truth is, same with judges and lawyers.  Even experts have problems trying to make anyone else understand its complexities and why things aren’t always as simple as people would like them to be.

But it would certainly make Judge Sperrazza’s life easier if the defense scores big on beating up the DNA evidence and gets an acquittal.  Then, there will be no appeal of the DNA taser ruling, and she can forget that it ever happened.  Until the next time, when some other judge cites to her decision approving the use of a taser as the friendly persuader.

Another Lesson From Charlie Nesson

Harvard lawprof Charles Nesson was thought a visionary by all. Well, almost all, given that Ken at Popehat has yet to forgive him for throwing chalk at him in evidence class.  But Ken aside, Nesson saw the future of the internet well before most. 


Ten years ago, Professor Lessig dedicated his first book to Professor Nesson: “For Charlie Nesson, whose every idea seems crazy — for about a year.”

That’s really something.  If the rest of us have one novel idea in our lifetime, we’re way ahead of the crowd.  Charlie Nesson thought differently than the rest of us.  He saw things that we couldn’t, wouldn’t, see. 

This is why his invitation to add his brilliance to the defense of Joel Tenenbaum against the hated RIAA, the storm troopers of the music industry, was greeted with such excitement.  Aside from the outrageously draconian penalties exacted by the RIAA with Congress’ blessing, this was where old school copyright, the ability of a creator to earn money from his work, met new school freedom to enjoy the intellectual property of others without compensation. 

It was a disaster.  From the New York Times post-mortem :


The problems for the case, however, started well before the first day of trial; Professor Nesson’s court filings and tactics were decidedly informal and offbeat. As part of his almost obsessive desire for transparency and documentation, he posted a recorded telephone conference call with the judge and industry lawyers on his blog, and even posted e-mail messages from friends discussing case strategy.

The crucial blow came on the stand, when Professor Nesson encouraged Mr. Tenenbaum to admit freely that he had downloaded and shared songs, after having denied it in depositions, “because it’s the truth,” Professor Nesson said, stripping the case to the core issue of the law’s unfairness. Judge Gertner essentially declared the case over, directing a verdict against Mr. Tenenbaum and leaving the jury to decide only the penalty.

The $675,000 result could have been avoided by paying $4,000, the amount the industry demanded before trial. The 30 songs can be bought for less than $30.
It’s been suggested that Nesson, 70, was past his prime and had taken on more than he could handle.  Unlike TV trials, the real things are enormously taxing. They take longer than an hour.  They use rules that TV ignores.  They are about people and facts rather than theories and visions. 

To say that Charlie Nesson blew it big time is both an understatement and, in all likelihood, wrong.  Sure, on a practical level, Nesson’s defense of Tenenbaum was a nightmare.  From his papers to his opening to his examination to his casual attire, he was an epic failure.  But I doubt that was his purpose in serving Tenenbaum. 

I suspect that Nesson saw Nancy Gertner’s courtroom as a laboratory to test his theories, his approaches, his novel ideas.  He envisioned a trial of substance over form, of a larger truth than the petty details that concerned the RIAA.  He saw a showdown between the forces of cash and carry and the freedom to exchange everything, from ideas to music, because the internet could.  Once a song was created, it could be heard a billion times without  any additional cost to the creator and enjoyed through a medium that allowed it to be shared at will.  The creator’s work was done, and it was no skin off the creator’s nose whether it was heard by one or a billion people.

Allow me to say at this juncture that I do not agree with this view.  Whoever creates something is entitled to benefit from it, and the idea that the world is entitled to freely enjoy it simply because technology has made it easy to do so is absurd.  We are all able to easily break a glass window, but that doesn’t entitle us to enter other people’s homes at will and take whatever we like.  Denying the creator the opportunity to capitalize on his creation to the maximum extent the market will bear is his right.  I realize that kids who want a free ride have rationalized their theft to death, but it’s still theft.  And I realize that thieving kids think I don’t get it.

That said, I don’t begrudge Charlie Nesson his attempt to sell his theory on a bigger stage.  The problem isn’t that his vision is wrong, but that he lacked the skills necessary to make the tune in his head play in the courtroom.  First, Judge Gertner shut down his fair use approach.  Then, he got slam-dunked when Tenenbaum readily admitted to engaging in the conduct complained of, ending the liability phase of the trial.  In other words, his lack of practical knowledge and skills served to deprive him of the opportunity to make his point, the essence of his involvement.  Here he was on the big stage, and his fly was open. 

In my own prickly way, this is a problem I’ve been trying to address for a long time.  Most lawyers, and worse still, most judges, have a pedestrian understanding of the law.  It’s exercised by rote, with knee-jerk arguments and decisions that can be predicted from miles away.  Calendars are cattle drives. Defendants are cattle.  The rest of us just drive the cattle forward to their slaughter. 

There are some, both lawyers and judges, who have the skills and the will to fight the inertia of the system, the think daring thoughts, to understand why one case, one defendant, differs from another.  But we’re constantly bumping up against the others, the ones who won’t make the arguments, or read the papers, or engage the brain before the mouth says “denied”, in order to keep the herd moving forward. 

We would all be far better off if we could break this cycle of mindless herding.  The Charlie Nessons of the world be the ones to challenge our cattle drive mentality.  But the Charlie Nessons of the world need add their brilliant thinking to the skills and muscle of lawyers who know how to translate their vision into courtroom reality.  We are better working together than we are alone.  In our quest for a better system, both the ideas and the skills must come together. 

This point arose just yesterday in an exchange with GW Lawprof Dan Solove from Concurring Opinions.  He was annoyed with me for being critical of the isolation of law professors from practitioners. Against his better judgment, he let me have it.  I’m glad he did, because it was one of the few honest exchanges we’ve had on the subject, and allowed me to let him know that I’m annoyed as well as the lawprofs who shun and ignore practitioners have an aversion to engaging practitioners in discussion, it being too likely to end up in mud-wrestling than understanding.

There are a number of reasons for this, as I see it, but spelling them out seems to just inflame the situation.  Academics use a different language and tone than practitioners, and they find us offensive rather than staightforward.  When they disagree with each other, they do so by nuanced complements, or at worst faint praise.  We tend to be more direct, which is viewed as “vehement contempt.”

It was my hope that the conversation will continue, an open dialogue about how the law, the focus of both sides, will be better for all if we can combine the theory with the practice.  Practitioners complain that our system is stuck, unjust and ineffective at achieving its goals.  Some fall back on vapid platitudes to justify this (“it may not be perfect but it’s the best their is”) and would happily spend their careers defending a failed status quo.  Others want to improve the system, finding perpetuation of a broken system an unacceptable way to spend one’s life. 

Dan has yet to reply to my rejoinder, and no other lawprof has jumped into the breach.  Perhaps this is just more evidence that scholars deem practitioners unworthy of their time.  Perhaps this is evidence that they have no response, and prefer to hide inside the Academy rather than look us in the face.  Perhaps this is just means that they have more important things to do than write comments on a trench lawyer’s blawg.

But given the wealth of ideas that flow around the lawprof blawgosphere, it’s a terrible shame that this separation between the theoretical and the practical persists.  Let them test their theories under the crucible of practical scrutiny.  How many more symposia amongst their own will serve to bring change to the law?  Is this all about tenure, or is there any real hope that they can improve the system, the human condition?  Then why not do something about it?

The law professors paid very close attention to Charlie Nesson’s defense of Joel Tenenbaum
.  It must have been painful to watch.  One of their own was finally at the helm, and steered the ship straight into the shoal.  Did you learn anything from Charlie Nesson’s experiment?  Anything at all?

Then let’s talk about it.  Working together, we might actually make things better for people.  Trust me, actually helping people is better than getting a law review article published.  And it matters.  I hope to hear from Dan Solove.  I hope to hear from all the lawprofs.  Are you tough enough to take the chance?  Charlie Nesson was, and you have to give him credit for that.

What Your Email Says About You

When I opened up shop in 1983, my second big decision was stationery.  Cranes Crest or Cranes Crest Laid?  Engraved or not?  The gravitas of a lawyer was judged by the weight of his stationery.  It was a first impression thing, when all you knew about someone you had yet to meet was the quality of his letterhead.  When it came to the allocation of scarce resources, letterhead was something no self-respecting lawyer skimped on. 

Does anyone still buy letterhead?  Would any new practitioner fret over whether engraving was worth its princely cost?  Heck, how many letters are sent by snail mail today anyway?

Dan Hull, who has long made the point that an email thank you note is the clearest indication of a bad upbringing, has turned his attention to the use of email as a substitute for communication.


Are you typing or lawyering? Is either one of them working for you? I receive about 100 non-spam e-mails a day. I write about one third that many, most as replies. Usually short ones. They are often soulless, and easy to misunderstand, even when I try to be precise.


The ones I get back are often worse. The truth: most lawyers just can’t write. When they write, they “talk to themselves”–like mental patients do rocking back and forth. Typing it themselves makes all that more of a problem.


Folks, the electronic toys we have were supposed to be helping tools–not be the main event. Do we appreciate the way e-mail, search engines and social media (yes, including blogging) often degrade and dumb down the complexity of hard problems in this world? Has all this made us smarter and better? Or are we just lemmings, cattle and sheep–lulled into thinking we must be doing good work if these new tools are so amazing? Is Google–how many impulses, instincts, synapses does that dude have?–more inspiring and useful than the wonderfully storied brain of that lawyer next door?


As another tool in the box, email is fabulous.  But if you pull out the email and the box is empty, you’ve got a problem.  Back when many lawyers refused to use email, viewing it as a fad soon to pass and beneath their dignity, there were voices in the dark saying that email was both here to stay, and the wave of the future.  They were right, with a vengeance.

But the Slackoisie have taken email to an undeserved height, challenged only by texting.  It is incapable of capturing the tone, the soul, of a missive on engraved letterhead.  It’s brevity often leads to misapprehension of attitude and tone.  It’s lack of spelling, grammar and syntax compels one to jump to the conclusion that the sender is suffers from a severe intellectual deficit.  But most importantly, it frequently fails to serve its communicative purpose.

Yesterday, I wrote about what an email address says about a person, after being informed that my old email address, sufficient at the time to convey a seriousness of purpose, was now horribly de classé under the current regime.  My response was that I’m sticking to my guns, awaiting its return when vintage is cool again.  After all, I’ve kept my doubleknit leisure suits in my closet just in case.

Sure, email is faster and easier than writing a letter, putting a stamp on it and taking it to the mailbox (that’s the oddly shaped blue boxy-thing on the street corner).  But life isn’t always about faster and easier.  Sometimes, it’s about better.  And better often takes more effort.

A Dangerous Blogger (Update)

Elisha Strom sits in jail because she can’t make the $750 bail.  Why bail was needed to assure her return to court is unclear, given that it’s unlikely that will abscond, leaving her 12 year old daughter behind in Virginia.  Her crime?  Blogging in the first degree.  From  WSLS 10 News :


Elisha Strom, 34, of Thaxton, is charged with one count of harassment of a police officer.

A search warrant on file in Bedford County circuit court claims on July 3rd, Strom posted the home address of a Charlottesville police sergeant.

It also shows she posted a picture of the officer getting into his unmarked patrol car in front of his home.


The officer works for the Jefferson Area Drug Enforcement Task Force, or JADE.


Court records indicate the officer confiscated her computers, notebooks, and cameras.


Great in-depth reporting.  Apparently, the rulebook for WSLS 10 limits each paragraph to a sentence, and requires that they never actually highlight the single most significant fact: Strom did this on her blog. 


A police spokesman said, “We ain’t got no stinkin’ first amendment crap around here.  And if you write something on that pad of yours I don’t like, I’ll toss your sorry butt in jail too.”

No, he didn’t really say that.  I just made that up.

But this arrest, and the fact that Strom sits in a jail cell, caught the attention of the Washington Post, which provides a somewhat better description of events.


Elisha Strom, who appears unable to make the $750 bail, was arrested outside Charlottesville on July 16 when police raided her house, confiscating notebooks, computers and camera equipment. Although the Charlottesville police chief, Timothy J. Longo Sr., had previously written to Ms. Strom warning her that her blog posts were interfering with the work of a local drug enforcement task force, she was not charged with obstruction of justice or any similar offense. Rather, she was indicted on a single count of identifying a police officer with intent to harass, a felony under state law.

It’s fair to say that Ms. Strom was unusually focused on the Jefferson Area Drug Enforcement task force, a 14-year-old unit drawn mainly from the police departments of Charlottesville, Albemarle County and the University of Virginia. (Her blog at http://iheartejade.blogspot.com, expresses the view that the task force is “nothing more than a group of arrogant thugs.”) In a nearly year-long barrage of blog posts, she published snapshots she took in public of many or most of the task force’s officers; detailed their comings and goings by following them in her car; mused about their habits and looks; hinted that she may have had a personal relationship with one of them; and, in one instance, reported that she had tipped off a local newspaper about their movements.

It’s rather naughty to post pics and home addresses of cops, particularly those working a narcotics task force and possibly undercover.  But a crime?  Did she harass them by doing nothing more than posting about them, using publicly available information to chronicle their daring work?  And what of her free speech and press rights?  Oh, I forget.  They ain’t got none of them down their in Virginny.

Obviously, a judge thinks there’s probable cause to prosecute her.  Not only that, but that she’s a flight risk.  I can picture her sitting at a bar in Argentina, explaining to the former concentration camp guard next to her, “Yeah, I had to flee because they were going to lock me away for blogging.” 

The WaPo has this to say:

Ms. Strom is not the most sympathetic symbol of free-speech rights. She has previously advocated creating a separate, all-white nation, and her blog veers from the whimsical to the self-righteous to the bizarre. But the real problem here is the Virginia statute, in which an overly broad, ill-defined ban on harassment-by-identification, specifically in regard to police officers, seems to criminalize just about anything that might irritate targets.

It should not be a crime to annoy the cops, whose raid on Ms. Strom’s house looks more like a fit of pique than an act of law enforcement. Some of her postings may have consisted of obnoxious speech, but they were nonetheless speech and constitutionally protected. That would hold true right up through her last blog post, written as the police raid on her home began at 7 a.m.: “Uh-Oh They’re Here.”


Two thoughts come to mind.  As much as I’m disgusted by Strom’s politics, so what?  That’s the beauty of America, room for disgusting political thought, where it will be roundly rejected in the marketplace of ideas.  No sale.  That’s how you get rid of disgusting ideas.

But not jail.  Not prosecution.  And yet that’s exactly what’s happened.  And given Dan Solove’s complaint about too much discretion in the Henry Gates and Big Yawn cases, maybe this one, given its additional overlay of free speech, ought to be cause for scholarly concern.  I hope her nasty politics don’t stand in the way of intellectual integrity.

However, one bone remains to be picked with WaPo.  Notably missing from its editorial slam is Strom’s free press right.  I take from this that WaPo, the real press, won’t give Strom, a lowly blogger, the credit of deserving the right to publish as if it was covered by that other clause of the First Amendment.  I can’t help but wonder whether those who think the Washington Post isn’t so great would do the same.

H/T The anonymous Ed at Blawgreview.

Update:  Jdog, posting at his alterego blog, ShaygetzPundit, offers his thoughts on Strom’s health and wellbeing:


Fine.  If she happens to be out walking someday and a cow falls out of a clear blue sky to squash her flat, that would be a sad thing only because it would be a waste of a good cow.  Got it.

He’s an animal lover, you know.  He prefers them barbecued. but fried is good too.  Everything tastes better fried.  Yet Joel writes:


Damn.  Well, you don’t always get the good poster boys and girls on this civil rights stuff.  Yeah, sometimes you luck out and get a real hero like Rosa Parks, or Savana Redding.

But most of the time it’s scumbags like Ernesto Miranda or Elisha Strom.
What did Ernesto do to get into the middle of this? 

What Your Email Address Says About You

In the old days, there were only a few places where a regular fellow could get an email account.  For most, it was either America Online or Compuserve, the two service providers for regular folks who paid for a way to get online.  Back then, getting a good email address was a sign that you were awfully darn cool.  But times change.

I hadn’t given it any thought until Doug Cornelius twitted about it yesterday.


Esquire’s Rule #1033. If your lawyer’s email address ends in hotmail.com, gmail.com or yahoo.com (or aol.com), find a new lawyer.
OMG!  Am I that out of touch?  You see, while I have email via Simple Justice, the truth is that I still use the email address I handpicked in 1993, when all the cool kids used AOL.  It’s SHGLaw, from back in the days when LALaw was cutting edge. Today, it would be SHGLaw318795 if I tried to get it again.  But I don’t have to.  It’s mine.  It’s always been mine.  Everybody who knows me emails me there.

When I questioned whether this means that all my clients would flee because of my ancient email address, I was told by Jeffrey Brandt to just suck it up and “Just rip that band-aid off! ”  I felt so old.  So feeble.  So pathetic.  Sure, today I have plenty of business, but it could all be gone tomorrow when they realize that I use an AOL email address.

This troubled me, since I’m so used to being on the cutting edge and realized that others look to me as an early adapter to show them the way to the next cool thing.  Could I let them down like this?  Oh, the horror.

However, after some deep contemplation and soul-searching, I’ve reached a decision.  Screw anyone who thinks that my 1993 email address means that I’m not cool enough to be your lawyer.  Go find some lawyer whose concern is whether they have the newest iPhone, or the Kindle 39, or doesn’t have to google the Urban Dictionary to look up the meaning of the word “choad”.  So what if I don’t text or leave 487 minutes unused on my 500 minute plan. 

Call me an anachronism.  An old man.  A dinosaur.  If you’re looking for a Dude, you’re in the wrong place.  I don’t hold it against anyone that they are obsessed with the superficial accouterments of coolness and geekdom.  Well, maybe I sneer at them a little and think they smell like elderberries, but they’re allowed.  Just not me.

I prefer to think of myself as a rebel.  Someone who refuses to be a slave to trends, to each new shiny thing that comes along.  I have a great email address, even if it’s got a suffix for a service upon which the sun has set.  If you think a different URL would make me a better lawyer, then I would pay attention.  But to make me look trendier?  Forget it.

I’m sticking with my stinky, old AOL email address.  If that puts you off, then don’t email me.  I can live with that.

Fettered Discretion

Over at Concurring Opinions, Dan Solove says that all the hoopla over GatesGate missed the real problem.


In what country can people routinely be arrested (and sometimes imprisoned for a significant amount of time) based on the whim of a police officer or a judge?  Sounds like something that would happen in a totalitarian state, but it’s the way things work in the United States.

In the frenzy of news coverage of the recent incident involving the arrest of Professor Henry Louis Gates in his home, only a small amount of attention was devoted to the issue of police discretion.  Gates was arrested on a charge of disorderly conduct, which was later dropped. Charges such as disorderly conduct basically give the police an enormously broad range of discretion to arrest anyone for nearly any reason.

I’m constrained to conclude that Dan’s opinion is premised on his observations of the blawgosphere, which means that he’s not reading a whole lot outside of his comfort zone of scholarly posts discussing normative pedagogical paradigms.  Or, in English, he’s got to get outside the academy once in a while.

Dan is right about discretion, but totally wrong about the absence of discussion.  The problem is that academics are so busy trying to out-scholarly one another that they refuse to pay attention to anything said outside the clique.  And the problem with this is that all these fine minds are wasted by their refusal to acknowledge that there is a world of discussion, perspective, opinion, by a blawgosphere full of folks whose primary concern isn’t impressing the tenure committee.

I enjoy and appreciate much of the depth of thought and discussion that happens inside the big ivy walls.  Why won’t the lawprofs step outside once in a while to learn what happens in the trenches?  Are we too ugly?  Are we too course?  Are we too forthright?  Do we not use big enough words?  I dunno, but for all my efforts to prod these otherwise brilliant men and women to engage in discourse that might actually do something, they persist in hiding amongst their own.

Dan’s post caught my eye because of his discussion of the Big Yawn case, where Will County Circuit Judge Daniel Rozak, an otherwise decent judge by all accounts, held Clifton Williams in contempt for the Big Yawn.  Williams, there to watch his cousin get sentenced to probation, bought 6 months.


Judges have broad discretion under the law, which defines contempt as acts that embarrass, hinder or obstruct the court in its administration of justice or lessen its authority or dignity. As long as the sentence is not longer than 6 months, there is no review of the case — unless the offender appeals to the judge or a higher court. . . .


In the two-story brick home where Williams had been living with his aunt Cheryl Mayfield and caring for his 79-year-old grandmother, family members said they were in shock over the sentence but were unable to afford an attorney to appeal.


Dan questions why Rozak didn’t just toss Williams out of the courtroom rather than hold him in contempt and slap him with the max sentence.  This reinforces Dan’s point about too much discretion, allowing judges (like cops) to do as they please without any realistic possibility of being held accountable.  Sure, there’s a theoretical path available for redress, but no one is going down it without some non-theoretical money to pay the legal fee.  Unless of course the public defender has some spare time on his hands.  Or maybe, just maybe, some law professor who is actually licensed to practice wants to pick up the ball and run with it.

But the Gates case and the Big Yawn case are the tip of the iceberg.  In the trenches, we know that these are daily hourly occurrences.  Only the really weird ones, or ones involving Harvard professors, make it onto the radar screen.  The garden-variety abuse of discretion lacks the sexiness to interest the media, but is equally meaningful to those poor schmucks who suffer it on the streets of America regularly.

Those of us in the trenches write about this sort of abuse all the time.  Post after post offers examples of abuse of discretion, its cause and effect.  Yet Dan thinks he’s stumbled onto a new idea? 

Seriously.  Get out of the marble halls and see what real life looks like.  You never know, you might learn something.  And maybe even make lawprofs relevant.  Remember, a mind is a terrible thing to waste.

Good Work, If You Can Get It

Bernie Madoff was so terribly evil that no less than 150 years in prison would be enough to right the wrong done his victims.  And what about those victims?  They’ve got Irv Picard on their side, the court-appointed trustee doing God’s work to make sure that each and every victim of Madoff’s scheme gets back what they lost, right?  Well, kinda.

From Bloomberg :



The trustee liquidating Bernard Madoff’s investment company won court approval of a $14.7 million bill for four months’ work by his law firm, overcoming challenges from victims.


The payment to trustee Irving Picard and his firm, Baker & Hostetler LLP was approved today by U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Burton Lifland in New York. Some victims argued that Picard isn’t paying Madoff clients fast enough and is wasting money that should go to them.


“Nothing has been shown that this trustee is not acting in good faith,” Lifland said. “Many of the objections are based on the assumption that granting fees here affects the amount to be distributed; that isn’t the case.”

Now let me crunch those numbers a bit.  $14.7 million for 4 months work times one team of lawyers equals one damn fine payday. While Judge Lifland may be correct in concluding that Picard isn’t acting in bad faith, it’s hard to follow his reasoning that draining $14,.7 million from the pool of available assets to distribute to the victims doesn’t matter.  Did he miss that day in Economic 101 where they explained the allocation of scarce resources?

So if Picard managed to amass more than $3.6 million in legal fees per month, though the number of lawyers on his team is unknown, one has to wonder why?  Granted, he’s probably really good at handling billing, and there’s no doubt that every B&H partner needs a few associates trailing behind them to carry their bags and open doors, while victims lose their houses.  So what did Picard to rack up these kinds of fees?


The amount covers Picard’s work from Dec. 15 to April 30. The trustee and the law firm argued the fees were justified by their recovery of $1.08 billion for victims as of June 30 and their filing of complex lawsuits against the con man’s biggest investors seeking about $14 billion more in damages.

Recovering $1.08 billion sounds pretty good, but for the most part it was just picking up loose change on the floor.  As for filing “complex lawsuits,” preparing complaints really isn’t heavy lifting either.  And once he’s done the first one, others demand little more than changing the names. 

Even if Picard is putting in hundred hour weeks, and has a dozen lawyers on his “team” all of whom are putting in 100 hour weeks, that nets out an hourly fee of $656 per lawyer.  While I can’t imagine that he’s got that many lawyers on the team, or that they are all working hundred hour weeks, or that they would have an average hourly billing rate at the very tippy-top of the scale of $656, that’s what Lifland approved. 

Wait, you say.  Greenfield, you doofus, what about expenses?

Picard has said 20 percent of the firm’s fee will be deferred until the Madoff brokerage has been liquidated. His law firm said it made a voluntary reduction of more than $111,000 by not charging for intra-office expenses including lodging, meals, airfare and other transportation.

It’s not like Picard is heartless.  The man is nearly a saint, suffering for the good of the victims.  But he does have to pay the lease on the Maybach, and it’s not like Irv’s kids don’t need new shoes.  Really nice new shoes.

The victims, in the meantime, are complaining that they aren’t seeing much out of the whole magillah, and up to now, those who haven’t agreed with Picard about how much they’ve lost had the screws put to them by being denied any payouts.  But Irv has seen the light on that count as well.


Picard yesterday changed his procedure for paying as much as $500,000 to victims, dropping a requirement that blocked payments to investors who disputed his calculation of their claims. Under the new plan, undisputed sums will be paid promptly and the disputed portions will be dealt with later.
No longer will acquiescence with Irv’s assessment be extorted by the refusal to pay undisputed claims, at least to the extent that any claims are being paid by pennies on the dollar.  I told you he was nearly a saint.

Of course, we’ve barely touched the subject of clawbacks, for those victims who manages to pull back their investments before the house of cards fell.  Just wait until Picard starts to exact his revenge for their lack of greed or simple sound personal judgment, ripping mortgage and college tuition payments from the grasp of retirees.  It’s going to be painful and difficult work for the trustee. 

Anybody want to guess how much he’s going to charge for that bit of litigation?

Answer:  It won’t matter, because Judge Lifland will approve it.  At least Bernie won’t miss another meal in what’s left of his life.

Ted Frank Finds His Groove

It’s been quite a while since Ted Frank’s waking hours were spent maligning every action taken by a lawyer to represent evil individuals who suffered at the benign hand of corporate neglect and greed as a major player at Overlawyered.  Was he hunkered down at an unknown location, with only his neighbor Cheney to talk to, awaiting the end of time?  No, it turns out.  As disclosed in a revealing interview at Above The Law, Ted has re-emerged, and now he’s really pissed.



Ted Frank . . .  is starting a new public interest law firm that specializes in pro bono representation of consumers unhappy with class action settlements.


ATL: How did you get started with this new venture? What was your inspiration?


TF: It all started with my Grand Theft Auto objection last summer. It really showed me how easy it is for a bad class action settlement to get rubber-stamped. I ended up spending several hundred dollars of my own money on that case, and I understood right away why judges see so few objections to bad settlements. After the New York Times article came out about my objection, I got many phone calls and emails from people wanting my help in objecting to settlements, and I had to turn them away because it wasn’t part of the work I was doing at AEI.


Last October, I gave a talk to the University of Chicago Law School Federalist Society where the students wondered how the problem of bad settlements could be addressed if no one had the economic incentive to object. At the time, I supposed that my class action objection could be scaled up if there was someone crazy enough to do the same thing pro bono. Seeing noone else crazy enough to do it, I figured it might as well be me.
Now before anybody jumps on Ted to point out the irony of his new direction, allow me.  Soooo, Mr. Lawyer Ted, there’s suddenly merit in representing the interest of the individual, helpless in facing the well-financed behemoth whose interests may not include those of the very people they purport to serve?  Standing up for the little guy who suffers at the hand of an unfeeling, uncaring Goliath?  The names of the players may be different, but the idea is exactly the same as that of the personal injury lawyers representing the lone suffering individual against the corporate titans who sacrificed the consumer’s limb for another $1.79 in profit.  Have you gotten your ATLA membership yet?

In all fairness, Ted has finally found his niche.  His attacks on trial lawyers for doing exactly what he plans to do, except against corporations, may not be a thing of the past, but he’s at least found a way to put his belligerence to good use.  Class actions are a necessary means of keeping corporate malfeasance in check when the harm done isn’t sufficient to give rise to individual actions, and we would be a worse society without them. 

But there is also an element to them, revealed in the Grand Theft Auto class action as well as the Ford Explorer one, which demonstrates that they can easily become vehicles for lawyers to make money at the expense of the class.  Whether a lawyer serves one or ten thousand clients, it’s the clients’ interest that must prevail.  We don’t do this to generate fees for ourselves while providing no value to our clients.  And as both cases show, and as Ted’s experience showed, there’s no incentive to challenge the class action settlements, and even if there was, the road is rocky and almost impossible for the non-lawyer to traverse.

When someone claims that his cause is in the “public interest,” I tend to wince.  After all, who anointed him savior of the public, with the inherent vision to know what’s good or bad for the public (particularly when it’s obvious that I am the only one who knows what’s truly in the public interest, though others may dispute this fact).  But I suspect that this time, Ted’s the right man for the job. 

Unless you’re as blindly supportive of trial lawyers as Ted was once against them, you will see the merit in Ted’s new crusade.  Not every class action is bad, but there is most assuredly a need for someone to serve as a check on lawyer greed as there is on corporate greed.  Whether it proves to be a viable plan has yet to be seen, as Ted has no doubt come to realize that even public interest lawyers need to feed their kids, and it takes financing to keep a firm, even one dedicated to the public interest, in business.  That revenue has to come from somewhere, and he’ll have to learn how to pick his causes.  Just like trial lawyers.

I wish Ted Frank the best in his new endeavor.  I trust that he’ll flex his muscles cautiously and appropriately.  I take no issue with someone keeping a close watch on the legal fees relative to the benefits of the settlement to the class, and I look forward to seeing Ted’s efforts make class actions serve the class rather than the lawyers. 

Seven Lawyer Lives Lost

Via Turley, it’s reported that seven lawyers put their lives on the line to defend to defend Iranians who were detained in the post-presidential election.  They lost.



Sources say that the bodies of the lawyers were returned to their families by the government. After the lawyers began representing the protesters, they were themselves accused of disrupting security and encouraging unethical actions against the regime. Five were sentenced to three years each in jail and three died for injuries suffered during their incarceration. Families said that they were beaten so badly that they could not be recognized.

Two of the lawyers were executed after being sentenced to death for drug possession — charges that the families insist were manufactured to secure their death sentences.
General George Patten’s admonition comes to mind, that the object isn’t to die for your country, but make the other poor bastard die for his.  Thankfully, few of us face the possibility of death for doing what we do.  But how many amongst us would readily be the next Atticus Finch?

One of the continuing themes here is that competence, ethics and dedication have given way to the overarching concern for making money.  The only passion seen from many is when their bread and butter is threatened by nasty old Greenfield, with his old school ideas about putting clients first, telling the truth even when it’s unpleasant and suffering for one’s profession when appropriate. 

While I’ve yet to advocate that any American criminal defense lawyer lay down his life for his profession, and doubt that I ever will (or would do so myself), the fact that lawyers elsewhere have done so, have taken risks far beyond anything we can imagine being asked of us here, leaves me feeling unworthy.  Seven Iranian lawyers felt strongly enough to defy their government and defend their clients, with the appreciation of what it meant to defy their government.  They faced death to do the right thing.  And here, we worry about fees, or worse still, work/life balance.  If criminal defense lawyers find it unduly onerous to show up for court when it’s inconvenient, what are the chances they will take a risk, any risk, to serve their clients?

Even within our profession, ignorance persists.  Just yesterday, a cruise ship personal injury lawyer’s means of trying to smear me was to accuse me of defending criminals.  Guilty.  But this buffoon’s knee-jerk reaction (which he subsequently deleted after realizing what a blithering ass he was) reflects the ignorance amongst lawyers as to what we’re here to do.  Not only is there little support within the profession for our taking a personal risk by defending the unpopular, but we’re seen as pariahs for doing our job at all by those who think Nancy Grace is an intellectual.  Greed, pompousness and self-promotion they understand.  Competence, duty and dedication to the client, the law and the Constitution are foreign.  They wouldn’t risk their lives for anything.  They wouldn’t risk a dime.

There isn’t much likelihood that any American criminal defense lawyer will be asked to put his life on the line like the seven Iranian lawyers.  We may die from stress, obesity, alcoholism or get hit by a bus, but not from defending our clients.  But if you’re so weak-kneed that you’re unwilling to take a chance, to put yourself at the slightest personal risk, to defend an unpopular defendant, then compare yourself to these seven Iranian lawyers who lost it all in the defense of their clients.  So little is expected of you in comparison that its the least you can do.