Author Archives: SHG

Return to Willowbrook

Back in 1972, Geraldo Rivera, who was still a reporter, opened the nation’s eyes to the deplorable condition and abuse heaped upon children at Staten Island’s Willowbrook School for mentally retarded children.  It was appalling, and Americans were shocked when Rivera exposed the deplorable conditions. 

The solution was to end the large scale warehousing of children, and later adults, in these megafacilities where they were kept out of the public eye and everyone forgot about them.  Out of sight, out of mind.  What happened in Willowbrook stayed in Willowbrook.  But as the New York Times reports, closing the nation’s Willowbrooks, which made everyone feel quite proud of themselves for being so concerned for the welfare of children and the mentally ill and incompetent, was no solution.

Over the years, mentally ill adults, given new rights and freedoms after the scandal, exercised their right to live in squalor on the street, with a cardboard box as their shelter in subzero weather.  But at least people realized this unintended consequence, if for no other reason than they had to step over them to get to their limousines.  Children, on the other hand, remained out of sight.

The New York Times reports on what became of the children. 



As cash-starved states slash mental health programs in communities and schools, they are increasingly relying on the juvenile corrections system to handle a generation of young offenders with psychiatric disorders. About two-thirds of the nation’s juvenile inmates — who numbered 92,854 in 2006, down from 107,000 in 1999 — have at least one mental illness, according to surveys of youth prisons, and are more in need of therapy than punishment.

“We’re seeing more and more mentally ill kids who couldn’t find community programs that were intensive enough to treat them,” said Joseph Penn, a child psychiatrist at the Texas Youth Commission. “Jails and juvenile justice facilities are the new asylums.”
Like a society with attention deficit syndrome, we’ve forgotten that there are mentally ill children.  It’s so much easier to pigeonhole them as criminals, and with false bravado, demand that be treated like the animals they are.  Of course, this serves the dual purposes of getting them out of our sight and making us feel that we’ve achieved safety and justice, as if mentally ill children without resources to help them to co-exist peacefully in society reduces them to the class of animal to which we ascribe all other criminals.

The problem is that prisons aren’t intended or equipped to deal with mentally ill children.  They try, if for no other reason than self-preservation, but the best they can hope to achieve is relative isolation and mind-numbing drugs.  They aren’t there to be cured, or stabilized so that they can return to society, but to prevent them from doing harm to others or, more likely, being the victim of others’ harm.  It’s costly.  It’s difficult.  It’s ineffective.  It’s all we’ve got.

What amazes is how we’ve turned a blind eye to the fact that these are children.  Sick children.  Our hearts go out to children who suffer tragic harm in automobile accidents.  But we have no room left for sympathy for children who suffer from mental illness.  To a large extent, we have still not accepted that mental illness, like bipolar disorder, is real.  Many adults, who have never had the pleasure of having one of their children suffer, refuse to believe in a disease they can’t see or feel.  Rather than see mentally ill children as sick, they are simply bad.  They will tell you that a good smack will fix these bad kids up real fast.  Who’s insane now?

By the time they find themselves embroiled in the juvenile justice system for having done sufficient damage to warrant the attention of the law, they aren’t as cute and cuddly as they once were.  Their faces have sneers and chances are pretty good that their conduct can be characterized in adult terms, making them appear far more analogous to the vicious than the sick. 

There was once a time when we believed that boys and girls who had yet to reach the age of majority were still children.  As children, they deserved society’s help and protection, rather than wrath.  Is the best we can hope for today a prison cell and a heavy dose of Abilify?  While people complain, and rightfully so, of the myriad of problems we face in a complex society in economic turmoil, there remains one discrete group that will never have the ability to lift itself out of its problems, it’s pit, and therefore deserves, more than any other, our care and concern.  These are our children.  Do it for the children.

Future Lawyer

I remember going to the 1964 World’s Fair and taking the  GM Futuramaride that showed life in the future.  It was so cool, all the things that would change over time. Plus, my parents bought me one of those really nifty hats with the big ostrich feathers.  It was much better than what those fools in the 1930s thought fashion would look like in year A.D. 2000.



There are a host of blawgs that are dedicated to predicting the future of the lawyers.  As before, it’s not presented as merely a future of possibilities, but a reality upon which we are exhorted to stake our careers.  From Susan Cartier Leibel saying that Biglaw is dead and solo is the future, to Patrick Lamb saying that the billable hour is dead and value billing is the future, to Jordon Furlong saying that technology will render in-house handwork an anachronism and make lawyering a commodity.  Even within these seers of the future, there is dispute over whether virtual firms are the future, a future, or utter nonsense.

Whether those who inform us of what the future will be are oracles or profiteers, there are many who want to hitch their wagon to a rising star, whether because it furthers their personal wishes by offering a future that suits them or because they have failed in the past and need a new option. 

In the past, my challenges to those who claim that they know what the future holds has met with arguments, invariably misguided, about why it shouldn’t be this way.  That, of course, is irrelevant, since the future happens as it happens, not as a result of argument.  We aren’t wearing the clothing that 1930s designers thought appropriate, and our food isn’t grown on the bottom of the ocean.  No amount of argument will change this; it’s simply so.

There is nothing wrong with trying to divine the future, and using reason to do so.  But its somewhat disingenuous to promote the idea that anyone knows what the future will bring.  Very few have done so well, like Jules Verne and Gene Roddenberry, and in their cases the question is whether they predicted the future or the future met their imaginations and was guided by it.  With all due respect to my fellow blawgers, I don’t think they will be viewed as such visionaries that they will guide the future.

Some of these predictions strike me as nothing more than snake oil, with hard sell promoters sucking the weak and failed into their web with the promise of future success that comports with their silly dreams.  They are not dangerous because they posit a future that disrupts existing practice, but because they offer a promise to the desperate that they cannot keep.  Some promote the positives of solo practice while ignoring, if not overtly distorting, the risks, problems and negatives.  This disturbs me as it is targeted to some of the most vulnerable and desperate within the profession, and it’s flagrantly false and dishonest. 

Similarly, the entire cabal of work/life balance promoters offer a false god to those least capable of understanding why it’s a fool’s path.  They all have one thing in common, their availability for speaking engagements.  For the most part, they are failed lawyers who have reimagined themselves consultants and marketers.  It would funny as can be that people turn to failures to teach success, except that some actually do.  Of course, some claim that they were huge successes as lawyers, though they can’t offer any rational explanation why then they left the law to put red paint on their faces and sell themselves on Market Street. 

These oracles of the future of the law will get somethings right.  The law of averages dictates that some of their prophesies will come true, though when and how remains in doubt.  But denizens of the blawgosphere, desperately seeking solutions to their current miseries, would do well to be skeptical of prophets.  They don’t know anymore about the future than you do.

On the other hand, if you want to consider a change in your career path, with someone who will tell you the good, the bad and the ugly, I urge you to read Carolyn Elefant’s ebook, From Biglaw to Yourlaw, and should you decide to change your direction, pick up a copy of Carolyn’s book, Solo By Choice, clearly the best, and most honest, primer on going solo there is.

And as for predictions of the future of the legal profession, I have one to make.  The heart of what we do will continue to be represent our clients, first and foremost.  Neither commoditization, nor techno-outsourcing, nor work/life balance, will be accepted as a substitute for excellence.  Anyone who predicts otherwise will be proven wrong.  I stake my reputation on it.

I’m no Jules Verne either, but if you think the future of the law can be found in snake oil, I won’t cry for you when you crash and burn. 

The First Lawyer on the Obama Court

In the old days, one might expect to have a glimmer of understanding about what your judge might be like based upon which president appointed him or her.  Now that we have the Minister of Change in the White House, having gotten the Sotomayor appointment behind him, lesser seats are being filled. 

From the BLT :



Jane Stranch, partner at Nashville’s Branstetter, Stranch & Jennings, has been tapped to fill a spot on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, while Judge Thomas Vanaskie of the Middle District of Pennsylvania has been picked for the Third Circuit.

According to the White House announcement, Stranch, a labor lawyer, graduated from Vanderbilt University School of Law in 1975 and is known for her work on complex ERISA litigation. The 55-year-old Vanaskie, meanwhile, was appointed to his current post in 1994, and was chief judge from 1996 through 2006. As a young lawyer, he practiced in the Scranton office of Dilworth, Paxson, Kalish & Kauffman alongside future governor Robert Casey, Sr., the father of Sen. Robert Casey, Jr. (D-Pa.).
Bold. Fearless.  Fighters for the Constitution.  A labor lawyer and a current judge who made his bones in Scranton in the office next to a senator’s father.  I can’t wait for this “change” stuff to kick in.  Anytime now.  Any time.  Whenever you’re ready, Mr. President.

The face of the federal judiciary hasn’t change much in, well forever.  It’s not that most of them aren’t excellent lawyers within their practice area, but that they will have a great impact as judges in a much broader pond.  Criminal cases come immediately to mind for me.  And so I ask, what the heck do they know about criminal law?  What do they think about it?  What do they know about the people who will appear before them as defendants?  What do they think about the honesty and integrity of the police, the prosecutors, the system?

My experience has been that most lawyers whose career has been firmly rooted in the civil side of law have no greater knowledge than the general public about criminal law.  They hold dear the same erroneous assumptions and prejudices, that by and large the police tell the truth; that most defendants are guilty, at least of something; that if the Constitution was supposed to mean what it says, judges before them wouldn’t have crafted the million exceptions to the rule; that law and order are the same things.

They tend to be quite conservative in their view of civil rights and personal freedom, as they are heavily vested in the system and enjoy the mindset of the successful lawyer.  Don’t get too close to my Mercedes!  They don’t mean to be uncaring or naive, but they truly believe that the status quo is the way it’s supposed to be. 

Many thought that a Barack Obama presidency might bring change to the status quo.  I never thought so, at least when it comes to the federal bench.  When Norm told me that he might be up for a judgeship, I was, to be blunt, shocked.  That would have been one incredibly bold move.  And of course, it wasn’t to be.

It’s not that there aren’t some excellent judges on the federal bench, or that all judges whose careers were spent on the civil side are ignorant or uncaring about criminal cases and constitutional rights.  It’s that the only people to be deemed safe enough for an appointment who have had experience in criminal law are prosecutors, with Massachusetts Judge Nancy Gertner being the exception that proves the rule.  She’s quite a stand-out as a judge, and as it happens she was a criminal defense lawyer.

In my home districts, SDNY and EDNY, we have a number of judges whose legal career journey went from the United States Attorney’s office to the Courthouse.  Some moved physically, but their heart remained behind.  Others try very hard to be fair, but really lack the breadth of experience to comprehend what fairness means.  One, John Gleeson, has been a standout, making some very bold decisions and demonstrating a willingness to use his bench to challenge the status quo when he believes it to be wrong. 

Perhaps President Obama has yet to get his sea legs.  Perhaps he believes his capital is better spent at  passing whatever plans he feels will establish him as an agent of change.  I dunno, and this isn’t a post about whether his agenda is good, bad or otherwise, so let’s not get into that.  But if Bill Clinton is any measure, the expectation of a shift in the federal judiciary has no legs.  Sure, the neocons label any judge appointed by a Democratic President “liberal”, proving that knee-jerk vapidity is alive and well, both in Washington and in the hearts and minds of true-believers.  But today’s idea of a “liberal” judge covers Richard Nixon’s appointments in the 60s. 

Meet the new boss.  Same as the old boss.  You guys can fight over your labels all you want.  Wake me up when the change happens.

The Jester Isn’t Laughing Now

Former Supreme Court Justice Ronald Tills, a proud member of the Royal Order of Jesters, was sentenced to 18 months by U.S District Judge William M. Skretny for gathering up prostitutes, including one who had been before him as a judge, putting them in a Winnebago and transporting them across state lines to enjoy an All-American Weekend of Mirth.

Bummer.  Judge Skretny was unimpressed with Tills’ expression of remorse.


“I will never forgive myself for the possible harm I’ve caused to the victims in this case,” he said. “I’m embarrassed, and I feel terrible about the shame I’ve brought to the bench and the bar.”

But Skretny referred to Tills as a “real Jekyll and Hyde” and suggested the former judge and state assemblyman had not shown the level of remorse Skretny would have liked to have seen from him.

You would think that Tills, having had the experience of doing some sentencing in his time, would know how to grovel properly.  Even Terry Connors’ words didn’t do the trick of keeping the old judge from the clink.


“He knows what he did was reprehensible,” said Terrence M. Connors, one of Tills’ lawyers. “He know he’s disgraced that robe.”
Disgraced the robe?  Yeah, that would be fair.  Frankly, I can’t imagine any amount of remorse that would have saved Tills from a prison sentence, and I can’t think of a good reason why he should have been.

Wanna be a judge?  Wanna sentence people to jail?  To prison?  Wanna lecture them about the majesty of the law, the importance of obeying the law, how bad and evil they are?  Then don’t commit crimes yourself.

Bye-bye, Ronny.  Hope you meet up with somebody you sentenced in there.  I know, you will be going to Club Fed rather than the state stinkholes where your defendants were sent, but it could happen.  You can explain to them how sorry you really are for being a judge who committed a crime.

H/T Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen.

The Loudest Scream

I don’t know enough about the President’s health care plan to know whether I would support it.  My first problem is that it hasn’t been sufficiently published for all to see, to read, to digest, to comprehend.  Transparency isn’t what it used to be.  Amidst the debate (?), much of the negative position falls flat as it ignores that existing health care is a nightmare, outrageously expensive and still leaving millions uncovered.

Going into the debate, there was consensus that what we have isn’t good and we need something else.  The issue is what the “something else” should look like.  The absurd television commercials appear to argue that the new plan will destroy democracy, and that we should stick with the wonders of what we’re already doing.  That would be the system that gave rise to the need for change.  I bet the folks who devise these ads are awfully thankful that most people aren’t adept at two-step thinking.

Yet, the latest approach to the health care plan, attack-dog disruption of town hall meetings of legislators to explain the plan and answer questions, may be the worst of all possible worlds.  According to the New York Times, the disruption is the product of Republican neo-con organized attack by people who claim to be non-partisan, but are shown to be lying Republican party shills.  Fox News, on the other hand, calls the disruptions “protests” that arose organically by disaffected Americans.  Sarah Palin calls the plan “downright evil,” because it will “deny care to the neediest Americans.”  The hooligans are, of course, deeply concerned for the neediest Americans.

Like most, the cost of health insurance troubles me.  Unlike most, reimbursement rates are also a concern.  And all this crap about denying “cutting edge” medical care upon demand to the “neediest American’s” is just a scam.  The screamers couldn’t care less about needy anyone other than themselves.  Anyone claiming otherwise is simply a liar.

Those who are busily screaming at their elected representatives claim that it’s they are merely exercising their First Amendment right to express their opinion about the health care plan.  On the one hand, that’s true.  They have a right to scream at their elected representatives.  As much as one may wish they would choose not to exercise their right in this fashion, rights are rights.  And while everyone is not entitled to an opinion, they are entitled to rights.  There is no test of knowledge to possess rights; that only applies to opinions.  Perhaps this is a glorious demonstration of the Constitution at work.

Unfortunately, it also serves to prevent the dissemination of information.  From the “best practices” perspective, first learn the information, then scream bloody murder.  The other way around just doesn’t do much to convince anyone else of the fact that your screams count for much.  It does serve to remind that sheep will scream on cue, or that the disaffected will take up arms on subjects about which they know nothing or wally in misinformation.

The Obama administration has done little to make its case substantively, by providing more than vague rhetorical assurances that this is a viable plan.  When a major shift in public policy, not to mention expense, is being proposed, it’s only fair that it be subject to serious scrutiny from all angles.  As for me, hard information will go a lot farther than fuzzy speechifying.  Only the USA Patriot Act was so critically important as to be worthy of blind passage. 

Yet, the void is being filled by the quasi-organized hooligans who fill  the seats and obey the command to scream and disrupt.  This boomerang tactic may do more to awaken those who remember why we’re talking about health care in the first place, and boil the blood of those who may support the plan, or may not, based upon what it really means and really does.  The screamers are stopping the rest from gathering the information necessary to decide. 

Americans may not demand total accuracy from their politicians, but they surely don’t like it when a bunch of demagoguing jerks prevent them from learning anything.  The screamers may awaken the sleeping giant in the middle of the political spectrum to two things.  First, that they can’t stomach the forces in opposition who are responsible for denying the rest of us information upon which to form an opinion.  Second, that the Republicans, who were soundly rejected in the last election as the party lacking any clue how to make life in America any better, remain clueless.  This attack demonstrates an affinity for the negative with no positive ideas to offer.  If it weren’t for bad ideas, they would have no ideas at all.

Left to its own devices, the Obama administration may well have fallen short on the health care plan, with the Blue Dogs troubled and the middle American scratching his head in confusion.  The screamers have made their headlines, but haven’t persuaded anyone not already inclined to join them.  What would be a shame is if this plan passed not because it was worthy, but because of the reaction to this incredibly stupid and unproductive tactic.  The screamers will have lost, but that doesn’t mean that America will have won.

The Saddest Person in the Twittersphere

Twitter got hacked and went down.  A year ago, who would have cared?  Who would have noticed?  Not me.  But I did notice yesterday.  It changed my world.  I had an extra 15 minutes in my day, which I put to good use.

But something else happened yesterday to make me think of twitter.  I was followed by Rex7.



Hi, Scott Greenfield.


Rex7 (Rex7) is now following your tweets on Twitter.


A little information about Rex7:







http://twitter.com/Rex7?utm_campaign=twitter20080331162631&utm_medium=email&utm_source=follow 63837 followers
2779 tweets
following 61785 people

For those of you who don’t know, Rex7 is a 2009 law school graduate named Rex Gradeless who has accumulated the largest number of followers of anyone in the legal arena, assuming ones take a broad view of who is in the legal arena.  Like getting into the Guiness Book of World Records for accomplishing a feat that few others have chosen to try, Rex7 has staked his claim on twitter.

But his success at accumulating followers is demonstrable evidence of it’s relative utility.  Rex needs a job.  Nothing wrong with that, particularly given the current situation for law school graduates.  But he has almost 64,000 followers on twitter.  Still, he’s jobless, per his twitter bio.  Contrary to popular belief, no one gets paid for the number of followers they have on twitter.

Rex isn’t the only young man hoping that twitter will aid in his success.  There are others, Adrian Dayton for one, who believe that their future can be found on twitter.  Adrian is a twitter consultant, available to teach lawyers and firms how to achieve financial success through twitting.  He believes that it’s true, and that he can help.

To Rex and Adrian, twitter is their vehicle to recognition.  When twitter went down, so too did their vehicle. 

But if Rex can’t manage to find a job with his almost 68,000 followers, then one has to wonder whether those who promote twitter as a vehicle of success are just blowing smoke. 

I’ve come to like twitter for certain purposes.  But I remain doubtful that it will serve the purpose of enhancing my practice.  Others will explain to me using the vagaries preferred by marketing folks about how it builds relationships and networks and communities, will find you love and help you to lose those excess pounds.  I haven’t seen it.  I had more followers on twitter than I should, but many of them are part of the coterie of twitterers who are selling to lawyers or just following others in the hope of a return follow.  They want to be like Rex7.  They are keeping score.

This morning, Rex7 stopped following me.  Perhaps it was because I didn’t follow him back.  Perhaps it was because my twits are boring.  Perhaps it was because I don’t have a job for him. 

I wish Rex, who was an occasional commenter here, the best of luck in finding a fine job as a lawyer.  It will likely interfere with his ability to accumulate followers on twitter, but it will provide him with a paycheck, a sense of real accomplishment and a taste of what the profession is all about.  What it is not about is twitting, accumulating followers or finding your purpose in life crushed when twitter crashes.  That would make you the saddest person in the twittersphere.

Symbolism, Substance and the Future

Sonia Sotomayor was confirmed, to no one’s surprise.  The newspapers report that Hispanics are proud to have a justice on the Supreme Court who shares their heritage.  That’s great, showing that the United States is no longer foreclosing the possibility that a Latina can be a justice, any more than a black man can be President.

Now that the nation has overcome another hurdle on the road to inclusiveness, however, it’s time to live with the consequences of the choice.  The same Hispanics who applaud now-Justice Sotomayor’s elevation to the big bench may well find themselves stopped and searched on the streets of Washington Heights for no better reason than the cops can, and do, routinely stop Hispanics just to check them out.

Will a wise Latina, whose legal career was largely attuned to the needs of police to enforce Order, care about her fans? 

It’s possible that she will remember who she is, and that but for her ADA shield, or judicial license plates, she might be the one stopped for fun.  Colin Powell remembers that he was treated like a black man rather than a General.  Perhaps Sonia Sotomayor has had a similar experience.  Perhaps Sonia Sotomayor, realizing that she is now in a position to give effect to the promise of the Constitution, will chose to extol the rule rather than the exceptions.  It’s not like she can be unconfirmed.

Some of us are suspicious of this choice for justice.  If a Democratic President, with a Democratic Senate, can’t find the will or desire to nominate someone who brings a strong passion for constitutional rights and personal freedom, and instead manifests a career of putting order ahead of law, then there isn’t much hope.  But it’s possible that Judge Sotomayor’s support of law enforcement over defendants during her career on the lower benches will change now that she is part of a small cabal charged with formulating the rules rather than merely following them.  The power that comes of being one of 9 could change everything.  It has before.  And it hasn’t before.

Whether Sonia Sotomayor will be a justice who will be remembered for anything more than being Latina has yet to be seen.  In her first year, she will have an opportunity to vote, and write, about issues that matter enormously to this nation.  It may take longer, perhaps even a few years, before she feels sufficiently comfortable to take a firm stance.  For the sake of the nation and the Constitution, I hope that her stance will be for the Rule of Law over the expediency of Order.  We shall see.

The Real You: Cash Machine

Some years ago, an ADA who was on his way out of the office asked me how criminal defense lawyers got their clients.  I didn’t like this kid, as he was a nasty cretin as an assistant, so I patiently explained that the quickest way to get clients was to stand by the hot dog seller outside the courthouse, looking very professional, and the family of newly arrested defendants in search of a lawyer would come up to him, inquire if he was a lawyer, and retain him on the spot.  I got the idea from another former ADA who asked me if it was ethical to pay the hot dog vendor for referrals.

About a year later, I ran into the former assistant in the hallway, and he thanked me for my help.  As it turned out, he made a cottage industry out of taking whatever a defendant’s family had in their pockets and doing arraignments.  He made up on volume what he lost on quality.  The same could be said for his clientèle.

The new school approach uses different tactics, but the same strategy.  Brian Tannebaum provides 10 Rules for getting Rich Quick as a lawyer at his My Law License blog.  Brian actually offers 11 rules, but I think he’s off on Rule 8, so I’ve chosen to ignore it.

The gravamen of Brian’s rules are simple:  Enjoy the benefits of the internet to carefully craft an online persona that conceals who you really are and gives the world a deliberately false impression, playing upon ignorance and ambiguity to skirt ethics and competence while sucking in the desperate.  It’s foolproof.  It’s available.  It is, indeed, a viable way to turn yourself into a cash machine overnight, even though you may not quite deserve it.

But there are two questions you need to ask yourself before indulging in Brian’s 10 steps.  Is this who you are?  Is this who you want to be?

Once you have established yourself as a money-grubbing, incompetent slut, that’s who you will be for the balance of your career.  Your reputation exists amongst judges, court personnel, and most importantly, other lawyers.  You will be what you’ve chosen to be, and it’s a reputation that’s almost impossible to change.  Granted, you won’t be the only one, and you may well have plenty of company in your effort to pick off the low-hanging fruit for the quick buck, but you will never be recognized as a good lawyer, and certainly never a great lawyer.

There is money to be made as a quick-buck artist.  Spin through enough arraignments, enough guilty pleas, and even with fees well below market you can accumulate quite a bit.  You will even have clients who think you’ve done a fine job, pleading them out to crimes they didn’t commit or when their rights were violated or when they have a great defense.  Clients are funny; their perception of competence is proportional to their happiness with the outcome.  If you can convince them that the outcome is good, even if it’s not, they will be happy.  They just don’t know any better.

Lord knows there are certainly plenty of people around the internet who are chomping at the bit to help you down the path to making a quick buck.  For the most part, these are failed lawyers who, like you, pretend to be something they’re not and are playing you for a fool just like you will play your clients for fools.  You will probably get along great with these charlatans.  You have so much in common.

Some of Brian’s rules are more important than others.  For example, Rules 3 and 4 are critical:


[3] If you are a young lawyer (less than 10 years out) do not say, on your website or brochure, when you graduated from either college or law school. Leave no evidence of how long you’ve been practicing.

[4] Find a creative writer that can make you appear more experienced than you are without crossing ethical lines. Use words and phrases like “aggressive,” “experienced,” “fight for you,” and “in your corner.”

Nobody is going to retain you if they know that you’ve got no experience and plan to cop a plea at the first opportunity.  So never put your resume online, or reveal that you’ve got all of 12 minutes experience as a lawyer.  And since no one can challenge the ethics of excessive adjectives, you can claim pretty much anything you want about yourself as long as its subjective.  Who’s to know?

Another critical Rule is number 7:


[7] You will get busy very quickly. Do not worry. Find young, unemployed and less experienced lawyers to do the work. Your clients are paying little money so it really doesn’t matter who does the work.
This is where one distinguishes between the practice of law and the business of law.  When you’re going low fee/high volume, as you must to make a quick buck, there’s no time to practice law, and you certainly can’t be in ten places at the same time.  This is where you use others who are just as inexperienced but less entrepreneurial to fill the gaps.  Lawyers are a dime a dozen, and you gather up a handful who have nothing better to do, send them out with a list and have them cop pleas for you.  These lawyers are called “profit centers,” and will become a valuable asset.  If they start to balk, or ask for more money, toss them aside and get some new ones.  There will always be plenty to chose from.

An even better alternative is to not use lawyers at all, but paralegals to appear in court.  Sure, it’s not quite ethical, but few judges care as long as they move dockets along.  It takes about 10 minutes to teach them the plea mantra, and you’ve got as skilled a person standing next to the defendant as you need.  And you can pay them even less than a lawyer, making them an even bigger profit center.

Many lawyers starting out complain about their outstanding loans from law school, the need to make the payments on the obligatory BMW, the desire to going out drinking nightly with your employed buddies.  I understand.  You need money.  Going to law school didn’t pan out quite the way mom thought it would, or perhaps you never really wanted to be a lawyer at all and are now really pissed at the notion that you’ve suffered for three years and still become wealthy overnight.  Here’s your chance.

There are only the two caveats to consider before following Brian’s 10 Rules. Will you be able to sleep at night?  When you look into the mirror ten years from now, having accumulated great wealth and living in the lap of luxury, will you be proud of who you see?  Only you can answer these questions.  It doesn’t matter what Brian, or I, thinks.

Real Life Telephone Call

Ring. . . ring . . . ring.

SHG:  Hello.

Caller:  Car service?

SHG: You have the wrong number.

Caller:  What number is this?

SHG:  It doesn’t matter.  It’s the wrong number.

Caller: Listen, I need a car now, it’s really important. (epithets omitted)

SHG:  That may be, but it’s not a car service.

Caller:  I’m not screwing with you.  I need a car now. (epithets omitted again)

SHG: Oh, you want car service?

Caller:  Yeah.

SHG:  Okay, where you at?

Caller:  168 and St. Nick.

SHG:  Ten minutes.

Caller:  Cool . . . (click)

I don’t know what comes over me.

Big Pictures and Mouse-Milking

Former Chief Judge of the Southern District of New York, Charles Brieant, used this great phrase, “mouse-milking,” long before it made its way into the urban lexicon.  With his goofy mustache and big smile, he would look down from the bench and suggest that we let go of a point we tried so strenuously to make for this reason.  We were mouse-milking.

Lawyers can’t seem to stop themselves from mouse-milking.  We will fight to the death over the most trivial of points, de minimus non curat lex notwithstanding.  Lawyers get hung up on minute details, giving rise to the well-founded allegation that we can’t see the forest through the trees. 

This has proven to be the case with the Second Amendment issue arising from the Plaxico Burress case.  The most prominent challenger to the its advocates, Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy, who has long been watching whether the Heller decision will filter through the law to the point where it matters, and wondering whether the forces behind it will show up to pursue their agenda when the real fights happen in the trenches. 

Comments to Doug’s posts are replete with mouse-milking, nipping at the fringes of the facts of the case (Plax never applied for a NYC carry permit, for example) or the Heller decision (incorporation), ignoring the big picture.  If the right to keep and bear arms is a fundamental individual right, and it is because Justice Scalia said so, then it must be given meaning in real life.  Fundamental rights are not limitless, perhaps (and this is subject to dispute, past Supreme Court decisions notwithstanding), but we either have rights or don’t.  A right, subject to a bunch of caveats, conditions, provisos, exceptions and limitations, that produce the result of having no right at all, isn’t a right. 

While I am no particular fan of the notion of people walking around the city with a gun in the waistband, despite the social utility that its advocates claim, I am a big fan of the Constitution.  Indeed, I’ve been known to complain from time to time about how the Fourth Amendment has so many exceptions that the rule exists in theory only, there being essentially no practical protection left.  That’s what happens when the mouse-milkers take over. 

So given the long-fought battle over the definition and scope of the Second Amendment, this is where the fight between the forces favoring constitutional rights over the forces favoring Order should occur.  Constitutional rights are big.  Bigger than the trivial details raised by naysayers.  Forget about whether you, like me, don’t really care about the right to have a snub-nose, and think about whether our Courts should be supporting the rights reserved for the people against the government, or making up excuses for the government to undermine those rights.  It’s a big picture thing.

To that end, Doug responds to his commenters:



Let’s get precise here, gang, especially in light of the multiple charges brought back by the grand jury. Plaxico may well deserve punishment and certainly can be constitutionally punished for unjustified risks he created with a loaded gun in the bar, and that’s what the charged crime of reckless endangerment covers. Of course, this crime does not depend on gun possession — he might have had a (sharp-edged) pocket bible and US constitution in his sweatpants and, if he started throwing them around the bar to ward off imagined foes, perhaps he could have been guilty of reckless endangerment under NY law.

But Plaxico could not be constitutionally punished at all simply for possessing a (sharp-edged) pocket bible and US constitution in a NYC bar, and I think we would all be aghast if he was facing 3-1/2 years to 15 years in prison for two counts of possessing these constitutionally protected items. Now, in the wake of Heller declaration that a gun is a constitutionally protected item under the Second Amendment, I ask whether and why we should not be greatly troubled by subjecting Plax to 3.5 or more years in prison simply for possessing this item.

As lawyers, we need to stop all the mouse-milking and start looking at the big picture when it comes to constitutional rights.  If we get dragged down by the details, the trivia, we miss the fundamental points.  Our constitutional rights should not be parsed to death, dissected, rationalized to the point of meaninglessness.  Even when it’s a right that some of us don’t feel that we particularly favor.  Even when it’s a right that some of us would rather do without.

It’s time to put aside our lawyerly compulsion to focus on the trivial and fight it out to the death, and speak in unison in favor of the robust recognition and protection of the few constitutional rights we possess.  It’s time we stop accepting that the Bill of Rights, since its enactment, has been the target of a thousand limiting arguments.  Rarely do we get a Heller, an expansion of rights, long since limited, toward its original breadth. 

And when we’ve finally stood up for rights under the Second Amendment, and our judges have finally chosen to protect and defend the Constitution rather than circumvent it, maybe we can work on the Fourth Amendment next?

I add the following just for fun.  The above-quoted comment from Doug concludes this paragraph:


If I were representing Plax, I would contest the gun possession counts on constitutional grounds and then perhaps agree to a deal with a plea to reckless endagerment (sic). This would seem like a sensible resolution on these fact, and one that I think any and all Second Amendment fans should be urging
Somehow, I have a sneaking suspicion that it’s not going to be quite that easy.  But I’m sure that if the District Attorney is willing to accept a plea to misdemeanor Reckless Endangerment and let go of the gun felonies, both Brafman and Burress would give it their most serious consideration.