Author Archives: SHG

The Vernacular of The Lawyer

It’s more than a week and half into the trial of Bob Simels, a well-known and well-regarded New York criminal defense lawyer who was recorded by a snitch talking about neutralizing and killing witnesses.  Simels was a tough-guy lawyer, and his defense is that it takes a tough-talking man to stand up to the government.  No argument there.

To that end, Simels took the stand to offer his explanation for his conversations is that these are the types of words criminal defense lawyers use.  From the NYLJ :


Mr. Simels, appearing calm and deliberate and looking directly at the jurors throughout his testimony, said that when he talked of the need to “neutralize” or “kill” a witness, as repeatedly heard on tapes of secretly recorded conversations played by the prosecution, he was not suggesting an intent to do harm, but rather to discredit the witnesses’ testimony.

“I use [those terms] all the time, and lawyers use them all the time,” Mr. Simels said. “It’s part of the vernacular of being a lawyer.”

Simels claimed that in his effort to investigate and develop evidence on behalf of his client, he tried to “play” the snitch, who he understood to be nothing more than a witness, to get him to talk, provide information, assist the defense in gathering as much as possible to match the government.  Most outsiders don’t realize how little information and discovery the defense receives from the government, and how the defense goes into battle essentially blind, unless the defense lawyer can develop his own sources of information and evidence.  The government, and the courts consider it unduly prejudicial to give the defense a fighting chance.

Simels’ lawyer, Gerald Shargel, sought to bolster the defendant’s testimony by calling Tony Ricco as an expert witness.  Tony, another highly regarded criminal defense lawyer, was put on the stand to testify as to the ethical requirements and limits of a criminal defense lawyer.


Though he did not discuss such a tact specifically, Mr. Ricco told the jury, “There’s nothing wrong with talking with witnesses and potential witnesses about anything. The bottom line is, what the lawyer ultimately decides to put in the courtroom…must be within the bounds of the law.”

Mr. Ricco proved an unusually candid expert witness. In an animated, hour-long back and forth with Assistant U.S. Attorney Morris J. Fodeman, Mr. Ricco frequently agreed with Mr. Fodeman, on occasion even emphatically expanding on Mr. Fodeman’s points—such as the rationale behind the prohibition of payments to witnesses.

When Mr. Fodeman asked Mr Ricco “how does Tony Ricco react?” to a witness’ suggestion that “an act of violence” might benefit the client, Mr. Ricco took a rare pause, then said, “The answer is that you’d dissuade somebody from doing that, but it depends on the circumstances.”

Mr. Ricco then added, “A lot of people say a lot of things,” for a lot of different reasons.

The irony here is that undercover government agents are given vast latitude to say, and suggest, all manner of criminal acts in order to induce their target to say incriminating things.  The government knows all too well what it takes to get people to open up, to believe, to speak the words it wants to hear.  Yet it prosecutes a criminal defense lawyer for taking his turn.

But is this really the “vernacular” of the criminal defense lawyer?  I dunno.  It’s not exactly the way I speak with witnesses, but then it’s not entirely off base to suggest that we don’t talk in terms of killing a witness on cross or neutralizing a witnesses testimony.  Then again, what difference does it make whether I, or any other criminal defense lawyer, uses the same language as Bob Simels?  It’s not like there’s a class in law school about how to talk tough to witnesses, or a disciplinary rule limiting the hyperbolic descriptions permitted.  Each of uses the language, the words, that we feel are appropriate to express whatever it is we are trying to say.  Sometimes, the words sound very wrong when taken out of context.  Sometimes, the words sound very wrong in context. 

Of course, using words like “kill” and “neutralize” can also mean that harm is intended, especially when accompanied by caveats like don’t harm the woman.  But Bob Simels says that’s not what he meant.


“I didn’t think I was sanctioning harm; I didn’t think I was suggesting harm,” Simels said, adding that he “never” intended to bribe witnesses or persuade them to lie.

Instead, Simels said, he was merely “flattering” the informant Selwyn Vaughn, a former associate of Khan’s, who had volunteered to track down witnesses.

This doesn’t mean that Simels wasn’t out on the ledge in the way he conducted himself.  He’s often been considered a bit extreme, whether in scoring the case or in its handling.


Simels’ considerable ego was on display for the jury when he recalled besting a gaggle of lawyers competing for the job of representing Khan – a process known as a “beauty contest” – and mentioned he was featured in a book on lawyering because he was one of the best cross-examiners in the country.
Then again, no successful criminal defense lawyer lacks in ego.  It’s a requisite for doing this job and staring down the might of the United States government.

I’ve tried to avoid posting about the trial as it’s progressed, largely because trials aren’t baseball games, with sides scoring runs inning by inning.  No perspective can be gained in the middle, aside from some particularly notable evidence or testimony coming out.  But the “vernacular” defense implicated the criminal defense bar as a whole, and raised a larger question than whether Bob Simels intended harm when he talked tough to the snitch.

This isn’t my vernacular, but then there’s no reason why Bob Simels shouldn’t be able to use whatever vernacular he finds most effective in performing his function.  He doesn’t need to do it my way.  Or your way. 

H/T The Blind Guy

Everyone is Not Entitled to an Opinion

During a momentary lapse of judgment, I listened to CNN yesterday and heard President Obama exclaim that Americans must be the “best-educated, highest-skilled workers in the world.”  This caused me to immediately think of Tatiana von Tauber’s post at Randazza’s Legal Satyricon.

Seems the international mind is interested in what’s really going on around the world – those issues which truly affect freedom, government and society.  America seems more interested in Annie Liebovitz, sex scandals of politicians and the Bible.  Once again, a firm reminder I’m not in Germany anymore. If I sing “Somewhere Over the Rainbow”, will that change? Even the U.S. edition of CNN is very different than the international one I used to watch and since coming back to the states I find the news too Hollywood hyped for the kind of information I’m used to getting.

Strong words from someone with a last name like von Tauber, ridiculing American concerns, interests and, yes, ultimately intelligence.  Ah, how those Europeans so enjoy making fun of the average American, the very ones who our President says must be the “best educated” in the world if we are to complete.

Is Tatiana entitled to her opinion?  Exhibit 1, a British CNN segment:

They say that everyone is entitled to an opinion.  I’ve never subscribed to that belief.  In order to have an opinion, at least on a matter more significant than whether one prefers chocolate over vanilla, one has to have some basis for it.

Writing this blawg has been quite a learning experience for me.  The strength with which people hold opinions is quite remarkable, but the foundation upon which those opinions are built is sometimes so fundamentally lacking as to be deeply disturbing.  The part of the video that I found most troubling, most inexcusable, is that man who would appear to be in his 60s who lacked any knowledge about World War II.  Even if he lacked any education whatsoever, it seems impossible that he wouldn’t know how many World Wars we’ve endured.

These appear to be perfectly nice, normal, quite ordinary Americans.  No doubt each one believes they know what’s wrong with America, and what needs to be done to fix it.  No doubt each has an opinion.  These are the people that our President says must be the “best educated” in the world.  That’s going to require some heavy work. I wonder how many read newspapers, or even watch television news?  Do they read blogs?  Do they write comments telling others how wrong they are on subject of national importance?

I wonder how many of these people exercise the franchise?  Are they capable of assessing the best leadership for this country?

This doesn’t prove, as the voiceover suggests, that Americans are any worse than people anywhere else.  They may well be, but this segment offers neither context nor comparison, and is hardly scientific.  But we can’t forget that these are Americans, and we can’t assume that whoever we meet, befriend, work with, talk to, can name a country with a name beginning with “U”.  Keep this in mind when you read the comments here and elsewhere. The strength with which some expresses their opinion is not evidence that they are entitled to hold an opinion at all.

Tatiana has earned her opinion.  Most people who read SJ have earned theirs.  But not everyone.  And certainly not every American is entitled to an opinion.  Even if they appear to be perfectly nice, normal, quite ordinary Americans.

I do not believe that Americans are stupid.  But it’s unacceptable that many are so ignorant.

Eric Holder’s Awesome Solution

Aside from the lack of relevance of anything the ABA does to anything lawyers do, not to mention its desperation to find people willing to put on freebie programs that it will wallow in the gutter to muddle together enough of a schedule to pretend it’s worth a few days off for those lawyers who love committees, titles, and the great majesty of being able to tell other lawyers that they are important ABA-type lawyers, there was the Attorney General of the United States of America to give a speech.

And what a speech it was. 

It was rather long.  It was somewhat inspirational.  Not Obama-quality inspirational, but second-stringer inspirational.  And it hit the magic words.  To sum it up, while we must still be tough on crime, we must also be smart on crime.  See how he got both tough and smart in there?  Then he said, he’s going to “conduct a comprehensive, evidence-based review of federal sentencing and corrections policy.”  Who doesn’t love comprehensive, evidenced-based stuff?  I certainly do.

See?  I told you it was inspirational.

But I am here to bury Caesar, not to praise him.  It’s not just that I loathe the political resort to studies and committees in the face of generations-old problems, but I similarly have a problem with the guy whose finger is on the button claiming that he needs someone else’s approval to push.

So Eric (may I call you “Eric”, now that we’re all simpatico?), here’s my issue.  There are a whole bunch of kid prosecutors who work for you and are busy prosecuting tenuous case and demanding lengthy prison sentences for people for whom there’s just no real need for imprisonment.  You know it.  You said so.  So why not send a memo down the line to all those youngsters to just stop doing it? 

I’ll even help (since we’re on a first-name basis now):


To:  All United States Attorneys and Assistant United States Attorneys
From:  Eric Holder, The Boss
Re: Smart on Crime

From now on, it will be the policy of the United States Department of Justice to be smart.  Anything short of smart will be frowned upon.  This means that you should assess every case, every defendant, to determine whether we the crime alleged is really that big a deal that we need to make a federal case of it.  Or even whether it’s a crime at all.

And even if you decide that the defendant really needs prosecuting, decide whether putting the person in prison is worth it.  Think of it this way; Would it be important enough to imprison the defendant that you would be willing to take a salary but to do so?  After all, the American people, in effect, take a hit every time we put someone into prison, so it better be worth it.

And I’ve got another nit to pick with you, Eric.  You’re only talking here about the guilty.  What about the shenanigans being played to nail the suckers.  You know, the Ted Stevens-type stuff that’s going around your office.  I realize that you don’t want to acknowledge the ugliness, but you’re leaving a big part of the problem out of the picture.  In the effort to save trees (or bytes, as the case may be), why not get it out of the way as long as you’re already sending a memo.  Here’s what you might add:


And while we’re trying to whittle down the prison population, let’s start to consider the possibility that not everything out of an agent’s mouth is gospel.  I know, they are fine, upstanding Americans, but sometimes they, well, fudge the details a bit.  I want you to start considering the possibility that some of the more ridiculous stuff isn’t exactly 110% true.  Especially when there is videotape showing that the things the agent said happened didn’t.  It really looks bad for us.

Since you’re on a roll, let’s take this baby home, Eric.  This will make a great closer.


Speaking of videotapes, there are way too many showing police officers and agents doing some really bad things to people.  Not just lying about what happened, but cracking skulls and such.  We’re a little late on the uptake here, and people are beginning to realize that every time we put out a press release claiming that they are conducting themselves in accordance with proper policy, or were justified in tasing someone because they were threatened by extremely mean looks, people are beginning to think we’re a little loopy.  I don’t want to look loopy.  I want to look presidential attorney generalish. 

Accordingly, it shall henceforth by the policy of the Department of Justice to prosecute all law enforcement officers to the fullest extent of the law, provided however that none of them should ever go to prison.  We’ve just got way too many people there already.
There you have it, Eric.  Just copy and paste this sucker and send it right down the line.  By the end of the week, we should have this whole problem straightened out, save the country a fortune, return the DOJ to a position of trust and integrity, and make you the smartest guy on crime I know.  Sure, some malcontents like Brian Tannebaum will probably still find something to complain about,  but who cares? 

After all, you’re the Attorney General of the United States of America.  You can do something about these problems any time you want.

Killer Keller and the Twinkie Defense

It’s not easy to mount a criminal defense.  And it’s not easy to be Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Judge Sharon Keller, excoriated across the country for slamming the courthouse doors shut to make sure an execution proceeds.  As her trial is about to begin, her defense attorney has decided to announce his strategy in advance. 


Judge Sharon Keller, facing potentially career-ending charges that she improperly closed her court to a death row appeal, will argue that defense lawyers fabricated — or at least exaggerated — computer problems the day Texas executed Michael Richard.

Keller’s new accusation is an attack on the credibility of Richard’s lawyers, three of whom are expected to be called as witnesses when her special trial convenes Aug. 17 in San Antonio.

The attack, a recent addition to Keller’s defense strategy, also seeks to undermine the narrative that has emerged against the judge: that she refused a reasonable request to keep the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals open past 5 p.m., penalizing Richard for events outside his control — computer breakdowns experienced by his lawyers.

“Judge Keller’s position will be that there was no computer problem,” said her lawyer, Chip Babcock. “There will be testimony that (Richard’s lawyers) — maybe — had e-mail problems for a few minutes in the afternoon.”

Now I wouldn’t want to suggest that I know better than Chip (or Muffy, for that matter), but I don’t think this is much of a strategy.  The best I can make out of the nexus between the truth of the defense lawyer’s computer problems and Keller’s door slamming is the “no harm, no foul” rule.  Essentially, she’s saying, “Yeah, so I shut the doors at 5 to make sure Richard fried.  Big deal, it’s not like they deserved a chance since they were full of it anyway.” 

This seems awfully weak to me.  It doesn’t excuse Keller’s conduct, but merely argues that Richard’s lawyers at Texas Defender Services were wrong as well.  It’s not like she’s claiming she knew they were full of it about the computer problems when she ordered the doors be closed, and made a decision based upon their purported deceptive claims to deny their application via the closed door method.

Of course, it bears noting that she can’t offer any real support for her claim either.  Computer problems come in all sorts of flavors, as anyone who has ever pounded their fists on an uncooperative keyboard knows.  There is always the presumption of Irregularity, a special rule for defense lawyers where judges presume that anything they say is suspect, designed to deceive the court and hence deemed incredible unless and until proven otherwise, usually by scientific proof or papal decree (the latter be much harder to obtain than the former).  This is contrasted with the presumption as applied to youthful prosecutors, who have never been known to say anything inaccurate, no less deceitful.

Now I’m not the first to arrive at the conclusion that Chip’s defense sucks.

“The issue of whether there were or were not computer problems is completely irrelevant to the charges made against Judge Keller,” Manne said. Richard’s briefs “could’ve been late because of computer problems, which is in fact the case, or 101 other problems. But did she act properly when asked? That’s the issue at trial.”

But since Manne is from Texas Defender Services, his analysis must be presumed wrong.  Accordingly, the Chipster responds:


Babcock said the computer issue matters because the “myth of the computer problem” skewed media coverage of the Richard case. “A lot of the coverage spins out a story that isn’t true,” he said.
This may surprise a lot of people, but the real issue in Killer Keller’s trial isn’t her conduct as being a forceful conduit for the fine people of Texas who expect, no demand, regular executions.  It’s a PR problem.  If only those darn reporters would stick to the real story, that criminal defense lawyers are lying scum and Sharon Keller put a stop to their attempt to lie their way into scuttling a perfectly good execution.

But don’t weep for the trauma Sharon Keller is going through at the hands of scoundrel lawyers and the liberal MSM.  If things go south for her and she’s forced off the bench in disgrace, there’s always the possibility of her getting a gig on cable TV doing small claims cases.  I bet there’s even a role for Chip in there somewhere.

The Rational Health Plan

As President Obama’s health care plan is considered, one point of debate looms large.  Should health care be rationed?

If you were a parent of a child whose life was about to end, you would desperately seek any measure, no matter how small the chance of such success or how expensive, to save her.  I know I would.  That’s what a parent should, must, do.

But that’s not how policy should work.  It’s not the product of emotion and desperation, but one that can sustain the whole and provide for the welfare of a society of people rather than any particular individual within it.  Science has sought to advance our ability to treat disease by developing heroic measures.  This is good, and will no doubt inure to the benefit of society as a whole in the long run.  It doesn’t mean, however, that we can ignore the allocation of scare resources, or that society can sustain a health care system that will provide every individual in need with any treatment possible at any time.

Here is a difficult concept to swallow.  Everyone cannot be saved.

If we accept the proposition that there are not enough doctors, hospitals, medicine or cash to pay for them to allow every person in need access to every medical procedure available. we must accept the notion that care must ultimately be rationed.  For every procedure that costs $100,000, how many poor pregnant women could be provided free, quality pre-natal care?  Do we trade the health of those pregnant women for a chance that some ultra-expensive, low percentage procedure might save one child?  What if the percentage of success was high, but the cost was $1 million? 

As we sit today, the cost of health insurance is, frankly, outrageous.  For those like me, who pay a multiple of our medical usage in insurance, financing the health of others who make greater use of resources, it’s already painful.  I don’t take issue with the needs of other people per se, though I am troubled by those who undergo needless tests to keep a physician’s CAT scan operating 24/7 so that he can turn it into a profit center. 

It’s similarly disturbing when some, like the elderly, use medical care as a social activity, enjoying inordinately expensive tests every time they get a twinge of pain, simply because medicare will cover it and they get to hang with the old homies while they wait for their turn.  I’m not beating up on the elderly for fun, but in recognition that we’ve dedicated a great deal of resources toward the sentimental goal of extending life, with little thought of its quality or cost. 

Our octogenerians view medicare as a right they’ve earned, but few would agree to pay for their care if they had ever been required to do so.  It’s the disconnect between a fine sounding concept and a harsh reality.  Would they really sacrifice their own grandchildren for an extra, needless, MRI?  But they are never asked to think of it that way, as if the magic medical elves just produce medical procedures out of thin air rather than at the expense of their children and grandchildren.  Some pays for it, folks.  Just not you.

As much as I understand (and I most assuredly do) how a parent feels watching the pain suffered by their child, and can appreciate the desire to do anything, everything, possible, I similarly understand that our society would be required to dedicate an impossible amount of its resources to health care if we were to offer every conceivable treatment to anyone who needs it upon demand. 

I don’t suggest that I know where the line should be drawn.  But I do know that we can’t do it all, no matter how sad it is that someone may die even though there is a potential treatment available.  I know that we trade off the extraordinary care for one for the ordinary care for many.  I can feel the pain of a parent whose child’s life is on the line.  I can also feel the pain of a parent who can’t afford basic health care for his child.  And I understand that we cannot afford to do it all.

For anyone who thinks me callous, and it may be an accurate characterization, tell me how we pay for heroic health care when the cost will preclude the ability to buy food and clothing for a child equally beloved by a parent?  It’s not that one child is less worthy than another, but that the cost of the extraordinary procedure has to come from somewhere.  Who pays the price?  What do we give up to make it happen?  Something has to give.

I don’t see how we can do anything other than ration health care and survive.  And I don’t like it any better than anyone else, but I realize that it must be.  The real question is where to draw the line, but we’ll never get to that question until we, as a society, have come to grips with the fact that we can’t do it all.

Then again, we’re not very good about dealing with harsh realities.  We would rather pretend they don’t exist while people suffer for lack of basic care, as long as we get whatever we need.

Can You Hear Me Now?

Marketing philosopher Seth Godin has more in common with me than I thought.  He hates cellphones too.  Not because they are a blight on society, making access ubiquitous and (ugh) on demand, but because he can’t stand the fact that the sound quality sucks. 


Am I the only person who wants a Hi Def telephone?


A headset that sounds better than the handheld receiver, and a handheld receiver that delivers the kind of quality calls we had back in the day…


I want to have a phone call where I don’t have to strain to hear the other person, apologize for static, call people back because they went through a dandelion storm…


No Seth, no.  Me too! 

While Seth explains it in marketing terms, that people are willing to give up convenience for quality, I suspect he has the same problem I do.  I can’t hear as well as I used to.  And no, Mom, it’s not because I was listening to Buddy Miles with the sound turned up to 11 on my Koss earphones when you told me it would make me deaf.  At least I don’t think so.

Whatever the reason, my hearing isn’t what it used to be.  My eyes aren’t either, but then whose are?  As people adapt to the use of cellphones in lieu of real telephones, or “land lines” as they come to be called by those who sneer at anyone who doesn’t text, it’s time to come to grips with a cold, hard fact.  Cellphones are not a sufficiently reliable means of communication.

You can debate how wonderful, how miraculous they are all you want.  In fact, you may have plenty of time to ponder the question when no one shows up for your arraignment after you’ve left a message for your lawyer that you’ve been arrested via a cellphone.  No amount of argument, no heartfelt rationale, is going to alter the fact that cellphones fade in and out, garble your words, leave the other party to hope that he’s heard what you’ve said, without any assurance that communication was well received.

Perhaps other ears, younger ears, are more attuned to the incomprehensible sounds emitted through the itty-bitty speaker.  Perhaps missing the 38 ties “you know?” is spoken in the course of a sentence isn’t deemed particularly important.  Or perhaps this is just a old folks problem, as the weight of time and human frailty takes its toll on our poor ears.  But I just can’t stand the crackle and gaps that happen regularly on a cellphone.

Granted, I have some issues hearing when there’s no cellphone in sight, such as when Dr. SJ speaks to me from another room, facing in an opposite direction, mumbling under her breath, but I believe that she really doesn’t want me to hear what she has to say, though she will later insist she absolutely, positively did tell me that her parents were coming for a two month visit.  I think that’s different.

So yes, Seth, I share your desire for a Hi Def telephone.  I want to hear what people are saying to me without struggling, straining, asking them to repeat themselves, and repeat themselves again. 

And if not a Hi Def telephone, I would settle for a nice old black bakelite one with a metal rotary dial.  I was always able to hear what’s being said on an old rotary phone.

Plaxico Burress Tries The Option Play

The beauty of the option play is that if your first receiver is covered, you can always toss the ball to your secondary or tertiary receiver.  You’ve got options.  And so does Plaxico Burress, now that his attempt to pull down the long ball was blocked when the grand jury handed down an indictment for two counts of criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree and misdemeanor reckless endangerment.

It was worth a try, putting Plax in the grand jury and trying to distinguish between a gun in the hands of a pro football player and one in the hands of a person bent on committing a crime.  It just didn’t work.  That doesn’t mean that it was a mistake, or that bad strategy.  He took a shot, and it was a good shot to take.  Plax just didn’t get his arms around the ball.  That happens.

From the New York Times :


Benjamin Brafman, Mr. Burress’s lawyer, accused Mr. Morgenthau’s office of a “lack of flexibility.” He had tried to negotiate a plea that would have required less prison time than the mandatory minimum sentence of three and a half years. He argued that Mr. Burress deserves leniency because he was not carrying the gun to commit a crime, was the only person injured, had bought the gun legally, and agreed to testify before the grand jury.

“For an isolated act of poor judgment in which nobody else was hurt, this man may be separated from his family for several years and will lose a brilliant career,” Mr. Brafman said in an interview before Monday’s grand jury decision was announced.

All true, and certainly persuasive to Giant’s fans, but remains problematic if one bears in mind that New York has laws prohibiting the possession of loaded guns, whether by tall receivers or even rap entrepreneurs.  You see, New York City has a lot of celebrities around town, many of whom believe that they are at risk and could use some protection.  But there is no exception in the law for guns in the hands of stars.  Even star athletes are supposed to abide the laws.

But this was the option play, so the real question is where will it go next.  This blends into an interesting question, given the concurring opinion by 10th Circuit Judge Tymkovich in US v. McCane , stating:

My first point is that the felon dispossession dictum may lack the “longstanding” historical basis that Heller ascribes to it. Indeed, the scope of what Heller describes as “longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons,” is far from clear. To be sure, some sources would support the proposition. But more recent authorities have not found evidence of longstanding dispossession laws. On the contrary, a number have specifically argued such laws did not exist and have questioned the sources relied upon by the earlier authorities. Instead, they assert, the weight of historical evidence suggests felon dispossession laws are creatures of the twentieth — rather than the eighteenth — century. Together these authorities cast doubt on a categorical approach to felon dispossession laws.

* * *

Rather than seriously wrestling with how to apply this new Second Amendment rule, therefore, courts will continue to simply reference the applicable Heller dictum and move on. And in light of the Supreme Court’s clear direction, this is perhaps how it should be. After all, “our job as a federal appellate court is to follow the Supreme Court’s directions, not pick and choose among them as if ordering from a menu.” I nevertheless wonder whether Second Amendment law would have been better served if the regulations Heller addressed in dicta had been left to later cases.

If I were in Brafman’s shoes, my next attack would be to challenge the underlying prohibition against carrying a handgun for self-defense under Heller.  I’m betting that Ben and Mark Baker have already thought of this.  Far stronger than the felon in possession argument, no one suggests that Burress had the gun to commit a crime, making this a great test case on the facts since this case presents the rarely seen “clean defendant” subjected to laws that were never quite meant to apply this way.

But it won’t be an easy road.  It implicates many of the questions left unanswered in Heller’s individual rights interpretation of the Second Amendment, from whether it applies to the states via the 14th Amendment, to whether it applies outside the home, to whether crossing from New Jersey to Manhattan with loaded gun in pants alters the scenario.

Of course, as Doug Berman astutely notes, the next big question is whether it will be left to Brafman alone to fight the battle, or whether this will be the opportunity for so many Second Amendment fans to jump into the fray and block for Burress.


I think anyone seriously and deeply committed to enforceable individual right to possess a gun for self-protection ought to be greatly troubled by both the decision to criminally prosecute Burress and by the considerable prison terms being threatened in this case.  Though a few Second Amendment fans have previously express some concern for Plaxico’s plight, I will be interested to see if more start coming to his defense now that he has been formally indicted.
Mind you, it would be inconceivable for the District Attorney to have not prosecuted Burress, there being both law that prohibits his conduct and thousands of others who have been and are still being prosecuted for the criminal possession of a weapon.  But few present an opportunity like this, to take on the crime head first, with the right defendant and the best of circumstances.  The only question now is whether the Second Amendment advocates will let the fact that Burress doesn’t play for Dallas cloud their thinking.

Even if the entire NRA lines up behind Burress, it’s going to be a tough sell to whichever New York County Supreme Court Justice will end up with the case, at present an unknown.  There aren’t too many with both the ability and will to be the one to change everything when it comes to New York’s, and the nation’s, gun laws. 

In the meantime, I emailed Chief Assistant Mark Dwyer after learning of the indictment yesterday, and asked whether they would keep the two year plea offer on the table.  He replied:


We love to talk. We will talk if the defense wants to talk. We have taken nothing “legal” off the table. No one thinks this is a “max” situation.

The DA’s office walked a fine line on this case as well.  They don’t want to “hurt” Plaxico Burress, who still has many fans out there who wonder how the Giants would have finished if he was still on the field.  On the other hand, there is a very real message at stake in this case about the legitimacy of New York’s revamped, extra-harsh 2006 amendments to the gun laws.  You can’t send the message that guns won’t be tolerated, and then cut too sweet a deal with a star wide-out. 

On the other hand, Brafman won’t be much of a hero if he can’t pull out a better deal than the run-of-the-mill two years that anyone could have gotten Plax.  The good news is that the DA didn’t pull the offer off the table when it was rejected the first time around.  The good news is that it will still be there should every trick in Brafman’s bag fail, which is quite possible under the circumstances.  The bad news is that Plax really needs a score and he’s got a long way to go to reach the end zone.

At least Plax still has options.  No one wants to go for the short yardage outlet pass, but at least it’s still there.

Baptism By Taser

There are few things more American than celebrating a right of passage with a family party in the backyard.  The sound of children laughing and playing in the backyard of a 55 year old church family counselor and bible study teacher whose grandchildren had just been baptized isn’t the sort of thing that should strike fear in the hearts of Manassas, Virginia police.

From Fox55 News :


Edgar Rodriguez says the backyard celebration came to an abrupt halt. After some confusion, his 55-year-old father, Edgar Rodriguez, Sr. says he was asked for an ID and handed it over. Then, he was Tasered three times.

The elder Rodriguez explains how he pulls out his wallet. Interpreting for his father, Edgar says, “He took out his wallet. He had the license in his hand and gave his wallet to his wife. When he lifted up his hands with his license, he started feeling the electric shock in his back.”

“All of a sudden he got Tasered in the back and then this side, and then officer in the front of him Tasered him from the front.

But the charge had yet to drain from the cops’ Taser, so


The pregnant mother of the baptized boys was Tasered, too. The family says the woman tried to help Rodriguez, who was on the ground. She was charged with assaulting a police officer.

“They Tasered her in the back. She didn’t assault the officer. She was assaulted by officer,” said Edgar, Jr. who was just steps away from his father.
And since the tasing of pregnant women is generally frowned upon, the cops held her in jail overnight until immigration and customers enforcement could take her off their hands.
 
As it was a baptism party, this dangerous family had the video camera going, capturing the evil-doings of happy, raucous, tumultuous children at play.



The police claim that Rodriguez (note the ethnic name, which may or may not have played some role in the attitude of cops, Henry Gates’ myopia notwithstanding) was drunk and refused to comply with the officers’ demands for his identification.


A spokesperson says, “The officers contacted the homeowner, who was highly intoxicated. The officers explained the noise ordinance to the homeowner, who refused several requests to turn down the loud music. Rodriguez began to act disorderly and refused to identify himself to officers.”
And so, while enjoying the baptism party for his two grandsons in his own backyard, Rodriguez was arrested for public intoxication. 

The best thing anyone can say about this absurd incident is that no one died, especially the mother’s unborn child who may be one of the first fetus’ to feel the sensation of 50,000 volts in the womb.  That the fine men and women charged with tasing pregnant women during backyard baptism parties thought it best to use force is but one issue.  But the question lingers whether, had the officers not been armed with tasers, would they have just beaten Rodriquez and the pregnant mother senseless with clubs?

The confluence of tasers and police authority seems to be a constant source of stories for me.  I’m sick of these stories.  The solution isn’t to stop reading or writing about them, but to continue to do whatever is possible to make others aware of the dangers inherent in putting tasers in the hands of police officers, and putting police officers on a pedestal.  I can think of no other “tool” in the hands of police that has given rise to such flagrant abuse and misuse. 

I might quip, “when in doubt, tase,” but there was no doubt here at all.  The worst that could be said of Rodriguez, assuming the cops are accurate and the family is lying through its teeth, is that he wasn’t sufficiently deferential and didn’t pull out his ID fast enough.  In his own backyard.  We can’t have that in America.

Or maybe the cops just don’t like Latinos, even if that includes pregnant mothers of two boys who were just baptized. 

H/T Karl Mansoor

They All Rolled Over

I’m generally disinclined to criticize the plaintiff’s class action bar, despite the fact that it ordinarily produces monumental fees for itself and little material value for its purported class.  I recognize that it’s important to mount a class against large corporations to stop bad actors from small but pervasive wrongs, and this is the only way to do it.  I know all this.

But the Ford Rollover class action was an outrage.  From WSJ Law Blog :



The AP has a story out Monday taking a sort of retrospective snapshot on the Ford Explorer rollover class-action litigation. As part of a settlement reached last year, the nearly 1 million class members covered by the lawsuit each received the opportunity to claim a coupon worth either $300 or $500 toward the purchase of a new Ford vehicle. As of June 2009, according to the piece, only 75 people had used the coupons, at a cost to Ford of $37,500. The plaintiffs’ lawyers, meanwhile, took home $25 million in fees and expenses.

That this case settled for coupons for the class members is absurd.  That the judge approved this settlement is ridiculous. That the attorneys for the class were paid $25 million is the stuff of tort reform.


Last year, Sacramento County Superior Court Judge David De Alba authorized the settlement of a class action that lawyers argued could be worth as much as $500 million to people who owned Ford Explorers during the 1990s. As part of the settlement, Ford customers could receive a $500 discount coupon toward the purchase of a new SUV or a $300 coupon to buy another Ford vehicle.
Does it come as a shock that owners of a vehicle that has an unfortunate tendency to rollover are unlikely to want another one?  This wasn’t compensation for past wrongs, but fundamental malpractice and outrageous greed.  These lawyers sold out their clients, the class.  This judge can’t possibly be that blind to not realize that approving a $25 million fee when the class received nothing of value was wrong.

Class actions are very expensive to litigate.  It’s understandable why the legal fees appear grossly disproportionate to the payouts to individual class members.  After all, that’s the reason why class actions are necessary in the first place, that the individual loss may be small or trivial, but added together can amount to a very substantial amount of money of a very real harm done the class. 

But this settlement, coupons for the class and a huge check for the lawyers, was a sellout.  That these lawyers agreed to, and that this judge, approved this settlement feeds everyone’s worst nightmare about lawyers, and the plaintiff’s bar in particular, and rightfully so.

The lawyers blame the coupon settlement on the economy and Ford’s prospects for bankruptcy.  That’s nonsense.  They weren’t worried about the economy when they went to cash their legal fee check.    If someone can offer a legitimate justification for this settlement, I would appreciate it.  But I doubt anyone can do so. 

These are the sorts of issues that people have in the back of their mind when they retain me.  As a lawyer, I won’t be responsible for conduct such as this. Like others, I too am outraged.

New Meaning For Badgelickers

Joel Rosenberg is fond of calling people who place blind faith in police badgelickers.  Not that he’s got anything against police, per se, but that he’s not inclined toward blind faith in anyone.  So badgelicker came immediately to mind when I read Turley’s post about a disgusting clash between a couple of Wisconsin National Guardsmen and a pair of cops.



The guardsmen, both of whom have served two tours of duty in Iraq, were in the Dells for weekend training and were stopped by police officers Wayne W. Thomas and Collin H. Jacobson early the morning of June 1 and accused of having urinated in public, according to a lawsuit filed Monday in U.S. District Court in Madison.

The officers pointed out a wet spot in an alley that they thought was urine, the lawsuit states, but the guardsmen, Sgt. Anthony R. Anderson, of West Bend, and Specialist Robert C. Schiman, of Kaukauna, denied having relieved themselves in the alley.

In order to prove that it was not their urine and avoid a citation, Thomas and Jacobson made Anderson and Schiman lick the ground and scrape mud up with their hands and lick it, according to the lawsuit.

Schiman also was made to eat a plant that was drenched in the liquid, the lawsuit states.
Is this supposed to be a man thing?  A “guys with guns” thing?  A Wisconsin thing?  My problem is not limited to what sort of psychological deficiency causes two men, police officers, to even consider telling others to do such a thing.  My problem is that two National Guardsmen, both of whom have served two tours of duty in Iraq, would even consider, no less perform, such an act.  To avoid a citation?  Not even to avoid a damn good beating is this normal conduct. 

It’s not clear what pathology this reveals, what deep-seated psychological need was left unfulfilled or overfilled, but I fear that this facially gross story reveals some deeply troubled issues that are normally hidden from polite company.  This is not the sort of thing that happens amongst people of even moderately normal mental health.  It is not so much a story about police abuse, but a story about sick men, all of whom bear arms to some greater or lesser extent, and are charged with the protection of American society.  Is this a reflection of some psychological impairment that pervades those who make the choice to serve as society’s protectors?

What would possibly drive two police officers to want to direct two national guardsmen to do such a thing?  And worse yet, what would drive two national guardsmen to do it?  There is something very wrong here.  Very wrong indeed.