Author Archives: SHG

Popular Mechanics, A Handbook For Judges

When I was a kid, Popular Mechanics was a really cool magazine.  It had cars that could be driven into the water like a boat, and wild one-person helicopters and jetpacks that we would all be using one day to get around.  It was the stuff that dreams were made of, at least for 12 year olds.  I haven’t read it in a long, long time.  In fact, I haven’t even seen one around.  My metrosexual dentist prefers Architectural Digest.

But after reading Radley Balko’s post about Popular Mechanics and its story on the flaws of forensic science, I’m think that it might be time for the state to buy a bunch of copies and leave them lying around the judges’ lounge.


The article includes a skeptical look at four common forensic specialties, including fingerprint analysis, ballistic evidence, trace evidence, and biological evidence, and explains how none are as certain as they’re often portrayed in the courtroom.
Lawyers are not required to know squat about science to pass the bar.  For some bizarre reason, judges, upon their elevation to the bench and donning of the robe, are of the belief that they’ve suddenly become scientific savants (as well as funny, which is another issue).  As the gatekeepers of evidence, they ought to be.  But, of course, they’re not.

A while back, I wrote a piece for the now defunct Judicial Reports about how the thousands of videos of police doing the dirty makes it impossible for judges to honestly default to the assumption of police credibility and integrity.  My position was that it was no longer possible to close one’s eyes to the fact that some cops lie and harm people, and do so without what others might see as a comprehensible reason.  It just happens.

Nothing changed.  Judges are either too busy or too disinterested to spend their time watching Youtube to learn what the rest of us have come to realize by being bombarded day to day with the proof that our fears of the past are indeed valid.  We may be firmly convinced, but we’re not the decisionmakers.  The decisionmakers haven’t budged.  A few, perhaps, but not enough to make a dent.

The same is true with advances in science, They are still in love with science, viewed as perfect evidence in contrast with the garbage of testimony that we’re all forced to endure.  Their job is so much easier when scientific proof, something upon which they can rely without any nagging doubt in their back of their mind, is presented.  They lose no sleep when some tech takes the stand and speaks the results of their test.

Of course, judges are the last people one would want to decide the validity of scientific testing.  They know zip about it to begin with, and haven’t kept pace with new data and faults that appear in the literature.  Of course, one might remind them that at one point in time, bleeding with leeches was considered the height of medical knowledge.  Things change.  Except in the courtroom.  Debunked science will continue to be embraced with love and appreciation long after researchers have determined that it’s just another round of leeches.

Judges are the human version of lemmings, following each other blindly under the guise of precedent.  Not until some rebel judge challenges the orthodoxy will another even consider the question of whether a test, once deemed reliable, might be full of crap.  It’s not that each judge doesn’t have the capacity to be the rebel, though most lack the desire.  It’s that they can never go wrong (legally) by falling back on that which has already been decided.  What was once good science remains good science, so long as no judge has broken ranks.

Publishing this article in Popular Mechanics seems like an important step in breaking away from the mindset that if some scientist once said that this is good evidence, it’s now irrefutable in perpetuity.  You can bet money they won’t be reading the scholarly journals to find out that fingerprinting isn’t perfect, but it’s just possible that they will read Popular Mechanics.  After, it’s got pictures.

Now if we could just get Playboy to cover the subject.  They only read it for the article, you know. 

The process of turning the ship of justice around is brutally long and difficult.  Anyone reading this post is likely to keep abreast of new developments, whether in the law, science or otherwise.  While I know of some judges who do so, I similarly know that they aren’t inclined to reveal to their brethren that they actually know how to use a computer, or that they’ve come to realize that the easiest path is no longer the presumptively correct one.  If they disclosed their geekishness, or that they possess intellectual curiosity and a desire not to follow bad scientific evidence, the other judges would make fun of them and they would never advance in the judicial hierarchy.  Since these enlightened judges are all still in their teen years, they couldn’t possible take that risk.

Eventually, the time will come when judges realize that their love of scientific proof of dubious merit is unrequited, and that so many men and women spent lives in prison based on a scientific fraud.  Unfortunately, the lag between scientific recognition of its own failings and judicial acceptance of another silver bullet hitting the wrong target will be long indeed.  And even if they read the current issue of Popular Mechanics, they will be far more interested in the story about personal jetpacks than this one.

Blawg Review #223, Sphincter Rules

Today was not my day to do Blawg Review.  Some marketing guru-type signed up for the job, and then disappeared.  What a shock.  So the anonymous Ed, being the happy guy he is, decided to stick it to me publicly, knowing how much I hate doing Blawg Review. Nice guy.  

But then, it’s raining outside, my father-in-law stopped by unannounced for a visit, so doing a quick Blawg Review suddenly didn’t seem nearly as unpalatable as it normally would.  After a firm discussion with myself, considering what would Geeklawyer do if Ed did this to him, I realized: Sphincter Rules.  Wrapping my arms around a bottle of rioja, the only Atkins-friendly wine I know, I set to work.

Walter Olson at Overlawyered posts that school boys in Britain must now wear clip-on ties to avoid a potential choking hazard.  It’s not that he wants boys to choke, but that he gave Ted Frank a clip on for his birthday and now fears that Ted will take it the wrong way.  On a more frivolous note, Walter shows his softer side with a little poetry.


I think that I shall always rue
The day a tree got rights to sue.

A tree whose hungry lawyer’s plea
Is filed on a contingency…

 


Ridiculous.  No lawyer would take a case for a tree on contingecy.  Sphincter Rules.

In contrast, we have the kiss thrown by Adrian Dayton to our own Ed, thanking him for the opportunity to do Blawg Review (as if Ed wouldn’t have paid him if he held out), which follows his 10 Things Every CEO and Managing Partners Should Know About Social Media.  Just tell me one thing, kid.  Have you ever met a CEO or Managing Partner?  And you, Mr. Twitter-Maven, are going to tell them what they should know?  Maybe I should cut the kid a break, but I’m not as nice to the Slackoisie as the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, who has done a far kinder job of explaining work/life balance than I would. I prefer the Cher method from Moonstruck.

And if the young’ns don’t like it, they are always free to leave, unlike the prisoner who ended up getting screwed when the lawprof assigned to handle his appeal handed it off to a student to play lawyer for a day, per Mike at Crime & Federalism, only to find that the inchoate lawyer, as Judge Alex Kozinski held, “waived waiver” and blew the whole gig.  Would Judge Norm Pattis have done that?  We’ll never know, now will we. 

Dave Hoffman at Concurring Opinions writes about how Beatty Chadwick, the lawyer who sat in jail since 1995 rather than comply with the court’s order in his divorce, was finally released.  His strategy was finally vindicated, and it only took 14 years of his life.  Great deal, though for only a few extra years, he could have comitted murder.  But at least Chadwick got his name in the paper, which is more than can be said for Brian Tannebaum, who starts by asking why journalists love prosecutors, and then has to explain why his own name was left out of a big story when the writer was a personal friend.  Maybe he should take kiss throwing lessons from Adrian?

Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Law Blog figures out that you can pretty much get any personal information you want about a person by just going through the court record.  And that goes for lawyers’ social security numbers too. Lest this upset you. Marc Randazza at the Legal Satyricon has some good news about porn law, that DOJ has agreed that it’s wrong to prosecute a New Jersey pornographer in Montana just because the latter smells better and no one at DOJ has an appropriate wardrobe of doubleknit suits.  You can get a lot of personal information by watching porn as well, by the way, though Randazza doesn’t seem nearly as concerned about it as Turk does.  Sphincter Really Rules.  Scratch that image.

Seth at Quizlaw posts about the drunk kid who was told by a Milwaukee cop that  he couldn’t just sleep it off in his car, forcing the kid to move along.  Of course, the kid was then immediately busted for drunk driving.  The Wisconsin Court of Appeals decided that this time, the Sphincter didn’t rule in the end.  But  as Patrick at Popehat posts, the same couldn’t be said for Antonio Love, deaf and mentally disabled, who was tased and pepper-sprayed for not responding when a cop knocked on the bathroom door.  Rule of Life: Whenever the word Taser appears in a story, you can rest assured that the Sphincter Rules.

At Above The Law, where Elie Mystal  recently showed why he’s writing for a blawg rather than practicing law, they’re hard at work coming up with alternative career paths for their now-unemployed Biglaw associate readers (to be distinguished from their readers under the age of 12), all of whom are named “anonymous”.  The latest idea is New England Innkeeper, for which they have slightly less chance of success than solo practice, but at least equal likelihood of competence.  Of course, their chances are better than Brandon Pereira, a passenger in the negligent car suing the innocent car because, as his lawyer Roland Hughes explains, “I’m trying to get compensation for my client anywhere I can.”  Hughes is rumored to have Elie’s roommate in law school.

Over at Prawfsblawg, David Fagundes wants to know whether other lawprofs think it’s worth his while to keep his law license active, even though he’s now a scholar and he would have to pay the freight out of pocket.  After all, it’s not like a lawprof should have anything to do with the law, right.  It’s yucky, and could get an academic’s hands all dirty.  Like those of public defender Skelly, at Arbitrary& Capricious, who’s grown weary of his blawging after five years, and has decided to take a breather, if not a powder.  I bet he wishes he had the chance to ponder whether he could give up the practice of law for the good life of the Academy, if only all those nasty indigent criminal defendants would stop demanding that he save their lives.  But nothing there to concern you, David.  You’re a scholar.  No need for you to, maybe, actually help someone with that brilliance of yours.

In a post ironically appropriate to both Fagundes and Skelly, Charon QC notes that The Law Society has launched a campaign to warn students to “think twice about embarking on a career in law,” which suits Charon just fine given his belief that those who can’t cut it should, perhaps, consider an alternative career path. (No, Geeklawyer, this was not about you.)  Maybe Innkeeper? What, you thought I was going to say blawger for Above the Law?  But hey, any profession beats the crap out of Congressman, the abuse of whom, per Reynolds, is the “the highest of for patriotism.”  I don’t know what that means either, but then I’m not a scholar, right David?  Of course, Sphincter Rules. Even Especially in the marble hallways of the Academy.

Which brings me to the Sphincter Rules Story of the Week, with Henry Gates playing Ward Cleaver, Cambridge Police Sergeant James Crowley playing Eddie Haskell, Barack Obama as June Cleaver, Joe Biden as Wally Cleaver and Lucia Whelan as T
he Beav.  Wendy Murphy does a cameo as Lumpy Rutherford. 

But Ed told me to lay off the whole GatesGate and Beer Summit posts, which of course are the really good stuff across the blawgosphere (and just about everywhere else) this week, as he was going to keep those for himself in order to make the point that there’s nothing involved in centuries of racial prejudice and discord that a few beers can’t solve.  I’m not even allowed to touch Rick Horowitz’s subtle hand pointing out that if Whelan is the darling of America (which she is, I might add), how do we explain Crowley’s police report laying the nasty racist stuff off on her?  Nope, I can’t touch it, not even to point out that how few have noticed that his official police report is the product of Sphincter Rules.

That out of the way, I close with one final thought.  I didn’t want to do this Blawg Review.  I never wanted to do another Blawg Review again.  And yet I did.  Sphincter Rules. And not a single mention of What About Clients?, since nothing Dan Hull has ever done falls under the rubric, Sphincter Rules.  Over to you, Ed.

Next week’s Blawg Review is to be hosted by BabyBarista (or who I prefer to call the prick blawger who didn’t send me a free copy of his book BabyBarista and the Art of War).  You can get instructions from Blawg Review how to get your blawg reviewed for an upcoming Blawg Review, just like I would have reviewed BabyBarista’s book if Tim Kevan sent me a free friggin copy (but he didn’t, that loser). 

Need Options In A Troubled Economy?

While the recession may be receding, provided your a Wall Street Bonus Baby, many criminal defense lawyers continue to find it difficult to make a go of it, unable to find defendants capable or willing to shell over their few remaining dollars to give them a fighting chance.  Does it feel like a lost cause?  Then consider the options.

From Grey Tesh, President of the Palm Beach Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and eyeglass model:


There’s plenty of work out there.  If you are a hustler, you’ll do fine.  I try and stay away from the naysayers.  You know.  The people that say “Business sucks. Nobody has any money…I’ve never seen it this bad in my 22 years of practice.”  Stop complaining, get off your ass and hustle. Do something.  Build a better website, take civil lawyers to lunch, volunteer in something you believe in – anything.  Take your tale of woe elsewhere.  

If people are not hiring you, it may not just be that they “have no money.”  Many times it is a lack of trust.  Concentrate on what they want and need, care about them and the trust will come.

Or maybe you just have ugly eyeglasses, you negative nellies.  Think contacts.

Perhaps you’ve grown tired of the law, the grind, the head-banging.  Maybe you really don’t want to put the effort into hustling your way to vast wealth, Palm Beach style.  If so, there’s always the path of Casey Berman, Hastings Law Grad and card-carrying member of the Slackoisie.


Long before the recession killed the job market, Casey Berman realized the law wasn’t for him.

Having launched a number of companies already — and sold one — now he’s launching another: a consultancy called Leave Law Behind through which he’ll hold the hands of disillusioned lawyers who want to start their own businesses.
It seems Casey’s an old pro at creating businesses, though it hasn’t done him a lot of good, considering that while pushing his new consultancy start-up, he’s “working full time at Berman Capital, his father’s investment banking firm in North Beach.”  Remember, it’s always best when “leaving law behind” to have a daddy with an investment banking firm.  Just to speak to you father.  He’ll be happy to do it for you.

Or, as I found out in the mail yesterday, one can approach new options from the other side.  I received a letter from the very prestigious Cambridge Who’s Who.  Note that it is not to be confused with Fat Tony’s Who’s Who, which is not nearly as prestigious.  Only Who’s Who with Anglo sounding names are prestigious.

Having regularly received these Who’s Who letters over the years, ranging from Who’s Who on my Street to Who’s Who in the World (because Nelson Mandella and I have so very much in common), I was about to toss it when my kid, who rarely receives mail, asked if he could open it.  I gave it to him, and watched as his eyes exploded.  He informed with newfound respect that I was now going to be in Who’s Who in Medicine.  Woo hoo!

Please understand that I’m constrained to suffer the disdain of my darling wife, Dr. SJ, who enjoys immensely reminding me of my deficient education and that lawyers’ degrees only say the word “doctor” for government pay grade purposes.  This letter changed everything.

Obviously, I am now a powerful force in medicine.  I know this because Cambridge Who’s Who said so.  They would never lie.  Whereas yesterday my career options were limited, either to learn how to do the hustle (something I failed to accomplish in the 1970s) or to beg my father to end his retirement to found a wonderfully successful investment banking firm, I can now begin my career in medicine from the very top of the profession.  And I don’t even have my own pair of latex gloves!  What a great country!

As for me, I’ve already got as much business as I can handle and would hate to leave my clients in the lurch while engaging in much needed proctology examinations (bare-handed), so I’m just going to keep doing what I’ve always done.  But at least I can tell Dr. SJ that she’s got nothing on me anymore.

But For Video, Volume 43 (Update)

There is probably no “tool” that has done more for injecting a wee bit of honesty into busts than the dash cam, which is why you won’t find one on any police car in New York City.  But you will in Cookeville, Tennessee.

If Carlos Ferrell had been arrested in the Bronx, there would no chance, absolute zero, that anyone would have believed him when he said that the cops who arrested him, after having a police dog dine on his leg for a tasty delight, planted pot on him.  Not that it hasn’t been claimed before, along with the other claims of planted throw-away weapons and the tuning up given a recalcitrant perp.  

Fortunately for Ferrell, his arrest was caught on a dash cam, showing not only the needless dog attack after he submitted to authority, but the hand signal and then the goofy pronouncement of Police Officer Chris Melton that he found marijuana, “Whoa, Carlos…”


Cops Plant Drugs On Suspect – Watch more Funny Videos

As Ferrell’s attorney, Blair Durham notes, when the cops have the hand signals already worked out, it suggests that this isn’t exactly the first time they’ve planted pot on a perp.  Indeed, having a bag of weed in his right breast pocket suggests that Melton was a believing in the boy scout creed, to be prepared.  Or maybe the Nike creed, just do it.

It seems somewhat obvious that cops with dash cams would behave themselves just a bit better than would otherwise be the case, given that they may well find their behavior on the internet.  No matter how many police chiefs respond to embarrassing videos with the hackneyed “consistent with police policy,” the fact remains that videos have proven remarkably effective in disclosing police misconduct and abuse, and cutting short a fine career in law enforcement.  Or at least forcing the offending officer to lose three days pay while on suspension.

A well-intended person might believe that videos would be embraced by cops nationwide.  After all, they would provide evidence of crimes and serve to corroborate police testimony in court, where (in the minds of our well-intended citizenry) activist judges give criminals a free ride with laws that favor the wrong-doers at the expense of the law-abiding.  But no, the police despise the idea of dash cams.  Hate it.  How could that be, you wonder?

In the absence of video, we’re left with only the cops word on what happened.  Typical testimony is that an officer from the 34 Precinct stopped a car because the driver changed lanes without signaling.  Sure, it’s uptown, where nobody has ever signaled to change lanes in the history of man, but it’s still a traffic infraction and the cops said he saw it.  That’s it.  End of story. Nothing more needed, and nothing to do to counter it. There’s no evidence to support it, and the worst one can do is put a defendant on the stand to deny it.  You will never find an independent witness who happened to be watching the car at that moment and can testify that it either didn’t change lanes or did signal.

Without a dash cam, it is impossible to contradict an officer’s relatively innocuous allegation.  Of course, it becomes critical when he finds the 27 kilos of marijuana in the trunk of the car, which he smelled with his hypersensitive nose.  But that’s a story for another day.

There’s no upside to cops in having a dash cam.  But as Chris Melton found out, it can have a definite downside.  And without the video, no judge would ever believe that stuff like this happens.  Unfortunately, even with this video, they still don’t believe it happens in Manhattan.  After all, it’s just an isolated incident.

Update:   Thanks to  Karl Mansoor, we have an answer to the burning question of what became of P.O. Melton. 


Whoa, Carlos, weed? Now you got you another freaking charge, how about that?” Melton told Ferrell in the video.

But a Tennessee Bureau of Investigation concluded that Melton was reaching into his pocket to hit a button to make sure the camera in his car was recording the arrest.

Acting District Attorney Tony Craighead also pointed out some audio later in the tape where Ferrell can be heard saying to the arresting officers, “Yeah, you found the weed in my pocket.”

“The TBI’s finding is there is no wrongdoing by Officer Melton. The DA’s office is not picking sides here,” Craighead said.
Ferrell’s lawyers state that it was a total plant and they are pressing forward with the case.  Melton appears likely to have a commendation in his very bright law enforcement future.  Justice is served.  Eat it while it’s hot.

Plea Rejected, Thankfully

For anyone who loves children, justice and harbors any belief in the promise of America hidden deep within their soul, far from the cynical exterior we show the world, this one will bring a smile to your jaundiced eye.  From the New York Times via Doug Berman, District Court Judge Edwin Kosik of the Middle District of Pennsylvania decided to reject the sweet plea deal cut by state court judges Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. and Michael T. Conahan.

Those names strike a bell, don’t they?  Just in case anyone has forgotten, which would be a tragedy in itself, let me remind you just who these two individuals are, and why their names must be remembered.  These were the two Pennsylvania judges who sold children into prison, making millions in kickbacks.  Children, without prior histories of wrong and whose misconduct was often trivial, expected a stern lecture from the court and instead were hauled away to a private juvenile detention facility.  The take was $2.6 million.

The government, which doesn’t flinch when it puts a poverty stricken mother who turns mule to feed her starving children behind bars for 121 months, offered a plea to 87 months for the two titans of the law, substantially below the guidelines.  In lay terms, that means they would be out in less than 6 years at worst.  And even with this sweet deal, the arrogant scum tried to bully their way through the Pre-Sentence Investigation Report, refusing to explain their motivations, denying critical facts and refusing to accept responsibility beyond how terribly this affected them. 

How wrong was this deal?  Well, let’s see how it stacks up on the Bernie Scale.  They racked up a potential 2,183 children wrongfully sent to jail.  How much is a child’s life, a child’s belief in fairness and a child’s expectation that their society won’t abuse them so mercilessly, worth when compared to pensions and college funds for the grandkids?  Bernie took 150 years.  These scum get a deal for 87 months. 

To his enormous credit, Judge Kosik wouldn’t play ball.  He rejected the plea.



In a highly critical order, issued Friday, Judge Edwin M. Kosik of Federal District Court in Scranton, Pa., said he based his decision on the comments and conduct of the two men after they entered guilty pleas to serve 87 months in prison.

Judge Kosik said the presentence report prepared by probation officers found that Mr. Conahan “refused to discuss the motivation behind his conduct, attempted to obstruct and impede justice and failed to clearly demonstrate affirmative acceptance of responsibility with his denials and contradiction of evidence.”

“Defendant Ciavarella is less obstructive,” the judge continued, “but instead has resorted to public statements of remorse, more for his personal circumstances, yet he continues to deny what he terms ‘quid pro quo,’ his receipt of money as a finder’s fee, not withstanding the government’s abundance of evidence of his routine deprivation of children’s constitutional rights by commitments to private juvenile facilities he helped to create in return for a ‘finder’s fee’ in direct conflict with his judicial roles.”
Rejection of a plea agreement is a true rarity.  Rarely will a judge second-guess the government’s notion of a proper deal.  But this one was so offensive, so disgraceful, so utterly and inexplicably soft, that if ever the was a deal worthy of rejection, this was it.  And these two arrogant pieces of trash did everything in their power to demonstrate their unworthiness of the government’s “mercy”, the very thing that they laughed at when they busily sent children to jail as they rang up their receipts on their judicial cash registers.

The maximum sentence available for the crimes to which they pleaded guilty is 25 years.  Based on the Bernie Scale, it still falls well below the proper sentence.  But we don’t apply the Bernie Scale, though if ever a case cried out for retribution, this one does.  Nonetheless, application of the proper sentencing considerations of §3553(a) would make a 10 year sentence about right to remind any other judge inclined to sell his robe, conduct all too easily concealed behind a law and order facade that would be applauded by the mindless throngs, think twice.

Upon rejection of the deal, the scoundrels have two options.  They can withdraw their pleas and the case move forward to trial, or they can continue to sentence and the court will have a free hand to impose whatever sentence he believes proper. If ever a case called out for a good, well-publicized trial, this is it. 

But here’s the problem.  The same Assistant United States Attorneys who thought that 87 months for these crimes fit the bill will be the ones who would try these two despicable pieces of scum.  Will they do so with the zeal they would bring to the man who downloaded cartoon porn, or would it be closer to the gentle way they treat cops who beat and taser perps?  Which government will show up for trial?

These two judges, who were entrusted with the lives of children and sold them for a tidy profit, have done mindboggling harm to the belief that there is any justice to be found in the courthouse.  Will the United States Attorney for the Middle District of Pennsylvania add insult to injury?  Given the 87 month deal, I wouldn’t be the farm on our government doing the right thing.

Facing one of the gravest abuses of the publics’ trust ever, let’s see how the government deals with it.  We’ve already got gutless court administrators and lawyers, both prosecution and defense, who have some explaining to do.  How many more cogs in the machine will fail before this case is over?

But we thankfully have Judge Kosik, who refused to allow this case to just quietly fade away.

Fear of Signing

The police have developed extraordinary means of overcoming good sense and persuading/manipulating people to say things to them that will inure to their great detriment.  It’s perhaps the most significant tool that ever existed in obtaining convictions, whether the speaker is guilty or innocent.  It’s one of the very few things that police do well, and they do it very well.  But signing one’s name to a piece of paper is another matter entirely.

People have, thankfully, a fear of signing.  Speaking aloud doesn’t seem to implicate the same level of permanency, of seriousness, as signing one’s name to a piece of paper.  Whether that paper is a written statement or confession, or merely an acknowledgment of the Miranda warning, or a consent to interrogation or search, the act of signing causes some different mix of chemicals in the brain that hits the limit of what people will do impetuously.

It’s for this reason that the Second Circuit decision In US v. Plugh is so significant.  By a 2-1 majority, the court held:



This appeal raises the question of whether a suspect in custody and informed of his rights in accordance with Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966), is entitled to the prophylactic bar prohibiting police questioning established in Edwards v. Arizona, 451 U.S. 477 (1981) (right to counsel), and Michigan v. Mosley, 423 U.S. 96 (1975) (right to silence), when he expresses uncertainty with regard to  asserting his Fifth Amendment rights while contemporaneously refusing to sign a waiver of rights form. We believe he is entitled to the prophylaxis and affirm the district court. By unequivocally refusing to sign the waiver form in response to a custodial agent’s instruction to sign the waiver form if defendant agreed with it, defendant in this case invoked his Fifth Amendment rights, and therefore his custodial agents were required to refrain from further interrogation.

Notwithstanding the equivocal nature of a defendant’s reaction to Miranda warning, a constant source of problems given that few defendants are bold enough to just say “no” or not speak at all, the refusal to execute a waiver of rights form has been held to constitute a sufficient invocation of the privilege against self-incrimination to stop further interrogation.

This has long been one of the most absurd fictions of criminal law, that a defendant’s failure to speak the magic words to terminate questioning reflects an equivocal position, allowing cops to use every manipulative weapon on their tool belt to get him to spill his guts and confess.  Only a judge could believe that an inartful attempt to invoke one’s right, to refuse to speak, is really equivocal.  People are scared to death to refuse to succumb to the demands of cops, and will do almost anything to avoid their wrath.  An affirmative refusal to comply is like begging for a good beating.  Nobody wants to be the recipient of a cop’s wrath.

But the refusal to sign the waiver form is a bright line test, and one that conforms to the will of most defendants, despite police pressure.  They will talk, but they don’t want to sign.

Don’t sign, and that’s that.  Let’s hope that this decision stands.

Life and Death in the Blawgosphere

The blawgosphere is much like any other place, assuming the place has only a digital existence. Over time, shiny new faces appear and old, wrinkled faces fade away.  At one minute to midnight last night, Skelly took his leave.  His blog, Arbitrary & Capricious, was well established and respected when I first stepped foot in the blawgosphere.  And now he’s decided to go on what he’s calling “hiatus”.

Skelly was funny, fascinating and always brought something new and interesting to the fore.   I remember once mentioning that I didn’t know how he kept finding such strange stories about Public Defender life, a realm that I saw only from the outside.  Skelly was on my original blogroll and has been there ever since.  Along with a handful of blogs, his is one that I’ve read every daily, every post. 

I salute Skelly and thank him for the effort, the great work and perspective he’s provided me personally.  Arbitrary & Capricious enriched the blawgosphere for me, and I will miss it and Skelly.  He’s left the door open to return, and I hope he finds that his juices keep flowing and call him back to blawging. 

Others have also been fading a bit lately as well. My very dear friend Gideon at A Public Defender, has been largely dormant, his time consumed by bigger fish in the trenches.  Norm of course goes in and out of the blawgosphere with the wind. It isn’t easy doing this.  It wears on you over time.

This seems a good place to devolve into a rambling discussion of blawgs, and why they aren’t going to be as meaningful and successful as Arbitrary & Capricious, or A Public Defender.  Kevin O’Keefe, one of the foremost promoters of the blawgosphere, recently predicted that there will ultimately a hundred thousand blawgs.  He may well be right, but not in the sense that they will fill the shoes of the blogs that brought people to the blawgosphere, that people read regularly, that people cared about.  They will have pretentious names and make arrogant claims of worthiness.  And no one will read them.  And they will stop posting one day and no one will care.  No one will even notice.  They will leave no footprints.

Over the past year, a number of things people call blogs have appeared, some of which are produced lawyers I know.  They have heard the siren call of the blawgosphere and wanted to get their piece of the pie.  I haven’t mentioned them, because I don’t want to constantly speak ill of new blogs.  But they aren’t worthy of a mention.  They offer nothing. 

We don’t need a hundred thousand blawgs repeating yesterday’s news in a paragraph.  The claim that if you start a blog, people will read it is a lie.  No one has the time to read a hundred thousand blawgs.  No one needs to read the same rehashed news stories a hundred thousand times.  The same is true of blogs describing court decisions, It’s been done to death.  I’ve read your blogs and saw nothing there.  Some of you are great lawyers, but your blawgs suck.  There’s no necessary correlation between the two.  You will soon tire of posting, since there’s no reason to blawg when no one reads it.  And your blawg will fade into oblivion.

In the end, there will never be more than 50 blawgs that matter.  There may be thousands around, but only 50 that get read. Maybe. And I’m not including those blawgs that facially exist to promote your business.  They will invariably fail.  This is the biggest lie of the blawgosphere, that you can use blawgs to puff yourself and gain clients.  I’m offended by those whose blawg is a flagrant advertisement.  You are the trash of the blawgosphere, and do the most harm to its vitality.  Not only will I not help to promote you, but I will out you and denigrate you whenever possible. 

Don’t tell me you can’t think of anything worth blawging about.  I leave a half dozen posts on the table almost daily.  There is so much out there to write about, to think about, to add value to.  If you can’t think of something to write about, then blawging just isn’t for you.

And then there’s your voice.  I write like a criminal defense lawyer.  My views are clear and strong; no one reads my posts and wonders what I really think.  You may think I’m dead wrong, or a blithering idiot, but you won’t think I’m wishy-washy or pointless.  This upsets people.  Some accuse me of being controversial to attract readers.  Some say I’m too intense or over the top. Some call me a barroom bully.  I couldn’t care less.  I don’t write to attract anyone or please anyone.  If I’m not your cup of tea, then don’t read me. No one makes you and you’re not doing me any favors.  But don’t ask me to tone it down and stay within your comfort zone.

I’ve got little tolerance for people who have never had an original thought, or are scared to death of expressing an opinion for fear that it will offend someone, or want to be loved and admired to fill the gap in their psyches left by mommy’s neglect.  Grow up. Grow a pair.  Talk to people over a beer, and they know everything, have an answer for everything, have an opinion on everything.  Ask them to put it in writing and they quiver like a bowl of jello. 

But if you post something that I think is foolish or wrong, don’t whine to me that I’m mean to call you on it.  And bear one thing in mind: Some of you just aren’t that bright, even though others might not be aware of it until you’ve written a post expressing your deepest thoughts.  Once you’ve done that, you’ve proven to the rest of us that you’re a dolt.  If you don’t want us to know, don’t write. If you think you’re brilliant nonetheless, then take the heat that comes along with expressing your thoughts.  But just don’t whine about it. 

And for God’s sake, don’t send me an email telling me that I’m too mean to you.  If I thought I was too mean, I wouldn’t have written whatever I wrote.  If I wrote it, I think I’m being just the right amount of mean.  If you don’t like it, write something mean about me in return.  You won’t be the first.  But you won’t do it, because you’re gutless and thoughtless.  This is why you bring nothing to the blawgosphere. It would negatively impact your carefully crafted internet persona.  We couldn’t have that now.

Kevin uses the term “thought leader” all the time.  I hate the phrase, and it makes me bristle whenever I hear it.  But the alternatives, thought follower, or worse still, thoughtless, characterize most of the blawgosphere, and particularly the self-promoters.  If you’ve got nothing to add to the discussion, or are afraid that expressing your thoughts will scare away business, then do yourself a favor and go away.  You’re wasting your time and no one will read your blawg. 

The blawgosphere needs people like Skelly.  And Gideon.  And Norm.  These are the people who breath life into the blawgosphere, and breed thought and interest and curiosity.  They make others think.  If you can’t fill their shoes, then be a reader if you want, but don’t blawg.  And if you can’t stand the heat, then stay out of the blawgosphere.  You’re not Skelly.

Beer Delivery For Obama

If the president’s solution to sorting out disputes between cops and people who get angry with them is to sit everyone down for a beer, then he’s either looking for excuses to drink and stumbled on a doozy, or he’s going to have to learn to handle his Bud Lights.  Why?  Our next couple is waiting in the wings :



District resident Pepin Tuma, 33, an attorney in private practice, said the arrest took place at 17th and U streets, N.W., shortly after midnight July 26, seconds after a police officer overheard him telling two friends “jokingly” and in a loud voice, “I hate the police.”

Tuma said he made the comment in jest as he and two friends, who also are lawyers, were walking to Dupont Circle gay bar Cobalt while talking among themselves about the controversial arrest of Harvard University Professor Henry Louis Gates in Cambridge, Mass., for disorderly conduct.

In an e-mail to Lanier, Tuma said that after repeating twice to his friends in a “sing-song” voice, “I hate the police,” an officer “charged 40-50 feet towards us while yelling at me phrases like ‘who do you think you are’ and ‘who do you think you’re talking to.’”

“As Officer Culp moved me toward a police cruiser, he told me to ‘just shut up, faggot,’” Tuma told Lanier in his e-mail.

Will that be two Bud Lights, gentlemen?

I tend to doubt that a personal meeting with the warring factions will produce sufficient change.  While Henry Gates’ problem may have been a little closer to the President’s heart, them being friends and all, he can’t now ignore the gay bashing cop.  That would be offensive.

But the problem isn’t black.  Or gay.  It’s cop.  And the more we try to wiggle between the hard facts, the cold law and appeasing that large segment of society that is very fond of police officers, no matter what (and coincidentally, isn’t always so fond or tolerant of blacks or gays).  We just don’t seem to be making much headway with the notion that being disrespectful, even mean, to a police officer is not a crime.  Maybe some of the TV talking head guys will borrow this quote from a commenter at Turley’s blog:


“The freedom of individuals verbally to oppose or challenge police action without thereby risking arrest is one of the principal characteristics by which we distinguish a free nation from a police state.” Houston v. Hill, 482 U.S. 451, 462-463 (1987)
Seriously, it’s the perfect length for a sound bite and will make you seem remarkably learned.  We won’t tell where you got it from.  Promise.

Or maybe you think Obama can hold his alcohol?

Reverence and A Child’s Eye

Sitting around a courtroom waiting for your case to be called is one of the primary activities of a criminal defense lawyer in New York City.  There are many things to do to occupy your time, ranging from counting to 21 on body parts to silent critique on the latest in street fashion. One of my personal favorite pastimes is to watch young lawyers, men and women I’ve never before seen, stand up and make the most of their 30 seconds before the court.

There are occasional flashes of brilliance, guts, creativity.  There is a more steady stream of lawyers repeating the typical jargon, routine sounds that tell us that whatever purpose is being served during those precious seconds, it’s not different to the lawyer than the case before it or the case after.  It’s as if this was a big charade with a predetermined outcome, and they are just going through the motions.  And indeed, that’s exactly what it is to them.

Most young lawyers, and far too many more experienced ones as well, have a deep desire to play the role of the yeoman.  They learn in their first few weeks of practice to mouth the words that the bulk of lawyers do, so they can repeat the mantras of the law like a pro.  Their last two years of law school, steeped in theory that bears no connection to anything they will ever have to do for client, they are left with only the most basic lessons of year one.  The lessons of ancient history.  They want to be accepted by the guild of lawyers who regularly appear, and these lawyers say the mantra so perfectly that they are the models the new kids emulate.

I was once one of these young lawyers, but had a nagging belief that if I looked harder, tried harder, thought harder, I could find a way to accomplish anything.  Which brings me to Dan Hull’s post, imploring lawyers to get some fresh eyeglasses.



Few of us can have Albert Einstein’s talent for Western logic, or IQ. But Einstein’s advantage over other physicists may have been that he was a “new soul”; he looked at everything as if he were seeing it for the first time.

Work. He approached it from a wellspring of joy. There are others like him in that respect. Those are the kind of people I want as friends to inspire me, and as co-workers to solve clients’ problems. I’ll take an IQ a lot lower than Einstein’s (for associates, though, Coif or Law Review would be nice).

Reverence and a child’s awe. That’s the outlook I prize. Energy, intensity and creativity always seem to come with it.
Dan has captured the essence of what it means to be a lawyer.  No, not one of those yeomen who can spout the mantras with perfection.  That’s not lawyering.  Every case, every client, is an original.  It’s the very first time.  No case has ever happened before, and it’s entirely up to you to invent it in whatever fashion best serves your client. 

The vast majority of lawyers, not to mention judges, view the law as something that’s already happened.  Some brilliant person who died centuries ago came up with the ideas, and everything since is just its routine application, with the odd minor tweak here and there. 

There are few lawyers, a handful, who create the law.  Who challenge precedent.  Who broaden old horizons, and see new ones that no one has ever seen before.  To this handful of lawyers, no case is typical.  No client is common.  No scenario is garden variety.  Every one is absolutely, totally, completely new.  Every case is an opportunity to be a virgin.  Again.

These lawyers look at a case like a child, unaware of what “can’t be done” and determined instead to just find a way to do it.  They see the law as if it’s the first time, with infinite possibilities and no fear that the burdens of the past will crush their spirit.  They believe that they can accomplish great things.

Which lawyer are you?  Which lawyer do you want to be?  It’s entirely up to you.

Plaxico Burress Goes Long

So Plaxico Burress had a gun.  He had it on him when he went out in Manhattan to do a little partying.  In some cities in America, this makes him a regular guy.  In Manhattan, this makes him so serious a criminal that he’s got to go to prison.  Dallas Cowboys fans finally have a reason to love New York’s highly restrictive carry law.  But the New York Football Giants need him.  The New York football fans want him. 

The New York County District Attorneys office has a different idea for Plax’s new training regimen.  According to Sports Illustrated, negotiations for a plea broke down with Ben Brafman, Plax’s lawyer, shooting for one year, and the prosecution demanding two.  After trial, he’s looking at three and half.  Anyone who lived through the Ray Handley years knows that the Giants can’t take two years of failure, no less three and a half.

The Plax defense is a strategic nightmare.  There is none.  There is no question that he had the gun, and no question that he committed a crime.  The only argument in his favor is that he did not possess the gun to be an evil, violent person, to use it for unlawful or malevolent purposes against another.  Wrong?  According to the law, no question about it.  Bad?  Well, that’s according to whether you feel that someone is bad just because a law says you can’t do something.  Laws, like panty hose, are written so one size fits all.  As the photo of Plax and Brafman shows, one size does not fit all.  No, that’s not a doctored photo.  Brafman is, well, diminutive in stature.  But he’s got one heck of a bite.


p1.burress.jpgThe old saw is that when the facts are against you, argue the law. When the law is against you, argue the facts.  But here, everything is against Plax.  For many lawyers, begging would come to mind as the best option.  But I doubt that Ben Brafman is much for begging.

Given the situation, and the defendant, it was only natural that thoughts would turn toward the long ball.  Plaxico would do the unthinkable.  He would walk into the grand jury, face 23 (they will all show up for this one) good men and women (hopefully more men than women) and tell the truth.  He would tell them what he did and why he did it.  He will explain that one size does not fit all, and hope that at least a majority of the 23 accepts the idea that they, good citizens of New York County, will decide that New York’s very strict, very harsh gun law doesn’t fit the wide out.  They will return a “no true bill.” 

Despite our country’s rich history of nullification, it’s frowned upon by the law as a means of allowing a person to escape criminal liability.  It’s the longest of long shots, the ultimate end run.  It’s a “hail Mary.”  If there’s anyone in New York who can bring the “hail Mary” home, it’s Plaxico Burress.

Some say it’s crazy.  Some say it’s too risky.  I say Brafman nailed it.  When Ben Brafman puts his mind to a case, he’s one of the best there is.  And when it’s a high profile case, Ben puts his mind to it.

Vermont Lawprof Michael McCann considers the risks of the move:


Depending upon the prosecutor’s style and tactics, Burress may have testified in a very hostile environment. By testifying, Burress may have also unwittingly revealed his potential trial strategy to prosecutors. Even worse, if he ultimately faces a trial and testifies in it, his testimony must be consistent with his grand jury testimony, for otherwise he could face additional charges for perjury and obstruction of justice.
 
Given those drawbacks, Burress’ decision to  testify would appear unwise.

In some other case, some typical case, McCann’s points would have some merit.  But one size does not fit all.  Plax has nothing to give away, and there’s no reason in the world for him to fudge his testimony.  There’s no secret awesome trial strategy to reveal.  On the law and facts, he dead as they come.  These are the cases that separate pedestrian lawyering from greatness.  Even when looking brilliance square in the face, some lawyers won’t recognize it.  Not even some lawprofs.

The SI article offers an explanation of the defense side by “New York criminal defense attorney and former Manhattan prosecutor Jeremy Saland.”   Gulp.  Apparently his bona fides as a criminal defense lawyer are inadequate, requiring him to establish his value by announcing that he was a former prosecutor.  It’s worth noting that Saland has a blog called New York Criminal Lawyer Blog, a sleazy, unadulterated, self-promotional, advertising blog.  It’s a shame that a decent blog name died for this purpose.

Saland attempts to explain what Brafman was thinking:


Burress’ appearance before the grand jury appears driven not by a desire to claim innocence but rather by a desire for jury nullification — meaning, in this case, the grand jury would decide to disregard the actual law which Burress appears to have broken.

“By humanizing himself beyond the perception that he is a privileged athlete, painting himself as remorseful, and establishing that he was the only one hurt, Burress hopes that he can mitigate and ‘nullify’ the evidence,” Saland says. “Yet, the reality for Mr. Burress is that unless he can sway the emotions of the grand jury towards ‘nullification,’ he lacks a true legal defense.”
On a superficial level, he’s accurate.  But if that was all Plax had to offer, he might as well surrender while he’s at 100 Centre Street, as that’s not going to do the trick. 

The grand jury testimony has got to distinguish between the purposes served by the law, to prevent people will ill-intent, criminal motives, from walking around the City with gun in waistband to shove into the ribs of some working man who’s just left the ATM, or the lesser culpable drug dealer just protecting himself from deal gone bad, and the well-intended, even constitutional, purpose of a target for the criminal. 

Plaxico Burress must show the grand jury that he didn’t carry a gun to stick anyone up.  He would never harm another human being deliberately (off the field). He wasn’t carrying the weapon to use it affirmatively against another person.  None of the purposes for which the Legislature made it illegal to possess a weapon apply to his situation.  One size does not fit all.

Plax has to explain to the jury what it’s like to be a sports hero in this town.  While most New Yorkers admire his efforts on behalf of the New York football Giants, there are people walking around who see a bullseye on his back.  Whether because he’s wealthy, and would provide a good yield to anyone who wanted whatever was loose in his wallet, or just because taking down Plaxico Burress, big time wide out for the Giants, would make some punk a big man on the street.  At least in his own, warped mind.  High profile people are targets to people with sick minds.  Plaxico Burress is one such target.  He may be big and tough on the football field, but he’s just a normal guy, trying to enjoy a night out with friends, and hoping to make it home without incident.  Is that too much to ask?

But Plax, that’s why New York City has a police force larger than the population of most midwestern cities.  True dat, but they aren’t standing next to you when the shiv slips between your ribs.  The reality, as Plax must explain, is that the cops will show up to cordon off the crime scene, but a little too late to stop the bleeding.  It’s not the cops’ fault.  They can’t be everywhere.  But that won’t save Plaxico Burress from death at the psycho’s hand.  He felt the need to be capable of defending himself, and he is, like it or not, a target.

Plax will be remorseful.  It wasn’t his plan to break the law, but just to survive a night out.  Is it wrong, when someone has a bullseye on his back, to want to survive?  Is it better to break no law but lie dead on the floor?  Since Plax would never use his gun offensively, criminally, against another person, is the purpose of this harsh law served by prosecuting him?  Is anyone better off by putting Plax in prison for years?  Years!  That’s what this law demands.  Does it make any sense this time? He’s not the man for whom this law was intended.  One size does not fit all.

And there’s no downside, as McCann suggests.  There’s no trial strategy that might be spilled inside the grand jury.  There’s no trial strategy beyond nullification.  You can bet your life that Ben Brafman prepared Plax within an inch of his life for this grand jury testimony, and should he testify at trial, there will be no inconsistency.  Nor should there be.  There’s no reason for Plax to lie.  The truth is the best he’s got, and the only thing to do is tell it well.

Will it work?  Who knows, but given what’s at stake and the options available, it was a bold move.  Why pass up the first opportunity to prevail upon the soul of the grand jurors to serve a higher purpose than rubber stamp an indictment.  There are too few chances to pull down the long ball to pass up this first and ten opportunity.  It’s just a matter of doing it well, doing it right, and there aren’t many lawyers capable of clearly understanding how to make the most of this opportunity, maximize the chance for success.  There aren’t too many lawyers with the stomach to make such a bold play.

And if you’re wondering, should this attempt to nullify fail, anticipate that Ben Brafman’s next tactic, post-indictment, will be a major effort to apply Heller’s constitutional right to self-defense to Plaxico Burress’ reason for carrying a gun.  Given the particulars, this could prove to be the perfect case to put Scalia’s dubious dictum to the test.  I wouldn’t be surprised if Mark Baker was hard at work on the memorandum of law already.