Author Archives: SHG

Those Who Don’t, Teach (Update)

When lawyers chided the lawprofs about their alleged disconnect from the actual practice of law, the usual response is that they not only engage in their scholarly endeavors, but roll in the trenches every now and again to keep their law chops in shape.  Given Paul Lippe’s salvo across the bow of the Academy, this detail is elevated to critical status.

I held this claim to be sacred.  My heart is now broken.  Southwestern Lawprof David Fagundes has crushed my spirit.


I wrote a few weeks ago about whether lawprofs count as lawyers. There is, in my opinion, no right or wrong answer to this question, but one distinction between the two is clear: you have to be a bar member to do much of the work of a lawyer, but you don’t have to be a bar member to work as a law professor. Indeed, some law professors, such as HLS’s Duncan Kennedy and Scott Brewer, have never even taken a bar exam.

That said, I’d wager that most law professors are bar members, and I’m no exception, having been a member of the California Bar since 2003. When I was working at a firm, this was a requirement, but since I left for academia, it obviously isn’t any longer, and I’ve grown ambivalent about whether it makes sense to maintain active bar membership status (primarily because of the high cost of bar dues: $410 last time around and going up every year).

While David didn’t ask for the opinion of practicing lawyers, but rather elected to keep it within the chorus, I realize that my barging into the discussion is boorish and vulgar.  But then, I’m a lawyer.  What would you expect?

First, David, there is a “right answer” to the question of whether lawprofs count as lawyers.  You should.  Not that you do, but you should.  Here’s a secret for all the lawprofs harboring doubts as to their lawyerdom.  You’re supposed to be teaching kids to become lawyers.  That’s why the kids are paying tuition.  That’s why your employer is accredited.  That’s why you get a paycheck, modern pedagogical notions notwithstanding.  If there were no students, you would have to work for a living.  See the connection?

The obvious cliché to be inserted at this moment is “those who can do; those who can’t teach.”  I don’t buy into that joke at all.  Some of you guys are awfully smart.  Some just think brilliant thoughts.  But when brilliance looses its connection to purpose, then it ceases to matter.  Once you’ve elected to divorce yourself from the practice you’re charged to teach, you have lost your intellectual authority. 

It seems that the trend, if anything, should go in the exact opposite direction.  Certainly nobody needs another law review article that no one in a position to make or influence the course of the law will ever read, but the real world could use some more laboring oars rowing toward a more just society.  Lawprofs should not only be required, required, to be members of the bar (including the bar of the state in which they teach), but should be required to engage in the practice of law throughout the course of their teaching career.

It’s like this: Guys (and gals, since I know Ann Bartow keeps numbers on this sort of thing), having some clue about how the things you spout actually happen, whether in the courtroom, the wood-paneled office, the street or the kitchen table, is necessary for you to impart to young minds what they will spend the rest of their natural lives doing, assuming they make it out of law school, pass the bar and stay in the profession long enough.  They believe you when you tell them things.  They believe you know what you’re talking about.  They trust you.  And it’s not worth it for you to actually do, every once in a while, the thing you teach?  Aw, come on.  Even if you suck at being a lawyer, at least you will have some idea of what it means.

In reaction to challenges such as Lippe’s, lawprofs respond that they believe that law schools are doing an adequate job at turning out people capable of practicing law.  In order to credit this opinion, however, there must be a basis for the lawprofs to know what constitutes the capacity to practice law.  How does a lawprof who has never passed the bar judge such a thing?  What about the lawprof whose entire frame of reference consists of three years writing memos at Biglaw?  Or the one whose experience was limited to a United States Attorney’s office?  This isn’t the practice of law.  At best, you’re barely out of knickers.  You only get to have an opinion if you have basis in reality to form it.  That basis has to be earned, and you can’t earn it if you don’t do it.

Still don’t believe me?  How do you think Charles Nesson is doing on the Joel Tennebaum trial?  Put aside the fact that he forgot how one dresses for trial.  Do you think it’s significant that Nancy Gertner, as good a judge for Nesson as could possibly be, had her fill of him from the outset:


Indeed, on several occasions “sustained” escaped from Judge Gertner’s lips before Oppenheim even had the chance to object. Chiding Nesson on his frequently unorthodox questions, Judge Gertner at one point told the evidence professor, “I’m just trying to translate this into the Federal Rules of Evidence.” And when Nesson, reacting to a sustained objection, explained what he was trying to “say,” Gertner cut him off: “You’re not supposed to be saying anything. You’re supposed to be asking questions.”
Is Nesson brilliant?  Not if he can’t ask an unobjectionable question.  And this is someone who is supposed to teach evidence to law students?  Scholarship is no excuse for functional imcompetence. 

David Fagundes would do well to keep his bar admission active.  Not just active in terms of paying the freight, but active in reality.  If he wants credibility in the classroom, or even in the law review, there’s only one place to earn it.  It’s not the marble hallways of academia.  It’s the trenches of the courtroom.  At the absolute least, you ought to know where the local courthouse is.

The following is added for practicing lawyers only.  All lawprofs can return now to more scholarly pursuits.  Bye.

Just so you know, some of the lawprofs will come by and read this post.  Chances are slim that they will comment here, or write about it elsewhere.  They hate it when someone like me, a pedestrian lawyer, takes them on.  I get nasty emails, asking me to keep them private, lambasting me for being so mean and confrontational.  Why can’t I be more like them, collegial, and demure.

But they will read the post, if for no reason that to have yet another reason to stick a pin in their voodoo doll of me.  It’s a shame that we can’t have an honest discussion between the scholars and the trench lawyers, but they find our manner offensive and prefer to hide amongst their own where no one will ever say anything mean about them or facially challenge their facile self-deception.

As it’s becoming universally recognized that law schools, aside from its other problems, is becoming increasingly less relevant in producing competent practitioners, this discussion needs to be had.  Until lawprofs are willing to have a real discussion with those who work in the trenches about where it’s failing, nothing will change.  That conversation will not happen until the lawprofs decide to stop hiding from us.  That they can’t handle the confrontational, even vulgar, manner in which we hash things out is part of the problem.  We are lawyers,  Lawyers face challenges head on.  That they refuse to do so demonstrates why their lack of participation in the profession, as well as the discussion, imperils the future of law school.

So when you see that no lawprof respond, don’t assume they know nothing about this post.  They do.  Know that they have chosen to hide their sensitive heads in the sand and refuse to acknowledge that there is a whole bunch of practicing lawyers who aren’t impressed with how they’ve chosen to put their brilliance to use.  And that’s why law schools can’t produce functional lawyers.


I may be too hard on them, but somebody has to call them on this nonsense.

Update:  Rick Bales, a lawprof at Chase Law School, Northern Kentucky University, left this comment to David’s post:


As privileged members of a distinguished profession, I believe we are ethically obligated to provide pro bono representation to those less fortunate. It is doubly true because we serve as role models for our students. In most states, however, we cannot perform pro bono legal work without a bar license. This, I believe, is reason enough to get a bar license in the jurisdiction in which you teach.
Rick Bales is my hero.  I believe that Chase Law School has just hit Number 1 in USN&WR, and Bales is up for a Nobel Prize.  Or at least a Greenfield Prize.  I’m naming my next kid after him.  Maybe even my next two kids.  Or more.

Lawyer Fashionista: Haute Bronx

As battles break out in backwaters over the proper attire for court, lawyers in the Big Apple felt confident that they could hold their head high, knowing that their judges, for all their other faults, perceived or real, were above such petty concerns.  While this remains true in the land of fashion week, our heads hang in shame for the province to the north.

From the Daily News :


Bronx Judge Joseph Dawson has had enough of the skimpy, casual attire worn by defendants in his courtroom – and Monday he decided to let everyone know it.

“Your client comes up in a T-shirt and sweatpants, chewing gum?” Dawson chided lawyer Edward McGowan. “This court deserves more respect than that.”

Dawson admonished another man sporting a T-shirt and shorts: “I’m not saying you have to wear a suit. You don’t. Just wear something appropriate.”

Finally, a judge bold enough to state the obvious.  Dress for probation.  How many defendants have suffered the Rock just to put them in a slimming jumpsuit in place of those hot pants or, God forbid, the Frankie Say Relax t-shirt.

It used to be that the mere fact that a defendant showed up for court was enough respect to sate the appetite of a judge.  They were so easily pacified across the river.  Isn’t it time that defendants came to appreciate that court wasn’t a place to model the latest in Juicy Couture?  Granted many defendants would sweat standing before a stern-faced titan of the law, but that doesn’t mean he should wear special enabling pants for the occasion.

Though Edward McGowan does note a problem with the edict:



McGowan, a lawyer with the nonprofit Bronx Defenders, said while the judge’s position is reasonable, sometimes “the clothes they got [are] the clothes they got.”

“All of our clients are poor,” he said. “What may be the best clothes they have might be considered by others to be disrespectful to the court.”
If you’ve ever taken a leisurely stroll down the Grand Concourse, you will note that there is neither a Gap nor Banana Republic to be found.  Rather, the haberdasheries offer a style of clothing that is appealing to local tastes, at a price point matching the fiscal sensibilities of the natives.  Very few people in the Bronx have a preppie wardrobe hiding in the back of their closet.  It’s just not the way they roll.

I learned this from my own experience, advising (well, actually demanding) that my clients dress in accordance with my own refined sense of propriety and fashion-backward thinking, anticipating that attire more appealing to the tastes of the judge would remove a nasty distraction.  I explained to my clients that court was not a place to meet new friends of the opposite sex, and it therefore would not harm their status on the street to dress in manner befitting a court appearance.

Of course, after acquittal, they would rip off the Oxford button down shirt in the hallway, revealing the “Vote For Pedro” tee underneath. Freedom is sweet.

During my decades as arbitrator in Manhattan small claims court, I was once confronted by a litigant who sat before me with his shirt open from collar to waist, revealing a hairless chest and the same musculature I possess, though mine is covered by the requisite layor of human protective material.  It was, to be blunt, disturbing.  I asked him why his shirt was fully open, and he told me it was “a look.” 

Judge Dawson’s expectation that defendants consider the fact that they are going to court when they select their attire in the morning hardly strikes me as much of a stretch.  Even in the Bronx, consideration of the day’s events should guide one’s choices.  However, when one’s Sunday Best on the Concourse is either the best they can do, or a casual reflection of a cultural distinction, perhaps it would be wise to spend less time concerned with the questionable merit of halter tops or droopy pantaloons and appreciate the fact that the defendants have appeared as required by law, turned off their cellphones so as to avoid disruption and kept their hands to their sides.

Yes, the Bronx is where court-friendly fashion goes to die.  But if that’s the only thing that dies in the Bronx, we’re way ahead of the game.  No disrespect intended.

Living a Life of Splendor

Throughout the Bernie Madoff fiasco, little made much sense.  Ike Sorkin’s strategy of an open plea to an information.  Denny Chin’s 150 year sentence. The government’s forfeiture stipulation with Ruth allowing her to keep $2.5 million.  Finally, somebody has decided to do something inside the box, and it’s about time.  The WSJ Law Blog reports that Irv Picard, trustee of the BLMIS, Bernie’s biz, wants Ruth’s dowry back.



For decades, Mrs. Madoff lived a life of splendor using the money of BLMIS’s customers. Regardless of whether or not Mrs. Madoff knew of the fraud her husband perpetrated at BLMIS, during the past two- and six-year statutory periods, she received tens of millions of dollars from BLMIS for which BLMIS received no corresponding benefit or value and to which Mrs. Madoff had no good faith basis to believe she was entitled. The purpose of this action is to recover that money to the extent possible for the benefit of BLMIS and its defrauded customers.
If one believes that Ruth had no clue that hubby Bernie was scamming the hell out of his customers, then she bears no moral or legal culpability for his actions.  A stretch, but speculation as to the quality of their pillow talk is none of my business.  But that has no bearing on whether Ruth gets to keep the loot. 

I can appreciate, as can any right-thinking person, how difficult this has been for Ruth.  Suffering the humiliation of falling from grace, not to mention losing her American Express Black Card and replacing it with a Wal-Mart Master Card.  Seriously, she was left with only a pittance to survive.

Now $2.5 million in the bank, for most people, would be considered a respectable nest egg.  Enough to do a dinner at Sonic plus a movie once a week.  Enough to buy a new car every three years, if only a Corolla.  But enough to survive if she was careful.  And cut coupons.  For most, this is doable, even normal and expected.  But these would require choices and skills that are unfamiliar in Ruth’s world.  It’s not her fault.  Bernie’s take home pay was very healthy, and when your sugar daddy brings in the big bucks, you’re allowed to live a decent life.

But a Life of Splendor?  Sure.  Why not?  If you’ve got the wherewithal, enjoy your life to the fullest.  As far as you know, it’s your money, your life, and you get to live it any old way you please.  Sorry for the anrachosyndicalists in the neighborhood, but rich people get to live like rich people.  It’s not a crime.  Unless it was a crime, which changes things.

Picard, whose job it is to recapture as much of the money that went through Bernie’s hands as possible and then dole it out to the victims of his fraud, has the duty of trying to get his hands on the money the government inexplicably decided to leave to Ruth.  That’s his obligation, and he’s absolutely right to fulfill his obligations with zeal.  He owes Ruth no sympathy, and she isn’t exactly a sympathetic person in the scheme of who’s been hurt here.

However, there’s no reason to attack Ruth’s lifestyle in the process, or to vilify her for having done what every red-blooded filthy rich American wife would do under the same circumstances.   Picard doesn’t need to justify doing his job by literally adding insult to injury.   Irv doesn’t need to win a public relations battle over his efforts to impoverish Ruth Madoff; there’s no one coming to her defense.

And is it wrong to leave Ruth broke?  No.  Not because she enjoyed the benefits of the good life, a life to which she was seemingly entitled given the zeros in the family bank account.  This is America.  People are allowed to be wealth and enjoy a Life of Splendor.  It’s what the rest of us strive to achieve.  Well, maybe not exactly a life of splendor, but the ability to afford to do as we please.  To denigrate someone for enjoying the life which she can afford is to suggest that there’s evil in financial success.  It is not evil.  It’s the American way.

Ruth Madoff will learn to survive, just as the other 99.9% of Americans do.  She will carefully follow the health care debate (health care is very important as one ages), and since she won’t be dining at the best restaurants frequently or attending charity Galas every Friday night, her clothing needs will be modest.

On the other hand, it’s unlikely that she will be eating cat food to survive.  If she finds herself falling short at the supermarket check-out counter, she can always ask one of her sons for a loan.  They still have a few bucks socked away.

The Sound of a Twit in an Empty Room

When I received the email this morning from my buddy, the TV news talking guy, it was clearly not to be.  He asked me to do color commentary on Ben Brafman’s strategy of putting Plaxico Burress into the grand jury to testify.  He needed some background about what it all meant, the rules, the crime, the sentence.  That was easy enough, but I was just too busy to go on air.

I called a friend of mine to ask him if he wanted to do it, but he was out of the office.  Either he was too busy or he’s not taking my calls anymore.  Either way, he wasn’t going to work.

So I decided to try an experiment.  I twitted.


Any Manhattan criminal defense lawyer want to do commentary on Plaxico Burress grand jury testimony today? DM me.
Hear that?  Shhh.  Listen closely.  That, dear readers, is the sound of silence.  No response.  Nothing.  Dead, perfect silence.

Now this would have been a pretty easy gig, it being a CPW3 and there being absolutely no defense on the facts.  Sure, there was a Heller implication, but that wasn’t on the table today.  So here is an opportunity for someone to get themselves on a network in New York City to talk about Plax.  Yet not a single response.

This caused me to take a look at my followers, who at this moment in time number 573 after twitter’s vetting of spammers the other day.  What did I see?

One wants me to look at her XXX pictures.  Another has cheap airfares.  A third tells me he’s a rainmaker of some sort, who follows twice as many people as follow him. A few people who have something to do with SEO.  Then there are some who look to be lawyers.

Who are you people?  Why have you followed me?  I have almost 600 people following me, and how many could care less about what I have to twit.  Not a soul there who cares a whit about what I was twitting.  It went to the girl with the XXX photos.  The rainmaker guy.  Do they want to read my twits?  I don’t think they do.  I don’t think they follow me because they are interested in the same things as me.  I think they want something from me.  What could it be?

Whenever there’s a challenge to the efficacy of twitter, people post comments about community building, networking, and other meaningless marketing jargon and concepts artfully designed to sound as if it’s important and substantial.  It’s so routine that I would expect the response to be straight out of Bangalore, all prepackaged and none bearing a resemblance to the use of English with which I’m familiar. 

I am fully prepared to accept that twitter is working just great for all these business folks who have thousands of people dying to learn about their latest adventure in sales.  It sounds remarkably like a commercial to me, and I’ve never been fond of commercials, so I don’t follow them.  But I assume it must work for someone, or all these people wouldn’t be so excited about it.  They must be thought leaders, which makes me thought leaderless.

So if there are almost 600 people in my room, but not one interested in what I’m twitting, then why am I doing this?  And who are these people taking up space in my twitter room, giving me the impression that they want to read my twits when they aren’t really interested in me at all? 

It seems that there might be a few lawyers, most likely within my particular niche, who would think that I might be a good person to follow.  Maybe they do, and there’s no room for them with all the women with XXX pictures of themselves crowding the door.  Maybe they got tired of the crowds and all left and followed someone more important than me.  Maybe they aren’t really on twitter at all.

But not one person responded to my twit about the Plax commentary.  Not one lawyer made a peep.  In fairness, I checked the woman with the XXX pictures to show me.  You never know.  She could have a strong interest in criminal law.

Membership In A Club You Didn’t Join

The economic opportunity on the internet, while still evolving, has one significant flaw.  There is a very low barrier for entry.  That means that almost anyone can start up a business online and make a go of it.  While this can present a vast opportunity for scammers and thieves, it similarly presents a bit of a problem for lawyers.

Almost daily, I receive an email about some new lawyer search website, spamming me about how it’s the Number 1 website to promote my practice.  Lately, the spam has come as emails thanking me for joining their Number 1 website.  Except, I don’t know who they are and I most assuredly haven’t joined. 

The business model is simple.  Put together a list of lawyer names and addresses from publicly available sources, mix in a basic search function, and you too can be the Number 1 lawyer search website on the internet.  After that, it’s just a struggle for SEO supremacy and some advertisements.  Lawyers are notorious at paying for advertisements if they can be sucked into believing that they will get business, whether it’s the yellow pages or the latest scummy effort like lawyersearch.com, whose 3 emails arrived yesterday.

Who’s the genius behind this latest scam?


Why was the site founded?
The site was founded by Harvard Law School and Harvard Business School graduates who kept receiving the same requests from their friends, family, and neighbors: Do you know a good lawyer in this practice area?

But not a name to be found.  Harvard really?  Not that it matters. 

Some will remember my thoughts about USLaw.com, the scummy website the skims blog content off RSS feeds to sell advertising on its site, under the theory that if they can steal it, it must be their right.  This new lawyersearch is such garbage that they’ve listed at least one dead lawyer from my cursory inspection.  I’m fairly certain that he didn’t join from the grave.

So why should we care that these entrepreneurs are skimming our content, taking out name, capitalizing off our existence to manufacture an enterprise?  This is America, the land of opportunity.  Shouldn’t every slacker be entitled to make a cheap buck off his effort to join the many others before him with the same idea?

To the person who finds your name on the website of some scum, along with his promises and representations, whether they be free consultations, brilliance or success, you are now perpetually tainted by whatever characterizations and representations that this entrepreneur, a total stranger to you, has imposed.  For the poor reader who came upon your name through that website, it is no different than if you spoke the words yourself.  You may not bear any responsibility whatsoever for the misinformation, but you are nonetheless tainted as far as the reader is concerned.

I googled myself today, and see that I am listed on many, perhaps hundreds, of legal directories.  One might suppose that I am deeply engaging in marketing, getting my name listed wherever possible.  I’m not.  I don’t have a clue how I got there, but there I am.  Much of the information is wrong, but it’s still there. 

If nothing else, it gives the impression that I have sought to promote my availability to the public.  I don’t see voices raised to inform the public that the lawyers listed in these low-entry-barrier scams have nothing to do with them, don’t endorse them, would prefer that they disappear off the face of the internet.   Maybe I’m the only one who thinks this is a problem?

But I did not join your “club” and do not support your efforts.  I don’t care how wonderful you think you are, what an important and valuable service you believe you are offering to the public (with a mere side of self-serving profit for yourself using my name).  I am not part of your path to financial independence, and the fact that I can be easily found online, or that I have an RSS feed available to readers, does not mean that you are entitled to build your business on my coattails.

I am not a member of your club.  I do not want to be a member of your club.  Leave me out of your scam. 

And to other lawyers, consider what your inadvertent inclusion in these lawyer search websites means for your integrity and public perception.  This has grown far out of control, and every lawyer whose name shows up in these scummy websites is presented as every bit as scummy as the low-threshold entrepreneur.  Is that who you want to be?  Think about it.

The Judge Who Almost Was

Imagine, if you will, the judge taking the bench in the hushed, wood-paneled courtroom, and suddenly the room bursts out, NORM!    

Even writing these words, a smile comes across my face.  Not only for the pleasant memory of my favorite part of Cheers, but the idea that a judge might sit on the federal bench, less concerned with the solemnity of his reception than with the product of his efforts, would really be something.

Alas, it’s just a dream.

For a brief, shining moment, the possibility was out there that Norm Pattis might be appointed a United States District Court Judge.  I was honored to be amongst the friends he called when the opportunity was first posed.  His question was simple: Is this nuts?  The answer seemed clear.  Of course it is, but how can you say no?

We are offered only so many opportunities to do something meaningful in life.  To pass them up is to waste them.  It’s wrong to squander such opportunities.  They are precious.

One such opportunity is to write a blawg, to possibly change a few minds, or let some folks know that they aren’t alone in their thinking.  Another is to walk into court with the accused and bang one’s head against the wall, day after day, in the hope that every once in a while the right thing will happen.  And then there is the chance to sit on the big bench and be the decisionmaker, the person who can, with the wave of a hand, stroke of a pen, utterance of a word, make justice happen.  How can you say no to that possibility?

When the opportunity was dangled in front of Norm, he reacted as any sane person would.  With grave reluctance.  Sure, the opportunity was overwhelming.  But he wasn’t the sort of guy who had himself fitted for a black robe at 29, just in case.  He had dreams of power and prominence.  The thought of sitting outside on a beautiful day reading a book brought him fulfillment. 

But what about the dark side?  Norm Pattis made a career out of speaking his mind, telling the truth as he saw it, and never pulling a punch.  I flatter myself to think that I follow in his footsteps.  He made enemies.  That happens when one doesn’t sugar coat the truth, or keep one’s friends out of bounds.  Even friends could be the target of Norm’s barbs, and if they were real friends, they understood and shot a barb or two back at him, to be followed by a beer and a laugh.  But some couldn’t take it, and cried about how mean Norm could be.  Yes, Norm made some enemies.

To become a federal judge, one needs to garner the support of the state’s federal politicians, particularly the senior senator.  That’s who whispers in the President’s ear and says, “do me a favor and appoint my buddy here.”  The minimum qualification for being the beneficiary of such a whisper is to not make too many enemies. 

After a while, Norm heard back from the powerful fellow in his state, a fellow I might add whose mealiness knows no bounds.  His very voice makes me twitch, I find it so grating.  Yet, the people of Connecticut elected him, proving that they spend far too much time drinking gin and chatting with Muffy than checking their pants to be sure they’re still there.


It all came crashing down on me the other day. I am told that I will not enjoy the support of the Senator who matters in these things. And my congresswoman won’t extend a hand either. I am dead in the water, it seems, despite the good wishes from folks in New York.

I am not surprised, even if rejection hurts. I’ve thrown so many stones in my life it was hard to believe that some would not boomerang and come hurtling back at me. So in the trenches I remain, free to speak my mind and do as I please. Things could be worse.
I can’t say I’m surprised either.  Norm didn’t fit the mold.  Nobody who one would really want to sit on the bench fits the mold.  But only those who do will get the support of important senators.  That’s the way it works.  If guys like Norm, or maybe even like me, had aspirations of greatness, we would have to sit in silence and bite our tongue.  There is no way we could speak or write openly and honestly without making enemies. 

Norm made his choice.  He will suffer for it.  As will the rest of us.

Neither Had the Sense

Antonio Love lacked the sense of hearing.  Mobile, Alabama, police just lacked sense.  Guess what happened?

Via Turley, from the Alabama Press-Register :


Mobile police used pepper spray and a Taser on a deaf and mentally disabled man Friday after they were unable to get him to come out of a bathroom at a Dollar General store, authorities said.

After forcibly removing Antonio Love from the bathroom of the Azalea Road store, officers attempted to book the 37-year-old, on charges of resisting arrest, disorderly conduct and failure to obey a police officer, but the magistrate on duty at the jail refused to accept any of those charges.

Love was both deaf and mentally disabled, with the intellectual capacity of a 10 year old.  After remaining in the rest room of the dollar store, it’s understandable that employees had some concern.  So where is the dividing line between reasonable cause for concern and the use of taser and pepper spray?  And then there’s always the resort to arrest and charges to cover up and justify their use of force.


Use of the Taser and the pepper spray appear to be justified according to the department’s policy, he [Christopher Levy, a Police Department spokesman] said.

This line, which almost invariably appears in every media account following the inappropriate use of force, often goes unnoticed, but is possibly the most troubling of all.  Why should the police department’s “policy” trump the law, the Constitution, the rights of citizens to exist without being harmed by police resort to force whenever it suits them?  The answer, it appears, is that its a necessary component of the public relations efforts of law enforcement to instill a belief in the public that they are entitled to do so.  It’s their policy.  And if it’s their policy, it must be proper.  After all, if it was improper, it couldn’t be their policy, could it?

The most dangerous sense to live without when confronted by police if the ability to hear.  When someone appears to ignore a command by a police officer, it tantamount to a facial challenge to their authority,   Nothing raises fear and ire more than the refusal to succumb to their authority.  Whether one prefers to all it deference, obedience, obsequiousness, it’s all the same to a cop.  You’ve been given an order. You’ve failed to comply (often, fast enough).  You deserve whatever follows.

It’s one thing to argue that someone of great intelligence, not to mention hubris, made the active choice to assert his rights, challenge conduct by an officer that was unlawful, or at least unjustified, and risk the consequences.  But there are many people in our society who make no such decision.  They simply can’t hear.  They cannot hear the command, and cannot obey what they cannot hear.  There is no moral wrong, even in the minds of the most blind adherent of police obedience, for a deaf person to be deaf.  Or is there?

To this end, I note some of the more challenging comments from Jonathon Turley’s post about Antonio Love.  First this :


If someone is disabled to that degree, then may be they should not be let out by themselves. How do the police know the individual in that bathroom is not dangerous? Newsfalsh: Police is not an expert in diagnosis on the spot.

Then these two :


I guess it is probably easy to judge others from comfort and safety of your place. I am not an LEO, I just hate people who feel entitled and are abusive towards the society. The handicapped man has been failed by his family and society, otherwise he would have been kept under supervision. Being drunk, drugged, or mentally ill, is not a carte blanche to inflict abuse on society or LEs. LEOs have to ensure their own safety first, when confronted with potentially dangerous situations. There is no way of telling what the “suspect” in the bathroom might have done beforehand. Monday morning quarterbacking anyone?

and


Freedom is not absolute and entails certain responsibilities, whether it is freedom of expression, moving around, etc. In this case, the guy disrupted a business establishment, and caused concern, if not fear in employees, and possibly the patrons in that establishment by his “freedom to move”. Freedom of moving about does not equal occupying the facilities of a restaurant for that length of time. Staying one hour in a public bathroom does raise legitimate concern about possible suspicious activity and public safety.

And finally this :



NPO, thank you for making a valid point. That man may have been engaged in any number of dangerous activities inside that restroom. It’s people like you who should be running things around here, and making the country a safer, and more hospitable place for true Americans.

God Bless You, friend …
As these comments demonstrate, the ability to rationalize the use of force by police, even at the expense of someone who is wholly blameless for his having refused to comply, seems utterly boundless.  This forces me to ask, what is a deaf person, or for that matter, a blind person, a mentally disabled person, to do?  It’s fine to assert that the police were merely wrong and this incident should never have happened, but unlike a Henry Gates who had a choice in how his interaction with Sgt. Jim Crowley came down, Antonio Love made no decision to take a chance. 

This is hardly the first time a cop used unnecessary and inappropriate force on a deaf person, and it surely won’t be the last.  As the case of Christopher Ferrell in Fort Worth showed, even the effort on the part of a deaf man to inform the police of his disability by taking a card out of his pocket that explained he was deaf can be the impetus for harm.  There doesn’t appear to be much of a viable way to address the conflict of demanding cop and disabled citizen that results in safety and sanity.

One of the most distressing aspects is that promoted by Turley’s commenter, that a disabled person has no business being out in public, enjoying as much of life as he is capable.  Others, in reaction to the Ferrell case, were ready to brand him with the scarlet letter, for his own good.  It would appear that too many people are willing to either limit the rights of others to enjoy the rights and privileges of citizens of this country, or stigmatize them for convenience.  And these include the well-intended folks, only trying to help.

This reaction stems from the belief that there is no stopping police from the knee-jerk resort to force at the slightest provocation, or the perception that force would relieve the officer of any potential risk or complete his mission with the least possible effort.  Shifting the onus to citizens to accommodate police “policy” is not merely enabling, a giant leap down a slippery slope, but the perpetuation of the problem for citizens generally, and the disabled in particular.  The solution is to stop the wrong, not blame the victim.

Don’t blame Antonio Love for being deaf and mentally disabled.  Don’t blame his family for letting him out in public.  Blame the men who employed force when they could have employed reason.  If only Love was a Harvard professor and friend of Obama, perhaps the many inquiring minds of this nation would put in the effort make this a teaching moment.  Antonio Love deserves no less than Henry Gates.

Like It Or Not, These Are Your Rights

Radley Balko presents this find by Andrew Sullivan, from a 1990 decision by 9th Circuit Judge Alex Kozinski.  Sullivan repeated it. Balko repeated it.  I repeat it too. 


Defendant relies heavily on the fact that Duran was making obscene gestures toward him and yelling profanities in Spanish while traveling along a rural Arizona highway. We cannot, of course, condone Duran’s conduct; it was boorish, crass and, initially at least, unjustified. Our hard-working law enforcement officers surely deserve better treatment from members of the public. But disgraceful as Duran’s behavior may have been, it was not illegal; criticism of the police is not a crime.


[T]he First Amendment protects a significant amount of verbal criticism and challenge directed at police officers…


The freedom of individuals to oppose or challenge police action verbally without thereby risking arrest is one important characteristic by which we distinguish ourselves from a police state…


Thus, while police, no less than anyone else, may resent having obscene words and gestures directed at them, they may not exercise the awesome power at their disposal to punish individuals for conduct that is not merely lawful, but protected by the First Amendment.


Inarticulate and crude as Duran’s conduct may have been, it represented an expression of disapproval toward a police officer with whom he had just had a run-in. As such, it fell squarely within the protective umbrella of the First Amendment and any action to punish or deter such speech–such as stopping or hassling the speaker–is categorically prohibited by the Constitution…


No matter how peculiar, abrasive, unruly or distasteful a person’s conduct may be, it cannot justify a police stop unless it suggests that some specific crime has been, or is about to be, committed, or that there is an imminent danger to persons or property.


Some people possessed of less than thoughtful rightwing political ideology think this is some silly liberal construct.  Others suggest, as Lou Dobbs did last night, that we have elevated the rights of jerks at the expense of the rights of our police, who are there to protect and serve us. 

But this is no liberal plot, as Judge Kozinksi has yet to make it to any of the clubhouse meetings, and wouldn’t get in anyway since he doesn’t know the secret handshake.  Dobbs, whose stint on CNN only makes sense in light of the fact that Rick Sanchez is on the air, is confused as always.  And citizens retain those rights they have not given up to the government.

This cannot be made clear enough: Hurting a police officer feelings by saying mean things to him, being uncooperative, even belligerent, making obscene gestures, berating the officer, even dressing his mother in imaginary army boots, is not a crime.  It’s not necessarily the smartest thing to do, but it is not a crime.  It’s not.  No, it’s not.  It’s just not a crime.

And you officers reading this (and I know you do), suck it up. 

Pride or Revenue

There once was a day when Martindale-Hubbell was the undisputed king of resources when it comes to getting the low-down on lawyers.  They sold books.  Big brown books.  Really big, and a lot of them.  Big firms would buy the complete set every year.  Small firms would sneak into the libraries to read the books big firms had, or better still take the books from the year before that big firms tossed out and make it look like they were rich enough to buy the full set.

But M-H was the rock of Gibraltar.  That was when people used books.  As books fell out of favor, so too did Martindale-Hubbell’s very substantial revenue stream.  Still, M-H had one thing that no one else could offer.  The rating. 

The rating consisted of two parts.  The first, the general ethical rating, was reflected in the letter “V”, for “very high.”  If you didn’t get a “V”, you didn’t move forward.  There was no other rating than “V”.

The second part reflected ability:

Legal Ability Ratings are:
C – Good to High
B – High to Very High
A – Very High to Preeminent

Getting a CV rating is tantamount to saying that you’re ethical but incompetent.  A BV was an embarrassment.  An AV rating was expected of any half-way competent lawyer.  It may not have assumed skill, but it reflected what was purported to be a peer-reviewed assessment of your lack of incompetence.

Whether the ratings were legitimate is subject to dispute, but they were certainly perceived as legit, and that’s all the really matters.  It was this perception that made M-H matter; any fool could list a bunch of lawyers, but nobody else could offer a peer rating that would be accepted throughout the profession as the minimum standard of competence.

When one obtained an AV rating, it would appear next to your name in the big brown books that M-H sold to big law firms.  The books contained the name of every lawyer in the country, together with basic biographical information, even if the lawyer didn’t pay for a nice firm “biography” in the white pages, the M-H version of an advertisement for lawyers who would never consider such a thing.  If you were rated, it was in there.

Now M-H runs a website called lawyers.com.  It’s a great url, since it has all the right words.  On that website, M-H lists all the lawyers it knows about or cares to include.  I’ve found some who should be there but aren’t, and I assume that M-H has gotten lax in its standards.

When you search for a lawyer on lawyers.com, you may or may not find out that the lawyer is rated.  The absence of a rating on lawyers.com doesn’t mean that the lawyer doesn’t have a rating, but rather that the lawyer hasn’t paid $59 to M-H to have her rating posted next to her name.  It’s safe to say that it doesn’t cost M-H $59 to add the rating to the name, so I’m constrained to assume that it’s a mechanism for increasing revenue.

Martindale-Hubbell has put its ratings up for sale.  Perhaps not to obtain a rating, though I once pushed a M-H salesman into giving an associate an AV rating when all he had was a BV if he wanted me to consider paying to be in the Bar Register of Preeminent Lawyers (as if most criminal defendants cracked it open in search of counsel), but to make it matter.  If no one knows you have an AV rating, then you effectively don’t.

Old time lawyers take a small amount of pride in their AV rating.  When we served as “peers” to review others, we took it seriously and tried to be as honest as possible, even to the point of being fair to people we despised.  A rating wasn’t nearly as meaningful as being able to win a case, but it beat the crap out of having a BV, or (God forbid) a CV, next to your name.  We thought of the ratings as a something above and beyond a commodity.  While M-H managed it, the rating came from us, fellow lawyers. 

Kevin O’Keefe and Brian Tannebaum have been pounding the twittersphere over the last few days about how M-H is trying to grab $59 out of the pockets of lawyers, holding their ratings hostage.  Not too much interest in the subject around the twittersphere.  I suspect that’s because there isn’t too much interest in M-H ratings anymore. Who cares about AV when your website can proclaim you the bestest, most empathetic lawyer in the world.  An AV rating pales in comparison.

I won’t pay M-H it’s $59 tare to have the two letters placed next to my name.  I am, for better or worse, AV rated, and have been for many years.  It has not, to my knowledge, persuaded any client to retain me or any judge to rule in my favor.  It’s just something that had always been there, always been mine, since the day it was conferred.

Today, M-H wants to pay to buy it back.  No sale.  And I threw all the second hand books out years ago, when I turned off the lights and shut the library doors for the last time.

Are We Not Lawyers? (Update)

One by one, the dominoes fell.  First state courts.  Then the outlier districts, and the Eastern District.  Until there was but one.  That’s right, there is now only one courthouse in New York where a lawyer not on the public dole is treated as so scurrilous, so dangerous, so unworthy, that she cannot be trusted.  It’s the Southern District of New York.  The mother ship.

When I first raised my right hand and stated in a stentorian voice, “I, state you name, do hereby . . .,” there were no cards issued by any government entity to prove to others that you were, indeed, a lawyer.  It was sufficient that you said so, and no one thought to challenge the assertion.  Perhaps it was because no one would claim to be a lawyer unless it was true, but that’s how it was.

Then came the New York City Corrections Department ID card, which included a photograph of our taking on a card that would embarrass a Times Square cubbyhole owner.  It was so amateurish that it would cause uproarious laughter today.  Soon, the Office of Court Administration picked up the gauntlet and issued ID cards of its own, which Corrections spitefully refused to recognize as official given its preference for its own in the turf war.

Lawyers were required to provide their bar numbers.  We didn’t even know we had bar numbers.

It’s hard to remember whether this happened over weeks, years or decades, but there was a point where the court system decided that lawyers, like our clients, would have to pass through the magnetometers, empty our pockets, take off our belts and cufflinks, to gain entrance to the trenches.  That lasted only a brief period, until Dick Barbuto, then President of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and now the Blind Guy, sent a letter to the Office of Court Administration advising them that we would not be treated like the scum of the profession, with ADAs given red carpet treatment while we were forced to do the perp walk.  OCA back down immediately.

Then came the Secure Pass.  What made this special was a cool name and the ability to charge lawyers for the pleasure of having an identification card that told the world they had no felony convictions.  It had holograms, and secret hidden stuff that only showed under the glow of black lights.  Lawyers were now truly official, as few cubbyholes in Times Square could reproduce a card this secure.  Not that anyone would want to.

The secure pass was touted for its, well, security.  It’s highly professional appearance.  It’s many security features.  It was very official. Accordingly, it was accepted everywhere I went, courthouses around the country.  I was treated with the same respect shown attorneys everywhere, for better or worse.  But no one questioned whether I was an attorney.

Except in the Southern District of New York.

One courthouse.  Just one courthouse.  Entering through the magnetometer portal, emptying pockets (thought thankfully being allowed to keep one’s Guccis on one’s feet) remained de rigor at the federal courthouses, lest we bear a slight resemblance to swarthy Mediterranean looking fellows.  It would be too much to expect criminal defense lawyers to be treated like AUSA, who strolled through with a flash of their government issued IDs, not missing a beat.  But this was a minor indignity that will likely remain intact forever. 

There is one thing that happens in the Southern District of New York that happens in no other courthouse:  They refuse to allow attorneys to enter with a cellphone.  Or a crackberry.  Or laptop.  Or any of the computering-communicating type devices that have become as essential to the practice of law as breathing.

There are a laundry list of reasons for this.  Security.  Disturbance.  Just to remind us who’s boss.  The message is clear.  We cannot be trusted to enter a courthouse with our devices hanging from our belt without causing trouble.  It is better to strip away the accouterments of modern society than risk a rogue lawyer on a cellphone.

To its credit, the NYSACDL actually wrote a letter to Judge Paul Crotty arguing for an end to this embargo.  The letter may be tepid and obvious, but it’s the first thing done that might actually improve the lot of criminal defense lawyers in years.  This could be the start of a trend.

Will it work?  Will the Southern District of New York, like its fellow districts, accept us as responsible lawyers, capable of making our way through a courthouse without wreaking crackberry havoc?  Or will the future end at the doorway at 500 Pearl Street?

You can trust us.  We’re lawyers.  We have cards to prove it.

Update:  Per the NYSACDL twit, it’s been announced that Donna Newman will testify at the hearing on 7/29.  I expect all 12 followers will be ecstatic to learn this, and I wish Donna best of luck.  This would be a really good time for Donna to speak out loud and clear, and put aside the fear and equivocation that might control the more squeamish on the board.  And I hope it pans out to be accurate that criminal defense lawyers are heard hearing.  The fact that the NYSACDL wasn’t involved from the outset was a disgrace.  Now that it found its way to the table (assuming it actually happens), make it mean something.