Author Archives: SHG

Total Disaster

Not that I’ve got anything personally against the enterprise known as Total Attorneys, which has somehow positioned itself as the future of success for the Slackoisie.  This would be the company that hosted the Get A Life Conference, where twinkie lawyers more concerned with playtime than competence could go to learn the secrets of success without effort.

And then there is the self-proclaimed Slackoisie guru, Ed Scanlon, ushering in his new version of the perfect society.  The sky is falling change is coming, we’re told.  Apparently, it’s far more true than they realized, but not exactly the way they hoped.

The Connecticut Law Tribune has a headline story that the Slackoisie freight train is heading for a crash, and Total Attorneys President Kevin Chern is at the wheel.  [Since the Ct Law Trib is a pay for view site, and few have access, here’s another post about the story that is readily accessible.]

You’re a lawyer. You receive a telephone call from a for-profit company offering to feed you clients who visit the company’s web site seeking legal help. In exchange, you pay a fee for every consumer who contacts you. The company markets itself as a lawyer advertising site and claims the fee is used to cover operational costs and support services. But disciplinary officials, in Connecticut at least, think the agreement might be an example of paying for referrals, which is a felony offense in the state. The question of what constitutes ethical and legal Internet advertising of attorney services is back in the spotlight after local grievance panels recently found probable cause against two Connecticut attorneys who entered into business agreements with a Chicago-based company.

Shocking that the promoters of easy legal living didn’t notice the ethical line they toed, isn’t it?  Frankly, there’s nothing surprising about it.  This is a business whose model depends on the ongoing conscious avoidance of its adherents of the rules of the game.  They care for the cash, and happily turn a blind eye to the ethical responsibilities of what used to be a respected profession.  Why let old school concepts, like ethics and competence, stand in the way of Web 2.0 thinking: Grab as much as you can from any place you can and then Party, Party, Party!

Critical to the cash and party mindset is the use of online marketing to replace the grind of having to earn one’s clientèle through hard work, excellent client representation and experience gained in the trenches.  That’s old-man stuff.  New kid stuff is pay a guru for a magic bullet and come out of the box on day one making a million off the internet, whether it’s twitter, blogging, facebook, whatever.  Why go through all that hard work that grumpy old Mr. Wilson demands when you can get it all overnight?

Since posting about Ed Scanlon, whose screed about the brave new world of the Slackoisie workplace was possibly the most laughably ridiculous thing to come out of the Slackoisie since Alexis Neely proclaimed that “I feel this is a gift from God and to do anything less than [be a consultant] would be doing a disservice to the world.”   [Side Note: Alexis thinks I’m an old meany who’s picking on her.  I’m really not.  It’s just that she’s set herself up as a prime example of twinkiehood by placing herself on a pedestal, thus becoming an excellent example of what’s gone so very wrong for the Slackoisie. The downside to creating a high profile for oneself is to be called on it from time to time.]

Following the Scanlon screed, allegations of rampant misconduct at Total Attorneys started coming in.  One, alleging conduct that was not merely unethical but criminal, was posted as a comment.  As the commenter used only a first name, and the allegations were most serious, I removed the post.  I have no intention of concealing misconduct for Total Attorneys or anyone else, but I similarly expect that anyone who wants to raise criminal allegations against an enterprise be willing to stand behind them. 

I’ve also received various emails from people who claim to be former employees (and I have no reason to doubt them, since I don’t think anyone cares all that much about Total Attorneys to fabricate such a claim) raising allegations about their business practices, suggesting that they are no more honest, ethical or legitimate internally than externally.  Once again, these will not hit the surface until someone is willing to put their name to the allegations publicly.  But there is clearly a very serious groundswell of antagonism toward Total Attorneys.

Some  around the blawgosphere keep insisting that this is the future, that it’s all going to change and curmudgeons like me can either hop on board the freight train or be left behind.  While I agree that some changes have and will continue to come, they are the changes that enhance our ability to deliver better client representation, not the changes that allow quick-buck-artists and scammers to sell magic bullets and work/life balance to the entitled Slackoisie. 

There’s trouble ahead for that freight train, and perhaps those who have foolishly jumped on board would do well to get off before it crashes.

A Vicious Libel and a Favor

A few days ago, I received an email from the president of a corporation that was mentioned in one of my posts.  It wasn’t a corporation that I admired, but being a capitalist, I don’t begrudge business that cater to the foolish their opportunity separate them from their money.

The president emailed me because a commenter made some very serious, even criminal allegations against the business.  His purpose was to ask for a favor, if I would pull the comment.  This was how he approached the request:


Scott, I have had only minor interaction with you and you have always been cordial.  I understand your methodology of using controversial content to attract readership, and even though I do not always necessarily agree with your tactics (especially when they are directed at my close friend and business partner), I appreciate your right to exercise your free speech and contribute to the conversation.  That being said, I am not sure what credibility you add to your argument about the Slackoisie manifesto by posting an irrelevant comment  from an anonymous poster whose comments are unverified and quite frankly not true.
I found the second sentence fascinating.   My “methodology” was to court controversy to attract readership.  Who knew?  I had long maintained that my methodology was to amuse myself, make the occasional point, and engage in the ongoing conversation of the blawgosphere. 

Frankly, I was not amused.  It was painfully obvious that this president imputed his motivations onto me.  It doesn’t change my purposes, but revealed him to be arrogant fool.  Just because he can’t conceive of a purpose beyond collecting eyeballs doesn’t mean that I share his motives.  Ironically,  his secondary assumption, that my post involving his business would attract readers, is itself incredibly arrogant.  Hey pal, not that many people care if your business exists, no less what I have to say about.  You are not the center of attention for the masses, but just a sideshow with some passing curiosity to a larger point that has nothing to do with your business.  If I was looking to attract eyeballs, I wouldn’t have bothered with you.

Bear in mind, the company he works for is not one for which I hold much respect, regardless of whether the allegations raised in the stinging comment are true or not.  I assume that the business will soon fail, as its target audience of slackoisie either go broke or grow up.

But his purpose in writing me was to ask me for a favor.  So here’s another life lesson: If you want someone to do you a favor, don’t open up with an insult.  As a corollary, if you’re a blithering idiot, don’t assume everyone else is as well. 

I responded to this email by offering the president these life lessons.  It would seem that someone who believes himself competent to serve as a president of a real business would already be aware of such things, but obviously that cannot be assumed.  Sometimes, it’s necessary to point out the obvious.
 
To his credit, the president responded with an apology.  He even offered that he hoped he could someday return the favor.  I can’t imagine what he could ever do for me, but it was a nice thing to say.

Apparently, he only needs to be spanked once to get the point.  That must be why they made him president.  Either that, or he’s the only one in the place who owns a tie and a pair of lace-up shoes.  And I removed the offending comment, not so much because he asked as because it was a particularly serious set of allegations from an unknown commenter, thus invoking the Publius Syndrome.  It should be noted that I received some emails afterward corroborating the allegations, but the senders didn’t want to disclose their identities or post their thoughts in comments, and hence received no credit for their claims.

Too often, people have attributed motive to the existence of Simple Justice by projecting their purposed onto me.  Don’t do it.  I’ve made my purpose clear, and the assumption that whatever moves you moves me won’t be appreciated.  But more importantly, if you’re going to ask me to do you a favor, do not insult me in the process.  I’ve got no butts to kiss in the blawgosphere, and I assure you that it’s far more likely that I will burn you publicly for your attack than cover your butt.

The Publius Syndrome

When Dan Hull announced that What About Clients? would become the blawgosphere’s first No-Wuss zone, refusing to allow anonymous comments, I felt the heat.  His reasons were clear and accurate, and I certainly agreed with everything he said.  He made it even more clear in  a podcast with the Bard of the Brit blawgoshere,  CharonQC (his 150th!).

Then Mark Bennett, whose Defending People is the blawgosphere’s best in criminal law, locked arms with Hull, announcing that he too would refuse anonymous comments.  The heat was turned up.

And what of Simple Justice? 

I’ve had much to say about comments in the past, having a love/hate relationship with the concept and execution.  My voice has been raised against anonymity on numerous occasions.  Given the respect I have for both Hull and Bennett, coupled with my general aversion to anonymity as an excuse to mouth off like a jackass, the prospect of adopting the No-Wuss Zone policy had great appeal.  Yet I decided not to join.  Here’s why.

Comments fall into a number of different categories.  Some are the presentment of ideas that stand or fall on their own, and the speaker’s identity neither adds nor detracts from the value of the idea.  These constitute a relatively small segment of the comments, as few true concepts are presented that are not dependent on a value judgment (or normative, as the lawprofs love to say)  which is meaningless without knowing who is doing the talking.  Is the commenter a lawyer?  What type of law does she practice?  How much experience does she have?  What axes does the commenter have to grind?  The list goes on. 

Some argue that these things shouldn’t matter, and they are correct when the comment is limited to a stand-alone idea, but absolutely wrong then the comment is value laden.  The value of a commenter’s opinion can only be judged in context.  A comment along the lines of “Justice Scalia is an idiot” means nothing in itself.  No one, especially me, gives a hoot what some unknown commenter thinks about Scalia.  It’s a totally worthless comment and a waste of my bandwidth.  You have no right to waste my bandwidth.

Of course, commenters who might appear anonymous to others might be well known to me.  I have access, as the blog owner, to information that you, as the reader, do not.  Sometimes, I have someone posting a comment under an anonymous name but, knowing the true identity, I recognize to be significant.  While I won’t out the commenter, I will allow the comment and even engage the person. 

In contrast, there are commenters, and a lot of them, who are anonymous to me as well as you, but who inexplicably think that their opinions are monumentally important.  They believe that they are endowed with the inalienable right to spew their beliefs, or challenge mine, in the comments.  This is the Publius Syndrome, where they liken themselves to Madison’s pseudonymous writings.  As my friends Hull and Bennett have both pointed out, they ain’t Publius.

Forget about Madison’s need to anonymity, and their lack thereof.  These self-proclaimed pundits have an overly developed sense of self-importance, of entitlement.  Without benefit of context, or the guts to show themselves, they nonetheless demand, and often in a highly aggressive manner, attention.  These are the primary targets of the no-wuss problem.  Too gutless to stand behind their assertions, yet bold enough to spew over and over, and in the boldest of language.

Odder still, these would-be Publius’ harbor the bizarre expectation that because they throw down the gauntlet, I must pick it up.  They demand debate.  They scream for my attention.  When they don’t get it, they spew about my worthlessness for failing to do as they want. 

Here’s the deal, Pub.  You’re spewing isn’t all that fascinating to me, though I realize that you think you’re brilliant.  Sometimes I will make a joke about it, just to have a little fun.  This enrages you because I’ve not taken you seriously.  You are very serious to yourself.  Sorry, but you’re just not serious to me.  More often than not, you’ve said things that have been said a thousand times before, and just because you are self-obsessed doesn’t mean that I am required to explain why you’re a blithering idiot like the 999 people who came before you.

Other times, I will point out that Publius’ comment is valueless because of its anonymity, whereas it might be of some worth had Publius been tough enough to put his name to his spew.  In response, Pub will inform me that he’s hardly anonymous, but a well known quantity elsewhere.  This happens a lot when SJ gets link love from a political blog, and sends its readers over.  The whole anonymity thing is way bigger amongst the political crowd, where substance is often irrelevant to vapid anger. 

But here, Pub, you are anonymous.  That includes people who use their first name, or even first name and initial.  If your identity isn’t clear on the surface, then anonymous you are.  Obviously, it includes people who use cute names, pompous names, even initials. 

I have no plans to research who you are and painstakingly read your past comments elsewhere so that I can be overwhelmed with your long history of spewing.  When you show up here, you start anew.  I have no plans to spend my time worrying about who you are, and if you can’t manage to stand behind your spewing, I certainly won’t enable you.  If I don’t already know who you are, I have no interest in figuring it out.  That’s your responsibility.

There is another issue deriving from anonymity that falls into a more troubling category, that of the whistleblower.  Some commenters will post some very nasty allegations or information about the subject of a post.  These may very well be true, or they may just reflect the commenters anger toward a subject and an opportunity to vent.  If you want to malign someone here, that’s fine.  But then, you really must identify yourself if you want to be taken seriously or want to assure that your comment isn’t deleted.  Some are too harmful or malicious to be allowed to stand, even though I may have no liability for the content, when posed anonymously.  I understand why you want to be anonymous, but that’s the price for attacking someone.  If you want credibility, then you must pay the price.

Despite the pressure felt from Hull and Bennett, I’ve decided not to adopt the No-Wuss policy.  To the extent that anonymous comments offer some substance despite the lack of context, I accept them for what they are worth.  Most are discounted to the extent the ideas don’t stand on their own.  What does anyone care if you prefer vanilla to chocolate?  It tends to prove one thing, that the commenter is a jerk of no consequence.  And it isn’t going to make anyone switch from chocolate to vanilla anyway.

But when the anon commenter posts something that is either totally foolish, malevolent or ignorant, I will delete it without a second thought.  I hate to have to break this to you, but just because you think you’re a genius doesn’t mean anyone
else agrees.

There are many commenters here who have used pseudonyms for a long time, despite lacking any particular reason for doing so.  That’s fine with me.  Your comments might mean a whole lot more if I knew who you were, had some background about you to put your thoughts into context, but that’s your choice.

As for the car-keyers of the internet, as Bennett calls them, or the Ned Beatty wannabes per Hull, I feel no compulsion to engage anyone who I view as a jerk, twinkie or worthless.  And when I delete your brilliant comment and ban you from Simple Justice, your subsequent email informing me that I am whimpering, gutless pussy for not squaring off with you man to man pains me deeply.  But I get over it.

And so, Simple Justice will allow the anonymous commenter, the wuss, those suffering from the Publius Syndrome.  But don’t expect to be taken seriously if you think you can toss handgrenades while hiding under a rock.  If you want to be given credit, then grow a set and stand behind your opinions.

When The Court Needs a Friend

Eugene Volokh has put together a series of posts on being amicus curiae, friend of the court based on the foundation of Mayer Brown’s Federal Appellate Practice book.  Having served as amicus chair for a number of years for the a criminal defense lawyer bar association, I found this to be a terribly misunderstood and poorly utilized weapon in the fight for good law. 

Every day, we’re confronted with bad caselaw.  It doesn’t happen overnight, but inch by inch.  It isn’t entirely an accident.  We could do something about it, but too often we don’t.

While the primary problem may be attributed to a judiciary lacking a meaningful concern for constitutional rights, given that many of the fine men and women who become judges are pillars of society, dedicated to elevation of order over law and firmly on the side of good in the fight against evil (or at least desirous of appearing that way), other problems can’t be blamed on the judges.  We are at fault, “we” being the voices who should be speaking out in favor of the Constitution and against bad law but instead remain mute.

There are some huge issues sitting on our doorstep that are routinely neglected.  The first is that when an appeal arises that presents a critical issue, one that extends far beyond the interests of a particular defendant but will impact defendants going forward, we watch from the sidelines hoping that the attorney handling the appeal does an adequate job and the praying that the courts come out the right way.  The problem here is that, while we may recognize that a case will produce an overarching rule that will effect us and our clients for years to come, we fail to acknowledge that we have as much at stake as does the individual defendant.  We choose to sit it out.  This is nuts.

One of the foremost uses of our specialized bar associations and interest groups is to speak for the larger group, the broader interests.  Unfortunately, many either can’t be bothered, obsess over collecting dues for self-perpetuation, or exist to give out awards to each other to pretend that we’re doing far better than we are.  They are not serving our mutual self-interest because it’s far more difficult to actually do work, exert effort, pay attention, give a damn.  Getting awards is so much more fun than working hard.  And being a selfish and self-aggrandizing sort of group, most want the kudos but few want to lift a finger to actually produce something useful.

Through amicus work, we could assert our positions, concerns, views and interests into cases of greater interest and import than the mere concerns of any individual defendant.  Counsel for the appellant all too often is an inadequate guardian of the greater interest.  Some simply aren’t good enough lawyers to be entrusted with big issues, and hence decisions come back to bite us in the butt because an appellate lawyer couldn’t manage to put a comprehensive and comprehensible argument together.  This is, I believe, the primary cause on our side of bad law.  Lawyers take cases that far exceed their skill level, and we suffer the consequences of a huge and perhaps needless loss.  We bemoan the result, but failed to lift a finger to achieve a better result.

From the courts’ perspective, it’s one thing to smack down a bad defendant who raises a significant issue, but one where the court would be very reluctant to reverse because this isn’t the sort of person they want to see walk.  When the only voice raised is the lone defendant, the court gets no sense of how the issue will impact others, often many others, who may not be such an unsympathetic appellant.  A bit outcome oriented, you say?  Judges are human.  Also, judges may not appreciate how a decision in one small, seemingly inconsequential case can become a fundamental decision that alters the course of the law for many others. 

Amicus work requires not merely the interest and will of an organized group to make the decision to become involved, but also the willingness of talented lawyers to step up to the plate and do the work.  And here’s the kicker: For Free.  Lest anyone call me disingenuous, I’ve produced dozens of amicus briefs over the years, happily and willingly.  Indeed, when I was in the position of amicus chair and couldn’t find anyone willing to step forward, I did it myself.  I never let a case that I believed to involve a significant issue fall between the cracks.  If no one else would write, then I did.  Someone had to do it.

On this aspect, some of the people who are responsible for bar association amicus work see it as a burden rather than an opportunity.  They refuse to seek out important cases, and wait for cases to come to them.  They challenge those who seek help as to why they are deserving, rather than embrace the chance to improve the law and stand up for what’s right.  It seems like their focus is to do as little amicus work as possible, rather than be there whenever they can be a positive force in the law.  This attitude toward amicus work completely misses the point; if it’s too much trouble, then the reins are in the wrong hands.

I’ve also seen lawyers who agreed to produce the brief drop the ball completely, with the submission date past and a “sorry” as their sole excuse.  On huge cases, mind you.  As an aside, these include lawyers who are long-term bar association mavens whose mouths never seem to close when it comes time to spout facile opinions, but they never seem to manage to find the time or ability to actually do anything.  Plenty of promises, spoken loudly for the whole room to applaud, and no production after the clapping dies down and the promises are forgotten. 

We have a lot of that ilk, desiring to appear to be “important” lawyers but, if one looks under the hood, having done nothing to fulfill the obligations they’ve undertaken or justify their worth.  Beware of our bar association bigshots, whose only interest is becoming very important in the eyes of lawyers who don’t know better and are impressed with official titles. 

Writing amicus briefs is, as Eugene points out, very different than representing the individual on appeal.  It’s all about the issue, not the individual.  It need not be lengthy, and often is far more meaningful and persuasive when directed solely at the critical issue at hand.  Amicus work offers the opportunity to stand back from the details of a case and argue how a decision, one way or another, will affect the state of ithe law and the functioning of society.  It speaks to right and wrong, to philosophical positions, which are often far afield from the arguments that counsel for the appellant might proffer.  Without amicus, these concerns would never be presented to the appellate court, or ineffectively presented, and other interests and arguments will prevail. 

Amicus also serves to let a court know that a case isn’t just about a particular defendant, but that the entire bar is watching them closely because of the larger issue at stake.  If nothing else, this may cause a court to give much more thought to a case, and the issues involved, then it might otherwise.  There are times when the appellant’s counsel has done excellent work, has covered the issue well, and has presented every argument needed, but st
ill would benefit from the assistance of amicus to let the court know just how important the issue at stake is to the rest of the bar. 

In my anecdotal and unscientific experience, amicus curiae briefs are submitted in a mere 20% of the cases in which they should be, leaving 80% of appeals up for grabs for one reason or another.  It is perhaps the most massive failure of the organized bar to impact the incremental growth of the law and to fulfill its mission, assuming it has any mission to fill beyond patting each other on the back. 

Between incompetent counsel, lazy, self-serving,self-important bar association “leaders”, a myopic understanding of what amicus work means and sheer lack of interest, the critical work of amicus curiae has been horribly neglected.  And we’ve got the law to prove it. 

The Associated Press Sucks Eggs

It’s war.  The AP has declared war. 


Tom Curley, The A.P.’s president and chief executive, said the company’s position was that even minimal use of a news article online required a licensing agreement with the news organization that produced it. In an interview, he specifically cited references that include a headline and a link to an article, a standard practice of search engines like Google, Bing and Yahoo, news aggregators and blogs.

Asked if that stance went further than The A.P. had gone before, he said, “That’s right.” The company envisions a campaign that goes far beyond The A.P., a nonprofit corporation. It wants the 1,400 American newspapers that own the company to join the effort and use its software.

“If someone can build multibillion-dollar businesses out of keywords, we can build multihundred-million businesses out of headlines, and we’re going to do that,” Mr. Curley said. The goal, he said, was not to have less use of the news articles, but to be paid for any use.

Screw fair use.  The hell with dissemination of information.  I wonder if Curley cleared this with the rest of the brain trust, Moe, Larry and Shemp?

The AP wants its piece of the pie, and it will no longer tolerate people like me taking so much as a headline without compensation.  But how will it know that the evil Greenfield is linking to its stories for my own evil purposes?


Each article — and, in the future, each picture and video — would go out with what The A.P. called a digital “wrapper,” data invisible to the ordinary consumer that is intended, among other things, to maximize its ranking in Internet searches. The software would also send signals back to The A.P., letting it track use of the article across the Web.
No longer will a scoundrel like me fly under the radar of newsgathering giants.  I don’t know that I will be AP Enemy Number 1, but I could be in the top 100.  Okay, maybe the top 10,000.  But I will still be an enemy, undone by the secret, hidden tracking thingies in the news.

But I have a plan to foil the AP and continue my nefarious scheme for world hegemony.  I will simply make absolutely no profit whatsoever from Simple Justice.  Hah! They can have their piece of my pie any time they want.  And they can starve from it.  Just like I do.

Give me a break.  People like me send readers to their stories, rather than the other way around.  There’s no gain in it for me.  In the event that Simple Justice becomes a multi-billion dollar business, I will re-evaluate.  Until then, bite me.

Cy Vance Plays The Stop and Frisk Numbers Game

Candidate for Manhattan District Attorney, Cy Vance, Jr., was given a platform on the Huffington Post to set out his views on dealing with racial disparities in police interactions with citizens on the street.

It is no secret that African-Americans and Latinos are stopped and frisked disproportionately by the police.

This statement, on its face, is significant.  While seemingly obvious, it is an acknowledgment that no matter how hard the rest of society tries to put racial prejudice behind us, it remains a hard, cold reality when it comes to policing.

According to the Civil Liberties Union, in 2007, the NYPD stopped about 469,000 New Yorkers, which equals about 1,300 people a day. Of these 469,000, 88 percent were not charged. African-Americans, who represent 25 percent of the City’s population, represent over 50 percent of those stopped; 30 percent of those stopped were Latino. Non-Latino Whites, who make up about 35 percent of the city’s population, only represent 11 percent of those stopped. In both 2006 and 2007 African Americans and Latinos made up over 90 percent of those stopped.

Lest anyone challenge these numbers on the basis of their being compiled by the NYCLU, it was Vance’s choice to adopt these figures in his post.  I will defer to his decision, and accept them as accurate.  They tell an appalling story, that 88% of those people subject to a stop and frisk are not charged with any wrong.  That’s a monumental number.

Consider, for a moment, what this means.  Police officers make the decision to take a person, walking down the street minding his own business, seize him (in the legal sense of preventing him from continuing on his way unimpeded) and then place their hands on his body to determine whether he has anything that would lead them to arrest him.  This could include a weapon, or drugs, or stolen property.  But whatever causes the police officers to make the decision to seize and touch a citizen, they are wrong 88% of the time.  That’s an extraordinary number of innocent, law-abiding citizens who are being denied their right to walk down the street unmolested by the police.

Who are these people being hassled by the cops?  In New York City, 90% of them are black and Hispanic.  The reason I’ve framed the story this way is to prevent those who would immediately resort to the argument that it’s because blacks and Hispanics are more likely to be criminals from taking comfort in their bias.  Since 88% of these people are not charged with any crime, there is no blame to be placed on blacks and Hispanics for just being there when a cop feels compelled to give them a toss.

Under New York law, before a police officer can lawfully stop and frisk an individual, he must have an objectively reasonable belief that the person has committed, is committing or will commit a crime.  It’s less than probable cause, which is required for arrest, and greater than a suspicion that “criminal activity is afoot,” justifying the common law right of inquiry.  A stop and frisk is a significant intrusion on the sanctity of the person.

To Vance’s credit, he acknowledges the existence of a very serious extant problem with the police, both in the fact that police are engaging in rampant constitutional violations generally, and that these violations are having a grossly disproportionate impact on blacks and Hispanics.  Of course, this does little to stop the assistants in the New York County District Attorney’s office from enabling the fabrication of constitutionally acceptable excuses for unlawful police conduct.  So much for that oath of protecting and defending the Constitution, eh?

The current means of addressing this problem is to hand out palm cards.  I wouldn’t kid you about this.  After police engage in rampant violations of constitutional rights, the problem is smoothed over for the 88% of those not charged by giving them a card.

The NYPD recently began a pilot program in three precincts in which officers give an explanatory “palm card” to those they stop and frisk. The card serves to inform suspects why they’re being stopped and of their rights.

I’m not sure what these cards say, but I doubt that they explain, “You were stopped and frisked because you are black or Hispanic, and we suspect all of you to be criminals.  Better safe than sorry.”

While Vance states that these palm cards are “a positive step in the right direction” (as opposed to a positive step in the wrong direction?), he acknowledges that they are inadequate to deal with the problem.

The Manhattan DA must work closely with the NYPD. No relationship is more important — or more complex — than the relationship between the DA’s office and the NYPD. The two offices work closely together on thousands of cases, incidents and issues every year. Yet, the DA provides a critical oversight role for the public in regard to the NYPD. The DA prosecutes NYPD officers when they go over the line — whenever they go over the line.

This is where things get a bit fuzzy for me.  Does this mean that Cy Vance plans to start prosecuting police officers for engaging in systemic violations of the constitutional rights of black and Hispanic citizens, those 88% of the 90% of all those stopped and frisked?  He states that he wants to put ADAs closer to the people, in the neighborhoods where these New Yorkers live, work, get frisked.  But is that to make them closer to the people?  Will his ADAs remain the child brigade of the Police Department, or will they be the voice of the 88% of New Yorkers whose constitutional right to be left alone is subject to the whim of any cop with an attitude?

In a courtroom, the players often find themselves dealing with a fantastic scenarios constructed for the purpose of overcoming constitutional limitations on what police are permitted to do in their efforts to stop crime.  But the only ones who make it to the courtroom are the 12% of individuals subject to stop and frisk who are charged with an offense as a result.  The other 88% simply disappear into the mist, happy to be allowed to go on their way after this baseless assault on their dignity.  The system never hears from them again.  No one is held accountable.  It’s as if it never happened.

Will Cy Vance speak for the 88%?  They too are the victims of a terrible wrong.

A Crime By Any Other Name (Non-Lawyer Edition)

GatesGate has, as anticipated, produced a great deal of conversation, most of which is productive in the sense that it has people talking about the issue of whether a person should be subject to arrest for being belligerent and disagreeable with a police officer.  In this comment, Sojourner links to a terrific New York Times article discussing the breadth of police attitude toward dealing with the angry citizen who verbalizes their disagreement.

But the discussion is inhibited by one disturbing factor: Many people have absolutely no idea what constitutes an offense, and the debates has too often involves people inventing crimes from their vague sense of what they either believe the law to be, or think the law should be.

As my posts on GatesGate have found their way into some non-lawyer political blogs over the last few days, I’ve had an opportunity to check out blogs that I had never before seen, and read some of the comments reflecting people’s understanding of the law.  Not surprisingly, they often demonstrated a fundamental lack of understanding.  It’s hard to talk about a subject when there is no shared recognition of the basics.  As comments to these blog posts show, people simply insist that being disagreeable toward a cop is a crime. 

In order to facilitate a higher level of discussion, I offer this post to help the non-lawyer better understand the subject of discussion.  A crime, whether infraction, misdemeanor or felony, is an offense created by a law enacted by a legislature.  There is no such thing as common law crime, a crime that we all kinda agree exists but we just make up as we go along.  If it is not expressly prohibited by law, it is not a crime.

Each crime has specific elements, things that must happen in order for conduct to be criminal.  If all of the elements of the crime are not met, then the conduct is not criminal.  We may think there should be more elements or less, but they are whatever the law says they are, and the crime consists of all required elements regardless of how much you love or hate them.  That’s the legislature’s decision, and until it’s changed, and it defines the crime.  The reason it’s important that the crime is defined is that we wouldn’t know what not to do otherwise.  The law puts on notice of the conduct that is illegal, which in turn is important so that each of us doesn’t get to behave in whatever manner we think appropriate, raising or lowering the bar in accordance with our personal idea of criminality.  The bar stays put.

For those commenters who bandy about legal jargon with abandon, there is a difference between civil and criminal law.  Civil law gives rise to an award of damages or injunctive relief.  Criminal lands you in jail (more or less).  They are not two sides of the same coin, and slander, as was discussed in some comments, is a civil concept rather than a criminal one.  In other words, there is no crime of slander per se, though in some jurisdictions, there are crimes that involve the use false statements with various additional elements.

And now for one of the most difficult concepts for the non-lawyer, jurisdictional differences.  States get to pass their own laws.  One state may enact a law making something a crime that is perfectly legal in another state.  Similarly, the elements of a crime in one state can differ markedly from that in another. This is counterintuitive, in that one would naturally believe that if certain conduct is wrong, it would be wrong everywhere.  That’s not necessarily the case.  It’s usually true for crimes that are malum in se, conduct that is evil in itself, but less so for conduct that it malum prohibitum, conduct that is prohibited simply because the state chooses to make it so.  For example, there is nothing inherently evil about driving on the left hand side of the road, but states have chosen to have us drive on the right hand side to avoid a lot of nasty crashes.  In Britain, they got it backwards.

Adding to the confusion is that fact that laws are enacted using the English language, as understood by politicians.  Words require definitions, and people often understand their meaning differently.  Consequently, courts spend a great deal of time defining words.  The objective is to make their meaning clearer.  Courts often fail to achieve this objective, and either make relatively clear words fuzzy to encompass conduct that would not ordinarily be understood to be covered or so broad and vague as to be rendered meaningless.  To understand what the words in a law mean, lawyer are constrained to read caselaw, the decisions of judges, and try to make sense out of them.  It’s not always easy.  It’s not always illuminating.

In GatesGate, Henry Gates was arrested for disorderly conduct (not disturbing the peace, as many seem to think).  The New York version of disorderly conduct, contained in New York Penal Law Section 240.20, provides:

§ 240.20 Disorderly conduct.
    A  person  is  guilty of disorderly conduct when, with intent to cause public inconvenience, annoyance or alarm, or recklessly creating a risk thereof:
    1.  He  engages in fighting or in violent, tumultuous or threatening behavior; or
    2. He makes unreasonable noise; or
    3. In a public place, he uses abusive or obscene language, or makes an obscene gesture; or
    4. Without lawful  authority, he disturbs any lawful assembly or meeting of persons; or
    5. He obstructs vehicular or pedestrian traffic; or
    6.  He congregates with other persons in a public place and refuses to comply with a lawful order of the police to disperse; or
    7. He creates a hazardous or physically offensive condition by any act which serves no legitimate purpose.
    Disorderly conduct is a violation.

The law as enacted is remarkably broad, covering a variety of actions that would otherwise appear perfectly lawful, if not constitutionally protected.  A key to appreciating the law is the preliminary requirement, that the conduct be done with the “intent to cause public inconvenience, annoyance or alarm.”  That means that the person engaging in the conduct desired those outcomes. 
If the purpose of a person’s conduct is to express outrage and anger toward a police officer for acting in a manner that the individual believes to be wrong, improper, racially motivated, for example, then his intent is not to cause public alarm.  No disorderly conduct.

(Edit: for the reckless version, as opposed to intentional version, at the annoyingly vigilant prodding of my dear Prof. Yabut, whose gnawing concern with precision keeps me on my toes, see the comment below.)

Of course, this is how the law works in theory.  On the street, it’s another matter.  The police officer, such as Sgt. Jim Crowley in the Gates matter, makes the arrest and it’s then left to the judge to decide whether there is sufficient cause to maintain the charges against the individual.  In New York, the time between arrest and being brought before a judge for initial arraignment, at which point a neutral magistrate will have an opportunity to determine whether the allegations o
f fact are sufficient to meet the elements of the offense, is about 24 hours.  Those are often the worst 24 hours a person will ever experience. 

It doesn’t necessarily matter whether the prosecution proceeds.  If nothing else, those first 24 hours will be the price of mouthing off to a cop.  It’s a high price for exercising one’s right to speak one’s mind to a overly sensitive police officer.

Cambridge PD Sergeant Saves President From Crash

Regardless of what really happened, which largely depends on whether one prefers to default to the police version or common sense, for the President of the United States to state that he doesn’t know that facts, yet conclude that the Cambridge Police handled the case of Henry Louis Gates (I won’t call him Skip until he invited me to do so) stupidly was foolish. 

Of course, they did handle the matter stupidly, but that doesn’t make the leap by Obama acceptable.  Either you first learn the facts or you don’t draw a conclusion.  For a president to make such a rash statement while conceding the lack of basis is disturbing. 

Left alone, the President’s remarks drew a firestorm of criticism.  Life Lesson: When the world is busy criticizing the person who maligned you, keep you head low and your mouth shut.  Sgt. Jim Crowley didn’t learn this lesson, so he decided to talk to the media and respond to the President, vowing that he would never apologize.  As he did this, heads across the country started turning from the President, who was about to crash and burn, to Crowley.  There’s nothing the media loves more than fresh meat.

Today, the rest of the Cambridge Police Department, plus all of their various unions, feeling unloved and unappreciated, decided that they too had to chime in and speak their mind.  We ain’t no stupid cops.  We think we’re good cops.  We stand behind Jim Crowley.

Now, they demand that the President of the United States of America apologize to law enforcement officer across the nation, all of whom he insulted by calling the actions of the Cambridge Police Department stupid.

A catch-phrase from the character Forest Gump was, “stupid is as stupid does.”  Welcome to Cambridge, Massachusetts. 

Ironically, the argument on behalf of Sgt. Crowley is that his conduct was not, repeat not, racially motivated.  Gates was being “belligerent”.  Crowley would never determine a course of conduct based upon race, they claimed.  Fair enough.  Since I’ve never been able to see inside another person’s head, I can accept that he doesn’t believe that race played any role whatsoever.  I don’t know that his saying so makes it so, but I similarly don’t know that it doesn’t.

Of course, some think that a white guy (like me) has no business giving up the racial profiling issue:


The most disturbing aspect of the news coverage about Henry Louis Gates’s arrest has been the running commentary by white men about appropriate decorum for black men.
Just so we’re clear, I have no authority to speak on behalf of Gates, so I’m not giving anything away, and fully concede that I have never lived as a black man, precluding me from opining that Gates conduct was inappropriate.  I do note, of course, that I think it was appropriate for someone hassled in their home by a cop to be furious and act accordingly, regardless of race.  But I’m white, so what do I know?

That said, let’s go to the place where the cops stand arm in arm, proud of their work.  Henry Gates was belligerent.  Is that belligerent in the first or second degree?  You see belligerence is not, to my knowledge, a crime.  Even in Cambridge.  Rather, belligerence is an attitude that police officers do not care for and will not tolerate.  You must respect their authoritae.  Feeling hostile toward a police officer?  Then be prepared to pay the price. 

Now that the Cambridge Police Department, along with its unions for supervisory personnel as well as the rank and file, have made it that Crowley’s arrest of Gates was not because of race but because of belligerence, the opportunity presents itself to ask why citizens are required to be complacent and cooperative with police rousting them in their own homes?  Certainly the path of least resistance, but when did we give up the right to get angry with a police officer?

And in case you haven’t noticed, the discussion has shifted away from the foolishness of President Obama leaping to conclusions to the lame, possibly idiotic, effort of the Cambridge Police Department to justify arresting an American citizen in his own home because he became belligerent after being subject to the commands of Sgt. Jim Crowley.  When the cop says jump, you ask, “how high,” Professor Gates.  

I don’t think Obama owes Crowley an apology.  I do think he owes him a thank you. After all, Crowley did save the President from crashing.   It’s the nice thing to do.

Wanna Buy My Brief?

The confluence of two issues raised, one by Eugene Volokh and the other by Rick Horowitz, presents a disturbing question as to who owns what when it comes to the law, and why we’re paying for things that should belong to all of us in the first place.

Eugene posted the question of whether Lexis and Westlaw infringe upon copyright when the publish appellate briefs.


The question is whether the commercial posting of the briefs is fair use; and fair use law is, as usual, vague enough that there’s no clear answer. I do think that the posting is quite valuable to researchers and to others who are trying to figure out what actually happened in a case, and why courts reached the results they did, and I think courts can consider this social value in the fair use analysis. It’s also quite unlikely that allowing such posting would materially diminish the incentive to write good briefs, or the market value of a good brief; that too is potentially relevant to the fair use inquiry. But the case isn’t open and shut, because there are no precedents (at least that I know of) that are clearly on point, because the various fair use factors seem to cut in both directions, and because fair use analysis is so vague in such situations.

I agree that there are certainly fair use aspects to having briefs available to others, not for the purpose of copying and using them ourselves, but rather to understand the arguments made for and against a position resulting in a court decision.  But it implicates another point as well.  Lexis and Westlaw charge, and charge well, for their services.  Should they be entitled to charge me for access to your brief, while you gain nothing from it? 

They provide the medium, but you (and I) provide the content.  We don’t play on Lexis because we enjoy the interface; we use it to search for content.  But this content isn’t theirs to sell.  The same is true, when you think about it, of the cases and statutes.  Those belong to the courts, and to the people, yet they sell it as if it was their very own.  How does this sit with you?

Rick Horowitz came at this issue when seeking to download the California Penal Code.


Statutes…those are public domain, right? So shouldn’t it be easier to find ebooks like, “California Penal Code” in complete form?
It seems like it should.  After all, the Penal Code is the product of government, of elected officials, whose work is done for the benefit of the citizens of California.  We’re not paying them to pass laws so Lexis and Westlaw have something to post on their commercial websites.

Years ago, at the dawn of time before computers and the internet, companies like West Publishing had to pay people to take court decisions and retype them so that they could be published in these bulky, expensive, things we called “books”.  Lawyer back then had whole rooms dedicated to these things called “books”.  The rooms were called “law libraries.”  They made great backdrops for television interviews.  They were also good for researching. 

Things are different today.  No longer does West have to send hard copy of court decisions overseas to have non-English speaking typists create the fodder of their law books.  Now it’s a click here, a click there, and a scan, and everything is done.  It’s just the fine work of our legislators, courts and lawyers, and Westlaw and Lexis are in business, charging absurd amounts of money to access our own material, bought and paid for by the same people who get the computer research bill.

I over simplify the process a bit, but our acceptance of the fact that Lexis and Westlaw performed a function worthy of significant payment in the olden days may have carried over to the modern age without undergoing much scrutiny.  Perhaps it’s time to start asking why we, the people, are giving them, the businesses charging us, our goods and then paying them to buy them back?  It seems to me that the business model has changed, and it’s time we reconsider whether Lexis and Westlaw should be allowed to freeride off our work, or whether the fees we pay them are rational and commensurate with their contribution to the cause.

Or to put it another way, I wonder whether the function of any halfway competent search engine couldn’t perform as well, and perhaps better given that Lexis has done nothing in years to improve its functioning, at no cost to the user?  The only think we would need is to have all the public materials available publicly.  That doesn’t seem like such an unreasonable thing to expect.

Hang the Jury or the Lawyer

It was indeed a sad commentary on something when San Francisco lawyer Francis T. Fahy’s vote mysteriously switched from plaintiff to defendant, thus ending the deadlock that prevented his return to his law practice. The California Supreme Court decided unanimously that the commentary was about Fahy, and stripped him of his license.

Certainly, his lack of fortitude to stand firm with his belief, to honor his oath as juror, and to tell the trial judge the truth (and not “disrespect the court”) don’t serve him well.  Fahy was an embarrassment.  But let’s not forget that juror’s switching votes to end a hung jury that kept them from other things is hardly a unusual issue.  Any lawyer who has sat while his jury remained out for days, four, five, six days, knows that deadlock is only as strong as the pull on the holdout juror.

The Allen charge is carefully crafted to suggest that it’s not intended to coerce the holdout juror into agreeing with the majority and giving up their firmly held belief.  But no one believes in their heart that it works that way.  It’s just more legal gobbledygook to a juror with pressing affairs to address. 

Now that juror reform commands that previously exempt folks must be part of the venire like regular people, no longer cloaked in that special treatment that annoyed so many and made jury duty seem unfair, we added a new dimension to the problem.  You see, when a mother of young children is called for duty and selected to sit, her mind is on the needs of her babies who have no one to greet them at the door, fix them a healthy snack, help with their homework and kiss their knee when they fall.  Is anyone so myopic to believe that the trial is more important to a mother of young children than the welfare of your kids?

While jurors can make arrangements for someone else to stand in their place for a while, time begins to take its toll.  First the time is lost to selection process.  Then more time is lost to the trial.  Finally, time is lost to deliberations.  That time is the worst, since after a day or two there is nothing that hasn’t be said.  Repeating positions over and over, to people who have heard it again and again, strikes no one as a particularly good use of time.  And the children are sitting at home, essentially motherless.  While they can live without mom for a few days, and while mom may be willing to sacrifice for a worthy cause, all of this is drained by the fourth day of deliberations.  It’s too long.  The sacrifice is too great.  There is no longer purpose to the sacrifice, and the kids really need their mother back.

But if the mom switches her vote to end the deliberations, return to her children and put everyone out of their misery, there is no penalty.  A lawyer can be disbarred.  A mom can’t be dis-mommed. 

Had Fahy been a physician, would he have lost his license?  What if he was a priest, would he have been defrocked? 

Inside the jury room, Fahy was not a lawyer, but a juror.  Indeed, the jury is told that his opinion is no more worthy than anyone else’s, and clearly they agreed with that assessment as his opinion carried no weight with the others whatsoever.  Not much of a recommendation, frankly, as a lawyer hold out who cannot persuade others to see his point of view doesn’t sound like much of a lawyer.  But since he was there solely as a juror, why would his license to practice law come into play at all?  Punish him for his misconduct if you must, but in the role he was playing, juror.

It struck me as silly pandering when it became fashionable to end the jury duty exemption for lawyers.  I don’t want one on my jury.  No one I know wants a lawyer on theirs.  Lawyers are distinguishable when it comes to jury duty from everyone else.  Courts are about law, and lawyers are, well, lawyers.  Nothing deeper than that, and that seems to me to be enough.  Reformers tend to overlook the obvious sometimes.

Having decided to ignore common sense and put lawyers on juries anyway, however, shouldn’t give rise to another potential means of pulling the plug on a bad juror cum lawyer.  It seems quite likely that Francis Fahy had some collateral issues, as a lawyer, that informed the court that he might not be the best of the profession, and might give rise to some sense that his disbarment was neither a great loss to the profession nor a decision to lose sleep over. 

Fine, if he’s a bad lawyer, disbar away.  But not because he was a bad juror.  That’s not a risk one takes when compelled to sit as a trial juror.