Author Archives: SHG

Taser Goes Too Far

Via Ken at Crimlaw, our friends at Taser International have expanded their line of less-lethal weaponry.


[Taser] has released a new shotgun-ready projectile similar to its other stun-gun products, but with twice the range and the first with wireless capabilities.

The wireless device has the same effect as Taser’s other products, but can be fired from up to 100 feet away. It also can be used by other 12-gauge, smooth-bore shotguns, although the Taser-produced shotgun is designed only for the less-lethal projectiles.
Because it was too darn hard for the officers to walk the 20 paces from their cruiser to the 72 year old woman who refused to sign her speeding ticket, we needed this.

The problem with tasers isn’t that they offer a less than less-lethal alternative to bullets, itself not an entirely bad thing.  The problem is that tasers, both by marketing and inclination, have become a substitute for minimal intelligence.  It’s just too easy to pull out the taser when there is no justification for the use of any force whatsoever.  It’s become the “great persuader” for lazy and stupid cops.  Why spend the 10 minutes to talk someone off the ledge when you can taze ’em and be back before the donuts come out of the oven?

Of course, there is a risk involved with getting too close to someone armed with a knife or club in order to use a hand-held taser to subdue them.  They can still be shot from a bit of distance, but not 100 feet away.  I can foresee circumstances where the distance makes sense, and would protect police from unnecessary risk.

I can also see the circumstance where some cop stands next to his RMP and plugs the recalcitrant but harmless citizen with his taser enabled shotgun rather than exert the effort to resolve the situation without need to resort to force at all.  I see a whole lot more of this happening than the alternative.  It’s just too easy to do.

Just as we can debate whether it’s the gun that kills people or people who kill people, the taser is only as good as the person holding it or, now, pulling the trigger.  The problem is that experience has shown that too many cops aren’t good enough.  And now it’s even easier, safer and, frankly, requires less effort.  Just what we need, an easier way to get stupid.

If You Liked Secret Wiretaps, You’ll Love This

Now a Harvard Lawprof. Jack Goldsmith could only tolerate 9 months in the Office of Legal Counsel during the Bush administration, documented in his book The Terror Presidency.  You might think that the lessons learned inside Ashcroft’s Justice Department would have sunk in, but unfortunately not, as shown in his New York Times Op-Ed.

After describing the obvious, that the nation, it’s daily functioning and ultimately our national security, relies on the viability of the internet, he points out that a chain is only as strong as its weakest link.


One of many hurdles to meeting this goal is that the private sector owns and controls most of the networks the government must protect. In addition to banks, energy suppliers and telecommunication companies, military and intelligence agencies use these private networks. This is a dangerous state of affairs, because the firms that build and run computer and communications networks focus on increasing profits, not protecting national security. They invest in levels of safety that satisfy their own purposes, and tend not to worry when they contribute to insecure networks that jeopardize national security.

This is a classic market failure that only government leadership can correct. The tricky task is for the government to fix the problem in ways that do not stifle innovation or unduly hamper civil liberties.

Already, the question asked suggests how Goldsmith is going to veer off course. or not “unduly hamper civil liberties.”  What are the chances that his “unduly” will align with the “unduly” of the rest of us?

Goldsmith’s contention that our nation needs a secure internet, capable of preventing everyone from hackers to terrorists from seizing control of our systems and crashing our nation.  But to suggest that private networks have no interest in security, and therefore needs to be under the thumb of our government to protect us from them is the attitude of those who are true believers that government, and only government, can be trusted.  This trust of government leads Goldsmith down the wrong path.

Our digital security problems start with ordinary computer users who do not take security seriously. Their computers can be infiltrated and used as vehicles for attacks on military or corporate systems. They are also often the first place that adversaries go to steal credentials or identify targets as a prelude to larger attacks.

So stealing my passwords is the key to infiltrating our government computer systems?  I don’t think so.  Hard as it is to imagine, I have no entrée into the government’s computers.  I would like to, but I don’t.  Assuming computer hackers with evil intent get hold of my computer, they could lay waste to Simple Justice, but I believe that the government remains safe.

The problem with this paragraph is that this is where Goldsmith meanders down the road from major computer systems to the computers of the little people, which now, by extension, require the same government oversight, “for our own good.”  See where this is heading yet?

But the private sector cannot protect these networks by itself any more than it can protect the land, air or water channels through which foreign adversaries or criminal organizations might attack us. The government must be prepared to monitor and, if necessary, intervene to secure channels of cyberattack as well.

And here it comes.  We can’t protect ourselves, which is why we need the government to do it for us.  Analogies between “land, air or water channels” are curious, considering they certainly require the efforts of a large military force to defend but bear no similarity to the internet.  Goldsmith lays it out as if it’s obvious, but offers zero explanation for the value of this comparison.  Will our wi-fis have little soldiers running in and out of the waves? 

The Obama administration recently announced that it would set up a Pentagon cybercommand to defend military networks. Some in the administration want to use Cybercom to help the Department of Homeland Security protect the domestic components of private networks that are under attack or being used for attacks. Along similar lines, a Senate bill introduced in April would give the executive branch broad emergency authority to limit or halt private Internet traffic related to “critical infrastructure information systems.”


The internet version of the Gulf of Tomkin Resolution is on the table.  After all, given how vital these systems are to the wellbeing of our nation, and how an attack can come at any moment and the executive branch must be prepared to respond at that very moment, we must give our President the tools to protect us.  And if we can’t trust the President, who can we trust?

The government must be given wider latitude than in the past to monitor private networks and respond to the most serious computer threats.


After all, the government can’t fight with one hand tied behind its back, right?

These new powers should be strictly defined and regularly vetted to ensure legal compliance and effectiveness. Last year’s amendments to the nation’s secret wiretapping regime are a useful model. They expanded the president’s secret wiretapping powers, but also required quasi-independent inspectors general in the Department of Justice and the intelligence community to review effectiveness and legal compliance and report to Congress regularly.


You see, the problem isn’t that the government can’t be trusted, but that there are occasional regimes that overreach more than others.


Many will balk at this proposal because of the excesses and mistakes associated with the secret wiretapping regime in the Bush administration. These legitimate concerns can be addressed with improved systems of review.
Ask the wrong question and you arrive at the wrong answer.  Goldsmith’s solution is to vest the government with yet another secret power to “wiretap” our computers, and while acknowledging that this might be just a wee bit intrusive, dismisses the problem by offering that one finger of government can keep a post hoc eye on the rest of it.  Problem solved!

This train of thought goes off the tracks at the very beginning, with its assumption that private industry lacks sufficient desire or interest in internet security to adapt.  Goldsmith’s assumption doesn’t hold water.  The problem isn’t will, but way.  If the government has a magic solution that will secure the airwaves from attack, then why is it hiding it?  Private lanes in the information superhighway would love to be secure, free from crashes if you will, but hasn’t figured out a foolproof plan.  Neither had the government, obviously, yet Goldsmith would give the government access to our laptops in the name of our protection.

Worse still, the zealous belief that government, at the end of the day, is a trustworthy player, whether in its entirety or, as Goldsmith expressly states, via some quasi-independent inspector general system of review to keep the government honest, is nothing more than an article of faith.  Either we’re willing to give the government access to every aspect of our lives that exists within our hard drives, and trust the government not to abuse its authority, or not.  Goldsmith’s faith is with the government.  Is yours?

And yes, I do have an alternative proposal.  Our government, the one that could put a man on the moon when it put it’s nose to the grindstone, may well be capable of developing security systems that can protect our computer infrastructure from outside attack.  Why not put the same zeal that would otherwise go into accessing the personal computers of every American into developing the secure system, which can then be made available to every private access point around the nation, if not the world,

It may well be beyond the ability of private enterprise to develop a truly secure system, but I’m sure everyone will be more than happy to take what the government develops and use it.  It’s like Tang or the pen that writes upside down.  While the government may have been the impetus for the development, it can subsequently benefit everyone (except the Ruskies, who ignored the pen and used a pencil instead).  We just need to make sure that our friends at the CIA don’t build their own backdoor into the secure system, “just in case.” 

And what if the government can’t come up with a fool-proof secure system?  Then they haven’t really demonstrated any reason why they should be allowed to access our laptops instead.  If this is about security, then the failure reveals that the government doesn’t bring any more to the table than anyone else.  It doesn’t have the technology to protect us, but only to spy on us in the purported hope that they will catch the hacking terrorist before the damage is done.  A big if, coupled with a big intrusion.

If this is about Big Brother keeping its eye on me to make sure that Osama Bin Laden isn’t trying to bring down western civilization via my laptop, then I’m not prepared for the trade-off.  And before I would even consider it, let Goldsmith focus his solutions on the government developing real solutions to internet security before they go for the fear factor of accessing my PC.  If he trusts the government so much, then why not trust its ability to come up with a real solution that doesn’t require its intrusion into the lives of Americans.  For our own protection.

Time, Time, Time, Is On My Side

At My Shingle, Carolyn Elefant raises the bane of every solo practitioner’s existence.



The Report opens with a reminder that 55 percent of New York State Bar Association 74,000 members are solos and that their needs must be comprehensively addressed.  And one of the major problems faced by solos is decidedly unglamorous:  the time waste associated with waiting in court.  From the report:


It is Abraham Lincoln who is credited with having observed, two centuries ago, that a lawyer’s time and advice are his stock in trade. The message still resounds. The loss of significant periods of time spent waiting in courthouses is costly—for attorneys if they do not bill their clients out of sheer good conscience, or for their clients when their attorneys bill for those non-productive hours. Throughout the state, this waste is widely reported to be enormous—perhaps hundreds or thousands of hours daily adding up to thousands or perhaps tens of thousands of dollars or more. For attorneys, their clients and others, it is an imposition and a burden on their time and resources. 
Before you say it, obviously Lincoln didn’t “observe” that a lawyer’s time and advice are his stock in trade two centuries ago.  He was born in February, 1809, and I am confident these were not his very first utterances.  Welcome to the detailed exactitude of the New York State Bar Association, a club where the discalcic flourish.

Criminal defense lawyers, with certain exceptions, do not bill by the hour.  We suffer the waste of our time sitting in local courtrooms for hours on end, awaiting our 60 second in front of the judge.  Unlike civil matters, our cases are adjourned from one date to another, with defendants required to appear, whether there is something to do on that date or not.  It’s a matter of control, keeping cases and clients before the court on a routine basis to make sure that we’re all still around.  This means that the lawyers return to court, along with the other 30 to 70 of our brethren on the calendar that date, to await our turn to smile and get a new date to return to court.  Until the defendant’s name is called, we sit.

Over time, I’ve been able to significantly reduce the time lost to waiting by handling a substantially lower volume of cases.  Other lawyers, particularly younger lawyers, don’t have that option.  They are compelled to take on as many cases as possible to make ends meet.  That means that they spend an enormous percentage of their day waiting in one courtroom after another for their cases to be called, time that could be spent working on their cases, investigating, writing, meeting, researching.  Gone.  Time lost can never be recaptured.  It’s just gone.

Most judges never experienced this loss of time.  Most criminal judges come from the ranks of prosecutors, who have a calendar assistant whose job it is to stay in one courtroom all day long and read from notes sent in by the assigned prosecutor.  The assigned prosecutor gets to sit in his office, or do a hearing or trial, or hang out at Forlinis, but isn’t required to sit in courtroom after courtroom.  Solo practitioners don’t have calendar assistants to cover their lost time.  Former prosecutors who become judges lack any understanding or empathy for this situation.

But even former criminal defense lawyers, the few who assume the bench, forget what the loss of time meant to them.  Rather, they just take the waste as a cost of doing business.  They went through it when they worked for a living, and now they are happy to be able to impose it on others, in a “right of passage” sort of way.  Former criminal defense lawyers who assume the bench are often meaner toward their own than former prosecutors, as they ought to know better.

If there is one attribute that a criminal defense lawyer must possess to survive the job, it’s the ability to sit and wait.  It’s what we do most.  If you can’t do it, then you can’t be a criminal defense lawyer.  And it’s a terrible waste.

But He Could Run, Couldn’t He?

When it came time for R. Allen Stanford to put on the steel bracelets, he did it like a champ.   While Dick DeGuerin deserves much of the credit for how well Stanford handled his surrender, Stanford had the opportunity to flee the United States long before DeGuerin’s advice came in handy.  But to what avail?

When Magistrate Judge Frances Stacy set bond at $500,000, secured by $100,000, it was a triumph of reason and law.  Whether or not Allen Stanford is guilty as sin, he didn’t flee despite opportunity and reason to do so if he was so inclined, and surrendered to agents, who were there to seize him despite DeGuerin’s clear and unequivocal offer to have Stanford voluntarily surrender to the United States Attorney in Houston.  There isn’t anything more a putative defendant can do to make himself more amenable to prosecution.

But the same lack of class that was revealed by the U.S. Attorney’s stunt in trying to nab Stanford outside his girlfriends Virginia home reared its ugly head again when the bail order was appealed to federal District Court Judge David Hittner.  And the judge showed that he was no better.  Stanford was detained.



U.S. District Judge David Hittner on Tuesday approved a request by prosecutors to overturn a magistrate judge’s decision to allow Stanford freed on $500,000 bond pending his trial.

Prosecutors argue that Stanford’s international ties make him a serious flight risk. Stanford holds dual U.S. and Antiguan citizenship, has an international network of wealthy acquaintances who would help him and possibly access to vast wealth hidden around the world.

The absurdity of this line of argument is only trumped by its acceptance by Judge Hittner.  Stanford is a wealthy man.  Of course he’s got the wherewithal to flee.  But that bears no connection, and offers no evidence of, any intention or desire to flee.  Yet again, the theoretical subsumes reality, suggesting that any defendant with more than modest assets is, by definition, a flight risk and requires detention.  It’s crazy.

The touchstone for bond is whether any set of conditions will reasonably assure the defendant’s return to court.  Key to this determination is whether there is any basis in fact to suggest that a defendant has any intention of leaving the jurisdiction to avoid prosecution.  It’s not whether he can afford to run or has friends in other countries.  It’s whether there is any factual basis to believe he would do so. 

In the case of Allen Stanford, not only has there been no showing of any intent or desire to flee, but there has been an overwhelming showing that he will stay and fight.  Not overwhelming merely be dint of argument, but by facts.  The allegations of his running a Ponzi scheme, the crime du jour, was long known by all, and Allen Stanford was free to run off to any darn place he wanted, with his alleged hidden cache of “vast wealth” and his “international network of wealth acquaintances” to provide him aid and succor.  Yet he stayed. 

Before these allegations arose, Stanford lived outside the United States for 15 years.  Instead of ducking jurisdiction, he returned to the United States, established residence in Houston, and actually made himself available to the government for prosecution. 

He hired a lawyer.  He hired an exceptionally good lawyer.  This isn’t what you do when your intention is to flee; this is the action of a man who is preparing for a fight.  Stanford’s offer to surrender was ignored; he knew that the feds could knock on his door in the wee hours of the morning any time they wanted, and that he would have no advance notice of their arrival to decide to hop a plane to Antigua.  But he didn’t flinch.  He continued to live his life as before, readily available to government agents to pick him up at their leisure.  This too is the action of a man who is preparing to fight.

There is nothing more a person can do to prove, by virtue of his conduct, that he will not flee, but will stay and fight.  Nothing.

It’s not surprising that the government pursued an appeal of the magistrate’s decision to the district court judge.  They can’t stand it when they don’t get their way.  That Judge Hittner bought into it, however, is unfortunate.  He’s been a judge long enough to know better.  Much better. 

Aside from the big deal of another erroneous and baseless decision that deprives a man of his constitutional right to appropriate bail, it presents a scenario that suggests that there is nothing, absolutely nothing, that can be done by a defendant to demonstrate that he has no intention of fleeing when faced with a government determined to detain him no matter what. 

Bail is not punishment.  A defendant is not to be punished until after he’s convicted, no matter how disturbing that is to most Americans.  Given how Allen Stanford has conducted himself in the face of arrest and prosecution, his detention is a disgrace.  It doesn’t matter whether he’s “extraordinarily evil” (anticipate that I will be using this phrase with abandon for the foreseeable future); it only matters whether he will return to court.  Stanford has proven he will, and if we wish to pretend to be a nation of laws, not men, then he should be released.

Now That There Is No Bar

The ramifications of imposing a sentence of 150 years on Bernie Madoff are already rippling through the system.  It’s as if judges and prosecutors have been freed from the chains of proportionality, not to mention incentives, and can now impose, or argue for the imposition, of punishment based upon unadulterated rhetoric.

“Extraordinarily evil.”  Across the river in New Jersey, Glyn Richards was sentenced to 30 years on a plea of guilty for a $6 million scam.  Judge Renée Marie Bumb explained:


“It doesn’t take a life – like a violent crime does, but it does destroy life,” Bumb said. “I think you are a con man. You have been and you always will be. I think you’ll be pulling a scam when you walk out the gates of prison.”

If it didn’t cause harm, it wouldn’t be a crime.  So what does the empty rhetoric add to explain this vast upward departure to the guidelines?  Is Richards “extraordinarily evil” too?  What is ordinarily evil?

Cy Vance, Jr., running for the Democratic line for New York County District Attorney as Robert Morgenthau’s handpicked successor, applauded the Madoff sentence on twitter:


I believe the federal prosecutors have done an excellent job moving the Madoff case to a swift & just conclusion.

So I asked Cy a question :


@CyVanceforDA Should economic crimes be dealt with more severely than violent crimes, such as rape and murder?

Uh oh.  Cy responded :


@ScottGreenfield Serious crime must be dealt with seriously & substantially whether it’s economic crime or a crime against a person.
Caught by the rhetoric, Cy was left to scramble.  You see, the New York County District Attorney, being the only local DA who has the actual Wall Street just a few blocks down from his office, white collar fraud prosecutions are handled with some regularity, hand in hand with the more typical crimes prosecuted in state court, like murder.  But under New York law, the most severe sentence available for a person convicted of murder 2 is 25 years to life in prison.  So how do you square the sentence available for murder with a fraud?  Is murder not “extraordinarily evil?”

Lacking any rational way to justify his position, Cy was left to dangle in the wind with a response that serious crime must be dealt with seriously.  Seriously?  As in, did he seriously write that?

Viewed in a vacuum, every crime is evil.  Where the line between ordinarily and extraordinary evil falls can’t be discerned, but when prosecutors and judges view sentences divorced from all context and feel comfortable arguing for, and relying upon, hyperbolic rhetoric to justify the imposition of retribution, there is no longer any measure upon which to determine a sentence.  It’s just numbers connected to adjectives and descriptions of pain and misery.  There’s no denying that the victims suffered, but that offers nothing to explain why one sentence is more appropriate than another.

My question to Cy Vance was one of proportionality.  As a matter of policy, is it his position that murders aren’t as bad as scams?  If he wants to be the District Attorney, and his office will be prosecuting both, then his opinion matters.  He dodged the question, poorly I might add.  My purpose wasn’t to embarrass him, but since he raised the issue, the question flowed naturally.

There are sound policy reasons to have sentences that increase proportionately with the severity of the crime, and that a certain degree of leniency must be shown for acquiescence.  I realize that most people aren’t wonky enough to care, and I realize that there are some insane jurisdictions with 3 Strike laws that put the guy smoking a blunt in prison for life, which makes every other sentence look ridiculously lenient.  But we need to be intellectually on guard against one asinine law justifying a domino effect of irrational policy and arbitrary sentencing. 

If the sentence to be imposed no longer appears to require a sound basis connected to the legitimate purpose for sentence, as was clearly the case in Bernie Madoff’s case since 18 USC 3553(a) requires that the sentence be “sufficient, but no more than necessary,” a requirement that was facially violated by sentencing a man to a term greater than his possible lifespan which by definition is “more than necessary,” we are freed from the constraints of proportionality and reason.  And we have no basis remaining by which to measure a sentence, beyond “extraordinarily evil.”

I suppose that the defense can argue at sentence going forward that he’s just ordinarily evil?  Is there any other limit to retribution?  Or is it who uses the most convincing adjectives?

Talking Heads: Just Smile and Look Pretty

Whenever a high profile case hits the airwaves, as it did yesterday with Bernie Madoff’s sentencing, the news outlets trot out purported “experts” to fill the time.  I spent a few minutes watching shortly after sentence was imposed, and was, well, underwhelmed.  At first, I thought that the “experts” just had little to offer; they were not illuminating, interesting, or controversial.  Heck, they weren’t even informative.

But after some reflection, I realized that the experts weren’t at fault.  It was the interviewers, primarily the anchors who were reading their parts as they are so well-qualified to do.  The problem was that the question, usually a long, often meandering query with numerous predicate phrases that veered without segue into a statement of the flagrantly obvious, concluded with the query, “so what do was Judge Chin thinking?”

Of course, we have no clue what Judge Chin was thinking.  We only know what he was saying, but it really didn’t matter at that point since the anchor already stated the obvious and left little to do but agree with the anchor’s brilliance.  “Oh yes, you are so right; that’s exactly what happened.”  And we need to hear this from an expert?

The shame is that there was much to discuss following sentence, as there tends to be following any sort of legal action.  It’s just that no one wants to let it happen.  So why bother to get an expert?  Window dressing; it makes the report appear legitimate and knowledgeable, and gives the viewer the comfort of believing that he too, now, has an expert understanding of events and the law.

The reason for doing this is multifold.  First, TV people are scared to death that if you put someone in front of the camera and leave them to their own devices, they will blow it big time.  Either they will freeze, and stare at the camera like a deer in the headlights, or they will fumble and mumble and make no sense at all, undermining the erudition of the news program itself.  Worse still, they are afraid the expert will start talking like a lawyer and bore the living crap out of the audience or, worst of all, use multisyllabic words that will make viewers change to the Fox News Network.  Trust me, they despise any word with more than two syllables, and greatly prefer words with just one.

The upshot is that the expert may well be an expert, and have great things to say about the subject at hand.  You would just never know from the manner of the interview, which is designed to control the expert, aggrandize the anchor (hey, it is their show, ya know), and not piss off the viewers.  The talking heads are just window dressing, there to provide the imprimatur of credibility to statements so painfully obvious that they have already occurred to every viewer watching.  Viewers love confirmation bias, of course, which reminds them why they love watching the news, where it is proven that they know as much as everyone else about everything that matters.

In contrast, the blawgosphere has a few people who are willing to go out on a limb, actually offer some insight or an opinion, stare controversy in the eye and speak their mind.  It also has plenty of stiff shirts who offer nothing worthwhile, for fear that they would be viewed as too strident or undignified.  Maybe they are afraid that if they actually do something to illuminate the issues in a case, they won’t be asked to do a gig on TV as a talking head.

The Madoff Show Is Over. Who Won? (Update)

So Judge Denny Chin sentenced Bernie Madoff to 150 years.  That’s along the lines of one and half lifetimes, assuming you start at birth.  It was three times the recommendation of the Probation Department, which suggested a mere 50 years, still rather steep for any 71 year old short of Methuselah. 

Obviously, the interests that took precedence were general deterrence and retribution.  It makes sense, in a strange sort of way, that the judge would sentence the defendant to 150 years rather than 50, since both will result in Madoff’s death in prison, but the longer sentence packs a far greater punch as far as the media, and deterrence, are concerned.  Plus, it has the added benefit of satisfying the understandable lust for retribution for the victims.

Yet, there are some deeper institutional issues at stake that flew over the heads of most of TV commentators.  Will this really serve as a deterrence, going as far over the top as it did?  What impact will this have on future guilty pleas?  Who wants Ike Sorkin to be their lawyer?

Judge Chin said that Madoff’s crimes were “extraordinarily evil.”  That may be true, but it doesn’t do much to quantify a sentence.  We hear judges say things like that with some frequency, but it’s an ever-moving bar so that it doesn’t do much to explain whether a fraudster will be just fine if he only steals, say, $50 million from 10 people or $1 billion from 5 people. 

Judge Chin also noted that not a single letter was submitted in support of Madoff.  What were the chances that anyone in this country wanted to be named as a friend of Bernie?  Come on.  That’s just silly, not to mention a decision by Sorkin to avoid pursuing that line at sentence.  I’m sure the judge knew that, but he was using what he had available.

Throughout the course of the Madoff defense, I’ve questioned what the heck the defense was thinking.  Like most people, I would have guessed that Ike Sorkin had something up his sleeve that he would pull out at the moment it was needed.  As it turns out, Sorkin came up empty.  Totally, completely, utterly empty.  His client copped to everything, got the max and will be remembered as one of nation’s worst scoundrels. 

To the extent that there is any lesson to be learned from the Madoff case, it’s all negative.  If someone’s about to rat you out for scamming a few billion, you might as well murder them since they can’t give you life plus cancer.  And if you get caught, you might as well fight with everything you’ve got, as hard as you can, no matter what, as you won’t get the slightest consideration for doing the right thing.  And while the going is good, hide as much cash as you can where the government won’t find it so you can afford a lawyer with a better strategy than Sorkin.

What are they gonna do?  Give you life plus cancer?

I wonder if Judge Chin thought about that when he came up with 150 years.

Update:  I’ve read a number of posts reflecting the thoughts of lawprofs on the significance and virtue of the Madoff sentence.  Without naming names, or linking links, I need to add one bit to this post:  I have yet to see one lawprof post that demonstrates any depth of comprehension of how things work in real-life courtrooms.  One couldn’t fathom why Chin didn’t go along with the probation department’s recommendation, “because they’re the professionals.”  I swear to God, that’s what she wrote.  Another sees the sentence as a ceiling problem (as if all other defendants can somehow age themselves out of their sentence) while others don’t think it’s going to have any impact on how future white collar defendants will perceive the system.  You gotta be kidding.  Who will take a plea after this?

People, get out of the classrooms and books and stick your heads into a courtroom once in a while.  Not just when it’s a high profile case, but a real case with real people and no TV cameras.  There’s a whole wide world of law happening out there, and it’s passing you by.

“A Strong Basis In Evidence” of What?

When it comes to criminal law, the question to be answered is what would a reasonable Scalia think?  After the Supreme Court’s 5-4 decision in Ricci v. DeStefano, the answer isn’t so clear under Title VII.  Did the Court just tacitly overrule Griggs v. Duke Power, or did they just set up an impossible standard for employers?

For those unfamiliar with discrimination law, here’s the dilemma.  There are two ways in which an employer can engage in discriminatory hiring practices, disparate treatment and disparate impact.  The former is affirmatively treating employees of protected classes differently, while the latter is using a facially neutral approach which has the unintended result of affecting a suspect class differently.  Following Griggs, both were equally forbidden by Title VII.

The problem arose from the fact that, in an effort to avoid discrimination by disparate impact, an employer would necessarily have to make race (for example) a consideration, which would implicate disparate treatment.  Until yesterday, this was permissible when it was done to remedy disparate impact.

By 5-4 (yes, another 5-4 decision), the Supremes decided to take a reasonably clear remedy and muddy it all up.  Now, an employer faced with apparent disparate impact is liable for discrimination for attempting to remedy it unless there is “a strong basis in evidence.”  What that means is anybody’s guess, but you can bet on one thing: An employer won’t know for sure until after it’s been sued and a decision has been reached.  In other words, the answer will only be known after an employer has been sued.  Great solution.  Can you imagine an employer coming into court saying, “but my lawyer said so?”  The courtroom will burst with uproarious laughter.

The Ricci case has been used as the touchstone for Sonia Sotomayor’s competence to be a Supreme.  Her qualifications aside, this was pure propaganda, and the reversal by the Supremes (did I mention it was 5-4?) proves absolutely nothing either way.  Aside from the fact that Sotomayor was one of three unanimous judges on the panel, and that the ruling was a basic deference decision given the district court’s lengthy opinion, the Supremes didn’t reject the 2d Circuit’s reasoning but changed the rules of the game.  They rejected their own decision in Griggs.  The Supreme can do that.  The Circuit cannot.

In an article for Forbes that proves that the keyboard is faster than the sword, Walter Olson recognizes that this is a “sued if you do, sued if you don’t” scenario.  While Walter’s view is clearly against reverse discrimination, it really doesn’t matter which side of the decision matches your politics.  The fact is that employers, if nothing else, need to know what is demanded of them in order to avoid violating Title VII.  Walter calls the Court’s decision a “middle ground.”  As any soldier will tell you, when you’re in the midst of battle, the one place you don’t want to get caught is in the middle ground.  That’s where both sides are shooting at you.

The problem is that after Sotomayor has been confirmed for the Court, as we all know she will be, the Ricci decision will remain behind to haunt us.  In dissent, Justice Ginsburg offered this admonition:  “The court’s order and opinion, I anticipate, will not have staying power.”  I have no doubt she’s right, since this decision is wholly unworkable, leaving employers screwed no matter what they do, no matter how hard they try to comply with Title VII. 

This is a Catch-22, with an answer coming only after the harm to all parties has been done.  Of course, how many decades it will take before some future Supreme Court disavows this foolishness has yet to be seen, but regardless of which side you are on in the reverse discrimination debate, there’s no doubt that you will come to hate this decision and demand that the Court clean up yet another mess made in the heat of political warfare.



Three Answers to Nastiness

At Ex Forencis, Larry Daniels is working out the anonymity issue.  Not because of the lack of credibility problem, but because they are mean. Larry, you should know, is a southern gentleman, as well as a guy who puts his name to his opinions, for better or worse.  He wouldn’t post something online that he wouldn’t say to your face.  Others do not adhere to Larry’s code of honor.


Is the internet making people meaner? Or is it just giving people a chance to be mean without consequences, allowing them to channel their inner monsters in a fast and convenient way?

If you read the comments that follow many news stories on web sites for television stations and other news outlets, it is frightening to see what people post about people accused of crimes, local politicians, celebrities, and anyone else who happens to raise their ire. Veiled threats, accusations about the personal lives of the person in the news, hate speech, it’s all there.

While I value free speech as much as anybody, it is funny that exercising that free speech is so much easier when you can remain hidden behind your keyboard. I don’t think people would be so quick to say some of the things they do about a person if they were within nose-punching distance of their target.

Notably, Larry hasn’t tried to work this nastiness into any side agenda in order to claim that it’s sexist or ageist or lookist, or any other “ist”.  It’s just plain nasty.


While the courts go to great lengths to protect the first amendment right of anonymous speech, it is not absolute as courts are now beginning to tackle serving anonymous defendants in internet harassment and defamation cases.

States have passed or are considering passing cyberbullying laws and other protections for people who are the subject of on-line threats, defamation and harassment.


Is this the answer?  It’s one of three potential solutions.  Another option is to do nothing, which apparently isn’t sufficiently satisfying to those who are wounded by the harsh words of their detractors.  And then there’s a third:


Sticks and stone…
Remember when someone called you a name as a child, and you ran home to Mommy to seek comfort and retribution?  What did Mom tell you?  That’s right.  Sticks and stones, baby.  Sticks and stones.  Anyone who has spent any time online knows that the cyberworld is filled with otherwise perfectly nice people who are disinhibited by anonymity and self-importance, allowing them to vent their worst self to compensate for their particularly small genitalia.  So what?

These aren’t special people.  They are the same people we meet, speak with, shake hands and give money to every day of our lives.  We just don’t know if because we see the actual person rather than read his or her ugliest thoughts. 

When I finished college, I put on a backpack and took to the road.  Eventually, I ended up in Germany, which was a very fun place for a young man.  But this was a long time ago, and every time I looked into the face of a 60 year old man, I thought to myself, “what were you doing in 1943?”  It disturbed me greatly.  World War II hadn’t been over long enough for the horror to wear off yet, and I found it impossible to divorce myself from the idea that anyone of these people could have been shooting at my father or murdering my distant relatives. 

But I couldn’t see what was inside their heads.  And I couldn’t blame them blindly for what they might, or might not, have done.  So I kept my suspicions to myself and went on to enjoy my time in Germany immensely.

I don’t know who these nasty anonymous posters are.  I know they aren’t me.  I know they aren’t Larry.  But they could be the guy at the gas station, or the gal at the grocery store.  I could walk around suspicious of them, but it wouldn’t help me any.  I could find out if I wanted to start suing every nasty person in sight, but that’s really not much of a life and, more than likely, wouldn’t improve the condition of life on the internet since there are far more nasty comments that courtrooms.

What strikes me as a far better way to deal with the nastiness is to come up with one of those cool internet words, like w00t or n00b, but one for anonymous posters who post nasty things.  We all know, or certainly should know, that these posts are worthless, meaningless, incredible and ugly.  When we read someone else’s bit of nastiness, we should be able to post that word as the response of the normal to the disinhibited nasty people.  Cut them down to size with a single syllable.  And the rest of us can LOL at them for being nasty and stupid.

If I can get past looking into the eyes of men who carried guns for the Third Reich, then I can certainly get beyond some disinhibited jerks who feel tough by posting nasty, vicious comments under a cloud of anonymity.  I bet others can manage this as well, without asking for new laws and judicial interference to silence people who call them names.  We already have laws to protect us from those who would actually act out their anger toward people whose views disagree with theirs, so we don’t need to concern ourselves with that. 

But nasty comments are still just words.  Sticks and stones, baby.