Author Archives: SHG

Rights, Warnings, Weapons.

Over at Underdog, Jon Katz has a fascinating post about a case where a judge allowed a cop to testify about the defendant’s exercise of his right to remain silent.



At a recent drunk driving bench trial . . . the police officer testified that my client was silent when the officer asked my client on the roadside about what he had imbibed earlier that evening.

I objected to that line of testimony, on the grounds that my client had a Fifth Amendment right not to answer the question, and to have his silence excluded from evidence. The judge overruled my objection, on the basis that a Terry stop — Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968) — was in progress, and not an arrest. 

The judge’s rationale was that the defendant’s Miranda rights had not yet attached, and therefore the underlying rights, including the right to remain silent, were not yet in play.  At the same time, the stop was justified per Terry, giving the officer a right to inquire. A relatively sophisticated analysis, and, as Jon notes, totally wrong.

We possess our constitutional rights at all times.  We don’t need the government’s permission or approval to exercise them.  Indeed, they would be relatively worthless if we did.  But the exercise of these rights is rendered meaningless if the very exercise itself can be used to impugn a defendant at trial. 

So let’s parse this out a bit.  We have the right to remain silent, whether subject to custodial interrogation or just a passing question. Miranda merely provides the timing for the cops to tell us of our rights, nothing more.  So the police in Jon’s case were under no duty to provide Miranda warnings?  That’s fine, and likely correct, but the timing of police taking a person into custody neither creates nor confers the initial availability of constitutional rights.  The two issues are entirely distinct.

As for the Terry stop, it provides the police with a guide to their level of intrusiveness into the personal realm of people.  They are allowed to ask questions.  That doesn’t mean that we are required to answer them.  It’s quite a significant distinction, and one that easily eludes certain robed decision-makers.  By chosing not to answer, we do not open ourselves up to our silence becoming a weapon against us.  We are exercising our rights as Americans.  You don’t have something against Americans, do you?

But the final step in the process is the judge recognizing that the exercise of rights, which to an outsider can look as bad, if not worse, than a confession to kidnapping the Lindbergh baby, does not constitute evidence in itself.  When a cop testifies, as he did in Jon’s case, as to silence when the typical juror would expect a law-abiding person to simply answer the cop’s question, the defendant is damned by his exercise of rights.  If permitted, then the exercise of rights embodied in the Constitution are tantamount to a confession.  Only guilty people invoke their rights.

The problem isn’t that the police officer is Jon’s case sought to use what he believed (wrongly) to be perfectly good evidence that the defendant was a bad person by his refusal to respond to the officer’s perfectly reasonable inquiry.  The problem is a judge who put two and two together and ended up with 39. 

Bear in mind, if the police can use silence as a weapon, as potent if not more so than a statement offered in disregard of one’s rights, then we’re left with one odd Catch-22.  I hope Jon’s judge down in Maryland is paying attention to him.  He knows what he’s talking about.

Mother of the Year Lost

In the shadow of Lori Drew comes Long Island’s own version of a monumentally out of control mother, whose way of handling a dispute between her child and another 9 year old reflects just how warped a parent can get.  From Newsday :

Hauppauge social worker [Margery Tannenbaum, 40] has been charged with endangering the welfare of a child for posting a sexually suggestive ad on Craigslist directing callers to the home of a 9-year-old girl, Suffolk prosecutors said.

Police said the ad was posted in the “casual encounters” section of the Web site in February. “I need a little affection,” the ad read, according to a criminal complaint filed in court. “I am blonde and very cute! I’ll be waiting.” The first name of the girl, whom Newsday is not identifying, was also included in the ad.

Tannenbaum replied via e-mail to those who expressed interest, giving them the home phone number of the girl, who lives about a mile away in Smithtown, the complaint said.

The ad generated nearly two dozen calls from men seeking sex, police said.

A parent’s love and concern for her own child is one thing, admirable in its own way.  But what drives a parent, especially a social worker, to create a scheme such as this to harm another child is beyond comprehension.  Sure, we want to protect and defend our kids.  It’s one of the strongest driving forces in a parents life.  But the urge is to defend our own, not harm another.

The question is whether conduct of this ilk, so utterly shocking and bizarre, is a reflection of some greater disease that’s flowing through parents who have either lost touch with reality, abandoned all morals or are so filled with rage that they cannot control their most outrageous impulses. 

Note that this was not a single instance of lashing out, but a well planned and executed scheme, requiring numerous parts over a period of time.  Even if we try to explain it as moment of uncontrolled rage, it fails to offer any rationale for the ongoing engagement.  Move by move, Margery Tannenbaum persisted in this disagraceful conduct, each time renewing her purpose in causing harm to a 9 year old child.  To maintain that level of fury, and persist in this sort of irrational and outrageous behavior, over a prolonged period of time suggests some serious mental defect.  There is no explanation.  There is no justification.  None.

In an online editorial, Newsday columnist Anne Michaud writes:



It kills me when parents act like this; in my view of the world, we are supposed to look out for children, even if they are not ours. We certainly should not be victimizing them. And this woman is a social worker besides — another supposed caretaker position.

Of course we should be protecting children, rather than affirmatively harming them, whether they are our own or not.  Is there any question about this?  But then, let’s remember that when it comes time to treat the next child offender like an adult, disposable and unworthy of saving.  We truly need to return to the culture of caring for all children rather than only our own, and that includes the children who get in trouble as well as the cute and cuddly ones.  They are all children, all worthy of our caring and concern.

On the other side of the equation, there is much to be said for the handling of this case, particularly in comparison to the horribly ill-conceived Lori Drew prosecution.  Tannenbaum is being prosecuted locally for child endangerment, even though much of her conduct involved a computer, a lie and harm.  Imagine, a prosecutor staying within the bounds of the law and his jurisdiction.

Prosecutors need not distort the law, abandon principle and abuse process to address the damage caused by this sick woman.  While I hope Tannenbaum’s conduct, following on Lori Drew and the Texas Cheerleader mom, isn’t part of a growing trend of parents going off the deep end when it comes to their children, I applaud the prosecutor for dealing with it properly, and staying within the bounds of the law.  At least somebody in this absurd case kept their wits about them.

Credit is a Two Way Street

Judge Richard Posner recently suggested an extreme solution to the potential death of the newspaper.  Using the argument that there’s no reason to buy the cow when you can get the milk for free, Posner urged the expansion of copyright law to “bar online access to copyrighted materials without the copyright holder’s consent, or to bar linking to or paraphrasing copyrighted materials without the copyright holder’s consent.”  In other words, burn blogs to save newspapers.

But this assumes, as Posner does, that its only blogs that free-ride off the newsgathering efforts of “legitimate” media.  While this is certainly the predominant flow, it’s not always the case, as was clear today when the New York Times published a story about Sonia Sotomayor’s foray into private practice under the name “Sotomayor and Associates.”  It was a wonderful piece of investigative journalism, but for one detail.  The news was unearthed not by the Times, but by blawger Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Attorney Blog.

Nowhere does the New York Times mention that Turk was the source of its “news”.  At least when Turk uses the Times as a source, he links to the original story.  The Times doesn’t return the favor.

This isn’t the first time that Turk has come up with a bit of news that ultimately made big headlines.  He was well ahead of the curve on the Flea, and even his brilliant April Fools post about baseball conflicted Supremes tricked a few media outlets.  When it comes to producing exceptionally significant blawg posts, Eric Turkewitz is one of the best.

So where’s the media love and appreciation?  They don’t mind borrowing the work of blawgers like Turk, so why not return the favor by giving credit where credit is due?

I fear that the answer for “real” journalists is that they matter and blawgers just don’t.  While Posner sees the blogosphere as the little people free-riding on the coattails of the hard-working legitimate journalists (and I don’t deny that some are indeed hard-working, and some are occasionally legitimate journalists), any rules he would impose ought to cut both ways.  Not only does the Times free-ride off Turkewitz, but it does so without acknowledgment that some lowly blawger came up with news that they didn’t, and that they had to steal from a blawger to get the story.

Most of us in the blawgosphere, and I include myself in this group, go to great lengths to give credit to the source of our posts, whether it’s a hat tip to a reader who sent a lead or the newspaper that carried the story or another blog that brought it to the fore.  Whatever it may be, we give attribution.  Not only is it a matter good etiquette, but it’s the honest thing to do.  There are a few, including some very well known bloggers, who simply don’t give credit, or credit “friends” when the source is obviously elsewhere.  But the ones who do this, including some of the academics who are happy to glom ideas from trench lawyers but will only cite to scholars lest they be revealed as slummers, compromise their integrity.  While the casual reader might not realize who the dishonest bloggers are, we know.

Internal disputes over sources amongst blawgers are hardly the same as when a newspaper like the New York Times, the Paper of Record, does the stealing.  While Huff Po and Drudge may have pretensions of matching the big boys, ordinary blawgers aren’t playing in the same game as big time newspapers.  I suppose that’s what makes it too painful for the Times to recognize that it needs a blawger like Turkewitz to come up with the information upon which its story relies.

But make no mistake about it.  Turk is the source of the New York Times story, and the absence of his name, and his blawg, in the piece is a shoddy reflection of its journalistic integrity.  Don’t ask the blawgosphere to love you when you won’t love us back, boys.

Unfollowed in St. Louis

One the mysteries of twitter is the accumulation of followers.  Everyone seems to want them, more of them, always more, as if there is a prize at the end of the day.  I assume it’s some validation of self-worth, for people who don’t get out much, unless one’s purpose is to get information out to as many people as possible, a la Alltop impresario @GuyKawasaki.  But is the effort to collect followers real or a house of cards?

From the Riverfront Times, the test came in St. Louis:

A few weeks ago a local Twitter user, Rex Gradeless (Rex7) and non-local Twitterer Brandon Prebynski (Prebynski) of Indianapolis began promoting what they billed as the “St. Louis Largest Tweet-up Ever!” which was to happen last Friday at McGurk’s in Soulard. Well, by all accounts it wasn’t. I wasn’t able to attend myself but, Todd Jordan (Tojosan if you’re nasty) did, and he reported that there were about 19 people in attendance.

Having 19 people come to your party doesn’t sound so terrible at first blush, but consider how many were invited.

The turnout was especially disappointing since both Gradeless and Prebynski have thousands and thousands of followers on Twitter. Gradeless has over 60,000 followers all by himself. You would think that a twitterer that influential should be able to attract more than 19 people to a tweetup right? What could have possibly have gone wrong?
The problem appears to be the nature of one’s followers.  Accumulation of numbers doesn’t speak to the “quality” of followers, meaning people who one would actually care about.  It’s easy to get numbers, given how many people are spammers looking to build up their own numbers by following everyone in sight in the hope that they will follow in return.  But these aren’t your friends.  They don’t love you.  They don’t care about you.  They don’t even know who you are.  If someone following you couldn’t care less what you have to twit, then what good are they as a follower? 

Rex Gradeless is a law student who has joined the ranks of social media advocates, much like my young buddy Adrian Dayton, who has accumulated more than 22,000 followers.  Both have impressive numbers, to be sure, if the numbers mean anything at all.  But as the St. Louis tweet-up (don’t blame me, I don’t create silly twitter words) demonstrates, it’s a meaningless bit of self-deception promoted unceasingly by the twitter sycophants.  How many of those followers have the slightest desire to meet their hero?  How many of those followers would have followed our heroes if they didn’t follow them back?  How many of those followers are busy trying to sell something to the same folks who are trying to sell them something in return?

What eludes me in all this is the compulsive need to accumulate followers.  I guess this is the twitter equivalent of friends on Facebook, another subject of little interest to me.  This isn’t to suggest, as the acolytes no doubt will, that I’m a twitter hater (or a Facebook hater, for that matter), but that I reject the notion that the accumulation of followers means anything whatsoever.  Give me 10 followers with whom I actually want to interact and I’ll trade you 10,000 spammers. 

And contrary to the contention of the inchoate twitter marketing guru wannabes, these huge numbers do not increase your odds of getting a date for Saturday night, unless you want to dress up like Ned Beatty and squeal like a pig.  If you want to know whether you’re loved and admired by your followers, just ask Rex7. 

I’ve been called a dinosaur and curmudgeon for throwing wet blankets on the youth of the law and their efforts to reinvent the wheel.  Chatting with Turkewitz last night, who was getting a kick out of my provocative posts about the Slackoisie, particularly a second year law student’s “response” to my latest challenge to the failed work/life crowd, we commiserated at all the energy of these “go-getters” misdirected from worthy causes into such nonsensical endeavors as demanding their right to be slackers (all the while insisting they aren’t, by their own definition) and collecting twitter followers.  Turk observed, “it’s like trying to explain chocolate to someone who’s never tasted it.”  They’re young and full of life, and can’t possibly comprehend that there’s anything more to understand than what’s in front of their face at the moment.

I don’t blame the Rex7s and Prebynskis of the world for trying to rack up more followers than anyone else.  It’s a hobby, like collecting rubber bands.  But there’s no prize at the end of the game.  They would do better to spend their time getting a taste of chocolate.  Then they would understand.

H/T Venkat

Courting Confrontation

In the world of criminal defense lawyers, one of the most significant positive changes coming from the Supremes has been the expansion (or re-expansion, according to your religion) of the Confrontation Clause.  Beginning with Scalia’s earth shattering Crawford decision in 2004 and culminating, at least for the moment, in this term’s decision in Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts.

What it means is that we get to cross-examine living, breathing people rather than pieces of paper or tapes, that say what they say and can’t be challenged.  Before that, the rule was that the Confrontation Clause was secondary to a “firmly rooted exception” to hearsay, an out of court statement offered for the truth of its contents.

What’s forgotten in the mix is that right to confront witnesses, worthy of inclusion in the 6th Amendment to the United States Constitution, wasn’t applicable to the states until Pointer v. Texas in 1965, when it was held to be so fundamental a right as to be worthy of incorporation under the 14th Amendment due process clause. 

David Bernstein at Volokh raises an interesting argument that Scalia’s originalist position on the Confrontation Clause, that it means what it says as it was understood in 1791 by the guys who passed it, may be baloney.  Not because the founders didn’t have such an understanding of confrontation, but because it quickly devolved to become another rule swallowed by its exception.  As an aside, a “firmly rooted hearsay exception” was whatever the court decided it to be, whether business records, excited utterance, etc.  The notion was that if the hearsay statement was deemed sufficiently reliable, the hearsay came in and the Confrontation Clause was forgotten.

The problem, per Bernstein, is that Scalia looked at the wrong Amendment in determining what the proper originalist understanding should be.  Rather than 1791, when the 6th was passed, he contends that the correct understanding should be that of 1868, when the 14th Amendment was passed, which gave rise to the incorporation doctrine.  At that point in time, when due process per the federal Constitution allowed for its rights to be passed along to the states, the Confrontation Clause was understood to be toothless, such that it was this relatively tepid right that was intended to be imposed upon the states, rather than the robust right originally passed.

Beyond the fact that I do not believe in the originalist view of constitutional interpretation, I nonetheless find Bernstein’s proposition wrong.  The passage of the 14th Amendment incorporation doctrine carried with it all the baggage of the bill of rights, as they were originally intended and as they had since developed.  To the extent one wants to pretend that we know what long-dead people had in mind, and further to the extent that we pretend that this large and diverse group of people were of identical motivation and understanding (a ridiculous notion, but one that serves as a foundation for the originalist perspective), they were well aware that the rights were subject to change, expansion, contraction and reinterpretation.  And still they passed the 14th, knowing that the past saw change and the future would as well. 

Of course, Bernstein’s proposition is purely academic, since the hard fact is that the Supremes have revitalized the Confrontation Clause to a great degree, although it’s “testimonial” versus “non-testimonial” distinction left the door open to much mischief and confusion, From the perspective of trying a case, the purpose of the creator of hearsay evidence, as well as his understanding of the use to which it would be put, has little relation to whether a defendant can mount an effective challenge to traditionally “reliable” hearsay which is nonetheless wrong.

To those who aren’t in the position of having to contest the substantive accuracy of a piece of paper or a tape recording, the enormity of the problem may not be apparent.  The fact is that people sometimes lie when they tell a story. Even if not lying, people can be mistaken.  It’s hardly an unusual thing.  When the font of testimony sits on the witness stand, we can question their senses, memory and comprehension abilities. 

When their evidence is reduced to a writing, it is fixed forever.  We can question whether the person actually wrote what was on the paper, or whether the paper was altered, but we cannot question whether the person who wrote the paper but is not before us at trial actually saw or comprehended what he says.  Ironically, it elevates human frailty to perfection, making it immune from challenge, no matter how wrong it may be.

If you’ve ever been forced to try a case where critical challenged facts are proven by evidence admitted via hearsay exception, you can appreciate how devastating this situation can be.  No matter how hard you stare at a piece of paper, the writing doesn’t change.  No matter how inaccurate the content of that writing may be, it remains a untouchable testament.  And if a defendant is entitled to due process, then Scalia’s interpretation of the Confrontation Clause returns a crucial right to its place in the due process arsenal.  Regardless of how we got back there, it’s clearly one of the best things to come out of the Supremes for the purpose of defending against false accusations.

What this issue should remind us, however, is how a constitutional right, with a relatively clear purpose well-grounded in reason and practice, gets muddled up over the years as court after court fashions facile exceptions until the rule is rendered meaningless.  Crawford was the exception, with the Court returning the rule to its roots.  What’s become of search and seizure under the 4th Amendment, for example, informs us of just how much damage courts can do over time. chipping away bit by bit until there is no rule left.

And Heidgen Sits and Waits (Update)

One of my earliest posts at Simple Justice was about Martin Heidgen, the first person to be convicted of murder for having driven drunk. The results of his conduct were horrible.


His actions resulted in a horrific crash with a limousine driving a wedding party, and resulted in the deaths in the limo driver, Stanley Rabinowitz, 59, and flower girl Katie Flynn, age 7.It is impossible to forget the image of Katie’s mother holding the severed head of her daughter afterwords.Let there be no mistake, this was a tragedy of untold proportions.

But horrible results don’t dictate the crime.  It’s all about the conduct, not the outcome, and the Heidgen case was an extreme example of prosecutorial overreaching.  The problem is that Heidgen was sentenced on Wednesday, February 28, 2007.  The appeal has yet to be decided.  The appellant’s brief has yet to be perfected.  More than two years have elapsed, all the while Martin Heidgen sits in prison serving his 18 year sentence as a murderer.

Much has happened since Heidgen’s conviction.  The case of Alberia Valencia was decided by the Appellate Division, Second Department, the same court that will hear Heidgen’s appeal.  There, the court rejected the “depraved indifference” theory of assault upon which the conviction rested, the same theory (though applied to second degree murder) that was used against Heidgen.  Valencia was sentenced on February 23, 2007, five days before Heidgen. 

Heidgen was represented at trial by Stephen LaMagna, who I noted at the time was way over his head in a case of this magnitude.  But following the conviction, he was unwilling to let go of his grip on this high profile murder case.  More than two years later, LaMagna is nowhere to be found.  What exactly happened is unknown, but two things are clear. No appeal has been completed and Martin Heidgen is now been appointed an 18b lawyer, Sergey Mikhlin from Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn.  Ironically, Mikhlin was a Nassau County ADA until 2007, perhaps overlapping his time as a prosecutor when his client was being prosecuted by his own office.

Based upon Mikhlin’s website, his practice seems to be geared toward doing drunk driving cases for the Russian community.  What experience he has in appellate work or murder cases is wholly unclear.  On a promotional website called , Mikhlin highlights his work on “Criminal Law, Drunk Driving & DUI Law, Traffic Law.”  He’s obviously got enough extra time to do an occasional indigent appeal.

In an effort to find out what became of LaMagna, and the status of the appeal, I tried to contact Mikhlin but received no response.  This is troubling in a case where the legal ramifications of an appeal are so enormous, with so many questions unanswered and so much time lost. 

Many people wonder how the law goes so far astray at times.  Perhaps what’s happened in the Heidgen case provides an answer.  While it was front page news, the lawyer representing Heidgen was too caught up with enjoying the high profile to recognize that he was over his head and needed help.  He flew solo, and lost.  Then comes the promised appeal, and the case falls off the radar until the hard work gets done.  In the meantime, the money runs out, and the thrill of being in the newspapers wears off.  The lawyer quietly bails out of the case, leaving the now indigent defendant to dangle in the wind.  In his place is an attorney of unknown experience in appellate or serious criminal work.  It’s now up to this new lawyer to carry the ball.

Will Sergey Mikhlin be up to the job of handling the Heidgen appeal?  Who knows.  A case of this magnitude, this importance, and not only is it far behind schedule, but it’s almost entirely a shot in the dark at this point.  And that’s how the law goes wrong. Twice. 

And so, along with Martin Heidgen, we all sit and wait.  No matter how horrible the outcome of Heidgen’s drunk driving, this murder conviction must be reversed.

Update:  Information has since been obtained via the Nassau County Assigned Counsel Plan that Mehklin is no longer on the case, but that his assignment was not for the primary appeal but an ancillary proceeding.  No one knew what that proceeding might be, unfortunately.

As to the primary appeal, I know understand that Heidgen is being privately represented by Jillian Harrington of  Rochman Platzer Fallick Sternheim Luca & Pearl in Manhattan.  So why have more than two years elapsed without an appellant’s brief?  A darn good question, and I look forward to finding out the answer.

Dear Sir, Please Help Me

While criminal defense lawyers have long been the recipients of letters from “innocent” prisoners seeking their help, email in conjunction with the culture of free legal advice has generated a new phenomenon that, while similar in some ways, is far more dangerous and potentially ruinous.  The blind email with full blown explanation of their “crimes”.  I get these almost daily, and it scares me.

In a post yesterday, I referenced a problem with the type of client who cruises twitter in search of a lawyer.  While less accurate for more obscure practice areas, one has to wonder why someone would need to scour social media in search of a lawyer engaged in one of the more common practice areas, contracts or criminal defense, for example.  There are a ton of them out there, and one can barely walk down the block without tripping over a lawyer.  As for finding a good one, a twit is hardly a basis for a recommendation.  Nor is a website, all of which tout their owner as the next best thing to slice bread no matter what the actual competency might be.

One source of the problem as it’s come across my computer is Avvo, which inspires people to ask people they don’t know for free answers, with the assumption that it’s there for the taking.  I get a ton of calls from people who have found me on Avvo, not one of which has ever produced a case that I was interested in taking and almost invariably from people who have no funds to retain counsel in any event.  This comes as no surprise, given the header on Avvo’s website reads “Find a lawyer. Free legal advice. Lawyer ratings. Avvo.”  The suggestion is about as clear as it could be.

But it’s the emails that shock and disturb me.  Emails from people I don’t know, and who don’t know me, disclosing their deepest secrets.  Telling me all about what’s happened to them, and what they’ve done.  Why would anyone send an email to another person they don’t know revealing such things about themselves?  Because I’m a lawyer?  Is that alone sufficient reason to feel comfortable confessing their secrets?

Brian Tannebaum at My Law License, has a little fun with the latest edition of Super Burgers Lawyers, a stroke of marketing genius designed to suck cash from lawyers desperate to have something hard to prove their worthiness.


But in Gainesville, Florida, apparently two Super criminal defense lawyers, are prosecutors.

Yes, Alachua County Assistant State Attorney Jim Colaw is a Super criminal defense lawyer, devoting 100% of his practice to criminal defense. Only problem is that he’s a prosecutor, and always has been I hear.

Not to be out done, Gainesville Federal Prosecutor Francis (Frank) Williams, is also a Super Duper criminal defense lawyer.

Most troubling, is that the way I verified these two were prosecutors, was by checking the Florida Bar website. Super Lawyers, did check this website, I trust? Colaw’s email address is “sao8” as in “State Attorney’s Office 8th Circuit, and Williams email is the well known “usdoj.gov” that is assigned to all federal prosecutors. They, work at the United States Department of Justice.

Does this demonstrate a monumental failing with Superlawyers?  You betcha.  All the protestations by the cashiers at Superlawyers won’t change this flagrant screw up and make them credible, but then the lawyers who use something like this marketing gimmick to sell themselves already know that it’s only purpose is to market.  No one wins a case by telling the jury that they’re a Superlawyer.

On the other hand, what of the poor, desperate fellow who comes across this “accolade” and believes it’s real?  What if he emails his confession to a federal prosecutor?  Even though I will not become involved in these blind email proposals, I would never rat out the sender, despite the fact that there is no attorney/client relationship created.  A prosecutor isn’t likely to share my feelings.  Should he receive an email disclosing an act of violence or harm committed against another, chances are awfully good that he’s going to take that email and put it to good use.  And there’s no reason why he shouldn’t.

I am not a fan of the concept of using the internet to blindly thrash about in search of a lawyer to begin with.  From the clients’ perspective, you are as likely to find the right lawyer this way as you are to find the right stock to purchase by throwing a dart.  Maybe less so. 

From the lawyers’ perspective, the people searching for lawyers online are the ones who can’t find a lawyer through ordinary channels, the predominant reason being that they don’t have the ability to retain counsel and are searching for that one great lawyer who will take him on pro bono.  If you’re searching for pro bono work, one twit to that effect ought to keep you busy for a lifetime.  If you have to work for a living, however, this isn’t going to be the route you want to take.  People who can afford counsel are not usually constrained to search very hard to find a lawyer.

I’ve no delusion that anything I write will stop defendants from seeking out lawyers willing to take on their cause for free.  Indeed, it could happen, as we would all be happy to serve the higher cause in those rarest of rare cases, where an innocent person is imprisoned and we can truly help.  But no, most of us will not go diving into cases (especially in far flung jurisdictions, a point ignored by most emailers who neglect to mention that they are in jail on the other side of the country) blindly, and you emails will not result in lawyers rushing to your rescue.

But whatever you do, please don’t tell your story to anyone you don’t know.  The recipient may very well be a “Superlawyer”, but one who works for the other side.  And believe me, he won’t help you.

Compromise, And Other Bad Ideas

At a very young age, we’re taught to get along with others.  It’s a fine lesson for the age and circumstance, but as we mature, we need to recognize that not everything mommy told us turns out to be a universal truth.  Some never do.

For some time now, the leading advocate for young lawyers, Dan Hull, has pursued an aggressive agenda designed to enlighten them to some of the more useful, but less pleasant, realities of the practice of law.  Not the least of which is that there is no such thing as work/life balance when it comes to providing excellence to clients. 

This has raised the ire of the Slackoisie, the lot of which has whined incessantly about why it can’t have everything to which they feel entitled.  Rather than look toward their professionalism, responsibility, duty, all dirty words to Generation Y, they seek the magic bullet that will enable them to achieve success in the absence of inconvenient effort.  A leader in this effort, like a pig sniffing out truffles, was the host of this week’s Blawg Review, Adrian Dayton.

Adrian used his moment in the sun to promote two concepts, the first being twitter. 



One day one of the individuals I was following on Twitter sent a message or “tweet” that changed the direction of my professional life.


“Does anybody know a contracts attorney?”  Was the message.  There I was, a young associate practicing Corporate Law, so I responded.


Within 48 hours our New York firm had a Texas client, the client paid the retainer by credit card, and all communications were conducted by email and phone.  Not only had I found a new legal client on Twitter- it was almost too easy. Over the next few weeks I tested out multiple searches, and was blown away by how many individuals and companies were on Twitter asking about legal services.  Then I started developing a system to find the leads on Twitter and other social media platforms and turn them into clients.


It’s a wonderful anecdote, not so much to prove Adrian’s point but to show the failure of anecdotes to prove their purported point.  One case does not a practice make.  There are many lawyers out there.  The streets are littered with them.  Why would Adrian’s Texas client need to twit to ask blindly for a lawyer?  It suggest that the client can’t find anyone locally who would deal with them.  Perhaps they’ve gone through all the local lawyers and been tossed out on their butt, whether for being unduly annoying, demanding or cheap.  But something is wrong when a client has to twit to find a lawyer, and will give up a credit card number to any lawyer with a twitter account.

On the flip side, what client would want to find a lawyer on twitter?  A desperate one, no doubt, since there is no possibility that the client could have any sense of competency in his counsel.  There is nothing one can say in 140 characters that would provide an adequate showing of skill to justify retention as a lawyer to any but the worst conceivable client. 

Adrian thinks he’s discovered a panacea.  In reality, he’s discovered a trap for the unwary.  Worse still, nowhere in his paradigm does he concern himself with what to do with a client once he’s got one.  This is perhaps the greatest failing of the focus of the Slackoisie, where they demonstrate no comprehension that they are lawyers, not soap salesmen.  Nowhere does Adrian mention anything about honing his skills, providing excellent representation, serving his clients.  It’s all about getting the credit card number. 

Left to his own devices, he would have us all become the Alexis Neely’s of the internet, vessels filled with disgustingly sweet goo, utterly devoid of substance.  Spouting words without meaning, I’m left to wonder whether the Slackoisie has the slightest clue what substance is?  I suspect some do, playing the Adrian Dayton’s for their available cash to get them to jump on board the newest, shiniest bandwagon to quick and easy happiness.  They keep selling “secrets”, and the children keep believing that there really are secrets to happiness, just as they believed in Pretty Ponies and Unicorns before that.

That the Slackoisie have a different view of life is neither surprising nor a matter of deep concern in itself; it has long been common for youth to believe that everyone who came before them is an ignorant Luddite, and only they possess a clear vision, unmuddled by convention.  As if nobody before them ever thought of a new way to do something.

While some demand their due, that the world rotate on its axis to make their lives more special and wonderful, others whine about the need for their elders to “understand” them.  They want to sit down and negotiate a truce of sorts, where we can hash out our differences and reach a compromise.  They have found an ally in Diane Levin at Mediation Channel,  As a mediator, every disagreement is an opportunity “bridge the gap.”  If Diane was a hammer, every disagreement would look like a nail.


After describing the rancorous arguing that has ensued between members of different generations of lawyers, Dayton, a Gen Y lawyer, observes:

What does that tell us? That there is a real conflict – and lack of understanding – on both sides. The biggest message I took away from it was that we’d better figure each other out – we’re going to be together for a while.

Dayton has thus signaled his willingness to bridge the generation gap. So what about his counterparts on the other side?


 There’s nothing to mediate.  There are no “counterparts”.  If the Slackoisie don’t like the lifestyle at Biglaw, reject the billable hour demands, want to go without undergarments, let ’em.  It’s no skin off our nose.  They can have anything they want; they just can’t have it on our dime.  No one has a gun to their head, forcing them to work 2300 billable hours a year.  Every one of them, every single one, is free to hang out his own shingle at any moment. 

As far as Biglaw’s “needs” are concerned, who cares.  There are still plenty of young lawyers who want to earn as much money as possible. And more significantly, the Biglaw model has crashed anyway, and they are far more likely to disappear in the next few years than hire the next class of money-hungry wannabes.  So don’t worry about the pressures of Biglaw, as it won’t be there anyway.

But when you go to work for someone, you will be expected to earn your keep.  Lawfirms don’t exist to provide you with a corner office and BMW so you can leave early and drink Jello shots with your buds.  When the going gets tough, no one needs a lawyer who leaves the office whenever they have something more fun to do.  And stop telling us how wonderful your work is.  It’s not.  That you disagree is immaterial, as you aren’t in a position to judge your competence.  It takes years of hard work and experience to improve the quality of your work to the point where your efforts merit your self-assessed kudos.  Some never improve.  Most never achieve excellence.  It’s not that easy to do.

Surrounding yourselves with others who similarly whine and believe in magic bullets isn’t going to turn day into night, or you into lawyers.  Even if you could use twitter to get enough clients, good clients, paying clients, to maintain a practice, you wouldn’t have the capacity to serve them.  And don’t throw up an anecdote about how one young lawyer somewhere did a really good job.  The reason the story gets told is that it’s so rare.  It won’t happen to you because you really, really want it to.

The thought is embodied in this letter from a former youngster who learned a little something along the way.


For having lived long, I have experienced many instances of being obliged by better information, or fuller consideration, to change opinions even on important subjects, which I once thought right, but found to be otherwise. It is therefore that the older I grow, the more apt I am to doubt my own judgment, and to pay more respect to the judgment of others.
There is no argument to be had here.  There is merely a learning curve that the Slackoisie has yet to climb.  There is nothing to mediate, nor a gap to be filled.  We all want to live in our wonderful fantasy land, where clients with loads of money troll twitter for lawyers to give it to without any demands that they perform services that might interfere with the kids little league games or dinner with our best friends forever. 

Oddly, clients have similar thoughts, where they retain counsel wholly dedicated to their cause, night and day, fully prepared to drop everything at a moments notice to put in 36 hours of work in every 24 hour period.  They expect lawyers to know all the magic secrets too, but not the same ones that Adrian dreams about.  The magic bullets clients dream about are the ones that win their cause, do so swiftly and at a fraction of the cost (if any cost at all) they might otherwise be charged.  So whose dreams are more worthy?

Adrian’s second Blawg Review theme are his 12 Virtues, “that will make our world a better place to live.”  That’s nice.

Another Independence Day Parade

I find myself sitting in a hotel room in Dallas this 4th of July, wondering whether it’s worth another stab at an uplifting post about the promise of liberty and freedom.  Two years ago, I felt that it was.  Last year, not so much.  Being in Dallas, a misbegotten pseudo-city in the Sovereign Republic of Texas, doesn’t help.

My less than optimistic perspective last year was largely due to the state of the economy and the state of the American psyche.  We faced hard economic times and, in a peaceful regime change, replaced one set of folks who produced a lot of problems for this country with another set of folks who haven’t figured out how to fix the problems of their predecessors.  My assumption last year was that an America concerned with keeping a job wasn’t an America concerned with higher order problems.  Abe Maslow had it nailed down.

But what’s really bothering me this year, this 4th of July, is that we’re still us.  Dan Hull at What About Clients? has pointed out too many times to count that we’re still a young country.  He’s right, but how long can we use that excuse?  There has to come a time when we grow up, open our eyes and stop substituting the fantasy of platitudes for the reality that surrounds us.  We’ve now had 233 years to get it right. 

The word last year was “change”.  It served President Obama well, as it galvanized the dissatisfaction that permeated America.  But it’s a negative concept, that we don’t like where we are.  It tells us nothing of where we should be going.  As it turns out, “change” in the current lexicon doesn’t mean a whole lot, as we seem to be doing much of the same as we were doing before.  Frankly, I never thought otherwise. 

I’ve just lived through too many elections to believe that shifts in regime mean shifts in America.  I watch in faint amusement as Judge Sonia Sotomayor is castigated by Republicans as a liberal, when she would have made a fine selection had her name been put in the hopper by President George W. Bush.  It’s not a positive sign.   We’re fighting to keep our head above water, as if that’s the best we can hope to do.  It’s not enough, really.

As another Fourth goes by, and my mind turns to barbecued ribs, I find myself thinking about the young lawyers who comment here, who have so many more answers than I do to the pressing concerns of the day.  I remember when I had the clarity of my convictions, before I came to the realization that very few things pan out in reality quite the way they’re supposed to or we think they should.  But youth brings the optimism of future potential.  Experience brings the cynicism of past disappointment.  Last year was a disappointing one in many ways.

It’s not that I want to be disappointed in how little forward progress we achieved, but that I don’t feel like I have enough time left on earth to hide my head in the sand and pretend that everything is going to work out.  Too often, it doesn’t work out.  At least not well. 

But there is a bright side to all this.  Many of us, myself included, will keep on plugging away, despite our less than optimistic perspective and our heightened skepticism that today’s choices will prove any better than yesterday’s.  I will do this because I refuse to give up.  Not on people.  Not on the United States of America.  Not on the Fourth of July.

So as I sit here trying to muster something patriotic, perhaps even stirring, to say, the best I can come up with at the moment is that I wish I was out of Dallas and back in America.  And if we all do heavier lifting, starting today, perhaps next year we can look back with pride at our accomplishments and look forward with hope that we are moving forward in achieving our promise.

A Win Too Late

The prosecution of Lori Drew in the Myspace suicide case of Megan Meier was a test of the American system of criminal justice.  It’s fitting on this Fourth of July to grade ourself.  How did we do?

Well before the trial, the defense moved to dismiss the indictment, which charged Drew with violating the  Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 USC §1030, for creating a false Myspace account.  While many found it impossible to divorce the disgust they felt toward Drew for her manipulation of a teenager, ultimately driven to commit suicide, the legal issues raised by the government’s imaginative use of the CFAA had disastrous implications.

Judge George Wu reserved decision on the motion.  The case went to trial.  Lori Drew was convicted of three misdemeanor counts of intentionally accessing a computer in violation of the terms of service.  The motion to dismiss remained undecided. 

On July 2nd, Drew was finally to be sentenced.  She wasn’t.  Instead, Judge Wu announced that he would be filing a written decision acquitting her of the charges, notwithstanding the verdict.


U.S. District Judge George Wu said he was acquitting Lori Drew of misdemeanor counts of accessing computers without authorization but stressed the ruling was tentative until he issues it in writing. He noted the case of a judge who changed his mind after ruling.

She was convicted in November, but the judge said that if she is to be found guilty of illegally accessing computers, anyone who has ever violated the social networking site‘s terms of service would be guilty of a misdemeanor. That would be unconstitutional, he said.

“You could prosecute pretty much anyone who violated terms of service,” he said.

And when the written decision is filed, assuming Judge Wu, who has been known to change his mind doesn’t have a change of heart, the case will come to its conclusion.  Unless the government decides to appeal. 

Some commentaries applaud Judge Wu’s decision, despite the widespread disgust with Lori Drew’s conduct on a moral level.  I do as well.  But I am less sanguine about its timing.  As I wrote at the time of trial:


No person should be put on trial if the accusation against her fails to constitute a crime under the law.  Trial is a nightmarish experience for any defendant, and that’s why a defendant moves to dismiss an indictment before trial, to avoid this experience if the allegations, even if proven, do not constitute a crime.  It is a threshold issue, and it requires a threshold determination.

Judge Wu has now tried judicial roulette, to see if the jury would remove the heavy burden of deciding the reserved motions so he wouldn’t have to.  He lost.  I agree with Gideon that it’s past time for the judge to do his job.  And having dropped the ball once, I hope he won’t do so again. 

With so many people watching the case, and already way too many embarrassing moments for the legal system, it’s time for Judge Wu to earn his keep.  Whether Lori Drew does probation makes little difference to most of us.  Whether Judge Wu does his job is critical.
It’s good that Judge Wu has apparently reached the correct result.  It’s not so good that a pre-trial motion to dismiss was left undecided while a defendant went to trial and verdict.  Most notably, Judge Wu’s explanation for his decision, which will no doubt be fleshed out in loftier language when it appears all dolled up for the books, is what we’ve been saying since the day the indictment was announced.  It was obvious to so very many all along.  It was the subject of innumerable commentaries, article, discussions and rants.  And yet it continued to go undecided while Lori Drew’s case was tried.

Is all well that ends well?  Certainly, it’s better to end well than end badly.  But this is not a simple dance, engaging the government in the system, and it’s many moving parts are all supposed to work properly.  It’s not sufficient that at the very end of the process, we finally obtain the result desired.  Not for a system that is supposed to deal with the lives of real people.

This is where so many who are deeply concerned with the more existential aspects of law fall short.  There are real lives involved in the process, and these lives are often destroyed by the process itself, regardless of outcome.  Financial ruin was an “extraordinary evil” when done by Bernie Madoff.  Is it better when done at the hands of the criminal justice system?  The trauma of prosecution and trial is a nightmare, but it’s no less a nightmare when you find out after it’s completed that there was never a crime to begin with.

Judge George Wu, on the date he set to sentence Lori Drew, acquitted her instead.   Perhaps this was his way of sentencing her to the hell of the criminal justice system, then ending it all at the very last second for the benefit of the rest of us?  This too would be wrong, and I would not impute any secret motive to Judge Wu’s timing.  But his timing sucks. 

The decision ultimately reached is clearly the right one.  It seemed painfully obvious to the rest of us that there could be no other correct decision.  And indeed, as obvious as it sounds when said by Judge Wu is as obvious as it has been all along.  So why didn’t Judge Wu do his job and decide the motion before letting all the wheels of justice grind?

This case was a test of the American criminal justice system.  It was the right decision unduly delayed.  First do the harm and then try to undo it.  Despite our many platitudes, like justice delayed is justice denied, the saving grace of the Lori Drew acquittal is that too often, if not most often, we don’t even end up with the right decision, making it almost disingenuous to complain that it should have issued before putting Drew to the test of trial.

This case turns out to be one of the better ones for our system.  And thus, it barely passes the test.  Just barely.