Author Archives: SHG

Why Olson’s “Better Shake” Is Mostly For The Wealthy

When the Supremes decided Forest Grove v. TA last week, it struck me as a sound statutory interpretation decision, removing an unintended barrier from the path of children obtaining a free appropriate public education.  The Court held that a student could obtain reimbursement for private education for a learning disabled child who not been part of a district’s special education program first.

While it’s not surprising that school districts, faced with special education as an unfunded mandate, found the decision unpalatable.  They were constrained to pay the freight, which came from budgets that were already tight and subject to the ever increasing demands of teacher contracts and the beloved step increases.  But they weren’t the only ones troubled.

Walter Olson, from Overlawyered, usually has quite a good feel for such issues.  But this time, he wasn’t persuaded.  Quoted by San Francisco Chronicle columnist Debra Saunders, Olson said: 


Walter Olson of overlawyered.com nailed the problem with the majority ruling when he opined in an e-mail, “The impulse to get a better shake for one’s kid is universal, but it’s disproportionately wealthy and clever parents, with their hired lawyers and experts, who succeed in using these rules to obtain a private school education at public expense. In this case, the question was whether parents should at least try the public schools’ proffer of special-ed services before declaring them inadequate, which doesn’t seem to me to be too much to ask.”
Walter’s beef raises two issues, both warranting some discussion.  The larger issue, why parent’s shouldn’t have to “try” public school programs before “declaring them inadequate” seems perfectly reasonable on its face, but reflects that same sort of theoretical misunderstanding that we so often find in Supreme Court decisions on criminal law issues.  It’s a view that’s disconnected from harsh reality, whether it’s the reality of life on the streets or life in the classroom.

For those whose view of special education is from a distance, learning disabled kids all look pretty much the same.  As any parent of a learning disabled child will be happy to tell you, at great length, is that no two are the same.  While they tend to use the same handful of diagnoses to categorize and pigeonhole them, mostly for lack of better or more specific explanations, the range of disabilities and severity has wild swings.  Their needs differ enormously, in ways that can, and have, filled tomes of academic and medical studies.  The one thing that parents, as well as neuropsychologists, understand is that there is no such thing as the panacea of special education.

Schools, on the other hand, have some hard constraints.  There is only so much money, room, personnel and understanding available to deal with children with special educational needs.  Because of this, they use the “panty-hose method,” or one size fits all.  A district with a particularly good program, and there are some, will be able to adequately educate a middle ground of learning disabled students this way, those with moderately severe disabilities of a generalized sort.  Never a great solution, but FAPE doesn’t promise perfection.

But the panty-hose method is worthless for those students whose disabilities fall outside the “norm”, though there really is no norm except in the minds of public school educators.  As for those districts whose programs are just awful, more like going through the motions of putting the LD kids in the same classroom to keep them away from the “normal” kids while offering a teacher who uses small words spoken in a loud voice, as if that was a viable pedagogical method, they can kiss any chance at a future goodbye.  This is babysitting under the guise of special ed. 

What becomes brutally clear very quickly to parents is how inappropriate these programs can be for their children.  In this context, inappropriate can range from the conflicting mix of disabilities found in a single classroom to the flagrantly clueless special ed teacher to the contra-indicated teaching methodologies.  Bear in mind, districts tend to have one, maybe two at most, special ed classes per grade.  All the special needs students are thrown in together, despite the fact that they may have diametrically opposed needs.  To use an analogy that people who have never actually held a learning disabled child’s hand will understand, it’s like putting a first grader and a high school senior in the same classroom, and telling them to have a nice day.

Walter’s question is why not give it a try, at least.  Aside from the fact that it is often obvious from the outset that some public school special ed programs offer no educational benefit, Walter ignores a very basic, very real problem for parents and children:  You only get one chance to be a child.  There is no “do-over” for childhood.  A year of school lost to worthless program is lost forever.  To a child, a year is forever. 

To an LD child, it’s the waste of an opportunity to improve one’s condition that we cannot afford to lose.  They need every year to count, to improve their education, understanding, life.  These children already function at a deficit, and need education more than “normal” children if they are going to survive, contribute and enjoy a relatively normal life.  They can’t afford to lose a year just to give  the school district’s a shot.  This isn’t a game for learning disabled students.  This is their one chance at having a life, and it’s not something to squander cavalierly.

As to Walter’s second issue, why the wealthy seem to be the ones most likely to take advantage of the law enabling learning disabled students to obtain reimbursement to private, specialized schools, his point is well-taken, but easily, and unfortunately, explainable.  There are a handful of specialized schools that provide life-changing education for learning disabled students, and they cost a fortune, if you are lucky enough to get a place.  If I was to guesstimate, there is one seat for every thousand children who would benefit from these schools.  They tend to be very small, very specialized and very, very good at what they do.  But it costs a bundle to provide this type of education to this small handful of students.

This sets up two financial obstacles that give rise to Walter’s issue.  The first is the cost of litigation, when the school district refuses to place an LD student in a private school.  The mechanics of a due process hearing under the IDEA take quite a while to reach fruition, meaning that the administrative proceedings that a parent must go through just to get to an “impartial hearing officer” (as they are called, to be distinguished from the “partial hearing officer” otherwise used by school districts), without even touching the issue of appeals, requires that a parent have substantial resources to pay an education law attorney. 

This isn’t a contingent fee situation; the attorneys get paid for their services, and there is no assurance that the parent will win in the end.  Indeed, many hearing officers have “heard it all before” and have lost any particular sensitivity to the needs of children.  So the parent must not only have the ability to pay a lawyer, but the ability to lose whatever money has been paid in the case of an adverse outcome. 

The time frame for these hearings essentially costs parents a year at minimum, which gives rise to the second expense.  Assuming a parent is fortunate enough to get a place for his child in an appropriate private school, the next step is to enroll the child and pay the private school bill while simultaneously maintaining the action against the school district.  This means that the parent must front the cost of the private school and seek reimbursement, rather than payment, of the costs.  This happens while the parent is paying the lawyer to challenge the district’s placement.  There is a huge amount of money at risk, and in the event a parent who is not possessed of substantial wealth loses, it could bankrupt a family.  Bear in mind, families may well have other children who suffer for the lack of funds used to pay the private school and lawyer in the hope of reimbursement.

So why is it the wealthy who end up being the movers in these cases?  Because no one else can afford to do it.  The wealthy make the fight so that others, whose children are every bit as deserving of a real education, can hopefully benefit from their efforts.  The problem isn’t that the wealthy seem to disproportionately benefit, but that the non-wealthy are precluded from obtaining a FAPE for their children by a system that makes it financially untenable for them to do so.  It’s not for lack of desire
, but lack of cash in the face of a system that is shockingly onerous, time-consuming and expensive.

It’s fair to say that most parents of learning disabled children want their babies to have a real shot at being educated and growing up to live a happy life.  It’s probably fair to say that most people think that’s what schools ought to be providing.  That it’s our public schools that are so often the impediment to this is the real shame.  It shouldn’t require a legal team and a wealthy parent to challenge the school district’s panty-hose methods, just as schools should show far greater comprehension of their mission than to just pigeonhole learning disabled students in a classroom at the back of the school building. 

For now, decisions like Forest Grove are necessary to compensate for the failure of public schools to provide a free appropriate public education to learning disabled students.  Great minds like Walter’s would be better put to fixing the problem with public schools than questioning the ad hoc methods of parents to obtain an education for their child.

Running to Lose

The big race for District Attorney will be in Manhattan, where the candidates scramble to fill the very large, and very old (but well maintained), shoes of Robert Morgenthau.  There are other races as well, but they won’t receive the same level of interest.  One such race is in Nassau County, where controversial District Attorney Kathleen Rice is up for re-election.

Rice rode into office on the coattails of Democratic County Supervisor Tom Suozzi, ousting long-time Republican District Attorney Denis Dillon, who spent far too much time concerned about women having control over their bodies to worry about some out-of-town upstart who lacked any apparent qualifications to serve.  In Nassau County, having the Republican Party line was all one needed to get elected.  That all changed with Suozzi.  Well, actually with Republican Party leader Joe Mondello, but that’s another story.

The Republicans are running Joy Watson for District Attorney, a long-time ADA under Dillon who served as Chief of Sex Crimes.  She is now the principal law clerk to Nassau Supreme Court Justice Karen Murphy.  I don’t know her, but my dear friend, who occasional comments here as The Blind Guy, speaks very well of her.  While she’s got one huge mountain to climb, given the current political climate, he tells me that Watson is running for real.

Hoping to learn a little bit more about the race, I did a bit of checking.  I was stunned by what I found.  No, nothing shocking about Joy Watson, but a tidbit in one of the local throw-away papers, the Floral Park Dispatch.




Anthony Colleluori Is Libertarian Party’s Candidate



The Nassau County Libertarian Party has named Anthony “Tony” Colleluori as their nominee for Nassau County District Attorney.


Colleluori stated that he will run his campaign highlighting his experience as a defense attorney and civil rights litigator for over 25 years. Issues which he says are his priorities include “ending the excessively punitive prosecutions against DWI suspects, cutting wasteful spending, videotaping all confessions, and de-prioritizing the prosecution of marijuana possession.”


Colleluori is sole partner of his law firm Colleluori & Associates. He is a longtime Nassau County resident presently living in Woodbury with his wife Mary Rose. They have two children Salvatore and Franklin.
I wasn’t aware that there was a Libertarian Party in Nassau County.  Then again, I wasn’t aware there could be such a thing as a “sole partner” by definition.  Go figure.  Tony is a major user of social media, occasionally blogging as That Lawyer Dude and twitting up a storm under the same name.  He works Avvo Answers, with 504 “answers” as of this writing. On Avvo, he calls himself the “senior partner,” though one would have to have a junior partner for that to make sense.  Tony has worked very hard to craft an online persona for the purpose of promoting his practice. 

And now Tony is running for District Attorney on a minor party line.  What is he thinking?

Clearly, he’s got no chance of winning, so he’s running to lose.  Why would someone run to lose?  There are two possible answers.  The first is that he hopes to have a hand in framing the discussion for the campaign.  Rather than have Rice and Watson slug it out over who’s going to lock more people away, Tony will inject alternative views into the rhetoric, providing a counterbalance to the fear-mongering that typifies District Attorney races. 

The second possible reason is that it’s an opportunity to promote his law practice by using the campaign as a self-promotional marketing opportunity.  The benefit here is that if you know you’re guaranteed to lose, there’s no harm to the campaign by using it for personal gain.

Reason number 1 is a very good reason to run for office, even though you know that you have no chance of winning.  Reason number 2 is cynical and manipulate.  Well-intended supporters of the Libertarian Party will donate their time and money to help promote candidates for the benefit of the party’s agenda.  They aren’t doing it so a candidate can get business.

Given how little interest there is in the District Attorney’s race in Nassau County, since Rice and the Democrats are expected to have this election locked up, and even if there is any public discussion on the issues, it will be between the two major party candidates, it’s a huge stretch to imagine that Tony will have much opportunity to contribute to the discussion.  Though tilting at windmills perhaps, it would at least be an honorable effort.  There is something to be said for people willing to tilt at windmills.

If it’s the second reason, then it would be a subversion of the political process and an unfortunate choice, for him and for the criminal defense bar.  It would not be an honorable thing to do. I hope it’s the first reason, Quixotic though it may be, for everyone’s sake.

A Slice of the Health Care Pie

As private health insurers argue their talking points that we’re all going to die from bad health care if the government puts its fingers on the scale, while the cost of their policies rose at a rate of four times the earnings rate of the past 10 years, I had to laugh.  Living with Dr. Simple Justice, a/k/a SWMBO, I’ve come to hear a bit about this world from the other side.

Most private health care providing, those not working on salary, are providers for a number of systems, such as United Healthcare, as well as medicare and/or medicaid.  They have contracts with these HMOs, insurers and the government with require them to agree to their payment terms.  They set the reimbursement rates for medical services, sometimes providing for the patient to pay their deductible or a co-payment.

Since Dr. SJ first opened her shop in 1984, her reimbursement rates have fallen approximately 60%.  In other words, she now receives payment of 40% of what she received way back then for the same health care services.  Every year, she receives a letter from them informing her of what they will be paying for her services.  Each year, the number on the letter is a little lower than it was the year before. 

There’s no one to argue with about the number.  It is what it is.  The choice is to accept patients from that insurer or HMO or government program or not.  When the cost of providing the service exceeds the reimbursement rate, as it has with numerous outfits, she terminates her contract with them and stops taking their patients.  She’s done this a few times. 

If I do say so, Dr. SJ is awfully good at what she does.  She refuses to give her patients the bum’s rush, or put them on expensive equipment and pretend its the same thing as real treatment.  She makes herself available to them when they need her, calls in the evening to explain things again or to talk with family members who are worried about their parents or children.  It’s all part of the job.  It’s not reimbursable. 

When she first opened shop in 1984, we leased a bunch of expensive equipment because she felt that it was necessary to perform treatment in some cases.  The leasing company makes very clear that the only viable way to pay for their leases is to make sure that the equipment is fully utilized.  When managed properly, the equipment becomes a profit center.  When neglected, it’s a very expensive burden. 

Properly managed equipment means that you schedule patients to use it during every available hour.  Sometimes, patients don’t need this equipment, whether be cause the tests aren’t necessary or the treatment isn’t helpful.  The equipment can be used as a placeholder for patients, meaning that they feel as if you’re doing something useful even if you’re not.  Patients don’t argue about tests or equipment; if you tell them that’s what they need, they are happy to comply.  The equipment gets used (and billed), the patients are kept busy without eating up any hands-on time and everybody is happy.  Except it may be totally unnecessary and unhelpful.  Not necessarily harmful, but unhelpful.

Eventually, Dr. SJ got rid of the equipment that she didn’t believe to be beneficial to her patients and only kept the stuff that she thought was really needed.  And then, she only used it when it was appropriate, beneficial to her patients.  Instead of equipment being a profit center, it became an expense as it sat idle if it wasn’t indicated.  She ate the expense rather than use it just to bill it out or keep patients busy.

Most of Dr. SJ’s treatment is hands-on and personal.  This means that her time is what she gives to her patients.  It’s the scarcest resource she has, but it’s also the only resources that proves truly beneficial.  She receives the same reimbursement for her time as someone who spends 12 seconds putting someone on a machine for a half hour.  Her patients get better, and then they go away.

Dr. SJ loves what she does.  I bet she would treat her patients if she wasn’t paid at all, not that I’m suggesting such a thing.  Of course, she also has a swell husband to make sure that the milk money is always there.

Whether the government’s intrusion into the private domain of health care will put the private carriers and HMOs out of business has yet to be seen.  That it will drive costs down in a competitive climate is likely undeniable, at least at first.  Even without executive salaries and perks, it’s unclear that government won’t create a bureaucracy that will eat up money at pace that equals, if not dwarfs, private enterprise.  The fact that it could be done well is no assurance that it will.  The fact the private enterprise has been a disaster makes taking a chance on governmental involvement more palatable.

But with all the money being pumped into the health care industry, Dr. SJ makes a fraction of what she did 25 years ago.  It’s not going to her.  She could play the system, billing for needless tests, using expensive equipment as a profit center and quadrupling up on patients by putting them on unhelpful equipment where she need never actually touch them to make the reduced reimbursement rates less painful, but she won’t. 

I pay for healthcare insurance.  It costs a bloody fortune, and I’ve never come anywhere near using as much in services as I pay out in premiums.  I would prefer to be “self-insured,” but the problem is catastrophic disease or injury, which could swiftly bankrupt anybody.  We’re all just one car crash away from financial and medical ruin.

It’s not just what we pay into the system that matters, but what we get out of the system that counts as well.  Nobody talks about it in real terms.  Some complain about malpractice insurance rates, but they’re not really a problem for Dr. SJ.  She’s never been sued.  This vast amount of money is going somewhere, but it never manages to find its way to her mailbox.  One day, when the checks that come in are less than the checks that go out, I will ask her to pack her bags and enjoy life without health care insurers, HMOs or government programs. 

As people argue about how much money we pump into the system, there’s little understanding of what becomes of that money once it’s paid and where it comes out on the other end.  This isn’t a guessing game around our house.  We know one place where the money isn’t ending up, in Dr. SJs hands.  Lucky she has such a swell husband.

In Dog We Trust?

No, not the pondering of a dyslexic agnostic, but the interesting difference in a police officer’s love of dogs when they’re theirs rather than yours.  From the South Florida Sun Sentinel :


It was 1 a.m. when the doorbell rang at the McDonald family home. Deputies rushed in screaming: “Get down! Get everyone down!”

As the deputies screamed for everyone to get down, two of the McDonald children, 7 and 13, “were panicked, crying, holding onto their father as if their very lives depended upon it,” the lawsuit says.

The McDonalds asked the deputies why they were in their home without a warrant.

After detaining the family for three hours in their home, the deputies left, deciding it was the wrong address.

So why would West Palm Beach deputies do such a thing to a nice family like the McDonalds?


That night, the deputies were investigating a possible car burglary in the 18000 block of Old Princeton Lane, according to a Sheriff’s Office report. Deputies were called when the car’s alarm went off, though nothing was reported missing from the car. The dog unit was called in and led deputies to the McDonald house, according to the report.

The dog said so.  And really, can you argue with a dog?   That’s the question that police are constrained to ask themselves when it’s someone else’s dog that comes playfully running, leaping, barking, as they approach.  Which, naturally, compels the officers to pull out their 9mm and kill the dog, lest the dog harm them with their wagging tail.


More than 10 deputies were involved in the entry. They were investigating a car burglary report and the Sheriff’s Office dog unit led deputies from the crime scene to the home about a mile away on the 10000 block of Crescendo Circle, west of Boca Raton.

The deputies spread throughout the house, some wearing colored goggles, black vests and gloves. One wearing goggles pointed a handgun at Nicolette McDonald, 17, until it touched her chest.

Could those goggles have been rose-colored?  At least when it comes to dogs, they could.  Nicolette McDonald?  Not so much.

This is the point that Radley Balko, chronicler of dog killings, misses:  Police don’t hate dogs.  Police hate your dogs.  They love their own.  In fact, they love them so much that they are prepared to break into your home in the night and shoot your children, if need be, to honor their dogs. 

The police in West Palm Beach say that the McDonalds’ description of the night is untrue.  According to the cops, the McDonalds invited them into their house at gunpoint at 1 a.m. with their 7 and 13 year old children crying.  While some might find the police claims incredible, they should consider the possibility that the McDonalds were deeply concerned that a car thief had slipped in through the lanai room slider and the police were there to protect them.  It could happen, right?

But the question that remains unanswered is what were the cops doing for 3 hours?  While I’m sure the McDonalds have a lovely home in WPB, the chances of its requiring 3 hours to search are, well, slim.  Now it’s possible that with only 10 deputies inside the house, the search might take a little longer than it would with, say, 25, though it might well be that diminishing returns set in with either number. 

In any event, other residents of West Palm Beach should be aware that this potentially disturbing event shouldn’t disrupt their sleep.  When the McDonald’s attorney made a complaint with internal affair,


investigators in May found the claim “unsubstantiated,” records show. The report said despite the family’s assertions, there is no evidence deputies pushed their way into their house, yelled at them or pointed their guns at anyone.
After all, it was the McDonalds’ word against the dog’s.  Who you gonna believe?

H/T Packratt at Injustice Everywhere

The Greenfield Approach to Bernie Madoff

Having spent a fairly good amount of time and energy deconstructing the Madoff case, and the respective positions of Madoff’s lawyer, Ike Sorkin, and AUSA Marc Litt for the government, it’s time to put my own butt on the line with how I would approach the sentence if Judge Denny Chin called for advice.  For the record, he has yet to do so, but the phone lines are open (call me anytime, DC).

The view from the Simple Justice bleachers is that there is little question, in fact no question whatsoever, that Madoff has caused monumental harm by his conduct, demonstrating almost no concern for the damage done to others in the process of creating and perpetuating a scheme that extended so far beyond mere financial gain that it’s truly impossible to imagine a person with the slightest concern for humanity to do so.  While his weapon was investment house statements rather than a gun or a bomb, it was used with the same lack of conscience that a mass murderer or terrorist might, although terrorists usually believe in something beyond themselves.  Bernie believed only in Bernie, and took no prisoners.

Thus, I can find absolutely no saving grace on behalf of Bernard Madoff.  It surprises me deeply that Sorkin didn’t offer any, no less a substantial, basis to show the good works that Madoff performed with the vast wealth he accumulated, to demonstrate the there was something beating in his chest.  I cannot assume it in the absence of evidence.  It similarly surprises me that Sorkin offered no explanation of how Bernie started down the road to perdition, how a small larcenous heart grew to a monstrosity. 

Had I been in Ike Sorkin’s (extremely well paid) shoes, my efforts would have been directed toward humanizing Bernie Madoff, showing the frailties that led an otherwise normal man to engage in conduct that was so terribly wrong, and how the “success” of his larceny fed upon itself in such a way that he couldn’t stop its momentum despite his desire to do so.  Bernie had enough, but couldn’t figure out how to slow down and ultimately conclude the scheme once it took on a life of its own.  But since Sorkin never made that argument, nor offered any evidence in support of it, I will not assume it either.

Clearly, the coverage of this case lends itself to a strong general deterrence argument.  But this is more limited than the government acknowledges.  If Bernie Ebbers’ 25 year sentence doesn’t serve to make the point that financial crimes are taken seriously and will result in far worse than the proverbial “slap on the wrist,” then this sentence isn’t going to do much to change the equation. 

Moreover, there’s a very real question in my mind as to the merit of the general deterrence prong itself.  It’s meant to affect the decision to engage in comparable criminal conduct, and in this particular case, it’s difficult to imagine that there will be any, no less many, who would have the ability to do anything comparable to Bernie Madoff.  Further, it’s fair to question whether the potential sentence has any impact on the decision to engage in a crime, that decision being far more likely made by the expectation of not being caught rather than what happens if and when caught.  While the law assumes that criminals engage in a cost/benefit analysis, my experience is that it just doesn’t work that way. 

That said, the bigger question posed by the sentence of Bernard Madoff is whether a sentence should be imposed that will offer him the potential of ever walking out of prison.  As Jeralyn Merritt astutely noted in one of my favorite concepts, they can’t sentence you to life plus cancer.  Madoff is 71 years old.  How long he will live is a known unknown, and it’s possible that he will not survive any sentence imposed.  If not, then the sentence becomes immaterial to the life of Bernie Madoff.

But it is possible that Madoff will live into his 90s, maybe even to 100.  No doubt his health care to date has been pretty darned good, and this may enable a longer life than most.  Coupled with the mechanics of  a federal sentence, with 57 days off per year for good behavior, plus eligibility for work release a year before his anticipated sentence expiration, plus the potential for time reductions for programs (though nothing comes to mind at the moment assuming he isn’t an alcoholic or drug abuser), it is conceivable that Bernie could one day breath free air despite his age and a severe sentence.  Even a sentence of 25 years could result in his release in 19 to 21 years from now, and it’s quite possible that a 92 year old Madoff will take that long limousine ride back to his Park Avenue digs.

And hence, the bottom line question: Should Madoff ever leave prison alive?

My answer comes down to the distinction between the nature of financial crime and physical harm.  There is, and there must be, a clear delineation between crimes that violate the physical integrity of another human being and crimes that reflect greed.  This is not meant to trivialize financial crimes or the harm suffered by the victims of a Madoff or a Bernie Ebbers, but to distinguish a rape or a murder from the theft of money without any act of violence. 

While greed is an ugly word, it is also one that can be used without stretch with many lawful and commonplace acts.  Greed on a grand scale can cause proportionately grand harm, all the while still being lawful.  We are awash with corporations cheating consumers out of their hard-earned funds by selling shoddy, deceptive merchandise, or charging improper or exorbitant fees, or taking advantage of market forces when it turns in their favor, and cause grave harm to many, all the while engaging in lawful, or at least not prosecutable, conduct. 

As painful as it may be to those victims of Bernard Madoff, similar pain is spread amongst millions of individuals across our nation from losses generated by overarching economic forces.  I reject the comparison to someone who has been raped, maimed or murdered.  It is not the same, and the treatment should not be deemed comparable.

I would impose a sentence of 360 months (30 years for those who aren’t used to the way federal sentences are imposed), resulting in a net sentence of approximately 25 years,    Madoff would likely be released from custody at the age of 96 years old, should he survive.  He could then experience his remaining years as his victims will, in poverty and misery at his own hand.  And if Madoff does not survive to reach his release date, so be it.

The Government’s Turn: Bernie Is Baaaaaad

With sentencing just around the corner, AUSA Marc Litt has filed the government’s sentencing memorandum and argues that Bernie Madoff should get 150 years in prison for his crimes.  There appears to be a wide disparity between Ike Sorkin’s 12 year proposal and the government’s life plus cancer position.

In juxtaposition to Sorkin’s informal and surprisingly short letter memo, Litt submitted a formal memorandum which, for the first time, provides some insight into the real case against Bernie Madoff.  Up to now, reports of Bernie’s crimes have been largely cursory and hyperbolic, without much by way of hard allegations of criminal conduct.  To some extent, the government’s memo finally puts some meat on the bones, though it’s slim pickings given the scope of the crimes.

From next Monday’s (sentencing date) New York Law Journal :


In a 24-page sentencing memorandum, Acting U.S. Attorney for the Southern District Lev L. Dassin, noted that between December 1995 and December 2008, the Ponzi scheme Mr. Madoff, 71, engaged in was “wholesale fraud” causing net losses of $13.2 billion to 1,341 accounts. It characterized his crimes as “serious and long-running, complex and highly orchestrated and devastating to generations of investors around the country and abroad.”

The government’s loss calculations remain somewhat unclear, though largely a product of what it describes as poor record keeping and the duration of the scheme, going back to the 1970s.  Yet $13.2 billion falls short of the initial claim of $50 billion, which was (as anticipated) an exaggeration.  On the other hand, even a $13.2 billion loss dwarfs anything that came before it.  Imagine, who ever thought we would come to the day when a loss was just $13.2 billion?

The more significant aspect of the government’s memo was the opportunity to grasp the “what” and “how” someone could have managed to pull off a scheme of this scope and duration.  Seriously, if strains credulity to believe that someone could create a private brokerage which took in about $170 billion in the course of its existence, without ever actually functioning.  Unfortunately, the scenario remains as vague now as ever.


Madoff had represented to his account holders that they had assets with BLMIS worth approximately $65 billion when, in fact, Madoff had not purchased any securities on their behalf. (emphasis added)


This sentence is astounding.  How is it possible that no one, but no one, knew that Madoff, one of the highest fliers within the securities, was taking in billions and didn’t trade any securities.  “[H]ad not purchased any securities on their behalf” is not the sort of thing that wouldn’t be noticed on the street.  Somebody, somewhere, had to notice that Bernie’s trader was sitting there, sipping lattes, for more than 20 years, while the rest of them were busily buying and selling. 

In fact, given Bernie’s fabulous success, you would think that every house on the street would have someone whose only job was to keep an eagle eye on what Bernie was buying and selling.  They should have known every time a Madoff trader burped.  Yet this went on for more than a generation and it never occurred to anyone that Bernie didn’t hold a single position?  The cursory description of the scheme, unfortunately, provides little insight into how it was possible that this happened.

Litt knocks down the two primary arguments made by Ike Sorkin in support of his request for “justice and objectivity.”  Quickly and easily disposing of the comparison to other white collar frauds, it was noted that the top of the line fraudsters received sentences in the 25 year range, but that their offenses were petty in contrast to Bernie’s based on loss, scope, duration and impact.  This comes as little surprise, given how exposed Sorkin’s argument was (based on an in-house “average” of fraud sentences) to being ripped apart.

The government’s response to the mitigation argument is more interesting.  Whereas Bernie’s claim was the he ultimately came forward, albeit to his sons (who he claimed he knew would immediately run to the government and rat out their father), on his own accord, the answer is that he did so, after more than a generation of running the scheme, only because the collapse of the scheme was imminent and, within days, would be exposed when he lacked the wherewithal to pay out the withdrawals.  In other words, Bernie kinda came clean only when he realized that the game was over.

But there’s another tidbit that further undermines Bernie’s claim to a change of heart.


Specifically, Madoff made plans to distribute to employees, family and close associates the remaining cash that BLMIS had on hand; in fact, $173 million in signed checks were found in his office’s desk drawer.

To the bitter end, according to the government, Bernie was trying to suck the last few pennies out of the scheme.  The government alleges that had the FBI not arrested Bernie when it did, these funds too would have been gone.

In its analysis of the criteria of §3553(a), the government’s emphasis is clearly on general deterrence.  If nothing else comes of Bernie’s crimes, at least the rest of the investment world should see that such massive theft will result in massive punishment.  The other factors, per the government’s reckoning, militate against any leniency toward Madoff, noting that the trail of victims, from elderly individuals to pensions, trusts and charitable organizations, will continue to cause harm for generations.  The government dismisses any concern for Madoff, and focuses instead on how this case should serve to prevent anyone else from doing similar harm.

The question posed shortly after this case broke was whether the amount of loss was a meaningful metric for the determination of a sentence for Bernard Madoff.  After all, this case showed that the same crimes, committed by someone who was simply better at the scheme than others and had far more money available to steal, could ultimately reach stratospheric numbers.  Should sentence proportionality be based on the cash value of the loss, as the Sentencing Guidelines assume, as the correct measure of a sentence?  If he stole 20 times as much as the next guy, should his sentence be 20 times greater?

The prosecution’s argument, which relies ultimately on the Guidelines to frame its request for 150 years in prison, only because life imprisonment (as the Guidelines would “advise”) is not available under the statutory maximum term for any of the offense to which Madoff pleaded guilty, goes far beyond mere dollar figures.  The government makes a very persuasive case for the human side of the loss calculations, that the elderly individuals, pension funds, trusts and charitable organizations represent a flow of harm that will ripple through families, businesses and society.  Forget about the dollar amounts and consider just the people.  No matter how you cut it, the effect is huge, devastating and perpetual. 

As for Bernie, there’s little room for sympathy for the devil.  What’s laid bare in the government’s memo is how he made decisions, cut checks and ate caviar (at least metaphorically) for decades that reflected a depth of amorality of shocking proportions.  It wasn’t simply that Bernie seemed not to be bothered much by his committing crime after crime, day after day, for so very long, but that he was never touched at all by the damage he was doing to so many others in the process. 

Think of it this way: Had Madoff stolen only from the rich, but taken the funds of the Elie Weisel Foundation ($10,680,922) and preserved and invested them, lawfully and properly, he might have had some claim to a limited moral compass.  But he didn’t.  He took without regard to anyone or anything.  He simply took.  Even the myth of John Dillinger reflected a heart, when he returned cash to a customer saying that he only stole from banks.  Dillinger makes Bernie Madoff look evil.

Come June 29th, Southern District Judge Denny Chin will be put to the test of having to answer one of the most difficult sentencing questions posed, what to do with Bernie.  We’ve gotten Ike Sorkin’s take, and now the government’s take.  This means, of course, that you’re probably asking yourself, “so what’s Greenfield’s take?”  Read on, Garth.

Savanna Redding: Almost a Victory. Almost. (Update)

Following the rather strange, borderline bizarre, comments made during oral argument, the odds seemed stacked against Savanna Redding.  Despite a set of facts that strained rational acceptance, from its outset on its path to the Supreme Court, it appeared as if blind deference to school officials, no matter how patently offensive and intrusive and disgusting their decision, would win the day.

The good news is that it didn’t.  Justice Souter, writing for an 8 to 1 majority (with Clarence Thomas dissenting), held that school administrators went over the line when they strip-searched Savanna.

Its indignity does not outlaw the search, but it does implicate the rule that “the search [be] ‘reasonably related in scope to the circumstances which justified the interference in the first place.’ ” T. L. O., supra, at 341. Here, the content of the suspicion failed to match the degree of intrusion. Because Wilson knew that the pills were common pain relievers, he must have known of their nature and limited threat and had no reason to suspect that large amounts were being passed around or that individual students had great quantities. Nor could he have suspected that Savana was hiding common painkillers in her underwear.When suspected facts must support the categorically extreme intrusiveness of a search down to an adolescent’s body, petitioners’ general belief that students hide contraband in their clothing falls short; a reasonable search that extensive calls for suspicion that it will succeed.

And so this means that school administrators should stop forcing teenage girls to bare their genitalia on demand?  No.  It doesn’t say that.  Rather, the best Souter can come up with is that it was unreasonable under the particular facts of this case.  Your daughter’s mileage may vary.

David Bernstein at Volokh was the first to express his disdain for this tepid decision in a post aptly entitled “I’ll say it if Justice Souter Won’t.”

Justice Souter, writing for the Court, stated that the majority meant to cast “no ill reflection” on the school official, assistant principal Kerry Wilson, who ordered the search. Well, it should have. The combination of drug hysteria and the tyranny of petty government officials is rarely a pretty sight.

It’s become increasingly difficult to determine whether the effort to avoid offense is what makes these decisions, even when they ultimately come out on the right side, so distasteful.  Would it kill them to be honest?  Would it destroy the fabric of society to proclaim an assistant principal disgraceful for his rush to strip search a 13 year old girl for anything short of weapon of mass destruction?

And if you thought Souter’s luke-warm, apologist critique of this conduct fell short of the mark, consider Justice Thomas’ dissent:

The majority imposes a vague and amorphous standard on school administrators. It also grants judges sweeping authority to second-guess the measures that these officials take to maintain discipline in their schools and ensure the health and safety of the students in their charge. This deep intrusion into the administration of public schools exemplifies why the Court should return to the common-law doctrine of in loco parentis under which “the judiciary was reluctant to interfere in the routine business of school administration, allowing schools and teachers to set and enforce rules and to maintain order.”

In other words, Thomas would allow petty tyrants to do as they please, holding that courts have no business “second-guessing” their actions.  Did anyone mention to Clarence Thomas that “second-guessing” the actions of government officials is one of the primary reasons we have courts?

While I appreciate Bernstein’s ridicule of Souter’s opinion as much as the next guy, it falls far short of the mark as far as I’m concerned.  It’s not that I disagree with the two points raised, but that this failure runs far deeper than its lack of recognition of drug hysteria and the tyranny of school administrators.  I’ve certainly done my share of complaining about both.

The decision stands for the court’s willfully turning a blind eye to the rights of everyone, students included, to fundamental personal security from those who feel empowered to decide when, how or if we are to be subject to the compulsion of government force.  Whether it’s a 13 year old girl being forced to comply with the orders of an assistant principal, or a 50 year old man being forced to comply with the orders of a beat cop, it doesn’t matter.  Whether it’s a search for ibuprofen, heroin or a switchblade, it doesn’t matter.  There is a reason why our Constitution requires those people who believe themselves empowered by the might of the government to compel people to comply with their orders to present their views to a neutral magistrate first, before simply doing as they please.

This decision merely side-steps this fundamental problem.  By parsing the details, in a particularly egregious case, the Court has managed to eke out the right outcome, but for the wrong reasons.  Ironically, this is where Clarence Thomas gets it right.  The majority, in its effort to be mushy and apologetic, does impose a “vague and amorphous standard.”  A “reasonableness” standard offers no direction, and a reasonableness standard left to the discretion of the very people least inclined to be capable of being reasonable is absurd.  Is Souter suggesting that Kerry Wilson, the same assistant principal that he simultaneously exculpates with his “no ill reflection” comment, was an unreasonable person?  It must be so, as he concluded that Wilson’s decision to strip search Savanna was unreasonable, and hence Wilson’s judgment can’t be trusted.  Yet the decision leaves it up to the Wilson’s of the world to decide what is reasonable?

Given that I had serious doubts that the Supreme Court reach the right outcome, I must say that it’s gratifying to know that eight of our nine top jurists think it’s wrong to strip search a 13 year old girl in a witch hunt for advil.  That will be relief to fathers across the nation.  But I can’t help but wonder what the next excuse for strip searching a 13 year old will be.

To add insult to injury, of course, the Court also held that the administrators can’t be held liable for damages, since “clearly established law” failed to show that this conduct violated the fourth amendment.  In the eyes of a 7-2 majority (Stevens and Ginsburg dissenting), this wasn’t sufficiently outrageous that one would expect the assistant principal and his posse to know that you don’t strip search a 13 year old in search of ibuprofen.  Perhaps the justices are awaiting the anal penetration of a kindergartner before reaching the true measure of outrageous governmental conduct?

Sorry, but despite the outcome on the primary issue, this is a monumentally disappointing decision.

Update:  Scott at Grits for Breakfast has posted about the case (as have many others, of course), but posed an interesting question:

A commenter over at Sentencing Law & Policy wondered, “Is the message that the 4th Amendment is a facts and circumstances question, rather than a clean cut set of doctrines?” IMO that’s exactly the message, and it’s the same one the court’s been sending on the Fourth Amendment for the last 25 years or so.

I believe that what this means is that the court is producing and encouraging result-oriented law, and to that extent I don’t think there’s much to dispute in this case.  But the problem is that 4th Amendment law has tended to be limited to either the creation of ever-increasing exceptions or, when the rare defense decision comes in, it’s a fact-bound decision that precludes easy doctrinal adaptation.  In other words, it’s either a fact-specific decision or it’s a pro-police decision.  Some message, bad or worse.

How Long Before The Plug Gets Pulled?

I have to wonder what went through Edward Trujillo’s mind as his lawyer dozed during his trial.  Did he think to give his lawyer a nudge?  Did he think that he should have hired a lawyer rather than go 18b?  Did he think that he was better off letting his lawyer sleep? 

Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Vincent Del Giudice vacated Trujillo’s conviction after trial for third degree weapons possession based on ineffective assistance of counsel in People v. Irazarry.  On its surface, the decision might be taken as a funny one, comparing New York criminal defense lawyers in low degree felonies with the sleeping lawyers in Texas capital cases.

The lawyer involved, whose name was omitted by Justice Del Giudice but was identified in this Law.com post, Michael Harrison, challenged Trujillo’s allegations of ineffective assistance.


Reached by phone Wednesday, Harrison called his opening statement “very logical and precise.” As for the laughing jurors, he said, “Well, laughter’s very good when you’re looking at many years in prison.” Regarding the allegation that he slept throughout the trial, he added, “That sounds very relaxing.”

Harrison added that “just about everything” alleged in the decision was untrue, and that he intended to “take [the matter] up with the judiciary grievance committee.”

Clearly, Harrison is dismissive of the of claims, which is an interesting approach subsequent to a decision granting a motion to vacate alleging that he not only slept and read a fitness magazine during trial, but that his opening statement and cross-examination was so bad that the jurors laughed at him.  Not with him, but at him. 

But this isn’t a funny decision.  Not for Harrison.  Not for Trujillo.  Not for the rest of us either.  Justice Del Giudice found:


It is very unusual for this court to criticize a member of the bar and I am hesitant to do so in this opinion. This is a learned profession and I appreciate and enjoy watching members of the bar perform their craft. However, during this trial, I found myself very uncomfortable whenever defendant Trujillo’s counsel addressed either a witness or the jury. It was impossible to predict what he was going to say. Based upon all of the foregoing, I conclude that this defendant did not receive the minimum level of representation that is required by law.

It’s unlikely that the judge realized the gravamen of this statement, but it’s quite clear to me.  Justice Del Giudice admits that as he sat there, putatively presiding over a criminal trial in Brooklyn Supreme, he observed a lawyer before him whose conduct failed to meet the minimum level of representation required under New York law.  And he did nothing.

In New York, ineffective assistance of counsel isn’t based on Strickland v. Washington, as it is under federal law, but rather People v. Baldi.  It requires that counsel provide “meaningful representation,” without requiring the prejudice prong of Strickland.  If the attorney’s choices can be attributed to some strategic purpose, even though it failed to achieve success, then the lawyer wasn’t ineffective.  But it need not be judged by resulting prejudice.  This means that a trial judge need not wait for the jury to convict to determined that counsel has been ineffective.



Del Giudice confirmed that he witnessed much of what Trujillo alleged.

“At one point during the trial, this court stopped the proceedings and required all parties to engage in a side bar, because I observed [Harrison] apparently sleeping at the counsel table. The court asked counsel, at side bar, if he was feeling well and if he needed a break to eat or drink,” the judge wrote.

He added, “[Harrison] did, indeed, give a bizarre opening statement. The beginning … was so off topic and irrelevant that this court was compelled to stop counsel and direct that he address what he intended to prove during the course of the trial. The jury was, in fact, laughing during counsel’s opening statement and such laughter at a member of the bar created an unprofessional atmosphere.”

The judge also stated that although he did not witness Harrison reading magazines while witnesses were being examined, he did see him drop one.
At what point does the judge, whose responsibility includes assuring that the defendant is afforded his constitutional rights, including the right to counsel at trial, decide that it’s time to do something?  Whats striking here is that the judge concedes that he saw the train wreck coming, and he did nothing.  He saw it happen, and he did nothing.  He saw the aftermath, and still he did nothing.  Not until new counsel was appointed and moved to vacate did the court figure out that it has a role to play in this trial.

I don’t know Michael Harrison, who “[b]y his own count, he has taken more than 600 trials to verdict.”  Let me say that I am skeptical of this claim, in the extreme.  But even if he’s tried 100 cases to verdict, still quite a lot, it does nothing to counterbalance what happened in the trial of Edward Trujillo, who was as entitled to competent counsel as any other defendant. 

The judge’s expressed reluctance to “criticize” a member of the bar reflects misguided priorities.  His job was to give the defendant a fair trial, where all constitutional rights were fully afforded.  His job is not to cover for a fellow lawyer, or even sit back and enjoy the show.  There’s nothing funny about this.

500 Comments Later

Personal to my spammer “Nick”. 

Nick,

You worked hard again last night.  It’s not easy posting 500 spam comments.  I would have thought that you would have learned that your efforts would come to naught the last time you did it.  Yes, I was forced to waste my time deleting all of them, but I do what’s necessary.  Your posting another 500 comments last night must have been tedious and monotonous.  It must have taken a very long time.  I admire your persistence and perseverence. 

But I still deleted all of them.  Every one.  Even if I hadn’t, your comments would never see the light of day.  I realize that you’re just trying to do your job.  I realize you’re just trying to make a living.  But it won’t happen here.  If you can’t find a position that provides something more societally useful, then at least spend your time at a blog that will tolerate your efforts more.  If you post another 500 comments, I will delete them again.  And if need be, again.  You will not make any money here.  Sorry.

Yours,

Scott

The Old Guard’s Last Stand

Robert Morgenthau, the august District Attorney of the County of New York, has one last thing to do before he takes leave of his office at the age of 89 years: make sure that Leslie Crocker Snyder never sits in his chair.

Later today, Morgy will endorse his former assistant district attorney, Cy Vance, Jr.  Caroline Kennedy threw a party for him this week.  Leslie wasn’t invited.  According to New York Magazine, Morgy’s official position is that he’s offended by Leslie Crocker Snyder’s claim to fame, her outrageously harsh, loud pro-prosecution stance while serving as an Acting Supreme Court Justice.



She’s living in the past,” Morgenthau, who turns 90 next month, says. That past was Manhattan’s crack-and-murder years: a time when Morgenthau wanted his overload of violent cases argued in Snyder’s courtroom, a period she detailed in her memoir, a tell-all of the death threats against her and the exploits of gangs like the Jheri Curls.

 


Morgenthau doesn’t care for the book, starting with its title.

 


Twenty-five to Life?” he says, his face in full pucker mode.

Having been one of the twelve people to read the book, I can attest to the fact that it sucked.  Rarely has a judge proclaimed her impropriety on the bench as proudly as Leslie.  In fact, the only other book to come close was Harold  “The Prince of Darkness” Rothwax’s “Guilty”, a paean to psychopathy. 

But that’s just Morgy’s public stance. The fact is, his office enjoyed the benefit of Leslie’s harshness many times, steering the most difficult cases to her courtroom any way they could, knowing full well that they would find no more loving ear than Leslie’s.  There was no better way to guarantee a conviction in the spottiest of prosecutions than to make sure it went straight to Part 72.

Four years ago, Leslie Crocker Snyder took a calculated risk.  She wasn’t getting any younger, and Morgenthau showed no sign of realizing that he was indeed getting older.  She felt like the paid her dues, and if her mentor wasn’t going to hand her the crown, she would snatch it.  This violates the first rule of royalty: kill the king.



But the root of Morgenthau’s problem with Snyder is her impertinence. Four years ago, Snyder challenged Morgenthau in a Democratic primary, his first serious fight in twenty years. One central tenet of her campaign was that Morgenthau was too old. “He’s the district attorney of the past, and I’m the district attorney of the future,” she said. Morgenthau won handily—but that was the easy part. The hard part was to ensure that, once he left the job, Snyder couldn’t step in to take it.
Having lost, Leslie was faced with Morgenthau’s wrath.  Now, she can never be District Attorney.  Not that he ever actually wanted her to succeed him, but he would likely have not felt so strongly that it was his duty to make sure that she never, never, wins the office.  Once Leslie challenged him, however, this became his mission.  She must not win.

I’ve enjoyed watching Leslie reinvent herself over the past few years.  The new, kinder, gentler, less patently offensive Leslie Crocker Snyder has enjoyed epiphany after epiphany.  Suddenly, she’s against the death penalty, whereas before she would beg to pull the switch.  Suddenly, empathy toward drug defendants and their needs supplants her rants that they are the scourge of society and deserve life plus cancer.  Suddenly, she is all about fairness.  How she would know what fairness means is beyond me.  I’ve certainly never seen any evidence of it in her before.

Isn’t it amazing how running for office and epiphanies go hand in hand? 

Despite the emergence of the new Leslie Crocker Snyder, there is one thing she can never be.  Old guard.  Morgenthau is the last of the Old Guard in Manhattan, from the families of wealth and breeding whose sons turned to public service as demanded by noblesse oblige.  The Office of the District Attorney of New York County is the last bastion, the place where duty trumps all else.  It’s not for the social climber or the self-aggrandizer.  There are other, lesser offices for people of that ilk.  Let the nouveau riche take the flashier positions they so crave; leave DANY to those who were bred to the post.

There is only one potential candidate who is suitable today.  Cyrus Vance, Junior.

Of course, Leslie has something that Cy Vance doesn’t, quite marketable in today’s political arena.  She’s a woman.  That detail alone is likely to play a huge role in the election.  On top of that, Leslie will likely have the support of the police unions, given that she has single-handedly brought vast overtime wealth to more cops than any other human being.  No cop has had a better friend than Leslie. 

And finally, nobody wants the job more than Leslie Crocker Snyder.  And nobody wants to stop her from getting it more than Robert Morgenthau.  This should be interesting.

H/T Former Kings County ADA under Eugene “The Child Molster” Gold, Andrew Lavoott Bluestone.