Author Archives: SHG

Pro Se Meets Confrontation

There are few crimes that evoke the degree of anguish in a trial witness than rape, where the victim, assuming the witness to have indeed been a victim, must relive the experience with the eyes of the accused upon her.  This was how the “victim” felt as she was questioned by the prosecutor, according to the Seattle Post Intelligencer.

[Senior Deputy Prosecutor Julie] Kays gently questioned the woman about that night, subtly blocking [defendant Sankarandi] Skanda’s line of sight to the witness box. Skanda was left to shift in his seat, trying to reacquire a view of his alleged victim.

But there is no trial more susceptible to wrongful conviction than the single eyewitness sexual assault,  Whether due to fabricated accusations or mistaken identification, rapes are particularly suspect.  But the efforts of the prosecutrix to block the defendant from being able to look into the eyes of his accuser were pointless. 

Skanda, whose name was Frank Antill until he converted to Hinduism while serving a stretch in Idaho for a “similar assault,” was going to get his chance to look his accuser square in the face.  He was pro se.

A self-described “religious doctor” who was attempting to found an Ecstasy-fueled “Temple of Love” when he was arrested, Skanda, 36, contends he and the woman had a long-running affair and had been propositioned by her to kill her husband. Three weeks into his trial, Skanda has offered scant evidence to support his claim, which prosecutors contend is entirely baseless.

Not surprisingly, the religious use of ecstasy does not tend to enhance one’s advocacy skills.  It apparently didn’t do much for Skanda.


When given an opportunity to question his alleged victim, Skanda quickly violated pre-trial orders against raising certain unsupported allegations against the woman and her husband. Skanda had previously violated those restrictions in opening statements, but — to the consternation of prosecutors — had not received a contempt citation from King County Superior Court Judge Douglass A. North.

The limitations on the Skanda’s questioning are curious, given that they are characterized as “unsupported allegations.”  As Skanda was the source of the allegations, and by his own accord the witness to his claims, they are every bit as supported as the allegations against him.  Nutsy crazy, perhaps, but still supported.  And if this fellow was sane enough to stand trial, and sane enough to represent himself, then why would his allegations be so unworthy of credit as to deny him his right to present his defense?

The prosecutrix was not amused by Skanda’s questioning of the victim, as one might well expect.  If one believed the victim, as Julie Kays obviously did, then this trial was an outrage.


“This is the most offensive line of questioning I’ve heard in 10 years of practice,” said Kays, struggling to contain her disdain for Skanda and apparent anger over his failure to abide by North’s earlier orders.

“This is a court of law, not a court of terror for him, and I can’t help but believe he is getting off on terrorizing this woman again,” she added. “He is thumbing his nose at this process and he’s using it to terrorize this woman.”
While it may well be that having a rapist question a victim constitutes “terrorizing this woman,” the defendant was hardly thumbing his nose at the process.  As unseemly as it may be to the prosecutrix, the defendant has both the right to confront witnesses against him and the right to represent himself.  That is the process. 

While it’s difficult not to feel for the witness, forced to take questions that impugn her credibility, dignity and sexual conduct, assuming that she was in fact raped at knife point by Skanda, this ugly and painful scene is precisely what’s demanded of a trial.  Indeed, as long as they prosecution seeks to convict, and the defendant is deemed psychologically convictable, it would appear that the limitations placed by the judge on the pro se defendant are unjustifiable.  He’s entitled to defend himself, and if he, as a person with actual knowledge, says it’s so, then he has a good faith basis to pursue a defense that involves attacking the purported victim based upon his rather bizarre claims.

Does it all sound too ridiculous and outrageous?  Perhaps, but that’s the price of having a trial.  Due process isn’t limited to situations where everybody feels happy and comfortable.

When Classrooms are Lined in Rubber

More often than not, parents are convinced that the secret to better education is higher pay for teachers.  It’s never dawned on most that if you pay a lousy teacher more, you get a better paid lousy teacher.  But perhaps this AP story, the confluence of some perverted version of due process and your tax dollars at work, will change a mind or two.

Hundreds of New York City public school teachers accused of offenses ranging from insubordination to sexual misconduct are being paid their full salaries to sit around all day playing Scrabble, surfing the Internet or just staring at the wall, if that’s what they want to do.

Because their union contract makes it extremely difficult to fire them, the teachers have been banished by the school system to its “rubber rooms” — off-campus office space where they wait months, even years, for their disciplinary hearings.

Yes, years.  And they get paid for every minute of it.  And benefits.  In NYC, the cost is estimated at $65 million.  That would be $65 million that people believe is being spent on the education of children.

One might think that if it was prudent to remove teachers from the classroom, the very least the NYC Board of Education might do is use them to perform some useful function.  Grading papers perhaps, or reviewing textbooks.  Granted they can’t scrape the lead paint off classroom walls, as they aren’t qualified and it would violate the paint scrapers’ union contract.  But something.  Nope.  Scrabble is huge.  You have to find some way to kill eight hours, day after day, month after month, year after year.

“No one wants teachers who don’t belong in the classroom. However, we cannot neglect the teachers’ rights to due process,” Davis said. The union represents more than 228,000 employees, including nearly 90,000 teachers.

The complaint from many of the rubber room teachers is that their “crime” is making enemies with someone in power, which certainly has the smell of truth given how things work in schools.  Vindictive and retaliatory co-workers are not exactly unheard of in public service

Many teachers say they are being punished because they ran afoul of a vindictive boss or because they blew the whistle when somebody fudged test scores.

“The principal wants you out, you’re gone,” said Michael Thomas, a high school math teacher who has been in a reassignment center for 14 months after accusing an assistant principal of tinkering with test results.

Assuming the good intentions of both the City and the United Federation of Teachers, the question remains: Why should it take months and years, with teachers wasting away at full salary, to conduct a hearing to determine whether the teacher should be returned to the classroom, fired or otherwise disciplined?

Once their hearings are over, they are either sent back to the classroom or fired. But because their cases are heard by 23 arbitrators who work only five days a month, stints of two or three years in a rubber room are common, and some teachers have been there for five or six.

Do the math, guys.  If it costs you $65 million to have the teachers sit there, and you have only 23 arbs working five days a month, what about taking, oh, say $10 million from the cost of teacher dead time, put it into 100 more arbs working full time, and cut the length of wasted time down by, oh, say 80%, with a net savings of $42 million?

And we entrust these people with our children.

H/T Kathleen Casey, our hinterlands correspondent

Madoff’s Turn

Having heard what the victims had to say, Dickstein Shapiro’s Ike Sorkin has now laid out Bernie Madoff’s argument for sentence.  In an 11 page sentencing letter, Sorkin makes his pitch:


We seek neither mercy nor sympathy. Respectfully, we seek the justice and objectivity that have been — and we hope always will be — the bedrock of our criminal justice system.

Awkward.  Not that it doesn’t use nice sounding words, but that Sorkin starts out with the same argument that could well be used by the government in seeking an assurance that Bernie never breathes free air again.  That’s one of the fundamental problems in using the broad brush “truth and justice” rhetoric that some advocate.  They are merely matters of perspective, and are just as easily argued in favor of severity and leniency.

Sorkin then seeks to undermine the impact of the victims.


Both [Madoff] and his counsel acknowledge the scope and magnitude of those losses and understand the victims’ calls for reprisal . . . Nevertheless, we believe that the unified tone of the victim statements suggests a desire for a type of mob vengeance that, if countenanced here, would negate and render meaningless the role of the Court.

Clearly, Sorkin sought to diminish the emotional appeal of the victims’ letters and emails, but I’ve got no idea what he’s trying to suggest by arguing that if Judge Denny Chin considers the pleas of the victims, it would “negate and render meaningless” his role as judge.  It seems to mean that Judge Chin shouldn’t rubber stamp the victims demands for blood, but does Sorkin really contend that Judge Chin abdicate his duty and let the victims dictate sentence?  

That’s rather insulting to the judge, and certainly not to be expected of Judge Chin, who is fully capable of reading the victims’ letters, giving them appropriate weight and fulfilling his responsibility independently.  Moreover, while the victims’ letter share a sense of anger and outrage, they do not smack of mob vengeance, but of many, many victims, all of whom suffered greatly at the hands of the defendant.  While it’s appropriate for Sorkin to address them, this smacks of an effort to trivialize the impact on the victims, almost ridicule their pleas for justice (see how that word comes up again?).  It’s a bit unseemly to attack the victims.

Finally, Sorkin comes to the part where he offers some mitigation in favor of the defendant, a critical argument for sentencing purposes.


Affording due consideration to Mr. Madoff’s voluntary surrender, full acceptance of responsibility, meaningful cooperation efforts and in light of the non-violent nature of the offense, Mr. Madoff should be sentenced to a term of years short of effective life imprisonment. Mr. Madoff is currently 71 years old and has an approximate life expectancy of 13 years. A prison term of 12 years — just short of an effective life sentence — will sufficiently address the goals of deterrence, protecting the public, and promoting respect for the law without being “greater than necessary” to achieve them.

After all the speculation about what Bernie Madoff had up his sleeve when he copped an open plea, we now have the answer.  Not much.  There’s no neat trick involved, no twist of the guidelines or legal ploy.  The strategy was nothing more than making the best possible lemonade out of 50 billion lemons.

This is Madoff’s primary sentencing position, no doubt offered with little expectation that it will capture the judge’s sensibilities under §3553(a).  The argument is to sentence Madoff to life minus 1 year, his best case scenario.  The life part is based on actuarial life expectancy, not a guarantee that he will die in 13 years.  It might be more persuasive if Sorkin could offer the court an assurance, because 83 years of age might well be his actuarial life expectancy but we all know that Bernie could have plenty of good years after that. 

The real reason for this argument is to set up the “fallback” position:


Alternatively, we respectfully submit that a 15 to 20 year prison term will effectively achieve the stated goals of §3553(a) without disproportionately punishing Mr. Madoff. Indeed, such a range will appropriately eliminate concerns for disparate treatment among similarly situated non-violent offenders.

The primary and secondary positions are facially inconsistent, which Sorkin obviously knows, as will Judge Chin.  If the former satisfies §3553(a), then the latter must by definition be excessive.  But the argument for a 12 year sentence is made for rejection, to make the more harsh, 15 to 20 year sentence, more palatable.  Sorkin recognizes that whatever sentence he requests, it will be deemed far too lenient by the victims and likely the public, and Judge Chin will realize that the general deterrent purpose of sentence will not be satisfied by an overwhelming public reaction that Madoff got away with “murder”.  This sentence is all about general deterrence.

For this reason, Sorkin has put in some effort to establish the average range of sentences imposed on large scale fraud defendants.


Significantly, for fraud-related cases between 1999 and 2008 in which a defendant was assigned a guideline range of life imprisonment, did not receive a downward departure pursuant to Sentencing Guidelines §5k1.1, and plead guilty, the average sentence imposed was 184 months, or approximately 15.3 years. . . . Because the majority of these cases involved loss figures in excess of $400,000,000 — as does Mr. Madoff’s case — we respectfully urge this Court to impose a sentence on Mr. Madoff that reflects a just degree of proportionality.

This is a rather tricky statement in many respects.  Initially, the sentencing structure under the guidelines changed dramatically in 2003 in response to the perceived lenient guidelines sentences for massive frauds in such cases as Enron’s Jeffrey Skilling and Worldcom’s Bernie Ebbers.  If one was to change the equation by limiting the statistics to frauds over $400,000,000 post 2003, it might reveal a very different picture.  And, of course, $400 million is the maximum amount under the fraud table of the guidelines.  It must have seemed like a lot of loss at the time, but that was before Madoff’s case.  Who knew that the guidelines needed to go well into the billions?

But this Bloomberg story makes the point quite clearly:


Ebbers is serving 25 years in prison and Rigas 12. Ex-Enron Corp. Chief Executive Officer Jeffrey Skilling was sentenced to 24 years. A federal appeals court has ordered that he be resentenced.

Bernie Madoff isn’t your average white collar fraudster.  He was always better before, and he’s still better.  He wins the prize for the greatest loss ever, no matter how hard Sorkin seeks to reduce his client to merely the “mean”.  As he pleads for proportionality, it’s this very concept that makes his argument collapse around him.  Proportionality demands that the sentence imposed on Madoff dwarf those imposed on the closest comparables by the magnitude of the loss he caused.  It’s hard to ignore the fact that no one, but no one, caused as much loss as Bernie.


It’s unlikely Madoff will receive the requested sentence, Anthony Sabino, a business-law professor at St. John’s University in New York, said today in an interview. Sorkin advanced the best arguments he could, Sabino said.
This is a peculiar statement, and one with which I am not inclined to agree.  It’s not that Ike Sorkin did a lousy job of it, but the arguments on behalf of Madoff are, given the financial resources he had available, relatively tepid.  Maybe the thought was that there really wasn’t anything particularly effective that could be said, since this isn’t exactly a case that’s flying under the radar and everyone has a thought on the subject. 

But if that was the theory, then perhaps Sorkin should have gone for broke.  After all, that’s how Madoff left his victims. 

Kindle DX: An Opposing View

There is sudden flurry of interest around the blawgosphere about something called the Kindle DX.  Ken at Popehat cuts to the chase:


I’ve had 24 hours with the Kindle DX now, so time for some first impressions.

Short answer: it’s just great.


Mike at Crime & Federalism was much longer winded:


The .pdf feature is what sold me on the DX rather than the Kindle 2.  The DX is larger, though.  With the Kindle 2, you must convert .pdf files.  Not everyone has had good luck with the conversion.  Most of my day is spent reading trial transcripts.  It’d be nice to take my “office” to the dog park.  Looks like that will be much easier with the DX.  I can probably justify it as a tax write off, too.  

Gushing?  Oozing love?  Well, now it’s time for Scott at Simple Justice to chime in.

Are you guys nuts?  Is there nothing new and shiny that you boys won’t buy?

Back in the olden days, we have a telephone, for which we paid rather dearly on a monthly basis.  We were always careful about who we called, and how far away they were. this was because the charge varied by calling area, some inexplicable concept that made the cost entirely different based upon how many miles the sound had to travel.  It was like the call passed through itty bitty telephone toll booths on the way to the recipient of the call.  Dial the wrong number and you could have a heart attack when the bill came.

But at least television was free.  All 7 channels, though three of them really weren’t worth much except on Sunday mornings, when the only show on was Davey and Goliath.  It was horrible, but it’s not like there was a plan B.  We managed.

Time has changed everything.  We now have cell phones, internet, cable television and all the various permutations and inter-relations thereof.  The price of a long distance call no longer matters, but then Ma Bell gave us the phone.  Today, it’s not just the cost of our monthly basic necessities, but the newest, coolest must-have hardware that makes life worth living. 

I’m perplexed.  I don’t understand how young people can afford their toys.  They still have to eat, put a roof over their heads, wear clothing and get places.  Then there are student loans.  All these things cost money, and from what I can tell, a fairly good amount of it.  But that’s just the beginning.  I see crackberries and iPhones everywhere.  And they aren’t those old, yucky iPhones from last month, but new, shiny iPhones that make their owner more virile. 

Granted, the trend toward moving into their parent’s basement may alleviate some of the financial strain, though the notion that they would happily live in mommy’s house so that they can afford a shiny toy and all the waves necessary to juice it up, flies in the face of my priorities.

I’m not a total Luddite. I’ve got a cellphone, though it doesn’t have a keyboard of any sort and I only turn it on to make outgoing calls.  My plan is the same as the one I started with, although the cellphone company has increased my minutes from 30 to 100 without raising my fee.  I’ve never come close to using them all up, and wish they would roll over.

The cable company has tried to force me to use a converter box.  And if I needed their remote control, why do the television makers include one in the box?  I’m not that easily fooled.  The same with this HD nonsense.  I’ve seen a show on regular TV and HDTV, and it looks exactly the same to me.  Of course, I don’t have HD eyes anymore.

And now Kindle.  I take it that you guys must be so well-heeled that you can’t possibly come up with ways to squander the vast wealth you’ve accumulated, because you now need to purchase a device that costs almost $500 on Amazon to, get this, read a book.  No, you still have to buy the book, but now you also have to buy the machine on which to read the book.  And buy it again when the next generation comes out, the Kindle DXX 3.2.  It’s the one that comes in colors with a sparkly exterior. 

You do realize that eventually, someone is going to come up with Kindle Green, eerily reminiscent of what your grandparents used to call “a book.”

Atop the Fence

Via Skelly at Arbitrary & Capricious, a young PD blogging at Sloth Bear Diaries posts about the types of defendants who annoy him.  For anyone who’s practiced criminal defense for more than 12 minutes, the descriptions will be familiar and bring a knowing smile to your face.  There are some other “types” left off the list, the defendant who believes lawyers can see into the future, for example, or the defendant who thinks we have some magic way to make their case go away, but we save it for “special” defendants.

One type on the list doesn’t fall into the annoying category for me, but rather the disturbing.  This type is all too common, and impairs my ability to provide the best possible defense.  For me, that’s the most problematic defendant.


The Fence Sitter – This guy doesn’t want to go to trial. But he doesn’t want to plea either. In fact there is no course of action that he wants to take. He just wants to stare at the case and think eventually it will go away. He’s terrified of having his day in court, but doesn’t want to admit fault either. Please try not to be this guy. Make a decision!!!
In white collar defense, this is unfortunately an extremely common attitude amongst defendant.  Ironically, these are defendants who are often masters of their own industry and fate, capable of making difficult decisions in the course of their business without blinking.  Yet when it comes to their defense, they are paralyzed.

The problem derives from the confluence of three factors: They are psychologically ill-equipped to come to grips with the fact that they are the target of a criminal prosecution.  These defendants can’t perceive themselves as criminals, and they immediately resort to denial, whether of their conduct or their circumstance.  They are indignant.  They are outraged at their treatment.  They refuse to face the fact that they are, indeed, a criminal defendant.

The second factor is the refusal to accept the proposition that there are, at the outset of a criminal defense, only two options.  They can fight or they can acquiesce, whether by plea or cooperation.  They demand a third option, usually involving an apology from the prosecutor and a tropical vacation.  When informed that there is no third option, the immediate reaction is that they obviously need a better lawyer. 

The final factor is that they expect to get what they paid for, meaning that they view the lawyer as a plumber who guarantees that, when he’s done, the pipes won’t leak.  These defendants tend to be regular consumers of services, and expect their service providers to meet expectations.  When told the truth, that lawyers provide time, experience, intelligence and effort, but not a guaranteed outcome, they are not satisfied.  They make demands, and they are used to making demands.  They have no interest in paying for ambiguity.

Like most people whose knowledge of the criminal justice system is limited to the nonsense they see on TV or read in the New York Times Magazine, they do not believe in trials.  They are convinced that the fix is in, that no one wins at trial.  They instruct you on Day 1 that they are not going to trial.  No trial, period.  You explain to them that this is a perfectly fine choice, provided that they understand that this leaves only two options, cooperate or plead guilty.  This is when they look at you like you’re nuts.  They announce that they’ve apparently retained the singular stupidest lawyer on the face of the earth, who is unaware of the only viable option in their case: Explain to the prosecution that this is all a big mistake, so that everyone can have a good laugh about it, shake hands and go home.  Duh.

The defendant, upon hearing the word “cooperation”, immediately lights up.  This is their opportunity to explain to the prosecution the error of its ways, how it’s misunderstood and misinterpret perfectly innocent and understandable conduct that some ignorant agent has mistakenly cast as impropriety.  If their stupid lawyer can’t manage to explain this adequately, then they will be forced to do so, they inform you.  Of course, being good and lawful citizens, they like the sound of the word “cooperation”, as it puts them on the same team as the good guys, the government.  They want to be on the good guys team.  They are good guys. 

This is a particularly dangerous point in the discussion, as the client in denial thinks that he can waltz into a proffer session, explain his innocence, and put this whole silly misadventure to rest.  After explaining what a 1001 violation is, the concept of confession is raised.  As with the attempted exculpatory statement upon arrest, this is the most likely way to seal one’s fate and destroy any possibility of a viable defense.  No matter what “harmless” statements the defendants believes will come out, you can be assured that someone will ask a question that will either require a deceitful response or admit criminal conduct.  Either way, the defendant isn’t walking out with an apology and a friendly slap on the back.

The root of the problem is that white collar defendants, unlike good, solid criminals, reject the idea that anyone could seriously believe that they have committed a crime, no matter what the evidence may be against them.  Without a full recognition of the harsh reality that they are criminal defendants, every bit as much a defendant as the drug dealer or the batterer, they cannot begin to mount a viable defense.  They cannot come to grips with the fact that they are now embroiled in that horrendously unfair system that they vigorously supported throughout their careers.  They are now on the other side of the fence, and they refuse to accept it.

For some, the ones who have skirted the edges of the law if not trampled it with reckless abandon, their disgruntlement is a matter of foolish bravado.  Yes, you were a master of the universe, but now you’re a defendant.  You need to deal with it.  For others, whose conduct or intent was innocent and who have done no wrong, welcome to the crazy world of the prosecuted, where even innocent people are accused of crimes.  No, it isn’t fair or just, but it’s still your reality and you still need to deal with it.

Fence sitting is the result of a disconnect with reality.  Some people just need a grieving period, a time to adjust to the fact that their lives will never be the same now that they’ve become enmeshed in a system that isn’t nearly as perfect as they want to believe.  Some people never regain their grasp of reality following their arrest.  None are necessarily bad people.  Most are quite likable under other circumstances, the kind of folks that you would happily chat with at cocktail parties.  But when your relationship is one of attorney and client, the nature of your relationship is entirely different, and your responsibility is to make clear what they are facing on either side of the fence. 

It’s not our choice which side of the fence a client ultimately chooses.  But there is little we can do while the defendant remains on the fence.  And the longer they sit there, the more opportunities are lost.  Yes, we understand how difficult it is for you.  That’s why we want you to get off the fence so that we can help.

Dangerous Confusion on Truth and Justice (Update)

It’s always amazing how a bad set of facts, a poorly reasoned decision and well-intended but slightly off-kilter vision of justice produces confused and misguided rhetoric.  Such has been the case with the Osborne decision, and it’s happened again. At Grits for Breakfast, Scott picks up on the commentary of Michael Landauer of the Dallas News :


I’m torn. … I have a hard time thinking it’s OK to limit any evidence from being submitted that might prove guilt or innocence. Why would we do that? It drives me nuts that the appeals process is treated by some as a chess match instead of a search for truth. Once the jury speaks, that search ends and it’s all about tactical, constitutional arguments, it seems.

Still, I would hate to see people who are so clearly guilty use this as a ploy to sorta roll the dice. We saw on Dallas DNA, the show about exonerations in our county, that some people really do that. They waste the courts’ time just for kicks.

Non-lawyers really love to believe that a trial is a search for truth.  Judges often feed into this mess by using phrases like this when it suits their convenience.  It sounds so legitimate.  It makes the system sound dignified and purposeful.  It appeals to our American sensibilities.  Justice.  Truth.  Hooray!

I’m begging you, please stop.  You’re living in a fantasy, and not a particularly pretty one.  The reduction of life to such simplistic concepts as truth and justice is not merely absurd, but dangerously so.  Just stop.

I assume that what’s meant by Landauer’s statement is that DNA, and specifically DNA, is proof of sufficient certainty to exonerate an innocent person, and hence should be subject to a very different set of rules than applies to every other form of proof.*  Taking it a step further, the rules of procedure that apply otherwise should not be used to preclude a defendant from obtaining a DNA test that could serve to exonerate.  Except that he doesn’t want this to apply when the person is actually guilty, since it’s wastes the courts’ time “for kicks.” 

Of course, that’s not at all what he said.  He urges that all evidence come in to “prove guilt or innocence.”  Does he have the slightest clue what that means?  I doubt it.  What about propensity evidence?  What about inflammatory evidence?  What about illegally seized evidence?  Did you consider any of this before you decided to write this grandiose yet childish rhetoric?

It’s hard enough trying to make sense of the criminal justice system, a lousy system but what we’re left to use, to the public without newspaper editors spreading ideas like this.  Because Landauer is an editor for the Dallas News, people expect him to have a clue what he’s talking about.  He doesn’t.  He’s likely well-intended, and might well agree that his rhetoric is foolish if someone sat him down and explained, slowly, why his thought processes are naive and child-like.  But this didn’t happen before he posted his opinion, and we are left with another example of dangerous rhetoric, feeding ignorantly simplistic notions to the public.

The other day, I watched the Today Show while trying to put a decent knot in my tie.  The segment was about some criminal justice issue of no particular consequence, and Danny Abrams (Floyd’s kid) was on as the legal analyst.  Now I like Danny.  I really do.  But he’s never actually practiced law, no less criminal law.  And he is totally, fundamentally clueless.  But you would never know it by watching him on the tube.  He comes off with great expertise, pontificating at length in response to silly questions.  Lately, Danny has become more strident in his views, which (I note in passing) have become increasingly supportive of law enforcement. 

I recall that Dan informed the audience about the law that applied to the issue du jour.  He was wrong.  Had it completely backward, and I started laughing.  My tie knot was just horrible by the time I was done and I had to retie it from scratch.  Danny was very, very serious as he rendered his opinion.  He’s a very serious kid.  He’s just wrong at the same time he’s being very serious.

It’s hard enough to have an intelligent discussion on troubling issue amongst people who have a sufficient background and comprehension skills.  Why must people in the media who don’t have a clue continue to move their lips or their pens or their fingers as they dance across a keyboard?  If you don’t know, just stop.  It’s okay.  You don’t have to express an opinion about everything.  Remember, you have the ascribed credibility of the mainstream media.  People think you know something, and rely on your words, no matter how wrong they are.  This is why it’s dangerous.

They say that everyone is entitled to an opinion.  I disagree. You have to know what you’re talking about before you’re entitled to an opinion.  Otherwise, you’re just making noise.  The criminal justice system is dangerous enough.  I’m begging you, stop adding your confusion to the cacophony.  Please.

* I’ve chosen not to go anywhere near the wealth of significant issues surrounding DNA evidence, it’s viability as preclusive rather than inclusive evidence, the problems with collection, contamination, maintenance, etc., all of which would require a very different discussion than the one intended by this post. 

Update:  Mark Bennett has posted a quote from Ann Althouse’s Blog that serves to further the point of this one:


One of the most annoying things about lawyers is the way they casually conflate “law” with “justice.” To clarify: justice is a concept in philosophy; also to some extent in psychology, sociology, economics, etc. Law is what a bunch of mostly long-dead politicians thought would get them reelected. There’s no connection between the two. None. The relation between law and those other fields is much like the relation between astrology and astronomy…except that astrologers don’t have guns.
Ignore the cynicism and gratuitous gun allusion, and cut to the chase.  Laws are the rules imposed on us.  Justice is a value judgment each of us makes, and each of us makes differently.  The two are unrelated.  Even if we argued that we would want there to be a direct correlation between the two, each of us would have a different expectation of what that correlation should be. 

We want fair rules that serve their intended purpose well.  We hope that those rules comport with our sense of justice.  But since each of us has a different understanding of what constitutes justice, the law cannot, by definition, equate with justice.  We need to stop telling people that it can and should.  It just isn’t true.

The Blawgosphere and Real World Collide

When I first learned of Packratt’s existence, he was writing to tell the story of what happened to him.  Following his ungentle handling by police, he learned that lawyers can be just as callous.  It was a cautionary tale, and one that needed telling and retelling.  Sure, he was outraged and in turn outrageous, but he was still a person who needed help.  He found none.

I’ve followed Packratt since then, as he released a part of his anger toward police and lawyers by trying to turn his energies toward more productive uses.  The catharsis helped him.  The information Packratt brought to the blawgosphere helped everyone.  In the process, Packratt became a target of his local police, who weren’t at all pleased with his efforts in highlighting their misconduct in Seattle. 

While criminal defense lawyer do this as part of our job, without any reason to fear retaliation, Packratt took his chances.  He started out a victim of the cops, and then continued down a road that nearly begged for another lesson on who has the power.  Still, he continued, uncowed.

A few months back, Packratt took a big leap forward by starting a new endeavor, Injustice Everywhere, coupled with his twitter feed Injustice News, providing links to police misconduct nationwide.  It was a time-consuming and ambitious endeavor.  There are far more stories in the media about police misconduct and abuse than you would believe, and Packratt not only broadcast as many as he could find, but was trying to create a statistical backdrop for his findings.  His efforts caught many important eyes, including those of Radley Balko, the Agitator.  Packratt was doing great work, and some very heavy lifting.

But it’s all about to come to an abrupt end.  Packratt announced it with a misguided apology, as if he’s failed us.



Today, fathers day, was going well for the most part, but then a bombshell sort of destroyed the calm pleasant day. My wife, bless her, tried to keep it a secret and not let it bother her, but the stress of it sort of made things come to a head and she told me what was going on…


We only have $100 to last us until the first of next month, and next month looks even bleaker than that, we’ll run dry by mid-month.


It appears as though what I’m doing here and with the feed is no longer sustainable for me because it’s using up time that I should be spending trying to find ways to take care of my primary responsibility as a dad… being that I need to make sure my family has a roof over their heads and food in their bellies.
There is nothing about a blog, or twitter feed, that let’s us in on the details of real life.  Packratt hit the wall, and I never knew it until he said something.  How could I?  Why would I?  Packratt is a real person, with a real family to feed.  No matter how great a job he did on the internet, we forget that he still has to go to the supermarket and buy dinner.  The supermarket people still charge for the food he takes home.  A great job online doesn’t translate to a great job in real life.  Packratt didn’t have one, and sure could have used one.

There are a few people who write blogs who earn a living that way.  Balko is one.  I’m not, but then I’m a lawyer and throw this together in my spare time.  Packratt wasn’t getting paid for what he did online, and he wasn’t a lawyer.  He was just a guy who wrote about police misconduct for the benefit of the rest of us.

It seems as if there ought to be a way that Packratt should have been paid for his effort.  He certainly put in the effort, posting late into the night about cases that the rest of us needed to know about.  At another time, some media outlet might have hired him.  But here, we give it away.  No reason to buy the cow when you get the milk for free.  I’m not suggesting that everything in the blawgosphere is worth paying for, though I sincerely believe that some of it is.  Judging from the number of people who read, learn, and benefit from the blawgosphere, my guess is that many readers should feel it worthy.

Maybe Radley Balko, who I know follows Packratt’s twitter feed, will read about this and tell his people at Reason Magazine that this guy should be on the payroll.  I won’t press the issue as I have no idea whether the idea has any feasibility at all, but I can’t help but wonder whether Balko’s work will be the worse for Packratt’s absence.  I suspect it will.  I don’t suspect that Reason will put Packratt on the payroll.

For the readers who have followed Packratt and benefited from his efforts, consider that he stayed awake late at night researching, reading learning and posting about stories that mattered to you while his bank account dwindled.  He doesn’t need donations, but a well-paying day job.  What happens here in the blawgosphere is free for all to enjoy.  But we still live in the real world.  We still need to pay the bills and feed the kids.  This blawging thing doesn’t much when it comes to that.

Packratt says he’s sorry that things have come down to this.  It makes no sense for him to say that, as there is no one to whom he owes an apology for anything.  As for us, if you’ve read his work, gained any benefit from his efforts, then you might want to let Packratt know.  We owe him thanks for his efforts.  They didn’t cost us a thing.

The Humble Father

To save anyone else from the embarrassment of being the target of my keyboard, I write about myself this father’s day.  As an attorney, people come to me for advice and counsel.  My understanding of the law is held in reasonably high regard in some quarters.  Some people actually pay me for my thoughts (I know, but it’s true). 

So one might suspect that I am the object of respect and admiration, right?  Not in my house.

There is a firm, yet pervasive belief amongst my very own family, that I am incapable of doing anything, and I mean anything, without the oversight and direction of a family member.  It doesn’t matter how simple or pedestrian the task.  It doesn’t matter how many times I’ve done it (successfully) before.  If they don’t tell me how to do it, they fully expect my actions to result in disaster.  To avoid disaster, they watch me like a hawk to make sure I don’t screw everything up.

Someone harboring a sexist bias might think that this is a product of my darling wife’s need for control.  After all, Dr. Simple Justice has long been known around here as She Who Must Be Obeyed, or SWMBO for short.  But that would not be accurate, and she informs me that she is not a control freak, but rather just an ordinary gal who is charged with keeping me from blowing everything I do.  Since she has given herself two votes in the household legislature, I am unable to challenge her position in a fair and democratic vote.

But it’s not SWMBO who gets me, no matter how many times she leaves her car keys in the refrigerator then can’t find them.  After all, I’m not her father.  It’s my children, whose births were apparently destined to serve as reminder that no life comes without a price. 

My eldest child, a daughter of great beauty and talent, has the Jedi ability of mind control.  She need not speak to me, and in fact has rarely done so for the past few years.  She need only cock her eye and emit a sound similar to “tsk” to make clear that she disapproves.  It’s crushing in its simplicity and force.

My youngest, a son who exceeds my best qualities at every turn, never passes up an opportunity to point out my deficits.  Lately, he’s become a motor mouth.   I attribute this to my failure to beat him as an infant, but he was just so darned cute.  Nonetheless, he informs me on an hourly basis that I am not cool, just in case senility set in and I’ve forgotten his last admonition.

Some readers here write kind words about me, telling me that they find my writings interesting or thoughtful.  To anyone who thinks that these kinds words might serve to inflate my ego, make me thing that I’m a bigshot, take comfort.  No matter how many nice comments I receive for my writings, I have a wonderful family at home whose primary purpose is to keep me humble.  And they are particularly good at their job.  Really, really good,  

It would have been nice if somebody made me breakfast in bed, but I’m here writing and the rest of them are all fast asleep.  It’s the only time of day I can do stuff without supervision.

Happy father’s day. 

Not Dead Yet

Age is a relative thing.  When I was 30, 50 seemed ancient.  Not anymore.  I have friends in their 60s, 70s, even 80s.  I have no friends in their 90s.  You have to draw the line somewhere, right?  Not according to the Chief Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court, who authored the opinion striking down the state’s mandatory retirement age of 75 for judges on the complaint of Cook County Circuit Judge William Maddux.

The decision, grounded on equal protection, is hardly what one would expect.  Justice Freeman did not conclude that the state law mandating retirement at age 75 was arbitrary and capricious, under the theory that there is nothing about the age of 75 that creates a presumption of unfitness for the position, lacking the stamina and vigor demanded of a judge. 

Rather, the decision picks apart the law which mandates “automatic retirement” of a judge at the end of the term in which a judge attains the age of 75, while permitting a person age 75 or older to run for election, de novo, as a judge.  This, Freeman concludes, makes no sense and violates equal protection.  As it happens, it also dodges the bigger question.

Clearly, judges can function beyond the age of 75 years.  Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens is now 89 and still puts up a decent fight.  But should they?  And what of those judge’s whose mental faculties diminish slowly, incrementally, without doing something so egregious as to compel their being thrown off the court?  Or the problem with judges losing touch, whether with evolving societal norms, or perhaps technology, or, worse still, reality?

On the one hand, political correctness demands that we pretend that age plays no role in how a person functions.  But as a guy getting older, and watching his friends and family get older,  For some, age tempers hard positions, allowing people to see the world in a more empathetic, less dogmatic way.  For others, age takes the bias of youth and personal experience and hardens it until the mind has closed completely to any new thought.  This changes from person to person, and there is neither a specific personality type nor age where things get ugly.  It also changes by subject matter, where people soften on some issues and harden on others, or demonstrate far more attention to things that interest them, yet appear to zone out when it comes to something that doesn’t.

Considering the job we expect of a judge, it’s hardly acceptable to allow our concern for political correctness to trump our demand for justice.  No judge has a right to remain on the bench after his ability to fulfill the demands of the job have diminished.  And truth be told, age plays a role for many who wear the robe, though not all and clearly not always in the same way.

So do we rid ourselves of the judge who has garnered and maintained respect and admiration for wisdom, propriety and justice, because she’s reached a ripe age?  Do we toss out the good with the bad?  And if so, where should the line be drawn?

And just to muddy up the waters a bit more, consider the implications for new blood in the system.  If we keep the old folks on the bench forever, it uses up the seats that would otherwise become available for new, younger judges.  This would have a deleterious affect on political parties, leaving no one to lick envelopes in the hope of getting the nod for the next judicial election.  And where would party leaders get their “walking around” money?

The mandatory retirement age for judges in New York is 70.  Ten years ago, that struck me as a bit young.  Today, it seems ridiculously young.  The state task force reached a similar conclusion in 1997, with nothing coming of it. 

Still, I would be afraid of the elimination of retirement age altogether, given that I’ve experienced some judges who haven’t aged well and, frankly, would be nearly impossible to get rid of despite having gone well beyond their shelf-life.  It’s extremely unlikely that they would leave on their own, particularly since part of the aging process is to seek continued usefulness in the face of declining faculties.  And few have the will to force a judge well past his prime to leave the bench, as a matter of courtesy if not fear. 

There is much to be said for vigor and open-mindedness.  There is much to be said for experience and maturity.  There is much to be said for putting an end to a reign of terror.  But I don’t know where to draw the line, and it’s become an increasingly difficult problem with each passing year.

Due Influence

The trial of Brandon J. Piekarsky and Derrick M. Donchak, two Shenandoah teens who beat Luis Ramirez to death almost a year ago didn’t go as planned.  Despite the racial overtones raised by the death of the Mexican immigrant, the teens were convicted only of simple assault. 

When time for sentence rolled around, however, this high profile case drew the attention of Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell, who wrote a letter to District Attorney James P. Goodman expressing his views on sentencing, to be presented to the court.


From the bench Wednesday afternoon, county President Judge William E. Baldwin criticized Gov. Ed Rendell’s recent interjection into the sentencing of Shenandoah-area teens Brandon J. Piekarsky and Derrick M. Donchak.

“I’ve never before heard of a head of state giving a suggested sentence for a specific criminal case. I am not giving consideration to the governor’s recommendation,” Baldwin said.

While I’m no fan of victim’s input, whether in the trial process or sentencing, I nonetheless have difficulty understanding why Ed Rendell’s letter should be treated any differently than anyone else’s.  He is the governor of a state, but should that preclude his offering his views on the proper sentence to be imposed?

Rendell, being Ed Rendell, naturally overshot the mark by urging the judge to sentence the two teens as if they had been convicted of a racially-motivated murder rather than simple assault.


“I also believe … the maximum sentence is warranted given both the sheer brutality of Piekarsky’s and Donchak’s deadly attack and that the crime appears to be racially motivated,” Rendell said in the letter, which Goodman later shared with Baldwin and defense counsel.
I would assume that this was politically motivated, given the nature of the case and the potential to use his “outrage” when it comes time to court the vote for his next campaign.  But that aside, is it inherently wrong for a governor to offer his input to a judge on sentencing?  Clearly, Judge Baldwin believed so. 

Typically, the prosecution, defense and defendant will be heard at the time of sentencing.  The prosecution, an arm of the executive branch of government, is permitted to argue for the sentence it believes appropriate.  Often, the decision of what to argue, and what sentence to propose, is left to the individual assistant before the court, and whether harsh or lenient, whatever words spout from the prosecutor’s mouth represent the state’s view of what constitutes a proper sentence. 

The nature of criminal proceedings, reflecting a harm done to the people of the state rather than the wrong done to the individual victim, makes the prosecutor the appropriate person to speak on behalf of the state at sentence.  This is where the victim’s rights argument falls down, since criminal laws do not vindicate the rights of particular victims, but the will of the state.  This being so, then a statement by the governor, the chief executive officer of the state, would be particularly appropriate, as he more than anyone is charged with protecting and defending the interests of the citizenry.

While most district attorneys are elected independently of the governor, and are empowered to exercise independent discretion, this too offers no rationale for preventing the governor from being heard.  To the extent that both reflect the executive branch of government, Rendell’s letter merely informs an independently elected official within the same branch of government of his views, which suggests nothing inherently inappropriate. 

If the district attorney finds the governors views disagreeable, he can bury the letter, ask for a different sentence or do whatever his independent discretion demands.  The DA doesn’t work at the governor’s pleasure, so it’s not as if he’s obliged to take direction from “the boss.” On the other hand, if the DA succumbs to the governor’s influence, and fails to exercise independent discretion, then the problem is with a weak DA, not a strong governor.

From a posture less deferential to the citizenry, the governor also remains a citizen, with the right to express his personal views on matter of public concern.  Certainly, a criminal prosecution and sentence falls within the ambit of a matter of public concern.  As the issues have captured the attention of the citizen who holds the office of governor, and he has personal feelings on the subject, why should he be denied the same right that any citizen would have to voice his views?

Mind you, no judge need take the views of the governor, or any elected official or private citizen, into account in determining sentence.  Judge Baldwin was under no constraint to give Ed Rendell’s views any greater weight than anyone else’s, or ignore them altogether.  Sentence is imposed by the judge, who is a part of the third branch of government and does not serve the executive.  There is absolutely nothing that Ed Rendell could do to force Baldwin’s hand; he had no greater authority over the sentence than anyone else, save Judge Baldwin.  And as Judge Baldwin made clear, he was not swayed by the governor’s influence.

Granted, Ed Rendell’s letter urging the court to impose “the maximum sentence” upon crimes for which the teens weren’t convicted leaves him looking like a bit of a fool.  But isn’t that a politician’s right too?

And not leave anyone hanging, Brandon J. Piekarsky and Derrick M. Donchak were sentenced to six months. 

H/T Doug Berman