With musical accompaniment.
H/T Lexmonitor (Kevin O’Keefe’s love child)
Author Archives: SHG
But Seriously, Give Up The Seat
A new campaign reminds subway and bus riders to give up reserved seats to the elderly or disabled.
Those who refuse could be fined $25 to $50 — or even face up to 10 days in jail.
Signs are going up this week in thousands of subway cars and buses. The law has long been on the books; transit officials are now trying to get people to obey it.
There has been a steading criminalization of bad conduct in the United States, as discussed in earlier columns. We can add the New York subways push to force people to give up their seats to the elderly and disabled — or face a potential 10 day jail term.Yeah, right. And taxi drivers have to speak English too. And use the most direct route. Man, I can barely stop laughing thinking about that one being enforced.
One of the most surprising things about New York City is that people occasionally give up a seat on the subway to the elderly, mothers with young children and pregnant women. I mean, this is New York, renown for attitude, and yet kids who would be pegged as gangbangers anywhere else offer their seat to a kid. It’s amazing.
But nobody is going to jail over it. Fuggedaboutit. Ain’t happening.
The only way to make a dent in the consciousness of New Yorkers is with a sledgehammer. It’s not a city of subtlety. Appeals to our better nature reveal that we don’t have a better nature. It’s dog eat dog, and everybody knows it. So when the powers of the subway want to persuade people to be a little more thoughtful, they need to use a little clout to make their point clear.
There are plenty of infractions in New York. No one is ever prosecuted for most of them, unless someone has simultaneously managed to severely piss off a cop in the process, in which case it doesn’t matter what the infraction is since the cop will find some reason to make you spend 24 hours in a holding cell to teach a lesson.
So the Transit Authority has decided to push the envelope with a new campaign to give up seats to the elderly or disabled or face 10 days in jail? It’s good to hear that they’ve got the money to put thousands of stickers on subway cars while they’re jacking up fares yet again.
Top 10 People to Follow on Twitter
Over at Blue Must Be True, Karl Mansoor’s homage to honest cops, he posts a list created by a police instructor, Dave Smith (sounds liek alias to me) over at PoliceOne. It’s one of those lists that tells us how the police view life from the inside of Fort Apache looking out.
1. Never run from me. My dog likes it, and I’ll just find you again… soon.Karl decided to throw in a few “nevers” of his own:
2. Never put your hands where I can’t see them… ever!
3. Never touch me, just pretend I am on fire because you will get burned.
4. Never fail to stop when I turn on my lights to pull you over; “World’s Greatest Chases” isn’t a reality show you want to get on.
5. Never argue with me. I am looking for facts not opinion… least of all yours.
6. Never lie to me, I am not one of your parents, and I probably already know more than you think.
7. Never get involved in a police action if you aren’t the complainant, a witness, or a suspect… it usually doesn’t go well.
8. Never tell me you have only had two beers, tell me the truth… we have tests.
9. Never threaten your kids with the police unless, of course, they need to be arrested!
10. Never tell me you didn’t know “that” was against the law; it doesn’t get you off and makes you look even dumber.
1. Never use more force than is absolutely necessary. Excessive force is Constitutionally unacceptable.
2. Never treat the public with disrespect. Always speak politely.
3. Never conceal the truth, even when, and especially if, the complete truth is detrimental to the police.
4. Never try to make up laws! You don’t get paid to make the laws, you get paid to enforce them.
5. Never get pissy when a citizen asserts his rights. If you want to enter my home or car, you’re going to need probable cause or a warrant, because you’re not getting my consent, (no matter home much you bitch, whine, or threaten). Not because I have anything to hide, but because I don’t want the police to forget we have a Constitution.
6. Never lie in your police report or jury testimony; you never know when there is going to be video to contradict you.
7. Never put your ego above your duty
8. Never use your office to settle personal scores
9. Never use your office to subvert the democratic process
1. Never forget that you are a public servant, not a public master.
2. Never forget that “servant” is as dignified an occupation as you make it.
3. Never forget that your credibility, and that of your fellow officers, is like a balloon — one little prick can damage it beyond repair.
4. Never forget that they guys who are telling you how special you are have their own agenda, and it’s not public service.
5. Never forget the Peelian Principles; they’re every bit as true now as they were then.
6. Never forget that the world is full of backstops, and some of those backstops have loved ones.
7. Never forget that you are a person, not “law enforcement.”
8. Never forget that the coverup gets you in more trouble than the mistake, as it should.
1. Never forget that the person you are dealing with my be another LEO’s family member – how would you like another LEO to treat them the way you do?I know how much people love lists, so I figured these lists had a little something for everyone. Sorry that this post isn’t really about the top 10 people to follow on Twitter. It’s just that a lot of people seem much more interested in whether their name is on such a list than they are in cops and constitutional rights and such, so I figured that by using a misleading title, a few of them might actually read this post and broaden their horizons a bit.
2. Never forget that the taser is the (mostly) non-lethal tool of /last/ resort. You supposedly have a brain – use it!
3. Never forget that with every encounter with the public, you are affecting the public’s trust in your fellow-officers. Negative word-of-mouth is one of the strongest advertising forces there is. Think about it!
4. Never get to thinking you are Chuck Norris. Chuck Norris has been known to roundhouse kick people pretending they are Him
5. Never forget that you not only serve the public, but that without the support of the people you serve, you cannot do your job.
6. Never get to thinking that the cops on TV dramas and in movies do things that you can get away with.
7. Never ignore the Constitution – it’s the only thing that keeps Others from putting YOU in a small, dark room, and beating the crap – or the life – out of you. Likewise the people you care about.
8. Never forget what Joe Friday said: “It’s an endless, thankless, glamorless job that’s gotta be done.” If you want thanks and glamor, got try your hand in Hollywood – if you can.
9. Never forget that one “oh, crap” erases one hundred “atta boys!”, and this applies to how the people you serve, as well.
10. Never forget that you are neither judge, jury, nor executioner, nor should you try to influence them to rack up a higher score. The only thing worse than you screwing up and blowing a conviction of the guilty is screwing up and convicting an innocent – even if the one innocent of your charges is actually guilty of worse.
11. (Bonus) Never forget that you are human, and subject to the same foibles that the people you interact with.
12. (round dozen) Never forget that the misdemeanor of your brother officer that you turn a blind eye to damages us all worse than the minor felony of a habitual offender.
13. (Baker’s dozen) Never forget that trust is a very delicate thing. Treat it as you would a fragile, precious crystal sculpture – that you promised to keep safe for your mother.
Part of the Plan
In the reviews of the factual backdrop to the Supreme Court’s Osborne decision, one factor seems to weigh heavily in some people’s mind against concern that the State of Alaska’s refusal to allow William Osborne, at his own expense, to conduct a DNA test to prove his innocence.
Prior to trial, a tactical decision was made :
Mr. Osborne’s trial lawyer decided not to pursue a second kind of DNA testing that was more discriminating. The lawyer said she feared that the results might further incriminate her client. After his conviction, Mr. Osborne sued state officials in federal court seeking access to the DNA evidence for a third kind of yet-more-discriminating testing.
This bit of information takes the wind out of Osborne’s sails. He had the chance. He rejected it for strategic reasons. Now he wants a second chance, his strategy having failed. Claims of innocence aside, it smacks of disingenuity. We’re all for fairness, but he had a fair chance and chose not to take it. Screw him, right?
This is one of the most difficult constructs in criminal law: Tactical decisions are made by the attorney, often without the defendant’s approval and, even if with the defendant’s approval, based upon the relationship of trust and expectation of professional expertise that defendant’s have in their counsel. In other words, the lawyer chose a course and it turned out wrong.
The basis for the lawyer’s choice is subject to subsequent review on the issue of ineffective assistance of counsel. In other words, if the decision was strategic, then counsel was not ineffective. Counsel simply made a decision that didn’t pan out as well as hoped. The defendant is saddled with this strategic choice because of the need for finality of convictions. If we allow defendants to revisit every choice by his lawyer, then cases would go on indefinitely and nothing would ever be resolved. Institutionally, this would mean that the system would grind to a halt as every defendant challenged every decision made in a failed defense.
There are reasons why strategic decisions are left to lawyers rather than require the approval of defendants. At the top of the list is that defendants don’t ordinarily have a clue what will make for the best strategy, and commonly make incredibly foolish choices (which is often reflected in the conduct that got them in trouble in the first place). Lower down on the list are influences that are less lofty, such as the lawyer just isn’t very good or knowledgeable or hard-working. Lower still, perhaps the lawyer had dinner plans and didn’t feel like putting in the time to research, or simply think, about what he was doing. Nonetheless, the choice is viewed on appeal as strategic if there is some way to characterize it as having some potential tactical purpose, even if not the choice that makes sense after the fact.
It’s far easier to figure out that a choice wasn’t great after trial. Losing is a great indicator. On the other hand, there’s no evidence that the alternative choice would have resulted in victory, something often assumed by clients who have been convicted. Choices are sometimes limited to bad and worse, and the best decision is to pick the least harmful course when there isn’t a good course in sight. No defendant likes to admit this after a loss.
In considering the choice made by Osborne’s trial counsel, knowing that DNA analysis at the time was somewhat spotty and, more significantly, knowing that an inconclusive DNA test was better for the defendant than a conclusive DNA test that would have nailed him to the wall, one can appreciate why his attorney made the decision she did. It’s also quite possible that she didn’t believe her client’s protests of innocence. Defendants sometimes lie to their lawyers. Maybe Osborne had a bit of history of being less than truthful, and he suffered from the defendant who cried wolf syndrome.
But there is a difference in this case that removes the pall cast over the case that comes from the sense that he had a chance to test his DNA and left it behind. By seeking one final DNA test, at the defendant’s own expense and using a test that was better than what was available at the time of trial, it fell under the “no harm, no foul” rule. It would cost the State of Alaska nothing to let Osborne have his test. If it proved that he was not the rapist, a man would be proven innocent. No state has an interest in preserving a conviction against an innocent man. Either way, the state wins, and suffers nothing in the process.
As for Osborne, I have no idea whether he harbors any animosity at his trial counsel for making the decision that she did. The available information suggests that Osborne wanted his lawyer to do the test, and the lawyer made the decision to take a pass. It’s fair to say that Osborne should not be burdened with his lawyer’s decision when his choice was otherwise. But that opens the door to gamesmanship, since the lawyer and defendant could split on every decision, just for fun, and later claim an opening to revisit each of counsel’s strategic decisions. It also undermines the lawyers ability to defend, if she loses the authority to act in what she believes to be the defendant’s best interests.
Some here believe that proclamations of innocence trump all, and that defendants should be allowed to challenge and rechallenge every aspect of the defense, ad infinitum. It’s not going to happen. It can’t happen. It shouldn’t happen. In our zeal to protect personal freedom and constitutional rights, we sometimes forget that some defendants are people who have done some very bad, very harmful things. There is a legitimate, indeed important, reason to the finality of convictions, aside from the systemic need not to tie up resources by revisiting old cases.
But the exact same rationale that demands finality of the convictions of the factually guilty similarly demands the allowance of a test that will prove, with “unparalleled ability,” that a convicted defendant is innocent. That’s where the Osborne decision went so horribly wrong.
Movie Review: Shouting Fire: Stories from the Edge of Free Speech
Airing on HBO on June 29th at 9 p.m. is a documentary film by Liz Garbus, Shouting Fire: Stories from the Edge of Free Speech. If the name Garbus sounds familiar, it should. Liz is the daughter of Martin Garbus, first amendment lawyer for clients ranging from Lenny Bruce to Don Imus. The heart of this film is an homage by daughter to father for his life’s work, a very endearing and poignant subtext to a fascinating study of the state of free speech in America.
The fear about documentaries is that they are leaden and heavy-handed in their desire to drive a point home. This was of particular concern with Shouting Fire, given that the subject lends itself to being overwrought and hyperbolic. But Liz Garbus’ handling was exceptionally gentle, never ramming the message down our throat, and instead showing sensitivity toward all sides of the argument rather than using her film to ridicule those for whom free speech was either an inconvenience or an infringement on political correctness.
Juxtaposing some of the best known historic examples of the abridgment of free speech. such as McCarthyism, Skokie and the Pentagon Papers, with some current examples, like Ward Churchill, Debbie Almontaser and Chase Harper, a high schooler who wore a t-shirt with words “Homosexuality is Shameful.” As one would expect, Garbus didn’t go for the low-handing fruit, but dealt with the problematic aspects of the first amendment head on. Free speech is almost always protected in the ugly cases, the ones expressing ideas we would rather not hear. And that, of couse, is the point of free speech.
The movie is largely fast pased, interrupted by soft-spoken commentary from Martin Garbus which makes one wonder how anyone could call him a bully, as well as Ken Starr and 7th Circuit Judge Richard Posner. Garbus also included commentary by Donna Lieberman, executive director of the New York Civil Liberties Union, which added little and fed into the stereotype of wild Jewish liberal, and Floyd Abrams, who has certainly done his share of important First Amendment cases but comes off pedantic and devoid of charm.
For those who keep abreast of First Amendment cases, the descriptions tended to be a little too long and tedious, but not so much as to make you hope for a commercial. Still, with the historic aspect of the documentary, it served to draw insightful parallels and remind us how our zeal for freedom ebbs and flows, and how the voices that one would expect to speak out in support of constitutional rights can be the same as those that seek to curtail it when transitory fears emerge.
A particularly compelling aspect of this documentary can be found in the final question posed to Martin Garbus, as to why today might be different than our past digressions into the curtailment of free speech. Garbus notes that unlike before, we are now looking at a very young Supreme Court contingent, disinclined to be terribly concerned over the infringement of speech, giving us 25 to 30 years before there is even a chance that the Supreme Court will renew its interest in returning to a robust right to free speech. He makes a great point, and to take it a step farther, there’s no guarantee that the next few justices will be cut from a different cloth than the current majority, such that his estimate might be a bit rosy.
For anyone who has a concern for the freedom of speech, and is mentally equipped to consider that it’s not just about the freedom to hear that which pleases you politically, this is a great documentary. Whatever you do, don’t miss Posner’s mumbled line about the worthiness of what children have to say. It’s a keeper.
Fair weather friends of free speech are likely to find this film more troubling, as it clearly demonstrates that some of those politically inclined toward free speech are in fact some of speech’s worst enemies, reminiscent of the recent Cyber Civil Rights debate. And for those younger folks of the libertarian bent, this documentary will serve as a great primer as to how we arrived at our current state, and will provide you with some historical perspective.
Liz Garbus’ Shouting Fire: Stories from the Edge of Free Speech is a great documentary and a fascinating film. Not only will you learn something, but you’ll enjoy it in the process. It will air on HBO on June 29th at 9 p.m.
The Right Way To Surrender (Update)
It seems like we’ve been waiting forever for the feds to arrest R. Allen Stanford for his alleged Ponzi Madoff scheme. Well, it’s finally happened, but it’s worthwhile considering the details.
Stanford, 59, was taken into custody yesterday by FBI agents who were waiting outside his girlfriend’s house in Fredericksburg, Va., said Dick DeGuerin, an attorney for the Texas financier.Regardless of what you think of Stanford otherwise, he was arrested with style. It’s not that being arrested is the new black, but if it’s going to happen, it might as well happen with class and dignity. And that’s precisely how it happened.
“Federal agents in black SUVs surrounded his girlfriend’s house this afternoon, and just sat there,” DeGuerin said. “I told him to walk out and introduce himself. So he did, and he asked them, ‘If you’ve got a warrant, take me into custody. If you don’t, I’m going to Houston.’ And they did, so they arrested him.”
This isn’t because Stanford is such a classy buy, being a billionaire notwithstanding, but because he was represented by a real criminal defense lawyer, Dick DeGuerin. There was no slinking out the back door, or hiding in the basement. There was no hiding his head. DeGuerin had his client act with dignity. An arrest can’t go any better than this.
Now, if only that could be said of both sides of the equation. Since Stanford’s arrest has been impending forever, DeGuerin had long since advised the U.S. Attorney in Houston that Stanford would be available to surrender at any time. Yet, the choice was made to take him down in Fredericksburg, Virginia rather than Houston, where he was indicted, and to send out the troops to get him rather than allow Stanford to surrender. No class at all.
It’s not that the Stanford had a right to surrender, and that the agents had no right to go out and find him wherever he might be. It’s just each side had an opportunity to show what they were made of. DeGuerin wins. No contest. That’s what you get when you have a real criminal defense lawyer advising you.
Update: United States Magistrate Judge Frances Stacy has set $500,000 bond, secured by $100,000 cash, for Stanford’s release. The government (naturally) argued that he should be held without bond since he’s a billionaire, and (naturally) has access to billions. No doubt, people will rail about the bond given the accusations against Stanford, but they are absolutely dead wrong.
Stanford, through DeGuerin, made clear to the government that he was ready, willing and able to surrender at any moment. It was the government’s choice to eschew the offer and go out to arrest him despite the offer. Even then, Stanford offered himself to agents like a gentleman. It doesn’t mean he didn’t commit the crimes alleged, but it does mean that he didn’t flee. He had those same billions available to him before, and he (like everyone else in the country) was aware this his indictment was imminent. If he wanted to flee, he had every opportunity in the world. He chose to stay.
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how it should happen, all around. Let’s see what happens with the government’s knee-jerk appeal of the Magistrate’s bond determination.
Search, Untethered
Now, with the help of the ACLU, Bierfeldt is suing Homeland Security Czar Janet Napolitano for the trouble. Via Patrick at Popehat, here is a copy of Bierfeldt’s complaint, which includes this curious paragraph:
It is well established that subjecting airline passengers to limited searches designed to detect weapons and explosives is consistent with the Fourth Amendment. But it is equally clear that such search authority constitutes a narrow exception to the Fourth Amendment’s basic prohibition of suspicionless searches, and that authority is carefully circumscribed to serve its limited purpose. As a matter of policy or practice, however, TSA has attempted to enlarge its authority, untethering it from the pressing but limited purpose of protecting civilian aviation.
I hate to be picky, but who told the ACLU that it’s up to them to give away my 4th Amendment rights? It is hardly well established that airline passenger searches are an exception to the 4th Amendment, nor does my 4th Amendment provide a “basic prohibition of suspicionless searches.” My 4th requires a warrant issued by a neutral magistrate upon probable cause. My 4th has no airplane exception. If I choose to go on a plane, I consent to being subject to a search for weapons and explosives. If I’m not in the mood for a search, I can turn around and walk toward the train station. But there is no new exception.
To the extent that we are subject to search upon seeking to board an airplane, it is an administrative search (rather than a law enforcement search) to which we willingly submit by virtue of making the decision to fly on a commercial carrier. No big deal, but no exception to the warrant requirement either.
One might think that between the ACLU and the libertarians, someone would have a clue about the scope of the 4th Amendment, both as a matter of existing law and as a matter of how they interpret the vagaries of existing law. Do these two groups mean to suggest that good old probable cause is no longer needed for a search? Are they now in the business of adopting “well-established” exceptions that courts have yet to find?
What happened to Steve Bierfeldt was clearly a violation of his 4th Amendment rights, having no bearing on the TSAs function, no justification in law of any sort and basically just an excess of chest-puffery by former Dairy Queen servers with badges who were under the mistaken belief that they could manufacture a reason to search a citizen from whatever struck their fancy. He should sue, and he should win.
But please, ACLU and libertarians, don’t go around giving away 4th Amendment rights in the process. We have courts to do that.
Why Do The Supremes Bother?
What’s surprising is that the underwhelming decision appears to be generated for no better purpose than to smack the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals with reversal. When a court’s rationale is a gooey, circular mess, there’s usually a good reason. It’s because the court doesn’t really have much of a reason for its decision, but wants a particular outcome nonetheless. Osborne is such a case.
After reciting all the expected verbiage about what great evidence DNA is, Chief Justice Roberts proceeds to justify (as succinctly explained in the syllabus) the basis for the “no new rights” policy:
The Court rejects Osborne’s invitation to recognize a freestanding, substantive due process right to DNA evidence untethered from the liberty interests he hopes to vindicate with it. In the circumstances of this case, there is no such right. Generally, the Court is “reluctant to expand the concept of substantive due process because guideposts for responsible decision making in this unchartered area are scarce and open-ended.” Collins v. Harker Heights, 503 U. S. 115, 125. There is no long history of a right of access to state evidence for DNA testing that might prove innocence. “The mere novelty of such a claim is reason enough to doubt that ‘substantive due process’ sustains it.” Reno v. Flores, 507 U. S. 292, 303. Moreover, to suddenly constitutionalize this area would short-circuit what has been a prompt and considered legislative response by Congress and the States. It would shift to the Federal Judiciary responsibility for devising rules governing DNA access and creating a new constitutional code of procedures to answer the myriad questions that would arise. There is no reason to suppose that federal courts’ answers to those questions will be any better than those of state courts and legislatures, and good reason to suspect the opposite. See, e.g., Collins, supra, at 125. Pp. 19–21.
Got it? Neither do I. If there already was a right, then why would the case be before the Supreme Court? And if the Supreme Court won’t decide whether there should be a due process right to post DNA evidence, then who is supposed to decide the parameters of substantive due process in the face of evolving technology? Feh.
While Osborne sits in prison for a rape conviction, which are curious Chief Justice notes limits his liberty interest since he’s guilty and imprisoned, and it’s not like guilty people have any particular interest in proving that they are actually innocent, the case will go back to the state court in Alaska for another shot at trying, via the nonspecific state procedures, to access the DNA. My understanding is that beneath the procedural surface in this case is a huge dispute between the defense and court about whether the right papers were submitted. Because Alaska has no procedure for handling this post-conviction relief, the defendant’s efforts to obtain testing were thwarted by constantly changing procedural requirements.
But the pressing question is whether Justice Roberts is of the view that there is a real Supreme Court hiding in a back room somewhere, awaiting a call to action when the Court actually plans to address issues and resolve grievances. That most states and the federal government have procedures in place hardly moots the issue of whether post-conviction access to DNA testing, as may prove the guilt or innocence of a defendant, is a substantive due process right. For the defendant, like Osborne, who is imprisoned in a state that doesn’t, the issue is very real and very important.
Sure, the Supreme Court is comprised of big picture guys, who can’t be bothered thinking about the plight of some guy named Osborne in Alaska, and certainly isn’t about to change the law of the land around this one poor schmuck’s rights. Fine, so don’t grant cert and let the Circuit decision stand. But no, they couldn’t tolerate that.
It’s questionable whether ten, twenty years from now, this decision would be of any worth whatsoever. The nation remains in the throws of trying to deal with emerging DNA technology and convictions that came down before it was available or before testing methods and procedures were improved. Perhaps these issues will all be suitably resolved over time, and problems with access to DNA will be old news. But for the moment, it’s not, and even if it’s only one man in a prison in Alaska, he’s still entitled to get one that makes some sense.
In response to the decision, the Innocence Project, representing William Osborne, put out a press release that said:
In states without adequate laws granting DNA testing, federal court can be the last option – as it was for Osborne. Less than a dozen of the 240 people nationwide who were exonerated through DNA testing received that testing through federal court. “Most people who need DNA testing to prove their innocence will not be affected by today’s ruling, but the small number of people who are impacted may suffer greatly. As a result of this decision, more innocent people will languish in prison and some may die in prison because they were prevented from proving their innocence,” [Peter] Neufeld said.If the majority of the Supremes didn’t want to be bothered with the plight of this small number of people, that’s fine. Then don’t take the case. But don’t take the case and then punt with an “it’s not my job” decision.
This decision goes nowhere, and certainly does nothing for poor Osborne, whose only point is to try to get his hands on the DNA to prove that he’s an innocent man. Even Chief Judge Roberts proclaims the glory of DNA for proving innocence. So where are they hiding the real Supreme Court, the one that actually decides things about due process? The one we have doesn’t seem to be of much use to anyone.
The Law, From the Cheap Seats
Another takeaway from this is the reminder of just how limited the concept of “commercial speech” is. Only advertising-centric speech qualifies; only narrowly-tailored rules can constrain it. Despite efforts by the NY state attorney licensing bureaucrats and others to expansively sweep all manner of attorney speech under the rubric of “attorney advertising,” there is a very real limit to their ability to do so. Something to keep in mind for lawyers who are concerned that their blogs need to comply with bar advertising rules.
In my ever-so-delicate manner, I replied to Josh that he was correct as of that writing, but he would have been wrong a week earlier. Josh responded that “[i]t’s been the law for almost 30 years.” This statement reflects one of the fundamental differences between litigators and non-litigators. Litigators see the contours of the law as ever-changing, the edge in a constant state of flux. Non-litigators see “The Law,” a firm and stable monolith of right and wrong, totally dependable, fixed and clear.
So why are all those lawyers and judges wasting their time in court?
This is a difference in perspective. I don’t disagree with Josh’s take, that it’s what the law “is” if one views the law as a constant. But trial lawyers rarely see the law as stagnant. Certainly, there is black letter law, issues conclusively resolved and reliable, but even these have a nasty habit of getting mangled in application. It’s a lot easier to be certain when it’s not your job to get the right judgment.
It’s long been something of a sore point with me when I engage a non-litigating lawyer in discussion over a disputed issue. These are the people you chat with when there’s a problem with a government agency, a corporation, any entity that has a lawyer “advising” them. These are lawyers who sit behind desks and opine to non-lawyers, explaining in somber tones what the law “is”. When they talk to litigators, they do the same, telling us how they “see” the law. It makes me cringe.
It’s not that they’re necessarily wrong (though they often are), but that they have this simplistic view of the law, as if whatever it says in the textbook must be true. Try achieving a resolution of a dispute with a guy who firmly believes that he knows the law, that there can be no disagreement and that he’s absolutely right. Only after a bunch of years and a ton of money will they come to realize that, maybe, just maybe, they were wrong. What would be funny if it wasn’t so sad is how they are shocked to learn of a crushing verdict when they were so certain of their correctness at the outset.
The problem with getting a firm grasp on the law is tolerance for ambiguity. Non-litigators are expected to know the law and be able to render opinions to non-lawyers as to what they can and cannot do. Nobody wants to hear a recitation of variables, but a bottom line. Is this right or wrong? That’s their job, and they do what’s expected of them. Whether they know in their heart that their very serious opinions mean nothing in the face of litigation is another matter.
Litigators, on the other hand, must have enormous tolerance for ambiguity, knowing that any case can be lost and the law is rarely, if ever, clear. Certainty, to a litigator, is a fairy tale for children.
So while Josh can blithely state that free speech for lawyers has been the law “for almost 30 years,” I have to chuckle. Josh’s opinion turns out to be right. It took a litigator to win the case make it so.
Etiquette in Charm City
From the Baltimore Sun :
Baltimore circuit judge, who has three times been the subject of judicial disciplinary investigations, ordered a spectator to jail for 10 days for crying out “love you” to her handcuffed brother in the courtroom – and then reversed himself after a public defender spoke up on her behalf.
As Tamika Clevenger left a Baltimore courtroom Friday, she shouted, “Love you, Nick,” which set off Judge Alfred Nance. He ordered a sheriff to pull Clevenger from the hallway and found the 24-year-old in contempt.
“Ma’am, your talking is over,” Nance said. Turning his ire to the other woman, who had stood up from the bench in a strapless top, Nance said, “Young lady, step in the hall. The beach is three blocks down and to the right. It’s not in this courtroom.”
There is no question that a judge has the authority to control conduct in his courtroom, ranging from maintaining order to the appropriate decorum. It’s hardly unusual for spectators to engage in disruptive outbursts, and no one would question a judge’s effort to maintain an appropriate level of control. Removing askew baseball caps, shutting off cellphones, not screaming at loved/hated ones, are all issues that are properly addressed.
For anyone reading who isn’t a lawyer, you wouldn’t believe how some people dress to come to court, or behave once they are there, as if they are daring the judge to give them a smack. It is just mind-bogglingly inappropriate and foolish. It often borders on laughable, as if they were searching for ways to piss off the judge. But there are ways to deal with this that give rise to respect. A calm explanation of why particular attire or conduct is inappropriate, coupled with a warning for the next time, usually serves far better than knee-jerk contempt with a 10 day sentence. This guy’s nuts.
So why, one wonders, is he still sitting on the bench terrorizing people for their etiquette deficits?
“Attorneys are hard-pressed to complain because they fear retaliation,” said Page Croyder, a former deputy state’s attorney who ran for judge in 1998, in part, because of allegations of improper conduct against Nance. “Attorneys know perfectly well that nothing is going to happen to these judges.”
In 2000, a commission that monitors judges’ conduct interviewed four women, then current or former prosecutors, who complained of Nance’s explosive temper and said he had made comments about their appearance and touched their faces, according to a December 2000 Sun article. At that time, State’s Attorney Patricia C. Jessamy complained about his behavior.
The Commission on Judicial Disabilities issued a reprimand, finding that he had demeaned women in court and in chambers and had been “rude” and “hostile” to attorneys in a medical malpractice case.
No doubt Judge Nance was deeply hurt by the reprimand. The proof can be seen in how he’s mended his ways.
The combination of two factors feeds on each other. The impotence of the judicial disciplinary mechanism to control judges whose conduct is improper, but not so flagrantly wrong as to warrant their removal, combined with fear of retaliation by the lawyers who have to face these judges on behalf of clients. Disciplinary commissions complain that unless people bring grievances against judges, there’s nothing they can do. Lawyers complain that if they bring grievances, the commission does nothing of consequence, and the judge remains on the bench to pay them back for their insolence.
The public is confused by all of this. How is it possible that a judge like Nance can continue to “teach” charm school in his courtroom with impunity. There must be some constraint on out-of-control judges, abusing their power like petty tyrants. There must be, right?
The short answer is that there is little to be done to stop a judge whose improprieties fall short of corruption. Chances of a judge being removed for lesser improprieties, particularly issues of temperament, are slim, and any lawyer complaining will not only make an enemy of the judge, but will harm future clients in the process. It’s hard to payback an attorney directly. It’s far easier to make the client pay.
It’s one of the reasons that a guy with a blawg must highlight and challenge conduct like this, when the locals are either too afraid or too concerned for the harm that might befall their clients. We all want to see respect prevail in the courtroom. But respect should be shown by all participants, judge included.
