Author Archives: SHG

The Death of Innocence

In the aftermath of the “shocking” DNA exoneration of convicted rapist Steven Avery in 2003,  the Wisconsin Criminal Justice Study Commission was formed.  It’s purpose, to put “a diverse body of experts and leading practitioners” in the same room and arrive at reform proposals to prevent this from happening.  Yesterday, Michael O’Hear, one of four lawprofs on the commission, posted at PrawfsBlawg of its demise.  No one was saved.

O’Hear conducts a fascinating post-mortem (I told you O’Hear was good) on this well-intended effort to improve a system which ultimately ran out of steam before accomplishing anything.  Some of the reasons he points to are basic and institutional, such as the size (two or three dozen people from diverse backgrounds) and changing fiscal priorities.  These are lessons that never seem to be learned when grand plans are made.


Another difficulty is that Wisconsin (like just about every other state right now) is experiencing great fiscal pressure, and all of our agencies are fighting tooth and nail to hold onto their budgets.In truth, our prosecutors are underpaid, and I can understand their resistance to any reform (e.g., increasing Wisconsin’s worst-in-the-nation compensation rate for court-appointed counsel) that would require a commitment of the state’s dwindling tax resources.

But the primary failure of the Wisconsin Commission is also the most basic.  The two groups needed to reach consensus, prosecutors and defense lawyers, don’t agree.

Those on the prosecution side genuinely wished to avoid wrongful convictions and listened patiently to the information and arguments presented in support of proposed reforms.I heard no accusations that either side was intentionally seeking to subvert justice or otherwise advancing a hidden agenda.Rather, each side was convinced that the other suffered from a fatal cognitive blind spot.

On the defense side, the view was that police and prosecutors did not appreciate their own subconscious tendencies to ignore or downplay the significance of exculpatory evidence (or to exaggerate the significance of dubious inculpatory evidence) once they had settled on the identity of a perpetrator. 

On the prosecution side, the view was that the defense lawyers and professors were making too much of a few high-profile DNA-based exonerations that were not truly representative of the operation of the criminal justice system.Police and prosecutors felt that defense-side concerns were speculative.In the absence of hard evidence of systemic failure, they saw no reason not to continue to rely on largely unconstrained police and prosecutor discretion to screen out innocent suspects.

This not only sums up the daily battle in the trenches, but makes one of the more painful points about the existing system.  The system has developed to the point where it facilitates conviction.  If you’re a defense lawyer, the thumb on the prosecution side is the problem that produces the conviction of the innocent.  If you’re a prosecutor, you believe that everyone you convict is guilty and, aside from the minuscule oddball case, the system is working pretty darn well, thank you very much. 

O’Hear attributes the inherent conflict to cognitive bias, each side viewing the same set of facts from its own perspective and absolutely positive that the other side just didn’t get it.  As the genesis of the reform movement was DNA exonerations, which defense lawyers view as only a fraction of the problem, prosecutors were unmoved that these cases reflected a systemic failure (on their part and the part of law enforcement, naturally) rather isolated instances.  Were these “ice cubes or the tip of the iceberg?” 

My problem is that this fight will go on forever without a winner.  If we were capable of ascertaining a real statistical basis for assessing how many people were wrongly, or overly, convicted, we would similarly be capable of preventing it.  DNA exonerations are indeed the oddball, since DNA plays a role in only a fraction of criminal cases.  But it has proven what defense lawyers have been saying forever: the system is substantially less than perfect, far less so than the public realizes. 

This raises the question of how many innocent people the public is willing to sacrifice on the alter of law and order.  Since the general public suffers from cognitive bias as well, believing as it must that the system generally functions satisfactorily and that cops, even in light of the multitude of videos now available and coming out daily proving that some fall far short of credible, are still more trustworthy than not.  As defense lawyers know all too well, the message doesn’t strike home until it affects you or someone you love.  Only then does the injustice of it all seem to matter.

The failure of the Wisconsin Commission reflects the governmental inertia and ambivalence toward reform.  Despite the well-intended desire to “reform”, when one side at the table takes the position that there is nothing to reform, there is little to talk about.  Hopes rise every time a new commission is formed, or as legislatures “finally” consider making significant changes to the processes that have encouraged and allowed the perpetuation of the problems.  But when they end in a whimper, without any significant reform, or at best “camel” proposals that achieve nothing, few people seem to notice.  We are left with essentially the same system, for better or worse.  The status quo wins.

And people wonder why I am less than supportive every time I hear about a new “reform” commission.  Did anyone notice the huge groundswell of anger and frustration from the people of Wisconsin at the failure of their commission to fulfill its mission?  I didn’t.

Error Corrected, Error Revealed

When District Court Judge John Woodcock sentenced Quinta Layin Tuleh to 238 days in jail for the good of her unborn child, it presented a conundrum.  Clearly an excess of authority on the court’s part, but certainly done with good intent.  It’s hard to argue against a laudable purpose, like making sure that a pregnant, HIV woman receives adequate medical care so that her child might be born AIDS free.

But Judge Woodcock, after imposition of sentence, had a second chance to consider his decision when, during the hearing on a motion for bail pending appeal, he learned that she could be released and receive proper medical care. From the Bangor Daily News :


Testimony on Monday from Putnam and an agent with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement allayed those concerns, Woodcock said in granting the motion for bail.

“I recognize that the sentence turned out to be controversial,” he said. “I can certainly understand how some have misinterpreted what the court intended to do in this case.”

Woodcock said that what he had wanted to do was “to step in between the prison system and the social [safety] net” to ensure that Tuleh remained healthy and that the child was born healthy.

While it’s doubtful that anyone “misinterpreted” what the court intended, Had it not been for the efforts of Tuleh’s counsel and the existence and willingness of the Frannie Peabody Center, providing support to people diagnosed with AIDS and HIV, it’s likely that the judge’s imposition of a sentence of imprisonment “for Tuleh’s own good” would have de facto stood, since even an expedited appeal to the Circuit was unlikely to have helped in time. 

So, all’s well that end’s well?  Not exactly.



“At the time of the sentencing, I had no clear understanding of what the community could do,” Woodcock said. “I had no specifics.”

This sentence is the most problematic of the bunch.  It reveals that the judge, acting upon his own assumptions, decided to put a woman in jail because he had no clue what alternative were available.  In other words, jail was the default for ignorance.  That’s outrageous.

There was no reason in the world that Tuleh’s counsel should have anticipated that the judge needed to know how Tuleh’s medical care would be handled.  It’s wholly outside the scope of the judge’s authority, and bears no connection to any cognizable sentencing factor.  If the judge, despite the fact that medical care is beyond the scope of his authority, demanded to know how she would deal with pregnancy, the method of finding out is relatively clear:  Ask someone.  Ask defense counsel, for example.  Let Tuleh’s lawyer know that this seemingly irrelevant factor is weighing heavily on the court’s mind, and no doubt he would provide the court with the information needed. 

What happened instead should send shivers down your spine.  The judge just guessed, based upon his own limited personal knowledge.  He essentially made it up.  And that became the basis for a sentence of incarceration. 

To Judge Woodcock’s credit, he was open about the purpose of his sentence, albeit after the fact.  At least this presented an opportunity for the defense to address this hitherto unknown issue that the judge, by himself and without any factual basis or investigation, addressed in his sentence.  It happens routinely, however, that judges make assumptions, never known to the parties.  No chance to challenge, to correct, even to know what’s going on inside the judge’s head. 

While federal judges deserve, and are given, ample credit for their intelligence, they don’t know everything.  There’s a wide world of information out there, and no matter how smart or worldly, even judges need to seek hard facts to fill the gaps of assumption.  The requisite information should be subject to the same adversarial testing if disputed as any other claimed fact. 

What should never happen is a judge admitting, after his error is shown, that he acted without a “clear understanding.”  No matter how brilliant a judge thinks he is, it’s never within his authority to simply assume that he inherently possesses sufficient information to make secret assumptions as here.  At least Judge Woodcock had the integrity to admit it.

H/T Doug Berman

One Camera Too Many

Investigative journalism has brought us some remarkably important stories.  Would there have been a Watergate with Bernstein and Woodward?  Not likely, and it toppled a regime.  But that doesn’t mean that a camera in the hands of every journalist is by definition a good thing. 

Tara Rosenblum, a News 12 reporter in the employ of Cablevision, proved the point when she sought to manufacture a story at Holy Cross Catholic Church in New Rochelle.  From New Rochelle Talk :

With lights blazing and cameras rolling, Tara Rosenblum, in what could pass for an homage to [Anchorman character Ron]Burgundy’s co-anchor Veronica Corningstone, pushes her way into a meeting room at Holy Family Church and interrupts an in-progress, closed 12-Step meeting in a grand-standing stunt she grandiosely bills as “The Confrontation”. She is also trespassing and when asked to leave refuses and continues to question the people. You can just barely hear it over her shouted questions but you can make out a man’s voice saying politely “please leave”.
It seems that Rosenblum learned that the church was simultaneously hosting CYO basketball in its gymnasium and a Sexaholics Anonymous meeting elsewhere at Holy Cross.  Having “staked out” the place, she goes in for the kill.



As noted by Robert Cox in his New Rochelle Talk post, the production value, intended to make this travesty appear melodramatic, apparently the next best thing to substantive when an investigation turns up a turd, News isn’t mean to be film noir, and bad journalism isn’t made better by sound and lighting effects.  But that’s a reflection of bad production taste.  What of Rosenblum’s total lack of journalistic integrity?

She asserts at one point that there is a known pedophile amongst the group.  How she would know such a thing with an anonymous group is a mystery, though she later claims there are multiple sex offenders in there.  Details matter when one purports to be a journalist.

But even more to the point, this is an anonymous 12 step meeting of people who are trying to deal with a problem.  Granted, sexaholics sound funnier to most people than alcoholics, and hence might make the children watching twitter with evil glee, feeling far less inclined to take a critical view of Rosenblum’s attempt to “out” the anonymous participants.  But these are people making an effort to deal with their problems, not people on the prowl for young children.  People go to these programs for a socially critical purpose, and do so under the belief that their identities will remain anonymous.  And yet this twinkie thinks that’s an invitation to push her way in with the camera rolling?

There is no suggestion that any child has in any way been harmed, or even that harm of any sort has been threatened, at Holy Cross Church.  Had there been such a suggestion, perhaps this group might be worthy of journalistic interest, though the handling of such a story in this fashion could never be justified.  But this was an invention by Rosenblum, wholly without justification.

The ramifications of this one twinkie’s efforts for people seeking help are obvious.  Should people attending 12 step meetings fear being outed by every fifth-string pseudo-investigative reporter, avoid seeking help and fail to make the effort to address their problems?  Should church’s stop providing the rooms for these meetings to be held because they serve a wider community with programs for teens as well as adults?  Maybe Cablevision would like to offer up its executive suite for use by 12 step programs?  I’ve been in the executive wing of Cablevision’s offices.  They’re very elegant and would do nicely for the next Sexaholics Anonymous meeting.  The list goes on.

Clearly, Tara Rosenblum lacks the intelligence, discretion and basic good taste to be allowed outside with a camera crew.  She’s dangerous.  If Cablevision feels constrained to keep her on the payroll, perhaps they could find another job more suited to her skills.  Like answering Jim Dolan’s phone.

H/T The Turk (who is not, I repeat, not one of the individuals in Rosenblum’s video, no matter how great the similarity.)

A Talk With Judge Chin About Bernie

Sentencing date for Bernie Madoff is fast approaching, and the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York has submitted statements from 113 victims of his fraud.  The statements consist of letters and emails, some straightforward and some in multiple parts, with varying requests and copies to Senators. 

One email, from a fellow named Ed Hamilton, is only copied to the judge, but directed at Ira Lee Sorkin, Madoff’s lawyer, offering an argument about how Madoff’s crimes pale in comparison to those perpetrated by the government by suckering in the public to invest in a corrupt system, supported by media silence.  It can be found at page 33 of the submission, and was copied to everyone from the President to the WSJ Law Blog.

For the most part, they tend to follow a familiar formula.  The writers are in their twilight years.  Their savings disappeared in an instant.  Their lives, their plans, their goals, turned upside down.  They express their anger, horror, misery at being left destitute despite a lifetime of work and saving.  The vast majority of writers aren’t celebrities or fabulously wealthy, but our next door neighbors who worked hard, saved and invested. 

Many end up invested with Madoff through a variety of feeder funds.  These people neither expected nor received irresponsible returns.  Some explained that they were getting 6% or 9% returns, meaning that the good people with whom they thought they were investing were taking the difference between Bernie’s promises and the victim’s single digits.  While a few had large positions and endowed medical schools, most had rather modest investments.  The vast majority had their entire life savings invested.

There a bunch of letters from people who have formed a group called the Ponzi Victims Coalition, apparently believing that they can carry greater weight through numbers.  They are sought to obtain ancillary relief from the Senate Finance Committee for Madoff victims, via the IRS and SIPC, with some success.  The government included copies of their letters to the Senate in the package.

In Exhibit B are the requests to speak at the time of sentence.  These are people who believe that their personal knowledge, experience, rhetorical skills, will have be especially persuasive.  Some are willing to travel across the country to have their say. 

There is one theme that pervades the letters.  They believe that Bernie Madoff’s open plea is part of some shifty scheme to beat the system, to gain sympathy for himself and his family, and to trick the court into imposing a lenient sentence.  They are scared that Bernie’s going to pull off one last scam.  They want him in prison forever.  They want him to die there.

The letters are very personal, many providing financial and health details that really shouldn’t be broadcast on the internet.  They are filled with the anger and frustration of real people.  And strangely, they are remarkably pedestrian.  They are victims of crime, economic circumstances, the many maladies that ordinary people suffer.  Each victim, standing alone, sounds very much like the victim of any crime, suffering the consequences and seeing their plight as the most horrible thing that can happen to a person.

Having read these letters and email, what’s a judge to do?

Clearly, these letters serve a critical cathartic need for many victims.  To the extent that they allow the victims to feel that they are participating in the process, their voices heard, their circumstances considered, their anger released, these letters and emails serve a valuable purpose. 

Whether you feel sorry for the victims or see them as complicit in Madoff’s crimes, as greedy people seeking to cash in on the scheme for their own ends, isn’t relevant.  The letters tell the story of normal people, who have suffered greatly as a result of Madoff.  Even if they are less than pure, the consequences have dwarfed by a huge magnitude whatever guilt one imputes to them.  And for many, the letters make clear that they had no responsibility whatsoever.  They received no disproportionate returns and never knew that their money ended up invested with Madoff.

But there is nothing in these letters that Judge Chin didn’t already know.  In spades.

Many of the letters suggest that Madoff is a murderer, for having murdered the dreams and efforts that the victims accumulated over a lifetime.  They write that he murdered the futures of children and grandchildren, who expected their college tuitions to be paid.  They want Bernie Madoff to be sentenced as a murderer. 

Such exaggerations struck me in the opposite way from that intended.  It reminded me that Madoff was not a murderer, and that his victims lost only money, not lives or loved ones.  Ask the family of a murder victim whether it’s the same, and they will no doubt be happy to explain the difference between the loss of money and the loss of a child or a father.

Another thing that struck me was the expectation that their financial futures were secure, until Madoff came along to change everything.  This came across poorly because of the times, an economy that has ruined many lives, depleted savings and rendered well-intended people destitute.  There are many in similar situations as the Madoff victims, but with no face to stare at and hate. 

It’s not that Madoff’s victims haven’t suffered, but that they aren’t alone in their suffering.  It’s not like the rest of America is having a party.  Financial suffering is pervasive; the Madoff victims have someone to blame while the rest have angst with no particular villain.

But I don’t imagine that any of this will change Judge Denny Chin’s mind when it comes time to impose sentence.  Bernie Madoff will go to prison and will, in all likelihood, die in prison.  It’s inconceivable that he or Sorkin would believe otherwise.  The magnitude of the offense, combined with his age, presents few other options. 

It’s impossible to explain what sentence billions of dollars of loss by fraud should merit under 18 USC 3553(a).  There’s simply no calculus that has a grounded basis.  But to the extent that it must reflect a degree of seriousness that exceeds the sentences imposed and upheld on others who engaged in large scale fraud, it will likely exceed any life expectancy Bernie might have.  And Judge Chin cannot impose life plus cancer, so the pleas that the judge make Madoff suffer like they do will never be adequately fulfilled.

But the letter and emails helped these individuals to release their feelings of anger and frustration.  They served their purpose.

When Bennett Goes Slumming

The Texas Tornado, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, isn’t one to hang out at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center all day long waiting for something fun to happen.  He goes out and finds it, and he’s done it again in this post.  That’s why he was voted the best criminal law blawger around.

Bennett has taken notice of the growth of cop blogs, and lists a few of his favs.



I started reading, and frankly, found it incredibly hard to stop.  These are simply fascinating.  And there are plenty more, from the venerable Beat and Release to the depth of The Philosophical Cop.  While each brings a slightly different twist on a remarkably common theme, my favorite is the first one listed by Bennett, If you got stopped….you deserved it.  Not only does our dirty talking motorcycle cop have plenty of stories about the really bad people who speed, but he’s got a marvelous way of telling them which makes it almost sounds as if he wasn’t totally insane.

Once I started reading the cop blogs, I found myself mesmerized.  If ever there was good reason to blog anonymously, this was it.  These were posts straight from the heart, if not the mind, of real cops.  They smelled real.  They tasted real.  They were real.  If they had to put a name to them, you can bet that they would be utterly worthless and totally official.  This is what goes on in the mind of an officer when they are free to tell it as they see it. 

No sense in my telling you any more about these blogs when you can read them yourself.  One warning: Put aside a good hour of your life to read and absorb.  Once you start, you’re going to keep reading and reading.  If you ever wondered whether your view of cops was a product of prejudice or paranoia, these will put the question to rest and answer all of your doubts.

Invitations to the Party, Academic Edition

Criminal Law Professor Michael O’Hear of Marquette Law School, famous for its “we don’t teach nobody to be stinkin’ lawyers” approach to education, provides a fascinating insight into how scholars go astray.  In this post at PrawfsBlawg, O’Hear asks some questions about how best to throw a party.  He calls it a conference.

First, a bit about O’Hear for those who may not be familiar.  A 1996 Yale Law grad, he clerked for Connecticut District Court Judge Janet Bond Aterton, of Ricci v. DeStefano fame, before getting a job with Sonnenschein Nath & Rosenthal in Chicago doing civil and criminal litigation.  After three years, he joined the faculty at Marquette Law School, where he’s described as:


A nationally recognized authority on sentencing and federal criminal law, Dean O’Hear teaches Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure, and related courses. He is an editor of the Federal Sentencing Reporter and the author of more than thirty scholarly articles on sentencing and criminal procedure.

Michael O'Hear

Just in case you don’t recognize him, his photo is on the right.  You wouldn’t want to be the only one nationally who doesn’t.  Now that I’ve written something overly snarky to highlight that even academics have a knack for needless self-aggrandizement, I happen to think well of Michael O’Hear’s writing.  The fact that I’m taking advantage of his post to make my point shouldn’t be read to suggest otherwise.  But that said, let’s consider O’Hear’s question to the other lawprofs, about how best to throw a conference.


Finally, who should the audience be? I have attended some conferences that have plainly been conceptualized as academics talking to academics, but others that have just as plainly been designed for a larger, more diverse audience, including students and practitioners. I have taken the latter approach with my two conferences. If my law school is footing the bill to fly in a bunch of smart people from around the country to have an interesting conversation, it seems only natural to try serve as many institutional interests as possible through that conversation, including teaching and community outreach interests. Moreover, I’ve found that law students and practitioners, while perhaps not as steeped in the scholarly literature as academics, often have valuable comments and questions that inject important practical considerations into scholarly discussions.

Reading this query, I was constrained to begin with the fact that O’Hear, who I assume to be smart as a whip, has substantially less actual experience than your basic public defender.  To the extent that he’s got anything to say about criminal law, procedure or sentencing, it’s theoretical.  He can’t even claim a stint in the U.S Attorneys office to say he’s got the chops to talk about the practice of law.  And yet he teaches it to future lawyers?  It’s a fascinating thing, scholarship.  So high-brow, yet so disconnected.

But when it comes time for conferences, O’Hear takes the position that the larger community, students and practitioners, should be allowed in the door.  Here’s the line that caught me:


I’ve found that law students and practitioners, while perhaps not as steeped in the scholarly literature as academics, often have valuable comments and questions that inject important practical considerations into scholarly discussions.
The first curiosity is the lumping together of students and practitioners, who O’Hear notes, “often have valuable comments.”  By feeling compelled to mention this, he suggests that this is something that other academics would dispute.  Of course, students and practitioners are fundamentally similar, as far as scholars are concerned, neither being “steeped in the scholarly literature.”  To me, there are a few distinctions worthy of note, but then, I’m a practitioner.  What would I know?

In the past, Marc Randazza has characterized the doings of academics as a “circle jerk,” a phrase which  at least one finds “juvenile”.  Yeah, well, it may be but it’s just so darned descriptive.  The question that demands an answer is why bother to hold a conference at all?  Is there a purpose to all this scholarship, aside from getting tenure or gaining even greater national recognition for one’s scholarliness?  Might a conference on a topic of, oh, say criminal law, have some ultimate applicability to something like, oh, say criminal law?  Or is this a chance for the gang to party?  Put on those blazers with the leather patches over the elbows and impress your friends in the Academy?  Share a glass of sherry while smoking a pipe?  Actually, I don’t think smoking is allowed any longer, so strike the pipe thing.

In my effort to avoid needless offense as I offer my low-brow, unsteeped practitioner view of the world, might I suggest that putting a group of lawprofs into a room who sum total of actually experience in the real world is the practical equivalent of kindergarten serves little utility?  If you think you’ve got a brilliant theory, test is against my reality.  If it’s got any rigor, it can withstand a little scrutiny.  But if it doesn’t fly to the unsteeped crowd, the ones who stand besides the folks who you would have live with the theories you develop under your sanitary conditions, then what the heck are you wasting your time for?

Again, I use Michael O’Hear as my example only because he was foolish enough to ask a question that I’ve no doubt many in academia have considered.  There’s nothing he’s done, that I’m aware of, that suggests he’s a bad sort of fellow, or hasn’t contributed some good ideas on the issue of criminal law.  But he reveals the scholarly bias that compels confrontation.  Since so many of us, practitioners and media, turn to lawprofs for their thoughts on very important substantive matters, and the lawprofs are ever so eager to give their opinion, it’s of critical importance that we appreciate the value of these comments.  These opinions frame issues and thought.  Scary.

The problem with filling a room with very intelligent, overly steeped lawprofs, whose only gap is that they’re possessed of such limited actual experience that their most enlightened thoughts are wholly disconnected from reality, is that it serves no functional purpose whatsoever.  This may not disturb scholars, but it makes the rest of us wince in pain.  We don’t see much point in engaging in discussion about subjects that lead nowhere and have no actual purpose or application.  It matters not how many pats on the back the conference coordinator receives from his peers. 

As for the students, they really don’t have much to offer for our purposes.  Lacking any experience at all, they’re finest thoughts are even less connected to reality than yours.  But on the other hand, since it’s their tuition that pays for your sherry, you ought to let them sit and watch so that at least they will know why they’re in debt for the decade following graduation.

Who You Gonna Call?

On the heels of Brian Cardall’s death by taser comes the demise of Manny Morales in Port St. Lucie, Florida.  Depressed and suicidal, after losing custody of his four kids as well as his job, he locked himself in a room and started drinking.  His sister Angie was worried for him, so she sought help.

According to police, Manny was first tased and then shot twice in the abdomen.  The media reports are sparse on details, with the police saying that he was “armed”.  The family said that there was a BB gun in the house, but no other weapons.  Of course, a man with a BB gun can look sufficiently armed to cause an officer to pull his weapon out and protect himself.  Yet that doesn’t appear to be what happened.

According to WPTV News :


“They gave him several commands,” said Tom Nichols with the Port St. Lucie Police Department.  “He didn’t comply and the officers felt their life was in jeopardy.”

If Manny had a gun, even if only a BB gun, you can bet big money that Nichols would have said so.  Few would seriously question a cop facing a gun and acting upon it.  When the reports are limited only to the vague term “armed”, it’s because whatever “weapon” he was supposedly holding would be more embarrassing if disclosed than concealed. 

But the point isn’t whether the shooting was justified.  The officer involved, Albert Riccardi, has been placed on administrative leave and is under investigation.  No doubt he wishes he could take those two rounds back, for his own sake if not Manny’s.  But it’s done.  He’s tainted for life and Manny Morales is dead.


“We didn’t want to shoot anybody,” Nichols said. “But at the end of the day our responsibility is to protect and serve.”
Therein lies the problem.  By some tacit twist of logic, the death of a psychologically disturbed man falls into the “protect and serve” hole.  What he means to say is that, at the end of the day, stercus accidit, and the world of policing moves on.

The irony is that we still believe that when we are in need of assistance, we can turn to police, close our eyes, click our heels twice, and believe that they will arrive, exercise intelligence, discretion and, dare I say it, empathy, and help us.  We believe that our loved one will weather the encounter alive. 

When someone you care about is suffering from psychological distress, think twice about who you call.  Once for Brian Cardall.  Once for Manny Morales.  Once the call is made, there’s no going back.

Soapbox Justice

The first post on Simple Justice, long before the regular readers today even knew of its existence, was entitled “Justice is a funny thing.”  It reflects my pragmatic view of the system and my role of criminal defense lawyer.  We aren’t advocates for justice.  We’re advocates for defendants accused of crimes.  This upsets those who want to climb up on the soapbox.

Many readers, and particularly many commenters, wear the helmet that Cervantes placed on Don Quixote.  They get on a soapbox to rail against injustice.  These people tend to be shocked when I dismiss their naiveté, or fail to applaud their cries for justice.  They expect me to stand behind them 100% and provide them with a platform for their views.  They turn on me for my failure to do so, whether because I disagree or because I don’t allow Simple Justice to become a church to the cause.  They can’t begin to understand why.

Here’s the deal.  I join with others to expect and demand justice from the government, the police, the prosecutors.  These are institutions of government, the existence of which depends on their serving the purposes for which we have given them power and authority to control the lives of others.  It’s my belief that these institutions must be held to their purpose or they have no reason to exist. 

But criminal defense lawyers are not the opposite of these institutions.  Our existence is not to serve justice, as some mistakenly assert.  Our existence is to defend clients using whatever means the law allows, with the single-minded zeal our clients deserve.  This means that we are often the enemies of justice, to the extent that justice is defined as the outcome that best serves the greater good.  This means that if we do our jobs properly, guilty people will walk free. 

I see the audience at Simple Justice as being lawyers and sophisticated non-lawyers.  But I have no control over who reads this stuff.  I frequently get comments, often prolix, barely comprehensible rants, tangentially related to a post and screaming about Freedom, and Due Process and the like.  Most readers never see these comments, as I delete them as soon as I see them.  They are the rants of ideologues who, their fervor aside, present a simplistic, usually ignorant, perspective.  They bring nothing intelligent to the discussion, even though I may well be sympathetic to their cause.

This happens with lawyers as well, unfortunately.  Usually young lawyers, naive and full of their own self-importance, believing that thoughts that just popped into their heads are so valuable and original that they must be shared with others.  Sometimes, I try to talk these lawyers off the ledge, but they tend not to believe that they haven’t come up with a truly novel and important idea and get angry with me for trying.  These lawyers tend not to last long here either.  They get angry with me for speaking my piece here without letting them speak theirs.  It’s unfair. 

I’m often told that my posts here are properly characterized as “rants”.  That may be, but it’s not how I see them.  I write what I think, as clearly as possible.  My suspicion is that my writing tends to be far clearer, and stronger, than many others, which makes them appear rant-like in contrast.  From where I stand, the problem is not me, but others in their failure to present a point of view clearly or forcefully.  So many people write posts that, after reading them, leave you either unclear as to their point or so equivocal that they can wiggle out of their opinion as needed.  Many writers are deathly afraid of writing what they think lest someone disagree.  I do not admire people who are too afraid to state their true opinions, even if unpopular or potentially contrary to their carefully-crafted marketing persona.

At least the ideologues, stupid as their comments often are, have hard opinions.  At least they have the guts to write what they mean.  This is tempered by those who  use absurd names, like “Truth Seeker” or “Voice of Reason,” which almost invariably assures us that they are the views of a nutjob.  This, by the way, is a word of caution to anyone who is inclined to post under such names; Chances are very good that I will assume you’re insane and either delete or ignore whatever you post.  Just because you belief your thoughts to be the “truth” doesn’t mean they are, or that they are worthy of consideration.  Sorry, but if they don’t pass muster with me as offering anything worthy of consideration, they are subject to deletion.  You are free, of course, to start your own blog and post your thoughts to your heart’s content, but I don’t have to let you use my bandwidth.

If you expect to find a sympathetic ear at Simple Justice for those who are on a mission for justice, you might find be disappointed.  First and foremost, I am a criminal defense lawyer.  I defend people accused of crimes.  They don’t come to me for justice; they come to me to win.  That’s what I try to do.  My commentary is colored by my role as a criminal defense lawyer.  For my intended audience, this comes as no surprise.  Ideologues, however, are not pragmatic.

Other criminal defense lawyers may well believe that they stand for justice.  I stand for clients. 

Another Prosecutor Loses Her Virginity

This could have started out as another story about bad cops, lying their way into a drug bust of two innocent men.  But then, what’s new about that, except that this time there was a videotape proving that the two men were innocent.  Not less guilty than alleged, but totally, 100% innocent, as in there was no drug deal at all and the bust was a wholesale fabrication.

On the one side of this story, but for an uptown bar with video surveillance, there would have been no way to prove that the two men, bothers Jose and Maximo Colon, did not do what the undercover detective claimed they did.  Their word, the word of two Dominican immigrants, against the word of New York City Police Officer Henry Tavarez.  Guess who wins that swearing contest? 

But this isn’t a story about the victory of truth over police lies.  The brothers owned a convenience store.  Owned, as in past tense, as the arrest caused them to lose their license to sell tobacco, alcohol and lottery tickets, the lifeblood of convenience stores.  Their business was ruined, and their lives left in shambles.  So they weren’t convicted of crimes they didn’t commit, but hardly escaped unscathed.

Jose was represented by a Queens lawyer, Rochelle Berliner.  When he brought her the surveillance videotape from the bar proving that no drug deal occurred, her reaction, according to the New York Times, was quite strong:


”I almost threw up,” she said. ”Because I must’ve prosecuted 1,500, 2,000 drug cases … and all felonies. And I think back, Oh my God, I believed everything everyone told me. Maybe a handful of times did something not sound right to me. I don’t mean to sound overly dramatic but I was like, sick.”

It’s good that Berliner had this epiphany, and disturbing in the extreme.  She promotes herself heavily on her website as a former prosecutor.



CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY WITH OVER 17 YEARS EXPERIENCE
FORMER NEW YORK COUNTY ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY,
ASSISTANT SPECIAL NARCOTICS PROSECUTOR,
AND APPELLATE PROSECUTOR

Her biography goes into greater detail. 


Immediately after law school, I started working at the New York County D.A.’s Office, where I stayed for approximately 14 years. I spent my first two years in the Appeals Bureau and then transferred to Special Narcotics, where I remained until I left the office in May 2005. While in narcotics, I worked on long-term and short-term investigations, a lengthy wiretap case and, of course, street-level drug sale cases. During that time, I tried many cases and acquired extensive litigation skills and experience.

I left the D.A.’s office in May 2005 and started my own criminal defense practice, and that is what I am doing today.

She does indeed have 17 years of experience, though only 4 years as a criminal defense lawyer.  Those four years became more valuable after she met Jose Colon.  I’ve discussed the problems, both ethical and practical, with the exploitation of prior experience as a prosecutor.  Rochelle Berliner just learned the lesson the hard way.  This case stole her virginity.

What is disturbing about Berliner’s exclamation is not that she spent 14 years prosecuting people without having realized that maybe, just maybe, her cops weren’t perfect.  That’s to be expected of career prosecutors, who often spend their entire careers with their heads deeply embedded in the cops’ derrière.  It tends to give one a poor view of reality.  It’s that she spent four years since leaving Special Narcotics as a defense lawyer and yet, not until now, was aware of the fact that cops, sometimes, fabricate crimes out of whole cloth.  That’s four years of defendants represented by someone who was certain that they wouldn’t have been arrested if they weren’t guilty.

Now, Rochelle Berliner knows better. That’s good.  It was time she learned what it means to be a defense lawyer.  After four years as a criminal defense lawyer, the time was long past due that she pulled her head out.

The District Attorney’s office has a pat response whenever someone claims that the cops fabricated a crime:  Why would they do such a thing?  It’s not like they have a vendetta against the defendants, where they would go out and find Jose and Maximo Colon, target them for a false allegation and manufacture a case against them.  Why would police officer risk their jobs, their careers, their pensions, to get two men they never met before?  It’s ridiculous.

And it is ridiculous, but that doesn’t mean that it doesn’t happen.  It means that neither Jose nor Maximo Colon could explain why.  Only Police Officer Henry Tavarez can explain his motive in framing the Colon brothers for a crime, and no doubt he’s not talking.  There are, of course, some generic reasons, to get a bust, any bust, under his belt.  To get some overtime.  To get a medal.  To show his pals in the group that he’s not a screw up.  But this is mere speculation. 

Consider the learning curve of a former prosecutor turned criminal defense lawyer.  Full of their insider knowledge, they take on cases believing that they have all the weapons that any other lawyer would have, plus the knowledge gained from their years on the other side, giving them a great advantage over those lawyers who lack a prosecutorial background. 

Consider how many times this caused the former prosecutor to rush to the wrong assumption about her own clients, believing that the defendant was dead in the water despite his protestations of innocence, and persuading defendants to cop a plea.  No sleep was lost because, at the end of the day, the defendant was where he belonged.  You can’t spend that long in the District Attorney’s office without gaining a belief that its mission is pure and its judgment sound. 

Rochelle Berliner now knows better.  Welcome to the ranks of criminal defense lawyer, where we don’t have all the answers but we do know that the prosecution doesn’t either.  You’re lucky that you’ve joined in the age of pervasive video, or you still wouldn’t believe this possible.  Imagine how many times before the age of video Dominican immigrants like the Colon brothers were convicted for crimes that never happened, with someone like you feeling awfully good about it.  I can understand why this would make you sick.

So congratulations on losing your virginity.  I hope it didn’t hurt too much.  I’m sure it didn’t feel very good for Jose and Maximo Colon, and I hope Police Officer Henry Tavarez loses his soon.

Dead and Dying Links

Every now and again, I take a spin around the blogosphere to see who’s still alive.  I check my own blogroll to see whether blogs that were once vibrant are now dormant.  I check the blogrolls of others for blogs I’ve never read before or blogs that once held some interest but for one reason or another have failed to keep it.

So many are gone.  So many dead links.

There are many reasons why blogs die.  The bloggers were sold a bill of goods by the marketers that social media was the future of the law, and they learned that it was a load of crap after the 12th telephone call from a person desperately in need of a lawyer.  Pro bono.  The bloggers learned that it isn’t easy to write a couple times a week, particularly if you want to produce content of any substance.  The bloggers learned that if you post crap, nobody comes.  The bloggers found out that telling others how great you are really isn’t going to help your practice.

What I find particularly interesting is the correlation between blogs with grandiose names, or pompous claims, and blogospheric failure.  I suppose this is due to the fact that the lawyers who desire the most readily searchable names are likely to be the lawyers least capable of producing a worthwhile blog.

What this does produce, unfortunately, is a ton of flotsam and jetsam left behind in the blogosphere, the sort of debris floating about the ether into which the unwary will crash.  Bear in mind, dead blogs don’t necessarily go away, but simply exist like the ancient shipwrecks at the bottom of the ocean, except with nothing interesting or cool about them.  A better analogy would be the lawn signs of losing candidates left along a highway, reminding people that the candidate lost until the signs finally deteriorate and disintegrate.  But nothing disintegrates on the internet, so the reminder of the failure of these blogs could be there forever.

It’s understandable that many lawyer wanted to hop on the bandwagon when blogs were the newest, coolest thing going.  It’s similarly understandable that it didn’t work out, whether because it failed to produce your desired outcome or you just couldn’t handle the pace.  It’s okay.  Blogging isn’t for everybody.  And blogging certainly isn’t the magic bullet to success that its promoters contend.

But when you decide to call it a day, I ask you one thing.  Take it down.  Pull it.  Remove it, once and for all.  Do this for me.  More importantly, do this for you.

For my purpose, you’re leaving your litter and cluttering up my blogosphere.  Clean up after yourself so the blogosphere doesn’t become a dump, a wasteland of old/bad news. 

For your purpose, your dead blog is a tombstone.  When someone googles your name, they may find your old, ugly, dead blog, a monument to failure.  Is that the image you’re seeking to promote?  Trust me, when your last post dealt with a novel bit of news from October, 2008, you’ve brought yourself no glory.  It makes you look bad, particularly when your sidebar proclaims that you’re on the cutting edge of legal news and thought, and that your blog reflects how great you are as a lawyer. 

There was no expectation that every lawyer would one day have a blog, except from the folks who make their living off selling lawyers blogs.  The rest of us knew that this wasn’t for everyone, and didn’t serve the purpose that motivated the vast majority of short-run bloggers.  So you had to find out for yourself?  Fair enough. 

Now that you’ve given it a shot, and moved on to greener pastures like twitter, please take your old blog down.  Consider it the greening of the blogosphere.