When the case of Stern v. Bluestone was first discussed here, it was following a 3-2 loss at the Appellate Division, First Department, which held that “it defied common sense” to believe that a lawyer would write an essay on a legal subject and distribute it but for the purpose of advertising. I took umbrage with that characterization.
Well, it’s no longer the law of the State of New York. The Court of Appeals decision has come down, and the decision of the First Department was reversed, with costs. That our names may be attached to our writings is no longer conclusive proof that lawyer speech is, by definition, commercial. Not that the judges believe we’re altruistic, but they have chosen to give us the benefit of the doubt.
The case, arising under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, was a flashpoint between those who hate junk faxes (which is pretty much everyone with a fax machine) and those who understood that this wasn’t about faxes at all, but about defining lawyers as self-promoting scoundrels worthy of only limited speech rights.
It’s not say that some lawyers aren’t just scum, whose exercise of free speech brings disgrace upon them and shame upon the profession. We certainly have our share. But not all of us, and not every lawyer should be tarred by those lawyers who just can’t help themselves from the constant, nauseating self-promotion that the hypsters tell them will bring great wealth and success.
This was a crucial battle fought to establish that there are lawyers whose speech deserves full protection. And there are. As Eugene Volokh and Eric the Turk have noted, the emanations from this case had the potential for disastrous consequences for all lawyer writings, from articles to the blogosphere. No longer will the equation be “lawyer + writing = advertising.”
Discussion of this case, and the TCPA, has raised many cackles in the past, with TCPA supporters arguing zealously that nobody, but nobody, has the right to send them an unsolicited fax. Lest this issue arise again, and I get the rush of zealots who want to argue the same irrational arguments that have been tried and rejected by intelligent people (as happened to Eugene when he posted about this), the question has nothing to do with intrinsic right to annoy anyone or intrude on their fax machine, toner or paper.
The TCPA prohibits what it prohibits, and it’s limited, by its terms, to commercial solicitations. If you think it should cover everything, that’s fine but irrelevant to the issue in this case. The law simply does not prohibit faxes that are not commercial solicitations, and that’s not a subject of debate. It’s the law. You can disagree all you want, but you’re wrong. End of story.
Of course, that doesn’t mean you should go out and hype yourself under the guise of being a great humanitarian. We know who’s full of it and whose not, as does everyone else. And if there’s anyone out there who still uses a fax machine, don’t send anything out that hasn’t been requested. It just pisses people off, whether you have a right to do so or not.
Author Archives: SHG
There’s No Cravath System For Criminal Defense
Jordon goes full bore on the “best and the brightest” claim that is supposed to bring comfort to the top law schools and top law firms, who promote a self-image that, in the trenches, has long been recognized as utterly meaningless.
Let’s start with the law schools. Everyone knows there are elite schools and non-elite schools, right? Even if you don’t read the noxious US News & World Report law school rankings or their equivalents in other countries, you “know” which are the “best” schools, especially if you graduated from one of them.
And that brings me to the final aspect of the “best and brightest” phenomenon that’s so problematic: this belief that the “top” lawyers are to be found at the “top” firms. I am not saying, not a for a nanosecond, that large well-known firms don’t count among their ranks some of the finest lawyers the profession has produced. Of course they do. But they don’t own the exclusive monopoly on that particular asset.
But the main reason these firms are considered the best is — wait for it — they recruit only from the best law schools! The Cravath system has been around for so long that the “top” law schools and the “top” law firms now perform a little pas-de-deux, each using the other tautologically to confirm its own higher sense of self (”our graduates go to the best firms”; “we recruit only from the best schools.”)
For those who have worked hard to follow the path most acknowledged, their faith in the truth of the path is unshakable. And they consider others who been unable to meet their achievements failure. Those who attend the best schools and are hired by the best firms are, by definition, “the best and the brightest.”
Put aside for a moment that the phrase comes from David Halberstam’s book about those who laid claim to the title proving to have failed miserably; a ignominious title of self-aggrandizing, massive failure. The phrase has been used for so long to signify the opposite of its original intent as to assume the nouvelle meaning. It’s become a blanket of self-fulfillment that its adherents wrap around themselves to shield them from actual scrutiny.
Indeed, the obsession and assumption is that law school/Biglaw answers all questions when it comes to legal greatness. Jordon has had enough of it. I’ve never accepted it. Neither should you. If this means that everything you’ve done, struggled for, fought for, achieved, amounts to nothing, tough nuggies. The pas-de-deux is not a substitute for proving your mettle.
Recently, a commenter tried to ridicule me by point at my law school, as if the absence of HLS on my diploma proved me a loser. He could not have missed the mark any worse. For one thing, after 25 years of practice, I can barely remember my law school. But more importantly, I am the product of my 25 years of cases, of clients, of causes and arguments and verdicts and decisions. No Harvard diploma would save me from a career of lost cases. No lack of a Harvard diploma changes the victories, successes and lives saved by my work.
As it happens, my first civil trial was against an older lawyer, a name partner in a mid-sized New York law firm (which would be considered huge almost anywhere else). During the preliminary jousting, my adversary announced that I, unlike him, had obviously not been an editor of the Harvard Law Review. I responded that he was quite correct, and yet I fully expected that the decision would be a product of the law and evidence rather than my adversary’s pedigree. The judge laughed loudly and told my adversary to move on. The judge was an alumnus of the same law school that I attended, as it turned out.
There is some need that humans have to possess status unrelated to performance, a shorthand method of letting the world know how great we are without having to prove it. It’s the hallmark of Biglaw, and its pas-de deux with the great law schools. It no doubt makes those whose employment starting dates have been deferred feel better about themselves as they wonder how, having done everything right, it now feels so horribly wrong. Of course, if they want to know what wrong feels like, just wait until they wear their butt image in the seat of the firm library while writing the same memos that their predecessors wrote for the past 5 decades.
Criminal defense lawyers present a curious contrast to the Cravath system. By CDLs, I don’t mean the faux white collar kids, fresh out of the United States Attorneys offices, trotted out to CEOs under indictment as “insider” experts. I mean lawyers who actually have the competency to defend those accused of crimes, regardless of the color of their collars. While there are a few firms that try to mimic the Biglaw approach with the pretense of greatness, they are notable for their fine reputations and usually losing results. But they have “resources”, which brings comfort to corporate types who need to believe that bigger is better.
A real CDLs law school or firm reputation means nothing. We prove our worth one case at a time, one client at a time. What we did yesterday, or for the other guy, means nothing to the human being we stand next to today. Our wall of parchment doesn’t buy a single vote on the jury. No comfort is taken by wearing our rep tie to court, as if the government machine will quiver when they get a whiff of our importance.
Jordon points out that there is no correlation between the tests that open the doors to the great law schools, and hence the great law firms, and the skills that make a great lawyer. This truth is painfully, no brutally, clear in the trenches. Whether you’re 10 minutes or ten years out of Harvard, it’s meaningless. Either you can cross-examine a federal agent to tears or you can’t.
Unlike Jordon, however, I believe that the Cravath system is largely a fraud. I’ve seen lawyers from the bottom of the barrel law school beat the crap out of a witness. They don’t teach you how to do that at Harvard, and my experience is that the best and the brightest don’t have the killer instinct that a lawyer who has had to fight and claw his way possesses. I’ve seen lawyers who aren’t brilliant, perhaps even not particularly smart, demonstrate unbelievable skills in the courtroom. I’ve asserted that brilliance is often a handicap for lawyers, taking up that space in the brain that might otherwise be filled with an understanding of human nature. Gut instinct means a whole lot more at trial than a working knowledge of case citations or the evidentiary rule numbers.
This makes me a heretic. So what? When a lawyer stands in the trenches questioning a witness, arguing a summation to the jury, no one cares what law school he went to. Not every lawyer from a Tier 39 law school turns out well. Not every lawyer from a Cravath does either. But if I had to pick one to stand next to me, I wouldn’t ask what law school he went to. And I wouldn’t pick the partner from Cravath who has tried 3 cases when I could get a real lawyer who has tried 300 and proven that he’s got the chops.
Was It The Cop Or The Taser?
When Brian Cardall’s wife, 6 months pregnant, dialed 911, she couldn’t have expected to end the day as a widow. Cardell, a doctoral student in molecular ecology, had an episode of mental illness while passing through Hurricane City, Utah on his way home from his parents. His wife called for help. Things didn’t turn out well.
“During the incident, a Hurricane City Police officer deployed a Taser and the subject lost consciousness,” Undersheriff Jake Adams, of the Washington County Sheriff’s Office, said in a prepared statement. “The subject was treated within moments by EMS personnel, but was pronounced dead after being transported to the hospital,” the statement continued.
According to a witness, Cardall removed his clothing and stood on the side of the road, as if directing traffic.
The woman says Cardall was calm; he’d taken off his clothes and was waving his hands as if he were directing traffic next to the officers on the side of the road.
“As I looked back, he was still standing there. The kids looked back. He was still standing there. He was not running at all the whole time I was driving,” the woman said.
She was able to view the scene for about a minute and didn’t see Cardall behaving aggressively toward police.
Not exactly worthy of death. But that’s a disingenuous statement. I’m sure the officer had no intention of causing Brian Cardall any harm. After all, he was using less-than-lethal force.
Taser International is defending their safety record, saying no device is 100 percent risk free, but its safer that other options.
When it comes to the appropriate time to use a taser, each law enforcement agency has it’s own policy.Hurricane police are not commenting yet use a general use of force police when in the line of duty, similar to the Washington County Sheriff’s Department. “In the Sheriff’s Office we consider the taser to be a less lethal weapon so in our use of force continuum, we would put it on the same level as pepper spray,” says Adams.
Taser International’s statement, however, is most disingenuous. The officer involved, aside from likely having inadequate training in the handling of mentally ill individuals, was led to believe that a Taser is a quick and easy way to deal with anyone for whom reasoning fails. If you can’t order them to do what you want, there’s always the Taser.
The problem is the Taser. It’s too easy. It’s the “go-to” tool for anything that might otherwise require some patience, thought and discretion. It’s marketed that way, and used that way. Why try to calm down a mentally ill man when you can immediately subdue him? Why waste time when you have a magic weapon that fixes problems in a flash?
Before Tasers, the choice was limited. Shoot to kill or be forced to physically beat a person. The former had reporting consequences, and the latter took a certain degree of personal connection that most cops won’t want when dealing with a non-violent or otherwise non-criminal person. Sure, they will happily beat the perp, even if just for fun, but to physically harm someone perceived to be innocent is a harder, more personal, problem. Now we have Tasers.
It’s too late to change the mindset about Tasers, I suspect. Not for the officer who will live with the fact that Brian Cardall died at his hand. Not for the officer who will think of the child born without a father because he couldn’t spend the time to wait out the episode and gain control without using a weapon. The officer will live with this for a long, long time, as will the Cardall family and the unborn child. But police everywhere else will shrug this off as the anomaly, the thing that will never happen when they use a Taser.
Tasers. They are just so easy.
H/T Injustice Everywhere (@InjusticeNews)
No, He Doesn’t “Get It”
From MSNBC via Doug Berman :
[Aaron] Hart has an IQ of 47 and was diagnosed as mentally disabled as a child. He never learned to read or write and speaks unsteadily.
Despite being a target of bullies, he was courteous, well-behaved and earned money by doing chores for neighbors, supporters said. His parents say he’d never acted out sexually.
Jurors said they sent the judge notes during deliberations in February, asking about alternatives to prison, but didn’t get a clear answer. They believed the judge would order concurrent sentences, jurors said.
Lamar County Judge Eric Clifford decided to stack the sentences against Hart after jurors settled on two five-year terms and three 30-year terms, The Dallas Morning News reported Wednesday. The judge said neither he nor jurors liked the idea of prison for Hart but they felt there was no other option.Add ’em up, and it’s your basic 100 year sentence. In what rational sense can a judge, on one side of his mouth, claim he didn’t like the idea of prison, but then run the sentences consecutive to end up with a century? Perhaps I lack a basic understanding of Texas logic, but this makes no sense whatsoever.
What belies this nightmare is a gross misunderstanding of the nature of mental disability. Make no mistake, with an IQ of 47, Aaron Hart is profoundly mentally retarded. People don’t like to use that phrase, as it makes mental retardation appear ugly and undesirable. Guess what? It’s unfortunate that it exists, but it exists. That it hurts feelings is an unfortunate, but sometimes necessary, by-product. There is no coloration to Aaron Hart’s world that will make it the same as others, to allow him to share the understandings that others in society come to inherently recognize. This kid was severely retarded, and to consider him in any other light is absurd.
But then, even mentally retarded teens have hormones, giving rise to sexual urges they don’t understand but feel compelled to do something about. For Hart, it’s not like he could ask out a cheerleader and borrow dad’s car, hoping for the best. He manifested his sexual urge in a wholly wrong and horribly improper way. For the child fondled, Hart’s IQ was irrelevant. But for the criminal justice system, it’s at the core of our purpose.
Did Hart act maliciously, comprehending the wrongfulness of his action? He couldn’t do so even if he wanted to. It was beyond his ken, completely outside his understanding of the norms of behavior. To prosecute him as if he understood and meant harm is to ignore every purpose of the criminal justice system and undermine any sense of legitimacy to the use of police power. They beat up a retarded teenager because he behaved like a retarded teenager.
Certainly, Aaron Hart needs to be taught with utmost clarity that he cannot touch a child at any time, or anyone else without their permission. The parents of other children who are mentally retarded need to learn the problems that hormones will bring for their children, and teach them as well to behave properly. But to sentence a mentally retarded teenager to 100 years in prison serves no purpose whatsoever.
At least we’re supposed to feel better knowing that neither the judge nor jury really wanted to do it. Even though they did.
Your Family, Unwitting Stars
Reports this week said that Jeff and Danielle Smith, of St. Louis, had learned that their 2008 Christmas-card family photo was being displayed in the window of a grocery store in Prague. Like the Taster, the Smiths learned this only by chance, after a college friend visiting Prague happened to see their life-size images enticing Czechs to buy groceries.
Now it’s one thing for a model to find out years later that his lovely face is on the Taster’s Choice label. After all, at least the photo was of someone who chose to have his image shown to millions. But absent a Christmas list the length of Harry Lipzig’s, this was not in the plans for the Smiths of St. Louis.
This goes beyond issues of online privacy, into issues of online sanity. Every photo that’s openly available on the web is subject to being used, repurposed as some call it, by anyone anywhere for any use they choose. It’s essentially two clicks away from celebrity, or notoriety, or commercial exploitation. And chances of your finding out about it are slim. I mean, Prague, of all places. Not the locale of the Smith family’s last vacation.
Funny as this may seem on the surface, it’s filled with problems that may not be easily anticipated. Initially, there is little to nothing you can do cross-border to stop someone from using your image for their commercial purposes. You can retain a lawyer from the country where the use originated, but that involves costs and laws that may not reflect anything you think are sensible, usually problems that present an insurmountable barrier to action. It’s not fair? That’s right, it’s not.
Even when the use occurs within the United States, those who willingly place their image online and become part of a story of public interest are subject to fair use, allowing others to take your photo and display it in places you might wish it wasn’t. It’s happened here. For public figures, everything is fair game.
While Kevin’s story is, thankfully, pretty funny and ends on a nice note, there is a far more insidious story lurking behind your online photos. Ten minutes with photoshop and the two lovely children in the photo can have their angelic faces attached to naked bodies engaged in horrible sexual contact. If you think it’s troubling to find your family as a blown-up come-on for a Prague grocery store, don’t even try to imagine how it would be to find your children’s heads attached to pornography.
If you think it would be incredibly cool to see a pic of yourself or your family go viral on the internet, or have no issue with someone halfway around the world exploiting your photo for commercial use, then perhaps this is just silliness to you. Post whatever foolish pics you want on your Facebook page, and let that image of your swilling booze with ten of your best half-naked friends engaged in behavior that your father will never know about become way your dream employer views you when he does a 12 second background search. That’s your call.
But as you post photos online, bear in mind that other people who happen to be in your pics, and especially children, yours or someone else’s, may not want to end up on a billboard, or worse. Understand what you’re getting into and use some judgment.
How Is She Supposed to Act?
Amanda Knox, the American student on trial in Italy for the murder of her roommate, is scheduled to testify today. The case is a travesty from the word go, for far more reasons than a blawg post can contain. So much is different in the Italian legal system, where many of the protections we take for granted, or rail about when failed, simply don’t exist. It’s not that it’s an unjust system, as much as it’s not our image of a just system. No, it sucks.
But there’s one aspect of the “proof” against Knox that is eerily reminiscent of a common effort to convict here in cases where the evidence of guilt is missing: Character assassination. In the Knox case, part of the evidence of her guilt is that she failed, in the opinion of the police, to behave the way they think she should have after she was told of her roommates death. She didn’t do it right.
This brought back a rush of memories for me, as I can vividly recall being asked for my advice by a client years ago as to how to behave after the death of a spouse. There’s no book on the subject, no rules to turn to for answers. Miss Manners never touched on the subject of how to behave after an alleged murder so as not to appear “inappropriate”. I certainly couldn’t answer the questions.
The police, however, seem to know exactly how people should behave. Where they got their rules from I don’t know. When asked, I was told that it was based on “typical behavior.” This was unsatisfying, both because I don’t believe it, that there is any typical behavior, and because it fails to account for the fact that we are all individuals and react differently. The cops scoffed. They knew. It never ceases to amaze me how much they know. They know everything.
As is normally my way, I place the onus on the judge, as gatekeeper of trial evidence, to preclude testimony that is facile and baseless. I’m often disappointed in how wide the gate swings open. One of the great ironies of trial work is that the less evidence of guilt there is, the greater the latitude of a judge in allowing bad evidence. In other words, the scrutiny is reduced in direct inverse proportion to the extent of viable evidence. It tends to make weak prosecutions more dangerous, as they are bolstered by increasingly unreliable evidence. And of course, unreliable evidence is the stuff that jurors love best. It comports with their decision-making abilities, and satisfies their prejudices.
So instead of hard evidence, of the sort that can be challenged and questioned and disputed, the case is made up of soft, ever-flexible evidence about the police’s perception of how someone acted. There’s no way to cross-examine a witness on this, as it’s all about personal opinion, colored testimony, vague yet damning characterizations. And the jury has no way to assess this testimony. They don’t know what the “typical” behavior should be. It’s not like a lot of us have the experience behind us. If the cops are allowed to say so, how is a juror supposed to disagree?
So why doesn’t the defense put on its own expert to testify what the typical behavior should be? Ah, because that wouldn’t be material. The police are testifying that the defendant’s behavior was all wrong. The defense expert would be testifying as to why the defendant’s behavior is not inappropriate. It’s speculative. It’s argumentative. It’s without factual basis. Take your pick.
There are two things you can count on when you hear it said that the defendant failed to act appropriately. First, it’s utter nonsense, since we are all the product of a different mix of psychological influences and personal motives, none of which are known by those who would judge the propriety of our conduct. Second, it means that the prosecution has no real evidence and is constrained to reach into the gutter for garbage evidence.
And remember, the worse the evidence, the wider the gate swings open.
The One-Dimensional Defendant
Rick’s first rule is the one that grabbed me.
Rule #1: You are testifying about an evil, vile, lowlife gang member. They’re all the same.
If a slimy defense attorney tries to humanize her client, you must do what you can to resist. Any ordinary emotions, motivations, or other reasons for the gang member’s behavior must be explained away. Better yet, see if you can twist normal emotions into something horrible.
Obviously, the rhetoric is ridiculously hyperbolic. Some gang members are indeed bad people who have done bad things. Some alleged gang members aren’t gang members at all. A cop may say one is, and may well believe it’s true, but that doesn’t make it so. I know, it’s hard to imagine that a police officer could be wrong, but it happens.
Rick’s problem isn’t with cops doing their job, but the twisting of reality to accomplish the task. To the police gang expert, every breath the alleged gang member takes is for the benefit of the gang.
Did he kick a dog because it yelped and startled him when he accidentally stepped on its tail? No! Weren’t you listening?! That might be a normal immature human reaction. This dude kicked the dog to earn respect and to benefit a criminal street gang. If he let people think that he wouldn’t enforce the rules on respect in this instance, the next thing you know, he’d be a laughingstock and gang members would come from as far away as New Zealand just to beat him down and laugh at him.
In other words, the defendant must be a gang member because whatever he did, according to the police expert, is definitional proof and inherently connected to gang membership. Rick gave some additional examples twitting with Packratt, of Injustice Anywhere fame, using the subject of tattoos. If a defendant has a tattoo, the expert will testify that tattoos are “brands” typically worn by gang members. If the tattoo happens to say “Tiffany”, then the testimony is changed ever so slightly to accommodate, by the expert then saying that gang members typically brand themselves with the names of their girlfriends. You get the message. No matter what the evidence, the defendant can’t win. It’s always connectible to being a gang member, according to the expert.
The problem, of course, is that defendants, like cops, aren’t one-dimensional. Some things they may do wrong, but other things they do are just ordinary human acts, with no deeper significance or secret meaning. Just regular stuff like a regular person might do.
A defendant may even do good at one moment and bad another. Like the cop who will tase a 72 year old woman one day and save a kitten from a tree the next. We’re human. They’re human too. Except to the gang expert wearing the uniform.
The justification for this manipulation of truth is that the police officer who arrests and pursues the prosecution of a person he believes to be a gangbanger is that he’s taking one bad dude off the streets. It’s for our benefit. He’s protecting our safety, whether we want to admit it or not. The problem, of course, is that through his false expert testimony, he’s reducing a trial to a farce, and has set himself up as judge and executioner. He knows best, and the rest of the process is just a weigh station on the road to the big house, something to pass through to get to the ultimate goal.
That cops play this game with their expert testimony, converting a human being into a one-dimensional gang member, isn’t really much of a surprise. The question that nags me is why judges cooperate with this farce. If they know better and still allow it, they have no business on the bench. If they don’t know better and actually believe this nonsense, they have no business on the bench. But then, judges are human too.
So You Think You Can Judge
But Ken Lammers at CrimLaw has been working on an alternative, and has clearly put in a lot of time thinking outside the box. He’s come up with a very interesting proposal. These are the rough details, and Ken’s fleshed out the proposal far more than appears here, so it’s worth your time to go straight to the horses mouth to get the full idea.
Initially, the possibility of becoming a judge must be an opt in choice. If an attorney is interested in becoming a judge he should be required to have taken a test similar to a Bar exam within a set period of time prior to the judicial position becoming open (3 to 5 years probably being the best time frame).
Next should be peer evaluation. Members of the Bar who practice in the jurisdiction wherein the candidate would be eligible to become a judge should be confidentially polled as to their perception of the candidate’s demeanor, perceived knowledge, and ability to communicate.
Finally should come an examination by a group of judges. These judges should not be from the area of the State wherein the attorney practices – preferably not even from the same half of the State – and should not know the lawyer . . . The candidates with the top 5 combined scores should be interviewed and the judges should score the candidate on his demeanor, ability to communicate his ideas, and apparent ability to apply legal knowledge.
But consider the imperfections in light of a system that is far less perfect, far more prone to favoritism, leading to lazy, nasty, incompetent people sitting in judgment of others. The idea is to build a better mousetrap, even if there can be no perfect one. It seems that Ken’s process is far, far better than either the current elected or appointed systems that are used. The former, elected judges, is a joke of the worst order, The latter is rife with abuse. Even a moment’s thought about the current options makes Ken’s idea seem glowingly better.
I can hear in the back of my head a guy like Mark Bennett saying, anyone who presumes to judge another person isn’t fit for the job. Perhaps, but it defeats the point. Someone is going to want the job, and the question is whether she gets it because of competence or connections. We can decry anyone interested in judging, but it doesn’t move us forward since there will be judges in any event, and the problem is to get the best qualified people in position.
Imagine a judiciary built on ability rather than friendship or political contributions. I don’t impugn all judges, as there are many excellent, capable judges on the bench. And there are some mutts. Mean spirited and ignorant, clearly biased and devoid of soul. People who have had the experience of dealing with a bad judge leave with a hatred of the law and the system. It’s not just because they lost their case, as I’ve seen good judges send losers away with a better understanding of the law and a sense that, while they lost, they had their day in court and were given a fair hearing.
All-in-all, I think it’s a better system for selecting judges than I’ve seen anywhere. However, I doubt we shall ever see its like.Someone will cry, why not? Aside from the fact that the institution does not change direction easily, and the love that official people have for doing things the way they always have, there are strong vested interests at stake here. Debts to be paid. Power to be managed. Even the academics will ignore a better mousetrap if one of their own didn’t come up with it, because ideas from trench lawyers like Ken are too declasse to be given serious consideration.
But Ken’s onto something here. And if the powerful and brilliant people of our nation were honest, they would give the Lammers Method some hard thought.
As Blatant As It Gets
From Newsday:
Baribault, 30, of Nesconset, appeared Tuesday at the trial of Rahiem Griffin, the man accused of drunken driving and slamming into Baribault’s patrol car on May 18, 2008, as he was arresting another driver for drunken driving. But Baribault did not testify. Rather, he was asked to take the stand while his doctor testified to show the jury what he is, and is not, capable of doing.
As Baribault, who was brought into the courtroom in a wheelchair, demonstrated almost silently on the stand, some jurors sighed deeply, while others shook their heads.
Judge Jerald Carter told jurors that Baribault was being allowed to take the stand only as evidence that he received “serious physical injury” as a result of the crash. He said that “sympathy or empathy” are not to enter into their deliberations.
And what does crusading District Attorney Kathleen Rice, who just happens to be for re-election, have to say about this play to prejudice?
District Attorney Kathleen Rice said what Baribault did Tuesday took “bravery beyond words.”What the heck is she talking about? Perhaps Rice misunderstood the question? What at first appears to be an obvious non sequitur is merely another sound bite with no apparent connection to anything beyond mouthing words that she thinks people want to hear.
“Today, he honored the badge,” she said.
As to the defendant, Rahiem Griffin, the story discloses no particular reason why he’s chosen to go to trial, or what, if any, defense he’s got to offer. Not having followed the case, I’m unaware of how the case reached this status. Chances are pretty good that he’s gone to trial for no better reason than the prosecution offered him no other option. Plea to the charge and take a sentence of life plus cancer?
But no matter how clear the crime, how strong the proof, how tragic the victim, this is not the way to conduct a trial. If ever there was evidence where prejudice outweighed its probative value, this is it. By a mile. By a thousand miles. It’s not a matter of letting Griffin escape the consequences of his actions, but a matter of allowing a jury to see “evidence”, the only purpose of which is to inflame and prejudice them.
If Baribault “honored” the badge, the district attorney and judge dishonored the law. What an embarrassment.
H/T The Blind Guy
Was P.O. Omar Edwards Left In The Gutter?
As the hand-wringing over the needless shooting death of P.O. Omar Edwards at the hands of a fellow officer begins to fade, a report by WABC News’ Jeff Pegues raises an ugly specter. Two witnesses, whose identities were concealed, have come forward.
“We pull up and then we see a cop handcuffing him and leaving him there,” one said.
“They just left him. Didn’t give him no aid. Told the officers not to touch a gun. It was a silver gun. He was about 10 to 15 feet away from his gun,” the other said. “He was just on the floor cuffed. Face in a ditch, in the gutter… They weren’t paying attention to him.”
The question posed is whether the downed officer received the attention he required from the police, or was left in the gutter while the blood flowed and life ebbed from his body. The problem, which Pegues unfortunately leaves unsaid, it that it wasn’t until later, when aid arrived and was rendered, that the cops discovered that they had shot one of their own. Only then did it hit the fan.
What remains behind is the tacit expectation, together with its equally tacit approval, of a process that distinguishes a cop shot from any other black man with gun shot on a Harlem street, Does the NYPD policy support letting suspects lie in the street and die, though cops are entitled to immediate attention? No doubt the policy says otherwise, though the practice may have some difficulty keep pace.
But while WABC story about these two witnesses, who were told to get out of there by cops on the night it happened rather than questioned as to what they saw, is an important piece of new to get out, the fact that nobody thought to question why it’s different and acceptable to leave any person shot, bleeding, dying, in the gutter without attention is astounding. While few of us toiling in the hard, cold trenches are surprised by the fact that police are just a wee bit less concerned with the welfare of non-officers, no matter how much they might deny the fact that they treat an officer down with the care worthy of a saint, one would hope that the media would know better and report it.
We showed the officials with the district attorney’s office and the NYPD the video. They would not comment.
This speaks volumes, if only the media was inclined to pay attention.
