Author Archives: SHG

When The Going Gets Tough

Not that there isn’t good reason for those coming out of law school to gripe these days, as it certainly isn’t their fault that the job market disappeared and everything they spent the last seen years working towards is now a dead issue, but it won’t get you anywhere.  Seth Godin offered some suggestions :



How about a post-graduate year doing some combination of the following (not just one, how about all):

  • Spend twenty hours a week running a project for a non-profit.
  • Teach yourself Java, HTML, Flash, PHP and SQL. Not a little, but mastery. [Clarification: I know you can’t become a master programmer of all these in a year. I used the word mastery to distinguish it from ‘familiarity’ which is what you get from one of those Dummies type books. I would hope you could write code that solves problems, works and is reasonably clear, not that you can program well enough to work for Joel Spolsky. Sorry if I ruffled feathers.]
  • Volunteer to coach or assistant coach a kids sports team.
  • Start, run and grow an online community.
  • Give a speech a week to local organizations.
  • Write a regular newsletter or blog about an industry you care about.
  • Learn a foreign language fluently.
  • Write three detailed business plans for projects in the industry you care about.
  • Self-publish a book.
  • Run a marathon.

He concludes the list with this gem: “Beats law school.”  This apparent throwaway line is quite meaningful.  How many of you really want to be lawyers?  How many of you even knew what lawyers did before going to law school?  How many of you really know what lawyers do as you walk up to accept your diploma? 

No doubt some fully understood what they were getting into, and had goals and aspirations to be a lawyer.  But we all know that law school is the place of last resort for students who can’t stand the sight of blood or suck at science.  So now what?

After Godin gave great advice, get off the couch, stop whining and do something useful with yourself, he became  the butt of the disaffected.  Ah, how quickly they turn on you when there’s no easy answer in sight.  Calling his response “Tough!”, Seth wrote:


I got some fascinating responses to yesterday’s post.

A few were from entitled college grads. They basically asked, “With all this debt, how can I possibly do what you asked? Sure, some people might be able to do this, but I have no choice but to take a menial job, look for work and then party at night so I can have some friends.”

The first thing that should register is Seth’s use of the word “entitled”.  That’s right, kids.  I didn’t invent this stuff.  I’ve just done my small part to smack you in the face with it.  For your own good.  The point is that your unhappiness with the way life is playing out doesn’t change the fact that this is the only life we’ve got, and you either make the best of it or complain that it’s just not working for you.  The former offers you an opportunity to do something to improve your lot, even though it won’t be quick and easy, and offers no guarantee.  The latter offers a guarantee of unhappiness and failure, because stamping your feet just isn’t going to do the trick.

Seth goes on to say that he heard from more people who got the message.


More, though, were from people who said, “Yes! I can do this. I’ll sleep on a friend’s floor and eat beans and rice every night if I have to, but this is as much a part of my education as taking English 101 was.” I heard from three recruiters who violently agreed with this plan–who else would you hire?
While there is an abundance of Slackoisie roaming the internet, many with law school diplomas, claiming to be marketing consultants in the hope that they can get paid for mouthing irrationally exuberant optimism, couple with vague or simplistic assertions of how you can make a million and still be at the bar for happy hour, have you asked yourselves why they are huckstering for your last $5 rather than running the most successful young law firm in town?  How does someone who has never had a successful business in their lives tell you the magic secret to success?  And for those who claim that they did indeed have million dollar practices, why have they left them to spend their days trying desperately to get your last $5?

Many have argued, and some quite vociferously, that this isn’t a generational problem.  In some ways it’s not, as every generation has had those who thought success was a magic trick, responsibility a burden that only fools carried and over-developed sense of their own worth.  The difference this time around is that it’s the norm, the accepted frame of reference for a wide-swathe.  I’m not saying this to ridicule youth, but like Seth Godin, to encourage the Slackoisie to pull it together, grow up and get to work.

Consider Seth’s query, “who else would you hire?”  Picture in your heads sitting across from the hiring partner and telling him that your goal in five years is to be in the corner office, driving a BMW and out of there by no later than 5 every day.  Would you hire you? 

We’re sorry that this advice isn’t pleasing to you.  We’re sorry that the world (the one you blame us for thrusting upon you at a time when you were supposed to due a good time) isn’t the one you expected.  But as Seth says, tough.  Blame us all you want, but it doesn’t change anything.  You won’t find a satisfying life by complaining, no matter how strongly you believe your complaints to be valid. 

When Adrian Dayton recently called me the Grumpiest Boomer on the Internet, I was honored.  But it’s quite possible that I will have to share the title with Seth Godin.  I don’t think he’s surpassed me yet, but it’s close.

A Dollar and A Dream

There’s a new kid in town in the blog-o-rama marketing effort, Avvo Blogs. That’s right, the same Avvo that rated you a 2.3 because you’re young and dress funny is now offering you the chance to buy a blog and tell them what you think.  And this time, Avvo’s effort to monetize itself seems right on target.

Not always a fan of Avvo’s ideas (like the nasty Avvo Answers), this seems to be a great fit for Avvo, neither competing with its proclaimed core mission of providing the consumers of legal services with unbiased information about lawyer nor pushing ne’er-do-well lawyers to provide bad information to people who pay what it’s worth to get their name highlighted. 

What’s most interesting about the concept is how Avvo has set itself up as the low-priced alternative to Kevin O’Keefe’s Lexblog.


With Avvo Blogs, you can blog for less than $1 per day. You shouldn’t have to spend a truckload to showcase your expertise in a professional manner.

Many companies will try to sell you “more-effective” blogging technology for thousands of dollars per year, but few bloggers will need such a fancy blog. Think of blogging like buying a suit. You can spend thousands of dollars on a custom-made suit, or you can buy one off the rack at Macy’s that your client’s will love just as much. Clients will focus on the brains in the suit, not whether you have hand-stitching on your lapel.

There are already blogging programs out there for free or low priced, substantially lower than the marketing chestnut of $1 a day, but they have plenty of drawbacks and require the blogging lawyer to put in the effort to make it work for a legal blogger.  In contrast, Kevin offers customization that will make the blog of the worst lawyer in town look like a winner.  It’s a fascinating conundrum, pitting the cheap generic against the finely tailored suit.  If you’re a lawyer who is intent on blogging for business, which one should you go for? 

Some may feel that the cheap generic approach is a poor reflection of their practice.  As Avvo blogs catches on, and more of them appear, it stands to reason that the generic appearance of your blog will become immediately apparent, and make you seem inordinately common.  But you get what you pay for, and not everybody is prepared to pay for the good stuff.

Of course, these are programs and templates.  Nobody offers a blog that anyone will care to read.  That part’s up to you.  If you’re boring or flaky, no program is going to help.  If you’re a flagrant marketer, the most perfectly tailored suit won’t fit.  And if you just don’t bother to put in the effort to create worthy content, a dollar a day is money in the toilet.

For the record, I’ve been hanging out in the blawgosphere for a while now, and have watched a lot of blawgs come and go.  Most lawyer’s don’t have it in them to keep a blawg alive.  They start out all full of energy, then slowly peter out until one day they simply disappear.  It’s happened with some pretty good blawgs.  It’s happened with some truly awful blawgs.  Most blawgs fall into the latter category.

If you think that your marketing effort might not merit the big bucks, but are willing to take a chance for a dollar a day, then you’re the guy Avvo Blogs is looking for.  Just don’t sign up for too long a stretch if you really aren’t all that interested in blogging, or if you’re sole purpose is getting great new cases and making tons of money.  You’re unlikely to be the sort of person who can keep it going for the long hall, and it’s not likely that the blog is going to bring in enough business to pay for itself, no less make you fabulously wealthy.  But for a $1 a day, at least it won’t break the bank.

And as a parting thought, my blawg is about as low rent as it gets as far as appearance and programming go.  But it hasn’t held me back.

Sentences Don’t Have to Be Arbitrary Anymore

A call came in last week from a seriously distraught woman, the wife of a newly minted guest of the United States Bureau of Prisons.  “It’s so unfair,” she sobbed.  She went through the 12 steps, from “he did nothing wrong” to “it’s not like he murdered somebody.”  I understood the pain she felt, and knew from having heard this conversation many times before that there was nothing I could say that would help her to understand.  It wasn’t rational, but emotional.  And that’s the problem with sentencing.

Via Doug Berman, Dan Markel (of the PrawfsBlawg Markels) has a new abstract up at SSRN with one of the best titles I’ve ever seen, Luck or Law? The Constitutional Case Against Indeterminate Sentencing.  The first three words are classic, and sum up the sense that permeates the public’s understanding of criminal sentencing.  It similarly creates the problem, since it feeds the false sense that there is a solution to the problem out there somewhere.



In the majority of states indeterminate sentencing schemes prevail — under which the decision for whether a person serves anywhere from one year to a life in prison for a given crime is left largely to the unfettered discretion of a judge.  Indeed, ever since the Supreme Court decided Booker v. United States and thereby rendered the federal sentencing guidelines “effectively advisory,” many state courts have read Booker to lend an imprimatur upon their indeterminate sentencing schemes.  Thus, in many jurisdictions, virtually no restraints upon judicial and/or executive discretion exist to ensure that similarly situated offenders convicted of similar criminal conduct will, within the same sovereign jurisdiction, receive punishments that are roughly similar to each other.
Certainly, this was the scheme behind the sentencing guidelines, and one that even criminal defense icon Norm Pattis has endorsed for his state of Connecticut in order to stay the tide of wildly differing sentences for similar conduct.  Lets face facts, there is an element of arbitrariness in every indeterminate sentence imposed.  What makes a crime “worth” a sentence of 20 years to one judge and 10 to another.  And where the heck does a third come up with 13 years?  Why not 13 years, 3 months, 12 days, for that matter? 

But the counterpoint to the argument against the arbitrary imposition of a length of time in prison is individualized sentencing, where the legitimate purpose of imposing a sentence are based on the person as well as the crime.  The Guidelines allowed for this in extreme cases, though the determination of what fell outside the heartland of the guidelines was again an arbitrary call.  Within the Guidelines, individuals with wildly differing circumstances, needs, fault and even crimes were treated as the same.  And let’s not even touch the subject of acquitted conduct sentencing, which muddies the waters beyond repair.

I doubt that anyone would argue in favor of arbitrary sentencing, yet if we’re honest about it, sentencing by its nature is arbitrary.  Typically, the victim sees the sentence as too lenient.  The defendant’s family sees the sentence as too harsh.  Only the judge sees the sentence as just right.  And yet sentences defy explanation for their precision.  There is simply no magic basis for saying that a sentence of one year, as opposed to two, is proper to satisfy the legitimate purposes of sentencing. 

The gist of the Sentencing Guidelines was to take a survey of how judges, given vast discretion to impose whatever sentence they believe proper, came out and develop a norm based on the nature of the crime, the harm caused (or alleged to be caused, since the Guidelines largely rely on fictional harms as decided by the prosecution), and the defendant’s prior criminal history.  This covers the basics in a rough justice sort of way.  It should have resulted in a type of consensus value for sentencing, and received widespread acceptance.  It never did.  Not even the judges like it, though they were ultimately forced to adhere to it by the Supreme Court until the Supreme Court changed its mind clarified itself.

Having not read Dan’s article (largely because it’s unavailable yet and secondarily because I’m trying to find time to read Dan’s new book, Privilege or Punish: Criminal Justice and the Challenge of Family Ties), I don’t know where exactly Dan comes out on the subject, though it would appear likely that his thesis is that giving judges too much latitude in sentencing is unconstitutionally arbitrary.  If so, he would be right, of course.  As would be the person who argued that giving judges too little latitude in sentencing is unconstitutionally arbitrary. 

For this reason, I propose to develop for judicial use the Sentencealyzer 5000.  A defendant blows into a straw protruding from a little black box, which then shows a number on an LCD screen with the correct sentence to be imposed.  I would like to tell you how it works, but that’s proprietary information.  This will eliminate arbitrariness from sentencing, whether in terms of disparate sentences for roughly the same crime as doled out by different judges, or the same sentence for roughly the same crime as applied to different defendants.  Finally, a solution.

Big Words, Little Words, Bad Words

The commentary surrounding Ed Whelan’s ill-advised outing of his nemisis Publius raises interesting questions about whether credibility is established solely through the merit of one’s writing or whether attaching a name is necessary.  This made me think about both the nature of the content and the manner of presentation.  This led me to Mister Thorne.

Mister Thorne has a blog called Set in Style.  Before you ask, “Mister” is his first name, not his formal title or an affectation.  Don’t ask me.  I didn’t name him.  In any event, he’s an editor and his blog is dedicated to helping lawyers present themselves in the best possible light through their writing. 

Thorne (as he prefers to be called) posted about an article by Daniel Oppenheimer, professor of psychology at Princeton.


Dr. Oppenheimer reiterates what few attorney-authors can believe: readers consistently judge the writer who uses plain, clear language as more intelligent than the writer who arranges obscure terms in convoluted constructions.

To the extent that the content is internally credible, it is a function to some extent of the ability to use ordinary language in ordinary form.  This idea flies in the face of those who believe that tossing around jargon, or using $10 words, makes them look smarter.  It pains lawyers who, in their attempt to be hyper-precise, make their sentences so long and convoluted as to be both painful to read and far too much work for the reader to decipher.  For my part, when someone makes me work that hard, I take a pass unless it’s something I’m absolutely required to read.  It’s just not worth the effort.

My own version of this concept is that if you’ve got something to say, just say it.  It’s far more effective to take a complex concept and say it simply than muddle it up in prolix, painful language. 

But this applies to stand-alone ideas. Regardless of the source, the idea either has merit or doesn’t.   When it comes to a basic opinion (e.g., I like chocolate better than vanilla), an opinion is utterly worthless if the writer is unknown.  No one cares if you prefer chocolate.  Each of us has our own opinion, and no one else’s preference is going to persuade us that their choice is better than ours.  Each of us already has enough information to formulate our own opinion, and we don’t need anyone else’s help.

When it comes to more complex opinions (e.g., I believe that Sotomayor has demonstrated inadequate respect for the rights of criminal defendants), dealing with subjects on which we may not have sufficient information to formulate a valid opinion, we are subject to persuasion.  The basis could be examples supporting the position, or the credibility of the person offering the opinion.  If we tend to agree with the person offering the opinion, or hold that person’s opinion in high regard, the opinion is more likely to matter to us.

Very little of what we read online falls into the category of basic opinion.  Much of it falls into the complex opinion category.  This is where people get into trouble.  When the person offering opinion is anonymous, we have no basis whatsoever to determine whether they know what they are talking about.  Maybe it’s a Supreme Court justice opining off the cuff, or maybe it’s a 12 year old hiding in the basement trying to cause trouble.  We don’t know.  The fallback position is that the content should stand alone, regardless of who’s doing the writing. 

Sometimes, the merit of the content is clear, and it doesn’t make a bit of difference who is doing the writing.  This is far more rare than advocates of this position realize.  Almost every writing of this sort involves a value judgment, which depends on the worthiness of the writer.  More often than not, it involves a claim of knowledge (i.e., I read the decision and this is what it says) which can’t be tested.  If we are expected to rely on the integrity of the writer, then we must have some reason to trust the writer.  That he says so isn’t good enough.  That he insists “strenuously” makes it even worse.

The anonymity of the internet lends itself to being a soapbox for those who hold their own opinions in unduly high esteem.  There are some incredibly stupid people out there who suffer from the Dunning-Kruger Effect, yet feel compelled to make sure as many people know their thoughts as possible.  They get angry when their thoughts aren’t given the respect they believe they deserve.  And they believe that their mere announcement of their thoughts, standing alone, mandates that others address them respectfully.  It gets tiresome.

Still, I give a substantially greater amount of credence to someone who expresses their thoughts in a clear, simple manner.  I have never attributed it to a belief that they are more intelligent, as Thorne suggests, but to the honesty of their position.  I’m a sucker for someone with an honestly held belief, no matter how much I disagree with it.

Patrick at Popehat added Obsidian Wings to his blogroll following the outing of Publius.  In a comment to his post, an anonymous person offered this observation :

Ed Whelen is white trash.

Why do people think blogging under their real name is courageous?


In law, if you know your shit, you can prove it. Make your fucking arguments.


People who blog under their full names want to be lazy. LOOK AT MY (to my pea brain) BIG NAME. I NEED NOT CITE CASES OR ANALYZE ISSUES. BEING ME IS ENOUGH!


I think that’s being a pussy. Make your arguments. Don’t rely on who you (think) you are to make your case. (Wo)Man up.


Incidentally, I blogged anonymously until my blog was one of the first 8 Law.com blogs. (Later I quit because they cramped my style.) Then I had to out myself. It was no thing. If anything, I got “glory.” Which doesn’t really motivate me. Wow, look at me. I’m a unique snow flake. Whatever.


Now I blog only under my first name. It just spares me drama to not have people stalking me based on my blog posts. Yes, if you Google my name, my blog will be the first result. So people who know me can find my blog. But people who only know my blog need to do at least some diligence in order to find out my real name…. which is still pretty easy.


So I’m a half-coward? LMFAO!


I truly think real-named blogging is self-involved. My blogging has been cited twice in federal judicial opinions. They were “serious” posts on Section 1983 law, about which I’d say I know more than anyone what perhaps Sheldon Nahmod and Erwin Chemersinky.


Allow me to go orgasm all over myself!


Seriously, this shit cracks me up. I’ve had more success when I was blogging as a law student than most people who call others “cowards” for blogging anonymously will EVER have with their blogs.


They can all fuck off.


Get cited in some federal opinions. Then fucking tell me how brave and special you are because you blog under your real name!


The shit that impresses people about themselves truly astounds me!


Plain language?  Check.  Clear language?  Check.  Direct, uncovoluted sentences?  Check.  Presumption of intelligence?  Nope.  Credibility?  Zero.  On the other hand, if this was something I decided to write and post for the world to see, I would have done so anonymously too.  Perhaps with some effort I could identify the author of this comment, but there is no reason why I would want to do so. 

The Risk of Outing

One debate begets another.  Jonathon Adler at Volokh does the best job of explaining the source:

Over the past two months, Ed Whelan (with whom I blog on NRO’s “Bench Memos”) and a pseudonymous blogger at Obsidian Wings known as “publius,” have traded barbs and insults while debating various issues related to President Obama’s nominations of Harold Koh and Sonia Sotomayor.

Over time, the heat-to-light ratio in the Whelan-publius exchanges increased, and Whelan learned publius’ real identity – a recently minted, untenured law professor. As part of a recent response to publius, Whelan decided to disclose this information in a blog post.

While Adler’s views are decidedly colored by his sympathies (as well as his personal history as an anonymous blogger, Juan Non-Volokh), the set-up portrays the problem of getting into a pissing match when hiding inside a glass house.

It’s long been my view that, in the absence of certain particularly well-justified reasons, anonymous blogging and commenting are for cowards.  How easy it is to throw stones when you bear no responsibility for who or what they strike.  I’m not against stone-throwing per se, when there is a need for strong words and purpose for taking a strong position, but doing so when there are no consequences to be suffered.

But this isn’t a debate about whether one should post online under a pseudonym.  Rather, this is a debate over whether one should “out” one’s pseudonymous adversary, an entirely different issue.

At Point of Law, Walter Olson and Michael Krauss have expressed two very different views.  First came Krauss’ view :

Incredibly, [South Texas School of Law Professor John] Blevins [formerly known as Publius] has defended his anonymous sniping as ethical: he didn’t want to get in trouble with his law school, he didn’t want to embarrass his family, he didn’t want to offend his students. What Blevins didn’t want to do, sez me, is take responsibility for his opinions. When you attack someone by name, you name yourself — we are not in revolutionary times where the original Publius could go appropriately unnamed.

Krauss, incidently, strongly supports Whelan’s views and disagrees vehemently with Blevins’.  But compare Krauss’ co-blogger, Walter Olson, who shares Krauss’ substantive views that Whelan was right and Blevins wrong, but:


I understand why “hiding behind a pseudonym while sniping at a critic who is out in the open”, in Michael’s words, will often provoke wrath, as it provoked Whelan’s. But I can’t go along with the seeming implication that 1) only those of us willing to attach real names to our opinions should consider participating in online controversy; 2) publicly outing hitherto anonymous commentators is the deserved response to their hopes of anonymity;
And more particularly to the punishment Whelan exacted on Bevins:


Wishing that certain personalities would publicly identify themselves, tweaking them publicly for not doing so, or vowing to ignore them until they do, are quite different from triumphantly announcing their secret in public, thus inflicting on them the train of personal consequences they had sought to avoid.
Michael Krauss, in what he describes as his “brief and only response,” states :


This may be one of those areas where libertarians and conservatives disagree. For the former, no fraud or coercion is involved in anonymous blogging and that’s that. [An anonymous blog posting is not necessarily itself a lie, even if the anonymity is motivated by a desire to misrepresent oneself to third parties.] For the latter, arguments are illegitimately launched when they are launched from behind a hood, as it were, unless there is a force majeure involved. We have the moral (not legal — I’m making no argument here about legislating any of this) right to confront our virtual accusers when they confront us, I think. Ed Whelan was deprived of that right until someone (who? I have no idea, but that would be an interesting story) had enough and removed Blevins’ hood.
Frankly, my sympathies lie far closer to Krauss.  There is something seriously amiss with the person hiding behind a closed door while hurling insults.  It’s exacerbated when they lay claim to personal knowledge or insight to support their arguments, but which can’t be known or tested because of their veil of secrecy.  It smells bad.  It smells disingenuous.  It smells like a lie.

Yet, revealing the identity of someone who, whether we agree or not, has decided to conceal his true identity is not merely to discount the pseudonymous bloggers claims, but to do him harm.  Whether we see the harm as great or trivial is immaterial; it’s not our life and we don’t get a vote in another person’s choices, a point missed with great frequency in the blawgosphere.

Was it Whelan’s right to punish Blevins by disclosing his identity?  Absolutely not.  He was entitled to ignore him, to ridicule him, to discount him and to attack his credibility as a person who lacked the fortitude of putting his name to his positions.  But not to punish him.

The unfairness toward Whelan of having a faceless, nameless accuser was beyond question.  But illegitimate arguments from anonymous attackers are legion on the internet, and there are way to deal with them (often to their dismay and disappointment, given their demands to be taken seriously).  Outing them is not the way.  Outing them goes a step too far.  They deserve to bear the risk of public ridicule, but not the risk of outing.  Whelan was wrong to do so.

A Reason To Round Up The Kids

In the swirl of outrage surrounding the tasing of Ryan Smith to compel his “voluntary” compliance with a court order to collect his DNA, we tend to forget about the reasons underlying the general desire of law enforcement to have DNA samples from anyone and everyone they possibly can.  While in Smith’s case it was to compare it with DNA involved in the specific offense, it’s taken from people convicted of crimes, and now people merely arrested. 

British cops, apparently, don’t find that sufficient, according to The Register.


Police officers in Camden, north London, are deliberately targeting kids under-18 for arrest just so their DNA samples can be taken.

The Met denies any such action has taken place, but an anonymous police officer told The Ham and High : “It is part of a long term crime prevention strategy. We are often told that we have just one chance to get that DNA sample and if we miss it that might mean a rape or a murder goes unsolved in the future.

The problem is one of incentive.  Since there’s little in the way of a disincentive to round kids up for the purpose of collecting DNA, and a huge incentive to have everyone’s DNA on file “just in case,” it seems only logical that police would be pro-active in gathering their samples.  No reason not to be prepared, you know.


“Have we got targets for young people who have not been arrested yet? The answer is yes. But we are not just waiting outside schools to pick them up, we are acting on intelligence. If you know you have had your DNA taken and it is on a database then you will think twice about committing burglary for a living.”
Plus, it serves double duty.  Not only does it provide wonderful assistance in identifying the perpetrator of a crime, but it serves the prophylactic purpose of letting kids know that they are now “on file,” easily found and identifiable should they decide to pull a move in the future. 

Oddly, I suspect that many people who learn of this Brit trend will quietly say to themselves, this is actually not such a terrible thing.  Less crime, easier apprehension and identification.  What’s yer beef, Greenfield?

It’s about a value judgment, contrasting personal privacy with governmental intrusion.  It’s about the right to be left alone.  It’s about the government having far too much information about each of us, for it to use for its intended purpose as well as any greater purpose that technology later brings our way.  It’s about our not being in a government databank simply because it makes their job easier.

Oh yeah, and it’s about not arresting innocent kids on a pretext. 

We’ve taken much of our culture from the Brits.  Will we be so cynical as to take our cue from them when it comes to the rounding up of our children to fill the government’s DNA banks?

Another Tragedy, Another Criminal

It’s spurred the Ohio legislature to name a law after her, always a bad sign.  When 2 year old Emily Jerry slipped into a coma and quietly passed away, it was a tragedy of terrible proportions.  An inexcusable combination of incompetence and neglect when a pharmacy prepared tiny Emily’s chemotherapy medicine in a hypertonic saline solution.  And Emily died because of it.

Via MedCity News,


As a result of the incident, the Ohio legislature passed what is now known as “Emily’s Law”, which provided quality control guidelines for pharmacy technicians. Prior to the law, people could obtain employment in a pharmacy lab with barely a high school diploma. Reassuring, no?

For those of us who expect that the kindly fellow in the white lab coat who prepared and provides us with medicine either does it himself, or closely watches those who do, so they don’t poison us, this comes as a surprise.  Who would have thought we needed a law to require them not to be careless, not to allow drugs to kill rather than cure.

But the pain from the death of Emily Jerry demanded something more than a law requiring the obvious.  It demanded that someone pay.


The pharmacy technician in this case, Katie Dudash, was granted immunity in return for testifying against her boss, Eric Cropp.

Eric Cropp, the supervising pharmacist on duty that day, had signed off on the preparation.

According to the Cleveland Plain Dealer, Eric Cropp pleaded no contest to involuntary manslaughter.  He was stripped of his pharmacy license in 2007, a year after this happened.  Now he stands convicted.

There’s no point in straining to think of an explanation or excuse for Cropp’s failure to demonstrate the minimal degree of competence and interest that was needed to save Emily Jerry from death by medication.  Nor does he deserve such effort.  But this wasn’t a crime and he wasn’t a criminal.  It was a tragedy and he was incompetent, negligent and should not be allowed anywhere near a pharmacy.

One of the unfortunately recurring themes is the criminalization of conduct based on outcome rather than intent.  Had Cropp meant to do harm, the story would be different.  Had Cropp voluntarily arrived at work drunk or high, knowingly engaging in conduct that presented a grave risk to patients, the story would be different.  But there is nothing here to suggest anything beyond the fact that Cropp screwed up royally by signing off on a medication that was improperly prepared by a tech.  I don’t care if he was busy or overworked and understaffed (sound familiar, for those who are apologists for indigent defense screw-ups?).  A professional carries a duty, and that duty remains in as full force when busy and overworked as it does when one has all the time in the world. 

Still, simple negligence is not a crime.  Unless some prosecutor decides that it’s his duty to put someone in prison, in which case anything and everything becomes a crime.  And, of course, the prosecutor merely sets the wheels in motion; it’s up to the rest of the system, including the defense lawyers, to make sure that there is no justice.

For those who complain bitterly about the unfairness of medical malpractice, tell that to the parents of Emily Jerry.  But it’s still not a crime, no matter how tragic the outcome.

H/T Walter Olson of Overlawyered

Blaming The Judge For Counsel’s Bad Argument

It’s a particularly odd choice of case to be given such great scrutiny, Ricci v. DeStefano.  Held as an example of why Sonia Sotomayor is unworthy of joining Clarence Thomas on the Supreme Court, despite the fact that it was a unanimous panel with Sotomayor as the most junior of the three 2d Circuit judges:


In the Second Circuit, Judge Sotomayor was the junior judge on the panel, which also included Judge Rosemary S. Pooler, who was the presiding judge at the argument, and Judge Robert D. Sack, who did not attend due to illness.

In the end, according to court personnel familiar with some of the internal discussions of the case, the three judges had difficulty finding consensus, with Judge Sack the most reluctant to join a decision affirming the district court. Judge Pooler, as the presiding judge, took the leading role in fashioning the compromise. The use of a summary order, which ordinarily cannot be cited as precedent, was part of that compromise.

Liptak at the New York Times tries to make something interesting out of a decision that defies real controversy.  But it was little more than a deference decision, no matter how one tries to spin it, ultimately following black letter law and a thorough 48 page district court opinion that was more than adequate to satisfy the outcome.


That sort of race consciousness, she said, may be perfectly lawful. “You can’t have a racially neutral policy that adversely affects minorities,” Judge Sotomayor said, “unless there is a business necessity.”

Try as one might, this isn’t a reflection of some strange devolution into activist racial lawmaking.  It’s the law, and it’s been the law for a very long time.  That non-lawyers, and lawyers who are unfamiliar with discrimination law, are unfamiliar doesn’t render it novel or damning.  You may not like the state of the law, but that doesn’t change what it is.

According to Liptak, it wasn’t the result that was surprising, or improper, but that such an important case resulted in a summary decision rather than a lengthy published decision.  What makes this such an “important” case?  Were all the other thousands of case heard by Judge Sotomayor in her tenure on the Circuit trivial?  One might think so, given the emphasis placed on Ricci, but I don’t for a moment believe that to be the case.

The reason that Ricci has emerged as a touchstone for those inclined to attack peaks through in Liptak’s piece in this “heated” exchange:


“Firefighters die every week in this country,” the lawyer, Karen Lee Torre said. Using the test, she said, could save lives.

“Counsel,” Judge Sotomayor responded, “we’re not suggesting that unqualified people be hired. The city’s not suggesting that. All right?”

That’s right.  It’s the “do it for the children” argument, firefighter version.  When the law is against you, and when the thrust of your position is to ask a judge to turn a blind eye to the Constitution, in this case ignoring the disparate impact of the test on minorities, and neither facts nor reason support your position, then devolve to the nadir of legal arguments, an appeal to emotion and fear.  Judge Sotomayor blew a hole through that effort big enough for a busload of freedom riders to drive through.

But the key to why this case has become a cause celebre isn’t that it involved white applicants failing to get their appointments because the test was tossed for disparate impact; there’s nothing new about that at all.  No-o-othing. Nothing.  The key is the identity of the lawyer who made one of the worst possible, most disingenuous, most insulting and ignorant arguments possible in favor of Frank Ricci.  The key is Karen Lee Torre.

Don’t like the outcome of Ricci v. DeStefano?  Don’t blame Sotomayor.  Blame Karen Lee Torre. 

For those of you who are unfamiliar with that name, allow me to illuminate.  I’ve mentioned her here a couple of times, much to her consternation.  She thinks I’m a meany.  I think she’s a twinkie.  She actually used foul language to describe me, but I’m disinclined to indulge in the same word choices she makes.  I’m too much of a gentleman.

Karen Lee is a rabid neo-con, and I apologize to all rabid dogs who may be insulted by the comparison.  She’s like a lawyer version of Ann Coulter, except not as smart, attractive or persuasive, and that’s coming from someone who doesn’t find Coulter persuasive in the least.  But like Coulter, Karen Lee is a true believer, foaming-at-the-mouth sort of person who will dedicate her life to the destruction of her political enemies.  After she get smacked by Judge Sotomayor for her disingenuous, not to mention idiotic, argument on behalf of Frank Ricci, Sotomayor was written into the enemies column in permanent marker.

Notably, when Ricci was argued before the Supreme Court, they wised up and wouldn’t let Torre near the podium.

With Sonia Sotomayor on the short list of nominees should Obama win the presidency, the neo-con forces had a year to gear up for their attack, giving them plenty of time to hire a flak to promote the cause and find a scapegoat when it all came tumbling down around them with a resounding Senate confirmation.  Who would be willing to sacrifice good name and credibility for such a losing cause?  It would have to be a true believer.  Someone who would do anything to help the cause.  A person who hated Sotomayor.  Where could anyone like that be found?  And so all heads in the room turned to Karen Lee Torre, who, for a brief and shining moment, would be star, a martyr to the cause.

But Adam Liptak, quietly, in the way that a journalist lawyer tries to sneak in an idea so that it’s available for anyone who chooses to see it, plucked this exchange out of the 2d Circuit oral argument to show just what an awful job Torre did in arguing the case. 



[Judge Sotomayor’s] extensive and probing questions at the argument were typical of her methodical approach to cases, and they offer sometimes conflicting hints about her views on when the government may take account of race in decisions concerning hiring and promotion.

At times, her questions were small lectures on the governing legal standards.

Judges often give “small lectures” when lawyers make arguments that demonstrate their lack of understanding of the legal standards.  It’s not to talk down to counsel, but to assist them when they appear for argument without being prepared, knowledgeable or, perhaps, competent.  It’s like a cue to the lawyer to cut the crap and start dealing with the case like a lawyer.  Good lawyers take the cue.  Bad lawyers resist, insisting that they know better. 

Karen Lee Torre suffers from a disability.  She’s blind.  And it has nothing to do with her eyesight.  Her affliction prevented her from seeing how bad her argument was before the 2d Circuit.  Her limitations precluded her from recognizing that she lost all credibility, assuming she had any to begin with, with her appeal to fear.  No judge on that panel forced Torre to take such an absurd tact.

A decision will issue from the Supreme Court on Ricci sometime soon, and it may well reverse the circuit decision.  On the one hand, Sonia Sotomayor will not be one of the judges deciding, her absence being one difference.  On the other hand, Karen Lee Torre was not the lawyer arguing the cause for Frank Ricci and 17 other firefighter applicants, being another difference.  If one was to chose between one out of a gaggle of judges or the lawyer arguing for the party as being more critical to outcome, the key becomes clear. 

Sunday Stuff That Irks Me

On occasion, I post something a bit more introspective than my typical commentary on law, news or the loss of dignity, client service and professionalism amongst lawyers.  Today is going to be one of those days.  For readers who hate when I do this, go away now.  Run.  Flee. Avert your eyes.

For quite some time now, my brethren and sistren in the blawgosphere have used the adjective “prolific” to describe my posting.  It pisses me off.  There, I’ve said it.  I hate it when I’m described that way.  It insults me.  It offends me. 

Others, usually clueless about what I do at Simple Justice and more often than not card-carrying members of the Slackoisie, assume that in order to produce posts on a blawg, not to mention respond to their silly comments, I must spend every waking moment hard at work at my keyboard.  They assume this because it would take them hours, maybe even days, to produce a post.  They can’t write worth a damn, so that means it must take me as long as them to write something.  After all, it isn’t possible that there are people out there who can do anything they can’t do.  They are the most awesomest person ever, and everyone else is measured by them.  I can easily ignore these fools, though I feel sorry for them and want to help. 

But it’s the people who have come to know me through my writing that bother me.  You know who you are.  You should know better.  You’ve read what I have to say on the subject, that I have spent the past quarter century doing pretty much the same thing I do now at Simple Justice, thinking about stuff and cranking my thoughts out in words.  I don’t count the number of words or posts or the minutes ticking away on the clock.  I just pound the keyboard until it’s out of my head and onto my screen. 

Calling me prolific elevates quantity over quality.  On very rare occasion, I look back at something I’ve written.  Usually, I do it because I see a typo (I use spellcheck before posting, but I never proof anything on the blawg, ever.  That’s reserved for real work) which bothers me when it comes on my radar.  As I reread my stuff, I usually like it.  Sometimes, I like it a lot.  I think to myself, that’s pretty good writing or that’s a pretty good analysis.  There is a measure of pride in what I produce.  Not because there’s a lot of it, but because the ideas, the language, the delivery, pleases me.  But not you, eh?

Am I just the smorgasbord with so much food laid out before you that you can gorge yourselves, but none so tasty or well-prepared that it’s worthy of mention?  That’s how calling me prolific makes me feel.  When the first thought that comes to mind about Simple Justice is that Greenfield sure writes a lot, the message is clear.  Expressio unius est exclusio alterius.  Don’t you think I can read between the lines?  I get the message.  Simple Justice, where words go to die.

Thanks for your kind thoughts.  Prolific.  Feh.  Why not just come right out and say it, ya buncha wussies.  Go ahead.  I dare you.

And now for something completely different.*

Dan Hull, who is finally beginning to shed his shrinking violet image at What About Clients?, has had enough of “big mouths, no names.”  Me too.  This is not to invite another debate about good reasons for anonymous posting, but to make a point to all those who believe that their value judgments matter when they express it under some silly nom-de-comment.  It happens constantly.

Sometimes the identity of the person posting a comment doesn’t matter because the content speaks for itself.  But that’s rare.  Usually, the content involves a rank opinion, for or against something, or an assessment which only derives meaning from the fact that you’ve got a basis to lay claim to an opinion.  What possible worth is your opinion standing alone?  This isn’t a Gallup poll, and the side with the most votes doesn’t win.  When some anonymous person writes “I’m a really good lawyer,” it means nothing since you aren’t the judge of your own competence.  On the other hand, it tells me that you’re too stupid and egocentric to realize it, so that suggests you’re a really bad lawyer who just doesn’t get it.

These anonymous commenters get their panties in a twist when I call them out.  They take it personally, and fail to recognize the irony of shielding their bona fides through anonymity while being personally hurt by being told they don’t matter.  If you want to matter, than be bold enough to stand behind your opinion by using your real name.  Hull, enemy of the spineless, thinks it’s time to start a NWZ.


Because WAC? is seriously considering a policy of “No Real Name, No Real Publish, Jack”.  A No-Wankers Policy. A No-Weenies Standing Order. No-Wank Zone. No-Wimp Zone. Set up your own No-Weakling area. Establish “Spines-Only” districts. Not sure. Maybe…”No-Wuss” zone. I think I like that one best.
Stop kidding yourself.  If you don’t have the balls to stand behind your opinions, to let others know that your views are worth the ten seconds it takes to read them, to provide some basis, any basis, to make anyone care what you think, then use your name. 

I’ve got no plans to block anonymous commenters.  But don’t expect me to fawn all over you as if you’re entitled to being taken seriously.  On the flip side, if you twit under some idiotic name that involves body parts or your favorite critter or anything else that clouds who you are, I will not follow you, respond to you or take you seriously.  I’m terribly wrong not to appreciate your brilliance?  I’ll live.

And one more thing:  No anonymous commenter, nor any commenter under the age of 30, is allowed to call anyone else “whiny”.  You are presumptively wrong and clueless.  It’s like one toddler calling the other “stupid”, and the second saying, “No, you are!”  I’ve had enough of it.  All of you, go to your rooms until your mother and I tell you to come out.

Why?  Because I say so.  So there.

And now for something else completely different.

Most blogs link to the source of a post, when something comes on their radar because another blog picked it up.  Most are very good about doing so, both because of etiquette, credibility and the mutual benefits of link love.  Most.  Some, not so good.  Some bad.  Very bad.  Some never link to the source of their information at all, ignoring completely how they became aware of a case or issue, and going instead to the initial source (like a newspaper story) as if they came up with it all on their own.  Res ipse loquitur, my butt.

It’s not quite plagiarism, but it stinks from a lack of integrity and etiquette.  If someone else did the heavy lifting that now benefits you, don’t pretend that you did it all by yourself.  That’s deceptive, and you’re milking someone else’s efforts.  It’s all out there in the ether for anyone to find?  True.  But you didn’t.  Someone else did.  Give ’em the credit.  Both because it’s the right thing to do and because your integrity is suspect. 

It’s Not For The Money

It’s been said many times the being a police officer isn’t just a job, but a calling.  Of course, that doesn’t mean that cops don’t have families to feed.  Just ask Westhampton Beach Chief Raymond Dean.

From Newsday :


Westhampton Beach Police Chief Raymond Dean makes $188,709 a year, is given a car for his work and personal use, and he wants more.

Some trustees of the 2.9-square-mile village on the South Fork are not so sure. They’re expected to discuss Dean’s contract – as well as 583 hours in compensatory time he accrued – at a meeting at 7 Thursday in Village Hall.

If Dean gets a raise of any kind – a village official says there is a 7.9 percent raise in his contract – Dean would make more than New York City Police Commissioner Ray Kelly, who oversees the largest police department in the country. Kelly makes $189,700, said his spokesman, Paul Browne.

In case you aren’t familiar with Westhampton Beach, that 2.9-square-mile description fails to do it justice.  That’s 2.9 of the roughest, toughest Hamptons miles you’ll ever see.  I can’t begin to describe how the Mercedes and Porsches whiz along Dune Road, sometimes going 40 on the 30 mile per hour road.  It’s a war zone.


Westhampton Beach Police Dept. Chief Raymond Dean It’s not easy being Chief Dean.  And yes, that certainly looks like a Rolex on his wrist.  But not a new one.  And clearly not a Daytona.  One of the lesser models.  In Westhampton Beach, that’s humiliating.

But comparisons between Chief Dean and NYPD Chief Ray Kelly are just unfair.  After all, Kelly has about 35,000 people in his department.  Dean has about 21. 


Last year, there were 116,824 serious crimes reported in New York City – a historic low, Browne said. By comparison, there were 43 serious crimes, including robbery and aggravated assault, reported in Westhampton Beach, according to state criminal justice statistics.
When you break the hundred thou mark, you have mechanisms in place to keep track of all that serious crime.  When it’s a mere 43 crimes, you have to do it all in your head.  Need I tell you what a headache a Chief can get from having to remember that many things?  Seriously, I don’t know how he does it.

The good news is that Board of Trustees of the Village of Westhampton Beach has now resolved to declare Chief Raymond Dean’s contract “invalid and unenforceable.” How exactly that works is unclear, given that even baby government’s can’t abrogate contractual obligations at will.  I expect that the Village attorney, Herman J (Bo) Bishop, will have a brilliant scheme whereby they can do any darn thing they want.  Frankly, if he’s got a lawful way to pull this off, I would be most  impressed.

But there’s still one question that remains unanswered.  How in the world did these dedicated public servants get themselves in this position in the first place, giving the Chief a deal that would make a Saudi prince blush?