Author Archives: SHG

Schools Have Rules, Taser Edition

Cellphones are a problem in school.  They can be disruptive and a huge distraction.  Some schools ban them altogether.  Others, like Penn Hills High School, around Pittsburgh, has been a bit gentler in its limitation, allowing students to have cellphones in school provided they only use them for emergencies.  On the other hand, they also allow cops in school to make sure that students adhere to the rule.

Via Turley (who I might add never notes who his sources might be) comes this shocking bit of news from the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review :


The officer, who was stationed at the school, saw a male student walking in a hallway talking on a cell phone between classes and ordered the teenager to return to class, according to police Chief Howard Burton.

“The student ignored the officer, who then took him by the arm to escort him to the office,” Burton said. “But the student resisted and pushed the officer.”

“The kid was violating two rules — he should have been in class and he shouldn’t have been talking on a cell phone,” Burton said.

To subdue the student the officer used his Taser to perform a drive stun, Burton said.

Two rules at once?  This kid must be a bad seed.  He must be taught a lesson.  Tase him.

But Chief Burton’s explanation of the offense presents a problem.  If the student was “between classes,” what should he have done in response to the “order” to return to class?  Apparently, he should have bowed deeply to the officer and acknowledge his omnipotence, or at least kissed his ring.  The notion that we are not obliged to respond because a police officer speaks doesn’t enter the picture.  In Penn Hills High School, there is no right to be left alone.

No doubt, someone will think to themselves that this student, the bad seed, could have easily avoided the problem by merely complying with the officer’s order.  How hard would it be to just do whatever the cop says?  That’s what a good boy would have done, right?  Well, of course it is.  It’s what a good sheep would have done as well.  There’s a lesson to be taught in all high schools.

So having ignored the officer’s less than well-conceived order, the officer does what he has to do.  He places his hands on this student.  Mind you, no one at this point asserts that the student wasn’t in complete compliance with the school rules, as in his telephone call was not an emergency and he was still trying to get through to vote for Sanjaya on American Idol.  As far as can be told, he might have been telling his mother than he was suffering from Swine Flu.  We don’t know, though one might surmise that if the police had information to bolster the officer’s conduct (like the kid had a rap sheet), it would have been the first thing out of Chief Burton’s mouth.

Contrary to the belief of many, police officers have no inherent right to grab someone.  No one, but no one, has an inherent right to place their hands on another person and seize them.  Before doing so, there must be a cognizable basis.  In this instance, the claimed basis is that the student ignored the cop’s order.  Does that do it for you?  It falls just a bit short for me.

When someone, even a cop, grabs an arm without the permission of the rest of the body, there is a right to defend oneself.  This is where most thinking gets muddled.  I don’t recommend it, not because it’s wrong but because the immediate consequences are often dire, but the law allows each of us to protect ourselves from a seizure by a police officer acting without legal justification. 

And then the officer, locked and loaded with taser, teaches the kid a lesson.  This is where the story gets really interesting.  While the article neglects to mention the source of this information ( which is presumptively Chief Burton), it notes that the taser was on “drive stun” and then states:


A drive stun is when the Taser is placed against a person’s body, typically the thigh, and is activated, sending out an electrical charge that only contracts the muscles in the roughly 2-inch area where it is touching.
No big deal, right?  I mean, seriously, a 2-inch area?  It’s like a love tap, right?  And I bet the writer knows this first hand, as he’s probably been the target of a taser on drive stun many times before, laughing it off as a quick buzz.  Elsewhere, “drive stun” has been described as a “searing jolt of pain.”  Maybe things don’t hurt as much in Pittsburgh.

As for the bad seed, his problems have just begun:

The student was handcuffed after he went down on the ground because he continued to resist, the chief said. The boy, who complained about being dizzy and having a headache, was taken to Forbes Regional Hospital for treatment.

Not only must he be the wussiest kid in Pittsburgh, feeling dizzy from a mere tasing, but now he’s going to cost his father for the hospital bills.  Hope Dad has insurance, or maybe he’ll have to terminate his kid’s cellphone plan to cover the cost.  I told you there were consequences for ignoring a cop. And no, we aren’t done yet with our bad seed:


The teenager, whose age and grade level were not available, will likely face multiple criminal charges including a felony count of assaulting an officer, Burton said.

This part is unclear:  Did he assault the officer when he pulled his arm away (that can hurt really, really bad, right officer?) or by proxy when he assaulted the end of the taser on drive stun, thus attacking the officer’s shooting hand?  Or maybe both, since he will face “multiple” criminal charges. 

Can’t we all agree that the halls of Penn Hills High are safer today because of this police officer’s bravery, quick thinking and, mostly, adept use of a taser?  You can bet there won’t be many students chatting on cellphones come Monday, no matter how bad the emergency.


But What If She Was Black and Poor?

Following Dan Solove’s post at Co-Op on the utterly disgusting conduct of California Highway Patrol Officers who posted photographs of the decapitated Nikki Catsouris online, I jumped in to express my outrage and disgust that our protectors would do something like this.  Now Marc Randazza (of the Sicilian Randazzas) at the Legal Satyricon has stepped into the mix, and brings a very different perspective to the mess.

In an extraordinarily powerful post, Randazza, after noting that his utter disgust for the photos and the conduct of the wealth of nutjobs who enjoy such images and frequent the internet earth, hiding their diseased minds in feigned normalcy and online anonymity, reminds us that offended sensibilities, no matter how justified, shouldn’t move us to forget why we have freedom of speech.  That said, he goes into an entirely different area.

“Cultural class warfare,” Randazza explains, distinguishes the Catsouris case.  Here’s a young woman, high on cocaine, driving a Porsche, and now she’s dead with hideous pics to prove it.  Had it not been a “privilege, young white girl,” no one would have cared enough to post her photos.  And if they did, no one would have cared enough to write about it.  And if they did, no one would have cared enough to be outraged.  What was once the object of envy of the poor is now the subject of ridicule.  They got their revenge at the expense of the Catsouris’. 

Sadly, Randazza’s right.  Horrible things happen to poor people, to black people, to poor black people.  No one bothers to post the photos or bemoan the wrong done them.  It just doesn’t seem to matter.

This “phenomenon” can be more easily observed, and happens with far greater frequency, with missing, murdered and abused children.  The back of milk cartons are filled with faces, often of color, and yet we hear nothing about them.  Yet, when a white child of well-to-do parents goes missing or turns up dead, it becomes a national story.  It’s shocking how bald the distinction is.  Think Natalee Holloway.

So when images of Nikki Catsouris appeared on the internet, horrible photos that no one should ever want to see, it was time for payback.  As if the Catsouris family was to be blamed.  But this really had nothing to do with the Catsouris family, though they suffered directly,  Randazza says that this “provides a salve to the daily suffering that comes from being a low-life.”  So much of our cultural angst derives from some miserable human being needing someone they can deride to feel a momentary sense of being better than someone else.  It explains why the sickest, stupidest, lowest white man will ridicule a successful, educated black man, as if the color of his skin made the former intrinsically better.  The former needs to hate black skin to show that he isn’t at the very bottom of the ladder of humanity, all evidence to the contrary notwithstanding.

The “solution” to the Catsouris dilemma is that we ought to be far better people than we are, and by no means is there any excuse for the conduct of the CHiPs officers who initially distributed the photos.  But we aren’t better people, and those who seized upon the photos to rub it in the face of Nikki Catsouris’ family are the worst of us.  No law has ever been enacted to change the diseased mind of the miserable.  And there will always be miserable, disgusting human beings.  It’s our nature.

Bodine to Twitter: You Ugly and You Dress Funny

When it comes to marketing worthiness, I’m not exactly the first person people turn to for advice.  My strong (some would say virulent) position on lawyer marketing makes me anathema to those inclined to pursue clients the new-fashioned way: huckstering.  I realize that you need business and are prepared to put on lipstick and walk about, but don’t hate me for calling you on it.

But Larry Bodine?  That’s another story altogether.  He’s all about marketing, and he’s got some of the best street cred in lawyer marketing around.  If I was going to market, he would be the guy I would go to.

Yet Larry just made himself persona non grata in the twittersphere.  The Web 2.0 zealots, the early adapters, the sycophants of all things binary, have fallen in love with twitter and can’t gush enough about its worthiness.  Word on twitter is that it’s soon to cure cancer.  Or at least herpes.  I can’t say whether that would be simplex or duplex.

Larry, however, has not been sucked in.  Sure, he’s on it.  He tried it.  He gave it a fair shake.  And he’s arrived at a conclusion:



But that doesn’t make Twitter an effective law firm marketing tool. Consider that:



  • 60% of Twitter users drop out after one month.
  • It is the least effective way to boost traffic to your website, compared with SEO, email promotions and blogs.
  • Twitter will generate leads, but not necessarily sales.
  • Twitter can get lawyers and firms in a lot of trouble in the event of litigation.
  • Twitter is a powerful distraction from getting real marketing work done.

 When he uttered these words at the Get A Life Conference, according to Adrian Dayton, Bodine “caused audible gasps in the audience.”  The unthinkable, challenging a sacred cow of the technoslackers, was met with shock.   But, but, but . . . it’s new and it’s techie and it’s, it’s, it’s easy. 

My life on twitter has settled in to a relatively comfortable co-existence.  It can be fun for brief period of time, like some background chatter outside my office by people I like, allowing me to jump in when I feel like it and ignore it when I don’t.  This works for me.  But I am one of those twitterers who doesn’t play by the rules.  I don’t follow people because they follow me.  I don’t care if I have more followers than someone else.  In fact, I occasionally try to chase away undesirables by letting them know that (a) I won’t be following them and (b) I won’t be buying anything from them.  Whenever I twit things like this, a bunch of followers magically disappear, significantly reducing my chances of winning the prize for most twitter followers.  Bummer. 

I’ve come across some of the puffy sort of people who frequent the internet claiming to have made big money on twitter.  I bet the owners of twitter would like to know how, since they have yet to figure out how to monetize their baby.  These fast-talkers tend to be the same ones who claim to have made fortunes on blogs as well.  There are a surprising number of people who make claims of great wealth gained from promoting themselves online.  I don’t believe them.  I think they are full of it.

Some of these voices I know to be liars.  Some I merely suspect.  Some I think are so shameless in the promotion of their self-interest that they’ve lost any sense of honesty and decency, and feel no compulsion to keep their claims anywhere near the realm of reality.  But I know that those who claim their seldom-read blogs are generating millions are suspect.  I know a little something about blogs.  As does Mark Hermann.  Don’t try to sell me magic blogging beans.

Larry Bodine has guts.  I admire guts.  He looked the sacred cow square in the eye and spoke his mind.  The audience was made up of very likely candidates for his services, and yet he told them something they didn’t want to hear.  It’s so much easier to appeal to their bias.  People like you better when you tell them what they already believe to be true.  You attain instant credibility.  It would have been very easy for Larry to scam the fools to get their love, not to mention their business.  He chose not to.  That’s integrity.

Some may fear that if Bodine’s right, it could spell the death of twitter.  A meteoric rise, and similar crash.  I don’t think it means anything of the sort.  It only means that twitter’s utility, assuming utility is a word that can be associated with twitter at all, isn’t commercial.  For me, that’s more of a reason to like twitter, the hope that the self-promoters, the hucksters, the marketers, will find it worthless and abandon it in droves, leaving it to the few who just want to twit with some friends when the mood strikes.

I still don’t know how the inventers of twitter are going to monetize their creation, unless they plan to put a webcam into their offices and charge for the pleasure of watching them rid the twittersphere of Ponzi schemers.  And speaking of webcams, to the young ladies who are following me in the expectation that I will sign up to watch them in their private moments on their very own webcam, chances are not good at all.  I don’t even think they are lawyers.

H/T Carolyn Elefant at Legal Blog Watch

The Nanny Sentence

Doug Berman posts at Sentencing Law & Policy about a sentence imposed by a District Court judge in Bangor, Maine, which stretches even the hardest criminal lawyer’s heart to the breaking point.  From the Bangor Daily News :


U.S. District Judge John Woodcock last month sentenced Quinta Layin Tuleh, 28, to 238 days in federal prison for having fake documents. Woodcock said the sentence would ensure that Tuleh’s baby, due Aug. 29, has a good chance of being born free of the AIDS virus.

Both the federal prosecutor and the defense attorney urged the judge to sentence Tuleh to 114 days, or time served, according to a transcript of the sentencing hearing. Woodcock instead ignored the federal sentencing guidelines and calculated her sentence to coincide with her due date.

Talk about an activist judge, it doesn’t get more overt than this.  But it’s awfully hard to fault the judge’s good intentions.  Idealogical issues aside, no one wants to see a baby born with AIDS, and who amongst us wouldn’t want to do something to help?  Judge Woodcock made no bones about his purpose.


Woodcock told Tuleh at her sentencing on May 14 in U.S. District Court that he was not imposing the longer prison term to punish her further but to protect her unborn child. He said that the defendant was more likely to receive medical treatment and follow a drug regimen in federal prison than out on her own or in the custody of immigration officials. The judge also said that his decision was based entirely on her HIV status. If Tuleh were pregnant but not infected with the AIDS virus, he would have sentenced her to time served.

One might well question whether the judge puts a bit more stock in the fine medical care available to prisoners, but cynicism aside, his flagrant abuse of his sentencing power at least serves a greater good.  Certainly, judges have abused their power before for reasons far less worthy.

There really can be no rational basis in law for imposing this sentence.  Protecting an unborn child by assuring the provision of medical care is simply not one of the available bases for a judge to impose a sentence.  Nowhere in Section 3553 is the welfare of a child mentioned.  The point is clearly made by the MCLU:


“Judges cannot lock a woman up simply because she is sick and pregnant,” [Zachary Heiden, legal director for the MCLU] said. “Judges have enormous discretion in imposing sentences, and that is appropriate. But jailing someone is punishment — it is depriving them of liberty. That deprivation has to be justified, and illness or pregnancy is not justification for imprisonment.”
There’s no legally cognizable counterargument.  And yet, there’s a baby to think about.  Judge Woodcock did his best to fashion his sentence as if it fell under the deterrence prong of 3553, stating the this could be deemed an assault on her baby when born, and knowing that there is a likelihood that she will assault her baby when born, he must act to prevent that assault by deterring her conduct by keeping her incarcerated.  It was a valiant try, quite imaginative, but it’s hard to believe that even the judge bought it.  He said enough words to give it the color of legitimacy, so that his sentence would last long enough to keep her in until the baby was born.  He could be reversed afterward, but by then the issue would be past.

Institutionally, this is a terrible precedent, leaving it up to the sensibilities of individual judges to ignore the limits of their authority whenever something comes along where they feel that they can further an agenda in which the believe, stay a harm that they feel needs staying, and help in a way that they believe deserves help. 

But this was a baby.  It’s just so hard to argue against protecting a baby.

Vanity Fair

Having been a litigator throughout my legal career, I don’t feel competent to assert that this is true of all lawyers, but I can tell you that almost every trial lawyer I’ve ever known is vain.  It’s perfectly understandable, as a component of putting ourselves on the line for a cause in front of a bunch of other people whose purpose is to make us look like wrong at best, idiots at worst. 

We must believe in ourselves or we couldn’t stand up and face the judge and jury.  It’s not that we don’t have self-doubt.  In fact, we have quite a bit at times, but can’t afford to let it show.  Thus, it should come as no surprise that validation of our belief in ourselves is something we desire.  It’s palpable proof that we exist, we are worthy, we can do it.

The other day, Deven Desai at Concurring Opinions wrote about “Who’s Who.”  It’s one of those seemingly harmless things that validates us.  It sounds impressive, to tell others that you are in “Who’s Who,” though I’m unaware of anyone who has ever actually referred to “Who’s Who” to figure out who’s who.

Deven, however, raises some concerns that makes it appear less benign than assumed.


In a world where people develop online reputations, being included in a database such as Who’s Who may not be desired. I always thought of the publication as one requiring payment for inclusion; that is apparently not so. Still that image persists in my mind so I don’t like being in the database.
When I received my first “Who’s Who” inquiry, it was by snail mail.  There was no internet yet, and certainly no email.  The mailing certainly made it seem as if it was a come-on to buy the book, touting the special insider rate for those worthy of inclusion. But I did go along with being included, though the come-on suggested that I was only being “considered”, with no guarantee.  Unless, perhaps, I bought the book?   I passed.  I knew who I was and didn’t need a book to tell me.  Especially one that costs more than $100, which was a princely sum at the time.

Over the years, I received notification from the publishers, Marquis primarily but a few others as well, of my honor.  I was in Who’s Who in American Law.  Later Who’s Who in America, and then Who’s Who in the World.  I could understand being in the one about law, but never really understood why anyone in the world would be interested in me.  Still, who was I to disagree with the sound judgment of whoever made such decisions?

With the letters came a biography of me.  I never gave them any information, and yet they had quite a bit, ranging from stuff about my parents to details about my children.  That was shocking.  Where did these guys get all this information about me?  Remember, there was no internet then, and the idea of Googling someone wasn’t even a twinkle in their eye.  Yet they had it, and published it.  I still assumed that while it would appear in book after book, I was safe since no one would ever bother to look me up and see it.  There’s safety in being buried in the “G’s”.

Things are different now.  Deven’s concern is real, given that personal information, usable for a plethora of dastardly purposes, is readily available to anyone who bothers to look.  And what was once a harmless vanity is now a source of personal data that could fuel an attack upon privacy. 

A couple of years ago, I was rummaging through a church used book sale and came upon a Who’s Who in the World.  I couldn’t help myself, I had to look.  It was a huge book, a monster.  And only one of a series of huge books.  It was big enough that one might assume it listed everyone in the world who had the wherewithal to buy the books.  It appeared untouched by human hands, what people on eBay refer to as mint.  I ruined that by shuffling through the pages until I came to the place where my name should be.

There is was.  I was in it just like they said, even though I never spent a dime.  Me and a few gazillion similarly situated folks. 

I turned to my wife and said, “You wanna buy this?”  It was only a quarter.  She looked at me square in the eyes.  Her passion in our household is to counterbalance any pretensions I might have of importance.  “Why?”  That was all she needed to say to take the wind out of my sails.  Why indeed? 

Lawyers, at least litigators, are always searching for some honor to put on our wall to make us believe that we are as good as we want to believe we are.  The validation for which we strive in the privacy of our own minds.  Some pay for the privilege.  Some wait for someone to send us notice that we are the recipient of some “honor”.  It’s not like we build a beautiful house that we can point to with pride as an example of our worth.  The closest we come is the “ego wall” that holds the many certificates that come with bar and association memberships, which may impress some clients but which we know to be the product of mailing a check with sufficient funds behind it. 

The only real validation we receive is the knowledge that there are people walking around, families eating dinner together that night, who wouldn’t be but for our efforts.  It should be enough.  And yet we willingly sacrifice our privacy and risk financial ruin to allow our name to be published in a meaningless book. 

Taser, With Love From Niagara Falls (Update)

When the Niagara Falls police put their heads together and decided that tasing a guy was the best idea for collecting a DNA sample, I “tsked”.  That, apparently, is why I’m not sitting on the big bench, like Niagara County Judge Sara Sheldon Sperrazza.  I lack her imagination.

From the Buffalo News :


It is legally permissible for police to zap a suspect with a Taser to obtain a DNA sample, as long as it’s not done “maliciously, or to an excessive extent, or with resulting injury,” a county judge has ruled in the first case of its kind in New York State, and possibly the nation.

Not to nitpick, but does that mean the intentional infliction of pain in order to obtain compliance with an ex parte order is fine as long as it’s done lovingly?  Must they cradle the taser in their warm and caring hands before they fire?  Just asking.

For anyone who may not recall, Ryan Smith gave a DNA sample willingly, which the cops promptly screwed up, thus requiring another one.


He already had given a sample, a swab of the inside of his cheek, without protest the previous month. But police sent it to the wrong lab, where it was opened and spoiled. Prosecutors who had obtained a court order for the first sample went back to Sperrazza, who signed another order without consulting the defense.

The judge figured, if he didn’t mind the first one, why bother asking about the second?  After all, nothing crazy could happen, right?  But Smith didn’t see it that way, and decided that he didn’t want to give up his DNA again.  So the cops have a court order and an uncooperative defendant.  Normally, the refusal to comply with a court order would compel the police to let the prosecutor know, who would then move to have the defendant held in contempt for failure to obey the court order.  But not in Niagara Falls.


Smith was handcuffed and sitting on the floor of Niagara Falls Police Headquarters when he was zapped with the 50,000- volt electronic stun gun after he insisted he would not give a DNA sample.

But the police took no pleasure from this, I bet.  Just doing their job.


In her ruling, Sperrazza cited numerous legal precedents and the state’s Criminal Procedure Law, allowing the use of reasonable force to carry out a court order.

Although there are no New York cases specifically dealing with using a Taser to accomplish that, the judge did find a Wyoming case where a court ruled it was legal to use a Taser to force a suspect to open his hand for a search.

Balkin and other lawyers familiar with the case say they know of no other case in the country in which a Taser was used to gather DNA.

Wyoming?  Let me see if I have this straight, a Niagara County Court judge wanted so desperately not to rule against the cops that she researched?  And she researched Wyoming?  Because Wyoming is so fundamentally relevant and persuasive in the formation of novel New York law?  I’m still stuck on the part where she did research.  Boy, would I like to see this decisions, but it’s not yet available online. Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen Casey, is hot on its trail, however, so I hope we’ll have it available soon.

Update: Kathleen has gotten the decision and This entry was posted in Uncategorized on by .

Newsflash: Indigents Need Lawyers. Judges too

The Washington Post has another article about the crisis in indigent defense.  Are you surprised to learn that no one has found a pile of money to hire your public defenders or to lighten the caseload to human levels?  Neither am I, but people keep doing incredibly, and inexcusably, stupid stuff that ends up landing them in the dock.  Go figure.

The article opens on the tale of Kimberly Hurrell-Harring, whose husband is on vacation in Great Meadows Correctional Facility.  He’s got one itty, bitty favor.  Can she just squeeze a little weed into an orifice when she comes to see him?  Really, is that too much to ask?  And he asked on the prison phone.  You know, the ones with the really big signs over them that say, “Your Call Is Being Recorded!”  Oh, those prison jokesters.  Who would believe them?


He was calling from a maximum-security prison, and someone must have been listening because when she walked into the Great Meadows Correctional Facility in upstate New York, guards immediately yanked her to the side.

They told her things would go easier if she handed over the dope without a fuss. She did, and things immediately got worse.

With a swiftness that made her head spin, she was handcuffed and hauled to jail. At her arraignment, there was no public defender available, though she was entitled to one. Standing alone, she was charged with one felony count of bringing dangerous contraband into a prison.

And so, lacking funds to retain counsel, standing alone, afraid, confused, guilty.

After her arraignment, Hurrell-Harring went back to jail because she couldn’t afford bail, either. Three weeks passed before a public defender appeared, and she says she spent a total of 15 to 20 minutes with him before her sentencing hearing.

He told her not to fight the district attorney’s recommended punishment _ six months behind bars and five years of probation. It was the best she could hope for, he said. But she had no criminal record. Surely, she begged, couldn’t possession of less than an ounce of pot, a misdemeanor under other circumstances, be bargained down to probation?

“It was like he had no time for me,” she says now, still unemployed 17 months after her release because she lost her nursing license when she became a convicted felon. “He told me to plead guilty.”

This tale of woe is a terrific beginning, not because it engenders huge sympathy per se, but because it reflects the start of a series of problems that seem to fly right over the head of the writer.  For a story about the horrors of funding for public defenders, it’ tells a very different story.  Find a good guy amongst this crowd if you can.

Let’s start with our heroine, secreting marijuana in her private parts.  Did it surprise her that this might get her in trouble?  Her dear husband, already in prison, wanted it, and as she later explains, women do bad things for their men.  Really?  Then women get in trouble for doing bad things for their men.  It’s a cause and effect thing.  If you can’t afford to get in trouble for trying to sneak some drugs into prison, then here’s a solution.  Don’t do it.  Not to hard to figure out.

And what about the guards who lied to her that it would go easier if she just gave it up?  Isn’t it heart-warming to know that the primary tool of law enforcement is lying?  Yes, it’s effective.  No, it’s not the sort of thing that engenders respect for the law.  Especially when they manipulate some clearly clueless woman.  Big, tough prison guards.  Aren’t you proud of yourselves?

Then we have our prosecutor, who could have charged her with a misdemeanor, given that it was only a small amount of marijuana (it’s not clear how much, but there are few places within a body where you can hide a brick).  But this prosecutor was shooting fish in a barrel, so why not dump a full load on this woman and do as much damage as humanly possible.  After all, it’s not like she’s in a position to fight back, right?

Strangely, the article makes no mention of a judge.  Was there a judge around?  We can only assume, it being a court and all, but nary a mention of why the judge held her on bail (was she going to flee with her man in Great Meadows?), thus imposing one of the most coercive means of getting a plea, nor why the charge and sentence for this minor offense was cool with him. 

But since this was an article about indigent defense, I reserve my special thoughts for the lawyer charged with defending our heroine from tragedy.  What does Patrick Barber, the part-time public defender, have to say about this case?


He agrees with his former client. He doesn’t have much time to visit clients. It’s not possible to see every defendant, he said. Many have no car, and can’t get to his office. Others are in jail, and he simply can’t get to all of them, he says.

Barber claims he did the best he could for Hurrell-Harring.

“She couldn’t have been charged with a misdemeanor because it wasn’t offered. It wasn’t going to be offered. The district attorney takes a very hard stance when it comes to prison contraband,” he said.

No amount of money would cure this disease.  His problem wasn’t lack of time or funds, but lack of heart.  The defense was lost before it even began.  Was standing before the judge to accept a pre-dictated plea really the “best” he could do?  Had Barber said that he would have fought this case zealously, challenging the confession and search, maybe even making a Clayton motion, if only he had the time to do so, I would give him credit for good intentions. But instead he defends his representation, and for that he gets what he deserves.


Hurrell-Harring, 33, doesn’t much care about Baker’s caseload . . .
Nor should she.  What we do is defend people who do stupid things, guilty or not.  That she screwed up big time is irrelevant.  She still deserves representation by a lawyer who hasn’t surrendered before he met her.  That’s how our system is supposed to work.

Of course indigent funding is a disaster.  But this example shows a system of failure at every level, from every individual involved, not just indigent funding.  No amount of money is going to change what happened here.  They say it may not be perfect, but it’s the best there is.  Just keep repeating that to yourself and you can sleep soundly at night.



Party, Slackoisie Style

Adrian Dayton’s found his dream world :Dilbert



Generation X Shows Boomers How to Throw a Party (Conference)


-Free massages
-Video game station with a Nintendo Wii
-Flowers and grass displays creating a virtual arboretum
-Young energetic staff
-Great Chicago food
-The man in charge with his shirt un-tucked.

(see a video of the conference hall here)
[Ed. Note: Watch the video, it’s precious]


Does this sound like a nice place to hang out?

And he let’s me know that this world is far more desirable than what I have to offer.  Except for the video game station, which holds no interest for me at all if it doesn’t include Ms. Pacman or ‘stroids, it sounds wonderful.  But it’s a conference, not a job, kid.  And it didn’t work at that, given that there were only 110 paying attendees.  Other people had kids of their own, with mouths to feed.  Those darn hungry kids. 

I understand why this is much more fun.  It would be fun for me too, if only somebody wouldn’t mind being the grown-up and defending my clients while I was getting a massage and playing videogames.  Oh yeah, and paying me the money while I did so.  How cool would that be!  Awesome!  Awesomosity! Awesomositiness!  Or however you kids say it.

Sorry Scott Greenfield, but that type of success story is just far too appealing to Generation X and Y. And to reply to your post, the issue is not that Generation Y has a problem showing up for work; we just have a problem showing up to work for people like you.

And you don’t have to.  If you can find your dream world, by all means go for it.  But you can’t have it with me.  I don’t throw parties to appeal to children for a living.  My clients have more serious concerns. 

My favorite part of Adrian’s memory of a good time had is this:

I wasn’t just impressed by Edmund Scanlan as a person, but by his unique conference that was highly informative. There were awesome speakers like Stephen Fairley who besides being a really nice guy also taught how to build a 7 figure law practice,
I can’t wait to hear how soon you’re all making 7 figures the easy way.  But then:

In wasn’t all good however. There was one speaker whose unprovoked criticism of Twitter as a marketing tool caused audible gasps in the audience.  His recommendation to get free publicity? Use the telephone and just call newspapers. How 1970’s can you get? Actually, the unnamed person was Larry Bodine,

Someone always has to suck all the fun out of things.  He’s old, you know.


So far we have been through the Months of Integrity, Courage, and Gratitude and so I think it is fitting that this month, in honor of Ed Scanlan and to spite Scott Greenfireld, that we have June be the Month of Balance.
Perhaps the problem we have is that you were not yet ready to absord the lessons we tried to teach you, Adrian.  You’re older now, more mature perhaps, so let’s give it another try, shall we?  I’ve watched your video.  Now you watch mine.  Let’s see if this time around, you get the point:



Think about it. 

How Many Justices Should It Take

The platitude is that we are a nation of laws, not men.  This buck stops at the Supreme Court, where we rise or fall on the sensibilities, philosophies and experiences of Nine, right?  Well, not exactly.  It’s actually five, not nine.  Every decision of the Supreme Court of the United States is dictated by the votes of merely five people.  Fine people all, but still just people.

For the most part, this isn’t, and shouldn’t be, a problem.  Most critical decisions in the law are made by just one person, the trial level judge.  After that, the free-hand is far more constrained, and subject to greater scrutiny.  But when it comes to a court holding a law (not conduct, but a law) unconstitutional, that’s a big thing.  For better or worse, our tripartite system puts laws through many eyes and hands before they are imposed on the citizenry.  Each pair got there by election.  We, in other words, picked them to make decisions for us.

The same can’t quite be said for the Supreme Court Justices.  While they are nominated by elected officials, and subject to the advice and consent of elected officials, there are layers of distance that distinguish them from anyone else in power, not the least of which is the fact that they enjoy life tenure.  Ask any teacher, there’s nothing better than tenure to turn Mr. Rogers into Bobby McGee.

For non-lawyers, there is something almost mystical about the position of Supreme Court Justice.  They are endowed with an intelligence, an understanding, a wisdom, that distinguishes them from the other 300 million.  It’s a branch of government, a co-equal branch at that, which is comprised of nine people, who remain for life, passing judgment over the other two.  It is, unquestionably, an awesome amount of power and responsibility.

In his New York Times op-ed, Ross Douthat reflects on the fact that it takes only a majority of the nine, five human beings, to declare a law unconstitutional.  While the raw number, in a vacuum, may not strike one as intrinsically problematic, consider how many decisions of recent vintage have been decided by a 5-4 split.  More to the point, consider how many laws have been declared unconstitutional.


Complaints about the Supreme Court’s power are almost as old as the Constitution, but they have more merit now than ever. According to calculations by the Harvard law professor Jed Shugerman, the Court has gone from overturning roughly one state law every two years in the pre-Civil War era, to roughly four a year in the later 1800’s, to over 10 a year in the last half-century. So too with federal law: Prior to 1954, the Court had struck down just 77 federal statutes in a century-and-a-half of jurisprudence; in the 50-odd years since, it’s overturned more than 80. Under Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, the Court invalidated federal statutes at an unprecedented rate — and by the barest of majorities, in many cases. In one eight-year period, the University of Michigan’s Evan Caminker has noted, the Court invalidated 16 Congressional statutes by a 5-to-4 vote, something that had happened just 25 times in the previous two centuries.

If it seems like it’s happening at an unprecedented clip these days, it is.  Part of the reason, which Douthat neglects to mention, is that we already had a lot of laws in place that covered pretty much everything that needed to be legislated.  That left Congress without much to do as far as the basic social compact was concerned, which was bad news for all those politicians forced to run for office over and over, each of whom needed an accomplishment to show their constituents to justify their remaining on the dole.  That left a lot of people scrambling to find something to legislate, forcing them to tweak around the edges of appropriate governance and giving rise to far more dubious legislation than their predecessors. 

But Douthat’s primary point is that 5-4 decisions declaring laws unconstitutional emits a stink.  It reflects a transitory split along political and philosophical lines, one that changes with each new Justice and his or her nominating patron.  Constitutionality was supposed to be for the long haul, not subject to change every time a new body dons the robe.  The stability, reliability, continuity of the process demanded that there be clear, firm agreement amongst the chosen Nine about what the Constitution meant.  Each 5-4 decision undermined our faith in the stability of the law.

Detractors of 5-4 decisions come from all parts of the political spectrum,  We want desperately to see declarations of constitutionality, or not, be unanimous.  We want to know with certainty that it’s reliable, that it won’t change with the next personnel shift.  And as painful as this may be to state, we want to believe that a mere five can’t undo the balance of government, with four in disagreement. 

It is unseemly that out of the nine chosen ones, five insist that no rational person could possibly see things any way other than as they do, while the four in dissent explain why the majority is clueless.  After all, only one of the five need be clueless for the earth to shift on its axis and the entirety of the decision, the law, the constitutionality and the social compact to swing in the opposite direction.  Ultimately, five is reduced to one.  By the vote of a single Supreme Court Justice, everything changes.


There are bipartisan ways that the Court could be reined in, and the legislative branch reinvigorated. Shugerman, Caminker and others have proposed a supermajority rule, for instance, requiring a 6-to-3 vote to overturn federal legislation. To get conservatives on board, the rule would have to be extended to state legislation as well. This isn’t as crazy as it sounds — versions of the supermajority idea have been batted around by left and right alike since Reconstruction, and merely proposing it might spur the Court toward greater consensus, and perhaps greater modesty as well.
While I am very suspect of Rooseveltian methods to manipulate the Supreme Court, and would hardly agree with an attempt to try to Schechter Poultry them, Douthat has a point.  By requiring a supermajority of 6 to declare a law unconstitutional, then it would put the laws of this nation in the hands of two people, fully doubling what’s required to turn the earth on its axis.  That’s comforting.

“Optimism Is Not A Strategy”

While off the beaten path of Simple Justice, I spend quite a lot of time around cars.  As the proud owner of a 1964 Austin Healey BJ8 (That, for the uninitiated, is what us insiders call it.  Others refer to it as the 3000, MK III, phase 2), I go to classic car shows throughout the sunny months, many of which are frequented by Americans.  Cars, that is, not people.  From Model Ts to T-buckets, I’ve spent innumerable hours with the objects of Detroit’s lust. 

That General Motors, a very large rock in the foundation of American industry, would crack and collapse is shocking.  We always expect rocks to just remain rocks.  Even though we know they could collapse, we never expect it to happen while we are there, watching.  As it stumbled into Chapter 11 bankruptcy, after a mere $30 billion infusion, GM showed its age.

I saw this coming about two decades ago in the eyes of my mother.  My parents, who (much to my personal misfortune) never accumulated great wealth.  Yet my mother always aspired to own an American icon of wealth and success, a Cadillac Fleetwood.  Her other dream was to be a princess, but that was more difficult to achieve.  As they were entering the retirement years, they set aside some money to obtain the things that had always been the apple of my mother’s eye, the thinking being why die without enjoying the fruit of their labor.  And so, during on of my weekly telephone conversations, my mother informed me that she was, finally, going to the Cadillac dealer to purchase her sleek, black Cadillac.

“Mother (I always called her mother, at her insistence, as it made her feel more formal), we need to talk,” I responded.  I explained that the Cadillac she was thinking of ceased being an status icon sometime in 1972, and that the only remaining purchasers were living in the same gated complex in West Palm Beach.  It was still expensive, but would no longer sate her desire.  She was 20 years too late on the Cadillac.

She finished the phone call with a brave voice, but looked around afterward.  She saw.  She was crestfallen, having spent so many years coveting a car that had long since fallen out of favor.  She told me the following week that she changed her mind.  She was going to buy a Lexus!  That, she informed me, was what the “in” people around the gated community were driving these days.  It was a very sad day for my mother, but even she realized that the Cadillac of her youth, or her younger years, even of her more mature years, was gone. 

We now are told that the new GM will demonstrate a commitment to fuel economy, alternative fuel and the American worker.  There is nothing wrong with this.  But it will not sell many cars.  Lust sells cars.  When is the last time anyone lusted for a car made by General Motors?  Think quick, can you even name a model that matters?

The New York Times revisits the many announcements by GM over the past years about it’s “turnaround”, the one that never happened.  Their cars are priced below the Japanese competition, yet still fail to attract.  The quality remains worse, though we’re told it’s better.  While its profitability will benefit from the cost cutting, falling largely on the backs of former GM workers who got more, and less, than they bargained for, this bears no connection with the selling of cars.

What’s the plan, man?

To judge from their latest rose-colored predictions, those executives still don’t quite get it. Most of their cars are not yet reliable nor appealing enough. That — not car buyers who are too slow to know a good thing when they see one — remains the biggest problem.

We’ve heard what economists, pundits, executives and politicians have to say about turning GM around.  All by the numbers, making a very rational argument, well documented and empirically based.  But we’re talking about cars here.


All these steps should help the company focus on building cars that enough people want to buy. But G.M. still hasn’t explained how, at long last, it will manage to do so. And optimism doesn’t qualify as a strategy
I’ve seen cars made by General Motors that inspired lust.  They are all more than 30 years old.