Author Archives: SHG

Lisa, Jose and Profuse Apologies (Update)

Two American journalists,  Laura Ling and Euna Lee, are about to be put on trial in North Korea for illegal entry.  Laura’s sister, Lisa, has been making the rounds to plead for her sister’s freedom.  They are very scared for her.  Who wouldn’t be.

I saw Lisa Ling on Good Morning America, where she said that if her sister had illegally entered North Korea during her investigation of female sex trafficking across the North Korean and Chinese border, it was by accident and it was a totally unintentional.  She offered her “profuse apologies.”  The report went on to discuss how Laura Ling has health issues (an ulcer), and a daughter waiting for her at home.

One would have to be a heartless cretin not to be sympathetic toward Laura Ling and Euna Lee.  I am.  I believe what Lisa says, and certainly have no reason in the world to dispute it.  I join in her plea for the release of these two Americans held by North Korea.

But one thing bothers me.  There’s a fellow I know, who I’ll call Jose, who also crossed a border illegally.  His children were starving.  He lived in a country where the regime was harsh and callous, and not inclined to care much for the welfare of Jose’s children.  Jose’s health wasn’t all that great either, but he wouldn’t know what was wrong as he had never seen a physician.  So Jose crossed a border illegally in the hope of getting a job, making some money and feeding his children.

Jose never found a job, as he was caught and placed in a prison.  He was then told that he would be put on trial for illegally crossing the border.  Jose tried to explain his purpose, that he was just trying to save his children from starvation and he meant no harm.  He begged to return to his homeland, to his children.  He offered his profuse apologies. 

No one listened to Jose. 

I waited as a watched the Lisa Ling interview on Good Morning America.  As long as they were interested in the topic of illegal entry, this would be the perfect opportunity for Diane Sawyer to ask that Jose be returned to his family.  There was no mention of Jose in the story.  There was a great deal of hand-wringing over Laura Ling, as well there should be.  Let her go.

Of course, the situations are entirely different.  We are the United States of America.  North Korea is, well, North Korea. 

Update:  To the extent an imperfect analogy could be used to make a point, it stops dead in its tracks with the  sentencing of Laura Ling and Euna Lee to “12 years of reform through labor.”  

Tolerance and Tolerance for Ambiguity

Dealing with defendants in state court, charged mostly with standard street crime of the malum in se variety, it’s common to expect the client to demand answers of his attorney, the most notable being “what’s going to happen?”  While the obvious response is that we never know, lacking the ability to see into the future, it’s a very unsatisfying answer.  Clients want to have a clue of whether they have a chance or are dead in the water.  Naturally, they are happier to hear the former.

One underlying problem is the lack of tolerance for ambiguity.  We can explain how the various pieces of the puzzle fit together, or should fit together if things go according to plan, but there are always variables that defy our prediction.  Trying to handicap the outcome is a dangerous endeavor, often leading to discontent and recriminations later.

But the client doesn’t care at the time of the inquiry.  Many of our clients lack formal education, or at least much of it, and have a remarkably low tolerance for ambiguity.  Their world consists of concrete things, things that can be touched, seen or felt.  Things either are or are not; they refuse to allow voids to exist because it disturbs the clarity of their world.  It’s understandable.

The problem is that my inability to provide a concrete answer to their question leaves them to arrive at their own conclusion and attribute it to me.  I tend to be fairly cautious and explicit in my discussions of outcome with my clients because of my concern for being as truthful with my clients as possible.  Others differ.  Yet I still hear the subsequent refrain, “but you said . . .”  even though I didn’t.  It doesn’t bother me that this happens.  I expect it and tolerate it. It’s the nature of representing criminal defendants.

What surprises me, however, is that this lack of tolerance for ambiguity has reared its ugly head here with shocking frequency in the comments received from young lawyers.  Most are lawyers, so lack of education can’t be the problem.  Or can it?

My observation is that they engage in pervasive assumption to fill the gaps in information, but do so without the slightest recognition of what they are doing.  Gestalt explains this phenomenon to some extent, but fails to address the fact that once they assume, they argue to the death the validity of their assumptions.  Even when confronted with facts to the contrary, their belief in the infallibility of their own assumptions persists.  What’s with that?

It’s of little real consequence when this happens on something as innocuous as the comment section of a blog.  After all, it’s just sound and fury, soon to drift to the bottom of the page and be forgotten.  Sure, tempers flare on occasion, and foolish words are written, but one need only ignore it for the feelings to fade away.

What’s more significant is that this abiding belief that these young lawyers maintain in their own assumptions.  If they do this on a blog, do they do this when representing their clients as well?  I fear they do.  There are few things more dangerous for a lawyer to do than assume facts they don’t possess, and act upon them as if their assumptions were real.  We are forced at times to fill in voids in our information, but must recognize that these are mere assumptions, of dubious worth and subject to change as better information becomes available.  We can never afford to get stuck on our own assumptions.  This is not tolerable.

Having given this some thought, I wonder why this remains true after the completion of three years of law school.  Regardless of what insanity drives them to be so protective of their assumptions, one would think that law school would teach them to think like a lawyer, part of which is to appreciate and gain a tolerance for ambiguity.  Is this a by-product of the Socratic method falling into disrepute, or of the lack of critical reaction by lawprofs?  It’s hard for me to say, not having sat in a classroom for a number of decades.  From what I hear, no one is ever wrong anymore.  They are just “differently right.”  Of course, that comes to a complete halt with the first judge they meet head to head, a very tough lesson indeed.

Encouragement and positive reinforcement are certainly important pedagogical tools, far more likely to motivate a student than criticism.  Yet, there are indulgences that are inherently dangerous to a lawyer, or more precisely, the client.  The lack of tolerance for ambiguity is one, and it appears that there is an abundance of tolerance for this lack.  It’s got to stop.  No matter how smart or self-absorbed a young lawyer may be, she cannot be allowed to believe that her assumptions take on the value of fact simply because they pop into her head and she believes them to be valid. 

Ironically, I fully expect the people who have demonstrated the greatest inclination toward assumption to be the first to deny or defend it.  And I shudder at the implications for their clients.  I hope somebody teaching law school gives this some thought.



A Cache of Guns and Two Chickens

As every criminal defense lawyer knows, clients are sometimes a little short on cash to pay the legal fee.  They mean to pay it.  They want to pay it.  They just don’t have it.  It happens.  So in an effort to reach an accommodation, we are forced to take payment in kind.  Is there anything wrong with that?

According to this post by Dave Hoffman at Concurring Opinions, it’s not a great idea.



A pharmacist accused of murder decided to pay his lawyer with his firearm collection.  When the Judge presiding over his case inquired as to how many guns, exactly, that collection entailed, a constitutional fight ensued.




“I gave every weapon of mine to my attorney. I swear to the Lord,” Jerome Jay Ersland said.


Oklahoma County District Judge Tammy Bass-LeSure last week allowed Ersland, 57, of Chickasha to be released on $100,000 bail but she banned him from any access to weapons. The hearing today was to see if he had complied with her order.


Ersland told the judge he no longer owns the weapons. Defense attorney Irven Box said he took the weapons and other personal property from Ersland as payment of part of the attorney fees in the case.

The report comes from the Oklahoman, which offers little clue as to why Box was reluctant to tell the judge how many guns he received in lieu of payment.  Dave reads between the lines and concludes that the reason is that the murder weapon was amongst them.

This advice is generalizable. Take cash over credit, and credit over barter.  And never, ever, take the instruments of the crime.


I don’t see that as being the problem.  Rather, since the defense isn’t that Ersland didn’t kill the individual, but rather did so in self-defense as his store was being robbed, the gun is likely locked safely away in the evidence vault and isn’t in issue in any event.  More likely, the number of weapons that Ersland kept would relate to the depth of his interest in maintaining deadly force, and the suggestion that having so many weapons, he was inclined to use them at the first possible opportunity.  Motive for over exuberance in the use of a gun to stop a robbery. 

Normally, the amount of the fee paid a lawyer is not privileged, a ruling that I fundamentally disagree with but the court never asked me what I thought about it.  So if the fee is paid in weapons, it would seem that the number (not to mention type, value and other details) would be subject to the court’s inquiry. 

Irven Box was asked how many weapons he received, and told Judge Bass-LeSure to go fly a kite.  The basis for his refusal was the defendant’s privilege against self-incrimination:


District Attorney David Prater also said prosecutors could use the answer to that question against Ersland at trial.
This is a prime example of a good time to keep one’s mouth shut.  Had Prater just stood there twiddling his thumbs, Box’s position may well have found no legal justification.  But with the addition of the prosecutor’s acknowledgment that he planned to take this otherwise innocuous bit of information and use it against the defendant, suddenly Box has the force of the 5th Amendment behind him, and is not merely justified in his refusal to disclose information that would be used against his client, but stands tall as a defender of righteousness.  A very well armed defender, I might add.

The judge was not pleased.


The judge at one point said she would put Ersland back in jail if he didn’t answer her question but eventually she decided not to revoke his bail. She said she had learned a lesson and will not in the future let a defense attorney collect a defendant’s weapons.
While the revocation of bail based upon the assertion of a constitutional right raises other problems, the judge’s threat amounted to nothing and, in the finest of legal traditions, falls under the heading of “no harm, no foul.”   On the other hand, what business it is to the judge how the lawyer gets paid remains a mystery.  Whether it’s a cache of guns or two chickens, it’s not her call and her approval isn’t needed.

As for Dave Hoffman’s admonition to prefer cash over credit, credit over barter, that’s a bit facile when your family’s next meal is paid for via a check bearing the name George Washington Law School.  It’s not that criminal defense lawyers necessarily desire barter over cash, but that’s just the way it happens sometimes when we try to accommodate our clients. 

Barr Is Right, But So Very Wrong

Bob Barr, the man who shut the doors to the courthouse on defendants for whom the system failed, says nobody understood him.  From his New York Times op-ed in which Barr, no enemy of the death penalty, argues to spare the life of Troy Davis.



This threat of injustice has come about because the lower courts have misread the Anti-Terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996, a law I helped write when I was in Congress. As a member of the House Judiciary Committee in the 1990s, I wanted to stop the unfounded and abusive delays in capital cases that tend to undermine our criminal justice system.

With the effective death penalty act, Congress limited the number of habeas corpus petitions that a defendant could file, and set a time after which those petitions could no longer be filed. But nothing in the statute should have left the courts with the impression that they were barred from hearing claims of actual innocence like Troy Davis’s.
Nothing?  Try everything.  Try that’s precisely what your beloved law does when an convicted man who claims actual innocence comes late to the party or gets smacked by the court on the first go-round and has to try for a second bite of the apple to show his innocence.  That’s what your law says and does, Bob.   Didn’t you read it?

But now that a man whose guilt is in serious doubt is about to be put to death, you’ve suddenly discovered that your law, so manly and firm in its end of “the unfounded and abusive delays” in court proceedings designed to make sure that only the guilty, the unquestionably guilty, the absolutely positively guilty, are executed.  A bit disingenuous in light of the fact that your law left out any mention of allowing defendants who are “actually innocent” from coming back when his evidence or counsel improves. 

The problem with Bob Barr’s epiphany is that I don’t, for a moment, believe that he would have done anything different in supporting his beloved law had someone argued that it would result in the execution of innocent people.  There would be no sympathy, but hot rhetoric about abuse of the system by filthy murderers who feign innocence when we all know that they are guilty as sin.  He would have shrugged it off as a casualty of war at worst.  He would have pulled the switch on Troy Davis himself.

Using post hoc belief of innocence to cover the law’s inflexibility, and claim it was never intended to work that way, is palliative nonsense.  Barr can claim to be the good guy, supporting Troy Davis, when he was the same congressman responsible for Davis’ plight.  Now he blames the courts for following his law?  It’s not that the courts shouldn’t be capable of finding a viable way around this misbegotten law, but that of all people in the country to have no standing to complain, Bob Barr is at the head of the line.

The message behind Barr’s conversion to sanity is that these are the views of the very people who are entrusted with crafting the procedures that seek to deny justice, claiming afterward that it wasn’t their intention.  Well, wasn’t it your job to make sure the law you passed reflected your intention?  Your newfound claim that your law is a monument to cavalier and clueless legislating hardly provides us with faith in your ability to serve.

Bob Barr now asks the Supreme Court to take the “activist” position of ignoring his law based on unintended consequences and rewriting it to prevent a single case of injustice, because Barr agrees that the execution of Troy Davis would be terribly wrong.  Sorry Bob, but while you are absolutely correct that Davis should not be executed, he’s just the one who found his way onto your radar.  Your law still shuts the door on thousands of other innocent men and women who might have a chance to find redress but for you.

It’s good that Bob Barr had his epiphany.  Too bad they never seem to get religion while they still have the power to do something about it.  Funny how that works.

From Edwards’ Death, The Hope of Change

The death of P.O. Omar Edwards was a tragedy.  No, not more of a tragedy than the unnecessary death of so many others at the hands of police officers who shot first and asked questions later, but a tragedy nonetheless.  The difference this time is that police feel something in the aftermath of one of their own being killed, where the death of others is an excuse to check the rap sheet first and explain why he deserved it anyway.  They can’t play that game here.

But it looks like the New York Police Department might actually be open to doing something meaningful as a result of this tragedy, something all the marches and protests have been useless in accomplishing.  From the New York Times :


Police officials were already moving on Sunday to change police training and to seek fresh ideas for preventing a repetition of the interracial killings of one officer by another that have claimed the lives of several black officers dating to 1940.

Paul J. Browne, the chief spokesman for the Police Department, said the department was immediately scrapping scheduled police training on courtroom testimony and replacing it with “confrontation training” — encounters like the one between Officer Dunton, who was with two other white officers in an unmarked patrol car, and Officer Edwards, who was in civilian clothes, and had drawn his gun while pursuing a man he had found breaking into his car on an East Harlem street.

Imagine, police brass “scrapping” training on how to make sure cops know how to testify to convict whoever they arrest in favor of training how not to kill someone needlessly.  Mark this date on your calendar. 

According to the article, it appears that the police department, for the first time ever, is seriously re-evaluating its policies and seeking to find a real answer to how to prevent this from happening again. 


“This is the first time I am hearing the department saying, ‘We need help,’ ” [State Senator and former police officer, Eric Adams] said, adding, “I believe the commissioner sees how large this problem is.”
The focus is on how to prevent an off-duty cop, and particularly a black off-duty cop (noting that this doesn’t seem to be nearly as much of a problem with white off-duty cops) from being shot and killed.  No one, at least for now, is considering the problem of killing innocent blacks (or whites, for that matter) who don’t happen to also be cops.  That, apparently, still falls under the collateral damage theory in the war on crime.  Unfortunate but unavoidable.

One might view this from the cynical perspective, but it strikes me as a start.  If they can’t even figure out how not to kill their own, there isn’t a chance in the world that they can figure out how to not kill others.  Changing the police mindset has to start down the path from somewhere.  At least this may present a start.

No one has yet to come up with a solution.  I certainly don’t have one.  But the fact that the people who have the power to change things are, for the first time, recognizing that a problem exists and seriously seeking a better way is promising.  Maybe, just maybe, once they figure out how not to kill black cops, they can figure out how not to kill other people.  Maybe.

A Wartime Consigliere

Of all the movies ever made, none offers as many  rules to live by as Mario Puzo’s 1972 epic,  The Godfather.  None even comes close.  If you don’t understand why this is so, then you should stop reading immediately and go to another blawg, like Feminist Law Professors or perhaps some blog dedicated to work-life balance.

Dan Hull at What About Clients? gets it.  In his ode to Rees Morrison at Law Department Management Blog, Dan makes the point that every lawyer, even a General Counsel, needs to be both philosopher and warrior.  When you’re in a fight, running scared is not an option. 



It’s just a business fact, especially in changing industries. And especially now. General Counsel at corporations do make a difference. She should be broad-gauged, intellectual, take-charge, organized, preventive, resourceful–and war-like at heart. Hates war as expensive–but likes and even revels in a fight. Tells management what to do–and not a tentative, qualified “what you can do”.


At his well-regarded Law Department Management, Rees Morrison, by far one of the smarter, sager and more experienced lawyer-consultants out there, just asked “Does a General Counsel Make All That Much Difference?” Our two cents is in the WAC? post title above. The right GC? Get thee a philosopher-warrior. Be safe and feel safe, friends.
The superficial reaction of the Tom Hagen’s is that everything doesn’t have to be a battle; sometimes appeasement is the better route.  This is true, but misses the lesson of the Godfather.  A warrior knows how to make peace.  A scared bunny will never know how to win a war.  Worse still, a scared bunny will do everything in his power to avoid a war, even when it’s fundamentally contrary to reason and interest.  The scared bunny will do this because he can do nothing else.
11_500.jpg
This is a particular problem in the defense of white collar criminal prosecutions, where the very hint of government interest makes civil lawyers start to shake.  The in-house guys, particularly adept at proof-reading contracts and offering vague opinions on legal matters to non-lawyers when there is no one in the room to disagree with them, collapse into a bowl of jello when the threat of investigation or prosecution looms.  They are over their head, and they know it.  They want the scrutiny to go away, to return to the warmth and comfort of their world without threat.  Their heads spin, trying to figure out a way to make the powerful leave them alone, to please the prosecutors and agents who are about to bring their legal world down around them.

This is why they need a wartime consigliere.  The best strategy isn’t born of fear.  The best outcome isn’t derived from running scared and hiding from the potential of battle.  Clear thinking and a firm hand in the face of threat is critical at this very instant, and most lawyers aren’t prepared to handle the pressure.  They collapse just when they are needed most.

Aversion to the unpleasantness of confrontation is a perfectly understandable reaction.  It’s far more comfortable to make peace than war, for the warrior as well as the philosopher.  But when the strategy is dictated by the lawyer’s inability to fight the war, to face up to the hard task of recognizing that a lasting peace can only come from the ability to wage a successful war, then the war is lost before it has begun. 

Much of the time, two reactions arise from the threat of corporate or white collar investigation or prosecution:  Denial and appeasement.  Whether it’s “we did nothing wrong,” or its corollary, “everyone does it,” the executive approach is to maintain one’s dignity by refusing to acknowledge that they are facing a potentially catastrophic problem.  This is frequently where the war is lost, when choices are made that later spell disaster for the defense against the attack.

The second reaction, appeasement, is the equivalent of surrender.  Whether driven by the weak strategy of “no one can win” so we must surrender, or the “we’re the good guys” so we must cooperate, it’s really the path of least resistance, the one favored by the Tom Hagens.  It may be the right course to take in some instances, but when it’s dictated by legal advice driven by fear and paralysis, then it’s just like going into battle unarmed.  You were doomed to lose before you began.

Every lawyer is not a wartime consigliere.  Most aren’t cut out for the heat of battle, the ability to stare down an enemy more powerful than you and be fully able to engage him if needed.  But without a wartime consigliere, you are guaranteed to lose the war.  Only from a position of strength, based on clear thought, fearlessness and the capacity to fight if needed, can one obtain the best results from white collar or corporate prosecutions. 

If the threat of war is looming, make sure you are the wartime consigliere.  If you’re Tom Hagen, at least recognize it and align yourself with someone who can fight for you.  Think of The Godfather.

Age Versus Crime

Via Skelly at Arbitrary and Capricious, a 14 year old boy named Trevor Reizenstein will be tried as an adult for the sexual assault and beating of a 5 year old girl in 2007.  A horrible crime for sure, but even if we assume Reizenstein to be guilty, he was 12 years old at the time it happened.


Reizenstein’s case was in limbo since November 2008, when Canyon County sheriff’s deputies transfered the boy from the juvenile facility to the adult jail after receiving a signed court order to do so.

His attorney moved to have him tried as a juvenile, which kept the case on hold until the Idaho Supreme Court ultimately held 4-1 that he should be tried as an adult.  Thus far, a now-14 year old boy has spent two years detained awaiting trial.  The Idaho Press article contains this inexplicable paragraph:


According to Idaho law, if a juvenile age 14 or older commits a serious crime, his or her juvenile status is automatically waived. However, Reizenstein was 12 years old at the time the girl was attacked.

This provocative assertion required further investigation, as the article provided no further explanation.  But an article from USA Today following the Idaho Supreme Court’s decision raised more questions than answers:


The high court ruled 4-1 that Trevor Reizenstein should be tried as adult for attempted murder, battery and forcible penetration with a foreign object.

A psychologist and a juvenile probation department committee both said the boy would be best served in the juvenile court system, based on his immaturity and lack of competency to stand trial as an adult.

But in its 20-page ruling, the high court found the youth would likely need treatment long after he would be released if convicted under the juvenile court system, and that he was sophisticated and street-smart for his age.

To the extent this explanation of the decision makes sense, the court ignored the court appointed psychologist and probation in favor of its own projection of the boy’s future treatment needs? 


In his appeal, Sullivan pointed out the findings of Dr. Craig Beaver, a psychologist appointed by the lower court to evaluate Reizenstein. Beaver found the boy had an IQ of 75, five points above the threshold for mild mental retardation, and that he had behavior disorders. Beaver also found that the boy was significantly immature, had a significant drug and alcohol history for a child his age and showed signs of depression, according to the court ruling.

Beaver ultimately recommended that Reizenstein’s case be handled in juvenile court, and a committee of 10 juvenile correction officials made the same recommendation after determining that the state’s juvenile detention system had services available to help Reizenstein and that it could meet his needs while protecting the community.

Certainly, the objective evidence appears overwhelmingly in favor of Reizenstein being treated as the child he is.  But none of this explains what became of Idaho law that only at age 14 may the court determine that his alleged conduct warrants adult treatment.  The articles discussion of the Supreme Court’s decision stated:


The Supreme Court — which referred to Reizenstein as “John Doe” throughout its ruling — said that even though the boy was young, had below-average intelligence and was behind other students his age at school, he was still a street-wise minor who had a sophistication exceeding his chronological age.

What was the basis for this conclusion.  This anecdote:


“After working on competency at NCH for over four months, Doe became angry during a group session and announced that he could have passed the competency test at any time, but felt he was being railroaded. He then took the test and passed with a 96 percent,” Justice Jim Jones wrote for the majority. “According to the court, this sequence of events indicated a disturbing ‘level of deceit and sophistication.”‘

Reizenstein’s penchant for engaging in adult behaviors — such as using drugs and alcohol and fending for himself at home — also were evidence of an increased maturity level, the court said.
Of course, Reizenstein’s penchant might have had something to do with the fact that he and his siblings were horribly neglected by their parents.


Beaver also said Reizenstein had little family support, with parents who condoned his use of alcohol, tobacco and marijuana and a mother — who was on probation for possession of methamphetamine — who frequently left him and his sisters home alone, without food, for days.

In fact, the Idaho Supreme Court noted in its ruling, several child protection cases alleging neglect and abuse had been filed against Reizenstein’s parents since his birth.
The determination that a 12 year old, borderline retarded boy, neglected by his parents and left to abuse drugs and alcohol, should be treated as an adult is, standing alone, a travesty.  It is not to diminish the seriousness of the harm done to a 5 year old girl, but no matter how horrible the crime, it doesn’t alter the fact that Trevor Reizenstein is a child as well.  Except perhaps in Idaho?

What is more shocking is the lame rationalization provided by the Supreme Court in support of its throwing Reizenstein to the wolves of the adult legal system.  Despite every safeguard supposedly in place to protect children from the law, the Court chose to ignore the findings of the psychologist and probation officials and rely instead on one of the weakest, most absurdly cobbled together bases, imaginable. 

The message here is clear.  The crime was horrific and this “bad” kid was going to be sacrificed to pay for it.  So what if every legitimate factor militates against it, he’s going to pay.

For those of us who reject the notion that children should be treated as adults to satisfy the blood lust of public opinion, Trevor Reizenstein should not be tried as an adult under any circumstances.  But for the Idaho Supreme Court to so facially flaunt its bias, and to conclude, in the face of all objective evidence to the contrary, that this boy be treated like a man reduces the law to a sham. 

It was a horrible crime.  What happened to this 5 year old girl is awful, and should never happen.  But that doesn’t turn a 12 year old boy into an adult.  Nor does the terrible nature of the crime make him guilty.  Now he’s just another child lost to the system.

Suck Face

Adrian Dayton explains the Slackoisie aversion to being forced to show up for work.  Adrian has become the rational voice of his generation. He’s still wrong, of course, but he gets a “B” for his efforts.  He could bring that up to an “A” if he makes sure his quotes are accurate.



Face time. It’s really just about control, isn’t it? Even if there isn’t work to be done, the boss demands that you be there, sitting at your desk, watching the minutes of your life tick away. The boss is paying you, and therefore believes he deserves you until late. How late? Late enough to prove your commitment to the company. Work Saturdays? You bet, at least half a day. Note to employers: this rubs Generation Y the wrong way.
The source of Adrian’s confusion is a definitional problem.  He sees the act of physically appearing at one’s place of work as a voluntary matter, subject to the employee’s agreement that a physical appearance is worthy and necessary.  What he calls “face time” is what others might call fulfilling the expectations of the guy who signs your paycheck.  The Slackoisie believe that they are entitled to “mail it in” when they don’t deem an appearance worthy.


I think that is the disconnect. Generation Y wants their life to mean something. They want to handle work that is significant, and they certainly don’t want to crank out the billable hours reviewing non-urgent documents on a Saturday afternoon just to line the pockets of the otherwise wealthy partners.

 The attitude in years past to this sort of brazen attitude by young lawyers would have been, “tough sh**, deal with it.” Bosses, you should realize you could get away with that in the past, but I am going to let you in on a little secret.


WE AREN’T AFRAID OF YOU ANYMORE



Brazen indeed, but in defiance of the basic premise of law firm economics.  Contrary to Adrian’s understanding, law firms do not exist to provide jobs for young lawyers.  They exist to provide legal services to clients.  They hire associates in order to perform some of the work needed to provide these services, subject to the overview and approval of the partners of the firm.  In the course of billing out the services of the employees, the partners seek to recover not just the salaries paid to these fine young men and women, but the fixed and variable costs associated with the provision of services.

Then comes the “line the pockets of the otherwise wealthy partners” issue.  The wealthy partners are the owners of the law firm.  Owners are, in a capitalist society, entitled to make money off their business.  How much money is none of the employees business.  The owners do not need their employees approval to become wealthy.  It’s just not part of the deal.

If the partners do not earn a premium on their associates time, so that they “line the[ir] pockets,” then there is little purpose to taking on the additional work that clients bring to the firm.  Law firms are not charities for their clients.  Did you think otherwise?  The partners take on new work for the purpose of increasing the profitability of the firm for the benefit of the owners of the firm.  The owners, you may recall Adrian, are the partners, not the associates. 

So each associate, if a firm is properly managed, should be a profit center for the partners.  If an associate is not a profit center, then there is no reason to employ him.  After all, it’s not nearly as much fun managing whiny, questioning, demanding, complaining associates as you think.  They are tolerated because they bring additional profit to the firm.  Not because they are good looking.  Well, for the most part, anyway.  There are exceptions, though this is probably very wrong.

As for fear, which you emphasize through the use of all-caps and bold face type, I’m not sure what you mean.  Slavery is no longer permitted in the United States.  No one, even the wealthiest partner at a law firm, can force you to do something you don’t want to do.  You have nothing to be afraid of.  Of course, you can always be fired, as you have no right to a job or paycheck if you refuse to follow the directions of your employer. 


We can start our own firm, build our own company, or go work for someone that knows how to motivate us. We are the largest demographic since the boomers, and you raised us to fear nothing, and for that we thank you. Learn to live with us, or learn to live without us- either way, once you are long gone or retired, we will run this country.
It’s not quite that simple.  If you think hanging out a shingle is all it takes to make people throw money at you while enjoying life on your own terms, most of you are in for a shock.  It takes more, not less, time and effort to run a successful law practice.  There’s no guarantee that clients will flock to you, no matter how hard you puff yourselves on your website or blog or how many SEO words find their way into your every post.

Worse still, even if you get a client, your then stuck with actually having to represent that client.  Oh My God!  What do I do now!

When your client calls you in the middle of the night, will you tell them to go away?  When your client demands to see you at the very moment you planned to have dinner with your girlfriend, will you tell him to get lost?  When there is a do-or-die court appearance in the morning and you have just completed a night of serious partying with your BFFs, will you show up?

We can all understand how much more pleasant life would be if we could just work in our pajamas and bathrobe from home whenever spare time allowed.  It’s not that we don’t get it.  But when we took the responsibility of representing our clients, plus feeding our beautiful children who demand to eat day after day, we realized that we cannot have everything the way we want.  It’s time for the Slackoisie to come to that realization as well.  We’re sorry that it’s not turning out to be nearly as convenient as you hoped, but that’s the best we can do.

With A Side of Spam

Over the past two weeks, I’ve deleted literally hundreds of spam comments here.  This is in addition to the ones I normally delete, from those who want to use the comments here as their soapbox or to expose their own blogs or posts to a different audience.  There are some very tenacious people posting comments that they hope will see the light of day, one particular commenter who was responsible for nearly 300 spam comments in the past week.

It’s not going to happen.  As much of a waste of my time as it may be, I will not allow the comments section to become your billboard, no matter how nice your comments may be (they are usually along the lines of, “great post . . .”) or how devious your challenge (“I will consider being a regular reader if you respect my point of view”). 

Amongst my many peculiarities is that I have not shown much concern over whether any particular reader loves or hates what I write here.  Nor have I cared a whit whether a reader shares my sensibilities on a particular issue; I’ve been as quick to delete a rant against the death penalty as one that ultimately proposes the efficacy of a drug to correct penile dysfunction.  I realize that commenters often find my rules hard to understand, seeing their comments are both informative and interesting when I see them as tangential and self-promotional.  The rule is:  My blog, my rules.  They aren’t subject to democratic approval.  I know this because I control the delete button and you don’t.

Deleting a few hundred purely spam comments is not merely a pain in the butt, but a waste of time.  Having a blawg isn’t nearly as glamorous as many think.  It requires that I keep an eye on things, as they can spin out of control quite quickly at times, particularly when a post draws a bunch of day-trippers who are unfamiliar with SJ, my rules, my prickly ways, my snarkiness and the limits of my tolerance.  Most of these comments I allow, even though I find them unbearably assumptive, a typical trait of many younger readers.  It’s a fault of the Slackoisie, the characterization they deny vehemently, who mistakenly project their shallowness and egocentricity on me because, well, that’s what the Slackoisie do.

I recently saw a comment about me on another blawg that struck me as interesting.  The comment, clearly by a new lawyer, said that I was a “decent” blawger, except when I went on an off topic rant.  I would be fine, the commenter said, if I stuck to criminal law.  This falls into the pigeonhole of readers who believe that my purpose here is to please them and provide posts that suit their interests.  Readers of this ilk can bite me.  Simple Justice is about whatever I decide it’s about, and until you pay for the privilege, you get no say in what that might be.  I’m not courting your approval, and you can stop reading at any time.

On Twitter, I am now at about 500 followers.  Some are young women with webcams showing them engaged in sex acts.  Why they follow me is unclear.  I doubt they are interested in much of anything I say or write about.  I have no plans to watch their webcams.  I also have many followers who are “consultants”, all of whom are “available for speaking engagements.”  They may or may not be interested in something I write about, but I am unlikely to consult with them, and I have no speaking engagements for them at all. 

One young lawyer wanted to engage me in a twittering discussion of my posts here.  I suggested he post his thoughts in a comment, as I won’t discuss my posts in twits, to which he took offense.  He complained that I was telling him what not to twit, and that nobody, but nobody, told him what not to twit.  I was telling him that I wasn’t going to engage in a twittering discussion.  He can twit whatever he wants.  I’ll just ignore it.  And I do.  It’s really easy to ignore people on Twitter.

There are lists of “must-read” blogs and “must-follow” twitterers.  I don’t think I’ve made either.  They are mostly put together by those with a marketing-bent, both as a promotional tool and a means of capturing attention.  Blawgers and twitterers have a obsessive thing about lists which eludes me.  When they make a “top 10” list put out by the Chopped Liver Association of America, they will promote themselves shamelessly for having been so honored. 

The more I think about it, the more I understand why I’ve been deluged with spam comment lately.  They aren’t necessarily different in kind from much of the flotsam and jetsam that finds its way onto the blogosphere or twittersphere, but merely more unabashed about it.  Being an unapologetic capitalist, I can appreciate the tenacity of someone who would make 300 tries to post a commercial comment on Simple Justice.  In fact, I can better appreciate that than the kids who argue that they truly deserve to have the world revolve around them.  I may rethink my definition of spam.

A “Wise Latina” Herring

Most of believe that our life experiences run the gamut, enabling and entitling us to believe that we understand the full spectrum of experiences.  We are, of course, delusional.

Our experiences are ours.  Not being a “wise Latina,” the experiences of a wise Latina would not be mine.  Nor the experiences of a black man.  Not even an Italian man.  But I do have the experiences of a Jewish man.  The problem is that my experience as a Jewish man is likely to be different than Joel Rosenberg’s, also a Jewish man, but far better armed.

The latest blawg rage is discussion of a statement by Sonia Sotomayor, which made the New York Times’ editorial page today.


The talking point conservatives pushed hardest last week — to the alarm finally of some Republican senators — was a 2001 speech in which Judge Sotomayor said she hoped a “wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn’t lived that life.”

The context matters: she was pointing out that throughout history even esteemed white male justices like Oliver Wendell Holmes voted to uphold race and sex discrimination. She said accidents of birth inform people’s views, but judges must strive to look beyond them.

The Times pointed out similar expressions by Justices Alito and Thomas in their confirmation hearings.  This makes two points that are very important, and should take the wind out of the both sides of the discussion.  Each brings experiences that others, who don’t share their ethnicity, race or color, won’t have in their bag of tricks. 

None of these Supreme Court Justices or nominee, on the other hand, is the exclusive source of experience for their ethnicity, race or color.  None speaks for all Italians, all blacks or all wise Latinas.  Even more to the point, none reflects the median experience of their identified groups.  If you were hoping that a black judge, any black judge, would sit on the court to be the root source, the go-to guy, for black issues, you are likely disappointed by Justice Thomas.  He is not the poster boy. 

Sonia Sotomayor went to Princeton and Yale Law School.  Not the norm for Latinas, I’m afraid.  She was a prosecutor.  Also not the norm.  She never succumbs to life on the street in the Bronx.  Not the norm.  The mere fact that she is Hispanic from the Bronx will confuse many who believe that she must, by virtue of her experience, understand what life is like for Hispanics from the Bronx.  I suggest that anyone who thinks that she brings that perspective to the table will be as disappointed in Sotomayor as others are in Thomas.  These individuals are the exceptions. 

If you want someone who understands the experience of a Hispanic in the Bronx, I would be a better choice than Sonia Sotomayor.  Not because my life experience is that of a “wise Latina,” which it obviously is not, but because I’ve spent the past quarter century with Hispanics from the Bronx and gotten to know some quite well.  I’ve listened to them tell me what life is like for them, how they are treated by the cops, what they think and believe, for better or worse.  I may not always agree with their view of life, but I can appreciate why they do certain things based upon their life experiences.  I can say with certainty that the life experiences of many of the Hispanics I’ve known will not be shared by Judge Sotomayor. 

We want to believe that merely by being a Latina from the Bronx that she gets it.  Lord knows the Supremes, particularly after the decisions in Montejo and Ventris, could use someone who has a clue how things really happen outside of the marble hallways.  But to assume that one’s race and ethnicity are enough to assume an understanding and shared range of experience would be a mistake.  Judge Sotomayor was an SDNY and 2d Circuit judge.  That’s not the typical experience of Hispanics from the Bronx.  And to anyone who has spent much time in that courthouse, the vision of Judge Sotomayor strolling the Grand Concourse in search of amigas and cervesas, no less diablita, is ludicrous.  That’s not her experience.

I know that I suggested that there isn’t really much to discuss about Judge Sotomayor’s nomination, so I apologize for doing so anyway.  But this is less about Judge Sotomayor than it is about those who are busily ruminating on the subject of her nomination, both for and against, writing furiously about every detail of her life that comes up from one side or the other.  This discussion is all in the abstract, replete with assumptions being made by people for whom the real Judge Sonia Sotomayor isn’t part of their life experience.  That doesn’t seem to stop them.  It doesn’t even slow them down.

The other day in court, a friend of mine whose practice is primarily before the 2d Circuit told me how hard he’s been laughing about all the Sotomayor commentary.  He’s also been crying, because he knows that Judge Sotomayor is not even close to being the liberal judge we keep hearing about from those who oppose her.  The irony, he notes, is that if they had a clue what they were talking about, the conservatives should be applauding the nomination and rushing it through before the liberals figured out how off-target their assumptions are.  When it comes to criminal cases, personal freedom and civil rights, Judge Sotomayor is not exactly empathetic. 

Indeed, if one really wanted to understand why such a stink is being made of Ricci v. DeStefano, one need only look at who represented the plaintiff in the case to realize that it was a wacky radical neo-conservative loud-mouthed lawyer with deep connections in the uber-conservative movement who has a personal grudge against her and has no doubt planned for the past year to rally the fellow-travelers against her nomination.  It’s not like it hasn’t been expected.  Aside from that, the per curiam circuit ruling was your basic deference decision, which would hardly be worth a second look.

If you are amongst those who are hoping for someone on the Supreme Court to reflect the experience of a wise Latina, or deathly afraid of it, don’t be too sure that Judge Sonia Sotomayor is the one to watch.  Maybe if she was characterized as the “wise Latina” who was raised in the Bronx and then went to Princeton and Yale Law School, then became a prosecutor, and later sat on the SDNY bench until elevated to the 2d Circuit, people would have a better idea of who they were talking about.  But even that doesn’t properly cover it.