Author Archives: SHG

Win An SJ Excellence in Criminal Defense Award Today!

When it comes to offering opportunities to show the world that you, a criminal defense lawyer extraordinaire, are a pre-eminent defender in your city, county or state, the criminal defense bar lags far behind other practice areas, particularly the personal injury field.  Hard to believe but true.

As Eric Turkewitz found out, a few shekels buys a PI lawyer a huge return in client self-promotion, the sort of thing that makes a client with a catastrophic injury chose pick one over the vast array of available talent out there.  How to distinguish yourself this way?


I’ve received the letter a few times, beseeching me to join the “Million Dollar Advocates Forum.” Oh boy! That looks mighty impressive. So I investigated to find out what, exactly, it is.

And now I’m here to report: It’s a great way to make money for the guy that thought it up. And little more. You pay him $1,200 and he gives you a certificate (gold embossed and suitable for framing!) and the right to use one of those groovy logos that you see to the right on your website. It is to me, short and simple, a marketing program.

The Forum is a “prestigious” group that is “limited” to those that have “won” million dollar settlements or verdicts. If you Google Million Dollar Advocates Forum you will find no shortage of lawyers boasting of this faux honor. But if a lawyer already lists such results on a website, why pay this guy $1,200 in cold, hard cash for this piece of marketing?

If you ask me, the logo is rather cheesy looking, and the name, while suggesting Big Money, just wouldn’t translate well for criminal defense lawyers, since it sounds like the Million Dollars refers to the legal fee, a potentially off-putting idea.  But for a mere $1,200 smackers, they get a great piece of paper to put on the Ego Wall and impress the living crap out of potential clients, plus a logo to use on a website, as well as something really big to crow about, that will draw in the injured and maimed like flies to sugar.  Why should PI lawyers get all the really good marketing tricks and criminal defense lawyers be left to fend for themselves.

Therefore, I have decided to institute something special for criminal defense lawyers: 


The Simple Justice Excellence in Criminal Defense Award
Here’s the deal.  The “winners”, and since it’s based on purely objective, fixed criteria, must satisfy my extremely high standards, will receive a huge certificate to hang on the wall, something like the old Supreme Court admissions certificates before the cut them down in size and changed the image to the front of the Supreme Court building.  You know, when it used to look really impressive.  It will have old English style writing, like the New York Times banner, and a big gold-colored seal with ribbons hanging off.  The ribbons will be bright red and blue, so that you can’t miss them.  This impressive certificate, guaranteed to impress even the most hardened of criminal, will be the centerpiece of your marketing strategy, and will more than pay for itself.*

In the upper center, there will be a logo, something like the Monaco Coat of Arms that appears really regal and important, that includes a motto like “Champion of Justice.”  It will also include something in Latin, because no one can understand what it says but people are blown away with lawyers who appear to know and use Latin, which reflects your intelligence and education and shows that you know more than they do.  The same logo will be available for use on your website and the Award can be included when you claim your Avvo profile, raising your Avvo rating to 10, the best there is!
http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Image:Coat-of-arms-of-Monaco.svg
All “nominees” will have to pass my personal scrutiny to determine whether you meet my exacting criteria for this prestigious award.  You can nominate yourself or someone else, but all nominations must be accompanied with a check (good, not rubber) to cover my nominal processing costs of $2,400.  That’s right, only $2,400, twice what it costs to join the PI lawyer one, because we’re criminal defense lawyers and with this prestigious award, clients are going to be throwing money at you to defend them!  We’re twice as good and should pay twice as much.  Let’s rub it in their little PI faces that we can win Awards for a mere $2,400!

And the best part is that this Award comes with the name Simple Justice, the most trusted name in criminal defense, recognized worldwide as the gold standard for excellence, integrity and zealous representation. 

Don’t delay.  There will only be a grand total of only 5,000 awards available per year, so don’t miss out on this opportunity to show your clients and potential clients that they are fortunate indeed to have the opportunity to be represented by an SJ Excellence in Criminal Defense Award winner.

You paid for it.  You deserve it.  Operators are standing by. 

*Allow 6-12 months for deliver.

A Story for Young Prosecutors

Criminal defense lawyers can whisper, speak, shout about the flaws of a system that can convict the innocent, but you won’t care.  You believe in what you are doing.  You trust the experienced police officer who looks you straight in the eye and tells you he knows, knows, that the defendant is guilty.  You hear the victim, who has most certainly suffered pain and anguish, beg you to make the person pay for what he did to her.  She studied his face.  She knows who did it.  She would certainly never lie about it.  She will never forget that face.

James A. Fry was an assistant in the Dallas County District Attorney’s office.  He prosecuted Charles Chatman for aggravated rape in 1981.  Even if I don’t have the authority to tell you this story, he does.


I was certain I had the right man. His case was one of my first important felony cases as a Dallas County assistant district attorney. Chatman was convicted in a court of law by a jury of his peers. They, like me, were convinced of his guilt.


Nearly 27 years later, DNA proved me – and the criminal justice system – wrong. Chatman was freed from prison in January after DNA testing proved him innocent. He spent nearly three decades behind bars for a crime he did not commit – a stark reminder that our justice system is not immune from error. No reasonable person can question this simple truth.

So many of the elements that have long been sacred in the prosecution of a human being appear in Fry’s story.  The belief.  The evidence.  The certainty.  The win.  The satisfaction that comes from justice being done.  It took 27 years before it all fell apart. 


Chatman’s story is tragically not unique. The staggering number of exonerations attest to just how easily the innocent can be convicted. Nationally, 225 people have been released from prison after DNA testing proved their innocence. Seventeen of them had been sentenced to death. Twenty DNA exonerations were from Dallas County alone, the most of any U.S. jurisdiction. The vast majority of those exonerated in Dallas County would still be in prison but for the fact Dallas preserved its DNA evidence.

How many cases involve the Dr. Watson’s baby, DNA?  Very few.  Very few indeed.  Yet the elements that comprised a good conviction in 1981 remain the very elements that comprise a good conviction today.  But there won’t be any DNA to sort out decades later.  The conviction will be immutable.  It will be forever.  You won’t have a story to tell 27 years later about how, despite the absolute certainty that the outcome was just, you were wrong.  You can sleep well at night knowing that no miracle of science will ever prove that you convicted an innocent man.  But that doesn’t mean that it didn’t happen.

James Fry has no regrets about being a prosecutor. Indeed, we need prosecutors.  There is crime.  There are bad people.  There are victims whose lives and bodies are horribly hurt by crime.  But within this need is also a need for concern that two wrongs don’t happen:  The wrong done the victim and the wrong done the second victim, the innocent person convicted.



I am no bleeding heart. I have been a Republican for over 30 years. I started my career as a supporter of removing violent people from society for as long as possible, and I still believe that to be appropriate.

But I also believe that the government should be held to the strictest burden before it deprives a citizen of his freedom. It is not too much to ask that we not convict and execute innocent people in our quest to enforce the law. Let’s get this system fixed. 
It’s axiomatic to say the system isn’t perfect.  For some, the mere incantation of these words relieves all sense of responsibility for the flaws of the system.  But we are the system.  The system is people, prosecutors, defense lawyers, cops, judges, each of whom has a role to play.  Each of us has a role to play in doing everything we can to make sure that a crime doesn’t have a second victim. 

Don’t be so smug.  Don’t be so certain that you know everything.  Don’t be so absolute that you can’t harbor doubt.  You aren’t that good.  None of us are that good.

Don’t believe me?  That’s fine.  Then believe James A. Fry.  He’s been there.  Read Fry’s story in the Dallas Morning News and ask yourself, are you so much smarter than Fry that you could never be wrong?

Chicago: Get a Life, Give a Life

Next week, Total Attorneys is throwing a conference in Chicago.  It’s not for criminal lawyers, or IP lawyers, or family lawyers, though all lawyers of these and other stripes are invited.  It’s for lawyers who want to “run their practice without running themselves into the ground.”  Who doesn’t?  It’s the Get A Life Conference.

I remember as a young lawyer whose days were spent in court, using my evenings to meet clients, return phone calls, read mail, write motions and briefs, discuss cases and generally suck up time that might otherwise have been spent with my young family. 

Contrary to popular belief, I didn’t hang out in the office because it was way more fun than being home.  I wanted to enjoy time with my wife and children.  I wanted to relax.  I wanted a happy and fulfilling life.  Who doesn’t?

The focus of the Get A Life Conference is to teach lawyers how to achieve Work-Life Balance.


In this two-day conference you’ll learn how to manage all the moving parts of a successful law practice while still maintaining a life. Learn from some of the foremost experts on the subject.
No, I wasn’t asked to speak at this conference.  In fact, I’m probably one of the last people the participants want to hear from.  I’ve been somewhat vocal about my thoughts on work-life balance.  The notion is that one can have a profitable, successful law practice without sacrificing your personal life. 

At the moment, according to Total Attorneys honcho Kevin Chern, there are 110 lawyers who have paid good money to learn the secret.  The number isn’t huge, but then when one considers the nature of the conference, it’s really quite amazing that 110 lawyers have chosen to spend their time and money going to this conference.  After all, if they have two free days, and cash to burn, why not take a short trip to the Bahamas instead?  Work-life balance and all.

The gist of the conference is marketing, judging from the agenda and speakers.  I’m also not a big fan of overemphasis on lawyer marketing, a silver bullet that too many lawyers view as the lazy way to achieve success rather than through effort and skill.  But some of the speakers are people I respect, such as Kevin O’Keefe and Larry Bodine, who view marketing as an adjunct to quality rather than a substitute.  Others, like Alexis Martin Neeley, not so much, claiming that after she created her own million dollar practice three years out of school, she threw it away because of a calling from God to help other lawyers.  For a hefty fee.  I’ve asked her why she did this and she told me it was her gift.  Right.

There are apparently many lawyers, mostly young, whose professional focus is the attainment of wealth while enjoying a high quality of life.  So much so that they will pay money to find out how to achieve these ends.  And then there are many lawyers who have turned away from the law to create businesses whose purpose is to help these lawyers to do so.  Come next week, they will be in Chicago.

There are 36 people who will not be attending a conference, the purpose of which is to Get A Life.  Granted, they aren’t lawyers.  They will never have the chance to be lawyers.  These 36 people are school aged children who have been murdered so far this school year.  About one a week.  In Chicago.

The juxtaposition of these two occurrences serves to make me wonder why people become lawyers these days.  The cynical public perception is that lawyers are in it just for the money.  These cynical people are wrong, according to the Work-Life Balance crowd.  They’re in it for the money and the good life.  Having carefully parsed the agenda of the Get A Life Conference, I see no workshops on how to use our education, skills, clout for the benefit of anyone else.  Not clients.  Not school age children in Chicago.

I don’t think that the attendees have no feelings toward the 36 school age children who were murdered in Chicago this year.  I bet they feel awful for them, about the lives of innocents lost.  What sort of unfeeling animal wouldn’t care?  Just not enough to put aside their personal desire to make a lot of money and spend as little time doing so as possible.  The latter is important enough for 110 lawyers to take two days, travel to Chicago, pay the conference fee and listen to salespeople.  The former merits a “tsk” over morning coffee.

There are 36 families in Chicago at this moment who would like to get a life.  Back.  There are 110 lawyers coming to Chicago for something that matters a great deal to them.  It’s a shame the two share nothing in common.

Retribution and the Goldilocks Syndrome

Former defense lawyer turned prosecutor Ken Lammers, of  CrimLaw fame, has proven yet again his vast computer skills by the creation of a colorful graphic designed to make the point that Sherry Colb’s post on the “holier than thou” effect, raised by the New York Times, is misdirected.  In its place, Ken offers the “there but for the grace of God” process.  Since everybody else was giving their thoughts cool names, I’ve decided to do it too.

Ken describes Colb’s views on the “holier than thou” effect:

Basically, it is the inability of people see themselves as a person who would fail in situations where they were tempted – through chance, fate, or desperation – to break the societal compact as embodied in the law.

Ms. Colb goes further identifying 4 purposes to criminal law: retribution, deterrence, incapacitating offenders, and rehabilitation. She identifies retribution as the primary focus of the American system based upon the lack of rehabilitation programs in prisons in combination with rapes and gangs. Then she concludes that locking someone away in this situation, away from law-abiding citizens is a bad thing, so that shorter sentences are most likely preferable.
The initial description, that people fail to see themselves as criminals, seems merely a variation on Hart’s moral condemnation theory, explaining the existence of criminal law to address those whom society feels are bad people and in deserving of punishment.  The problem with this definition, of course, is that our criminal laws extend well beyond acts that most people, if independently asked, would believe to reflect a moral failing.  Some of our malum prohibitum laws are a real stretch from evil-doing, but people still chose to believe that only those deserving of moral condemnation end up in prison. 

As for Colb’s “identifying 4 purposes,” these have long been recognized as the bases for the imposition of sentence, both statutorily, by caselaw as well as theory, and are the universally accepted and acknowledged legitimate rationales for the imposition of sentence.  Not sure if Ken really takes issue with them, but by attributing them to Colb as if the invented them, he suggests that there’s something controversial about them.  If so, I haven’t a clue what the problem might be.

And finally, Ken gets to the heart of his problem, that Colb concludes that retribution results in sentences that are counterproductive to the other purposes of sentencing and is societally detrimental.  Here’s where Ken’s graphic comes into play.



Ken explains:


This article struck me as wrong in many ways, but I’m just going to concentrate on one here: Ms. Colb badly overestimates the effect of “holier than thou” on the system. Our system is far more dominated by the “there but for the Grace of God” thought process.

Here’s a graphic of how I’ve observed the punishment of offenders in the time I’ve been practicing.

While Ken’s chart is crafted from his personal experience, I really have little issue with the curve.  It’s the same as my experience, without any overly slavish reliance on the specific numbers.  It captures the point. 


Why is there such a severe downslope? Because the greatest number of offenses are treated with mercy. People just don’t get thrown in jail for reckless driving, DUI, writing a bad check, or most misdemeanors the first time they are convicted (without aggravating circumstances). There’s a good chance they won’t go to jail for a second or even third misdemeanor conviction, particularly if they are different types (driving suspended, bad check, assault and battery). Furthermore, there’s a whole slew of felonies wherein the first conviction will only get an offender probation.

Next come the convictions which should lead to incarceration, but do not because they are somehow diverted. Sometimes this is just having a case continued to be dismissed if there are no problems for a year. In other cases there are drug courts, shoplifting classes, anger management programs, and/or community service given in lieu of incarceration.
I think Ken may be ignoring some salient aspects in his equation.  First, that there are invariably going to be a far greater number of petty offenses than what we consider to be the more serious ones deserving of moral condemnation, such as murder, rape and robbery.  I doubt that anyone, regardless of what chair one is seated in, believes that there should be only one penalty for all offenses, regardless of seriousness.  Thus, the fact that there are a far greater number of offenders receiving lesser punishments doesn’t reflect society’s “there but for the grace of God go I” attitude, but merely a proportionate scale of moral culpability.  A jaywalker simply doesn’t deserve the death penalty under any theory of punishment.

Second, Ken’s approach assumes that every criminal offense inherently reflects a societal determination that the conduct itself is evil, as if there was no distinction between malum prohibitum and malum in se.  This ignores the fact that our legislative bodies have disconnected the concept of moral wrong from the criminal law, enacting laws that criminalize conduct that carry no inherent moral fault.  The condemnation stems from the mere fact that it is a criminal offense to do, or not do, a particular act because a legislature has so decided, not because the act itself is inherently wrong. 

There’s no reason why we drive on the right side of the road rather than the left per se, and it only constitutes recklessness because a choice was made to keep us to the right so that we don’t crash into each other if every person was left to his own personal choice.  The problem is exacerbated 10,000 fold when we consider the plethora of technical regulatory violations that are designed to keep us to the right even though, in and of themselves, they are merely choices to smooth out the societal compact.

Rather, I think Ken’s issue with Sherry Colb is the “Goldilocks Syndrome” (see, I told you I had a cute name for my own theory).  Ken’s take is colored by where he now sits, at the table closest to the jury.  Where I see jailing or imprisonment used too frequently in the name of retribution, Ken sees it as under-utilized.  Too much, too little, just right.  It’s different for each of us.

The reason for our difference seems quite plain.  Retribution, unlike the other sentencing considerations, is a purely subjective measure.  How much suffering should be imposed for certain criminal conduct?  Should jaywalkers get the death penalty?  Should murderers get life in prison?  The spectrum ranges from a stern talking-to all the way to the executioner’s chamber.  Where along that spectrum should a particular act fall in order to satisfy the lust to impose some degree of suffering on the wrongdoer?

This isn’t a fair subject for argument.  We each see the degree of appropriate restitution differently, and certainly those of us disconnected from the specific offense see it differently from those who suffered as the victim of the offense.  Most of the time, victims feel that the perpetrator of their suffering have gotten away “too easy,” meaning they haven’t suffered nearly enough for the suffering they’ve imposed.  This is why sentences are supposed to be imposed by a detached person, whose vision isn’t colored by the pain of the victims, and why the “victims rights” movement is misguided.  On the other hand, what basis would a detached sentencer use to determine the appropriate degree of retribution to be imposed?  It’s retribution.  It’s supposed to cause suffering.

Which brings us back to Sherry Colb’s point.  If our purpose in imposing suffering on criminals is retribution, then the question of whether a sentence is too harsh, too lenient or just right is wholly personal and arbitrary.  There is simply no right or wrong answer as we each weigh the degree of moral condemnation differently.  But if the purpose of sentencing is to reduce crime and take wrongdoers and convert them into productive, law-abiding citizens, then retribution is counterproductive to the goal.

For those who think that we are too soft on crime because we say, “there but for the grace of God go I,” I wonder what amount of suffering would satisfy your visceral desire.  How do you propose that society arrive at the “right” amount of suffering?  What cost, in terms of turning out productive, law-abiding citizens, are you prepared to accept to indulge in the imposition of suffering for its own sake?

Most people would insist that some degree of retribution is needed as part of a criminal sentence, provided of course they don’t look too closely at some of the stuff they call criminal these days, but few consider why retribution seems to quiet our soul.  Since it comes at a relatively steep price, we really need to consider the trade-off between our moral outrage and what we expect to get out of prison at the end of the sentence.  We pay for it either way.

Love Science, Hate Science

As the collection of DNA samples by law enforcement and courts expands exponentially in order to create a database that can be used to identify those who commit crimes, these same advocates fight hard to prevent access to DNA from the past that might undo their “hard won” convictions.  This seemingly irreconcilable stance belies the constant tension between the prosecution and the defense, and the emptiness of the claim that we only want to convict the guilty. 

The New York Times provides a survey of cases where prosecutors are fighting to keep defendants from obtaining DNA tests to prove their innocence.  Why?  Why would prosecutors, whose professed ethical responsibility is not to convict but to do justice, argue against the use of the very test that they so desire, so enjoy, when it suits their purposes?



Mr. Reed has been seeking a DNA test for three years, saying it will prove his innocence. But prosecutors have refused, saying he was identified by witnesses, making his identification by DNA unnecessary.

In Illinois, prosecutors have opposed a DNA test for Johnnie Lee Savory, convicted of committing a double murder when he was 14, on the grounds that a jury was convinced of his guilt without DNA and that the 175 convicts already exonerated by DNA were “statistically insignificant.”

And in Tennessee, prosecutors withdrew their consent to DNA testing for Rudolph Powers, convicted of a 1980 rape, because the victim had an unidentified consensual sex partner shortly before the attack.
These reactions, when stripped of their rhetorical elements, are clear:  We won and we’re not giving up the conviction without a fight.  Bearing in mind that DNA evidence applies in a minute fraction of cases, meaning that the statistical significance of wrongful convictions, often as a result of mistaken identifications, is proportionately larger when one considers that it should happen with the same frequency in cases where there is no DNA to be tested, one would think that the prosecutors could show a little more grace in letting the convicted have a chance to test the DNA.  But no, all the nice talk about the government’s ethical responsibilities go flying out the window when they’ve got a conviction to protect. 

On the one hand, it’s fair to assume they believe they have the right guy in prison, so are acting with a good faith belief that they aren’t imprisoning an innocent person.  On the other hand, if their belief holds water, then what’s the harm of letting the test proceed?  If the defendant is guilty, why should they fear a test that could conclusively prove it?  If nothing else, it has the stink of a disingenuous position.  Why is this miracle of science wonderful when used by the prosecution, but unfair when used by the defendant?

While it would be easy to harp on the prosecutor’s duty, distinct from the defense in that it is supposed to seek justice, whether that be the conviction or acquittal of the defendant.  The prosecutor should no more want to see an innocent person convicted than the defense.  So, the truth comes out in this Times’ article that there are prosecutors out there whose interest in protecting their convictions exceeds their ethical duties.  What a shock. 

The excuses offered are silly, easily undermined by basic arguments, facts and the science itself.  There is no good reason to refuse a convicted prisoner access to DNA testing.  Even the slippery slope, that if they let one prisoner do it, every prisoner will want to if for no better reason than to take a shot in the dark.  After all, they can’t do worse than they already have.  But this doesn’t pan out either, both because there are so few DNA cases to begin with, and because it involves DNA testing on old cases, since new cases are having it done already as a matter of routine.  Assuming the worst, it’s just not much of a burden. 

And so we get down to the bottom line of the issue squarely framed in the Times’ article, yet wholly ignored.  Who cares what the prosecutors have to say.  Why aren’t judges ordering these DNA tests? 

Somehow, these stories forget that there is a person in the room who gets paid to make decisions about disputed issues.  Even if prosecutors are busily defending their convictions, they can only do so if judges are busily facilitating them.  A judge need only utter the word “granted” when a defendant seeks a test to put the issue to rest (at least absent appeal). 

When one reads that a defendant has been waiting for years to get a test, or that a prosecutor is not agreeable, does anyone question what the judge is doing about this?  How did this escape the Times’ attention?

While one can easily point the finger at the adversary and complain that he’s not as kind-hearted as we would want, we need to get beyond this expectation that every prosecutor in the criminal justice system is going perform his function admirably and remember, there’s a reason we have judges.  I’m not excusing prosecutors for their failure to honor their ethical duties; I’m challenging judges to fill the breach.  That’s why you get to wear the cool robes.

The Academy’s Guardians of Free Speech

Intellectual freedom is a fundamental hallmark of education.  Just ask any tenured teacher, asked to justify why she can’t be fired for incompetence.  But when it comes to the American Association of Law Schools, freedom is just another word for women first and foremost, judging from the ideological capture of the Section on Defamation and Privacy.


Chair:  Professor Danielle Keats Citron, University of Maryland

Chair-Elect:  Ann Bartow, University of South Carolina

Any names ring a bell?  Why yes, that would be Cyber Civil Rights advocate Danielle Citron, who argues for the elimination of free speech online in the name of converting online bullying into a women’s rights issue.  And right behind her is Ann Bartow, ringleader of Feminist Law Professors, whose personal brand of “take no prisoners” feminism tolerates no dissent, and has cowed most pedagogues into silence for fear of public excoriation.  I’m not suggesting that they aren’t entitled to their views, but can’t imagine how the rest of the lawprofs allowed such extremists to seize control.

As if to make the point, when Paul Horwitz at PrawfsBlawg posted about his “uneasy feeling” with the stifling of dissent to Danielle Citron’s theories during the Cyber Civil Rights Symposium at Concurring Opinions, a robust discussion followed.  The post was written on April 16th and the discussion continued through April 20th.  Everyone took a deep breath and went back to their corners.

On April 28th, more than a week after the last comment, up shows Danielle Citron, who produced a lengthy, though vapid and entirely self-serving, rationalization of her position, ending with this gem:


I hesitated speaking to this issue as I fear cyber harassment, which I have clearly experienced personally and indeed as Dave notes has included menacing threats of physical harm (which we at CoOp removed).

Thus, we at CoOp feared that this would happen–harassing reputation harming assertions against women in the comments–and it did.


How wonderfully circular her self-serving assertion of victimization.  The problem with questioning, challenging, disagreeing or disputing Citron’s position is that the act of doing so constitutes harassment against women, since harassment has an ever-floating definition of anything that makes Citron feel bad and she is (“clearly”, as she uses to emphasize her secret personal experiences) a woman.  We are awaiting a protest from the Harassment Against People Want to Stop My Free Speech In Favor of Their Free Speech contingent (club in formation).  After Citron left this comment on the 28th, comments were closed.  End of story.

Some might see my chiding the views espoused by Citron and Bartow as harassment.  No doubt many lawprofs will, since I hesitate to use the sweet endearments of the Academy designed to soften the blow of disagreement by obfuscating the message (oops, there I did it again).  But to the extent that the AALS hopes to maintain integrity and carry any suasive force, having people take over a section when their facial agenda is the subjugation of speech to their gender politics smacks of absurdity.  Should their views be expressed and debated:  Absolutely.  Should the AALS lead the charge for the elimination of free speech whenever somebody’s feelings are hurt?  I don’t think so.  If the person whose feelings are hurt is a woman, does that change everything into women’s rights issue?  Not even close. 

Much as I hate to correct a leading feminist, women are people too.  Stuff that happens to the rest of us can happen to women.  That doesn’t change the fact that it happens into a civil rights issue.

What made this perversion of intellectual integrity more ironic was Anne Reed’s latest post at Deliberations about why mean women are so fascinating, based on the New York Times article about bullies in the workplace:



It’s probably no surprise that most of [workplace] bullies are men, as a survey by the Workplace Bullying Institute, an advocacy group, makes clear. But a good 40 percent of bullies are women. And at least the male bullies take an egalitarian approach, mowing down men and women pretty much in equal measure. The women appear to prefer their own kind, choosing other women as targets more than 70 percent of the time.

NO! NO! NO!  Heresy!  Burn her at the stake!  You see, the feminine mystique depends upon men being evil and women being sisters, cowering in fear of the evil men harassing and attacking them by their unwanted gaze.  If women are subject to no greater negative attention from men than persons of the other gender, and are in fact subject to attack by their own far in excess, the whole paradigm falls to crap.  Let’s have the feminists explain that one.  Actually, they can, since there are good women and evil women.  Guess which ones are the good women?

That there are many in the Academy who share the views of Citron (and even a couple who agree with Bartow, though more feign agreement just to avoid being the target of her venom) is absolutely fine.  Everyone is entitled to be wrong.  But that the Academy has elected chairs for whom free speech is a value just one step below herpes calls into question any intellectual authority the AALS might have to either lead the discussion, or in fact participate as the representative of law schools.  It has traded its mission, “as the learned society for law teachers and is legal education’s principal representative to the federal government and to other national higher education organizations and learned societies,” to pander to strident extremists. 

Glad I’m not a lawprof so I can write these things.  I’m sure that my horrible words, coming from a lowly trench lawyer like me, will mean little to the intellectually superior pedagogues who vouchsafe the legal education of our youth, who no doubt will honor, protect and defend the sensibilities of our delicate flowers now that Citron and Bartow are in charge.

Tortured In Buffalo

No, torture is not intended as a commentary on merely being in Buffalo, though some might disagree with me.  But Ryan Smith, who was tasered by a coterie of cops who put their very best thoughts together and decided a good tasering was the brilliant method of obtaining compliance with a court order for another DNA sample after the first was lost, was looking at torture straight in the eye, according to his lawyer, Patrick Balkin. 

From the Buffalo News :


Friday, wrapping up a hearing on the Taser case, Balkin repeatedly called the use of the stun gun “torture.”

He said testimony from four of the five police officers at the scene established that Smith was handcuffed and sitting on the floor when the Taser was used.

“No defendant has ever been brought before a court for contempt in the United States where a judge ordered them Tasered to comply,” Balkin said. “We have 100 years of [collective] police experience with these officers and this is the best they can do, to Taser a handcuffed client?”

Balkin quoted Detective James Galie as saying, “Ryan, we’re going to do this again and again until you comply.”


While there was no testimony to this effect, the general understanding in Buffalo is that waterboarding is unacceptable because the water would freeze before filling anyone’s lungs.  This, unfortunately, limits the options.

Of course, the prosecution, by ADA Susan B. Bjornholm, wasn’t without its arguments in support of the decision by police to use a little “persuasion”:

“The people believe the evidence in this case was legally obtained,” Bjornholm said. “[Smith’s] DNA was found at the scene of a horrific crime where a person was shot and children were duct-taped.”

And yet, they do conduct the occasional trial in Buffalo to determine whether people are guilty or not, circular reasoning notwithstanding.

But the better argument came to me via our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen, who informs that she learned from Balkin the prosecution’s best argument in the hearing:

We  use electricity in the courtroom all the time.

You can’t make this stuff up, though one has to wonder how this line didn’t make it into the Buffalo News article.  I’m shocked Bjornholm didn’t invoke the memory of Old Sparky.  Ah, if chairs could talk.  But I digress.

What cannot be explained is the prosecution’s inexcusable failure to raise the really strong arguments in favor of using a taser as “the great persuader,” given that corrections officers in Florida are happy totase their own children just for fun, when “43 children were directly and indirectly shocked by electric stun guns during simultaneous Take Your Sons and Daughters to Work Day events at three Florida state prisons last month.”  Aside from the weather, is Tallahassee really all that different from Buffalo?  I mean, 50,000 volts is still 50,000 volts, right? 

Following the lengthy hearing, the court reserved decision.

Niagara County Judge Sara Sheldon Sperrazza on Friday gave herself two weeks to decide whether to allow prosecutors to use a DNA sample taken from a Niagara Falls man after he was zapped with a Taser electronic stun gun.

“I’m not certain until I do all the research which way the decision is going to go,” Sperrazza said from the bench.

But the prosecution is taking no chances.


It filed a request asking for another DNA sample from Smith, which defense attorney Patrick M. Balkin said was probably a fail-safe in case he wins his motion to throw out the sample taken after the Sept. 29 Taser incident at Niagara Falls Police Headquarters.

I can’t wait to find out what they come up with next time to persuade Smith to cooperate.  After all, we’re now going into the temperate season in Buffalo, and water will again readily flow.

The Simpleton’s Guide to Liars

When television executives decide to put a show on the air like Lie to Me*, you can bet that they believe that people will be fascinated by the concept.  The possibility that it may cause the next generation CSI-Effect isn’t their concern, nor should it be.  They are in the business of entertaining us and selling advertising.  Enlightenment, if any, is purely collateral.

But the general fascination with lying, or more particularly how to tell if someone is lying, has been with us forever.  Lying, a pervasive human trait proven necessary for the propagation of the human race, covers a broad spectrum of human conduct, much of it quite acceptable and even salutary.  Then, of course, there are the nasty ones that happen when someone, oh say a cop, wants to put someone, oh say a defendant, in prison.  In fairness, it happens the other way around too, lest we forget.

Forbes Magazine has entered the fray with a story about how to tell if someone is lying.  Melanie Lindner’s article, replete with equivocation in almost every paragraph, sums up a set of 11 rules to “sniff out a liar.”  According to the piece:



“Although there are some ways in which liars behave differently from truth-tellers, there are no perfectly reliable cues to deception,” admits DePaulo, author of more than a dozen deception studies. “Cues to deception differ according to factors such as the type of lie and the motivation for getting away with it.”

While there is no surefire on-the-spot way to sniff out dissemblers, there are some helpful tactics for uncovering untruths.
Thus, with the caveat that nothing said is reliable, Lindner nonetheless provides answers.



  1. Liars often give short or one-word responses to questions, while truth tellers are more likely to flesh out their answers.
  2. Skilled liars don’t break a sweat, but the rest of us get a little fidgety. Four possible giveaways: shifty eyes, higher vocal pitch, perspiration and heavier breathing.
  3. Liars are often reluctant to admit ordinary storytelling mistakes. When honest people tell stories, they may realize partway through that they left out some details and would unselfconsciously backtrack to fill in holes.
  4. To psychologically distance themselves from a lie, people often pepper their tales with second- and third-person pronouns like “you,” “we” and “they.”
  5. Liars are also more likely to ask that questions be repeated and begin responses with phrases like, “to tell you the truth,” and “to be perfectly honest.”
  6. When telling the truth, people often make hand gestures to the rhythm of their speech. Hands emphasize points or phrases–a natural and compelling technique when they actually believe the points they’re making.
  7. Truthful people more likely to face her questioners head on. Liars, on the other hand, are”likely to lack frontal alignment and will often sit with both their arms and legs crossed as if frozen,”
  8. Liars are more likely to ask that questions be repeated.
  9. Liars–amateur ones, anyway–may not have thought through all the particulars of their stories.
  10. When a person is lying, the gaps between their words often increase,
Yes, I know the list doesn’t add up to 11, but neither did hers so don’t blame me. 

Aside from the obvious, the point of Lindner’s caveat that none of these “rules” necessarily means someone is lying, what is striking about it is its reflection of witnesses at trial, particularly given how lawyers typically prepare and instruct witnesses to testify.  For those who are shocked that lawyers prepare witnesses to testify, grow up.  Only an idiot would put a normal human being on the witness stand, perhaps the most peculiar seat in the world, without preparing them. 

This doesn’t mean we tell them what to say, but rather how to comport themselves, deal with the pressure of having at least two dozen eyeballs on them, address the situation and deal with the typical issues that arise.  There’s nothing nefarious about it.  If you think this is disingenuous, consider that police must go through a course at the Academy on testifying in their training, far more extensive and structured than anything a lawyer could provide.  That’s why the cops are so much better at it.

Amongst Lindner’s “liar rules” are numerous specifics that we, lawyers, instruct our clients and witness in anticipation of testimony.  We tell them to listen to the question and answer it in the fewest possible words, particularly “yes” or “no” if possible.  We tell them to ask to have the question repeated if they aren’t clear.  He tell them not to add in collateral details, but simple answer the question as directly and clearly as possible.

Sitting on the witness stand is an enormous pressure cooker, with normal people pushed to their stress limit.  Put an unpracticed witness on the stand and the fear that some facile questioning will take an honest person and turn him into a lying scuzzball permeates his thinking.  Added to the mix are the consequences of the word, each and every one potentially resulting in conviction if poorly chosen or imprecise.  Minds race to figure out why a question is being asked, and what pitfalls any particular answer will bring.  Doubt rages as to whether anyone will accept the truth, particularly when someone earlier told a perfectly reasonable story in a calm, cool manner, that was utterly false. 

When it comes to the witness stand, all Lindner’s rules go out the window.  In fact, the very opposite may be true, where these very same rules reflect the truthful witness rather than the liar, given the shift in situation and the nature of the humans under stress.  Yet here we have another publication instructing people how to tell if someone is lying.  This is a problem.

What’s peculiar is the extent to which Lindner seeks to clarify her “rules” by the numerous caveats that they are hardly conclusive or reliable.  Why give “rules”, and why call them “rules”, if they are unreliable?  Aside from it making decent enough fodder for an article, the exculpatory caveat does little to clarify, since readers will remember the rules and ignore the boring equivocation.  After all, rules make things simple, and people like simple things like rules to tell if someone is lying.  The only problem, of course, is that the “rules” illuminate nothing and feed the simpleton’s belief that there is some magic to distinguishing truth from lies.

There is, of course, good news and bad news here.  The good news is that few, if any, jurors read Forbes Magazine, the Capitalists Tool.  They are far too busy trying to keep their bonuses to serve on a jury.  The bad news is that they regularly read the New York Post, which informs them that cops are always right and anyone arrested is guilty anyway. 

Who Will Be The Next Enemy?

The Wall Street Journal reports that our new Drug Czar, Gil Kerlikowske, has announced that the War on Drugs is over.  It’s unclear who won, since I haven’t seen any “Mission Accomplished” banner, but there’s still an awful lot of people in prison across the nation.  Of course, it’s not that the government has embraced the sin, but rather eschewed the rhetoric.


“Regardless of how you try to explain to people it’s a ‘war on drugs’ or a ‘war on a product,’ people see a war as a war on them,” he said. “We’re not at war with people in this country.”

The new administration, by its own pronouncements, plans to shift the focus away from viewing drug use as a criminal matter and seeing it as a public health issue, requiring emphasis on treatment rather than imprisonment. 


Prior administrations talked about pushing treatment and reducing demand while continuing to focus primarily on a tough criminal-justice approach.

I’m confused.  Does this mean that the prisons will be opening their door and letting out the hundreds of thousands of Americans serving prison sentences ranging in the decades, opening beds and treatment centers to aid them in their efforts to leave behind their addictive ways?  Does this mean that the people who sold drugs are now to be viewed as niche marketing specialists, enjoying the benefits of a free market capitalist society?  How does one turn around a Titanic that has been moving full steam ahead for more than two generations?  What does one do with the detritus of a failed policy of ever increasing harshness?

The answer, I believe, is that this newfangled view reflects a shift not so much in policy but in rhetoric.  I’ve heard nothing to suggest that the DEA is disbanding, or that Kerlikowske’s post be shifted over to Health and Human Services.  When the United States Sentencing Commission hinted that it was considering equalizing crack with powder cocaine, a position so obviously rational that it enraged law-abiding citizens everywhere, cries of a nation over-run by crack-crazed sex offenders could be heard throughout the nation.  It’s not easy changing such a long-held bogeyman, one so carefully and thoroughly created and embedded in the consciousness of a country that even the suggestion of rationality was universally deemed outrageous.

The War on Drugs, one of the most brilliant and useful government schemes ever crafted, has served our nation well.  It’s given us a some great television commercials, pithy slogans (who can forget “Just Say No?”) and an industry that has fed the children of prison guards in communities otherwise devoid of productive employment opportunities.  The government is changing its advertising campaign.  Nothing more.

There is some hope that our government’s enforcement priorities will change with regard to one drug, marijuana.  Kerlikowske, in particular, sought to shift enforcement focus away while Chief of Police in Seattle.


Mr. Kerlikowske was most recently the police chief in Seattle, a city known for experimenting with drug programs. In 2003, voters there passed an initiative making the enforcement of simple marijuana violations a low priority. The city has long had a needle-exchange program and hosts Hempfest, which draws tens of thousands of hemp and marijuana advocates.

His officers, however, did not buy into the program.


Mr. Kerlikowske said he opposed the city’s 2003 initiative on police priorities. His officers, however, say drug enforcement — especially for pot crimes — took a back seat, according to Sgt. Richard O’Neill, president of the Seattle Police Officers Guild. One result was an open-air drug market in the downtown business district, Mr. O’Neill said.

“The average rank-and-file officer is saying, ‘He can’t control two blocks of Seattle, how is he going to control the nation?’ ” Mr. O’Neill said.
After all these years of making drugs the disease that was destroying America, it’s going to be hard to change attitudes.  The advertising campaign was incredibly successful, and it’s now a fundamental part of our American criminal justice psyche.  Especially if you happen to be a cop.  They have never hated the sin but loved the sinner.  They hate them all, and they’re not about to change.

But this change in focus leaves one terrible question unanswered.  If we are abandoning the rhetoric of the War on Drugs, if not the war itself, who will be the enemy of the next war?  There must be a next war, as Americans need an enemy, someone to blame for all their problems and to resoundingly agree that if we could just rid ourselves of this villain, everything could be made right.

Who will the next war be against?  And will there be a theme song?

Solo, The Last Refuge of Incompetence?

A solo practitioner is no less competent than the cog-lawyer at Biglaw, no matter how much indoctrination is required to make them believe so in order to get them to mesh properly with all the other cogs in their cubicles who perform tasks that a partially alert cocker spaniel would refuse.  No insult to cocker spaniels intended.  Indeed, many solo practitioners exhibit far greater competence in their niche than any Biglawyer could imagine.  Yes, I’ve said it and I damn well mean it.

But then something comes along to undermine the very core of this assertion.  This time, it came from Carolyn Elefant at My Shingle.  As much as I respect and admire Carolyn’s efforts, I believe that this time she’s missed the boat.


A few weeks back, a reader, discouraged after having failed the bar exam yet again, asked whether he should give up on his dream of starting his own practice.  Of the advice that I offered, what resonated most with the reader was my reminder that no matter how many times he passed the bar, once he passed, he’d be a full fledged lawyer, no different from me or any other solo or even the Justices on the Supreme Court.  Moreover, clients would never have to know how long he needed to become a lawyer, only that he was a duly licensed member of the bar.
I must disagree with this, on every level.  It’s not that I believe the bar exam to be such a terrific indicator of competence, but that it’s sufficiently related to law, and sufficiently easy to pass, that more than one failure to pass the bar exam places someone’s worthiness to be entrusted with the life of others in serious question. 

Not everyone should be a lawyer, and it’s not enough that you got into law school and somebody footed the bill, to justify your entitlement to ultimately practice.  Granted, law schools should vet the pool before passing them through, but financial interests and political correctness preclude law schools from doing their jobs.  Not every law school graduate is good enough.

Starting from the perspective that someone who has failed the bar exam multiple times is already suspect, Carolyn’s point that once they do pass, whether by the blind squirrel theory (a variation on the stopped clock paradigm) or by applying a greater level of effort than before, they are indeed Lawyers.  This is bone-chilling.  The other day, I used the last in the medical school class joke to make the point that all lawyers are not the same, and it applies in spades here.  Will our finally-passed-the-bar lawyer possess the level of ability necessary to entrusted with the life of another human being?  Will he exert that level of effort employed to finally pass the bar, or try to squeeze by with the level of effort that brought him failure?  Will the client know which lawyer he is getting?

As an employee of a firm, we can at least take potential comfort in the knowledge that there might be someone supervising the lawyer to make sure he doesn’t destroy someone’s life with incompetence.  I know, there’s no guarantee that this will be the case, but we can hope that someone is watching, for malpractice purposes if nothing else.  But what of the incompetent solo?  Who will keep an eye on this lawyer, every bit the same lawyer as any other lawyer from all outward appearances, to make sure that the trust reposed in him is deserved?

From the perspective of marketing, the point Carolyn makes when noting that no client need ever know of his multiple failures to pass the bar exam, we devolve to the lowest rings of the profession.  In the old days, a lawyer’s practice was driven by his work, with satisfied clients telling others that the lawyer was worthy of their trust.  Not so today.

Today, we have the vast wasteland of the internet to allow the least competent lawyer amongst us to portray himself as the most competent, most effective, most caring lawyer available.  It’s just words, and any fool can claim them.  And if the words escape this particular fool, there are a vast array of people (perpetually available for speaking engagements) who will provide the bestest marketing words for a small fee.  The incompetent lawyer need not even be competent in marketing, as there is no shortage of assistance.

While Carolyn is absolutely accurate in her advice, consider what this means for those who will require the services of a lawyer and into whose hands they place their life, their welfare, their trust.  Not every law school graduate should be a lawyer.  Not every lawyer should be a solo practitioner.  It is an honor to be a lawyer and a solo, and not everyone deserves to be so honored.