Author Archives: SHG

Teach Your Children Well

We are bombarded with images these days, given the ubiquitous cameras on every cellphone and many lamp posts, showing us the many thousands of isolated instances of wrong doing that were easily deniable before.  But few images had as strong an impact as this photograph posted by Radley Balko at The Agitator.



No, these aren’t the newest LAPD SWAT team trainees.  These are the children of the Explorers, an arm of the Boy Scouts of America, from Imperial, California, as profiled in the New York Times.



Many law enforcement officials, particularly those who work for the rapidly growing Border Patrol, part of the Homeland Security Department, have helped shape the program’s focus and see it as preparing the Explorers as potential employees. The Explorer posts are attached to various agencies, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation and local police and fire departments, that sponsor them much the way churches sponsor Boy Scout troops.

I generally reject comparison’s between anything that happens today with the Nazis, because it’s an offensive comparison,it’s facile, hyperbolic, cliché and almost invariably not illuminating in the slightest.  This time, I cannot ignore the comparison.  To do so would be foolish.  Rick Horowitz at Probable Cause drew the same conclusion. It’s inescapable.

Regular readers know of my deep concern for children, probably more so than most of the brethren would like since I probably give greater weight to the safety of children than many others.  But it’s this concern for the welfare of kids that makes my heart break seeing this photograph.  Kids love uniforms.  Kids love weapons.  Kids love belonging to a group that bolsters their self-esteem.  Kids are not prepared to be pawns in geo-political causes.

To allow impressionable children to be indoctrinated into a nationalistic, paramilitary cause scares the hell out of me.  Radley called this “jackbootery”.  The word is too cute by far.  This is how a free society is murdered.

I might make a joke about the sort of merit badge one obtains by the accurate shooting of a wetback, but I can’t muster the will to find humor in this photograph. 

Judging Empathy: Is It Just the Five Percenters?

When President Obama announced that he would seek to appoint a justice to the Supreme Court who had empathy, Orin Kerr at Volokh Conspiracy attempted to figure out what he meant.  Orin used Obama’s words when he voted against John Roberts’ nomination as Chief Justice to frame the issue:


[W]hile adherence to legal precedent and rules of statutory or constitutional construction will dispose of 95 percent of the cases that come before a court, so that both a Scalia and a Ginsburg will arrive at the same place most of the time on those 95 percent of the cases — what matters on the Supreme Court is those 5 percent of cases that are truly difficult. In those cases, adherence to precedent and rules of construction and interpretation will only get you through the 25th mile of the marathon. That last mile can only be determined on the basis of one’s deepest values, one’s core concerns, one’s broader perspectives on how the world works, and the depth and breadth of one’s empathy.

Before Turk reads this quote and places undue emphasis on the marathon analogy, this has nothing to do with running, and is not an endorsement of Eric Turkewitz, not that he wouldn’t be empathetic or a wonderful choice.  This quote formed the basis for Norm Pattis to create the Trench Lawyer Movement, a post that Orin obviously neglected to read before writing his post.  No doubt Kerr regrets that omission now.

Orin accepted the premise that 95% of the cases considered by the Supremes would be easily disposed of as a matter of precedent, with all competent judges readily agreeing in the proper disposition.  The “empathy” factor, therefore, only came into play in the 5% of cases where the law failed to provide an “obvious” answer due to legal ambiguity. (Don’t get stuck on the percentage, as it’s a somewhat arbitrary number only intended to make the point that the percentage of cases in which there is a real dispute is relatively small.)  Orin offered two ways to think of how a justice would deal with that final 5%:


One approach is to see legal ambiguity as cause for judicial weighing. This view sees the role of the judge as narrow. The judge must weigh the best legal arguments on one side and the best legal arguments for the other, and must pick the side that has the better of it, no matter how slight the advantage.

The other approach is to see legal ambiguity as cause for judicial empowerment. This view sees the judge as dutifully following the law when the law is clear. But as soon as there is some ambiguity, and the law is unclear, then the judge is free to decide the case however he wants.

While the latter explanation was phrased in an obviously negative light, and for which Orin had his head ripped off by a couple hundred commenters, it was less intended to be pejorative than to make clear that it provided an opportunity for justices to exercise their “empathetic” views to fill the gap that the law left behind.

Dan Solove at Concurring Opinions took issue with Orin’s characterization of the empathetic judge as being “lawless” or “activist” in that 5% gap,



Ironically, empathy in the first sense would not be replacing law with politics as some critics may charge at least not from Hart’s perspective.  In hard cases, the law is silent.

In the second sense, is empathy more akin to lawlessness?  True, in a Hartian perspective, the judge who finds more cases to be hard will find more cases to be beyond the law.  But if those cases are indeed hard cases, then such a judge isn’t being lawless.  In fact, such a judge is being faithful to the law by not twisting it to fit cases it doesn’t fit.

Sadly, the issue gets perverted by the common critique that judges are being lawless or activist.  The issue is much more complicated, and it involves questions in jurisprudence that haven’t been adequately worked out.

While Dan admirably argues what empathy is not, there is no definition of what empathy is, or should be.

I start my approach from an entirely different stance than Orin or Dan, which should come as little surprise to either.  Initially, I reject Obama’s characterization of cases falling within the 95-5 percent framework.  When a case reaches the Supreme Court, it tends to have been subject to numerous levels of sanitization, meaning that all the ugly humanity has been drained from the statement of facts and the justices are shown a simplistic, cleansed vision of complex human interaction, and then asked to make its decision on a set of facts that never, in reality, existed. 

From my seat, one can either accept the sanitized version of reality or one can look more deeply into the facts as they crawled uphill to  Washington.  One of my constant criticisms of Supreme Court decisions is that they reflect a vision of conduct (and here I’m limiting my thoughts to criminal cases, since that’s obviously my focus) that we, trench lawyers, know isn’t real.  People are described as one dimensional, with singular motivations and characterized as entirely good or evil, honest or lying, worthy or unworthy.  The Supreme Court Justices tend to adopt these characterizations uncritically, and thereby make difficult decisions far easier. 

In my view, the empathetic judge is the one who rejects the simplistic version of a sanitized humanity, and views the human beings behind the briefs as living, breathing people, engaging in conduct that cannot be summed up in one sentence, with complex motivations, and engaging in conduct based on a breadth of influences.  In other words, the empathetic judge rejects the reduction of humanity to a sanitized caricature.  This will really screw things up on the bench, as it would require the justices to delve far deeper into reality than they are ever inclined to go.

When judges stop viewing the cases before them as “pat”, far more cases become “difficult” in the sense that they are no longer the clean, clear issues with the weighing of relative merit having been predigested for them. 

This leads to the next element of empathy, the weighing process.  In almost every Supreme Court decision, the issue before the Court requires a weighing of rights against authority, the government’s power to effectively execute its function.  This is, without question, where the empathy factor is most critical.  The Supreme Court, being both part of a branch of government and being comprised of people whose views have been framed by a lifetime of service within the government, tends to overestimate the value of government effectiveness and underestimate the value of personal freedom and protection.  In other words, the Justices perform their weighing function with the finger already on the government’s side of the scale.

Another criticism I’ve often levied on the Supremes is their lack of connection and understanding of how ordinary people think, feel, act and believe.  Most justices don’t hang out with regular folks often enough to understand, and even less with the downtrodden.  They go to different cocktail parties.  The Justices often dismiss the value of constitutional rights to real people with shocking regularity, and tend to lack an appreciation of the fact that most of us, at our most basic, believe that we have the right to be left alone. 

This lack of appreciation of how ordinary people view their rights is apparent in Justice Scalia’s recent decision in Kansas v. Ventris, where he dismissed as inconsequential a defendant’s right to counsel post arraignment.  This seemed to be a no-brainer; a defendant represented by counsel shouldn’t be questioned by the cops (or their agents).  Yet the decision went the other way.  This is one in a line of cases where the Court begins with the premise that a constitutional violation has, unquestionably, occurred, yet holds that there need be no remedy for suppression would hinder the effectiveness of police.

One can only deem the effectiveness of police more important than providing a remedy for an undisputed violation of the Constitution by a lack of empathy.  This over-appreciation of the need for governmental effectiveness demands justices who fail to understand that ordinary people believe that the proscriptions of the Constitution must mean something, and don’t when they can be admittedly violated at will.  As this weighing process occurs in almost every criminal case before the Supreme Court, then empathy will alter the calculation by taking into account the expectation of the citizenry that our favorable constitutional platitudes will find enforcement by our top court.  The empathetic judge will appreciate that people aren’t swayed or appeased by sophistry that manages to always favor government effectiveness over their constitutional rights.

The final element of empathy addresses another great failing of the Supreme Court, providing meaningful guidance of how we are to act following the rendering of a decision.  A pervasive problem with the Court’s decisions is that, after all is said and done, they have failed to provide any clear direction to the rest of us.  In other words, they decide cases but fail to sufficiently answer the real question so that we know what to do with their decision.

This was recently the case in Gant, but the best recent example is D.C. v. Heller, the blockbuster 2nd Amendment decision that left more questions on the table than it answered.  As the Court knew, absolutely, positively knew, that it opened the door to a bunch of questions that had to be answered in order to provide meaning to its central holding, Justice Scalia’s abject failure to address these questions was an affront to the people. 

An empathetic justice understand that a decision of the Supreme Court is not merely fodder for law review articles, or even blawg posts, but a guidepost for how real lives are judged, and how real people get locked up in prison, or freed on the rare occasion that a case goes the right way.  The empathetic justice comprehends that the Supreme Court does not engage in intellectual exercise, but in determining how ordinary folks are to guide themselves in their everyday conduct.  To do this, the decisions of the Court must answer the questions that real people have, in a way the provides meaning to real people.  The empathetic justice asks whether the Court’s ruling clarifies or muddies the waters for real people, whether for better or worse, the Supreme Court has made itself relevant to society by performing its function as the court of last resort.

Unlike Orin’s view of the empathetic justice flexing her empathetic muscles on the five percent of cases where the decision isn’t obvious, I believe that the empathetic justice will comprehend that many, perhaps most, decisions fail to satisfy the needs of the people for the reasons I’ve outline.  The empathetic judge, therefore, is the judge who considers the Supreme Court’s function in terms of how it applies to, impacts, affects, guides and helps the lives of all those people who believe that there are nine people wearing robes in Washington whose job it is to protect us from the government.   Who care.

And you already know what sort of lawyer I believe best suited to this task.

Only A Matter of Time: Brooklyn Law Cheats Its Way to 61 (Update)

Via the National Law Journal, Brooklyn Law Schools needs a good criminal defense lawyer, because they got nabbed.  While this is no doubt a very serious matter within the Academy, it strikes me as picture perfect.  Law schools have given the high ground to the annual rankings of U.S. News and World Reports.  Their vitality depends on where they fall on the list.  How could seemingly intelligent people willingly give away their souls to a magazine?


U.S. News & World Report said that it is “investigating” Brooklyn Law School’s responses to the magazine’s annual survey used to rank the country’s top law schools, specifically with respect to part-time students.

The magazine said it would look into the matter after some rival law schools noted that Brooklyn Law wasn’t listed in the part-time ranking and questioned whether the school also excluded part-time students in its responses for the overall ranking in an effort to boost its ranking.

Looking beyond the fact that this is Brooklyn, a borough not known for playing by someone else’s set of rules (or phonics), does it come as a shock that a school(s), which claim to hate the rankings yet comply like Pavlovian dogs, isn’t going to put its reputation in the hands of Mort Zuckerman’s minions to decide whether it’s sufficiently worthy of respect?  Think about it.  I still can’t imagine that any law school dean was foolish enough to send back the first questionaire.  Now they live and die on the rankings.

Bear in mind, law schools are reporting to a magazine, not the court, or the church or their mother.  This isn’t perjury; there isn’t a duty to tell USN&WR anything simply because they ask.  No one can force law schools to participate in this goofy charade.  No one can tell students to apply or alumni to contribute or to hire new grads, because a magazine said so.  Yet the law schools dutifully fill out the forms, send them in and eagerly await the results. 

Brooklyn Law School dismisses their “error”.


“For many years, we have engaged U.S. News editors in debate over what we regard as flaws in its rankings methodology,” the school said in a statement. “An important aspect of this debate has been our position that it is inappropriate to consider the numerical credentials (LSAT and GPA) of part-time students on the same basis as full-time students.”

After the school received no response from the magazine to a letter it sent to editors arguing against including part-time students and having heard no announcement that the change was going forward, the school kept up its past practice of excluding part-time students in it responses, the school said. In answering some questions that asked for information based on combined full- and part-time students, the school said its erroneous response providing information for full-time students was “completely inadvertent.”

Wrong answer.  To suggest that it was an “inadvertent” mistake is laughable.  They pore over these forms, crunch the numbers, then crunch them again.  At least within the very small pond of law schools, these numbers are god.  They don’t make “inadvertent” mistakes when it comes to their rankings.  To the extent that Brooklyn had any credibility following its response to the rankings questionaire, it lost it when it proffered this explanation.  Now we know that it cheated.  It would be a “so what” proposition, but for the fact that these rankings were so important, so critical, that it was something worthy of cheating on.

The right answer is so much simpler, so much more honest.  The rankings are crap and we’ve not playing the game anymore. 

What would happen to any law school that chose not to play?  Would it explode?  Disappear off the face of the earth?  Never receive another penny in donations, another application, another job offer to its students?  Come on.  It would, of course, be easiest for all if it started at the top, the law schools who don’t need the USN&WR seal of approval to prove their worth, but I suspect that these are the schools that secretly love the ratings, since they do well and it inures to their benefit.

It’s the law schools down the line, the ones that will never make it into the top 20, who want to pull the plug.  But then, if they creep up a few notches, they send out a press release about how they’re now the ginchiest law school around, hoping to attract another hundred applicants (and their application fees).  You see, as much as they hate the rankings, it’s a self-serving hatred.  They are equally shameless about using them to their own advantage whenever possible.

It’s a testament to the integrity of law schools that they made it this far without a scandal.  If these rankings were about lawyers, people would be gaming the system from day 1.  There isn’t a chance in the world that lawyers would play fair, or even care if they were playing fair.  Getting an advantage wherever possible is sport for lawyers, and there is no shame in trying.  Law schools prefer to believe they are on a higher ethical plane.  For academia, it’s about honor.  At least until the cash flow starts to dry up, at which point it’s about survival on a playing field designed by some magazine editors.

So Brooklyn Law School tried to play the system.  It’s still there, teaching students how to succeed in the game of law.  What is most curious about this scandal isn’t that it happened, but that it was instigated by other law schools jealous of Brooklyn’s position in the rankings.  If Brooklyn Law School is pathetic for having tried to game this silly system, how sad are the ones who ratted Brooklyn out.

Update: In a related matter, Syracuse will only let law students go to the bathroom once during exams to stop cheating.  When asked why, the dean responded, “because we’re not Brooklyn, dammit!”  Only kidding.  From Turley :


The law school told students that “During this exam period, we have received a significant number of reports from (first-year) students alleging academic dishonesty.” Limiting bathroom runs was better and more efficient than cavity searches or catheters.

And besides, cavity searches and catheters are exclusively reserved for the post exam parties.  So where exactly on the USN&WR’s questionaire is the space for “number of times cheating law students are allowed to go to the bathroom?”

Shotguns Aren’t Always the Answer

Gale and Sheila Muhs, of Liberty County, Texas, aren’t a good looking couple.  In fact, they are quite unattractive, even more so in their mug shots.  So it comes as no surprise that they were both easily annoyed and overly protective of the few things that were theirs.  This cost a 7 year old boy his life.  The Muhs’ had a shotgun.

From the Houston Chronicle :


Donald Coffey Jr., his father and friends were on their way back from joy riding near a levee and swimming in the Trinity River around 9 p.m. Thursday when homeowners Gale and Sheila Muhs fired at them with a 12-gauge shotgun, police say.

The men stopped to use the bathroom and got out of the Jeep near the Muhses’ home in the Westlake subdivision south of Dayton when a woman’s voice boomed through the darkness, Nelton said.

In a message peppered with expletives, she said, the voice ordered the group to get their vehicles off the property.

“And then I heard a shot and our windows were blown out,” Nelton said.

Donald Coffey Jr. was shot in the face, and later died.  Sheila Muhs felt entirely justified. 


Meanwhile, Sheila Muhs — whose home is fronted by a sign warning: “Trespassers will be shot. Survivers will be reshot!! Smile I will” — had called 911. Bishop said the woman told a dispatcher: “They’re running over our levee in big-wheel vehicles, and I shot them.” Officials have not released the 911 tape.


Now I’ve been told in the past that I just don’t understand how people think in Texas.  I admit it.  I don’t.  Is it their desperate love of property rights, the same that makes them feel that their Castle Doctrine should entitle them to kill at will anyone who breaches their doublewide?  Is it that they consider life so cheap that it’s barely worth a shrug when they take it, whether from those sentenced to execution or 7 year old children?  My Texas friends are right.  I don’t get it.

The stories don’t quite explain what Donald Coffey was doing on the Muhs’ property.  Was he peeing in the bushes or “big-wheeling” over their levies.  Was he doing harm to the property or simply touching it when the Muhs’ didn’t want anyone touching it.  I can’t tell.  But regardless, was it worth a death sentence?

Texans tell me that they have a fierce love of freedom, one that they are prepared to kill for.  It seems to me that they are prepared to kill for a lot of things, and that each individual Texan feels entitled to decide for himself what he’s entitled to do.  The Muhs thought their right to kill someone was not only so clear that they shot at will, but so funny that they put up a sign to reflect their sense of humor.  In other places, these people would be considered diseased. 

We regularly hear that every infringement on personal freedom finds justification “for the children,” which of course is nonsensical most (though not all) of the time.  It can be said of pretty much anything, and usually is, though the children excuse, aside from being cliché, usually bears little rational connection to the freedom infringed.  This time is different.  We know that because these two unattractive people killed a 7 year old.  Aren’t they proud of themselves for pulling the trigger on their shotgun?  Aren’t they so very Texan?

The machismo reflected in the attitude of those who see life as so cheap may not be quite as macho after this.  It doesn’t take a he-man to shoot a child.  Over an alleged trespass.  No threat of burglary or harm, just a simple trespass.  It seems that a little boy had to pee, not necessarily something one would want to happen on your property, but not quite worthy of a killing.

Are you proud of your son and daughter of Texas?  Does it make you feel righteous to fire a shotgun at a trespasser in the dark?  Can my Texas friends shrug off the death of a 7 year old, under the “he needed killing” theory?  It’s time to reassess just how willing people are to pull the trigger whenever something annoys them.

The Taser/DNA Decision: When Cops Put Their Heads Together

As previously promised, our hinterlands correspondent Kathleen Casey snuck into the Ryan Smith hearing to find out why police chose to taser Smith in order to collect a DNA sample to make up for the one he had previously given but they lost.  I am happy to report that she emerged physically unscathed, although she did suffer something akin to TMJ from stifling laughter in the courtroom.

Unfortunately, ADA Doreen Hoffmann never made it to the witness stand as Patrick Balkin, the defense lawyer, was satisfied that she was neither asked, nor told, that the cops planned to taser the DNA out of his client, and only learned of the details after 50,000 volts was spent.. 

So how did the cops reach the decision to use a taser to persuade the defendant to give up his spit?  From the Buffalo News :



In testimony contrary to what was written in a police report, Detective Lt. William M. Thomson said he was told by Assistant Niagara County District Attorney Doreen M. Hoffmann “we could use the minimum force that was necessary” to compel Ryan S. Smith to submit to a DNA sample while he was being detained by police.


Officers discussed different methods of forcing Smith to give the sample, including prying open his mouth with their hands, but the decided the Taser “would be the safest way,” testified Officer George W. McDonell, who administered the shock.


See, you cynics.  They were just trying to protect Smith.  And you thought it was some nefarious scheme to play with their tasers and teach Smith, who refused to comply for 20 minutes, that it’s not nice to disobey cops. And McDonell was no doubt correct, that a taser is far safer than the standard beating the crap out of the perp with batons (which also happens to leave marks).


During their testimony, McDonell, Sykes and Galie said Smith had refused numerous times to submit to the swab. They said Smith told them that if they wanted the sample they were going to have to shock him with a Taser.

Ding, ding, ding.  Taser!  Say, fellow officers.  Why didn’t we think of that.  And now, he’s requested it.  Right? I mean, he did say that we should shock him with a taser, didn’t he?  That’s like giving permission, right?


McDonell testified he gave Smith a “dry stun” — referring to what police call a “less effective” shock that doesn’t shoot prongs from the Taser into the recipient — to his left shoulder for about 1 to 2 seconds. The normal length of time a person is shocked is five seconds, unless the officer manually stops the equipment, McDonell testified.

After the shock, Smith complied with their request to take a mouth swab, they said.

There nothing like a taser to get someone to voluntarily comply, ya know.


After the sample was taken from Smith, he was charged with criminal contempt, “because of the means that it took to get him to comply,” McDonell said.

After all, they were forced to taser him first, and the officers will suffer the trauma for the rest of their lives.  Someone has to pay for their psychic pain.

Now the refusal of a defendant to comply with a lawful court order would ordinary subject the defendant to criminal contempt, entitling the cops to arrest and jail him until the judge determines what to do about it.  But that would be no fun at all, and this group of cops certainly needed to have some fun after the emotional drain of watching their partner and buddy, Officer Ryan G. Warme, humiliated by the feds when he was nabbed for conspiracy to distribute crack.  Unfortunately, Warme was unavailable to testify at the hearing. 

And besides, Smith asked for it.

On a serious note, the choice of using a taser to subdue Smith to obtain his “compliance” was the product of this groups of fine police officers and detectives putting their heads together and carefully, deliberately and rationally thinking through their options and selecting the one that, in their view, best suited the situation.  This is what comes of giving police officers discretion in how best to protect and serve.

New York Court of Appeals: GPS Requires A Warrant

In a lengthy split decision, the New York Court of Appeals has reversed the denial of suppression where police placed a GPS tracking device called a “Q Ball” on a car in People v. Weaver.  In a 4-3 decision authored by Chief Judge Jonathon Lippman, the Court rejected the argument that GPS tracking was merely an extension of a police officers acknowledged right to observe a vehicle on a public road.


With the addition of new GPS satellites, the technology is rapidly improving so that any person or object,such as a car, may be tracked with uncanny accuracy to virtually any interior or exterior location, at any time and regardless of atmospheric conditions. Constant, relentless tracking of anything is now not merely possible but entirely practicable, indeed much more practicable than the surveillance conducted in Knotts. GPS is not a mere enhancement of human sensory capacity, it facilitates a new technological perception of the world in which the situation of any object may be followed and exhaustively recorded over, in most cases, a practically unlimited period. The potential for a similar capture of information or “seeing” by law enforcement would require, at a minimum, millions of additional police officers and cameras on every street lamp.

While it’s difficult to discern the dividing line, the Court held, under the state Constitution which it reaffirmed to be more protective than the federal Constitution, that technological intrusion into the realm of personal privacy has its limits, no matter how good an analogy can be crafted to argue that it’s just the latest flavor of what police have been allowed to do all along.


It would appear clear to us that the great popularity of GPS technology for its many useful applications, may not be taken simply as a massive, undifferentiated concession of personal privacy to agents of the state. Indeed, contemporary technology projects our private activities into public space as never before. Cell technology has moved presumptively private phone conversation from the enclosure of Katz’s phone booth to the open sidewalk and the car, and the advent of portable computing devices has re-situated transactions of all kinds to relatively public spaces. It is fair to say, and we think consistent with prevalent social views, that this change in venue has not been accompanied by any dramatic diminution in the  socially reasonable expectation that our communications and transactions will remain to a large extent private.

While leaving open the possibility, indeed probability, that there will be exigencies where a GPS device can be used without a warrant, Judge Lippman nonetheless affirms that we haven’t forsaken all rights to privacy by turning on the ignition, and that even in automobiles we retain a reasonable expectation of some privacy.

It is, of course, true that the expectation of privacy has been deemed diminished in a car upon a public thoroughfare. But, it is one thing to suppose that the diminished expectation affords a police officer certain well-circumscribed options for which a warrant is not required and quite another to suppose that when we drive or ride in a vehicle our expectations of privacy are so utterly diminished that we effectively consent to the unsupervised disclosure to law enforcement authorities of all that GPS technology can and will reveal.

The Weaver decision is a hugely significant decision on many levels, ranging from the internal division amongst the judges on the issues of search and seizure, technology, automobile exception, state constitutional breadth and deference to law enforcement.  With Judge Lippman in his new seat at the center of the bench, this decision provides a critical insight into where the Court of Appeals places constitutional rights in general, and how they view use of perpetually more intrusive technology in law enforcement.

The opinion explains its rejection of GPS as just another pair of eyes based upon its degree of intrusiveness into the lives and movement of the individual, which is unlikely to provide much guidance for the next techno-enforcement trick to find its way into the police arsenal.  It does, however, suggest that the Court, by a slim majority, is unprepared to let the scope of constitutional rights be dictated by technological advances rather than the preservation of personal privacy.

Unfortunate though the wiggle room remains for future exceptions may be, the clear message is that the New York Constitution still considers personal privacy, even in an automobile, worthy of protection, and that they will not blindly accept the intrusiveness of new technology to diminish constitutional rights.  A very encouraging decision, and one that every New York criminal defense lawyer should read.

Can You Smell That Smell?

Anyone who has ever done a motion to suppress a dog alert is likely to be well aware of the many variables, not to mention foibles, of drug dogs.  They aren’t nearly as perfect as most people think, subject both to fairly common false positive alerts as well as the indications of their handlers to “alert”, itself a curious choice of descriptions, whenever they want them to get excited.  Yet, when a drug dog alerts, humans with robes throw up their hands and accept it as conclusive.  We so love things that take responsibility for decision-making out of our hands.

But what about the human nose?  There’s no myth attached to the human ability to smell.  Unless, of course, the nose is attached to the face of a police officer.  Then, like the other senses that far surpass those of mortals, it can achieve almost dog-like abilities.  David Tarrell at In the Moment got me thinking about this when he posted about passing “The Smell Test.”


I read a police report the other day in which a search warrant was procured after an investigator allegedly “smelled” raw marijuana when his allergies flared up after he entered a house. Another time, in misdemeanor DUI case, the judge denied the motion to suppress I filed after a cop smelled marijuana while sitting at a stop light and my client cruised through the green light with the window rolled down. When he denied the motion, after I argued the impossibility of such “probable cause,” he commented that I must not have been around pot very much. (How was I supposed to answer that question? Maybe he was just mad at me for asking the cop if he drove, Ace Ventura-style, with his head out the window?)

Having had my share of cases involving an officer’s discovery of marijuana by scent, and having discussed the possibility of this with a variety of people who are far more knowledgeable on the subject than me, two questions arose.  First, stemming from David’s experience, I can’t help but wonder what personal experience the judge possessed for him to suggest that David hadn’t been around pot very much.  If a defendant said something like that, you can bet that it would come in as an admission.

Perhaps the judge was speaking from the experience in the courtroom, where pot comes into evidence at trial.  Of course, by the time of trial, the marijuana is a putrid mass of decaying vegetable matter, emitting a strong, often sickening odor.  Just so I’m clear, this isn’t about the seizure of a joint, but large quantities of growing or fresh-cut marijuana; raw, unburning marijuana.  I suspect that few judges have much experience with the fresh stuff, and confuse the odor of the stuff a year later, having been kept in sealed plastic bags, with the smell of green pot on the stem. 

In almost every instance, there is testimony of a police officer about the strong odor of this fresh marijuana, which invariably leads them to search and discover it, whether it’s in a grow house, car trunk or suitcase.  No matter that it’s perma-sealed in airtight containers.  The odor, as judges apparently believe, escapes nonetheless whenever a police officer comes near.  This has long been a source of amusement  for defense lawyers.  Probably for cops as well.

The second issue is that absence of any good research, or viable expert, to dispel this ridiculous claim that police officers can smell fresh marijuana, while the rest of us cannot.  I’m not sure that this falls into the same category of “furtive movements,” that old saw that can never be disproven and invariably rears its ugly head whenever a cop can offer no other explanation for pistol whipping a perp.  There is objective evidence relating to marijuana, such as the place its found and the manner in which it’s sealed.  Consequently, there should be a way to put police claims to the smell test.

The problem, obviously, is that the people I know who know exactly what odors are emitted by large quantities of fresh marijuana aren’t inclined to offer testimony.  There’s even a question as to whether they would be allowed to testify as experts, though no rational person would question their expertise.  But these experts inform me, each and every time, that the cops are full of it.  There is no possible way their claims could be true.  Not even close.  Yet judges, who have heard them repeated with great frequency, know better.  As did David’s judge, they look down from on high, smile and mutter, “silly lawyer who doesn’t know as much about marijuana as I do.”  Hahaha.  Suppression denied.

It’s bad enough that the law bridges its own logical gap through the facile use of legal fictions.  It;s the factual fictions, the ones that conclude that the earth is flat no matter the truth may be, that drive people nuts.  In the absence of empirical proof that a police officer’s alleged mystical nose cannot smell the scent of fresh marijuana through vacuum sealed packaging, within a sealed container, through glass windows and more than a mile away, we are left with the testimony of a cop that he did so and the “inside knowledge” of a judge that fresh cut marijuana can stink up a courtroom like nobody’s business.

If only there were some aggie profs who would dedicate their professional careers to the empirical study of cannibis sativa.  Or maybe there’s a nose expert out there who can fill the gap.

USLaw.com: A Call to Arms

One of the “victims” of the USLaw.com fiasco is none other than copyright and trademark lawyer, not to mention lawprof, Marc Randazza.  He’s not pleased about it.  And more importantly, he’s prepared to do something about it, having the knowledge, experience and slew of eager law students at the ready.

Gregory Chase, or whatever name he’s using today, has had an opportunity to address his infringement of copyright and trademark across the blawgosphere since this matter first arose.  It appears that he’s hoping to ride it out, that the anger at his flagrant theft of the efforts of others for his own benefit will subside, and he can go on using content as if this unpleasantness never happened. 

Even with the things I’ve said to him, he continues to keep Simple Justice on his website, as if this never happened.  For many others who had no idea that this anonymous thief had included your blawg and was stealing your content, your outrage was palpable.  This doesn’t appear to be going away on its own.  Indeed, Chase put up a post (not that anyone would look for it on a website like his, but he did nonetheless) in which he promised an explanation for his conduct.  As of this writing, nothing further has appeared.

I’ve heard from many blawgers, both in comments and emails, who are outraged by what USLaw.com has done.  Many have sent Chase emails demanding that their blawg be removed from his website and that he stop stealing their content.  But mine remains, and continues to include his screen shot of Simple Justice with his USLaw.com logo superimposed on it.  Even those he’s taken down upon demand should consider that he has fed off their efforts, that the theft will live forever in cyberspace and that he’s likely to put them back up when we turn our attention away from this situation.

It’s time to take a stand, both for this mutt and any other who decides that he’s entitled to start a business based on our efforts. 

Randazza has offered to take this matter pro bono, but as we are all aware, the initial outrage that this has sparked across the blawgosphere needs to translate to a desire to follow through and deal with this once and for all.  It will not merely apply to USLaw.com, the current instance of some geek who thinks his version of life trumps your rights to your content, but consider its impact on future generations of online entrepreneurs who think that they too can take whatever they want.  Do we want to spend the rest of our blawging lives seeing our content stolen in its entirety and working for someone else’s profit?

Randazza has two conditions before plunging into this matter.  First, that it reflect the will and interest of a significant portion of the blawgosphere, meaning that enough blawgers sign aboard to show that the blawgosphere is behind this movement, supports it and is willing to stay with it until completion.  Not every blawger need sign up, but it really must reflect our commitment to protecting our copyright and trademark from infringement at will.  There will be no cost associates with his representation, but there must be a commitment to the concept.

Second, this will be a unified effort, meaning that Randazza isn’t going to waste his time herding the feral cats of the blawgosphere.  We all realize that our opinions, both legal and moral, differ.  Often vehemently.  But this litigation cannot be maintained if it requires accommodation of the thousand differing opinions we often bring to the table.  While each of us may have our own thoughts on what aspect is most disturbing, critical, immoral or illegal, the decision-making must rest with Randazza, who will be doing all the heavy lifting on our behalf.  We will need to leave our personal pet peeves behind and allow Randazza to serve the good of the blawgosphere as he sees fit.

The overarching point is that what happened with USLaw.com should not be allowed to fade into the background as we move on to other issues and concerns.  It was very wrong and remains very wrong, and as long as it continues, it presents a threat to each of us.

So the question posed is, who wants in to an action to put a stop to USLaw.com’s infringement of copyright and trademark?  This is the time to stand up and be heard, or never complain about someone stealing your content again.  Let’s hope that we, lawyers all, show the fortitude to do the right thing about this wrongdoing, and show others that we are prepared to come forward and put a stop to illegal conduct. 

Are you with us?

P.S. Spread the word so that anyone who wants a piece of this knows about it, and that every blawger whose content has been stolen has a chance to do something about it.

Lawyers Are Not Fungible

There’s an old joke about physicians: What do you call the guy who graduated last in his medical school class?  Doctor.  The part of this joke that matters here is that some people view those they hire to do a job as fungible; one as good (or bad) as another, and hence readily exchangeable. 

Some people want a lawyer.  Which lawyer they get doesn’t really matter.  Any one will do.  From the lawyer side, this is only a bad thing when people make a decision who to retain.  Once retained, however, lawyers are more than happy to make themselves interchangeable, so that whoever is available at a given moment can show up to represent a defendant, whether partner or associate, whether they know anything about the case and whether there is a personal relationship between lawyer or client.  The argument is that the client retains the Firm, and gets whoever the Firm sends.  How convenient for the Firm.

Carolyn Elefant, over at Legal Blog Watch, posts about a Maryland decision that addresses this practice, the old lawyer switcheroo.


A criminal defendant can’t be forced to settle for representation by his lawyer’s partner when the lawyer  he hired is unavailable for trial, ruled the Maryland Court of Appeals in Miguel Gonzales v. State of Maryland.  As the Maryland Daily Record summarizes, Gonzales’ attorney F. Spencer Gordon was unavailable on the day of trial, so Marshall Henslee, his partner appeared instead. Gonzales insisted that he was represented by Gordon, not Henslee, so the judge gave Gonzales the option of either going forward with Henslee or representing himself. Gonzales chose to represent himself and lost.

It’s one thing to show up for a “routine” court appearance and find some other suit standing where your lawyer is supposed to be, but trial?  Apparently the trial judge didn’t find this as big a deal as I do.  Or as the defendant did, offering the defendant the absurd choice of using the lawyer whose only virtue was presence or flying solo.  Nice choice.

Fortunately, that Maryland Court of Appeals (which has been issuing some bang up decisions lately) made a radical ruling, that defendants are entitled to the lawyer they retained.  Not the law firm.  Not whoever the lawyer sends on a day when he’s busy defending someone more important.  The lawyer they retained.  Ironically, Gonzalez may have rethought his choice after what happened to him, but his initial reaction remained valid.

Criminal defense, probably more so than any other practice area, is personal.  Your lawyer is a particular person, one in whom you develop and repose a level of trust and confidence that doesn’t transfer easily.  She’s the woman who looks into the defendant’s eyes, holds the defendant’s hand, hears the defendant’s voice break as he described what happened and how it will affect his life.  It doesn’t matter how many lawyers in a firm, or how vast the firm’s resources.  It’s one person standing next to you in court, shielding you from everything the government can do to you.

More to the point, it’s not up to a lawyer to decide that the client will be represented by whoever the lawyer decides.  This is a decision that belongs exclusively to the client.  He has chosen you, and for that you should be appreciative and honor his decision.  While I often hear from defendants that their decision was motivated by the “resources” a large firm can bring to a case, a concept I think is ridiculously misguided but one that persists nonetheless, the choice invariably comes down to the lawyer who will stand next to the defendant.  The defendant must trust that one human being in a pin-striped suit.

This, Carolyn explains, isn’t the Firm’s understanding:


One would think that the defendant’s lawyers would be excited about the decision (though apparently they did not argue the appeal) — but instead, Gordon’s partner Henslee expressed concerns over the court’s ruling. Henslee complained to the Daily Record  that the court’s ruling would force his firm to “reconsider the fairly established practice of having law partners stand in for each other at trial when the primary attorney is unavailable that day.” Gordon also commented, saying that the ruling will compel defense firms to make it clear to their clients that “it’s the firm that represents them” and that any attorney in the practice may handle the case.

I’m unaware of any established practice of having some lawyer  a defendant has never met before showing up for trial?  Is this a Maryland thing?  Being from New York, I can’t say, but I would have a hard time believing it.  Appearing for routine court appearances is understandable.  But trial?  That’s crazy.

Worse still is the focus of these lawyers: It’s all about what’s good for them.  Even “worser” is the notion that they can and should “exculpate” themselves from what is facially a scam by informing clients that they hire the Firm, not a specific attorney.  If any lawyer says that to you, run like the wind.  Away from that lawyer.  You’ve just been told that they will do what’s best for them rather than what’s best for you.

What’s deeply disturbing about this is that the defendant, who has met with a lawyer, decided that he is willing to stake his life on the person whose hand he’s just shaken, would get “played” by a facile and somewhat obtuse disclaimer by the very person who just sold his services based on trust.  Trusting the untrustworthy is hardly what a defendant has in mind, and clearly not a reflection of who lawyers should be.

It doesn’t matter if your lawyer is solo or one of a thousand.  Your lawyer is your lawyer.  When you arrive in court for trial, that’s the lawyer you expect to have standing next to you.  Anyone else is unacceptable. 

The Gunslinger and the Nun

Every once in a while, a criminal defense blawger will post a metacognitive description of their work by analogizing themselves to something other than a criminal defense lawyer.  Today’s flavor is Remy Orozco at Hostis Civitas, and the ice cream parlor across the street is run by Mark Bennett at Defending People.  Remy posts about how to hire a gunslinger, and Bennett responds that Paladin doesn’t charge by the bullet.

We love the gunfighter analogy.  It suits what we do in so many ways.  Plus, it’s incredibly romantic and manly, which is what we wish we were if we hadn’t become lawyers.  It’s not a perfect analogy, but no analogy is ever perfect.  If we tried to use the gladiator analogy, some twerp would argue that we were suits when we fight, though Oscar Wilde would likely riposte that we’re intellectually naked.

As much fun as it might be to join in the sparring, that’s not the purpose of this post.  Rather, my use of these posts is to make an entirely different point:  We’ve been here before, yet when a new reader spies a new post, it’s new to her.  I can’t remember when Bennett first raised his thoughts on the subject of charging for trial insurance in his fee structure in order to avoid the problem of a client feeling compelled to plead guilty because he can’t afford the cost of a trial, but I remember writing about it at the time.  It was a very interesting concept, and a very thoughtful approach.  I didn’t agree with it, but that doesn’t mean it’s wrong.

One of my readers sent me an email with a link to Bennett’s post.  I then read Remy’s post.  And I smiled to myself.  These were horses that I’ve beaten to death so many times already.  Yet I also know that someone will happen upon Simple Justice and never see these posts, never know that I’ve discussed what to look for in a criminal defense lawyer, how fees are structured and what’s right and wrong about varying fee structures.  It happens constantly that a reader will read a post and assume that it reflects the entirety of thought on a broad subject, unaware that there are a multitude of other posts on the subject that address the many nuanced aspects of the issue.

What to do?  It pains me to think that my thoughts are so misinterpreted because the reader hasn’t read every single thing I’ve ever written.  It would likely pain them to do so.  There are times I’ve reminded readers to take a look elsewhere and see that there is more to a topic than just the individual post that brought them here, but I certainly can’t demand that anyone be required to research my every post for others on the same or similar topic.

One alternative is to pull out my best posts, or perhaps my posts on the most basic issues, and repeat them from time to time.  If my purpose in writing was to promote myself, it would likely be in my best interest to do so.  I would look far better if I were to stick with the things that potential clients would be interested in, and fashion my blawg in a way that would highlight what a great guy I am, rather than prattle on about whatever strikes my fancy on a daily basis.  After all, my posts about the need for integrity in the criminal defense bar are certainly more likely to capture the attention of potential clients than my posts about why twitter isn’t the intellectual endgame of the internet.

But I can’t bring myself to do it.  It would be boring to me and would undermine the very reason for Simple Justice to exist.  So I offer no post today about whether criminal defense lawyers are gunslingers, or whether Paladin charges for 6 bullets in his retainer even if only one is needed.  I’ve already had my say on the subject, and am not inclined to repeat myself.

But instead, I will analogize myself to a nun, My faith in the law, for better or worse, was established long ago, and my choice to write whatever strikes my fancy each morning is now a matter of habit.  Yeah, it’s a horrible analogy, but at least I can take comfort in the fact that Simple Justice remains chaste. 

And if you want to know what I think about the subject of Remy’s and Bennett’s posts, they’re in here somewhere to be found by anyone who cares enough to look.  FYI, I like the Paladin analogy too, but it’s mostly for his business card.