While Dan admirably argues what empathy is not, there is no definition of what empathy is, or should be.
I start my approach from an entirely different stance than Orin or Dan, which should come as little surprise to either. Initially, I reject Obama’s characterization of cases falling within the 95-5 percent framework. When a case reaches the Supreme Court, it tends to have been subject to numerous levels of sanitization, meaning that all the ugly humanity has been drained from the statement of facts and the justices are shown a simplistic, cleansed vision of complex human interaction, and then asked to make its decision on a set of facts that never, in reality, existed.
From my seat, one can either accept the sanitized version of reality or one can look more deeply into the facts as they crawled uphill to Washington. One of my constant criticisms of Supreme Court decisions is that they reflect a vision of conduct (and here I’m limiting my thoughts to criminal cases, since that’s obviously my focus) that we, trench lawyers, know isn’t real. People are described as one dimensional, with singular motivations and characterized as entirely good or evil, honest or lying, worthy or unworthy. The Supreme Court Justices tend to adopt these characterizations uncritically, and thereby make difficult decisions far easier.
In my view, the empathetic judge is the one who rejects the simplistic version of a sanitized humanity, and views the human beings behind the briefs as living, breathing people, engaging in conduct that cannot be summed up in one sentence, with complex motivations, and engaging in conduct based on a breadth of influences. In other words, the empathetic judge rejects the reduction of humanity to a sanitized caricature. This will really screw things up on the bench, as it would require the justices to delve far deeper into reality than they are ever inclined to go.
When judges stop viewing the cases before them as “pat”, far more cases become “difficult” in the sense that they are no longer the clean, clear issues with the weighing of relative merit having been predigested for them.
This leads to the next element of empathy, the weighing process. In almost every Supreme Court decision, the issue before the Court requires a weighing of rights against authority, the government’s power to effectively execute its function. This is, without question, where the empathy factor is most critical. The Supreme Court, being both part of a branch of government and being comprised of people whose views have been framed by a lifetime of service within the government, tends to overestimate the value of government effectiveness and underestimate the value of personal freedom and protection. In other words, the Justices perform their weighing function with the finger already on the government’s side of the scale.
Another criticism I’ve often levied on the Supremes is their lack of connection and understanding of how ordinary people think, feel, act and believe. Most justices don’t hang out with regular folks often enough to understand, and even less with the downtrodden. They go to different cocktail parties. The Justices often dismiss the value of constitutional rights to real people with shocking regularity, and tend to lack an appreciation of the fact that most of us, at our most basic, believe that we have the right to be left alone.
This lack of appreciation of how ordinary people view their rights is apparent in Justice Scalia’s
recent decision in
Kansas v. Ventris, where he dismissed as inconsequential a defendant’s right to counsel post arraignment. This seemed to be a no-brainer; a defendant represented by counsel shouldn’t be questioned by the cops (or their agents). Yet the decision went the other way. This is one in a line of cases where the Court begins with the premise that a constitutional violation has, unquestionably, occurred, yet holds that there need be no remedy for suppression would hinder the effectiveness of police.
One can only deem the effectiveness of police more important than providing a remedy for an undisputed violation of the Constitution by a lack of empathy. This over-appreciation of the need for governmental effectiveness demands justices who fail to understand that ordinary people believe that the proscriptions of the Constitution must mean
something, and don’t when they can be admittedly violated at will. As this weighing process occurs in almost every criminal case before the Supreme Court, then empathy will alter the calculation by taking into account the expectation of the citizenry that our favorable constitutional platitudes will find enforcement by our top court. The empathetic judge will appreciate that people aren’t swayed or appeased by sophistry that manages to always favor government effectiveness over their constitutional rights.
The final element of empathy addresses
another great failing of the Supreme Court, providing meaningful guidance of how we are to act following the rendering of a decision. A pervasive problem with the Court’s decisions is that, after all is said and done, they have failed to provide any clear direction to the rest of us. In other words, they decide cases but fail to sufficiently answer the real question so that we know what to do with their decision.
This was recently the case in
Gant, but the best recent example is
D.C. v. Heller, the blockbuster 2nd Amendment decision that left more questions on the table than it answered. As the Court knew, absolutely, positively knew, that it opened the door to a bunch of questions that had to be answered in order to provide meaning to its central holding, Justice Scalia’s abject failure to address these questions was an affront to the people.
An empathetic justice understand that a decision of the Supreme Court is not merely fodder for law review articles, or even blawg posts, but a guidepost for how real lives are judged, and how real people get locked up in prison, or freed on the rare occasion that a case goes the right way. The empathetic justice comprehends that the Supreme Court does not engage in intellectual exercise, but in determining how ordinary folks are to guide themselves in their everyday conduct. To do this, the decisions of the Court must answer the questions that real people have, in a way the provides meaning to real people. The empathetic justice asks whether the Court’s ruling clarifies or muddies the waters for real people, whether for better or worse, the Supreme Court has made itself relevant to society by performing its function as the court of last resort.
Unlike Orin’s view of the empathetic justice flexing her empathetic muscles on the five percent of cases where the decision isn’t obvious, I believe that the empathetic justice will comprehend that many, perhaps most, decisions fail to satisfy the needs of the people for the reasons I’ve outline. The empathetic judge, therefore, is the judge who considers the Supreme Court’s function in terms of how it applies to, impacts, affects, guides and helps the lives of all those people who believe that there are nine people wearing robes in Washington whose job it is to protect us from the government. Who care.
And you already know what sort of lawyer I believe best suited to this task.