Author Archives: SHG

Safer and Cheaper: Will It Fly?

The New York Times editorial urges Congress to provide meaningful funding for the Second Chance Act, passed last year by Congress as part of the President’s prisoner re-entry initiative.  That would be President Bush, by the way.

With the economy in recession, and prison costs rising, states that used to lock up as many inmates as possible are looking for sensible alternatives. President Obama has asked Congress to commit more than $100 million to prisoner re-entry programs, with three-quarters going to the Second Chance Act. That would be a good down payment, but only a down payment, on what is needed.

The editorial describes how two states, Texas and Kansas, both known for their deep and abiding concern for criminal defendants, have implemented aspects of this bill and had significant success in reducing recidivism.  In Texas, according to the editorial, a 25% reduction in parole revocations was achieved within two years of implementation, saving the state hundreds of millions of dollars.

But two years ago, we weren’t in a recession.  With people unemployed, services cut to the bone and businesses failing, the standard complaints will rear their ugly heads:  Why should the hard-earned money of good, law-abiding folks be used to coddle criminals.  Why help them get jobs when we don’t have them.  Why educate criminals when we can’t afford to educate our own children. 

The promise of a safer society and less expensive system in the future has been around for a long time, and even when times were flush, people had a hard time accepting the idea that prisoners were worthy of being helped to re-integrate.  If you think people don’t care much for criminal defendants, they really, really don’t care much for returning prisoners.

The complaints about funding programs to help prisoners return to society as productive, law-abiding citizens present some difficult questions.  Why do we deny education to poor people who’ve committed no crime, yet provide it those who have done harm?  It is a very good question.  We know how it will help the latter, but aren’t the former worthy of help too?  Perhaps even more worthy?

This year’s federal budget will emphasize the allocation of scarce resources, even more so than usual since so much money has already been spent on bailouts, wars and other dubious uses.  The pool is small, and legislators still have to feed though mouths of those who pull their lever in the voting booth.  Can congressmen and senators use this to their advantage?  Can they at least withstand the heat from their constituents?  Will they want to?

Over the past 25 years, society’s view of prisoners has gone from bad to worse.  At one time, a prisoner was someone who paid his debt to society.  Today, he’s someone who has more rights than law-abiding people, being released because of some ACLU conspiracy that prevented his well-deserved execution.   That would end the problem, right? 

Simple Justice, like most criminal defense blawgs, tends to preach to the choir, with only a handful of ignorant nutjobs sticking their two cents in to remind us that we’re evil, our clients are evil, and the country has gone to hell in a handbasket.  Most of the time, we can ignore these loony comments as the reflections of ignorant, self-serving, angry people who feel compelled to lash out at others to compensate for the misery they’ve made of their own lives.  I’m not entirely sure that’s the case when it comes to prisoner re-integration.

While the need and utility for the Second Chance Act is clear, and its benefits likely to far outweigh its costs, it does demand a value judgment be made between using current resources to help those who have committed crimes at the expense of those who haven’t.  A very good argument could be made that if the same resources were put into education, we could prevent many people from engaging in crime in the first place, thus reducing the need for prisoner integration by reducing the number of prisoners in the first place.  The cynical response is that we would never use funds this way; we only throw money at problems, not prevention.  While true, why shouldn’t this be the thrust of re-educating the voter?

We will never eliminate crime, and hence we will always be stuck with the problem of what to do with criminals.  This becomes more of an issue as we increase the number of crimes every time there’s a new name to pin to a law.  Make more conduct criminal and there’s a strong likelihood we’ll have more criminals to deal with.  But the fact remains that we have them now, and need to figure out a way to deal with them after they have completed their sentence and must return to society. 

Oddly, nobody seems to consider why the years of very expensive warehousing of prisoners doesn’t seem to do much to stop recidivism or help prisoners to return to society as productive and law-abiding citizens.  Perhaps the real trade-off is our societal love for retribution at the cost of free college for everyone.  Until we are ready for a serious re-evaluation of what the heck we are doing with prisoners (and I for one won’t hold my breath), the Second Chance Act is a necessary stopgap.  As I said, it’s a start.  And it’s got a much better likelihood of a decent return on investment than saving Chrysler.

In Defense of the Socratic Method (Update)

I think back with fond memories at being called “mustache man” when my torts professor demanded that I rise and explain the holding in Palsgraff v. Long Island Railroad.  I hadn’t read the case the night before as I was supposed to, and Palsgraf wasn’t one of those cases you could fudge.  As I stumbled with my cursory knowledge of the decision, which clearly showed that I hadn’t a clue, the professor then called “blond woman” to stand and state whether I was correct or a blithering idiot.  Unlike me, she got the answer right.

One of the most recognizable rights of passage in law school is enduring the Socratic Method, being questioned in front of your law school classmates with the risk of public humiliation if you couldn’t muster a reasonable response on the spot.  It was popularized in The Paper Chase , first by movie and then television, in which Professor Kingsfield, the quintessential Harvard lawprof, emasculated students for their inability to reason on demand. 

Apparently, this right of passage has itself passed out of favor.  Reading Dave Hoffman’s post at Concurring Opinions, I learned this from two of my favorite blawging lawprofs, Dave and Orin Kerr of VC fame, both of whom were contemplating their Big Wheels while I was called to explain Palsgraf.  The post, about the difference between being smart and possessing wisdom as a qualification for the Supreme Court,


As Orin points out, the quality of the information we use to evaluate the smartness of judges is terrible.  So why the focus?  I blame the Socratic Method, which teaches young lawyers that being a good lawyer is the same thing as being a good debater: quick, witty, cutting, etc.  We don’t want the smartest justice.  We want the wisest. 

Orin shot back:


I don’t see the connection to the Socratic Method. The Socratic Method does not reward intelligence; it rewards glibness. But as far as I know, no one claims to want a Supreme Court Justice who is exceedingly glib.

I began to get the impression that they didn’t care for the Socratic Method.  I took no issue with Dave’s primary point, that smart and wise were hardly the same, and that wisdom was by far the more important attribute.  But why blame it on the Socratic Method?

While there are many practice areas in the law, and niches within practice areas, where a lawyer enjoys the luxury of either speaking without anyone knowledgeable around to question his pedantic assertions, or the time to contemplate and reflect before providing an answer to a question, or the expectation that a twenty page memorandum, with footnotes and exhibits, will be forthcoming to respond to an inquiry, this isn’t the life of a trench lawyer.  For these others, the Socratic Method is like death by a thousand knives, jabbing and poking his inadequate psyche and intellect, demanding that he performs in ways he can’t and never will.  For these lawyers, it was humiliation and shame.

For the trench lawyer, this was preparation for life.  We work with a gun to our heads, given half a second to analyze the situation, the spectrum of possible responses, ascertain the correct response, put it into comprehensible words and utter those words in such a way that we have served our client’s interest.  And served it well.  We don’t have the luxury of telling the judge in the midst of trial, “can we get back to you in a week or two on that one?”  It’s now or never, do or die.  Either we act or the opportunity is lost.  Our argument either prevails or not, but we will never get another chance to object, question, argue, challenge, explain, justify, persuade. 

“Glib” is such an ugly word.  Whether meant as “superficial” or “insincere”, or just the ability to speak without forethought, the lack of substance notwithstanding, “glib” is not good.  Is that really all the Socratic Method teaches? 

Certainly, the Socratic Method is not a nurturing pedagogical tool.  It’s not intended to make the student feel worthy and comfortable, to enhance self-esteem.  Nurturing is the trend in law school today.  I wonder what lawprofs a generation from now will have to say about it.  I already know what I think of nurturing :


Law school is the time to learn how to beat them at their own game.  Learn this and the rest is a snap.  And if you go to one of those law schools where they are deeply concerned about how you feel about yourself and want to foster a nurturing environment, tell them you want your money back. 

No use of the pejorative “glib” is going to change the dynamic of the courtroom.  The judge will not say “denied” in a kindly, yet supportive, tone.  Your client will not be sympathetic to your need for “more time” to think about whether to object to inadmissible evidence.  There are good answers in a courtroom and bad answers in a courtroom, and the half second you have to distinguish between the two won’t get any longer because someone called the lawyer capable of addressing the question “glib”.  Good answers are both timely and persuasive.  Lack either one and it’s a bad answer, no matter how great an response you come up with a day or two later.

We work with a gun to our head, demanding that we analyze and react in a split second.  We risk public humiliation if our utterances are foolish or incomprehensible.  We face a room of people who are wholly unconcerned about whether we feel warm and fuzzy, and are by definition judgmental and critical.  So what pedagogical exercise best prepares a law student to survive in this environment?

Like hemlines, teaching methods go in and out of style.  After all, there would be nothing new to write about if the old methods weren’t deemed passé, and new methods lauded in their place.  But unlike hemlines, it’s not a fashion statement of no substantive purpose.  The Socratic Method forces law students to face the circumstances they will face in the courtroom, and to either figure out how to deal with it or figure out what else they should do with their lives.  If you can’t handle the pressure, then you don’t belong in the trenches.

Certainly the skillset required to survive the Socratic Method isn’t the same as that requires to be an excellent judge.  It’s not about wisdom, and no one ever said it was.  But it doesn’t preclude wisdom either.  Orin blames the Socratic Method for sucking the wisdom out of law students.  I fail to see any connection whatsoever; those lawyers and law students who are so one dimensional that they are incapable of thought, of understanding, beyond a single teaching method were never destined for wisdom to begin with.  If they have the capacity for wisdom, no lawprof is going to change that.  Sorry guys, but you don’t carry that much influence.

Years ago, I was asked to allow a college student to intern with me for a month because she was considering a career as a lawyer and her mother wanted her to experience it first.  It seemed like a smart move, and I agreed.  I asked the young woman on her first day why she wanted to be a lawyer, and she told me that everyone said she should be because she liked to argue.  And indeed, she did like to argue.  Unfortunately, her arguments were markedly unpersuasive and ill-conceived, more of the ilk of mindless disagreement rather than thoughtful contrariness.  She went on to a career teaching college psychology, where thought would never be involved.

Not everyone possesses wisdom.  And we are not the judge of our own wisdom.  We all think of ourselves as wise, and the vast majority of us are dead wrong.  It’s up to others to decide whether our very finest thoughts qualify as wisdom.  For the very few who possess this great gift, one essential to being a person entitled to sit in judgment of others, no teaching method will take it away.  For those who lack wisdom, no amount of nurturing will provide it.  

If your daily work involves putting nails into a piece of wood, it’s good to know how to use a hammer. It’s a poor craftsman who blames his tools, guys.  You don’t teach wisdom.  You can’t.  But you do teach people to be trench lawyers, and the Socratic Method is a darned good way to do so.

Update:  Ashby Jones found this sufficiently humerous to post about it at the WSJ Law Blog, evoking one comment that was just too funny not to share.  By Anonymous at 2:32 :


It’s clear that Greenfield went direct from undergrad to law school. When I think of a profession in which people “work with a gun to [their] head, demanding that we analyze and react in a split second” I think of a stock broker. Lawyers prep anywhere from a few weeks to a few years for each of these confrontations, what’s more, they already know what the other side is going to say via motions and discovery.
.
What’s really killing the profession is that it has an artificial, academic barrier to entry, which walls out most people who understand how work is done in the rest of the world. And your left with people like Greenfield who have no real understanding of anything outside of law.

Hey, what would a kid like me know?

Because Religion Isn’t Supposed to be Fair

Americans have two conflicting belief systems, and we can’t seem to accept the premise that they are irreconcilable.  Most of us belief in God, and identify ourselves with a religion.  Most of us believe in fairness.  Sorry, but you can’t always have both.

Turley posts about an awfully harsh consequence for a kid who attends a Christian High School in Ohio (need I explain this further?) who has been suspended for attending his girlfriend’s prom, where they (gasp) had music and danced!


Tyler Frost, 17, a senior at Heritage Christian School in Findlay, Ohio has been suspended for attending a prom with his girlfriend because the Findlay High School’s prom allowed dancing and music. This Taliban-like ruling is based on the Christian school’s policy that forbids dancing, rock music, hand holding and kissing.

The head of the school won’t cut the kid any slack.


Principal Tim England says that Frost was supposed to receive his diploma on May 24 but will now receive an “incomplete” on his remaining assignments. He absence will be hard to miss: he is in a class of four students.

England further threatens that, if he learns that Frost “is involved with alcohol or sex” at the prom, he will be expelled from Heritage.

Sounds ridiculous?  Outrageous?  Totally unfair?  Well get over it.  It’s not.  Not even close.  You see, this was a religious school, and it had rules.  The parents and students agreed, in this case they actually had to sign a contract with the school, to abide the school’s rules.  Nobody made the Frost family pick the Heritage Christian School as the place to send little Tyler.  Nobody told them they had to attend a school with ridiculous religious rules.  Apparently, they didn’t seem so ridiculous to the Frost family at the time they signed up.  Yet they made the decision to do so, and are now stuck with the religious precepts they agreed to.

Here’s the problem: We are entitled to pick our religion, whether it be stuck in the 50’s or avant garde.  That’s the point of the establishment clause.  We are each entitled to believe as wish.  If our beliefs happen to be bizarre and irrational, so be it.  This is America and no one can tell us what to believe.

But religion, by definition, is not modulated by reason.  It’s belief, and there is nothing fair about it.  Don’t like a religion?  Don’t be a part of it.  Don’t like a sect that holds music and dancing to be the devil’s work?  Find one more to your liking.  But once you’ve sign on to a religion, you don’t get to reinvent it when things don’t go your way.  Leave it, yes.  Disagree with it while remaining a part of it?  Nope.  Not your choice.

While denying Tyler Frost the opportunity graduate seems overly harsh and, frankly, unbearably doctrinaire, that was the deal when he and his parents signed up for the Heritage Christian School.  Don’t blame the school for being what it is.  And if you want fairness, then perhaps religious sects aren’t where you belong.  You can’t have a religion and then demand that it changes its precepts to meet your idea of fairness, no matter what you believe.

Cops Combine Two Favorites: Taser and DNA

From our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen Casey, comes this remarkable story of how Niagara Falls cops and a county prosecutor, Doreen Hoffmann, came up with a great way to have some fun with a defendant.



Ryan S. Smith refused a judge’s order last fall to give a DNA sample, insisting to police that he didn’t care what court papers said.


“You are gonna have to Taser me if you want my DNA,” an officer reported Smith saying.


So police did just that, jolting Smith with electricity before swabbing the inside of his mouth.


Can’t you just see the smile on their face when Smith refused to comply.  After all, how much better does it get, a DNA sample and a Taser all rolled into one!


According to police records obtained by The Buffalo News, officers involved had been told by superiors to “use any means necessary” to collect the sample.

The judge could have ordered Smith jailed until he gave the sample, the lawyers said, but police and prosecutors had no legal authority to force him to provide one.

“If someone refuses to give their DNA, then they can be held in contempt and be held in jail until they comply,” said Patrick Balkin of Lockport, Smith’s defense lawyer.

The judge who ordered the DNA sample, to replace a DNA sample that the cops lost (oops) isn’t pleased, and has ordered a hearing to determine how this happened.  But the best line in the case, where Smith supposedly tells Police Officer Ryan G. Warme that if he wants another sample, he’s going to have to taser him, may present a bit of a problem.


Balkin plans to call all of the officers involved to testify except Warme, who has been jailed and suspended from his job since FBI agents charged him in October with wire fraud, conspiracy to distribute crack cocaine and other charges.

Don’t you just hate it when that happens?  But what about the role the county prosecutor play in this mess.  After Smith refused to cooperate by providing another DNA:


[P.O.] Galie then contacted Detective Lt. William Thomson and Assistant District Attorney Doreen M. Hoffmann, McDonell reported.

“It was relayed the officers could use any means necessary to secure the sample,” he wrote

Any means necessary?  And that was okay with ADA Hoffmann?  Defense counsel Patrick Balkin plans to have Hoffmann decide for herself what to say about it.


Balkin said he also plans to call Hoffmann to the witness stand.

“I’d like to give [Hoffmann] some credit in this case. I sure can’t picture any district attorney thinking that they would use a Taser,” Balkin said.

Hoffmann told The News that she will offer a very different version of what happened that day than Smith did.

My guess is we can bet on that one.  No doubt it was all a big misunderstanding, when Hoffmann told them to show Smith the love and they misunderstood that to mean taser the sucker.  It can happen like that, you know. 

Our hinterlands correspondent will follow up on the hearing, provided they don’t taser her for showing up in court.




 

The Slackoisie Fight Back (Update)

Adrian Dayton, blawger and tweeter, is a great young man.  Happy, smiling, smart and engaging.  It was great to meet him on the way out of the Gen-Y Panel discussion at SuperConference. But poor Adrian, one of the small vocal group of millenials at the conference trying to defend their honor against the rash of senior lawyers (with one curious exception), suffers from the same disease that infects the Slackoisie: the inability to see life in terms of anything other than “me”.

Don’t get me wrong.  I truly liked Adrian, enjoyed meeting him and wish him the best in his new endeavor to teach lawyers to market on twitter, notwithstanding his being a lawyer for a total of 12 minutes and being successfully unemployed.  This alone, is an indication of the trend.  On the other hand, when it comes to being an expert on something twitterific, it’s quite likely that 12 minutes is all you need.  We are talking twitter here.

They have expertise that they believe to be worthy of the cash of others based upon nothing more than a belief in themselves.  It’s not like they’ve actually done much of anything, since they haven’t had time to achieve success, but that doesn’t deter them from seeing themselves as “experts”.  No longer must you achieve expertise.  You are an expert if you say you are, if you decide you are.  That’s the Gen Y vision.  Work has nothing to do with it.  If I say so, then it is.

Adrian’s retort to the Gen-Y panel is enlightening:

Partners, you don’t understand us.  Let me tell you a little bit about our generation (both X and Y).  We grew up in the suburbs.  We came home from school to empty houses.  You may have heard of us being referred to as the “latch-key” generation.  We had two cars, and in most cases money to buy all the food and clothes we needed.  We would have traded it all just to have parents that were around more.  We don’t want to make the same mistakes our parents made.

We are not motivated by money.  At least not as much as our parents were.  The currency we are most interested in is  lifestyle.  Some of us are brilliant and hard working, but you have to dangle the right carrot in front of us.

While I’m sure this wasn’t Adrian’s point, the message is clear.  The Slackoisie can’t comprehend that there are any valid concerns other than themselves.  We understand this.  We realize that your entire world is all about you.  What can we do for you? What can the world do for you?  How can we make you happier?

It’s fine to say that you don’t want to make the mistakes of your parents, though therapy might also be indicated.  There are a wealth of jobs out there in the world where expectations and demands of you are minimal, and they are otherwise so low paying and nasty that they’re hard to fill.  I’m sure these folks would be happy to accommodate your needs.  But you don’t get to be a lawyer, to take on “a responsibility to others” (a phrase that never finds its way into any thought in a Gen Y head), but only on your terms and when it’s convenient to you. 

The Gen Yers in the audience asserted that they could be reliable, but only if they deemed the reason they were expected to stay late or come in on the weekend worthy of their sacrifice.  The GCs, in the meantime, talked about how 5 o’clock came around and they found themselves alone in their office, with the Gen Yers gone, finishing up the work that remained.  The Gen Yers saw no reason why the work couldn’t be done “whenever”, and the fact that their bosses (a word used to compass the broad array of people who supposedly are in charge of the youngsters) told them to do it, but failed to adequately justify their orders, was facially insufficient.  Their bosses were only their bosses if they decided they were worthy, and the decision was invariably ad hoc.  “Want me on a Saturday?  Then tell me why and I’ll decide if your reason is good enough.”

They believed they were reasonable.  They believed they were hard working. They believed their work was competent. That no one else agreed with their self-assessments didn’t seem to phase them in the slightest.  They were right.  No one else mattered.  Me, me, me.  That was all they needed to confidently assert that they were the cat’s meow.

There was, however, one GC in the audience who had smoke on the roof but sided with the Slackoisie.  He, he claimed, agreed that work-life balance mattered.  “Would you care if your outside counsel wasn’t as concerned with work-life balance” Dan Hull asked?  “Yes, I would,” he replied, “and your firm wouldn’t be satisfactory.”  “And we wouldn’t work for you, if your expectation was that we would elevate work-life balance over excellent legal representation,” Hull concluded. 

Being a lawyer is different.  We have chosen a profession where we are responsible for the welfare of others.  Would our touchy-feely GC be as willing to put work-life balance ahead of excellence if a critical deadline passed unmet, his corporation was bankrupted by a massive loss, because the lawyers paid to represent them had something better to do that day?  That would never happen, you say.  Probably not, but then it only has to happen once.

Adrian’s post elicited a number of comments supporting him, with two notable common threads.  First, not a single commenter was a successful lawyer.  They were largely lawyers who didn’t practice and found alternative careers, where they could say they were lawyers without having any lawyerly responsibility.  They assumed that non-Gen Y lawyers (like Dan and I) had no lives and never stopped to “smell the roses,” a common, though erroneous, assumption.  We work hard, play hard, enjoy life to its fullest.  We just don’t do so at the expense of the people who put their trust in us.  The Slackoisie can’t comprehend this as being possible; pleasure is on their terms or can’t possibly exist.  Their myopic view is that everything in life is a zero sum game, rather than a spectrum of possibility.  It’s a common problem with children who see the world in black and white.

The second thread is that everyone else “must” change to accommodate them.  No explanation is offered for this demand, other than the fact that they are here, they aren’t changing and they aren’t going to do it our way. They’re wrong.  Not every Gen Yer is a card-carrying member of the Slackoisie.  Not every Gen Yer’s world consists of only what makes them happy.  There are millenials out there who are both capable of performing excellent work and desire to fulfill the responsibility they’ve undertaken.  These will be the leaders of the future, while the whiners can sit in their parent’s basement eating Cheetos and telling the world how wonderful and brilliant they are. 

The day will come when the Slackoisie won’t be able to feed off the hard work, success and efforts of those who came before them.  What the heck are they going to do when each of them demands that the rest of them change their world to make their life easier?  They’re going to run out of people to whine to, and then there will be nobody left to make their Cheetos.  And that’s the problem with a world that’s all about “me”.

Update:  Adrian has responded in a post entitled, So the Partners Think I’m a Slacker, explaining that we really aren’t different, but just have our own understanding of work-life balance.


You are completely satisfied with your life-balance.  So was Dan Hull.  When I spoke with him after he asked, “You don’t think I know the names of my kids do you?”  That’s not it at all.

You each have built great firms, provided great service to your clients, and apparently lived life to the fullest in the process.

We want to do the same, but for us “living life to the fullest” means something different.

Stephanie West Allen at Idealawg, a co-panelist at the SuperConference, read Adrian’s post as well.  She sums it up with a story that seeks to make the point:


Not long ago, the executive director of a law firm told me that her managing partner returned from a meeting of the women’s bar association (can’t recall the organization’s exact name) in shock. He said a hypothetical situation had been presented about the staffing of a case. The decision to be made was between a male associate and a female associate who was pregnant and would give birth about the time the case was set for trial. The debate was long and spirited. What puzzled the managing partner was silence about the best interests of the client. The word “client” was never mentioned.

Does this story help to clarify things, Adrian?  Or does it just sound pointless, since it isn’t about what’s good for the Slackoisie?

Value, A Novel Concept For Lawyers

As the legal market hits the skids, and the marketers who couldn’t cut it as lawyers ramp-up their hype to suck in the unwary young lawyers who have bills to pay and mouths to feed, the stench of desperation floats around the blawgosphere.  But I read Seth Godin every day, and learn what distinguishes higher order thinking from the crass, demeaning, worthless baloney that threatens to suck the last breath from the desperate. 

Godin is a marketing philosopher, rather than shill, and to the extent your practice isn’t what you want it to be, your failure to read his work is a disgrace, and you have no one to blame but yourself.  Forget the magic bullet scammers who pervade the blawgosphere, and spend some time doing something completely different:  Thinking.

Seth’s post today is typical: clear and simple, yet brilliant.  He debunks the obvious reaction to a bad economy, which is to reduce price when business is down, by offering an equation.


Value = benefit/price

One way to alter the equation is to reduce price.  But that’s not the only, or best way.  He explains:


The thing is, there’s another way to make the value go up. Increase what you give. Increase quality and quantity and the unmeasurable pieces that bring confidence and joy to an interaction.

The law is a service profession.  We sell our time and effort to clients who require them.  Here’s a radical notion:  make the effort to be a better lawyer, provide better client service, fulfill your clients needs.  Do so at a cost commensurate with your benefit.

Being a cheap lawyer makes you, well, cheap.  Providing value makes you valuable to your clients.  Give your clients everything you’ve got.  Whether it’s a big case or a really itty-bitty case, treat every client as if he’s your only client.  All aspects of excellent client service must be part of the experience that you provide every client.

No, every client will not be thrilled, no matter what you do.  Outcomes remain problematic, since they are outside your control.  But your clients will know that you’ve done both everything you can, and that your work was superlative, even if the outcome is ugly.  It’s all we can do, but it’s what we must do.

Notice how I haven’t mentioned anything about how your can make millions with self-promotional blawgs or twitter your way to riches?  Notice how all the talk that demeaning yourself by acting like a shoe salesman hasn’t produced success.  And it costs nothing to read Seth Godin.  Think about it over the weekend, and on Monday, call all your clients and let them know that when they retained you, they obtained value.  Then give them value, and you will be appreciated.

The Shame of Parenting

Proving the blind squirrel theory, Above the Law breaks the news that Madlyn Primoff, the Kaye Scholer partner who took an old parenting tactic a few steps too far, took a conditional discharge to end her prosecution for endangering the welfare of a child. 

In case you missed this, Primoff’s kids were misbehaving in the back seat, and she had enough.  She did what so many parents have threatened to do, kick them out and make them walk home.  The difference is, she actually did it. 

Madlyn Primoff apparently couldn’t bear any more squabbling between her 10- and 12-year-old daughters Sunday and booted them out of the car in White Plains, Westchester County, authorities said.

The fedup Scarsdale mom – a partner at white-shoe firm Kaye Scholer – soon relented and let her 12-year-old daughter back in when she caught up with the family car.

The younger daughter wandered around the corner to Mamaroneck Ave., where a good Samaritan spotted her in tears about 7:30 p.m., bought her ice cream and then approached a cop in a patrol car.

Next time you’re threatened by a Kaye Scholar partner, you might want to take it seriously.  Madlyn Primoff Kaye Scholer mugshot.jpg

There’s not a parent around who hasn’t made the same threat as Primoff.  Granted, she took it farther than most of us would ever consider, but then the claim that she actually abandoned a 10 and 12 year old on the mean streets of Mamaroneck Avenue is somewhat exaggerated.  She went back to get them after making the threat real.  After all, don’t the experts tell us that when we threaten punishment, we have to follow through on it?

Not that I’m advocating either the threat or the conduct, but there was once a time when parents were not merely allowed to discipline their children, but expected to do so.  The old axiom, spare the rod and spoil the child, held meaning.  We complain bitterly about what’s become of parental discipline, yet put parents at risk of prosecution for doing the things that our parents did routinely.

So Madlyn Primoff was prosecuted, and the case ended with a conditional discharge, meaning that it will be dismissed in six months provided she doesn’t commit a crime.  While it’s a favorable outcome in that it concludes the matter without a conviction, it’s not considered an outcome favorable to the accused under New York law.  It’s more of a tie.

But the sentence means nothing.  The image of Primoff’s mugshot will follow her forever.  She is the Biglaw poster child for parental abuse and poor judgment.  I assume she’s a good lawyer, or they wouldn’t have made her a partner, but that’s all forgotten now that she could be easily mistaken for one of Charles Manson’s disciples.  Was her conduct that bad that she will bear the scar of shaming for the rest of her life?

Some will think that by tossing her kids out of the car, she took a terrible risk of harm to her children and deserves the shame she’s received.  Maybe so.  But the dividing line between acceptable parental discipline in the age of fear, and the momentary blown synapse that results in a bad call, is far too blurry to destroy a career and ruin a life over.  I wouldn’t have done what Primoff did, and trust me that I’ve had the urge and the opportunity, but I similarly understand everyone makes a judgment call that, after the fact, they wish they hadn’t.

No harm came to Primoff’s kids, though her youngest was scared.  This was fortuitous, in that they didn’t wander into the streets or get kidnapped by a pervert.  Of course, these weren’t likely outcomes, except in the fantasies of those advocates for whom no parental act beyond a hug is deemed acceptable.  There is no allowance for the fact that sometimes kids need to be taught a lesson about behavior.  Hugs are great, but they aren’t always the proper response.

The point is that Primoff walked out of court with a conditional discharge, but will never be able to walk away from a moment of lapsed judgment in a twisted effort to be a parent.  Before you assign moral condemnation to her choice, think about the myriad of choices a parent faces in trying to raise their children to act appropriately, and how many of us can navigate parenthood perfectly. 

Wal-Mart Cops A Deal

A district attorney’s job is to ascertain who has committed a crime and then prosecute the sucker.  Unless, of course, that sucker happens to be a giant corporation and it’s willing to throw some cash into the middle of negotiations, which then turns the DA into a politician with a constituency.  Suddenly, all is forgiven, for a price.

When a worker died under the heels of anxious shoppers at a Long Island Walmart, a criminal investigation ensued.  Was Walmart criminally liable for its failure to have an adequate security plan in effect to protect the life of Jdimytai Damour, a temporary employee who had the misfortune of being between the shoppers and cheap goods?

From Newsday :


Mega-retailer Wal-Mart will avoid criminal prosecution for its role in the fatal post- Thanksgiving Day stampede at its Valley Stream store by agreeing to overhaul its statewide safety plan, paying out $400,000 to victims of the melee and donating $1.5 million to community programs, Nassau District Attorney Kathleen Rice said Wednesday.

“No prosecution could have achieved what we have been able to do with this agreement,” Rice said. “Rather than bringing the world’s largest retailer to court and imposing a small fine against them, I felt it was important to require significant safety changes that will affect the whole state.”

Rice “felt”.  Rice is the elected district attorney, not the elected “feeler”.  We haven’t had one of those since Bill Clinton.  Worse still, Rice explained (and when there’s a camera on or a reporter around, Rice is always available to explain):


Rice said the agreement is “unprecedented” and stressed that it is rare that a local prosecutor’s office could win major concessions from the nation’s largest retailer.

Rare indeed.  Not because a local prosecutor can’t use the power of prosecution to exact cash in exchange for prosecution, but because most local prosecutors understand the purpose of their office. 

It’s not that I’m against this deal, as a criminal defense lawyer, but that I’m jealous.  Why can’t all targets (get the pun?) buy their way out of prosecution for a cash contribution?  Bernie Madoff is likely thinking the same thing.  If Rice truly wanted to benefit her “constituents”, she should post a fee schedule on the courthouse door.  I wonder how much she would charge to get out of a murder?  According to this story, the price appears to be $1.9 million.  That’s quite a deal, really.  Plus, there are always manager’s specials for those who are of the egalitarian point of view.

Frankly, I don’t know that Walmart holds any criminal responsibility for the animalistic actions of shoppers.  I don’t know that anyone, or any corporation, can anticipate relatively normal people (assuming that Long Island shoppers are relatively normal) stampeding and trampling a human being.  Personally, it’s unlikely that a Thanksgiving Day sale would be worth my killing someone, but that’s just me.

But Rice doesn’t argue that this deal was acceptable because liability was questionable.  That would have been a very different position.  She lauds herself for doing the politician’s job of getting cash from a potential criminal defendant in exchange for not prosecuting.  In Nassau County, cash is king. 

The only question now is when Kathleen Rice plans to run a two-for-one sale.  Now that’s a deal.

USLaw.com: The Verdict Is In

When I questioned why USLaw.com used my posts, in their entirety, on its website, it caused quite a ruckus.  It seems that the proprietor of USLaw.com, a fellow who uses the name Gregory Chase, though I have good reason to believe it’s a fake, reacted quite poorly.  I was absolutely wrong, he informed me, and I was damaging his business.  He was going to “embarrass” me and tossed slander out (I know, but he apparently isn’t aware of the distinction between slander and libel).

Using an appeal to “fairness”, a curious thing for someone in his position, Chase told me that I had agreed to allow him to steal my stuff in January, 2008.  Anything being possible, I decided to check.  In the meantime, he continued to defend his honor, going so far as to email commenters to the post to tell them how wrong I was.  As the subsequent comments show, Chase’s efforts were not well received. 

Now that I’ve had a chance to review the emails from and to Chase, here’s the deal.   Chase was correct that we had email correspondence in January, 2008.  He send me a solicitation that stated:


We’d be pleased to add your excellent Blog to our great new law blog directory at:


www.uslaw.com/law_blogs


You’ll find a link to a form through which you can submit your blog for inclusion.  As you’re no doubt aware, a high quality directory is a greet way to increase your exposure and web traffic.  Let me know if you have any questions.


Best,
-Chase
USLaw.com
#1 Consumer Law Website


I took a look around the website and saw that Skelly at Arbitrary & Capricious was on there, so I sent Skelly an email asking him what he know about the joint.  He responded that he knew nothing and was unaware that his blawg were in there.  He didn’t seem pleased.  I nonetheless decided that it was no big deal to be part of someone’s blog directory.  After all, he offered “exposure and web traffic,” which is fine, and being in someone’s “directory” hardly seemed a big deal.   

I saw that the website listed Skelly’s blog and had blurbs, which I assumed linked back to A&C, like every other blog directory I’ve ever seen.  Nothing suggested that he would scrape other people’s website for their content, effectively appropriating their content wholesale.  Given the content of USLaw.com, there was no reason to ever go back and look again.  Had it not been for David Giacalone, I would never have known.  I bet that most blawgers have no clue that this is happening to their content.

Nowhere did he mention anything about infringing on my copyright and trademark.  Nowhere does he mention linking his index of my posts to his own republished versions of my posts on his website.  Indeed, the one thing he absolutely did not deliver was web traffic, since what he was doing was directing traffic for my posts in his directory to his own unauthorized copies of my content on his website.  Uh oh.

So I was going to put SJ into the directory, but the link didn’t work.  I let Chase (back then he had yet to add the Gregory, apparently) know, and he added Simple Justice to his directory.  And from this he apparently believe he was entitled to appropriate my content.  And if you saw the index of my posts and wanted to read the full post, would click in his link which would take you to my post on his website.  And apparently, to the extent there are links back to my blawg, they are “no follow” links so that they aren’t recognized by Google and the like.

The confusion here appears to be that Gregory Chase, or whatever he calls himself today, is of the view that allowing my blawg to be listed in his blawg directory somehow constituted authorization for him to take my content, in its entirety, and republish it on his website, link his index of my posts to his reproduction of my content and, apparently, superimpose an image of his USLaw logo on an image of my blawg, as if that existed in reality.  He’s wrong.  Absolutely, completely, wrong.  I’m sure he will disagree, but it doesn’t matter since it’s not up to him.  The law is clear, and he’s on the very wrong side of it.  He doesn’t get a license to my content because he “feels” that he’s entitled, and it doesn’t matter how strenuously he feels.  It’s just not his to take or use.

What we have here is a failure to communicate.  Chase absolutely, if I can trust his emails to me (see below), believes that by including SJ in his directory, I waived all rights to my content and authorized him to do as he pleased with it.  Because of this, he believes that he is entirely in the right.  He went even further in a comment to WindyPundit where he wrote :


For the record, Scott Greenfield granted USLaw.com permission to include his blog feed in it’s Blog Directory. His recollection has been refreshed on this point and we await his response.

Note the disconnect from reality, where it went from a directory, to permission to include my blog feed, to permission to infringe on my copyright and trademark, with absolutely no comprehension of the distinctions.  He’s totally, ignorantly wrong, and whoever told him that this was acceptable, and legal, needs to have a long talk with competent counsel.  I might be inclined to call this an outright lie, but for the fact that I don’t think Chase comprehends that he lacks permission to republish my original content or alter my trademark by superimposing his onto mine.  It’s just sheer, banal ignorance, rather than venal conduct.  The guy’s just plain wrong but suffers from the Dunning-Kruger Effect.

While I don’t think much of the way Chase runs his little website, concealing his identity and making it impossible to communicate with him except on his terms, I can forgive his ignorance because he has apparently been horribly misinformed.  But I find it far harder to forgive his fraudulent inducement, claiming to increase web traffic when he links to his infringed copy of content rather than to the original.  More web savvy guys than me can explain all the details of how this happens and what it’s called.  But the bottom line is he’s infringing on my copyright and trademark, defrauding blawgers by inducing them to list in his directory in exchange for traffic that will never come, and doing all of this to make a dime off the work of others.  He’s not my kind of guy.

Chase has asked me to review all of this and then apologize profusely for all the harm I’ve done his business.  I don’t think he’s going to be satisfied with this post.  Interestingly, I’ve received a number of emails from him since all this began, with Chase assuming that I will honor his request not to disclose his emails because he wants to keep this quiet and “de-escalate” what he perceives as my attack on his perfectly legal, wholly legitimate business.  Why he would think this is unclear, but I owe him no duty to conceal his emails, and have reproduced his last one below.  Now you can see what we’re dealing with first hand. 

While Gregory Chase may want (desperately) to keep his dirty laundry private, it’s not my job to cover his butt.  And so you know, this is the kindest version of his peculiar view of life, which I’m including so readers can “consider” his point of view.  Some of his earlier emails were truly wacky.  He’s now had his chance to make his case, since I have no intention of spending the rest of my life debating his vision of what he is and isn’t allowed to do.  If this isn’t enough for him, maybe I’ll post the rest of his emails.  It appears that this disclosure of what he’s doing has really got him burning, and I would expect him to do anything possible to fight it.

Maybe he’ll sue me for “slander”, and then we can find out just who this fellow is and how many blawgs have been the victims of his conduct.  Then we’ll have a nice chat about copyright and trademark infringement, and he’ll find out how the world of litigators works.  As far as I’m concerned, he’s just another leech, albeit a particularly stupid and self-serving one.  He will no doubt be pissed with me, but he would do better to reserve his cranium space for the interesting wire fraud issues raised by his conduct.  As clueless as he might be, he’s engaged in some very bad stuff.  I think it needs to stop.

If, by the way, you don’t mind that he’s stealing your content and posting it on his website, then that’s fine.  But for those who do mind that he’s taking it, using it on his for-profit website, without permission, you should know that it’s happening.   And it might well be worth our while to make sure that everyone in the blawgosphere is aware of what USLaw is doing, so feel free to spread the word.

And the funny thing is that he still has Simple Justice up at his website, and based upon his email to me, he thinks he’s doing me a favor.  He really does.
_____________

Subject: Re: Your house, your rules – De-escalation
From: [email protected]
To: [email protected]

Your blog post caught me in a raw mood last evening which was made even more raw when you removed and blocked my comments from your blog this morning.  After a day of blowing off some steam with a few short comments, in the spirit of resolving the confusion and addressing your concerns, please digest the following when time allows.  In return, I ask that you thoughtfully consider retracting the accusations and name calling that could easily spiral out of control.


As Simple Justice is so popular and you have so many sites linking to you, it must have slipped your recollection that back in January, 2008 we exchanged a few emails in which you acknowledged having your blog indexed by USLaw.com.  Please let me know if you have changed your position.  Please also understand that I do not believe USLaw.com’s Blog Directory, Index, and Blog Reader make use of publicly available RSS feeds in a way that absolutely requires any more or less permission than sought by other internet companies including companies like Google and Yahoo.  Although you granted permission, from your recent reaction it seems as though you are not happy to have your syndication feed available to thid party blog readers.  If that is the case, I’m sure you aware of ways to modify what content is mnade available in your such feeds.

 

As for my blog comments which I prefer to associate with the USLaw.com name, I’m sure you appreciate there are several legitimate reasons many people prefer to be published by pseudonum (in books, onlne, etc.).  USLaw.com is currently a relatively modest operation which I prefer not to dominate my professional associations outside of the legal industry.  In addition, assistants occassionally respond to emails from a common account.

 

As for my interest in keeping our private dialog private, I have had bad experiences with disclosing phone numbers in co-ordination with producing a website to someone whose intentions are not clear to me.  There are so many inconsiderate and misintentioned people in the web/blog publishing business– I’m sure you’ve had to deal with quite a few yourself– that I consider it “best practices” to keep web business discussions through email and remain cautious with additional contact information until I more fully who I am dealing with.  Further, I believe private correspondence should not be shared publicly without the consent of the parties involved.  As many bloggers do not share that sentiment, I prefer to determine a potential correspondent’s feeling about that principle before investing too much time in a dialog.

 

Below, please find the email we shared last January which I took the time to retrieve from an archive (best if read chronologically from bottom to top).  I hope that you will use this information to set the record straight on your blog post.

 

Thank you,

Gregory Chase