Author Archives: SHG

Partying In House, or Why General Counsel Aren’t Like Us

I’ve just returned from three days in Chicago at SuperConference, a gathering of in-house counsel from corporations across the nation.  No, they aren’t like us. 

Dan Hull at What About Client? was kind enough to think of me when he was asked to put together a panel of lawyers to speak on the subject of Gen Y lawyers, and Sheila Brennan, the brains and brawn behind SuperConference, was kind enough to ask me to come. Sheila was a sweetheart, and anyone who throws a conference without Sheila at the helm is a fool.  Having gone to many a conference of criminal defense lawyers, but nary one of our brethren whose life is spent behind desks rather than in the well, it was a fascinating experience.

First, contrary to popular belief, they don’t wear Grateful Dead t-shirts when they are amongst their own.  They may let their hair down, but it doesn’t have a long way to fall.  These are guys who show up in a pin-striped suit when no one makes them.  They like to.  It’s them. Hull told me about this in advance, so I wore the uniform too. 

It was an abundantly friendly crowd, and they were happy to meet anyone, even a criminal defense lawyer.  The first question out of every mouth was, “Who are you with?”  This is a question one never gets at criminal lawyer conferences, but the basis for everything that follows amongst in-house lawyers as well as the outside counsel who came to lobby.  Everybody is with “somebody”.  The idea that you weren’t with “somebody” was as foreign as, well, not wearing a pinstripe suit.  It just wasn’t done.

The in-house guys were not merely friendly, but exceptionally smart and savvy within the confines of their niche. Unlike trench lawyers, they were inclined to be agreeable, to follow instructions and to be on time and prepared.  It was strange to see a room full of lawyers and no one screaming at anyone else.  It was nearly impossible to find alone in disagreement about anything.  They knew what their job was, where their interests lie, and who buttered their bread.

As I met GC after GC, and after we got past the obligatory “who are you with,” and I explained what my day job was, there was the quizzical “so why are you here?” look.  I followed Hull’s lead, as he works a room like nobody’s business.  When I talked about white collar work, and how it related to their world, there was a disconnected interest, as if they heard about how corporate executives were subject to compliance, regulatory violations, fraud and the occasional prosecution, but it has no real meaning in their world. 

It was brutally clear how and why so many executives, particularly those who turn to their pals in the general counsel’s office, get themselves into a jam.  They just can’t conceive of how their world connects to ours.  They are good, clean-living, corporate types.  They would never engage in conduct worthy of moral reprobation.  Never. And if it did, the overwhelming sense was that there was nothing one could do about it.  Their remarkable savvy when it came to structuring their transactional work evaporated entirely.  It gave me a great idea for a topic for next year’s conference, as these guys and gals had an awful lot to learn about how to keep their executives, and themselves, out of trouble.  They just don’t believe they have the capacity to get into trouble, or once trouble finds them, any way to get out.

The biggest ongoing controversy at SuperConference was billing, whether the billable hour was dead and whether flat fee billing was the future.  Everyone claim to love it.  Everyone claimed that the world was changing.  Nobody could explain why it was all talk and no action.  As David Boies said in a keynote address, businesses look for the best way to do things while lawyers look to the way it was always done.  If there was any moving force amongst the GCs, it was inertia. 

Hanging with my new friends kept me up and out way to late, and away from the news and caselaw that finds its way into the pages of Simple Justice, which is why there were no posts yesterday.  I’m still trying to recover today.  It was exhausting to be nice to so many people for so long.

Beyond the high point of getting to hang out with Dan Hull was meeting Ed of Blawg Review.  A great guy who bears a faint resemblance to Chuck Norris (and that’s as much as I’ll tell), I was almost persuaded to give Blawg Review another try.  Almost.  Whether I will be invited to speak at SuperConference again has yet to be seen.  There are a few topics that connect our world with theirs, and information which these guys desperately need.  But I did learn one thing which I will carry with me should I be asked to attend again:  Don’t let them suck you into late night dinner and drinking if you’re not used to it. 

I’ll be back to normal soon, for better or worse, and plan to clean up the mess around here and catch up on the real world. 

Granny and Me

Judge Alex Kozinski makes the point in the Cato Institute’s book, In the Name of Justice, that we’re all likely criminals these days, despite the moral reprobation the ones who haven’t yet been caught feel toward the ones who have.  But are we all sex offenders?

From the York Daily Record via Turley, Grandma Donna Dull took some pics of her 3 year old granddaughter to Walmart for development.  The kid was nude.  Grandma was arrested for kiddie porn, and spent the next 15 months fighting the charge until it was dismissed. 

Christopher Moore, a special prosecutor in the York County District Attorney’s Office, is after “perverts, not parents.”

Moore was commenting on the “gray area” between the typical family picture of the 2-year-old getting a bath in the kitchen sink and a picture a pedophile may enjoy.

It can be the same picture, Moore said.

That’s a problem, guys, except Moore says that they’re looking for pervs, not parents.  And grandmas don’t qualify?

[District Attorney Stan] Rebert said in Dull’s case, “What made them offensive was their graphic nature. A little girl with her bare butt showing, kind of looking over her shoulder.

“It’s a difficult distinction to make. What’s a cute butt and what’s pornographic?

“I think what she (Dull) did was stupid and in very poor judgment. It was an interesting case and I think we did the right thing.”

Well that explains it.  The difference between a perv and a parent is whatever Stan Rebert decides it is 15 months later.  Not much help in forecasting the consequences of one’s conduct, but a bright line test as long as Stan Rebert is around.

This gives me pause.  You see, I too have a photograph of my daughter in the bathtub when she was an infant.  She’s absolutely adorable.  She’s also quite naked.  There are cute parts of her anatomy showing, though I would never have called them graphic or offensive.  I supposed if one was of the mind to find sexual titillation in a child, it might do.  It never dawned on us that this was even a concern.

Clearly, Rebert hasn’t got a clue how anyone is to distinguish the good from the bad, the keepsake from the evil.  And if he doesn’t know, how should we?  Should we ask him first?  Do we get advanced permission?

Or are we stupid and show “very poor judgment” when we engage in the time-honored tradition of a photograph of our child, whether bear rug or bath, or just being awfully darned cute, if they aren’t fully attired?  Is it really our duty to conduct our family affairs in accordance with prosecutorial sensibilities?

One would think that after the call from Walmart to the cops, demonstrating why the caller was working at Walmart rather than NASA, it would have taken a prosecutor all of 30 second to distinguish grandma from a perv.  One would be wrong.

I can’t decide whether to hide my photo or barricade the doors.  Either way, I don’t want to end up like Donna Dull, but don’t want to give away that memory of my daughter.  I guess we can amend Judge Kozinski’s admonition to cover sex offender for some.  Maybe he knows something about that too?

The Cowardly Law Clerks Attack

With Sonia Sotomayor as the leading candidate for Justice David Souter’s chair on the Supremes (which, I note, is almost always the kiss of death), the knives are coming out.  Jeffrey Rosen in The New Republic is the messenger of deep Second Circuit secrets.

After reporting that many praised Judge Sotomayor, Rosen writes:



Over the past few weeks, I’ve been talking to a range of people who have worked with her, nearly all of them former law clerks for other judges on the Second Circuit or former federal prosecutors in New York. Most are Democrats and all of them want President Obama to appoint a judicial star of the highest intellectual caliber who has the potential to change the direction of the court. Nearly all of them acknowledged that Sotomayor is a presumptive front-runner, but nearly none of them raved about her. They expressed questions about her temperament, her judicial craftsmanship, and most of all, her ability to provide an intellectual counterweight to the conservative justices, as well as a clear liberal alternative.



The most consistent concern was that Sotomayor, although an able lawyer, was “not that smart and kind of a bully on the bench,” as one former Second Circuit clerk for another judge put it. “She has an inflated opinion of herself, and is domineering during oral arguments, but her questions aren’t penetrating and don’t get to the heart of the issue.” (During one argument, an elderly judicial colleague is said to have leaned over and said, “Will you please stop talking and let them talk?”)


So the complaining comes from (a) anonymous (b) law clerks for (c) other circuit judges or (d) former assistants?  While it’s impossible to know whether Rosen is talking about three or three hundred, and the value of anything they have to say is obviously undercut by their cowardice in refusing to put their name to their claim, there is one thing that comes out of this nonetheless.  The failure to meet the intellectual expectations of a clerk suggests that maybe, just maybe, the judge gets it and the clerk is a pompous, pseudo-intellectual elitist? 

Who exactly are these young men and women to offer opinions on Judge Sotomayor’s general intellectual prowess?  No doubt they see themselves as brilliant, as every circuit clerk does, and far better able to comprehend than the doddering old fools in robes for whom they work.  Do we all share their high opinion of themselves, such that they are entitled to question the intellect of a circuit judge?  Even if accurate, does this reflect what we, as opposed to they, find important in a Supreme Court Justice?  I sense that we might not all share the same vision of critical attributes that the Scions of Eli hold dear.  I bet some of us would happily trade some pragmatism for intellect any day, not that I’m suggesting that would be the case.  And we certainly know that the current writing on the court leaves much to be desired.

I have no clue whether Rosen’s assessment bears any relation to reality, or is just an example of the attacks starting.  But Gerard Magliocca, who clerked for Judge Sotomayor, has taken up arms in her defense over at Concurring Opinions.  With my starting point being that law clerks are not the measure of a good judge, coupled with anonymity so there is no price for their comments, and given Magliocca’s measured response, Rosen’s piece strikes me as mere inflammatory fodder.  It may be right, but I’m not buying based on that.

Unless and until the anonymous complainers care to come forward and take the heat for their thoughts, I’m sticking with Magliocca and what I know of the Judge. 

What Can USLaw.com Do For You? (Update)

The other day, David Giacalone, formerly of f/k/a, asked me a very good question.  Does a website called USLaw have my permission to , both in abstracts as well as in their entirety?  Curious, I took a look, and just as David said, there were my posts, published in full.  So I wondered too why the fine folks at USLaw felt entitled.

I searched to find out who the fine folks at USLaw might be reached.  There was one of those email forms, that someone can fill in their blanks to send them a communique, but without an email address to do so on one’s own terms.  Well that wasn’t what I was looking for, so my search continued.

No telephone number.  No identity of the owner of the website. No nothing.  I asked David if he could do some digging for me, and he went to the source,   After checking “Whois” and coming up with only the host, David went to the “Aboutus” website and thought he hit paydirt.  There was a telephone number.  He let me know.

I called the telephone number for USLaw.com.  A message.  It was disconnected.  Nor was there a listing for USLaw anywhere to be found.

After sending the fine folks at USLaw an email, using their form, inquiring why they were under the belief that they could take my copyrighted original content and use it in full on their commercial website, I awaited a response.  I’m still waiting.

The part I find most peculiar is that they have an image of Simple Justice on their website, with the USLaw logo superimposed on it to suggest that I am somehow a part of the US Law family.  The same is true for Mark Bennett’s , which I guess makes us brothers of different mothers (leaving me naturally to be the runt of the litter).

So who are these fine folks who are of the view that they are entitled to capture my content, and I would imagine the content of every other blawg in creation, and sell it others so that they can enjoy a profitable commercial blog?  It’s not that I have anything against a profitable commercial venture.  I’m no commie.  But there is a small issue of their enjoyment of the fruits of my labors, and yours as well, to discuss.

Inquiring minds want to know.  I want to know.

Update:  While no word from USLaw.com about what they’re up to, WindyPundit has questioned why it bothers me that this sort of stuff happened.



I’m a bit mystified by Scott’s reaction. It’s not like USLaw.com is scraping the content off his website. Scott publishes full feeds for Simple Justice—in RSS and Atom, both also advertised as related content in the HTML header—and USLaw.com has picked them up. This is how content syndication works.


I’m not sure if U.S. law recognizes a syndication link as granting a license, but it’s common usage in the blogosphere. If Scott doesn’t want other people publishing the full articles, he probably shouldn’t be offering the full articles in the feed.


Since Windy’s not a lawyer, the points has nothing to do with his lack of understanding of fair use and copyright, and more to do with an appreciation of stealing, a fairly universal notion.  The fact that it’s easy to steal online, via an RSS feed, doesn’t change the fact that stealing is still wrong.  I’m surprised that Windy doesn’t recognize that distinction, but I suspect that it has more to do with the fact that he doesn’t see his original content having value, so taking something valueless isn’t much of a problem.  I think Windy is mistaken, that his content has value and if it didn’t, no one would bother taking it.

To the extent Windy has issues, they are geek issues.  He’s miffed that he’s not in their directory, and that he doesn’t get SEO benefit because of the “no follow” code they use.  But he’s got no problem that a commercial enterprise would take the fruits of his labor and use them to make money without his permission and without his participation.  To each his own, I guess.  But as I explained in the comment to Windy’s post, the fact that it’s okay with him doesn’t mean that stealing should be fine with me. 

And to the geeky point, stealing online is easy.  Stealing online is still stealing.  Easy doesn’t make it right. 

Then There Can Be No Drunk Driving

From the remarkable efforts of Packratt with his Injustice in Seattle twitterfeed of police misconduct and abuse comes this story a drunk driver who crashed into a carload of kids coming from church.  A murder case?  Hardly.  The defendant was a former New York City cop.

A jury convicted former NYPD officer Santos Tirado of drunk driving and possession of an unlicensed handgun, with illegal bullets.  After the verdict, the judge decided otherwise.

However, the Hackensack Superior Court judge, in a separate set of rulings on lesser police summonses, said he did not think there was enough evidence to say Santos Tirado, of Monroe, N.Y., was intoxicated. A conviction on that charge would have entailed additional penalties.

The watery eyes and slurred speech reported by Fair Lawn police the night of the Oct., 26, 2007, accident could also have been caused by a head injury, Judge Eugene H. Austin said in court.

“I’ve struggled with this case since we finished and got the jury verdict,” Austin said. “I have gone over it and over it and over it in my mind. It’s a very difficult decision to make under all the circumstances.”

It’s heartwarming to hear that the judge struggled.  They should all struggle.  And struggle some more.  Yet at the end of their struggle, judges invariably go with the verdict of the jury.  Judges invariably accept the testimony of their local police officers, one after another taking the stand to testify that the cop:


The Fair Lawn officers, several of whom testified in court, said Tirado smelled of alcohol and had an empty Coors Light can in his car.

They said he was belligerent when they attempted to arrest him for carrying the handgun without a permit required in New Jersey. He also asked them to give him special treatment because he was a fellow officer, they said.

Tirado refused to take blood and breath tests to measure his blood-alcohol level after the accident.

[Side note:  Notice how cops always refuse the test?  Does that tell you anything?]  So what part of smelling like alcohol comes from a head injury?  And what are the chances that Fair Lawn cops would pick a brother in blue to be the dupe in some testilying conspiracy?  If anything, this is a case where the Fair Law cops have performed their duty with the highest integrity, despite the expectation of protecting their own from harsh consequences.  And for this, they are smacked in the face by the judge.

No doubt, the five former and active New York City cops from Tirado’s former precinct, the 30th (strike a bell to anyone, as in “Dirty 30?”) had some influence.  Judge Austin’s choice, to eschew the testimony of the Fair Lawn cops over the influence of their character testimony, is quite amazing.  What it means to be “legendary” in the 30th is certainly suspect, and even beloved cops get drunk.  Rather than being mutually exclusive, some might say they go hand in hand.

The judge’s rationale may well be valid, for all I know.  But would he have done the same for anyone other than a cop?  If so, then there should never be another conviction in that courtroom for drunk driving so long as they don’t blow the test.  I wouldn’t test the theory, however, unless you’re a cop.

Flexing the Wrong Muscles

Via Skelly at Arbitrary & Capricious, there are few defendant-gone-wild stories to match this one from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette:


Timothy Lee Williams’ lawyer, Frank C. Walker II, stood next to him, powerless.

He had advised Mr. Williams not to testify, but his client didn’t listen.

“All I really wanted to do was express myself,” the defendant began, launching into an incoherent diatribe about his life and the circumstances surrounding a Hill District homicide.

His testimony Tuesday — during which Mr. Williams, 40, admitted to the killing and revealed that he was a “swinger” with 17 girlfriends — sealed his first-degree murder conviction.

The story chalks this up to the “uncooperative client,” the client who doesn’t “heed” his lawyer’s advice.  While that’s certainly a problem, and a phenomenon, that happens with remarkable frequency, I doubt it was the case here.  The client simply had a very different agenda than the lawyer, whose sole focus was defending his client against the murder charge.  We lawyers assume that the clients want what we want. 

The problem here wasn’t that Timothy Lee Williams thought he was smarter than his lawyer, or that he would be more effective in his defense than his lawyer.  The problem is that he wanted to tell his story.  He had a room full of people who were there solely for him, rapt with every minute detail of his actions.  He was the center of attention.  He was the star.  How many times before in his life had anyone cared a whit about anything he had to say?  Now, that’s all they cared about.


One right that can cause conflict between lawyer and client is the right to testify. Many defendants — especially ones who have stewed in jail for a long time — want a chance to tell their side of the story. But from a legal perspective, it often does more harm than good.

“Very few defendants who take the stand actually help themselves,” said Sumner Parker, who has worked in the Allegheny County public defender’s office for 22 years.

Lawyers know that.  Defendants, for the most part, know that as well.  But a superficial analysis as reflected by this story neglects to consider the psychological makeup of a defendant, and the forces that drive someone to implode.  Does anyone really think that the defendant didn’t realize that admitting to the murder would be detrimental to the cause of acquittal?  But that wasn’t really his game; he wanted to be heard.


“The lawyers have a great deal of experience trying cases. For the defendant, this is one of the few times they will ever be in a courtroom. [But] they think they have the answers.”

The answers often come from “jailhouse lawyers” — fellow inmates who advise on legal matters but don’t have the training — or family members, rather than a defendant’s attorney.

Certainly, jailhouse lawyers and overly helpful relatives present roadblocks in presenting an effective defense.  They tend toward magic bullet solutions, unrealistic and ineffective.  Often, following their advice will doom a defense, even when there’s a great defense available.  But that’s a case management issue for a criminal defense lawyer, and one which any good lawyer should be capable of handling, particularly given its frequency.  But handling crazy collateral advice wouldn’t change Williams’ testimony.


The contradictory advice comes most often when an attorney is a public defender or court-appointed.

“[Defendants] view the system as being all against them and a lawyer — defense or prosecution — is part of the system,” said John Elash, who has been court-appointed to represent numerous indigent criminal defendants.

“They don’t view you as somebody who’s on their side. They view you as somebody who’s part of this big machine who is oppressing them.”

Somewhat true, though a bit on the martyrdom side of rationalizations.  While many defendants sneer at public defenders, viewing them as the booby-prize of indigency, second-stringers in a second-tier profession, there’s no reason why the good ones (meaning of course that there are indeed some lousy ones as well) can’t handle their clients’ fears and dread as would any other lawyer.  Neither retained nor assigned lawyers get a free ride on client trust and respect.  We all have to earn it.

The fact remains that sometimes a defendant primary goal in the midst of trial isn’t to defend himself, isn’t to win.  It’s to seize the moment, to enjoy the one thing that hes never had in his life and will never have again.  People who will listen.  For these defendant, a stately room filled with a dozen citizens, a black robed God-like figure sitting high on a bench, plus some others, who listen with rapt attention to his every word for as long as he cares to speak, is the high point of their lives. 

Much of crime is a grab for attention.  It’s the assertion of power over others by might.  It’s a demonstration of control.  The reason someone engages in anti-social behaviors like this is that they have never had any control or power over others, and perhaps not even over themselves, and so seize it the only way they can.  It’s certainly a sociopathic reaction, and it’s intolerable in society.  But it happens with some frequency. 

If you compare the need for attention as manifested in a criminal act with the opportunity presented to a defendant in a criminal court room, the former doesn’t hold a candle to the latter.  It’s the ultimate pulpit for a defendant to spread his brilliance, vindicate his self-worth, express his every thought.  Yes, it’s crazy, but people are presumed innocent, not sane.  Or at least not legally insane.

Timothy Lee Williams had his day in court.  He chose to spend it by telling the gathered throng his views on life.  He was convicted of first-degree murder.  I hope it was as satisfying for Williams as he hoped, as the price of his day in the sun will be very high.

Birth Of The Trench Lawyer Movement

A couple of days ago, I fell into a trap.  I posed that Sonia Sotomayor should replace Justice David Souter on the Supreme Court.  While I maintain that she would be a fine appointment, Norm Pattis has opened my eyes to an ugly bias that found its way into my thinking, and disabused me of my error.


The current court is composed entirely of former federal appeals court judges. All but one got their professional tickets punched at two of the nation’s premiere status factories: Harvard and Yale. Three of the current justices have never even worked in private practices. As lawyers go, the current justices are glittering gems. It is an elite group, long since detached from the world the vast majority of folks inhabit.

When he looks for someone with real world experience on the Court he turns to David Souter. Why Souter was a trial judge and an attorney general of the State of New Hampshire. “No other justice has either sort of experience,”  [Adam Liptak] writes.

Norm is right.  We have so elevated the position of Supreme Court Justice that it has become inconceivable that anyone could be worthy of the seat without experience on the federal bench, preferably a big circuit one, or the intellectual prowess of the Academy, or the “practical” experience of holding high office, with the blind assumption that a few years serving the government constitutes real experience. 

There’s a reason for this, as past experience with Supreme Court appointments, not the least of which was Justice Souter who obviously didn’t turn out the way Bush the Elder expected, is that these are people with clearly discernible track records.  Whether it’s the written opinion, the law review article or the executive policy making, we know what we’re buying.  No pigs in a poke here. 

Of course, that means the breadth of experience on the Supreme Court will run the full gamut of judge to lawprof to prosecutor, at best.  As Norm points out:


When President Obama opposed John Roberts’ appointment to the Supreme Court, he said “adherence to precedent and rules of construction will only get you thought the 25th mile of the marathon.” What concerns the president is the view during the last mile, a view that takes account of “the broader perspective on how the world works.”

Where could we possibly find someone capable of running that last mile?  The answer is clear:


A trial lawyer knows about raw human need and the law’s rough edges. It is a trial lawyer’s job to find the intersection of terror, fear and tears with the high doctrine and principle of the law. Not one member of the current court has ever sat with a client and his family during jury deliberations to discuss what will become of a family should the client be sent to prison. Not one of these legal scholars have ever told a person that the law’s reach will not embrace the harm they have endured. I cannot fathom Scalia counseling a client about sovereign immunity.

In the trenches, we experience life, along with the huddled masses who care far less about whether a judge is a constructionist or originalist or texturalist.  We know the consequences of decisions, together with the consequences of delayed decisions.  Our view is ground level, and our understanding of how badly the law can hurt comes from holding the hands of the maimed.  We know that people lie, cheat and steal, but we know that isn’t limited to the defendants.  We have philosophies, but we live realities.


The bar’s elite will shudder at the thought of an uncouth lawyer sitting atop justice’s pyramid. But the shuddering really reflects the conceit of those who view the law as little more than a pyramid scheme. The law is not science. There is no Platonic elite governing eternal truths exposed briefly to view in qoutidian conflicts. The law is simple: It is civilized society’s way of brokering peace in the face of conflicts rubbed raw by human need. A man dies, and another is accused of the killing; a mother cannot afford the rent for her home, and her landlord presses her; a child’s parents do not provide the care a state official thinks necessary and now hearts are torn assunder. This is the world most Americans inhabit. We do not command corporations, run large agencies, stride the corridors of power as lawmakers or judges. When we awaken in the morning, we hope, and the law is what we turn to when the hopes of conflicting parties threaten to turn into despair.

Isn’t this what President Obama says he is looking for in the next Supreme Court Justice?  We have a court comprised of doctrinal elitists, who render opinions that reflect what they believe to be real in a world they’ve never actually touched or experienced.  What if there was a justice sitting on that Court who had actually looked into the eyes of the mother denied her child, or had to explain why a young man would spend years in prison awaiting the 3% chance of reversal, if only someone would risk the possibility that his less than perfect trial could have ended wrongly.


The Times reports that Mr. Obama wants a judge who “understands that justice isn’t about some abstract legal theory or footnote in a casebook…. It is also about how our laws affect the daily realities of people’s lives.” Hence the first question of any potential nominee: “When is the last time you appeared in a courtroom to represent a person making less than the median income of the United States?” No one on the short list of names being tossed about can answer that question with anything other than silence.

With this begins a Movement.  I call it the Trench Lawyer Movement, born of Norm’s rejection of the status quo of Justices isolated from the people, ignorant of the problems and blinded by their theoretical or elitist notions of how the real world is. 

Consider, if a mere one of nine was to be a trench lawyer, without the trappings of great wealth, power or importance, how terrible would be the disruption in the halls of power if there was a lone voice to speak for the hundreds of millions of Americans about whom the others speculate and theorize?  Shouldn’t every person who sits in judgment of another have had the experience of holding the hand of a living, breathing person, and seeing the real world consequences of his or her decisions?

Norm Pattis has persuaded me that my bias was shortsighted and wrongheaded.  We don’t need another appellate judge, or law professor, or high office holder, or prosecutor on the Supreme Court.  We already have those voices.  We need the voice of a trench lawyer.

Are you with us?

The Gentlemen’s “A”

This year, more than any other, law students will obsess over the grades they receive under the blind assumption that their grades are the only standing between the breadline and the winner’s circle.  They are far more attuned than lawyers can imagine to the layoffs, outsourcing and pay cuts in law firms across the country: this was the money-back guarantee of law school if only one got the grades. 

But what does a law professor think of grades?  This never makes it onto the students’ radar, since they are the Big Kahunas who know all the integral secrets of law that they, lowly students, must absorb fully to win the prize.  Dave Hoffman at Concurring Opinions shares the secret.


“A” exams validate professors’ vanity by suggesting that the exam made sense & fairly tested the course. The rest of the pile makes us feel either like terrible teachers, or gob-smacked fools who asked incomprehensible questions. Therefore, the goal of a test taker should be to write an answer that makes the exam seem like it was internally coherent. This is not the same as trying to guess the professor’s politics and bringing vomit back to the dog.

Students only consider a slice, make that a sliver, of the law school pie when they think about grades.  They only think about themselves, their future, their success.  Lawprofs, on the other hand, think about their own validation.  Grades are proof that lawprofs succeeded, or failed, the pedagogical test.  Lawprofs hate to fail.  Who doesn’t.

But it’s a bigger issue for lawprofs than the students could possibly know. It’s the way they feel about their professors when they fill out the forms that comprise the USN&WR ratings, the ones that everyone in or trying to get in to academia study in excruciating detail, hating yet secreting loving when their ranking goes up one or two places.  To the dean, it’s cash.  To the Lawprof, it’s prestige.  To all, its validation that they are winners, not losers. 

Around this time each year, it’s important to provide perspective to law students about the importance of grades.  There will be many, if not most, whose entire world will crash around their shoulders when they look at the letter across from their secret student number and see rounded lines rather than the pure, straight, beautiful angled legs of the “A”.  There will be others who can hardly catch their breath as they see the letter that they’ve been told their entire life is the payoff for hard work, playing the game properly, sacrifice and persistence.  It’s the brass ring, and it’s within their grasp.  They’ve earned it and now it’s their moment to grab it.

Here’s the bad news, students.  There are more “A”s than jobs for students with “A”s.  There are more top ten percenters than jobs for top ten percenters.  The really dirty secret, and this hasn’t changed as a result of economic circumstances at all, is that the life you thought you were promised paid very well, was never really what you wanted anyway, and your chances of surviving it intact and happy were quite slim.  Your mommies and daddies wanted you to enjoy a life of financial security, if quiet misery, but even that’s no longer on the table. 

Here’s the good news, students.  The death of the promise has opened up a world of opportunity for you that would never have been considered a mere year ago.  No one could pass up the top of the pay scale, despite facing the loss of any semblance of a life or professional accomplishment.  Now that the opportunity is gone for most of you, you are free to leave the hallowed halls and become something that you could never have done before:  Lawyers.

You can meet real people.  You can practice law the way it’s described in fairy tales.  You can be like the people on TV, going into real courtrooms and dealing with real issues and arguing for or against anything you want.  You can do all the things no one would ever conceive of letting you do in the big money jobs.  You can be a lawyer.

And what of grades?  They mean nothing.  No one, but no one, will ever ask you what your grade in torts was when you leave the shelter of the academy.  No one cares what school you went to.  No one cares whether you were law review.  No one cares about the Coif, the Note, the Moot Court or the Am Jur prize.  In the snap of fingers, they disappear.  The only thing anyone cares about in the real world is whether you can analyze a situation quickly and effectively, devise a viable strategy and put it to work to win your cause.  The kid with the “C” in criminal pro is every bit the star when he gets a dismissal, and all is forgotten.

After you leave law school, you may look over your shoulder once or twice, but that is as far as it goes.  Fond memories of the good times, but the glory days of law school are now the business of other, younger followers.  Your eyes are focused straight ahead, on the many years you will spend practicing law.  That’s all that matters now.

But those giants in the front of the classroom will still be there long after you’ve forgotten your grade.  Some will seek the validation they feel from your getting an “A”.  A few will take comfort in knowing that you are out there, in the world of practicing lawyers, capable of doing what clients, courts and society expects of you, because of the things they taught you in law school.  They gave you the only grade that really matters.

To all the 3Ls this year, shake off the fear and loathing.  You will be lawyers.  Make use of it.  And when your grades come out, ignore them.  They don’t matter at all.  Not to real lawyers.

Qualifications: No Thought Greater Than 140 Characters

Simon Owen at Blogasm alerted me to the newest profession,  If you thought professional blogger was pushing things, consider professional twitterer.  Simon points to this blurb in the SkyMall magazine, the one everybody reads when crushing boredom overcomes good judgment in the steerage seats of an airplane.


In 2007, SkyMall embarked on an aggressive marketing campaign that drove up its Web sales. In January, SkyMall ventured into social networking territory, hiring an official corporate Twitterer.

What distinguishes this twitterer is not merely the pseudonymous assistance, but that it’s the “official corporate” one.  This, of course, means that there is an Executive Vice President of Twittering, who answered to the Senior Executive Vice President of Twittering.  While it’s conceivable that there is a Twitter Divisional President, that seems silly.  Who would have a division dedicated to twits?

Aside from the fact that everybody who’s anybody is now on twitter, because it is the thing to do for all the really cool kids (and grandmothers, and corporations, and politicians, and nobodies), the fact that corporations have official twitterers, sitting there every day, all day long, twitting the company line is just pathetic.  You can’t help but smile, if not laugh out loud, at the idea of some card-carrying member of the Slackoisie punching promos at 140 characters a shot onto a keyboard all day long.

Of course, now that every very busy celebrity is busily empowering his or her fan base to follow their moments of transitory embarrassment on twitter, the potential of a full-blown profession of twitterers is coming to fruition.  I mean, seriously, how can Lindsay Lohan find the time to get drunk and still twit about her love life?  And all the time Britney spends at the auto repair shop must take her focus off twitter momentarily.  Ashton, on the other hand, appears to multi-task well, plus it’s hard to let your twitter assistant enjoy a view of wife Demi when he’s supposed to be a serious professional twitterer.

The rush to join in the newest, coolest thing around has its downside.  It takes time and, despite the compulsion to be involved, doesn’t actually serve any purpose beyond racking up followers and making sure you aren’t the only doofus left out of the newest, coolest thing around.  I still don’t know what the prize is for having the most following, but there has to be one or all these otherwise senscient people wouldn’t be trying so desperately hard to get them.

And since I am a professional, and this is the newest, coolest profession, I wish to announce that I too am available to twit for you.  At my standard rate.  I can’t promise to gain as many followers as somebody like @guykawasaki, I can assure you that my twits will be better than Ashton Kutcher’s (who, I might add, is not following me, no doubt for fear of twitting inadequacy).  Any takers?

Severe, Repeated and Hostile, This Means You!

Via Eugene Volokh, the Democratic Congresswoman from California’s 39th, Linda T. Sanchez, has proposed a new law to criminalize all that nasty cyberbullying we’ve heard so much about.  Just so you know. she is a lawyer, so she must have a clue what she’s doing when she proposes a law, right?

The bill is warmly entitled the Megan Meier Cyberbullying Prevention Act, making it yet another Megan’s Law, and has 14 co-sponsors.  It’s brief and to the point:


Sec. 881. Cyberbullying


    `(a) Whoever transmits in interstate or foreign commerce any communication, with the intent to coerce, intimidate, harass, or cause substantial emotional distress to a person, using electronic means to support severe, repeated, and hostile behavior, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than two years, or both.


    `(b) As used in this section–



      `(1) the term `communication’ means the electronic transmission, between or among points specified by the user, of information of the user’s choosing, without change in the form or content of the information as sent and received; and



      `(2) the term `electronic means’ means any equipment dependent on electrical power to access an information service, including email, instant messaging, blogs, websites, telephones, and text messages.’.

Just so we’re clear, this means you.  You see, when you write a blog post, post a comment, write on your facebook wall or even send an IM or email, it’s a communication sent by electronic means.  I’m doing it now, and you do it all the time. We all do.  It’s how we do things these days.  And it’s covered.

So what is cyberbullying?  It’s using electronic means to “support severe, repeated, and hostile behavior.”  No, I have no clue what this means either.  The only word that appears to be semi-objective is repeated, meaning that it requires more than one “severe and hostile” transmission, but what constitutes, and who decides what constitutes, “severe and hostile” remains a mystery.

The problem isn’t Rep. Sanchez’s motives, which is to provide a law to prosecute someone who engaged in the conduct committed by Lori Drew, particularly given how poor the fit of the crime for which she stands convicted.  Many believe that it was a wrong that needs to be righted.  The problem is finding a way to fix the problem that doesn’t sweep in about a zillion people who have done nothing more than expressed a view of displeasure, anger or frustration by electronic means.

It’s one thing for an adult to attack and emotionally undermine a teenager, and quite another to criminalize legitimate free speech that some might find unpleasant.  The sweeping breadth of this proposed law, combined with its shocking vagueness, covers it all, and then some.  As for the “intent” section, intent is shown by the act, and merely a matter of permissible inference.  It adds an element but does nothing to limit the application.

It’s hard to imagine that a law this ridiculously poorly written stands a chance of passage.  Even if it were to pass, it seems impossible that it would be held constitutional, given it’s inane overbreadth.  But it does serve to warn how difficult it will be to frame a law that will prevent the wrong without criminalizing just about every other expression of anger, unhappiness or dissatisfaction.

So next time someone feels compelled to post two comments here about how you disagree with me, consider the possibility that you might hurt my feelings, forcing me to complain to the feds that you have cyberbullied me and need a good spanking.  And after all, it’s only two years in prison.  Or in cyber terms, 15 versions of the Iphone.