Author Archives: SHG

Chief Judge Lippman Forms Another Commission

The New York Law Journal announced that Jonathon Lippman, the new Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals, has called for the formation of a commission to study wrongful convictions.  Sound familiar?  It should. 

Less than a year ago, the New York State Bar Association formed a commission for the same purpose, headed by then criminal defense lawyer, now judge, Barry Kamins.  The NYSBA  approved the commission report less than a month ago.  So here we go again?


The chief judge said in an interview that he wants to form the “Justice Task Force” as a permanent entity under the auspices of the judiciary because judges have as much to lose as anyone in the criminal justice system when people are convicted of crimes they do not commit.

“What could be worse for the branch of government whose constitutional responsibility is to administer justice than to have an injustice, a wrongful conviction?” Judge Lippman said.

What could be worse indeed.Well, a commission on wrongful convictions that neglected to include the one leg of the tripod that was closest to the problem, knew the most about the problem and could inject the most reasoned, experienced and viable solutions to the problem.  So who will be included in this commission?


Judge Theodore T. Jones Jr. of the Court of Appeals and Westchester County District Attorney Janet DiFiore will chair the task force, Judge Lippman said, adding that both have wide-ranging experience in the criminal justice system. Judge Jones was a criminal defense attorney before he became a judge and Ms. DiFiore was a Supreme Court justice before her 2005 election as district attorney.

The chief judge said the Codes Committee chairman in the two chambers of the Legislature, Assemblyman Joseph Lentol, D-Brooklyn, and Senator Eric Schneiderman, D-Manhattan, also have agreed to sit on the panel, as has Denise O’Donnell, Mr. Paterson’s commissioner of the Division of Criminal Justice Services.

So we have a judge, a prosecutor, two legislators and the governor’s commission of Criminal Justice Services.  Fine choices all.  But there’s something missing.  


Judge Lippman said it is important that all three branches of state government be represented on the task force and while panels have been established in other states to review wrongful convictions, he said the New York group would be the first to incorporate judges, lawmakers, executive branch officials, prosecutors, defense attorneys and others in the criminal justice system.

That’s it.  Criminal defense lawyers.  Thankfully, Judge Lippman acknowledges that they have a role to play in the system, along with the more important official people who comprise government’s view of the powerful voices.  At least we were actually mentioned, and not relegated to the “others” category.

While naming a commission, ordinarily a very “government” thing to do, would satisfy what small public zeal there might be to address the vexing problem of putting innocent people in prison, the significance is only as great as the commission’s ability to provide meaningful solutions to the problem.  Otherwise, it’s just another dog and pony show. 

The hard, cold reality is that the influences that go into any recommendations of such a standing commission will only be as good as the input of its members, and when the membership is lopsided, meaning comprised of the “official” side of life and devoid of those who have actual knowledge of the ugly underbelly of criminal justice, it’s doomed to reflect the governmental excuses, policy concerns and inertia.  Who stands up for the innocent in this commission?  Who tells the official member that their baby is ugly?

But Judge Lippman knows something that most of us forget.  He’s well versed from his years as Chief Administrative Judge in the ways of Albany, a place where Diogenes gave up.  As this commission comes on the heels of the well known and well regarded NYSBA commission, led by Barry Kamins, it’s purpose may well be somewhat different than reinventing the wheel.  The constitution of the commission may be carefully calculated to bring the players of change into the same room to accomplish something that rarely happens in Albany, a buy in from the three branches of government in reform.

Regardless of how many really good ideas are discussed by the members of the commission, and actually serve the goals of reducing the conviction of innocent people, it means nothing if it can’t find its way into law.  It means nothing if it can’t find its way into law in effective and meaningful legislation.  It’s a long, winding path from commission report to the statutes, and I suspect that no one appreciates this better than Judge Lippman.

If this is the case, then perhaps this commission is designed as an effective means of moving from conceptual to actual reform with the support of the players who can actually make it happen.  Perhaps this will be the commission that has real potential to make the changes and improvements that have long been recognized but never mustered the necessary support of the always wrangling fingers of government.  Maybe it will happen this time.

But a word of caution.  In building the camel of consensus, as commission invariably do, the input of the criminal defense bar is crucial to keep the more “official” influences honest.  While including Judge Kamins is a good start, he’s now part of the official world and shouldn’t be placed in the position of having to tussle with those who hold his future in their hands.  The commission must include real, honest-to-God, defense lawyers.  And not the criminal bar association glad-handing types, or the usual suspects, or the life-long prosecutors who became criminal defense lawyers 12 second ago, but real, hard-core criminal defense lawyers.

No one knows more about, or will speak more zealously for, the convicted innocent and the systemic problems that cause them to be convicted, then the men and women who fight the frustrating and never-ending battles in the trenches, day after day, and watch as the official world shrugs off another life lost to the beloved way things are always done.  Without them, the best, most politically effective commission is doomed to failure, for its recommendations may reach the governor’s desk but its accomplishments will be illusory.  Let’s make this one for real.  For once.

We Don’t Need No Stinkin’ Synapses

Amongst the daily deluge of press releases, trying to get me to post a flattering story about someone else’s story, came one from a flack for the Daily Beast.  This was curious, since I really didn’t see why the Daily Beast needed my attention.  But the reason quickly became clear.  It wasn’t so much a Daily Beast issue, but a plea for recognition of a post authored by one of the least rational, most ridiculous legal pseudo-pundits around.

Who makes Nancy Grace appear almost reasonable?  That’s right!  It’s Wendy Murphy!  Woo hoo!  With screaming headlines came this effort to prove that one can go from NFL Cheerleader to blithering idiot in one lifetime:


Former sex crimes prosecutor Wendy Murphy says the grisly murders of Caylee Anthony and Sandra Cantu may have been linked to the child-porn industry—and their killers likely didn’t act alone.

The predominant word in this modern day acid-trip is “maybe”.  Maybe this happened.  Maybe this is why.  Maybe, maybe, maybe.  You think I jest?

Maybe Casey Anthony didn’t kill Caylee. Maybe she died while engaged in some nefarious business—and Casey was forced to dispose of her child’s body. Maybe Huckaby found herself in a similar situation.

Told ya.  So what is this crackpots thoughts on the subject?  That the mothers of these dead children didn’t actually kill them, but sold them to the child-porn industry because they were desperate for money.  That the mothers are the “little people” being left to take the rap by the porn industry big shots.  And what is there to back this up?

Both cases also include evidence that children have been sedated, and experts in the child porn business know that drugs like valium and chloroform are commonly used to make young victims compliant. Such drugs also affect the memory, so victims have no recall of the abuse when the drugs wear off—a nice benefit if you’re trying not to get caught.

Sedatives were taken the Anthony home in connection with a search warrant issued after Caylee’s body was found. Police can’t take drugs from someone’s home without reason to believe they’re tied to a crime.

Mind you, this is coming from a woman who bills herself as a scholar.

Wendy is a former child abuse and sex crimes prosecutor who teaches at New England Law|Boston. A Visiting Scholar at Harvard Law School from 02-03, Wendy is an impact litigator who specializes in the representation of crime victims, women and children.

Now most of us can conceive of crazy stories, with the most tenuous of connections to both fact and reality, drawing fantastic conclusions based upon wild speculation.  We call these fairy tales, and we read them to our children before bed provided they aren’t too scary.  If they are too scary, they might keep the kids up at night, afraid of what’s lurking in the shadows.  That wouldn’t be very good.  But we tell our children that it isn’t real, and by doing so begin to train the synapses in their brains to connect facts to fears, and by doing so, eliminate them. 

And yet there are hot chicks like Wendy Murphy who somehow manage to find room for their strange and detached ramblings on media venues other than FOX.  The question becomes, how can this happen?  Does no one read what they write, listen to what they say, before deciding that it’s something that bears a public airing?  When we provide someone like Wendy Murphy with a platform to spout stuff like this, we give her credibility.  Should the Flat Earth Society get equal time?

My own beliefs notwithstanding, I think it is beneficial to have and know alternative perspectives and philosophies.  Whether we agree or not, we learn and possibly expand our thoughts beyond our own limitations.  But that doesn’t mean that every wacko around has something worth publishing.  Yet Wendy Murphy gets play, and to those inclined to believe that former NFL cheerleaders (and I mention this because she does every time she promotes herself) represent the height of intellectual accomplishment, she’s actually taken seriously.  Can anyone from Harvard explain to me what she was doing up there in 2002 to 2003? 

Like a child, I too have a fear of what might be lurking in the shadows.  I fear it might be Wendy Murphy.  She’s scary.


The Mercenary Profession

During oral argument before the New York Court of Appeals this week, I contended that lawyers sometimes do things for other than mercenary motives.  The reaction broke my heart.  After a chuckle all around, the chorus was, “No, seriously.”  It was dismissed out of hand and never considered again.

While not a critical component of my argument, it mattered to me.  My position was the lawyers write about the law for reasons having nothing to do with marketing.  For those of you who have seen some of my anti-marketing posts, this will come as no shock.  That it was considered an outlandish position by the judges of New York’s highest court does.  At least to me.

In preparation, I had a list of reasons why a lawyer might write for reasons other than marketing.  I also had a list of comparables, like judges who write about the law though they certainly aren’t looking for more business, and public defenders who do so even though more business is the last thing they need.  Law professors would fall into that category, but only after they’ve gotten tenure.  The newer ones need to prove themselves by writing, so they don’t count.

I never had the chance to go to my list.  I tried.  I started to recite my reasons, but was immediately cut off.  To the extent that any play was given the notion at all, it was to suggest that sheer, monumental ego might push a lawyer to write something without visions of a cash register on the other end.  It was still pejorative, as if the flip side of crass, mercenary motives was crass, overblown ego, with absolutely nothing in between.

With regularity, lawyers approach the blawgosphere in exactly the way that marketers tell them.  The framework of their efforts is guided by SEO and potential client palatability.  When I’ve done panel discussions on “how to blog,” the questions are rigid and silly, such as, “How many posts a week do I need to do to get clients?”  I want to tell them to post as frequently as they beat their wife, but I know they won’t see the irony in my retort.

It would be one thing for the lawyer cabal conspiracy theorists to posit that we are all about money, since they see nothing beneficial to come from our existence.  But these are judges.  Judges!  And they think no better of lawyers than rug salesmen.  Maybe even worse.

There are some lawyers who write for the primary purpose of self-expression, because they have thoughts every day and feel compelled to put them into words because that’s how they express themselves.  They enjoy the conversation, at least when it doesn’t get too stupid.  There are some lawyers who feel distinctly dissatisfied with the limitations imposed on their efforts by courts and clients, and look for a more efficacious means of fulfilling the purposes that drove them toward the practice of law.  They have things to say, and their ability to say them within the framework of a law practice is unfulfilling.  And so they write.

There are some lawyers who do their writing on a blawg.  If one was to read the blawg, the inescapable conclusion is that they aren’t writing for the purpose of marketing themselves.  If anything, as my buddy Norm once noted, the blawg would scare clients away if anything.  Clearly, marketing could not be their purpose.  But if not marketing, then what?

The reaction by the judges of the New York Court of Appeals is my nightmare.  What I do cannot be, from their perspective.  Or at least, is so very far from the norm that it would require special dispensation from the rules that find our profession.  If the judges, men and women who have no horse in the race, are so jaded as to the motives of lawyers that they believe it ridiculous to suggest that some of us might actually have “pure hearts,” a characterization offered as an assumption during the argument, then we have realized the worst fears of our critics.

And I, for one, find myself wholly disconnected with my profession, for I refuse to accept that there is no possibility that any of us have “pure hearts.”  And I will continue to fight those who push lawyers to serve their lowest instincts.

Who’s Next?

Justice David H. Souter, was the 105th person to get the job of being a judge with none higher, at least from the secular perspective.  Only one of nine, of course, but that’s still a pretty significant vote.  And unlike others, Justice Souter has chosen to close up shop while he is still young, vital and healthy enough to enjoy the benefits of being a rock-climbing former justice.  The manner in which he’s taking his leave reflects dignity, a rare commodity.

Speculation on who the next justice would be began during the Obama campaign, with the natural claims that he would appoint some wild lefty to fill the seat.  To the people complaining, everyone left of Genghis Khan is a wild lefty.  But the greater likelihood is that the politics of identity will play a larger role at first in the pressure to be applied by the various interest groups.  As much as I’m disgusted by the notion that it’s more important that our laws and Constitution be decided by someone based upon immutable and irrelevant characteristics, to ignore this would be folly.

The two initial traits to be demanded are gender and race, with the expectation that the Court needs a second woman and has a glaring hole where a Hispanic should be.  Why this is so remains unclear, since neither females nor Latinos are some monolithic group where the members are fungible.  Did we learn nothing from Clarence Thomas?  It is particularly galling that, as we argue and some even believe that gender and race should become nonexistent factors in America, we continue to harp on them unmercifully.  Black president aside, we’re still a ways off from being gender and color blind. 

The advocates of a woman or a Hispanic will explain that by putting one on the Court, we will inure people to the hard fact that they are here, they are as worthy as anyone else and they are ready to take their place as leaders.  To say this is to suggest that it’s a question.  There is no question.  We’ve had female Supreme Court justices already, and we know they can do the job.  There has been no Hispanic justice, but does anyone really think that Hispanics can’t do the job?  I think we’re past that.

The next question is political ideology, which is the one that seems most interesting from where I sit.  I remember a day when the Court really stretched its wings on the issues of civil rights and personal freedom.  A fellow named Earl Warren was in charge, and decisions made by his Court are still household names and fix the parameters of the world we enjoy.  How many Supreme Court decisions since Rehnquist put velvet strips on his black robe can be remembered by anyone other than lawprofs and wonks?  Think about it.  The measure of a Supreme Court is the extent to which its work impacted society.  Anything less and it’s just a spaceholder.

I’ve complained that the Supreme Court has lost its function in our society, issuing decisions that decide little and raise more questions than we started.  The whole trend of judicial modesty is sorta nuts; If you open an issue, then give us a complete, useful answer on what to do.  Anything less and you’ve just taken the law and made it a mess for the rest of us to suffer and sort out over the next 20 years, only to learn that some future Court will eventually tell us how we got it all wrong.  Of course, they still won’t tell us what is right, and all the nice men and women who relied upon the Court’s pronouncements to their detriment will have a moral victory, which they can enjoy from their prison cell.

Given how important the Supreme Court could be if only it fulfilled its function, these are the things I urge President Obama to consider in selecting the next justice:

1.  Experience:  Without question, the most important criterion is that a Supreme Court Justice possess a breadth of experience in the real world, including a firm appreciation of how real people live, work, love and behave.  The appointee must understand and appreciate that most people aren’t brilliant, didn’t go to Harvard, can’t grow up to be President and struggle with trying to understand what the right thing to do is so that they can do it. 

They need to know that there is no such thing as “common” sense because there is nothing common about the human experience.  We each possess our own, and extrapolate that to everyone else.  Every time I see a judge hide behind “common sense,” I see a coward and someone lacking in intellectual integrity.  We need a justice who is neither.

Experience isn’t learned from a book, or is something we pretend to have because we’ve read numerous law review articles on the subject.  Experience is gained by being on the street as well as in the courtroom.  The surest path to the bench is to hole oneself up in the wood-paneled rooms of the courthouse.  It’s also the place where one is isolated from real experience and insulated from the real world. 

The next Supreme Court Justice should know what it’s like to listen to the ignorance, fear and craziness of litigant trying to comprehend why the law can’t seem to cure their ills.  The next justice should know how it feels to have a judge try to humiliate them in a courtroom because they wear the robe and get to make the rules.  The next justice should appreciate that the 5+ years between the start and end of child custody proceedings destroys lives and ruins children.  The next justice should know how it feels to be innocent and in prison because some legal fiction was more important than some person’s life.

And for the record, this experience doesn’t come from a few years working as a government lawyer, where none of this experience is ever gained.

2. Intelligence:  A certain level of intelligence is required, but not too much. Intellectual integrity is far more important than intellect.  The law is for real people, not theoretical discussion or doctrinal purity.  Intelligence isn’t a negative, per se, but can be when it interferes with someone’s ability to feel compassion, to appreciate that others may not be or behave in a way that meets the expectations of the Oxford Don or society matron, or to understand what it’s like to live in a world of powerlessness.  Intelligence is often over-rated.  Smart is much better.  Integrity even better than smart. 

3.  A real person: Rarely does anyone climb the ladder of professional importance without it affecting their view of the world.  The unfortunate loss in the process is that they forget, if they ever knew, what it’s like to grab a beer after a hard day’s work.  This is where most of us live, and where we talk about the things that matter.  The bottom line to every decision the Supreme Court issues, or more accurately, should issue if it did its job, is that it must fulfill the expectations of real people.  Real people aren’t afraid to disagree when they disagree.  Real people actually believe in things.  Real people temper their belief with the understanding of how it affects real people.  Real people are not idealogues.

No, this is not a plug for Joe Six-Pack, the fictional beer swiller who wants courts to vindicate his prejudices without having to suffer the indignity of thought.  This is a plug for protecting all the Joe Six-Packs out there from themselves, knowing how stupid and thoughtless people can be, how prejudice pervades their opinions, how self-serving their choices. 

There are, of course, many others characteristics that could be brought into the mix, but these are the main considerations.  The rest are the details, and they can be debated ad naseum. 

This said, the person who stands poised to be the right choice for the Supreme Court of the United
States of America is 2nd Circuit Judge Sonia Sotomayor. 

And as it happens, she’s female and Hispanic, for whatever that’s worth.

John Stossel: Credit Cards Are Banks Gift To The Poor.

If you’re ever in need of amusement, read an op-ed by John Stossel.  If that doesn’t get you laughing nothing will.  The easily outraged Stossel, whom I note as an aside hates lawyers except when they’re his, has turned his attention to banks, and specifically their credit cards.  It’s not that he loves banks, though one might think he’s angling for a Black Am Ex, but it’s his devotion to the poor that propels him forward.  Here’s his latest brainstorm.

Credit cards are a demagogue’s dream come true. What better way to win public affection than to rail against banks for their harsh terms? In the politicians’ morality play, creditors are the villains and debtors their helpless victims.

A little context first: No one has a natural right to a credit card. Someone has to be willing to undertake the risk in issuing it. Banks issue cards in their quest for profits. Nothing wrong with that.

Didn’t I tell you that he’s shooting for a Black Card?  They are a privilege, not a right.  Got it?

Stossel then explains how credit cards make our life easier, more convenient and just downright wonderful, and we don’t show banks anywhere near enough appreciation for just being there for us. 


To appreciate credit cards, it is worth recalling that before they came along, people got personal loans from banks, finance companies, pawnshops and loan sharks. Such loans were less convenient, and repayment was less flexible. Some people bought things on layaway, which meant they didn’t take the goods home until they were paid for. Loan sharks sometimes broke people’s legs.

When’s the last time a banker broke your leg?  That’s right, never!  Banks are better than loan sharks.  Got it?  And still you don’t love them enough.  That, Stossel explains, is why credit cards are a “demagogue’s dream come true.”  Vilify the banks for making our lives easier with their plastic, and the ignorant huddled masses applaud.


Politicians are too short-sighted and vote-hungry to say such things. They want a “credit card holders’ bill of rights” that would prohibit certain billing practices, like raising interest rates on existing balances. The House could approve the “bill of rights” this week.

Understandably, these billing practices endear themselves to no one, but competition makes the worst of them far less common. And as for raising rates, revolving credit means that a balance is a fresh loan each month; as the terms state, the rate can change. If issuers can never raise rates on existing balances, even when economic conditions change, they will be likely to charge everyone a higher rate to make up for the risk.

It’s only fair to banks, ya know.  And really, we’re a fair people.  We want to be fair.  Fair, fair, fair.  Don’t banks deserve fair too?  This is where Stossel invokes the idea of Volokh Conspirator Todd Zywicki, who is bursting with pride for being the source of Stossel’s knowledge.


Politicians assume we are ignorant about credit-card terms. However, Zywicki points to evidence that people who carry credit-card balances are aware of the interest rate they’re paying, and “those who carry larger balances are even more likely to … comparison shop.”

It’s just like criminals, who know everything there is to know about playing the criminal justice system.  You know how “those people” are.  After all, the credit card business is very competitive, Stossel tells us, and they desperately want the business of poor people who fail to pay their bills timely and rake up a ton of interest on their outstanding debt.  It’s the American way.  And then they just shift a few numbers around and, voilà, the banks are flush again.  They’re just trying to help.

So what’s missing from Stossel’s analysis?  Maybe the competition for business is more about hooking the debtor at the outset, and once hooked, it’s about as much fine print, shifting interest rates, recalculation methods, all designed to create a debt hole that the credit card holder can’t claw his way out of.  Maybe the relative bargaining power after the honeymoon period is all in favor of the banks and the holder, despite Stossel’s attribution of great sophistication, doesn’t stand a chance of arguing against the impending financial rape.

As usual, Stossel manages to set up a paradigm that could only exist in the frontal lobe of the truly simple-minded, No one suggests that banks should carry credit balances without charging interest, but that what’s the problem with only charging the interest rate you tell people you’re charging on only the actual past due balance?  Why do banks get to change the rules, all the rules, at will and with impunity?  Loan sharks may break legs, but they risk prison for their business.  Banks get to charge usurious rates when you add up the interest and plethora of ancillary charges, and get to lobby Congress. 

Ironically, a study just came out on the subject of credit card rates by none other than Mike Cernovich at Crime & Federalism.  Talk about fortuitous timing!

I’ve studied credit card scams and abuses in the abstract.  I wanted to do an experiment to see how shady credit card company “accounting” really is.  My cynical self was astounded. 

My previous balance was $979.90.  Payment Activity (how much I paid) was $704.90.  Thus, should have had an unpaid credit card balance of $275 that I would pay interest on.  My annual percentage rate is 13.4%. 


Question: How much should have interest payment have been?  Answer: When dealing with credit card companies, forget what you think you know about math.


I was charged $13.63 in finance charges?  How?  My APR is 13.24%.   


Is there some hidden usurious rate?   


The answer is even more amazing. 


Even though I paid off all but $275 of my balance, I was required to pay interest on an “average daily balance”  of $1,211.03.  So American Express calculated my 13.4% APR based on money I did not actually owe them.  Remember, I paid them back all but $275.


How is that legal? 


This leads Mike to conclude:


Henceforth, I’m going to use credit cards as a litmus test.  Anyone who mentions “freedom of contract” within the context of credit cards has such an unrealistic understanding of how credit card companies operate that their opinions are per se invalid.

For some reason, I can’t help but feel that Stossel may be unfamiliar with the term “litmus test,” but will likely believe it to be another government conspiracy.

In any event, I have bad news for ya, John.  Your black card has been denied. You’re just not worthy.

Scalia’s Idea of Incentives (Update)

Just because Justice Antonin Scalia’s life is an open book doesn’t mean everyone’s should be.  For Donnie Ray Ventris, unfortunately, there are no secrets.  Ventris was in jail awaiting trial for the robbery and murder of Ernest Hicks when the cops decided that it would be a good idea to convince another fellow inside to get Ventris to talk.  Donnie Ray Ventris had a lawyer, but that didn’t seem to bother them much when they turned the prisoner into their agent.

At trial, Ventris took the stand to testify in his own defense, one of those rights enumerated in the 6th Amendment but observed primarily in the breach.  Given the defense, that it wasn’t Ventris but his co-defendant Heel who pulled the trigger, his testifying could be seen a mile away.  Afterward, the prosecution called their snitch to impeach Ventris’ denial of shooting Hicks.

The Kansas Supreme Court reversed, holding that once a defendant is represented by counsel, the police cannot use an agent to elicit statements, and that the statements can’t be used for any purpose, in chief or impeachment.  Enter Scalia in  Kanas v. Ventris.

It is one thing to say that the Government cannot make an affirmative use of evidence unlawfully obtained. It is quite another to say that the defendant can . . . provide himself with a shield against contradiction of his untruths.” Walder, supra, at 65. Once the defendant testifies in a way that contradicts prior statements, denying the prosecution use of “the traditional truth-testing devices of the adversary process,” Harris, supra, at 225, is a high price to pay for vindication of the right to counsel at the prior stage.

What a strangely backward way to claim that the defendant has created “a shield against contradiction,” by blaming the defendant for the police having deliberately violated his constitutional rights.  It’s as if it was the defendant who forced the cops to plant an unlawful snitch in jail for the purpose of denying them the opportunity to use the snitch’s testimony to impeach his testimony at trial.  The reasoning is so fundamentally circular that it takes a few tries to make sense of how the majority ultimately comes to blame the defendant for the cops unconstitutional acts.

But the Court takes it a step further, since it’s still stuck with the cops violating Ventris’ rights by planting the snitch. 


On the other side of the scale, preventing impeachment use of statements taken in violation of Massiah would add little appreciable deterrence. Officers have significant incentive to ensure that they and their informants comply with the Constitution’s demands, since statements lawfully obtained can be used for all purposes rather than simply for impeachment. And the ex ante probability that evidence gained in violation of Massiah would be of use for impeachment is exceedingly small.

Thus, the Court returns to its basic foolery with the exclusionary rule, holding that the 4th Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures isn’t a sufficient wrong in itself to warrant a remedy, but only serves to require exclusion if it provides an adequate incentive to get the cops to stop violating those darn constitutional rights.  For Scalia, he’s just not seeing it here.

Again, the reasoning is so strained as to require a few moments of reflection.  Since statements lawfully obtained can be used for any purpose, cops have a strong incentive to comply with the Constitution, and therefore have no incentive to violate the Constitution by doing precisely what they did here.  Of course, they did precisely what they did here, so apparently they have enough of an incentive to do it, as proven by the fact that they did it.  

Aside from the fact that it happened, a possibility Scalia calls “exceedingly small,”  the Court ignores the “incentive” structure when the defendant has a lawyer and the time to obtain a confession lawfully has come and gone.  At that point, the only potential for nailing the sucker is by violating Massiah, which is exactly what they did.  Moreover, when the defense seems awfully clear that it’s going to be two defendants pointing fingers at each other as the shooter, the “exceedingly small” chance that the defendant will testify becomes exceeding large. 

While it’s true that the cases in which a defendant is likely to exercise his right to testify in his own defense represents a small subset of all criminal cases, the fact remains that there are certain defenses where a defendant’s testimony is a necessary part, and within this subset, the likelihood that the defendant will testify is huge.  Say, wouldn’t that be a great time to violate Massiah?

The logic of the majority decision is staggeringly flawed, as noted by Justice Stevens’ dissent, but what’s worse is that the Court lays the burden of the police facially unconstitutional conduct on the defendant, as if it’s all his fault that they did this because he later testified in a way that they believed to be deceptive.  If the question comes down to incentives, trading off the risk of a defendant giving perjurious testimony versus the police violating the Constitution, Justice Scalia clearly comes down on violating the Constitution as the lesser of two evils.  After all, it’s not like the Constitution is the Supreme Law of the Land or anything.

Mind you, it’s still considered the better practice for defendants, particularly those like Ventris, to keep their blabbing yaps shut at all times.  But the fact that people just can’t seem to get that “remain silent” concept doesn’t mean that cops should enlist jailhouse snitches whenever convenient, just in case they get a chance to use the ill-gotten evidence later.  And as long as he’s authorizing unlawful conduct by police, our favorite Jurist throws in the fact that the right to counsel “simply isn’t worth much” for good measure, just so we know that it’s not like the 6th Amendment violation he’s giving away is a big deal anyway.

Witnesses lie all the time.  No one is asking for the Court’s approval of it.  But that doesn’t justify the opposite, the Court’s approval of clearly and concededly unconstitutional conduct by police, just in case. 

Update:  Ken Lammers, former defense lawyer who found his niche prosecuting, dissects the Ventris decision at CrimLaw, in a very thorough and lawyerly review.  Lacking the “incentives” I have in concluding that this decision is nuts, Ken nonetheless reaches the same conclusion:


That’s correct, a US Supreme Court decision is based on a belief that it is unlikely that the defendant will testify. It’s backed up by a statement that shows an amazing lack of understanding of why a statement would be taken by a police officer. The exact purpose that an officer would be taking a statement after the defendant has an attorney is to lock him into a particular version of the facts with the thought that the defendant could tell a different story at trial. After all, if the officer expected the defendant to take the stand and testify exactly in the manner most likely to lead to a conviction, why would he waste time trying to get a statement from the defendant?

[Correction per Gideon’s comment below] Even more extraordinary, Tom McKenna, a prosecutor whose blog Seeking Justice would make John Yoo blush, adds this comment to Ken’s post: left a comment which gave rise to Ken responding:


I have a problem with the Court promoting violations of the constitution. In this decision the Court states that what the government did was clearly unconstitutional. Then it says “Go ahead and do it anyway. We won’t use the only remedy we have for this violation against you.”

To my knowledge, there’s no “enhancement” to prosecuting that McKenna doesn’t support.  Until now.  When even McKenna finds the Supremes conclusion unpalatable and incomprehensible, you know we’re talking off-the-wall daffy.  In his three sentences, he sums up the basic failure of Ventris, as well as many of the decisions, as well as complaints, about the application of the exclusionof evidence at trial.  If it violates the Constitution and you won’t do anything about it, then the Constitution ceases to matter. Game over.  Thankfully, Ken possesses the thoughtfulness and fairness that reflects the best in a prosecutor.  McKenna is the alternative.

Free Speech in the First Degree

Via Doug Berman, it appears that a Utah judge is trying to keep more under wraps than secret holy underwear.

Susan Henwood, a mother of four, has been sentenced to 30 days in the Tooele County Jail because she sent a text message about a court hearing she was observing.

“She shouldn’t be there. She did nothing wrong,” her husband, Joshua Henwood, said.

In early April, Joshua was sick and couldn’t make his court appearance in a debt collection case. He sent Susan to ask for a continuance and to keep him updated, so she sent a text that said: “It doesn’t look good for you” and “They’re coming for the Polaris Ranger.”

Now I can well appreciate that a judge would be upset by someone using a communications device in the courtroom.  After all, that could cause, well, communications from a courtroom, and we can’t have that.  Seriously, if she disturbed the proceedings, then she deserved to be admonished and to have her thingy (the specific type of texting device is not mentioned) taken away until she leaves the room.  Maybe even worse, keep it for the whole day, and make her sit around until the end of court to get it back.  That’s got to be painful.

But jailing someone is another matter.  Even for a day, no less 30.

The explanation is that she wasn’t held in contempt for texting, but for content of her text.  As if they could tell that from a distance.  But even if we assume that to be true, can the judge make the leap from what was actually texted to the assumption of improper purpose?  Ah, free speech.  We are so quick to know what’s in the hearts and minds of others.

Had Henwood texted “quick, hide the Polaris Ranger so the jerks can’t seize it,” perhaps the judge would have something.  But she didn’t.  She transmitted information, likely quite accurately.  Does that mean that her son would take that information, alight from his sickbed and bury the Polaris Ranger in the front yard to keep it out of the hands of the creditor?  Maybe, but maybe not.  Who is this judge to jump to such assumption?

The tolerance for speech is a curious thing.  We protect it dearly, when it’s our speech at stake.  Yet we’re quick to shut it down when it’s someone else’s, whether because it annoys us, or because it interferes with ours being the exclusive voice, or because, as here, we find it so very easy to assume a malevolent hidden purpose and then rationalize why we are justified int silencing it.

But 30 days?  Will our debtors prisons be able to accommodate all the free speech moms?

Joe Lieberman: Arlen Spector Is My Illegitimate Son

Arlen Specter, in a move that stunned no one Democrats and Republicans alike, switched sides of the aisle.  Olympia Snowe, Republican Senator from Maine, penned an Op-Ed for the New York Times :


It is disheartening and disconcerting, at the very least, that here we are today — almost exactly eight years after Senator Jim Jeffords left the Republican Party — witnessing the departure of my good friend and fellow moderate Republican, Senator Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania, for the Democratic Party. And the announcement of his switch was all the more painful because I believe it didn’t have to be this way.

Did it have to be this way?  Only if Specter wanted a sixth term.  To this Snowe writes:


Senator Specter indicated that his decision was based on the political situation in Pennsylvania, where he faced a tough primary battle. In my view, the political environment that has made it inhospitable for a moderate Republican in Pennsylvania is a microcosm of a deeper, more pervasive problem that places our party in jeopardy nationwide.

Now I’m quite a maven on the subject of mid to north Atlantic geography, and thus know with great certainty that Pennsylvania is just a stones throw away from Connecticut, where a fellow named Ned Lamont won the senatorial Democratic primary against this meely-mouthed milquetoast named Lieberman.  Like Specter, Lieberman framed himself as a “moderate”, which in political parlance means he gets to vote with the other team whenever he wants. 

Lieberman was not happy about getting his milky white butt kicked, and so fashioned himself an Independent in the general election, where he beat back the forces of the party system by winning election.  To then prove his virtue, he engaged in a torrid love affair with Republic presidential candidate John McCain, fully expecting to be embraced by Democrats and Republicans alike for his fierce independence.  Fierce is not a word often used in connection to Lieberman.

The Senate has long been described as a gentlemen’s club, sans stripper pole.  The Senators employ the utmost courtesy in their exchanges, and are expected to remain above the fray of the House, where the riff-raff squabble amongst themselves.  The Senate is the elite chamber, and the Senators, a mere 2 per state, are the legislative stars. 

But the unseemly election of Lieberman, combined with the unseemly switcheroo of Specter, diminishes the luster of the Senate.  It’s all just crass politics, and the names and affiliations fall in the face of a stiff challenge.  Olympia Snowe’s point, that the Republican Party has failed to capture the hearts and minds of the public during the last election cycle, and is poised for yet another disaster ahead.  But her comprehension of the problem is misguided:


There is no plausible scenario under which Republicans can grow into a majority while shrinking our ideological confines and continuing to retract into a regional party. Ideological purity is not the ticket back to the promised land of governing majorities — indeed, it was when we began to emphasize social issues to the detriment of some of our basic tenets as a party that we encountered an electoral backlash.

The solution isn’t finding a new spin that will suck in the ignorant and foolish, but figuring out who you are and then finding out whether anyone actually agrees with you.  It is all about ideological purity, but at the risk of learning that your ideology is not the ideology that enough other people want to elect you to office.  In other words, be real and, if the electorate likes the real you, they will elect the real you. 

As much as some say that a two party system provides an inadequate check and balance, a one party system is far worse.  An opposition with teeth is needed to keep the majority in check, no matter how much one agrees with the majority.  Indeed, too much non-critical agreement will result in the worst possible decision-making, with no one challenging assumptions and hidden agendas. 

As for Senators Specter and Lieberman, who live close enough to one another to have a pleasant lunch once a week even when the Senate is not in session, they are the posterboys for political cynicism, ideological bankruptcy and back-stabbing.  If the voters of Pennsylvania reward Specter for his duplicity by re-electing him, they get what they deserve, Joe Lieberman.  And as for Lieberman, the apple hasn’t rolled far from the tree.

Perhaps the gentlemen of the Senate can create a caucus of two, if the Democrats and Republicans can show the fortitude to slam shut the doors to their own caucuses rather than let these snakes slither in.  If only there was someone like Al Franken in Washington to straighten these guys out.  Together with his partner, Tom Davis.

$1.3 Million Awarded to Soros Justice Fellows

The Open Society Institute, a project founded and funded by George Soros, sent out a press release naming its 2009 Soros Justice Fellows yesterday.  Regardless of what one thinks of Soros and his politics, you have to give the guy credit for putting his money where his belief system is. 



The Open Society Institute today awarded Soros Justice Fellowships to 17 outstanding individuals working to restore fairness to a deeply flawed system.

The lawyers, advocates, and journalists will tackle issues from death penalty reform and the criminalization of immigrants to juvenile justice and the challenges of parenting in prison. The Soros Justice Fellows will receive a total of more than $1.3 million.

“At a time of uncertainty and hardship for many in America, criminal justice looms as one of our most pressing challenges,” said Ann Beeson, executive director of the Open Society Institute’s U.S. Programs.  “The new group of Soros Justice Fellows will bring fresh ideas to fix a failed system that breaks America’s promise of fairness under the law.”


The recipient of fellowships will receive between $ 45,000 to $79,500 to work on projects lasting 12–18 month.  While falling somewhat short of serious money, most people who work on criminal justice projects do so as a labor of love, so having someone fund their efforts, not to mention providing the capacity to feed one’s kids in the meantime, can be quite helpful.  The recipients are listed below.

The list is an interesting one, though as I read through it, I noted two things.  First, the recipients are overwhelmingly female, which suggests that there are far more women than men interested in doing something about criminal justice problems in America, or that the Soros folks would rather give cash to women.  It could, of course, be just coincidence, but who believes in coincidence?

The more significant thing noted is that absence of anyone who blawgs on the subject of criminal justice.  I immediately wondered, given the Herculean efforts of people like Packratt at Injustice in Seattle, or Scott Henson at Grits for Breakfast, either of whom would be a perfect recipient of a fellowship like this, whether there was no consideration of blawgers because they were unworthy, they were doing it anyway or the folks handing out the cash weren’t aware of their efforts. 

I queried the good Soros people on the absence of blawgers, and was told that, since their goals include public awareness of criminal justice issues, they would “welcome” applications from blawgers.  “Applications”, I responded?  “Feral blawgers don’t ‘apply’ for things. It’s not in our nature to do anything so ‘official’.”  But that doesn’t prevent the Soros bankers from doing a quick spin around the blawgosphere to see the efforts being made here to enlighten the world as to the frightening reality of our criminal justice system.

So be warned: There are people out there with large bank accounts, even in this economy, who will potentially fund the efforts to keep pushing out, day after day, the unpleasant news that all is not well in American justice.  But if they won’t get off their butts to look for those worthy of a fellowship, then the only way to get one is to jump through their hoops and then beg for love.  Somehow, that doesn’t strike me as the blawgospheric way, and yet we are doing every day, for free, because it’s right, what they hope to accomplish with a checkbook. 

Of course, we do it more and better, but let’s not make them feel inadequate about it.  After all, they only have money.

And now, the 2009 Soros Justice Fellows:

Mass Incarceration


Khalilah Brown-Dean; ersonName w:st=”on”>scholarersonName>; Yale University; New Haven, CT


Brown-Dean will test voter registration and mobilization strategies in five high-incarceration communities in Connecticut. Although Connecticut reformed its felony disenfranchisement laws in 2001, confusion about voter eligibility has resulted in weakened civic engagement.



Renay Frankel; lawyer; Committee for Public Counsel Services; Boston, MA


Frankel will create an innovative partnership between criminal and civil legal services in Massachusetts to ensure more effective legal representation for low-income defendants. A lack of coordination among attorneys can result in a person pleading guilty to a criminal charge without understanding that a conviction can significantly hamper their ability to find a job, secure housing, or pursue an education.  


Patrice Gaines; author; Lake Wylie, SC


Gaines will write a series of articles exploring the impact of mass incarceration on African American communities. In some neighborhoods, half of the young male population is in prison or on probation or parole.



Catherine Greensfelder; lawyer; National Housing Law Project; Oakland, CA


Greensfelder will work with community organizations to improve access to housing for formerly incarcerated people. Laws that ban individuals with recent convictions from public housing have led to endemic homelessness among people on parole and probation.


Lauren Melodia; community organizer; Center for Community Alternatives; New York, NY


Melodia will work with community members in rural “prison towns” to re-think their local economies. In New York, as in many other states, the warehousing of urban residents in remote rural prisons has proven to be a poor substitute for viable economic development. Melodia’s project involves a collaborative effort to help these rural areas develop sustainable models for growth.


Nancy Mullane; broadcast journalist and producer; San Francisco, CA


Mullane will produce a radio documentary about men and women awaiting parole in California. A 1988 law politicized the parole process by making the governor, and not parole boards, the final authority on early release decisions for people serving life sentences with the possibility of parole. Mullane’s project will take listeners inside a world where people struggle to reform their lives amid diminishing hope that they will ever be granted parole.


Jessica Pupovac; journalist; Chicago, IL


Pupovac will explore the emerging crisis of an aging prison population. By 2010, one-third of all federal and state prison inmates will be over the age of 50—a development that portends significant hardship for people both inside and outside of prison.  


Immigrant Detention and Wrongful Arrest


Sam Brooke; lawyer; Southern Poverty Law Center; Montgomery, AL


Brooke will engage in advocacy and public education to curb arbitrary detentions and abuses at Immigration and Customs Enforcement facilities in the southeastern United States.


Amalia Greenberg Delgado; lawyer; American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California; San Francisco, CA


Greenberg Delgado will develop a public education program to counter myths about immigrants and crime, and advocate for improved law-enforcement practices in immigrant communities. State and local police in California increasingly target people based not on suspected criminal activity but on supposed immigration violations. This tactic has made immigrant neighborhoods less safe and places a severe burden on families and communities.


Juvenile Justice


Liane Rozzell; community organizer; laceName w:st=”on”>Legal Aid JusticelaceName> laceType w:st=”on”>CenterlaceType>; Charlottesville, VA


Rozzell will build an organization of family, youth, and community allies to reform Virginia’s juvenile justice system. Many children in Virginia are incarcerated or placed in the adult system, and children of color are targeted disproportionately.


Reentry


Clemmie Greenlee; community organizer; Urban EpiCenter; Nashville, TN


Greenlee will train current and former gang members in Nashville to advocate for criminal justice reform. A formerly incarcerated community organizer and advocate, Greenlee believes that gang-involved youth have the potential to become positive agents of change. Since the murder of her son over a decade ago, Greenlee has devoted herself to helping those with criminal records transform their lives and their communities.


Policing


Anita Khandelwal; lawyer; The Defender Association; Seattle, WA


Khandelwal will challenge a common practice by the Seattle Police Department that targets homeless and poor people and bans them from entire city neighborhoods for years at a time.


Death Penalty


Wyatt Feeler; lawyer; ACLU Capital Punishment Project; Durham, NC


Feeler’s project seeks to bring a measure of fairness to the jury selection process and thereby reduce the number of death sentences. Jury selection in death penalty cases is heavily skewed in favor of the prosecution. As a result, jurors in capital cases tend to be more willing than the public at large to sentence defendants to death.


Kristin Traicoff; lawyer; Capital Post-Conviction Project of Louisiana; New Orleans, LA


Traicoff will challenge Louisiana’s lethal injection protocol. Lethal injection enjoys an undeserved reputation as a humane way to kill. For years, advocates and medical professionals have maintained that the process can produce excruciating pain.


Halting the Export of Prisoners


Carrie Ann Shirota; lawyer and advocate; Maui Economic Opportunity, Inc.; Wailuku, HI


Shirota will work to mitigate and reduce the transfer of incarcerated Hawaiians to mainland prisons thousands of miles away. Hawaii’s growing reliance on transfers severs family ties, disconnects Hawaiians from cultural traditions, gives rise to prison gangs, and complicates community reintegration. 


Parenting from Prison


Shannon Heffernan; broadcast journalist and producer; Chicago, IL


Heffernan will go into prisons and communities in the Chicago area to record the sorrows and aspirations of incarcerated parents. Although two-thirds of people in federal prisons and over one-half of those in state prisons are parents of minor children, few Americans understand the trials and heartbreak of those who try to maintain family ties while incarcerated.


Children’s Literature and Criminal Justice


Katheryn Russell-Brown; ersonName w:st=”on”>scholarersonName>; Gainesville, FL


Russell-Brown, a criminologist and law professor, will develop children’s books on criminal justice issues to help young people understand the court system, corrections, and the police. Despite the myriad ways the criminal justice system affects American communities, books for young children seldom discuss these issues.


 

Dreier To Plead: Keep Yer Stinkin’ Deal

Marc Dreier, who stands as a testament to the fact that stealing a ton of money doesn’t mean you have good taste in art, has decided to plead guilty to the superseding indictment for his $400 Million fraud, according to the WSJ Law Blog. 

Gerald L. Shargel, Dreier’s lawyer, said his client will enter a guilty plea to all the charges in a superseding indictment unsealed in March — conspiracy, securities fraud, money laundering and five counts of wire fraud. Dreier will plead guilty without a deal in place with the government, Shargel said. His lawyer had previously indicated they expected a quick resolution of the case.

This appears to be an open plea, meaning that there is no deal on the table.  As was asked when Bernie Madoff did the same thing, why?

Unlike the Madoff cases, where the open plea made little sense given how many issues were on the table and lost in the process, an open plea in this case appears to have some very different considerations.  Shargel is a very smart lawyer, and no doubt has calculated the decision with great precision. 

My bet is that the government offered Dreier bupkus on the deal.  A plea to a guidelines sentence with three points off for acceptance.  Big deal.  In the typical SDNY plea agreement, he would have given up his opportunity to argue for a downward departure, and more significantly, an appropriate sentence under 3553(a).  He would be locked into the worst possible scenario, conceding the propriety of the guidelines and agreeing to be sentenced within them. 

In a post-Booker, non-mandatory guidelines world, the open plea may offer far more opportunity to obtain a fair sentence than the government is inclined to provide by agreement.  There’s little doubt that the evidence against Dreier was going to slam dunk him, but that’s not the end of the story.  This was such a bizarre scenario that there is likely to be some strong mitigating factors to consider.  The government wasn’t impressed?  Who cares.  The sentence is no longer left to the government’s discretion alone. 

Which brings us to the judge, Jed Rakoff.  While Judge Rakoff is no softie, he has shown himself to be bold and reasonable, having rejected the guidelines and mandatory minimum stacking approaches when he finds them to exceed that which is necessary to fulfill the purpose of 3553(a).  It will be no walk in the park, but Shargel and Dreier at least have a judge who will listen to reason and give them every opportunity to make their pitch for an appropriate sentence.

Unlike Madoff, who has little chance of ever walking the earth a free man again, Marc Dreier may well have a chance to breath free air some day.  After all, he only stole $400 Million, a drop in the bucket compared to the big boy these days.  And if there is any chance that he will do so, this appears to be the route most likely to succeed.

It’s not up to Shargel to put together a sentencing pitch that encompasses the mitigating factors that will help Judge Rakoff to conclude that Marc Dreier need not spend the entirety of his life in prison to satisfy the legitimate sentencing considerations of 3553(a).  This should be a fascinating, and instructive, lesson in sentencing when the time comes.