Author Archives: SHG

Hug A Victim

This is National Crime Victims’ Rights Week, our government says.  I wasn’t aware of this until Doug Berman let the cat out of the bag.  The cat was likely a victim.  President Obama wants to raise awareness of victims’ rights.  I do too.

The victim of a wrong must have access to the courts, to be compensated and made whole for their suffering at the hands of another.  We must stand shoulder to shoulder with victims and support them, both in their time of need and in their quest for justice.  But there is something I don’t get about my fellow supporters of victims.

Over at Law.com is a National Law Journal article about the victims of environmental crimes, It discusses the alleged abuse of the Crime Victims Rights Act in cases where potentially huge numbers of people are affected and seek to insert themselves in the criminal process against alleged corporate polluters.  More about that later.

It occurs to me that there is a substantial overlap between the people deeply concerned for victims having rights in a criminal prosecution who strive to deny victims their right to compensation in a civil proceeding.  Curious, no?  Why is it that victims are good when going after the criminal, and bad when going after the negligent physician or corporation?  Why is it that they fully support a third table in the well of a criminal case, but want to slam the courthouse doors shut on victims when they seek damages for the pain and suffering?  Worse still, why is it that they applaud punitive punishment but despise punitive damages?

As for the claims that the CVRA has given an unintended advantage to the government in environmental crimes, consider this:


“The BP case and the W.R. Grace case are harbingers of things to come,” said Paul Cassell, who is representing the victims in the W.R. Grace case and represented victims in the BP case. “It’s one of the new areas where crime victims advocates are trying to make sure victims’ rights are protected,” Cassell said of environmental crimes.

But as for whether crime victims in general deserve a greater voice in environmental cases, he said the CVRA gives them that right. “It was designed to make victims participants in the criminal justice process,” Cassell said. “And it was designed to extend rights to all victims of crimes — across the board.”

Of course, Cassell’s vision is derived solely from the fact that the CVRA creates “rights” out of vapor.  Congress says victims have rights, and so they must.  The defense lawyers respond:


“You’re blurring the criminal process with the traditional civil process where people can go and get any harm remedied and get compensation. And by blurring the process, I think you’re potentially harming and prejudicing defendants’ rights,” said Jerry Block, a partner at Venable and a former chief of DOJ’s environmental crimes section.

Judson W. Starr, also a Venable partner and a former chief of that DOJ section, believes the CVRA is being misused. “I think the act was originally intended for fraud, murder and drug cases, not environmental crimes,” said Starr. “I’m feeling that the original intent of the act did not contemplate an array of witnesses as large as the potential is in environmental crimes cases. … Right now, it puts another party at the table in what is already a complicated environment.”

Notice anything curious about these views?  They jump at the chance to sell out the considerations that apply to cases that don’t directly affect their pocketbook, but whine that it’s unfair in their particular circumstances alone.  They do not challenge the concept that crime victims are entitled to be thrust into the adversarial mix of a criminal prosecution, but just that victims have no business being involved in their cases.  You can almost hear the disgust dripping from their lips as they utter the filthy words, “fraud, murder and drug cases,” those low-life crimes that the pristine hands of venerable Venable lawyers would never touch.

The doctrinal flaws, inherent contradictions, facial inconsistencies that fly around the crime victims rights issue, and are repeated by seemingly intelligent people, disappear in the face of our inherent sympathy toward victims.  Who doesn’t care about victims, as long as they keep their grubby little victim mitts off corporate cash.  Then victims become money grubbers hellbent on destroying capitalism and our economy, denying healthcare to the masses by forcing physicians to practice defensive medicine and the like.

So it’s National Crime Victims’ Week.  Hug a crime victim.  Help a crime victim to obtain compensation and care.  Support crime victims to recover the life stolen from them by the act of another.  And in the process, consider whether crime victims are better served by the CVRA, undermining the basic structure of criminal proceedings designed to provide just a hint of fairness to the accused, or by supporting the ability of victims to obtain civil relief, to compensate them for their suffering and to make them whole again.



When Your Manhood Measures 3 1/2 Inches

Despite my admonitions, many of my brethren continue to be charmed by the siren call of the marketers in the belief that blogging and twittering, if only done according to their magic Rules.  But in case you haven’t considered just how ridiculous all of this can really be, consider the mindset of this fellow, a marketing genius by his own assessment, courtesy of Boing Boing.



It’s all about business cards.  That’s right, you are only half a lawyer if you don’t have a business card that substitutes for origami when you have nothing else to play with.  It’s the key to success.  It’s the magic bullet. 

This is insanity.  As lawyers, we are reputed to have a modicum of intelligence, and at minimum cursory reasoning skills which would allow us to consider and recognize that we are being told crap.  This is utter, total crap.  The problem is that this crap reflects the mindset of the marketer, for whom ordinary details take on overwhelming significance, as if each is the critical key to wild success.  It’s the psychotic’s view of the world.  Is this your view?

I’ve had numerous business cards over the course of my career.  I tend to make sure my card is on good, heavy stock, so that it doesn’t look all tattered within minutes of handing it out.  Often, a client won’t need my card right away, so it needs to remain in readable condition for when it’s needed.  If it doesn’t, then it’s failed to serve its purpose

My business card contains the basic information needed to reach me, printed in clear, readable type.  When my clients need to call, they may be stressed, excited, even agitated.  If the number is big and easy to read, it makes it easier for my clients to see it and call it.  If not, then it’s failed to serve its purpose.

My business card has no colors.  My business card has no graphics.  My business card has no cute sayings or mottos.  It’s utilitarian.  It fulfills its purpose of providing my contact information.  It gets the job done.  That’s its purpose.

What my business card is not is cute, tricky, oddly sized or unduly complex.  My card is meant to be carried in a wallet, because I want it there when someone needs me.  My quality as an attorney is not dependent on my business card.  If it is, then all is lost and I am unworthy of the trust my clients place in me.  I do not strive to draw attention to myself via gimmicks, as if that was the measure of worth. 

I’ve seen some interesting business cards from other lawyers.  Some are so cheap looking and feeling as to be disturbing.  They crumble in your hand as you touch them, and don’t last long enough to make it to the garbage can.  Cheap is a negative reflection, telling me that the lawyer either can’t afford a card of decent quality or has a low-rent approach to his practice.  The card shouldn’t be a negative influence.

But is a card a positive, a paper rainmaker?  One lawyer whom I respect greatly gave ma a business card made of metal.  I was impressed, recognizing that it served one of the important features of a business card.  It was indestructible.  That’s important.  But it was expensive, and it was a bit flashing.  I thought about it, and showed it to a few people.  More people found it slightly unseemly, and one even thought it seemed a bit desperate.  I personally like it because of its indestructible quality.

I’ve known many lawyers with 4 color cards, with logos and mottos (even when deemed unethical).  I’ve known many lawyers whose cards have gold-embossed seals, making them look very official.  They don’t have any more business, or better business, than the quality of the services dictate.  The card did not bring them success.  The quality of their representation and client service brought them success.  Or not.

Back to our erstwhile business card guru.  Does he persuade you that by following his rant, you too can achieve great success?  Or does he strike you as a lunatic, utterly obsessed with his own gimmick and fundamentally disconnected from reality?  If the latter, why then do you think that marketers know some secret that you don’t know, and if only by following the rules you too can have clients coming out of your butt?  If such a magic bullet existed, we would all have it.  But then, they would neutralize each other and we would be right back where we started.  Do you really believe in magic?

For this marketer, the business card, a mere 3 1/2 inches of paper, is a substitute for his manhood.  Is it the same for you?

Obviously, not every marketer is as insane as this guy.  But then, a point is often best made by the extreme example.  The secret to a successful law practice isn’t your business card, or having a blog, or being on twitter and adhering to the 29 rules (or less).  All of these may be fine things to do, particularly if done well.  But contrary to the hype, they will never be a substitute for the quality of your representation.  There is no 3 1/2 inch magic bullet.

No Right, But Utterly Wrong

Sadly, there is an inexhaustible supply of things that are beyond heart-breaking to a parent.  Having your daughter strip searched by an unduly officious school administrator is one.  Having death-scene photos of your decapitated daughter spread around the internet for fun by some California Highway Patrol officers is another.

From Dan Solove at Co-Op,


CHP.gifIn Newsweek, Jessica Bennett tells the tragic story about a family being harassed by the spread of death-scene images of their daughter, who was killed in an automobile accident. The photos of Nikki Catsouras were particularly gruesome — Nikki was decapitated in the crash. According to the article, soon after the crash, photos taken by the California Highway Patrol started circulating on the Internet.

Apparently, the two California Highway Patrol officers took the pictures and improperly circulated them to others. The photos then started spreading like a virus around the Internet.

I can think of no better word than “diseased” to describe the conduct of these officers.  This is just fundamentally sick.  There has got to be a special place in hell for people who would do something like this.

So the family sued the CHP, alleging, inter alia, that the release of the crime-scene photos was a violation of their right to informational privacy under Whalen v. Roe, 429 U.S. 589 (1977).


But the trial court threw out their claim. In a pithy order, the court declared that no duty exists between the highway patrol officers and the family members.

Solove isn’t buying.


The California Highway Patrol owes a duty to all citizens to not violate their constitutional rights. This includes the Catsouras family’s constitutional right to information privacy.

The constitutional right to information privacy provides protection if a person has a privacy interest, if government officials violated that interest by disclosing personal information, and if the privacy interest isn’t outweighed by the government’s interest in disclosure. All of these elements are met.

Once a privacy interest is identified, the government has a duty to avoid unwarranted disclosure of personal information unless there is a countervailing interest that outweighs the privacy interest. In the Catsouras case, the disclosure of the photos was clearly unwarranted.

This goes to one of the fundamental problems that stands between the firmly-held expectation of the citizenry and the institutional protectionism of government, particularly law enforcement.  Since there are so many possible ways in which cops can fail to perform their duties, or actively cause harm to others, because they think it’s funny, or are inherently venal human beings hiding behind shields, or just aren’t smart enough to avoid doing something so inherently wrong as post photos of a decapitated young woman on the internet, government feels the need to protect itself from the citizens who it exists to serve and are simultaneously harmed by its failure to serve.

If nothing else, the distinction between failed duties, such as arriving timely, handling a situation properly, actually doing all the fine things that are shown on the multitude of TV cops shows to capture the love of the public, and affirmative harms done to people by diseased cops like these two wannabe-Ponches, should comprise the dividing line between protectionism and obvious, and well-deserved, liability.

My brightline test would be simple: If it makes you want to puke, then liability exists.  Do we really need to engage in deep analysis to know that this is just so very wrong?

The Gripes of Wrath

Val Deming is a wrathful woman.  Hurt her feelings and you can bet that she’s going to do something about it.  Do it online and she’s going to come after you. You see, Val Deming will not be the typical female victim of cyber attacks, allowing it to push her into a hole, deprive her of her cyber civil rights and take it like some helpless female.  That she has yet to receive a Victim of the Week Award from the Feminist Law Profs mystifies me.

But the, Val Deming has some issues that are peculiar to her situation.  You see, Deming is the Chief of Police in Orlando, County of Disney, State of Florida.  And according to Randazza, who keeps a close watch on things in that most ambivalent of states, she’s a pretty darn good Chief of Police, save for the stolen gun incident (which could happen to anybody).

Even so, not everyone in Orlando is a fan.  From the Orlando Sentinel :


Valdemings.com is run by Ezell “Easy” Harris, a frequent critic of Demings’, and contains a disclaimer stating the chief has no association with the site.

What kind of cool stuff does Harris, who owns a travel agency, put on his website?


Harris said he won’t take the site down because he’s simply exercising his First Amendment rights. “If someone didn’t tip the Orlando Sentinel about this gun, we probably wouldn’t even know it happened,” Harris said. “I thought it was wrong that the public didn’t know.”

The Web site also contains an article on a stolen Orlando police car that was found in Parramore and a piece on Demings’ husband, Orange County Sheriff Jerry Demings, and his policy against media leaks.

The site further criticizes the Police Department’s handling of a 2007 case in which an officer was accused of pushing a woman down stairs at the now-defunct Club Paris downtown. The officer, Fernando Trinidad, was cleared criminally, but an internal investigation concluded he violated departmental standards of conduct.

Frankly, rather pedestrian misconduct if you ask me.  Given the wealth of really bad things that cops can do, coupled with size and breath of matters that come before a department like Orlando’s, Demings sounds like she has things fairly well under control.  So while she may prefer that Harris’ website not exist, it ought to be the sort of thing she can easily shrug off with a smile.  But no, apparently she can’t.

Harris’ gripes evoked the Wrath of Val Deming. 


Demings’ attorney, Griffith J. Winthrop III, accuses Harris in an April 17 letter of “maligning” and defaming the chief. The letter also says Harris violated the law by using her “persona” and identity and claims Harris’ behavior is “malicious.”

Demings is demanding that the Web site be taken down and threatens to sue Harris if he refuses.

This is where hurt feelings could turn this misbegotten choice on its head and force Deming to find out the hard way that there’s a price for feigned victimhood, even when it happens that you’re female. 


Harris refused to take down the site – correctly claiming that he is “simply exercising his First Amendment rights.” However, Winthrop (Demings attorney) says that Harris is portraying Demings in a “false light.”

Winthrop would not elaborate on Demings’ claims or the logic behind them. He said he prefers to argue the matter in court. (source<)


Poor Mr. Winthrop. When you represent a public figure and threaten a citizen for criticizing that public figure, you have to go to two courts — one being the court of public opinion. Winthrop and Demings need to simply back out of this hole slowly, apologetically, and contritely. If Winthrop does get a chance to argue this matter in court, it isn’t going to end well for his client — nor will his reputation likely ever be the same. Of course, I don’t predict that they will take that advice.


I get a funny feeling that Mr. Winthrop and Ms. Demings are about to learn some valuable lessons about defamation law and litigation public relations. In fact, I’ll provide some here, free of charge.


As Randazza points out in excruciatingly painful detail, the fact that she’s a public official doesn’t help either.  For a primer on defamation law and a great discussion (including photos!) of the Streisand Effect, read Randazza’s post.  One of the funniest lines within the explanation of the law of defamation comes Demings lawyer:


“Truth is not always a defense,” Winthrop said. “I hope he [Harris] gets himself a really good lawyer,” he said. (source)

You can’t make this stuff up, but it provides the perfect jumping off point to note why such indulgent demands, in the grander scheme of things, tend to backfire and take a matter of little consequence and even less interest and turn it into a sensation:  When you accept the responsibility that comes with a position of substantial authority and power, you accept having your actions subject to public scrutiny.  Val Deming is a public official, and her actions should be publicly known and openly challenged, even if she’s a darn good police chief.  That’s how being a public official works, regardless of gender.

And if that hurts your feelings. tough nuggies.

When The Magistrate Twits

The phenomenon of twitter is hardly an American thing, captivating cutting edge Brits as well.  But when IT consultant, professor and part-time Magistrate Steve Molyneux decided to combine his fancies, he found that the world wasn’t quite ready for a twittering Mag.  Molyneux explains his situation in a podcast with  CharonQC on his InsiteLaw Magazine.

Molyneux, who twits under the name @profontheprowl, was called in to sit as Magistrate one night, expecting the usual drunks.  Instead, he found himself being asked to set bond for accused bank robbers, a somewhat bigger matter than he was used to.  And so he twitted. 



Finished hearing bail. 3 refused for planning robbery of £480,000 from Tsb in Dawley, Telford.1st defendant. Conspiricy to rob TSB of £500,000. Good start – wrong previous convictions presented.Just about to hear application from 3 robbers from Manchster as to whether to remand or not.Called into Court today to deal with those arrested last night and held in custody. I guess they will be mostly drunks but you never know.


Someone complained, the matter escalated until he felt constrained to resign after 16 years of serving as a magistrate.  From the BBC :


“I was using the technology after hearing a remand case just to inform local people and others that follow me in my role of magistrate and didn’t think I’d done anything wrong.

“I didn’t prejudice a case, I didn’t do anything like that.”

Of course, twits being what they are, certain extraneous words, like “accused” or “alleged” were omitted to fit his thoughts into 140 characters.  But that’s twitter, right?  Certainly Molyneux didn’t think this was enough to turn perfectly innocent twits into earth shattering problems.


In fact, he argued, his feed was providing people with a service.

“I use it to communicate with the public. The people who read the Twitter read the same thing in the newspaper that evening.

“The fact [is] I used a piece of technology that allowed others [to know about the case outcome] that may not have read the local newspaper but were just as interested. I saw no harm in it.”

Molyneux saw himself on the cutting edge, doing nothing more than using today’s flavor of technology to let his tweeps know what he was up to. Indeed, after he resigned under pressure, he decided to apply a little pressure of his own by twitting:



Thanks for support. I believe the debate is that maybe Govt should look at twitter as 21st Century Court reporter.

So is twitter the “21st Century court reporter,” or an improper extrajudicial statement, outside the hearing of the defendants and their counsel, reflecting an inarticulate and improper biased description of the accused?  Put another way, does the fact that twitter exists mean that it’s an appropriate fit for all uses?

Listening to Charon’s podcast with Molyneux, I have no doubt that he meant no harm and his twits, to the extent that they failed to use the appropriate phraseology in discussing his actions as a sitting magistrate weren’t intended to reflect a preconceived notion that the defendants were guilty.  I similarly have no doubt that Molyneux failed to perceive the problems raised.

Twitter, by its intrinsic limitations, is a particularly poor medium to convey delicate messages.  When you only have 140 characters, something has to give.  Here, it happened to be the level of neutral detail demanded of someone sitting in the position of Magistrate, instead offering a gross description devoid of nuance.  But that’s only part of the problem.

Should judges be expressing their thoughts on cases before them publicly, yet off the record?  Twitter is not the equivalent of a court reporter, as it doesn’t do any of the things a court reporter is expected  to do.  It’s not a verbatim transcript.  It does not reflect the statements of the parties in the case.  It’s public, yet not public at all if you don’t follow the twitterer and don’t know it has been the subject of twits. 

Much as I realize that testing the parameters of new technologies is something of an article of faith for many, Molyneux pushed the envelope too far when he failed to distinguish the difference between his twitting his thoughts as a Magistrate versus his other roles.  Whether there is, should be, will be parameters for the appropriate use of twitter by a judge has yet to be seen, and is certainly subject to worthy debate.  But the unilateral decision to do so demonstrated poor judgment and reflected a fundamental misunderstanding of the obligations inherent in his judicial role as opposed to just a guy who likes to twit. 

It really wasn’t up to Molyneux to decide for himself whether this was a harmless exercise and his twits were inconsequential.  It wasn’t up to him to omit the little detail words, like “accused” and “alleged” to fit his thoughts into 140 characters.  Whether it was worthy of his resignation is another matter, as it barely registers in the scheme of judicial impropriety, but it still was poor choice.

It’s Broken, Just Because You Say So

Many people in the blawgosphere are surprised to learn of my interest in Seth Godin, given my general antipathy toward marketing.  But his way of seeing things gives me pause, and makes me rethink my way of seeing things.  Things that makes us think are good, and Seth makes me think.  It’s not that I necessarily agree, or that his advice applies as well to my world as to his, but he still makes me think.

One of Seth’s recent posts really had me going for a while,  The premise is that “things are broken” because you think they are broken.  It doesn’t matter what someone else thinks.  It doesn’t matter whether there is a good reason for them to be the way they are, and it surely doesn’t matter whether there is no reason for them to be the way they are.  Most importantly, it doesn’t matter that someone else doesn’t care or doesn’t think it’s a big deal.  If they are broken to you, then they are broken.

The post is comprised of a video of one of Seth’s lectures, and Seth provides a list of reasons why things are broken, and a bunch of examples of things he thinks are broken.  Some are quite funny and make his point well, while others don’t strike me as broken at all.  But then, that’s his point.  It doesn’t matter if I agree that they are broken, as it’s enough that he thinks so.

Why do I raise this?  It’s quite possible that there is nothing more widely perceived as broken, and simultaneously more deeply stuck in its ways, than the criminal law.  The only thing coming even close is civil law.  Notice a commonality between the two?

Lawyers, judges and legislators find it easy to explain why this mass perception is wrong, and shrug off the public’s belief that our legal system is broken.  We need our rules, they say.  It must be done this way.  This is the product of hundreds of years of development of the law, and it’s the best system ever devised.  We know this because we repeat it with great regularity.

I am not suggesting that this has anything to do with new technologies, which I doubt will cause anywhere near the seismic shift that its advocates claim.  In fact, I think this is far more fundamental, utterly unrelated to the type of minituae that lawyers tend to focus on and debate.  On our best day, the legal system cannot seem to satisfy the needs of our society to deliver a prompt, inexpensive and just result.

My posts are regularly filled with stories of injustice, some of which are later corrected.  Consider some of the regular fodder and say with a straight face that we’re doing a bang up job of delivering justice.  Tell it to the child denied her parent.  Tell it to the paraplegic beaten for not jumping upon demand fast enough.  Sure, we have a million excuses/explanations (lawyers are particularly good at coming up with excuses), but if you’re not vested in rationalizing away failures, it’s just plain, old broken.

And just so you know, it doesn’t matter if you disagree.  It’s broken, because that’s what non-lawyers (and some lawyers as well) think.  And that’s the point.

How To Blog, As If They Have A Clue

Blawgers, meaning those people who actually have blawgs and actually blawg with some modicum of recognition in the blawgosphere, disagree a lot about the way to do it.  From the self-styled marketers to Kevin O’Keefe’s LexBlog to guys like me, there are many disagreements about how to do it and what makes for a viable blawg.  Weekly, if not daily, somebody puts out a list of really cool tips about blogging, and the blawgosphere loves a list, not matter how ridiculous the list or dubious the source.

But things never got as goofy as this promotion for a CLE by the New York State Bar Association that ended up in my email box.












New York State Bar Association
NYSBACLE



Live Programs |  Online Programs |  Recorded Programs |  NYSBA Books





Telephone Seminar


Internet Marketing for Law Firms
How to Ramp Up Visibility and Build Clientele


Wednesday, May 6, 2009 | 12:00 – 2:00 p.m.
2.0 MCLE Credits


In an era when it is harder and harder to reach new clients, an increasing number of firms are using the Web to reach a wide audience quickly, inexpensively and effectively. Learn the secrets of Internet Marketing—not just having a website—but using the Web in a variety of ways to generate business legally and ethically.


Learn what other firms are successfully doing and learn how to:



  • Use the Internet as a cost effective tool to gain prominence in your field of practice
  • Leverage Web-based communication tools to reach a wider audience and build your reputation
  • Find and use opportunities to author online publications as a method to gain higher visibility
  • How to use advertising on select Web sites to reach your target audience
  • Keep up with your peers and learn what they are doing to market themselves
  • Save time and money by avoiding the common pitfalls

The Internet can raise a firm’s profile, signal credibility, attract clients, strengthen referral sources and garner media attention. Yet firms must know how to avoid the ethical and legal pitfalls. If firms, or those working on their behalf, are not careful, they might subject themselves to potential liability. This program will address:



  • Ethical issues associated with online marketing under the revised New York Rules of Professional Conduct
  • Other legal considerations implicated by presence on the Web
  • Elements of risk that firms should understand when engaging in online activities

Speakers:
Adam Bialek, Partner Wilson Elser Moskowitz Edelman & Dicker, LLP
Stacy S. Salmon, Marketing, Phillips Nizer, LLP

_____________________________________

Now I don’t know the two speakers who are, in the NYSBA’s eyes, sufficiently versed in the subject of blogging to present a CLE on the subject, but I do know one thing:  In the blawgsphere, they don’t exist. 

They come from big firms, the type of law firms that the NYSBA loves to draw from when it looks for “credible” sources of information for its CLEs.  After all, if the firms are credible, then speakers from the firms must be credible as well.

Hello?  Are any of my fellow blawgers familiar with the brilliant and respected Wilson Elser blog?  No?  Well, what about the Phillips Nizer blog?  No, not that one either?  But they must have blogs, since the NYSBA is having them teach a CLE on how to blawg to its members, lawyers all.  They must.  Mustn’t they?

Apparently, no.  There are many out there who are abundantly competent to teach lawyers how to blawg.  Kevin O’Keefe, for one, is amazingly knowledgeable about the technology and what tends to distinguish the successful blawg from the thousands of blawgs that fade into obscurity.  What do Bialek and Salmon bring to the table?  Neither firm has a blog, and neither Bialek or Salmon are bloggers.  So what would possibly compel the NYSBA to select these two individuals to teach a CLE on the subject? 

To the extent that this reflects the absurdity of mandatory CLE (note that you get 2 credits for this particular one), it’s a doozy.  Is this what they had in mind when requiring lawyers to continue their legal education for the benefit of the public and to enhance their professional skills and qualifications? 

But from my blawging perspective, this promotes exactly what the blawgosphere doesn’t need.  We don’t need lawyers, who may have some real desire to join the blawgosphere by offering some worthwhile insight, being told how to do it by people who lack any indicia of knowledge or competence or who suggest that they can teach others how to “market themselves” as if that’s all the blawgosphere is good for,   

Should we have lawyers who have never tried a case teaching cross-examination?  Should we have lawyers who have never closed a deal teaching transactions?  Should we have lawyers who have never blawged teaching blawging?  I think not.

What a joke this is, and when the influx into the blawgosphere of self-promotional, worthless blawgs has so badly cluttered the blawgosphere that no one cares to sort through the chafe to find some wheat, remember that you have the NYSBA to thank for its help. 

Next week:  Twittering for Fun and Profit, brought to you by Skadden Arps.

Slander, Talk Radio and Cyber Civil Rights

Given the recent hubbub over Danielle Citron’s call to silence the cyberbullies as a matter of civil rights, based upon the claim that it disproportionately hurts the feelings of women, the 9th Circuits decision in Gardner v. Martino may put to rest at least one of the claims.  From the San Francisco Chronicle :


A federal appeals court had some advice Friday for anyone whose reputation gets trashed on talk radio: Don’t bother suing for slander, because no one reasonably expects objective facts from the typical talk show host.

It can be an unpleasant world out there, with people saying mean things in public forums that hurt one’s feelings.  Talk radio, as opposed to a chat room or website, reaches a substantially greater audience and carries, at least to its listeners, who are often adherents to whatever political views the host promotes, great credibility.  Still, as the court held, it is unreasonable to believe that it’s reliable. 

If Talk Radio commentary is beneath the credibility threshold for slander, how then can anonymous comments on a thread on a website be elevated to the stature necessary to be worthy of impairing free speech at all, and then to justify a shift in responsibility from the speaker to the forum owner and pipeline provider, third parties to any speech uttered, holding them liable for the hurt feelings caused by anonymous speech if they don’t become part of the speech police?

As was argued by Marc Randazza, though found unworthy of attention by the scholarly chorus, one of the primary flaws of this approach to silence hurtful speech was that it was so lacking in credibility from the outset as to hardly constitute a serious threat.  In the event that it turned from stupid, venal speech into action, then existing law kicks in, which is sufficient to address the harm.  But the anonymous garbage spewed by idiots on the internet just didn’t reach the level of credibility to justify a wholesale shift in paradigm.

This aspect, of course, was only one of the issues tossed into the hat in favor of regulating speech online under the umbrella of cyber civil rights, but it was a critical one in that it elevated what some considered comments that, despite the fact that they hurt people’s feelings and made outrageous allegations about others, were facially lacking in credibility to the status of slander. 

In response, the point was made that these were juvenile, idiotic comments made by people who were so gutless as to be unwilling to sign their name to them.  They were not to be taken seriously, and they were unworthy of being taken seriously.  This response was in turn ridiculed as the “boys will be boys” argument, which supporters of cyber civil rights contended was an inadequate answer to those whose reputations were harmed by these comments and were unworthy of protection.  In other words, who cares if these jerks and just jerks; these are jerks who are hurting women’s feeling with their comments and their free speech right to post jerky things should not trump women’s rights to speak without fear ot attack by the jerks.

Aside from the widely assumed but as yet unproven assertion that this is a women’s issue at all, the 9th Circuit decision makes an important dent in the CCR advocates argument:  Hurtful though it may be, if it isn’t credible, it can’t be slander.  While no one has (yet) claimed that Talk Radio is a civil rights issue for women, it clearly has a greater impact based on its far broader audience reach and far greater credibility than anonymous comments on Auto-Admit.  And yet it is incapable of giving rise to actionable slander because it is what every reasonable person knows it to be: Hyperbolic commentary intended to feed the bias of its audience, with little concern for truth or accuracy. 

The call to record and maintain the identities of these anonymous attackers is based upon the need to identify the miscreants so that the victims can go after them.  But go after them for what?  If Talk Radio doesn’t give rise to slander for lack of credibility, then how could an anonymous, baseless attack on a website be held sufficiently credible to maintain a slander action?  It can’t, and it never should.  It is not credible.  It was never credible.  There may be many hurt feelings, but there is no slander.

It occurs to me that rather than try to reconstruct the problem of anonymous nastiness and attacks as a womens rights issue to gain rhetorical and political advantage, and use it to seek legislation to curtail everyone’s free speech and shift liability to third parties by making them part of the cyber police patrol, the efforts would be far better spent pounding home the point that anonymous attacks online are worthless, incredible crap, and people who post them are the idiots of this cyber village. 

Important Lawyer-Type Stuff You Should Know About

As a public service, I occasionally present some newsy stuff that criminal defense lawyers ought to be aware of.  Just so you know.

A “Not Guilty” Box:  Don’t go to verdict without it.

From Law.com, Wayne County, Michigan, Circuit Judge Annette Berry liked to prepare her own verdict sheet.  Why this is remains unclear.  Maybe it has little smiley faces on it, or gives her courtroom that homey feel.  I dunno.  But there’s one thing her verdict sheet neglected to include, the little box for “not guilty.”  You know, just in case.


“The verdict form was defective, requiring reversal, because it did not give the jury the opportunity to return a general verdict of not guilty,” the three-judge panel wrote in its opinion on Tuesday. “[B]ecause of the way the verdict form was set up, the jury was not given the opportunity to find defendant either generally not guilty or not guilty of the lesser-included offenses in violation of his constitutional right to a trial by jury.”

Of course, silly little mistakes like this can happen.  After all, there are a ton of details that a judge must address, and it’s perfectly understandable that something as perfunctory as a “not guilty” box on the verdict sheet could fall through the cracks.  But then, it would probably have not been quite as ridiculously embarrassing if Judge Berry hadn’t been so jerky and arrogant when everyone else in the courtroom figured out that she screwed up.


“The jury foreman actually got up and had some confusion. He was stuttering about … and before he could get a question out, the judge said, ‘Just tell me which box you checked,’ ” Gentry said. “And then the judge accepted that as a verdict.”

Gentry said that during jury deliberations, the prosecution and defense also expressed concern about the verdict form, and asked the judge to issue a new one. But she said no, he said.

When everybody else in the courtroom is telling that there’s a problem, there’s an awfully good chance that there’s a problem.  What are the chances that Judge Berry will make this mistake again?  What are the chances that she should be given the chance?

The Financial Suffering When Defending Prosecutors

When Judge Emmitt Sullivan ordered an investigation into the government’s impropriety in the Ted Steven’s case, we all cheered.  Hooray!  Investigation!  Woo hoo!  But how many thought about the little side details, like who defends our prosecutors?  And, more importantly, who pays them and how much do they get?

The WSJ Law Blog did, and they give details.

And that’s where the BigLaw juggernaut comes into the picture.

The DOJ is footing the legal bill for the prosecutors ─ or at least part of the bill ─ and the lawyers have hired some of the nation’s top firms for help, according to this post in the Legal Time’s BLT blog.

The BLT notes that the DOJ will reimburse the prosecutors up to $200 per hour in legal fees, not to exceed 120 billable hours per month, for a total reimbursement of $24,000 per month. Now, $200/hr is roughly a paralegal’s rate at many top firms, but, still, all works is good work in this economy, especially such a high-profile assignment.

You did catch that little detail in the last sentence, about the Biglaw paralegal’s billing rate, right?  Can you imagine the suffering, the pain, a Biglaw firm must go through to perform a public service?  Lawyers working at a rate barely sufficient for a paralegal?  Oh, the humiliation.

Of course, since CJA lawyers get $110 an hour, which I believe is only slightly less than the billing rate of the guy who sweeps the floors and empties the shredding machines at Biglaw, it may bring our erstwhile defenders some comfort.  Not much, but some.  At least they aren’t paid like the real criminal defense lawyers who have to represent the icky criminals.

I can’t speak for anyone else, but I feel better knowing my dedicated public servants in the DOJ are receiving the finest criminal defense Biglaw has to offer at a special discount rate.  A penny saved is a penny earned, you know.

If a Crime is Committed in the Woods and No One Prosecutes…

Also from the WSJ Law Blog, Contra Costa County, California, District Attorney Robert Kochly has announced that because of severe budget cuts, he has to lay off 20% of his staff.

On Tuesday District Attorney Robert Kochly told his county’s police chiefs that beginning in May, his office will no longer prosecute a host of misdemeanors because he has to lay off 20% of his staff, or about 18 prosecutors.

Which infractions won’t be prosecuted? The list includes non-DUI traffic offenses such as driving with a suspended license and reckless driving, simple assault and battery, lewd conduct, trespassing and shoplifting.

Even some felony drug cases involving smaller amounts of narcotics won’t end up in court. That means anyone caught with less than a gram of methamphetamine or cocaine, less than 0.5 grams of heroin and fewer than five pills of ecstasy, OxyContin or Vicodin won’t be charged, according to the Chron story.

So here’s the thing.  It’s one thing for the DA to find himself forced by budgetary constraints to engage in prosecutorial triage.  But wouldn’t you think this is the sort of thing he would want to keep quiet?  I suspect that the non-prosecution of shoplifters is going to seriously affect purchasing decisions at malls throughout Contra Costa County.

But all isn’t roses for criminals, you know.

But bad boys (and girls) shouldn’t get too cocky: “Core” misdemeanors offenses involving domestic violence, drunken driving, firearms and vehicular manslaughter will still be prosecuted. And the Mercury News reports that the police department says it will still make arrests for all misdemeanors, meaning suspects could spend time in jail, even if they aren’t punished by prosecutors.

(Note to self:  Let WSJ know that prosecutors aren’t supposed to be the ones who punish criminals.)  So the cops are going to arrest “suspects” to make sure they spend time in jail even though they aren’t going to be prosecuted?  Nothing to see here, folks.  Just keep moving.

The Free Speech of Bad Cops

Just how stupid can a cop be to tell a journalism student doing a ride around with him that the people he’s there to “serve and protect” are animals?  And then even worse?  From the Philadelphia Inquirer, via David Post at VC :

Five Philadelphia police officers were fired yesterday for alleged misconduct, including two incidents in which officers were accused of using racial slurs.

Among them was William Thrasher, 24, who allegedly called African Americans in his 22d District “animals” and worse.

Thrasher, who had been on the force for two years, was quoted by a Temple University journalism student who was riding with him on patrol for a class assignment. . . . During the ride-along, Thrasher allegedly referred to the violence in his predominantly African American district as “typical n- s-” or “TNS.”

Putting aside for the moment the appalling language, and the even more appalling stupidity of any cop who would use that language in front of a student journalist, Post is outraged that the cops were fired for the exercise of their 1st Amendment rights of free speech.


We’ve come to a pretty unfortunate place when the words “First Amendment” do not even show up in an article like this. Putting aside consideration of what kind of jackass would say stuff like that when he’s got a journalism student in the back seat for a ride-along, firing a cop because he said nasty things to a ride-along journalist seems fairly outrageous to me — without any showing that his conduct on the job was in any way deficient.

When commenters to his post not only failed to circle the wagons around him, but disagree in droves, Post was driven to update his concerns:


Well, I must say I’m very, very surprised at the comments here. The vast majority of VC readers (or at least VC commenters) don’t seem to find any First Amendment issue when the government of Philadelphia fires a policeman for remarks that he made in a conversation with a journalist. I’m stupefied by that, to be candid. That’s what I mean when I said “we’ve come to a pretty unfortunate place” — the First Amendment, which one would think would quite obviously protect a government employee’s speech, has simply lost much of its power, and most people seem to take it for granted that it doesn’t apply here. . . Silly me, but I thought the First Amendment meant that the state couldn’t punish you for the content of your speech without a truly compelling reason for doing so.

Being a huge free speech advocate, I completely understand David Post’s point.  That, of course, doesn’t change the fact that he’s absolutely wrong and, well, “silly” doesn’t suffice. 

First, this was not a person who happened to be a police officer, but a man wearing a shield and carrying a gun, driving around in a car with fancy lights owned by the Philly police department, in the performance of his duty as a law enforcement officer.  During the period that he enjoys the authority granted the shield, he forgoes the freedom that he personally possesses as an individual when he struts the streets in his Fubu football jersey.  In other words, when he is exercising his authority as a cop, it is not a vindication of his personal prejudices.

Second, the problem with his uttering this garbage is that he did so in front of a journalism student.  He just failed to intelligence test to be a rock, no less a cop.  The exercise of discretion is a fundamental component of the police performance, and his choice of words to utter makes it clear that he has no discretion, and is therefore unqualified for the position.

And finally, it’s not the words themselves, but the mindset belied by the words, that reflects a bias wholly incompatible with the performance of his job as a Philly cop.  He cannot be trusted to protect and serve people he feels are subhuman, so unworthy of his effort.  And he was walking around the streets of Philadelphia, the City of Brotherly Love, with a gun? 

I fully support the officer’s right to utter such words all he wants, no matter how disgusting this cretin cop may be.  He just can’t do so in the uniform of a police officer, with shield and gun, enjoying the authority conferred on a cop by law while holding the attitudes the words reflect.  Let him mutter them to himself in his bathrobe swilling beer all he likes, but he has not right to be a cop while he does so.