Author Archives: SHG

Good Tips for Potheads

Not that you care, but just in case you’re going to smoke pot anyway, Dallas criminal defense lawyer Robert Guest has some tips, courtesy of NORML, that just might help to keep you out of the clinker.  Remember, there are no munchies in there, so life can get really rough.

My personal favorite:  One law at a time.  Put on the seat belt.  Put down the cellphone.  It won’t kill you.

There’s nothing worse than some kid getting popped for smoking a blunt, a misdemeanor at worst and decriminalized in many jurisdictions, then committing some felony like fleeing or trying to bribe the cops.  Then again, this could be why no one has ever urged that marijuana be used as a good judgment enhancer.

Cash Needed, But Not Good Enough

Amongst the many press release emails that I regularly find in my box is one from the Center for Independent Media, Since no such thing exists, and somebody thought it wise to send it to me, I assumed that it’s more preaching to the choir.  I guess nobody told them that I can’t sing worth a lick.  Most of the PRs don’t make it past a quick glance, but when I saw one about fighting life sentences for children, I took a look.  As regular readers know, I have a particular soft spot for children, and strongly disagree with their being treated as adults and relegated to the human junk heap.

The PR linked to a post by Eartha Jane Melzer at the Michigan Messenger, relating that a bill to end life without parole sentences for kids languished in the state Senate judiciary committee.  The post goes on to note that Michigan’s high rate of juvenile LWOP sentences is a product of inadequate defense funding.



Young Defendants Often Lack Adequate Defense

 When juveniles are facing charges that carry a life sentence, they are especially dependent on legal counsel in a state that has one of the most under-funded public defender systems in the country. A recent report by the National Legal Aid and Defender Association done in cooperation with the State Bar of Michigan found that the lack of state funding, standards and oversight leads to inadequate public defense locally where counties often lack the resources to provide adequate support for those who can’t afford an attorney.


Because young people are especially dependent on counsel to represent their interests, the failure of the state to provide adequate resources for public defense hits youth especially hard. According to the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan, 78 percent of juveniles sentenced to life without parole relied on appointed counsel.


Coalition for Justice, an alliance of legal and human rights groups concerned about inequities in the state justice system, together with the ACLU of Michigan is suing the state for failing to ensure equal access to representation in Michigan. The group point out that in Berrien County, for example, the prosecution receives four times as much funding as the defense.


Clearly, the 4 to 1 funding disparity signals a major problem, though it still needs to take into account the fact that some juvenile defendants are privately defended, and the prosecution handles cases and investigations that might never make it into the system, thus not requiring an equivalent response from an indigent defender.  Still, the disparity is far greater than can be rationally justified.

But I am deeply troubled by the assertion that this is only a money issue, and that funding is the solution to all problems.  Just as teachers unions constantly argue that lack of money is the root of our children’s poor educational performance, yet end up post-contract negotiations with better paid incompetent teachers, the quality of representation is not cash-dependent. 

There is no macroeconomic issues in a courtroom.  There’s only a lawyer and a defendant, in these cases a child defendant.  It doesn’t matter how many files a public defender has; he only stands up for one person at a time.  Melzer provides an anecdote to make her case:


[Scott] Elliot [a member of the Coalition for Justice’s public defense task force] has closely followed the case of Efren Paredes, a 15-year old Latino honor student who in 1989 became Michigan’s first juvenile to receive the life-without-parole sentence after being convicted of murder and robbery. Paredes, who has now served 20 years in prison, maintains that he is innocent.

Elliot said stereotypes and cultural bias were an important factor in Paredes conviction.  A notebook with lyrics from rap group N.W.A.’s double platinum selling “Straight Outta Compton” album was found in Paredes’ locker at school.

Despite the fact that Paredes was a good student and had no criminal record, the prosecutor, who assumed that the lyrics were written by Paredes himself, Elliot said, introduced them as a “window into his mind” and tried to characterize him as a dangerous gang member.


Try as hard as I might, I find no connection between Efren Paredes’ conviction and lack of funding.  Had he not been represented for lack of an available public defender, that would be one thing, though it’s hard to conceive of a juvenile accused of murder being left out in the cold when it comes to representation.  These are the cases that suck the resources out of the everyday, mundane ones, which often get short shrift.

Every criminal defense lawyer, whether private, public or somewhere in between, takes on a personal duty to provide each and every defendant with zealous representation.  When you hit the wall, have too many files in the bag to fulfill this duty, then you have another duty:  Stop taking cases.  As Our Lady of Abstinence told us, “Just say no.” 

That the state has failed to provide sufficient funds to hire sufficient lawyers to defend all those bad boys and girls they keep arresting presents one side of the problem.  That lawyers who undertake the responsibility of defending those bad boys and girls fail to provide effective representation is another. The former doesn’t dictate the latter.  Only the lawyer can make the decision to personally fail. 

Before anyone starts whining about how I don’t understand, let me assure you I do.  You are told to handle a certain number of cases.  You can’t spend the time to meet with clients, read documents, research issues, investigate facts, prepare, THINK, when you have too many cases on your desk.  What are you supposed to do, just leave the kids without lawyers at all?  A little representation is better than none at all.

Well, no.  It’s a cop out, an excuse, a rationalization.  As lawyers, we are each solely responsible for our representation, no matter who hands us a paycheck.  Your boss told you to do it?  If this is enough justification for you, you are in the wrong line of work.  Next, bad representation is not better than none.  Bad representation is what fills prisons with innocent kids.  No representation places the burden exactly where it belongs, on the state.  They can’t prosecute people who do not have counsel because the state refuses to spend the money necessary to have enough indigent defenders available.  The only to pull that off is to have an enabler at the defense table to give the appearance of representation when there is in fact none.  You enable the state to neglect its responsibility by failing to perform yours.

While Melzer is no doubt right that funding presents a constant struggle for indigent defense, including the representation of those disposable kids who get LWOP, no fair argument exists that ignores the duty of lawyers to defend their clients.  If no one wants to be a public defender under these circumstances, then let’s shut the whole damn system down.  But to facilitate a system that does this to children, and then deny ones complicity in the fiasco, is nonsense.  No amount of money is going to save children when their lawyers fail to do their job.  Even if it means that the lawyers have to take their own heat for standing up for the right thing.

In Praise of Vigorous Advocacy

It’s a dog eat dog world in the trenches.  For lawyers who spend their days toiling in a climate controlled office, sipping coffee to keep them awake, explaining at leisure the law to people who pay to hear their exotic-sounding words without fear of challenge, it is easy to maintain a calm, soothing tone, a steady gaze and even temper.  Try it when you have a split second to say a word that spells life or death to another human being, and puts everything at risk.  Not so easy.

Defending in the trenches involves choices.  Some are hard, while others are easy.  The easy path leads to a happy judge, little (or no) pressure on counsel and smooth proceedings.  But this often means that you’ve hung your client out to dry.  John Kindley recognized the dilemma in a comment here, and pointed to a case in Indiana where a lawyer, Michael Wilkins, was banned from the courtroom for 30 days for including in his brief this footnote:


The opinion is so factually and legally inaccurate that one is left to wonder whether the Court of Appeals was determined to find for ‘the defendant ” and then said whatever was necessary to reach that conclusion.

This footnote, according to the court, was improper because it undermined ”the public’s confidence in the administration of justice.”  Without knowing the decision under attack, I can’t say whether Wilkins’ assessment was accurate, but I can certainly empathize and understand why he felt compelled to state his position.  There are times that lawyers must make hard choices, even those that are likely to raise the ire of a judge and put the lawyer at risk.

Last week, I stood before a federal court for the sentencing of my client.  He pleaded guilty pursuant to an agreement, that left open our right to challenge the guidelines application by providing a ceiling but no floor.  While he had committed the crime (naturally a conspiracy), there remained huge disagreement about the million collateral details surrounding a crime that occurred over a 10 year period.  Two business partners comprised the conspiracy, and each pointed at the other as the moving force.  One sided with the government and I represented the other, if you get my drift.

We were faced with two choices in preparation for sentence.  We could take the easy path, acquiescing in the government’s view of how things happened over this lengthy period of time, with its cooperator minimizing his role and shifting culpability toward my client, or we could mount a serious challenge to the government’s position at sentence.  While this may seem like a no-brainer to the uninitiated, this presented a monumental risk to the defendant. 

By disputing the government’s “facts”, the defendant stood to be seen as deceiving the court, obstructing justice and failing to accept responsibility.  Judges like sentences that go smoothly, and hate having to deal with a serious challenge to the underlying facts at sentence. But my client, and every witness who would speak to me, asserted that the business partner was a liar and that my client was being falsely tarred for things he never did.  It’s not that he wasn’t guilty, but within the sphere of guilty there are many aspects that distinguish a malevolent intent and hand from a laboring oar. 

If we attacked the government’s vision of how the crime occurred, and the relative roles of the players, we invited the ire of the court.  We would either persuade the judge that my client was the least culpable person involved, or face the potential of an enhanced sentence for having the audacity not to take the punishment quietly.  We chose to fight.  If we sat quietly, the sentence would be that spelled out in the sentencing guidelines.  If we prevailed, the sentence would be lower, possibly even probation.  If we didn’t, the sentence could be enhanced and the defendant could face even greater time than anticipated by the agreement.  Everything was on the line.

My argument directly and forcefully disputed the allegations that my client was the mastermind of the scheme.  I called the government’s cooperator a liar, though in slightly less inflammatory language, but with equal clarity.  I left no doubt where we stood.  If the defendant was going to crash and burn, it would not be without a fight for the truth, even if it meant putting my own butt on the line for taking such an aggressive stance.  My client would not sit quietly and be sentenced to prison for someone else’s conduct.

The court first inquired whether the government sought a Fatico hearing.  It did not.  Did the defense?  This was a curious question, since the burden is on the government to prove the facts upon which it relies at sentence when disputed by the defense.  Despite my client’s secret hope that he would have the chance to stare his former partner in the eyes, I demurred.  No good could come from a Fatico hearing, which would ultimately prove a swearing contest, and plenty bad can happen.  While I was ready for it if the government was, which was an eminent possibility, the ball was theirs to hit, not mine.

After submissions and argument, the judge started by explaining her reasoning for the record.  Argument by argument, the judge sided with government.  Knowing the arguments favoring one set of facts over another in excruciating detail, each sentence was like a blow to the chest.  But this was the warm up, with the main event still to come.

Finally, after finding ourselves on the south end of horse headed north, the judge reached the crucial point where someone must pay for having the audacity to suck all the ease and pleasantness out of this sentencing.


But I attribute the defendant’s position to vigorous advocacy rather than any improper intention.

At first blush, one might think this an assault on my efforts to defend my client, where the judge imposed the blame for having fought the “truth” as she found it on me.  But this is where an understanding of the implications of such critical conclusions is necessary.  What the judge did was find for the government, thus removing the onus on it for having backed the wrong horse, but relieve the defendant of any taint for having chosen to fight rather than run scared.  By chalking up the fight to “vigorous advocacy,” my client would have no bill to pay for having refused to lie down and take it like a lamb at slaughter.

The judge imposed a non-guidelines sentence that was one-third less than the minimum sentence called for in the plea agreement, concluding it sufficient to satisfy 18 U.S.C. 3553.  All rhetoric aside, the judge understood.  She just couldn’t say so.

Of course, as any trench lawyer knows, this isn’t the end of the story.  Walking out of the courtroom, some family members immediately began spewing venom at the outrageous miscarriage of justice that just took place in front of their very noses.  One family member, who happened to be an attorney, fed the fire by muttering that he wished he had been the lawyer.  He would have tried the case and beaten it.  It was a disgrace, he said. 

The problem was that the extensive submissions and forceful arguments morphed into a belief that the defendant would not merely do better than the guidelines sentence in the plea agreement, all he was entitled to hope for under the circumstances, and the possibility that he was achieve the greatest possible victory, a sentence of probation.  That the sentence imposed was one third less than his guidelines would suggest was seen as a loss, a failure. 

At the courthouse door, the defendant’s wife said to me, “we appreciate everything you did, and we know you tried your best. It’s just so unfair.”





The Finance Cloud Has a Silver Lining

The New York Times reports that there is good news coming from the recession and collapse of the finance sector.  Smart kids are abandoning the path to wealth and glory as investment bankers and lawyers, and instead put their minds to good use instead.


Today, the financial crisis and the economic downturn are likely to alter drastically the career paths of future years. The contours of the shift are still in flux, in part because there is so much uncertainty about the shape of the economic landscape and the job market ahead.

“In choosing careers, young people look for signals from society, and Wall Street will no longer pull the talent that it did for so many years,” said Richard Freeman, director of the labor studies program at the National Bureau of Economic Research. “We have a great experiment before us.”


Graduate schools of government and public policy are seeing a surge of applications. In a survey of its members released last week, the National Association of Schools of Public Affairs and Administration found that 82 percent reported an increase in applications this year, and many saw the largest percentage jumps in several years, or ever. The most-cited reason was the expectation by students that government will be hiring.


Maybe there’s hope for us yet?

Sure, it would be better if young people sought careers that would serve the greater good because they were actually interested in the greater good, rather than speculation that the government will be the only one hiring.  There stands some probability that they will see themselves as an oligarchical cabal, smarter than average bear citizen who is undeserving of the gifts of their brilliance.  And there is no necessary requirement that they’ve given up hope on the BMW within the first two weeks of employment.

But at least they bring some hope that government won’t be left to the chronically unemployable anymore.  It may not be much, and may required a good deal of oversight to make sure that our best and brightest don’t screw things up even worse than dumb and dumber. but I’m trying to make some lemonade here.  Work with me.

Play Nice, Little Blawger

Following my post yesterday about Texas Lawprof Wayne Schiess’ “7 Tips” for blogging, I received an email chastising me for not playing nice.


SHG: I’m surprised to find myself playing the role of “Disgusted, Tunbridge Wells,” but reading your “Blogging by the Numbers” post was akin to having to witness the posturing of a barroom bully. Include me out. Ken Adams

Now I don’t know Ken Adams.  He has a blog called Adams Drafting,  I suspect the blog name has something to do with the fact that his name is Adams and he’s selling contract drafting. The fact that the blog opens with his telling us that he is a “leading authority on modern and effective contract drafting” supports that suspicion. 

It’s fine with me that Ken didn’t like my post, and even that he described it as the “posturing of a barroom bully.”  Lawyers who spend their days toiling at the art and science of drafting contracts often find trial lawyers too rough for their refined tastes.  But what I couldn’t quite understand was what purpose was served in sending me the email.  So I did what my type of lawyer does when I receive an email from his type of lawyer.  I asked.


Perhaps I’m missing something, but why are you writing me about this?  You’re free to like or dislike anything I write, but it isn’t written for your approval.  What exactly was your purpose in sending this email?  Should I change my world view to seek your approval?

And Ken explained himself:


Scott: If you were writing solely for your own edification, you wouldn’t publish it. By publishing it, you’re electing to be part of a community. And by subscribing to your blog feed a few weeks ago, I became part of that community. Just as you’re free to write whatever you wish, I’m free, in parting, to tell you what I think of it.

Your cock-of-the-walk posturing is mostly unobjectionable, as your usual targets —brutal cops and the like—could do with vigorous handling. But it beats me why you should think that indulging in a smarmy takedown of someone as benign as Wayne Schiess represents good sport.

Ken

This response fascinated me, and offers a wonderful opportunity to clarify two separate points about the blawgosphere.  The first is that the reader doesn’t get to impose the rules.  For someone who drafts contracts, not to mention risks those extremely painful paper cuts on a regular basis, Ken engages in some remarkably poor reasoning.  The assumption that I publish for his approval, proved by the fact of publication, is a strange one.  Trial lawyers expect a logical nexus between assertions.  Apparently, contract drafters don’t bother with such onerous demands.  Clearly, Ken hasn’t been around here long enough to get the message.  But when ignorant assumption can fill the gap, why bother?

Then he’s decided that I’ve elected to be part of a community.  I’ve looked around for Mr. Rogers, but he’s nowhere to be found in my neighborhood.  I note that I’ve never linked to Adams Drafting, but then I can’t imagine any reason I would.  So what community is this that I’ve elected to be a part of?  Aha!  It’s Ken’s community, because he subscribed to my feed, which somehow confers some authority on him to chastise me for being a bad member of the Ken Community. 

I wish he had told me his rules beforehand, so I could have been a better member of the Ken Community when he subscribed to my feed.  If only I had known.  After all, how can I faithfully comply with my duty as a member of the Ken Community, which I joined by virtue of Ken’s subscription, when no one tells me Ken’s rules?  Of course, given that the Ken Community revolves around a blog that exists to promote Ken, Ken’s consulting, Ken’s speaker availability, and Ken (did I mention that already?), it may be likely that I would be unable to fulfill my role as his faithful servant.

But following my initial violation of Ken’s right to tell me how I should conduct myself in his community comes an explanation of how my “cock-of-the-walk posturing” (which I humbly note is a different use of the word “cock” than has ever been ascribed to me before) is “mostly unobjectionable” when used against targets with whom Ken agrees, “brutal cops and the like.”  But he draws the line when I “indulge in a smarmy takedown” of someone Ken feels is undeserving on my invective. 

This is where I must part ways with the Ken Community.  While I can appreciate that Ken’s delicate sensitivities are offended by “cocks” such as me, handling with “vigor” subjects and topics and people and ideas that meet Ken’s approval, he cannot tolerate my “vigorous handling” of those within his Community.  I’ve gone too far.  I’ve gone over the top.  I’ve crossed the line.  I touched one of our own.

Now hear this.  Ken, your attitude is why people despise lawyers.  Real lawyers challenge things with which they disagree.  There is no secret cabal of lawyers, keeping hands-off the brethren lest the little people be let in on the secret that we aren’t above scrutiny.  Bad cops circle the wagons around each other when they get caught.  You are the lawyer equivalent.  How dare you assume that I am one of your type, happy to conceal the warts of the profession to maintain the facade that makes you, a desk jockey, feel self-important and proud to be a self-described “leading authority.” 

I am a criminal defense lawyer.  I am not a member of the Ken Community, with its delicate sensibilities. I handle everyone “vigorously”, and can take some vigorous handling in return.  I will not cry and whine if someone disagrees with me, or (god forbid) calls me a mean name.  And I will not shy away from writing things that I believe to be true and need to be said.  You can hide under your desk and shit your pants all you want, but do not expect me to join you.

As for the “benign” Wayne Schiess, when he undertook to publicly provide “tips” to others on how to blog, he assumed the risk of disagreement.  And I very much disagree, though I can see why you might feel otherwise since your blog is flagrantly self-promotional.  Those inclined to puff themselves are often easily offended when their sham is exposed.  That Wayne promoted the mercenary side of blogging, the one you enjoy, exposed him to dispute from a “cock” like me.  By sticking your nose in, you did too.  If honesty is being a bully, then a bully I am. 

This was my reply to Ken Adams:


I think you’ve seriously misconstrued how my blawgosphere works.  Very seriously.  I strongly urge you to take me off your feed as I fear that I am not worthy of your community.  And just in case your eyes happen to spy one of my posts, avert them immediately.  I can further assure you that my cock-of-the-walk posturing will prove smarmy yet again, and I am deeply concerned that I not offend your sensibilities.

This is no place for the gutless, the mercenary or desk lawyers with fragile sensibilities.  Go away before your head explodes.  And Happy Easter.

Addendum:  My decision to post about this exchange was brought about by a number of things that occurred across the blawgosphere over the past week, not just Ken’s emails (though they did provide a perfect example of what’s wrong with lawyers and the blawgosphere).  Within the practical blawgosphere, we disagree with one another all the time, and post about it in clear, forthright language.  We spar back and forth, and recognize that disagreement, and the expression of disagreement, is what we deal with every day.  Afterward, we go right back to our usual banter, no hard feelings.  It’s just what we do. 

However, there were a number of instances over the past week where posts and twits that were critical of someone’s writings caused some hard feelings.  “But you’re supposed to be my friend,” was the refrain. “How can you say something mean about me?”  Just for clarity, this involved a number of others in the blawgosphere, as well as me. 

Here’s the deal.  When you post something, whether on a blog or in a twit, or anywhere for that matter, you subject your writing to peer review.  Just as Ken Adams didn’t like what I wrote, which is absolutely fine in itself, sometimes a post by a friend asserts something with which other friends disagree.  Sometimes the disagreement is strong enough to merit a post stating the disagreement.  This doesn’t mean that the friendship is over, but merely that there is a disagreement.  In most of these instances, the fact that there would be disagreement should have been obvious from the outset.  That it comes as a surprise is, frankly, quite incredible.

But that’s the point of having a big, worldwide, no-holds-barred discussion that hopefully produces something of both interest and worth.  The practical blawgosphere isn’t the chorus, singing hallelujah at best and remaining mute at worst, when someone posts something with which someone else disagrees.  We won’t use the circumspect language of the Academy, but state our positions with the same clarity and force as we do elsewhere.  We are not inclined to be delicate.

If a blogger cannot stand the scrutiny, then we pose a terrible threat.  There you are, trying to put together a post that sells a proposition, and then comes a bunch of wildmen ripping you to shreds for it.  It tends to happen with great frequency to those are trying to sell their product, usually themselves.  People trying to sell abhor controversy.  It doesn’t help their business.

But it is the very openness of the blawgosphere, that every word and phrase is subject to peer (and nonpeer) scrutiny, that makes it worthwhile.  This is what distinguishes it from the infomercial that I so dearly dread.  This is what keeps the blawgosphere honest.  And if you can’t handle honesty, then you really don’t belong here.

When I post my thoughts on a subject, anybody in the world with a blog can write about what a “cock” I am.  If you think so, go do it.  I may defend my position or not, and I may even be dead wrong though I believe otherwise.  Never before in the history of the law have we had a mechanism that allowed lawyers to express their views and review the views of others without limitation.  Those that survive the scrutiny will be the best, whether they are mine, yours or even Ken’s.  But stop the crap about hurt feelings and let the best ideas prevail.

Oh yeah.  And Happy Easter to everyone.

Can You Hear Me?

Some of the saddest recurring experiences in the interactions between law enforcement and the public are those involving people who are physically or mentally “challenged” in some way.  It’s a clash between demand and disability.  The cops demand and the disability precludes compliance. 

Turley posts about Christopher Ferrell, a deaf man stopped by Fort Worth Officer J.A. Miller.

It began with Christopher Ferrell, 43, being pulled over in his maroon sedan for speeding. Ferrell reached for his identification to inform the officer of his disability.  But, Officer J.A. Miller said he was concerned Ferrell was reaching for a gun. Miller withdrew his gun, grabbed Ferrell, swung him around and slammed his head into the rear windshield. “He was trying to show his identification to the officer so that the officer would know that he was simply unable to communicate with him on a normal basis,” Goetz said.

“It did break his nose,” [Ferrell Attorney Paul] Goetz said of the incident. “There was a lot of blood.”

The best one can say is that at least Miller didn’t tase him.  That can’t be said for Donnell Williams, also deaf, of Wichita.


Donnell Williams had just gotten out of the bath tub, wearing only a towel around his waist, when he turned the corner to see guns pointing right at him.  “I ain’t never been so scared,” says Williams.

Police forced entry into Williams home while responding to a shooting, but it turned out to be a false call.  They had no idea at the time the call wasn’t real and that Williams is hearing impaired.  Without his hearing aid he is basically deaf.

“I kept going to my ear yelling that I was scared.  I can’t hear!  I can’t hear!”

Officers were worried about their own safety because at the time it appeared Williams was refusing to obey their commands to show his hands.  That’s when they shot him with a Taser.

There are a number of distinctions that makes these scenarios particularly painful, and particularly troubling.  On the one hand, disabled people cannot be faulted for being disabled.  Unlike the perennial favorites, drunks or druggies, about whom police are fond of noting that they are inherently evil, worthless people when beaten, maimed or killed, even though the harm bore no connection to their faults or “long criminal history,” disabled people can’t be blamed for being disabled. 

On the other hand, we must bear in mind the prime directive of all police work: Get home alive.  No matter how much training an officer is given, a cop has a split second to determine whether he is about to face a bullet or about to become the poster boy for police abuse.  Most will chose life, even at the risk of making a mistake.

This is not the same scenario as the cop who sadistically abuses his power to harm someone for failing to bow to his authority.  This is about fear of the unknown, complicated by what the cop perceives as the wrong reaction to his command.  They are trained to take charge of the situation first.  Traffic stops are particularly problematic since they don’t know if they’ve just stopped the monsignor or the drug kingpin, and they only need to make the mistake of assuming that the person in the car is harmless once.

But this doesn’t help a disabled person.  He can’t change his disability any more than a cop can change his fear.  Hearing impairment presents a particular problem, since verbal commands are the primary means for an officer to seize control, and refusal to abide the commands are the primary hallmark of a threat.  But it goes farther, as has happened with autistic children, psychotic adults and people in extremis.  I’ve urged parents of learning disabled children to forge a relationship with their local police so that their children are recognized as disabled should they have an encounter in the future.

By no means should this be construed as an apology of any sort for the violent conduct of a cop in excess of that necessary to protect himself.  In Christopher Ferrell’s case, Officer Miller’s slamming his head against the rear window was an pointless, vicious assault that would have put anyone without a badge in jail.  Miller only lost two days pay. 

Strangely, one of the outcomes of the Ferrell case is that the Forth Worth Police Department has announced that it will make sign language interpreters available to officers within a half hour of a request.  While fine, this would have done absolutely nothing to help Christopher Ferrell.  Great solution to the wrong problem.

We still need some mechanism for those with disabilities to be securely protected from the police.  And every story of a disabled person harmed for no reason other than being disabled drives him this dilemma.  We can’t demand that blind people see or deaf people hear.  We can’t expect cops to expose themselves to harm from an unknown person, waiting patiently to learn whether he is disabled to dangerous.  We’ve got a real problem.

But on the third hand, when a cop can’t control himself enough to not slam a subdued man’s head against a window, and faces only the most trivial of consequences, if any, for conduct that would put any other member of society behind bars, we’ve got a real problem as well. 

Blogging By The Numbers (Texas Lawprof Version)

While I was looking around the Incisive Media family of legal technology posts for the functionally ignorant, I came across a post by Wayne Schiess entitled “7 Tips for Writing a Successful Legal Blog.”  Who is Wayne Schiess? 


Wayne Schiess is the director of legal writing at the University of Texas School of Law in Austin. He blawgs at Blog.LegalWriting.net, and his blawg was named to the ABA Blawg 100 in 2007.

Well that’s certainly impressive.  After all, I do some blogging and nobody made me director of legal writing at a law school (even if it is in Austin, Texas).  And after all, I sure want to write a successful legal blog.  So I read the post, fully prepared to take notes if necessary.

Lots of lawyers are blogging about the law, aka blawging. There are about 3000 blawgs out there, according to the ABA Journal , which began honoring the best law-related blogs in 2007 with its annual “ABA Blawg 100.”

That may be a bit of an overstatement of the worth of the ABA Blawg 100, given that it’s chosen by whatever strikes the fancy of a handful of nonlawyers in a backroom at the ABA Journal, and some aren’t even blawgs.  But I guess since Wayne’s World got into it, and given how lawprofs love being on lists, he’s got to start out be establishing his credibility.  Fair enough.

For a lawyer, producing a blawg can be a nice break from traditional legal writing. It’s a chance to try something new that demands creativity, skill and consistency. Although the blawg may not immediately pull in clients or referrals — the monetary rewards of blawging can be modest — it offers other rewards.

Other rewards like . . . keeping oneself off the street and at the keyboard?  Avoiding any semblance of actual human contact?  Wayne doesn’t say, but I bet it’s got something to do with tenure in his case.  For me, it’s the joy of cooking. 

So what are these 7 tips?


1. Blawg for the right reasons. Lots of blawgers begin with hopes of generating business and promoting their practices. But given the thousands of blawgs already out there, not to mention the thousands of other blogs and Web sites available today, getting business and promoting the practice might not be the best reasons to start.

Right on, Wayne! 


2. Post consistently. Once the blawg is underway, keep at it. Post frequently, or at least regularly. Successful blawgers try to develop a following, and when the posts are consistent, readers stay with the blawg. When a blawg goes idle for weeks at a time, it slips from readers’ minds, and they might tune it out and stop visiting.

Definitely.  Readers minds can very, very slippery.

3. Aim at someone and check to see if the blawg hits the target. Once a blawg has been publishing for a short while, the author may be able to focus the content more. What began as a writing outlet for the author may attract a following; by tuning in to reader comments, the author can begin to gear the content to specific reader groups.

Now you’re starting to lose me Wayne. So you told me to blawg for the right reasons, but now you’re telling to change the right reasons to attract a following.  Am I writing for me, or for them?  What if the audience wants to see naked pictures of me (just an example, don’t get scared)?  So I should start writing to satisfy the demands of readers rather than write to satisfy myself?  You’re getting a little too inconsistent for me here, pal.

4. Adopt a readable, personable style. It’s not the point of a blawg to write in a traditional, lawyerly voice. It’s the opposite: Make the posts readable, informal, alive.

There we go, we’re back on track again, brother.  Nice how you avoided saying that lawyers shouldn’t write like the boring stiffs they are, but like human beings. 

5. Advertise. Get the name of the blawg out there. If your firm or company allows you to do so, put a link to your blawg on its main Web site. Find blawgs on similar topics or blawgs by colleagues and acquaintances, then offer to exchange links. Embed a link to the blawg in the signature block of e-mail messages.

Oh crap.  Are you getting some of that incisive media cash under the table that you’re not telling us about Wayne?  What the heck is this garbage in here for? Link exchanges, the surest route to total humiliation and disrepute possible?  Did you start drinking heavily between number 4 and 5?  Did Wayne “party on?”

6. Avoid pitfalls. In trying to be interesting and relevant, resist the urge to engage in harsh criticism, personal attacks and name calling. Peers, colleagues, clients and even judges can and will see the blawg. Maintain a professional approach.

I’m gonna give you the benefit of the doubt here, considering your likely state of “ebriation” and the fact that being a lawprof, you probably live in abject fear of ever saying anything that might conceivably offend anyone by providing a clear, concise and cognizable opinion using words that actually mean something.  “When something deserves harsh criticism, be a pussy” hardly seems like the sort of thing someone from Texas would write.  But then, the old saying, “all hat and no cattle” had to come from somewhere.

And finally,

7. Try humor. Being professional does not mean being somber. Humor usually won’t work in court documents or letters to opposing counsel, and it’s a pretty tough go in e-mail, too. But a blawg is just the place for humor. The point is to let the blawg show the personality of the author.

Ah, you got me.  You were just being a jokester, weren’t you?  And I just fell for it, hook, line and sinker.  What a dope I am, taking these “7 Tips” for real.  Good one, Wayne.  Party on.

Raped Twice in the Subway

The spirit of Kitty Genovese remains very much a part of New York, and it’s good to know that our courts stand behind it.  From MSNBC’s Today People :


The young woman had been attacked in full view of a New York City subway clerk, then dragged down the steps onto a deserted platform where she was raped and raped again, the assailant not stopping even when a subway train pulled into the station.

Now, after nearly four years of constant nightmares, bouts of depression and anxiety, the woman has been told by a judge that two transit workers who saw her being attacked had no obligation to do anything to help her other than to signal their superiors that police were needed at the station.

Our government.  It’s always there to help.


The former graduate student said she didn’t expect the ticket clerk to leave the safety of his booth or the conductor of the train that stopped at — and left — the station during her attack to jump off his train to aid her.

“He could have just gotten over the intercom and said, ‘Hey! Stop what you’re doing! I’ve called the cops!’ Anything like that would have helped,” she said. “He didn’t have to get out of the booth. I don’t expect him to be a police officer. But he could have definitely said something over the intercom, or perhaps having a quicker system of notifying the police would have been effective, too.”

The victim, known only as Maria, is being a bit too legally correct for my taste.  A young woman is being raped before your eyes and two men did nothing.  What if it was their daughter?  What if was mine?  Has there every been two bigger cowards, hiding inside their bulletproof booth and letting this happen?


At the civil trial, the judge who ruled for the MTA concluded that the clerk and conductor “had taken prompt and decisive action” in calling for help and had complied with work rules.

The MTA issued a statement that said, “It is important to note that while NYC Transit workers are trained to the highest degree of professionalism in their assigned jobs, they are not and should not be expected to perform in the capacity of law enforcement officers.”

The legal duty of government employees, “trained to the highest degree of professionalism” in handing out metrocards, is limited.  After all, the city could be subject to massive liability if these welfare queens were expected to actually do something to help people in need.  So the law has watered down their duty, as well as (here’s a big secret folks) the duty of police to actually do police type stuff (that’s right, they have no responsibility to actually protect anybody absent a “special duty” to a particular individual) as to make it essentially impossible to hold them accountable for being the cowards they are.

I’m sure that some will argue that these two transit employees, who watched as Maria was dragged and raped, were not suited to stop a rapist, who might have been armed, and might have been strong, and might have been angry, and might have been any number of other things that would put these two manly transit workers at risk.  It’s true.  There are risks in life.  There are risks in doing the right thing for another human being.  Or, one can save one’s own butt and hide in your bulletproof booth while a young woman gets raped.  It’s definitely much safer for you to hide. 

I’m not sure I can fault the judge for ruling the way he/she did.  It’s likely legally correct.  But I can slam the decision for its verbiage, “prompt and decisive action.”  How about this ruling judge? 

While it is painful and disgraceful that two men could hide in their bulletproof booth while a young woman was brutally raped before their eyes, and a horrific commentary on human nature that they cared far more for their own safety than to assume any risk to help another human being, I am constrained by the law to find for the defendant on the issue of liability because the law safeguards the interests of government over the harms done its citizens.

It’s bad enough that the two transit employee cowards lacked humanity.  Was it necessary for the court to lack it as well?

Law is Easy. Ask Anybody

For years, DIY was the hottest thing in home improvement.  Anybody could rewire a house, after watching a couple of shows on TV.  It looked so easy, and it was always done in a half hour.  So it’s only natural that people would eventually figure out that they could be their own lawyers too.  Hey, between Perry Mason, L.A. Law and Boston Legal, viewers had all the legal education they need, right?  

And if that wasn’t enough, a couple of hours of daytime TV judges was equal to an LL.M. at least.  Nothing to it.  Plus, lawyers cost money, and people don’t have money.

The New York Times published an article about how nonlawyers have taken up arms in their own cause.



Financially pressed people like Ms. Barros are representing themselves more and more in court, according to judges, lawyers and courthouse officials across the country, raising questions of how just the outcomes are and clogging courthouses already facing their own budget woes as clerks spend more time helping people unfamiliar with forms, filings and fees.

Judges complain that people miss deadlines, fail to bring the right documents or evidence and are simply unprepared for legal proceedings. Such mistakes make it more likely they will fare poorly — no matter the merit of their cases.


As it turns out, it’s not as easy as people seem to think.  In fact, it’s not easy at all, even for those trained and licensed.  And to add insult to injury, court is nothing like the TV dramas you’ve watched your whole life, and I think Judge Alex and Joe Brown are wrong more often than they’re right.

It’s not, as most laypeople would assume, that the law is some vast conspiracy of complex rules designed to keep the ordinary person out and line the pockets of lawyer.  Much of it makes perfect sense and is compelled by the human ability to both screw up and rationalize their screw ups so that people believe they’re right no matter how wrong they are. 

Having spent more than 20 years as a pro bono arbitrator in Manhattan civil court, and having tried thousands of cases there with good people acting on their own behalf, I have a pretty good idea what it’s like when two otherwise nice people find themselves in disagreement.  I also have a really good idea of how they come to court with a good cause and screw it all up, whether for lack of proof, the inability to distinguish a viable argument from their emotional or visceral positions or just their inability to present a cogent statement of facts.  It can be painfully difficult for people to even explain their position. 

But there’s an underlying issue here that is separate from the fact that people tend to make lousy lawyers for themselves.  In tough economic times, disputes still occur and people can’t afford representation.  What are they to do?

The questions remains whether the court, meaning everyone from the clerks to the judge, should accommodate these pro se litigants.  Most clerks have a difficult time when litigants inexplicably fail to meet filing deadlines, and truth be told, most litigants have no good excuse.  Whether they just didn’t know (and they should if they are going to represent themselves), or the dog ate their evidence, or they just didn’t get it in on time, critical details to lawyers just don’t mean the same thing to nonlawyers. 

Then there is the fear factor, as a person stands before a judge’s bench and becomes paralyzed with fear.  Most people can’t speak publicly to begin with, and the pressure of being expected to stand and deliver is too much for them to take.  Some write it all down in advance, and request/demand that the judge read it.  When that doesn’t work, they haven’t a clue what to do.  Others find it impossible to distinguish facts from feelings, and begin a pitch about how they feel about the issue at hand.  Judges tire of this quickly.  Still others present facts and argument so utterly lacking in logic and coherence that they come off as cross between the village idiot and the world’s greatest liar, when they are neither.

Many of the problems are bred by what people are taught at the television’s knee, where impassioned pleas of righteousness tend to win the day.  They are so utterly convinced of the propriety of their own position that it doesn’t occur to them that someone else might be less persuaded.  One of the oft-spoken lines is, “To tell you the truth…”  Were you lying before?  They don’t get it.

When I arbitrate, I do my best to both put people at ease, and tell them that it’s no different than talking to some regular person who doesn’t know anything about their problem.  I try to guide them when they skip over a critical detail through subtle questioning, and ask for the necessary evidence that will save us both about 10 minutes of emotional but needless explanation.  I do the same for both sides, and find with amazing frequency that positions that appeared ridiculous at first actually are correct once the facts are clarified.  Then I often tell litigants who have fully presented their cases but can’t seem to figure out when the time has come to stop talking, “you’ve made your point, so be careful about seizing defeat from the jaws of victory.”  They usually smile and stop speaking.

But many judges aren’t capable of dealing with regular people.  Most judges in the New York City civil courts never represented human beings, but worked as law secretaries for other judges, or prosecutors, or corporate counsel, their entire careers.  When they take the bench, they see people as annoyances, drains on their time, interferences with their orderly process.  They can be rude, unbearably pompous, and incomprehensible, spouting legalisms as if to show how smart they are.  Ironically, most aren’t particularly good on the law either.

Not only does this not help the situation, but it tends to exacerbate a tense and difficult experience for people.  And there’s just no need for it, but for the fact that understanding and dealing with normal people is a gift too many judges do not possess.  It’s not the pro se litigants who are wrong; they come to court exactly as they are.  It’s the judges’ lack of training and experience with normal people that mucks up the system.

Don’t begrudge pro se litigants the opportunity to make their case on the merits despite the roadblocks the law places in front of them.  Lawyers are expensive, and the unwillingness to let your children go hungry in order to pay for a lawyer is hardly irrational.  Still, people need to litigate when they have a dispute, and that’s why we have courts, lawyers notwithstanding.  Help nonlawyers to present their position in the best possible light, without unnecessary entanglement in procedure, and even the losing side will leave believing that they have had their day in court, a fair chance and were shown respect.

I can’t tell you how many times over the years a losing litigant, who came into my room absolute in his belief that he was right, will thank me after the arbitration is concluded for listening, for helping, for explaining and mostly for showing him the respect he deserved.  Yes, there are always the nutcases, but most people just need help understanding and want to be treated with a little dignity. 

Slackoisie to Biglaw: Be Funner

While the millenials claim to possess many virtues, good timing is apparently not amongst them.  A gang of the best and brightest have stolen away from the couch in the basement, pushed aside their half-eaten bag of Doritos, to find power in numbers and change the world for the better.  At least the better for them.  What? You expected them to give a damn about anyone else?

From the National Law Journal :


Gathering at Stanford Law School over the weekend, about 50 students from Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Stanford and other premier law schools were part of Building a Better Legal Profession’s National Conference of Student Leaders. The two-day event focused on changing what were often painted as the evil ways of big law firms and included presentations and discussion from well-known practitioners and professors.

The goal of Building a Better Legal Profession (BBLP) is to create collective action among students and associates from top schools to prod large law firms to implement what it says are significant changes needed in billable hour requirements, diversity and the commitment to pro bono work. Their hope is that students and associates from the best schools will not accept jobs at firms that do not change their ways.

I know!  I can’t read that last line without laughing either.  Neither can the recently resurrected Holden Oliver at What About Clients?


Clueless in America. When WAC? was just 25-years-old, he was already a brilliant securities lawyer, independently wealthy, and a leading expert on: (1) law firm economics and management, and (2) working with clients in global markets. And so were all his friends. Well, weren’t you? Hey, it could happen. And monkeys could fly out of your wazoo.

Reformation of the evils of Biglaw is a wonderful thing.  The billable hour, for example, is indeed evil, but the evil isn’t to the poor, unfortunate associates who are forced by taskmasters in pinstriped suits to work endless hours until they drop for a mere $190,000 a year (plus bonus).  It’s evil to the clients who pay for useless hours by young associates whose work product could be more swiftly and competently produced by monkeys sitting at typewriters in the bowels of the Library of Britain. 

Of course, there are two practical impediments to this grand gesture.  First, Biglaw is hemorrhaging at the moment, trying to shed the self-proclaimed best and brightest as fast as they can without making it look like they’re about to sell off their faux mahogany desks and ergonomic chairs.  In other words, the collective might of this group of go-getters, with their call to refuse to go to work in the morning, poses somewhat less of a threat than, say, telling managing partners that they dress funny.

The second problem, which is one that likely never dawned on these new-dawners, is that there is a bunch of people out there who are delightfully called “clients”.  This group called “clients” are the nice folks to send in large checks to pay for the sweet dreams shared by the best and brightest.  And it is neither the best and brightest, nor even the Biglaw firms who allow them the gesture of having formative legal years, who pay the price for each of the BBLP demands.  One might think all these sharp young lawyers understood that there is a cost to their demands, and it gets paid by somebody. 

Connect the dots, kids.  If you’re getting the big bucks (theoretically) and spending your days performing highly fulfilling pro bono work, where do you think the lucre comes from?  You can perform good deeds all day long if you would like.  Once you’re a lawyer, do pro bono!  Work for the Legal Aid Society!  Give blood, if you want.  Nobody is stopping you from doing good deeds for others.  You just can’t demand that somebody pay you an astronomically high salary while you get to fulfill your dreams. 

It would be so much more fun if Biglaw paid the best and brightest to do the things they think are fun.  Come on, Biglaw.  Be funner.  It’s not like they’re asking for more pizza parties or balloons every Thursday.  This is good, clean fun, helping the people we want to help. 

Unfortunately, there is no right to drive up to the food bank in a Ferrari.  Even if you think you’re the best and the brightest.  Even if it’s your idea of fun.  But while you protest, there are a whole bunch of students from “lesser” law schools who would be happy to have a job at half your salary.